สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:04.080 --> 00:00:06.320
Hey, welcome back to the Lawrence Larson Show.
00:00:06.480 --> 00:00:11.679
So a judge takes off his robe, marches two kids to jail, threatens them with foster care.
00:00:11.839 --> 00:00:14.160
Should that judge be able to hide behind immunity?
00:00:14.320 --> 00:00:19.199
I thought we'd start with that question with Dylan Moore, who's an attorney with the Institute for Justice.
00:00:19.440 --> 00:00:21.120
Dylan, welcome back to the program.
00:00:22.079 --> 00:00:22.960
Hi there, Lawrence.
00:00:23.039 --> 00:00:23.600
Happy to be here.
00:00:24.000 --> 00:00:25.359
What did this Eighth U.S.
00:00:25.440 --> 00:00:35.039
Circuit Court of Appeals rule when it comes to this judge who apparently took a very personal role in taking these kids, innocent kids, off to jail?
00:00:35.759 --> 00:00:51.920
Yeah, the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled this was so obviously unconstitutional that qualified immunity doesn't apply, and you don't have to find another case that had basically the exact same facts from the past, which is normally what you have to do to get around qualified immunity.
00:00:52.079 --> 00:00:55.520
So what the court said was this is just so obviously wrong.
00:00:55.679 --> 00:00:58.880
Every judge, every person should know you can't do this.
00:00:59.039 --> 00:01:02.159
And so, no, you don't get to hide behind qualified immunity.
00:01:02.479 --> 00:01:07.760
Okay, all of this started with about 2019, so roughly seven years ago.
00:01:07.920 --> 00:01:12.079
It was a custody dispute to start with involving the child's two parents.
00:01:12.239 --> 00:01:18.719
Would you mind telling my audience what happened that might that inspired this judge to take such an extraordinary action?
00:01:19.439 --> 00:01:20.159
Absolutely.
00:01:20.319 --> 00:01:24.640
So just like you said, this arose in about 2019 from a custody dispute.
00:01:24.879 --> 00:01:30.959
So the parents are in the courtroom, hashing it out about how it's gonna go, and the kids are waiting outside.
00:01:31.120 --> 00:01:35.040
They're in the courtroom and they decide that day the kids are gonna go home with their mom.
00:01:35.200 --> 00:01:40.159
Um, so everybody goes out, they tell the kids about the arrangement, and they're not happy.
00:01:40.239 --> 00:01:41.920
They want to go home with their dad that day.
00:01:42.159 --> 00:01:46.319
So they're going back and forth about it with their mom in sort of the lobby of the courthouse.
00:01:46.560 --> 00:01:52.000
And the judge, now, no robe on, is just walking by and he overhears this argument.
00:01:52.159 --> 00:01:55.359
And now what the judge should have done is just keep walking.
00:01:55.519 --> 00:02:01.200
But instead, the judge sort of injects himself into this argument between the kids and their mom.
00:02:01.359 --> 00:02:07.680
And so he leads the kids over to a conference room and tells them, look, go home with your mom today, or you're gonna have to go into
Load full transcript
foster care.
00:02:07.760 --> 00:02:09.280
You won't see your family again.
00:02:09.520 --> 00:02:11.520
And, you know, the kids are pretty brave here.
00:02:11.599 --> 00:02:13.840
They hold their ground and they say, no, we don't want to do it.
00:02:13.919 --> 00:02:14.719
We're upset.
00:02:14.800 --> 00:02:17.439
Um, and then the judge says, Okay, well, follow me.
00:02:17.520 --> 00:02:30.080
And he takes them to a holding cell attached to the courthouse and orders them to be put into jail cells until they dis until they uh kind of relent and say that they'll go home with their mom.
00:02:30.800 --> 00:02:32.240
Now, hold on a second.
00:02:32.400 --> 00:02:34.000
I'm not a lawyer, Dylan.
00:02:34.159 --> 00:02:38.719
You are, but I know that judges can do things like finding somebody in contempt.
00:02:38.800 --> 00:02:42.159
If a judge were to order me to do something and say, Mr.
00:02:42.240 --> 00:02:45.840
Larson, you're involved in this case, I'm ordering you to produce some documents.
00:02:45.919 --> 00:02:54.479
If I said, hey, uh, Your Honor, take a take a long walk off a short pier, I'm not doing it, he can set me in a jail cell because I'm in contempt.
00:02:54.639 --> 00:03:03.360
Is a judge allowed to do anything like this with a couple of kids who just happen to be, you know, the subjects of a dispute between their parents over custody?
00:03:03.520 --> 00:03:05.599
Is he allowed to do this to the kids?
00:03:06.400 --> 00:03:07.439
Absolutely not.
00:03:07.599 --> 00:03:13.039
And I gotta give you some credit because you're drawing the exact sort of line that the courts will draw in cases like this.
00:03:13.280 --> 00:03:21.599
So, yeah, courts have inherent authority to kind of police their courtrooms and hold people in contempt if they're not following the judge's orders or the law.
00:03:21.919 --> 00:03:32.319
But what they can't do is shed their robes, go find people who are kind of tangentially related to a court proceeding, and throw them in jail just because they don't like the outcome of the hearing.
00:03:33.120 --> 00:03:38.719
So did the judge have any kind of explanation as to why, and it's Eric Amy, isn't it?
00:03:38.879 --> 00:03:42.960
E-I-G-H-M-Y, uh Taney County judge Eric Amy.
00:03:43.280 --> 00:03:46.400
Did he have an explanation for his outrageous behavior?
00:03:47.680 --> 00:04:01.919
His explanation was that he was just doing what he thought was in the kids' best interest, but I don't think, you know, taking off the robe and tossing kids in jail cells because they're unhappy with the custody dispute is promoting their best interests at all.
00:04:02.319 --> 00:04:14.080
No, and in fact, you know, I I will tell you this, Dylan, right after cameras came into courtrooms, I don't know, three decades ago or something, I saw something, it kind of reminded me of this, but in a positive way.
00:04:14.240 --> 00:04:23.439
Um there was a judge uh and he had cameras in his courtroom, but they also allowed
you to sit in the judge's chambers and watch what was going on in the courtroom.
00:04:23.680 --> 00:04:35.519
And so uh uh and I think there was also a camera in his chamber so that if you if he had an ex-party, if he had a, you know, some kind of contact with the lawyers on one side or the other, that could be documented as well.
00:04:35.759 --> 00:04:38.800
And the parents were disagreeing about where the kid should go.
00:04:38.959 --> 00:04:44.879
Uh, and of course each parent had their own point of view or his or her own point of view on where the kid should go.
00:04:45.040 --> 00:04:50.160
And he asked uh, I think it might have been a single child, he asked the child to come into his chambers with him.
00:04:50.240 --> 00:04:53.199
And then he sat there and he said, Look, who do you want to go home with?
00:04:53.439 --> 00:04:55.279
And uh the I think it was a boy.
00:04:55.439 --> 00:05:01.439
Uh he said to the judge, uh look, I don't want to hurt my mom's feelings, but I really want to go home with my dad, or vice versa.
00:05:01.680 --> 00:05:02.240
Doesn't matter.
00:05:02.399 --> 00:05:09.839
In any case, he allowed the courtroom to watch what was going on as he just sat and and talked to the child about the circumstance.
00:05:09.920 --> 00:05:13.120
And I thought, that seems like a good way to resolve all this.
00:05:13.279 --> 00:05:15.199
Find out where the kid really wants to go.
00:05:15.360 --> 00:05:21.199
I mean, the kids don't don't necessarily decide all this, they're kids, uh, and adults make decisions.
00:05:21.360 --> 00:05:31.759
But once the mom and dad heard what the what the kids, honest to God, out of the earshot of mom and dad, uh, what their point of view was, they said, okay, that's the way we'll handle it.
00:05:31.839 --> 00:05:34.079
And he managed to make it better.
00:05:34.240 --> 00:05:40.240
The fact that this judge, Judge Amy, uh managed to make it worse, it just it flabbergassed me.
00:05:40.399 --> 00:05:42.240
Is this judge going to stay a judge?
00:05:43.279 --> 00:06:02.160
I I don't know if he's going to stay a judge, but on that story that you just told, yeah, it's funny that you mentioned that because at the oral argument um when we were at the Eighth Circuit talking through all of this, one of the judges asked me, you know, are you trying to say that judges can't do anything sort of informal to resolve disputes in front of them?
00:06:02.399 --> 00:06:03.920
I said, No, that's not quite right.
00:06:04.079 --> 00:06:07.519
I mean, everybody should be able to work these problems out just sort of as people.
00:06:07.680 --> 00:06:11.439
And it sounds like the story that you told is a judge doing that in a good way.
00:06:11.600 --> 00:06:16.000
You know, you should ask the kids where they want to go and take their considerations into account.
00:06:16.240 --> 00:06:24.720
But what happened here was just so far afield from any sort of like acceptable informal proceeding and just went a bridge way too far.
00:06:25.120 --> 00:06:28.639
Well, I mean, because Dylan, this this is what that's why I was so impressed.
00:06:28.720 --> 00:06:33.519
And I when I went and did a jud uh, you know, a story on the judge and said, this is really extraordinary.
00:06:33.600 --> 00:06:34.480
Have you ever done this before?
00:06:34.639 --> 00:06:35.360
And he said, No.
00:06:35.519 --> 00:06:41.360
He said, Before this, we didn't have cameras in the courtroom and we didn't have cameras in my chambers.
00:06:41.519 --> 00:06:52.959
And so I don't know how you would have arranged it before cameras and microphones, but he thought maybe if the parents here, you know, the kid giving is unabashed, you know, again, without mom or dad sitting there.
00:06:53.199 --> 00:06:59.279
Because, you know, I had parents who split up when I was about uh ten years old, and it was uh it was not fun.
00:06:59.439 --> 00:07:11.360
And and but on the other hand, as much as you might say, you know, I love my mom, I love my dad, but I really don't want to hurt either one's feelings, you know, by saying I'd rather go with dad or I'd rather go with mom.
00:07:11.439 --> 00:07:13.439
And this judge, you know, knew that.
00:07:13.600 --> 00:07:16.240
And he just decided there's a way to resolve this.
00:07:16.399 --> 00:07:23.600
And and he said once he told the once the parents saw what the kids did, the parents immediately told the judge, Your Honor, we got it taken care of.
00:07:23.680 --> 00:07:24.800
We're gonna go that direction.
00:07:24.959 --> 00:07:25.920
And and that was it.
00:07:26.000 --> 00:07:27.759
Oh, you know, problem solved.
00:07:28.639 --> 00:07:33.759
Yeah, that's a much better way to handle this sort of situation and to actually bring the kids' desires into account.
00:07:33.920 --> 00:07:36.800
I mean, here they didn't really have any say over the process at all.
00:07:36.879 --> 00:07:39.920
They just got told, you know, you're going home with your mom, like it or not.
00:07:40.079 --> 00:07:44.800
And then when they, you know, started to push back on that at all, they got thrown in prison.
00:07:45.439 --> 00:07:50.560
Which is not exactly this the right kind of situation you want to tell any young citizen.
00:07:50.720 --> 00:07:55.920
By the way, if if you're not doing what the government wants you to do, the government will come and punish you.
00:07:56.079 --> 00:08:01.360
I think there's a reason that that we left England and said we don't want to carry those traditions with us.
00:08:01.519 --> 00:08:02.480
That's Dylan Moore.
00:08:02.560 --> 00:08:05.360
Dylan is an attorney with the Institute for Justice.
00:08:05.519 --> 00:08:07.439
Dylan, it's a pleasure to have you on the program.
00:08:07.600 --> 00:08:09.680
Glad to get to your calls and your emails.
00:08:09.839 --> 00:08:15.839
If you want to jump into the best conversation in Talk Journalism, it's here every day at 866-Hey Lars.
00:08:16.079 --> 00:08:19.519
That's 866-439-5277.
00:08:19.839 --> 00:08:23.040
Send your emails to talk at LarsLarson.com.
00:08:23.199 --> 00:08:25.040
Oh, check me out on Instagram.
00:08:25.199 --> 00:08:26.800
I know I've got a face for radio.
00:08:26.959 --> 00:08:27.680
I understand that.
00:08:27.839 --> 00:08:31.040
And tell Alexa to play the Lars Larson show.