สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: This episode of the Chuck Podcast is brought to you by Wild Grain. Wild Grain is the first bake from Frozen subscription box for our teasonal breads, seasonal pastries, and fresh pastas, plus all items conveniently bake in twenty five minutes or less. Unlike many store bought options, Wild Grain uses simple ingredients you can pronounce and a slow fermentation process that can be easier on your belly and richer in nutrients and antioxidants. Wildgrain's boxes are fully customizable. They're constantly adding seasonal and limited tiding products for you to enjoy. In addition to their classic box, they now feature a gluten free box and a plant based box. I checked out the gluten free box, and let me tell you, they have a gluten free sour dough bread. It is. We got two loads of it and we've done one loaf already. It's a cranberry and almond sour dough bread. It's like the best raisin bread you've ever had, except it's not raisin. It's great. You're gonna love this. You know it's in or miss if you mess around in the gluten free bread world. This is a hit. Seriously, I was impressed, so look for a limited time, Wildgrain is offering our listeners thirty dollars off your first box plus free croissants in every box when you go to wildgrain dot com slash podcast. To start your subscription, follow these instructions. Free crossants in every box, thirty dollars off your first box when you go to wildgrain dot com slash podcast. That's wildgrain dot com slash podcast. Or simply use the promo code podcast at checkout. Always use the code, get the discount. I'm telling you it's excellent, excellent bread. Well, it's been a couple generations since the United States added a star to its flag. We've had fifty states. Now going back, I guess might in my entire lifetime, we've been fifty as sudden, the oldest generation that can say that, because of course we added states in Hawaii and Alaska before that. There's been two potential new states that have been sort of on and off again. One is for the District of Columbia and one is Puerto Rico. Just to give a summary, there's over four according to the last census, over four million Americans who live in a territory or a district that does not have any state representation, and four basically four of those four million reside in either Puerto Rico in DC. To break it down further, Puerto Rico with a population twenty twenty four EPs of three point two million. If it were a state, it would essentially be approximately the size of Iowa and Utah population wise, which means at least four members of Congress A full anywhere, depending on the estimate you use, anywhere from eighteen to twenty states have less population than Puerto Rico. As for the District of Columbia, there are two states with less population, y Oming and Vermont. So now if you're asking about the Pacific Islands, I did do those numbers as well. Combined you're looking at about three hundred and fifty thousand, so not even quite one congressional district Quam Guam at over one hundred and fifty thousand. The US Virgin Islands, which I've got an idea on this that I will I will, I will put further, has about eighty seven thousand. American Simona with a fifty little under fifty thousand, then the Northern Mariana Islands under fifty thousand. So if you took. Basically, it's about two hundred and fifty thousand Americans in Pacific Island territories and with the eighty with the nearly one hundred thousand in the US virgin Island, to throw that in with Puerto Rico, you're looking at three point three million. But that's the scenario. That's a lot of people who don't have representation, who pay taxes without representation, living in the DMV, which in this case is not the Division of Motor vehicles, but when I talk about the district Maryland and Virginia, that's what that DMV stands for. I've spent a lot of time with people who have had efforts to get statehood for d C. There were moments it was close and not. In Puerto Rico. There's a sort of a three way divide, if you will, when it comes to the statehood conversation. There are some people that want full independence, there are some people that want full statehood, and there are even others on the island that still argue for essentially what we have so far a commonwealth with you know, with the American umbrella citizenship. But that's about it. So joining me to discuss the fight for STATEO. These are two advocates for statehood, both with Puerto Rico and DC, because I believe you're not going to get one state. The only shot you have it each has is probably working together two states and give both parties the idea that they have something to gain. Here. George las Garcia is the executive director of the Puerto Rican Statehood Council and the shadow represent from DC who is elected to lobby for statehood. Oya oh Oleiwa joins me. I will be using his nickname of Oya for the rest of the time. Thank you both for joining us. Oh Yea, I hope you're okay with that. Absolutely, Thanks for having me look, and I want to give you. I want to give you a shout out here because you and I have been talking for some time about this issue. You've always been looking for better ways to get more national coverage of this, and I suggested, hey, why don't we, why don't we get somebody advocating for Puerto Rican statehood and let's have you guys on together. And sure enough, o Ya, you were my book aro on this one. So thank you. Let me start. Let me start with you, Oya, which is about ten years ago. I thought, you know, maybe DC statehood happens in my lifetime, and then, you know, and then some roadblocks have been hit. How would you describe the status? I just recently sat down with Mayor Bowser and she, you know, fights she you know, the issue of the National Guard was a reminder, as she said, Hey, if you don't like it, that's why you need to advocate for statehood. Where would you how would you describe where we are on the on the fight for
Load full transcript
statehood in the district.
00:06:18
Speaker 2: Yeah, thank you for that question, Thank you for having me. As you mentioned before, we had the opportunity.
00:06:23
Speaker 3: To become a state, whether it's having the Democrats control of the House, Senate and the presidency. However, the fight for d Z state was never really prioritized, and when I became the US representative four or five years ago, the.
00:06:39
Speaker 2: Conversation about statehood usually relied and ended at Congressional representation, which is critical for DC. However, since my election, we've seen things like our old our bills being overturned by Congress, the National Guard not being deployed on time on January sixth, Even more recently, the federal occupation of agents on the ground of DC. So we're seeing people, you know, really activate behind the idea of DC becoming a state, but definitely politically we're taking a step back because the same dynamics that we may have enjoyed in two thousand and eight isn't here in twenty twenty five. But because of your platform, because of other people speaking, I believe we are a getting closer and closer to DC statehood being an actual issue.
00:07:21
Speaker 1: George, walk me through where how's the state of Puerto Rican statehood? And if you have a pushback on how I described the debate, I've always thought that one of the challenges for Puerto Rican statehood is that the fact that it isn't at clean there Really there aren't two sides of the argument in Puerto Rico, there are three sides to the argument.
00:07:40
Speaker 4: Yeah, well, thank you so much, Chuck for the opportunity.
00:07:44
Speaker 5: The issue of Puerto Rico's statehood is one that has made a lot of progress in the past decades. As you mentioned, on the island, political parties aren't necessarily aligned along the republican and democratic political spectrum. They've mostly been focused on where the political parties support the different status solutions. So there's been a very small minority traditionally between two and about six percent that supports full independence.
00:08:16
Speaker 4: For Puerto Rico, small percent. It's been that small.
00:08:21
Speaker 5: There has been a larger political party that has had the control of the governorship and the legislature for a lot of the twentieth century that supports either continuing as a territory or improving that in some way. They call it the commonwealth and use that term earlier, but the reality is the Supreme Court Justice justices have decided in a number of cases that ultimately, even though that's a formal name of Puerto Rico, Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, for the purposes of the US Constitution, Puerto Rico is an unincorporated territory, meaning that it belongs to the United States. It's a property United States, but it isn't actually incorporated into the Union permanently, which is one of the constitutional differences between Puerto Rico and Washington, d C. Which is definitely incorporated on
a permanent basis into the Union.
00:09:12
Speaker 1: It's written into the Constitution right. DC's existence is written into the Constitution.
00:09:18
Speaker 5: Exactly exactly, so DC couldn't be made into independent country. They either become a state, they're retroceeded into another existing state, or or they stay as what they are.
00:09:29
Speaker 1: You know.
00:09:29
Speaker 4: Right now, with Puerto Rico, we've got different options.
00:09:32
Speaker 5: Right, We've got independence, which a majority of the island residents have consistently opposed. We've got continuing to be a territory, which means that you get treated unequally under federal laws and programs, and you don't have a full participation in the US Congress that makes the laws that you live under. Right, so you get kind of this terrible treatment of you know, unequal treatment under laws and then no representation the body that makes those laws. And then we've got an added factor, which is that, like DC, the Congress can actually govern.
00:10:08
Speaker 4: Us at the local level.
00:10:09
Speaker 5: So all states across the Union, they've got the Tenth Amendment where the state itself is a sovereign and it reserves all the rights to the states and the people that aren't explicitly granted to the federal government by the Constitution in the case of Washington, d C. In Puerto Rico, Congress can literally pass local laws that govern us, and in the case of Puerto Rico, they've done so. And what that has done most recently is mean that we have a federal oversight board that is essentially ruling Puerto Rico over and above the decisions of our elected officials. And what this has done is it has pushed the residents on the island to recognize the continuing under territory status isn't the best option. And and over four different plubisites that have been held between twenty twelve and today, voters have consistently rejected the current territory status and favored statehood as the best option for Puerto Rico's future.
00:11:13
Speaker 1: What's been the biggest number on that?
00:11:15
Speaker 5: The biggest number in supportive statehood. The most recent one was fifty eight percent. And that really just shows that, you know, nearly two thirds of the residents on the island supports statehood versus independence. Got like eleven percent.
00:11:33
Speaker 4: Yeah, and it.
00:11:34
Speaker 1: Correct me if I'm wrong. So you got a large majority like that. And there were three choices on the ballot, not two, correct.
00:11:41
Speaker 5: Yeah, And I'll explain the third choice. Right, So I mentioned independence, I mentioned statehood. There's a form of independence called free association. And what this is is a relationship the United States has with some of the former Pacific Trust territories that are Palao, Federated States of Micronesia, and the Marshall Islands, and they're basically independent countries. They've got their own president, their own passport, their own constitution, but the United States essentially.
00:12:08
Speaker 4: Protects them militarily.
00:12:11
Speaker 5: The United States uses them as a shield against the potential influence of China in the Pacific, and in exchange, they basically get some very limited federal support. But the people there aren't United States citizens. And in Puerto Rico, everyone born on the island since nineteen seventeen has been a United States citizen. And I don't think anyone on the island really wants to consider any possibility of having us stripped of our United States citizenship, because what they would do is it would separate the island's residents from the three point two million on the island from the more than six million Puerto Ricans that live stateside.
00:12:52
Speaker 4: And who wants that?
00:12:53
Speaker 1: No one? Oh yeah, I know, DC held won once about ten years ago, a referendum. Do you think this needs to be had again? Do you think these I've always thought the referendums in Puerto Rico actually they were pr efforts, right, It wasn't just about getting people on the island to express themselves, but reminding us on the mainland here, Hey, there are some basically some people who are not getting full constitutional rights that are American citizens. Do you think DC should be holding referendums more often on this issue?
00:13:29
Speaker 2: Well, while referendum would bring this issue to the masses, similar to what Puerto Rico has been doing, we have seen on a regular basis people walking around talking about DC, stand going on the news. When it came to the recent occupation where we had National Guard members in DC, we have a record high or straight gays. Where is the CNNs and the msnbcs we're talking about DC staylors. So I think it's really important for us to keep that energy. But I do also believe that we also had to go to other states. You know a lot of people all across this country. When I go to Utahs, when I go to Colorado's they don't understand what's going on in DC, and they think that the district is just the White House, it's just Congress, it's just the statues, but not the seven hundred thousand Americas living in DC. So, yes, the referendum will help, but we also have other means to get the message forward. As the child represented for the past four years, I'm not only interacted with people across the country.
00:14:29
Speaker 6: We also engage with state legislators. We introduce a DC statehood resolution in West Virginia. We contacted people in Utah. We went to other states, especially red states, to get people on record to show that they support DC stately and as an a media impact, because today's state legislator it's gonna be tomorrow's congressional candidate, and we can get people to start becoming fans and champions of DDC stale before going into office, we in DC have a much better bet of getting that voting passage in the getting.
00:15:00
Speaker 2: That majority in the Senate, and hopefully getting a president
that understands that this is not just a Parson issue. This is an American rights issue. I mean, we fought a war over tax station with our representation. We're still seeing that happening today. And just combining the elements of this country with the things that's happening today would be really really important, like being vocal about the occupation and not calling it a search, you know, use the words that really mattered, that really engage people across this country to really understand that, especially in today's time, DC residents are so vulnerable compared to other areas. We see Brandon Scott talking tough, we see we see Brandon Johnson Chicago talking tough. We see Gavin Newsoen talking tough. But our mayor, in certain ways, it's compromised because we're not a state.
00:15:50
Speaker 1: And that's what she'll say. I mean, I think she'd fight more if it wouldn't maybe wreck Home rule completely. I mean, she was in a real box here because a Republican House might have stripped Home rule from DC.
00:16:03
Speaker 2: They tried to. There's actually the Bowser Act in the House, and it's said that Will Lily stripped away our only way to elect our mayor, the only way to elect our council, attorney generals under attack, and we're seeing marches in the street of d C. We just passed the No King's rally, but a lot of us in office are afraid to speak on the same way because we're so compromised by not being a state.
00:16:30
Speaker 1: Let me play a little Devil's advocate here. I'm not saying I'm advocating this, but this has been I've been here thirty five years and one of the alternative. You know, just like with with there's sort of a third way in Puerto Rico that some people have wanted to talk about, there's a third way in d C, which is what if DC became part of Maryland? What say you?
00:16:52
Speaker 2: Yeah, that's the terms called retro session, you know, Virginia to the way parts of DC in the past was.
00:16:58
Speaker 1: I I live in the piece of I always say, I live in Arlington. I tell people where's Arlington? I said. If you look at a map of d C and you see the missing square, We're the missing square.
00:17:09
Speaker 2: You are in old DC, My friends, you slim back over.
00:17:13
Speaker 1: No, I that's why I'm old d C. I'm here. I'm here, trust me.
00:17:17
Speaker 2: But for many reasons, culturally, financially, and politically, you know, DC doesn't want to be part of Maryland, and Maryland sorts thought doesn't want us. You know.
00:17:25
Speaker 1: Yeah, when it comes to our culture, Baltimore fights it. There's no doubt right there, the dominant culture in the city. I get that, and they don't, you know, because if d C became part of Maryland, the center of gravity would all change in that state.
00:17:40
Speaker 2: Yeah, right, So we want to be disagressives. We don't want to fight the fight. We don't want to run from them by We want to make sure we tree like everybody else, nothing better than Maryland, Virginia, Ohioans want
to be treated the same exactly, George.
00:17:52
Speaker 1: Let me throw up a one wrinkle by you that I've always found a bit I've just been curious about. Why shouldn't the Virgin Islands be part of the Puerto Rico fight for DC statehood? Accuse me? First state of not DC state? Why shouldn't Why shouldn't the Virgin Islands sort of almost the same way we have of the Hawaiian Islands as a state. You know, is because it's the Virgin Island population is too small to be a state on its own. Is that is? Is there any way that that would be of help? Do you think to your ability to lobby for statehood?
00:18:33
Speaker 5: Well, Chuck, the reality is that the US Virgin Islands was acquired at a different time by the United States. They were acquired from Denmark and purchased I believe it was around nineteen seventeen. Puerto Rico was acquired in Spanish micrant Ward eighteen ninety eight. The culture and the language is different. US Virgin Islands are predominantly African American roots and speak predominantly English.
00:19:07
Speaker 1: Uh.
00:19:07
Speaker 5: There's a lot of intermixing, particularly on the Saint Croix, with people from Puerto Rico, particularly from the municipality of Veeks, which is right next to the US Virgin Islands. So there are some strong connections there. But I definitely think that both territories see their identities as unique and distinct and separate. I don't think that there has been any serious discussion, either in Puerto Rico or in the US Virgin Islands of having the two territories combined under statehood. However, you know, if you ask me if tomorrow Congress says.
00:19:45
Speaker 4: We'll give you statehood if you add U.
00:19:48
Speaker 5: S v I on as part of state, I'd be like, I'll take it, you know, and you know, we'll we'll we'll add them on and we'll treat them with respect, and you know they'll be The question is informed consent and consent of the government. Course is that something that the people in USBI would want? And I don't know, you know, they've been arguing and trying to figure out if they can even establish a local constitution now for several decades.
00:20:13
Speaker 4: So you know that, I think is really what's at the heart of it.
00:20:17
Speaker 5: We can't just talk about putting together jurisdictions. We had to go back to America's founding value, which is government by consent of the government. That requires asking the people of those jurisdictions what is that they want.
00:20:32
Speaker 1: There's a reason results matter more than promises, just like there's a reason. Morgan and Morgan is America's largest injury law firm. For the last thirty five years, they've recovered twenty five billion dollars for more than half a million clients. It includes cases where insurance companies offered next to nothing, just hoping to get away with paying as little as possible. Morgan and Morgan fought back ended up winning millions. In fact, in Pennsylvania, one client was awarded twenty six
million dollars, which was a staggering forty times the amount that the insurance company originally offered. That original offer six hundred and fifty thousand dollars twenty six million, six hundred and fifty thousand dollars. So with more than one thousand lawyers across the country, they know how to deliver for everyday people, if you're injured, you need a lawyer. You need somebody to get your back. Check out for the People dot Com, Slash podcast or now Pound Law, Pound five two nine law on your cell phone. And remember all law firms are not the same. So check out Morgan and Morgan. Their fee is free unless they win. So let's go to strategy here. I've always believed, you know, if you look at various statehood expansions, it was never because it was a good idea to have statehood. It was there were always political power considerations in the moment. You know, I always remind people, you know why South Dakota is a state because Republicans wanted another pair of senators, so they decided to break up the Dakota. There's no other re said there's two Dakotas, but it was they wanted. This was during the fight, you know, the North Loan out of state, the South Lounaita state, and they were going to be all these back and forth. So you know, this is this stuff gets more arbitrary than people realize. The Dakotas is a perfect example. Their perception of DC is that it would be two more Democratic senators, which is why Republicans try to block it. I think it's pretty clear given the politics of Puerto Rico, you can't you can't assume anything that it is automatically gonna be one way or the other. You've got people like Rick Scott and Marco Rubio, who for years as Florida senators, have treated Puerto Rico as sort of, hey, you know, we've got a lot of Puerto Rico, Puerto Rican cities, people of Puerto Rican descent living in Florida. You know, we should help Puerto Rico. And so I've always thought that the two either coming together or neither one gets statehood.
00:22:55
Speaker 4: Do you buy that, you know, personally, I don't think so.
00:22:59
Speaker 5: I think that DC and Puerto Rico have parallel issues in the sense that they are both jurisdictions where you have United States citizens that lack full voting rights and lack full civil rights in the federal government that they live under.
00:23:18
Speaker 4: And I think that that needs to be addressed. But the reality is that we're.
00:23:23
Speaker 5: Also coming from different constitutional situations, and we're also coming from different political situations. And I think that therefore, kind of conflating the two issues and bringing trying to address them both together is challenging, right. And in the case of Puerto Rico, we are in a similar circumstance to where Alaska and Hawaii were before their admission in nineteen fifty nine, where we were US territories that have voted for admission into statehood. And you know, Congress has the power to admit us. There's no constitutional constraints to that. The only thing that Congress needs to do is to pass a law a bill in the House and in the Senate and have the President sign it.
00:24:10
Speaker 1: Right.
00:24:11
Speaker 4: In the case of the.
00:24:12
Speaker 1: Made it for two thirds, there's no need for some extra hurdle.
00:24:15
Speaker 5: Yeah, it just the case at Congress, exactly simple act of Congress.
00:24:19
Speaker 1: Right.
00:24:19
Speaker 5: In the case of Washington, d C. It can be admitted, uh, in the same way. But there is the issue of how do you deal with the territoriality of Washington, d C. Versus the seat of government, right, And that is a constitutional question that needs to be addressed. And it is also possible that you know, in response to the twenty third Amendment, another amendment to the Constitution may need to be passed, and that really is quite different from the you know, process of admitting Puerto Rico as a state. I know that, and and fully respect all the different ideas for how that can be done. But I'm just saying it's a different track procedurally.
00:25:06
Speaker 1: Oh, I address that because I've seen so. I know it. When this got a little bit attraction when it passed the House about a decade ago, we had you know, there was I remember, I think some people had some maps that in order to essentially make sure this wasn't you know that you weren't violating the Constitution. The District of Columbia would still exist. The Federal District would simply shrink down to I want to say, you know, for those thinking of the map out loud, think I guess between Pennsylvania Avenue and the river essentially. But but maybe you can give me some more details on that. Oh, yes, you both are one.
00:25:47
Speaker 2: Hundred percent right. Under the Constitution, a new state of Columbia, which you know, our own version of the new DC would look like we would basically shrink the US capital to the federal encrep think the Congresses, think the Why House, Supreme Court in the monuments outside of that would be the new state of Columbia. Now, while my friend right here is one hundred percent right. There are two different tracks for Puerto Rico and DC becoming a state. When it comes to the political reality of it, states are added by the duo. There is no party will allow one state to come in and potentially wreck the uneven balance of power. Now, when Hawaii and Alaska were admitted as into the Union, Hawaii was seen as a Republican state and Alaska was seen as the liberal state. Now in due time, they flipped. Now, unfortunately today's Republican Party, they know they can't get new people to join their party, so instead they just take away people's voting rights and try to retract and restrict the amount of votes available. So I don't think the Republican Party is that interested in l n DC become a state. I don't think they can win us over. However, they do feel in my gad, I've talked to some sanators and talked to some staffers in the House. The only
way they'll really start thinking about DC becoming a state is that they can have a republic in Carowell to it. I know in the past they were willing to grant Congresolman Norm vote if they added a seat in usaw but like I said before, there will be no democratic state at it unless there's a Republican counterpart. And they're as sure as hell will be here republican states at it. This is a democratic a democratic counterpart. Now that may not be fair, but as a reporter Steve Basemith said, the only thing, the only thing that's fair is where pigs are sold. So this is politics.
00:27:32
Speaker 1: We have to deal with it.
00:27:33
Speaker 2: And at the end of the day, in order for DC become a state, they probably need to be that counterbalancing acts to manage the plical difference.
00:27:41
Speaker 1: Look, I want I'm gonna play moderator here. Look I think I get it. I think I'm gonna just be honest. Oh yeah, you need Puerto Rico as your partner to get statehood. Puerto Rico, what's that? You need a dance partner? And I think George is arguing, you know, I could probably do this without a dance partner.
00:27:56
Speaker 2: And I see, I.
00:27:59
Speaker 1: Sort of see where George where you're coming from on that, because there's been such a bipartisan history of both parties going back and forth with the governor's office and both parties successfully raising money off the island. Right there, is a bit more of a bipartisan tradition in Puerto Rico that probably wouldn't spook party leaders from either side of the aisle.
00:28:24
Speaker 5: Yeah, and you know, this is not something that is theoretical to me. I've actually served governors that have been Republicans and Democrats. I've seen support on this issue from both Democratic and Republican House and Senate members. The issue has a long history of bipartisan support when it comes to Puerto Rico. But what I can also very much acknowledge is that, you know, Puerto Rico is a question mark when it comes to where things will pan out, you know, electorally after admission as a state. Just like with Alaska and Hawaii, what you mentioned is one hundred percent right. You know, they were looking at Alaska as the democratic state and Hawaii as as the Republican state, and you know, things ended.
00:29:18
Speaker 4: Up being the exact opposite.
00:29:20
Speaker 5: There's nothing that can guarantee that Puerto Rico, if it's admitted into a state, will be a democratic state and a republic or republican state. Although right now, if we look at the current makeup of the political leadership in Puerto Rico, the Resident Commission or Puerto Rico's non voting member in the House is a Democrat, but the governor is a Republican, and the speaker in Puerto Rico's houses a Republican. The majority of the representatives in Portrico's legislature Republicans, and the leader in the Senate is a Republican, and the majority of the Senators in.
00:29:57
Speaker 4: Puerto Rico are Republicans.
00:29:59
Speaker 5: So it
really does present a situation where members looking at it from Washington need to actually look at what's happening electorally on the island, and also the geographic reality of Puerto Rico. Much like any other state, the urban areas tend to be significantly more liberal, and if you look at the rest of Puerto Rico, the rural areas tend to be significantly more conservative. And that's a little bit of a challenge for DC because DC is almost entirely an urban area right in.
00:30:34
Speaker 1: If the population estimates, it would be four congressional seats for Puerto Rico roughly, how would that break up. Would it be two in San Juan and then the rest of the island would be broken up that way or.
00:30:46
Speaker 5: How it would depend on how the districting is done, which is also something very interesting because as we're seeing right now with the whole effort to redo districting nationwide, if you had a Republican majority in Portos we have right now decide to draw district maps that would you know, end up favoring Republicans, then you know, maybe that could be the.
00:31:07
Speaker 1: Outcome woe or something.
00:31:10
Speaker 4: But you know, the realities we don't know.
00:31:12
Speaker 5: When we've had shadow delegations appointed and then elected to serve and represent Puerto Rico, we've had them fifty to fifty split. They've been half Democrats and half Republicans, And I think that ultimately that is actually what's most representative of the island's population because we've never had the chance to draw our own district maps and elect our own centers representatives, so we just have to use the data that we have up to nout.
00:31:45
Speaker 1: Look. In total, there are four point three million people without full American citizens, without full rights that live in these territories, either District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, or any of these states and territories. Is there a middle ground at all that would give everybody more rights without statehood? Oh yeah, let me start with you. I don't think so.
00:32:07
Speaker 2: I'll be quite honest, I don't think so. If the question was just about voting representation in Congress, then maybe there'll be a half measure that makes everybody happy.
00:32:15
Speaker 1: Well, you might get a member in the House, but not in the Senate, like right, right, the conversations that we're.
00:32:20
Speaker 4: Having, but that requires a constitutional amendment. We're back to that.
00:32:23
Speaker 2: But give me one second. So when we had in twenty twenty five our local budget slash and we had to almost get rid of teachers and firefighters, when you're seeing the President send the National Guard to patrol areas in our communities and send ice to grab people face off how they look. The only thing that protects DC residents is statehood. This is no longer just how many votes we can count Congress. This is really an opportunity for DC residents to have full ownership over our lives on local governance. There is no half measure to it. I know. Earlier my friend here said we're far away from from d C State. Well, within the last six years we passed the d C State and the Missions Act in the House. I would say anything like that. Puerto Rico, we have forty more than forty centers cosponds from the bill to make DC a state. I don't know we're out Puerto Rico. So I do believe there is a pathway forward for DC residents to become residents of the state. I think we have to push forard on that because it means so much more than just count of both of Congress.
00:33:23
Speaker 1: George, the same question to you, do you think there's a is there some half measure that gives more rights to whether you live in Guam, Puerto Rico, or DC.
00:33:34
Speaker 5: So you know, I think with the smaller territories in the Pacific and the US Virgin Islands, there is a separate question than the one that we have for Washington, d C. And for Puerto Rico, just because of the population size, right, and the fact that in none of those territories they've actually expressed themselves by votes that they want to end their territorial status and that they want statehood. One thing that is one hundred percent in alignment between DC and Puerto Rico is that in both places you've had voters express their consent to ending the territorial status in the case of Puerto Rico and the seat of government status in the case of DC and you know, express their desire for statehood. The half measures don't work, and i'll tell you why. In the case of Puerto Rico, you can get additional federal funding and maybe treated you know, equally in certain federal programs, but the territorial clause allows any future Congress to claw that back at any point. So even if you can get like full Medicaid parity or full parody nutritional assistance or whatever else that we don't have unequal right now, any future Congress can say, no, we're taking it away, and that you can't build an economy that's sustainable.
00:34:54
Speaker 4: Off of that.
00:34:54
Speaker 5: And then the other piece is that ultimately, if every single day, Congress and the federal government are passing laws and regulations that apply to the territory, and Puerto Rico doesn't have representation that's equal in the House and zero presentation in the Senate, and doesn't have any representation in the Electoral College, then how can we expect to have oversight over the federal agencies that apply these laws and policies, And how can we expect the interests and the goals and aspirations of the US citizens of Puerto Rico to be taken into account in the legislative process. You can't and any half measures to try to give Puerto Rico, you know, and a representative in the House, or you know, a single representative that can vote. That would require constitutional a hounta. That's harder than passing statehood. Right, It's easier to pass a statehood admission bill than it is to pass an amendment to give Puerto Rico one voting representative in
the House, and that single vote would not compensate that island for the representational gap in the demographic democratic deficit that currently exists.
00:36:05
Speaker 1: The Congressional Black Caucus has been a huge advocate of DC statehood, and it may explain why a bill got on the floor of the House and did get passed. What has been the How would you explain why there hasn't been a similar effort for Puerto Rico.
00:36:26
Speaker 5: Well, you know, the reality is that we have had two bills past the House, one in twenty ten and the most recent one in twenty twenty two. The last one in twenty twenty two, it's called the Puerto Rico Status Act, passed with a bipartisan majority that included unanimous Democratic support in the House and sixteen Republican votes, which is, you know, quite impressive given this overall level of polarization that we see in American politics nowadays. The bill had at that point a state of administration policy from UH then President Biden, and in the following session of Congress we did have that bill reintroduced because the US Senate just didn't have enough time to address you say.
00:37:14
Speaker 1: LA status, what what is? What would specifically would that bill do? Put it basically that.
00:37:20
Speaker 5: Congress has a responsibility and Puerto Rico's colonial territory status and offers voters UH single vote between the three non territorial options of statehood, UH, independence and independence with free association, which is this bilatteral Marshaled Marshall Island idea.
00:37:43
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:37:43
Speaker 5: And what ended up happening is the Senate didn't pass that UH, but it was reintroduced in the following session, and we had twenty seven senators supported, all of them Democrats, UH, no Rick Scott, no Rick Scott, and no Marco Ruvial. However, since then, we have had at least one Republican senator express his support for Puerto Rico's statehood, and that is the Senator from Oklahoma, Mark Wayne Mullen, which is also very interesting.
00:38:14
Speaker 4: Because he's just the President's here exactly right.
00:38:18
Speaker 5: So it does reflect the continued bipartisan nature of the Puerto Rico.
00:38:25
Speaker 4: Statehood push.
00:38:28
Speaker 5: But what ended up happening in Puerto Rico is that Congress didn't act, but locally, we decided, you know what, we're going to continue sending the message from our citizenry. So we took that same ballot that was designed in the Puerto Rico Status Act, and we put it up to voters literally exactly as it was written and passed by the House of Representatives. And that's what happened last November, and fifty eight percent of voters supported statehood for Puerto Rico.
00:38:55
Speaker 1: And this was the strongest version of independence that's ever been on the meaning the independence with essentially protection from the United States, and the fact that that couldn't get the number that it got, I.
00:39:07
Speaker 5: Think, yeah, so so independence just beer independence got like just under twelve percent, eleven point eight free association, which is a form of independence that in that case was included even continued US citizenship after you know, being made a sovereign country, right, which I ultimately don't think that Congress would pass it in that way. But you know, it was a really nice offer that only got twenty nine percent, and you ended up with fifty eight percent supporting you know, full statehood, and that really shows that the majority of people in Puerto Rico don't want to continue under the current territory status and they want statehood. And now it's it's up to Congress act. But as Aye said, it's not just Congress. It's up to the American people across all all of the states to say, we need to end a circumstance where we have nearly four million fellow American citizens that are being denied their full rights, and we need to have an active conversation about how we offer full enfranchisement and full democratic rights to the citizens of Puerto Rico, of DC, and even of the other territories.
00:40:23
Speaker 4: And there may be.
00:40:24
Speaker 5: Different solutions for each one, but that fundamental principle, that's a debate that has to happen for America as a whole.
00:40:33
Speaker 1: Having good life insurance is incredibly important. I know from personal experience. I was sixteen when my father passed away. We didn't have any money. He didn't leave us in the best shape. My mother, single mother, now widow, myself sixteen, trying to figure out how am I going to pay for college? And lo and behold, my dad had one life insurance policy that we found wasn't a lot, but it was important at the time, and it's why I was able to go to college. Little did he know how important that would be in that moment. Well, guess what. That's why I am here to tell you about Ethos Life. They can provide you with peace of mind knowing your family is protected even if the worst comes to pass. Ethos is an online platform that makes getting life insurance fast and easy, all designed to protect your family's future in minutes, not months. There's no complicated process, and it's one hundred percent online. There's no medical exam require you just answer a few health questions online. You can get a quote in as little as ten minutes, and you can get same day coverage without ever leaving your home. You can get up to three million dollars in coverage, and some policies start as low as two dollars a day that would be billed monthly. As of March twenty twenty five, Business Insider named Ethos the number one, no medical exam instant life insurance provider. So protect your family with life insurance from Ethos. Get your free quote at ethos dot com slash chuck. So again that's Ethos dot com slash chuck. Application times may vary and the rates themselves may vary as well, but trust me, life insurance is something you should really think about it, especially if you've got a growing family.
I'm just curious, you know, he was talking about how he's been going to other states trying to get resolutions passed. Have you tried that? And I was just inton, I was just gonna say, let's do it Florida, New York. Right, if you had a Governor de Santis at a Governor Holcal signing the same resolution, that'd be pretty good, a pretty good piece of marketing material for you with and.
00:42:43
Speaker 4: And we're working on that.
00:42:44
Speaker 5: There is a state side advocacy movement that supports statehood for Puerto Rico. We've been working on that in the Statehood Council for many years. There's also been another effort called the Extended Congressional Delegation that's been working on it for the past few years. And there's literally, you know, tens of thousands of US citizens from across the country that support statehood for Puerto Rico. And you know, also national polling has shown this. You know, I think that the Gallup polls have shown for decades that over you know, sixty percent of Americans support statehood for Puerto Rico.
00:43:21
Speaker 1: I want to get before I let you both go, I want to get to the financial consequences of a lack of statehood. You hinted at it a bit, George, Oh, yeah, you were talking. We were talking a bit more about obviously control of the budget, right, some of that home rule decisions. But is there a you know, do you get less Medicaid reimbursements in DC because of the status? What do you can you put a dollar figure on what you think statehood costs the district financially.
00:43:50
Speaker 2: We lose millions, if not billions of dollars by not being a state. Years ago, when we were battling the pandemic together and they passed legislation that will provide billions of dollars to shade the combat the COVID pandemic, d C was regulated to becoming a territory. It's released. We lost about half a million, half a billion dollars.
00:44:10
Speaker 1: So did Wyoming get more money?
00:44:12
Speaker 2: Wyoming got more, Maryland got more, Virginia.
00:44:15
Speaker 1: Got less people. Yeah, than the district. That's why sing Wyoming absolutely.
00:44:21
Speaker 2: And unlike Puerto Rico on other locations, we were a landlocked So the problems that Maryland was spilled into d C. And just to piggyback on from a previous conversation, the things I've done in other states were two tiered. It wasn't just enough to tell people that we deserved DC statehood. We also made sure that folks understood how their lives would improve by us becoming a state, us having voter representation. When I went to Boone County, West Virginia, where I was the only black guy around, I didn't stop the conversation by d C residsts, mostly minority people deserve equal rights. We talked about the issues that they cared about, let in their water, not having an access to employment, the coal industry is evaporating, and talking about some of the things that I've experienced living in common sights south East Washington, d C. Bridge of those gaps and understanding that a center from d C, voting representative from d C can actually pass legislation that then center mansion or capital wasn't passing and really engaging them in a way that they felt that they gained from DC becoming a state.
00:45:27
Speaker 4: It helped a lot.
00:45:28
Speaker 2: And I advise anybody who's buying for a statement to also make sure that we let them know what their investment needs to folks living in other places outside of Puerto Rico or outside of d C.
00:45:40
Speaker 1: George put a dollar figure on it. You were talking about when it comes to certain funding things and the lack of equity. Oh, you just talked about it with COVID funding. If Wyoming is getting more dollars for fewer people than DC, that does seem unequal. What's give me a few examples in Puerto Rico.
00:45:57
Speaker 4: In the case of.
00:45:57
Speaker 5: Puerto Rico, it is definitely very explicit that Puerto Rico receives unequal treatment under federal laws and programs. And this not only impacts negatively the quality of life of people on the island, but it actually spurs people and pushes them to leave.
00:46:13
Speaker 4: Right.
00:46:14
Speaker 1: Oh, that's why they I mean, that's why they leave right Not usually?
00:46:17
Speaker 5: Yeah, And so the areas some of the main areas where Porto Rico gets treated unequally. Most egregious is in Medicare and Medicaid, so our elderly people don't get the same level of financial support for their medical care.
00:46:32
Speaker 4: So let's say if the average.
00:46:34
Speaker 5: Medicare Medicare patient in the States gets about fifteen thousand dollars per year given to them for their healthcare coverage, in Porto Rico's five, you know, and that means that there's a huge reduction in the amount of money going into our medical service providers. Our hospitals are nurses, so all the basic care are you know, lower income family These in Medicaid get you know, less support services too, and that has a massively negative impact on the economy because ultimately, these.
00:47:08
Speaker 4: People are your workforce.
00:47:10
Speaker 5: So if they're if they're more sick, if they're more impacted by chronic illnesses that aren't being able to be treated. Because with Puerto Rico we don't have enough money in our Medicaid system to have long term care access, that's a huge problem for our economy and our society, and it also impacts.
00:47:27
Speaker 4: The local budget.
00:47:28
Speaker 5: Portugo gets different treatment under nutritional assistance, so we have one of the highest child poverty rates in the entire United States, and and that's devastating. You're talking about, you know, money that is not coming in to support children in their critical moments of physiological development, and that impacts educational outcomes, that impacts long term outcomes in terms of their socioeconomic mobility because you know, you just didn't get the support at the ritical moments when when you
needed it. So these deficiencies and lack of equality amount to tens of billions of dollars in less money that's flowing through the economy in Puerto Rico every single year. And as a result, the overall quality of life on the island is lower, which means more people leave, and then that creates a negative spiral that we're in. The more people leave, the more consumer demand goes down. The more consumer demand goes down, the more businesses have to shutter, the more your tax base gets reduced, the worse your fiscal circumstance, you know, the higher the share of per capita debt for the debt that you already have in your jurisdiction. But you know, I think one key point that made that I would like to also reiterate. You know a lot of people stateside have this misconception that Puerto Rico is just a jurisdiction that takes from the federal government, and that just is not true. Puerto Rico actually pays more in federal taxes than at least three states in the nation, even though in Puerto Rico, local residents do not pay federal income taxes on their income that they derive from the island. And the other piece is that in Puerto Rico, we have about seventy billion dollars worth of annual interstate commerce between the island and the States. So Puerto Rico actually helps to generate profits and jobs for companies stateside that are employing people and that are making an economic difference in Florida, in New York, in Texas, you know, throughout the entire country. Because guess what, for example, in Puerto Rico we import you know, I think it's over eighty eighty five percent of the you know, fresh fruit products.
00:49:49
Speaker 4: Most of that's coming from the States. Most of that is being farmed state side.
00:49:53
Speaker 5: So if we grow the pie by giving Puerto Rico the quality that it needs to have an equal playing field, what we see is the same thing we saw with Alaskan, Hawaii, which is a process of economic integration where the territories grew economically in a very significant way and they ended up helping the other states because then those states had more of a market to sell their products and services to and we grow.
00:50:21
Speaker 4: The pie of the American economy as a whole.
00:50:24
Speaker 1: Look, I can confess that I know what happens to DC is that people leave because of the lack of representation, and so I know the tax base would be stronger in DC they had they had statehood. You know, people like myself might not have left, and others might not have left. I'm curious.
00:50:43
Speaker 5: I'm a former DC resident myself, by the way, and now live in Virginia.
00:50:47
Speaker 1: So no, you sit there and you you know it. The unfairness, unfair treatment of DC. Everybody starts. You know, at the end of the day, you worry about yourself, right, bottom line, everybody does. Last question for both of you, Oh yeah, I'll start with you, which is are there businesses that won't relocate to d C because of the lack of statehood?
And is that a maybe? Is there a way to fire up the business world to support something like this as well? I just think about other ways to create more support outside of traditional political lines.
00:51:26
Speaker 2: Absolutely. I mean, right now there is a recession in DC. We are the highest unemployment because of the massive cuts, whether it's Elon Musks, Doge, or Trump's continue planning to fire more federal workers during the shutdown. DC residents are in need of a new industry. And one industry that comes to mind us really, obviously, maybe because I'm a Nigerian American, is the international development scene. You go to New York, you go to Manhattan, you see you and a Seth, You see the un you even see the Millennium Hotel on the Manhattan Island. And imagine if DC had that scene. Given our lack of statehood, given our political stagnation, the fact that because we're not a state, we don't have governors, we don't have a thousand different things could run for, Like if you're in Virginia or man we only have looks like four or five seeds. It makes it much harder for us to create those new industries. Whereas all we leaned on was the government. All we leaned on was contractors and sings like that. So when Trump kind of sweeps them away, where it can't just left but naked outside.
00:52:31
Speaker 1: It's tough to diversify your economy.
00:52:33
Speaker 2: Absolutely. I think something we should do is bring in those NGOs, those things that we've see in other areas, because DC can be the home of that, but lack we stay here. We have seen how hard it is to do the best and bring in and recruit businesses and take a chance on the niches capital.
00:52:49
Speaker 1: George, I assume there's some business because you talk about that that specific law that if you earn money on the island you supposedly don't get to pay taxes on which feels like more like a loophole for an accountant than it is like a pragmatic approach to building a business. Yeah.
00:53:05
Speaker 5: So, you know, the issue with Puerto Rico's economic development model since the nineteen fifties and then accelerated more recently, is that a lot of the economic development has been industrialization by invitation based on tax exemption, right since Puerto Rico is not subject to federal income taxes for income derived on the island or federal corporate taxes for income derived on the island. For Unfortunately, that same model that was done for the industrialization of Puerto Rico in the nineteen fifties and sixties. That led to a massive manufacturing base on the island. We produce many of the top ten pharmaceuticals for the United States. We do a ton of pacemakers and other medical devices. So a lot of people think about Puerto Rico. They think is like beaches and rama. Right, It's not just that we've got some really amazing advanced manufacturing that's going on on the island.
00:54:03
Speaker 4: It's critical to meet America's national supply chain.
00:54:06
Speaker 5: But if
that development is all based on federal tax loopholes that at any point future Congress can change, you create a fragility in Puerto Rico's economic development model. And that's exactly what happened with a provision of the IRS tax Code called Section nine thirty six. It was phased out from nineteen ninety six to two thousand and six, and we did see a significant decline in manufacturing on the island. With statehood, what you get is you get more certainty around the possibility of investing in the jurisdiction because you know what you're.
00:54:42
Speaker 4: Going to get.
00:54:42
Speaker 5: You know that you're going to get equal treatment to all the other states. You're not going to have a circumstance where Congress, for example, extends the medicaid funding for a little while and then decides to drop it off afterwards, or improves you in this area and then takes away this tax break. The other thing that you get when you have statehood is you have senators and representatives that can fight, and they can advocate, and they can trade their votes, and they can make sure that whenever a bill passes, whether it's on transportation issues, environmental issues, labor issues, education issues, the interests of your constituents in your jurisdiction are taken into account. And right now we don't have that, and that is a huge limiting factor for our economic development.
00:55:29
Speaker 1: Here's what I can tell you. Any American citizen living in one of the fifty states, if they if they left one of those fifty states and realize what rights they don't have living in the district in Puerto Rico, they'd be angry. And what's interesting about this is that giving STATA to DC and Puerto Rico wouldn't change anybody else's life in any other of the fifty states. It is what would be the argument that what hard I can't think of the argument of harm to the other fifty states. No, I guess it would be carving up go ahead.
00:56:03
Speaker 2: Oh yeah, I've heard things like people want to see only fifty stars in the flag but don't know that fifty Yeah, that's ridiculous, but also an incentive. There are people who would like being the fiftieth vogue, being the forty ninth folks.
00:56:17
Speaker 1: So even if so, somebody will enjoy being the fifty second vote or the fifty third vote. What's wrong with that?
00:56:25
Speaker 2: You know?
00:56:26
Speaker 1: I could do, man, there's fifty two cards in a deck. We could have fifty two stars on a flag. I want to bring you back to the hell shot. You gotta come on me.
00:56:37
Speaker 2: Like me.
00:56:39
Speaker 1: I mean, my issue is fifty one. That's harder to divide up. Fifty two. That's you know, even number. We know how to work that. But that's the yeah, I mean, in all seriousness, you know, other than I guess, dividing up the pie. But these are all American citizens already, so they're already getting a smaller piece of the pie, but they should be getting a fuller one.
00:57:01
Speaker 5: So way was transparent with regards to the issue of political power. And you know, some people feeling threatened by the potential admission of a new state. You know, I'll be transparent with the issue of language and culture. You know, there's some people who outright argue that if Puerto Rico were admitted into the Union, you know, we'd suddenly have you know, a whole bunch of US citizens that speak Spanish. And to me, that argument is laughable because, believe it or not, the United States has more Spanish speakers as current United States citizens than Puerto Rico does, right, you know, there's forty million, you know, Hispanics in the United States.
00:57:38
Speaker 4: Spanish is the second most spoken language in the I.
00:57:42
Speaker 1: Don't mean interrupt, but how many states were added in the in the nineteenth century where majority spoke German? Yeah, a majority spoke right Like, I mean this, this is not We did this all the time in the nineteenth century.
00:57:54
Speaker 5: And there's many states to this day that have multiple official languages Alaska, why Alaska, and New Mexico, some of them even have them baked into their constitution for God's sakes. So if that hasn't been an issue for them, why isn't an issue for us?
00:58:10
Speaker 4: Now? I think it's just another cheap excuse.
00:58:13
Speaker 1: Well, look, I think that there's no doubt. There's no doubt that some people listening to this or watching this will assume that identity is playing a bigger part of this than any of us want to talk about. And it's hard to separate it out right. You just brought up the language issue, George. Oh yeah, we know that there's others that you know, the having two black senators and you just sitt there going it kind of feels antiquated, right, These arguments feel very early twentieth century at best.
00:58:41
Speaker 5: Absolutely, yeah, And there are things that America has to work through if we're going to become a stronger, more democratic, more inclusive country and a country that really abides by its founding values of equal justice under the law and government by consent to the government.
00:59:02
Speaker 1: Uh. And I'll use the phrase more perfect union. That's right, you got this would help us be a more perfect union. The message that would be sent if we did have two states that were majority minority in this country, it would it would speak volumes around the world anyway.
00:59:20
Speaker 2: Oh yeah, and.
00:59:21
Speaker 1: George, you guys are terrific at this. It almost was a mini debate, is but but it wasn't meant. I mean, I really look, I I'm the I'm the you know, the the faux expert here of political what what of the political side. So I do believe ultimately, you know, you guys will live together or die together on this. But we shall see. Oh yeah, and George, good luck to both of you.
00:59:45
Speaker 4: Appreciate it so much