TRANSKRİPT 🔗
Corporate Venturing Insider #104 with Steve Westly from the Westly Group (audio podcast)
===
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Welcome to the Corporate Venturing Insider series! Where I interview top practitioners in the CVC world and learn with you the best practices and golden nuggets that they have accumulated over their careers. This week, you will be hearing a conversation I had with a very special guest. Steve Westly is the Founder and Managing Partner at the Westly Group and also the former Controller and Chief Fiscal Officer of the state of California – the world’s fourth-largest economy, he joins me now. Steve could you take a few minutes to share your story and how you got to where you are today?
Introduction to Steve Westly
---
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Well, my journey I think is a little different from others. I should explain, I am probably the one person you know, who grew up in Silicon Valley when there was nothing there, but Stanford University, Hewlett Packard, and a lot of fruit trees. My dad was a beer salesman and so I had a front row seat to the most dramatic rise in innovation and wealth creation in human history.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: When I graduated from Stanford University, I made a beeline to the Department of Energy because we were all talking about solar and green energy back in the seventies. And it sounded good, but it turned out to be way out of the money. We call it the bleeding edge, not the leading edge. And so I had gone to the Department of Energy.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: I worked in the Office of Conservation Solar. I had two books published when I was 23 and 24 years old ahead of everybody else. But none of these technologies made financial sense.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: And I had a wake up call and realized I better go back to Stanford, get my MBA in business, and so I could figure out how to make a profit with all this stuff.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: And I became an entrepreneur. I was CEO of some companies. I'm best known for having taken eBay public in 1998. I did better there than I ever dreamed. And I ran for public office. I'd been very politically active, and I was elected controller and chief financial officer of the state of California, the world's fifth largest economy.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: It was great, but in the middle of the term, there was a colossal meltdown in California having to do with an energy company called Enron. Oh my gosh. Our economy tanked. Our governor was recalled for the first time in California history and overnight I am all of a sudden working with Austrian bodybuilder named Schwarzenegger.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: And so I actually crossed party lines. I worked with him to pass the state's uh, fiscal solution to the crisis. I ran for governor myself in 2006. I lost by three and a half points. My wife was delighted. We came back to Silicon Valley and I started our venture fund, and so we've been focused on sustainable energy, mobility and buildings for the last 18 years.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: We've done this very successfully financially. We've raised five funds. We're now raising a sixth fund. And what we have learned is contrary to the standard wisdom, which is go get financial investors, get CalPERS where I serve on the board, or New York Commons or the Stanford Endowment. That's good.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: And well, we think having corporate strategic investors is better for three reasons. They can help provide extra deal flow, they can provide world class due diligence, and they can become customers. And we realized that contrary to what everybody said, having a lot of coordinated strategic investors gives you more power than these other firms.
20 Years of VC
---
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Now, can you share, actually maybe we, with this 20 years of experience, if you could go back in time and you would say, Steve, this is my advice to you for the next 20 years of venture capital, what would the, what would you have done differently?
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Yeah. I will tell you, we're not that smart. We've made every mistake in the book along the way. I think, for anybody considering investing in a venture fund. Whatever you do, don't invest in a first time or second time fund. Those people are just going to make a lot of mistakes and you can't help it. It's no one's fault.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Now that we're coming up to our sixth fund, corporations can depend on us because they've seen our track record.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: We know how to work with corporates. We have a bigger team than other venture firms because we dedicate a specific individual to every one of our partners because our investors are looking for a market rate of return. No one wants to lose money but they don't, they're not looking to make sure they get, 21% IRR instead of 17.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: What they really want is to make sure that they are not missing any technology or any company that could be an intrinsic threat. Yeah. And if they see something that is really new and powerful, maybe some new AI driven tool, they need to buy that technology before their competitor does, or their business could be gone like that.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: So in a way, a little defensive move.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Exactly right.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: But let me go back to this corporate LP. So the second point you said is it helps with due diligence. Now that one is really interesting because these LPs indeed have world class experts in their own domain.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: But how do you harness it?
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: So there's two really interesting points here. The first question is, do you wanna invest in this company? And we do this global search and then we'll go if it's in the energy sector. To Duke Energy, who's an LP to Eon, that's an lp, maybe
Load full transcript
to a b, B in Switzerland, maybe to China Light and Power or Tokyo Gas and say, okay, you're interested in ev, fleet management, or you're interested in virtual power plants.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: We think this is the best company globally. Have you seen anything better? And we can call people around the world. And if everybody comes back and says, wow, we haven't seen anything like this. We think you should invest Nicolas, but also we'd like to invest next to you. Oh, I see. The minute I have that call, it goes to the top of our list and it's just a very positive synergy.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: And the more we can do this, the better. As I like to joke it's like playing poker. And in poker it's a statistical game. Whoever has the most statistical background and IQ points usually wins. But in this game, if I know that Duke Energy and Tokyo Gas and Eon and RWE like this company the best, or électricité de france and others don't know that, it's like I get to peak under the card.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: so we're simply put looking for an unfair advantage and this gives us a huge one. This is why we like corporate strategic so much.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: But the second point is it helps us win the most competitive deals.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Because if I go to Nicolas and I say, look, I give you our money at this pre-money valuation, you could say, but Steve, I have Andreessen and I have Sequoia and they're interested too. And I'll say, yes, but we can walk you in to the C-suite at 14 of the world's largest utilities.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Now there's one thing which is interesting about your venture capital is that it's also mission driven.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Correct. Okay. Which sometimes people will say, wait a second, you're mission driven, so you're not going to go for the best financial outcome. Can you remove this myth for all of us? Yeah.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: First and foremost, I'm a capitalist. I'm not investing in my heart. I'm not investing to change the world. We do know this. The entire world is moving towards a sustainable future.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Let me just give you two examples. One, I think 187 countries are still part of the Paris protocols. There's only four that have stepped out there. Iraq, Yemen, Libya, and the United States. This is a terrible group to be part of, but the rest of the world is still moving forward full speed. Every company in the world essentially has made a commitment to get to Carbon Net neutral. Now, for some firms, it's by 2030.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Great for others. It's more difficult if heavy manufacturing, maybe they commit to by 2040 for oil companies. And it's important part of the puzzle. Maybe it's 2050. Our job is to help people get to carbon net neutral without losing their shirts. That's important while making a profit. And we must make a market rate of return.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: But if we make a market rate of return and help people get a strategic advantage over their competition, they become LPs for life and it is a win-win relationship.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Now, you made the point that don't invest in first time or second time manager. So if you were back to 20 years and you want to convince LPs, you would've a different pitch to them.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: And I think part of it was your background, your experience in energy and everything. So for the first time managers who are listening Sure. How would you pitch?
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: So as a first time manager, I was fortunate because I could say I was an entrepreneur. A lot of VCs aren't. Yeah. If you're gonna invest with VCs, find someone who has been an entrepreneur, I'd help take eBay public.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: It was a $30 billion company.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: That was a good one.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Second, I committed a lot of my money and found partners that would too. Here's a story you won't hear other places. I served on the board at CalPERS and Stirs. They had over 1000 investment vehicles. And I asked the head, the chief investment officer, what is the number one correlate to superior performance?
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Is it past performance, I think? And he said, actually, number one highest correlation to strong performance is percent of GP commitment. Now, I was running for governor back then. I said, okay, that's lovely. I put that piece of data in my back pocket. But when I did this first fund, I remembered that and I knew it was important to say I was an entrepreneur.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: But we put, I think 5% the partners and I in that first fund, and people said it's okay to come in. We still, even though we'd invested in Tesla, that was probably our least good fund. But every fund after got better and better. So I don't want to discourage young people, but for most corporates that have more of a conservative bent, you probably want someone that has been around the block a few times and has a track record of wins
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: And GP commit is really the percentage you are committing to the fund.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Yes. Next to the LPs. So when you say 5%, it's 5% of your own money and your partners 95% from the LPs.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: This is essential to know, 'cause all of the venture funds and I've been on the other side of the table too, say, ah, Nicolas, I am really deeply committed. And you must say, Steve, how committed are you? If I say 1%.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: You should kick me right out the door because what that means is I want a lot of your money. I'm gonna make a bunch of money myself on fees, and if I don't get any return, what the heck come visit me in my summer house in France, because I've got all your money already
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures:
through the management fee,
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Through the two and 20 management fees.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: You don't want people to be going to the casino with your money if you are TDK or Honda or IBM, you want people to have skin in the game. So there is what we say, complete alignment skin in the game.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Now, for first time manager who can't afford the 5%, should they loan the money to get to that point of commitment,
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: they should put in as much money as they can and they should start with a smaller fund till they can show the world they know what they're doing.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: I like that. That's actually a very practical approach. Now I want to go back to some of your amazing successes. You have Tesla, Luminar, and many other unicorns at the time of the investment of this amazing successes. Is there like connecting the dots Yeah. That allows you to see what, why they would be successful, why they could be so successful.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: So as a venture capitalist, our job is to do three things. One is to have a perspective, a vision of where things are going in the world. And I'll give you two examples or three second, then I have to run out and find the best company in that sector. And then you have to invest ideally in the A and double down in the B and the C and the D if it's taking off.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: In 2007, everybody in the world, when you said electric cars, they said, oh like golf carts, they go eight, nine miles an hour and you have to plug them in every 20 minutes.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: And we said no, lithium ion has changed everything. Cost down curve like this, it's now time for electric vehicles. And everybody, including my wife, thought I was nuts because I'd known Elon Musk now for 30 years and he said, Steve, I wish you to join the board before we even invested. You understand where this is going.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Oh. And so we had to not only realize that the cost down curve of lithium ion batteries in this new battery chemistry, lithium ion is changing the entire landscape from anything anybody had seen. And Tesla did exactly right. They started out with a very expensive a hundred thousand dollars car, but within three to four to five years, they were already developing the model three and the Model Y.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: So their market share increased 10 x model Y in 20, I think 18 or 19 became the biggest selling car in the world, gas or electric, all in a very quick time. So we're looking for the trends. Then we're waiting for the inflection point. You've got to know where the inflection point is. I like hydrogen, but the inflection point's still five years out.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Fusion wonderful. Probably 25 years out. So you have to know where the inflection point is, and we've done a pretty good job of that.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: And so if you think about these companies, let's talk about Tesla. Clearly you knew Elon Musk, so you knew how exceptional he was already then.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Yeah. Exceptional in many ways. He is brilliant. He sees the future, he moves very quickly. He's also erratic and stubborn. So it was not always clear. And he has emotional ups and downs and uh, I will tell you he was a very different human being then. I think he's perhaps become more challenging, but I think his most positive trait.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Is he has a force of will and he moves quickly. We talk with other auto company execs and they have the same vision, but they have to check with headquarters and dip their toe in the water and come back in six months. Have a few meetings and then maybe do an investment and then some pilots, and then go to the board again with Elon, he, for better or worse, he moves the agenda quickly.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: And is that some the same trait you saw in all of your other unicorns founders?
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: I think most all of them have this, but I just wanna say something controversial. A lot of people ask, I teach at Stanford's Graduate School of Business and they say, do you have to be an asshole to be a great CEO, A terrible person?
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: A, A screamer. You do not. Some of the best CEOs in the world, you might say, who? Reed Hastings at Netflix. One of the best. Executives I have ever seen, Jensen Wong, one of the best executives I've ever seen. And you would want these people to raise your children if something happened to you.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: They're also extraordinary human beings and very kind. You do not have to be flamboyant, vindictive, separate that out altogether.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: I really like that. That's a good golden nugget for everyone to listen to.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: And by the way, those people are gonna be CEO for much longer than some of the other people.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: So I want to double click on that. The chip on the shoulder, the immigrants. I see that as an opportunity for VCs or services to have a positive bias towards the funders. Yeah. They have something to prove. Yeah. They're going to do whatever it takes. Is that what you look for funders? Is that too be
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Absolutely. 100%.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Okay.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Let me tell you my wife's story.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: My wife is Chinese, grew up in Hong Kong, family from Guangzhou. It was the dream to come to America and she came, her father passed away. Tragically single mom didn't speak much English. Five kids. What's tougher than having five kids? No money, not speaking the language. And being a single mom, every one of the kids has done pretty well.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: And my wife worked her way up, got
a college degree from a public school, not the most famous at a big firm called Accenture, doing it consulting because in my world, in tech, no one cares if you have a little accent. No one cares what you look like, what ethnicity, what country. If technology and can solve the problem, you get hired and you usually get a big paycheck.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: And she moved up and she realized at a certain point. A lot of the white guys were becoming partner and a lot of the Asian women who were doing all the hard work somehow weren't getting in the top. And she said, okay, fine. I leave and go help build a new startup. She took it public and made millions, it makes me proud to be an American because the classic American story is my wife's story.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: It's a Chinese immigrant, comes here with nothing, grows up practically on welfare and ends up helping build a company and making millions not every place in the world can you do that. And I take particular pride that she didn't come from the right family. She didn't look like everybody else. She got teased a little bit growing up, but it didn't slow her down.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: It made her tougher and better. That's what gives us an edge.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: That's very nice. Now going back to my question on energy. Yeah. So this big demand of energy coming from this generative AI, exponential growth. How can we handle it? How should we think about it?
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: This is the biggest, one of the biggest problems of our generation, because demand for energy is going like this.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Yeah. Like nothing we've ever seen huge data centers to power AI at the same time. All of a sudden it's one out of five cars is electric and next year it's gonna be one out of four and pretty soon it's gonna be 50%. Yeah. And pretty before it's all of them. A confluence of these two things.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Electrification of the entire transportation grid and the data centers. The utility executives have a great challenge and they need to double the power production and become greener at the same time. That means turning off the coal and eventually the natural gas. So how do you do this? As often when you have to solve a big problem, you break it into pieces.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Short term, you're gonna see more solar. And wind and batteries built than ever before.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Yeah, the proven technologies,
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: but they're not only proven, they're also the lowest cost,
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: highly scaled
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: and the fastest to get to market longer term. And there will be some natural gas to get us there, but natural gas is still heavily polluting and it takes a longer time to build.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: As you look out, five years and 10 years, I think you will see geothermal come
down in price and become more prevalent. You will also see over time, but probably more in the 10 to 20 year timeframe nuclear small modular reactors, what's called gen four fission becoming more prominent. But it's not just important to know which technologies.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: It's important to know which ones now, which ones in five years, which one, 10 years. The cost curves are always changing. You have to understand the inflection point. This is where we help companies.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: I think it's the second time. You mentioned cost curves. I can see this is one of your key criteria for deciding Yeah.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Not necessarily where to invest, but when to invest.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: It's the when. So again, I must tell you the story. It's my crazy Californian story. So when I came to found our venture firm in 2008, I said look we've looked at all the cost curves and the solar growth is gonna go like this.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: And people said, you're crazy because for the last 20 years, looking back, solar growth, it had barely moved at all. And the reason is when solar cost a watt, which is what it cost back in 1980, when I worked at the Department of Energy, no one anywhere wants to buy solar when it comes down to $60 a watt.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: No one wants to buy solar 40. No one 20, no one. We knew solar had to get down to about $4 a watt. And in fact, no one thought it would go here. They said crazy Californians. The reality is the curve went like that and it continues to go like that. Do you know what the cost per watt to build for solar is today
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: in the cents?
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: 20 cents.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: You're exactly right. Yeah. You're the first person who's known it's 20 cents going to 15 cents down from $78.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: It's orders of magnitudes.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: A lot of people still think solar is $20 a wat, and they make the wrong business judgment. They think Trump's elected. So everybody's gonna start drilling oil wells and coal mines again.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: This is not the way the world is going. You must look at the cost curves.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: I think there is also an argument that all of these technologies we invest in which are green actually so important for energy resilience no matter what.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: No matter what, and this is just one thing I tell even my most conservative friends, global warming is getting worse every year.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: We can track it. There's no uncertainty whatsoever. The only question is what is the rate? Unfortunately, curves in life don't continue on the same rate. The rate changes we're seeing the rate of heating up of the planet increasing. And the good news is, you don't have to take my word for it. Our good friends at Swiss Re and Munich re the reinsurers for all the insurance companies.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Yeah. They have all this data and every year they say, you must raise the rates because we're having more calamitous energy events. These are the facts. Yeah. It's a sad thing for America that our president denies the facts, but all of the thoughtful people understand. The people running companies understand, and even the oil companies are generally speaking all on a path to get to carbon net neutral.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: By 2050. I want to give a particular shout out to Ecuador and the Norwegians for really being on the cutting edge. But even Saudi Aramco and the others bp, Dutch shell, they see where the world is going.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: So if we think about the next 10 years, what are you most hopeful for?
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Ah, so there's this big transition going on, and I want people who are watching to understand this.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: My whole life, your whole life, it's been about how do you produce electrons or molecules most cost-effectively. We're now getting really good at this. But the big issue now is how do you manage the electrons based on the time of day? Now, utility is essentially going three ways.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: It goes from utilities to buildings to vehicles. And it goes back and forth based on the hour and the minute and the time of day. This is what I'm optimistic about, because in the past you had to build capacity to handle those few moments of peak demand. The worst
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: case moments. Yeah.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Now you can spread out the cost curve with batteries and time of day pricing and transfer of power based on the pricing.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: This is exciting stuff. And once again Silicon Valley is at the forefront. Most of the leading AI companies almost all have immigrant founders, but it's happening in San Francisco.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Actually in Silicon Valley, we invested in a company doing sodium ion batteries for grid, which is all about this energy storage you need, but without relying on all these materials like lithium.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: So I think there is interesting innovation happening in Silicon Valley, even on the ENG Energy side, not only on the AI side.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: People are using AI to develop next gen manufacturing techniques. We've always done that. But now the curve is going quickly. We're using AI to literally develop humanoid robots that aren't just doing repetitive tasks, but you can ask them to do things and they will understand.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: We're using AI to more quickly identify which new materials and battery chemistries will be most efficient, less combustible, highest power density. We are moving forward faster than all of these areas because of ai. It's not just a tool. It's like having the world's smartest assistant at your fingertips with instantaneous answers.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Yep. Instant recall of everything, which we cannot do as humans.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: Exactly. Right.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: So if I'm thinking about the next 12 months, what are you excited to invest in? Without sharing too much of course, but ah,
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: I was gonna say, tell you all my secrets you need to invest in our fund.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: So, but yeah, to the limit of teasing enough,
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: we have just produced three cutting edge reports on AI and the utilities, AI and the oil and gas sector, and AI in the auto sector.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: And we're doing a new one on AI and next gen manufacturing. We are really going deep on how AI is changing all of these industries.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: So today we are GCV Montre 2025. I owe a lot to GCV for helping me to learn about how to do corporate VC well. Why do you spend time and contribute to GCV?
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: We love GCV because it's one stop virtually all of the major strategics in the world, literally hundreds from every quarter of the planet, come here for this two and a half days.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: We come every year. It's essential. And each year we used to send one person, then it was two. Now it's three. Next year it may be four. If you have a corporate strategic and you want to up your game or you're thinking about starting a corporate for strategic, this is the best place on the planet to learn.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: And it's once a year and it's once a year.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Perfect. Steve, it was so good to interview you. Thank you so much,
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: KU. I thank you. You are a spectacular interviewer. I'm honored to be here.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Thank you. Thank you. Alright. Thank you Steve.
Steve Westly | The Westly Group: You bet.