TRANSKRİPT 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: John is on X.
00:00:02
Speaker 2: At John Perlman.
00:00:04
Speaker 1: Right.
00:00:05
Speaker 2: Let's focus on this now. Very important moment. It would seem that the Palm Ridge Specialized Commercial Crimes Unit, two people appeared where they faced charges involving fraud, corruption, and money laundering. Both Ernest de Cajillo Munaghotla and Chaki Tsele are people who were managers at the Tembisa Hospital and The charges they face are connected to the well-documented looting of that facility. Hundreds of millions, literally, of public money lost in the course of that. Both of them granted 30,000 rand bail. So what does this mean as the cries for justice in regard to this, particularly with the focus on the life and murder of Babita Diokaran in the background and the foreground whenever possible? There are developments around Tembisa Hospital. How much closer does this take us to some kind of just outcome in terms of what has happened? Jeff Wicks is Deputy Investigations Editor at News24. First of all, in the many columns, the many articles, I should rather say, investigative pieces, he wrote about that. He laid bare what went on at Tembisa Hospital, and that was then captured in a really excellent book called The Shadow State, by Babita Diokaran. One of the finest, by the way, for the Sunday Times Literary Awards. Jeff Wicks, a very good afternoon and welcome. Two more people in court. How significant do you think they would have been in what happened at Tembisa Hospital? Good afternoon to you.
00:01:41
Speaker 1: Good afternoon, John. Yes, significant, I would agree. And that's somewhat tempered by the fact that all this looting took place between 2020 and 2023, and we're now in 2026. And even if you get the times wrong, no one can explain that disparity. Yes. It's important in a sense that It appears that the arms of the state are not only going after the profiteers, the ultimate beneficiaries of all of these contracts which were flagged by Bita Diokran, excuse me, but also from their enablers within. And the two men before court are a prime example of that.
00:02:18
Speaker 2: Okay, so they're enablers. Would they have been able to do that without people above them being aware of what they were doing? Unless, of course, they had sufficient seniority to create a space of insulation where nobody else would have been observing what they did. But I would have thought the fingers do point upwards as well, don't they?
00:02:39
Speaker 1: Absolutely. And I mean, these two individuals are linked to syndicate boss Stefan Govind Raju, who's an engaged in plea negotiations with the states, and I'm sure that the arrest of these two men has come off the back of that. In his plea negotiations, he also revealed that... Included in the people he was paying kickbacks and bribes to was the hospital manager at the time, Dr. Ashley Mtunzi. He's dead now, but I have no doubt that had he still had a pulse, he would have been in the dock with the other two today. It also beggars belief that the authorities can't go further up the chain, because when we talk about Timbisa Hospital looting, it was so brazen. In effect, they blew their goods and services budget, not for one month, not for two months, but for four years on the trot. And that had to have been condoned by people up the ladder. And that is where the authorities should channel their energy next.
00:03:34
Speaker 2: Jeff, would it be possible that somebody would plausibly argue, well, the fact that people higher up the chain didn't notice, didn't take steps, would not necessarily be corruption, but simply ineptitude, that these are people paid handsomely to manage hospital budgets, but really don't, can't, won't, whichever it is? Or do you think that the magnitude of it was so great that it simply couldn't be anything other than willful collusion?
00:04:07
Speaker 1: I lean towards the latter, John. You know, it is a defense that could be raised. But the net effect is the same. Two billion rand is still pulled out of a provincial hospital that desperately needs that money. Patients who go to Timbisa Hospital in the lowest ebb of their lives starve to death because there's no PPE or no equipment that was all supposedly delivered by these profiteers. So whether it's gross ineptitude, that's a best case scenario. And then that should give us even more concern because these are the officials who steer a budget in the region of 65 billion rand per annum. So that in itself is an issue, even if the authorities can't follow the money back to their bank accounts.
00:04:51
Speaker 2: So we've got Stefan Govind Raju who, and my mind keeps going back to the graphics that You and your team produced at News24, literally creating webs, showing the connection between individuals, people in the Tembisa Hospital, various company entities, many of them with no material reality to them except news. as a vehicle for moving money back and forth. Who else was a substantial player in this space that has yet to, I don't know if they, they certainly haven't seen the inside of the courts. I don't know if they've sat across a hawk's desk even.
00:05:30
Speaker 1: No. So Stefan Govindaraj was interesting. We linked him to at least 55 entities. The SIU went further and linked him to more than 90. So it really was industrial-scale extraction at Timbisa Hospital, and he commanded that syndicate. Now, in terms of a rand value, he was only paid in the region of 650 million rand. The person who profited the most is Morgan Maumela, nephew to the president from a previous marriage. He's on the hook for Tembisa Hospital spending of 820 million rand. So, you know, this does signify some progress, but there are a lot of people who still walk around free who deserve to be held accountable.
00:06:11
Speaker 2: Do you have an understanding? I mean, do these kinds of prosecutions work in stages? I mean, if they are not dominoes in the same domino line, surely you can investigate more than one syndicate. Yes.
00:06:26
Speaker 1: So what the hawks have done is they've split the syndicates into five individual work streams, and they're pursuing those streams. Govind Raju was just one stream. They went and put out to tender to financial services companies to actually go through the documents and the numbers. They didn't have the capacity to do that on their own. And also, we must also bear in mind that whilst this is progress, the SIU made criminal referrals for these same gentlemen some years hence. And we're only seeing their arrests now. And one has to ask the question, why does it take so long? And if people were held to account in a timeous fashion, perhaps we could stay the flood of corruption that seems to beset our public institutions.
00:07:09
Speaker 2: Let's stay with your last thought there, Jeff, and ask you this. I mean, you've said before, because we've chatted on a number of occasions before, When there's a development, we've plugged it back into everything you know about and what you've published. Do you think some of these syndicates are still operating in the public health space?
00:07:28
Speaker 1: I can tell you with absolute certainty that they are.
00:07:32
Speaker 2: And tell us what you derive that certainty from. Is that material that's coming? That would ruin the surprise, John.
00:07:38
Speaker 1: That would ruin the surprise. But no, it's safe to say that the tentacular reach of these syndicates is not yet completely known, but we'll do our best to follow the money.
00:07:50
Speaker 2: And just finally, I mean, the confiscation of assets, I'm not sure if I've got this correctly, but I think it was Mr. Chisele had surrendered a certain amount of money to the SIU in the case of, Hangwani Morgan Maumela, there's been a seizure of his assets, property and vehicles, which he's contested. Does that make a difference? I know it's part of the process, but presumably it's not a substitute for prosecution.
00:08:22
Speaker 1: No, and it never can be. Listen, my view is that every rand reclaimed for the Fiscus is a win. It never should have gone to them in the first place. And it was actually intended for the very deserving patients and staff of Timbisa Hospital, who were shortchanged in the scandal. That said, it cannot take away the stick at the end of this, and that is criminal prosecutions, because we live in a country of law and order, and our constitutional democracy ensures that we're all equal before the law. If you step on the wrong side of it, you need to be held accountable.
00:08:52
Speaker 2: Thank you so much. Jeff Wicks, Deputy Investigations Editor at News24.