TRANSKRİPT 🔗
Eric W. Phillips
To keep our episodes focused on our experts and the value that they bring to these conversations, we're supplementing them with some deep-dives. These additional episodes may consist of conversations between Tim and Alyssa that deserve to be heard in full, or may highlight even more insight from our expert guests.
Lizzy Bean
A recurring theme in our interviews with mental health professionals was the culture of perfectionism within the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and how it contributes to an environment where abuse is difficult to confront. In LDS doctrine, members are not only encouraged to become perfected through Jesus Christ but are taught they can ultimately become like Him, as He is— literally perfect. This ideal filters down into daily life, where righteousness is often measured, both consciously and subconsciously, by outward appearance: modest clothing, cheerful demeanor, and the “light of Christ” visible in one’s countenance.
At its most extreme, this emphasis can breed scrupulosity, a form of religious obsessive-compulsive behavior where individuals become too preoccupied with avoiding sin and keeping the commandments. And in a culture where anything that suggests brokenness or discomfort threatens the appearance of spiritual success, members often avoid acknowledging difficult realities. For victims of abuse, this creates a painful bind. Without a framework for discussing imperfection or harm, many remain silent, afraid that speaking out would mark them as flawed— or worse, unworthy.
LDS Church General Conference speech: David B. Haight
And why did his neighbor decide to investigate the Church? The
neighbor said, “If any other neighbor had’ve come to my door to
invite me to investigate religion, I would have declined. But we have
been so impressed with your family, your cleanliness and your
actions. You are always friendly and smiling. Your yard looks so neat
and clean, and you're working in your yard before anyone else is out
of bed in the mornings. We wanted to learn more about you and
your church.”
Alyssa Grenfell
I think what sets Mormonism apart from other religion— and even other Christian religions or, you know, any other religion you might encounter within the United States— is I think Mormonism is exceptionally focused on appearances and on perfectionism and on how you look when you show up to church on Sunday.
If you recall when you asked me, you know, “How is your family devout?” What I led with was where we sat within the Church congregation. And that has nothing to do with my spiritual connection with God, and everything to do with how we showed our righteousness to the people around us.
LDS Church Ensign Magazine article: Robert D. Hales (read by
voiceover actor)
When we know who we are, children of God, and understand that
our outward appearance affects our inward spiritual polity and
ultimately our behavior, we show respect for God, for ourselves, and
for those around us by
Load full transcript
being modest in dress and behavior.
Ultimately, how we dress will greatly influence our obedience to
commandments and devotion to covenants. Dressing modestly will
guide our attitudes and behaviors as we conduct our daily lives. In
time, our dress may even determine who are friends and associates
may be, thus influencing whether we live worthy of enjoying the
blessings of happiness in this world and for eternity.
Alyssa Grenfell
And I think that that kind of is, in a nutshell, is how Mormonism is different, and why a Mormon culture within somewhere like Utah is different than a lot of other religious cultures, is that— that really heavy focus on what it looks like to be a good Mormon creates this sheen of people focusing on appearances, instead of on personal commitments to a god or to their family.
There are also a lot of scriptures and songs and just messages about how your righteousness shows through your countenance. And so, not just what you do, but just how you look.
LDS Church General Conference speech: Elaine Dalton
By the way you live the gospel, you reflect His light. It is the daily,
consistent things you do that will strengthen you to be a leader and
an example. Daily prayer. Daily scripture study. Daily obedience. As
you do these things, you will grow closer to the Savior and become
more and more like Him. Your face will glow with the fire of your
faith. Have ye received His image in your countenance?
Alyssa Grenfell
One of the number one comments I get on the videos I make is that, “She looked so much happier on her mission. She looked so much happier when she was, you know, younger and active.” And people will use specifically the word “countenance” as a way to discredit me. That the way— something in the way I look is proof that I'm no longer close to God. And I think that the willingness to embrace the parts of Mormon society that look good, and I think feeds into even Mormon missionaries going out and— as a missionary was so much of my training was about how to look nice, how to dress well, how to— what types of blazers to put on, how to wear my earrings, what types of earrings. If they were too long and dangly, they weren't good for a Mormon sister missionary.
So I think that all of this just said that whatever is going on internally, as long as you are looking the part, playing the part, putting a smile on your face and turning that frown upside down, and when appearance is attached to— and perfectionism is attached to— purity and righteousness and connection with God, it really creates a bad backwards incentive because everything is about appearances. And if everything is about appearances, then, ultimately, there can be a lot of bad in a community while everything still looks very nice.
Yeah, I think along with the countenance question, the interesting thing is anyone who isn't a member of the Church will always say I look so much happier, and anyone who is a member will always say, “She looks so much darker.” So it's very interesting for people to watch the same piece of media— same face presented on screen— and yet to draw such drastically different conclusions based off of what they perceive about me and my worthiness or my, you know, activity within the Church. And I think that what it looks like to be a Mormon is very multifaceted. I think the Church loves to claim they’re a global church and so, “Mormons don't look any certain way because we have people who are— you know, members in every country.” And of course, that is their usual response to that type of claim. Obviously, typically, I'm speaking about Utah Mormons specifically.
I have Mormonism in my bloodline back through Joseph Smith, basically, and I people always say I look really Mormon. I do. I know that about myself. But I think that it's white, it's thin, it's blond, and I think a lot of times you see in Utah, people going and paying a lot of money and going to great lengths to get that look, even if they weren't born with it. So I think to some extent— it's not just a genetic thing, because a lot of Mormon pioneers were from Scandinavia. That is that is a piece of the history that's proven, just— there's a large bloodline coming through Scandinavia. A lot of people converted over there and came to Utah. So that is, to some extent, just scientifically, genetically true, but I also think that that makes it so that there is a very high standard for expectation for what you should look like as a member of the Church, specifically in Utah.
And I think that feeds eating disorders. I think that that feeds into— I think that feeds into, you know, cosmetic procedures, diet culture, hair culture, getting your hair dyed, extensions. I think— I looked at Google search terms because it shows the volume of searches within different states, and Utah is highest for “boob job.” Lots of people getting— googling “how do I get a boob job?” out here. So I think that all of those things— it does feed back into this path of, you know, there's a straight and narrow path, there's one right way to be, there's a— you can be perfect. Mormons believe they will someday be perfect. And so all of that is not just spiritually perfect but it also needs to be present in my countenance. I need to look perfect.
I read in a book, she said that Mormons’ eyes are bright but not deep, and I felt like that was kind of like a perfect description of what it is to be a member where you're very bright and cheery and happy but often unable to cope or talk or speak to really deep, complex issues because your mind is really just filtering everything through a Mormon lens.
Lizzy Bean
Dr. Julie Hanks and Dr. Steven Hassan, who we heard from in Episode Three, spoke about this subject. Not only the culture of perfectionism that exists within the Church, but the way it manifests in LDS communities, and the way it manifests psychologically.
Alyssa Grenfell
What kind of impact does that doctrine and kind of theology have on people's
mental health, in your experience?
Julie Hanks
Yeah. From my practice, I mean, that's a huge issue, right? So it could be— so for women, it tends to be more physical appearance oriented and family appearance. And in general, it seems like for men, it's more Church callings and how much money you make and the prestige of your career. And so that can just be an avenue that perfectionism is directed toward.
And I think as a culture, we've kind of interpreted “be ye therefore perfect” as “be ye therefore externally flawless.” Look good. Like, have your kids look the part. And my understanding of that scripture is, “be ye therefore complete and whole.” And that's different than flawless, right? And so, perfectionism is something that I've seen in my practice so, so frequently, and I do think that misinterpretation of the doctrine is a huge— plays a huge part in that.
Alysssa Grenfell
How do you think perfectionism might play a role in downplaying or hiding events that are like abuse?
Julie Hanks
Yeah, I think in addition to perfectionism, it's not wanting to rock the boat, not wanting to have conflict, not wanting to hurt other people. And so I think sometimes, victims don't get the help they need or the support they need because it's like, we want to make the perpetrator feel okay. Like, “We don't want to hurt that family, we don't want to—” Right? And we want to keep this appearance that everything is going well. The appearance is kind of tied to, like, “We're going to prove that we're righteous, and if abuse is happening in our family or in our neighborhood or our ward, that makes us look like, you know, looks like something is wrong (because something is wrong) but that's not okay.” And that's somehow tied to, like, “So that must mean we're not righteous.
LDS Church General Conference: Marvin J. Ashton
“For verily, verily, I say unto you, he that hath the spirit of contention
is not of me, but is of the devil, who is the father of contention, and
he stirs up the hearts of men to contend with anger one with
another. Behold, this is not my doctrine, to stir up the hearts of men
with anger one against another. But this is my doctrine, that such
things should be done away.”
This means that Satan has power over us only when we let him in.
We have agency. We can choose our behavior.
Alyssa Grenfell
I think it brings me back to what I said about how Mormons, I think, in my opinion, have eyes that are bright but not deep because I think that often this idea that you shouldn't have contention— you shouldn't have any struggle, almost, you should only be focused on bright and happy things— keeps people from pursuing problems or questions in their lives and fixing them, or even addressing them, when they do become deep and difficult and contentious.
Hum your favorite hymn from LDS Church Children’s Songbook
Before you say an angry word
Remember you’ll regret it
For once it's said, the harm is done
And some folks won't forget it
Just hum your favorite
hymn!
Sing out with vigor and vim!
And you will find it clears your mind
Hum your favorite hymn
Steven Hassan
So what you described is exactly what's taught in the Moonies, Scientology— it’s this notion that either there's a thought that's in dissonance to the dogma or the doctrine or the hierarchy, or there's a feeling. Either one, we're trained to do “thought stopping,” which is maybe a prayer, a song, a meditation, an affirmation, a chant, whatever. In the Moonies, if I had a feeling or a thought that was negative to, you know, Father Moon, I would say, “Crush Satan, crush Satan, glory to Heaven, peace on earth, glory to Heaven, peace on earth,” over and over and over again, until I got rid of that. And likewise, feelings.
Tim Kosnoff
In my experience, with so many of the LDS that I deal with that are, you know, in these cases, most of whom are really kind, decent, nice people who would give you the shirt off their back, but you’re suing their church— God’s true Church? When it comes to defending this Church, they don't want to get sideways with the Church.
Alyssa Grenfell
I think, in a lot of cases, they respect the authority of the Church so much more than the legal system that they're being held accountable to, potentially.
Lizzy Bean
The next voice you’ll hear is that of therapist Natasha Helfer. Her work will become the focus of future episodes, but during our interview with her, she said something that really applies to this subject.
Natasha Helfer
I have been doing a lot of study into this idea of, is religion a protective factor or a harming factor in people's lives? And that's kind of language we use in journal— like, scientific journals— is like, where there are protective factors and where they're harmful factors? And the answer with religion in general is kind of— it's a mixed bag.
And actually a lot of the research shows that people who have religion— or spiritual communities or whatever— actually do better. It serves as a protective factor. However, I don't think that many of those studies have done a good job of delineating what kind of religion we're talking about, and there's different types of religion, right? So you've got very kind of liberal religions like Unitarianism or Reformed Judaism, where there's a lot of flexibility in how you can live your life and what kinds of things you can do, including who you can love and when you have sex, and that doesn't, you know, like, ostracize you from the community. It's not like you now can't call yourself, you know, a practicing or a believing member of their community because of these things. And then you have, you know, very fundamental parts of religion, like, you know, the Amish and the FLDS and the Mennonites and Benedictine monks, you know, where they almost have to remove themselves from mainstream culture to be seen as active and a member of their communities. And if they reject anything, they're very ostracized, you know, to the point that— like in the Amish community, can't even be in contact with your family anymore. So that— so I would imagine that the mental health of religious people also has to fluctuate tremendously depending on the flexibility versus the rigidity of the system.
Now, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints— the Mormons, as it's colloquially known— they trend to be deemed— they— in this book called Acts of Faith by Stark and Finke, they were put into the category of “strict”— or “ultra strict.” So there was “cult”— they didn't call it “cult, they called it— what’d they call it? I think they called it “fundamental” or something like that, and then there was “ultra strict,” and there was “strict.” And then it started the three categories of more liberal religions. Well, so just to give you an idea, under “strict” there was like Catholics, like Baptistists, things like that. “Ultra strict” was the LDS— Mormons— the Jehovah's Witnesses, like, the Scientologists. And then of course, the “fundamental” was like Amish, Mennonite, those kind of— FLDS. So, what we do have a little bit of research on, a little bit, is that the stricter it is— the stricter of a tradition you come from— the more mental health ramifications there are when you don't fit the group. And especially if you leave the group, it's a harder process for you.
But it's super interesting to see how, especially here in Utah, anytime there's— like, we've had the fight about, is depression because of “Mormon-land” or is depression due to high altitude? You know, it's the LGBTQ youth on the street— are they being kicked out by families, you know, because they're gay or are we just a super loving, you know, “protective factor” for gay people?
I mean, we have studies, especially coming out of BYU or done by people that— again, there's two biases I'm concerned about with these studies. One is the bias of the researchers, and two is the bias of the intended audience. Because there was a study not too long ago that showed that the LDS church is a “protective factor” for LGBTQ youth. And you can imagine all of us who are working with LGBTQ youth and see all the issues, we're all like, “What? That can't— that can’t be completely true.” So you have to kind of take these studies and say, “Who have they studied? How many people? Who was their target audience? Why did they answer the way that they do?” Because again, if I put myself in the role of a more believing, active LDS woman, I would have answered studies saying things like, “I am a feminist, I am not suppressed as a Mormon woman, I have very— I have every opportunity as a Mormon woman to speak and to be a leader.” And now I'd be like, “I was a little suppressed as a Mormon woman,” right? It's kind of ridiculous but I would have answered those questions very differently under that worldview. So it's a complicated thing.
So, let me give you— my answer (that isn't always completely supported by research, and I am aware of this) is: I do think that there is a correlation between high levels of depression here in the state of Utah and perfectionism. Which again, they just came out with a study out of BYU that I haven't found in any good academic research— it wasn't published in a place where I would respect it— where they said perfectionism is not higher in LDS folks, and that's another one where I'm like, “Eh?” Anyway, but so I do think depression is higher in the state of Utah due to its correlation with Mormon practice, which is very much behaviorally driven, you know, and you have to prove your worthiness. And that's actually language that we use, right? You have to— are you “worthy” or are you “unworthy,” right? Which is very different from my Evangelical Black friends in Kansas that would be like, “Hell yeah, I am unworthy and I need Jesus!” Right? There's an empowerment to that type of humility that we're not talking about an LDS-land, right? In LDS-land it’s like, “Oh no, I am unworthy. I need to get worthy, and I need to do that by next week for this Bishop's interview if I'm going to make it to the temple to get married or to do all the things that I need to do.”
So I do think there's a correlation there. And I do think there's a correlation with suicide. And I do think that there's a correlation with LGBTQ youth on our streets due to— directly due to LDS doctrine and practice and the cultural phenomenons that are happening in this state. Yes.