TRANSKRİPT 🔗
Arthur Chiaravalli: Overbeyond Grades is supported by GotLearning. GotLearning is a new type of classroom platform designed to help schools, teachers, and students provide ongoing feedback, facilitate formative assessment, personalize learning, and show growth over time. Students and teachers can send and receive feedback, post video reflections, and scan non-digital learning evidence directly into their learning conversations. Find out more at Gottlearning.com. Welcome to Grow Beyond Grades, where we explore more humane, meaningful ways of assessing learning and communicating growth. This 10th anniversary season features contributors to our forthcoming book, Beyond Grades: Why Grades Fall Short, and What Comes Next. After each episode, we invite you to continue the conversation with our guest at a free online community gathering offered each following Saturday at noon Eastern. If this work matters to you, please consider supporting us at growbeyondgrades.org/slash donate. Your support helps us produce the podcast, host these free gatherings, and bring the book into the world. My guest today is Paul Thomas, professor of education at Furman University and a longtime teacher and writer. Before moving into higher education, Paul taught high school English for 18 years. Over his more than four decades in education, Paul has experimented with ways to make assessment and feedback better support learning. Paul's chapter in our book traces that ongoing evolution from delaying grades and emphasizing revision to writing workshop and more recently grade contracts. In our conversation, we talk about why students can experience feedback as judgment, how grades can make learners risk-averse, what writing workshop actually demands. And what teachers can do even when they still work inside graded systems. Here's our conversation. Paul, we're excited to have you. ⁓ great to be here. I appreciate it lot. Yeah. So, you know, you have been on the show before and and you've written for us ⁓ on on our website. ⁓ you've been doing versions of ungrading for a long time, even before it had that language around it. What pushed you away from traditional grading in the beginning? Well, think it's it's really kind of been an interesting journey because I started teaching in nineteen eighty-four and I would say that first easily the first five to ten years, probably the ⁓ more like the first decade, I really struggled with how to make assignments effective for learning. And it took me a bit to kind of recognize that I really think grading makes assigning student work ⁓ antagonistic. And students would not produce in the artifacts that they created, you know, whatever we did, particularly essays, ⁓ it just didn't seem like it was working. ⁓ so I was always looking for a way ⁓ to avoid ⁓ the negative consequences of students trying not to fail or lose points. ⁓ so relatively early on I stopped giving grades to early submissions of essays. ⁓ and I always let stud ⁓ I always required students to rewrite after I gave them feedback. So I spent a lot of time those first 10 years working on Giving feedback, ⁓ making that manageable because I had a hundred to a hundred and twenty-five high school students. and so I was always working on how to make the feedback manageable, make the ⁓ revision process manageable. And at first I just didn't give a grade on the first submission. Then I would give a grade and then I started averaging the grades over the ⁓ s resubmissions, which I really disliked, ⁓ because the if they started off badly, they just were a little deflated. And then I settled ⁓ for a long time or for several years on only counting the last grade, which I think was the right decision. so it I mean that's kind of the metamorphosis when I was teaching h that was high school teaching, ⁓ and that was, you know, from eighty four to two thousand and two. And then when I got ⁓ to teaching higher ed, it was much easier just not to give a grade because I had pretty much complete autonomy. So I by the time I was teaching ⁓ at the university level, ⁓ I only and I still do this, I only give grades for the course. I don't give any grades on the assignments at all. ⁓ I give them ⁓ feedback, I still do the same thing. They have to revise their work. I found that was very problematic for my university students. ⁓ they felt like it was a gotcha situation. They were terrified they were going to do poorly. so from for several years I would just say, you know, you're going to be fine. And I kind of came up with this weird little rubric that said, if you do this, this and this, you can sort of anticipate making this grade in the course. ⁓ that seemed to help a little bit, but not really a lot. Also was willing to talk with students. I said, come conference with me and we'll talk about where you appear to be in your grades. ⁓ didn't work very well. Very few would follow up on that. So for several years now I've my most recent this is my forty second year of teaching. My most recent version of this is I do contract grading. ⁓ so I still don't ⁓ I still don't ⁓ give grades on assignments. I only give grades in the course, but they have a contract and it very clearly ⁓ they still are a little nervous, but if they do the contract they get the grade that it says like there's you know and the ones who don't do it are the ones like I have I still have students fail, which kind of shocks me. and it's simply just not doing the what is the contracted agreement. One of the things you deal with in your chapter is students experiencing feedback. So feedback is just the bread and butter of a of a writing course, but who experience it as negative. Why is feedback so emotionally loaded for students? Yeah, that's a really good question. It's really this is still one of my big struggles because ⁓ it's odd that on balance, my feedback is still routinely characterized as mean and harsh. And one one element of it is I think ⁓ that I teach at a selective
Load full transcript
university where these students have made A's and Bs. I would say that our so called good students typically get their A's and B's in one shot and kind of move on. So then they come to the you know ⁓ the to college and not only are they not going to get an A for one shot essay, ⁓ they're going to get feedback and have to revise. And in my particular situation, to get an A, you have to do at least two ⁓ major revisions and resubmissions. So you write the paper at least three times ⁓ to be in the A category. And a lot of them find that I I would say almost offensive. so they so they see it immediately as these are criticisms as opposed to this is how you can be better. So one ⁓ one strategy that I do is I share with them my submissions as a writer myself. And I you know, I show them a lot of things. ⁓ with track changes and ⁓ they will gasp, you know, when I put it up on the on the screen because there's more red. You know, I said, you I'll tell them I said, you I'm I'm in my sixties. I've published a a ton and I submit work for publication, I get, you know, just a huge amount of feedback. ⁓ and I did a piece ⁓ for the Washington Post last summer and I think it was eight or ten drafts. You know, and I and I show that and it's like that helps a little bit ⁓ for them to sort of understand. And also my rhetoric, I've started talking about their assignments are teaching and learning experiences. They're not evaluation. There's always this little percentage of my students who just really appreciate this and they're like, This is great. And I'm I'm such a better writer. And I'm like, how do I bottle that? There's just there's a personality type of a student that goes, I've never had this experience. This is really helpful. I feel like I'm a better writer. And on balance they say they do like it. I mean, I you know, I do a kind of a debriefing at the end of the semester and we talk about it and they're all like, you know, this was this was tough for a while, but ⁓ you know, I I feel like it really is the right way to do things. So I talk about lowering stress. You know, I also talked to ⁓ about the research on, you know, when you take a test and you're under stress, you're probably gonna score lower. ⁓ I mean, not probably, there's research on that. Right. ⁓ so we do l we try to do as much low stakes as we can and ⁓ I think working on them thinking differently about the low stakes and this isn't an assessment. I just say ⁓ on even on the grade contract it says your assignments are not for assessment. You know, you're not being evaluated. They are teaching and learning experiences. ⁓ the feedback is still something I'm really working on. It's it's amazing to me how difficult that is. I do want to get to this question of grade contracts, which you have layered into your ungrading or degrading ⁓ and workshop approach. What problem is contract solving for you? I think it helps ⁓ a couple of things. Institutionally, Still, hopefully ⁓ it'll continue this way,
professors have pretty much full academic freedom. however, if you're not a traditional grader, it makes administration very uncomfortable. I will say without hesitation, the administration at Furman has been incredibly supportive. I've never had any kind of even hints that I should do something different. But with students, it has sort of caused and solved the trust issue. Yeah. we have, since I have 18 years as a high school teacher, I have a lot it's easy for me to have this conversation with students. We'll talk about ⁓ have you ever studied for a test or really studied hard and still did badly on the test? And even at the, you know, even at the university level with good students, almost every one of them will sit there shaking their head or raise their hand and I say, How did that make you feel? And they'll say, Well, I kind of regretted studying. You know, like why did I spend my time doing that? So we start talking about gotcha culture. ⁓ a lot of students feel like that the the grading and and traditional grading is kind of a a gotcha. and I'll I will talk about, okay, so if you have this grade contract, this is a legal document. It is a public document. If if I tell you do X, Y, and Z, you get this grade and I don't give you that grade, you take that to the dean. You know, I literally say that to them. I said, you take that to the dean. And I said, I am now I've got a problem. The contract helps elevate ⁓ teaching and learning and teacher and student relationships to a more adult level. ⁓ And ⁓ it it also I think for most students, ⁓ it helps alleviate what we were talking about earlier. It it alleviates that fear of losing points, which I'd I I do the little I learned this from my major professor in my doctoral program, Lauren Anderson, who was wonderful. ⁓ but he you know, he put on the board, like I'll put a you know, a ten question ⁓ answer sheet ⁓ on the on the board and you know and I'll put a X beside four of them and then I'll up in the corner I'll put a 100 minus 40 equals 60. And we'll talk about what does that say. and the first thing I try to get them to notice is that we somehow think that students start assessments with a hundred points. And ⁓ this is the good thing I learned from advanced placement. ⁓ When you're taught to to grade ⁓ AP essays, you're told you start with nothing, right? Give them credit for what they do. Right. And I say, I'm sorry, but when you start an assessment, you have zero points. You haven't done anything. ⁓ so I try to talk about the concept of you're not you're not risking losing anything. You're trying to gain credit. ⁓ so I think the contract helps with that sort of rhetorical work. ⁓ that I don't think is trivial. I d you know, the to me the silliest thing in the world is telling students you start something with a hundred points for doing nothing and you you do everything you can not to lose those points. we tr we we train students to be risk averse. They don't want to take any chances. And
I'm like, that's not how you learn things. And it's helping students take chances, you know, I I I think since I've had the contract and you know, since I've been at the university level, I've heard more students say, You know, I tried something I've never tried before on this paper and I'm not sure if it works and I'm like, Hey, that's what we'll talk about. And like that's you've got to do that. Like every every creative person has to try something they haven't tried before. And a lot of times you go like, Well, well, that was a mistake, you know, I won't do that again. but that's a really good thing to learn. Could you talk a little bit more about your thoughts around the workshop model? Right. I and I'll tie that into again the the current environment on social media and the science of movement is trashing workshop. And it it's interesting the other day, the same thing happened again. They, you know, somebody who's I would say is more traditional, conservative. The science of movement is way more traditional and conservative, especially ⁓ internationally. ⁓ and they pointed out, you know, that that Lisa Delpit very famously criticized workshop. And, you know, I I always quote her 'cause she says she says in that criticism, she says, I am not endorsing basic skills. Like they completely misrepresent her. What she was criticizing is very poorly implemented workshop. Right. And I agree with her. Like I that there's nothing in her piece that I disagree with. and there is this idea that somehow reading and writing workshop is have kids come into class and just let them do whatever they want to do. And that's the farthest thing from the truth. it's it's individualized instruction. You give them very purposeful things to do and then you're you're integrating your teaching into that context. ⁓ And I was just thinking about this ⁓ you know, yesterday, I believe. ⁓ it's it's honoring this holistic nature of reading and writing. ⁓ they need to read, they need to write, but they don't need to read and write in isolation. ⁓ it's really would be wasting their time. ⁓ again, I've been teaching forty-two years, I'm sixty-five, I've written and read a ton. why would I cheat them out of that? Like I think I'm an incredible resource. So ⁓ while they're reading and writing and workshop, ⁓ you know, I'm I'm giving that my expertise. That's what that's what teaching is. I'm sharing my expertise. And you said it a minute ago, but I think it's really important. I've tried to be better about this when I'm talking to teachers. Look at the concepts of contract grading. Look at the concepts of ungrading, look at the concepts of the writing or reading workshop. Okay. Which of those concepts can you integrate into the norms and the requirements of being a K-12 teacher, recognizing that you cannot bring them in perfectly. So for me, you know, you know, ⁓ Nancy Atwell said that she used, I think it's Giacoby, ⁓ time ownership and response. These are the concepts that that you know At well said were reading workshop and that has always resonated with me. she's not popular anymore and she's been trash but Lucy Calkins and Nancy At well, I was a teacher in the eighties and nineties. I was reading their work and it just it it set me on fire. Like you know ⁓ I didn't take anything from those works like scripts or anything. Right. They just helped me think about my practice and I created my own versions of workshops. Absolutely. And it was really, really important to me, but you know, how do I integrate giving them time? How do I give them ⁓ how do I give them ownership? How how often can I let them choose what they do within the context of they can't choose everything and they also don't even know how to choose. I mean I've written one of my earliest pieces in the English journal was about, you know giving students choice in reading and it looked like it just bombed. And I literally had kids say, I'd never chose a book for school before. And I went, Well, okay, I'll teach you how to do that. Right. And then we talked about feedback. I mean, response is is huge. So, you know, I've told, you know, high school English teachers before, I said, I ran a workshop structure when I was teaching high school. I doubt that you can do that. So can you integrate more time? where they do were doing whole things. Can you inter can you ⁓ introduce more response? Can you d introduce more choice? ⁓ it's just doing more of that. and ⁓ you know best practice used to be a great term ⁓ I associate it with Harvey Smokey Daniels who's just a wonderful, wonderful ⁓ educator and thinker. and you know he got really upset because ⁓ best practice had the same problem workshop did. Tons of people were saying they were doing best practice, but it was a a pale or a distorted version of best practice. Right. And a Zimmelman Daniels and Hyde had a really great book just called Best Practice. And they have charts in the back for each section. And the charts say increase, decrease. And they list practices. Now, I think it's really important to understand they never say do this and don't do that. It's a very conscious increase decrease. Right. And that's to me is what best practice is. When you're a when you're a teacher, how do you increase these things that are more authentic? How do you increase these things that are more humanizing? And how do you decrease the things that are less authentic? How do you decrease the things that are less humanizing? Right. But we're never going to do that perfectly. And it shouldn't be. There's no script. ⁓ again, right now we're in a very scripted era where we think we can, you know, have templates for what students do. I mean, we're shifting back to saying teacher centered is good, direct instruction is good. Right. ⁓ and of course, teacher centered things and direct instruction are sometimes quite good. They're very important. ⁓ but they're not monolithic. And I think, you know, that's where we're that's the dangerous
thing. Absolutely. So you've been at this for forty, forty-two years teaching. Forty-two. Forty-two years. ⁓ for teachers who are listening to this, ⁓ and probably can't completely remove grades in their setting. I don't think many of us can. What is one practice that they could change immediately that would move them toward healthier assessment, less dehumanizing assessment, as you said? I think it's everybody can go through kind of the evolution that I did. I think step one is just delaying. That's why I kinda like deep degrading instead of ungrading. The right term is ungrading. I've given up. I'm I'm I'm I've you use the word ungrading. ⁓ but I do think all of us can delay. how can you have and ⁓ now that that requires ⁓ a commitment to process. so how d how do students do assignments where they get feedback that's not grades. and I think moving away from averaging, ⁓ averaging is a horrible practice. Why is that horrible? Tell it give us a thumbnail sketch of what the issue is there. I think it fits in with the delaying idea. I don't think we should hold students accountable while they're learning. Right. So if students are at the early stages of learning something and you assess them and you weigh that grade the same as after they've been given a chance to learn. I think that's statistically distorting. I mean it's just it's it's not a Lauren ⁓ Anderson again, his example is you're admitted to the hospital with a serious fever. ⁓ 104, 106 generally is considered really bad and you may be hospitalized. And they take your temperature, you know, over the course of several days and The doctor comes in a couple days later and he looks at your chart and he added adds up all of your temperatures and bases his ⁓ h bases his diagnosis on the average. You're lying in the bed then with ninety eight point six degree because you're fine. Right. So a doctor uses the most recent data. Like you've been given a chance to heal. And I think it s sometimes medicine is a bad analogy for education, but I think that's a perfect analogy for let's give students grades once they've had the opportunity to learn. So that's why I think the concept of I think all of us can delay grades. All of us can delay grades. And it's finding how how well you can do that or how tolerant your environment you teach in allows you to do it. Then Do the best you can and don't beat yourself up because you're limited. Like I I really think teachers we do martyr ourselves, ⁓ and we do beat ourselves up. ⁓ but we can do the best we can. I think delaying is the is the thing I would work on. Yeah. Paul, it has been a pleasure talking to you today. I it's I've really, really enjoyed this conversation and I'm so excited to have your chapter contribution be a part of this book. I think it's such an interesting ⁓ angle on on some of the topics that we're talking about. I really appreciate the opportunity. Today and the book and Growing Beyond Grades, it's been a good relationship and I I really appreciate it. Thanks for joining us. Remember, you can continue this conversation with Paul at our community gathering next Saturday, October 10th at noon Eastern. And if you'd like to help sustain the podcast, the gatherings, and the work leading up to our 10th anniversary book launch, please visit growbeyondgrades.org/slash donate. Thanks for listening. We hope you'll join us for the next episode of Grow Beyond Grades.