สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
00:00:01
Speaker 1: I'm Rebecca Jones and this is the Bloomberg Australia podcast. This isn't the episode we plan to end twenty twenty five with, and it's certainly not one we ever imagined. Having to make sixteen deceased persons is obviously a great tragedy for this state.
00:00:22
Speaker 2: Our thoughts, prayers and love.
00:00:24
Speaker 3: Go out to all of the families that have ceased.
00:00:27
Speaker 2: My government will continue to stand with Jewish Australians and continue to stand to stamp out anti Semitism in all of its forms.
00:00:36
Speaker 1: Bondai Beach is one of those rare places that belongs equally to locals as it does to the world. For Sydneysiders, it's a place of ritual from swims before work, hanging at the playground and on the grassy foreshore with mates, down in cocktails at icebergs, or for my kids, star spotting lifeguards from the TV show Bondai Rescue come a bit of a shorthand for Australia itself. Sunlit, multicultural resilient, a strip of sand that carries both the easy joy of life by the beach and a deeper meaning that shows us how special shared public spaces can be. On this week's show, we're examining why the terror attack at Bondai on December fourteenth, Australia's worst ever, represents much more than a single violent event. We'll examine why the events of that evening feel like a cultural flashpoint and explore what it says about Australia's relationship with the wider world. To help do that, I'm joined by Bloomberg Opinion columnist David Fickling. David, thank you for joining us.
00:01:44
Speaker 3: Thanks for raka.
00:01:45
Speaker 1: I have lived in Sydney before, and you know not far from Bondai, so I know it well. You live in Sydney now, but you're originally from the UK. Tell me how long did it take you after you first landed in Sydney to make that trek to Bondi Beach.
00:02:00
Speaker 2: I first came to Sydney during the Olympics in two thousand and I don't remember precisely when it was, but I was here for about three weeks and I definitely visited once then and I would say now, I'm actually a bit of a devotee. Back then, like a lot of people from the UK, I was not a good swimmer and I'm probably still not a good swim, but I'm a competent and avid ocean swimmer that now and most weekends, particularly in summer, but actually all through the year, you will find me at Bondi actually in exactly the location that these tragic events took place. I recognized that area very closely. I changed into my swimmers and my goggles exactly where that location took place. That concrete bridge that we've seen, I've crossed that or you know, most weeks over the last five years walking down to the beach, So I know that area very well, and it's a place that it's important to me as it is to a lot of Australians, Jewish Australians people around the world.
00:02:56
Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean Bondai Beach. You know, it's one of those places that, as you say, it's instantly recognizable, isn't it. David, You've got a
Load full transcript
new column mount for Bloomberg Opinion this week on the events of December fourteenth. Why does violence at Bondai and the events of Sunday night feel fundamentally different from similar events that we've seen happen elsewhere.
00:03:18
Speaker 2: I think in what you described there about the special nature of Bondi that something that everyone is quite aware of around the world. It's one of those iconic images of Australia, you know, like Guloru, like Sydney Harbor, like the Melbourne Cricket Ground. There's not many places like that that are instantly recognizable in.
00:03:36
Speaker 3: Quite that way.
00:03:38
Speaker 2: So lots of people are quite aware of that. But I think something as well that outsiders maybe don't realize is that Bondai more broadly is a real heartland of Jewish Australia as well. Even back in the nineteen twenty the bat a third of the Jewish population of Sydney lived in Bondi and neighboring suburbs, and a lot of you know, a lot of the most notable Jewish Australians Frank Lowey, the and of the Westfield shopping center chain, Harry Trigebov, notable apartment developer, they have roots in Bondai. Frank Loewe was longtime patron of a soccer club, the Hackoa Club in Bondai. They will get their haircut and Bondi Junction by a nonagenarian Plesma Singer. So it's there's a real culture there that people are maybe not aware of.
00:04:20
Speaker 3: Sea folly. The Australian swimwear.
00:04:22
Speaker 2: Brand was founded by in nineteen seventy five by a a Hungarian born Holocaust survivor.
00:04:27
Speaker 3: So there's that part of the image.
00:04:28
Speaker 2: But then the other thing is, of course what you mentioned in the first place, Australia. Although religion is possibly at the heart of this attack, Australia's a very secular place. About forty percent of the population is secular. But you know, if there's a place in Australia that's a sort of sacred space for that sort of secular nation, it is the beach. If you look at Australian literature, very diverse writers, Tim Winton, John Pilger, Alexis Right, David Malof, Bridger Delaney, they all write about this sense of the beaches, somewhere that is truly acred to Australia, a place that's far more than just a place that you go to relax, but someway that's almost spiritual. I think one of the most famous photographic images of Australia, there's a nineteen thirty seven photograph that any Australian and a lot of others will know, a man lying on.
00:05:13
Speaker 3: A beach in Australia.
00:05:14
Speaker 2: I think there was a Blue episode a few years ago where they referenced that particular photo. So yes, I think you know, nine percent of this population we live within fifty kilometers of the beach, especially this time of year it's the start of summer. Sydney in particular is a real beach city. It speaks to a lot of size of this country.
00:05:30
Speaker 1: You know, when I think about the holiday season getting warmer, especially on Christmas Day, one of those iconic images that we see broadcast here on December twenty fifth is that image of tourists and locals alike in their Santa hats down at Bondai Beach going for a swim. It really is deeply enmeshed in terms of our national identity. I want to talk a little bit about that with you, David. Australia has long seen itself as as relatively insulated from global turmoil. Has this punctured ourself image?
00:06:02
Speaker 2: I mean, I think clearly it has in some ways. I'm a migrant, as we gather, I'm from the UK originally that time when I first came to Australia, when I first went to Bondi Beach, I remember at that time and the subsequent times I've been here, there is a sense that you're distant from the world, even though we live in a very interconnected world. I remember living in the UK at the time of things like the Russian invasion of Georgia or some of the you know, pre Ukraine War, some of the aggression towards Ukraine, and I remember feeling that a lot of this stuff was very close to me, a sense of foreboding, that this stuff was all around me. And that is I think, certainly for me personally, but I think also for a lot of Australians. I think there is a sense that we are far from everywhere else. Having said that, I would push back a little bit from the idea that we're quite as isolated as we were. But back in the thirties, when some of these, you know, the Jewish migrants came to Australia that made Bondi Beach such a center of Jewish culture in Australia, we really were distant. You can only get here by boat, and you know, news traveled by telegraph, but pretty slowly. But that's changed, and that's actually been different for quite a long time. I mean I mentioned this the soccer club in Bonda. They had co club that Frank Lowe was a patron of. In nineteen eighty two there was a major bombing that was thought to be linked to Palestinian militants of that football club and also of the Israeli constitulate, and the suspected sort of perpetrators of that went on to bomber a pan Am flight from Tokyo to Los Angeles. So you know, we weren't insulated from that. The Barley bombings in two thousand and two, a lot of people remember two hundred and two people were killed. Eighty eight of those were Australians, and a lot of people talk about Barley as a sort of exclave of Australia.
00:07:39
Speaker 3: There's a lot of Australians there.
00:07:40
Speaker 2: I remember the last time after a terrorist attack being down at the beach, a lot of people from the next beach but one down from Bondai Kuji. A lot of people from the local rugby club in Kuji were killed in the Barley bombings, and I remember going Tokujie Beach in very similar circumstances to what we're seeing now. People morning what had happened, even like in you know, twenty nineteen, we had the christ Church mosque shootings of white supremacist from near Sydney who was radically radicalized after reading writings from a Norwegian mass killer shot fifty one people dead. So we're not quite
as isolated as we think. And I think, you know, we've seen this huge surze of anti Semitic attacks in the last couple of years in Australia. We're much more connected to things, so you know, if it's punctured that sense of us as somewhere that's sinsulated. I think that that sense of us as an insulated place was in some ways like an act of will in the first place. We've never been as insulated as we thought we were. We've really tried to make ourselves insulated.
00:08:37
Speaker 1: There has been significant international attention on this attack. Why do you think it's resonated beyond Australia.
00:08:45
Speaker 2: I mean, I think one thing is just that it's incredibly human, the circumstances on which in which it happened. I was looking at an online flyer for the Kuku festival that was attacked, and you look at the events that were listed. A petticins who face painting, ice cream, hot chip free doughnuts, kosher food and men are a lighting like these things are all. It's a family event and very familiar family things. Any Jewish person worldwide want to understand that feeling of Hanukah as a happily family event, and I guess you know, in a lot of people's minds there's a sort of fusion of the misery of Hunakh and Christmas as festivals in December, involving candles and gifts and families. So I think we all have a deep understanding of that, and if anything, the more alienating thing for most people around the world is that here in Australia we celebrate Hanoker and Christmas in thirty degree heat on the beach, which is which is that's the unfamiliar feeling on the deepest fundamental human level, there's that.
00:09:38
Speaker 3: But then, of course we've not spoke much.
00:09:41
Speaker 2: About yet, but we have to speak about there's a political element to this. We don't exactly know the motive yet. The police haven't stated that at this point, but it's not hard to speculate. We have an attack on a Hunuker festival on the first day of Hankker. One of the alleged shooters is ordered to have had links to extremists in Sydney who star themselves as an Islamic state cell. And of course, as I said, there's been since the Hummus attack on Israel in twenty twenty three and Israel's war on guards, that there has been global attention on political violence between Muslims and Jews. And this is incredily vivid and horrible instance of that. You know, to your point about isolation from global turmoil, there has been a huge rise in antismitic incidents over the last few years, as many in the past two years. In the previous ten, according to a report a couple of weeks ago by the Executive Council of Australian Jewy, there have been fire bombings of cars and homes, graffiti with threats, slurs, swastikas, windows smashed, countless verbal and physical abuse. And also, I would say, and you know, there has been an increase in Islamophobic attacks as well.
00:10:42
Speaker 3: But a lot of these.
00:10:43
Speaker 2: Anti Semitic attacks, they appear to have
been deliberately orchestrated from outside. Just in August, Australiak spelled Iran's ambassador and three other diplomats because They concluded that some of these attacks, in fact one of them are fire bombing of a kosher restaurant very close to Bondi Beach, have been orchestrated by Iran's Revolutionary Guard. All this together, Australia has successfully sold an image of itself both to the world and to itself as this is full beachy place, a refuge where the hatreds of the old world melt away, you know, take off our clothes and frolic.
00:11:11
Speaker 3: In the waves.
00:11:12
Speaker 2: You would be shocked to see violence, like you said on Sunday, anywhere, but I think there is something about the image of Australia to the world that makes it particularly shocking. You're particularly shocked to see it in a place which consciously styles itself as a place, you know, beyond some of these hatreds of the old world, and a place that you know, certainly you go to the beach, there is you know, there is no place where you feel more distant from from politics and from violence.
00:11:45
Speaker 1: I want to pick up a little bit on that beyond the social impact of this terror attack and look at it from an economical political perspective. I suppose is most appropriate, given that it's only happened in the last a couple of days. The economic impact of an incident like this does take some time to unravel and reveal itself.
00:12:08
Speaker 3: David, does this.
00:12:09
Speaker 1: Moment put a strain on Australia's political future? And in what ways should we expect to see this playing out in the days and weeks ahead.
00:12:19
Speaker 2: I mean a lot now depends on how politicians and public figures choose to respond to it. Australia prize itself on it's multiculturalism, and in general we're probably not as successful as a lot of people think we are, but in a lot of ways we have been pretty successful, and I think it's in the hands of politicians and public figures to how.
00:12:38
Speaker 3: To respond to this. Obviously, the alleged attackers.
00:12:41
Speaker 2: On Sunday, again we don't know their motives, but it looks pretty clear to me that they would want to strain on multiculturalism. Why would you choose this target, Why would you choose these people? You want to provoke people into a reaction, very much like the christ Church killer and all errors since time immemorial. You want you want to carry out something political with your violence, and public figures in these situations have a choice. They can decide whether they want to give the terrorists what they want or to deny it. Clearly, there's a problem with extremism in Australia, specifically with anti Semitism. You don't get sixteen hundred attacks in the pasty without that being the case. But you're already hearing on social media and elsewhere people trying to link this killing to immigration and to Islam, and responsible politicians are going to push back on that. They're not going to indulge that there's close to a million Muslims in Australia.
00:13:27
Speaker 3: They're exactly the same as the rest of us.
00:13:28
Speaker 2: This hero that a lot of people have seen on videos tackling one of the shooters, Ahmed, is a Muslim, And go to any Australian beach on a hot day like Sunday and you'll find Muslim families and Jewish families barbecuing, swimming, enjoying themselves like everyone else. So you know, if you want to tackle terrorism, you're a tackle terrorism, you infiltrate extremist networks, as the Australian government has been doing. Maybe not successfully enough, I think clearly from what we've seen, not successfully enough in this case. You know, if, as some of the have been saying recently, one of the killers have been investigated for extremist links, while the other one his father, was allowed to hold a gun license. If that's the case, it's clearly a terrible failure that two people so closely linked living in the same house. You know that this was this was not intervened in. When people are mourning and scared as they are at the moment, there's often an urge for vengeance, collective punishment, but you know, strong actions. He's serious about multiculturism. You attack terrorism, you don't attack you don't have collective punishment, you don't, you know, make it a broader issue.
00:14:31
Speaker 1: Finally, David, the events of Sunday have been described by some as a cultural flash point. What are the risks and opportunities in how Australia responds from this point?
00:14:43
Speaker 2: Well, I think it's it's very much as as we said it is a lot of people will want to frame this as a as a flashpoint in Australia as a multicultural nation. I am hopeful that the political backdrop in Australia is so and what different to what we've seen in other parts of the world.
00:15:02
Speaker 3: In that in most parts.
00:15:04
Speaker 2: Of the world there is a huge backlash against migration. There has certainly been like a rise in anti migration sentiment in Australia, but it's still I think I saw a survey from a couple of months ago. I think only thirteen percent of the population counted as a top three issue, So it's not a particularly salient issue. And one difference I think that we're seeing is that in a lot of the world, politicians are constantly worried about losing voters to their right and to stronger anti migration sentiment across the political spectrum from the left to the right. If you look at Albanese's response to this so far, mainly he's talked about gun control. He's not touched that rail of anti migration sentiment. Maybe that will come in the next few days, I sincerely hope not. I'm a migrant to Australia and I like the multiculture of Australia, and I like the spirit of you know, of that Hanneka festival on the beach.
00:15:57
Speaker 3: All people have all you know, creeds.
00:15:59
Speaker 2: And background and gathering together to just enjoy themselves. And that's actually I think there is something important to that. It's not just a scapism. I think there's something virtuous in that, and so I would like to see a little bit of spine and people in resisting that.
00:16:12
Speaker 1: David Fickling, thank you for your insights. If you found today's conversation insightfu'l be sure to follow the Bloomberg Australia Podcast wherever you listen, and check for more reading on Australia's people and politics, including the latest from Bloomberg Opinion columnist David Fickling at Bloomberg dot com. This episode was recorded on the traditional lands of the Wire Wondery and Getigal People. It was produced by Paul Allen and edited by Chris Burke and Ainsley Chandler. I'm Rebecca Jones. Thanks for listening.