สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00.000 --> 00:03.799
This is The Catholic Current with Father Robert
00:04.299 --> 00:07.983
Matthei. The insight for our time that we need to gain from Augustine is if
00:08.127 --> 00:11.942
we're not returning to Christ as individuals and families
00:12.118 --> 00:15.469
and communities, then we're just wasting our time.
00:15.725 --> 00:19.348
Absolutely, yeah. And I think that that's the real relevance of the City of God
00:19.848 --> 00:23.981
today, is that you do have this scramble among Christians right
00:24.481 --> 00:27.668
now trying to find the next, you know, hot ideology that's going to save us
00:28.168 --> 00:31.322
all. But what matters for you is the salvation of your soul.
00:31.691 --> 00:33.160
That is is what needs to be your priority.
00:34.820 --> 00:38.180
Praise be Jesus Christ. This is Father Robert McTaggart of the Society of Jesus,
00:38.680 --> 00:41.360
your daily host for The Catholic Current, where we bring Christ to the world and
00:41.860 --> 00:44.270
the world to Christ. You're listening to us from the Station of the Cross Studios,
00:44.320 --> 00:47.900
your local radio station, and the iCatholic Radio mobile app. We proclaim
00:48.400 --> 00:51.720
the fullness of truth with clarity and charity. As always,
00:52.220 --> 00:55.360
let's start with prayer. In the name of the Father, Son, and the Holy Spirit.
00:55.860 --> 00:58.740
Almighty God, through the intercession of Saint Ignatius Loyola, we ask that you pour forth
00:59.240 --> 01:01.980
your Holy Spirit upon us, a spirit of discernment that might hear your voice and
01:02.480 --> 01:05.950
obey your command. Of the Father, Son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen.
01:06.383 --> 01:09.737
Hey friends, it's a special kind of Friday here at The Catholic Current.
01:09.786 --> 01:13.477
It's not just your usual, uh, let's talk about this and
01:13.605 --> 01:16.911
weekend readiness. I'm recording this in advance because by
01:17.411 --> 01:20.506
the time you listen to this, I will be wrapping up a retreat. I will
01:21.006 --> 01:24.615
be sequestered in silence, spending a lot of time with the
01:25.115 --> 01:28.996
Blessed Sacrament. So if something catastrophic has
01:29.253 --> 01:32.428
happened in recent days and I don't talk about it,
01:32.861 --> 01:35.890
I'm probably praying about it up on the mountain where I'm going to be staying,
01:36.083 --> 01:39.529
but I just haven't had a chance to record it yet because it hasn't
01:39.609 --> 01:43.424
happened yet. And I want to talk about this in
01:43.521 --> 01:46.807
terms of stepping back from the cliff. And the
01:47.307 --> 01:51.167
reason I say that is because in the November issue of New Oxford Review,
01:51.311 --> 01:55.078
which everyone should have a subscription to— and I'm not saying that just
01:55.578 --> 01:59.246
because I'm a contributing editor to the New Oxford Review— I have
01:59.746 --> 02:03.638
an article here called Calling Catholics Back from cliff. And I want to share it
02:04.138 --> 02:08.253
with you. I want to read some portions of it. Now, it was written
02:08.366 --> 02:12.548
for the eye rather than the ear. It was made for a reader rather
02:13.048 --> 02:16.042
than a listener. So I'm going to offer some comments along the way. But here's
02:16.779 --> 02:20.048
my basic insight, and I think it's going to become
02:20.705 --> 02:24.151
the basis of my next, next book. The way that I say next,
02:24.167 --> 02:28.157
next book was because I'm about to send a manuscript
02:28.657 --> 02:31.907
to the publisher, and then in a week or two, another one after that.
02:32.003 --> 02:35.065
I know I've been slowing down. But then after that, I have
02:35.565 --> 02:39.040
a book about restoring Catholic intellectual life, which has
02:39.072 --> 02:42.006
been not doing well lately,
02:42.359 --> 02:46.366
very candidly. So the— and it doesn't have to be
02:46.866 --> 02:50.069
that way. You know, just because you're moving doesn't mean that
02:50.117 --> 02:53.852
you're making progress. And when you're heading towards the cliff,
02:54.542 --> 02:58.261
going backwards is absolutely an indication of progress.
02:58.533 --> 03:01.931
C.S. Lewis was very, very clear about that.
03:02.701 --> 03:06.679
So let's start with Genesis 6:4. That says there were giants
03:06.792 --> 03:10.791
on the earth in those days. And that made me think of King
03:10.904 --> 03:14.759
Théoden in The Lord of the Rings, who spoke of living in
03:15.259 --> 03:18.549
a time of lesser sons of greater sires. Now, why do I say
03:19.049 --> 03:22.581
that? Well, you know I'm a manic reader. I'm a constant reader. If I'm
03:22.629 --> 03:26.404
awake, I'm reading. If I could read while I'm brushing my teeth and
03:26.904 --> 03:29.584
in the shower, I would read then too. But more and more these days,
03:29.680 --> 03:32.946
I find myself reading Popes like Leo XIII,
03:33.381 --> 03:35.507
Pius X, Pius XI,
03:36.118 --> 03:39.726
Cardinal Pie, and then laymen like Étienne Gilson,
03:39.822 --> 03:42.868
Joseph Pieper, and Christopher Dawson. Now,
03:43.550 --> 03:46.696
what do they all have in common? Most of them
03:46.891 --> 03:50.192
died prior to 1962.
03:50.578 --> 03:53.808
Hmm. Now,
03:54.675 --> 03:57.847
some people means, well, obviously you have to
03:58.347 --> 04:01.694
label them as pre-conciliar, as if there were only one council,
04:01.711 --> 04:05.082
and therefore we label everything pre- and post-conciliar.
04:05.949 --> 04:09.160
Um, but anyway, it's pre-conciliar, pre-Vatican II,
04:09.482 --> 04:12.821
and therefore bad. And I want to say,
04:13.030 --> 04:17.188
nay nay, we're going to use John Paul's Fides et Ratio,
04:17.750 --> 04:21.299
uh, published in 1998, I believe.
04:22.085 --> 04:25.232
And John Paul was certainly a true man of the council,
04:25.248 --> 04:29.052
so I want to suggest that John
04:29.084 --> 04:33.026
Paul and Fides et Ratio can stop
04:33.075 --> 04:36.857
our progress off
Load full transcript
the cliff and be
04:37.357 --> 04:40.479
the bridge back to sanity to
04:41.008 --> 04:44.871
giants who were alive even in my lifetime
04:45.371 --> 04:48.557
and a few who went before. And the purpose of my next,
04:48.702 --> 04:51.971
next book is to turn to these 3 great Catholic laymen—
04:52.468 --> 04:55.802
Étienne Gilson, Josef Pieper, and Christopher Dawson— and say, hey,
04:55.994 --> 04:59.991
you know what? We don't have to reinvent the wheel, and we don't
05:00.087 --> 05:03.234
have to follow the conga line off the
05:03.734 --> 05:07.232
cliff. What does the conga line off the cliff look like? Well, you know,
05:07.392 --> 05:10.828
I've been working in media for the past 8 years, and that requires
05:10.925 --> 05:14.649
me to spend time with the words of synodal reports
05:15.500 --> 05:19.755
and the musings of certain progressive cardinals such as Blase
05:20.255 --> 05:23.751
Cupich, Victor Fernández, Timothy Radcliffe, Arthur Roach,
05:24.521 --> 05:27.679
and sometimes the work of laymen like Andrea Grillo
05:27.791 --> 05:31.718
and Austin Ivereigh. And suffice to say, the difference
05:32.218 --> 05:35.453
between the 2 groups are noticeable and undeniable.
05:35.726 --> 05:39.060
And that got me thinking to my student days. I was
05:39.316 --> 05:42.587
very, very fortunate as an undergraduate student to
05:42.619 --> 05:46.065
be in the honors program of the School of Philosophy at the Catholic University of
05:46.565 --> 05:49.993
America, and I took undergraduate classes and graduate classes with
05:50.493 --> 05:54.385
the great Thomist Monsignor John F. Whipple, who went to God just a couple
05:54.885 --> 05:58.456
years ago. And as a student, a very diligent student, he said something that made
05:58.488 --> 06:02.095
me bristle. He said, my biggest fear is to be remembered
06:02.595 --> 06:05.702
to posterity by the notebooks of my students. And I said, hey, I'm a pretty
06:06.202 --> 06:09.678
careful student. I take good notes. What the heck? But then I started teaching,
06:10.271 --> 06:13.413
and I saw what my students wrote in their essays and their notebooks.
06:14.198 --> 06:17.612
And I'd often ask them, how would you get that from what you read?
06:18.190 --> 06:21.941
How would you get that from what I said? What they jotted
06:22.037 --> 06:25.724
down gave no indication that they read the assigned text
06:25.740 --> 06:28.208
or that they heard my lecture. Lecture, and I would say to them, you can't
06:28.224 --> 06:31.396
get there from here. And I found myself frequently
06:31.412 --> 06:34.537
writing in the margins of their essays, you need
06:35.037 --> 06:38.847
to reconsider your method of preparation. And then, what you've written
06:38.863 --> 06:43.125
here casts doubt on your familiarity with the, with the relevant texts.
06:43.429 --> 06:46.377
What you've written here casts doubt on your understanding.
06:46.890 --> 06:50.159
And if it was really bad, I would
06:50.175 --> 06:53.460
say,
you need to reconsider your commitment
06:53.960 --> 06:57.627
to higher education. So when I read some
06:58.127 --> 07:01.811
of these progressive cardinals, Senior Catholic Cadres of the People Who Should
07:01.859 --> 07:05.610
Really Know Better Club, advocates of the typicalians,
07:05.642 --> 07:07.822
and then the synodalists, etc., etc.,
07:09.713 --> 07:13.064
I say, did you guys say what you said and
07:13.096 --> 07:16.350
wrote what you wrote after you read
07:16.703 --> 07:20.598
Leo XIII, Pius X, Pius XI, Cardinal Pie IX?
07:21.175 --> 07:24.958
Did you read that after you read Gilson, Pieper, and Christopher
07:25.458 --> 07:29.219
Dawson? Because you can't get there from here? I just don't
07:29.235 --> 07:32.136
see how. Which makes me wonder,
07:32.925 --> 07:36.779
maybe they didn't read any
07:37.040 --> 07:39.553
of that stuff at all.
07:41.808 --> 07:45.697
Oh, so when
07:46.197 --> 07:49.457
you're kind of making a generic rejection,
07:50.442 --> 07:53.972
we're not doing that old stuff anymore because, you know,
07:54.697 --> 07:58.553
It's old. There might be valuable stuff in there.
07:59.533 --> 08:02.779
And of course, there really is. Here's the analogy that I
08:02.811 --> 08:06.345
used to give to my students. I say, hey, supposing I'm looking under the
08:06.845 --> 08:10.169
hood of your car and I say, hey, there's a green wire over there.
08:10.522 --> 08:14.009
I'm inspired to cut the green wire.
08:14.860 --> 08:18.106
And you say, well, Father, what does the wire do? And I said, I don't
08:18.606 --> 08:21.720
know. I don't care. I just— my truth is that I want to
08:21.784 --> 08:25.523
cut the green wire. You might say, well, Father, you, you might be turning
08:25.539 --> 08:28.748
off the light for the glove compartment, or you might be cutting the brake
08:29.248 --> 08:32.503
line. Maybe you should find out what the green wire does
08:32.599 --> 08:36.675
before you think about cutting it. So likewise, for our friends
08:36.884 --> 08:40.334
who I describe as leading in the conga line off of the cliff,
08:40.879 --> 08:44.859
towards the cliff is not the only direction. There's really
08:45.388 --> 08:49.832
solid and beautiful ground not very
08:50.089 --> 08:53.745
far from us. And Gilson,
08:53.873 --> 08:57.321
Pieper, Dawson, they've all been translated
08:57.821 --> 09:00.913
into very good English. Dawson didn't need to be translated at all. He was English
09:01.413 --> 09:04.617
himself. So it doesn't have to be
09:05.178 --> 09:09.283
that way. I almost got into a bit of
09:09.427 --> 09:13.548
an altercation at a dinner party I was at recently when
09:13.596 --> 09:17.252
a young man who was very earnest said these words,
09:17.766 --> 09:21.374
the current Magisterium, and I
09:21.874 --> 09:25.111
saw the person sitting next to me trying to move the steak knife away from
09:25.207 --> 09:28.831
my hand. And I said, look, when, when you start
09:29.331 --> 09:33.129
putting adjectives in front of Magisterium,
09:33.787 --> 09:37.556
you're getting into trouble. The Magisterium is the Magisterium.
09:38.117 --> 09:41.421
The current Magisterium, that sounds more like
09:41.485 --> 09:44.676
ideology to me. So here's what I want you to think about as,
09:44.853 --> 09:48.847
as we come up on the break. A lot of people have been leading
09:48.943 --> 09:52.071
us into what I would call the cliff.
09:52.985 --> 09:57.380
Things are looking really bad for us. The intellectual
09:57.880 --> 10:01.904
life of the church is kind of embarrassing right now. Was it Cardinal Vasco
10:02.353 --> 10:05.754
who said, you know, we don't need no stinking proselytizing, we're not here
10:05.802 --> 10:09.074
to convert people because that might suggest that we think our
10:09.574 --> 10:12.603
religion is better than others? And Bishop Barron, to his credit,
10:12.620 --> 10:16.291
said, wait a minute, you know, the Great Commission, go make disciples
10:16.791 --> 10:19.577
of all nations. He said, we're not committed to that. He says, I need to
10:19.817 --> 10:22.991
quit my job and get honest work. And I think Bishop Barron is right about
10:23.023 --> 10:26.165
that. And I've said many times, especially in recent
10:26.665 --> 10:30.332
podcasts and videos, that the senior Catholic cadres of the
10:30.832 --> 10:34.067
People Who Should Really Know Better club need to get better ghostwriters,
10:34.580 --> 10:38.075
because the people putting words in their mouth or writing
10:38.107 --> 10:41.442
documents that they're having these people sign They're saying
10:41.538 --> 10:44.942
very embarrassing things that are going to hurt
10:45.311 --> 10:48.730
the faithful and cause scandal among people who can read and write.
10:49.180 --> 10:52.294
And I want to offer us an alternative. Friends, we come back,
10:52.310 --> 10:55.826
we're going to continue our discussion about stepping back from the cliff.
10:55.906 --> 10:58.828
Remember, our rallying cry here at the Catholic Current is Christus Mundo,
10:58.844 --> 11:02.504
Mundus Christo— bringing Christ to the world and the world to Christ. We do it
11:03.004 --> 11:05.811
because our Lord says so, for the greater glory of God, the love of our
11:06.311 --> 11:10.855
neighbor, and the salvation of our own soul. After the broadcast today, go to thestationofthecross.com,
11:10.919 --> 11:14.374
get our resources list, download our audio podcast. If you can
11:14.874 --> 11:18.487
find audio, you can find us. Follow us on your favorite platform, write a 5-star
11:18.987 --> 11:22.745
review. We need to attract the attention of the listeners that these conversations get the
11:23.245 --> 11:26.441
attention they deserve. Take us to your family and friends. Together we'll take
11:26.941 --> 11:30.892
it to the whole world. Let's strive mightily together to be so very much more
11:31.392 --> 11:34.564
than merely relevant. Back in just 2 minutes. Please do stay with us.
12:00.755 --> 12:04.786
You're listening to The Catholic Current with Father Robert McTague from
12:05.286 --> 12:09.365
the Station of the Cross Catholic Media Network. Stay connected with the show and
12:09.865 --> 12:13.254
our guests and topics by following the show on Twitter and Gab.
12:13.433 --> 12:16.188
Just search for The Catholic Current.
12:21.064 --> 12:24.498
Praise be Jesus Christ. This is Father Robert McTague of the Society of Jesus,
12:24.514 --> 12:27.786
your daily host for The Catholic Current. Where we bring Christ to the world and
12:28.286 --> 12:30.721
the world to Christ. You're listening to us from the Station of the Cross Studios,
12:30.753 --> 12:33.768
your local radio station, and the iCatholic Radio mobile app.
12:33.865 --> 12:37.137
We proclaim the fullness of truth with clarity and charity.
12:37.570 --> 12:40.745
Hey friends, did you know iCatholic Mobile supports only Catholic causes?
12:41.724 --> 12:45.413
iCatholic Mobile offers unlimited 5G data, text, and talk,
12:45.830 --> 12:49.262
and iCatholic Mobile gives a portion of every dollar earned to the Station of the
12:49.762 --> 12:53.224
Cross Catholic Media Network. By subscribing to iCatholic Mobile,
12:53.272 --> 12:56.704
you help fund programs that defend our Catholic faith.
12:57.121 --> 13:00.200
Here we are at a special kind of Friday here at The Catholic Current.
13:00.729 --> 13:04.690
As you're listening to this, I am on retreat,
13:04.834 --> 13:08.506
so there may have been very dramatic things that have happened since
13:09.006 --> 13:11.521
the time I've recorded this and you're listening to it, and I'm not mentioning it
13:11.569 --> 13:15.754
because it hasn't happened yet. I'm still up
13:15.802 --> 13:19.827
on the mountain sitting in silence before the Blessed Sacrament, so pray
13:20.327 --> 13:24.171
for me and that I get home safely. All right, we're talking about stepping back
13:24.235 --> 13:27.601
from the cliff. What is the cliff?
13:28.081 --> 13:31.334
Well, the cliff is where I think we're being led by the senior Catholic cadres
13:31.366 --> 13:35.260
of the people who should really know better club. I think there needs
13:35.276 --> 13:38.786
to be a, a new Catholic Union of Ghostwriters
13:38.882 --> 13:42.231
for Cardinals so the Cardinals aren't embarrassing themselves
13:42.263 --> 13:47.439
and causing scandal by saying things that their more careless ghostwriters
13:47.567 --> 13:50.483
are are giving them to say. So there is that.
13:50.996 --> 13:54.666
And I'm talking about and reading from an article I wrote in the November issue
13:54.682 --> 13:57.999
of New Oxford Review. Please get a subscription to that fine journal,
13:58.752 --> 14:02.790
and it's called Calling Catholics Back from the Cliff. And my
14:02.854 --> 14:06.427
suggestion is that rather than following the progressives
14:06.619 --> 14:10.481
right off the cliff, let's step back. Well, how far back?
14:10.529 --> 14:13.894
You can't turn back the clock, Father. Well,
no, what I want
14:14.394 --> 14:18.128
to do is refresh Catholic intelligence
14:19.027 --> 14:22.540
and turn to 3 laymen— Étienne Chausson,
14:22.604 --> 14:26.791
Joseph Pieper, Christopher Dawson— who wrote very
14:26.903 --> 14:30.159
accessible, smart, good things about
14:30.191 --> 14:35.324
how to use your intelligence in a very Catholic
14:35.645 --> 14:39.623
way. Now, how have people been using
14:39.656 --> 14:42.366
their intelligence in a not-so-Catholic way?
14:43.088 --> 14:48.257
Well, one of the ways they're doing it is through amnesia.
14:48.757 --> 14:52.659
They're either causing the amnesia or
14:52.708 --> 14:56.285
they're not aware that they're not aware, that they don't
14:56.785 --> 15:00.407
know what they don't know. I think back to George Orwell, and I've
15:00.423 --> 15:03.414
got to reread 1984 soon because I do want to come back to our Novel
15:03.430 --> 15:06.292
Prophecy series, and a lot of you have said the same.
15:07.880 --> 15:11.110
But Orwell said this: they lied about
15:11.305 --> 15:14.367
the truth They erased the truth.
15:15.346 --> 15:19.666
They replaced the truth with a lie. The truth was forgotten
15:19.778 --> 15:23.921
and the lie became the truth. So there are people who act
15:24.338 --> 15:28.256
as if, as if the church
15:28.288 --> 15:32.190
didn't exist before 1965. And then
15:32.222 --> 15:36.621
there were people who grew up after 1965 just
15:36.637 --> 15:39.349
assuming that, you know,
15:39.766 --> 15:43.149
post-1965 is all that there is. But, you know,
15:43.454 --> 15:46.581
Christopher Dawson died in 1970,
15:46.661 --> 15:50.638
Gilson in 1978, Josef Pieper in 1997,
15:51.151 --> 15:53.525
and they wrote a lot of stuff right up until they died, and they said,
15:53.541 --> 15:56.395
hey, you know, it doesn't have to be that way.
15:57.068 --> 16:00.211
So here are guys who knew right from wrong. They knew what
16:00.711 --> 16:04.509
men were. They knew what women were. They knew the principle of non-contradiction.
16:05.086 --> 16:09.080
And they knew the right relationship between faith and reason, and they wrote accordingly.
16:09.737 --> 16:12.945
And what they wrote is thrilling. And I say,
16:13.025 --> 16:16.024
let's be smart Catholics that way,
16:16.794 --> 16:20.562
rather than this— let's try to be invited
16:21.062 --> 16:24.459
to the cool kids' table. So, but the— we, we have to break down
16:24.524 --> 16:28.164
some vocabulary, and the first has to do with the words
16:28.196 --> 16:31.693
modern and modernity and modernism.
16:32.110 --> 16:35.383
And I think back to Kaiser Wilhelm
16:35.559 --> 16:39.281
of Germany, and he said, whenever someone
16:39.329 --> 16:42.987
uses the word culture, I immediately reach for my
16:43.099 --> 16:46.452
revolver. And there are some people who, if they hear the
16:46.548 --> 16:50.302
word modern or modernity, they think modernism
16:50.334 --> 16:54.409
and they reach for their revolver because they think back to Pope Saint Pius
16:54.909 --> 16:58.438
X, who said rightly, modernism is the
16:58.855 --> 17:02.389
synthesis of all heresies, and that's certainly true. I'm all
17:02.889 --> 17:06.484
on board for that. We got to make some distinctions, and here I think back
17:06.869 --> 17:10.483
to my senior year in college. I took
17:10.983 --> 17:14.129
a course, History of Modern Philosophy, taught by the great
17:14.241 --> 17:16.843
Dr. Richard Kennington, who's since gone to God,
17:17.469 --> 17:21.500
ultimately directed my master's thesis. And he started
17:22.000 --> 17:25.687
the semester with this question: What is modern about
17:25.799 --> 17:30.222
modern philosophy? And that question stuck with
17:30.270 --> 17:33.667
me. And here's my own answer
17:34.167 --> 17:37.593
to it, a partial answer of course, that the
17:38.093 --> 17:41.247
hallmark of modernity,
17:42.224 --> 17:46.134
of modern thought— listen to this carefully,
17:46.471 --> 17:50.865
jot it down— a progressive evacuation
17:51.684 --> 17:55.201
of the personal from both God
17:55.313 --> 17:58.894
and man. Let me say that again: a progressive
17:59.392 --> 18:03.326
evacuation of the personal from both God
18:03.826 --> 18:08.160
and man. So when you have the viewpoint of theism,
18:08.786 --> 18:11.806
God is personal, God has intelligence and will,
18:12.496 --> 18:15.788
he loves, he's provident, he's very much involved
18:16.288 --> 18:20.072
with creation. Problem with that though is if
18:20.217 --> 18:24.115
he's provident and good and moral and a
18:24.131 --> 18:28.061
big fan of the First Commandment, then worship
18:28.125 --> 18:31.286
and obedience are going to be really important. And oh my gosh,
18:31.671 --> 18:35.505
we're going to have to come into the Sixth Commandment, and who wants to put
18:36.005 --> 18:40.173
up with that? So to kind of get God's
18:40.673 --> 18:44.471
involvement out of the picture It's not really
18:45.049 --> 18:49.201
a no-contact order, but it's close. You have
18:49.553 --> 18:53.577
deism. So God is the blind watchmaker.
18:54.266 --> 18:58.226
He made the parts of— he designed creation, made the parts
18:58.726 --> 19:01.657
of creation, put it together, wound it up,
19:02.218 --> 19:05.633
and then let it go. And now we're on our own.
19:06.851 --> 19:10.476
And then you say, well, Even that,
19:10.492 --> 19:12.612
still having a creator God,
19:13.527 --> 19:16.546
that kind of makes us not the coolest thing ever.
19:17.686 --> 19:20.657
And we want to decide that we're the coolest thing ever because we have a
19:21.157 --> 19:23.210
cerebral cortex and opposable thumbs.
19:24.270 --> 19:27.224
So then you go to naturalism,
19:27.256 --> 19:30.195
that we don't need no God of any kind,
19:30.869 --> 19:33.888
not even a deist God, not even the God of Thomas Jefferson.
19:34.867 --> 19:38.063
And anything that's supernatural is— that's no,
19:38.111 --> 19:41.168
no, no, it's all just nature. It's all just science.
19:41.217 --> 19:44.880
Science is the cool kids, and there's nothing left. And that's true
19:45.187 --> 19:48.851
not only of God, but also of humanity. You went from
19:48.883 --> 19:53.055
man made in the image and likeness of God all
19:53.103 --> 19:56.515
the way down to, you know, man is just
19:57.015 --> 20:00.951
a bag of nerve endings and appetites waiting to be tickled and fed. So there
20:01.000 --> 20:04.728
is no God, and there's really not anything all that special
20:05.338 --> 20:07.594
about humanity. Human life.
20:08.606 --> 20:12.766
So that's really what modern thought is about,
20:13.312 --> 20:16.652
and Modernism says, let's run with that.
20:17.568 --> 20:21.005
We're smart apes with opposable thumbs
20:21.101 --> 20:24.731
who walk upright, and with the tools from science,
20:24.875 --> 20:28.344
by golly, there's nothing we can't do.
20:28.907 --> 20:32.633
And also very important, there's nothing
20:32.761 --> 20:34.622
that that we mustn't do.
20:35.568 --> 20:39.225
So here comes Leo XIII, one of my heroes,
20:39.803 --> 20:43.717
and he writes an encyclical called Aeterni
20:43.829 --> 20:47.438
Patris back in 1879. The common
20:47.938 --> 20:51.512
title in English is On the Restoration of Christian Philosophy to
20:52.012 --> 20:55.507
Our Schools, because the moderns of that time
20:55.619 --> 20:59.757
said, hey, look, you know, Darwin got rid of God
20:59.854 --> 21:04.280
in nature And, you know, Marx got pretty much rid
21:04.780 --> 21:07.487
of everything else. The only thing that matters is matter.
21:08.674 --> 21:11.818
The ultimate science is economics.
21:12.443 --> 21:16.228
And let's just get to work living happily ever after.
21:17.334 --> 21:20.734
That kind of noise from the French Revolution,
21:21.905 --> 21:24.631
don't worry about that. It's going to be different this time. It's going to be
21:25.131 --> 21:28.883
great. Just you wait. And we gotta get rid
21:29.383 --> 21:32.542
of the Church because, oh my goodness, can you believe it?
21:33.152 --> 21:36.795
The Church is so dumb that it's
21:37.003 --> 21:39.748
defending faith. Now,
21:40.133 --> 21:43.968
most of these people pooping on what Leo XIII wrote
21:44.305 --> 21:48.927
didn't actually read the encyclical and didn't actually read Aquinas
21:49.505 --> 21:52.987
either, and those like him. Now, you jump forward
21:53.116 --> 21:57.130
100 years, and we went from modernity and modernism
21:57.531 --> 22:01.641
to what is called postmodernity, which we'll dive into more in the next
22:02.141 --> 22:05.253
segment. But whereas Leo XIII was
22:05.753 --> 22:09.107
saying, no, no, it's okay, we can still use faith, by the time you
22:09.607 --> 22:13.329
get to Fides et Ratio in the 1990s with John Paul,
22:13.923 --> 22:17.503
he's saying, no, no, it's okay, you can still use reason.
22:18.740 --> 22:23.441
The The poster child, I think, for postmodernity is
22:23.553 --> 22:27.692
Heath Ledger's depiction of
22:27.724 --> 22:30.644
the Joker, I think in the movie The Dark Knight.
22:31.334 --> 22:35.008
Mr. Engineer, can you confirm that for me, please? Because you would always ask,
22:35.169 --> 22:39.131
why so serious? And so what calls itself
22:39.276 --> 22:42.725
postmodernity is really this
22:43.225 --> 22:46.834
smug, ironic, detached.
22:47.460 --> 22:50.719
Everything is a joke. Nothing is really real.
22:51.378 --> 22:55.392
You've got to figure out that everybody's making stuff up,
22:55.713 --> 22:59.374
that anything that was considered true or natural
22:59.904 --> 23:03.276
or real was just a construct,
23:03.822 --> 23:08.382
a ploy to grab political power.
23:08.976 --> 23:12.106
So there is no truth. There is no reality.
23:12.508 --> 23:16.874
There's just language games, politics, and manipulation,
23:17.387 --> 23:21.095
and we're on to you. So what's
23:21.595 --> 23:25.189
my quick response to postmodernity? There was a—
23:25.689 --> 23:29.314
it was 2008. That was from The Dark Knight. Thank you, Mr.
23:29.362 --> 23:33.359
Producer. There was a college in Ohio.
23:33.455 --> 23:37.228
I forget the name of it, but it was having this museum
23:37.728 --> 23:41.208
in honor of postmodernity, and it was going to be ironic and whimsical,
23:41.642 --> 23:44.382
And there were going to be staircases that went nowhere,
23:44.910 --> 23:48.660
and doors that opened up into brick walls, and windows
23:48.756 --> 23:52.521
that didn't have glass. Hahaha, look how daring and
23:53.098 --> 23:56.527
subversive we are, hahaha. But people couldn't go
23:56.607 --> 24:00.500
in and look at the postmodern exhibit until the engineers came in
24:00.628 --> 24:03.913
and measured exactly that it was up to code and it was
24:04.413 --> 24:08.127
safe for human habitation. So postmodernity as
24:08.159 --> 24:11.831
it has presented itself is a fraud. You know,
24:11.992 --> 24:15.924
when I would tell people, look, I said, when you're at some cocktail
24:15.940 --> 24:19.551
party with academics and some guy with his tweed jacket
24:19.856 --> 24:22.873
is leaning on the mantelpiece with his drink in his hand,
24:22.921 --> 24:26.805
smugly talking about there is no such thing as reality, it's all
24:26.933 --> 24:30.207
a social construct, here's all you need to do to prove that
24:30.707 --> 24:34.236
he's a fraud. Go up to him, whisper in his ear, dude,
24:34.862 --> 24:37.558
your fly's open. If he looks,
24:38.152 --> 24:41.522
he's a fraud. And most of what
24:42.022 --> 24:45.519
passes itself off for postmodernity is
24:45.776 --> 24:49.804
that kind of fraud too. And I'm
24:50.304 --> 24:54.347
going to make the claim that what considers— what calls itself postmodern
24:54.844 --> 24:57.958
is only really hypermodern,
24:58.552 --> 25:02.548
and the postmodern is something else entirely. We'll talk about
25:03.048 --> 25:06.882
more when we come back. After the broadcast today, go to thestationofthecross.com,
25:06.898 --> 25:10.173
get our
resources list, Download our audio podcast, or if you
25:10.673 --> 25:13.577
can find audio, you can find us. Follow us on your favorite platform. Write a
25:14.077 --> 25:18.137
5-star review. We need to attract the attention of the listeners so these conversations get
25:18.637 --> 25:22.135
the attention that they deserve. Take us to your family and friends. Together we'll
25:22.635 --> 25:25.202
take it to the whole world. We can do it with you. We cannot do
25:25.702 --> 25:29.361
without you. Let's do this very good work together. Let's work to be
25:29.521 --> 25:33.311
more than relevant. Back in just 2 minutes. Please do stay with
26:00.607 --> 26:04.412
This is The Catholic Current from the Station of the Cross Catholic Media
26:04.445 --> 26:08.009
Network. Catch up on an episode you've missed or share them with your
26:08.073 --> 26:11.911
family and friends. The Catholic Current is podcasted wherever
26:11.927 --> 26:14.849
you enjoy listening: Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
26:15.058 --> 26:19.297
Podbean, TuneIn, and the iCatholic Radio mobile app.
26:20.260 --> 26:23.729
Praise be Jesus Christ. This is Father Robert McTeague of the Society of Jesus,
26:23.793 --> 26:26.857
your daily host for The Catholic Current, where we bring Christ to the world and
26:27.357 --> 26:29.760
the world to Christ. You're listening to us on the Station of the Cross Studios,
26:29.808 --> 26:33.641
your local radio station, and the iCatholic Radio mobile app. We proclaim
26:33.753 --> 26:37.121
the fullness of truth with clarity and charity. Hey friends,
26:37.137 --> 26:40.184
if you value thoughtful Catholic analysis, help sustain this work
26:40.684 --> 26:44.225
at thestationofthecross.com. Here on the Catholic Current, we engage
26:44.273 --> 26:47.609
issues seriously and faithfully, and that intellectual
26:48.109 --> 26:51.604
freedom exists because we are listener-funded. Support us, please,
26:51.637 --> 26:54.913
thestationofthecross.com. This is a special,
26:54.994 --> 26:58.511
rather unusual Friday here at The Catholic Current. Let's talk about this.
26:59.250 --> 27:02.045
As always, we're walking through a complex issue together,
27:02.462 --> 27:06.285
and you may notice that I haven't said anything about
27:06.414 --> 27:10.397
what's going on in the past week because the past week hasn't
27:10.413 --> 27:14.204
happened yet because I'm pre-recording this. Because by the time you listen
27:14.704 --> 27:18.134
to this, I'll be up on a mountaintop on retreat. Please do pray
27:18.634 --> 27:22.172
for my retreat and for my safe return. Yeah, so I hope
27:22.445 --> 27:25.586
nothing cataclysmic happened because I try to
27:26.086 --> 27:29.848
keep up with those, those sorts of things. We're talking about stepping back
27:29.912 --> 27:33.213
from the cliff, and the cliff seems to be where
27:33.713 --> 27:37.700
the senior Catholic cadres of the People Who Should Really Know Better club have
27:37.748 --> 27:41.481
been leading us. And
my claim is that the momentum
27:41.834 --> 27:46.921
started with modernism, which has a
27:46.985 --> 27:50.887
shabby view of God and a shabby view of humanity
27:51.625 --> 27:54.339
and exaggerates reason.
27:55.157 --> 27:58.754
And then the aftermath is supposedly called
27:58.850 --> 28:02.848
postmodernity, where they say, look, not only is faith
28:02.944 --> 28:06.299
nonsense, reason is nonsense too.
28:06.910 --> 28:10.586
So let's just kind of kick back and make Joker
28:11.086 --> 28:14.263
movies and read Nietzsche. And that's kind of leading us all, you know,
28:14.423 --> 28:17.618
oh, truth, your truth, my truth, nobody's truth.
28:18.212 --> 28:20.941
Why so serious? Don't be a system builder.
28:21.567 --> 28:24.810
You know, the past is dumb. Bravely we go forward.
28:25.902 --> 28:29.258
And, you know, I have an article in the most recent issue of
28:29.354 --> 28:32.806
New Oxford Review, which I hope you get. I hope you get a subscription to
28:32.822 --> 28:36.578
it. I'm a contributing editor there, and I wrote an article called Calling
28:36.675 --> 28:40.044
Catholics Back from the Cliff. And the idea
28:40.589 --> 28:44.902
that we can leave reason behind and
28:45.158 --> 28:48.589
even leave faith behind, that we can
28:49.246 --> 28:52.565
reimagine the Church or have a
28:52.629 --> 28:57.054
new Church and a current and evolving Magisterium.
28:57.182 --> 28:59.202
And synodality means— well,
29:00.228 --> 29:03.867
what does synodality mean? On a practical level, it seems to
29:04.367 --> 29:08.052
me what synodality means is that anything that some really aggressive people
29:08.164 --> 29:11.713
don't like we can just talk our way
29:11.858 --> 29:14.525
out of it and call that the work of the Holy Spirit.
29:15.473 --> 29:19.249
And there are a lot of people who say, you know, I'm pretty sure God
29:19.749 --> 29:24.086
would not lead us off the cliff. God, whose only begotten
29:24.102 --> 29:27.589
Son is the eternal Word of the Father, the Logos,
29:28.328 --> 29:32.088
through whom all things were made, would not lead us
29:32.425 --> 29:35.797
off a hyper-modern cliff Where there's
29:36.297 --> 29:39.626
no faith, there's no reason, and really
29:40.459 --> 29:43.295
there's just human will,
29:44.449 --> 29:48.086
which of course leads to despair, because we're
29:48.375 --> 29:51.739
all dressed up with no place to go,
29:52.717 --> 29:56.082
and really nobody can live that way.
29:57.363 --> 30:01.209
Well, what are the alternatives? Well, we don't have to go
30:01.709 --> 30:05.588
that far back. The The exit ramp away
30:05.845 --> 30:09.763
from the cliff, I believe, is John Paul's document Fides
30:09.795 --> 30:12.332
et Ratio from 1998, Faith and Reason,
30:13.071 --> 30:18.273
and where they can take us is to Catholicism's
30:18.385 --> 30:20.136
very recent past.
30:21.195 --> 30:24.214
Étienne Nasson, Joseph Pieper, Christopher Dawson,
30:24.969 --> 30:28.148
writing in the mid to late 20th
century,
30:29.047 --> 30:33.041
that said, hey, you know what, God is really God,
30:34.500 --> 30:37.131
and only God can be God.
30:38.350 --> 30:42.167
And human reason, even after original sin,
30:42.697 --> 30:46.193
is pretty darn smart and can know
30:46.851 --> 30:50.043
true things, can know that God exists, can know
30:50.236 --> 30:53.652
that natural law is real, can know what a man is,
30:53.748 --> 30:56.315
can know what a woman is, know that men and women are made for each
30:56.815 --> 31:00.045
other. And human reason can be
31:00.190 --> 31:03.542
elevated and perfected by faith and by
31:03.736 --> 31:07.696
grace. And we who are made in the image
31:08.196 --> 31:11.602
of God, which is to say rational and free and therefore moral,
31:12.180 --> 31:16.045
can with revelation and with grace grow
31:16.206 --> 31:20.330
into the likeness of God and
31:20.830 --> 31:24.292
to be loving and communal as the Trinity
31:24.838 --> 31:28.695
is loving and communal. Of course, God Almighty does love and community
31:28.727 --> 31:30.745
at scale, and we're just doing it as, you know,
31:31.778 --> 31:35.679
finite beings. So here is what
31:35.761 --> 31:37.138
I am recommending.
31:40.343 --> 31:43.516
I— people like me who are in the business, so to speak,
31:43.922 --> 31:46.525
we have to read synodal reports.
31:47.859 --> 31:52.152
I suggest that you read Étienne
31:52.264 --> 31:56.062
Chalson, that you read Josef Pieper, that you
31:56.190 --> 31:59.811
read Christopher Dawson. Start with Josef. First of all, you really—
32:00.132 --> 32:03.721
I was just telling Mr. Engineer during the break, just find
32:04.186 --> 32:07.872
everything that Pieper wrote, which is
32:08.372 --> 32:11.974
a lot, and read all of it. He has a gift for
32:12.474 --> 32:16.268
taking 500 pages of wisdom and boiling
32:16.300 --> 32:20.119
it down to 100 crystal
32:20.312 --> 32:23.875
clear pages. Crystal clear,
32:24.646 --> 32:28.626
memorable. Start with his anthology,
32:28.722 --> 32:32.510
just a little bit of everything. And I'm going to ask Mr. Enjair to add
32:33.010 --> 32:37.053
another little book from Pieper called A Brief Reader on the Virtues of the Human
32:37.085 --> 32:40.375
Heart. It'd take you an hour and a half to read. I used
32:40.875 --> 32:43.633
to use it to wrap up my ethics class.
32:44.388 --> 32:48.193
And in particular, His meditation on
32:48.322 --> 32:51.807
chastity and purity is so beautiful
32:52.417 --> 32:56.143
that it'll move you to tears. You'll read
32:56.192 --> 33:00.078
those few pages and say, how can a sane person not
33:00.528 --> 33:04.383
want to be pure? He's just that
33:04.883 --> 33:08.607
good. And then for Gilson, read his book on God
33:08.783 --> 33:13.103
and philosophy. His stuff is amazing.
33:13.152 --> 33:16.556
It's so clear. And I have particular fondness for him because
33:16.748 --> 33:19.863
he taught my mentor, the, the late great
33:20.363 --> 33:24.247
Dr. Paul Weiss. And he
said that Gilson—
33:24.359 --> 33:28.229
he liked Gilson because he said he, he knew his
33:28.729 --> 33:32.387
stuff forwards and backwards, inside and out. He knew
33:32.484 --> 33:35.824
every footnote. And he said, and he was
33:36.080 --> 33:38.939
fearless. So imagine Étienne Gilson,
33:39.452 --> 33:43.338
Catholic to the max, at Harvard in the
33:43.838 --> 33:48.107
1920s, where there was a lot of anti-Catholic bigotry
33:48.685 --> 33:51.960
and everybody was smug. And at faculty cocktail parties,
33:52.474 --> 33:55.140
they would try to take cheap shots at the Catholic Church.
33:55.686 --> 33:59.202
And Dr. Weiss said, and whenever they did that, they had a fight
33:59.702 --> 34:02.975
on their hands with Étienne Gilson. He said this was like the Crips and
34:03.475 --> 34:07.329
the the Bloods. Like, you dissing me and my colors? So, but listen to
34:07.829 --> 34:10.590
this. At the end, Chaucer said that because he would, he would not have been
34:10.622 --> 34:14.156
described as a champion of dialogue.
34:14.301 --> 34:17.626
Listen to this quote from Chaucer. He said, I regret to say,
34:18.654 --> 34:22.237
not having myself any of the virtues of a skilled
34:22.751 --> 34:25.883
dialoguer, which are not to listen to what
34:26.383 --> 34:29.803
is being said and to take it in a sense that makes it easy to
34:30.303 --> 34:33.911
refute, It is a chimerical hope that
34:34.411 --> 34:37.665
there should be 2 people who proceed otherwise. In other
34:38.165 --> 34:41.629
words, dialogue means I really am gonna listen to you,
34:42.880 --> 34:46.731
and then if you're wrong, I'm gonna tell you where you're
34:46.812 --> 34:50.310
wrong. Now, that was the way I
34:50.358 --> 34:54.257
was taught to do philosophy, and that's not
34:54.433 --> 34:58.494
the way that people are taught to do philosophy or theology or
34:58.848 --> 35:02.526
anything else. Because in these synodal sessions,
35:02.558 --> 35:05.947
which are now being promoted, that apparently you can be
35:06.092 --> 35:09.529
a theologian and you can be a mystic, you just have to sit
35:10.029 --> 35:13.576
in a circle with other people and say what— say what's
35:13.641 --> 35:17.142
on your mind. And then if somebody says something that's on their mind,
35:17.560 --> 35:21.607
you're not allowed to respond to it. You're just supposed
35:22.107 --> 35:26.699
to nod. And so everybody gets a turn speaking their truth
35:27.694 --> 35:30.312
but you don't actually find the truth.
35:31.066 --> 35:35.145
Where does that lead to? I remember a religious sister,
35:35.161 --> 35:38.195
I'm very fond of her, and she was heroic. She,
35:38.597 --> 35:42.033
she was a missionary surgeon in
35:42.129 --> 35:45.598
the Caribbean in a really extreme situation, so I'm not
35:46.098 --> 35:49.596
going to embarrass her by mentioning her community. She retired, she moved back to the
35:50.096 --> 35:53.706
States, and she said that You couldn't talk about
35:54.206 --> 35:57.544
what was true because that was mean and
35:57.640 --> 36:01.558
preconciliar, and you couldn't say what was better because
36:02.058 --> 36:05.315
that would be hierarchical and male and therefore bad.
36:05.427 --> 36:08.783
So you had, you know, let's do X, and we'd
36:09.283 --> 36:12.171
go around the room. Can you live with that? Can you live with that?
36:12.252 --> 36:15.816
Can you live with that? And whoever said no, I can't live with it,
36:16.169 --> 36:19.846
had veto power. And then you would just keep lowering
36:19.878 --> 36:23.137
the standard. X minus 1, can you live with that?
36:23.250 --> 36:26.316
Can you live with that? No. Then X minus 2.
36:27.247 --> 36:30.603
And then you never pursued the greater good, and you never said things
36:30.619 --> 36:34.086
that are right or wrong. You just found the lowest
36:34.586 --> 36:37.827
common denominator that everyone can live
36:37.940 --> 36:42.146
with. And when we surrender common sense,
36:42.916 --> 36:46.655
and when we surrender revelation and the
36:46.671 --> 36:50.520
authority of the Church. Listen to this from Gilson,
36:50.536 --> 36:53.919
and this guy is a rock star. He said this: it
36:54.419 --> 36:58.121
is important for us to realize that mankind is
36:58.474 --> 37:02.178
doomed to live more and more under the spell
37:02.708 --> 37:04.969
of the new scientific,
37:05.370 --> 37:08.994
social, and political mythology unless
37:09.058 --> 37:12.602
we resolutely exorcise these befuddled
37:12.667 --> 37:16.165
notions whose influence on modern life is
37:16.197 --> 37:19.972
becoming appalling. Millions of men are
37:20.472 --> 37:24.003
starving or bleeding to death because 2 or
37:24.503 --> 37:28.517
3 of these pseudoscientific or pseudosocial
37:29.047 --> 37:33.015
deified abstractions are now at war.
37:33.223 --> 37:36.404
And listen to this, friends, write this down. I'm not kidding.
37:36.902 --> 37:40.436
He concludes with, for when gods fight
37:40.692 --> 37:44.462
among themselves, men have to
37:44.962 --> 37:49.644
die. Let me say that again. For when gods fight
37:50.141 --> 37:53.734
among themselves, men have
37:54.167 --> 37:57.825
to die. And modernity says
37:58.178 --> 38:02.878
there are no gods, and hyper-modernity masquerading
38:02.974 --> 38:07.210
as postmodernism says let there be a pantheon
38:07.787 --> 38:12.022
of gods. Uh, sex and Marxism
38:12.600 --> 38:16.354
and critical theory and gender ideology
38:17.091 --> 38:20.621
and singing a new church into being and
38:21.121 --> 38:24.326
green energy— these are the
38:24.487 --> 38:28.417
different gods that we can and should worship.
38:28.802 --> 38:32.492
And since there is no genuine authority and
38:32.588 --> 38:35.780
there is no genuine truth or nature,
38:35.797 --> 38:39.839
and certainly really no binding revelation
38:40.339 --> 38:43.945
because, you know, development of doctrine because Newman or something.
38:44.923 --> 38:48.837
What we have ultimately is the law of
38:48.869 --> 38:51.483
the jungle, but even worse.
38:52.253 --> 38:55.990
So let me end with one of my favorite curmudgeons, Hilaire Belloc.
38:56.728 --> 39:00.225
He said this: Men do not live long without gods,
39:00.722 --> 39:04.026
but when the gods of the new paganism come, they will not be merely
39:04.526 --> 39:08.162
insufficient, as were the gods of Greece, nor merely false.
39:08.915 --> 39:12.824
They will be evil. One might put it in a sentence and say
39:13.324 --> 39:16.814
that the new paganism, foolishly expecting satisfaction,
39:17.006 --> 39:20.947
will fall before it knows where it is into
39:21.556 --> 39:26.186
Satanism. Don't forget, friends, the United States is
39:26.394 --> 39:30.111
standing on a mountain of corpses of aborted children,
39:31.168 --> 39:35.014
and you've got women in the streets celebrating a woman who
39:35.514 --> 39:39.586
strangled her children to death. Do we not live in
39:40.086 --> 39:43.215
dark times? Shouldn't we be thinking of Shakespeare who
39:43.715 --> 39:46.459
said, hell is empty, the devils are all here?
39:47.374 --> 39:51.083
Friends, let us step back from the
39:51.583 --> 39:55.402
cliff while there is still time. I'm Jesuit Father Robert
39:55.902 --> 39:58.084
McTaggart, your host every day of The Catholic Current. You want to stay with us
39:58.132 --> 40:01.969
for the rest of the hour. Coming up next, Weekend Readiness, reviewing the headlines
40:01.985 --> 40:05.498
of the week in light of the upcoming Sunday scriptures. So be all prayed up
40:05.998 --> 40:09.965
for Sunday Mass. Be part of the conversation. Follow what we're following by following
40:10.143 --> 40:13.164
us on Gab. That's gab.com.
40:14.610 --> 40:18.009
The channel is The Catholic Current. You can influence the conversation.
40:18.446 --> 40:20.535
Contact us at stationofthecross.com/askfather.
40:23.330 --> 40:27.160
Comments, questions, suggestions, recommendations, objections— we want
40:27.660 --> 40:30.807
to hear from you. Let's do this good work together. Back in just
40:31.307 --> 40:32.300
2 minutes. Please do stay with us.
41:01.137 --> 41:05.659
Have a question or feedback about today's episode? Want to suggest
41:06.159 --> 41:13.121
a guest or a future topic? Go to thestationofthecross.com/askfather and
41:13.621 --> 41:15.148
help influence the conversation.
41:19.394 --> 41:22.766
Praised be Jesus Christ. This is Father
41:23.266 --> 41:26.282
Robert McTeague of the Society of Jesus, your daily host for The Catholic Current,
41:26.603 --> 41:29.397
where we bring Christ to the world and the world to Christ. You're listening to
41:29.429 --> 41:33.523
us from the Station of the Cross Studios, your local radio station, the iCatholic Radio
41:34.023 --> 41:37.296
mobile app. We proclaim the fullness of truth with clarity and charity.
41:37.922 --> 41:40.379
Here we are, the last segment of a Friday. You know what that means— week
41:40.443 --> 41:43.188
in readiness. You and me
reviewing the headlines of the week in light of the
41:43.237 --> 41:46.445
upcoming Sunday scriptures. So you'll be all prayed up for Sunday
41:46.945 --> 41:50.869
Mass. However, I'm recording this before
41:51.013 --> 41:54.748
I go away on retreat, and you will be hearing this as
41:54.844 --> 41:59.203
I am wrapping up my retreat. So all sorts of things might
41:59.703 --> 42:03.756
have happened between now and then that you and I don't know about just now.
42:04.701 --> 42:08.163
But what do we know for sure? Um, the world is a mess and
42:08.663 --> 42:12.395
needs a savior. People are shooting at each other, setting things on fire.
42:12.892 --> 42:16.668
Lying to each other. And the
42:17.168 --> 42:20.620
various cadres of the people who should really know better club are going
42:21.120 --> 42:24.508
to be very active and very vocal. And sadly, a lot of them will
42:24.540 --> 42:28.541
be very kinetic. And senior higher-ups
42:29.041 --> 42:32.124
will not take my advice and will not get better ghostwriters and will likely say
42:32.268 --> 42:35.417
embarrassing things. And then by the time you
42:35.449 --> 42:39.305
listen to this, I bet you they're gonna still be counting votes.
42:39.947 --> 42:43.489
Here in the United States. You know, India is a
42:43.989 --> 42:47.320
democracy of 600 million people. They count all their votes overnight.
42:47.417 --> 42:50.943
And America, with half the population, we can't
42:51.007 --> 42:54.181
get it done? So think
42:54.229 --> 42:57.259
about that. And recall this: Stalin said, I don't care who votes, I only care
42:57.759 --> 43:01.860
who counts the votes. Let's remember that too.
43:02.581 --> 43:05.819
All right, with that in mind, let's turn to the scriptures.
43:05.931 --> 43:09.666
We— if you're following the Novus Ordo calendar of the Pauline Rite, we're looking
43:09.683 --> 43:13.833
at the 33rd Sunday of Ordinary Time, Lectionary 157.
43:14.266 --> 43:17.920
We're coming up on the end of the liturgical year, and the readings
43:18.032 --> 43:22.791
in this lectionary start to get apocalyptic. My favorite.
43:23.544 --> 43:26.845
I love me the A-word. I love me some apocalypse.
43:27.630 --> 43:30.996
And we're gonna jump ahead right to Saint
43:31.496 --> 43:33.704
Paul, 1 Thessalonians chapter 5.
43:34.761 --> 43:38.993
And remember what I've said very often, and certainly with my series
43:39.089 --> 43:42.955
called Novel Prophecies, where we look at futuristic,
43:42.971 --> 43:46.933
apocalyptic, and dystopian literature. I'm not talking about
43:47.205 --> 43:50.670
the day and the hour because nobody knows that but our Heavenly Father. It's not
43:51.170 --> 43:55.257
about reading the tea leaves and which rainy Wednesday afternoon
43:55.289 --> 43:58.545
our Lord is going to return. That's not what I'm about, because Saint
43:58.593 --> 44:02.411
Paul writes this. He says, concerning times and seasons,
44:02.523 --> 44:05.907
brothers and sisters, you have no need for anything to be written to you.
44:06.678 --> 44:10.434
For you yourselves know very well that the day of the Lord will come
44:10.627 --> 44:14.158
like a thief in the night. When people are saying, peace and
44:14.658 --> 44:18.412
security, then sudden disaster comes upon them like
44:18.912 --> 44:22.988
labor pains upon a pregnant woman, and they will not escape.
44:23.084 --> 44:26.760
So, I'm probably not ever going to be
44:27.260 --> 44:30.902
one of the people who decides to lead folks in rousing choruses
44:31.014 --> 44:34.719
of, he's got the whole world in his hands. That's That's just
44:34.848 --> 44:38.260
not me. But we do know that our Lord will
44:38.773 --> 44:41.768
come in glory to judge the living and the dead and the world by fire.
44:42.393 --> 44:45.053
And we do know that each of us and all of us will have to
44:45.101 --> 44:48.449
give an accounting of our lives. And Saint Paul says
44:48.561 --> 44:51.894
that's okay. He says, but you brothers and sisters
44:52.006 --> 44:55.610
are not in darkness for that day to overtake you like a
44:56.110 --> 44:59.840
thief, for you're all children of the light and children of
45:00.340 --> 45:04.326
the day. We are not of the night or of darkness, so let's not sleep
45:05.047 --> 45:08.958
as the rest do, but let us stay alert and sober. Well,
45:08.990 --> 45:12.356
what does that mean practically speaking? Work really hard
45:12.856 --> 45:15.530
to stay in a state of grace. Stop negotiating with your sin.
45:16.027 --> 45:19.538
Go to confession, go to confession, go to confession.
45:19.634 --> 45:23.225
And after you go to confession, wait 2 weeks and go to confession
45:23.497 --> 45:26.671
again. Make that a habit.
45:27.745 --> 45:31.625
Find a good examination of conscience online and go to
45:32.139 --> 45:35.784
confession. Be in right relationship.
45:36.795 --> 45:39.750
Now jumping ahead to the Gospel, Matthew 25,
45:40.729 --> 45:45.081
and man's going on a journey and he gives his servants possessions.
45:45.145 --> 45:48.180
He gives one 5 talents, another 2, a third one,
45:48.613 --> 45:52.033
to each according to his ability. Now a talent was
45:53.350 --> 45:57.595
a measure of wealth, a large measure
45:58.014 --> 46:01.768
of wealth. So according to the sources I looked up, a whole
46:01.978 --> 46:05.733
talent would have been the equivalent of 20
46:05.992 --> 46:08.850
years' wages for a day laborer.
46:10.190 --> 46:14.098
So that's a lot. So if a guy has been given
46:14.598 --> 46:18.042
5 talents, that means he's been given the equivalent of 100 years'
46:18.140 --> 46:20.031
worth of wages of a day laborer,
46:21.560 --> 46:24.541
and he says, Come back and show me what you do with it.
46:25.183 --> 46:28.936
And the guy who has 5 comes back with 5
46:28.968 --> 46:32.882
more. The guy given 3 with 3 more. The guy who's given 1 dug a
46:33.382 --> 46:36.523
hole in the ground and buried his master's money. Now, I don't want to— no
46:36.588
--> 46:39.780
spoilers here on the Catholic Current, but let's just say it did not
46:39.796 --> 46:43.742
end well for the guy who didn't commit to stewardship
46:43.870 --> 46:47.784
over his gifts and opportunities. And as a Jesuit, I believe firmly
46:47.816 --> 46:51.474
that stewardship over gifts and opportunities is an essential
46:51.586 --> 46:55.100
element of discipleship.
46:56.063 --> 47:00.283
And God Almighty is gonna ask, what did you do with
47:00.396 --> 47:02.417
everything that I gave you?
47:03.846 --> 47:06.910
How do you want that conversation to go?
47:08.018 --> 47:11.050
I was busy. I had other things to do.
47:12.366 --> 47:15.688
I didn't know what to do with what you gave me. No one told
47:15.720 --> 47:19.760
me this was gonna be on the test. See, so let's
47:19.985 --> 47:24.589
not do that. So friends, look, we've been given
47:24.637 --> 47:28.835
the church and the gospel and the sacraments and
47:28.932 --> 47:31.957
2 millennia of saints and lots
47:32.086 --> 47:36.012
of beautiful art and amazing history and the testimony
47:36.125 --> 47:38.214
of martyrs red and white,
47:39.805 --> 47:43.470
and God will want to know what we
47:43.518 --> 47:47.179
did with them. Did we take those gifts and use them
47:47.211 --> 47:50.825
in a way that glorified him, that made Christ attractive,
47:50.922 --> 47:53.921
known, and loved wherever we went?
47:55.398 --> 47:59.198
Did we hand on the faith safe and secure to our
47:59.360 --> 48:03.830
children? Did we strive mightily for
48:04.330 --> 48:07.654
the salvation and sanctification of our spouse?
48:09.058 --> 48:12.483
If we're religious, did we live the charism of the
48:12.983 --> 48:16.339
community? Did we live out well
48:16.371 --> 48:19.704
our consecration to the Lord? And for
48:20.204 --> 48:24.051
those of us who were clergy, we made promises to
48:24.551 --> 48:28.967
God and the Church, and God infused us with very amazing
48:29.243 --> 48:32.609
gifts. And I tremble at the thought
48:33.109 --> 48:35.437
of my particular judgment because Saint John Vianney,
48:36.201 --> 48:39.413
certainly a heroically holy
48:39.589 --> 48:41.902
priest who scared the bejabbers out of Satan.
48:43.202 --> 48:46.959
I read somewhere he wept on his deathbed that
48:47.618 --> 48:50.186
he had basically, in his view,
48:50.684 --> 48:54.586
lived as such a slacker his very high calling.
48:55.180 --> 48:58.198
So if John Vianney is weeping on his deathbed,
48:58.375 --> 49:02.277
then I don't know about you, my brother priests, but I
49:02.325 --> 49:06.111
got some work to do and You'll better intercede for me
49:06.611 --> 49:09.974
mightily once I die, and especially remember me on All Souls' Day.
49:10.727 --> 49:14.398
So friends, here's the moral of the story: God loves us,
49:15.216 --> 49:18.902
wants the best for us. Saint Ignatius
49:19.402 --> 49:23.214
Loyola said the graces necessary for salvation are always
49:23.471 --> 49:27.702
available to us. And isn't it exciting
49:28.280 --> 49:31.389
that he's giving us so much and said, I mean, go ahead,
49:32.127 --> 49:35.528
Do something with it. Be creative. Work together.
49:36.539 --> 49:40.614
Help my Son to become known and loved. Share in his victory,
49:40.710 --> 49:42.940
his joy, and his glory.
49:43.918 --> 49:48.154
How shall we respond to that
49:48.747 --> 49:51.860
invitation? Please, dear God,
49:51.940 --> 49:55.549
let it be true of all of us that we have the good sense to
49:56.049 --> 49:59.834
say, Lord, with what you gave me, with your help, I was
49:59.963 --> 50:03.800
fruitful. Because what I want to hear at the end of my days is,
50:03.913 --> 50:07.526
well done, good and faithful servant, enter into the
50:07.590 --> 50:10.930
joy of your master. May God's holy name be praised now
50:10.946 --> 50:14.430
and forever. I'm Jesuit Father Robert McTague, your host here every
50:14.930 --> 50:17.818
day at The Catholic Hermit. Join us on Monday, another lively topic,
50:17.866 --> 50:21.495
great guest, great conversation, because that's how we roll here every day
50:21.575 --> 50:25.348
at The Catholic Hermit and the Station of the Cross. After the broadcast today,
50:25.413 --> 50:28.736
go to thestationofthecross.com, get our resources list,
50:28.785 --> 50:32.012
download our audio podcast, take us to your family and friends.
50:32.076 --> 50:35.352
Together we'll take it to the whole world through the intercession of Our Lady of
50:35.368 --> 50:38.451
Mount Carmel. May Almighty God bless you, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
50:38.900 --> 50:42.047
Go in peace, and please do pray for me, for I am a
50:42.112 --> 50:42.497
sinner.