TRANSKRİPT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:06.179 --> 00:00:09.900
Welcome everyone to DRI's conversation on one of the most
2
00:00:10.339 --> 00:00:14.199
important legal disputes to hit the desert in decades, Coyote
3
00:00:14.259 --> 00:00:17.399
versus Acme. Now, if you've seen the movie, you know
4
00:00:17.440 --> 00:00:20.320
that this is not your typical product liability case. We
5
00:00:20.359 --> 00:00:23.769
have a plaintiff who has spent decades purchasing products from
6
00:00:23.910 --> 00:00:27.070
the same company, repeatedly using those products in the pursuit
7
00:00:27.109 --> 00:00:30.370
of the same objective and suffering extraordinary number of injuries
8
00:00:30.510 --> 00:00:33.829
as a result. We also have a defendant that says, essentially,
9
00:00:34.270 --> 00:00:36.490
You bought a rocket power product designed to propel you
10
00:00:36.520 --> 00:00:40.320
through the air, ignored instructions, strapped it to yourself, sometimes
11
00:00:40.359 --> 00:00:42.939
with roller skates on, and then blamed us when it exploded.
12
00:00:43.420 --> 00:00:47.119
So naturally, we thought DRI members should debate this. Today,
13
00:00:47.140 --> 00:00:50.869
DRI member and product liability attorney Lindsay Lorimer at Macmillan
14
00:00:50.929 --> 00:00:53.829
in Toronto, Canada, will take the plaintiff's perspective on behalf
15
00:00:53.850 --> 00:00:57.250
of Wiley E. Coyote, while DRI national director and litigation
16
00:00:57.270 --> 00:01:01.229
attorney Trey Boren of Bradley Errant in Jackson, Mississippi, will
17
00:01:01.250 --> 00:01:04.950
defend ACME. And I, Dean Martinez, CEO of DRI, will
18
00:01:04.969 --> 00:01:08.689
do what every good moderator does, ask questions, stir the pot,
19
00:01:09.030 --> 00:01:10.650
and try not to get held in contempt.
20
00:01:11.790 --> 00:01:14.329
That's a very generous description of your role.
21
00:01:15.140 --> 00:01:17.200
Hey, I thought his role was to make sure nobody
22
00:01:17.239 --> 00:01:18.040
got disbarred.
23
00:01:19.040 --> 00:01:21.319
Well, that too, of course. But before we begin, a
24
00:01:21.599 --> 00:01:24.500
spoiler and warning to all of our audience. We are
25
00:01:24.519 --> 00:01:27.560
going to discuss the actual legal proceedings and the ending
26
00:01:27.579 --> 00:01:29.489
of the film. So if you haven't seen it yet,
27
00:01:29.730 --> 00:01:33.019
consider this your warning. And one more clarification is extremely
28
00:01:33.060 --> 00:01:35.849
important for all of our participants. Before we get into it,
29
00:01:36.340 --> 00:01:39.239
Lindsay and Trey are both defense attorneys. For purposes of
30
00:01:39.260 --> 00:01:42.739
this fictional role play, Lindsay is arguing the plaintiff side
31
00:01:43.079 --> 00:01:45.500
and Trey is arguing the defense side. So if you
32
00:01:45.560 --> 00:01:48.590
hear them take positions that sound very unlike them, that
33
00:01:48.670 --> 00:01:51.870
is the assignment, not necessarily their personal view. It's also
Load full transcript
34
00:01:51.890 --> 00:01:54.109
a good lesson for Lindsay. Don't miss the planning meeting
35
00:01:54.150 --> 00:01:57.989
next time, Lindsay. Let's start with an obvious question. Lindsay,
36
00:01:58.609 --> 00:02:01.909
you got Wiley E. Coyote as your client. Why does
37
00:02:01.950 --> 00:02:02.650
he have a case?
38
00:02:04.689 --> 00:02:08.849
Dean, because this isn't simply a case about a customer
39
00:02:08.969 --> 00:02:14.050
who misused a product. Wiley E. Coyote has spent decades
40
00:02:14.129 --> 00:02:18.729
purchasing products from Acme that repeatedly failed in catastrophic and
41
00:02:18.830 --> 00:02:27.020
remarkably consistent ways. We're talking rocket skates, explosives, anvils, rockets, wraps,
42
00:02:27.319 --> 00:02:30.960
you name it. And the key issue is not simply
43
00:02:31.689 --> 00:02:35.409
Did Wiley E. Coyote use the product? Of course he did.
44
00:02:35.849 --> 00:02:40.219
The question is, what Acme knew about these products, what
45
00:02:40.310 --> 00:02:44.159
risks it knew about, and whether those risks were addressed
46
00:02:44.379 --> 00:02:49.659
through design, warning, or other measures. Once we start looking
47
00:02:49.699 --> 00:02:52.680
at the facts through that lens, this becomes a very
48
00:02:52.719 --> 00:02:53.379
different case.
49
00:02:54.680 --> 00:02:57.379
That's a good point. Let's make the product's liability framework
50
00:02:57.460 --> 00:02:59.870
explicit here for all of our listeners. What is the
51
00:03:00.129 --> 00:03:03.710
actual defect theory here? Are we talking about a design defect,
52
00:03:03.780 --> 00:03:07.159
a manufacturing defect, a failure to warn, or some sort
53
00:03:07.199 --> 00:03:07.719
of combination?
54
00:03:10.099 --> 00:03:14.599
The fictional facts could support arguments in more than one direction.
55
00:03:15.080 --> 00:03:19.039
A design defect theory would ask whether the product's design
56
00:03:19.080 --> 00:03:24.240
itself was unreasonably dangerous and whether there was a safer
57
00:03:24.379 --> 00:03:28.830
alternative design, depending on the governing law. A failure to
58
00:03:28.889 --> 00:03:33.449
warn theory would focus on whether Acme adequately warned about
59
00:03:33.550 --> 00:03:39.490
known or reasonably foreseeable risks. A manufacturing defect theory would
60
00:03:39.530 --> 00:03:42.409
be different again because it would focus on whether a
61
00:03:42.449 --> 00:03:47.560
particular product departed from its intended design. And the recurring
62
00:03:47.620 --> 00:03:52.520
nature of the incidents makes the foreseeability question especially interesting.
63
00:03:53.620 --> 00:03:58.759
If Acme knew repeatedly watching this customer misusing its products
64
00:03:59.400 --> 00:04:02.879
in essentially the same pursuit, at what point does that
65
00:04:03.039 --> 00:04:08.250
misuse become foreseeable misuse, such that manufacturer has to account
66
00:04:08.289 --> 00:04:08.599
for it?
67
00:04:10.669
--> 00:04:12.069
Trey, what's your response?
68
00:04:13.389 --> 00:04:15.629
Well, first, I believe we could look at the facts
69
00:04:15.689 --> 00:04:19.779
through a completely different sort of lens. Wiley Cody is
70
00:04:19.839 --> 00:04:23.379
not an innocent consumer who accidentally purchased a toaster that
71
00:04:23.399 --> 00:04:27.870
caught fire. He repeatedly brought products for the express purpose
72
00:04:27.990 --> 00:04:32.029
of catching the roadrunner. He ignored warnings. He used products
73
00:04:32.069 --> 00:04:36.709
in increasingly ridiculous ways. And perhaps most importantly, he kept
74
00:04:36.730 --> 00:04:39.810
coming back. While he may be one of the most
75
00:04:40.069 --> 00:04:44.800
obvious assumption of risk plaintiffs in cinematic history, from the
76
00:04:44.819 --> 00:04:50.319
defense perspective, foreseeability does not mean every conceivable misuse becomes
77
00:04:50.360 --> 00:04:55.939
a design defect. Otherwise, manufacturers effectively become insurers against any
78
00:04:56.060 --> 00:05:00.899
creative misuse a determined customer could invent. We would still
79
00:05:01.110 --> 00:05:05.110
ask what the intended use was, what warnings were provided,
80
00:05:05.670 --> 00:05:09.290
how the product was actually used, and whether the alleged
81
00:05:09.310 --> 00:05:14.930
misuse was sufficiently foreseeable under the applicable law. And even
82
00:05:15.009 --> 00:05:18.779
if the plaintiff somehow does establish a defect, I'm still
83
00:05:18.800 --> 00:05:23.220
evaluating comparative faults. A jury may conclude there was a
84
00:05:23.279 --> 00:05:28.019
product issue and still assign significant responsibility to a plaintiff
85
00:05:28.439 --> 00:05:32.689
who repeatedly ignored warnings and used the product in a
86
00:05:32.790 --> 00:05:37.889
very dangerous manner. And perhaps most importantly, the defense gets
87
00:05:37.930 --> 00:05:43.470
to ask, where does the manufacturer's responsibility end and the
88
00:05:43.550 --> 00:05:45.290
plaintiff's responsibility begin?
89
00:05:47.069 --> 00:05:53.389
Except ACME knew what was happening. That's the problem. Well,
90
00:05:53.490 --> 00:05:53.810
I don't know.
91
00:05:53.850 --> 00:05:56.899
How exactly do we establish that? And I guess that's
92
00:05:56.939 --> 00:05:58.160
where the case gets interesting.
93
00:05:59.360 --> 00:06:03.160
And that's a good transition. Because for our DRI audience,
94
00:06:03.240 --> 00:06:05.800
this is where the movie starts becoming less about cartoon
95
00:06:05.819 --> 00:06:12.170
violence and more about something every defense attorney recognizes. Proof. Lindsay. Lindsay.
96
00:06:13.240 --> 00:06:15.620
One of the things I found fascinating about the movie
97
00:06:15.819 --> 00:06:18.560
is that the plaintiff has what looks like an overwhelming
98
00:06:18.600 --> 00:06:23.509
amount of evidence, years of products, injuries, and incidents, but
99
00:06:24.850 --> 00:06:29.110
quantity isn't necessarily admissibility. What is the plaintiff's strongest piece
100
00:06:29.129 --> 00:06:30.769
of evidence that you saw during the movie?
101
00:06:32.800 --> 00:06:37.360
The products themselves. You have the physical evidence. You have
102
00:06:37.399 --> 00:06:41.540
the history of what happened, and you have a pattern.
103
00:06:42.569 --> 00:06:46.810
One defective product might be an accident. Two might be
104
00:06:47.310 --> 00:06:51.709
a coincidence. But when you have decades of similar incidents,
105
00:06:51.949 --> 00:06:57.149
you start asking whether there's a systematic problem. And ultimately,
106
00:06:57.379 --> 00:06:59.980
that's where Project Sisyphus comes in.
107
00:07:01.439 --> 00:07:05.379
But that raises another issue. Products lawyers know all too well.
108
00:07:05.860 --> 00:07:10.970
Substantially similarity. Trey, does one incident involving an anvil tell
109
00:07:11.009 --> 00:07:14.189
us anything about a later incident involving rocket and skates?
110
00:07:15.290 --> 00:07:17.790
Well, not necessarily. And that is one of the first
111
00:07:17.990 --> 00:07:21.410
evidentiary distinctions I would make. If the plaintiff wants to
112
00:07:21.529 --> 00:07:26.529
use other incidents to show notice, defect, causation, or some
113
00:07:26.589 --> 00:07:29.610
sort of pattern, I'm going to ask whether those incidents
114
00:07:29.670 --> 00:07:34.939
are sufficiently similar in product, defect, circumstances, and mechanism of
115
00:07:35.079 --> 00:07:38.839
injury to be probative. An anvil incident does not automatically
116
00:07:38.879 --> 00:07:42.360
establish that acne's rocket skates were defective. And this is
117
00:07:42.420 --> 00:07:45.139
exactly where I'd be filing motions. The plaint can't just
118
00:07:45.180 --> 00:07:47.740
walk into the courtroom with a warehouse full of broken
119
00:07:47.879 --> 00:07:50.439
acne products and say, hey, your honor, look at all this.
120
00:07:51.370 --> 00:07:52.329
You need foundation.
121
00:07:52.689 --> 00:07:56.649
You need authentication. You need to establish what product caused
122
00:07:56.750 --> 00:08:00.889
what injury under what circumstances and whether the product was
123
00:08:01.029 --> 00:08:03.709
used as intended. And you also need causation.
124
00:08:05.339 --> 00:08:07.139
So this is one of my key questions for you, Trey.
125
00:08:07.459 --> 00:08:09.790
If you're defending Acme, what's your first move?
126
00:08:10.949 --> 00:08:13.790
Well, you know, I want to separate the emotional story
127
00:08:13.850 --> 00:08:17.769
from the legally relevant evidence because the emotional story is,
128
00:08:18.209 --> 00:08:22.310
of course, devastating here. Poor old Wiley has just gotten
129
00:08:22.439 --> 00:08:26.139
blown up over and over again for 80 years. That's
130
00:08:26.180 --> 00:08:30.199
a great movie. But in litigation, I'm asking what product,
131
00:08:30.680 --> 00:08:35.710
what warning, what
intended use, what misuse, what injury What
132
00:08:35.750 --> 00:08:40.149
medical evidence? What expert? What alternative cause? And can the
133
00:08:40.200 --> 00:08:44.860
plaintiff actually prove that this defendant caused this specific injury?
134
00:08:45.480 --> 00:08:48.360
But that's also the danger for the defense, Trey. If
135
00:08:48.399 --> 00:08:52.379
you focus so heavily on technical causation that you ignore
136
00:08:52.399 --> 00:08:58.389
the bigger story, you can lose credibility. A jury may hear, well, tactically,
137
00:08:58.470 --> 00:09:02.200
the plaintiff strapped a rocket to himself. but still wonder
138
00:09:02.340 --> 00:09:05.679
why the company keeps selling him rockets that explode.
139
00:09:06.750 --> 00:09:09.409
Yeah, that's a good point. And that's why the defense
140
00:09:09.490 --> 00:09:12.350
needs a story too. And the defense story here is
141
00:09:12.409 --> 00:09:17.429
not Wiley is a fool. It's Acme sells products. Customers
142
00:09:17.470 --> 00:09:22.490
have responsibilities. And a manufacturer isn't automatically responsible for every
143
00:09:22.549 --> 00:09:25.610
single consequence of every single conceivable use.
144
00:09:27.389 --> 00:09:30.600
So there we have our first major lesson. The plaintiff
145
00:09:30.620 --> 00:09:33.919
wants to tell the story of corporate responsibility. The defense
146
00:09:33.960 --> 00:09:37.299
wants to tell the story of individual responsibility and causation.
147
00:09:37.799 --> 00:09:40.620
And both sides are trying to make a complicated factual
148
00:09:40.679 --> 00:09:45.389
record understandable for the jury. Before we leave the evidence discussion,
149
00:09:45.450 --> 00:09:49.350
let's talk about Project Sisyphus. There's an important manufacturer side
150
00:09:49.389 --> 00:09:53.429
lesson here. The lesson isn't don't test your products. Responsible
151
00:09:53.470 --> 00:09:58.129
testing is essential. The lesson is to document testing responsibly,
152
00:09:58.690 --> 00:10:02.149
act on what you learn, and understand that internal documents
153
00:10:02.389 --> 00:10:05.039
may later become exhibits in litigation.
154
00:10:06.139 --> 00:10:06.659
Exactly.
155
00:10:06.899 --> 00:10:10.379
Testing can be a defense asset when it's thoughtful, documented,
156
00:10:10.539 --> 00:10:14.490
and tied to actual risk management. But if the company
157
00:10:14.529 --> 00:10:18.330
learns something significant and doesn't act on it or creates
158
00:10:18.389 --> 00:10:22.879
a document that makes the testing look reckless or misleading, well,
159
00:10:22.889 --> 00:10:26.080
then that document can become the plaintiff's favorite exhibit.
160
00:10:26.429 --> 00:10:26.960
And it does.
161
00:10:28.480 --> 00:10:32.460
And from the plaintiff's side, that's why discovery into testing,
162
00:10:32.980 --> 00:10:38.740
incident report, internal communication, and corporate knowledge can be so important.
163
00:10:39.419 --> 00:10:43.820
The question isn't simply whether a test happens. It's what
164
00:10:43.879 --> 00:10:47.100
the company learned from the testing and what it did
165
00:10:47.179 --> 00:10:48.259
with that information.
166
00:10:50.600 --> 00:10:53.580
Let's talk about settlement. Early in the movie, Wiley E.
167
00:10:53.610 --> 00:10:57.809
Coyote is offered $ 50, 000 and refuses it. Lindsay, as a
168
00:10:57.830 --> 00:10:59.769
plaintiff's counsel, was that a good decision?
169
00:10:59.789 --> 00:11:06.279
I'm going to say yes with an enormous asterisk. A
170
00:11:06.340 --> 00:11:10.919
settlement decision depends on a client's goals, the evidence, the damages,
171
00:11:11.259 --> 00:11:12.799
litigation costs, and risk.
172
00:11:13.620 --> 00:11:17.309
And Wiley E. had a very strong emotional reason for
173
00:11:17.370 --> 00:11:20.789
wanting his day in court. He didn't just want money.
174
00:11:21.289 --> 00:11:22.730
He wanted accountability.
175
00:11:24.090 --> 00:11:26.879
And that is exactly what makes him a very dangerous plaintiff.
176
00:11:27.460 --> 00:11:30.980
Because from the defense perspective, once the plaintiff has decided
177
00:11:31.159 --> 00:11:34.899
that this case is about principle, the subtle dynamics change.
178
00:11:35.360 --> 00:11:38.330
You can't necessarily solve a principle problem with a check.
179
00:11:40.029 --> 00:11:41.889
I can't agree more. And defense lawyers deal with this
180
00:11:42.110 --> 00:11:44.279
all the time. The client may be looking at a
181
00:11:44.320 --> 00:11:47.340
case through dollars and risk. The plaintiff may be looking
182
00:11:47.379 --> 00:11:50.159
at it through accountability. And the public may be looking
183
00:11:50.179 --> 00:11:53.399
at it through headlines. And the lawyer is standing in
184
00:11:53.440 --> 00:11:56.679
the middle saying, let's talk about actual exposure here, people.
185
00:11:57.940 --> 00:12:01.720
And I would add one more thing, Dean. The $ 50, 000
186
00:12:00.639 --> 00:12:05.059
offer becomes more interesting because we later learned that the
187
00:12:05.100 --> 00:12:09.360
case may be something much bigger than Wiley E. 's
188
00:12:09.639 --> 00:12:19.330
individual injuries. The alleged Project Sisyphus, conduct suggests intentional corporate behavior. Alleged.
189
00:12:20.129 --> 00:12:20.649
Good catch.
190
00:12:22.070 --> 00:12:22.830
Couldn't let that one go.
191
00:12:23.509 --> 00:12:25.889
And that may be the most defense lawyer sentence we've
192
00:12:25.929 --> 00:12:30.159
had all day. Now, we get to the courtroom. The
193
00:12:30.200 --> 00:12:33.639
plaintiff tries to introduce evidence related to Project Sisyphus. The
194
00:12:33.679 --> 00:12:36.580
defense challenges it. The judge excludes most of the evidence
195
00:12:36.840 --> 00:12:41.120
and ultimately dismisses the case. Trey, congratulations. You finally won
196
00:12:41.159 --> 00:12:41.419
a case.
197
00:12:42.379 --> 00:12:43.320
Well, thank you
very much.
198
00:12:45.019 --> 00:12:45.809
How does that feel?
199
00:12:46.730 --> 00:12:48.789
Well, it feels like I finally found a courtroom where
200
00:12:48.830 --> 00:12:50.789
the judge understands Rule 403.
201
00:12:50.789 --> 00:12:55.889
The plaintiff never got a fair shot.
202
00:12:56.929 --> 00:13:00.669
Lindsay, that's exactly the argument the plaintiff makes after the dismissal.
203
00:13:01.139 --> 00:13:04.279
But let's take the emotion out of it. Was the
204
00:13:04.320 --> 00:13:06.139
defense right to challenge the evidence?
205
00:13:07.240 --> 00:13:11.970
Absolutely. That's what defense counsel should do. The problem is
206
00:13:12.029 --> 00:13:15.809
that the legal process can produce results that feel very
207
00:13:15.889 --> 00:13:20.309
different from the underlying truth. The plaintiff believes Acme is
208
00:13:20.350 --> 00:13:24.070
responsible for decades of harm. The defense says the plaintiff
209
00:13:24.110 --> 00:13:29.659
hasn't established admissible evidence necessary to prove that case. Those
210
00:13:29.720 --> 00:13:32.019
are two very different questions.
211
00:13:32.919 --> 00:13:36.840
And that's important. A defense verdict or dismissal isn't necessarily
212
00:13:36.860 --> 00:13:40.990
a declaration that nothing bad happened. It's just a determination
213
00:13:41.029 --> 00:13:43.490
about whether the plaintiff met the legal burden.
214
00:13:45.090 --> 00:13:48.370
That is a useful distinction for our audience. The question
215
00:13:48.429 --> 00:13:51.549
isn't always, who do we believe? It may be, what
216
00:13:51.570 --> 00:13:55.889
can we prove? What evidence is admissible? Who has the burden?
217
00:13:56.409 --> 00:13:58.370
And what remedy is legally available?
218
00:13:59.409 --> 00:14:03.379
Although, I will point out that Wiley doesn't exactly respond
219
00:14:03.500 --> 00:14:06.620
to the dismissal by quietly accepting the ruling.
220
00:14:07.559 --> 00:14:08.679
I can't agree more.
221
00:14:08.720 --> 00:14:08.960
I know.
222
00:14:09.519 --> 00:14:13.120
He responded like any reasonable litigant by unleashing a six-foot
223
00:14:13.159 --> 00:14:13.919
cartoon rocket.
224
00:14:14.700 --> 00:14:15.480
Hey, now, wait a minute.
225
00:14:15.500 --> 00:14:17.039
That wasn't in my closing argument there.
226
00:14:18.759 --> 00:14:21.580
And this is where the movie takes a very interesting turn.
227
00:14:22.100 --> 00:14:27.110
The courtroom case is dismissed, but the controversy is not over. Instead,
228
00:14:27.139 --> 00:14:30.409
the dispute moves to Washington, D.C., and ultimately to a
229
00:14:30.409 --> 00:14:35.009
congressional hearing. The alleged Project Sisyphus program becomes central to
230
00:14:35.029 --> 00:14:39.110
the story. Trey, from ACME's perspective, What is the defense
231
00:14:39.129 --> 00:14:43.090
strategy now that we're in Washington, D.C.? Well, first, I'm.
232
00:14:43.049 --> 00:14:46.710
Going to completely change the battlefield. A congressional hearing is
233
00:14:46.809 --> 00:14:50.120
not a civil trial. The rules, objectives, and audience are
234
00:14:50.159 --> 00:14:54.200
completely different. And that's a major lesson for lawyers representing
235
00:14:54.259 --> 00:14:57.820
corporate clients. You can win the litigation and still have
236
00:14:57.860 --> 00:15:02.850
a serious reputational regulatory or political problem. In other words,
237
00:15:03.370 --> 00:15:06.330
the litigation outcome is only one part of the client
238
00:15:06.389 --> 00:15:11.289
counseling equation. Once allegations move into a public or governmental forum,
239
00:15:11.950 --> 00:15:15.299
the questions can expand from, can the plaintiff prove the claim,
240
00:15:15.960 --> 00:15:19.120
to what does the company actually know? What did it do?
241
00:15:19.419 --> 00:15:24.360
What will it say publicly? What will regulators, lawmakers, customers,
242
00:15:24.580 --> 00:15:26.659
and employees all think about what happened?
243
00:15:28.299 --> 00:15:32.889
Exactly. ACME may have won in the courtroom battle, but
244
00:15:32.929 --> 00:15:37.250
the underlying allegations aren't going away. And that's where I
245
00:15:37.299 --> 00:15:41.490
think the movie gives defense counsel a particularly useful reminder.
246
00:15:42.230 --> 00:15:47.029
Litigation strategy and broader corporate counseling cannot always be separate.
247
00:15:48.070 --> 00:15:50.610
The lawyer may need to help the client prepare not
248
00:15:50.690 --> 00:15:54.009
just for the next hearing or motion, but for the
249
00:15:54.070 --> 00:15:59.409
consequences of the story continuing outside that courtroom. And then
250
00:15:59.460 --> 00:16:00.820
we get the roadrunner.
251
00:16:02.080 --> 00:16:03.059
You mean the star witness?
252
00:16:03.600 --> 00:16:05.200
The planet's dream witness.
253
00:16:05.980 --> 00:16:08.299
The defense's nightmare witness, Trey.
254
00:16:09.480 --> 00:16:13.019
And perhaps the only witness in American jurisprudence whose testimony
255
00:16:13.059 --> 00:16:15.159
consists primarily of beep beep.
256
00:16:16.299 --> 00:16:19.950
Well, that also raises a fascinating evidentiary question.
257
00:16:20.620 --> 00:16:22.750
Yeah, I was thinking the same thing. Does beep beep
258
00:16:23.090 --> 00:16:26.009
satisfy the requirements of competent testimony?
259
00:16:26.029 --> 00:16:27.590
Yeah, I'm not going to touch that one.
260
00:16:28.549 --> 00:16:32.769
The important point is that Roadrunner's testimony changes the story.
261
00:16:33.250 --> 00:16:38.690
He confirms that he witnessed Wiley's suffering. But he also
262
00:16:38.750 --> 00:16:44.029
reveals something neither side really expected. He considers Wiley a friend.
263
00:16:45.139 --> 00:16:46.919
That even caught me for a loop, which brings us
264
00:16:46.960 --> 00:16:50.059
to one of the movie's more interesting themes. The plaintiff
265
00:16:50.220 --> 00:16:55.080
and the witness are not
necessarily enemies. The person Wiley
266
00:16:55.279 --> 00:16:58.379
spent the entire movie trying to catch is also the
267
00:16:58.419 --> 00:17:05.049
person who ultimately validates his experience. Trey, earlier, You were
268
00:17:05.069 --> 00:17:10.009
defending Acme, and when appropriate, the Roadrunner. But now Roadrunner
269
00:17:10.069 --> 00:17:14.099
is a plaintiff's star witness. Do you really represent both?
270
00:17:14.839 --> 00:17:18.339
No, only Acme. I was asked to represent the Roadrunner,
271
00:17:18.480 --> 00:17:25.430
but then I ran a conflicts check. And? He was already, well, gone.
272
00:17:26.130 --> 00:17:30.069
Oh, now that's not a robot nut joke yet. Let's
273
00:17:30.109 --> 00:17:32.859
pull this back to DRI, Trey. Give me three things
274
00:17:33.099 --> 00:17:35.819
a defense lawyer watching this movie would take away.
275
00:17:36.819 --> 00:17:37.640
Well, first, know your.
276
00:17:37.559 --> 00:17:40.240
Facts better than anyone. That is such a huge lesson.
277
00:17:40.660 --> 00:17:43.490
If your client has decades of product history, you need
278
00:17:43.509 --> 00:17:48.490
to understand all of it and not just the favorable incidents. Second,
279
00:17:48.750 --> 00:17:53.119
attack causation. Don't allow compelling narrative to substitute for the
280
00:17:53.190 --> 00:17:57.380
burden of proof the plaintiff has. And third, think beyond
281
00:17:57.420 --> 00:18:00.200
the courtroom. Your client may win the lawsuit and still
282
00:18:00.240 --> 00:18:05.640
face regulatory scrutiny, reputational damage, additional claims, or future litigation.
283
00:18:06.400 --> 00:18:09.640
Today's litigation strategy is often just one more piece of
284
00:18:09.680 --> 00:18:16.180
a larger business problem involving reputation, regulators, lawmakers, customers, and employees.
285
00:18:17.599 --> 00:18:19.829
Lindsay, let's flip this for a second. What are the
286
00:18:19.869 --> 00:18:22.670
three things that plaintiff's lawyers hope defense counsel miss?
287
00:18:25.329 --> 00:18:30.180
First, Don't underestimate the power of a story. A jury
288
00:18:30.220 --> 00:18:34.190
doesn't experience a case as a spreadsheet. They experience it
289
00:18:34.430 --> 00:18:37.630
as a story, and a technically strong defense can still
290
00:18:37.670 --> 00:18:41.750
struggle if it fails to explain the client's conduct in
291
00:18:41.789 --> 00:18:47.509
a credible way. Second, follow the evidence wherever it goes.
292
00:18:48.230 --> 00:18:53.410
The original case was about defective products. The investigation uncovered
293
00:18:53.519 --> 00:19:01.279
something potentially much larger. If discovery points towards corporate knowledge, testing, notice,
294
00:19:01.519 --> 00:19:05.380
or other conduct, don't assume the case will remain confined
295
00:19:05.420 --> 00:19:09.940
to the original theory. And third, understand what your client
296
00:19:10.200 --> 00:19:15.789
actually wants. Wiley didn't
simply want money. He wanted someone
297
00:19:15.849 --> 00:19:19.789
to acknowledge what happened to him. This matters when you're
298
00:19:19.809 --> 00:19:25.029
evaluating settlement, trial strategy, and what success actually means.
299
00:19:26.839 --> 00:19:29.819
Absolutely. And perhaps the biggest lesson is that litigation rarely
300
00:19:29.880 --> 00:19:33.299
stays as simple as it looks at the beginning. A
301
00:19:33.339 --> 00:19:37.420
product case becoming a corporate investigation, a settlement discussion becoming
302
00:19:37.460 --> 00:19:41.180
a trial, a trial becoming a congressional hearing, and one
303
00:19:41.240 --> 00:19:45.029
very fast bird becomes a star witness. We're going to
304
00:19:45.049 --> 00:19:49.809
finish with a lightning round. One sentence answers. Question one, Lindsay.
305
00:19:50.170 --> 00:19:50.750
who's your client?
306
00:19:51.730 --> 00:19:52.950
Wiley E. Coyote.
307
00:19:53.630 --> 00:19:53.930
Trey?
308
00:19:54.990 --> 00:19:55.809
Acme Corporation.
309
00:19:56.769 --> 00:19:58.569
Who's the most dangerous witness, Lindsay?
310
00:19:59.609 --> 00:20:00.130
Roadrunner.
311
00:20:00.910 --> 00:20:01.210
Trey?
312
00:20:02.230 --> 00:20:03.279
Foghorn Leghorn.
313
00:20:04.730 --> 00:20:06.480
Most important piece of evidence, Lindsay?
314
00:20:07.299 --> 00:20:08.880
The history of the products, Dean.
315
00:20:09.839 --> 00:20:10.119
Trey?
316
00:20:11.079 --> 00:20:12.299
Definitely the instructions.
317
00:20:13.319 --> 00:20:16.880
And what do you guys see as the biggest litigation mistake? Lindsay?
318
00:20:17.059 --> 00:20:18.619
Underestimating the defendant.
319
00:20:19.319 --> 00:20:19.619
Trey?
320
00:20:20.920 --> 00:20:21.920
Underestimating the plaintiff.
321
00:20:23.180 --> 00:20:25.730
Fair. And finally, a question I think a lot of
322
00:20:25.750 --> 00:20:29.970
people are asking, should Wiley and Coyote have taken the $ 50, 000 offer?
323
00:20:30.990 --> 00:20:32.009
Absolutely not.
324
00:20:34.190 --> 00:20:35.089
Absolutely yes.
325
00:20:36.130 --> 00:20:39.309
Of course. And there you have it. We have resolved
326
00:20:39.470 --> 00:20:44.609
absolutely nothing, which means we've successfully recreated modern litigation. Lindsay
327
00:20:44.829 --> 00:20:46.849
and Trey, thank you so much for joining us and
328
00:20:46.869 --> 00:20:48.690
giving us your time. We know how busy you are
329
00:20:48.730 --> 00:20:51.049
and thank you for everything you do for DRI. And
330
00:20:51.069 --> 00:20:55.880
thanks to everyone for listening to Coyote versus Acme. Maybe
331
00:20:55.920 --> 00:20:58.160
a comedy, but it gives us a surprising, useful way
332
00:20:58.200 --> 00:21:03.019
to think about some very real questions in litigation. Evidence, causation,
333
00:21:03.400 --> 00:21:08.779
client expectations, settlement, corporate liability, witness strategy, And what happens
334
00:21:08.819 --> 00:21:11.640
when a legal story becomes bigger than the lawsuit itself?
335
00:21:12.259 --> 00:21:16.400
For DRI members, those are questions that don't require a desert,
336
00:21:16.740 --> 00:21:20.029
a roadrunner, or a box of Acme explosives to become relevant.
337
00:21:20.509 --> 00:21:23.109
Although if this case does involve an Acme rocket, please
338
00:21:23.170 --> 00:21:27.369
call your defense lawyer immediately. Stay tuned for more content
339
00:21:27.410 --> 00:21:32.109
like this and check your DRI's on-demand library at mydri.org
340
00:21:32.230 --> 00:21:35.789
forward slash on-demand for robust online learning experience designed to
341
00:21:35.829 --> 00:21:39.349
support civil defense attorneys and litigation professionals at every stage
342
00:21:39.730 --> 00:21:43.509
of their career. Explore a wide selection of programs, including
343
00:21:43.589 --> 00:21:48.930
CLE-eligible courses and practical non-CLE learning opportunities across a broad
344
00:21:48.990 --> 00:21:51.920
range of topics. Whether you're looking to earn credit or
345
00:21:52.000 --> 00:21:56.960
build skills, DRI delivers engaging quality content you can access anytime,
346
00:21:57.339 --> 00:21:59.319
so you can learn at your own pace. And if
347
00:21:59.339 --> 00:22:02.240
you're not a member, join today to gain access to
348
00:22:02.299 --> 00:22:06.140
resources and tools for attorneys who strive to provide high-quality,
349
00:22:06.529 --> 00:22:10.250
balance and excellent service to their clients and corporations. Once again,
350
00:22:10.329 --> 00:22:13.380
thank you for Lindsay and Trey for participating in today's session.
351
00:22:13.720 --> 00:22:16.980
Until next time, I'm Dean Martinez, CEO of DRI, looking
352
00:22:17.000 --> 00:22:17.720
to see you guys soon.