TRANSKRİPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:07.714 --> 00:19.025
[SPEAKER_00]: Axis Mooney, it's dark out, winter time in New York City.
00:20.146 --> 00:24.611
[SPEAKER_00]: The snow on the ground crunches as my dad rushes past the subway station.
00:24.851 --> 00:31.157
[SPEAKER_00]: He usually takes to return home and continues toward my grandma's apartment in downtown Manhattan.
00:32.626 --> 00:37.850
[SPEAKER_00]: He's depleted after 12 hours at the workshop, but this can't wait.
00:39.170 --> 00:41.772
[SPEAKER_00]: He cuts across the park in order to save time.
00:42.753 --> 00:47.916
[SPEAKER_00]: His breath appearing like smoke in front of his frozen mouth every time he preves.
00:48.877 --> 00:50.918
[SPEAKER_00]: He's tired, but someone needs him.
00:52.960 --> 00:57.703
[SPEAKER_00]: He is still tripping and sweat from the heat and the factory and standing all day.
00:59.002 --> 01:03.284
[SPEAKER_00]: His internal temperature contrasts darkly with the frigid world around him.
01:04.304 --> 01:09.727
[SPEAKER_00]: It's as if the two exist in the same space, but occupy different planes of reality.
01:11.688 --> 01:16.210
[SPEAKER_00]: When Grandma hears my dad come in, she slowly moves to the couch.
01:17.730 --> 01:18.971
[SPEAKER_00]: She is still recovering.
01:20.351 --> 01:23.273
[SPEAKER_00]: This was the late 1990s, and she was in her 60s.
01:25.208 --> 01:28.650
[SPEAKER_00]: She was around five feet, maybe shorter with her hunch.
01:29.850 --> 01:38.094
[SPEAKER_00]: I remembered a tense skin on her face and fingers, were wrinkled from working so long in the sun and raising her six children.
01:39.715 --> 01:41.436
[SPEAKER_00]: Grandma just had a stroke.
01:43.397 --> 01:46.318
[SPEAKER_00]: She returned home from the hospital only a few days ago.
01:47.839 --> 01:50.900
[SPEAKER_00]: The stroke had left half her face paralyzed.
01:56.110 --> 02:05.236
[SPEAKER_00]: In 2026, doctors may suggest lip muscle training or mirror therapy, but in the 90s, these were not offered to her.
02:06.277 --> 02:11.540
[SPEAKER_00]: At her age, there was little they could do, at least using mainstream medicine.
02:12.881 --> 02:14.442
[SPEAKER_00]: All they could offer was to wait.
02:15.582 --> 02:20.085
[SPEAKER_00]: It's possible she could get a little better, but there wasn't a high chance that she
02:25.827 --> 02:27.608
[SPEAKER_00]: It was hard to see Grandma like this.
02:28.788 --> 02:29.868
[SPEAKER_00]: She didn't want to speak.
02:30.929 --> 02:36.991
[SPEAKER_00]: And when she did, moving only one side of her lips and tongue, we could barely understand her.
02:38.271 --> 02:39.652
[SPEAKER_00]: But my dad did not lose hope.
02:40.852 --> 02:43.413
[SPEAKER_00]: He told the entire family that he could heal her.
02:44.093 --> 02:44.553
[SPEAKER_00]: And he did.
02:45.914 --> 02:47.194
[SPEAKER_00]: And it seems like he did.
02:48.395 --> 02:51.416
[SPEAKER_00]: If he asked my dad, he will tell you that he definitely did.
02:55.945 --> 03:00.987
[SPEAKER_00]: My dad untangles the wires that are wrapped around the electronic acupuncture machine.
03:02.428 --> 03:03.888
[SPEAKER_00]: This one doesn't use needles.
03:04.809 --> 03:14.412
[SPEAKER_00]: It has sticky pads that send small electric pulses to the acupuncture points to stimulate tea and clear up blockage or stagnation.
03:16.273 --> 03:23.176
[SPEAKER_00]: Grandma is covered in sticky pads all over her face, scalp, neck and shoulders.
03:24.815 --> 03:31.040
[SPEAKER_00]: The treatment takes only 15 minutes of electric pulses, but a set-up and clean-up takes longer.
03:32.581 --> 03:38.025
[SPEAKER_00]: My dad had to get the exact placement of each pad just right to match her body.
03:40.067 --> 03:43.830
[SPEAKER_00]: Chinese medical doctors use June to measure distance.
03:44.870 --> 03:47.833
[SPEAKER_00]: It's usually translated as same body inch.
03:49.237 --> 03:55.264
[SPEAKER_00]: A person can find their tune by measuring the distance between the ends of their thumb knuckle.
03:56.585 --> 04:04.113
[SPEAKER_00]: Three tune is the distance between the knuckles of one's index finger and pinky when they're flat and together.
04:05.655 --> 04:11.061
[SPEAKER_00]: This means that my grandma's tune would be much shorter than a large football players.
04:12.926 --> 04:16.087
[SPEAKER_00]: In other words, measurements were relative to the patient.
04:17.628 --> 04:22.450
[SPEAKER_00]: Healing was always personal, felt, not standardized.
04:24.430 --> 04:27.292
[SPEAKER_00]: Every single night, my dad would treat grandma.
04:28.652 --> 04:31.233
[SPEAKER_00]: At first, she didn't notice much improvement.
04:32.714 --> 04:35.735
[SPEAKER_00]: Give it some time, my dad said, what do you have to lose?
04:37.315 --> 04:40.997
[SPEAKER_00]: After a few days, it's clear she was making progress.
04:42.565 --> 04:43.787
[SPEAKER_00]: She regained some movement.
04:44.848 --> 04:46.450
[SPEAKER_00]: We could understand her when she spoke.
04:48.353 --> 04:55.943
[SPEAKER_00]: Slowly, but surely, after two long months, she made a complete recovery.
04:57.284 --> 04:58.606
[SPEAKER_00]: The doctors were amazed.
04:59.447 --> 05:00.709
[SPEAKER_00]: My dad was not.
05:13.334 --> 05:22.221
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm Dr. Kim Chang, a scholar of religion, and this is between tea and science, my experience of what can't be measured.
05:23.122 --> 05:28.166
[SPEAKER_00]: When I was 17, my dad taught me Hacom what you may know as teacom.
05:29.187 --> 05:40.696
[SPEAKER_00]: We were standing in our living room in Coney Island Brooklyn, and as I followed his movements something strange happened, I felt a pressure between my hands, a warmth, something I could
05:43.390 --> 05:46.131
[SPEAKER_00]: That moment has stayed with me for nearly three decades.
05:47.492 --> 05:56.815
[SPEAKER_00]: My father became a healer, drawing on teagull, acupuncture, Buddhist rituals, rakey, and other Chinese medical and religious practices.
05:58.155 --> 05:59.556
[SPEAKER_00]: I took a very
Load full transcript
different path.
06:00.816 --> 06:10.400
[SPEAKER_00]: I became a scholar of religion, trained to ask questions about evidence, knowledge, belief, and what we meet when we say something is real.
06:11.580 --> 06:18.364
[SPEAKER_00]: And eventually, I realized that my father was at the center of many of the questions I had spent my life studying.
06:19.965 --> 06:30.832
[SPEAKER_00]: This series is an exploration of that complicated territory between science and religious practice, between what can be measured and what can be experienced.
06:31.773 --> 06:36.076
[SPEAKER_00]: Between a father and son, and the worlds we build for ourselves.
06:37.126 --> 06:50.798
[SPEAKER_00]: I'll tell my father's story, but I'll also ask larger questions about healing, migration, suffering, knowledge, and the ways our bodies and experiences shape what we believe is possible.
06:52.420 --> 06:53.861
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't have a simple answer.
06:54.762 --> 07:00.967
[SPEAKER_00]: In fact, the more I study these questions, the more comfortable I become with uncertainty.
07:02.104 --> 07:04.266
[SPEAKER_00]: So come with me into that uncertainty.
07:05.027 --> 07:10.192
[SPEAKER_00]: This is between tea and science, my experience of what can't be measured.
07:14.236 --> 07:20.222
[SPEAKER_00]: This is a story about healing miracles performed by my dad and how I am still trying to make sense of them.
07:21.623 --> 07:22.224
[SPEAKER_00]: Are they real?
07:23.245 --> 07:23.905
[SPEAKER_00]: Supernatural!
07:24.852 --> 07:29.657
[SPEAKER_00]: and if they are, how can I explain them, measure them, study them.
07:30.298 --> 07:31.559
[SPEAKER_00]: That's my job after all.
07:32.440 --> 07:39.128
[SPEAKER_00]: Maybe what he accomplished with Grandma wasn't that special, because he certainly didn't see it as special.
07:40.069 --> 07:45.555
[SPEAKER_00]: He expected her to heal, but it gets harder and harder to understand.
07:47.036 --> 07:51.977
[SPEAKER_00]: His Hagon practice healed a golf ball-sized tumor on our neighbor's neck.
07:52.917 --> 07:57.839
[SPEAKER_00]: He sent healing tea over the phone to a patient half way around the globe.
07:59.159 --> 08:06.561
[SPEAKER_00]: His Hagon practice combined with sitting meditation and Buddhist chanting led to his involuntary movements.
08:08.161 --> 08:11.042
[SPEAKER_00]: He developed what he called his sixth sense.
08:11.943 --> 08:13.764
[SPEAKER_00]: which allowed him to heal a patient of her memory disorder and loss of balance.
08:13.784 --> 08:17.406
[SPEAKER_00]: It's difficult to reconcile these events with the materialist view of mainstream medicine, which has no place for tea or Buddhist deities that healers can channel.
08:17.426 --> 08:41.797
[SPEAKER_00]: [♪ Music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing in background music playing
08:42.099 --> 08:45.960
[SPEAKER_00]: when he practiced Hagueung at a park near his former home in Brooklyn.
08:47.120 --> 08:52.621
[SPEAKER_00]: His neighbor, Jundia, meaning elder sister-ton, became his first student.
08:53.982 --> 08:58.382
[SPEAKER_00]: She had a background in Hagueung because she too was seeking healing.
09:00.443 --> 09:02.643
[SPEAKER_00]: Jundia was in her 60s at the time.
09:04.164 --> 09:09.705
[SPEAKER_00]: She is around 5 feet tall, has short hair and always a smile on her face.
09:10.894 --> 09:16.220
[SPEAKER_00]: She is one of the friendliest people around and is always paying everyone compliments.
09:17.702 --> 09:27.213
[SPEAKER_00]: From her cheerful attitude, you could hardly tell that she had been suffering from a large tumour on the back of her neck that bothered her for decades.
09:28.737 --> 09:33.721
[SPEAKER_00]: It bulged out of her vertebrae as if there was a golf ball underneath her skin.
09:35.162 --> 09:41.367
[SPEAKER_00]: It hurt her to sleep no matter how she positioned her head on her pillow, the tumor got in the way.
09:43.388 --> 09:51.274
[SPEAKER_00]: Because it was so close to vital nerves, the doctors did not suggest surgery to removing due to the high risk to her life.
09:52.475 --> 09:54.877
[SPEAKER_00]: Mainstream medicine offered her no solution.
09:58.299 --> 10:04.404
[SPEAKER_00]: she said that she could tell from just looking at my dad that day in the park that he was special.
10:05.945 --> 10:09.048
[SPEAKER_00]: You see, Tundi could see oras.
10:10.709 --> 10:18.015
[SPEAKER_00]: There's a term in Cantonese in fun that typically is translated as fate that brings people together.
10:19.416 --> 10:23.119
[SPEAKER_00]: The connotation is Buddhist, hence it's also translated as
10:26.292 --> 10:34.800
[SPEAKER_00]: Whatever it was that brought Zanzia to the park that day, at the exact time that my dad was practicing haygong, it changed her life.
10:36.101 --> 10:41.185
[SPEAKER_00]: She is not a shy person, and so she easily struck up a conversation with my dad.
10:42.006 --> 10:47.731
[SPEAKER_00]: Then asked him if
she could learn the style of haygong that he was practicing, which was not familiar to her.
10:49.273 --> 10:50.113
[SPEAKER_00]: He was eager to help.
10:51.368 --> 11:00.632
[SPEAKER_00]: After just two weeks of practice and receiving healing tea from my dad, Sanjay's tumor went away and has not returned since.
11:02.113 --> 11:03.293
[SPEAKER_00]: It was miraculous.
11:05.054 --> 11:09.756
[SPEAKER_00]: Her friends who have known her for years were convinced that my dad was special.
11:11.376 --> 11:14.358
[SPEAKER_00]: They too wanted healing and to learn from my dad.
11:15.498 --> 11:19.520
[SPEAKER_00]: That core group became the start of my dad's community of practice.
11:20.859 --> 11:25.260
[SPEAKER_00]: Tantia continues to be his most loyal student and vocal publicist.
11:26.480 --> 11:31.641
[SPEAKER_00]: And for her audience, my dad's results speak louder than the scientific method.
11:39.483 --> 11:45.144
[SPEAKER_00]: Other examples of healing success include the chronic back pain of a middle-aged male
11:50.855 --> 11:54.626
[SPEAKER_00]: It balanced this order and memory troubles of an elderly woman.
11:56.050 --> 11:58.637
[SPEAKER_00]: My dad is particularly proud of that one.
11:59.641 --> 12:11.151
[SPEAKER_00]: In recounting this episode, he emphasizes how American doctors, who examined this patient in the hospital, had no clue what was medically wrong with her from the mainstream medical perspective.
12:11.631 --> 12:22.460
[SPEAKER_00]: He visited her at the hospital to give treatments of hay gong, and used what he caused his diloconum, literally 6th function, or his 6th sense.
12:24.113 --> 12:34.177
[SPEAKER_00]: It took control over his hands, such that he involuntarily moved his fingers in order to provide acupressure manipulation on her ears.
12:35.578 --> 12:39.640
[SPEAKER_00]: That night she had a dream that a worm came out of her ear.
12:40.680 --> 12:44.722
[SPEAKER_00]: She woke up to a small object falling out of her right ear.
12:46.223 --> 12:53.646
[SPEAKER_00]: The four treatment, she cannot walk upstairs on her own and have difficulty remembering things like phone numbers.
12:55.204 --> 13:01.347
[SPEAKER_00]: Doctors guessed that some bacteria might be affecting her brain and wanted to do more testing.
13:03.068 --> 13:09.371
[SPEAKER_00]: Today after my dad's treatment, her balance and memory issues went away and she left the hospital.
13:10.171 --> 13:13.573
[SPEAKER_00]: She and my dad credit his diluculean for healing her.
13:15.334 --> 13:19.916
[SPEAKER_00]: His sixth sense is not the first time he has experienced involuntary movement.
13:32.676 --> 13:35.337
[SPEAKER_00]: Look, come look at me, my dad cried.
13:36.317 --> 13:36.697
[SPEAKER_00]: See this?
13:37.497 --> 13:40.338
[SPEAKER_00]: My body is moving by itself on its own.
13:41.958 --> 13:48.659
[SPEAKER_00]: My dad's torso was swinging in a circular motion, as if he was using a hula hoop without the hoop.
13:49.940 --> 13:52.000
[SPEAKER_00]: Then he moved in a bowing motion.
13:53.180 --> 13:55.801
[SPEAKER_00]: Again, here, I'm not doing this.
13:56.001 --> 13:56.801
[SPEAKER_00]: It's my body.
13:58.298 --> 14:05.760
[SPEAKER_00]: Soon Dad was walking in a small circle, and then a figure eight pattern while his torso continued to swing.
14:07.100 --> 14:07.801
[SPEAKER_00]: He was delighted.
14:09.301 --> 14:11.182
[SPEAKER_00]: This was spring 2013.
14:12.462 --> 14:15.643
[SPEAKER_00]: My parents and I were outside a Buddhist temple.
14:16.803 --> 14:21.504
[SPEAKER_00]: He was pleased because it's signal to him how attuned he is to the religious
14:24.850 --> 14:32.472
[SPEAKER_00]: Huang Yan, meaning, majestically adorned monastery and upstate New York, 60 miles north of Manhattan.
14:37.934 --> 14:42.596
[SPEAKER_00]: I have also seen this when we visited Kyoto, Japan, in the summer of 2014.
14:44.156 --> 14:49.798
[SPEAKER_00]: My parents and I were on our way to Kiyomi, Zudera, or pure water monastery.
14:50.818 --> 14:55.120
[SPEAKER_00]: There are plenty of shops and smaller temples along the path towards Kilmizudera.
14:56.041 --> 15:01.944
[SPEAKER_00]: We were walking slowly up the windy road when my mom and I noticed that was no longer near us.
15:02.944 --> 15:08.947
[SPEAKER_00]: Mom and I walked back down and found him bowing in front of a small shrine repeatedly.
15:09.968 --> 15:12.789
[SPEAKER_00]: He tells me he's not controlling his movements.
15:20.076 --> 15:29.641
[SPEAKER_00]: though related to these involuntary movements of his feet and torso, his more recent involuntary hand movements are a separate phenomenon.
15:31.042 --> 15:40.007
[SPEAKER_00]: He describes this sensation as a sixth sense that perceives where to perform acupressure on himself or patience.
15:41.428 --> 15:43.429
[SPEAKER_00]: This was how he healed that elderly
15:46.438 --> 15:55.440
[SPEAKER_00]: My dad describes his involuntary movements as a compulsion to move and allows himself to follow through with that sensation.
15:56.920 --> 16:02.342
[SPEAKER_00]: Yet, at any time, he can regain control and start moving if desired.
16:03.762 --> 16:10.324
[SPEAKER_00]: Another way to describe this sensation is as being nudged or pushed, though able
16:14.028 --> 16:20.894
[SPEAKER_00]: What my dad calls his sixth sense is an ability to develop a few years after he started a seam.
16:21.674 --> 16:25.778
[SPEAKER_00]: The Japanese is pronounced Zen Buddhist sitting meditation.
16:31.482 --> 16:36.867
[SPEAKER_00]: It started with the involuntary movement of his hands by means of which he gave himself
16:41.133 --> 16:44.536
[SPEAKER_00]: prior to this ability to involuntarily move his hands.
16:45.376 --> 16:48.959
[SPEAKER_00]: He used Hagueung for a different type of involuntary movement.
16:49.839 --> 16:59.967
[SPEAKER_00]: That of his hips and the swinging of his arms to cultivate T, a response that is acknowledged as normal in wisdom healing Tagueung.
17:01.948 -->
17:07.953
[SPEAKER_00]: He explains this to his students and patients who seem to understand and follow along as
17:11.258 --> 17:17.059
[SPEAKER_00]: I, on the other hand, have no idea how to understand, but I want to.
17:25.521 --> 17:32.663
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm a scholar of religion, trained to analyze religious people, what they do, and why they do those things.
17:34.232 --> 17:40.576
[SPEAKER_00]: Does my dad and his community have anything to gain with their claims of miraculous healing?
17:41.516 --> 17:43.418
[SPEAKER_00]: Is there something they're trying to sell?
17:44.538 --> 17:47.460
[SPEAKER_00]: My dad doesn't charge for his services after all.
17:48.941 --> 18:02.990
[SPEAKER_00]: Art of involuntary movements and healings verifiable phenomena or supernatural miracles just sticks me back to the experience of tea in my living room when I was 17.
18:04.785 --> 18:24.690
[SPEAKER_00]: is T real, the 55,000 English scientific research articles on T may seem to indicate that it is or at least something like T. I'm tempted to translate T into mainstream medicine and Western science, like those research articles.
18:26.070 --> 18:27.771
[SPEAKER_00]: But there's a big problem when I do.
18:29.191 --> 18:31.372
[SPEAKER_00]: Translation goes in one direction.
18:32.508 --> 18:36.451
[SPEAKER_00]: from T to the mainstream, not the other way around.
18:38.113 --> 18:43.137
[SPEAKER_00]: Translation gives Western science the final word on what's real or true.
18:45.139 --> 18:53.005
[SPEAKER_00]: Those 55,000 studies don't actually measure T. They measure the effects of acupuncture or T-Gone.
18:54.426 --> 18:58.270
[SPEAKER_00]: They measure self-reported experiences of pain reduction.
18:59.299 --> 19:07.101
[SPEAKER_00]: They measure cholesterol, cortisol, glucose, lung capacity, and all the other health benefits.
19:09.021 --> 19:14.863
[SPEAKER_00]: They translate a way to explain it a way and subsumit under mainstream medicine.
19:15.883 --> 19:24.145
[SPEAKER_00]: She isn't real because in the translation, Acupuncture is really working on the body's interstitial network.
19:26.454 --> 19:30.478
[SPEAKER_00]: This is a problem because I want to understand my dad on his own terms.
19:32.519 --> 19:36.363
[SPEAKER_00]: My academic training makes me skeptical of medical translation.
19:37.784 --> 19:40.947
[SPEAKER_00]: However, my skepticism doesn't play favorites.
19:42.188 --> 19:49.334
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm also skeptical of varieding I observe, everything I experience, everything my dad experiences and reports.
19:55.492 --> 20:01.713
[SPEAKER_00]: is karma real, tea energy, Buddhist spells, ancient trance.
20:04.414 --> 20:06.894
[SPEAKER_00]: Religion is deeply concerned with reality.
20:08.255 --> 20:14.696
[SPEAKER_00]: Therefore, scholars of religion seek to understand what is real, in what sense and for whom.
20:16.976 --> 20:20.657
[SPEAKER_00]: I tell my students that religion is not real.
20:21.875 --> 20:22.996
[SPEAKER_00]: Religion doesn't exist.
20:24.057 --> 20:25.799
[SPEAKER_00]: Religion doesn't do anything.
20:27.301 --> 20:36.270
[SPEAKER_00]: Christianity, Anati, Buddhism, Islam, Hinduism, all these terms are made up, useful, but abstract.
20:37.953 --> 20:55.460
[SPEAKER_00]: The tangible concrete agents who actually exist act and change the world are just people, Christians, Buddhists, Muslims, Hindus at a specific place and time.
21:07.362 --> 21:15.928
[SPEAKER_00]: explains that scholars try to provide a standard definition of religion, but nearly all of them do not actually define religion.
21:17.869 --> 21:20.571
[SPEAKER_00]: They merely pass the work on to another term.
21:21.611 --> 21:31.658
[SPEAKER_00]: For instance, they'll say that religion has to do with the sacred, holy, divine, culture, symbol, or supernatural.
21:33.287 --> 21:40.132
[SPEAKER_00]: They stop there and do not actually define the sacred, holy, divine, or supernatural.
21:42.133 --> 21:44.054
[SPEAKER_00]: Class offers his own definition.
21:45.555 --> 21:51.019
[SPEAKER_00]: Religion involves three things, reality, causality, and order.
21:51.839 --> 22:00.165
[SPEAKER_00]: For example, if someone has cancer, the religious world includes what's real and what causes that cancer.
22:01.683 --> 22:07.028
[SPEAKER_00]: mainstream medicine explains cancer as cells multiplying out of control.
22:08.289 --> 22:18.118
[SPEAKER_00]: Cancer is caused by many things, including exposure to radiation that damages the cells DNA, therefore making the multiply.
22:22.161 --> 22:28.066
[SPEAKER_00]: What religion adds are causes like demons or bad karma from a previous life,
22:28.991 --> 22:31.493
[SPEAKER_00]: which are very real to religious people.
22:33.355 --> 22:41.882
[SPEAKER_00]: Religion also provides order, which means the rules to follow, to heal from cancer, or avoid cancer in the first place.
22:42.843 --> 22:49.849
[SPEAKER_00]: For instance, prayer, ethical conduct, faith in God, rituals, or spells.
22:52.147 --> 23:05.560
[SPEAKER_00]: Places definition emphasizes how religion provides values and meaning, explains what is real, and offers some sense of agency and control in an uncertain world.
23:07.542 --> 23:14.068
[SPEAKER_00]: For my dad, his world includes the reality of mainstream medicine, T, and karma.
23:16.002 --> 23:24.104
[SPEAKER_00]: The fact that the worlds of materialist science, Chinese religion, and Buddhism, contradict each other, doesn't bother him.
23:25.784 --> 23:30.526
[SPEAKER_00]: He simply is not concerned with theoretical or philosophical consistency.
23:31.886 --> 23:34.346
[SPEAKER_00]: He's concerned with healing himself and others.
23:35.807 --> 23:42.889
[SPEAKER_00]: As a scholar, I am interested in how these worlds relate, and if and how they can be made
23:53.926 --> 23:59.108
[SPEAKER_00]: Is there a contradiction between the fact that I tell my students religion isn't real?
23:59.808 --> 24:05.070
[SPEAKER_00]: And yet I give them
classes definition of religion that says it has to do with reality.
24:06.768 --> 24:17.836
[SPEAKER_00]: I have to explain why I do this and how this apparent contradiction dissolves when I clarify how we use words and concepts and the different senses of reality.
24:19.737 --> 24:25.641
[SPEAKER_00]: First, my point about religion not being real is about the word religion itself.
24:26.242 --> 24:27.623
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a useful shorthand.
24:28.463 --> 24:32.326
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a category that helps us understand people and our world.
24:36.262 --> 24:38.044
[SPEAKER_00]: The word religion is misleading.
24:39.185 --> 24:42.327
[SPEAKER_00]: It tempts us to say that religion starts wars.
24:43.288 --> 24:44.429
[SPEAKER_00]: I hear this all the time.
24:45.690 --> 24:48.513
[SPEAKER_00]: Students claim that religion brain washes people.
24:49.614 --> 24:50.935
[SPEAKER_00]: Religion corrupts rulers.
24:51.836 --> 24:53.517
[SPEAKER_00]: Religion sees this political power.
24:54.958 --> 24:56.480
[SPEAKER_00]: This is not fully correct.
24:58.001 --> 24:59.983
[SPEAKER_00]: Religious people start wars.
25:01.254 --> 25:08.320
[SPEAKER_00]: It's not Christianity that attacked Islam during the Crusades, but Christians attacking Muslims.
25:09.861 --> 25:17.427
[SPEAKER_00]: It's not Catholicism and Protestantism that fought in Northern Ireland, but Catholics and Protestants.
25:19.208 --> 25:25.233
[SPEAKER_00]: It's not Buddhism and Hinduism at war in Sri Lanka, but Buddhists and Hindus.
25:26.975 --> 25:35.501
[SPEAKER_00]: So my point about the terms religion, Christianity, or Buddhism, not being real, is that they do not act upon the world.
25:36.441 --> 25:41.285
[SPEAKER_00]: Only religious people, specific Christians, actual Buddhists do things.
25:42.525 --> 25:52.032
[SPEAKER_00]: Of course, for some, angels, jins, animal spirits, ghosts, and flying bodhisattvas also act upon the world.
25:53.114 --> 26:01.216
[SPEAKER_00]: Religion is still a helpful word because it forces us to pay attention to what motivates people and to their underlying values.
26:02.417 --> 26:08.178
[SPEAKER_00]: But we need to be careful not to mistake and abstract category for actual agency.
26:09.659 --> 26:13.660
[SPEAKER_00]: The second point I want to make is regarding the different senses of reality.
26:23.593 --> 26:38.797
[SPEAKER_00]: an example of a mirage is when someone has a hallucination of seeing water in the desert due to the refraction of lights from the sky by heated air and by their desire for water.
26:40.357 --> 26:42.037
[SPEAKER_00]: What they experience is real.
26:43.138 --> 26:47.779
[SPEAKER_00]: They truly see a thin sheet of water, but the water is not
26:53.226 --> 27:01.191
[SPEAKER_00]: As a side note, Buddhist don't buy this distinction between experience and things outside the mind, but that is another story.
27:03.733 --> 27:05.174
[SPEAKER_00]: I love magic shows.
27:06.115 --> 27:10.658
[SPEAKER_00]: When I see a magician, cut their assistant in half with a buzz saw.
27:11.618 --> 27:13.640
[SPEAKER_00]: I really am seeing that happen.
27:14.404 --> 27:15.765
[SPEAKER_00]: my experience is real.
27:16.445 --> 27:23.090
[SPEAKER_00]: It looks absolutely like that person is cut in half to my eyes, which sends the signals to my brain.
27:25.491 --> 27:36.739
[SPEAKER_00]: Of course, we all know that the skilled magician is performing an optical illusion that tricks the audience into the experience of seeing something that isn't really happening.
27:37.955 --> 27:44.377
[SPEAKER_00]: Hence, we have to be careful when we use the word real and reality, because they mean multiple things.
27:46.538 --> 27:51.260
[SPEAKER_00]: As a scholar of religion, I am interested in the various senses of reality.
27:52.360 --> 27:56.781
[SPEAKER_00]: I am trained to look for contradictions and rational consistency.
28:08.013 --> 28:19.275
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a useful definition because it avoids loaded terms mentioned above, especially supernatural, which class convincingly argues is ethnocentric.
28:21.196 --> 28:26.797
[SPEAKER_00]: He provides a fascinating example from his fieldwork among South Asians and Trinidad.
28:28.597 --> 28:33.858
[SPEAKER_00]: This story could be a clue to help us understand my dad's miraculous healing.
28:36.107 --> 28:44.334
[SPEAKER_00]: The farmers in Trinidad rent their land from a landlord and make regular offerings to a deity of the field.
28:45.975 --> 29:01.449
[SPEAKER_00]: Class says an outsider who uses the term supernatural with simply label the deity to be supernatural because it falls outside the modern materialist worldview, whereas this outsider would
29:05.483 --> 29:12.590
[SPEAKER_00]: However, some of the farmers whom class has encountered have never seen or interacted with the landlord.
29:14.692 --> 29:25.823
[SPEAKER_00]: They have only paid rent through an intermediary party and have vague notions that if rent is not paid, this mysterious force will take away the land.
29:27.423 --> 29:38.626
[SPEAKER_00]: For such farmers, the deity is perfectly natural, because they, or their neighbors, have experienced poor harvest after feeling to make adequate or proper offerings.
29:40.247 --> 29:47.469
[SPEAKER_00]: They have been raised with knowledge of the land deity, heard stories from their gramas, seen paintings of it.
29:48.269 --> 29:50.170
[SPEAKER_00]: It's part of their reality.
29:58.200 --> 30:05.107
[SPEAKER_00]: The class, therefore, suggests that the farmers would categorize both the deity and the landlord as natural.
30:06.668 --> 30:13.896
[SPEAKER_00]: Perhaps, though, class can go even further and posit that the farmer might see the landlord as supernatural.
30:15.117 --> 30:17.980
[SPEAKER_00]: Regardless, class then provides a hypothetical.
30:19.125 --> 30:33.831
[SPEAKER_00]: But if the farmer has a child who goes to college and takes a course on anarchism and is convinced of anarchist tenets that challenge
any natural right to land ownership.
30:34.391 --> 30:44.415
[SPEAKER_00]: Class rights quotes, in principle, it is therefore a denial of the existence of landlords in a proper natural universe.
30:45.552 --> 30:51.396
[SPEAKER_00]: There we term the landlord, a supernatural entity from the Sun's perspective.
30:52.457 --> 30:54.859
[SPEAKER_00]: There we not, and quit.
30:56.800 --> 31:07.728
[SPEAKER_00]: Applying the category of supernatural from one person to another already assumes a division that may not apply to the worldviews of the subject.
31:12.477 --> 31:28.706
[SPEAKER_00]: A different anthropologist, Susan Syrede, highlights the political value judgments involved in using the decotomous label Natural versus Supernatural, because this contrast leads to other binaries.
31:29.946 --> 31:37.510
[SPEAKER_00]: That of the West versus the West, Christian, over pagan, true versus false,
31:41.812 --> 31:48.874
[SPEAKER_00]: science versus religion, modern, over-primitive, and the real versus the fake.
31:50.715 --> 31:59.778
[SPEAKER_00]: Seret offers yet another way to think of the supernatural, in terms of enhanced natural, rather than not natural.
32:01.419 --> 32:03.459
[SPEAKER_00]: If we return to the farmer's child,
32:09.437 --> 32:13.100
[SPEAKER_00]: This points to how even the word natural has multiple meanings.
32:14.401 --> 32:23.949
[SPEAKER_00]: Sored and class do not reject the use of supernatural completely, but advise a different way to approach it as a theoretical category.
32:25.290 --> 32:35.458
[SPEAKER_00]: Sored reminds us that there is a continuum rather than a strict binary, and warns us not to default to seeing one end as better than the other.
32:36.913 --> 32:47.361
[SPEAKER_00]: class reminds us that when the term supernatural is used, we have to ask ourselves, what does the speaker assume is natural or real in the world view?
32:57.028 --> 33:02.832
[SPEAKER_00]: I know within my dad's world view, the power of Buddha's and Bodhisattvas are real.
33:04.160 --> 33:08.921
[SPEAKER_00]: But how can I, as a scholar of religion, make sense of miraculous healing?
33:11.442 --> 33:17.103
[SPEAKER_00]: The distinction between natural and supernatural miracles may help us answer this question.
33:19.764 --> 33:25.085
[SPEAKER_00]: The Cantonese terms for miracle include K. Dick and Sun Dick.
33:26.265 --> 33:32.827
[SPEAKER_00]: The second character in these compounds, Dick, means trace or literally footprints.
33:34.432 --> 33:42.739
[SPEAKER_00]: miracles in Chinese have connotations of traces of the strange or uncanny, the divine.
33:44.500 --> 33:49.244
[SPEAKER_00]: Miraculous is mu-sal, meaning wondrously skilled hands.
33:50.165 --> 33:53.448
[SPEAKER_00]: A term used mainly to describe miraculous healers.
33:55.649 --> 34:02.175
[SPEAKER_00]: Chinese terms for miracles overlap with wonder, magic, and the superhuman.
34:03.704 --> 34:09.729
[SPEAKER_00]: However, the distinction between natural and supernatural is problematic in Chinese contexts.
34:11.450 --> 34:23.300
[SPEAKER_00]: Taoists, Buddhists, and popular or folk religious tales are filled with descriptions of incredible, meaning hard to believe, events and feats.
34:24.893 --> 34:34.197
[SPEAKER_00]: Taoists unseen, meaning in mortals, are able to fly, predict the future, and wield spells and talismans.
34:36.057 --> 34:46.902
[SPEAKER_00]: These are natural, and so far as the Taoist program is a way for ordinary human beings to obtain these super-normal or super-mundane abilities.
34:47.805 --> 34:56.632
[SPEAKER_00]: if they followed the regimen of a special diet, engage in alchemical practices, and receive support from other sunsine.
34:58.854 --> 35:07.782
[SPEAKER_00]: The most commonly touted supernormal, exceeding the normal ability, is extreme longevity or immortality.
35:09.173 --> 35:23.800
[SPEAKER_00]: The historian Robert Campany provides a useful distinction between miracles and an ontological sense which deals with existence and miracles and an epistemological sense which relates to knowledge.
35:25.821 --> 35:32.465
[SPEAKER_00]: In supernatural miracles, the rules of nature are the laws of physics are suspended.
35:33.507 --> 35:41.451
[SPEAKER_00]: For instance, Jesus walking on water, turning water into wine, or healing lepers, and the blind.
35:43.392 --> 35:59.300
[SPEAKER_00]: In Chinese religions, the miracles are in the words of company, quote, surprising, shocking, paranormal and strange, as interruptions of the ordinary, normally apparent everyday course of things, end quote.
36:01.232 --> 36:07.616
[SPEAKER_00]: But they are not miracles in the ontological sense, because the laws of nature are not suspended.
36:09.117 --> 36:17.081
[SPEAKER_00]: Rather, they are miracles in the sense that these events uncover or reveal what is normally hidden in nature.
36:18.822 --> 36:23.705
[SPEAKER_00]: I follow a company in using this distinction to understand natural miracles.
36:25.106 --> 36:29.008
[SPEAKER_00]: Natural miracles point to events that are normally inaccessible.
36:30.375 --> 36:37.961
[SPEAKER_00]: However, with proper training and practice miracles, especially the case of miraculous healing, naturally occur.
36:39.702 --> 36:42.825
[SPEAKER_00]: My dad repeatedly says, his healing is nothing special.
36:44.046 --> 36:45.607
[SPEAKER_00]: That is why he teaches haygong.
36:46.928 --> 36:51.712
[SPEAKER_00]: Because he believes anyone can learn it and use it to heal just as well as he does.
36:53.053 --> 36:57.577
[SPEAKER_00]: But it takes training, time, patience, and the proper teacher.
36:59.873 --> 37:07.139
[SPEAKER_00]: Buddhist texts make abundantly clear the power of chanting Buddhist spells and petitions to Buddha's and Bodhisattvas.
37:08.480 --> 37:15.805
[SPEAKER_00]: For Buddhist, it is only natural in the sense of occurring as a matter of course for wondrous healing to happen.
37:18.007 --> 37:21.670
[SPEAKER_00]: Miracles in Indian Buddhist
texts are categorized
37:29.455 --> 37:35.039
[SPEAKER_00]: the miraculous display of telepathy, and the miraculous display of instruction.
37:36.340 --> 37:55.773
[SPEAKER_00]: The Buddha and advanced Bodhisattvas are said to have the abilities to turn himself or others invisible, walk through walls and mountains, walk on water, fly, read other people's minds, see into past lives and heal.
37:58.193 --> 38:05.380
[SPEAKER_00]: These abilities can be obtained by Buddhist and non-Buddhas alike through cultivation practices.
38:07.142 --> 38:20.696
[SPEAKER_00]: Therefore, Buddhist miracles are, as the scholar of religion, David Viodales puts it, quote, natural expressions of the extraordinary power of the mind and quote.
38:22.881 --> 38:30.949
[SPEAKER_00]: Dophia Dalis is correct to translate the polyterm eddy found in Buddhist texts as superhuman powers.
38:32.030 --> 38:36.134
[SPEAKER_00]: Another appropriate translation is simply accomplishments.
38:37.835 --> 38:41.579
[SPEAKER_00]: To say that natural miracles result from hard work.
38:49.797 --> 38:52.879
[SPEAKER_00]: How do I make sense of my dad's healing miracles?
38:54.160 --> 38:57.161
[SPEAKER_00]: His sixth sense, his involuntary movements.
38:58.722 --> 39:02.424
[SPEAKER_00]: Classifying them as natural miracles doesn't seem enough.
39:04.005 --> 39:06.166
[SPEAKER_00]: That is why I turn to code switching.
39:07.207 --> 39:12.310
[SPEAKER_00]: Code switching is the alternating use of codes within one conversational episode.
39:14.018 --> 39:28.026
[SPEAKER_00]: Codes are not limited to discrete languages, but span the range of any marked change in speech, including dialects, accents, vernacular, register, or levels of formality.
39:29.606 --> 39:39.592
[SPEAKER_00]: Speakers do so consciously, in systematic and meaningful manners, as well as unconsciously, unintentionally, and at times unaware of their switches.
39:41.272 --> 39:49.639
[SPEAKER_00]: Intentions fall between a desire to assimilate to a dominant culture and accommodate others with limited ability in another language.
39:51.920 --> 40:06.272
[SPEAKER_00]: Specifically for Asian Americans, cold switching due to assimilation is situated in a long history of how Asian Americans are racially triangulated in relationship to black and white populations.
40:07.557 --> 40:26.569
[SPEAKER_00]: The political scientists, Claire Jean Kim, showed how Asian Americans are racialized as hardworking immigrants in a way that pits minorities against minorities, blaming black people for systemic racism, and casting Asian Americans as perpetual foreigners.
40:28.445 --> 40:40.811
[SPEAKER_00]: Therefore, Asian Americans often code switch to blend in during conversation as they are hyper-aware of how speech affects being accepted or rejected by others.
40:41.932 --> 40:48.455
[SPEAKER_00]: Co-switching is used for both identity performance and formation, both personal and in-group.
40:49.649 --> 40:58.617
[SPEAKER_00]: Asian Americans as not fully Asian and not fully American, experienced dual or multiple identities, or double consciousness.
41:00.558 --> 41:14.550
[SPEAKER_00]: Although my dad mainly speaks Cantonese and at times Mandarin Chinese, he still codes which is for my dad and his community, the code flips between T and mainstream medical paradigms of health.
41:16.649 --> 41:23.554
[SPEAKER_00]: Take, for example, discussions ranging from treatments for seasonal allergies to depression and anxiety.
41:24.875 --> 41:31.780
[SPEAKER_00]: These ailments are instances of conditions familiar in both the biomedical and Chinese medical context.
41:33.926 --> 41:48.291
[SPEAKER_00]: The cult switching takes the form of talking about pollen, anti-histamine, and T-depletion or blackage in the case of allergies, or dopamine imbalance, and T-degnation in the case of depression.
41:49.771 --> 41:58.314
[SPEAKER_00]: Does this to say that he and his community cults which in a way that integrates mainstream, Chinese and Buddhist medicine?
41:59.514 --> 42:00.615
[SPEAKER_00]: There is no translation.
42:01.503 --> 42:07.748
[SPEAKER_00]: No one code or medical religious language that is more true or more real than other languages.
42:08.788 --> 42:10.089
[SPEAKER_00]: Those worlds merge.
42:16.995 --> 42:19.276
[SPEAKER_00]: So I code switch to keep the world separate.
42:20.577 --> 42:27.803
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm against the idea of translation of medical religious languages, because translation keeps mainstream medicine on top.
42:28.708 --> 42:31.909
[SPEAKER_00]: as the one true or real medical religious language.
42:33.089 --> 42:37.470
[SPEAKER_00]: And so what I close with, I oscillate back and forth, moving among different worlds.
42:38.610 --> 42:43.612
[SPEAKER_00]: I can understand my dad's world a little better through natural miracles and cold coaching.
42:44.872 --> 42:46.652
[SPEAKER_00]: Maybe healing isn't supernatural.
42:47.593 --> 42:48.373
[SPEAKER_00]: Maybe hit to hidden.
42:49.573 --> 42:56.555
[SPEAKER_00]: Maybe it emerges through practices, disciplines, relationships, and ways of perceiving that most of us never
42:59.783 --> 43:10.247
[SPEAKER_00]: But that still leaves me with a problem, because if these healings are natural, if the part of the ordinary workings of the world, then how do they work?
43:11.767 --> 43:14.488
[SPEAKER_00]: What exactly is happening when someone gets better?
43:15.609 --> 43:16.249
[SPEAKER_00]: Is it tea?
43:17.450 --> 43:18.170
[SPEAKER_00]: Is it prayer?
43:18.710 --> 43:19.750
[SPEAKER_00]: Is it expectation?
43:20.371 --> 43:21.011
[SPEAKER_00]: Is it belief?
43:22.435 --> 43:24.896
[SPEAKER_00]: Is it something medicine calls placebo?
43:25.736 --> 43:30.078
[SPEAKER_00]: It's tempting to dismiss unexplained healing away as merely placebo.
43:31.298 --> 43:36.921
[SPEAKER_00]: By saying it's only in that person's head, it's easier to consider that something is not real.
43:39.322 --> 43:48.325
[SPEAKER_00]: The trouble is that once you start asking what a placebo actually is, the boundary between mind and body begins to dissolve.
43:49.385 --> 43:50.786
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's where we're headed next.
43:52.152 --> 44:02.798
[SPEAKER_00]: In the next episode, we'll talk about the relationship between mind and body and how trivializing these healing miracles as placebo doesn't explain anything at all.
44:03.859 --> 44:14.425
[SPEAKER_00]: When we think of the seabulls, we often imagine that alternative medicine and techniques are just psychological tricks to help patients be positive about their healing.
44:15.443 --> 44:24.546
[SPEAKER_00]: If just were true, then maybe my dad would be nothing more than a trickster, or a feel-good artist who used good vibes to make people feel better.
44:25.426 --> 44:26.526
[SPEAKER_00]: But I found something else.
44:27.547 --> 44:38.530
[SPEAKER_00]: When you consider placebo's carefully and philosophically, the foundation of mainstream medicine begins to crack, and healing becomes much bigger than you expected.
44:56.271 --> 45:03.478
[SPEAKER_00]: You've been listening to between T and science, my experience of what can't be measured by Dr. Kim Chang.
45:04.519 --> 45:14.870
[SPEAKER_00]: This series was made possible with funding from the Henry Lewis Foundation and in collaboration with Apari, the Asian Pacific American Religions Research Initiative.
45:17.348 --> 45:20.230
[SPEAKER_00]: The Executive Producer is Dr. Bradley Onishi.
45:21.170 --> 45:22.972
[SPEAKER_00]: The producer is Andrew Gil.
45:23.932 --> 45:26.594
[SPEAKER_00]: Editorial support comes from Dr. Leah Payne.
45:27.615 --> 45:34.219
[SPEAKER_00]: Original music and engineering are by Scott Volkomozo, with production assistance from Carrie Onishi.
45:35.725 --> 45:51.613
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for listening and for joining me and exploring the complicated relationship between healing and science, experience and evidence, family and scholarship, and what we think we know and what we may never fully understand.
45:52.594 --> 45:54.895
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm Dr. Kim Chau, until next time.