TRANSKRİPT 🔗
02 Rob Moor V2b: How much do we really know about trees? Jack and I are here today with Rob Moore, an award-winning writer and journalist whose work explores our connection to nature. His latest book, In Trees, takes us on a journey through the extraordinary world of our leafy neighbors, from their role in human history to the quirky ways they can behave, and the joy of climbing trees like a kid. So today we're talking about our relationship with trees. And how understanding these extraordinary organisms might change the way we see the natural world and ourselves? We had a brilliant time chatting with Rob, and I think you're going to really enjoy this one. You clearly have a lot of love and experience for being outside and seeing incredible things and getting deep diving into beautiful or wild places. Where did that start? Was there a particular life changing changing moment or an experience as a kid where you really got your spark, for getting out and experiencing nature? Yeah, I I grew up in the suburbs of Illinois and so there were a lot of there's a lot of forest there's still a a fair amount of relic forest and and prairies. they call them leafy suburbs, these these little suburbs in of Chicago that have still retained a lot of tree cover. And so I was i around my house I had little forest and and a little ravine that I used to play in, but The truth is I wasn't really an outdoorsy kid. I I like to call my parents profoundly indoorsy, They they never took me hiking or canoeing or anything like that, when I was a kid. I it un and so it really all started when my parents sent me to a a summer camp in Maine called Pine Island when I was about ten years old. And it's a a it's a remarkable place 'cause it it was founded in nineteen two and they just haven't really updated it since. So so they still there's no electricity, there's no running water, you sleep in a canvas tent, and you use a kerosene lantern at night. It's very much like this time capsule taking you back to to the early 20th century and the way that people were camping back then. And part of that camp was just going on a lot of hiking trips and a lot of you know a lot of paddling trips and and that really sparked my my love of the outdoors and and just just blew my mind. One of the things you mentioned in your in your book is the wild ore reference of of getting out of your head by experiencing and being in real wilderness or or wild areas. We've both been to Haidegui where you see the real rainforest, the real alive ecosystems, and that when I was there, that sense of wild awe was so obvious and clear. How have you experienced wild awe and what has it done for you as someone experiencing nature? I I think my first experience of of that feeling of wild awe came Not in the forest but but up in the mountains. that that as I was saying as a kid, I was going on these hiking trips in the Appalachians and one of them was to Mount Washington, which is actually a mountain you can drive to the top of. But for me as a ten year old kid, it felt like Mount Everest. And and there was one day where we were hiking around in the rain and I just it was, you know, the most spiritually expanding experience I'd had in my life up until that point. It just it it suddenly, you know, because d experienced it up until then it was j hiking was like drudgery, you were carrying this heavy pack and my leather boots were grinding my feet up and I was like, Who wants to do this? This is horrible, And then suddenly that day it it all it all clicked because I we put down our packs and we went on this little day hike in the clouds up above, you know, the tree line with the fog blowing past and and I felt it it was a very kind of Thorevian moment. You Thoreau describes having a similar experience on on top of Katain. of just feeling like you're in touch with with the cosmos, that that there's it's this raw experience. All your your your thoughts fall away and and you step outside yourself. And I think that's what wild awe is. what I particularly love about forests is that they do it in a very in a very alive and a relational way. You know, you feel that wild awe but you feel it in perspective to these trees and relationship with these trees that have been growing for hundreds or or even in Haidui, in the case of Heidegguai at thousands of years, right? in in Haidegua I stood in front of a spruce, I think that was 800 years old, and I couldn't even begin to to wrap my arms around it. It would have taken probably seven people in a kind of daisy chain to wrap all our arms around it. you can't not feel a feeling of awe when you're when you're standing in front of a a a being like that. Aaron You also said both in your your your book on trails as well as in trees a You would talk about how nature can shed light on things like our relationship with the internet, our our new modern connections. What do you think we can learn from trees around the way that we interact? Well, I think, you know, and this is not gonna come as a surprise to to anyone who spends any time on the internet, we're suffering from a a kind of crisis of what what some people call disconnection, DYS connection, meaning we're We are both disconnected, DIS connected from one another, in a face-to-face way, increasingly. But also we are hyperconnected, right? So so we are hyper-connected in this way that is unhealthy, that it that is too fast, it's too thin. It is not r that that that rich, thick, reciprocal relationship that humans should be having with one another and and with the more than human world. And I think that if you look at the way trees flourish along one side alongside one another in a forest, you you will see a model for that form of you know of of of of entanglement, right? It's and it and it does it again, it's not perfect. It's not perfectly free from conflict and it never will be, but it it's much healthier and more fulfilling than the way we're currently living. when you
Load full transcript
talked about in the book that really struck me, particularly a moment when you mentioned about self help books. and this idea that self help is fine, but communal help is good too. And this idea of kind of we're living in these towers, these kind of self towers of we can do it better ourselves. But this lack of community, this lack of entanglement, like as you mentioned with people and beyond. yeah, it got me thinking. Yeah, I mean I think that's one of the One of the overall effects of capitalism is that it creates products that are aimed at you. everything is aimed at you as the consumer. And so if you look at the genre of of self-help, it's like, how can I optimize myself? How can I be more, h healthier, smarter, more productive, oftentimes more productive? right. But the the bigger question is is, yeah, how do we how do we grow alongside one another and help one another grow? It's much more difficult, than just changing your sleep patterns or, you know, drinking some kind of green smoothie every morning. it's it's a really tough philosophical question. Well, it's Jack, I know you got lots of excited questions, but I'll just share one quick experience I had with Jack recently out in nature, or na nature ish, as community and I got a tiny boat recently, a tiny dinghy. And we went on the canal, three of us, me, Jack, and another friend, we could barely fit in this thing. And I paddled it down up a tiny river and through an arc of trees and up into this area of lily pond and completely sheltered. And that feeling of being with friends, deeply connected to nature, deeply connected with each other, was a fantastic experience and and nothing that you nothing can compare with that on the internet. as as we're doing this right now because of the internet is fantastic. But we do need to get back together outside. I think that is high hugely valuable. Yeah, I think I I I agree. I of course I use the internet every day and I don't I don't wish it to go away. I I I think that the the one thing that we should always keep an eye out for are are s are things that feel totalizing, you know, things that feel like they're they're trying to consume all other things and and consume every moment of our lives. And I think that social media and and just the the internet at large continues like optimizing down that path for for obvious reasons just to maximize profit. It's just trying to gobble up all our time. So we have to resist and we have to find those little places as pockets of resistance. you know, there's a great line, Donovan Hohn calls them, I think it's gardens outside of the noise. You know, it's just these like and I think more people are feeling that, that desire to find not just places. I mean obviously Going into the the wilderness is a great way to cut yourself off from all that that connection, that hyper connection. But I think that there's also gardens outside of the noise in the form of books, right? In the form of putting on an LP or or whatever it is you like to do where you get to to put all that noise aside for a moment and and and try to just enjoy the thing that's that's in front of you. it's so strange that we even have to say that, but but that's where where we are right now. As a species is we're just incredibly hyperconnected and distracted. Hi, Will here. If you're enjoying what you're hearing so far, subscribe to a new leaf on your platform of choice and leave us a review. You'll want to hear what's coming up next. See you out there. This might be a slightly provocative question. do you think we focus on trees too much at the expense of other forms of nature? I I I don't think we focus on them too much in the larger picture of things, because most people don't really pic think about them at all. You know, they're just going through their lives. They they call it plant blindness. You know, people just walk around and trees are like this back this green black backdrop. And but the people who think about nature do think about trees a lot and and I think about that all the time. I find it fascinating that trees are really the a sign of symbol for the environment at large. you know, so if you think about planting a tree, that's like the the archetypal symbol of going out and and doing something good for the environment. and that can create some weird distortions, right? That can create s actually people can kind of weaponize that that symbolism. in ways that make it very thin and and kind of greenwashing, right? So so one of the things that we've seen recently are these massive tree planting campaigns, led by, you know, Mr. Beast and other people. I hope his, you know, army doesn't come after me for saying this, but a lot of those tree planting campaigns did not achieve very much at all because they weren't thinking in a in a in an ecological way. They weren't thinking about the the overall ecosystem in the landscape, they were just thinking about putting seedlings in the ground, right? And it was, if we plant a tree, that's a good thing. Trees will grow, they'll absorb carbon. Well the truth is no. Most of those trees died because they were planted in the wrong place. They didn't have enough care after they were planted. And in fact what it allowed a lot of companies to do is to excuse themselves for their carbon output by saying, Well, we're we're gonna plant a bunch of trees. and yeah that's just one way in which, you know, we have to really think about trees a lot more deeply than we currently do. They we can't just reduce them into these flat little holograms that represent the environment and and stop there. I also want to ask as well about climbing because I I do a lot of climbing and I loved reading the beginning of your book with the the Douglas fir and that feeling of childhood and reaching out again into an adult and experiencing childlike things. I actually had a similar experience. I moved lived in LA for a while and I moved back to the UK and I was looking
for cliffs to climb and there's nothing near me and the first thing I found was a Douglas fir. and I went up it and it was absolutely transcendental. so when I heard you talk about Douglas Fur and that connection to childhood, that really that really resonated with me. Could you talk a little bit about that experience of reconnecting with tree climbing and the fear and the the focus that that brought you? Yeah. as a kid I I climbed trees as I think you guys probably did, right? I I think everyone does. not everyone, literally everyone, but Pretty much every culture on earth, if you go there, you will see little kids climbing trees. It's it's an incredibly common thing. It it it really resides in our anatomy. Or we're still an arboreal species to some degree. we we we it's just in our in our bones. And yet everyone stops climbing trees at some point. And I find that really interesting that as we get bigger and heavier, obviously gets a little bit more difficult, but I think it's really like a neural thing. I think that we start to wait, you know, the the the the cautious part of our brain becomes a lot stronger. And that wild, fearless part of our brain b starts to wither as we get older. And I started feeling this in my life in all sorts of ways, you know, like the way I was writing and the the way I was thinking and just I was like becoming too optimized to a very narrow way of life. And so I had this craving one day to to go out and climb a tree. I was also I'd also been reading Calvino's The Baron in the Trees. I don't know if you guys know that book, but it's this beautiful ode to to tree climbing. It's about a boy who climbs a tree and never comes back down. spends his entire life in the forest or hopping from tree to tree. And and you know, I had this like a little primal ancestral craving in me to go climb a tree. And so I there's a beautiful Dugfer out by the sea where I live. I I climbed up to the first branch and Thought I was doing pretty good, It's like, okay, I remember how to do this. And then got up to the second branch and looked down and suddenly just felt this wave of nausea and vertigo and completely froze. And of course, as you know, tree climbing is always coming down is always the worst part because you're reaching your foot out and it's kind of shaking and you you know, you can't quite reach the branch below you. And so after that I I said, What what the hell was that? what why why did I lock up so bad? Because I I climb, you know, I rock climb as well. And I I don't have overwhelming feelings of of vertigo when I'm roped up. and yet something about being in that tree was the combination of the height and and this feeling that, you know, the branch could drop, right? That you you don't have total trust that the tree will hold you. And so yeah, I started free climbing trees again and then I took this tree climbing course. Started doing that and and it it is when you're up in the branches of a tree, it's the phenomenology of
it's completely different from being on the ground, right? You feel completely different. and I love that feeling. There's a feeling of tenuousness, and fierce attention. You're really focused. But also there's a strange feeling of of being held, right? That that the tree has you in its hands and it's holding you up there and and it could drop you, but it doesn't. And so with that comes comes a certain gratitude. One of the things that we wanted to do in this podcast is help people reconnect with nature, whether that's climbing a tree or visiting those leafy suburbs and finding little insects or something in in in people's local communities or down their street. What advice would you have for people to reconnect with nature and find ways to f to explore nature in their own context? I mean, I think the easiest way to start is is to start local and to start communal, right? So so where I live, there's a a mushroom hunting group that goes out and we've we've gone on a couple of mushroom hunting trips with them in the fall and it's just remarkable this group of people, the the feeling of camaraderie you have, and also the feeling of of all this w knowledge that's been accryling in the older members of the group or the more knowledgeable members that they're just happy to share with you, right? That that is something 'cause I think part of what feels daunting about the interaction you know with with the wilderness is, well, first it's it's feeling unsafe. And so being in a group, especially, you know, if you're a woman, you're a person of color and and you don't feel safe in in those places, which I totally understand, being in that group can really help get rid of some of that feeling. But also there's just a feeling of like, what am I supposed to do here? Right? Like what what is that's how I felt as a kid. I was like, This is boring. And I think a lot of people feel that way. They're just like there's n It's just a bunch of trees and rocks and moss and stuff. And there's n I so they don't understand how to be in that in that place and and what will make it interesting. And so having that that knowledge from other people really helps i enrich the experience. And if you think about indigenous, traditional indigenous societies, that that you know, much of your day would have been spent, especially when you were a kid walking around with elders and they would be telling stories. And they would the stories would be about the plants and and the animals of that place. And often they would be taking place in that place. and so, you know, in High Degui, you'd know the exact place where the raven stole the light. You know, it took place on on that little spit of land right there. And that was such a rich way to interact with those wild places, with with those, you know, with the landscape at large. And I think we've lost a lot of that. So when we walk out into the forest behind my house or anywhere, it's just like this blank landscape. And and that that leads to that feeling of like, what am I supposed to do here? Rob, I know you've lived in British Columbia for a while where obviously trees, logging, old growth, these are huge debates that that we've kind of looked into and I've written about. I know that you've kind of looked into this extensively. How do you feel about what's going on in the area? And how do you feel about the forests that you now live around and and and you've been able to experience in all kinds of ways, including right behind you as we as we speak? Yeah, the big debate that's been going on here for quite a while now is has to do with old growth logging and and that's something that has not stopped in in British Columbia. you know, the estimate is somewhere between eight and and three percent of what they call the iconic old growth. So not stunted little trees growing up in the mountains, but the really big, healthy trees that are ancient ha have already been logged. And there's only there's only th three percent left according to Suzanne Samard. And this has sparked an enormous movement here, you know, to try to save these trees. That there's a place called Ferry Creek, which was the the last unlogged old growth watershed on southern Vancouver Island. And it saw the largest mass uprising in Canadian history. it I think twelve hundred people showed up to get arrested trying to stop these trees from from being cut down. And eventually they they they succeeded, they largely succeeded in in saving that land from being cut down. I went out and I tried to lend a hand to to the blockade and I was actually teaching tree climbing courses up at this place called Ridge Camp, where the oldest trees are, and I I spent a week there and it it got me thinking because the the blockade had a lot of indigenous leadership and and including a a remarkable man, a a carver and musician named Chiokin, would talk to us a lot about this relationship with the The wilderness with nature that is outside of the colonial frame of mind. And we're really trying to encourage us to, you know, decolonize our thinking. And that got, I mean, started down this long road of thinking about rootedness. What does it mean to be rooted to place? The deeper sense of rootedness to me has to do with relationality. It's having those deep and enduring relationships with local community and local species. that allow everyone to to to flourish over time. And and you know, you guys mentioned that you went to to Heidegwai. That was somewhere I went as well, I saw a a totem pole raising there, which was a remarkable experience. And and during that time I went for a hike with my husband Remy through some of the old trees there. And I I was just r you know thinking about this chain again, this chain of care, right, that stretches back the height of people having been In that forest for so long. In fact, the the the Haida myths tell that they were there before the trees were, that they were actually they watched the first trees grow up. science is is actually confirming this, that that you know the the Haida have have been on this island for for you know fourteen thousand years. And at that time it would have been more of like a a tundra. In fact, so they they have those ancient trees, they have been stewarding from the very beginning. What an incredibly inspiring model that that is for us. Absolutely. And and I think the way that the Cedar Tree ran through every aspect of of the Hyder life and the s the pride of place, the smells when you're there visiting visiting these carving workshops, the pride they have in in their trees in the forest and the island. I've never been somewhere where there's been quite so much kind of identity with with with where they live. And That's that's one of the sad things is the fact that they have these trees are such a huge part of their life, but they see the timber leaving their shores on these big boats to be sold on the international market. And and it just reminds you of how precious and fragile that relationship is between the community and trees, and the community and nature. And I think if there's anything I've learned from this podcast that we've discussed, thinking about that nature and those trees in a communal sense, in a way that you learn about these things from elders as opposed to in a book or as opposed to in your own on your own individual journey I think is is really powerful. Rob, thanks so much for this conversation. it's been fascinating. really enjoyed reading the book and and and talking about these issues with you and really looking forward to to seeing your your future work and what comes next. Yeah, thank you so much and thank you for for continuing this conversation. I I think this is something the world needs.