TRANSKRİPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:04.054 --> 00:00:10.695
Should oil and gas companies be using AI to make their exploration exercises more efficient.
00:00:11.175 --> 00:00:23.251
Should the energy hungry algorithms behind advertising campaigns make it easier for other companies to convince us to buy things that we don't really need?
00:00:23.501 --> 00:00:26.890
Is there a role for tech to, to kind of take responsibility in this regard?
00:00:27.254 --> 00:00:30.824
Good morning, good afternoon, or good evening, wherever you are in the world.
00:00:31.245 --> 00:00:38.895
Welcome to episode 236 of the Climate Confident Podcast, the go-to show for best practices in climate emission reductions.
00:00:39.674 --> 00:00:43.215
I'm your host, Tom Raftery, and before we jump in, a quick word.
00:00:44.174 --> 00:00:48.015
This podcast, Climate Confident now has a subscription option.
00:00:48.758 --> 00:00:59.003
For just five euros or dollars a month, you can unlock the full back catalog of hundreds of conversations with climate leaders who are actually moving the needle.
00:00:59.872 --> 00:01:07.492
Subscribers get a personal shout out in episodes plus direct access to me so you can pitch new directions, guests and ideas for the show.
00:01:08.543 --> 00:01:13.492
Everyone else still gets access to the most recent 30 days of episodes for free.
00:01:13.912 --> 00:01:19.852
But if you want the archive and a hand on the steering wheel, hit the subscribe link in the show notes.
00:01:20.530 --> 00:01:30.939
Now, let's be blunt, big tech loves to brag about being carbon neutral while raking in billions selling software and cloud services to oil and gas giants.
00:01:31.510 --> 00:01:38.680
The very tools that help them squeeze every last drop of fossil fuel from the ground, faster, cheaper, more efficiently.
00:01:39.219 --> 00:01:47.890
At the same time, those tech companies publish glossy climate pledges, padded with offsets and accounting tricks while their actual emissions soar.
00:01:48.819 --> 00:01:55.209
My guest today, Tom Day, from the New Climate Institute, has made a career out of exposing this hypocrisy.
00:01:56.155 --> 00:02:10.284
We dig into the credibility gap in corporate climate promises, why offsets are a dangerous distraction, and what real leadership would look like if tech companies stopped enabling fossil fuel expansion and actually committed to zero.
00:02:11.185 --> 00:02:12.925
This isn't just about emissions accounting.
00:02:13.134 --> 00:02:18.504
It's about asking whether Silicon Valley is building the future or quietly helping to burn it down.
00:02:19.375 --> 00:02:21.444
Tom, welcome to the podcast.
00:02:21.444 --> 00:02:23.034
Would you like to introduce yourself?
00:02:23.612 --> 00:02:24.032
Thanks, Tom.
00:02:24.032 --> 00:02:24.693
Yeah, sure.
00:02:24.752 --> 00:02:26.462
Tom Day from New Climate Institute.
00:02:26.552 --> 00:02:35.520
We're a think tank based in, in Germany and we're doing a bit of analysis on, what companies are
Load full transcript
up to and the credibility of the strategies they're putting forwards.
00:02:35.520 --> 00:02:46.030
Trying to identify some good practices and trying to offer insights to how the regulatory bodies or standards setters can incentivise some of those good practices.
00:02:46.834 --> 00:02:47.283
Okay.
00:02:47.403 --> 00:02:48.753
And how did you get into all this, Tom?
00:02:50.544 --> 00:03:01.848
I have been most active for the last 10 years in analysing the situation with regards to carbon credit markets, for the orange carbon market, the use of offsets.
00:03:01.948 --> 00:03:12.603
And we noticed obviously quite a wave of bold climate pledges coming forwards from corporates in around 2020, 2021.
00:03:12.900 --> 00:03:14.550
This kind of turned our heads a little bit.
00:03:14.616 --> 00:03:16.975
We were thinking hey, what's, what's going on over here?
00:03:17.026 --> 00:03:17.925
This looks really good.
00:03:18.205 --> 00:03:18.895
What's in it?
00:03:18.895 --> 00:03:24.036
And, and it was clear from the start that there was quite a bit of offsetting involved here.
00:03:24.036 --> 00:03:29.550
So, so I thought, okay, this is, this is an area to look at primarily with, with a carbon credits lens.
00:03:29.550 --> 00:03:38.319
In the meantime, it's obviously a much bigger picture that there's much more going on than, than just the use of carbon credits, which remains a very contentious topic in, in this space.
00:03:38.409 --> 00:03:43.500
But, but now it's obviously just one of many many issues that divide companies.
00:03:44.128 --> 00:03:49.468
Okay, so you've mentioned the use of offsets is contentious.
00:03:50.699 --> 00:03:52.498
Tell us why you think it is.
00:03:52.498 --> 00:03:56.304
I know why I think it is, and people listening might know why they think it is, but tell me why you think it is.
00:03:57.544 --> 00:03:58.175
Yeah.
00:03:58.175 --> 00:04:02.585
Well, I think there's, two elements of this, or there's two, there's two sides of it.
00:04:02.615 --> 00:04:18.050
And what was primarily, I think the main concern, maybe a decade ago or a little more than a decade ago when I first started looking into this, was the let's call it the supply side, kind of the quality of the credits that companies or governments could buy.
00:04:18.110 --> 00:04:20.269
Does it really represent an emission reduction?
00:04:20.269 --> 00:04:21.649
Was it gonna happen anyway?
00:04:21.889 --> 00:04:25.454
And there's, there's been endless amounts of debate about that.
00:04:25.454 --> 00:04:32.404
And I think there are very legitimate question mark still about the extent to which the problems that can ever be fixed.
00:04:32.504 --> 00:04:38.084
There's been plenty of efforts over decades to try and fix them, but that was the main problem.
00:04:38.084 --> 00:04:40.545
I think today that's not, that's a bit of a distraction.
00:04:40.574 --> 00:04:41.355
That whole problem.
00:04:41.355 --> 00:04:43.394
Like today, the problem is more on the demand side.
00:04:43.785 --> 00:04:49.805
We, we don't need anymore to be reducing emissions by 30, 40, 50%.
00:04:50.595 --> 00:04:59.204
The major companies in the world, they need to be deep decarb getting towards, towards net zero, towards real zero emissions, especially in the tech sector.
00:04:59.204 --> 00:05:01.305
They need to be getting towards real zero emissions.
00:05:01.745 --> 00:05:05.285
However good the quality of the carbon credit is, it's a distraction.
00:05:05.495 --> 00:05:11.555
It's a delay from the reality of the situation and the destination that companies need to be going towards.
00:05:11.615 --> 00:05:12.769
So I think we're seeing a lot of companies.
00:05:13.564 --> 00:05:14.735
Coming back from it now.
00:05:14.764 --> 00:05:18.814
We're seeing investors and consumers pushing back on it and courts pushing back on it.
00:05:19.055 --> 00:05:25.418
And it's really not the, the quality of the credits, this pushback is affected by, it's really more the demand side.
00:05:25.447 --> 00:05:27.637
What's the point of using credits in the first place?
00:05:28.192 --> 00:05:28.552
Okay.
00:05:28.552 --> 00:05:32.052
And how big a role is emissions accounting playing in all of this?
00:05:32.052 --> 00:05:38.382
Are companies just gaming the numbers or are the rules just too loose or, you know, what's happening in that space?
00:05:40.038 --> 00:05:58.403
Emissions accounting plays a, plays a huge role, in this and it's, it's been standard practice now since corporate climate action was, was a thing for companies to create greenhouse gas inventories, come to a number and to focus a climate strategy on reducing this number.
00:05:58.492 --> 00:06:02.213
The number being the aggregate GHG emission footprint.
00:06:02.632 --> 00:06:05.182
And there's, there's a lot of good reasons for doing that.
00:06:05.182 --> 00:06:08.812
There are still a lot of good reasons for doing that, especially at the country level.
00:06:09.182 --> 00:06:14.937
I think at the company level, greenhouse gas accounting is much more complicated.
00:06:15.028 --> 00:06:16.408
It's it's less black and white.
00:06:16.408 --> 00:06:17.817
The boundaries are difficult.
00:06:18.127 --> 00:06:24.728
The responsibility the companies have is difficult, and this means that the accounting system has a lot of value judgements in it.
00:06:24.728 --> 00:06:26.557
It has a lot of estimation in it.
00:06:26.947 --> 00:06:30.430
This doesn't make it very conducive to target setting.
00:06:30.490 --> 00:06:34.201
'cause all of these assumptions, boundaries change over time.
00:06:34.591 --> 00:06:48.211
But the other problem is that, that summarizing everything in this one metric and having the objective to, to just lower the number of this metric brings in the option of using all sorts of creative accounting mechanisms.
00:06:48.451 --> 00:06:51.740
Maybe creative accounting is a too cynical word for it.
00:06:51.740 --> 00:06:56.586
But, all these market-based
approaches with the primary focus to just bring this number down.
00:06:56.615 --> 00:07:04.625
Whereas we actually know what we want companies to be doing, what actions they need to be taking, what transitions they need to be embarking on.
00:07:05.055 --> 00:07:15.795
And I think there's a lot to be said about thinking about changing the system from focusing on this one number, which could have, which can really create a bit of a foggy scene for what's really going on in the background.
00:07:16.005 --> 00:07:26.065
And actually having a bit more transparency on, on where we are with those transitions and are companies embarking on those transitions or not and not trying to talk about it in terms of GHG metrics.
00:07:26.336 --> 00:07:35.425
So that is indeed one of the issues at the moment and the greenhouse gas protocol is in the process right now of revising the accounting standard.
00:07:35.846 --> 00:07:43.646
For now, a GHG accounting standard is going to remain the bedrock of, of corporate climate strategy development.
00:07:43.985 --> 00:07:51.065
But there's a lot of open questions and debates to be resolved still about how these metrics are defined.
00:07:51.125 --> 00:07:55.925
What kind of accounting approaches can be taken, will there be room for creative accounting?
00:07:55.925 --> 00:07:56.946
Will there be less room?
00:07:56.975 --> 00:07:58.086
Might there be more room?
00:07:58.360 --> 00:08:00.310
We're quite a crossroads in this regard right now.
00:08:00.923 --> 00:08:01.213
Okay.
00:08:01.218 --> 00:08:11.069
And the transitions you're referring to, are you talking about the transition, you know, the, the energy transition as it's known away from fossil fuels and to electric or some other, or.
00:08:11.309 --> 00:08:15.488
Or yeah, transitions are we referring to?
00:08:16.824 --> 00:08:17.035
Yeah.
00:08:17.035 --> 00:08:26.944
So for, for the tech sector I think the, primarily the transition to using renewable energy and to using renewable energy a hundred percent of the time.
00:08:28.149 --> 00:08:31.810
But also using renewable electricity in the supply chain.
00:08:32.590 --> 00:08:43.809
Also the transition to designing products in a way that increases the lifespan of the product, increasing the, the use of recycled materials in designing products.
00:08:44.179 --> 00:08:45.529
These are important transitions.
00:08:45.679 --> 00:08:58.779
There's a whole nother layer I think of, of very relevant transitions for this sector that, that I perceive the community really doesn't have a good grip of yet, and we also don't have a good grip of it.
00:08:58.779 --> 00:09:03.429
And, and that's what, what these platforms are even being used for.
00:09:03.539 --> 00:09:06.539
So I think there's, there's a big question mark about.
00:09:07.375 --> 00:09:10.105
What sustainable tech really looks like.
00:09:10.105 --> 00:09:26.345
Does it mean procuring a lot of renewable energy and making sure that your devices are made in a,
in, in a, in a clean way, or does it mean making sure that your platforms are not used for unsustainable consumption.
00:09:26.394 --> 00:09:34.687
And that's a completely different type of question, but, but there are already some sectors that are where their climate leadership is used more through this lens.
00:09:34.687 --> 00:09:47.868
If you look at financial institutions, for example, or consultancies or marketing agencies, it's more the question of, of which clients do they have, rather than do they power their offices with renewable electricity.
00:09:48.227 --> 00:09:55.337
There's more and more discussion about should the tech sector actually be seen in this box when it comes to its transitions.
00:09:55.832 --> 00:10:02.472
Should oil and gas companies be using AI to make their exploration exercises more efficient.
00:10:02.952 --> 00:10:15.029
Should the energy hungry algorithms behind advertising campaigns make it easier for other companies to convince us to buy things that we don't really need?
00:10:15.279 --> 00:10:18.669
Is there a role for tech to, to kind of take responsibility in this regard?
00:10:18.940 --> 00:10:26.754
That this could be a whole nother layer of transitions that we're really not talking about yet but I think is going to become increasingly important in the future.
00:10:26.754 --> 00:10:35.080
And it's not the kind of thing that, that you can easily address or even see as a relevant hotspot through traditional greenhouse gas accounting.
00:10:35.850 --> 00:10:36.240
Interesting.
00:10:37.139 --> 00:10:48.975
What about, maybe slightly controversial, but what about the likes of the Microsoft's, the Oracle's, the Salesforce's, et cetera.
00:10:49.394 --> 00:11:00.825
What about their selling their software and services to fossil fuel companies to enable fossil fuel companies more efficiently extract fossil fuels?
00:11:02.571 --> 00:11:03.020
Exactly.
00:11:03.020 --> 00:11:11.530
This is a very, I think this is the, the real challenge that we need to start talking about in the next the next few years.
00:11:11.591 --> 00:11:14.801
It's, it's something that we haven't been considering enough.
00:11:14.951 --> 00:11:18.010
Platforms like Science-Based Targets initiative haven't been considering enough.
00:11:18.010 --> 00:11:27.500
You will, when you look at the standards that companies need to comply with, it's really asking them to reduce their scope one, two, and three emissions.
00:11:27.500 --> 00:11:34.652
So that means to take actions like put solar panels on their roof to make sure that things are produced in a clean way.
00:11:34.652 --> 00:11:48.576
And our own reports, which are, which are already rather critical about the direction of power for the tech sector, is really focused in this area and no one yet really does even venture into this topic of who are they selling their services to?
00:11:48.576 --> 00:12:04.729
And it sounds almost outrageous, but that is what we're expecting the financial institutions, there's a new standard that exists for them now since a few days ago, which is published by the Science-Based Target Initiative where it's clear that they should not be financing exploration of oil and gas.
00:12:04.759 --> 00:12:14.808
And when you look at the drafts of standards or guidances under development for major consultancies or, or media companies.
00:12:14.808 --> 00:12:16.158
It's essentially the same thing.
00:12:16.158 --> 00:12:17.938
So it's really about choosing your clients.
00:12:18.568 --> 00:12:28.839
It's not clear how that's possible for, for tech companies with issues like software, but I think it is a thing that we'll need to, grapple with some of these breakthroughs.
00:12:28.938 --> 00:12:31.158
Like the breakthrough of artificial intelligence.
00:12:31.849 --> 00:12:48.354
The major tech companies are are saying themselves that they, yes, this causes a lot more energy consumption now, but it's a force for good in the future, but that there's a lot of uncertainty about that, but can only really be a force for good if the use of it is controlled and, and whether or not there's a role for tech to do that.
00:12:48.354 --> 00:12:53.604
I think that's the next frontier of, of climate leadership, but it's, it's very unclear at the moment.
00:12:54.467 --> 00:12:57.763
And I mean, as you mentioned, AI and its use.
00:12:57.972 --> 00:12:59.982
Its use is exploding.
00:12:59.982 --> 00:13:06.312
So how realistic is it to expect emissions to go down in this sector anytime soon.
00:13:07.653 --> 00:13:08.928
Being very unrealistic.
00:13:09.188 --> 00:13:13.724
That's that's a bit the problem right now for these companies.
00:13:14.053 --> 00:13:24.614
It seems there's a bit of a head scratching moment going on where the major tech companies, they always had these very bold sounding climate pledges around 2019, 2020.
00:13:25.147 --> 00:13:29.826
And perhaps the situation or the forecast for the future looked a little bit different back then.
00:13:30.086 --> 00:13:38.397
But in, in any case, in the, in the five years it's passed since then, the energy demand of these companies has increased by two, three times.
00:13:38.397 --> 00:13:42.907
And the forecast out into the end of the decade is for even further growth than.
00:13:44.996 --> 00:13:55.326
If you simply look at the, the emissions caused by this energy use on the grid that the energy is used, then the emissions are really going through the roof.
00:13:55.831 --> 00:14:01.020
Companies are trying that scrambling as quickly as they can to procure renewable electricity.
00:14:01.025 --> 00:14:07.890
These companies do finance a lot of renewable electricity, but it's not necessarily on the grids where it really matters for them.
00:14:08.201 --> 00:14:12.500
The rules currently allow them to do this where they want, or at least to some extent.
00:14:12.850 --> 00:14:14.801
And so they're publishing two different numbers.
00:14:14.801 --> 00:14:25.056
Basically one number that's exploding through the roof, and another number, which in some cases is, is growing less quickly and in other cases declining to to zero.
00:14:25.610 --> 00:14:36.500
It's really creates quite a, a confusing picture, but the reality is that the sector is not, it's currently not on a track to reducing its climate footprint.
00:14:36.811 --> 00:14:41.073
And there seems to be a bit of a moment where these companies are, acknowledging that.
00:14:41.073 --> 00:14:47.134
We are hearing noises and public statements coming out the companies where they're saying, yeah, hey, okay, emissions are exploding.
00:14:47.514 --> 00:14:49.269
But don't worry, we'll pull it back.
00:14:49.389 --> 00:14:56.183
And I think we need to ask ourselves as a society for this sector, like every other sector, what do we really want for this sector?
00:14:56.514 --> 00:15:02.662
Is it realistic, for every sector to reduce its emissions to zero tomorrow.
00:15:02.761 --> 00:15:11.692
Or do we really just want a kind of transparent discussion about how we, how we manage emissions across the economy and where, where it's useful and where it's not.
00:15:12.022 --> 00:15:23.042
And I think that's the bit what's missing from this sector at the moment is a bit more transparency about the challenges it faces because it's not going in a direction that's in line with the, the targets that has communicated in the past.
00:15:24.076 --> 00:15:29.125
And are we seeing any genuine leadership from any of the big players, or is it all just pr?
00:15:30.511 --> 00:16:06.339
No, certainly, certainly we are I think from for most of them there's a few things that they are pursuing that are having serious impact.
00:16:06.399 --> 00:16:08.014
Of course, they're very good at pr, these companies.
00:16:08.719 --> 00:16:15.259
But that's, that's not a surprise, but it's, it's, it's definitely a step too far to say that everything that they're saying is, is greenwashing.
00:16:15.259 --> 00:16:16.189
That would not be fair.
00:16:16.609 --> 00:16:19.106
It's just there seems to be a bit of a, a race.
00:16:19.371 --> 00:16:27.151
With regards to the PR to exaggerate where we are and, and this isn't leading to a very transparent picture of the moment, but we do see some positive examples.
00:16:27.151 --> 00:16:43.917
I think Google has been very constructive over the last decade or so with regards to discussing and encouraging discussion on the nuances of exactly what it means to procure renewable electricity.
00:16:44.257 --> 00:16:49.826
They set, for example, a, a target to be renewable, a hundred percent renewable quite a while ago.
00:16:50.177 --> 00:16:56.076
In the last decade they, they reached it relatively quickly, but at that point also said, Hey, you know what?
00:16:56.937 --> 00:16:58.287
This doesn't really make sense.
00:16:58.287 --> 00:16:59.757
Like, we're not a hundred percent renewable.
00:16:59.757 --> 00:17:07.196
We've bought all these certificates, but you know, like that's, that's not really what the transition is of this sector is about.
00:17:07.317 --> 00:17:18.801
And they've been at the forefront alongside also Microsoft of promoting what's sometimes referred to as hourly matching and sometimes 24 7 matching.
00:17:19.021 --> 00:17:27.001
But the idea that you can only claim to use renewable electricity if that electricity is generated at the time you use it in the place that you use it.
00:17:27.442 --> 00:17:31.552
And it's a much more ambitious approach, but it's, it's creeping now into the mainstream.
00:17:31.552 --> 00:17:37.507
It might be the approach that is now taken in the greenhouse gas protocol as the new accounting standard.
00:17:38.131 --> 00:17:44.151
These kind of developments wouldn't be possible if some major companies had not been pushing them.
00:17:44.151 --> 00:17:48.530
So I think this example has been a very strong example of leadership.
00:17:48.561 --> 00:18:00.615
Even if those companies, even if their climate strategies overall are still very much, having the credibility issues and the transparency issues in in other areas, and this is a really strong, strong area of leadership.
00:18:01.240 --> 00:18:01.690
Okay.
00:18:02.019 --> 00:18:20.500
And for people listening, can you explain why the hourly matching versus daily or even annual is so important, and you think that the likes of Google and Microsoft who have been leading in this space are doing so to kind of give themselves a competitive advantage?
00:18:21.689 --> 00:18:48.219
So the current rules for greenhouse gas accounting and for renewable energy or reporting renewable energy share are, based on regions and annual timeframes, mostly that you, it can even be more flexible in some circumstances, but that means essentially today a data center in Ireland could contract certificates from a solar generation facility in Spain.
00:18:48.584 --> 00:18:50.504
And claim to use that electricity.
00:18:50.713 --> 00:19:05.254
Not only that, but the data center in Ireland and during the night, in the winter month contract Spanish, solar certificates from daytime in the middle of summer when there's a huge surplus of those to claim that.
00:19:05.304 --> 00:19:12.264
And and so very quickly it's possible to say across our entire load, over the course of the year we're renewable.
00:19:12.844 --> 00:19:17.614
That's not addressing in any way the challenges of the energy transition.
00:19:17.614 --> 00:19:23.224
Renewable electricity is, is a very mature technology by now, and especially during peak times.
00:19:23.224 --> 00:19:26.074
We have no problem generating renewable electricity.
00:19:26.554 --> 00:19:42.209
The real problem with this transition is working out how to deal with the non-peak times, how to deal with nighttime hours, how to deal with the winter how to deal with moments where the wind isn't blowing and overcoming those challenges.
00:19:42.209 --> 00:19:47.338
Those are the
challenges that the electricity sector has to work overcome to decarbonise.
00:19:47.818 --> 00:20:01.403
So if we want companies to claim that they're decarbonising their emissions with this regard, they need to also have an accounting framework that holds them responsible to the same transition.
00:20:01.644 --> 00:20:08.197
If we allow them to, purchase electricity from whenever, wherever they like, then we are never gonna get anywhere with this transition.
00:20:08.557 --> 00:20:12.307
So it is a, it's a much more difficult goal.
00:20:12.616 --> 00:20:16.372
It really requires much more effort.
00:20:16.372 --> 00:20:22.221
It requires much more cooperation because it will not be possible for companies to do this in isolation.
00:20:22.282 --> 00:20:28.332
It requires them to cooperate with with grid operators, with other off-takers of the grid.
00:20:28.392 --> 00:20:38.112
Because until the grid is really nearly a hundred percent renewable, it's not going to be possible for companies to be reporting high shares of renewable electricity either.
00:20:38.451 --> 00:20:40.912
So it's much more of a. Yeah.
00:20:40.912 --> 00:20:47.622
Cooperative, solution oriented challenge to set for yourself than just to say, we'll buy some certificates from, from somewhere.
00:20:48.251 --> 00:20:51.991
Why these companies have done it, I think is I, I couldn't speculate.
00:20:52.092 --> 00:21:01.395
I suppose it could be that companies make different bets with regards to what direction they see accounting systems and regulation going in the future.
00:21:01.456 --> 00:21:19.230
And if, if accounting and regulation in the would go in this direction in the future, then obviously those that have been at the forefront of, of pioneering those approaches will be in a better place to continue them than those that have been advocating for rather loosening the rules of the current system, Okay.
00:21:19.309 --> 00:21:24.650
And we're seeing obviously, some companies shifting emissions to third party data centers.
00:21:24.650 --> 00:21:28.700
Is that a blind spot in reporting frameworks or is that an intentional dodge?
00:21:29.349 --> 00:21:30.489
It's a big blind spot.
00:21:30.489 --> 00:21:36.312
I hope that that will be re resolved now with the new Greenhouse Gas Protocol standards.
00:21:36.312 --> 00:21:38.532
Currently companies do it in very different ways.
00:21:38.532 --> 00:21:42.072
They report those emissions in different places in their inventory.
00:21:42.072 --> 00:21:44.112
In some cases, they don't report them at all.
00:21:44.501 --> 00:21:54.807
It's very unclear what proportion of data center usage is actually happening in companies' own data centers versus in third party data centers.
00:21:55.187 --> 00:22:06.413
And even if we see emissions data on these third party data centers, that also didn't give us a very clear sense because there will often be use of certificates involved in this as well.
00:22:06.463 --> 00:22:13.264
So there are
several companies, for example, that use Amazon Web Services for their data centers.
00:22:13.767 --> 00:22:28.304
You will never really see how much, they're actually using these or what the real emission footprint is because they'll often report zero emissions because this is the emissions factor that Amazon passed on to them because they are claiming to be using a hundred percent renewable electricity.
00:22:28.544 --> 00:22:32.301
So this is a a massive blind spot at the moment.
00:22:32.351 --> 00:22:41.510
And it's something where we'd like to see much more clarity and also to see other indicators being used that it's not just a single emissions point in the end.
00:22:41.561 --> 00:22:50.760
That a company is reporting, but that you also understand for example, using energy units as indicators, where are their activities actually taking place?
00:22:50.760 --> 00:22:52.500
Is it in-house, is it somewhere else?
00:22:53.047 --> 00:22:54.967
So yeah, I would hope that this really improves.
00:22:54.967 --> 00:22:58.207
Currently it's, it's not well covered by the accounting standards.
00:22:58.745 --> 00:23:03.455
And what should we make of efforts to change the rules around electricity related emissions accounting?
00:23:03.455 --> 00:23:06.080
Are they improving transparency or are they watering it down?
00:23:08.362 --> 00:23:11.451
The direction of travel, I think is, is, is positive.
00:23:11.486 --> 00:23:13.526
So this is the Scope two emissions.
00:23:14.006 --> 00:23:19.461
For most companies it's Scope 2 is the emissions from the energy that they procure elsewhere.
00:23:19.552 --> 00:23:22.042
So, for example, the generation of electricity.
00:23:22.442 --> 00:23:27.272
And for tech companies, this is in many cases a huge part of their emissions footprint.
00:23:27.721 --> 00:23:34.812
And this portion of emissions has its own accounting methodology with the greenhouse gas protocol that is currently being revised.
00:23:35.282 --> 00:23:37.862
And the direction of travel I think looks good.
00:23:37.912 --> 00:23:52.711
That there is, a clear consensus as far as I understand for that shift to hourly or more granular matching in terms of it being hourly and on the same grid, that this is a more accurate approach.
00:23:53.272 --> 00:24:00.092
But there still remains counter proposals and one counter proposal is actually to, to loosen the rules forever.
00:24:00.092 --> 00:24:28.010
So I said before that the data center in Ireland can procure energy from Spain and some companies including Amazon and Meta are part of what's called the Emissions First Partnership, where they would actually propose that it shouldn't really matter where you are procuring things from at all as long as there is an impact with reducing emissions, that the data center in Ireland should be able to support projects in South Africa or in Australia and still claim to reduce these emissions.
00:24:28.240 --> 00:24:32.576
Their point is that emissions are a global problem.
00:24:32.625 --> 00:24:34.395
It doesn't matter where the emissions come from.
00:24:34.395 --> 00:24:40.875
And if you reduce emissions one place then you should be able to account for that somewhere else in the electricity system.
00:24:41.236 --> 00:24:47.865
But I think the problem with this is it really, as I said before, it, it really misses the point of the electricity transition.
00:24:48.201 --> 00:24:54.631
That yes, in this year you might, by setting up that project in South Africa, you might reduce emissions.
00:24:54.631 --> 00:25:06.596
But is that action actually having any constructive impact on the transition of the sector that you're actually using or the grid that you're actually using?
00:25:06.876 --> 00:25:16.657
Are you helping to overcome the issues of renewables integration, of smart transmission that you'll need when you need decentralised renewables in all parts of the country.
00:25:16.707 --> 00:25:18.116
It's really not helping at all.
00:25:18.116 --> 00:25:22.677
So, so it's still, it's too early to say in what direction the accounting systems are going.
00:25:22.677 --> 00:25:27.537
I think we see positive signs that it's going for a more granular, tighter approach.
00:25:27.697 --> 00:25:30.807
But it's we'll see in a few months how this, how this develops.
00:25:31.480 --> 00:25:37.960
Is there enough pressure from regulators or is the accountability system still mostly self policed?
00:25:39.026 --> 00:25:45.611
I think on some of these issues, there's not enough oversight from, from regulators.
00:25:45.661 --> 00:26:08.895
I think on, on some more meta level issues related to change and disclosure, we perceive a trend over the last few years towards governments getting more involved, asking for more data, or more information, and requesting either for consumer protection or for or for investor protection.
00:26:09.811 --> 00:26:12.931
Requesting that things are less misleading.
00:26:13.030 --> 00:26:16.291
But this has slowed down quite significantly over the last years.
00:26:16.291 --> 00:26:22.081
And some, some of the developments in this regard, as you'll know, are being watered down to some extent.
00:26:22.111 --> 00:26:33.121
I, I don't perceive that there's much pressure at the moment from regulators, especially on these more specific issues with regards to accounting of renewable energy, for example.
00:26:33.151 --> 00:26:42.730
I think there's still here very big role for what we call some of these more voluntary initiatives which in the meantime is actually not a good, a good term.
00:26:42.730 --> 00:26:44.651
These initiatives, they set standards.
00:26:44.701 --> 00:26:49.591
They, they used to be voluntary, but they're, they, these days, they're just standards and, and they're not really voluntary at all.
00:26:49.591 --> 00:26:51.181
Every, almost every company is using them.
00:26:51.181 --> 00:26:57.326
And governments also rely on approaches like greenhouse gas protocol
to set regulations.
00:26:57.546 --> 00:27:07.576
But these initiatives are the ones at the moment that will have the most say in controlling the the direction of travel with regards to these accounting approaches for the next few years.
00:27:08.246 --> 00:27:17.916
And seeing, as you mentioned customers and investors, do they have any real influence in this space or are they just left to read glossy ESG reports and kind of hope for the best?
00:27:20.201 --> 00:27:26.442
I think both of those groups have had a, a serious impact maybe five or six years ago.
00:27:26.501 --> 00:27:38.099
And I perceived this, this wave of corporates coming forward, setting targets is very much in response to consumer and investor expectations.
00:27:38.699 --> 00:27:51.864
My own perception is that the level of influence at this point starts to wane as the details have become much more complicated for consumers and investors to follow.
00:27:51.953 --> 00:28:00.413
It's one thing if a company is, hasn't set itself a climate strategy yet for, for a consumer or an investor to say, Hey, come on.
00:28:00.443 --> 00:28:02.663
This is not, this is not the pathway we expect from you.
00:28:03.034 --> 00:28:05.644
And to, to get the company moving.
00:28:05.673 --> 00:28:16.206
It's another thing when companies have very detailed 100 page sustainability reports for customers or investors to understand the credibility behind them.
00:28:16.516 --> 00:28:26.276
So I think investors and, or investors especially, I think there is a, still quite a segment of investors that still really cares about this.
00:28:26.276 --> 00:28:40.051
But I do feel that their, their influence now when it's really about getting into the weeds is a little bit less than it is when, when it's more kind of black and white decisions about are companies talking about climate change or not.
00:28:41.346 --> 00:28:44.375
What can smaller companies learn from the messiness of the big players?
00:28:44.375 --> 00:28:52.369
What smaller companies can, I mean the big players are pursuing completely different approaches.
00:28:52.399 --> 00:28:57.588
So I think you can't say that there's only a lock-in to one certain approach depending on, on the standard.
00:28:57.588 --> 00:29:04.451
You can see from how Google and Microsoft push for one approach and how some other companies push for a different approach.
00:29:04.451 --> 00:29:12.639
The companies view despite the current frameworks, have flexibility to go for things that they perceive to be more credible.
00:29:12.739 --> 00:29:22.264
And there are by now many companies, including many smaller companies that sign up to setting targets based on 24 7 framework, for example.
00:29:22.634 --> 00:29:23.624
This is possible.
00:29:23.653 --> 00:29:34.794
It's also entirely possible for companies to talk with their suppliers to engage with suppliers that, are also making an effort towards things.
00:29:35.074 --> 00:29:41.777
So I think it's, it's very possible for smaller companies to make their own decisions and not just be takers of the rules.
00:29:42.116 --> 00:29:46.297
And to try to set up things in the most credible way that they can.
00:29:46.297 --> 00:29:51.856
And there are examples there and, and that's a little bit what we try to do with our exercise.
00:29:51.856 --> 00:30:01.342
It's, the results are generally very critical, but I think the reason for that is because there are isolated good practices out there.
00:30:01.372 --> 00:30:11.099
And it's really a shame when they're sort of hidden in the fogginess of everyone making the same claims and everyone being apparently as good as one another.
00:30:11.349 --> 00:30:18.875
And we really need somehow a system that brings these good practices forwards and therefore incentivises their replication.
00:30:19.125 --> 00:30:44.135
In the current system where there's no real means for investors or customers or even regulators to determine the differences between these companies, very different strategies, then there's also really no reason why a medium or small sized business on the one hand should understand what good practice is, and on the other hand, should have an incentive to pursue that good practice if they can see that other approaches are available.
00:30:45.259 --> 00:30:45.590
Fair.
00:30:45.830 --> 00:30:46.049
Yeah.
00:30:46.720 --> 00:30:53.330
And do you think tech can get back on track and still contribute meaningfully to a one and a half degree world?
00:30:54.201 --> 00:30:57.922
Oh, I mean, of course I think every sector can can be back on, on track.
00:30:57.951 --> 00:31:05.626
And the tech sector, the main emission sources underneath it are some of the, in inverted commas, easier to abate emission sources that exist.
00:31:05.626 --> 00:31:07.182
It's, it's primarily electricity.
00:31:07.602 --> 00:31:11.662
It's definitely possible to decarbonise this sector.
00:31:11.721 --> 00:31:21.278
I think where there needs to be some some serious discussions and questions is, is what role do we see for this sector in our society?
00:31:21.278 --> 00:31:22.778
Do we want to control it?
00:31:22.808 --> 00:31:36.519
Do we, do we want to allow it to to expand exponentially with the hope that it's improves efficiencies in, in other sectors, in which case maybe you allow it to be a sector that increases its own emissions.
00:31:36.818 --> 00:31:39.308
I think that's a, that would be a bit too much of a gamble.
00:31:39.588 --> 00:31:53.009
But for this sector, as for others, I think it's really, we need a bit more of a of a nuanced discussion at a societal level of what really are our priorities and how do we want to go about decarbonisation at the global level?
00:31:53.249 --> 00:32:03.899
And just to, to transpose the net zero objective of the economy or the society onto every company individually is really not a realistic way to go about that.
00:32:04.209 --> 00:32:07.179
So we first need to decide that for tech.
00:32:07.209 --> 00:32:12.129
What role do we see that it plays in, in a global net zero economy?
00:32:12.453 --> 00:32:16.953
And then we need to start asking ourselves these questions that I mentioned at the beginning.
00:32:17.054 --> 00:32:23.024
About what role does tech play in creating more sustainable consumption patterns?
00:32:23.334 --> 00:32:24.294
Who are its clients?
00:32:24.294 --> 00:32:25.794
How is advertising done?
00:32:26.104 --> 00:32:31.564
Of course, ai use has so many positive applications.
00:32:31.594 --> 00:32:40.413
It will also be something that's very important for security, for a lot of governments, for, for their own economic security as well as their defense.
00:32:40.474 --> 00:32:44.534
But do we need it to be driving unsustainable consumption?
00:32:44.534 --> 00:32:54.413
And so some of these question marks, we really need to talk about as, as I think the regulatory level and tell tech companies what we expect from them.
00:32:54.413 --> 00:33:00.504
But just asking them to, to set net zero targets and reduce their emissions, I think is, is missing the point.
00:33:00.534 --> 00:33:01.094
A little bit.
00:33:01.670 --> 00:33:07.245
So, what would real climate leadership look like from a big tech company in 2025?
00:33:08.372 --> 00:33:19.849
In 2025, I think from these big tech companies, we would really like to see them embracing these more legitimate accounting approaches like hourly matching.
00:33:19.849 --> 00:33:25.068
This is something that any of these big tech companies could do tomorrow to say, Hey, we are not a hundred percent renewable.
00:33:25.068 --> 00:33:27.588
That's clearly not where anyone is in this economy right now.
00:33:27.959 --> 00:33:32.881
We are going to give you more nuance and set more ambitious targets that reflect that nuance.
00:33:32.881 --> 00:33:34.681
That's something they could do right now.
00:33:35.020 --> 00:33:40.061
Also, right now they could set targets for renewable electricity in their supply chain.
00:33:40.121 --> 00:33:42.510
Apple is a really good example of this.
00:33:42.941 --> 00:33:58.092
And also go into the level of telling us what those targets mean and that it's not just about purchasing certificates in various countries, but actually setting up meaningful renewable electricity procurement in all the countries that they're trying to procure it from.
00:33:58.461 --> 00:34:01.491
That's something that all of these companies could do tomorrow.
00:34:01.951 --> 00:34:13.011
They could be giving us more concrete targets about the lifespan or how they deal with circularity and sufficiency with regards to the devices they make.
00:34:13.351 --> 00:34:26.152
But also I think the, we've, we've seen companies, like I said, with Google before being at the front of pushing some of these new questions about, for example, Google pushing hourly matching as the, as the new idea.
00:34:26.481 --> 00:34:27.592
And challenging themselves.
00:34:27.592 --> 00:34:37.682
And I would really like to see one of these companies coming forward on this more fundamental business model question and saying, Hey, actually we are, we are making as much progress as we can in these various transitions.
00:34:37.932 --> 00:34:44.782
But what we need to talk about is, is how our services are, are really used and how we make sure that they are.
00:34:45.132 --> 00:34:55.168
We don't just assume that they're used for efficiency improvements, but we want to steer that they're used for climate solutions and, and not for non climate solutions.
00:34:55.289 --> 00:35:01.229
And personally I think it's, it's too early to expect that any, these companies have a, a fully fledged strategy for right now.
00:35:01.469 --> 00:35:09.179
But I think leadership would be for one of these companies to acknowledge that and to, to start talking about it and kick off a discussion.
00:35:09.239 --> 00:35:17.284
And all of them are in a good position to kick off that discussion and I think they would set themselves they would demonstrate their leadership credentials immediately by doing so.
00:35:18.847 --> 00:35:19.268
Okay.
00:35:20.018 --> 00:35:21.427
A left field question for you, Tom.
00:35:21.818 --> 00:35:33.492
If you could have any person or character, alive or dead, real or fictional as a champion for climate leadership, who would it be and why?
00:35:34.706 --> 00:35:35.576
Yeah, good question.
00:35:36.092 --> 00:35:53.284
I'd like to see someone along the, along the lines of Greta Thunberg at the head of, of one of these companies and helping them to redefine how they understand value and redefine their role in underpinning the future of a sustainable economy.
00:35:53.313 --> 00:35:57.523
Tech is going to be underpinning the future of our economy for sure.
00:35:57.523 --> 00:36:07.496
And if we want that economy to operate in a quite radically different way and to be sustainable, then the companies that provide the foundation, the service for they need to do that too.
00:36:07.496 --> 00:36:16.291
And I think there's no one better than youth, those who have been on the forefront of youth activism that are not jaded and they're not stuck into our current system.
00:36:16.601 --> 00:36:20.512
These are the kind of people that you'd love to see at the in decision making roles.
00:36:20.512 --> 00:36:24.121
But yeah, not sure if that's a realistic pathway.
00:36:25.001 --> 00:36:25.211
Great.
00:36:25.931 --> 00:36:36.456
We're coming towards the end of the podcast now, Tom, is there any question that I haven't asked that you wish I had or any aspect of this we haven't touched on that you think it's important for people to think about?
00:36:37.534 --> 00:36:45.644
There's one issue where I think tech is being very very proactive, and that's with regards to carbon dioxide removals.
00:36:45.813 --> 00:36:54.708
And that's, that's, I think that's a really interesting area because on the one hand we undisputably need carbon
dioxide removals.
00:36:54.769 --> 00:37:01.278
At the societal level, we need to reach not only global net zero emissions but global net negative emissions.
00:37:01.639 --> 00:37:08.778
And there will be sectors like the agriculture sector that, that cannot reduce its emissions to zero.
00:37:08.858 --> 00:37:14.259
But so, we will need carbonide removals to, to be scaled up.
00:37:14.259 --> 00:37:16.119
It's currently extremely expensive.
00:37:16.148 --> 00:37:23.079
There's a lot of uncertainty with regard to the outcomes of more technological carbon dioxide removal problems.
00:37:23.079 --> 00:37:27.668
There's a lot of environmental concerns associated with these projects.
00:37:27.668 --> 00:37:29.918
The amount of water energy they require.
00:37:30.159 --> 00:37:36.278
We're really not there yet with this technology and tech is being very proactive in trying to support it.
00:37:36.309 --> 00:37:43.188
Microsoft, I think is responsible for over 80% of all agreements in the world for CDR.
00:37:43.489 --> 00:37:46.128
So they're really a big player in this regard.
00:37:46.469 --> 00:37:47.579
And this is on the one hand.
00:37:47.854 --> 00:37:49.864
This is great to see on the one hand.
00:37:49.974 --> 00:37:56.693
On the other hand, it's, it's, there's a question about how are the companies, why are companies doing this and how do they plan to use it?
00:37:56.693 --> 00:38:02.364
And for, for tech, that's a bit of a problem because the companies that are really leading on this.
00:38:02.364 --> 00:38:16.094
They, they appear to have plans to, to use the outcomes of carbon dioxide removal to, to kind of claim the offsetting of their own emissions in the future, to claim that they're already net zero at quite an early early stage.
00:38:16.543 --> 00:38:20.264
And realistically, this is a sector that should actually be able to get to zero emissions.
00:38:20.264 --> 00:38:24.554
There's not many sectors where we'll actually be able to hit real zero emissions.
00:38:24.554 --> 00:38:29.114
But, but tech should be one where that is actually the objective or as close to that as possible.
00:38:29.443 --> 00:38:42.126
So yes, these companies are in a great position to take responsibility for scaling up carbon dioxide removals, and, and we should create frameworks that encourage that and praise it.
00:38:42.436 --> 00:38:58.751
But we need to be clear about what we are doing it for, and it's quite different to make a, a claim to contribute to carbon dioxide removal as a public good, as opposed to claiming it for themselves as a license to continue polluting.
00:38:58.992 --> 00:39:12.192
And that's, a difference which takes this support or, or this activity from being potentially extremely good practice to being a highly critical issue.
00:39:12.472 --> 00:39:17.481
So, so this is, we'd obviously like the, this type of support continuing.
00:39:17.762 --> 00:39:34.307
But we would like to see these companies, yeah, change their communications with regards to what they actually plan to do with the CDR and to recognise that this is not a, a commodity that, that any private entity should be owning or claim to take ownership of.
00:39:36.066 --> 00:39:36.666
Makes sense.
00:39:36.816 --> 00:39:37.536
Okay, great.
00:39:37.596 --> 00:39:45.186
Tom, if people would like to know more about yourself or any of the things we discussed on the podcast today, where would you have me direct them?
00:39:46.231 --> 00:39:49.671
All of our analysis is on our website at newclimate.org.
00:39:49.860 --> 00:40:02.005
And the things we've been talking about today are discussed in a bit more detail in our recent Corporate Climate Responsibility Monitor report which was published in, in June this year.
00:40:02.076 --> 00:40:04.746
So yeah, I could highly recommend checking that out.
00:40:05.425 --> 00:40:06.034
Fantastic.
00:40:06.454 --> 00:40:07.110
Tom that's been great.
00:40:07.110 --> 00:40:08.894
Thanks a million for coming on the podcast today.
00:40:09.965 --> 00:40:10.596
Thanks so much, Tom.
00:40:10.887 --> 00:40:12.758
Okay, we've come to the end of the show.
00:40:13.478 --> 00:40:14.588
Thanks everyone for listening.
00:40:15.447 --> 00:40:23.518
If you'd like to know more about the Climate Confident podcast, feel free to drop me an email to tomraftery at outlook.
00:40:23.768 --> 00:40:27.248
com or message me on LinkedIn or Twitter.
00:40:27.818 --> 00:40:36.057
If you like the show, please don't forget to click follow on it in your podcast application of choice to get new episodes as soon as they're published.
00:40:36.688 --> 00:40:39.648
Also, please don't forget to rate and review the podcast.
00:40:39.847 --> 00:40:42.378
It really does help new people to find the show.
00:40:43.467 --> 00:40:43.918
Thanks.
00:40:44.588 --> 00:40:45.508
Catch you all next time.