สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:52.060 --> 00:00:53.020
Hello, dads.
00:00:53.179 --> 00:00:56.780
Welcome to this week's show and briefing.
00:00:57.660 --> 00:01:11.340
If you remember, back on July 20th, the episode on July 20th, I did an episode on what happens the moment a false allegation against you gets cleared.
00:01:11.579 --> 00:01:14.060
And in it, I gave you the what.
00:01:14.939 --> 00:01:18.299
I gave you the motions to file the day the allegation dies.
00:01:19.500 --> 00:01:23.900
The restoration of your schedule, makeup time, the house sanctions.
00:01:24.060 --> 00:01:28.700
I gave you the script to walk into your attorney's office and say it.
00:01:29.180 --> 00:01:37.740
And what I want to do today is I want to give you the why, because here's what's happened in the months since that episode.
00:01:37.900 --> 00:01:46.460
I've had dads in coaching, but but not only in coaching, but dads contact me and say, okay, Jude, I said exactly what you said.
00:01:46.539 --> 00:01:51.659
And my attorney nodded, wrote some notes, and then said, that's not really how it works.
00:01:51.819 --> 00:02:01.979
Or worse, the attorney said, okay, and then filed a motion so watered down it was basically a request for a step-up plan with nicer wording.
00:02:03.819 --> 00:02:06.060
And I understand why that happens.
00:02:06.379 --> 00:02:08.860
Demand isn't a legal argument.
00:02:09.020 --> 00:02:11.340
An analogy isn't a legal argument.
00:02:11.580 --> 00:02:15.819
And the car analogy I gave you is great for getting your own head right.
00:02:15.979 --> 00:02:20.620
And it's great for getting your attorney to feel what's happening to you.
00:02:20.860 --> 00:02:23.900
But a judge doesn't rule on feelings or analogies.
00:02:24.060 --> 00:02:27.020
A judge rules on standards, burdens, and findings.
00:02:27.259 --> 00:02:30.460
That's the language that that room runs on.
00:02:30.539 --> 00:02:48.539
And if you can't speak at least a little bit of it, your attorney will politely ask, well, you know, will politely take your demand and translate it back into a safe, reasonable version of what they were going to do or what they were going to file anyway.
00:02:48.699 --> 00:02:51.659
And so today, two things.
00:02:52.140 --> 00:02:59.260
First, we're going to talk about the actual legal argument underneath those July motions.
00:02:59.500 --> 00:03:09.020
I have I have a full legal memo built on this that in coaching I provide to dads who are going through this situation.
00:03:09.340 --> 00:03:14.540
And it includes constitutional law, statutes from around the country, and appellate standards.
00:03:14.620 --> 00:03:18.700
And it's written for a family law attorney to use.
00:03:18.939 --> 00:03:26.620
And so I'm going to walk you through what's in it in plain English so that you understand it and also can convey it.
00:03:26.700 --> 00:03:37.420
And that's the second thing we're going to do is how you hand it to your attorney so that they can actually use it without losing your credibility and without them tuning you out.
00:03:37.659 --> 00:03:40.939
And then I as always I got to say, I'm not a lawyer.
00:03:41.099 --> 00:03:42.620
This is not legal advice.
00:03:42.780 --> 00:03:50.700
This is a framework for a conversation with your licensed attorney in your state or your jurisdiction.
00:03:50.860 --> 00:03:55.099
That conversation is the entire point of our episode today.
00:03:55.740 --> 00:04:00.860
So let's start with the single sentence, the whole argument hangs on.
00:04:01.099 --> 00:04:04.060
And I want you to be able to say it from memory.
00:04:04.140 --> 00:04:05.980
And I'm going to say it twice.
00:04:06.700 --> 00:04:11.020
A failed allegation is not a neutral event.
00:04:11.340 --> 00:04:15.900
It takes away the only legal basis the restriction ever had.
00:04:16.060 --> 00:04:21.740
So the father goes back to where he stood before the allegation was made.
00:04:21.980 --> 00:04:28.060
And anyone who wants to keep him restricted has to prove it now.
00:04:28.699 --> 00:04:29.500
That's a lot.
00:04:29.579 --> 00:04:30.459
But let me say it again.
00:04:30.540 --> 00:04:38.620
And then you can write it down or you can get the strand the transcript right off of uh whatever podcast or what whatever platform you're listening to.
00:04:38.939 --> 00:04:42.620
A failed allegation is not a neutral event.
00:04:42.699 --> 00:04:44.620
That's an easy one to understand, right?
00:04:44.939 --> 00:04:50.219
It takes away the only legal basis the restriction ever had.
00:04:50.540 --> 00:04:55.579
So the father goes back to where he stood before the allegation was made.
00:04:55.819 --> 00:05:01.579
And anyone who wants to keep him restricted has to prove it now.
00:05:03.099 --> 00:05:06.459
The point is the burden never moved, dads.
00:05:06.620 --> 00:05:08.859
That's the and that's the title of the episode.
00:05:09.099 --> 00:05:12.539
Back in July, we talked about resetting the baseline.
00:05:12.779 --> 00:05:15.659
This is the legal reason the baseline resets.
00:05:15.739 --> 00:05:19.099
It isn't because it's fair, even though it is.
00:05:19.259 --> 00:05:24.139
It's because the law never put the burden on you in the first place.
00:05:25.019 --> 00:05:29.339
And there are four legal arguments that hold this up.
00:05:29.500 --> 00:05:32.779
And for each one, I'm going to give you the argument.
00:05:33.180 --> 00:05:41.659
I'm going to give you the weakness your attorney's going to see in it, and the exact question to put in front of your attorney.
00:05:41.819 --> 00:05:48.539
And I want you to pay uh special attention to the weaknesses because that's where dads lose credibility.
00:05:48.620 --> 00:05:53.579
And it's where you're going to earn it in your conversation with your attorney.
00:05:53.819 --> 00:06:09.180
And and I gotta and I gotta be clear here is because most situations, most divorces are not high conflict, most attorneys don't know or don't understand or never
Load full transcript
ever even get into this.
00:06:09.339 --> 00:06:13.739
So when you bring it to them, they may have never ever even heard of it.
00:06:13.899 --> 00:06:19.899
If they're an associate attorney, which most of us are going to be working with, unless you're going to trial or a hearing.
00:06:20.139 --> 00:06:23.099
So so just just know that.
00:06:26.219 --> 00:06:35.180
But what we're doing here is you're you're educating them and you're helping to move your case in a direction you want by giving them the ammunition to be able to do it.
00:06:35.339 --> 00:06:40.139
So the first argument in this is about due process.
00:06:40.939 --> 00:06:50.459
Your relationship with your kids is what the Supreme Court calls a fundamental liberty interest under the 14th Amendment.
00:06:50.620 --> 00:06:52.219
And this isn't a talking point.
00:06:52.379 --> 00:06:55.899
The court has said it again and again forever and ever.
00:06:56.060 --> 00:07:13.099
And when a family court enters an order restricting that relationship, that's the government acting, which means it owes you due process, notice, a hearing, a chance to be heard before something is taken away from you.
00:07:13.739 --> 00:07:22.939
So, how does a judge get away with removing you from your house and cutting your time with your children without ever hearing from you?
00:07:23.500 --> 00:07:25.099
It's an emergency.
00:07:25.339 --> 00:07:35.819
That's the only thing that makes an ex parte order constitutional is a claim of real immediate danger with no time for a full hearing.
00:07:36.060 --> 00:07:39.419
The danger is the permission slip for them.
00:07:39.579 --> 00:07:41.419
That's the whole justification.
00:07:42.139 --> 00:07:43.819
So follow that through.
00:07:43.979 --> 00:07:53.659
If the danger was the only thing that made the order legal, and the danger turns out not to be real, the permission slip then is gone.
00:07:53.819 --> 00:07:55.579
It should be revoked, right?
00:07:56.060 --> 00:08:01.500
Keeping the order in place after that is no longer caution.
00:08:01.819 --> 00:08:09.819
It is a new deprivation of your rights with nothing supporting it or holding it up.
00:08:10.139 --> 00:08:12.779
And federal courts have drawn this line for fathers.
00:08:12.939 --> 00:08:17.899
There's uh a third current third third circuit case called Croft.
00:08:18.139 --> 00:08:25.659
An anonymous tip accused a dad of abusing his daughter, and a caseworker told him to leave the house or his daughter goes to foster care.
00:08:25.739 --> 00:08:36.379
And the court held that that had violated his due process rights because an accusation without real justification isn't enough to force a parent out of his home.
00:08:36.700 --> 00:08:41.980
Some states write the write a time limit right into their statutes.
00:08:42.220 --> 00:08:51.100
Here in my home state of Colorado, if somebody files a motion claiming imminent danger, the court has 14 days or less to hear it and rule.
00:08:51.259 --> 00:08:59.180
And any order that keeps a restriction going has to contain a specific finding of endangerment with facts supporting it.
00:09:00.060 --> 00:09:01.659
Now, here's the weakness.
00:09:01.980 --> 00:09:13.899
Croft and cases like it come out of federal civil rights lawsuits against caseworkers and not against uh family court custody rulings.
00:09:14.139 --> 00:09:18.539
And your attorney knows that, should know that if they went to law school.
00:09:18.860 --> 00:09:25.740
So what you need to do is not to present Croft as a rule that family court has to follow.
00:09:26.060 --> 00:09:39.980
You present it as a clear statement of what due process requires, which is how the memo, you know, my memo and and what we do in in coaching and talking to your attorney frames it.
00:09:40.060 --> 00:09:42.700
That's how you're going to frame it to your attorney.
00:09:42.860 --> 00:09:52.860
Uh, and and and here's the question you put to them what does our state require before an emergency restriction can continue?
00:09:53.740 --> 00:09:56.300
What deadline and what finding?
00:09:56.780 --> 00:09:59.100
Was that deadline met in my case?
00:09:59.340 --> 00:10:01.900
And was that finding ever made?
00:10:02.460 --> 00:10:04.700
That's a question about your file.
00:10:05.180 --> 00:10:06.780
It has a factual answer.
00:10:06.860 --> 00:10:08.460
Your attorney has to go look.
00:10:08.540 --> 00:10:21.420
And if the answer is the deadline was missed, or no finding was ever made, which is usually the case here, you've just handed them the strongest piece of your motion that you're going to file.
00:10:22.379 --> 00:10:27.500
Now, the second argument is the heart of maybe this whole thing.
00:10:27.660 --> 00:10:29.980
And that is what I stated earlier.
00:10:30.139 --> 00:10:33.420
The burden never shifted to you.
00:10:33.580 --> 00:10:39.660
And this is where this is where everything where I see this, this is problematic everywhere all the time.
00:10:39.820 --> 00:10:42.139
I see when when this is happening.
00:10:42.379 --> 00:10:48.860
In state after state, the restriction statutes say the same thing in different words.
00:10:49.100 --> 00:10:53.820
To restrict a parent's time, the court has to find danger.
00:10:54.060 --> 00:11:05.420
Here in Colorado, it's a finding that your time would endanger the cr the child's physical health or significant significantly impair their emotional development.
00:11:05.740 --> 00:11:11.500
The person asking for that finding has to prove it.
00:11:11.820 --> 00:11:17.100
So when the allegation fails, there's nothing left to support the finding.
00:11:17.340 --> 00:11:21.660
And the statute itself says the restriction can't continue.
00:11:21.900 --> 00:11:28.460
And here's the piece I want you to really understand because almost no dad knows it.
00:11:28.620 --> 00:11:34.379
And it's the line that lands hardest when you're when you're having a conversation with your attorney.
00:11:34.620 --> 00:11:40.940
Legislatures know exactly how to put the burden on a parent to prove they're safe.
00:11:41.580 --> 00:11:47.980
They do it on purpose in narrow, very narrow situation, in narrow situations.
00:11:48.300 --> 00:12:04.540
Colorado does shift the burden to a parent to prove his time is in the child's best interest, but only after a conviction for certain for certain serious crimes.
00:12:04.860 --> 00:12:18.220
California also has a well-known presumption against custody for a parent who committed domestic violence, but it's triggered only by a finding that the abuse happened.
00:12:18.540 --> 00:12:21.259
A finding, not an accusation.
00:12:21.420 --> 00:12:22.139
Let me say that again.
00:12:22.300 --> 00:12:24.300
A finding, not an accusation.
00:12:24.460 --> 00:12:25.259
Completely different.
00:12:25.420 --> 00:12:39.900
So when anybody tells an exonerated father he needs to prove his fitness, they're putting on him a burden the legislature reserved for people who were convicted or found by a court to have done something.
00:12:40.060 --> 00:12:41.259
That's the sentence.
00:12:41.420 --> 00:12:43.340
Say it to your attorney just like that.
00:12:43.500 --> 00:12:48.540
You're asking me to carry a burden, the legislature reserved for convicted offenders.
00:12:48.700 --> 00:12:49.580
I'll say that again.
00:12:49.820 --> 00:12:54.860
You're asking me to carry a burden, the legislature reserved for convicted offenders.
00:12:55.100 --> 00:13:01.660
And the second half of this argument is that a temporary order doesn't create a new baseline.
00:13:01.820 --> 00:13:11.259
Many states say that right in the statute, that temporary orders don't prejudice, don't prejudice anybody's rights at later hearings and can be changed at any time.
00:13:11.420 --> 00:13:14.460
A temporary order is a holding pattern.
00:13:14.620 --> 00:13:24.060
And the fact that a judge signed an emergency order is not evidence that what he or she said was true.
00:13:29.740 --> 00:13:42.460
Now, the weakness on this one matters a lot because you may have you may have heard, well, you may not have heard, but you may have heard if you're a geek like me and you geek out on this stuff and and and this is your life, you may have.
00:13:42.620 --> 00:13:49.900
But you may have heard about the fit parent presumption, and it's from a case around uh Troxel case.
00:13:50.060 --> 00:13:54.300
Uh, fit parents are presumed to act in their kids' best interest.
00:13:54.860 --> 00:14:00.860
A lot of dads, sometimes dads will grab onto this and and and run, and we see this sometimes in the pro se community.
00:14:00.940 --> 00:14:05.340
But Troxel was a parent against grandparents case.
00:14:05.580 --> 00:14:10.860
When it's two parents, most courts say both of you have the presumption.
00:14:11.019 --> 00:14:13.019
So it doesn't decide who wins.
00:14:13.259 --> 00:14:20.700
If you walk into your attorney's office and say, hey, Troxel says I want, I you know, I win, you just got you just told them that you don't understand the case.
00:14:20.860 --> 00:14:28.700
But if you walk in and say, I I know and I understand the fit parent presumption doesn't pick a winner between parents.
00:14:29.019 --> 00:14:31.019
I'm using it for something narrower.
00:14:31.259 --> 00:15:22.620
My existing rights can't be cut back without the findings the statute requires.
00:15:22.860 --> 00:15:25.980
And an unproven allegation supplies none of them.
00:15:26.140 --> 00:15:28.860
Now your attorney is going to pay attention to you.
00:15:28.940 --> 00:15:34.539
They're going to sit up and pay attention to you, and they're going to know that you've done your homework.
00:15:34.779 --> 00:15:49.100
So the question for your attorney then becomes under our state's restriction statute, who carries the burden and what exact finding is required to keep a restriction in place?
00:15:49.500 --> 00:15:52.460
Does our state shift the burden to a parent anywhere?
00:15:52.539 --> 00:15:54.299
And if so, what triggers it?
00:15:54.460 --> 00:16:05.980
And if the only, and if in in in and probably the answer is going to be, but if the answer is only a conviction or only a finding, which is usually the case, you've got an argument, okay?
00:16:06.140 --> 00:16:08.380
You've got a legitimate argument.
00:16:10.299 --> 00:16:14.460
The third argument is the one you have to be most careful with.
00:16:14.620 --> 00:16:21.340
It applies when the allegation wasn't just unproven, it was knowingly false.
00:16:21.500 --> 00:16:25.579
So she knew it was wasn't true when she said it.
00:16:25.980 --> 00:16:36.860
When you can show that, the false allegation stops being something you're defending against, and then actually, dads, becomes evidence for you.
00:16:37.100 --> 00:16:47.819
A parent who makes up abuse to cut the other parent off has shown the court exactly how she'll treat your kid's relationship with you going forward.
00:16:48.059 --> 00:16:57.340
And almost every state's best interest factors look at which parent will support the child's relationship with the other.
00:16:57.660 --> 00:16:59.819
Several states put this right in their statutes.
00:17:00.059 --> 00:17:09.819
Arizona says the court shall award fees against someone who knowingly presented a false claim of abuse, and it can modify parenting time.
00:17:10.059 --> 00:17:12.539
Florida makes it a best interest factor.
00:17:12.700 --> 00:17:24.380
Texas has a mandatory civil penalty, and then here in Colorado, but we have mandatory fees when an emergency restriction motion was substantially frivolous or groundless.
00:17:24.779 --> 00:17:31.420
So in July, in and in the previous episode, we talked about the sanctions motion.
00:17:31.500 --> 00:17:36.140
And I told you not to be surprised if it gets denied.
00:17:36.299 --> 00:17:37.900
Here's the legal reason why.
00:17:38.059 --> 00:17:42.220
And then I'm also going to explain how you might be able to make it stick.
00:17:42.460 -->
00:17:47.420
Good faith reports are protected in every state, and they should be, right?
00:17:47.660 --> 00:17:51.179
Because that's how we protect kids who are actually in danger.
00:17:51.339 --> 00:17:58.539
And in Arizona, the statute says outright a false claim is not one that's merely unsubstantiated.
00:17:58.779 --> 00:18:02.299
So the case was dismissed, does not prove she lied.
00:18:02.539 --> 00:18:05.419
Unfounded is not the same as false.
00:18:05.579 --> 00:18:10.460
And your Tony, your attorney does know that, and a judge will definitely know that.
00:18:10.699 --> 00:18:15.099
What proves she knew is evidence of knowledge.
00:18:15.419 --> 00:18:25.819
Something like a recantation, uh, especially one with a motive behind it, text or emails that contradict her story, video is tremendous.
00:18:25.980 --> 00:18:36.779
Uh, a witness who heard her talk about the plan, timing that lines up perfectly with the filing in the divorce, uh, a pattern of prior reports that went nowhere.
00:18:37.019 --> 00:18:39.339
And so those are some examples.
00:18:39.500 --> 00:18:42.220
And here's how you convey this one.
00:18:42.460 --> 00:18:45.980
You don't walk in and say, She lied, I want sanctions.
00:18:46.220 --> 00:18:53.420
You walk in with the folder and you say, here's the evidence that she knew it was false when she said it.
00:18:53.740 --> 00:18:58.859
Is this enough to meet our state standard for a knowingly false report?
00:18:59.180 --> 00:19:01.099
If not, what's missing?
00:19:01.339 --> 00:19:13.019
And if you don't have that evidence, you lead with arguments one and two that we just talked about, which is which all which only need the allegation to have failed.
00:19:13.259 --> 00:19:17.900
That's enough to get the restrictions lifted, which is the minimum of what you want, right?
00:19:18.139 --> 00:19:31.740
But if then you start swinging that she's a liar and and and and then you miss with that swing, you look like an angry dad, and it gives the judge a reason to doubt everything else in your in your motion or even upcoming upcoming motions.
00:19:31.900 --> 00:19:35.420
So you got to be very careful with that, that third one.
00:19:35.819 --> 00:19:46.059
Now, the fourth argument is the makeup time argument, and and and I want to be straight because I'd rather you hear it from me than from your attorney on this one.
00:19:46.299 --> 00:19:55.259
Outside of states, with a time-taken, time back law, makeup time is the weakest argument of the four arguments.
00:19:55.420 --> 00:20:08.539
But I still think it's important to bring up states like Minnesota, Illinois, here, and Colorado have makeup time remedies with time of the same type and duration you lost, and sometimes fees will be included also.
00:20:08.779 --> 00:20:17.259
But those statutes were written for a parent who ignores a court order, not for time you lost while a court order was in place.
00:20:17.579 --> 00:20:37.740
And trust me, attorneys are going to know this and they're gonna state this exactly, which is exactly why the gap that uh Robert Garza's bills that you've heard me talk about and have had him on the show matters so much in the states that that have it and and matter in getting these passed in the states that don't have it.
00:20:37.900 --> 00:20:44.940
So if you're in if you're not in one of those states, your attorney needs one of two bridges that we're gonna talk about now.
00:20:45.180 --> 00:21:01.980
Bridge number one is if she withheld time behind beyond what an order actually required, she read the order broader than it was or kept enforcing it after it ended, then the regular makeup time statute applies directly.
00:21:02.139 --> 00:21:03.420
That's plain interference.
00:21:03.579 --> 00:21:07.339
So you need a record of every one of those days.
00:21:07.660 --> 00:21:20.139
Bridge number two is if the restriction was obtained through a knowing falsehood, the court can use its best interests and equitable powers to order a restorative schedule.
00:21:20.460 --> 00:21:26.379
Arizona statute expressly lets the court modify parenting time after a knowingly false claim.
00:21:26.619 --> 00:21:28.779
And the framing matters.
00:21:29.099 --> 00:21:32.700
Don't ask for makeup time to punish her.
00:21:33.099 --> 00:21:39.660
You're asking for makeup time in order to repair the relationship with your children.
00:21:39.900 --> 00:21:44.940
They lost weeks or months with a fit parent, and that that and that has damaged the bond.
00:21:45.180 --> 00:21:49.180
Makeup time is the remedy for the harm.
00:21:49.420 --> 00:21:57.579
A judge will move for the kids long before they'll move to punish the other parent, especially a mother.
00:21:57.819 --> 00:22:07.500
There's gonna be a huge there's gonna be a lot of grace and a huge room, an error of margin for error, if you will, for her.
00:22:07.660 --> 00:22:14.940
So here's the question that that you need to pose to your attorney when you're helping them with these two bridges.
00:22:15.180 --> 00:22:19.420
Does our state have a compensate compensatory time statute?
00:22:19.660 --> 00:22:26.700
And does it reach time lost under a court order or only time withheld in violation of one?
00:22:26.940 --> 00:22:31.339
If it's only violations, can we use either one of these two bridges?
00:22:31.740 --> 00:22:49.500
So now when you walk in, dads, knowing the gap, your attorney can't just, you know, wave you off and and and wave your request away with, well, makeup time doesn't apply here because you've already named the problem and brought two ways around it.
00:22:49.980 --> 00:22:52.940
So those are the legal arguments, dad.
00:22:53.019 --> 00:22:58.619
Now, now I understand if a lot of that is I understand that that is a lot, period, right?
00:22:58.779 --> 00:23:16.539
And and so I do want to offer, dads, if you would like the my my handout around this, just send me an email to Jude at thedivorcedadvocate.com or contact me through the
website, go to the divorced advocate.com.
00:23:16.940 --> 00:23:21.019
You can schedule a time for us to do a strategic risk consult.
00:23:21.180 --> 00:23:26.139
I can walk you through this and I will actually give you the information to take to your attorney.
00:23:26.379 --> 00:23:34.779
But but get in contact with me and I and I can give you this for for you to be able to uh give to your attorney and understand it specifically because.
00:23:35.339 --> 00:23:36.779
That was the legal argument.
00:23:36.940 --> 00:23:47.180
And now what I want to talk about in the second half of this is about how you actually deliver it because the delivery is where most dads fall apart.
00:23:47.500 --> 00:23:57.660
And in the episode in July, I told you that you're the coach, and you hear me say this all the time, especially if you're on our group calls, that you're the coach of the just this divorce team.
00:23:57.740 --> 00:24:02.139
And you give your attorney the playbook or the marching orders, if you will.
00:24:02.299 --> 00:24:04.220
And that is always going to stay true.
00:24:04.379 --> 00:24:08.299
You set the strategy and you decide what you will and won't accept.
00:24:08.619 --> 00:24:14.539
But there's a difference between giving orders on strategy and arguing law with somebody who went to law school, right?
00:24:14.940 --> 00:24:16.619
That's just common sense.
00:24:16.779 --> 00:24:35.500
How you carry the legal argument is what decides whether your attorney becomes your partner in this, and you prove yourself to be a partner on it, or gets defensive and digs in, which happens a lot of times with attorneys because some of them have sensitive egos.
00:24:35.660 --> 00:24:38.700
So here's how I coach dads through this conversation.
00:24:38.859 --> 00:24:42.220
Number one, there's seven seven points here, eight points.
00:24:42.619 --> 00:24:46.859
Number one, put it in writing and send it ahead of a meeting.
00:24:47.019 --> 00:24:49.660
Don't spring this on your attorney across the desk.
00:24:49.819 --> 00:24:57.500
Send an email a few days before with a one-page summary of the four arguments in your own words and the questions I just gave you.
00:24:57.740 --> 00:25:01.339
If you've got a fuller research memo memo, attach it.
00:25:01.579 --> 00:25:12.379
An attorney who has the time to read something responds differently than the one who's being cornered in a 15 or 30 minute conversation or a meeting.
00:25:12.940 --> 00:25:15.339
Number two, lead with questions.
00:25:15.500 --> 00:25:18.700
This is just this is just generally a good idea in life, right?
00:25:18.859 --> 00:25:21.579
Uh lead with questions, not with conclusions.
00:25:21.819 --> 00:25:25.099
Who has the burden under our restriction statute?
00:25:25.339 --> 00:25:29.500
That gets you a lot further than the burden is on her, right?
00:25:29.900 --> 00:25:30.619
See the difference?
00:25:30.779 --> 00:25:33.420
The question makes your attorney go check.
00:25:33.660 -->
00:25:41.579
Then the attorney, when they check and sees it's rights, it doesn't, it becomes their conclusion too, right?
00:25:41.740 --> 00:25:51.740
Now it's their conclusion, and an attorney will argue their own conclusion much harder than their than than the conclusion that you gave them, right?
00:25:51.900 --> 00:25:57.180
So if you ask it, they look and they find it, then they're like, wow, yeah, that's the conclusion.
00:25:57.259 --> 00:25:59.180
They're gonna go argue it for you, right?
00:25:59.579 --> 00:26:02.220
Number three, use their vocabulary.
00:26:02.299 --> 00:26:05.500
This is gonna maybe take you a little bit of studying and practice.
00:26:05.819 --> 00:26:09.500
Burden, finding, standard, record, preserve.
00:26:09.660 --> 00:26:13.579
Those five words tell your attorney you're talking about the law.
00:26:13.740 --> 00:26:21.339
And they and they make makes it clear you're not talking about your feelings about the law, which is a huge difference.
00:26:21.579 --> 00:26:28.940
Save the car analogy that I gave you in July for your own head and for and for getting your attorney fired up, right?
00:26:29.099 --> 00:26:33.180
In a legal discussion discussion, you want to talk in legalese.
00:26:33.500 --> 00:26:35.900
Talk about burdens and findings.
00:26:36.220 --> 00:26:37.740
Very important, dads.
00:26:37.980 --> 00:26:41.660
Number four, name the weaknesses before they do.
00:26:41.900 --> 00:26:47.500
Say, I know the fit parent presumption doesn't pick a winner between two parents.
00:26:47.740 --> 00:26:51.420
I know unfounded isn't the same as false.
00:26:51.660 --> 00:26:55.980
I know the makeup time statute was written for order violations.
00:26:56.220 --> 00:27:01.339
When you say that, and when you say those things first, two things happen.
00:27:01.660 --> 00:27:06.139
One, your attorney stops looking for reasons to just dismiss you, right?
00:27:06.220 --> 00:27:07.339
They got a lot of stuff to do.
00:27:07.420 --> 00:27:12.940
They got a bunch of cases, they get a lot of people coming even now with AI and blah, blah, blah.
00:27:13.019 --> 00:27:16.139
And they're like, oh shit, this is here we go again, right?
00:27:16.539 --> 00:27:20.859
They will stop looking for the reason to dismiss you if you're able to do that.
00:27:21.019 --> 00:27:28.379
The second is it starts working on the argument you're actually making, and that's important.
00:27:28.539 --> 00:27:37.819
So you start building it right there for them, and then you you're you're joining them in with you in continuing to build that argument.
00:27:39.180 --> 00:27:42.779
Number five, ask them to verify.
00:27:43.180 --> 00:27:44.299
This is huge.
00:27:44.539 --> 00:27:55.740
Every citation I've given you today, uh, and everyone in that memo that I'll give you needs to be pulled and checked against current law in your state before anything is filed.
00:27:55.980 --> 00:27:59.900
Some of the memo citations are flagged for exactly that.
00:28:00.059 --> 00:28:02.779
So you say, This is research.
00:28:03.180 --> 00:28:03.980
That's important.
00:28:04.139 --> 00:28:05.099
This is research, right?
00:28:05.180 --> 00:28:07.500
You're not an attorney, you're not giving them law.
00:28:07.579 --> 00:28:08.460
This is research.
00:28:08.619 --> 00:28:14.779
I need you to verify it for our state and tell me, you tell me what holds up.
00:28:14.940 --> 00:28:16.539
That's not you being weak.
00:28:16.700 --> 00:28:18.379
It's that is their job.
00:28:18.539 --> 00:28:22.059
And then it makes it their own result, right?
00:28:22.220 --> 00:28:26.220
So you're enlisting them to uh help build this together, right?
00:28:26.379 --> 00:28:29.259
And this is where I see dads blow it.
00:28:29.420 --> 00:28:38.220
The fastest way to lose your attorney's respect is to walk in and say, uh, what I just mentioned, I ran it through AI and it said I'm entitled to make up time.
00:28:38.379 --> 00:28:38.700
Okay.
00:28:39.019 --> 00:28:43.259
Attorneys, and I've just read some like a post LinkedIn post.
00:28:43.500 --> 00:28:48.619
As soon as the attorney hears AI said, and everything after that gets discounted, right?
00:28:48.859 --> 00:28:51.500
Research is a starting point.
00:28:52.059 --> 00:28:59.579
You bring it as research, you ask the professional to verify it, and you never present it as the final answer.
00:29:00.779 --> 00:29:03.019
Number six, keep it gender neutral.
00:29:03.099 --> 00:29:04.779
I alluded to this a little bit earlier.
00:29:05.740 --> 00:29:17.259
And while this dad's for shows, I know a lot and I know that you feel, and it is true, that the system is stacked against you, dads, but the motion that wins is about parents.
00:29:17.579 --> 00:29:25.339
It's about findings, it's about burdens, it's about due process, not about this always happens to dads.
00:29:25.579 --> 00:29:34.619
And tell your attorney not to use national statistics on false allegations, and definitely don't make this gender specific.
00:29:34.779 --> 00:29:50.619
I actually had this situation today in a in a motion that that was being submitted, and we took something out that was gender specific because it made it look like it was, you know, it's it just made it look bad.
00:29:50.779 --> 00:29:55.660
And so, you know, the same with this the statistics on the false allegations.
00:29:55.819 --> 00:30:03.660
Those numbers can be contested, and one disputed statistic can undercut an otherwise airtight motion.
00:30:03.819 --> 00:30:07.579
The evidence that matters is your file.
00:30:08.779 --> 00:30:14.139
Number seven, know the difference between legitimate pushback and fear.
00:30:14.700 --> 00:30:24.059
If your attorney says in our state, the protection order denial doesn't bind the custody court, so we'll have to make the record again.
00:30:24.379 --> 00:30:25.500
That's legitimate.
00:30:26.619 --> 00:30:27.420
Work with it.
00:30:27.740 --> 00:30:35.579
If you're now the different one is if
your attorney says the judge won't like it, let's look reasonable.
00:30:35.980 --> 00:30:38.859
That's the fear we talked about back in July.
00:30:39.180 --> 00:30:41.420
That isn't a legal reason.
00:30:42.940 --> 00:30:50.139
What you do then is you ask them straight up, what's the legal reason that argument fails?
00:30:50.460 --> 00:30:53.259
What's the legal reason that argument fails?
00:30:53.660 --> 00:30:56.940
If they can't name one, you have your answer.
00:30:57.180 --> 00:31:03.180
It's fear, or they're making some subjective reason why they don't want to do it.
00:31:04.299 --> 00:31:10.859
Now, number eight, and this is important get it in writing afterwards.
00:31:11.099 --> 00:31:13.980
Lots of attorneys like to talk on the phone about this stuff.
00:31:14.059 --> 00:31:14.539
That's fine.
00:31:14.619 --> 00:31:17.339
Hopefully, you've sent a memo, like I said before.
00:31:17.500 --> 00:31:27.259
Even if you're having the discussion over phone and you're running through the points and the questions on the phone with them after the meeting, send a short email recap.
00:31:27.500 --> 00:31:33.740
Per our conversation, we'll argue that the burden stays with the party seeking restriction.
00:31:33.980 --> 00:31:40.059
We'll request specific findings and we'll eject on the record if the court frames it as my burden.
00:31:40.379 --> 00:31:43.259
That email holds them to the plan.
00:31:43.500 --> 00:31:48.619
And if things go sideways later, you have the paper trail.
00:31:49.579 --> 00:31:55.900
Now, there's one more conversation you need to have with your attorney, and unfortunately, almost nobody has it.
00:31:55.980 --> 00:32:02.379
And it's the question if the judge denies this, what's our path to a higher court?
00:32:02.619 --> 00:32:09.420
And I know a lot of you say to me, because I've said it myself, and I've actually been in the situation myself, Dad.
00:32:09.819 --> 00:32:15.980
Family court judges do whatever the hell they want, and there's no recourse.
00:32:16.299 --> 00:32:25.099
Here's the truth a higher court and and this is sometimes that statement, what I just said, is sometimes true.
00:32:25.420 --> 00:32:45.339
But a higher court won't reweigh the evidence or second guess who the judge believed, but it will reverse a ruling built on the wrong burden, missing findings the statute requires, or a denial of due process.
00:32:45.579 --> 00:32:46.059
The U.S.
00:32:46.139 --> 00:32:48.539
Supreme Court said it in a case called Kuhn.
00:32:48.859 --> 00:32:55.819
A court by definition abuses its discretion when it makes an error of law.
00:32:55.900 --> 00:32:58.460
And that's key is the error of law.
00:32:58.619 --> 00:33:02.059
And so look at the four agreements that we just walked through.
00:33:02.220 --> 00:33:05.180
They're almost all claims of legal error.
00:33:05.339 --> 00:33:12.779
Wrong burden, that's one, missing findings, two, a temporary order treated as proof.
00:33:12.940 --> 00:33:22.059
Three,
that's exactly the kind of mistake that gets reviewed fresh on appeal without deferring to the trial judge.
00:33:22.299 --> 00:33:27.500
And the reason it feels like there's no recourse is that most of these denials happen on temporary orders.
00:33:27.660 --> 00:33:32.700
And in most states, you can't appeal a temporary order until the whole case ends.
00:33:32.859 --> 00:33:36.059
Uh, in Texas, it's written right into the family code.
00:33:36.220 --> 00:33:38.379
So the attorney says, we can't appeal that.
00:33:38.539 --> 00:33:40.940
Like that's they just automatically say that.
00:33:41.180 --> 00:33:41.980
Yes and no.
00:33:42.059 --> 00:33:45.660
And the dad hears, oh, you know, well, there's nothing we can do.
00:33:45.819 --> 00:33:52.619
But that's not, that's not usually always the case because usually there's a different door in order to get this done.
00:33:52.779 --> 00:34:04.779
It's a writ, often called called a mandamus, uh, it's an emergency petition straight to the higher court asking it to order the trial court to file the law.
00:34:05.259 --> 00:34:11.740
Because months of lost time with your kids is harm a later appeal can't fix.
00:34:11.980 --> 00:34:19.980
So if they say that, you know, the you know you can't appeal this temporary order, but this temporary order is going to be, you know, 15, 18 months.
00:34:20.220 --> 00:34:24.539
That is a harm a later appeal can't fix once your trial is done.
00:34:24.700 --> 00:34:27.180
So in Texas, it's the standard route.
00:34:27.260 --> 00:34:31.820
In Colorado, here, it's a petition directly to the to the Supreme Court.
00:34:32.059 --> 00:34:40.059
It's now it's granted sparingly, dads, but it exists for exactly this kind of legal error.
00:34:40.139 --> 00:34:45.820
And I'm telling you, if you have an associate attorney, they likely are not gonna have any clue about this.
00:34:45.900 --> 00:34:57.739
So, so it's something that you can have you need to have in your back pocket that you can bring up, and you're likely gonna need a senior associate, partner, et cetera, to be looking at this if you're gonna go down this route.
00:34:57.900 --> 00:35:07.579
So if if if an associate just says, yeah, no, no, no, and blows you off, then you know, we might have to have a conversation and strategize on how you pull somebody else in on this.
00:35:07.739 --> 00:35:13.179
Uh, and and here's why this belongs into conversation uh about how you convey the argument.
00:35:13.739 --> 00:35:16.619
Appeals, appeals are tricky, right?
00:35:16.779 --> 00:35:22.139
Number one, but in in a but appeals are won or lost at the first hearing.
00:35:22.379 --> 00:35:26.460
And and a higher court only sees what's in the record.
00:35:26.619 --> 00:35:34.940
Uh, if the argument wasn't raised, ruled on, and written down, then for that higher court, it's X it's never happened at all.
00:35:35.099 --> 00:35:37.659
So you can't bring that up at the appeal.
00:35:37.819 --> 00:35:45.019
Uh, and so you ask
your attorney to do a few specific things at that first hearing and you ask for them up front.
00:35:45.099 --> 00:35:46.059
And here they are.
00:35:46.380 --> 00:35:49.900
Raise every argument in rate in writing in the motion.
00:35:50.059 --> 00:35:52.300
Okay, so it's gotta be in the motion, right?
00:35:52.460 --> 00:35:57.579
Because if it's down there, the court can read it and then the appeal can read it.
00:35:57.900 --> 00:36:07.420
And and this is including the constitutional ones, because an argument raised for the first time on appeal is going to get it's going to get forfeited, almost guaranteed.
00:36:08.780 --> 00:36:11.739
The other thing, object out loud on record.
00:36:11.900 --> 00:36:24.380
Anytime the court frames it as has dad, this is a quote, quote unquote, has dad shown he's safe, or is dad proven, you know, he's whatever, and get a ruling on that objection.
00:36:24.780 --> 00:36:28.139
Request specific written findings.
00:36:28.699 --> 00:36:30.780
Because you want that down in writing.
00:36:30.860 --> 00:36:38.619
You want that written in in a motion and not just a verbal motion out loud, right?
00:36:38.699 --> 00:36:40.059
You got to get it written down.
00:36:40.219 --> 00:36:42.460
And this last one is my favorite.
00:36:42.539 --> 00:36:54.300
It's probably the hardest because you got to train if the attorney's not comfortable in court, I don't want to say comfortable, but not very seasoned or a veteran in court, then they just they don't know how to do this.
00:36:54.460 --> 00:37:06.460
But you want to get them to understand or train them or or prep them to politely, for the record, say to the judge, what standard and what burden is the court applying?
00:37:06.699 --> 00:37:11.659
So if the judge gives the wrong answer, that's your appeal right there.
00:37:11.820 --> 00:37:29.019
So if they make a, you know, if they they make a you know a determination in in the in the hearing uh or the trial, and your your attorney wants to know exactly what that is or wants it on the record, they say, what standard and what burden is the court applying, right?
00:37:29.179 --> 00:37:37.500
Then make sure that the court reporter or recording gets a signed written order rather than an or an oral ruling.
00:37:37.659 --> 00:37:40.139
And that's what I was uh alluding to a little bit earlier.
00:37:40.380 --> 00:37:43.579
Lots of times you'll just get an oral ruling, which is this.
00:37:43.820 --> 00:37:55.900
You want that written down, you want it to uh you want it in a motion, and and you want it on the calendar, the day of the ruling because it can be days, not weeks, right?
00:37:55.980 --> 00:37:57.900
That's that's the heart that's the biggest thing.
00:37:58.059 --> 00:38:10.139
And here's the best part a judge who has to say out loud, and this is the tough one for for some of these for some of these family court judges, because well, we won't go into why.
00:38:10.300 --> 00:38:25.579
Uh a judge who has to say out
loud what burden they're applying and has to put the required findings in writing is a lot less likely to rule against an exonerated father in the first place.
00:38:25.900 --> 00:38:26.940
Let me say that again.
00:38:27.099 --> 00:38:30.300
And this is a point that you can bring to your attorney.
00:38:30.460 --> 00:38:52.219
A judge who has to say out loud, you know, and state what standard and what burden the court is applying to whatever it is, and has to put that finding in writing is a lot less likely to rule against an exonerated father in the first place because they have to make sure that it is supported, right?
00:38:52.380 --> 00:38:59.259
So asking your attorney to make the record doesn't just set up the appeal, it actually changes the hearing itself.
00:38:59.739 --> 00:39:00.059
Okay.
00:39:01.019 --> 00:39:02.860
I know that second part was also a lot.
00:39:02.940 --> 00:39:04.380
So you combine it all together.
00:39:04.539 --> 00:39:12.699
It is a lot, Dads, but this is what we do and we work on in coaching with your attorney in going through this process because it's incredibly important.
00:39:12.780 --> 00:39:27.980
And because only a small percentage of cases in court are high conflict and that you've got to deal with this, then your attorneys, most the majority don't, and when I say majority, like 90 plus percent, don't know or understand this strategy.
00:39:28.059 --> 00:39:28.300
Okay.
00:39:28.699 --> 00:39:30.300
So here's your homework for the week.
00:39:30.380 --> 00:39:31.659
We're gonna wrap this up.
00:39:31.980 --> 00:39:37.820
First, write the one-sentence argument in your own words, not mine, yours.
00:39:37.980 --> 00:39:43.259
If you can't say it simply, you can't convey it, say it out loud until it sounds like you.
00:39:44.219 --> 00:39:46.380
Second, write the email.
00:39:49.019 --> 00:39:52.539
A one-page summary, excuse me.
00:39:53.420 --> 00:40:05.179
Write the email, a one-page summary of the four arguments, the weaknesses you already know about, and the questions from today to your attorney before your next meeting.
00:40:05.659 --> 00:40:15.019
Ask them to verify everything for your state or jurisdiction and send you their read on this in writing.
00:40:15.579 --> 00:40:21.340
The third is organize your folder by argument, not by date.
00:40:21.420 --> 00:40:24.219
And you've got to have all this stuff organized, dads.
00:40:24.619 --> 00:40:51.340
One section for the orders and anything showing a missing deadline or missing finding, one for the dismissal, denial, or closure uh letter, one for the evidence of what she knew, if you have any, and one for a calendar of every day, overnight, holiday, birthday, time that you lost, numbers, evidence, not feelings.
00:40:51.500 --> 00:40:56.619
When your attorney opens that folder, the emotion is already half written for them.
00:40:56.780 --> 00:41:03.099
Uh, and if you and if you're not in this right now, I still want you to remember one sentence.
00:41:03.500 --> 00:41:06.139
The burden never moved.
00:41:06.380 --> 00:41:07.420
Remember that sentence.
00:41:07.579 --> 00:41:09.099
The burden never moved.
00:41:09.259 --> 00:41:19.500
If the day ever comes when somebody tells you to prove you're a fit father after you've been cleared, I want you to be, I want this to be the first thing out of your mouth.
00:41:19.659 --> 00:41:21.579
The burden never moved.
00:41:21.739 --> 00:41:31.980
And if you are in this right now and you want help building that one pager or walking through how to have this conversation with your specific attorney, again, get in contact with me.
00:41:32.139 --> 00:41:34.940
Schedule something at talkwithjude.com.
00:41:35.019 --> 00:41:37.980
That's the strategic risk consult scheduling link.
00:41:38.219 --> 00:41:45.259
And then we'll talk through this and we'll create a strategy for you with your with your attorney.
00:41:45.500 --> 00:41:49.099
Dads, your kids need you back if you're experienced this.
00:41:49.179 --> 00:41:54.300
And the law, when it's actually argued the way it's written, is on your side.
00:41:54.539 --> 00:41:58.940
Your job is to make sure it gets argued that way.
00:41:59.500 --> 00:42:01.820
Dads, thanks for listening today.
00:42:02.059 --> 00:42:10.219
If you found some value with this, as always, please give us a star rating, write, write to a comment also.
00:42:10.300 --> 00:42:12.139
That makes it a lot an algorithm.
00:42:12.300 --> 00:42:14.460
Uh pick things up and spread it more.
00:42:14.699 --> 00:42:19.900
Put this out on on uh on social media or come find us on social media.
00:42:19.980 --> 00:42:24.539
I post clips of these uh everywhere so that you can comment on them, you can share them.
00:42:24.780 --> 00:42:28.059
We are starting to proliferate more and more across the world.
00:42:28.219 --> 00:42:30.219
We've even got AI that's picking up.
00:42:30.300 --> 00:42:34.619
I've got guys coming to me that said AI recommended that they they talk to me.
00:42:34.699 --> 00:42:44.860
So the more you'll the more that you do the the very small thing that you do like that, guys, like write a comment or post something on social media, actually has a huge impact.
00:42:45.019 --> 00:43:00.699
Because if you just help one by doing that one thing, you can help one other dad somewhere else that that maybe the algorithm moved it somewhere across the world or picked it up on yours and then put it somewhere else in the in the social media realm that's actually going to help another dad.
00:43:00.780 --> 00:43:03.099
So it seems small, but it does help.
00:43:03.259 --> 00:43:06.300
So I would appreciate it if you could please do that.
00:43:06.380 --> 00:43:09.259
That is incredibly beneficial for us.
00:43:09.500 --> 00:43:20.139
And and please, dads, if there's anything else I can do, go to the website at the divorcedadvocate.com, check out our information, take the weekend visitor risk risk assessment.
00:43:20.219 --> 00:43:27.420
That's going to help you gauge where you're at in this process, whether you're in something like this or you're not in something like this.
00:43:27.739 --> 00:43:29.500
As always, thanks for listening.
00:43:29.659 --> 00:43:30.619
I appreciate it.
00:43:30.780 --> 00:43:32.940
Stay strong and God bless.