สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
Adam Gomolin: Hi guys. Hi Noah. Good afternoon on The East Coast. I don't know about how you guys slept last night. year old was up from ⁓ one o'clock to three o'clock in The morning. So I've been wondering whether for a while The feeling I had in The morning was a hangover some days from a very small amount alcohol or fatigue. And given The fact that I drank almost nothing last night and felt like I woke up on The bad side of a bender, I can...
Noah Broyles: Good afternoon.
Adam Gomolin: now conclude that it was fatigue. Chase, you're what? You're six, seven years removed from sleepless nights?
Chase Pletts: Yeah, ⁓ say, well, no, I, when did they, when did they stop? You know, your brain erases everything after ⁓ The three years. I want to say, I think sleeplessness is — I'm about five years out. I'm actually, I'm exhausted right now. I'm mumbling, because my son did decide to get up at five in The morning and crawl into our bed. So I'm a little.
Adam Gomolin: Five years out. The brain erasure thing, everybody tells you about it before you become a parent that you're like, you'll ask them questions and they go, I don't remember that. And you go how can you not remember that? And then now I have a six month old and I'll be like, how did that work two and a half years ago? You know, cause I also can't remember.
M.M.DELUCA: Hmm.
Adam Gomolin: It's a pleasure to have all of you guys here. ⁓ Obviously, you not write in historical fiction. So you're here and capacity is, I think, co-host of this podcast. ⁓ But we have Chase, Marjorie, Chris gathered here. You you guys have written. You know, Chris, you write in The...
M.M.DELUCA: Hmm.
Noah Broyles: Indeed, indeed.
Adam Gomolin: The early 20th century chase and Marjorie, you guys both wrote in The latter half of The 19th century and I had The pleasure of serving as an editor ⁓ each of your books. I would imagine that many of The people who are tuning into this podcast have read your books, but for those who ⁓ haven't, Noah's going to give a little And The topic of The podcast is of course, it's kind of flowing out of some audio essays that we did recently on ⁓ The stupidification, ⁓ dumbing down. There many different ways to say it.
M.M.DELUCA: Ahem.
Adam Gomolin: of The state of fiction, both general fiction, genre fiction, and of course in their kind of The loss of a of importance of literary fiction in kind our reading diet in America. And we're going having, I think, a lot of different writers on to talk about this, but The goal here was to really kick off with something that I think ⁓ is one of most important aspects of fiction and fiction, which is historical fiction. And I've had, like I said, The pleasure of watching each of you guys work through increasingly deep, interesting, compelling, dramatic, and insightful drafts of each of your novels. So I wanted to talk to you and hopefully we could deliver some insights to The increasingly large listenership of this podcast. Mr. Broyles, want to kick us off?
Noah Broyles: Yeah, Marjorie, Chase, Christopher, thank you for joining us today. Brief intro to all of these fine folks. Marjorie is an author writing from Winnipeg. With Inkshare, she published The Savage Instinct back in 2021. That's a psychological thriller set in 1870s England, where a woman released from an asylum finds herself in an equally imprisoning marriage and forms a strange bond with Mary Ann Cotton, England's first female serial killer. The novel received a starred review from Publishers Weekly and was called by Booklist, a fascinating portrayal of womanhood in Victorian England that is also a nail-biting thriller that will keep readers riveted until The very last page. Chase lives and writes in Los Angeles. Inkshare has published his debut, also back in 2021, The Loving Wrath of Eldon Quint. The story follows a Dakota farmer whose twin brother is a notorious outlaw. After years of estrangement and in violence on a winter morning in 1883, The farmer Eldon Quint sets out to rid The world of The outlaw Jack Foss once and for all. The novel won two Spur Awards, Best Traditional Novel and Best First Novel, and was praised by Booklist as a clear winner for of Paulette Giles' News of The World or Charles Portis' classic True Grit. And Christopher grew up in Singapore and now lives in Canada. He's an architect by training. And he writes intricate mysteries in The Golden Age tradition. With Inkshares he has published The standalone Unnatural Ends and The first two installments in The Eric Peterkin series, most recent of which, A Pretender's Murder, was released back in February. Christopher has received wide praise, including from The Sun, The Montreal Gazette, Library Journal, Booklist, and Publishers Weekly. So all of you are masters in your respective areas of historic fiction, very eager to hear from you today.
Adam Gomolin: Yeah, what an set of accolades ⁓ across each of you, let alone all of you. I'm to just briefly articulate for anyone who hasn't had opportunity to listen to The previous two podcasts, what kind of some of The main takeaways were and The kind of arguments proffered so to speak. And then we can dive The questions. I think at The core of what we talking about in The audio essays was first and foremost, a loss of attention span.
M.M.DELUCA: Hmm
Adam Gomolin: Books require a tremendous amount of focus, both in obviously bringing The words to life in your head and The attention span for masticating something across, know, intellectually and emotionally across 8, 10, 12, 16, however many hours. It asks things of you that nonstop television, video games, social media, and perhaps even podcasts don't. So in, I think, ⁓ to that, we have just a general fracturing of ⁓ attention. It's allocated across so many more things that books themselves don't occupy that place of primacy. And addition to that, like a lot of what we've talked about ⁓ in audio essays is The loss of thinking, right? And The prevalence of
Load full transcript
feeling, ⁓ that it's not just that we've stopped reading, but that The things that we're reading don't ask us to contemplate The fundamental richness of The human experience. all entertainment and so much of it is nothing but titillation. Mr. Broyles, what else would you add in addition to that?
Noah Broyles: No, yeah, that's a good summation of The last two. I pulling from my essay a couple weeks ago was kind of just this mass proliferation of forms of entertainment has led in fiction, I think, almost hyperbole in so many genres where to get, like, to have your voice heard as an author these days, you need to be shouting The in a sense, and The fiction that shouts The loudest doesn't always say The most, ⁓ Yeah, I think we're looking to plumb The depths of where The meeting, The happy medium is between saying something but also entertaining audience at The same time. ⁓
Adam Gomolin: Yeah, I think fundamentally, just to kind of like add a little bit to that, like have never thought, it's something that you guys know, because we've had an opportunity to work with each of you guys, there's nothing with entertaining people in a book. You know, ⁓ I think like a book doesn't need to feel like homework. I've never picked up one of Christopher's books, except for The first drafts, of course. No, I'm kidding, Chris, it's never homework. And felt like... his rendering human frailty came at The cost of The quality of The rendering of that human framing. And that's one of The questions that we want to get into. But that when you settle for only entertaining and that when The term entertaining really comes to mean titillating that ⁓ one of The great things that a book can give you which is to put you in someone else's mind and experiences loses a lot of its value. So let's dive into that. And then Noah is going to do a dramatic reading of The first five chapters of The Court of Thorns and Roses after this. ⁓ we can start with you Marjorie. What's your favorite piece of historical fiction from
Noah Broyles: Hahaha
Adam Gomolin: another writer, whether it's it's recent or it's a bit ago. You know, for each of you, I don't think that anyone embarks upon The of writing historical fiction without having appreciated a piece of historical fiction. For almost everyone, you're in some sense, trying on a version of or making a contribution to a genre that you love. So who was it for you? What was it for you?
M.M.DELUCA: Yeah, well actually before I started writing The Savage Instinct, my favorite piece was The Wolf Hall series by Hilary Mantel. ⁓ Yes, but I knew that that wasn't really The kind of thing I wanted to write. It's so intricately researched. It's a study of one man and his kind of passage to a kind of notoriety and fame.
Adam Gomolin: who recently passed, right?
M.M.DELUCA: I sort of had another author in mind who was also a favorite at The time, Sarah Waters, wrote historical fiction pieces, Fingersmith, The Little Stranger, which was a big inspiration to
me because it's historical, but it's ⁓ very, it's sort of psychological horror almost. And in that book, There's such a slow burning sense of dread that I thought this is The kind of suspense story that I want to write. Something that's rich in character, but that has this overwhelmingly dark atmosphere. I don't know if you know that book, The Little Stranger. I know it was made into a movie it's The story of a man a working class background that is introduced to this big sort of a stately home and becomes as a child, but becomes obsessed by it and goes back to it as a adult and a doctor. And it's crumbling by that time. It's a sort of crumbling kind of gothic place. But Sarah Waters is able to entertain you, but also make you think about so many aspects of The human condition. And there's There were some other books of hers that I really loved. when read those, I thought that's The kind of effect that I'm going for. The sort of sweet spot between depth and character development, also this ⁓ amazing sense of and sort of darkness, of dread. So she, would say she was a major inspiration to me as well as Margaret Atwood with alias grace. was another big one. Yeah.
Adam Gomolin: Of course, something we talked about a lot. Chris, who was it for you? Chris, yours is actually, I mean, it's a bit peculiar perhaps because your form of fiction is actually something that was obviously, I think, largely contemporaneous, right? In The sense of ⁓
Chris: It wasn't historical when it was written.
Adam Gomolin: Yes, that's exactly right.
Chris: It's kind of hard to say what my favorite ⁓ thing because I've wondered so I remember being fond of Anthony Barchester series. In The Eric Peter Kitt mysteries, ⁓ Eric lives place called Barchester, which is very much a ⁓ to that. But was mostly of The author's narrative I've heard him described as third-person omniscient and chatty. He'll tell you what's going on, what he thinks is going on, what you should think is going on, how you should feel about it, and then he'll go on to The next thing. It's really incredible.
M.M.DELUCA: Ha
Chris: The stuff in The period that I'm writing, all The Agatha Christie's and so on and so forth, Father Brown and so on, yeah, those were all contemporary at The time, it's really hard to pick just one. no, I when I...
Adam Gomolin: Do you have a favorite Christie? Is Is there one that stands even, you know, a forehead above The rest?
Chris: Mm-mm. I was just thinking about it this morning, think I have three which really come to The top of my mind. Five Little Pigs. A Murder Announced. And Mrs. Dead ⁓
Adam Gomolin: Chase, what was it for you? ⁓ Cause you had a very strange genesis point
Chase Pletts: Yeah, my, yeah, I tripped into it, I guess you could say. There was an image in my mind and it felt old and it felt... I could feel a certain time and a place and it wasn't a place or a time that I'd ever really been attracted to before. Which is actually, I'd say that's probably The thematic through line with my writing is I often go into worlds that I don't know enough about. Both from a genre perspective, writing in genres that I don't really particularly understand, which has its benefits and its drawbacks. The benefit being, I tend not to
M.M.DELUCA: you
Chase Pletts: lean on tropes or established rules of a genre. And The downside is that I tend not to know The tropes or The established rules of The genre or just not how The genre functions. So can be a bit of kicking around in The dark. And that was The same for writing a western And I liked westerns and read some books and was aware of The genre, but it wasn't something that I aspired to write in. ⁓ then as far historical fiction,
M.M.DELUCA: you
Chase Pletts: And I actually, just sit and think about this Chris and Marjorie were describing The books that they really loved and The they love them. Because for me, I don't know if have that same affinity for it. But ⁓ there's a book I'm right now that's called... What is it? Kalima Tales? I think it's by a Russian writer named Varlam Shalimov. I think I believe is how you pronounce it Poor Varlam was in The Gulag For about 15 years from The 1930s. And what really ⁓ he this I guess call it documentary fiction because you know, he's writing about his experience but they're very much stories and he gives The The stories a shape and I think what I... What I really like about this book is it's a, a number of just short stories or even, you know, there's a story about a tree that in summer and then we'll sort of lay itself down in The winter, knowing that The snow is coming. And so it's, it's very much about nature and, ⁓ you know, and humanity. I think that's, you'd see that if read The Loving Wrath of Eldon Quint, there's a lot of that there. Maybe that's The attraction there. ⁓
Adam Gomolin: Had you read a lot of Westerns before you went into it or was it something that you then really had to-
Chase Pletts: No, I'd be a few. Yeah, a few. I think I'd read Lonesome Dove and... name of The book is escaping me... The Searchers, which I don't remember. I remember that was The name of The book or just The name of The movie. Alan LeMay and a few others, ⁓ I want say. But no, I didn't. And then, you know, in The writing process, I did, I just read anything I could get my hands on. for whatever purpose I needed it at that time. I, you know, not, more of it was just filling my brain with it, using it for The moment, and then it falling right back out The other side, which is just tends to be The process for me when, writing, I'm just sort of consuming anything I can get my hands on, but that stuff isn't necessarily sticking beyond, you know, The, The, what I need it for at that moment. Yeah.
Adam Gomolin: ⁓ me ask you guys this, We obviously have been having this conversation about what's gone wrong, I think. in The content that we consume, in terms of what comprises The literary diet today. And it's almost impossible to have that conversation
without having a conversation about The broader kind of cultural corpus in America, right? ⁓ Because what people write and what people is, is a of that I texted Noah at midnight or 1230 in The morning The other, The other night, because, I had been listening to a podcast while bottle feeding my, my younger child and I had been surprised to hear a critique of Herodotus in his... Historiae, right, his telling of The histories of The various regions of The ancient world. I I learned two things. One thing that I took away was I didn't know that The word Historiae, our word history comes from his title Historiae, which actually means The researches in Greek, which I thought was interesting. But I was also interested to find out that people had really critiqued him. for his kind of overuse of violence, his overuse of sex and scandal and all of these things. And it made me chuckle think of how this of critique ⁓ of over-fascination reliance on titillation and these just base, base instincts literally goes back. to The Iron Age, And presumably even well before then, ⁓ So this stuff is so just endemic to ⁓ our repeating cycle of how interact with serious and non-serious writing. Marjorie, we go back to you. ⁓ think we are in our Fiction Diet today.
M.M.DELUCA: Yeah, I went on to write a few contemporary suspense thrillers, which did quite well. ⁓ But The pressure editors and publishers that space, because psychological are very popular now, The pressure is they want you write, and I'm going to quote, ⁓ an unput downable, ⁓ absolutely gripping with a jaw-dropping twist. This is kind of thing they're asking you to do. So often what asking you is to do something at The expense of developing The characters, making The plot move really fast, ⁓ coming up twists that readers can't, will never figure in advance, ⁓ even though they're really plausible twists. So, I found that has been a pressure for me. I still continued to write books where I felt I couldn't resist developing characters more, going into their lives a bit more, their motivations. And what happened with The first couple of books that came out, when they first came out, readers, some of them were ⁓ this is a really slow burn. I can't get into this. because it wasn't The kind of wham-bam start that they were used to. But gradually I found an audience who really wanted that more in depth, sort of ⁓ I guess call it upmarket suspense, which sort of straddles The boundaries. But it was a bit of a tough thing to get there. But now I'm kind of feeling there is a bit more of a... ⁓ pressure to write something ⁓ less depth, something more like a sort of an ensemble ⁓ like Lucy Foley, I don't really want to mention names, Lucy Foley writes good examples of that kind of thing, where you throw a bunch of people together and a happens. I think I think it's sort of trending to be more driven. ⁓ than character dense, there are still some pretty good contemporary suspense writers out there that I enjoy, but many The bestsellers at The of The, like New York Times list are written by a select few people who are basically pumping out The same kind of suspense. you know, two a year maybe.
Adam Gomolin: Chris, I want to get your characterization. we've had a lot of global conflict. We're inundated constantly with news updates on our phones. we're stressed out and we're anxious and what people want is just fun. The world is so serious. because that seriousness is brought to us in a thousand headlines and push notifications a day, Is this now a permanent state that we live in where books are just network television, Of like disposable, repeatable plots with thin characters and some, know, big plot point twist or whatever that's going to bring you back from The commercial five times an hour, Or do you think we're going to have a moment in which we go, Hey, this really isn't working. And we just have to our phones on do not disturb for The whole day. ⁓ and to reading more serious things. It may not be as stark and binary as that, but which of those do you tend towards?
Chris: I'm actually ⁓ sure The issue is quite as dire as you think it is. I think a certain survivorship bias that's at play here, that we've always had dumb entertainment, ⁓ The and ⁓ from The Iron Age. just carried through. We've you know... ⁓ penny dreadfuls ⁓ were all The rage when they came out, and we don't really remember any of it. mean, ⁓ Sweetie Todd maybe Spring-Heeled Jack, I think, may still be The public consciousness, but you don't really remember dumb stuff. So when you look back The stuff that survives, ⁓ you think, ⁓ wow, that must have been really really smart, but ⁓ not really. You're still back at a period where people may have enjoyed ⁓ public hangings, baiting, gladiatorial and...
M.M.DELUCA: Mm-hmm.
Chris: feel like that in every age, people are always looking at The literature and comparing it to what happened in The past. I think that going to quote-unquote save this age is going to people looking back from maybe two or three ages in The future saying, oh wow, The early 21st century, they were so smart.
M.M.DELUCA: He
Adam Gomolin: hear you. mean, your argument, which you, heard few days ago for The first time is essentially that there's a, a positive survivorship bias in The sense that The kind of disposable stuff doesn't stick with us. Right. And The stuff that sticks with us is The more substantive stuff. So that you're going to look back. you know The first quarter century nobody's really gonna remember a court of thorns and roses or whichever romantic novel of The week month or year it is ⁓ they might
Chris: or they might, for completely different reasons. Another thing I think is that ⁓ dumb things actually turn out to be a lot smarter than we give them credit for.
Adam Gomolin: Yeah, I hear you. both that certain things that might be viewed as stupid in one age take on a subsequent meaning in another age, right? And similarly, just The more meretricious disposable
fiction doesn't have a staying power. So you'll look back and things like Goldfinch will have a more of... pronounced resonance in retrospect or things like, all The light you cannot see, which has obviously been a big book or The covenant of water or any of these books that are on The more serious side. will have a disproportionate share of our retrospective recollection, either 20 years from now in our lifetimes or 100 years from now. The most obvious thing to say about this, maybe it's not The most obvious, but one obvious thing to say is that I believe Gatsby was a critical failure in Fitzgerald's lifetime, that he died and it had sold fewer than 5,000 units.
M.M.DELUCA: Mm-hmm.
Adam Gomolin: so ⁓ think that there's at The very least a heck of a lot of anecdotal evidence in support of this hypothesis. Chase, let me ask you a subset of this question that I've had kicking around in my head for The last week. you, know, each of you is great novelist. Each of you also an incredible screenwriter. ⁓ chase, you've obviously had some big sales that, know, you're, ⁓ entering The WGA Marjorie. I've read your work, ⁓ both kind of in, you know, a Microsoft report file and in final draft, it's fantastic. And Chris, you and I've had a lot of opportunities to work together on The adaptation of your book, including with, a very big director in, John East chase. this weird thing right now where, and maybe it's always been true, but books were for a time, I think. The predominant creative engine of our society, reading drove Hollywood, right? it's not to say that there weren't plenty of spec screenplays that became gigantic hits. Of course there were, right? But reading felt like The fundamental kind of literary creative lens, And I think somewhere in The past 20 years, it flipped. Which isn't to say that people didn't love going to The movie theater before, but reading really was The primary form of cheap portable premium entertainment, hopefully premium entertainment. And that seems to have shifted a lot, Where we really are no longer a society that reads, we're a society that watches. And I think The thing about things that you watch is that they cost a lot of money to make. And because of that, they are so much more of a team effort. There's so much less of a function of an individual person, There's ⁓ much greater phalanx of executives that are modifying things. And there's often just so many individual writers that are brought in on a project, So that it's much less of, setting aside The word author for a second, it's much less of an auteur medium, right? You could that film itself is much less of an auteur medium than it was in The late 90s, for instance. but just it's much more of a group corporate effort than The book, Where it is just much more of an, ⁓ think an expression of a unique individual's perspective on how to tell a specific story. Do you think that kind of film, Becoming The dominant expressive lens, TV with it, of our society has reduced
The role of The author auteur? As like a singular storytelling, ⁓ A storyteller in a way that tends to make things dumber. Does that resonate at all for you?
Chase Pletts: Yes, ⁓ does, but also I don't know if, well one, I don't know if film and TV are The dominant medium anymore. I think that's, an argument be made that anything under 30 seconds is The dominant medium. And as far as The individual creator versus The committee, I don't know if Hollywood has essentially changed its ways. say that in The 90s, was as many sort of built projects, like movie like fugitive, for example, which probably had ⁓ seven or eight screenwriters on Where, you know, it's not because they would hire somebody and then they'd fire them. It was actually more because, yes, it was like not everybody's great at everything. And they would bring somebody into like, to write, you know, do a dialogue polish or do this or do that. But a lot of The times The really good people are only available for one or two drafts. And then they go off and leave The producer with a script that's not green lightable. And then they have to go and hire another writer and then. that writer's probably of a lesser caliber or not quite right, and then they have to hire another and another. So it's The, you know, often it's, it's a function of The marketplace that exists around The business and availability and whatnot. And I guess what I'm just saying is there are, are all these different factors that go into why a movie is successful or not, or if it feels like it has an authorship to it. it feels like something that was made by committee, something that, you know, clearly there's no through line. There's it's The voice is muddled. As far as where those projects start, whether from you know, what is just referred to by The blanket term of IP. I'd say IP is as prevalent, if not more so than ever, but it's not just books. It's graphic novels, it's webtoons, it's, it could be anything, a children's book, you know, ⁓ of us with kids have probably ⁓ read some version of The Pout Pout Fish to children. ⁓ Maybe and I, Adam, are The ones that's our age and they're making that. ⁓
M.M.DELUCA: Yeah.
Adam Gomolin: If you had to translate IP into a phrase, because we obviously hear this word all The time, what do you think it usually means?
Chase Pletts: I don't know if it has any meaning anymore because what a lot of people are doing is creating The IP to then make The movie, which ⁓ you IP, think inherently is something that was a, a crater of value and a pre-exist in a different format. Now it's just a different format you know, maybe it was successful. Maybe it's not, obviously it would always help for something to be successful. ⁓
Adam Gomolin: I mean, you could logically decompose The term IP, obviously, I mean, people mean intellectual property when they say that. And I've always thought, having heard it a million times over all of our time in Los Angeles, that is a certain point like ⁓ Hollywood ⁓ wanting to don The linguistic attire of more serious industries. But I think that you could say that ⁓ it... brings an audience with it, right? That it's something that people recognize that they're attached to, which means you have some presumptive viewership coming into your investment. Two, could say that it's in, and this is connected to that, that it's a form of validation, That you something that you can look at and you can say mechanically this works. and then you can at it and you can even adjacent to that say that it's some type of schematic, We're not starting from zero. We have access into The minds of these characters will inform screenwriters, ⁓ directors, and actors amongst all The other sundry, ⁓ of individuals that participate in The making of a television show or a movie. Let me ask you guys this kind of from your perspective in The process writing these books. What is it that you think that if we're talking about an age in which things may or may not be as Christopher asserts uniquely dumb, right? What do you think ⁓ irrespective of The validity that hypothesis or partial validity of that hypothesis? What why is historical fiction smart and why does it give that is above The norm and intelligence to to a reader? What are The various aspects of that?
Chris: think part of it is relating The past to The present and sort of revealing that certain things are universal, certain things continue to continue enthrall us ⁓ throughout The ages. I what that does it kind of to a universal human truth. So if there's something that, you something about The past that resonates with you, still resonates now, then... gives it even more depth. Going back to whole idea ⁓ of ⁓ fun depth, personal thought always is that having depth The fun is a false depth, because... ⁓ a fun actually is, is that ⁓ an appeal to ⁓ The human psyche. If humanity in general doesn't find appeal in what you're writing, ⁓ then there's a ⁓ real possibility that not connecting ⁓ with The human And if you're not connecting with The human truth, then what depth do really ⁓
Adam Gomolin: That's interesting. There's nothing, nothing inherently wrong or degrading about ⁓ an aspect of a story entertaining ⁓ in regard. something that really, ⁓ you said that strikes me as true and something. I've thought about a lot in editing historical fiction is that there's a, think an innate human desire to situate ourselves in The lineage, right? And to connect with The past. And to see ourselves, not just in kind of The context of our family and, you know, those that came before us in a kind of more ancestral, narrowly defined lineage, but to see The fears, The wants, The needs, The hopes and aspirations of humanity is constant across both history and also just different countries, civilizations, that feeling of sameness. I think is The opposite of almost hyper-consciousness and super individualization where you kind of achieve a sort of peace and knowing that you're kind of The teeny tiniest
thread in this larger, fairly common human fabric. Does that kind of, is The thing that I just said what you were thinking?
Chris: The other thing is The difference. It's similarity and a difference to know that though these have changed, even though this technology has changed, you're still dealing with something that is fundamentally The same.
Adam Gomolin: I want to take that and flip it into a question that will bring Chase into this conversation. point is obviously that it doesn't just give us an insight into The past, but that it gives us a little bit of an insight into The present, The frontier is closed by more or less 1890. Right? But westerns really begin 10, 20 years later. And yes, during The period of The West, you have The dime store, generic novels that maybe Christopher is referencing as in certain sense, those are The types of things that don't survive, But there's something about The Western that is this tale that we use to tell ourselves stories about ourselves, About The making of The American nation. And because of that, there's something about so many of them that are... there's an intentional dictation of a narrative, And then, you know, more recently with sort of revisionist Westerns, we've seen an intentional telling ⁓ an opposing narrative. So I'm curious for you, if we're talking about fiction makes us smarter, Do think that there's something unique about... many of The great Westerns in The fact that they are also narratives about kind of The birth and building of our nation.
Chase Pletts: ⁓ me try to, we try to knit those two. ⁓ fiction making us smarter, but also The Western which is divided into The myth then The revision of The myth. I mean, think what's, ⁓ sure there are other genres that have this inherent tension in a sort of polarity to them, like Western does. I can't think of them right off bat, but I'm sure they exist where. It starts out as one story and then that story is retold often from The alternative perspective to illuminate The, for lack of a better word, bullshit that inherent in The first version, The myth-making. I think that gave Westerns probably ⁓ a second life and I'm not sure they have a third life in them. think what's interesting about The Western, many things, but for me what was interesting was that tension between The myth ⁓ and then destruction of The myth. I just always found that. think that was The for me. The attraction to maybe reading The Bible. The Bible was written. Many of stories in The Bible are written, what, 100, 150 years after The actual occurrences. ⁓ I think you look at enough crazy TikTok videos, you'll start going back to ancient Sumeria. ⁓
Adam Gomolin: Certainly.
Chase Pletts: But that idea looking back, ⁓ mean, ⁓ of history, and I mean, maybe The thing that trying to articulate here is that all of history is fiction, right? It's always being told through The lens of looking backwards, generally through The voices that survived it ⁓ and to shape it to their benefit, right? So history itself whether it's considered fiction or actual fiction, ⁓ is all sort of narrative designed to tell a story that isn't necessarily The truth is not is going to leave out certain things benefit The teller The history.
Adam Gomolin: if you begin with this kind of like Hegelian notion, of there's a thesis, there's an antithesis, and then those are synthesized together you have The kind initial myth-making of The American West, Then you have an intentional unbundling evisceration, counter narrative, however you want to state it, that's proposed. And then in your novel, I think for instance, certainly not The only novel to do this, but it is something of an attempt to balance those two things, To acknowledge that is an unqualified ineluctable savagery to The kind of quote unquote settling of The American West, but also that The overwhelming majority of people that went out there were themselves impoverished, destitute, broken people, simply trying to establish something better than The hard scrabble poverty of either, The country they came from, number one, or number two, The East Coast that they found themselves in, which had no sanitation, famine, disease, The people that were sent out there were pitiful and pitiable, right? ⁓ And that those two narratives can sit by side
Chase Pletts: ⁓ think what you're saying and ⁓ you go to The, you're talking about holding to potentially opposing ideas.
Adam Gomolin: Yeah, The thing that we hate doing today, right? Yeah.
Chase Pletts: in The same in The same same breath and know, which is I forget who proffer that as their definition of intelligence, but can people do that still ⁓ in world where which we're sort of ⁓ always coerced or ⁓ cajoled ⁓ choosing side and a Western is inevitably about, you know, many of ⁓ pre-revisionist are, Indians are bad and
Adam Gomolin: Yes.
Chase Pletts: you know, The settlers are good or vice versa. And so, you know, it becomes this us-versus-them narrative. And then The revisionist portions start looking at, you know, start that apart. So I guess if you were going to, you know, look at The Western ⁓ could challenge to, you know, engage our critical skills, it would be looking at those different sides ⁓ of The coin coming up with
M.M.DELUCA: Hmm.
Chase Pletts: them that don't necessarily fit ⁓ prevailing on either side, we've maybe lost, not lost, I mean, The skill of many people can do this and talked about all The time. And I think we talk about how dumb we are in very smart ways today, ironically.
Adam Gomolin: There's some aspect that in having to engage with these notions of The past, Here's an argument, here's another argument, and not an argument in The sense of like you're given a political essay to read, But The various characters and their experiences, as humanized on The page by The writer give you a human insight into people, Marjorie, there were so many times in The editing of your book that I kept saying, Marjorie, there's a problem.
She just, she doesn't leave. she's beginning to realize The person she's with is terrible and she doesn't do anything about it. And you would go, well, she can't do anything. I would go well, what do mean she can't do anything? And over The course of editing that book, like The kind of bringing home, not like a intellectual understanding of powerlessness, but an emotional understanding of powerlessness, because across these drafts of empathizing with this character, you begin to live in this world. Christopher.
M.M.DELUCA: Yeah.
Adam Gomolin: In your book, you know, it deals with both issues of kind of, race relations and war trauma, and having to dig into those things and kind of economic and class conflicts, It makes you think about many things from back then versus today, Even The degree to which things like technology are beginning to upset The manner in which people interact with each other. Cause The telephone is this new dandy thing, right? Don't you think that there is something. about having and I don't think it's like a baseline level of having to do your homework right because The person that does The homework is The author but to go back to critical thinking right ⁓ if The thing that we're losing in our is thinking do you think there's a degree each of you to which reading something that is set in The past kind of carries with it a baseline intrinsic level of critical thought
Noah Broyles: Yeah, I mean, that's beautiful drawing together of what we've been saying, I think, ⁓ that if we can't, if like, The that we do in our contemporary fiction is naturally blinded our contemporary circumstances, which it seems be we've been saying ⁓ with all of discussion of history and historical fiction, then, ⁓ The only form of fiction that really lets us step outside of ourselves and outside of time of ourselves is historical fiction. And I think The Road Home may well be historical fiction novels that will see either... Many of The thinking fiction novels that mentioned earlier, Adam, ⁓ All The Light We Cannot Covenant of Water, ⁓ you know, they're all historical novels. So... Part of recognizing where we are and maybe trying to nudge our way towards somewhere else will probably be achieved through The lens of historical fiction.
M.M.DELUCA: I don't think it's The only genre though. and always drawn towards science fiction and speculative And ⁓ I've reading lot of stuff that I think that is also an area where you have to really think, requires a lot of critical thinking, which requires a lot of research because on something, some phenomena, some something real is happening now. I do believe that's why my, my favorite writer Margaret Atwood kind of ⁓ into science fiction ⁓ dystopian fiction. think definitely an area where, you know, you step outside of everything ⁓ and consider The possibilities of what if this happened or what if that happened and especially when you're thinking of some of The current trends today, The AI thing, it's limitless really ⁓ you can come up with. And I think that's a really hopeful area. I've read some really good pieces of work that are The boundaries ⁓
Chase Pletts: I
M.M.DELUCA: And I think that's an area that's going to save thinking person's fiction.
Adam Gomolin: Chase, you had a thought there.
Chase Pletts: I was just gonna say it's a great point about, you know. world building, essentially novels that are forced to build out a whole world. And I'm always by writers who can ⁓ a series of books like Dune or even of Thrones, right? But they all, what's interesting about those books is that they're creating this whole other world. I want say it was Game of Thrones that is based very heavily on certain period of history in The Middle East, ⁓ a thousand so
M.M.DELUCA: Yeah. Mm-hmm.
Chase Pletts: years ago. And, you know, Dune probably being very much based on just colonialism in general and The myth, make The, The, you know, religion that is used to control The people. So all those things have touch points in even though they're creating a world that is a little foreign to us, but there's still something that we can grab onto and go, this feels we're still living in The human space with so many of those books. That's a big epic. And don't have to be big and epic.
M.M.DELUCA: Hmm Hmm.
Chase Pletts: anything can, you know, can build a world that feels very small, but intricate and detailed. And yeah, I think I was having kind of a problem wrapping my mind around this book of, or this idea of books that, you know, you think, or The author has to do The thinking or, you know, something that is more than just tropey crap, you know, like stuff you were describing Marjorie that, you know, publishers would like you to make, which is just fabulayic.
M.M.DELUCA: You
Chase Pletts: nonsense, that, you know, in form requires ⁓ The to dig deeper, guess, where maybe that's The problem we're experiencing today is The form is encouraging The author to stay on The whether it's publishers who want The same kind of thriller and over again with minor differences or The, you know, The supposed Netflix decree that ⁓ a majority of their filmmakers, they need them to constantly engage The audience be giving The audience those dopamine hits. So while they're folding laundry, they occasionally look up at The television. So maybe it's formats are, it's sort of The circle, The circle where we're giving people kind of dumber stuff. That's what they have to watch. ⁓ They're half paying to it. And then we have to get dumber to make them pay more attention to it. ⁓
Adam Gomolin: Let me try and encapsulate a couple of things that you were saying. then it's fascinating, Because as Noah made that comment about historical fiction being The way that we do that, I could hear kind of like Tal Klein in my head who wrote The Punch-Escrow, was a great friend of mine, kind of going well, you can do The same thing in The future. And obviously, that's what Marjorie said. I think we all agree with
that, and so does Noah. I think at The core of that is this notion that In some way it's easier to contemplate our own questions and existence and feelings and nature in an environment that feels completely removed from our present. you remove all The constants or, ⁓ The environmentally, right. It's easier to, to kind understand and access certain things. Right. Which I think it, it makes sense. that can kind of think their way into why seeing things in a completely foreign allow you to look at it distinctly, and understand it more precisely. Marjorie, you were bringing up certain types of fiction before. I actually, I don't like, I don't know how different that is from some of The things that we're dealing with from Danielle Steele, I think Danielle Steele has a lot less staying power, 10, 20, 30, 40 years removed from The high-difference fiction, which would go to Christopher's point. But The thing that Chase was just saying that I think is interesting in kind of setting up that dichotomy is that like, listen, there's always been a market. for these kind of stories that keep people on The surface of something, right? That don't let you go deeper. Like they used to be in The mass market paperback, it was a small paperback with small print. They were disposable. They were 399 or 299 or a little four, five, 699, but they were cheaper, right? And The reason that it was called The mass market paperback was it had a mass market. It wasn't called The small market paperback, right? There was a huge audience for that. So just like by The name of The format, We can simply infer that there was always a big audience Chase, The thing that what you were saying that made me really think and The question that I would ask each of you and kind of concluding here is there a like a smart version of everything and there's a dumb version of everything. Right. And a lot The people that listen to this podcast are aspiring writers. I mean, I think that The overwhelming majority of The people that are, know, think we have our first episode now over about a thousand ⁓ downloads, which is wonderful. I know that like 650 of those downloads are aspiring writers. People in The larger ink shares audience, most of whom we've never met or interacted with. But to conclude this conversation with a question to each of you, There's a really smart version of everything and there's a really dumb version of everything, The... Dumb version of The Western is some version of The dime store, kind of like shoot Indian, Rob stage coach, drink whiskey, kiss girl, just that kind of lather, rinse, repeat, know, Jim tan laundry, right? The much more interesting, compelling version of it, I think, is to try and get into The humanity of The various people that of archetypally define The West, right? And to try to in that, get under The skin of The American story. you know, for you, you've done so much to to use The murder mystery to ask ourselves questions about society and really focus on motive
in a really deep way. it's never just murder for The sake of a murder. ⁓ It's a murder driven by humanity and that humanity is influenced by society. And The mores and norms of that society in all three of your The opposite of that, I think The version is essentially, like I always say with Noah, it's like The word of death. Where it's just like a puzzle, right? That is played for no other purpose than can I get The clues together faster than The person who's also reading The book at The same time? And while that may, stave off dementia and keep The mind nimble, it's not going, it's, it's, not enriching us. Right. In The context of self-understanding, understanding of humanity and our view of The world. Marjorie for you, it's ⁓ in a certain sense, like. could simply take all of The assets, The right? Of The of type of story that you're talking about ⁓ as derivative meretricious formulaic tropy. And you could simply pop that into history, And give it The thinnest AI enhanced gloss of period history. And it would be completely meretricious. Whereas ⁓ a better version of that, which is unequivocally what you accomplished in your novel and The reason you've received a lot of critical praise for it, audience praise, is that you can have aspects of a story that fulfill a desire for plot and fun, because watching a woman slowly gaslight leave isn't but you can have a story that has aspects of and aspects of all this stuff, ⁓ and in a certain sense, The thrill of spending with Mary Ann Cotton. England's, first female serial killer, And you can also leverage that to talk about really important concepts that bring you into The life of someone 150 years ago or so. While also enriching our understanding of The present. And I guess I would say to each of you guys, or not The writer that The aspiring writer that that that's listening to this ⁓ is focused on historical fiction or Maybe like you were saying, ⁓ Marjorie, it's a different of universe that allows us to contemplate our existence, or maybe it's just written in a present we recognize. Do you have any advice? Like what would your advice to that writer be on finding, engaging with a that they're developing in a way that maximizes its intelligence without necessarily making it homework for a reader?
M.M.DELUCA: I think for me The first step was to find a personal connection. I find a personal connection to something, I buy into it. obviously The Savage Instinct had personal connection because I was from The that The murderer was born. ⁓ knew The kind of people lived there. I lived that life. those people because grandmother lived there. ⁓ So connection kind of got me into it at first. Once I started researching it, if you're going to write historic fiction that really works well, you have to be prepared to delve into The past by, in my case, looking at newspapers from The era. I think that's The best way. ⁓ to actually understand The psyche The lifestyle of The times. Newspapers are amazing sources ⁓ everything from what used for medicine, what people did for entertainment, how people felt about social issues, The actual of The time. once I started getting all that reading accounts, of Mary Ann Cotton's hang. One of The very first pieces I from newspaper at The time was The account of Mary Ann Cotton's hanging. And it was so chilling. so, it read like piece of fiction. It was so descriptive. It had such atmosphere, but was ⁓ really disturbing. But at newspapers for me was a way to immerse myself in The era because obviously you can't go back and interview people ⁓ from that ⁓ So reading lot of first-hand information is The best to do. And ⁓ once you're immersed it and you're thinking that way, you know how The people speak. And I had an advantage there because I come from that area and I had an idea of how people lived and I don't you write something with real authenticity until you've done all of that research, I would
Adam Gomolin: you're kind of saying, number one, finding a piece of character that you can get into emotionally and from a dramatic perspective to seed it with real humanity, Like some people use themselves, some people use people know, right? The second thing that you said was that you have to do The research, You have to find things that allow you to get into this mindset, But they also give you specificity, I think, and reality, ⁓ And in both of those things you said, drawing from oneself somebody knows or doing The historical research, what you're looking for, I think, is authenticity.
M.M.DELUCA: Mm-hmm.
Adam Gomolin: Chris, what do you think keeps a young aspiring writer irrespective of genre, what is your advice on
Noah Broyles: I think you're muted, Chris.
Adam Gomolin: Chris, you're still muted.
Noah Broyles: You're muted, Christopher.
Adam Gomolin: Still muted.
Chase Pletts: might be telling us The most brilliant thing in The world right now and not being denied it. ⁓ We can't hear you. You're muted.
Adam Gomolin: It's unbelievable. We just lost it. Chris, we can't hear you.
Noah Broyles: He is.
Chris: My apologies.
Adam Gomolin: Smartest guy, smartest guy in The podcast can't find The unmute button.
Chase Pletts: and
Chris: Yeah, mean there are so many things and Marjory's already talked about doing your research but I guess I would go one step further and say to ⁓ open your eyes and attention The world around you. ⁓ In The Murder there were a bunch of things that I injected The setting based on ⁓ what I to see on visit to The south of England. There's a church, for instance, there's a church with a facade that's faced in Flint. I remember when I first saw a Flint wall, I had no idea what it was. thought that they built a wall ⁓ of The bones of a whale or something like that, but ⁓ it Flint. Someone explained to me, ⁓ and I a lot of it all... all across that of The world. ⁓ course, I had to put that in. ⁓ that just enriches your setting. It grounds you in The place where you are, and it lends a certain ⁓
authenticity to your writing, your setting, and where you are in The world. Just small you know. The color of sea when you're in that... particular part of The world where you've set your story, what The sky looks like. I know that in Singapore there was a lot of cloud cover. One of The things I noticed moving from Singapore to Canada was how different The sky was. those are things that you can, small little things that you just inject into your novel to enrich The sense of being there.
M.M.DELUCA: Yeah.
Adam Gomolin: One of The great gifts of spending time with you is you, I mean, you have an architect's eye, you see everything, right? But that The world is a fascinating place, And there are things all around us, Whether you're sitting on a bus, that we ought not, ⁓ as creatives forget to simply do The research of observing The world we live in and being fascinated by things and noticing things, I mean, I bet if you ask people 30 years ago, 40 years ago, 50 years ago to describe The color of The sky on any given day, and then you ask people today, we have an extremely diminished capacity to actually tell people what The world looks like around us. And I think that that's really interesting. Noah fell off. not sure where he went, but one of The things that we talk about a lot and Chase, you and I have had an opportunity to discuss this is what will novels look like in The future? Right? When The people that are writing them were raised on this their whole lives, That so much of a novel comes from a place of boredom, And this means you're never bored, right? Do we have to just take a hundred thousand kids and raise them in The woods with no phones in to identify ⁓ one that might be a Cormac McCarthy? obviously we're not going to do that, it's an important question. But Chris, I love your point of don't forget to do The research of looking at The world around you. And bringing even those kind of what we shouldn't think of as quotidian, but perhaps we think of as quotidian details and to build The dream Chase, what is it for What's your advice to a young writer in The sense of, I'm trying to remember how old you were when you started writing first novel. You're in your mid thirties.
Chase Pletts: I was in my mid 30s maybe. Let's see. Yeah, 20. I would have been about 36. ⁓
Adam Gomolin: And you had started writing maybe five years before that, six years before that as a screenwriter, is that right? Your late twenties, you kind of began to go like, maybe I'm a writer.
Chase Pletts: Yeah, mid to late 20s. came to it later than I guess.
Adam Gomolin: you're having, a level success now, I think professionally, both in your book and now in your screenwriting. That is something that for years, I think you really dreamed of, ⁓ Of being able to work both successful books, big projects, When you look back at The things that drove you toward really smart fiction, because If I looked at all The different things that you do in your writing, there really feels to be a level of research in all of them, Whether it's ⁓ deep military thriller, screenplay that requires you to talk to people who have been through soft, whether it's a Western what is it that draws you to these very specific research driven worlds and what's The advice coming from that experience that you'd give to a writer today?
Chase Pletts: Well, I think Marjorie Chris gave, you know, just fantastic advice. But let me give an additional perspective, which is, look at The world around you, look backwards, but also look ⁓ inside yourself. Because think that me, The function of... The research ⁓ I if ⁓ any I've written that's been successful, at least to me, it's because I had something to say. And then I started going out into The world and ⁓ looking for to challenge that thing that I thought ⁓ I was about. And then, you know, The whole process to me is, you know, you're a writer, you're sort of like Dr. Frankenstein and you're putting this monster together and got a limb and you've got this, you've got that. And eventually it starts to look like a human form, but The isn't quite beating yet. And you're looking for that little lightning strike that's going to, you know, set The body in flame and, you know, it stand up and start talking to you and being this living, breathing thing. So ultimately, The whole process is The hunt that thing and have to both go inside yourself and then you know when I was Elden I would I was trying to, you at The very beginning, I was just trying to think of names of characters and names are always really important to me to sort of get right. I started walking through graveyards and looking at people who died in that area, in that era and lived and just sort of getting a sense of that, you know, same as Chris's sort of flint wall in a way of just like being in a place and feeling it. Those are all really, really fantastic things to But for me, it always has to start from some question or some about The human condition. I think ultimately, The thing I'll say is smart is we've been talking about smart and dumb, but I think there's a whole that sort of leaves out The real reason I like to read fiction and write fiction, which is The feeling, The emotion, The human connection, The unveiling of some ⁓ mystery myself that I find is also within everybody else.
M.M.DELUCA: Mm-hmm.
Chase Pletts: insight The human that was not clear to me until that moment. So I think somebody being smart ⁓ is... is, we're tangling all that up in that word, but really for me it's something having an impact, something having a true emotional resonance to me. And that's not, all stories don't need to do that. Stories can be really satisfying without having some sort of grand insight into The human condition. But to me,
Adam Gomolin: Thank
Chase Pletts: That's what I'm looking for. And I don't always find it. But that's, think, thing that I'm searching for. That thing that's going to make The monster stand up and smile and feel The sun on their face. ⁓ I say look for that. ⁓ Yeah. ahead.
M.M.DELUCA: Yeah. once said to me right from a place of discomfort.
Chase Pletts: ⁓ I'm always doing that. always on call.
M.M.DELUCA: I'm not.
Adam Gomolin: I know we're gonna break. Chase, you said something a moment ago that really made me think, obviously everyone said a lot of things that are very thought inducing and thought provoking. But ⁓ The of The core of what you were saying was. that The word smart and dumb can mean a lot of things, right? And maybe in retrospect, we should have begun this probably by asking people to decompose what those words mean. So maybe we should do a couple of quick lighting rounds. Chase, if I said The word smart to you, what are The first two or three words that come to mind and kind of breaking that down into more precise component parts?
Chase Pletts: It's funny because in The way that I've been thinking about it, it's almost pejorative. Because in Hollywood, smart is something that people will, term people will throw around. Oh, this is so smart. And I feel like, oh, it's cold and lifeless and has like some twists. Yeah, yeah. So, so yeah, it's almost embedded in my mind is that an intelligent, I think, has a slightly different connotation that smart, which also I think is majority of Hollywood. Things can be too smart or too intelligent ⁓ like that. Yeah, I that's that those are words that were floating around my head. But I know that's I think The attention of how you met them, met them. ⁓
Adam Gomolin: Do you, yeah, but do you have,
Chase Pletts: Something feels original, subversive, irreverent, those are The things that I find, you know. ⁓
Adam Gomolin: Okay, I like it. Original subversive irreverent Marjorie.
M.M.DELUCA: Smart, ⁓ satirical, out of The box, ⁓ edgy, insightful, wise.
Adam Gomolin: Chris?
Chris: know, ⁓ ⁓ like when you get salt in your eye. Okay, really. If you're about synonyms, intelligent, ⁓ guess, would be very thing. aware of what you're doing, aware of ⁓ what you're ⁓ what it means, and not things for granted. of The big things about ⁓ I think, is people just throw a in without thinking about what The trope means. overall I think ⁓ a big part of is understanding The truth behind The tropes, ⁓ why The tropes exist, why it works, and ⁓ applying ⁓ without understanding.
Adam Gomolin: thank all for being generous with your time. you're just superlative role models to all The aspiring writers