TRANSKRİPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.080 --> 00:00:04.000
Sam Altman and Elon Musk are trying to destroy each other.
00:00:05.519 --> 00:00:11.039
We should never pretend that these people are like all on the same side.
00:00:11.519 --> 00:00:16.480
When it comes to threats to their oligarchic power, they become surprisingly unanimous.
00:00:16.719 --> 00:00:18.960
If it is an oligarchy, I guess I'm thankful for it.
00:00:19.039 --> 00:00:21.839
The result is more speech, more political participation.
00:00:22.000 --> 00:00:25.839
If I wanted to weigh in on a column in 1994, what would I do?
00:00:26.000 --> 00:00:27.280
Write a letter to the editor?
00:00:27.679 --> 00:00:33.200
Private platforms, Facebook, said they would reduce circulation on our story pending fact-checking.
00:00:33.359 --> 00:00:36.079
Twitter altogether banned it and suspended our account.
00:00:36.240 --> 00:00:40.240
The paper founded by Alexander Hamilton could not tweet.
00:00:50.960 --> 00:00:54.479
Today, we're gathered to debate the question: resolved.
00:00:54.880 --> 00:00:58.399
Oligarchy has destroyed American democracy.
00:00:58.640 --> 00:01:02.320
I'm joined by our two debaters, Sarab Amari, the U.S.
00:01:02.399 --> 00:01:07.439
editor of Unheard, and a Moynihan scholar at the City University of New York.
00:01:07.760 --> 00:01:13.359
And also Robbie Suave, the senior editor at Reason and the host of Rising.
00:01:13.760 --> 00:01:18.159
Today we'll be talking for 90 minutes on the question of American oligarchy.
00:01:18.319 --> 00:01:27.519
We'll begin with three to five minute opening statements from both debaters, and then I will be moderating a discussion, and we'll close at the end with closing statements from each.
00:01:27.760 --> 00:01:30.400
And I'm your host, Leah Sargent.
00:01:30.560 --> 00:01:32.400
I work in public policy in DC.
00:01:32.560 --> 00:01:36.959
I'm the author of The Dignity of Dependence, and I'm a roving gavel for hire.
00:01:37.359 --> 00:01:39.680
So now we begin with you, Siraab.
00:01:40.560 --> 00:01:45.359
The motion that we're discussing today is grimly depressing.
00:01:45.760 --> 00:01:48.400
It's also unfortunately true.
00:01:49.599 --> 00:01:55.280
Our debate takes place in the wake of the most expensive primary race for a U.S.
00:01:55.359 --> 00:01:56.560
House seat ever.
00:01:57.040 --> 00:02:07.760
I'm speaking of Kentucky's fourth congressional district, which had been safely held by Representative Thomas Massey, a libertarian with whom I disagree on many issues.
00:02:08.240 --> 00:02:12.400
In fact, Massey's politics are closer to my opponents than to my own.
00:02:12.960 --> 00:02:25.919
But then Massey was primaried by Ed Golrain, a GOP candidate who made only a single pledge to voters to be more loyal to President Trump than the Maverick Massey had been.
00:02:26.639 --> 00:02:34.400
In a Democratic Republic, candidates for high office are normally expected to debate their opponents and to address an adversarial press.
00:02:34.960 --> 00:02:37.120
But Golrain ignored all of that.
00:02:37.280 --> 00:02:40.560
He declined numerous debate invitations from Massey.
00:02:40.639 --> 00:02:44.800
He likewise refused nearly all interview requests from the local press.
00:02:45.199 --> 00:03:00.960
He didn't have to debate, and he didn't have to explain himself to the media and the local community because he had the support of out-of-state mega donors who collectively poured nearly$20 million into political action committees running a stream of anti-Massie ads.
00:03:01.840 --> 00:03:07.840
Massey and his supporters tried to counter this immense pile of organized money, but they numerically came up short.
00:03:08.319 --> 00:03:09.199
And that was that.
00:03:09.360 --> 00:03:13.439
A handful of billionaires effectively purchased a congressional seat.
00:03:14.240 --> 00:03:18.240
There's no other interpretation, no honest one anyway, of what took place.
00:03:18.800 --> 00:03:20.639
This was an all-too typical case.
00:03:20.879 --> 00:03:31.840
Ever since the Supreme Court handed down its decision in Citizens United, treating corporate spending as protected speech, an avalanche of unaccountable corporate cash has swept elections at every level.
00:03:33.120 --> 00:03:49.120
To take a different example, in 2019, Uber, Lyft, and other rideshare apps splurged north of$200 million to defeat a California ballot measure that would have treated their gig workers as employees entitled to certain benefits and protections.
00:03:49.360 --> 00:03:52.159
I ask, is that democracy in action?
00:03:53.199 --> 00:04:02.080
My opponent today, I think, will insist that this is all hunky-dory, that the immense influence of organized money in our politics is just a form of free speech.
00:04:02.319 --> 00:04:02.960
Deal with it.
00:04:03.599 --> 00:04:09.120
But the greatest thinkers in the classical and Christian political tradition had a different name for this arrangement.
00:04:09.280 --> 00:04:19.759
They would have called it oligarchy, defined by Aristotle as ruled by a small clique of persons wielding power not for the common good of the whole, but their own private gain.
00:04:20.079 --> 00:04:26.959
America's founding fathers, too, were acutely aware of the danger of oligarchy, even if they didn't always use the word.
00:04:27.279 --> 00:04:35.439
They believed this could take form in a democratic republic, subverting the substance of self-government while retaining its trappings.
00:04:35.600 --> 00:04:49.920
Thomas Jefferson, for example, warned against the rise of, quote, a splendid government of an aristocracy founded on banking institutions and moneyed in corporations, riding and ruling over the plundered plowmen and beggared yeomanry.
00:04:50.160 --> 00:05:02.240
John Adams likewise worried that, quote, the rich, the well-born, and the able acquire an influence among the people that will soon be too much for simple honesty and plain sense in a House of Representatives.
Load full transcript
00:05:02.480 --> 00:05:18.399
Much of the history of the Republic, from the age of Jackson to the New Deal order, can be read as a battle to tame the undue power that a wealthy few can accrue under a market system unless that power is checked by good government and a vigilant civil society.
00:05:18.800 --> 00:05:28.079
If only electoral oligarchy, enormous sums spent by a few to sway elections, undercutting the principle of one person, one vote, were the only problem.
00:05:28.399 --> 00:05:31.920
But in the course of this debate, I hope we can discuss two others.
00:05:32.160 --> 00:05:44.079
One might be called market oligarchy, entire sectors of our free enterprise system, which I support, being dominated by a handful of firms, again undercutting consumer and worker choice.
00:05:44.399 --> 00:05:52.160
This in turn undermines democracy since it concentrates wealth at the top, and wealth will never stop being politically influential.
00:05:52.399 --> 00:06:16.000
And the third is informational oligarchy, control over knowledge that makes possible authentic democratic life, whether in the form of big finance swallowing many local newspapers and driving them to extinction, or a handful of billionaires unaccountably determining what we get to see through social media or artificial intelligence algorithms, a crisis highlighted by Pope Leo in his first encyclical.
00:06:16.240 --> 00:06:24.000
Right now, all three of these, electoral oligarchy, market oligarchy, and informational oligarchy, are heading the nation at once.
00:06:24.240 --> 00:06:26.399
Fortunately, we've been here before.
00:06:26.639 --> 00:06:44.879
Andrew Jackson, regretting that, quote, the rich and powerful too often bend the acts of government to their selfish purposes, defeated the Second Bank of the United States, an oligarchic institution that played a similarly anti-democratic role, even if old Hickory's solution left something to be desired.
00:06:45.120 --> 00:07:03.120
More productively, Republican and Democratic reformers throughout the 20th century took important steps to empower the American majority and limit the undue influence of, quote, a few ruthless and domineering men whose wealth makes them peculiarly formidable, as Teddy Roosevelt said of the Gilded Age.
00:07:03.360 --> 00:07:13.759
If I were to modify our proposition ever so slightly to make it less grimly depressing, I'd say that oligarchy has severely harmed, but not yet destroyed, democracy in America.
00:07:13.920 --> 00:07:18.959
Repair is possible, but first we have to acknowledge the scale of the damage.
00:07:19.199 --> 00:07:23.279
So I urge you at home to be realistic and support the motion.
00:07:23.519 --> 00:07:24.240
Thank you.
00:07:24.639 --> 00:07:25.600
Thank you, Sarab.
00:07:26.000 --> 00:07:27.439
Robbie, your ripost?
00:07:27.920 --> 00:07:28.399
Sure.
00:07:28.800 --> 00:07:33.759
Um I didn't uh write down my remarks, so I'll be brief in my response.
00:07:33.920 --> 00:07:45.519
I
associate the idea that oligarchy has destroyed our democracy, uh, most predominantly with Senator Bernie Sanders, who's an important left-wing intellectual and political figure.
00:07:45.680 --> 00:07:56.000
Uh Bernie Sanders just went on a tour uh across the country in the last year claiming that oligarchy has corrupted, harmed, etc., the nation we we love.
00:07:56.160 --> 00:07:58.560
Uh but of course this is not a new claim from him.
00:07:58.720 --> 00:08:08.079
He has actually been saying this exact same line that all that America has become an entrenched oligarchy uh since longer than uh I have been alive.
00:08:08.240 --> 00:08:11.759
And uh you and I are the same age and you're just a few years older than us, Sarab.
00:08:12.079 --> 00:08:13.600
He's been saying this since the 80s.
00:08:13.759 --> 00:08:16.879
He said in 1993, America has become an oligarchy.
00:08:16.959 --> 00:08:25.040
He said it in 1995, he said it in 2007, he said it in 2012, he said it in 2017, and he said it in 2018.
00:08:25.279 --> 00:08:39.600
So I would submit if the foremost public advocate of this idea describes all circumstances we face at any moment in American political reality as uh as resembling oligarchy, uh, it becomes a non-falsifiable theory.
00:08:39.759 --> 00:08:57.200
And also that the conditions that prevailed in the 90s are so unlike what we see today, specifically because the people he has in mind, Bernie Sanders has in mind and probably to some extent Sorab has in mind when they describe oligarchs are Jeff Bezos and Mark Zuckerberg and Elon Musk and others.
00:08:57.440 --> 00:09:00.480
People whose uh who have tremendous power and wealth.
00:09:00.639 --> 00:09:07.519
There is no denying that these are powerful and wealthy people, but whose wealth and power uh is not inherited.
00:09:07.679 --> 00:09:11.440
They didn't uh it wasn't gifted to them by their predecessors.
00:09:11.519 --> 00:09:13.039
Uh they achieved it.
00:09:13.120 --> 00:09:20.399
Uh almost every single one of them, nine of the top ten most uh richest Americans are all self-made millionaires and billionaires.
00:09:20.559 --> 00:09:22.240
There's just one family wealth.
00:09:22.399 --> 00:09:25.279
Uh they all created this in this time period.
00:09:25.360 --> 00:09:30.159
Uh they didn't exist when Bernie Sanders first referred to the concept uh of oligarchy.
00:09:30.399 --> 00:09:47.919
And most importantly, the the power that they have from this wealth, which stems from creating companies that serve Americans, that Americans and American consumers love and depend on and want, and have spoken with their market power to say we affirmatively like the things these people have created.
00:09:48.240 --> 00:09:54.720
Elon Musk and uh Mark Zuckerberg and Jeff Bezos will pass on their wealth to their descendants, to their families.
00:09:54.799 --> 00:10:00.799
They will not pass on their political power because this power comes from having created companies that serve us.
00:10:01.039 --> 00:10:12.240
There has been tremendous market-based destruction and competition in the sectors that they are involved in, particularly this tech sector, that I think the anti-oligarch people are so wary of.
00:10:12.399 --> 00:10:22.720
Uh I I don't think you can honestly say that these uh figures are entrenched monopolists when they're subject to such vigorous competition from upstarts and from uh each other.
00:10:22.960 --> 00:10:43.759
The the story of these uh these companies over the time period uh Bernie Sanders is describing is about uh uh antitrust government regulator people uh failing to predict the trajectory the market would go and having concerns about these companies and about these people, then immediately not borne out by subsequent developments.
00:10:43.919 --> 00:10:48.159
Uh I I will say that doesn't mean they have no negative impacts on our democracy.
00:10:48.320 --> 00:10:51.120
We can, of course, debate the corporate spending uh question.
00:10:51.279 --> 00:11:06.960
I don't like what happened to Thomas Massey either, although I chalk that up to one single factor, which is this man who I like and support and agree with 95% of the time, lost the support of Donald Trump, the single and only factor in Republican primaries.
00:11:07.120 --> 00:11:09.600
I think our political system has a lot of defects.
00:11:09.919 --> 00:11:23.039
Our democracy can is in trouble, mostly from defects of the system, of the political system, redistricting, the filibuster, winner-take-all elections, impossibility of third parties to develop.
00:11:23.200 --> 00:11:33.279
I would submit that none of these things are particularly caused by corporate power or the rise of the tech sector or the so-called uh oligarchs, whoever they may be.
00:11:39.840 --> 00:11:45.600
So, Rob, before what year in American history would you be comfortable saying America was not an oligarchy?
00:11:46.399 --> 00:11:58.240
I would describe a sort of curve of American history during which we had periods of intense oligarchic power that gave rise to various populist movements.
00:11:58.559 --> 00:12:04.159
Um so beginning in the Jacksonian era, there I mentioned the Second Bank of the United States.
00:12:04.399 --> 00:12:09.039
The Second Bank of the United States was uh conceived by the Hamiltonians.
00:12:09.200 --> 00:12:12.799
Obviously, the first bank was Hamilton himself, but the second bank was the Hamiltonians.
00:12:12.960 --> 00:12:16.480
And they it served a very important function in the new republic.
00:12:16.639 --> 00:12:26.639
What it did was it facilitated the flow of a disciplined flow of credit in a new economy, in a newly industrialized economy, all good, all fine.
00:12:26.799 --> 00:12:43.039
But it it raised the ire of many sectors of American society in the Jacksonian age because A, it was partially congressionally funded, about a fifth of its capital came from the US taxpayer, but it resisted any sort of democratic oversight.
00:12:43.120 --> 00:12:50.159
And it was seen to favor some merchants at the expense of others, um, especially uh incumbents over upstarts.
00:12:50.320 --> 00:12:55.519
It was seen as um a very arrogant institution in in that.
00:12:55.919 --> 00:12:59.039
And you had this obviously pushback from the Jacksonians.
00:12:59.120 --> 00:13:07.200
Jackson destroyed the Bank of the United United States, having at one point said famously, you know, the bank is trying to kill me, but I will kill it.
00:13:07.360 --> 00:13:13.279
Now the solution he came up with was to have lots and lots of state smaller state banks become federal depositories.
00:13:13.360 --> 00:13:14.639
I'll be quick with this story.
00:13:14.799 --> 00:13:25.279
But um, you know, he he came up with this idea, and it would th those state banks turns out they could be just as prone to corruption as uh and in some ways they were less responsible than the federal bank, you have what have you.
00:13:25.519 --> 00:13:42.000
But the idea that there is this, you know, organized money power, as it was called throughout the 19th century, that risks undermining the the small D democratic power gave gave birth to the Capital D Democratic Party in the form of Jackson and Van Buren's party.
00:13:42.320 --> 00:13:46.320
Um and it continued obviously through the 19th century in the Gilded Age.
00:13:46.399 --> 00:13:47.279
It was a huge issue.
00:13:47.440 --> 00:13:48.960
It was called the trusts, et cetera.
00:13:49.360 --> 00:13:50.960
So I am going to jump in here at the Gilded Age.
00:13:51.039 --> 00:13:59.840
I want to check when is the last region of, let's say, at least 10 years in American history as close to the present as possible, where you would say oligarchic interests were held in check.
00:14:00.159 --> 00:14:00.639
We're tamed.
00:14:00.720 --> 00:14:01.440
So I'm getting to that.
00:14:01.519 --> 00:14:34.240
So after the Gilded Age, with the reforms initiated by populists and progressives at the beginning of the 20th century, and then very much so in the New Deal order, you had after the after the World War II period, in the first three decades after World War II, I think you had a period during which not that you didn't have wealthy people, not that you didn't have very powerful and dynamic corporations, but that their power was countervailed by the power of other forces in society, labor unions, consumer co-ops, uh, antitrust informs, and all of those have gone away now.
00:14:34.320 --> 00:14:48.559
So I would identify, roughly speaking, that period of the, it's called the three glorious, uh the 30 glorious years typically, after World War II, as that relatively less oligarchic figure.
00:14:48.720 --> 00:15:03.039
Again, perfectly prosperous, perfectly productive and dynamic economy, but a little bit less nakedly oligarchic because other social forces were not so under the thumb uh of a few corporations and of relatively few very wealthy people.
00:15:03.200 --> 00:15:09.440
They had they had a kind of balance between them, exactly a kind of power versus counterpower.
00:15:10.240 --> 00:15:16.080
Robbie, you know, I think as a libertarian, you are interested in kind of this lively scrum across American politics.
00:15:16.399 --> 00:15:22.720
Do you feel like there are more lively rival centers of power today than Sarab gives credit for?
00:15:22.879 --> 00:15:27.840
Is there a hollowing out of the alternate structures for Americans to organize, except around money?
00:15:28.799 --> 00:15:33.519
I do think uh how good it is now can be underrated uh in some ways.
00:15:33.679 --> 00:15:40.080
I mean, we're talking about the effects of uh oligarchy or concentrated wealth on democratic participation.
00:15:40.399 --> 00:15:43.440
Uh it it does become a little bit of a question of definitions.
00:15:43.600 --> 00:15:45.919
What does it mean to be participating fully in democracy?
00:15:46.080 --> 00:15:50.960
And one of the our our voting rights have not been meaningfully curtailed.
00:15:51.039 --> 00:15:53.120
I don't think we're too much debating that.
00:15:53.279 --> 00:15:57.840
People are it's it's good that pe people, everyone under over the age of 18 can vote, and that's a good thing.
00:15:58.000 --> 00:15:59.759
So that right is very protected.
00:15:59.840 --> 00:16:01.200
So then what are we talking about?
00:16:01.440 --> 00:16:09.200
One other uh way you can very importantly participate in uh in the democracy is making your voice heard, is exercising your free speech rights.
00:16:09.360 --> 00:16:15.759
Uh the 20th century was uh not a time at which your First Amendment rights were always vigorously protected.
00:16:15.840 --> 00:16:18.639
Uh, we're we're doing some very useful history lessons here.
00:16:18.799 --> 00:16:32.960
We can go back to a World War I era where uh the court held that you could be jailed for protesting against the war, that that's where the fire in a crowded theater example actually comes from, that being against this war was like shouting fire in a crowded theater and thus could be prohibited.
00:16:33.200 --> 00:16:50.399
I mean, uh the decision that supposedly opens the door to all this corporate spending is Citizens United, is one in which the court said these filmmakers who wished to release a film that was critical of Hillary Clinton right before the election, the government tried to take the position that they could not do that.
00:16:50.639 --> 00:16:58.799
And then the the justices on the Supreme Court asked, Well, could you are you saying you could stop a book that was criticizing her as well?
00:16:58.960 --> 00:17:00.480
And the government said yes.
00:17:00.639 --> 00:17:06.400
And that's where they lost the Supreme Court on that one, because uh we understand that our First Amendment protects that.
00:17:06.480 --> 00:17:10.880
And that has also opened the doors to corporations, associations of people to do the same thing.
00:17:11.119 --> 00:17:16.720
I
call that restoring the possibility of people to participate in democracy by making their voice heard.
00:17:16.960 --> 00:17:25.519
I appreciate you bringing up Citizens United because it's actually one of the few cases I can point to in my life where in the middle of a debate, based on the arguments advanced, I changed my position.
00:17:25.599 --> 00:17:32.799
Um, and it was from thinking it was an unfair decision to thinking it was logically compelled by our commitment to free speech.
00:17:33.119 --> 00:17:49.759
But I think some of the concerns people have today are not about money speaking by putting material in front of the voters that they can evaluate for themselves, but by finding channels to power that are not accessible to anyone else and don't depend on persuading others in a democracy to go along with them.
00:17:50.000 --> 00:18:09.359
I would point most recently to the pardon of a number of wealthy people, but I'll pick the head of Nicola, the self-driving truck that only ever self-drove by being put on a hill and rolled and filmed at a tilted angle, where this man perpetuated a scam.
00:18:09.680 --> 00:18:13.359
He appealed for a pardon without really expressing remorse.
00:18:13.680 --> 00:18:21.599
I think it's widely suspected that his wealth and access played a role in getting the pardon, and he's back to more vaporware scams again.
00:18:21.839 --> 00:18:31.440
Has anything shifted in terms of how money speaks, whether it is trying to speak to the people to persuade them, or whether it's just speaking to one particular person?
00:18:32.000 --> 00:18:39.359
I think that you've presented a pretty uh compelling uh example of um money being used nefariously.
00:18:39.599 --> 00:18:46.319
The president, I think, unfortunately, I guess, has this unlimited pardon power that is in our founding documents, right?
00:18:46.400 --> 00:18:51.519
That again, this is a if you consider this a defect, it's a structural one we've had from the beginning.
00:18:51.759 --> 00:19:09.680
We have, unfortunately, uh elected uh people, uh, President Donald Trump uh pardon this person, and before him Joe Biden, who uh pardoned his own son and uh pardoned uh Anthony Fauci to stave off any inquiry of how COVID was handled and perhaps the research that could have made something like COVID.
00:19:09.759 --> 00:19:15.440
And I think that's a uh a grave uh moral failing and and a problem and an argument for limiting this power.
00:19:15.599 --> 00:19:21.119
Uh I but I don't uh necessarily see that uh a problem of uh corporate power, moneyed interest.
00:19:21.839 --> 00:19:29.279
It is true that uh people can use power to get something or to get money rather to get something out of uh the system and that is unfair.
00:19:29.359 --> 00:19:35.599
And if there are uh ways we can uh curb those abuses, I'm happy to explore them and I would be in favor of some of them.
00:19:35.759 --> 00:19:39.920
But uh I don't think that speaks to us being uh in an oligarchic form of government.
00:19:40.000 --> 00:19:47.440
Aaron Ross Powell Well let's sit with this example for a second, because it sounds like you're saying you'd like to curb those abuses mostly by limiting the discretion of elected officials, right?
00:19:47.680 --> 00:19:50.720
So how much one man can decide based on whose wisdom is the same as the same thing.
00:19:50.960 --> 00:20:00.559
Well I would hope my fellow man would not elect people who would abuse that power in such a way, but demo the democracy has spoken, and uh my fellow voters disagreed.
00:20:00.640 --> 00:20:01.279
They said that was fine.
00:20:01.359 --> 00:20:01.519
Trevor Burrus, Jr.
00:20:01.759 --> 00:20:04.160
Zerob, what do you want to do to sandbag the rich?
00:20:04.240 --> 00:20:09.279
Aaron Powell Well, I I I I do want to address some of the um claims that Robbie made.
00:20:09.440 --> 00:20:24.079
Um the first one is well, where are the arenas in which oligarchy, which he rejects as being a uh descriptive of our present, I get it that he described, he rejects that, but he says if it were a problem, you it would manifest in two areas.
00:20:24.240 --> 00:20:27.920
One is um at the ballot box, but we still have the right to vote.
00:20:28.079 --> 00:20:36.319
I think that's a a very kind of pinched or impoverished view of what full democratic life, democratic participation um should look like.
00:20:36.559 --> 00:20:46.720
So um if you think that the right to vote is all that matters, but you have a system in which not necessarily people can buy elections, that's rare.
00:20:46.799 --> 00:20:58.160
I'm not saying it doesn't happen, unfortunately it does, but more often the parameters of what issues get discussed, who gets to be a candidate in the first place, is intensely informed by money.
00:20:58.400 --> 00:20:59.839
So let me give you an example.
00:21:00.000 --> 00:21:21.119
Uh, in his new book, Senator Chris Murphy, a Democrat of Connecticut, tells us, and I didn't know this, maybe you guys did, but there's a um a room, a call room at the Democratic National Convention in Washington, a so-called call room where all Democratic members of Congress uh are obliged every few days, you know, to spend a few hours calling people.
00:21:21.279 --> 00:21:23.119
And guess who whom they call?
00:21:23.359 --> 00:21:27.359
They don't call, you know, average people, they call the the very wealthy.
00:21:27.440 --> 00:21:39.119
And the way he puts it is he's like, in the most part, if I I'm speaking to someone and they demand a direct quid pro quo, Senator, I'll give you$100,000 for your current campaign if you do this and that for me.
00:21:39.279 --> 00:21:41.440
Typically, he said I would terminate the call.
00:21:41.599 --> 00:21:44.240
Probably most members of Congress realize how shady that is.
00:21:44.400 --> 00:21:51.440
But he says, at the end of the day, these people have a lot more access to me, and it makes me uncomfortable as a lawmaker that they have
this kind of access.
00:21:51.519 --> 00:21:53.759
So just bear right to vote.
00:21:54.000 --> 00:21:59.759
I don't think for our founders, that was like the the the only sort of sine qua non of.
00:22:00.400 --> 00:22:03.279
Of a rich participatory democratic life.
00:22:04.240 --> 00:22:13.680
I could give other examples and I will about like kind of how the sausage of congressional uh sort of lawmaking and how that's affected by money, but let's leave it at that one for now.
00:22:13.920 --> 00:22:15.680
The other he mentioned is free speech.
00:22:15.839 --> 00:22:23.359
And he noted that in um earlier periods in American history there could be pretty draconian uh encroachments on free speech.
00:22:23.599 --> 00:22:52.000
I think what we're facing now in the form of tech oligarchy, the kind of informational oligarchy that I mentioned in my opening, is in some ways much more um insidious and sinister and subtle and harder to combat precisely because the the speech takes place on supposedly private platforms under terms of service where most users don't have, they're like Tolstoy novel length, and all you can do is agree or disagree, but they are effectively our public square.
00:22:52.240 --> 00:22:58.400
I personally experienced this when I was the op editor of the uh of the New York Post during the Hunter Biden laptop story.
00:22:58.559 --> 00:23:00.319
Um I won't litigate the story.
00:23:00.400 --> 00:23:03.119
It's not this is not about Hunter Biden or what he did in Ukraine.
00:23:03.200 --> 00:23:10.799
It's about the fact that private platforms, Facebook, said they would reduce circulation on our story pending fact-checking.
00:23:10.880 --> 00:23:16.880
There's no, even for a big newspaper, the fifth largest newspaper in the country by circulation, there was like no recourse for us.
00:23:16.960 --> 00:23:17.920
Like they did this.
00:23:18.160 --> 00:23:21.039
And Twitter altogether banned it and suspended our account.
00:23:21.119 --> 00:23:27.519
And about for about two weeks, the New York Post, the paper founded by Alexander Hamilton, could not tweet.
00:23:27.680 --> 00:23:30.640
Um, and by the way, the problem hasn't gone away.
00:23:30.720 --> 00:23:38.799
It's just now a lot of the right is at peace with the new ownership because he's seen uh he's perceived as being on their side.
00:23:38.960 --> 00:23:44.880
And but the the algorithm and what I get to see is still pretty unaccountable.
00:23:45.039 --> 00:23:51.119
And people in different ways experience similar um effective censorship.
00:23:51.279 --> 00:24:04.000
So, in all these areas, I think we have to have a a kind of a richer account of which authority can censor you or what goes into the moment when a uh a voter puts their ballot into the ballot box.
00:24:04.160 --> 00:24:05.920
Are there other factors that inform that?
00:24:06.079 --> 00:24:16.799
And I would say that lately electoral, informational, and market oligarchy have have warped these processes to the
point where a lot of Americans report they feel powerless all the time.
00:24:17.200 --> 00:24:22.079
May I address that example because I think it actually goes to a very fundamental uh disagreement we have.
00:24:22.480 --> 00:24:26.400
I remember that happening at the time you talked about changing your mind, watching Citizens United.
00:24:26.559 --> 00:24:32.319
I did feel a real challenge to my ideology when uh what happened to the New York Post took place.
00:24:32.400 --> 00:24:38.480
And I said, this is really devastating for those of us who say these platforms should be free to make whatever choices they want to make.
00:24:38.640 --> 00:24:41.920
These are consequential wrong choices they were making.
00:24:42.079 --> 00:25:01.599
Um what we learned subsequently is the extent to which uh not just this one, but so much of the bad moderation choices, the censorship, was pressed on these companies at the behest of uh federal, uh, of political actors, of FBI agents, of CDC officials, if we're talking about COVID, government actors.
00:25:01.680 --> 00:25:24.720
The emails between these people and the companies that have been revealed by the Twitter files and all that, the extent to which the moderators of the company were horrified, but afraid of what the government would do to them, either with uh explicit punishments or the implicit threat of punishment, you will be hauled before Congress and made to answer for why your platform is spreading dangerous misinformation and people are dying because they're believing your lies and you haven't taken more action.
00:25:24.799 --> 00:25:30.640
These are literal manifestos from Elizabeth Elizabeth Warrens on one side and some Republicans on the other.
00:25:30.799 --> 00:25:39.680
Um that that goes to the nature of the problem we're talking about, because I would expect in an oligarchy these leaders of these companies to have power over the government.
00:25:39.839 --> 00:25:44.640
In fact, what it seems like is that they're terrified of the actions the government threatened to take against them.
00:25:44.799 --> 00:25:57.599
I mean, Joe Biden threatened to uh limit Section 230, the uh the federal statute that shields the platforms from some degree of liability that so that you can't you can't sue Twitter if someone libels you on Twitter, that kind of thing.
00:25:57.759 --> 00:26:06.240
He said he would take that away, make it so the platform can't even operate uh if they didn't have different rules for censoring speech the Democrats at the time didn't like.
00:26:06.480 --> 00:26:17.200
Um I I think that's uh that's a very bad thing, but it has made me just much more of a paranoid libertarian about the power the government seeks to wield over these companies, not the other way around.
00:26:17.599 --> 00:26:27.119
Okay, let's sit with this example for a second, because I think both you know the Twitter shutdown, you know, the FCC leaning on whether jokes are in poor taste and people lose their
broadcast license.
00:26:27.200 --> 00:26:29.680
Like in some ways, this is setting up what you guys have talked about.
00:26:29.839 --> 00:26:40.640
We have here rival centers of power, where you have Elon Musk personally ordering changes to the algorithm, or the Twitter people before him doing it in concert with the government.
00:26:40.799 --> 00:26:43.920
Uh, in some ways, it sounds like what you want, Sarab, right?
00:26:44.000 --> 00:26:47.200
Here are two Titans fighting each other, right?
00:26:47.279 --> 00:26:51.839
Like a sperm whale and a giant squid in this bloody public way.
00:26:52.000 --> 00:26:54.160
Uh but I don't think you're very happy with it.
00:26:54.240 --> 00:26:54.799
So why not?
00:26:55.200 --> 00:27:07.200
So to complete my thought from last time around, the reason I'm not is because if the government attempts to censor me, I have very clear mechanisms for appeal, right?
00:27:07.359 --> 00:27:14.559
I can I can sue in court, I can do all sorts of all sorts of things, I can raise a uh I can use my free speech otherwise and so on.
00:27:14.880 --> 00:27:16.079
You can call Robbie to defend you.
00:27:16.400 --> 00:27:19.200
It's it's a it's a pu it's a public authority.
00:27:19.359 --> 00:27:23.200
What we're facing now, I think, is largely a kind of privatized tyranny.
00:27:23.359 --> 00:27:33.039
I recognize that there was, I think it's it's incorrect to say that all the censorship that took place in that period, and I would say has continued to take place is government directed.
00:27:33.519 --> 00:27:41.839
At the end of the day, the question is does the user have any structural recourse versus these institutions?
00:27:42.000 --> 00:27:49.680
Whether or not the per the force driving the censorship is a government official or it just the whims of a programmer and so on.
00:27:49.839 --> 00:27:51.519
And the fact is we don't, right?
00:27:51.759 --> 00:27:56.799
Right now, um both we were talking about this um and the write over here.
00:27:57.440 --> 00:28:03.759
Facebook and Twitter are really basically making it hard for journalistic institutions to get their product out, right?
00:28:03.920 --> 00:28:09.200
If you have a link in a tweet, you're much less likely to users or other users are much less likely to see it.
00:28:09.359 --> 00:28:12.640
Facebook, meanwhile, has completely downgraded news.
00:28:12.880 --> 00:28:17.519
So you only see a kind of slop of and I like some of that stuff.
00:28:17.599 --> 00:28:27.279
I like I like the the the the chef, you know, whatever videos or the cooking video or or or uh or the vet restaurant influencer videos, but that's all you see.
00:28:27.440 --> 00:28:28.559
Now, what's happened?
00:28:28.640 --> 00:28:36.079
A space that I think actually Twitter and Facebook used to be rich spaces for public dialogue have become purveyors of slop.
00:28:36.240 --> 00:28:39.839
That's made our public life unquestionably poorer.
00:28:40.000 --> 00:28:41.920
However, I have no recourse over it.
00:28:42.079 --> 00:28:46.720
It's a business decision of Mark Zuckerberg and Elon Musk and a handful of others.
00:28:46.880 --> 00:28:58.799
Um and it's so and it's not necessarily censorship, although it is in a way, when you when you um the the technical tame is you degrade a link algorithmically, you're censoring in a way, you prioritizing certain information.
00:28:58.880 --> 00:29:07.119
And again, even a powerful media institution has no recourse against them because they're you know pretty autonomous entities.
00:29:07.279 --> 00:29:13.519
So the the fact, yes, the fact of subgovernment in some instances involvement is it was disturbing and it came out.
00:29:13.759 --> 00:29:16.319
It was not the full scope of the censorship that happened.
00:29:16.480 --> 00:29:25.839
And the structural imbalance of power between all users and a handful of tech oligarchs and their programmers remains, regardless of whether or not government is involved or not.
00:29:25.920 --> 00:29:41.599
Aaron Powell Robbie, is Sarab right that if you're going to get bullied by someone, it's better it be the government, where you have due process rights, FOIA access, et cetera, than you know, Facebook, where you kind of go through your LinkedIn trying to figure out who works at Facebook who will unblock your account.
00:29:42.160 --> 00:29:43.279
I'm not sure that's true.
00:29:43.440 --> 00:29:45.119
I'm maybe that's true in some cases.
00:29:45.279 --> 00:30:02.960
Uh uh I using myself as an example, every time I had trouble um with uh Facebook for taking down something, I I've been able to correct that m uh you know much uh faster than I got uh the city of uh District of Columbia to uh correct the wrongful parking tickets they've issued me, that sort of thing.
00:30:03.200 --> 00:30:19.519
Um but speaking for the I I think we should consider what the what the landscape, what we would expect the landscape for speech uh on these platforms to be if we thought there's oligarchical control and they're using that in nefarious ways.
00:30:19.680 --> 00:30:26.480
And I I would submit that right now, I there are absolutely things I liked better about Facebook in 2015.
00:30:26.559 --> 00:30:28.799
Uh so Rob and I did talk about some of those.
00:30:28.960 --> 00:30:33.039
There are things I like less about Twitter now than I did before, and there's some things I like better.
00:30:33.200 --> 00:30:44.559
But broadly speaking, over the course of my lifetime, the opportunities for uh average Americans to participate in political speech have have uh expanded uh exponentially so greatly.
00:30:44.799 --> 00:30:53.920
If I wanted to weigh in on a column Ezra Klein wrote for the New York Times in uh in you know 19 uh 94, I'm six years old and I feel like weighing in, what would I do?
00:30:54.079 --> 00:30:55.279
Write a letter to the editor?
00:30:55.440 --> 00:30:57.680
Uh uh Honestly, how what would I do?
00:30:57.920 --> 00:31:10.319
Now you can there is
the in addition to all of the array of alternate and independent media companies, some of them conservative, that have arisen because of social media, because of these tech platforms, uh they're numerous.
00:31:10.400 --> 00:31:11.279
There's so many of them.
00:31:11.440 --> 00:31:12.799
There are so many on the left.
00:31:12.880 --> 00:31:15.519
It is uh it's become a healthier environment on the left.
00:31:15.599 --> 00:31:24.720
And then just you and your personal capacity, there are so many from Substack to YouTube to Blue Sky to uh to all of these media companies I'm describing.
00:31:24.799 --> 00:31:34.079
Uh what I'm seeing is a great flourishing, such that right now uh very powerful people uh are buying up some of the major TV uh networks.
00:31:34.240 --> 00:31:39.359
We're discussing the Paramount acquisition, those to CNN and CBS might be under the same ownership.
00:31:39.519 --> 00:31:41.359
That has people scooped, uh spooked.
00:31:41.519 --> 00:31:50.319
I would submit that that has never mattered less in American history because who cares if CNN and CBS have the same ownership?
00:31:50.480 --> 00:32:00.720
There is so much vigorous competition now across all of these platforms, YouTube itself, that uh that that would defeats the idea that it is any kind of oligarchy.
00:32:00.880 --> 00:32:06.559
If it is an oligarchy, I guess I'm thankful for it because the result is more speech, more political participation.
00:32:07.039 --> 00:32:08.480
So I I do want to take these on.
00:32:08.720 --> 00:32:15.519
So um the the it it's interesting that Robbie himself brought up consolidation in traditional media.
00:32:15.759 --> 00:32:22.880
Um it is obviously not good for um these enormous giants to merge.
00:32:23.039 --> 00:32:24.720
You know, I I respect Barry Weiss.
00:32:24.799 --> 00:32:34.880
We used to work together, but Barry Weiss thought across CBS, CNN, TikTok, and Paramount is that's too much Barry Weiss thought, you know, in a democracy.
00:32:35.119 --> 00:32:37.279
Uh everything within limits, right?
00:32:37.519 --> 00:32:42.880
Uh so so and by the way, you know, you said, well, you have access to all these other platforms.
00:32:43.039 --> 00:32:49.839
Actually, a minuscule share of Americans are on X, and even more minuscule share of Americans are is on Blue Sky.
00:32:49.920 --> 00:32:53.599
In fact, I don't I wonder if there's anyone left, but that's neither here nor there.
00:32:53.839 --> 00:33:00.240
So, like lots of older Americans, lots of Americans who aren't like plugged in media types aren't on these platforms.
00:33:00.400 --> 00:33:01.759
CNN and CBS is all they have.
00:33:01.839 --> 00:33:18.640
And if it's as if it's a single world view being uh pushed across a movie network and two TV networks and TikTok, that's an enormous amount of power that I think would have made uh it would have been first of all incomprehensible to a lot of the founding fathers and the figures in in our early republic.
00:33:18.720 --> 00:33:21.359
And so, and and should should make us uncomfortable.
00:33:21.519 --> 00:33:24.640
I mean, I I not even as a consumer matter, but as a democratic matter.
00:33:24.960 --> 00:33:37.519
So I kind of want to go into where this feeling of betrayal comes from, because you know, there was a period where there were three TV channels, and I had no expectation that I could get myself, were I alive on any of them?
00:33:37.680 --> 00:33:48.160
Um but in some ways we have higher standards for parts of media, that Twitter is meant and positions itself explicitly as a public square for all people, not primarily as a curator.
00:33:48.559 --> 00:34:00.079
Is the problem that the information oligarchy has gotten worse, or is the problem that they've promised us more and now failing to deliver it angers us more?
00:34:00.559 --> 00:34:20.000
I I think this goes to a a point that Robbie made uh in his first response, you know, his first statement, um, which is you know, Americans are voting with their wallets for products that they like, and that has made a a handful of people extremely wealthy, and that's with the source of their power.
00:34:20.079 --> 00:34:24.000
So, in a way, it's our consumer satisfaction that is their bottom line.
00:34:24.320 --> 00:34:39.920
So I would say you can like you can have products that Americans like and not want Elon Musk to exercise the amount of power that he exercises over public life, then not want um, you know, like an omni channel of Barry Weiss thought.
00:34:40.079 --> 00:34:41.519
Like the you can be.
00:34:41.920 --> 00:34:45.760
But isn't this less Barry Weiss thought than I would have gotten when she was Walter Cronkite?
00:34:46.320 --> 00:34:57.280
Again, each moment has its advantages and disadvantages, but I think Americans feel acutely powerless today and they tell pollsters all the time.
00:34:57.440 --> 00:35:04.000
And I think there is a point to be made that there is is it a 100% causal relation?
00:35:04.159 --> 00:35:26.639
No, but there is a nexus between the fact that um so much of our life is actually not richly democratically contestable, even though we have the apparent trapping still of voting and going on YouTube and so on, but that structurally speaking, I have so little power against a large employer, I have structurally speaking so little power against the tech platform.
00:35:26.880 --> 00:35:31.280
Um there must be, I think, some nexus and some political science positive.
00:35:31.440 --> 00:35:45.360
I realize that's debatable between that material condition of immense consolidation of power and wealth and relative to what the state that lots of Americans find themselves in.
00:35:45.519 --> 00:35:48.320
Um and again, we're not even getting into the other elements.
00:35:48.400 --> 00:35:53.679
Uh I I said there's a kind of oligarchy that's built into the market, right?
00:35:54.159 --> 00:36:05.360
But here's the thing the term oligopoly, which we get from the
economist Joan Robinson in the mid-century era, describes most most markets, uh, most sectors in the market today, right?
00:36:05.760 --> 00:36:10.800
It's not that there's one big player, it's often typically there are just like a handful of big players.
00:36:10.960 --> 00:36:14.239
And this was happening already in the late 19th century century.
00:36:14.400 --> 00:36:22.480
You know, British American tobacco controlled 90% of the tobacco market, Otis Elevator controlled 70% of the elevator market, and so on.
00:36:22.639 --> 00:36:36.639
And so when you have a situation like that, the kind of dynamic push and pull of the market that is supposed to ensure that the price mechanism is a is a perfect, pristine index of supply and demand.
00:36:36.800 --> 00:36:43.840
And I, as a consumer or a worker, if I don't like something, I can always find a better deal elsewhere, actually begins to break down.
00:36:44.079 --> 00:36:50.480
There, the um the the the price becomes uh an index of relative bargaining power.
00:36:50.559 --> 00:36:57.599
And if the relative bargaining power is so lopsided, you're gonna have really, really lopsided distribution of the social income.
00:36:57.840 --> 00:37:13.679
And uh that also will play out politically because lots of people, you know, are just barely getting by and their wages have been stagnant for the better part of two generations, and a handful of people can will force their will not just in the market, but also then in the kind of political sphere.
00:37:14.000 --> 00:37:20.719
I do want us to spend some time on how many players or how much turnover can you have and still have people feel like the game is rigged against them.
00:37:20.800 --> 00:37:27.599
I wanted to ask one more question about information oligarchy specifically to both of you guys, and then let's transition to this more market-focused question.
00:37:28.239 --> 00:37:42.559
It seems like in this question of who you're facing pressure from, the government or information titans, part of what seems to drive people's feelings of frustration as I see it, and I'm curious for your thoughts, is what tool you have to wield against them.
00:37:43.039 --> 00:37:48.239
People expect that up against their government or in collaboration with their government, they have voice.
00:37:48.800 --> 00:37:53.199
Up against a Twitter, a Facebook, they only have exit.
00:37:54.000 --> 00:38:02.639
Is that accurate and just in terms of what tools people have available to them and how that might influence how they feel about pressure that's coming to them from these different arenas?
00:38:03.199 --> 00:38:04.079
I think that's right.
00:38:04.239 --> 00:38:14.079
Um, like I said, structurally speaking, it used to be in the mid-century era, the period that I think we did tame oligarchy to a great extent.
00:38:14.320 --> 00:38:24.320
Americans were able to exert counterpressure through all sorts of mass membership organizations, political parties that were robust and not so beholden to donors, right?
00:38:24.480 --> 00:38:29.840
Because when you're not beholden to donors, you can pay attention to mass members, labor unions, et cetera.
00:38:29.920 --> 00:38:32.320
So all of these have been eroded since then.
00:38:32.559 --> 00:38:43.039
And it's me versus big whatever, big finance, big tech, et cetera, et cetera, with and and and the and the deals on offer is is exactly as you said, Leia.
00:38:43.280 --> 00:38:45.360
It's you know, take it or leave it.
00:38:45.440 --> 00:38:47.679
And in many sectors, there is no leave it.
00:38:47.840 --> 00:38:53.679
But that there's no option to do that because so much of my social life is now mediated by these platforms.
00:38:53.840 --> 00:38:58.880
I would it's like sort of like go be a hermit and unperson yourself is the is the only option.
00:38:59.280 --> 00:39:05.360
I feel like it's always my libertarian friends who tell us I'm undervaluing exit, you know, whether they're setting up seasteading or something else.
00:39:05.440 --> 00:39:07.760
So are people undervaluing exit?
00:39:08.079 --> 00:39:11.519
Yeah, well, and they're under I think they're undervaluing the companies uh to begin with.
00:39:11.679 --> 00:39:19.760
Again, so many there are so many media businesses, just businesses in general, that can only exist because these platforms came along.
00:39:19.920 --> 00:39:23.760
And I start to think, well, what are the solutions to the things Sorab is describing?
00:39:23.840 --> 00:39:28.880
Even if I thought, okay, would it be better if Facebook had slightly less more transparent terms of service?
00:39:29.039 --> 00:39:29.840
Uh sure.
00:39:30.000 --> 00:39:31.760
But uh who's gonna compel them to do that?
00:39:31.920 --> 00:39:57.039
Some regulatory board of uh of senators or people picked by senators, um, who I know from the ideological makeup of the kinds of people who staff these organizations will be progressive of orientation and will be um uh combative toward uh business in general and uh will uh micromanage these uh places in a way that uh many consumers will make the the service worse uh for uh the consumers.
00:39:57.280 --> 00:40:03.039
Um I the last thing I wanted to say in like the because we I keep trying to bring it back to the democracy part of it.
00:40:03.280 --> 00:40:17.039
And when you think of uh again the kind of power being wielded uh over these these entities, the tech companies we're talking about, the social media platforms, I mean I think it's useful to consider that in the last several elections, it's always something different, right?
00:40:17.119 --> 00:40:32.719
There was a major panic after 216 from the mainstream media said Donald Trump was elected because Facebook, to a lesser extent Twitter, mostly Facebook, was irresponsible about allowing too much content and gind up Hasyria, and that was Donald Trump's success.
00:40:32.880 --> 00:40:40.880
When Barack Obama had been successful on Facebook eight years
previously and used it to tremendous advantage, no one had complained about that for some reason, but I digress.
00:40:41.119 --> 00:40:43.920
Uh fast forward to now, uh it's not Facebook.
00:40:44.079 --> 00:40:45.039
No one cares about Facebook.
00:40:45.119 --> 00:40:46.639
It's it was the podcast election.
00:40:46.719 --> 00:40:51.119
It was uh Trump successfully uh using those modes of of uh communication.
00:40:51.440 --> 00:40:54.639
If it's always the means of Joe Rogan and given to Kamala, yeah.
00:40:54.880 --> 00:40:59.599
So if it's always something different, aren't we less afraid about monopoly then?
00:40:59.760 --> 00:41:08.000
Like the arguments that were being made about how powerful Facebook was to our election, it was a moral panic about Mark Zuckerberg that to in the years 2016 to 2018.
00:41:08.079 --> 00:41:11.519
Go read headlines from that time about how that's all that mattered.
00:41:11.760 --> 00:41:17.360
I I have that in mind when Sorab talks about how scary it is that Barry Weiss has not just CBS and CNN.
00:41:17.599 --> 00:41:21.119
And I'm just like, that doesn't matter, I just don't think that matters.
00:41:21.199 --> 00:41:23.360
I think that would have mattered in 1970.
00:41:23.440 --> 00:41:24.639
I don't think that matters now.
00:41:24.719 --> 00:41:27.519
And it's because of the rise of these so-called oligarchs.
00:41:27.840 --> 00:41:30.880
Okay, because I think this is a perfect transition to the broader market question.
00:41:30.960 --> 00:41:40.800
But I think a thing that really divides you guys is how much it matters that there's churn among the elite versus that still leaves an elite and a masses.
00:41:40.960 --> 00:41:52.480
So Rob, you know, maybe just give us your best case against market power, concentration of market power, because we don't see dominant firms dominating forever, I think.
00:41:52.639 --> 00:41:54.719
But that's not enough to allay your concerns.
00:41:55.280 --> 00:42:09.920
I mean, look, uh I don't deny that there's uh these sort of technological innovations that happen, and then yesterday's incumbent becomes a firm you don't remember even anymore, pushing a product that you don't use anymore.
00:42:10.000 --> 00:42:10.800
I I get that.
00:42:11.039 --> 00:42:18.800
But during long, you know, those period those technological sort of changes happen on a kind of a cyclical basis, right?
00:42:20.000 --> 00:42:27.280
You know, there's like the obviously the first industrial revolution, then you have like uh the the second, and we arguably we're in the fourth.
00:42:27.519 --> 00:42:36.079
But in between, you have long periods of time during which you have uh, you know, an oligopolistic market structure in most sectors, right?
00:42:36.159 --> 00:42:40.159
That's that was true in the late 19th century, as I said, and it's true today.
00:42:40.239 --> 00:42:45.199
The you know the book selling market is dominated by Amazon and it can will its way.
00:42:45.440 --> 00:42:48.639
And by the way, I I should know this is a kind of wonky debate.
00:42:48.800 --> 00:42:52.800
I am not an ant like a systematic antitrust person.
00:42:52.960 --> 00:42:57.519
The reason being that um actually big is often rational, right?
00:42:57.679 --> 00:43:06.079
In network effect industries, you don't want a hundred railroads serving 200 cities, you want three or four, same thing with factory.
00:43:06.159 --> 00:43:11.519
You can't because of increasing returns to scale, you never are gonna have a mom and pop tire factory.
00:43:12.159 --> 00:43:14.239
Tire factory looks like 16 armor scale.
00:43:14.320 --> 00:43:25.280
So, but with that being the case, because network effects and factory effects are are sticky, they're and durable and powerful, you're gonna have market incumbents.
00:43:25.519 --> 00:43:26.079
That's fine.
00:43:26.239 --> 00:43:42.719
But as long as their power is countervailed by other uh forces in society, the main one I I would emphasize here is not like welfare, which is often what conservatives think this kind of New Deal project is about, is like sort of top down redistribution.
00:43:42.880 --> 00:43:43.440
It's not.
00:43:43.679 --> 00:43:53.039
It's um by empowering workers through collective bargaining most notably to secure a larger share of the social income for themselves.
00:43:53.199 --> 00:43:59.360
And that's an ability for them then therefore to be first of all more politically participating, right?
00:43:59.599 --> 00:44:09.840
So you If you're if you are have you have two gig jobs and you you're barely making ends meet, you cannot be a an an Aristotelian political animal.
00:44:10.400 --> 00:44:10.639
Right?
00:44:10.800 --> 00:44:11.440
You're not.
00:44:11.679 --> 00:44:13.199
That's your time is limited.
00:44:13.360 --> 00:44:21.360
And if you're constantly precarious, you're not you're not becoming the full kind of democratic citizen that uh I think the American ideal demands of you.
00:44:21.519 --> 00:44:22.880
And so that's another aspect.
00:44:23.039 --> 00:44:29.599
So we're not talking now directly oligarchs putting their hand on electoral outcomes or information outcomes.
00:44:29.760 --> 00:44:44.079
We're we're talking about an economy in which so many people are so sort of desperate that they can't fulfill themselves as domestic animals, their family life, they can't fulfill themselves most importantly as political animals.
00:44:44.400 --> 00:45:01.519
There are ways to correct for that, but it just means that being willing to have an economy that is not a socialism, it's not like publicly own everything, but that you know, there are ways you can shift the balance of the social outcome so it's not so one-sided and you don't have a mass of an underclass that can't participate.
00:45:02.079 --> 00:45:08.159
Are there particular American unions you think are offering a model for broader unionization?
00:45:08.320 --> 00:45:13.119
Or would you look to Europe or other countries for what
this balance of worker power looks like in your ideal?
00:45:13.760 --> 00:45:25.440
I've come around to the view that the Wagner Act model, which we inherited from the New Deal, which as you know is different from most other industrial states, where you in you uh unionize shop by shop as broken.
00:45:26.159 --> 00:45:33.519
You know, now union um uh density, so the share of workers who can benefit from collective bargaining is stuck at six percent and has been.
00:45:33.599 --> 00:45:36.639
Even under Biden, who was pretty pro-union, it it didn't budge.
00:45:36.800 --> 00:45:37.679
There are reasons for that.
00:45:37.760 --> 00:45:41.280
It's like it's companies have gotten much better at union bus.
00:45:41.519 --> 00:45:53.119
I think there's also macroeconomic reasons for that, but at any rate, um and also by the way, I talk to business people who are like who hear my ideas about why it's important to have organized labor, and they say, hey, I'm with you on that.
00:45:53.280 --> 00:45:58.719
The problem is if my shop unionizes but my competitor doesn't, well, like I go out of business.
00:45:58.800 --> 00:46:00.079
And I that's kind of rational.
00:46:00.239 --> 00:46:00.800
I get that.
00:46:01.039 --> 00:46:22.559
So I do prefer what's called sectoral bargaining, which is you don't go shop by shop across an entire industry, you have you know a much more peaceful model of labor relations like they have in Germany, where once a year industry, government, and and and and labor meet, and they sort of set wages and working conditions, they take into account prevailing economic conditions, blah, blah, blah.
00:46:22.639 --> 00:46:24.559
And then so you reach a bargain.
00:46:24.639 --> 00:46:27.840
And if you want, as a worker to be very active in union, you can.
00:46:28.000 --> 00:46:40.400
But for most people, when they go to work, they just are protected by collective bargaining without needing to like shop by shop fight, which is creates all this sort of waste of ex you know, energy for both sides, including for capital.
00:46:40.639 --> 00:46:46.719
So um now we're guy sort of straying far from, but I think this still has democratic implications.
00:46:47.039 --> 00:46:49.840
Robbie, where are you on in whichever order you'd like?
00:46:50.159 --> 00:46:53.679
Sectoral bargaining, unions, Lochner v.
00:46:53.840 --> 00:46:54.079
New York.
00:46:54.320 --> 00:46:56.559
Uh I'll get to unions in a moment.
00:46:56.719 --> 00:47:09.199
Uh because uh the international comparison was brought up, I'll say uh Europe is uh some is a place that has decided uh yeah, there will be no oligarchical control of our tech companies.
00:47:09.360 --> 00:47:15.360
We will rewrite the terms of service, and the terms of service are that there will be no sharing of what we c classify as hate speech.
00:47:15.440 --> 00:47:23.840
There will be no criticizing of political figures, there will be no native tech sector, so to speak, because these people don't want
to accept the people who run these companies don't want to accept these kind of rules.
00:47:23.920 --> 00:47:31.760
Uh we this could very well come to our company if we didn't have the protections of the First Amendment, warts and all uh corporate spending uh and all.
00:47:31.920 --> 00:47:44.559
Uh in terms of the like the the union question, um again, I think this is getting a little far from democracy point, but look, I will say I know someone's a question about what rival centers of power uh create a fruitful tension in the world.
00:47:44.960 --> 00:47:50.000
I know someone uh who works for a media company, a media company that decided to unionize.
00:47:50.239 --> 00:47:55.440
This friend of mine uh opposed the unionization effort, does not want to be a part of the union.
00:47:55.599 --> 00:48:09.840
Um this person I know uh says that the people most uh militant about the union are uh left-wing activists uh who hold the company in content, in contempt, and are actually just trying to provide uh protect the least productive employees uh at the company.
00:48:10.000 --> 00:48:15.760
Their ideas are absurd, doesn't want any part of his paycheck going to support what they are doing.
00:48:15.920 --> 00:48:26.880
But this friend of mine does not live in a right-to-work state and so is compelled uh to give his money for their partisan political project, which he views as harmful to the company.
00:48:27.039 --> 00:48:28.000
I oppose that.
00:48:28.079 --> 00:48:32.079
Uh I think that is the opposite of democracy or freedom or whatever it is.
00:48:32.239 --> 00:48:34.639
That person should not have to be uh involved with that.
00:48:34.800 --> 00:48:37.920
I have no problem with uh private unions in a variety of contexts.
00:48:38.079 --> 00:48:53.920
If the workers decide that's the best thing that they should do, I certainly see the argument uh particularly for kinds of employment or that are labor intensive or where the jobs everyone is doing is very similar and it is dangerous, and unions have been an important part of our history, have no problem with them.
00:48:54.079 --> 00:48:56.079
But uh it I it should be voluntary.
00:48:56.159 --> 00:49:01.199
If it's not voluntary, it's coercive, and then there's the infringement on your participation in your labor.
00:49:02.480 --> 00:49:08.000
So I mean I think these are very familiar like Reason magazine anti-union talking points.
00:49:08.159 --> 00:49:29.599
Um but the fact is that first of all, it the reason Europe doesn't have the Europe does have annoying tech laws uh and regulations, but the reason they don't have giants is just simply because that they don't have champions, they don't have corporate champions, and their tech companies are very that their their countries are very small, right?
00:49:29.679 --> 00:49:41.199
So you need in order for for Europe to be able to compete at the scale of China and the United States, they need to really pull their pull themselves together and they
don't have that they're all they only have the antitrust mentality, which it as I said I don't share.
00:49:41.360 --> 00:49:45.679
But it's not because like uh those kind of speech things you're talking about are bad.
00:49:45.840 --> 00:49:47.599
By the way, they can be kind of exaggerated.
00:49:47.679 --> 00:49:55.840
Um sometimes I think the Americans have this picture of of Britain or Europe where it's like and any minute you say something and a police officer knocks on your eye, I think that's exaggerated.
00:49:56.000 --> 00:49:56.719
But sometimes they do.
00:49:57.039 --> 00:49:57.440
Sometimes they do.
00:49:57.760 --> 00:50:04.079
The Undersecretary of the State Department tweeted an example from uh Germany that was uh actually I I I hear you.
00:50:04.159 --> 00:50:06.880
Uh when I've actually looked at all these things, I find them more outrageous.
00:50:07.119 --> 00:50:07.599
I you're right.
00:50:07.679 --> 00:50:11.440
I think of them as like, yeah, yeah, but this person was probably like, oh no, it's bad.
00:50:11.840 --> 00:50:16.800
I mean, it's the only place I know where they're getting arrested for just with their eyes closed next to an abortion clinic.
00:50:17.119 --> 00:50:20.719
This this this was a a a uh like a minor side point I just want to make.
00:50:20.880 --> 00:50:30.159
It's like these are still democracies, they have slightly different traditions of free speech, but the reason they don't have big companies is not because of those, it's other reasons, but other failings I recognize.
00:50:30.320 --> 00:50:36.159
But the larger point is labor unions have never been more popular than they are now, right?
00:50:36.320 --> 00:50:42.239
So there was a there's a uh a Gallup poll, annual just popularity of various institutions.
00:50:42.480 --> 00:50:49.360
Labor unions are more popular now than they have been since 1963, or the mid-1960s, I want to say.
00:50:49.519 --> 00:50:50.880
Um, and why is that?
00:50:50.960 --> 00:50:55.840
It's because a couple of generations have gone by during which American labor unions have been hollowed out.
00:50:56.000 --> 00:51:07.199
And the way you hollow them out is by saying it's it's you know it's voluntary, then the the the sh the deep bargaining unit isn't either isn't formed at all or it's it's not robust enough to uphold the workplace.
00:51:07.280 --> 00:51:18.719
So that's why the union movement has always opposed um so-called right to work laws because it undermines the whole idea of we have shared solidarity and this is a workplace that's unionized.
00:51:18.800 --> 00:51:21.760
You can always company can always sort of sort of sidestep them.
00:51:21.920 --> 00:51:26.559
Um but at any rate, like the fact is unions are really, really popular, Ravi.
00:51:26.960 --> 00:51:28.639
Like hugely so.
00:51:28.800 --> 00:51:34.639
Um and I think that's part of this loss of sense of power and loss of ability to push back.
00:51:34.719 --> 00:51:37.920
That's you know, do you feel I'm genuinely asking this as a question?
00:51:38.079 --> 00:51:41.039
Do you feel this way about public employee union as well?
00:51:41.119 --> 00:51:56.880
Or do you share some of the reason magazine criticisms or the I I do I share so I think the public union union, in fact, there are there are contexts in which where okay, you have uh a public authority outsourcing some function to a private company, you know, garbage collection or something.
00:51:56.960 --> 00:52:03.599
And I feel like that's effectively they're facing the same thing as they would be in the in the private economy, even if they might be somehow quasi-governmental.
00:52:03.679 --> 00:52:08.719
So I but there are I do share like the idea of a and so did FDR.
00:52:08.800 --> 00:52:10.719
He was very suspicious of public public union.
00:52:10.800 --> 00:52:11.760
So I that's a different case.
00:52:11.920 --> 00:52:22.400
I'm talking about the private economy, but I'd like to ask you both, you know, where do you see new experiments with rival centers of power at uh oligarchic wealth, right?
00:52:22.639 --> 00:52:28.400
Because I think in many ways none of us at the table expect to see unions return in exactly their former form.
00:52:28.960 --> 00:52:35.599
But I'm also kind of curious looking around at the landscape of where do people push back against politicians who are wealthy against companies?
00:52:35.920 --> 00:52:46.800
Part of what I see are parasocial attachments to groups like Libs of TikTok, where people will kind of track very carefully the marketing for one company and then all in one agglomerated mass complain about it.
00:52:46.880 --> 00:52:52.639
Like I don't know if that's kind of one of the weapons you hope to see people wield more, right?
00:52:53.199 --> 00:52:58.719
Where do people organize outside of the agglomerative effects of money to make their voice heard?
00:52:59.119 --> 00:53:00.159
That's an interesting question.
00:53:00.480 --> 00:53:02.559
Well, I I maybe this doesn't quite answer it.
00:53:02.639 --> 00:53:15.199
I I will say, in part of the rival power structures conversation, we should never pretend that these people who uh were debating the extent to which they're oligarchs are like all on the same side and have all the same interests.
00:53:15.360 --> 00:53:19.119
I mean, Sam Altman and Elon Musk are trying to destroy each other.
00:53:19.280 --> 00:53:22.880
Um there's been feuding between Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg.
00:53:23.039 --> 00:53:32.000
These are these are companies that are competing very vigorously in terms of their product and what they're trying to achieve, and then also in terms of the personalities of the people uh running them.
00:53:32.239 --> 00:53:47.039
So and then also that they're they're then they're competing um on behalf of our country against a major foreign antagonist and adversary, uh, China, that I you know speak of not participating in democracy or in the economy.
00:53:47.280 --> 00:53:50.960
That describes the reality for the people who live who live there.
00:53:51.119 --> 00:54:00.960
So that that is maybe the last line of argumentation I adopt or people of my my views will resort to because you know I don't want to always just say, but China's coming to get you, so you got to get on board with this.
00:54:01.039 --> 00:54:20.880
But we haven't touched on that argument yet, and we're 53 minutes in, so we should come to that, which is it is of pivotal importance for the survival of like the human race and human civilization, for American uh uh tech leaders to outcompete are the what the Chinese government is doing.
00:54:20.960 --> 00:54:36.000
Uh, I love the Chinese people, I love the country of China, but its government is an evil organization uh that we we must defeat, and we should defeat them not through military confrontation, but in the same way that the United States defeated the Soviet Union, which is by having a superior economy.
00:54:36.159 --> 00:54:41.760
And uh and that that requires uh being happy about the general landscape for tech that we have right now.
00:54:42.159 --> 00:54:44.000
So uh I want to address both points.
00:54:44.159 --> 00:54:52.800
The first one that Robbie raised, and it's a good one, which is look, the the the leading capitalists, oligarchs, whatever you want to call it, don't agree among themselves.
00:54:52.880 --> 00:54:58.320
In fact, they're they're um ruthlessly at odds with each other when it comes to competition.
00:54:58.480 --> 00:55:15.840
Um I would accept that in part, but also point out that when it comes to their um shared interests, where it counts, right, uh in terms of confrontations with threats to their oligarchic power, then they become surprisingly unanimous.
00:55:16.000 --> 00:55:28.159
So for example, uh this no longer holds, but in 2023, 2024, companies that are very different, Trader Joe's, Amazon, and Elon Musk's SpaceX, right?
00:55:28.239 --> 00:55:31.039
These are ideologically cater to different people.
00:55:31.360 --> 00:55:38.960
Elon was beginning to become very conservative coded, whereas Amazon in those days was still kind of progressive coded, and of course Trader Joe's.
00:55:39.119 --> 00:55:55.280
However, they all teamed up on a lawsuit that would basically render the National Labor Relations Act, the governing the Wagner Act, the governing basic labor law in this country, federal labor law in this country, they all sought to render it, uh have the suit have the high court declare it unconstitutional.
00:55:55.519 --> 00:56:01.440
So that is a kind of coordination that happens with organized money and capital.
00:56:01.519 --> 00:56:09.599
Um, and in a context in which other sources of social power have been uh hollowed out or weakened, then it they can definitely push their will.
00:56:09.760 --> 00:56:12.639
I'll give you another example which brings us back to electoral.
00:56:13.360 --> 00:56:17.840
Before the next example, I just want to paraphrase that back because I think it was actually really helpful in clarifying the disagreement.
00:56:17.920 --> 00:56:20.079
And I want to see if I've got your argument right, Sarab.
00:56:20.320 --> 00:56:25.840
It sounds like you're saying, even though there can be ideological diversity among the elites within the moat, right?
00:56:26.159 --> 00:56:30.880
The thing they all agree on is they want the fight to happen within that moat.
00:56:31.039 --> 00:56:35.280
That they're preserving it, they're excluding everyone else, they do have different views for the country.
00:56:35.760 --> 00:56:42.000
And they compete and at that broad scale, they want it to happen within and among the conversation they're happening.
00:56:42.159 --> 00:56:42.719
Is that a fair statement?
00:56:43.119 --> 00:56:47.440
And I think I think by the way, I also grant to Robbie that they compete with each other sometimes.
00:56:47.519 --> 00:56:50.400
They as as businessmen and women, they compete with each other.
00:56:50.559 --> 00:56:57.440
But when it comes to maintaining their power, they suddenly become pretty pretty much team players.
00:56:57.599 --> 00:57:06.480
I'll give you another example that's very and it ties together both kind of market oligarchy and electoral oligarchy, which is um the crypto industry.
00:57:06.719 --> 00:57:24.639
So in 2022-2023, as you know, there was efforts to regulate the uh crypto industry, which is I think it is interesting, but it seems to me a class of highly speculative, unregulated financial assets over which there hasn't been much robust regulation.
00:57:24.800 --> 00:57:30.159
And it a lot of the upside seems to be captured by a few players and everyone else ends up holding the bag.
00:57:30.480 --> 00:57:41.840
And the crypto industry and its supporters, who are otherwise can be very divided, targeted the person who was driving that legislation, who's Senator Sherrod Brown of Ohio.
00:57:42.079 --> 00:57:46.800
And these are people who are, believe me, in the crypto world, they have all sorts of disagreements with each other.
00:57:46.960 --> 00:58:00.800
But nevertheless, 86 million went into anti-Shared Brown from Coinbase, 44 million uh million from the founders of Andreessen Horowitz, 25 million from Ripple and other players who are competitors of each of each other in the market.
00:58:00.880 --> 00:58:06.400
But when it comes to this, they put their money together and Sherrod Brown lost that race in 2024.
00:58:06.480 --> 00:58:15.840
And then at a gathering of industry leaders, um, the pro crypto senator Tim Scott of South Carolina said, after the applause when he went up, he said, Thank you.
00:58:16.000 --> 00:58:19.039
Thanks to all you all for getting rid of Brown.
00:58:19.360 --> 00:58:22.400
So, like, that is that not such a naked case?
00:58:23.039 --> 00:58:25.039
Whatever you think of the merits of the legislation.
00:58:25.440 --> 00:58:46.719
No, I'm going to ask the reason question to both of you
here, which is I think, you know, one of the pitches for crypto from the first time I encountered it in Neil Stevenson is that it precisely sets up a rival center of power to the government and to other sources of power by setting up an alternative fifty currency, something decentralized, untrackable, great for crime.
00:58:46.800 --> 00:58:47.440
So that's not always.
00:58:48.000 --> 00:58:49.199
Andrew Jackson would have loved it.
00:58:49.360 --> 00:58:49.519
Yeah.
00:58:49.679 --> 00:58:50.239
So I'm curious.
00:58:50.639 --> 00:58:52.960
No, he was suspicious of all speculative assets.
00:58:53.039 --> 00:58:54.079
He just believed in hard money.
00:58:54.400 --> 00:58:55.920
I'm curious both, Robbie.
00:58:56.000 --> 00:59:03.840
I've seen this bandied around as a promise for a while with am I actually feeling like it is developing as a robust civic rival center of power.
00:59:03.920 --> 00:59:05.360
Do you see crypto moving in that direction?
00:59:05.519 --> 00:59:08.480
And so, Rob, why don't the crypto bros make you happier?
00:59:08.639 --> 00:59:13.840
They're saying we want vibrant diversity and more alternatives to existing power and money.
00:59:14.079 --> 00:59:14.480
Robbie?
00:59:14.800 --> 00:59:30.800
Um yeah Yeah, I'm a poor libertarian, I guess, because I uh crypto is beyond my realm of expertise, but I will say that uh I see a real use for it and uh a need for it that people should uh consider more seriously when you're uh actually going beyond the shores of the United States.
00:59:30.960 --> 00:59:56.800
There are there are places in the world where the the currency, the financial system they're reliant on is is very unstable, very unreliable, has been uh uh subjected to uh uh pressures from uh uh actual oligarchs, from uh nefarious warlord type people, uh, for which this as a uh potential competitor and alternative will be a very good thing uh for people who want to start businesses or engage in financial activity.
00:59:56.960 --> 01:00:03.039
Uh i in the context of the US, it's right, it looks like gambling compared to going through the normal financial system.
01:00:03.119 --> 01:00:10.239
But if people want to do that with uh their own money, uh aware of the risks, I I think it's hey, it's your money, and that's up to you.
01:00:10.639 --> 01:00:27.760
Well, that means the the legislation in question would have was partly about greater accountability for uh the uh not necessarily just even the coins themselves, but for the exchange to to imbue them with at least as much sort of transparency as we have, you know, in the kind of regular, regular equity markets, but whatever.
01:00:27.920 --> 01:00:40.400
The the the reason to your bigger question lay of you know why I don't embrace them is because as far as I can tell, it's it's this mentality of anti-solidaristic exit.
01:00:40.480 --> 01:00:48.239
You know, when I first I first encountered crypto through a friend who is actually an early, and by the way, she was like, You should you should buy a thousand Bitcoin.
01:00:48.559 --> 01:00:49.840
I also missed out on this opportunity.
01:00:50.159 --> 01:00:54.480
And it was a dollar at the equivalent to a dollar at the time, and I was like, that's crazy, why would I?
01:00:54.719 --> 01:01:10.719
But um the the whole the more I looked into it as a kind of ideological project, the more I saw this idea that like, you know, uh centralized money ties you to the to the democratic whims of the grubby many, right?
01:01:10.880 --> 01:01:18.960
That you know, that therefore the money is devalued because government prints more of it to help the needy and blah blah blah, therefore you should try to exit through this.
01:01:19.119 --> 01:01:25.920
So I I'm very and I'm very suspicious of this kind of exit mentality because I think it's fundamentally anti-political.
01:01:26.079 --> 01:01:42.559
And rather than sort of contesting how things are spent or what what uh blah blah blah, it's a kind of uh a desire to leave the p the actual political community with its demands, with its cries of solidarity, with its cries of need, and sort of elevate yourself out of it.
01:01:42.639 --> 01:01:44.559
And so I see it as fundamentally anti-political.
01:01:44.960 --> 01:02:00.000
But is not is not exit itself uh such a is a form of healthy participation in our democracy, especially as our country is envisioned as a union of 50 states that all uh have some common framework, certainly, but also have room.
01:02:00.159 --> 01:02:10.960
I'd like to actually have them have more room for laboratories of democracy and experimentation with different policies, particularly on uh divisive national uh topics for which there is not clear consensus.
01:02:11.119 --> 01:02:12.400
I would let the states decide.
01:02:12.480 --> 01:02:16.400
I I think it's been uh uh a problem that we've uh given the federal government more power.
01:02:16.559 --> 01:02:17.599
It's not surprising I'm saying that.
01:02:17.679 --> 01:02:35.440
I'm a libertarian, and I I think that has uh created actually has harmed our political process because it feels more important to win every national election, because now everyone in the country will be forced to languish under the tyranny of Donald Trump or the tyranny of Joe Biden, depending on what your political valence is.
01:02:35.599 --> 01:02:51.920
Our founders envisioned a system where uh, well, well, that person has broad power and authority, but the the people of Tennessee will live differently than the the people of Florida or the people of Illinois or the people of Massachusetts, and we'll, you know, all come together to pr protect our dear nation from external threat.
01:02:52.079 --> 01:02:56.639
But on some level, if you don't like the policies of California, Texas is there for you.
01:02:56.719 --> 01:03:00.079
If you don't like the the policies of Arkansas, you can move to New York.
01:03:00.320 --> 01:03:06.639
And and that that is uh the healthiest
aspect of our democracy, and we should turn back more toward that.
01:03:07.199 --> 01:03:13.360
So I would say, first of all, that I love federalism for many of the reasons that you suggested.
01:03:13.440 --> 01:03:16.880
I I it's part of our system and it has all sorts of healthy aspects.
01:03:17.119 --> 01:03:22.079
The question is at what scale exit and from which authority of the federal government?
01:03:22.320 --> 01:03:28.159
One authority of the federal government that we've granted it is is is uh oversight over the money supply.
01:03:28.639 --> 01:03:41.199
Um, and so it it it's I don't see them as analogous to saying I am going to move to a different state because I have more conservative cultural politics, I want to be in Tennessee, or I'm more liberal, I want to be in California.
01:03:41.360 --> 01:03:55.840
It's I want to exit from our shared compact about how the money supply should be organized, which is still that whatever you might think of the Federal Reserve has this kind of democratic component and congressional oversight of the Fed, presidential appointment, et cetera.
01:03:56.000 --> 01:03:57.360
That's all political.
01:03:57.920 --> 01:04:07.599
Um, this idea that a form of unregulated, highly speculative asset will uh allow you to get out of that.
01:04:07.760 --> 01:04:10.800
First of all, it's ineffectual because you see it already.
01:04:10.960 --> 01:04:23.679
In some ways, uh crypto is coming under uh, you know, the government itself has had is is asserting some, notwithstanding the efforts that I mentioned and the demise of for now of Senator Sherrod Brown's career.
01:04:23.840 --> 01:04:25.039
It's it's not even possible.
01:04:25.119 --> 01:04:32.639
But insofar as it were possible, it strikes me as a desire to leave the compact at the federal level.
01:04:33.039 --> 01:04:36.239
I I just uh recalled something I wanted to address uh earlier.
01:04:36.400 --> 01:04:38.239
Maybe this will be a a good direction to go.
01:04:38.320 --> 01:04:46.880
Uh Sorab was speaking uh generally about um uh it, you know, arguments you hear about it being harder for people, their economic situations.
01:04:47.039 --> 01:05:15.119
Uh uh left populists and some right populists make these arguments about wealth inequality, and it, you know, it used to be easier to pay for you could pay for college, you could get a good job, you could start a family, you know, those kinds of concerns, which I I think some people, maybe even on my own side, shrug at those in a way that is unhelpful because I I do think in in some ways it it has gotten materially more difficult for people to in some circumstances, not in all circumstances, but to buy a house, to start a family.
01:05:15.280 --> 01:05:21.119
You know, childcare has gotten way more expensive, education has gotten way more expensive, people are delaying starting families.
01:05:21.280 --> 01:05:27.199
I think those are bad and are uh to some degree uh uh uh because of policy decisions.
01:05:27.440 --> 01:05:56.719
If I was actually to advocate for the oligarchy framework, I would not, however, say it's you know an it's an oligarchy in terms of a small, wealthy, elite, the kinds of people Bernie Sanders is talking about, but rather that just our system uh is is our our our wealth and all our policies is designed to entrench the interests of older Americans uh in terms of Social Security and Medicare, skyrocketing the medical costs that young people have to pay for, and that our politicians want to exempt them.
01:05:56.880 --> 01:05:59.679
Nancy Mace uh tr uh the other day uh advocated.
01:06:00.159 --> 01:06:02.719
For no taxes for senior citizens.
01:06:02.880 --> 01:06:11.280
I'm in favor of getting rid of taxes, but you cannot get rid of taxes solely for the class that is deriving all of the government benefits and make someone else pay for it.
01:06:11.360 --> 01:06:16.079
That's a form of communism where one class gets all the benefits and a different class pays for it.
01:06:16.239 --> 01:06:20.159
I think that's very harmful, but it's not the kind of oligarchy that Bernie Sanders is talking about.
01:06:20.480 --> 01:06:21.519
Marxism, gerontocracy.
01:06:21.760 --> 01:06:21.840
Yeah.
01:06:22.400 --> 01:06:24.880
I think it's something we should we probably all agree to some things.
01:06:25.360 --> 01:06:28.880
We could have another debate on the intergenerational war, and I would love to.
01:06:29.039 --> 01:06:29.119
Yeah.
01:06:29.440 --> 01:06:36.800
Mindful of the time, there are two big picture questions I want to hear you both address in kind of a, you know, if not fully lightning, at least a rapid round.
01:06:36.960 --> 01:06:44.719
Um and the first is we were talking about new technology in terms of crypto, but let's talk for a moment about new technology in terms of AI.
01:06:45.119 --> 01:06:54.480
Is this a fundamentally different kind of tech and different kind of concentration of power than, you know, squeezing people out of the car market?
01:06:54.639 --> 01:07:02.079
You know, the leaders of AI companies say, and I think truly believe, they're not just talking their book, that this could be the last invention.
01:07:02.239 --> 01:07:11.599
And to me, it feels a little bit like I'm watching a private Manhattan project unfold without the government having a lot of oversight over who's building nukes in their backyard.
01:07:11.840 --> 01:07:16.000
Is this of a different order, Robbie, than some of the other concentrations of power?
01:07:16.159 --> 01:07:20.880
Is it more susceptible to Sarab's critique, or is it basically on a spectrum with everything else?
01:07:21.119 --> 01:07:26.079
You always have to remember that these people are hype man for a product and they want the valuation for the product to be higher.
01:07:26.239 --> 01:07:29.840
And so they speak We genuinely think they might all die in the next five years.
01:07:30.320 --> 01:07:32.960
Well, these are highly um unusual
individuals.
01:07:33.360 --> 01:07:34.559
They are, but I think they're sincere on that.
01:07:34.800 --> 01:07:38.639
No, I think obviously AI is going to have a major uh impact on our lives.
01:07:38.800 --> 01:07:45.840
I think it will be uh s similar to the impacts that major developments in technology have had in the in the past.
01:07:46.079 --> 01:07:57.440
The internet uh itself, you know, going all the way back to, you know, innovations in agriculture that made it so not everybody in the world had to do backbreaking farm work as their main occupation, right?
01:07:57.599 --> 01:08:03.679
And and the arguments you hear against because there will certainly be categories of jobs that are deleted by this.
01:08:03.760 --> 01:08:06.800
There will be uh a marketplace destruction.
01:08:07.280 --> 01:08:22.000
We may have to, even people of my ideological thinking might have to concede that their government will have to do something to, in order for people to accept this and not vote against it like crazy, that there will have to be some kind of policies to not stall this technology.
01:08:22.159 --> 01:08:33.279
I just I don't think you can do that, or guarantee people employment, but uh some do some kind of wealth payment to people so that people who are gonna lose out and not being able to change what their job is.
01:08:33.359 --> 01:08:35.600
I think we might just have to get used to that.
01:08:35.760 --> 01:08:38.880
But we should always not we should never miss the force for the trees.
01:08:38.960 --> 01:08:55.439
This technology is going to make it easier for people to uh start new and different kinds of businesses that we can't possibly comprehend in the same way that uh the existence of social media has led to a flourishing in the uh alternate to the mainstream media ecosystem.
01:08:55.600 --> 01:08:58.319
Um this will have some kind of effect uh like that.
01:08:58.479 --> 01:09:01.920
And and we're gonna have to we're gonna have to build the data centers.
01:09:02.000 --> 01:09:04.720
I know people don't love them, but gonna have to have them.
01:09:04.880 --> 01:09:06.800
We don't have to have them with eminent domain.
01:09:06.960 --> 01:09:09.680
We don't have to uh confiscate people's property to do it.
01:09:09.840 --> 01:09:14.960
If it's true that they're raising uh electricity prices, they can pay for their own water and their electricity.
01:09:15.039 --> 01:09:19.520
Well, we have to mitigate the third-party harm so that people are not so knee-jerk against them.
01:09:19.760 --> 01:09:20.640
But we gotta have them.
01:09:20.800 --> 01:09:21.520
There's no way around it.
01:09:21.840 --> 01:09:34.720
So Rob Pete Hagseth went to war against anthropic and he appears to be losing, not just in the courts, but in that he's authorizing and has to authorize the NSA to use these supply chain risk tools because they're just that good.
01:09:35.039 --> 01:09:41.279
What from your anti-oligarchic set of tools is appropriate to confront these kinds of companies?
01:09:41.520 --> 01:09:44.479
I I'm anti-olligarchic, but I'm not anti-technology.
01:09:44.640 --> 01:09:50.960
I actually you'd be surprised that that last answer, I have a lot of shared ground with what Robbie just said.
01:09:51.119 --> 01:10:00.800
Um, even even Pope Leo, in his would I think largely misunderstood insofar as it was seen as a an anti-uh technology statement.
01:10:00.880 --> 01:10:02.479
It's not the church has never been.
01:10:02.640 --> 01:10:08.720
He said that it, you know, the church welcomes the automation of quote, arduous, repetitive, and dangerous work.
01:10:08.960 --> 01:10:11.039
And this has this has deep roots.
01:10:11.199 --> 01:10:12.560
It goes back to Aristotle.
01:10:12.720 --> 01:10:21.840
In the opening of the politics, Aristotle says, if shuttles could weave and harps play themselves, then masters would have no need of slaves.
01:10:22.079 --> 01:10:24.000
Now, for him, that was like a crazy fantasy.
01:10:24.079 --> 01:10:30.079
But now actually by the 19th century, we came somewhat closer to that, and and that's a process has continued.
01:10:30.319 --> 01:10:39.680
So I think it's automation is good insofar as it opens up time for people to be political, for people to be family-oriented, for people.
01:10:39.920 --> 01:10:41.039
So that's all fine.
01:10:41.199 --> 01:10:47.600
The question I think is about uh one, like how what is the programming that goes into them?
01:10:47.760 --> 01:10:52.159
What is the what is the sort of moral logic that's built into them?
01:10:52.319 --> 01:10:56.399
I think the oligarchy problem is that that it resists public input into that.
01:10:56.640 --> 01:11:01.279
And I think that's something that was raised in the new encyclical by the Pope, uh, Magnifica Humanitas.
01:11:01.600 --> 01:11:03.600
And second, the distribution of the benefits.
01:11:03.760 --> 01:11:13.600
I think at some point I economists disagree, but I side with the ones who say that this might be the thing that brings about like drastic reduction of work.
01:11:13.760 --> 01:11:17.439
Again, welcome, because toil human beings are not made for repetitive toil.
01:11:18.000 --> 01:11:18.479
Good.
01:11:18.880 --> 01:11:22.880
But um then how do you sort of mitigate against that?
01:11:23.039 --> 01:11:43.199
If it's if it's our human knowledge that the machine trawl to like create its own knowledge or to deliver its own knowledge, then all of us as the sort of living human beings have our owed debt compensatory debts, which is kind of a fancy way of coming around to I don't know what that would look like, but some sort of transfer like Robbie's talking about.
01:11:43.279 --> 01:11:46.319
So I should that was the question where we we probably least disagree.
01:11:46.640 --> 01:11:52.319
Yeah, so no, what I'm realizing is I'm going to pitch ISI on a two-on-one debate where I fight both of you on AI risk.
01:11:52.479 --> 01:11:56.800
But I'm really going to ask
you guys one last big picture question, then we'll move into closing statements.
01:11:56.880 --> 01:11:59.520
And I say that so you know to start assembling them in your head.
01:11:59.680 --> 01:12:11.119
And I will say that given the other thing I think you guys agree on is that it's important in a democracy for there to be lively alternate centers of power, even if you disagree about what constraints you're putting on the wealthy.
01:12:11.279 --> 01:12:20.479
I would love it if in each of your closing statements you give a piece of practical advice to listeners about building up alternate structures of power in their day-to-day life.
01:12:20.560 --> 01:12:21.600
So that's my request.
01:12:21.920 --> 01:12:25.760
But for my last question, we started with Bernie, I'm ending with Bernie.
01:12:25.920 --> 01:12:43.359
The millionaires and billionaires, you know, a critique that's often heard from some of, you know, your allies, Sarab, less so on your side, is that something has gone wrong when there's a billionaire in America intrinsically, that no one creates that much value in himself.
01:12:43.520 --> 01:12:45.520
No one should capture that much value.
01:12:45.680 --> 01:12:48.479
It can only come about through stealing or injustice.
01:12:48.720 --> 01:12:50.560
I've got a sense of where you are, Robbie.
01:12:50.720 --> 01:12:56.800
I'd like to start with you about why you disagree with this reflexive suspicion of billionaires, and I'm not sure where you are, Surah.
01:12:56.880 --> 01:13:01.840
So it has something gone wrong when a billionaire exists, and if not, why not?
01:13:02.000 --> 01:13:04.159
And then we're going to move into closing statements.
01:13:04.239 --> 01:13:04.800
Aaron Ross Powell Right.
01:13:05.039 --> 01:13:13.520
You can certainly acquire great wealth illegitimately, or or in ways that we should condemn, or even in ways that the state should take actions uh to purvey.
01:13:13.600 --> 01:13:17.039
If you're stealing from someone, you should be brought uh to justice.
01:13:17.279 --> 01:13:22.800
I would submit that that does not broadly uh characterize the class of people we're talking about.
01:13:22.960 --> 01:13:44.159
Uh Elon Musk sold uh or it was the chief shareholder in PayPal in the early 2000s and made a$250 million in profit from selling this technology, which we probably all used, which is uh greatly simplified financial transactions, uh the businesses, small businesses that can only get started because that kind of task was automated so efficiently.
01:13:44.319 --> 01:13:47.039
Think of the the great value to people that's created.
01:13:47.199 --> 01:13:54.800
He took that$250 million and invested uh$100 million in uh in uh creating Tesla and another$100 million in SpaceX.
01:13:55.039 --> 01:14:10.560
Um there's I think there's a real danger that if uh the kind of wealth tax that Bernie Sanders uh advocates uh to a kind of mass confiscation of people at a very high level, uh maybe someone like Elon wouldn't have had the spare cash to put into those kinds of endeavors.
01:14:10.640 --> 01:14:18.640
I mean, these people, yes, they you know, they buy yachts and they buy planes and they they flaunt their wealth, but they also um you don't see them retiring.
01:14:18.880 --> 01:14:29.199
They are working very, very hard to use the wealth they've earned to create more products that um broadly speaking we have come to uh appreciate and rely on and give us a lot of good.
01:14:29.439 --> 01:14:32.800
Also, you know, AOC was saying, right, you could never get to that amount of money.
01:14:33.039 --> 01:14:34.399
Well, Taylor Swift's a billionaire.
01:14:34.560 --> 01:14:36.399
I mean, there there are also people, J.K.
01:14:36.479 --> 01:14:37.680
Rowling is very rich.
01:14:37.760 --> 01:14:44.239
There are people who have gotten to that level uh also by uh benefiting people in a way that is not even controversial.
01:14:44.319 --> 01:14:46.560
So I would say it's it's obviously wrong in that context.
01:14:46.640 --> 01:14:50.159
Aaron Powell Sural, behind every fortune there is a great crime, yes or no?
01:14:50.800 --> 01:15:15.600
Here's how I would put it I would not say that there is a certain threshold beyond which people should not be wealthy, but I would say that um you know in the past, in the New Deal order that I celebrated, the mid-century order, some people call it social contract America, roughly speaking, you had very successful companies, and at the same time, the CEOs of those companies were not making hundreds of times more than the average worker.
01:15:15.760 --> 01:15:34.640
And I think that that's good not just because of other reasons that I talked about, that the economy is that where you're s so struggling to make ends meet prevents you from being a political animal because you're just trying to survive, but also because it brings in the buy-in of the of the of the of the two classes.
01:15:34.800 --> 01:15:46.159
It it creates a kind of class compromise and it makes less likely demands that I think none of us around this table wants to countenance, which is mass confiscation, you know, actually, actually existing socialism.
01:15:46.319 --> 01:15:47.119
I don't want that.
01:15:47.279 --> 01:16:02.079
But precisely for that reason, I think there should be sensitivity about whether or not, you know, the sort of people who are uh the the lowest rungs of a of a particular company, can they make it men's eat, make make ends meet?
01:16:02.239 --> 01:16:08.560
Can they live a decent, dignified livelihood working 40 hours a week or not?
01:16:08.800 --> 01:16:14.399
And so it doesn't matter what the sort of total amount of the top is, there's always going to be wealthy people, that's fine.
01:16:14.720 --> 01:16:19.840
But at the bottom, what's the level of insecurity and and lack of dignity?
01:16:19.920 --> 01:16:20.720
I think is the issue.
01:16:21.039 --> 01:16:28.000
So just to check, as long as Taylor Swift's
roadies all make a living family wage, she can make an arbitrary multiple of what they make.
01:16:28.079 --> 01:16:28.399
Is that right?
01:16:28.640 --> 01:16:29.840
I totally exactly right.
01:16:30.000 --> 01:16:30.159
Yeah.
01:16:30.560 --> 01:16:31.039
Well put.
01:16:31.439 --> 01:16:32.000
Very good.
01:16:32.319 --> 01:16:32.720
All right.
01:16:32.880 --> 01:16:35.119
I'm going to move us into our closing statements.
01:16:35.279 --> 01:16:37.520
You guys will both have about uh five minutes.
01:16:37.680 --> 01:16:42.800
Uh since we started and gave Sir Rob the first word, I'm going to give you, Robbie, the last word.
01:16:43.119 --> 01:17:00.960
Uh I'd love for you to sum up where you are on the question of American oligarchy and where you think we should go, both on the level of federal policy or anything else, and for viewers, what they can do to build up alternative structures of power, whether or not they're doing it to subvert American oligarchy.
01:17:01.199 --> 01:17:12.720
Well, first of all, I really enjoyed this debate and I and I it ranged far beyond the kinds of things that I thought we would talk about, which is just sort of election spending and that kind of thing, to become something very rich.
01:17:12.800 --> 01:17:17.439
And I really appreciated Robbie's sort of good faith, open uh participation.
01:17:18.000 --> 01:17:38.000
I guess I would say that uh fundamentally I'm still where I was at the beginning, where I think that that there are kind of structural conditions of oligarchy that you can map onto the classical definition of rule by a relatively few for their own benefit rather than the common good.
01:17:38.319 --> 01:17:42.079
And that that can coexist with democracy.
01:17:42.239 --> 01:17:59.199
You can have voting, continue to have voting, you can have a formal First Amendment, but that the material conditions to make it possible for you to really participate, really be fulfill yourself as a political animal, is hindered by this kind of organized money power.
01:17:59.359 --> 01:18:00.720
Um, I'm still there.
01:18:00.880 --> 01:18:27.760
And I would say, uh, you know, I think especially the part where I felt Robbie didn't really address it is I brought up multiple very concrete cases where an industry organized, despite their other disagreements with each other, the various bat barons in it in crypto or where have you, and they marshalled hundreds of millions of dollars to essentially kill the political career of a senator who had proposed the reform.
01:18:28.239 --> 01:18:29.520
That should make us uncomfortable.
01:18:29.680 --> 01:18:40.239
And I think I haven't, I ultimately didn't hear an answer to that part of my case, which is that's the electoral oligarchy aspect of it.
01:18:40.399 --> 01:18:44.079
Um I could cite many more examples of the kind.
01:18:44.319 --> 01:18:57.359
Again, like you know, in um in 1974, the total spending by candidates and committees and their committees in in elections
was federal elections was 160 million dollars.
01:18:57.520 --> 01:19:01.199
In 2024, it was nearly 16 billion dollars.
01:19:01.359 --> 01:19:04.640
And you might say, wow, that's because of an infusion of small donor money.
01:19:04.880 --> 01:19:06.000
In fact, that's not the case.
01:19:06.800 --> 01:19:10.479
Small donors made up only a fraction of 15% of that.
01:19:10.640 --> 01:19:12.479
Most of it came from large donors.
01:19:12.640 --> 01:19:16.720
So the sort of miracle of of small donors is no longer holding.
01:19:16.960 --> 01:19:22.720
It used to be, it used to be the case in in an early America that most of the donations were actually small donors.
01:19:22.880 --> 01:19:24.880
That's not the case today, despite what you might hear.
01:19:24.960 --> 01:19:29.359
And that, again, I think should make us it should discomfit us at least a little bit.
01:19:29.520 --> 01:19:43.199
What to do very briefly, I I I would still say the number one is a better distribution of the social income by raising up the bargaining power of Americans, not just in the workplace, but relative to all the various kind of private forces that can govern us.
01:19:43.439 --> 01:19:44.399
That's number one.
01:19:44.640 --> 01:20:05.920
I would put limits against financialization, which we didn't get into, but it drives a lot of the erosion of the real economy and of civic institutions like newspapers, because we know when private equity and hedge funds take ownership of newspapers, they don't often run those in the same way that actually other capitalists do, which is I want to sustain this thing.
01:20:06.079 --> 01:20:14.159
They run them, they manage them for cash flow, extract the real assets, leave papers either completely dead or shells of what they used to be.
01:20:14.239 --> 01:20:15.279
That's just one example.
01:20:15.439 --> 01:20:16.960
But there's others of the kind.
01:20:17.119 --> 01:20:18.880
I do think antitrust has a role.
01:20:19.039 --> 01:20:21.520
Like I said, I'm not a uniform antitruster.
01:20:21.920 --> 01:20:25.199
I don't have a general suspicion of all big companies.
01:20:25.359 --> 01:20:40.560
Big is often rational, but there are instances where you have a kind of total media conglomerate, for example, where lots and lots of the news that an American might encounter throughout the whole day is under the same ownership and editorial leadership.
01:20:40.800 --> 01:20:44.800
I don't think I would be as cavalier again as Robbie was, which is, oh, who cares?
01:20:44.880 --> 01:20:45.680
Well, there is the internet.
01:20:45.920 --> 01:20:48.159
Lots of Americans aren't on the internet still.
01:20:48.319 --> 01:20:53.039
Um, and I would last one, which I didn't mention, is just greater transparency for philanthropy.
01:20:53.199 --> 01:20:55.520
I think philanthropy is such a great word.
01:20:55.680 --> 01:20:56.800
Who's not a philanthropist?
01:20:56.880 --> 01:21:10.800
But and I think this might be somewhere we where we
agree, but the sort of NGO blob is another sort of baronic, you know, uh uh uh oligarchic structure that should we should be suspicious that we should be suspicious of.
01:21:10.880 --> 01:21:17.920
But the biggest one is the kind of electoral money aspect, which I I don't feel that Robbie really addressed as much as I I appreciated his remarks.
01:21:18.079 --> 01:21:18.800
So thank you again.
01:21:18.880 --> 01:21:19.199
Thank you both.
01:21:19.520 --> 01:21:25.520
And for ordinary citizens who want to get in the arena and build up alternate structures where they can start right now?
01:21:26.399 --> 01:21:27.439
You can start everywhere.
01:21:27.600 --> 01:21:31.199
I mean, uh you know, you can start in your workplace, you can work in uh start in your school.
01:21:31.279 --> 01:21:37.439
And again, that's why I said, although the motion is really grim, I would not sign up for it the whole way.
01:21:37.520 --> 01:21:40.159
I think we still have the greatest democracy in the world.
01:21:40.319 --> 01:21:43.359
It's damaged by organized money, but it is not destroyed.
01:21:43.680 --> 01:21:46.800
You know, I'm gonna modify the motion just a little bit.
01:21:46.960 --> 01:21:53.359
Um, and that shows you the things you can do are still quite lively, but they face serious adversaries as well.
01:21:53.760 --> 01:21:55.199
Robbie, where do we go from here?
01:21:55.520 --> 01:21:56.560
Where do we go from here?
01:21:56.720 --> 01:22:00.000
Uh I appreciate very much uh the remarks that both of you have made.
01:22:00.079 --> 01:22:03.199
This was a wonderful, uh nuanced discussion of these important topics.
01:22:03.359 --> 01:22:15.520
Um You know, I I again I I do come back to Bernie Sanders, who is the foremost uh advocate of this idea that we're living in an oligarchy, because then if we accept that, don't we also have to look to him for some of the uh the solutions?
01:22:15.680 --> 01:22:27.279
And and that's where I think even people who, in a very good faith and sincere effort, want to grapple with some of these problems must step back in relative horror at what uh is going to be wrought.
01:22:27.359 --> 01:22:30.800
Uh Bernie Sanders has proposed both of these policies in recent weeks.
01:22:31.039 --> 01:22:34.319
First, uh a pol a moratorium on all new data center construction.
01:22:34.479 --> 01:22:35.600
That's it, period, done.
01:22:35.680 --> 01:22:36.479
No more stop.
01:22:36.800 --> 01:22:37.199
Stop.
01:22:37.359 --> 01:22:38.319
Big stop sign.
01:22:38.720 --> 01:22:45.119
Then he proposed a 50% uh ownership stake for the American people in the AI companies, 50% uh effectively.
01:22:45.359 --> 01:22:54.880
Um these policies are contradictory because if I'm a 50% owner in these AI companies, uh data center go burr, we're gonna build them everywhere.
01:22:55.039 --> 01:23:03.439
Uh I think that goes to show you that the people uh grappling with this idea don't always have a good understanding of the policy or even the
technology.
01:23:03.600 --> 01:23:18.000
I mean, this has never been more evident to me than in the hearings we went through in 2021, 2022, 2023, somewhere in there, where Mark Zuckerberg and uh the CEO of uh Twitter at the time, Jack Dorsey and others are hauled before Congress.
01:23:18.239 --> 01:23:24.479
I think in in oligarchical economies like Russian, they're not the oligarchs are not often hauled before of the political actors, right?
01:23:24.560 --> 01:23:26.319
The political actors are at the behest of the oligarchs.
01:23:26.479 --> 01:23:36.399
Here the oligarchs are dragged before uh the the government and accused of uh ridiculous lies, accused of getting people killed because they didn't moderate enough or too much.
01:23:36.640 --> 01:23:40.399
They're they're getting uh conflicting and contradictory things put on them.
01:23:40.560 --> 01:23:43.760
Democrats saying moderate more, Republicans saying moderate uh less.
01:23:43.920 --> 01:23:55.279
I've never been more sympathetic to our s alleged oligarchs than watching them try to answer uh uh uh uh uh questions about how their technology works from people who are far too old to understand what a Facebook group is.
01:23:55.520 --> 01:23:59.600
Um so that uh that uh uh uh pushes me back um uh from that framing.
01:23:59.680 --> 01:24:04.319
And not just Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, another major articulator of this philosophy.
01:24:04.399 --> 01:24:15.279
Uh but when when she thinks of confronting oligarchy, she thinks of writing letters to Amazon about how it should deprioritize in its algorithm books that have a different view of COVID than she does.
01:24:15.439 --> 01:24:28.640
Uh there are very tangible harms to our liberty and and our participation in democracy, the ultimate uh subject of the of this debate that would be uh realized if the anti-oligarch people had got it their way or get more power.
01:24:28.960 --> 01:24:33.359
The damaged nature of our democracy, we could have spent a lot more time on that.
01:24:33.520 --> 01:24:37.199
I I do see it as democracy as in profound peril.
01:24:37.439 --> 01:24:39.520
I just I do not see corporate power as one.
01:24:39.760 --> 01:24:42.720
I I would certainly the amount of spending on elections is is bad.
01:24:42.800 --> 01:24:48.560
I would certainly put it on like a list of things that are happening that uh have not an ideal outcomes many of the time.
01:24:48.720 --> 01:25:00.560
But the major problems we have is that the two political parties have agreed to arrange congressional districts so that uh most members face very little action, they don't face competitive elections.
01:25:00.720 --> 01:25:06.880
And uh thus the primaries are electing more radical people in both directions than the people of the state would support.
01:25:07.039 --> 01:25:15.760
In some uh alternate uh Western government systems, if you have a political party that gets 6% of the vote, then you're going to have 6% of the representation.
01:25:15.840 --> 01:25:21.119
And third parties can serve a very important check on power, I think, in other countries.
01:25:21.359 --> 01:25:23.840
Our system doesn't allow for that.
01:25:23.920 --> 01:25:25.119
Uh I love our founders.
01:25:25.199 --> 01:25:30.079
I love the system they designed for the most part, but there are certain definite tweaks I would make.
01:25:30.159 --> 01:25:37.359
Uh the the filibuster itself prevents a lot of it makes it, has raised the bar for legislation to be made at all.
01:25:37.520 --> 01:25:48.560
You can think that's a good thing or it's a bad thing, but it is uh it is something that uh uh has made it harder to pass legislation that is, again, a function of what Congress has done, not a function of corporate power.
01:25:48.720 --> 01:25:54.880
So there are so many things that are non-ideal about our system that are causing people a lot of frustration.
01:25:55.039 --> 01:25:58.880
Um and I would advocate for those uh things to be resolved.
01:25:58.960 --> 01:26:06.319
In answer to your question, uh significant reforms to uh our our actual democratic system, not to how people spend money on elections.
01:26:06.720 --> 01:26:15.439
And for ordinary citizens who won't fix gerrymandering in the next six months, where do they start up building healthy, alternate centers of power in a democracy?
01:26:15.600 --> 01:26:17.600
Aaron Powell I think they can start there.
01:26:17.760 --> 01:26:21.199
I think they can start by advocating uh actual uh reforms.
01:26:21.359 --> 01:26:29.439
They can start by advocating for things like ranked choice voting that some uh cities have, or for uh the electoral college vote to be awarded proportionally.
01:26:29.680 --> 01:26:41.840
Things to fight the winner-take-all system that that make it so that everyday Americans say, well, I hate the Democratic Party, but the Republican Party is no alternative, so I have to vote for the Democratic Party, or vice versa.
01:26:42.000 --> 01:26:47.760
That's the loss of meaningful choice in our political system that's part of the system.
01:26:49.039 --> 01:26:52.880
Well, so Rob, Robbie, thank you so much for joining me today.
01:26:53.119 --> 01:26:55.760
I think it's clear you disagree on a number of things.
01:26:55.920 --> 01:27:00.239
Some of them, I think, at even higher degrees of intensity than what we've debated today.
01:27:00.319 --> 01:27:07.439
And were one of you in danger of becoming president, the other might spend a lot of soft money to prevent that from happening.
01:27:07.840 --> 01:27:17.359
But what I'm really pleased about is that as a small model for a pluralistic democracy, you guys could come in here and scrap, and I never even had to stand up and separate you.
01:27:17.680 --> 01:27:18.960
So thank you for joining us.
01:27:19.119 --> 01:27:23.840
And for everyone watching, I hope you go out and pick a fruitful fight with your neighbor.
01:27:24.319 --> 01:27:24.960
Thank you.