สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:01.710 --> 00:00:05.769
Selections from the Principles of Philosophy by René Descartes. Translated
2
00:00:05.849 --> 00:00:10.089
by John Veitch. Letter of the author to the French
3
00:00:10.169 --> 00:00:15.380
translator of the Principles of Philosophy serving for a preface. Sir,
4
00:00:15.400 --> 00:00:18.280
the version of my principles which you have been at
5
00:00:18.300 --> 00:00:21.260
pains to make is so elegant and finished as to
6
00:00:21.320 --> 00:00:23.320
lead me to expect that the works will be more
7
00:00:23.379 --> 00:00:26.620
generally read in French than in Latin and better understood.
8
00:00:27.429 --> 00:00:30.489
The only apprehension I entertain is lest the title should
9
00:00:30.530 --> 00:00:32.969
deter some who have not been brought up to letters,
10
00:00:33.409 --> 00:00:36.299
or with whom philosophy is in bad repute, because the
11
00:00:36.310 --> 00:00:39.640
kind they were taught has proved unsatisfactory. And this makes
12
00:00:39.679 --> 00:00:41.420
me think that it will be useful to add a
13
00:00:41.460 --> 00:00:43.500
preface to it for the purpose of showing what the
14
00:00:43.579 --> 00:00:45.829
matter of the work is, what end I had in
15
00:00:45.869 --> 00:00:49.070
viewing writing it, and what utility may be derived from it.
16
00:00:49.829 --> 00:00:51.570
but although it might be my part to write a
17
00:00:51.609 --> 00:00:54.130
preface of this nature, seeing I ought to know these
18
00:00:54.170 --> 00:00:57.979
particulars better than any other person, I cannot nevertheless prevail
19
00:00:58.060 --> 00:01:00.479
upon myself to do anything more than merely to give
20
00:01:00.520 --> 00:01:03.579
a summary of the chief points that fall, as I think,
21
00:01:03.759 --> 00:01:06.099
to be discussed in it, and I leave it to
22
00:01:06.140 --> 00:01:08.750
your discretion to present to the public such part of
23
00:01:08.790 --> 00:01:12.549
them as you shall judge proper. I should have desired,
24
00:01:12.620 --> 00:01:15.450
in the first place, to explain in it what philosophy is,
25
00:01:15.650 --> 00:01:18.849
by commencing with the most common matters, as, for example,
26
00:01:19.209 --> 00:01:22.769
that the word philosophy signifies the study of wisdom, and
27
00:01:22.790 --> 00:01:25.370
that by wisdom is to be understood not merely prudence
28
00:01:25.450 --> 00:01:28.180
in the management of affairs, but a perfect knowledge of
29
00:01:28.280 --> 00:01:30.680
all that man can know, as well for the conduct
30
00:01:30.719 --> 00:01:32.840
of his life as for the preservation of his health
31
00:01:32.980 --> 00:01:35.840
and the discovery of all the arts, and that knowledge
32
00:01:35.859 --> 00:01:39.500
to subserve these ends must necessarily be deduced from first causes.
33
00:01:40.140 --> 00:01:42.329
so that in order to study the acquisition of it,
34
00:01:42.719 --> 00:01:46.090
which is properly called philosophizing, we must commence with the
35
Load full transcript
00:01:46.129 --> 00:01:50.129
investigation of those first causes which are called principles. Now
36
00:01:50.170 --> 00:01:53.930
these principles must possess two conditions. In the first place,
37
00:01:54.269 --> 00:01:57.040
they must be so clear and evident that the human mind,
38
00:01:57.379 --> 00:02:00.640
when it attentively considers them, cannot doubt of their truth.
39
00:02:01.319 --> 00:02:03.700
In the second place, the knowledge of other things must
40
00:02:03.739 --> 00:02:06.750
be so dependent on them, as that though the principles
41
00:02:06.769 --> 00:02:09.949
themselves may indeed be known apart from what depends on them,
42
00:02:10.409 --> 00:02:13.129
the latter cannot nevertheless be known apart from the former.
43
00:02:13.909 --> 00:02:17.310
It will accordingly be necessary, thereafter, to endeavour so to
44
00:02:17.349 --> 00:02:19.900
deduce from those principles the knowledge of the things that
45
00:02:19.939 --> 00:02:22.240
depend on them, as that there may be nothing in
46
00:02:22.259 --> 00:02:25.259
the whole series of deductions which is not perfectly manifest.
47
00:02:26.090 --> 00:02:29.009
God is in truth the only being who is absolutely wise,
48
00:02:29.030 --> 00:02:32.219
that is, who possesses a perfect knowledge of all things,
49
00:02:32.719 --> 00:02:35.099
but we may say that men are more or less wise,
50
00:02:35.219 --> 00:02:37.719
as their knowledge of the most important truths is greater
51
00:02:37.800 --> 00:02:40.729
or less. And I am confident that there is nothing,
52
00:02:40.750 --> 00:02:43.050
in what I have now said, in which all the
53
00:02:43.069 --> 00:02:46.819
learned do not concur. I should, in the next place,
54
00:02:47.000 --> 00:02:50.099
have proposed to consider the utility of philosophy, and at
55
00:02:50.139 --> 00:02:52.680
the same time have shown that, since it embraces all
56
00:02:52.699 --> 00:02:55.280
that the human mind can know, we ought to believe
57
00:02:55.319 --> 00:02:57.639
that it is by it we are distinguished from savages
58
00:02:57.719 --> 00:03:00.780
and barbarians, and that the civilization and culture of a
59
00:03:00.819 --> 00:03:03.800
nation is regulated by the degree in which true philosophy
60
00:03:03.879 --> 00:03:07.699
nourishes in it, and, accordingly, that to contain true philosophers
61
00:03:07.780 --> 00:03:11.259
is the highest privilege a state can enjoy. Besides this,
62
00:03:11.439 --> 00:03:14.319
I should have shown that, as regards individuals, it is
63
00:03:14.360 --> 00:03:17.060
not only useful for each man to have intercourse with
64
00:03:17.099 --> 00:03:20.039
those who apply themselves to this study, but that it
65
00:03:20.139 --> 00:03:23.560
is incomparably better he should himself direct his attention to it,
66
00:03:24.139 --> 00:03:26.419
just as it is doubtless to be preferred that any
67
00:03:26.479 --> 00:03:28.580
man should make use of his own eyes to direct
68
00:03:28.620 --> 00:03:31.240
his steps, and enjoy by means of the same the
69
00:03:31.280 --> 00:03:33.900
beauties of colour and light, than that he should blindly
70
00:03:33.979 --> 00:03:36.800
follow the guidance of another, though the latter course is
71
00:03:36.840 --> 00:03:39.030
certainly better than to have the eyes closed with no
72
00:03:39.060 --> 00:03:43.219
guide except oneself. But to live without philosophizing is, in truth,
73
00:03:43.280 --> 00:03:45.759
the same as keeping the eyes closed without attempting to
74
00:03:45.879 --> 00:03:48.590
open them. And the pleasure of seeing all that sight
75
00:03:48.620 --> 00:03:52.050
discloses is not to be compared with the satisfaction afforded
76
00:03:52.129 --> 00:03:55.669
by the discoveries of philosophy. And finally, the study is
77
00:03:55.710 --> 00:03:59.169
more imperatively requisite for the regulation of our manners and
78
00:03:59.210 --> 00:04:01.689
for conducting us through life than is the use of
79
00:04:01.750 --> 00:04:04.949
our eyes for directing our steps. The brutes, which have
80
00:04:05.030 --> 00:04:08.349
only their bodies to conserve, are continually occupied in seeking
81
00:04:08.409 --> 00:04:11.740
sources of nourishment. but men, of whom the chief part
82
00:04:11.800 --> 00:04:14.439
is the mind, ought to make the search after wisdom
83
00:04:14.500 --> 00:04:17.250
their principal care, for wisdom is the true nourishment of
84
00:04:17.290 --> 00:04:20.329
the mind, and I feel assured, moreover, that there are
85
00:04:20.389 --> 00:04:22.589
very many who would not fail in the search if
86
00:04:22.629 --> 00:04:25.170
they would but hope for success in it, and knew
87
00:04:25.189 --> 00:04:28.850
the degree of their capabilities for it. There is no mind,
88
00:04:28.930 --> 00:04:32.329
how ignoble soever it be, which remains so firmly bound
89
00:04:32.420 --> 00:04:34.920
up in the objects of the senses, as not some
90
00:04:34.959 --> 00:04:37.160
time or other to turn itself away from them in
91
00:04:37.180 --> 00:04:41.000
the aspiration after some higher good, although not knowing frequently
92
00:04:41.060 --> 00:04:45.310
wherein that good consists. The greatest favourites of fortune, those
93
00:04:45.350 --> 00:04:48.649
who have health, honours, and riches in abundance, are not
94
00:04:48.689 --> 00:04:52.069
more exempt from aspirations of this nature than others. Nay,
95
00:04:52.170 --> 00:04:54.410
I am persuaded that these are the persons who sigh
96
00:04:54.430 --> 00:04:57.430
the most deeply after another good greater and more perfect
97
00:04:57.490 --> 00:05:00.949
still than any they already possess. but the supreme good,
98
00:05:01.089 --> 00:05:04.060
considered by natural reason without the light of fate, is
99
00:05:04.100 --> 00:05:07.000
nothing more than the knowledge of truth through its first causes,
100
00:05:07.259 --> 00:05:10.180
in other words, the wisdom of which philosophy is to study.
101
00:05:10.939 -->
00:05:14.100
And as all these particulars are indisputably true, all that
102
00:05:14.160 --> 00:05:16.399
is required to gain assent to their truth is that
103
00:05:16.439 --> 00:05:19.720
they be well stated. But as one is restrained from
104
00:05:19.759 --> 00:05:22.990
assenting to these doctrines by experience, which shows that they
105
00:05:23.050 --> 00:05:25.930
who make pretensions to philosophy are often less wise and
106
00:05:25.949 --> 00:05:29.089
reasonable than others who have never applied themselves to the study,
107
00:05:29.620 --> 00:05:32.290
I should have here shortly explained wherein consists all the
108
00:05:32.319 --> 00:05:34.930
science we now possess, and what are the degrees of
109
00:05:34.970 --> 00:05:38.290
wisdom at which we have arrived. The first degree contains
110
00:05:38.410 --> 00:05:40.829
only notions so clear of themselves that they can be
111
00:05:40.870 --> 00:05:44.980
acquired without meditation. The second comprehends all that the experience
112
00:05:45.019 --> 00:05:48.319
of the senses dictates. The third, that which the conversation
113
00:05:48.339 --> 00:05:50.959
of other men teaches us, to which may be added
114
00:05:51.040 --> 00:05:53.779
as the fourth, the reading, not of all books, but
115
00:05:53.839 --> 00:05:56.550
especially of such as have been written by persons capable
116
00:05:56.589 --> 00:05:59.779
of conveying proper instruction. for it is a species of
117
00:05:59.819 --> 00:06:02.980
conversation we hold with their authors. And it seems to
118
00:06:03.040 --> 00:06:05.459
me that all the wisdom we in ordinary possess is
119
00:06:05.500 --> 00:06:08.170
acquired only in these four ways, for I do not
120
00:06:08.209 --> 00:06:11.410
class divine revelation among them, because it does not conduct
121
00:06:11.470 --> 00:06:14.269
us by degrees, but elevates us at once to an
122
00:06:14.350 --> 00:06:18.259
infallible faith. There have been, indeed, in all ages, great
123
00:06:18.319 --> 00:06:20.699
minds who endeavoured to find the fifth road to wisdom,
124
00:06:21.079 --> 00:06:24.480
incomparably more sure and elevated than the other four. The
125
00:06:24.519 --> 00:06:26.860
path they essayed was the search of first causes and
126
00:06:26.899 --> 00:06:29.720
true principles, for which might be deduced the reasons of
127
00:06:29.819 --> 00:06:31.839
all that can be known by man, and it is
128
00:06:31.879 --> 00:06:35.319
to them the appellation of philosophers has been more especially accorded.
129
00:06:36.040 --> 00:06:37.959
I am not aware that there is any one of them,
130
00:06:38.079 --> 00:06:40.639
up to the present, who has succeeded in this enterprise.
131
00:06:41.220 --> 00:06:43.939
the first and chief whose writings we possess are Plato
132
00:06:43.980 --> 00:06:47.370
and Aristotle, between whom there was no difference, except that
133
00:06:47.410 --> 00:06:50.730
the former, following in the footsteps of his master, Socrates,
134
00:06:51.149 --> 00:06:53.750
ingeniously confessed that he had never yet been able to
135
00:06:53.810 --> 00:06:56.730
find anything certain, and that he was contented to write
136
00:06:56.769 --> 00:07:00.069
what seemed to him probable, imagining, for this end, certain
137
00:07:00.129 --> 00:07:04.689
principles by which he endeavoured to account for the other things. Aristotle,
138
00:07:04.829 --> 00:07:07.829
on the other hand, characterized by less candor, although for
139
00:07:07.870 --> 00:07:10.850
twenty years the disciple of Plato, and with no principle
140
00:07:10.889 --> 00:07:13.899
beyond those of its master, completely reversed his mode of
141
00:07:13.939 --> 00:07:16.620
putting them, and proposed as true and certain what it
142
00:07:16.699 --> 00:07:20.120
is probable he himself never esteemed as such. But these
143
00:07:20.160 --> 00:07:22.639
two men had acquired much judgment and wisdom by the
144
00:07:22.680 --> 00:07:26.389
four preceding means, qualities which raised their authority very high,
145
00:07:26.829 --> 00:07:29.430
so much so that those who succeeded them were willing
146
00:07:29.490 --> 00:07:32.250
rather to acquiesce in their opinions than to seek better
147
00:07:32.290 --> 00:07:36.360
for themselves. The chief question among their disciples, however, was
148
00:07:36.439 --> 00:07:38.399
as to whether we ought to doubt of all things
149
00:07:38.500 --> 00:07:41.259
or hold some as certain, a dispute which led them
150
00:07:41.319 --> 00:07:44.480
on both sides into extravagant errors, for a part of
151
00:07:44.519 --> 00:07:47.009
those who were for doubt extended it even to the
152
00:07:47.089 --> 00:07:50.149
actions of life, to the neglect of the most ordinary
153
00:07:50.209 --> 00:07:53.470
rules required for its conduct. Those, on the other hand,
154
00:07:53.550 --> 00:07:56.850
who maintained the doctrine of certainty, supposing that it must
155
00:07:56.870 --> 00:08:00.610
depend upon the senses, trusted entirely to them. to such
156
00:08:00.649 --> 00:08:03.370
an extent was this carried by epicurus that it is
157
00:08:03.430 --> 00:08:06.490
said he ventured to affirm contrary to all the reasonings
158
00:08:06.550 --> 00:08:09.170
of the astronomers that the sun is no larger than
159
00:08:09.230 --> 00:08:12.230
it appears it is a fault we may remark in
160
00:08:12.269 --> 00:08:15.050
most disputes that as truth is the mean between the
161
00:08:15.110 --> 00:08:18.449
two opinions that are upheld each disputant departs from it
162
00:08:18.529 --> 00:08:20.810
in proportion to the degree in which he possesses the
163
00:08:20.829 --> 00:08:23.870
spirit of contradiction but the error of those who lend
164
00:08:23.970 --> 00:08:26.129
too much to the sight of doubt was not followed
165
00:08:26.149 --> 00:08:28.459
for any length of time, and that of the opposite
166
00:08:28.500 --> 00:08:31.180
party has been to some extent corrected by the doctrine
167
00:08:31.540
--> 00:08:35.580
that the senses are deceitful in many instances. Nevertheless, I
168
00:08:35.620 --> 00:08:37.820
do not know that this error was wholly removed by
169
00:08:37.860 --> 00:08:40.539
showing that certitude is not in the senses, but in
170
00:08:40.590 --> 00:08:43.720
the understanding alone when it has clear perceptions. and that
171
00:08:43.740 --> 00:08:46.200
while we only possess the knowledge which is acquired in
172
00:08:46.220 --> 00:08:48.700
the first four grades of wisdom, we ought not to
173
00:08:48.740 --> 00:08:50.980
doubt of the things that appear to be true in
174
00:08:51.000 --> 00:08:53.879
what regards the conduct of life, nor esteem them as
175
00:08:53.940 --> 00:08:56.679
so certain that we cannot change our opinions regarding them,
176
00:08:57.179 --> 00:09:00.980
even though constrained by the evidence of reason. From ignorance
177
00:09:01.019 --> 00:09:03.179
of this truth, or if there was anyone to whom
178
00:09:03.220 --> 00:09:05.879
it was known, from neglect of it, the majority of
179
00:09:05.919 --> 00:09:08.679
those who in these later ages aspired to be philosophers,
180
00:09:09.159 --> 00:09:12.679
blindly followed Aristotle, so that they frequently corrupted the sense
181
00:09:12.720 --> 00:09:15.919
of his writings, and attributed to him various opinions which
182
00:09:15.940 --> 00:09:18.340
he would not recognize as his own, were he now
183
00:09:18.379 --> 00:09:20.740
to return to the world. And those who did not
184
00:09:20.799 --> 00:09:23.340
follow him, among whom are to be found many of
185
00:09:23.379 --> 00:09:26.559
the greatest minds, did yet not escape being imbued with
186
00:09:26.600 --> 00:09:29.340
his opinions in their youth, as these formed a staple
187
00:09:29.379 --> 00:09:32.120
of instruction in the schools, and thus their minds were
188
00:09:32.159 --> 00:09:34.620
so preoccupied that they could not rise to the knowledge
189
00:09:34.639 --> 00:09:37.799
of true principles. and though i hold all the philosophers
190
00:09:37.870 --> 00:09:40.889
in esteem and am unwilling to incur odium by my
191
00:09:40.929 --> 00:09:44.330
censure i can adduce a proof of my assertion which
192
00:09:44.429 --> 00:09:46.990
i do not think any of them will gainsay which
193
00:09:47.090 --> 00:09:49.289
is that they all laid down as a principle what
194
00:09:49.330 --> 00:09:52.649
they did not perfectly know for example i know none
195
00:09:52.690 --> 00:09:54.850
of them who did not suppose that there was gravity
196
00:09:54.889 --> 00:09:58.490
in terrestrial bodies but although experience shows us very clearly
197
00:09:58.549 --> 00:10:01.320
that bodies we call heavy descend toward the centre of
198
00:10:01.360 --> 00:10:04.419
the earth, we do not, therefore, know the nature of gravity,
199
00:10:04.919 --> 00:10:07.480
that is, the cause or principle in virtue of which
200
00:10:07.539 --> 00:10:10.460
bodies descend, and we must derive our knowledge of it
201
00:10:10.580 --> 00:10:13.299
from some other source. The same may be said of
202
00:10:13.360 --> 00:10:16.120
a vacuum in atoms, of heat and cold, of dryness
203
00:10:16.159 --> 00:10:18.830
and humidity, and of salt, sulphur and mercury, and of
204
00:10:18.850 --> 00:10:20.879
the like. and the other things of this sort which
205
00:10:20.960 --> 00:10:24.460
some have adopted as their principles. But no conclusion deduced
206
00:10:24.500 --> 00:10:26.919
from a principle which is not clear can be evident,
207
00:10:27.419 --> 00:10:30.590
even although the deduction be formally valid. And hence it
208
00:10:30.620 --> 00:10:33.629
follows that no reasonings based on such principles could lead
209
00:10:33.649 --> 00:10:36.269
them to the certain knowledge of any one thing, nor
210
00:10:36.350 --> 00:10:39.269
consequently advance them one step in the search after wisdom.
211
00:10:39.289 --> 00:10:42.230
And if they did discover any truth, this was due
212
00:10:42.289 --> 00:10:44.490
to one or other of the four means above mentioned.
213
00:10:45.139 --> 00:10:48.370
Notwithstanding this, I am in no degree desirous to lessen
214
00:10:48.409 --> 00:10:51.169
the honour which each of them can justly claim. I
215
00:10:51.230 --> 00:10:53.769
am only constrained to say, for the consolation of those
216
00:10:53.809 --> 00:10:56.600
who have not given their attention to study, that just
217
00:10:56.649 --> 00:10:58.860
as in travelling, when we turn our back upon the
218
00:10:58.899 --> 00:11:01.519
place to which we were going, we recede the farther
219
00:11:01.559 --> 00:11:03.840
from it in proportion as we proceed in the new
220
00:11:03.860 --> 00:11:07.019
direction for a greater length of time and with greater speed,
221
00:11:07.519 --> 00:11:09.659
so that, though we may be afterwards brought back to
222
00:11:09.679 --> 00:11:12.789
the right way, we cannot nevertheless arrive at the destined
223
00:11:12.809 --> 00:11:14.970
place as soon as if we had not moved backwards
224
00:11:15.029 --> 00:11:17.740
at all. So in philosophy, when we make use of
225
00:11:17.799 --> 00:11:20.580
false principles, we depart the farther from the knowledge of
226
00:11:20.679 --> 00:11:23.639
truth and wisdom, exactly in proportion to the care with
227
00:11:23.679 --> 00:11:26.759
which we cultivate them, and apply ourselves to the deduction
228
00:11:26.779 --> 00:11:30.669
of diverse consequences from them, thinking that we are philosophizing well,
229
00:11:30.990 --> 00:11:33.289
while we are only departing the farther from the truth,
230
00:11:33.830 --> 00:11:35.769
from which it must be inferred that they who have
231
00:11:35.809 --> 00:11:38.549
learned the least of all that has been hitherto distinguished
232
00:11:38.590 --> 00:11:41.090
by the name of philosophy are the most fitted for
233
00:11:41.110 --> 00:11:45.590
the apprehension of truth. After making those matters clear, I should,
234
00:11:45.669 --> 00:11:48.149
in
the next place, have desired to set forth the
235
00:11:48.190 --> 00:11:50.870
grounds for holding that the true principles by which you
236
00:11:50.909 --> 00:11:53.820
may reach that highest degree of wisdom, wherein consists the
237
00:11:53.860 --> 00:11:56.779
sovereign good of human life, are those I have proposed
238
00:11:56.840 --> 00:12:00.019
in this work, and two considerations alone are sufficient to
239
00:12:00.080 --> 00:12:03.379
establish this, the first of which is that these principles
240
00:12:03.460 --> 00:12:06.110
are very clear, and the second that we can deduce
241
00:12:06.230 --> 00:12:08.830
all other truths from them, for it is only these
242
00:12:08.870 --> 00:12:12.240
two conditions that are required in true principles. but i
243
00:12:12.340 --> 00:12:15.279
easily proved that they are very clear firstly by a
244
00:12:15.340 --> 00:12:17.950
reference to the manner in which i found them namely
245
00:12:18.049 --> 00:12:21.070
by rejecting all propositions that were in the least doubtful
246
00:12:21.509 --> 00:12:23.649
for it is certain that such as could not be
247
00:12:23.690 --> 00:12:27.039
rejected by this test when they were attentively considered are
248
00:12:27.059 --> 00:12:29.379
the most evident and clear which the human mind can
249
00:12:29.399 --> 00:12:32.720
know thus by considering that he who strives to doubt
250
00:12:32.759 --> 00:12:35.740
of all is unable nevertheless to doubt that he is
251
00:12:35.879 --> 00:12:38.700
while he doubts and that what reason does in not
252
00:12:38.740 --> 00:12:41.370
being able to doubt of itself in doubting nevertheless of
253
00:12:41.429 --> 00:12:44.309
everything else is not that which we call our body
254
00:12:44.690 --> 00:12:47.129
but what we name our mind or thought i have
255
00:12:47.169 --> 00:12:49.769
taken the existence of this thought for the first principle
256
00:12:50.190 --> 00:12:53.470
from which I very clearly deduce the following truths, namely,
257
00:12:53.570 --> 00:12:55.250
that there is a God who is the author of
258
00:12:55.340 --> 00:12:57.519
all that is in the world, and who, being the
259
00:12:57.559 --> 00:13:00.860
source of all truth, cannot have created our understanding of
260
00:13:00.899 --> 00:13:03.279
such a nature as to be deceived in the judgments
261
00:13:03.360 --> 00:13:05.759
it forms of the things of which it possesses a
262
00:13:05.799 --> 00:13:09.279
very clear and distinct perception. Those are all the principles
263
00:13:09.340 --> 00:13:13.070
of which I avail myself touching immaterial or metaphysical objects.
264
00:13:13.519 --> 00:13:16.240
from which i most clearly deduce these other principles of
265
00:13:16.299 --> 00:13:20.039
physical and corporeal things namely that there are bodies extended
266
00:13:20.139 --> 00:13:23.259
in length breadth and depth which are of divers figures
267
00:13:23.360 --> 00:13:26.240
and are moved in a variety of ways such are
268
00:13:26.299
--> 00:13:28.720
in sum the principles from which i deduce all other
269
00:13:28.779 --> 00:13:32.269
truths the second circumstance that proves the clearness of these
270
00:13:32.309 --> 00:13:35.129
principles is that they have been known in all ages,
271
00:13:35.500 --> 00:13:38.340
and even received as true and indubitable by all men,
272
00:13:38.720 --> 00:13:41.580
with the exception only of the existence of God, which
273
00:13:41.620 --> 00:13:44.529
has been doubted by some, because they attributed too much
274
00:13:44.549 --> 00:13:47.389
to the perceptions of the senses, and God can neither
275
00:13:47.429 --> 00:13:51.049
be seen nor touched. but though all the truths which
276
00:13:51.090 --> 00:13:53.470
i classed among my principles were known at all times
277
00:13:53.789 --> 00:13:56.389
and by all men nevertheless there has been no one
278
00:13:56.450 --> 00:13:58.429
up to the present who so far as i know
279
00:13:58.450 --> 00:14:02.299
has adopted them as principles of philosophy in other words
280
00:14:02.480 --> 00:14:04.480
as such that we can deduce from them the knowledge
281
00:14:04.659 --> 00:14:07.820
of whatever else is in the world it accordingly now
282
00:14:07.860 --> 00:14:10.399
remains for me to prove that they are such and
283
00:14:10.440 --> 00:14:12.639
it appears to me that i cannot better establish this
284
00:14:12.700 --> 00:14:15.730
than by the test of experience in other words by
285
00:14:15.769 --> 00:14:19.080
inviting readers to peruse the following work For, though I
286
00:14:19.120 --> 00:14:22.440
have not treated in it of all matters, that being impossible,
287
00:14:23.019 --> 00:14:24.899
I think I have so explained all of which I
288
00:14:24.960 --> 00:14:27.879
had occasion to treat, that they who read it attentively
289
00:14:28.179 --> 00:14:31.039
will have ground for the persuasion that it is unnecessary
290
00:14:31.080 --> 00:14:33.960
to seek for any other principles than those I have given,
291
00:14:34.399 --> 00:14:36.700
in order to arrive at the most exalted knowledge of
292
00:14:36.740 --> 00:14:39.960
which the mind of man is capable. Especially if, after
293
00:14:40.000 --> 00:14:42.320
the perusal of my writings, they take the trouble to
294
00:14:42.360 --> 00:14:46.399
consider how many diverse questions are therein discussed and explained, and,
295
00:14:46.490 --> 00:14:49.200
referring to the writings of others, they see how little
296
00:14:49.240 --> 00:14:52.139
probability there is in the reasons that are adduced in
297
00:14:52.179 --> 00:14:55.350
explaining of the same questions by principles different from mine.
298
00:14:56.049 --> 00:14:58.370
And that they may the more easily undertake this, I
299
00:14:58.409 --> 00:15:00.990
might have said that those imbued with my doctrines have
300
00:15:01.049 --> 00:15:04.210
much less difficulty in comprehending the writings of others and
301
00:15:04.269 --> 00:15:06.789
estimating their true value
than those who have not been
302
00:15:06.830 --> 00:15:09.789
so imbued. And this is precisely the opposite of what
303
00:15:09.850 --> 00:15:13.590
I before said of such as commenced with the ancient philosophy, namely,
304
00:15:13.610 --> 00:15:15.549
that the more they have studied it, the less fit
305
00:15:15.610 --> 00:15:19.200
are they for rightly apprehending the truth. I should also
306
00:15:19.240 --> 00:15:21.419
have added a word of advice regarding the manner of
307
00:15:21.480 --> 00:15:23.639
reading this work, which is that I should wish the
308
00:15:23.679 --> 00:15:25.559
reader at first to go over the whole of it,
309
00:15:25.919 --> 00:15:29.179
as I would a romance, without greatly straining his attention,
310
00:15:29.590 --> 00:15:32.090
or tarrying at the difficulties he may perhaps meet with
311
00:15:32.169 --> 00:15:34.730
in it, with the view simply of knowing in general
312
00:15:34.789 --> 00:15:37.470
the matters of which I treat, and that afterwards, if
313
00:15:37.509 --> 00:15:39.990
they seem to him to merit a more careful examination,
314
00:15:40.330 --> 00:15:42.889
and he feel a desire to know their causes, he
315
00:15:42.929 --> 00:15:45.220
may read it a second time, in order to observe
316
00:15:45.240 --> 00:15:47.840
the connection of my reasonings. but that he must not
317
00:15:47.860 --> 00:15:50.279
then give it up in despair, although he may not
318
00:15:50.379 --> 00:15:53.740
everywhere sufficiently discover the connection of the proof, or understand
319
00:15:53.820 --> 00:15:56.759
all the reasonings, it being only necessary to mark with
320
00:15:56.799 --> 00:15:59.799
a pen the places where the difficulties occur, and continue
321
00:15:59.840 --> 00:16:02.500
to read without interruption to the end. Then, if he
322
00:16:02.519 --> 00:16:04.590
does not grudge to take up the book a third time,
323
00:16:04.950 --> 00:16:07.210
I am confident he will find in a fresh perusal
324
00:16:07.269 --> 00:16:09.809
the solution of most of the difficulties he will have
325
00:16:09.850 --> 00:16:12.990
marked before, and that if any still remain, their solution
326
00:16:13.029 --> 00:16:16.399
will in the end be found in another reading. i
327
00:16:16.440 --> 00:16:20.000
have observed on examining the natural constitutions of different minds
328
00:16:20.080 --> 00:16:22.230
that there are hardly any so dull or slow of
329
00:16:22.299 --> 00:16:26.289
understanding as to be incapable of apprehending good opinions or
330
00:16:26.389 --> 00:16:29.429
even of acquiring all the highest sciences if they be
331
00:16:29.490 --> 00:16:32.450
but conducted along the right road and this can also
332
00:16:32.490 --> 00:16:35.149
be proved by reason for as the principles are clear
333
00:16:35.509 --> 00:16:37.889
and as nothing ought to be deduced from them unless
334
00:16:37.960 --> 00:16:41.779
most manifest influences no one is so devoid of intelligence
335
00:16:41.899 --> 00:16:44.480
as
to be unable to comprehend the conclusions that flow
336
00:16:44.539 --> 00:16:48.440
from them but besides the entanglement of prejudices from which
337
00:16:48.500 --> 00:16:51.220
no one is entirely exempt although it is they who
338
00:16:51.259 --> 00:16:53.759
have been the most ardent students of the false sciences
339
00:16:54.080 --> 00:16:57.080
that receive the greatest detriment from them it happens very
340
00:16:57.139 --> 00:17:00.399
generally that people of ordinary capacity neglect to study from
341
00:17:00.450 --> 00:17:03.509
a conviction that they want ability and that others who
342
00:17:03.570 --> 00:17:06.910
are more ardent press on too rapidly whence it comes
343
00:17:06.950 --> 00:17:10.009
to pass that they frequently admit principles far from evident
344
00:17:10.170 --> 00:17:13.579
and dole doubtful inferences from them For this reason, I
345
00:17:13.599 --> 00:17:16.000
should wish to assure those who are too distrustful of
346
00:17:16.019 --> 00:17:18.619
their own ability that there is nothing in my writings
347
00:17:18.680 --> 00:17:21.559
which they may not entirely understand if they only take
348
00:17:21.579 --> 00:17:24.289
the trouble to examine them, and I should wish, at
349
00:17:24.329 --> 00:17:26.930
the same time, to warn those of an opposite tendency
350
00:17:27.269 --> 00:17:29.569
that even the most superior minds will have need of
351
00:17:29.650 --> 00:17:32.589
much time and attention to remark all I design to
352
00:17:32.690 --> 00:17:36.380
embrace therein. After this, that I might lead men to
353
00:17:36.440 --> 00:17:39.019
understand the real design I had in publishing them, I
354
00:17:39.039 --> 00:17:41.220
should have wished here to explain the order which it
355
00:17:41.279 --> 00:17:43.200
seems to me one ought to follow with the view
356
00:17:43.259 --> 00:17:46.380
of instructing himself. In the first place, a man who
357
00:17:46.420 --> 00:17:49.029
has merely the vulgar and imperfect knowledge which can be
358
00:17:49.089 --> 00:17:52.809
acquired by the four means above explained, ought, before all else,
359
00:17:52.910 --> 00:17:55.309
to endeavour to form for himself a code of morals
360
00:17:55.750 --> 00:17:58.710
sufficient to regulate the actions of his life, as well
361
00:17:58.750 --> 00:18:01.160
for the reason that this does not admit of delay
362
00:18:01.259 --> 00:18:03.160
as because it ought to be our first care to
363
00:18:03.200 --> 00:18:06.480
live well. In the next place he ought to study logic,
364
00:18:06.859 --> 00:18:09.950
not that of the schools, for it is only, properly speaking,
365
00:18:10.329 --> 00:18:13.210
a dialectic which teaches the mode of expounding to others
366
00:18:13.269 --> 00:18:16.349
what we already know, or even of speaking much without
367
00:18:16.410 --> 00:18:18.900
judgment of what we do not know, by which means
368
00:18:18.980 --> 00:18:22.559
it corrupts rather than increases good sense, but the logic
369
00:18:22.599 --> 00:18:24.880
which teaches the right conduct of the reason with the
370
00:18:24.940 --> 00:18:27.509
view of discovering the truths of which we are ignorant.
371
00:18:28.109 --> 00:18:31.289
and because it greatly depends on usage it is desirable
372
00:18:31.329 --> 00:18:33.990
he should exercise himself for a length of time in
373
00:18:34.029 --> 00:18:37.450
practising his rules on easy and simple questions as those
374
00:18:37.490 --> 00:18:40.819
of the mathematics then when he has acquired some skill
375
00:18:40.880 --> 00:18:43.809
in discovering the truth in these questions he should commence
376
00:18:43.869 --> 00:18:47.049
to apply himself in earnest to true philosophy, of which
377
00:18:47.109 --> 00:18:50.339
the first part is metaphysics, containing the principles of knowledge,
378
00:18:50.539 --> 00:18:53.319
among which it is the explication of the principal attributes
379
00:18:53.359 --> 00:18:56.420
of God, of the immateriality of the soul, and of
380
00:18:56.500 --> 00:18:58.559
all the clear and simple notions that are in us.
381
00:18:59.319 --> 00:19:02.259
The second is physics, in which, after finding the true
382
00:19:02.339 --> 00:19:06.180
principles of material things, we examine, in general, how the
383
00:19:06.220 --> 00:19:09.759
whole universe has been framed. In the next place, we consider,
384
00:19:09.819 --> 00:19:12.309
in particular, the nature of the earth and of all
385
00:19:12.329 --> 00:19:16.170
the bodies that are most generally found upon it, as air, water, fire,
386
00:19:16.509 --> 00:19:19.849
the lodestone, and other minerals. In the next place, it
387
00:19:19.910 --> 00:19:23.519
is necessary also to examine singly the nature of plants,
388
00:19:23.650 --> 00:19:26.519
of animals, and above all, of man, in order that
389
00:19:26.559 --> 00:19:29.160
we may thereafter be able to discover the other sciences
390
00:19:29.220 --> 00:19:32.460
that are useful to us. Thus, all philosophy is like
391
00:19:32.500 --> 00:19:36.000
a tree, of which metaphysics is the root, physics the trunk,
392
00:19:36.240 --> 00:19:38.579
and all the other sciences the branches that grow out
393
00:19:38.599 --> 00:19:43.109
of this trunk, which are reduced to three principles, namely medicine, mechanics,
394
00:19:43.190 --> 00:19:46.410
and ethics. By the science of morals, I understand the
395
00:19:46.470 --> 00:19:49.950
highest and most perfect which, presupposing an entire knowledge of
396
00:19:49.980 --> 00:19:54.220
the other sciences is the last degree of wisdom But
397
00:19:54.420 --> 00:19:56.140
as it is not from the roots or the trunk
398
00:19:56.160 --> 00:19:58.339
of trees that we gather the fruit, but only from
399
00:19:58.380 --> 00:20:01.900
the extremities of their branches, so the principal utility of
400
00:20:01.940 --> 00:20:05.160
philosophy depends on the separate uses of its parts, which
401
00:20:05.200 --> 00:20:07.740
we can only learn last of all.
But though I
402
00:20:07.819 --> 00:20:10.319
am ignorant of almost all these, the zeal I have
403
00:20:10.359 --> 00:20:12.460
always felt in endeavouring to be of service to the
404
00:20:12.509 --> 00:20:15.329
public was the reason why I published, some ten or
405
00:20:15.369 --> 00:20:18.490
twelve years ago, certain essays on the doctrines I thought
406
00:20:18.529 --> 00:20:21.490
I had acquired. The first part of these essays was
407
00:20:21.549 --> 00:20:24.269
a discourse on the method of rightly conducting the reason
408
00:20:24.589 --> 00:20:27.400
and seeking truth in the sciences, in which I gave
409
00:20:27.440 --> 00:20:30.079
a summary of the principal rules of logic, and also
410
00:20:30.220 --> 00:20:33.480
of an imperfect ethic, which a person may follow provisionally,
411
00:20:33.819 --> 00:20:36.559
so long as he does not know any better. The
412
00:20:36.599 --> 00:20:40.240
other parts were three treatises, the first of dioptrics, the
413
00:20:40.279 --> 00:20:44.539
second of meteors, and the third of geometry. In the Dioptrics,
414
00:20:44.740 --> 00:20:46.940
I designed to show that we might proceed far enough
415
00:20:46.980 --> 00:20:50.400
in philosophy as to arrive, by its means, at the
416
00:20:50.440 --> 00:20:52.980
knowledge of the arts that are useful to life, because
417
00:20:53.019 --> 00:20:55.349
the invention of the telescope, of which I there gave
418
00:20:55.369 --> 00:20:57.930
an explanation, is one of the most difficult that has
419
00:20:58.029 --> 00:21:01.430
ever been made. In the Treatise of Meteors, I desire
420
00:21:01.470 --> 00:21:04.329
to exhibit the difference that subsists between the philosophy I
421
00:21:04.390 --> 00:21:07.279
cultivate and that taught in the schools, in which the
422
00:21:07.319 --> 00:21:10.960
same matters are usually discussed. In fine, in the geometry,
423
00:21:11.099 --> 00:21:13.720
I profess to demonstrate that I have discovered many things
424
00:21:13.759 --> 00:21:16.819
that were before unknown, and thus afford ground for believing
425
00:21:16.859 --> 00:21:19.569
that we may still discover many others, with the view
426
00:21:19.650 --> 00:21:23.170
of thus stimulating all to the investigation of truth. Since
427
00:21:23.210 --> 00:21:26.609
that period, anticipating the difficulty which many would experience in
428
00:21:26.650 --> 00:21:30.410
apprehending the foundations of the metaphysics, I endeavour to explain
429
00:21:30.430 --> 00:21:32.910
the chief points of them in a book of meditations,
430
00:21:33.349 --> 00:21:35.809
which is not in itself large, but the size of
431
00:21:35.869 --> 00:21:39.470
which has been increased, and the matter greatly illustrated by
432
00:21:39.509 --> 00:21:42.690
the objections which several very learned persons sent to me
433
00:21:43.049 --> 00:21:45.529
on occasion of it, and by the replies which I
434
00:21:45.549 --> 00:21:48.589
made to them. At length, after it appeared to me
435
00:21:48.670 --> 00:21:52.170
that those preceding treatises had sufficiently prepared the minds of
436
00:21:52.210 --> 00:21:55.650
my readers for the principles of philosophy, I also published it,
437
00:21:56.089 --> 00:21:58.779
and I have divided this work into four parts, the
438
00:21:58.819 --> 00:22:01.799
first of which contains the principles of human knowledge, and
439
00:22:01.859 --> 00:22:05.539
which may be called the first philosophy, or metaphysics. That
440
00:22:05.559 --> 00:22:08.579
this part, accordingly, may be properly understood, it will be
441
00:22:08.680 --> 00:22:11.700
necessary to read beforehand the Book of Meditations I wrote
442
00:22:11.759 --> 00:22:15.039
on the same subject. The other three parts contain all
443
00:22:15.079 --> 00:22:18.279
that is most general in physics, namely the explication of
444
00:22:18.319 --> 00:22:20.960
the first laws or principles of nature, and the way
445
00:22:21.000 --> 00:22:24.420
in which the heavens, the fixed stars, the planets, comets,
446
00:22:24.589 --> 00:22:28.289
and generally the whole universe were composed. In the next place,
447
00:22:28.349 --> 00:22:31.450
the explication, in particular, of the nature of this earth,
448
00:22:31.650 --> 00:22:35.109
the air, water, fire, the magnet, which are the bodies
449
00:22:35.190 --> 00:22:38.200
we most commonly find everywhere around it, and of all
450
00:22:38.220 --> 00:22:42.140
the qualities we observe in those bodies, as light, heat, gravity,
451
00:22:42.240 --> 00:22:44.819
and the like. In this way, it seems to me,
452
00:22:44.839 --> 00:22:48.160
I have commenced the orderly explanation of the whole of philosophy,
453
00:22:48.589 --> 00:22:50.990
without omitting any of the matters that ought to precede
454
00:22:51.009 --> 00:22:54.029
the last which I discussed. but to bring this undertaking
455
00:22:54.069 --> 00:22:57.150
to its conclusion i ought hereafter to explain in the
456
00:22:57.190 --> 00:23:00.099
same manner the nature of the other more particular bodies
457
00:23:00.140 --> 00:23:03.579
that are on the earth namely minerals plants animals and
458
00:23:03.700 --> 00:23:08.490
especially man finally to treat thereafter with accuracy of medicine
459
00:23:08.609 --> 00:23:11.690
ethics and mechanics I should require to do this in
460
00:23:11.730 --> 00:23:14.109
order to give the world a complete body of philosophy,
461
00:23:14.569 --> 00:23:16.990
and I do not yet feel myself so old. I
462
00:23:17.029 --> 00:23:19.630
do not much distrust my strength, nor do I find
463
00:23:19.670 --> 00:23:22.259
myself so far removed from the knowledge of what remains,
464
00:23:22.640 --> 00:23:24.700
as that I should not dare to undertake to complete
465
00:23:24.740 --> 00:23:27.460
this design, provided I were in a position to make
466
00:23:27.519 --> 00:23:30.359
all the experiments which I should require for the basis
467
00:23:30.400 --> 00:23:33.930
and verification of my reasonings.
But seeing that would demand
468
00:23:33.950 --> 00:23:36.849
a great expenditure, to which the resources of a private
469
00:23:36.890 --> 00:23:40.049
individual like myself would not be adequate, unless aided by
470
00:23:40.089 --> 00:23:42.440
the public, and as I have no ground to expect
471
00:23:42.480 --> 00:23:44.880
this aid, I believe that I ought for the future
472
00:23:44.940 --> 00:23:48.220
to content myself with studying for my own instruction, and
473
00:23:48.259 --> 00:23:51.160
posterity will excuse me if I fail hereafter to labour
474
00:23:51.220 --> 00:23:54.829
for them. Meanwhile, that it may be seen wherein I
475
00:23:54.869 --> 00:23:57.529
think I have already promoted the general good, I will
476
00:23:57.589 --> 00:24:00.170
here mention the fruits that may be gathered from my principles.
477
00:24:00.740 --> 00:24:03.460
The first is the satisfaction which the mind will experience
478
00:24:03.539 --> 00:24:06.680
on finding in a work many truths before unknown, for
479
00:24:06.720 --> 00:24:10.220
although frequently truth does not so greatly affect our imagination
480
00:24:10.279 --> 00:24:13.569
as falsity and fiction, because it seems less wonderful and
481
00:24:13.609 --> 00:24:16.730
is more simple, yet the gratification it affords is always
482
00:24:16.769 --> 00:24:20.269
more durable and solid. The second fruit is that in
483
00:24:20.309 --> 00:24:23.609
studying these principles we will become accustomed by degrees to
484
00:24:23.650 --> 00:24:25.970
judge better of all the things we come in contact with.
485
00:24:26.490 --> 00:24:29.230
and thus be made wiser, in which respect the effect
486
00:24:29.269 --> 00:24:32.009
will be quite the opposite of the common philosophy, for
487
00:24:32.049 --> 00:24:34.650
we may easily remark in those we call pedants that
488
00:24:34.690 --> 00:24:37.849
it renders them less capable of rightly exercising their reason
489
00:24:38.190 --> 00:24:40.299
than they would have been if they had never known it.
490
00:24:41.099 --> 00:24:43.839
The third is that the truths which they contain, being
491
00:24:43.900 --> 00:24:47.220
highly clear and certain, will take away all ground of dispute,
492
00:24:47.599 --> 00:24:51.430
and thus dispose men's minds to gentleness and concord. whereas
493
00:24:51.470 --> 00:24:54.980
the contrary is the effect of the controversies of the schools, which,
494
00:24:55.160 --> 00:24:57.859
as they insensibly render those who are exercised in them
495
00:24:58.200 --> 00:25:01.660
more wrangling and opinionative, are perhaps the prime cause of
496
00:25:01.700 --> 00:25:05.500
the heresies and dissensions that now harass the world. The
497
00:25:05.539 --> 00:25:08.180
last and chief fruit of these principles is that one
498
00:25:08.220 --> 00:25:11.480
will be able, by cultivating them, to discover many truths
499
00:25:11.579 --> 00:25:14.869
I myself have not unfolded, and thus passing by degrees
500
00:25:14.910 --> 00:25:17.670
from one to another, to acquire in course of time
501
00:25:17.730 --> 00:25:20.289
a perfect knowledge of the whole of philosophy. and to
502
00:25:20.349 --> 00:25:23.210
rise to the highest degree of wisdom. For just as
503
00:25:23.289 --> 00:25:25.509
all the arts, though in their beginnings they are rude
504
00:25:25.569 --> 00:25:29.549
and imperfect, are yet gradually perfected by practice, from their
505
00:25:29.589 --> 00:25:33.309
containing at first something true, and whose effect experience evinces,
506
00:25:33.829 --> 00:25:36.609
so in philosophy, when we have true principles, we cannot
507
00:25:36.670 --> 00:25:39.670
fail by following them to meet sometimes with other truths,
508
00:25:40.150 --> 00:25:42.109
and we could not better prove the falsity of those
509
00:25:42.130 --> 00:25:45.190
of Aristotle than by saying that men made no progress
510
00:25:45.230 --> 00:25:47.529
in knowledge by their means during the many ages they
511
00:25:47.569 --> 00:25:51.099
prosecuted them. I well know that there are some men
512
00:25:51.170 --> 00:25:54.559
so precipitate and accustomed to use so little circumspection in
513
00:25:54.599 --> 00:25:57.559
what they do, that even with the most solid foundations
514
00:25:57.640 --> 00:26:00.619
they could not rear a firm superstructure, and as it
515
00:26:00.680 --> 00:26:02.980
is usually those who are the readiest to make books,
516
00:26:03.339 --> 00:26:05.259
they would in a short time mar all that I
517
00:26:05.299 --> 00:26:08.400
have done, and introduce uncertainty and doubt into my manner
518
00:26:08.440 --> 00:26:11.940
of philosophizing, from which I have carefully endeavored to banish them,
519
00:26:12.359 --> 00:26:14.940
if people were to receive their writings as mine, or
520
00:26:15.059 --> 00:26:18.670
as representing my opinions. I had, not long ago, some
521
00:26:18.690 --> 00:26:21.039
experience of this, in one of those who were believed
522
00:26:21.079 --> 00:26:24.480
desirous of following me the most closely, and one, too,
523
00:26:24.539 --> 00:26:26.420
of whom I had somewhere said that I had such
524
00:26:26.500 --> 00:26:29.460
confidence in his genius as to believe that he adhered
525
00:26:29.500 --> 00:26:31.480
to no opinions which I should not be ready to
526
00:26:31.559 --> 00:26:34.369
avow as mine. For he last year published a book
527
00:26:34.410 --> 00:26:37.769
entitled Fundamental Physics, in which, although he seems to have
528
00:26:37.809 --> 00:26:40.750
written nothing on the subject of physics and medicine... which
529
00:26:40.789 --> 00:26:43.109
he did not take from my writings, as well as
530
00:26:43.150 --> 00:26:45.230
from those that I have published, as from another still
531
00:26:45.309 --> 00:26:49.750
imperfect on the nature of animals, which fell into his hands. Nevertheless,
532
00:26:49.849 --> 00:26:52.450
because he has copied them badly, and changed the order,
533
00:26:52.630 --> 00:26:55.789
and denied certain metaphysical truths upon which all physics ought
534
00:26:55.809 --> 00:26:59.009
to be based, I am obliged wholly to disavow his work.
535
00:26:59.529 --> 00:27:01.990
and here to request readers not to attribute to me
536
00:27:02.150 --> 00:27:04.900
any opinion unless they find it expressly stated in my
537
00:27:04.960 --> 00:27:08.359
own writings, and to receive no opinion as true, whether
538
00:27:08.420 --> 00:27:11.079
in my writings or elsewhere, unless they see that it
539
00:27:11.160 --> 00:27:15.519
is very clearly deduced from true principles. I well know, likewise,
540
00:27:15.579 --> 00:27:18.500
that many ages may elapse ere all the truths deducible
541
00:27:18.539 --> 00:27:21.369
from these principles are evolved out of them, as well
542
00:27:21.430 --> 00:27:23.650
because the greater number of such as remain to be
543
00:27:23.670 --> 00:27:27.650
discovered depend on certain particular experiments that never occur by chance.
544
00:27:28.220 --> 00:27:31.039
but which require to be investigated with care and expense
545
00:27:31.099 --> 00:27:33.700
by men of the highest intelligence, as because it will
546
00:27:33.720 --> 00:27:36.380
hardly happen that the same persons who have the sagacity
547
00:27:36.420 --> 00:27:38.980
to make the right use of them will possess also
548
00:27:39.029 --> 00:27:41.849
the means of making them, and also because the majority
549
00:27:41.890 --> 00:27:44.069
of the best minds have formed so low an estimate
550
00:27:44.109 --> 00:27:47.210
of philosophy in general, from the imperfections they have remarked
551
00:27:47.269 --> 00:27:49.170
in the kind of vogue up to the present time,
552
00:27:49.190 --> 00:27:52.180
that they cannot apply themselves to the search after truth.
553
00:27:53.240 --> 00:27:57.029
but in conclusion if the difference discernible between the principles
554
00:27:57.069 --> 00:28:00.029
in question and those of every other system and the
555
00:28:00.069 --> 00:28:02.960
great array of truths deducible from them lead him to
556
00:28:03.000 --> 00:28:06.259
discern the importance of continuing the search after these truths
557
00:28:06.660 --> 00:28:09.339
and to observe the degree of wisdom, the perfection and
558
00:28:09.380 --> 00:28:12.359
felicity of life, to which they are fitted to conduct us,
559
00:28:12.900 --> 00:28:15.019
I venture to believe that there will not be found
560
00:28:15.240 --> 00:28:17.309
one who is not ready to labour hard in so
561
00:28:17.369 --> 00:28:20.190
profitable a study, or at least to favour and aid
562
00:28:20.230 --> 00:28:22.849
with all his might those who shall devote themselves to
563
00:28:22.910 --> 00:28:26.569
it with success. The height of my wishes is, that
564
00:28:26.609 --> 00:28:30.390
posterity may sometime behold the happy issue of it, etc.
565
00:28:30.410 --> 00:28:35.720
According by Vaughan Selections from the Principles of Philosophy by
566
00:28:35.759 --> 00:28:40.960
René Descartes, translated by John Veitch. Part 1. Of the
567
00:28:41.000 --> 00:28:46.609
Principles of Human Knowledge 1. That in order to seek truth,
568
00:28:46.829 --> 00:28:48.930
it is necessary once in the course of our life
569
00:28:49.009 --> 00:28:52.529
to doubt, as far as possible, of all things. As
570
00:28:52.569 --> 00:28:54.829
we were at one time children, and as we formed
571
00:28:54.869 --> 00:28:58.819
various judgments regarding the objects presented to our senses, when
572
00:28:58.880 --> 00:29:01.140
as yet we had not the entire use of our reason,
573
00:29:01.660 --> 00:29:04.380
numerous prejudices stand in the way of our arriving at
574
00:29:04.400 --> 00:29:07.349
the knowledge of truth. and of these it seems impossible
575
00:29:07.450 --> 00:29:10.710
for us to rid ourselves, unless we undertake, once in
576
00:29:10.779 --> 00:29:13.490
our lifetime, to doubt of all those things in which
577
00:29:13.559 --> 00:29:18.000
we may discover even the smallest suspicion of uncertainty. 2.
578
00:29:18.000 --> 00:29:21.559
That we ought also to consider as false all that
579
00:29:21.599 --> 00:29:25.819
is doubtful. Moreover, it will be useful, likewise, to esteem
580
00:29:25.880 --> 00:29:28.299
as false the things of which we shall be able
581
00:29:28.339 --> 00:29:31.359
to doubt, that we may with greater clearness discover what
582
00:29:31.400 --> 00:29:36.240
possesses most certainty and is the easiest to know. 3.
583
00:29:36.420 --> 00:29:39.410
That we ought not, meanwhile, to make use of doubt
584
00:29:39.450 --> 00:29:42.549
in the conduct of life. In the meantime, it is
585
00:29:42.569 --> 00:29:44.970
to be observed that we are to avail ourselves of
586
00:29:45.009 --> 00:29:48.559
this general doubt only while engaged in the contemplation of truth.
587
00:29:49.329 --> 00:29:52.089
For as far as concerns the conduct of life, we
588
00:29:52.150 --> 00:29:55.910
are very frequently obliged to follow opinions mere probable, or
589
00:29:55.990 --> 00:29:58.910
even sometimes, though of two courses of action, we may
590
00:29:58.950 --> 00:30:01.789
not perceive more probability in the one than in the other,
591
00:30:02.109 --> 00:30:05.150
to choose one or other, seeing the opportunity of acting
592
00:30:05.230 --> 00:30:08.349
would not unfrequently pass away before we could free ourselves
593
00:30:08.390 --> 00:30:12.789
from our doubts. 4. Why we may doubt of sensible
594
00:30:12.829 --> 00:30:17.230
things Accordingly, since we now only design to apply ourselves
595
00:30:17.289 --> 00:30:20.950
to the investigation of truth, we will doubt, first, whether
596
00:30:21.009 --> 00:30:23.529
of all the things that have ever fallen under our senses,
597
00:30:23.970 --> 00:30:26.869
or which we have ever imagined, any one really exist.
598
00:30:27.549 --> 00:30:30.190
In the first place, because we know by experience that
599
00:30:30.230 --> 00:30:33.079
the senses sometimes err,
and it would be imprudent to
600
00:30:33.140 --> 00:30:37.180
trust too much to what has even once deceived us. Secondly,
601
00:30:37.480 --> 00:30:40.440
because in dreams we perpetually seem to perceive or imagine
602
00:30:40.519 --> 00:30:44.369
innumerable objects which have no existence. and to one who
603
00:30:44.450 --> 00:30:47.309
is thus resolved upon a general doubt, there appear no
604
00:30:47.369 --> 00:30:50.490
marks by which he can with certainty distinguish sleep from
605
00:30:50.539 --> 00:30:54.900
the waking state. 5. Why we may also doubt of
606
00:30:54.960 --> 00:30:59.200
mathematical demonstrations We will also doubt of the other things
607
00:30:59.279 --> 00:31:01.960
we have before held as most certain, even of the
608
00:31:01.980 --> 00:31:05.380
demonstrations of mathematics, and of their principles, which we have
609
00:31:05.440 --> 00:31:09.119
hitherto deemed self-evident, in the first place because we have
610
00:31:09.160 --> 00:31:12.380
sometimes seen men fall into error in such matters, and
611
00:31:12.460 --> 00:31:16.240
admit as absolutely certain and self-evident what to us appeared false,
612
00:31:16.700 --> 00:31:19.380
but chiefly because we have learned that God who created
613
00:31:19.509 --> 00:31:22.569
us is all-powerful, for we do not yet know whether
614
00:31:22.589 --> 00:31:24.990
perhaps it was his will to create us so that
615
00:31:25.009 --> 00:31:27.809
we are always deceived, even in the things we think
616
00:31:27.869 --> 00:31:31.130
we know best, since this does not appear more impossible
617
00:31:31.170 --> 00:31:35.529
than our being occasionally deceived, which, however, as observation teaches us,
618
00:31:35.690 --> 00:31:38.829
is the case. And if we suppose that an all-powerful
619
00:31:38.869 --> 00:31:41.210
God is not the author of our being, and that
620
00:31:41.250 --> 00:31:44.450
we exist of ourselves by some other means, still, the
621
00:31:44.490 --> 00:31:47.430
less powerful we suppose our author to be, the greater
622
00:31:47.490 --> 00:31:49.670
reason will we have for believing that we are not
623
00:31:49.710 --> 00:31:54.630
so perfect as that we may not be continually deceived. 6.
624
00:31:55.059 --> 00:31:57.279
That we possess a free will by which we can
625
00:31:57.319 --> 00:32:00.579
withhold our assent from what is doubtful, and thus avoid error.
626
00:32:01.670 --> 00:32:04.259
But meanwhile, whoever in the end may be the author
627
00:32:04.319 --> 00:32:07.240
of our being, and however powerful and deceitful he may be,
628
00:32:07.640 --> 00:32:10.420
we are nevertheless conscious of a freedom by which we
629
00:32:10.460 --> 00:32:12.940
can refrain from admitting to a place in our belief
630
00:32:13.099 --> 00:32:16.559
ought that is not manifestly certain and undoubted, and thus
631
00:32:16.660 --> 00:32:22.049
guard against ever being deceived. 7. That we cannot doubt
632
00:32:22.089 --> 00:32:24.529
of our existence while
we doubt, and that this is
633
00:32:24.589 --> 00:32:27.349
the first knowledge we acquire when we philosophize in order.
634
00:32:28.500 --> 00:32:30.869
While we thus reject all of which we can entertain
635
00:32:30.880 --> 00:32:33.829
the smallest doubt, and even imagine that it is false,
636
00:32:34.230 --> 00:32:37.529
we easily indeed suppose that there is neither God, nor sky,
637
00:32:37.609 --> 00:32:40.829
nor bodies, and that we ourselves even have neither hands
638
00:32:40.890 --> 00:32:44.170
nor feet, nor, finally, a body, but we cannot in
639
00:32:44.210 --> 00:32:46.410
the same way suppose that we are not while we
640
00:32:46.450 --> 00:32:49.130
doubt of the truth of these things. For there is
641
00:32:49.190 --> 00:32:51.990
a repugnance in conceiving that what things does not exist
642
00:32:52.069 --> 00:32:55.569
at the very time when the things. Accordingly, the knowledge,
643
00:32:56.009 --> 00:32:58.900
I think, therefore I am, is the first and most
644
00:32:58.960 --> 00:33:04.450
certain that occurs to one who philosophizes orderly. 8. That
645
00:33:04.490 --> 00:33:07.289
we hence discover the distinction between the mind and the body,
646
00:33:07.670 --> 00:33:11.210
or between a thinking and corporeal thing. And this is
647
00:33:11.250 --> 00:33:13.509
the best mode of discovering the nature of the mind
648
00:33:13.670 --> 00:33:16.769
and its distinctness from the body. For examining that we are,
649
00:33:16.789 --> 00:33:19.710
while supposing, as we now do, that there is nothing
650
00:33:19.759 --> 00:33:23.019
really existing apart from our thought, we clearly perceive that
651
00:33:23.079 --> 00:33:27.859
neither extension, nor figure, nor locomotion, nor anything similar that
652
00:33:27.880 --> 00:33:31.200
can be attributed to body pertains to our nature, and
653
00:33:31.259 --> 00:33:35.130
nothing save thought alone, and consequently that the notion we
654
00:33:35.190 --> 00:33:38.190
have of our mind precedes that of any corporeal thing
655
00:33:38.609 --> 00:33:41.529
and is more certain, seeing we still doubt whether there
656
00:33:41.609 --> 00:33:44.759
is any body in existence while we already perceive that
657
00:33:44.779 --> 00:33:52.069
we think. 9. What thought, cogitatio, is By the word
658
00:33:52.109 --> 00:33:55.150
thought I understand all that which so takes place in
659
00:33:55.250 --> 00:33:57.990
us that we of ourselves are immediately conscious of it,
660
00:33:58.589 --> 00:34:05.190
and accordingly, not only to understand, intelligere, entendre, to will, velle,
661
00:34:05.990 --> 00:34:12.449
to imagine, imaginari, but even to perceive, sentire, sentir, are
662
00:34:12.489 --> 00:34:17.559
here the same as to think, cogitare, penser. For if
663
00:34:17.639 --> 00:34:20.539
I say, I see, or I walk, therefore I am,
664
00:34:21.429 --> 00:34:24.230
And if I understand by vision or walking the act
665
00:34:24.269 --> 00:34:26.610
of my eyes or of my limbs,
which is the
666
00:34:26.650 --> 00:34:30.409
work of the body, the conclusion is not absolutely certain, because,
667
00:34:30.610 --> 00:34:33.269
as is often the case in dreams, I may think
668
00:34:33.329 --> 00:34:35.769
that I see or walk, although I do not open
669
00:34:35.809 --> 00:34:38.789
my eyes or move from my place, and even, perhaps,
670
00:34:38.949 --> 00:34:41.730
although I have no body. But if I mean the
671
00:34:41.769 --> 00:34:45.800
sensation itself, or consciousness of seeing or walking, the knowledge
672
00:34:45.880 --> 00:34:49.199
is manifestly certain, because it is then referred to the mind,
673
00:34:49.650 --> 00:34:54.989
which alone perceives or is conscious that it sees or walks.
674
00:34:54.989 --> 00:34:55.809
10.
675
00:34:55.809 --> 00:34:59.250
That the notions which are simplest and self-evident are obscured
676
00:34:59.289 --> 00:35:02.550
by logical definitions, and that such are not to be
677
00:35:02.610 --> 00:35:05.940
reckoned among the cognitions acquired by study, but as born
678
00:35:05.980 --> 00:35:09.960
with us. I do not here explain several other terms
679
00:35:10.039 --> 00:35:12.460
which I have used or designed to use in the sequel,
680
00:35:12.920 --> 00:35:16.650
because their meaning seems to me sufficiently self-evident. And I
681
00:35:16.710 --> 00:35:20.369
frequently remarked that philosophers erred in attempting to explain, by
682
00:35:20.510 --> 00:35:24.750
logical definitions, such truths as are most simple and self-evident,
683
00:35:25.190 --> 00:35:28.389
for they thus only rendered them more obscure. And when
684
00:35:28.449 --> 00:35:31.400
I said that the proposition, I think, therefore I am,
685
00:35:31.920 --> 00:35:34.300
is of all others the first and most certain which
686
00:35:34.360 --> 00:35:38.099
occurs to one philosophizing orderly, I did not therefore deny
687
00:35:38.139 --> 00:35:40.880
that it was necessary to know what thought, existence, and
688
00:35:40.920 --> 00:35:43.880
certitude are, and the truth that, in order to think,
689
00:35:44.000 --> 00:35:47.530
it is necessary to be, and the like. But because
690
00:35:47.570 --> 00:35:50.219
these are the most simple notions, and such as of
691
00:35:50.280 --> 00:35:53.559
themselves afford the knowledge of nothing existing, I did not
692
00:35:53.599 --> 00:35:58.510
judge it proper there to enumerate them. 11. How we
693
00:35:58.550 --> 00:36:02.039
can know our mind more clearly than our body but
694
00:36:02.099 --> 00:36:04.239
now that it may be discerned how the knowledge we
695
00:36:04.300 --> 00:36:07.679
have of the mind not only precedes and has greater certainty,
696
00:36:08.070 --> 00:36:10.389
but is even clearer than that we have of the body,
697
00:36:10.889 --> 00:36:13.210
it must be remarked as a matter that is highly
698
00:36:13.250 --> 00:36:16.750
manifest by the natural light, that to nothing no affections
699
00:36:16.809 --> 00:36:21.369
or qualities belong,
and accordingly that where we observe certain affections,
700
00:36:21.769 --> 00:36:24.269
there a thing or substance to which these pertain is
701
00:36:24.309 --> 00:36:28.360
necessarily found. The same light also shows us that we
702
00:36:28.400 --> 00:36:31.599
know a thing or substance more clearly in proportion as
703
00:36:31.639 --> 00:36:35.320
we discover in it a greater number of qualities. Now
704
00:36:35.400 --> 00:36:37.699
it is manifest that we remark a greater number of
705
00:36:37.739 --> 00:36:40.829
qualities in our mind than in any other thing, for
706
00:36:40.849 --> 00:36:43.289
there is no occasion on which we know anything whatever
707
00:36:43.429 --> 00:36:45.510
when we are not at the same time led with
708
00:36:45.570 --> 00:36:48.469
much greater certainty to the knowledge of our own mind.
709
00:36:49.360 --> 00:36:51.590
For example, if I judge that there is an earth
710
00:36:51.659 --> 00:36:54.260
because I touch or see it, on the same ground
711
00:36:54.320 --> 00:36:57.070
and with still greater reason, I must be persuaded that
712
00:36:57.110 --> 00:37:00.030
my mind exists, for it may be, perhaps, that I
713
00:37:00.150 --> 00:37:02.769
think I touch the earth while there is one in existence,
714
00:37:03.329 --> 00:37:05.670
but it is not possible that I should so judge,
715
00:37:06.090 --> 00:37:09.230
and my mind which thus judges not exist, and the
716
00:37:09.269 --> 00:37:14.250
same holds good of whatever object is presented to our mind. 12.
717
00:37:14.789 --> 00:37:17.730
How it happens that everyone does not come equally to notice.
718
00:37:18.989 --> 00:37:21.690
those who have not philosophized in order have had other
719
00:37:21.769 --> 00:37:25.219
opinions on this subject, because they never distinguished with sufficient
720
00:37:25.280 --> 00:37:28.199
care the mind from the body. For although they had
721
00:37:28.260 --> 00:37:31.659
no difficulty in believing that they themselves existed, and that
722
00:37:31.699 --> 00:37:35.760
they had a higher assurance of this than any other thing, nevertheless,
723
00:37:35.960 --> 00:37:38.889
as they did not observe that by themselves they ought
724
00:37:38.949 --> 00:37:42.570
here to understand their minds alone, when the question related
725
00:37:42.610 --> 00:37:46.780
to metaphysical certainty. and since, on the contrary, they rather
726
00:37:46.820 --> 00:37:49.400
meant their bodies which they saw with their eyes, touched
727
00:37:49.420 --> 00:37:52.340
with their hands, and to which they erroneously attributed the
728
00:37:52.380 --> 00:37:56.239
faculty of perception, they were prevented from distinctly apprehending the
729
00:37:56.280 --> 00:37:57.170
nature of the mind.
730
00:37:57.170 --> 00:37:58.929
13.
731
00:37:58.929 --> 00:38:02.869
In what sense the knowledge of other things depends upon
732
00:38:02.929 --> 00:38:06.320
the knowledge of God? But when the mind, which thus
733
00:38:06.380 --> 00:38:08.679
knows itself but is still in doubt as to all
734
00:38:08.780 --> 00:38:11.960
other things, looks around on all sides, with a view
735
00:38:12.039 --> 00:38:14.610
to the farther extension of its knowledge, it first of
736
00:38:14.659 --> 00:38:18.230
all discovers within itself the ideas of many things, and
737
00:38:18.269 --> 00:38:21.730
while it simply contemplates them, and neither affirms nor denies
738
00:38:21.769 --> 00:38:24.929
that there is anything beyond itself corresponding to them, it
739
00:38:24.989 --> 00:38:28.489
is in no danger of erring. The mind also discovers
740
00:38:28.530 --> 00:38:31.960
certain common notions out of which it frames various demonstrations
741
00:38:32.019 --> 00:38:34.610
that carry conviction to such a degree that as to
742
00:38:34.670 --> 00:38:37.849
render doubt of their truth impossible, so long as we
743
00:38:37.869 --> 00:38:41.679
give attention to them. For example, the mind has within
744
00:38:41.719 --> 00:38:44.980
itself ideas of numbers and figures, and it has likewise
745
00:38:45.059 --> 00:38:48.480
among its common notions the principle that if equals be
746
00:38:48.579 --> 00:38:52.239
added to equals, the wholes will be equal, and the like,
747
00:38:52.980 --> 00:38:55.219
from which it is easy to demonstrate that the three
748
00:38:55.320 --> 00:38:58.630
angles of a triangle are equal to two right angles, etc.,
749
00:38:59.909 --> 00:39:02.050
now so long as we attend to the premises from
750
00:39:02.070 --> 00:39:05.010
which this conclusion and others similar to it were deduced
751
00:39:05.190 --> 00:39:07.840
we feel assured of their truth but as the mind
752
00:39:07.920 --> 00:39:11.000
cannot always think of these with attention when it has
753
00:39:11.039 --> 00:39:14.280
the remembrance of a conclusion without recollecting the order of
754
00:39:14.340 --> 00:39:17.469
its deduction and is uncertain whether the author of its
755
00:39:17.510 --> 00:39:20.170
being has created it of a nature that is liable
756
00:39:20.230 --> 00:39:23.650
to be deceived even in what appears most evident It
757
00:39:23.730 --> 00:39:26.539
perceives that there is just ground to distrust the truth
758
00:39:26.579 --> 00:39:29.969
of such conclusions, and that it cannot possess any certain knowledge.
759
00:39:30.260 --> 00:39:31.920
until it has discovered its author.
760
00:39:31.920 --> 00:39:33.739
14.
761
00:39:33.739 --> 00:39:37.670
That we may validly infer the existence of God from
762
00:39:37.710 --> 00:39:41.210
necessary existence being comprised in the concept we have of him.
763
00:39:42.329 --> 00:39:45.260
When the mind afterwards reviews the different ideas that are
764
00:39:45.320 --> 00:39:47.710
in it, it discovers what is by far the chief
765
00:39:47.769 --> 00:39:52.510
among them, that of a being omniscient, all-powerful, and absolutely perfect,
766
00:39:53.050 --> 00:39:55.610
and it observes that in this idea there is contained
767
00:39:55.630 --> 00:39:59.429
not only possible and contingent existence, as in the ideas
768
00:39:59.489 --> 00:40:02.960
of all other things which it clearly perceives, but existence
769
00:40:03.079 --> 00:40:07.320
absolutely necessary and eternal. And just as because, for example,
770
00:40:07.440 --> 00:40:10.119
the equality of its three angles to two right angles
771
00:40:10.219 --> 00:40:13.510
is necessarily comprised in the idea of a triangle, the
772
00:40:13.550 --> 00:40:16.210
mind is firmly persuaded that the three angles of a
773
00:40:16.230 --> 00:40:19.829
triangle are equal to two right angles. So, from its
774
00:40:19.909 --> 00:40:23.550
perceiving necessary and eternal existence to be comprised in the
775
00:40:23.610 --> 00:40:26.489
idea which it has of an all-perfect being, it ought
776
00:40:26.570 --> 00:40:29.889
manifestly to conclude that this all-perfect being exists.
777
00:40:29.889 --> 00:40:31.889
15.
778
00:40:32.880 --> 00:40:35.829
That necessary existence is not in the same way comprised
779
00:40:35.929 --> 00:40:38.429
in the notions which we have of other things but
780
00:40:38.489 --> 00:40:42.989
merely contingent existence the mind will be still more certain
781
00:40:43.030 --> 00:40:45.760
of the truth of this conclusion if it considers that
782
00:40:45.800 --> 00:40:47.900
it has no idea of any other thing in which
783
00:40:47.940 --> 00:40:52.010
it can discover that necessary existence is contained For, from
784
00:40:52.070 --> 00:40:54.949
this circumstance alone, it will discern that the idea of
785
00:40:54.989 --> 00:40:58.250
an all-perfect being has not been framed by itself, and
786
00:40:58.269 --> 00:41:00.909
that it does not represent a chimera, but a true
787
00:41:00.989 --> 00:41:04.429
and immutable nature, which must exist since it can only
788
00:41:04.489 --> 00:41:10.909
be conceived as necessarily existing. Of the Principles of Human
789
00:41:10.949 --> 00:41:17.059
Knowledge 16. That prejudices hinder many from clearly knowing the
790
00:41:17.119 --> 00:41:21.159
necessity of the existence of God. our mind would have
791
00:41:21.239 --> 00:41:24.159
no difficulty in ascending to this truth if it were,
792
00:41:24.320 --> 00:41:28.309
first of all, wholly free from prejudices. But as we
793
00:41:28.349 --> 00:41:31.610
have been accustomed to distinguish, in all other things, essence
794
00:41:31.650 --> 00:41:35.130
from existence, and to imagine at will many ideas of
795
00:41:35.190 --> 00:41:38.780
things which neither are nor have been, it easily happens,
796
00:41:38.900 --> 00:41:41.000
when we do not steadily fix our thoughts on the
797
00:41:41.059 --> 00:41:44.940
contemplation of the all-perfect being, that a doubt arises as
798
00:41:44.980 --> 00:41:47.260
to whether the idea we have of him is not
799
00:41:47.320 --> 00:41:49.690
one of those which we frame with pleasure, or at
800
00:41:49.750 --> 00:41:52.869
least of that class to whose essence existence does
not pertain.
801
00:41:52.869 --> 00:41:54.789
17.
802
00:41:54.789 --> 00:41:59.119
That the greater objective representative perfection there is in our
803
00:41:59.219 --> 00:42:01.679
idea of a thing, the greater also must be the
804
00:42:01.699 --> 00:42:05.420
perfection of its cause. When we further reflect on the
805
00:42:05.460 --> 00:42:07.780
various ideas that are in us, it is easy to
806
00:42:07.840 --> 00:42:10.679
perceive that there is not much difference among them. when
807
00:42:10.699 --> 00:42:13.500
we consider them simply as certain modes of thinking, but
808
00:42:13.539 --> 00:42:16.340
that they are widely different, considered in reference to the
809
00:42:16.420 --> 00:42:19.300
objects they represent, and that their causes must be so
810
00:42:19.340 --> 00:42:22.280
much the more perfect according to the degree of objective
811
00:42:22.340 --> 00:42:26.119
perfection contained in them. For there is no difference between
812
00:42:26.159 --> 00:42:27.980
this and the case of a person who has the
813
00:42:28.059 --> 00:42:31.159
idea of a machine, in the construction of which great
814
00:42:31.199 --> 00:42:34.300
skill is displayed, in which circumstances we have a right
815
00:42:34.340 --> 00:42:37.730
to inquire how he came by this idea, whether, for example,
816
00:42:37.829 --> 00:42:41.110
he somewhere saw such a machine constructed by another, or
817
00:42:41.130 --> 00:42:44.349
whether he was so accurately taught the mechanical sciences, or
818
00:42:44.429 --> 00:42:46.929
is endowed with such force of genius that he was
819
00:42:47.050 --> 00:42:50.289
able of himself to invent it, without having elsewhere seen
820
00:42:50.409 --> 00:42:53.690
anything like it. For all the ingenuity which is contained
821
00:42:53.750 --> 00:42:56.650
in the idea, objectively only, or as it were in
822
00:42:56.670 --> 00:42:59.469
a picture, must exist at least in its first and
823
00:42:59.510 --> 00:43:03.849
chief cause, whatever that may be, not only objectively or representatively,
824
00:43:04.110 --> 00:43:09.579
but in truth formally or eminently. Thus, because we discover
825
00:43:09.599 --> 00:43:10.900
in our minds the idea of God, or of an
826
00:43:10.920 --> 00:43:20.480
all-perfect being, we have a right to inquire into the
827
00:43:20.539 --> 00:43:23.349
source whence we derive it, and we will discover that
828
00:43:23.389 --> 00:43:26.469
the perfections it represents are so immense as to render
829
00:43:26.530 --> 00:43:28.909
it quite certain that we could only derive it from
830
00:43:28.969 --> 00:43:32.630
an all-perfect being, that is, from a God really existing.
831
00:43:33.389 --> 00:43:35.940
For it is not only manifest by the natural light
832
00:43:36.019 --> 00:43:39.039
that nothing cannot be the cause of anything whatever, and
833
00:43:39.059 --> 00:43:41.940
that the more perfect cannot arise from the less perfect,
834
00:43:42.380 --> 00:43:44.980
so as to be thereby produced
as by its sufficient
835
00:43:45.019 --> 00:43:48.030
and total cost, but also that it is impossible we
836
00:43:48.070 --> 00:43:51.530
can have the idea or representation of anything whatever unless
837
00:43:51.550 --> 00:43:54.170
there be somewhere, either in us or out of us,
838
00:43:54.679 --> 00:43:58.780
an original which comprises, in reality, all the perfections that
839
00:43:58.820 --> 00:44:01.840
are thus represented to us. But as we do not
840
00:44:01.900 --> 00:44:04.860
in any way find in ourselves those absolute perfections of
841
00:44:04.900 --> 00:44:07.449
which we have the idea, we must conclude that they
842
00:44:07.489 --> 00:44:11.329
exist in some nature different from ours, that is, in God,
843
00:44:11.769 --> 00:44:13.829
or at least that they were once in him. and
844
00:44:13.869 --> 00:44:17.369
it most manifestly follows, from their infinity, that they are
845
00:44:17.409 --> 00:44:17.989
still there.
846
00:44:17.989 --> 00:44:19.969
19.
847
00:44:19.969 --> 00:44:24.389
That, although we may not comprehend the nature of God,
848
00:44:24.719 --> 00:44:26.980
there is yet nothing which we know so clearly as
849
00:44:27.039 --> 00:44:31.840
his perfections. This will appear sufficiently certain and manifest to
850
00:44:31.880 --> 00:44:34.760
those who have been accustomed to contemplate the idea of God,
851
00:44:35.280 --> 00:44:38.300
and to turn their thoughts to his infinite perfections. For
852
00:44:38.380 --> 00:44:40.699
although we may not comprehend them, because it is of
853
00:44:40.739 --> 00:44:43.219
the nature of the infinite not to be comprehended by
854
00:44:43.260 --> 00:44:46.780
what is finite, we nevertheless conceive them more clearly and
855
00:44:46.820 --> 00:44:51.000
distinctly than material objects, for this reason that, being simple
856
00:44:51.440 --> 00:44:54.559
and unobscured by limits, they occupy their mind more fully.
857
00:44:54.559 --> 00:44:56.400
20.
858
00:44:56.400 --> 00:44:59.800
That we are not the cause of ourselves, but that
859
00:44:59.840 --> 00:45:02.570
this is God, and consequently that there is a God.
860
00:45:03.639 --> 00:45:07.280
But because everyone has not observed this, and because, when
861
00:45:07.320 --> 00:45:09.710
we have an idea of any machine in which great
862
00:45:09.809 --> 00:45:13.670
skill is displayed, we usually know with sufficient accuracy the
863
00:45:13.710 --> 00:45:16.130
manner in which we obtained it, and as we cannot
864
00:45:16.230 --> 00:45:18.730
even recollect when the idea we have of a god
865
00:45:18.750 --> 00:45:22.030
was communicated to us by him, seeing it was always
866
00:45:22.070 --> 00:45:24.670
in our minds, it is still necessary that we should
867
00:45:24.710 --> 00:45:29.059
continue our review and make inquiry after our author, possessing,
868
00:45:29.179 --> 00:45:31.820
as we do, the idea of the infinite perfections of
869
00:45:31.860 --> 00:45:34.840
a god. For it is in the highest degree evident
870
00:45:34.929 --> 00:45:37.730
by the natural light that that which knows something more
871
00:45:37.769 --> 00:45:40.650
perfect than itself is not the source of its own being,
872
00:45:41.010 --> 00:45:43.210
since it would thus have given to itself all the
873
00:45:43.250 --> 00:45:46.909
perfections which it knows, and that consequently it could draw
874
00:45:46.949 --> 00:45:49.659
its origin from no other being than from him who
875
00:45:49.699 --> 00:45:53.739
possesses in himself all those perfections, that is, from God.
876
00:45:53.739 --> 00:45:55.739
21.
877
00:45:56.860 --> 00:45:59.420
That the duration alone of our life is sufficient to
878
00:45:59.460 --> 00:46:03.989
demonstrate the existence of God. the truth of this demonstration
879
00:46:04.030 --> 00:46:07.429
will clearly appear, provided we consider the nature of time,
880
00:46:07.610 --> 00:46:10.309
or the duration of things. For this is of such
881
00:46:10.349 --> 00:46:13.150
a kind that its parts are not mutually dependent, and
882
00:46:13.190 --> 00:46:17.309
never co-existent. And accordingly, from the fact that we now are,
883
00:46:17.789 --> 00:46:19.969
it does not necessarily follow that we shall be a
884
00:46:20.030 --> 00:46:24.039
moment afterwards, unless some cause, that is, that which first
885
00:46:24.079 --> 00:46:28.519
produced us, shall, as it were, continually reproduce us, that is,
886
00:46:28.639 --> 00:46:32.250
conserve us. For we easily understand that there is no
887
00:46:32.309 --> 00:46:35.210
power in us by which we can conserve ourselves, and
888
00:46:35.250 --> 00:46:37.130
that the being who has so much power as to
889
00:46:37.170 --> 00:46:40.289
conserve us out of himself, must also by so much
890
00:46:40.329 --> 00:46:43.730
the greater reason conserve himself, or rather stand in need
891
00:46:43.769 --> 00:46:46.769
of being conserved by no one whatever, and, in fine,
892
00:46:46.989 --> 00:46:49.949
be God.
893
00:46:49.949 --> 00:46:50.949
22.
894
00:46:50.949 --> 00:46:53.699
That in knowing the existence of God, in the manner
895
00:46:53.739 --> 00:46:57.300
here explained, we likewise know all his attributes as far
896
00:46:57.360 --> 00:46:59.619
as they can be known by the natural light alone.
897
00:47:00.869 --> 00:47:03.349
There is a great advantage in proving the existence of
898
00:47:03.389 --> 00:47:06.429
God in this way, that is, by his idea, that
899
00:47:06.489 --> 00:47:08.739
we at the same time know what he is, as
900
00:47:08.800 --> 00:47:12.280
far as the weakness of our nature allows. For, reflecting
901
00:47:12.340 --> 00:47:14.400
on the idea we have of him, which is born
902
00:47:14.460 --> 00:47:18.380
with us, we perceive that he is eternal, omniscient, omnipotent,
903
00:47:18.599 --> 00:47:21.800
the source of all goodness and truth, creator of all things,
904
00:47:22.320 --> 00:47:25.340
and that, in fine... He has in himself all that
905
00:47:25.500 -->
00:47:28.860
in which we can clearly discover any infinite perfection or
906
00:47:28.920 --> 00:47:31.539
good that is not limited by any imperfection.
907
00:47:31.539 --> 00:47:33.539
23.
908
00:47:33.599 --> 00:47:37.489
That God is not corporeal, and does not perceive by
909
00:47:37.550 --> 00:47:40.230
means of senses as we do, or will the evil
910
00:47:40.289 --> 00:47:44.050
of sin. For there are indeed many things in the
911
00:47:44.090 --> 00:47:47.449
world that are to a certain extent imperfect or limited,
912
00:47:47.869 --> 00:47:51.989
though possessing also some perfection, and it is accordingly impossible
913
00:47:52.030 --> 00:47:56.239
that any such can be Goded. Thus, looking to corporeal nature,
914
00:47:56.719 --> 00:48:01.510
since divisibility is included in local extension, and this indicates imperfection,
915
00:48:01.750 --> 00:48:04.929
it is certain that God is not body. And although
916
00:48:04.989 --> 00:48:07.309
in men it is to some degree a perfection to
917
00:48:07.349 --> 00:48:11.030
be capable of perceiving by means of the senses, nevertheless,
918
00:48:11.090 --> 00:48:14.699
since in every sense there is passivity, which indicates dependency,
919
00:48:15.039 --> 00:48:17.500
we must conclude that God is in no manner possessed
920
00:48:17.539 --> 00:48:21.519
of senses, and that he only understands and wills, not, however,
921
00:48:21.539 --> 00:48:25.579
like us, by acts in any way distinct, but always
922
00:48:25.639 --> 00:48:30.530
by an act that is one, identical, and the simplest possible, understands, wills,
923
00:48:30.610 --> 00:48:34.550
and operates all, that is, all things that in reality exist.
924
00:48:35.210 --> 00:48:37.650
For he does not will the evil of sin, seeing
925
00:48:37.670 --> 00:48:39.489
this is but denigration of being.
926
00:48:39.489 --> 00:48:41.050
24.
927
00:48:41.050 --> 00:48:44.869
That in passing from the knowledge of God to the
928
00:48:44.909 --> 00:48:47.920
knowledge of the creatures, it is necessary to remember that
929
00:48:48.000 --> 00:48:51.480
our understanding is finite, and the power of God infinite.
930
00:48:52.769 --> 00:48:54.789
But as we know that God alone is the true
931
00:48:54.849 --> 00:48:57.260
cause of all that is or can be, we will
932
00:48:57.300 --> 00:49:00.760
doubtless follow the best way of philosophizing if, from the
933
00:49:00.800 --> 00:49:03.519
knowledge we have of God himself, we pass to the
934
00:49:03.619 --> 00:49:07.000
explication of the things which he has created, and essay
935
00:49:07.039 --> 00:49:09.400
to deduce it from the notions that are naturally in
936
00:49:09.460 --> 00:49:12.789
our minds, for we will thus obtain the most perfect science,
937
00:49:13.309 --> 00:49:16.769
that is, the knowledge of effects through their causes. But
938
00:49:16.809 --> 00:49:18.789
that we may be able to make this attempt with
939
00:49:18.829 --> 00:49:22.300
sufficient security for error, we must use the
precaution to
940
00:49:22.340 --> 00:49:25.300
bear in mind as much as possible that God, who
941
00:49:25.380 --> 00:49:28.340
is the author of things, is infinite while we are
942
00:49:28.360 --> 00:49:31.550
wholly finite.
943
00:49:31.550 --> 00:49:32.349
25.
944
00:49:32.349 --> 00:49:35.250
That we must believe all that God has revealed, although
945
00:49:35.289 --> 00:49:38.820
it may surpass the reach of our faculties. Thus, if
946
00:49:38.900 --> 00:49:42.519
perhaps God revealed to us or others matters concerning himself
947
00:49:42.599 --> 00:49:45.539
which surpass the natural powers of our mind, such as
948
00:49:45.599 --> 00:49:48.800
the mysteries of the Incarnation and of the Trinity, we
949
00:49:48.820 --> 00:49:51.530
will not refuse to believe them, although we may not
950
00:49:51.590 --> 00:49:54.809
clearly understand them. Nor will we be in any way
951
00:49:54.849 --> 00:49:57.869
surprised to find in the immensity of his nature, or
952
00:49:57.969 --> 00:50:00.949
even in what he has created, many things that exceed
953
00:50:01.010 --> 00:50:01.820
our comprehension.
954
00:50:01.820 --> 00:50:03.820
26.
955
00:50:04.710 --> 00:50:07.630
That it is not needful to enter into disputes regarding
956
00:50:07.670 --> 00:50:10.449
the infinite, but merely to hold all that in which
957
00:50:10.510 --> 00:50:13.650
we can find no limits as indefinite, such as the
958
00:50:13.710 --> 00:50:17.079
extension of the world, the divisibility of the parts of matter,
959
00:50:17.400 --> 00:50:21.360
the number of the stars, etc. We will thus never
960
00:50:21.440 --> 00:50:24.960
embarrass ourselves by disputes about the infinite, seeing it would
961
00:50:25.000 --> 00:50:28.260
be absurd for us, who are finite, to undertake to
962
00:50:28.300 --> 00:50:31.360
determine anything regarding it, and thus as it were to
963
00:50:31.420 --> 00:50:35.280
limit it by endeavouring to comprehend it. we will accordingly
964
00:50:35.360 --> 00:50:38.260
give ourselves no concern to reply to those who demand
965
00:50:38.579 --> 00:50:41.280
whether the half of an infinite line is also infinite,
966
00:50:41.840 --> 00:50:44.900
and whether an infinite number is even or odd, and
967
00:50:44.940 --> 00:50:47.679
the like, because it is only such as imagine their
968
00:50:47.699 --> 00:50:50.829
minds to be infinite who seem bound to entertain questions
969
00:50:50.889 --> 00:50:53.929
of this sort. And for our part, looking to all
970
00:50:53.949 --> 00:50:57.030
those things in which in certain senses we discover no limits,
971
00:50:57.449 --> 00:51:00.590
we will not, therefore, affirm that they are infinite, but
972
00:51:00.639 --> 00:51:04.739
will regard them simply as indefinite. Thus, because we cannot
973
00:51:04.840 --> 00:51:08.329
imagine extension so great that we cannot still conceive greater,
974
00:51:08.349 --> 00:51:12.190
we will say that the magnitude of possible things is indefinite,
975
00:51:12.670 --> 00:51:15.170
and because a body cannot be divided into parts so
976
00:51:15.230 --> 00:51:17.940
small that each of these may not be conceived as
977
00:51:18.000 --> 00:51:22.099
again divided into others still smaller, let us regard quantity
978
00:51:22.199 --> 00:51:26.539
as divisible into parts whose number is indefinite. And as
979
00:51:26.579 --> 00:51:28.949
we cannot imagine so many stars that it would seem
980
00:51:29.010 --> 00:51:32.119
impossible for God to create more, let us suppose that
981
00:51:32.139 --> 00:51:37.659
their number is indefinite, and so in other instances.
982
00:51:37.659 --> 00:51:38.599
27.
983
00:51:38.599 --> 00:51:41.599
What difference there is between the indefinite and the infinite?
984
00:51:42.599 --> 00:51:45.519
And we will call those things indefinite rather than infinite,
985
00:51:45.900 --> 00:51:48.659
with the view of reserving to God alone the appellation
986
00:51:48.699 --> 00:51:52.079
of infinite. In the first place, because not only do
987
00:51:52.119 --> 00:51:54.920
we discover in him alone no limits on any side,
988
00:51:55.260 --> 00:51:58.659
but also because we positively conceive that he admits of none.
989
00:51:59.340 --> 00:52:01.679
And in the second place... because we do not in
990
00:52:01.699 --> 00:52:04.760
the same way positively conceive that other things are in
991
00:52:04.840 --> 00:52:08.579
every part unlimited, but merely negatively admit that their limits,
992
00:52:08.880 --> 00:52:11.300
if they have any, cannot be discovered by us.
993
00:52:11.300 --> 00:52:13.260
28.
994
00:52:13.260 --> 00:52:17.070
That we must examine not the final, but the efficient
995
00:52:17.119 --> 00:52:21.949
causes of created things. Likewise, finally, we will not seek
996
00:52:22.030 --> 00:52:24.570
reasons of natural things from the end which God or
997
00:52:24.610 --> 00:52:28.630
nature proposed to himself in their creation, that is, final causes.
998
00:52:28.630 --> 00:52:29.519
29.
999
00:52:29.519 --> 00:52:31.599
For we ought not to presume so far as to
1000
00:52:31.639 --> 00:52:34.099
think that we are sharers in the counsels of deity,
1001
00:52:34.659 --> 00:52:37.500
but considering him as the efficient cause of all things,
1002
00:52:38.039 --> 00:52:40.719
let us endeavour to discover by the natural light which
1003
00:52:40.760 --> 00:52:43.360
he has planted in us, applied to those of his
1004
00:52:43.440 --> 00:52:45.599
attributes of which he has been willing we should have
1005
00:52:45.639 --> 00:52:49.110
some knowledge, what must be concluded regarding those effects we
1006
00:52:49.139 --> 00:52:52.869
perceive by our senses. Bearing in mind, however, what has
1007
00:52:52.909 --> 00:52:55.699
already been said, that we must only confide in this
1008
00:52:55.719 --> 00:52:59.300
natural light so long as nothing contrary to its dictates
1009
00:52:59.400 --> 00:53:04.980
is revealed by God himself. 29. That God is not
1010
00:53:05.019 -->
00:53:09.019
the cause of our errors. The first attribute of God
1011
00:53:09.079 --> 00:53:11.400
which here falls to be considered is that he is
1012
00:53:11.519 --> 00:53:14.840
absolutely voracious and the source of all light, so that
1013
00:53:14.969 --> 00:53:17.909
it is plainly repugnant for him to deceive us, or
1014
00:53:17.969 --> 00:53:20.750
to be properly and positively the cause of the errors
1015
00:53:21.150 --> 00:53:22.889
to which we are consciously subject.
1016
00:53:22.889 --> 00:53:23.630
30.
1017
00:53:23.630 --> 00:53:25.630
That consequently all which we clearly perceive is true, and
1018
00:53:25.670 --> 00:53:27.369
that we are thus delivered from the doubts above proposed.
1019
00:53:46.179 --> 00:53:49.099
whence it follows that the light of nature, or faculty
1020
00:53:49.159 --> 00:53:52.400
of knowledge given us by God, can never compass any
1021
00:53:52.539 --> 00:53:55.119
object which is not true, in as far as it
1022
00:53:55.179 --> 00:53:57.860
attains to a knowledge of it, that is, in as
1023
00:53:57.920 --> 00:54:01.750
far as the object is clearly and distinctly apprehended. For
1024
00:54:01.809 --> 00:54:04.389
God would have merited the appellation of a deceiver if
1025
00:54:04.409 --> 00:54:07.409
he had given us this faculty perverted, and such as
1026
00:54:07.469 --> 00:54:10.250
might lead us to take falsity for truth, when we
1027
00:54:10.329 --> 00:54:13.969
used it aright. Thus the highest doubt is removed, which
1028
00:54:14.030 --> 00:54:16.570
arose from our ignorance on the point as to whether
1029
00:54:16.639 --> 00:54:19.739
perhaps our nature was such that we might be deceived
1030
00:54:19.960 --> 00:54:22.360
even in those things that appear to us most evident.
1031
00:54:23.340 --> 00:54:26.059
The same principle ought also to be of avail against
1032
00:54:26.159 --> 00:54:29.280
all the other grounds of doubting that have already been enumerated.
1033
00:54:30.159 --> 00:54:33.409
For mathematical truths ought now to be above suspicion, since
1034
00:54:33.449 --> 00:54:36.730
these are of the clearest, and if we perceive anything
1035
00:54:36.769 --> 00:54:39.960
by our senses, whether while awake or asleep, We will
1036
00:54:40.039 --> 00:54:43.139
easily discover the truth, provided we separate what there is
1037
00:54:43.199 --> 00:54:45.739
of clear and distinct in the knowledge from what is
1038
00:54:45.780 --> 00:54:49.219
obscure and confused. There is no need that I should
1039
00:54:49.260 --> 00:54:52.130
here say more on this subject, since it has already
1040
00:54:52.170 --> 00:54:56.489
received ample treatment in the metaphysical meditations, and what follows
1041
00:54:56.530 --> 00:54:59.829
will serve to explain it still more accurately. Of the
1042
00:54:59.869 --> 00:55:04.630
Principles of Human Knowledge 31 that our errors are, in
1043
00:55:04.690 --> 00:55:09.710
respect of God, merely negations, but in respect of ourselves, privations.
1044
00:55:10.750 --> 00:55:13.340
But as it happens that we frequently fall into error,
1045
00:55:13.679 --> 00:55:16.880
although God is no deceiver, if we desire to inquire
1046
00:55:16.980 --> 00:55:19.539
into the origin and cause of our errors, with a
1047
00:55:19.579 --> 00:55:22.719
view to guard against them, it is necessary to observe
1048
00:55:22.800 --> 00:55:25.809
that they depend less on our understanding than on our will,
1049
00:55:26.230 --> 00:55:28.409
and that they have no need of the actual concourse
1050
00:55:28.449 --> 00:55:31.920
of God in order to their production. so that, when
1051
00:55:31.980 --> 00:55:35.489
considered in reference to God, they are merely negations, but
1052
00:55:35.530 --> 00:55:37.760
in reference to ourselves, privations.
1053
00:55:37.760 --> 00:55:39.760
32.
1054
00:55:39.909 --> 00:55:43.489
That there are only two modes of thinking in us,
1055
00:55:43.670 --> 00:55:46.489
that is, the perception of the understanding and the action
1056
00:55:46.510 --> 00:55:49.289
of the will. For all the modes of thinking of
1057
00:55:49.329 --> 00:55:52.570
which we are conscious may be referred to two general classes,
1058
00:55:53.010 --> 00:55:55.570
the one of which is the perception or operation of
1059
00:55:55.610 --> 00:55:58.989
the understanding, and the other the volition or operation of
1060
00:55:59.030 --> 00:56:03.389
the will. Thus to perceive by the senses, sentire, to
1061
00:56:03.489 --> 00:56:07.690
imagine and to conceive things purely intelligible, are only different
1062
00:56:07.730 --> 00:56:12.750
modes of perceiving, percipiendi, but to desire, to be averse from,
1063
00:56:12.949 --> 00:56:16.769
to affirm, to deny, to doubt, are different modes of willing.
1064
00:56:16.769 --> 00:56:18.469
33.
1065
00:56:18.469 --> 00:56:22.269
That we never err unless when we judge of something
1066
00:56:22.309 --> 00:56:26.420
which we do not sufficiently apprehend. When we apprehend anything
1067
00:56:26.539 --> 00:56:28.940
we are in no danger of error if we refrain
1068
00:56:28.980 --> 00:56:31.599
from judging of it in any way, and even when
1069
00:56:31.639 --> 00:56:34.400
we have formed a judgment regarding it, we would never
1070
00:56:34.460 --> 00:56:37.599
fall into error, provided we gave our assent only to
1071
00:56:37.639 --> 00:56:41.110
what we clearly and distinctly perceived. But the reason why
1072
00:56:41.170 --> 00:56:44.150
we are usually deceived is that we judge without possessing
1073
00:56:44.210 --> 00:56:46.329
an exact knowledge of that of which we judge.
1074
00:56:46.329 --> 00:56:48.210
34.
1075
00:56:48.210 --> 00:56:52.190
That the will as well as the understanding is required
1076
00:56:52.230 --> 00:57:24.769
for judging. that the will is of greater extension than
1077
00:57:24.789 --> 00:57:29.210
the understanding, and is thus the source of our errors. Further,
1078
00:57:29.389 --> 00:57:31.949
the perception of the intellect extends only to
the few
1079
00:57:32.030 --> 00:57:35.289
things that are presented to it, and is always very limited.
1080
00:57:35.869 --> 00:57:38.030
The will, on the other hand, may in a certain
1081
00:57:38.090 --> 00:57:41.489
sense be said to be infinite, because we observe nothing
1082
00:57:41.530 --> 00:57:43.750
that can be the object of the will of any other,
1083
00:57:44.309 --> 00:57:47.289
even of the unlimited will of God, to which ours
1084
00:57:47.349 --> 00:57:50.820
cannot also extend, so that we easily carry it beyond
1085
00:57:50.860 --> 00:57:53.820
the objects we clearly perceive. And when we do this,
1086
00:57:53.960 --> 00:57:56.280
it is not wonderful that we happen to be deceived.
1087
00:57:56.280 --> 00:57:57.900
36.
1088
00:57:57.900 --> 00:58:02.760
That our errors cannot be imputed to God. But although
1089
00:58:02.800 --> 00:58:06.219
God has not given us an omniscient understanding, he is
1090
00:58:06.260 --> 00:58:08.800
not on this account to be considered in any wise
1091
00:58:08.860 --> 00:58:11.380
the author of our errors, for it is of the
1092
00:58:11.420 --> 00:58:14.679
nature of created intellect to be finite, and of finite
1093
00:58:14.739 --> 00:58:16.789
intellect not to embrace all things.
1094
00:58:16.789 --> 00:58:18.789
37.
1095
00:58:19.670 --> 00:58:22.210
That the chief perfection of man is his being able
1096
00:58:22.250 --> 00:58:24.570
to act freely or by will, and that it is
1097
00:58:24.650 --> 00:58:28.329
this which renders him worthy of praise or blame. That
1098
00:58:28.369 --> 00:58:30.769
the will should be the more extensive is in harmony
1099
00:58:30.809 --> 00:58:33.340
with its nature, and it is a high perfection in
1100
00:58:33.389 --> 00:58:35.199
man to be able to act by means of it,
1101
00:58:35.590 --> 00:58:38.980
that is, freely, and thus in a peculiar way to
1102
00:58:39.000 --> 00:58:41.519
be the master of his own actions and merit praise
1103
00:58:41.579 --> 00:58:45.659
or blame. For self-acting machines are not commended because they
1104
00:58:45.699 --> 00:58:48.880
perform with exactness all the movements for which they were adapted.
1105
00:58:49.460 --> 00:58:52.920
seeing their motions are carried on necessarily but the maker
1106
00:58:52.960 --> 00:58:55.489
of them is praised on account of the exactness with
1107
00:58:55.590 --> 00:58:58.110
which they were framed because he did not act of
1108
00:58:58.190 --> 00:59:01.929
necessity but freely and on the same principle we must
1109
00:59:01.989 --> 00:59:05.190
attribute to ourselves something more on this account that when
1110
00:59:05.230 --> 00:59:08.500
we embrace truth we do so not of necessity but
1111
00:59:08.579 --> 00:59:14.190
freely 38. That error is a defect in our mode
1112
00:59:14.230 --> 00:59:17.170
of acting, not in our nature, and that the faults
1113
00:59:17.190 --> 00:59:20.429
of their subjects may be frequently attributed to other masters,
1114
00:59:20.570 --> 00:59:23.809
but never to God. It is true that as often
1115
00:59:23.869 --> 00:59:26.110
as we err, there is some defect in our mode
1116
00:59:26.130 --> 00:59:28.469
of action or in the use of our liberty, but
1117
00:59:28.530 --> 00:59:31.380
not in our nature, because this is always the same
1118
00:59:31.539 --> 00:59:35.039
whether our judgments be true or false. And although God
1119
00:59:35.119 --> 00:59:37.780
could have given to us such perspicacity of intellect that
1120
00:59:37.800 --> 00:59:40.920
we should never have erred, we have, notwithstanding, no right
1121
00:59:40.960 --> 00:59:44.110
to demand this of him. For although with us he
1122
00:59:44.170 --> 00:59:46.530
who was able to prevent evil and did not is
1123
00:59:46.550 --> 00:59:49.070
held guilty of it, God is not in the same
1124
00:59:49.130 --> 00:59:52.030
way to be reckoned responsible for our errors because he
1125
00:59:52.070 --> 00:59:55.099
had the power to prevent them, inasmuch as the dominion
1126
00:59:55.159 --> 00:59:58.269
which some men possess over others has been instituted for
1127
00:59:58.309 --> 01:00:01.110
the purpose of enabling them to hinder those under them
1128
01:00:01.190 --> 01:00:04.690
from doing evil, whereas the dominion which God exercises over
1129
01:00:04.710 --> 01:00:08.489
the universe is perfectly absolute and free. For this reason
1130
01:00:08.530 --> 01:00:10.369
we ought to thank him for the goods he has
1131
01:00:10.409 --> 01:00:13.110
given us, and not complain that he has not blessed
1132
01:00:13.179 --> 01:00:14.969
us with all which we know it was in his
1133
01:00:15.010 --> 01:00:18.239
power to impart.
1134
01:00:18.239 --> 01:00:18.699
39.
1135
01:00:18.699 --> 01:00:22.730
That the liberty of our will is self-evident finally it
1136
01:00:23.090 --> 01:00:26.210
is so manifest that we possess a free will capable
1137
01:00:26.250 --> 01:00:29.420
of giving or withholding its assent that this truth must
1138
01:00:29.460 --> 01:00:32.139
be reckoned among the first and most common notions which
1139
01:00:32.199 --> 01:00:35.820
are born with us this indeed has already very clearly
1140
01:00:35.889 --> 01:00:38.989
appeared for when essaying to doubt of all things we
1141
01:00:39.030 --> 01:00:41.389
went so far as to suppose even that he who
1142
01:00:41.449 --> 01:00:45.050
created us employed his limitless power in deceiving us in
1143
01:00:45.170 --> 01:00:48.179
every way, we were conscious nevertheless of being free to
1144
01:00:48.239 --> 01:00:51.440
abstain from believing what was not in every respect certain
1145
01:00:51.539 --> 01:00:54.699
and undoubted. But that of which we are unable to
1146
01:00:54.739 --> 01:00:57.880
doubt such a time is as self-evident and clear as
1147
01:00:57.980 --> 01:00:59.260
anything we can ever know.
1148
01:00:59.260 --> 01:01:01.050
40.
1149
01:01:01.050 --> 01:01:05.610
That it is likewise certain that God has foreordained all things.
1150
01:01:06.559 --> 01:01:09.610
But because what we have already discovered of God gives
1151
01:01:09.659 --> 01:01:12.309
us the assurance that his power is so immense that
1152
01:01:12.349 --> 01:01:15.409
we would sin in thinking ourselves capable of ever doing
1153
01:01:15.610 --> 01:01:19.230
anything which he had not ordained beforehand, we should soon
1154
01:01:19.269 --> 01:01:22.619
be embarrassed in great difficulties if we undertook to harmonize
1155
01:01:22.940 --> 01:01:25.639
the preordination of God with the freedom of our will
1156
01:01:25.920 --> 01:01:28.300
and endeavor to comprehend both truths at once.
1157
01:01:28.300 --> 01:01:30.300
41.
1158
01:01:31.400 --> 01:01:33.949
How the freedom of our will may be reconciled with
1159
01:01:33.969 --> 01:01:38.219
the divine preordination. But in place of this, we will
1160
01:01:38.260 --> 01:01:41.260
be free from these embarrassments if we recollect that our
1161
01:01:41.320 --> 01:01:44.079
mind is limited while the power of God, by which
1162
01:01:44.139 --> 01:01:46.780
he not only knew from all eternity what is or
1163
01:01:46.820 --> 01:01:50.539
can be, but also willed and preordained it, is infinite.
1164
01:01:51.659 --> 01:01:54.500
It thus happens that we possess sufficient intelligence to know
1165
01:01:54.599 --> 01:01:57.659
clearly and distinctly that this power is in God, but
1166
01:01:57.719 --> 01:02:00.429
not enough to comprehend how he leaves the free action
1167
01:02:00.469 --> 01:02:03.880
of men indeterminate and, on the other hand, We have
1168
01:02:03.940 --> 01:02:07.139
such consciousness of the liberty and indifference which exists in
1169
01:02:07.199 --> 01:02:11.239
ourselves that there is nothing we more clearly or perfectly comprehend,
1170
01:02:11.739 --> 01:02:14.010
so that the omnipotence of God ought not to keep
1171
01:02:14.070 --> 01:02:16.730
us from believing it. For it would be absurd to
1172
01:02:16.769 --> 01:02:19.170
doubt of that of which we are fully conscious, and
1173
01:02:19.190 --> 01:02:22.269
which we experience as existing in ourselves, because we do
1174
01:02:22.309 --> 01:02:25.570
not comprehend another matter which, from its very nature, we
1175
01:02:25.610 --> 01:02:31.869
know to be incomprehensible. 42 How? Although we never will
1176
01:02:31.909 --> 01:02:34.639
to err, it is nevertheless by our will that we
1177
01:02:34.679 --> 01:02:38.179
do err. But now, since we know that all our
1178
01:02:38.280 --> 01:02:41.219
errors depend upon our will, and as no one wishes
1179
01:02:41.280 --> 01:02:44.639
to deceive himself, it may seem wonderful that there is
1180
01:02:44.900 --> 01:02:48.179
any error in our judgments at all. It is necessary
1181
01:02:48.239 --> 01:02:51.199
to remark, however, that there is a great difference between
1182
01:02:51.260 --> 01:02:54.090
willing to be deceived and willing to yield assent to
1183
01:02:54.170 --> 01:02:57.739
opinions in which it happens that error is found. For
1184
01:02:57.780 --> 01:03:00.159
though there is no one who expressly wishes to fall
1185
01:03:00.199 --> 01:03:03.219
into error, we will yet hardly find anyone who is
1186
01:03:03.280 --> 01:03:06.719
not ready to ascend to things in which, unknown to himself,
1187
01:03:07.199 --> 01:03:10.719
error lurks. And it even frequently happens that it is
1188
01:03:10.780 --> 01:03:14.210
the desire itself of following after truth that leads those
1189
01:03:14.269 --> 01:03:16.429
not fully aware of the order in which it ought
1190
01:03:16.449 --> 01:03:19.190
to be sought for to pass judgment on matters of
1191
01:03:19.230 --> 01:03:24.230
which they have no adequate knowledge, and thus fall into error. 43.
1192
01:03:25.460 --> 01:03:27.639
that we shall never err if we give our assent
1193
01:03:27.780 --> 01:03:31.389
only to what we clearly and distinctly perceive. But it
1194
01:03:31.469 --> 01:03:34.789
is certain we will never admit falsity for truth, so
1195
01:03:34.849 --> 01:03:37.230
long as we judge only of that which we clearly
1196
01:03:37.269 --> 01:03:41.380
and distinctly perceive. Because, as God is no deceiver, the
1197
01:03:41.420 --> 01:03:45.360
faculty of knowledge which he has given us cannot be fallacious, nor,
1198
01:03:45.480 --> 01:03:48.119
for the same reason, the faculty of will, when we
1199
01:03:48.159 --> 01:03:50.699
do not extend it beyond the objects we clearly know.
1200
01:03:51.449 --> 01:03:53.969
and even although this truth could not be established by
1201
01:03:54.010 --> 01:03:56.860
reasoning the minds of all have been so impressed by
1202
01:03:56.940 --> 01:04:00.900
nature as spontaneously to assent to whatever is clearly perceived
1203
01:04:01.280 --> 01:04:04.400
and to experience an impossibility to doubt of its truth
1204
01:04:05.840 --> 01:04:10.079
forty four that we uniformly judge improperly when we ascend
1205
01:04:10.159 --> 01:04:13.139
to what we do not clearly perceive, although our judgment
1206
01:04:13.179 --> 01:04:15.829
may chance to be true, and that it is frequently
1207
01:04:15.929 --> 01:04:18.510
our memory which deceives us by leading us to believe
1208
01:04:18.570 --> 01:04:22.750
that certain things were formerly sufficiently understood by us. It
1209
01:04:22.809 --> 01:04:25.630
is likewise certain that, when we approve of any reason
1210
01:04:25.710 --> 01:04:28.900
which we do not apprehend, we are either deceived, or,
1211
01:04:29.079 --> 01:04:31.840
if we stumble on the truth, it is only by chance,
1212
01:04:32.380 --> 01:04:34.699
and thus we can never possess the assurance that we
1213
01:04:34.739 --> 01:04:38.469
are not in error. I confess, it seldom happens that
1214
01:04:38.570 --> 01:04:40.909
we judge of a thing when we have observed we
1215
01:04:40.949 --> 01:04:43.659
do not apprehend it, because it is a dictate of
1216
01:04:43.699 --> 01:04:45.960
the natural light never to judge of what we do
1217
01:04:46.019 --> 01:04:49.139
not
know. But we most frequently err in this, that
1218
01:04:49.179 --> 01:04:51.760
we presume upon a past knowledge of much to which
1219
01:04:51.820 --> 01:04:54.880
we give our assent, as to something treasured up in
1220
01:04:54.900 --> 01:04:58.659
the memory and perfectly known to us, whereas in truth
1221
01:04:58.820 --> 01:05:02.179
we have no such knowledge.
1222
01:05:02.179 --> 01:05:03.079
45.
1223
01:05:03.079 --> 01:05:07.539
What constitutes clear and distinct perception? There are indeed a
1224
01:05:07.699 --> 01:05:11.360
great many persons who, through their whole lifetime, never perceive
1225
01:05:11.519 --> 01:05:14.480
anything in a way necessary for judging of it properly.
1226
01:05:15.119 --> 01:05:17.800
For the knowledge upon which we can establish a certain
1227
01:05:17.900 --> 01:05:21.920
and indubitable judgment must be not only clear but also distinct.
1228
01:05:22.519 --> 01:05:25.079
I call that clear which is present and manifest to
1229
01:05:25.119 --> 01:05:27.739
the mind giving attention to it. Just as we are
1230
01:05:27.800 --> 01:05:30.909
said clearly to see objects when being present to the
1231
01:05:31.010 --> 01:05:34.239
eye looking on, they stimulate it with sufficient force and
1232
01:05:34.280 --> 01:05:37.300
it is disposed to regard them but the distinct is
1233
01:05:37.320 --> 01:05:39.980
that which is so precise and different from all other
1234
01:05:40.059 --> 01:05:43.199
objects as to comprehend in itself only what is clear
1235
01:05:45.800 --> 01:05:50.840
of the principles of human knowledge forty six it is
1236
01:05:50.900 --> 01:05:54.030
shown from the example of pain that a perception may
1237
01:05:54.070 --> 01:05:56.710
be clear without being distinct but that it cannot be
1238
01:05:56.769 --> 01:06:01.159
distinct unless it is clear For example, when anyone feels
1239
01:06:01.239 --> 01:06:04.139
intense pain, the knowledge which he has of this pain
1240
01:06:04.219 --> 01:06:07.280
is very clear, but it is not always distinct. For
1241
01:06:07.320 --> 01:06:10.300
men usually confound it with the obscure judgment they form
1242
01:06:10.340 --> 01:06:12.820
regarding its nature, and think that there is in the
1243
01:06:12.880 --> 01:06:15.900
suffering part something similar to the sensation of pain of
1244
01:06:15.940 --> 01:06:19.559
which they are alone conscious. And thus perception may be
1245
01:06:19.619 --> 01:06:22.559
clear without being distinct, but it can never be distinct
1246
01:06:22.599 --> 01:06:24.000
without likewise being clear.
1247
01:06:24.000 --> 01:06:26.000
47.
1248
01:06:27.289 --> 01:06:30.269
That to correct the prejudices of our early years we
1249
01:06:30.309 --> 01:06:32.659
must consider what is clear in each of our simple
1250
01:06:32.719 --> 01:06:36.840
notions and indeed in our early years the mind was
1251
01:06:36.880 --> 01:06:39.679
so immersed in the body that although it perceived many
1252
01:06:39.760 --> 01:06:43.980
things with sufficient clearness it yet knew nothing distinctly and
1253
01:06:44.019 --> 01:06:46.670
since even at that time we exercised our judgment in
1254
01:06:46.710 --> 01:06:51.659
many matters Numerous prejudices were thus contracted, which, by the majority,
1255
01:06:51.900 --> 01:06:55.000
are never afterwards laid aside. But that we may now
1256
01:06:55.059 --> 01:06:56.960
be in a position to get rid of these, I
1257
01:06:56.980 --> 01:06:59.960
will here briefly enumerate all the simple notions of which
1258
01:07:00.019 --> 01:07:03.079
our thoughts are composed, and distinguish in each what is
1259
01:07:03.139 --> 01:07:05.500
clear from what is obscure, or fit it to lead
1260
01:07:05.559 --> 01:07:11.110
into error. 48 that all the objects of our knowledge
1261
01:07:11.190 --> 01:07:13.989
are to be regarded either, one, as things or the
1262
01:07:14.030 --> 01:07:17.539
affection of things, or two, as eternal truths with the
1263
01:07:17.559 --> 01:07:21.800
enumeration of things. Whatever objects fall under our knowledge, we
1264
01:07:21.840 --> 01:07:25.059
consider either as things or the affections of things, or
1265
01:07:25.199 --> 01:07:28.980
as eternal truths possessing no existence beyond their thought. Of
1266
01:07:29.000 --> 01:07:32.809
the first class, the most general are substance, duration, order, number,
1267
01:07:33.170 --> 01:07:36.530
and perhaps also some others, which notions apply to all
1268
01:07:36.550 --> 01:07:40.019
the kinds of things. I do not, however, recognize more
1269
01:07:40.059 --> 01:07:44.559
than two highest kinds, summa genera, of things. The first
1270
01:07:44.619 --> 01:07:47.500
of intellectual things are such as have the power of thinking,
1271
01:07:47.900 --> 01:07:52.050
including mind or thinking substance and its properties. The second
1272
01:07:52.150 --> 01:07:58.469
of material things, embracing extended substance or body and its properties. Perception, volition,
1273
01:07:58.690 --> 01:08:01.139
and all modes as well of knowing as of willing
1274
01:08:01.480 --> 01:08:04.750
are related to thinking substance. On the other hand, to
1275
01:08:04.809 --> 01:08:08.369
extend the substance we refer magnitude, or extension in length,
1276
01:08:08.590 --> 01:08:13.230
breadth and depth, figure, motion, situation, divisibility of parts themselves,
1277
01:08:13.469 --> 01:08:17.869
and the like. There are, however, beside these, certain things
1278
01:08:17.909 --> 01:08:20.329
of which we have an internal experience that ought not
1279
01:08:20.369 --> 01:08:23.000
to be referred either to the mind of itself or
1280
01:08:23.060 --> 01:08:25.720
to the body alone, but to the close and intimate
1281
01:08:25.840 --> 01:08:29.140
union between them, as will hereafter be shown in its place.
1282
01:08:29.939 --> 01:08:32.689
Of this class are the appetites of hunger and thirst, etc.,
1283
01:08:33.470 --> 01:08:35.909
and also the emotions or passions
of the mind, which
1284
01:08:35.989 --> 01:08:41.939
are not exclusively mental affections, as the emotions of anger, joy, sadness, love, etc.
1285
01:08:42.609 --> 01:08:46.659
And finally, all the sensations, as of pain, titillation, light
1286
01:08:46.760 --> 01:08:51.380
and colours, sounds, smells, tastes, heat, hardness, and the other
1287
01:08:51.420 --> 01:08:52.439
tactile qualities.
1288
01:08:52.439 --> 01:08:54.439
49.
1289
01:08:54.810 --> 01:08:59.130
That the external truths cannot be thus enumerated, but that
1290
01:08:59.229 --> 01:09:03.100
this is not necessary. What I have already enumerated we
1291
01:09:03.140 --> 01:09:05.739
are to regard as things or the qualities or modes
1292
01:09:05.779 --> 01:09:08.810
of things. We now come to speak of eternal truths.
1293
01:09:09.270 --> 01:09:11.869
When we apprehend that it is impossible a thing can
1294
01:09:11.909 --> 01:09:16.390
arise from nothing, this proposition, ex nihilo nihil fit, is
1295
01:09:16.449 --> 01:09:19.289
not considered as somewhat existing or as the mode of
1296
01:09:19.310 --> 01:09:22.079
a thing, but as an eternal truth having its seat
1297
01:09:22.199 --> 01:09:25.420
in our mind, and is called a common notion or axiom.
1298
01:09:26.140 --> 01:09:29.119
Of this class are the following. It is impossible the
1299
01:09:29.159 --> 01:09:32.010
same thing can at once be and not be. What
1300
01:09:32.060 --> 01:09:36.149
is done cannot be undone. He who thinks must exist
1301
01:09:36.210 --> 01:09:39.550
while he thinks, and innumerable others, the whole of which
1302
01:09:39.630 --> 01:09:43.770
it is indeed difficult to enumerate, but this is not necessary, since,
1303
01:09:43.930 --> 01:09:46.989
if blinded by no prejudices, we cannot fail to know
1304
01:09:47.029 --> 01:09:49.229
them when the occasion of thinking them occurs.
1305
01:09:49.229 --> 01:09:51.229
50.
1306
01:09:52.039 --> 01:09:54.989
That these truths are clearly perceived, but not equally by
1307
01:09:55.069 --> 01:09:59.369
all men, on account of prejudices. And, indeed, with regard
1308
01:09:59.430 --> 01:10:01.850
to these common notions, it is not to be doubted
1309
01:10:01.890 --> 01:10:04.810
that they can be clearly and distinctly known, for otherwise
1310
01:10:04.850 --> 01:10:08.079
they would not merit this appellation, as, in truth, some
1311
01:10:08.119 --> 01:10:10.859
of them are not, with respect to all men, equally
1312
01:10:10.920 --> 01:10:13.859
deserving of the name, because they are not equally admitted
1313
01:10:13.920 --> 01:10:17.060
by all. Not, however, from this reason, as I think,
1314
01:10:17.260 --> 01:10:19.819
that the faculty of knowledge of one man extends farther
1315
01:10:19.890 --> 01:10:22.979
than that of another, but rather because these common notions
1316
01:10:23.100 --> 01:10:26.300
are opposed to the prejudices of some who, on this account,
1317
01:10:26.479 --> 01:10:29.779
are not able readily to embrace them, even although others
1318
01:10:29.840 --> 01:10:32.819
who are free from those prejudices apprehend them with the
1319
01:10:32.880 --> 01:10:38.500
greatest clearness. 51. What substance is, and that the term
1320
01:10:38.560 --> 01:10:40.850
is not applicable to God and the creatures in the
1321
01:10:40.890 --> 01:10:44.529
same sense. But with regard to what we consider as
1322
01:10:44.609 --> 01:10:47.449
things or the modes of things, it is worthwhile to
1323
01:10:47.510 --> 01:10:50.890
examine each of them by itself. By substance we can
1324
01:10:50.930 --> 01:10:53.489
conceive nothing else than a thing which exists in such
1325
01:10:53.550 --> 01:10:55.729
a way as to stand in need of nothing beyond
1326
01:10:55.789 --> 01:10:59.520
itself in order to its existence. And, in truth, there
1327
01:10:59.529 --> 01:11:03.119
can be conceived but one substance which is absolutely independent,
1328
01:11:03.619 --> 01:11:06.640
and that is God. We perceive that all other things
1329
01:11:06.720 --> 01:11:10.680
can exist only by help of the concourse of God. And, accordingly,
1330
01:11:10.699 --> 01:11:13.260
the term substance does not apply to God and the
1331
01:11:13.319 --> 01:11:18.970
creatures univocally to adopt a term familiar in the schools. 52.
1332
01:11:18.970 --> 01:11:28.399
That the term is applicable univocally to the mind and
1333
01:11:28.420 --> 01:11:30.819
the body, and how substance itself is known.
1334
01:11:30.819 --> 01:11:32.060
53.
1335
01:11:32.060 --> 01:11:36.250
Created substances, however, whether corporeal or thinking, may be conceived
1336
01:11:36.310 --> 01:11:39.250
under this common concept, for these are things which, in
1337
01:11:39.310 --> 01:11:42.210
order to their existence, stand in need of nothing but
1338
01:11:42.229 --> 01:11:45.270
the concourse of God. 54. But yet substance cannot be
1339
01:11:45.310 --> 01:11:49.109
first discovered merely from its being a thing which exists independently,
1340
01:11:49.609 --> 01:11:53.850
for existence by itself is not observed by us. We easily, however,
1341
01:11:53.989 --> 01:11:57.109
discover substance itself from any attribute of it, by this
1342
01:11:57.149 --> 01:12:00.479
common notion that of nothing there are no attributes, properties,
1343
01:12:00.560 --> 01:12:04.319
or qualities. For, from perceiving that some attribute is present,
1344
01:12:04.640 --> 01:12:07.420
we infer that some existing thing or substance to which
1345
01:12:07.479 --> 01:12:10.300
it may be attributed is also of necessity present.
1346
01:12:10.300 --> 01:12:12.300
53.
1347
01:12:13.109 --> 01:12:16.050
That of every substance there is one principal attribute, as
1348
01:12:16.090 --> 01:12:19.829
thinking of the mind, extension of the body. But although
1349
01:12:19.930 --> 01:12:22.300
any attribute is sufficient to lead us to the knowledge
1350
01:12:22.340 --> 01:12:26.659
of substance, there is, however, one principal property of every substance,
1351
01:12:27.060 --> 01:12:30.520
which constitutes its nature or essence, and upon which all
1352
01:12:30.539 --> 01:12:34.500
the others depend. Thus extension in length, breadth, and depth
1353
01:12:34.979 --> 01:12:38.789
constitutes the nature of corporeal substance, and thought the nature
1354
01:12:38.829 --> 01:12:41.729
of thinking substance. for every other thing that can be
1355
01:12:41.819 --> 01:12:45.800
attributed to body presupposes extension, and is only some mode
1356
01:12:45.840 --> 01:12:48.720
of an extended thing, as all the properties we discover
1357
01:12:48.779 --> 01:12:52.079
in the mind are only diverse modes of thinking. Thus,
1358
01:12:52.300 --> 01:12:56.000
for example, we cannot conceive figure unless in something extended,
1359
01:12:56.460 --> 01:13:00.960
nor motion unless in extended space, nor imagination, sensation or
1360
01:13:01.020 --> 01:13:04.840
will unless in a thinking thing. But, on the other hand,
1361
01:13:04.960 --> 01:13:08.380
we can conceive extension without figure or motion. and thought
1362
01:13:08.449 --> 01:13:12.100
without imagination or sensation, and so of the others, as
1363
01:13:12.180 --> 01:13:14.399
is clear to anyone who attends to these matters.
1364
01:13:14.399 --> 01:13:16.399
54.
1365
01:13:17.460 --> 01:13:19.760
How we may have clear and distinct notions of the
1366
01:13:19.800 --> 01:13:23.520
substance which thinks, of that which is corporeal, and of God.
1367
01:13:24.590 --> 01:13:26.890
And thus we may easily have two clear and distinct
1368
01:13:26.949 --> 01:13:30.670
notions or ideas, the one of created substance, which thinks,
1369
01:13:31.149 --> 01:13:34.750
the other of a corporeal substance, provided we carefully distinguish
1370
01:13:34.810 --> 01:13:38.210
all the attributes of thought from those of extension. We
1371
01:13:38.250 --> 01:13:40.529
may also have a clear and distinct idea of an
1372
01:13:40.729 --> 01:13:45.329
uncreated and independent thinking substance, that is, of God, provided
1373
01:13:45.390 --> 01:13:48.310
we do not suppose that this idea adequately represents to
1374
01:13:48.409 --> 01:13:50.850
us all that is in God, and do not mix
1375
01:13:50.930 --> 01:13:54.149
up with it anything fictitious, but attend simply to the
1376
01:13:54.189 --> 01:13:56.750
characters that are comprised in the notion we have of him,
1377
01:13:57.250 --> 01:13:59.489
and which we clearly know to belong to the nature
1378
01:13:59.529 --> 01:14:02.750
of an absolutely perfect being. for no one can deny
1379
01:14:02.810 --> 01:14:04.949
that there is in us such an idea of God
1380
01:14:05.130 --> 01:14:08.130
without groundlessly supposing that there is no knowledge of God
1381
01:14:08.189 --> 01:14:09.369
at all in the human mind.
1382
01:14:09.369 --> 01:14:11.369
55.
1383
01:14:11.680 --> 01:14:16.140
How duration, order and number may be also distinctly conceived.
1384
01:14:17.199 --> 01:14:19.939
We will also have the most distinct conceptions of duration,
1385
01:14:20.060 --> 01:14:22.880
order and number if, in place of mixing up with
1386
01:14:22.939 --> 01:14:25.359
our notions of them that which properly belongs to the
1387
01:14:25.399 --> 01:14:28.399
concept of substance, we merely think that the duration of
1388
01:14:28.460 --> 01:14:30.899
a thing is the mode under which we conceive this thing,
1389
01:14:31.340 --> 01:14:34.880
insofar as it continues to exist, and in like manner
1390
01:14:34.979 --> 01:14:37.539
that order and number are not in reality different from
1391
01:14:37.600 --> 01:14:41.020
things disposed in order and numbered, but only modes under
1392
01:14:41.079 --> 01:14:43.039
which we diversely consider these things.
1393
01:14:43.039 --> 01:14:45.039
56.
1394
01:14:46.189 --> 01:14:50.970
What are modes, qualities, attributes? And indeed, we here understand
1395
01:14:51.010 --> 01:14:54.069
by modes the same with what we elsewhere designate attributes
1396
01:14:54.130 --> 01:14:57.449
or qualities, but when we consider substance as affected or
1397
01:14:57.489 --> 01:15:00.640
varied by them, we use the term modes. when from
1398
01:15:00.680 --> 01:15:03.399
this variation it may be denominated of such a kind
1399
01:15:03.699 --> 01:15:07.029
we adopt the term qualities, to designate the different modes
1400
01:15:07.090 --> 01:15:09.989
which cause it to be so named. And finally, when
1401
01:15:10.010 --> 01:15:12.470
we simply regard these modes as in the substance, we
1402
01:15:12.510 --> 01:15:16.550
call them attributes. Accordingly, since God must be conceived as
1403
01:15:16.590 --> 01:15:19.380
superior to change, it is not proper to say that
1404
01:15:19.399 --> 01:15:22.479
there are modes or qualities in him, but simply attributes.
1405
01:15:23.119 --> 01:15:25.760
And even in created things, that which is found in them,
1406
01:15:25.939 --> 01:15:29.020
always in the same mode, as existence and duration in
1407
01:15:29.039 --> 01:15:32.220
the thing which exists and endures ought to be called
1408
01:15:32.319 --> 01:15:34.319
attribute and not mode or quality.
1409
01:15:34.319 --> 01:15:36.319
57.
1410
01:15:37.600 --> 01:15:40.180
That some attributes exist in the things to which they
1411
01:15:40.220 --> 01:15:43.359
are attributed, and others only in our thought, and what
1412
01:15:43.399 --> 01:15:47.270
duration and time are. Of these attributes or modes there
1413
01:15:47.329 --> 01:15:50.310
are some which exist in the things themselves, and others
1414
01:15:50.350 --> 01:15:54.319
that have only an existence in our thought. Thus, for example, time,
1415
01:15:54.680 --> 01:15:57.939
which we distinguish from duration taken in its generality, and
1416
01:15:57.979 --> 01:16:00.850
call the measure of motion, is only a certain mode
1417
01:16:00.949 --> 01:16:03.970
under which we think duration itself, for we do not
1418
01:16:04.050 --> 01:16:06.229
conceive the duration of things that are
moved to be
1419
01:16:06.289 --> 01:16:08.590
different from the duration of things that are not moved,
1420
01:16:09.210 --> 01:16:11.409
as is evident from this that if two bodies are
1421
01:16:11.449 --> 01:16:14.060
in motion for an hour, the one moving quickly and
1422
01:16:14.100 --> 01:16:16.760
the other slowly, we do not reckon more time in
1423
01:16:16.800 --> 01:16:18.939
the one than in the other, although there may be
1424
01:16:19.039 --> 01:16:21.079
much more motion in the one of the bodies than
1425
01:16:21.159 --> 01:16:24.170
in the other. But that we may comprehend the duration
1426
01:16:24.210 --> 01:16:26.930
of all things under a common measure, we compare their
1427
01:16:26.970 --> 01:16:29.569
duration with that of the greatest and most regular motions
1428
01:16:29.609 --> 01:16:32.000
that give rise to years and days, and which we
1429
01:16:32.039 --> 01:16:35.739
call time. Hence what is so designated is nothing superadded
1430
01:16:35.760 --> 01:16:39.640
to duration, chicken in its generality, but a mode of thinking.
1431
01:16:39.640 --> 01:16:41.560
58.
1432
01:16:41.560 --> 01:16:45.670
That number and all universals are only modes of thought.
1433
01:16:46.739 --> 01:16:49.319
In the same way, number, when it is not considered
1434
01:16:49.439 --> 01:16:52.300
as in created things, but merely in the abstract or
1435
01:16:52.319 --> 01:16:55.300
in general, is only a mode of thinking, and the
1436
01:16:55.340 --> 01:17:00.930
same is true of all those general ideas we call universals.
1437
01:17:00.930 --> 01:17:01.649
59.
1438
01:17:01.649 --> 01:17:04.569
How universals are formed, and what are the five common,
1439
01:17:04.710 --> 01:17:10.529
that is, genus, species, difference, property, and accident? Universals arise
1440
01:17:10.609 --> 01:17:12.699
merely from our making use of one and the same
1441
01:17:12.800 --> 01:17:16.039
idea in thinking of all individual objects between which there
1442
01:17:16.100 --> 01:17:19.399
subsists a certain likeness, and when we comprehend all the
1443
01:17:19.479 --> 01:17:23.029
objects represented by this idea under one name, this term
1444
01:17:23.069 --> 01:17:27.229
likewise becomes universal. For example, when we see two stones
1445
01:17:27.350 --> 01:17:29.689
and do not regard their nature farther than to remark
1446
01:17:29.729 --> 01:17:32.029
that there are two of them, we form the idea
1447
01:17:32.100 --> 01:17:35.149
of a certain number, which we call the binary. And
1448
01:17:35.170 --> 01:17:37.829
when we afterwards see two birds or two trees, and
1449
01:17:37.850 --> 01:17:40.050
merely take notice of them so far as to observe
1450
01:17:40.109 --> 01:17:42.529
that there are two of them, we again take up
1451
01:17:42.569 --> 01:17:46.510
the same idea as before, which is, accordingly, universal. And
1452
01:17:46.529 --> 01:17:49.409
we likewise give to this number the same universal appellation
1453
01:17:49.430 --> 01:17:52.250
of binary. In the same way, when we consider a
1454
01:17:52.310 --> 01:17:55.310
figure of three sides, we form a certain idea, which
1455
01:17:55.329 --> 01:17:58.090
we call the idea of a triangle, and we afterwards
1456
01:17:58.149 --> 01:18:00.829
make use of it as the universal to represent to
1457
01:18:00.890 --> 01:18:04.300
our mind all other figures of three sides. but when
1458
01:18:04.340 --> 01:18:07.420
we remark more particularly that of figures of three sides,
1459
01:18:07.840 --> 01:18:10.520
some have a right angle and others not, we form
1460
01:18:10.550 --> 01:18:14.489
the universal idea of a right-angle triangle, which, being related
1461
01:18:14.529 --> 01:18:17.489
to the proceeding as more general, may be called species,
1462
01:18:18.149 --> 01:18:20.970
and the right angle the universal difference by which right-angle
1463
01:18:21.010 --> 01:18:24.789
triangles are distinguished from all others, and farther, because the
1464
01:18:24.829 --> 01:18:27.270
square of the side which sustains the right angle is
1465
01:18:27.390 --> 01:18:29.890
equal to the squares of the other two sides, and
1466
01:18:29.909 --> 01:18:33.050
because this property belongs only to this species of triangles,
1467
01:18:33.489 --> 01:18:37.529
we may call it the universal property of the species. Finally,
1468
01:18:37.670 --> 01:18:40.100
if we suppose that of these triangles some are moved
1469
01:18:40.159 --> 01:18:43.520
and others not, this will be their universal accident, and
1470
01:18:43.560 --> 01:18:49.949
accordingly we commonly reckon five universals, that is, genus, species, difference, property, accident.
1471
01:18:52.350 --> 01:18:53.029
60.
1472
01:18:53.029 --> 01:18:56.560
Of distinctions, and first of the real. But number in
1473
01:18:56.600 --> 01:18:59.680
things themselves arises from the distinction there is between them,
1474
01:19:00.159 --> 01:19:03.880
and distinction is threefold, that is, real, modal, and of reason.
1475
01:19:04.619 --> 01:19:08.319
The real properly subsists between two or more substances, and
1476
01:19:08.380 --> 01:19:10.939
it is sufficient to assure us that two substances are
1477
01:19:10.960 --> 01:19:14.319
really mutually distinct, if only we are able clearly and
1478
01:19:14.359 --> 01:19:17.050
distinctly to conceive the one of them without the other.
1479
01:19:17.829 --> 01:19:20.130
For the knowledge we have of God renders it certain
1480
01:19:20.170 --> 01:19:22.229
that he can affect all that of which we have
1481
01:19:22.270 --> 01:19:25.810
a distinct idea. Wherefore, since we have now, for example,
1482
01:19:26.149 --> 01:19:29.630
the idea of an extended incorporeal substance, though we as
1483
01:19:29.670 --> 01:19:32.470
yet do not know with certainty whether any such thing
1484
01:19:32.550 --> 01:19:36.350
is really existent, Nevertheless, merely because we have the idea
1485
01:19:36.399 --> 01:19:39.640
of it, we may be assured that such
may exist, and,
1486
01:19:39.779 --> 01:19:42.319
if it really exists, that every part which we can
1487
01:19:42.359 --> 01:19:45.140
determine by thought must be really distinct from the other
1488
01:19:45.180 --> 01:19:48.460
parts of the same substance. In the same way, since
1489
01:19:48.520 --> 01:19:51.100
everyone is conscious that he thinks, and that he in
1490
01:19:51.159 --> 01:19:54.760
thought can exclude from himself every other substance, whether thinking
1491
01:19:54.840 --> 01:19:57.699
or extended, it is certain that each of us thus
1492
01:19:57.760 --> 01:20:01.920
considered is really distinct from every other thinking and corporeal substance.
1493
01:20:02.739 --> 01:20:05.180
And although we suppose that God united a body to
1494
01:20:05.260 --> 01:20:08.100
a soul so closely that it was impossible to form
1495
01:20:08.159 --> 01:20:11.119
a more intimate union, and thus made a composite whole,
1496
01:20:11.600 --> 01:20:15.479
the two substances would remain really distinct, notwithstanding this union.
1497
01:20:16.029 --> 01:20:18.810
For with whatever tie God connected them, he was not
1498
01:20:18.930 --> 01:20:21.050
able to rid himself of the power he possessed of
1499
01:20:21.090 --> 01:20:24.369
separating them, or of conserving the one part from the other.
1500
01:20:24.890 --> 01:20:27.949
And the things which God can separate or conserve separately
1501
01:20:28.170 --> 01:20:35.710
are really distinct. Of the principles of human knowledge, 61.
1502
01:20:35.750 --> 01:20:40.130
Of the modal distinction. There are two kinds of modal distinctions,
1503
01:20:40.310 --> 01:20:43.930
that is, that between the mode properly so-called and the
1504
01:20:43.970 --> 01:20:46.479
substance of which it is a mode, and that between
1505
01:20:46.529 --> 01:20:49.699
two modes of the same substance. Of the former we
1506
01:20:49.739 --> 01:20:52.359
have an example in this that we can clearly apprehend
1507
01:20:52.439 --> 01:20:55.460
substance apart from the mode which we say differs from it,
1508
01:20:56.100 --> 01:20:58.880
while on the other hand we cannot conceive this mode
1509
01:20:58.939 --> 01:21:03.399
without conceiving the substance itself. There is, for example, a
1510
01:21:03.439 --> 01:21:07.100
modal distinction between figure or motion and corporeal substance in
1511
01:21:07.119 --> 01:21:11.039
which both exist. There is a similar distinction between affirmation
1512
01:21:11.180 --> 01:21:14.340
or recollection and the mind. Of the latter kind, we
1513
01:21:14.380 --> 01:21:17.270
have an illustration in our ability to recognize the one
1514
01:21:17.350 --> 01:21:20.250
of two modes apart from the other, as figure apart
1515
01:21:20.310 --> 01:21:23.770
from motion, and motion apart from figure, though we cannot
1516
01:21:23.829 --> 01:21:26.390
think of either the one or the other without thinking
1517
01:21:26.430 --> 01:21:30.369
of the common substance in which they adhere. If, for example,
1518
01:21:30.590 --> 01:21:34.090
a stone is moved and is withal square, we can, indeed,
1519
01:21:34.250 --> 01:21:37.970
conceive its square figure without its motion, and reciprocally its
1520
01:21:38.010 --> 01:21:41.329
motion without its square figure, but we can conceive neither
1521
01:21:41.350 --> 01:21:44.260
this motion nor this figure apart from the substance of
1522
01:21:44.270 --> 01:21:47.449
the stone. As for the distinction according to which the
1523
01:21:47.500 --> 01:21:50.739
mode of one substance is different from another substance, or
1524
01:21:50.779 --> 01:21:53.430
from the mode of another substance... as the motion of
1525
01:21:53.529 --> 01:21:56.130
one body is different from another body or from the mind,
1526
01:21:56.510 --> 01:21:59.050
or motion is different from doubt, it seems to me
1527
01:21:59.109 --> 01:22:01.970
that it should be called real rather than modal, because
1528
01:22:02.010 --> 01:22:04.810
these modes cannot be clearly conceived apart from the really
1529
01:22:04.850 --> 01:22:14.479
distinct substances of which they are the modes. Finally, the
1530
01:22:14.520 --> 01:22:17.039
distinction of reason is that between a substance and some
1531
01:22:17.079 --> 01:22:20.699
of its attributes, without which it is impossible, however... we
1532
01:22:20.739 --> 01:22:24.119
can have a distinct conception of the substance itself, or
1533
01:22:24.199 --> 01:22:27.350
between two such attributes of a common substance, the one
1534
01:22:27.369 --> 01:22:30.550
of which we essay to think without the other. This
1535
01:22:30.590 --> 01:22:33.649
distinction is manifest from our inability to form a clear
1536
01:22:33.710 --> 01:22:36.810
and distinct idea of such substance, if we separate from
1537
01:22:36.869 --> 01:22:39.689
it such attribute, or to have a clear perception of
1538
01:22:39.729 --> 01:22:42.229
the one of two such attributes if we separate it
1539
01:22:42.270 --> 01:22:46.329
from the other. For example, because any substance which ceases
1540
01:22:46.369 --> 01:22:50.010
to endure ceases also to exist, duration is not distinct
1541
01:22:50.050 --> 01:22:54.479
from substance except in thought, and in general, all the
1542
01:22:54.520 --> 01:22:57.159
modes of thinking which we consider as in objects differ
1543
01:22:57.239 --> 01:22:59.779
only in thought, as well from the objects of which
1544
01:22:59.840 --> 01:23:02.319
they are thoughts, as from each other in a common object.
1545
01:23:03.659 --> 01:23:06.479
It occurs indeed to me that I have elsewhere classed
1546
01:23:06.520 --> 01:23:09.560
this kind of distinction with the modal, that is, towards
1547
01:23:09.600 --> 01:23:11.989
the end of the reply to the first objections to
1548
01:23:12.010 --> 01:23:15.229
the meditations on the first philosophy, but there it was
1549
01:23:15.289 --> 01:23:18.689
only necessary to treat of these distinctions generally. and it
1550
01:23:18.750 -->
01:23:21.430
was sufficient for my purpose at that time simply to
1551
01:23:21.470 --> 01:23:25.510
distinguish both of them from the wheel.
1552
01:23:25.510 --> 01:23:26.289
63.
1553
01:23:26.289 --> 01:23:29.789
How thought and extension may be distinctly known as constituting
1554
01:23:29.949 --> 01:23:32.109
the one the nature of the mind, the other that
1555
01:23:32.180 --> 01:23:36.460
of body. Thought and extension may be regarded as constituting
1556
01:23:36.500 --> 01:23:39.960
the natures of intelligent and corporeal substance, and then they
1557
01:23:40.000 --> 01:23:42.600
must not be otherwise conceived than as the thinking and
1558
01:23:42.659 --> 01:23:46.500
extended substance themselves, that is, as mind and body, which
1559
01:23:46.560 --> 01:23:51.130
in this way are conceived with the greatest clearness and distinctness. Moreover,
1560
01:23:51.229 --> 01:23:54.750
we more easily conceive extended or thinking substance than substance
1561
01:23:54.789 --> 01:23:58.350
by itself, or with the omission of its thinking or extension.
1562
01:23:59.069 --> 01:24:01.609
For there is some difficulty in abstracting the notion of
1563
01:24:01.649 --> 01:24:04.939
substance from the notions of thinking and extension, which in
1564
01:24:05.000 --> 01:24:09.380
truth are only diverse in thought itself, that is, logically different.
1565
01:24:10.159 --> 01:24:12.880
and the concept is not more distinct because it comprehends
1566
01:24:12.920 --> 01:24:16.899
fewer properties, but because we accurately distinguish what is comprehended
1567
01:24:17.010 --> 01:24:22.470
in it from all other notions. 64. How these may
1568
01:24:22.529 --> 01:24:26.869
likewise be distinctly conceived as modes of substance. Thought and
1569
01:24:26.909 --> 01:24:30.409
extension may be also considered as modes of substance, in
1570
01:24:30.470 --> 01:24:33.609
as far, namely, as the same mind may have different thoughts,
1571
01:24:33.829 --> 01:24:36.970
and the same body, with its size unchanged, may be
1572
01:24:37.050 --> 01:24:40.430
extended in several diverse ways, at one time more in
1573
01:24:40.479 --> 01:24:43.329
length and less in breadth or depth, and at another
1574
01:24:43.369 --> 01:24:46.210
time more in breadth and less in length, and then
1575
01:24:46.250 --> 01:24:49.390
they are modally distinguished from substance, and can be conceived
1576
01:24:49.470 --> 01:24:52.970
not less clearly and distinctly, provided they be not regarded
1577
01:24:53.029 --> 01:24:56.359
as substances or things separated from others, but simply as
1578
01:24:56.420 --> 01:24:59.220
modes of things. For by regarding them as in the
1579
01:24:59.260 --> 01:25:02.180
substances of which they are the modes, we distinguish them
1580
01:25:02.239 --> 01:25:04.739
from these substances, and take them for what in truth
1581
01:25:04.800 --> 01:25:07.539
they are, whereas, on the other hand, if we wish
1582
01:25:07.560 --> 01:25:10.199
to consider them apart from the substances in which they are,
1583
01:25:10.600 --> 01:25:13.560
we should by this itself regard them as self-subsisting things,
1584
01:25:13.960 --> 01:25:18.800
and thus confound the ideas of mode and substance.
1585
01:25:18.800 --> 01:25:19.520
65.
1586
01:25:19.520 --> 01:25:23.119
How we may likewise know their modes. In the same way,
1587
01:25:23.310 --> 01:25:29.829
we will best apprehend the diverse modes of thought, as intellection, imagination, recollection, volition, etc.,
1588
01:25:30.050 --> 01:25:33.029
and also the diverse modes of extension, or those that
1589
01:25:33.069 --> 01:25:37.020
belong to extension, as all figures, the situation of parts
1590
01:25:37.079 --> 01:25:40.359
and their motions, provided we consider them simply as modes
1591
01:25:40.430 --> 01:25:43.050
of the things in which they are, and motion, as
1592
01:25:43.090 --> 01:25:46.670
far as it is concerned, provided we think merely of locomotion,
1593
01:25:47.109 --> 01:25:49.689
without seeking to know the force that produces it, and
1594
01:25:49.729 --> 01:25:52.729
which nevertheless I will essay to explain in its own place.
1595
01:25:52.729 --> 01:25:54.729
66.
1596
01:25:56.029 --> 01:25:59.609
How our sensations, affections, and appetites may be clearly known,
1597
01:25:59.979 --> 01:26:02.859
although we are frequently wrong in our judgments regarding them.
1598
01:26:03.880 --> 01:26:07.779
There remain our sensations, affections and appetites, of which we
1599
01:26:07.819 --> 01:26:10.220
may also have a clear knowledge, if we take care
1600
01:26:10.279 --> 01:26:13.239
to comprehend in the judgments we form of them only
1601
01:26:13.300 --> 01:26:16.060
that which is precisely contained in our perception of them,
1602
01:26:16.590 --> 01:26:20.149
and of which we are immediately conscious. There is, however,
1603
01:26:20.329 --> 01:26:23.890
great difficulty in observing this, at least in respect of sensations,
1604
01:26:24.409 --> 01:26:27.689
because we have all, without exception, from our youth judged
1605
01:26:27.729 --> 01:26:30.470
that all the things we perceived by our senses had
1606
01:26:30.529 --> 01:26:33.659
an existence beyond our thought. and that they were entirely
1607
01:26:33.720 --> 01:26:37.520
similar to the sensations, that is, perceptions, we had of them.
1608
01:26:38.739 --> 01:26:41.960
Thus when, for example, we saw a certain colour, we
1609
01:26:42.000 --> 01:26:44.579
thought we saw something occupying a place out of us,
1610
01:26:45.050 --> 01:26:47.819
and which was entirely similar to that idea of colour
1611
01:26:48.100 --> 01:26:50.710
we were then conscious of. And from the habit of
1612
01:26:50.770 --> 01:26:53.189
judging in this way, we seem to see this so
1613
01:26:53.270 --> 01:26:56.189
clearly and distinctly that we esteemed it, that is, the
1614
01:26:56.289 --> 01:27:03.020
externality of the colour, certain and indubitable. 67 that we
1615
01:27:03.100 -->
01:27:07.659
are frequently deceived in our judgments regarding pain itself. The
1616
01:27:07.680 --> 01:27:10.979
same prejudice has place in all our other sensations, even
1617
01:27:11.039 --> 01:27:13.850
in those of titillation and pain. For though we are
1618
01:27:13.899 --> 01:27:16.250
not in the habit of believing that there exist out
1619
01:27:16.310 --> 01:27:19.630
of us objects that resemble titillation and pain, we do
1620
01:27:19.689 --> 01:27:22.750
not nevertheless consider these sensations as in the mind alone,
1621
01:27:23.189 --> 01:27:25.390
or in our perception, but as in the hand or
1622
01:27:25.449 --> 01:27:28.250
foot or some other part of the body. There is
1623
01:27:28.289 --> 01:27:31.109
no reason, however, to constrain us to believe that the pain,
1624
01:27:31.220 --> 01:27:34.229
for example, which we feel, as it were, in the foot,
1625
01:27:34.670 --> 01:27:37.029
is something out of the mind existing in the foot,
1626
01:27:37.569 --> 01:27:39.670
or that the light which we see, as it were,
1627
01:27:40.090 --> 01:27:42.149
in the sun exists in the sun as it is
1628
01:27:42.229 --> 01:27:45.640
in us. Both of these beliefs are prejudices of our
1629
01:27:45.689 --> 01:27:48.399
early years, as will clearly appear in the sequel.
1630
01:27:48.399 --> 01:27:50.399
68.
1631
01:27:50.600 --> 01:27:53.760
How in these things will we clearly conceive is to
1632
01:27:53.779 --> 01:27:56.420
be distinguished from that in which we may be deceived.
1633
01:27:57.380 --> 01:27:59.470
But that we may distinguish what is clear in our
1634
01:27:59.510 --> 01:28:03.020
sensations from what is obscured, we ought most carefully to
1635
01:28:03.079 --> 01:28:06.680
observe that we possess a clear and distinct knowledge of pain, colour,
1636
01:28:06.819 --> 01:28:09.399
and other things of this sort, when we consider them
1637
01:28:09.439 --> 01:28:12.779
simply as sensations or thought, but that, when they are
1638
01:28:12.850 --> 01:28:16.109
judged to be certain things subsisting beyond our mind, we
1639
01:28:16.189 --> 01:28:20.090
are wholly unable to form any conception of them. Indeed,
1640
01:28:20.189 --> 01:28:22.770
when anyone tells us that he sees colour in a body,
1641
01:28:23.170 --> 01:28:25.380
or feels pain in one of his limbs, this is
1642
01:28:25.460 --> 01:28:27.739
exactly the same as if he said that he there
1643
01:28:27.760 --> 01:28:30.000
saw or felt something of the nature of which he
1644
01:28:30.039 --> 01:28:33.130
was entirely ignorant, or that he did not know what
1645
01:28:33.170 --> 01:28:37.069
he saw or felt. For although, when less attentively examining
1646
01:28:37.109 --> 01:28:40.340
his thoughts, a person may easily persuade himself that he
1647
01:28:40.399 --> 01:28:43.000
has some knowledge of it, since he supposes that there
1648
01:28:43.060 --> 01:28:45.939
is something resembling that sensation of colour or of pain
1649
01:28:46.359 --> 01:28:49.350
of which he is conscious. Yet if he reflects on
1650
01:28:49.359 --> 01:28:51.890
what the sensation of colour or pain represents to him
1651
01:28:52.069 --> 01:28:55.029
as existing in a coloured body or in a wounded member,
1652
01:28:55.470 --> 01:28:58.210
he will find that of such he has absolutely no knowledge.
1653
01:28:58.210 --> 01:29:00.210
69.
1654
01:29:01.659 --> 01:29:06.319
That magnitude, figure, etc. are known far differently from colour, pain, etc.
1655
01:29:07.430 --> 01:29:10.550
What we have said above will be more manifest, especially
1656
01:29:10.630 --> 01:29:14.250
if we consider that size in the body perceived, figure, motion,
1657
01:29:14.449 --> 01:29:17.340
at least local for philosophers by fancying other kinds of
1658
01:29:17.399 --> 01:29:21.640
motion have rendered its nature less intelligible to themselves. the
1659
01:29:21.680 --> 01:29:25.699
situation of parts, duration, number, and those other properties which,
1660
01:29:25.939 --> 01:29:28.880
as we have already said, we clearly perceive in all bodies,
1661
01:29:29.340 --> 01:29:31.819
are known by us in a way altogether different from
1662
01:29:31.859 --> 01:29:33.680
that in which we know what colour is in the
1663
01:29:33.720 --> 01:29:37.180
same body, or pain, smell, taste, or any other of
1664
01:29:37.220 --> 01:29:39.699
those properties which I have said above must be referred
1665
01:29:39.739 --> 01:29:42.920
to the senses. For although when we see a body
1666
01:29:43.020 --> 01:29:46.460
we are not less assured of its existence from its appearing, figured,
1667
01:29:46.619 --> 01:29:49.840
than from its appearing coloured, we yet know with far
1668
01:29:49.920 --> 01:29:52.760
greater clearness its property of figure than its colour.
1669
01:29:52.760 --> 01:29:54.760
70.
1670
01:29:55.439 --> 01:29:58.680
That we may judge of sensible things in two ways,
1671
01:29:58.859 --> 01:30:01.029
by the one of which we avoid error, by the
1672
01:30:01.109 --> 01:30:04.590
other fall into it. It is thus manifest that to
1673
01:30:04.630 --> 01:30:07.890
say we perceive colours in objects is in reality equivalent
1674
01:30:08.210 --> 01:30:11.210
to saying we perceive something in objects, and are yet
1675
01:30:11.329 --> 01:30:14.420
ignorant of what it is, except as that which determines
1676
01:30:14.500 --> 01:30:17.640
in us a certain highly vivid and clear sensation, which
1677
01:30:17.699 --> 01:30:21.220
we call the sensation of colours. There is, however, very
1678
01:30:21.279 --> 01:30:24.439
great diversity in the manner of judging, for so long
1679
01:30:24.520 --> 01:30:27.060
as we simply judge that there is an unknown something
1680
01:30:27.119 --> 01:30:30.010
in objects, that is, in things such as they are,
1681
01:30:30.159 --> 01:30:33.350
from which the sensation reached us, so far are we
1682
01:30:33.409 --> 01:30:36.750
falling into error that, on the contrary, we thus rather
1683
01:30:36.789 --> 01:30:39.630
provide
against it, for we are less apt to judge
1684
01:30:39.710 --> 01:30:42.149
rashly of a thing which we observe we do not know.
1685
01:30:42.949 --> 01:30:45.850
But when we think we perceive colours in objects, although
1686
01:30:45.890 --> 01:30:49.180
we are in reality ignorant of what we then denominate colour,
1687
01:30:49.600 --> 01:30:52.539
and are unable to conceive any resemblance between the colour
1688
01:30:52.579 --> 01:30:55.039
we suppose to be in objects, and that of which
1689
01:30:55.100 --> 01:30:58.119
we are conscious in sensation, yet because we do not
1690
01:30:58.220 --> 01:31:01.520
observe this, or because there are in objects several properties,
1691
01:31:01.760 --> 01:31:06.119
as size, figure, number, etc., which, as we clearly know, exist,
1692
01:31:06.359 --> 01:31:08.449
or may exist in them as they are perceived by
1693
01:31:08.510 --> 01:31:12.270
our senses or conceived by our understanding, we easily glide
1694
01:31:12.329 --> 01:31:14.850
into the error of holding that what is called colour
1695
01:31:14.930 --> 01:31:18.850
in objects is something entirely resembling the colour we perceive,
1696
01:31:19.369 --> 01:31:22.090
and thereafter of supposing that we have a clear perception
1697
01:31:22.149 --> 01:31:27.399
of what is in no way perceived by us. 71.
1698
01:31:27.399 --> 01:31:29.520
That the chief cause of our errors is to be
1699
01:31:29.560 --> 01:31:33.340
found in the prejudices of our childhood. And here we
1700
01:31:33.359 --> 01:31:35.890
may notice the first and chief cause of our errors.
1701
01:31:36.630 --> 01:31:38.909
In early life the mind was so closely bound to
1702
01:31:38.930 --> 01:31:41.770
the body that it attended to nothing beyond the thoughts
1703
01:31:41.829 --> 01:31:44.390
by which it perceived the objects that made impression on
1704
01:31:44.409 --> 01:31:47.350
the body, nor as yet did it refer these thoughts
1705
01:31:47.390 --> 01:31:51.109
to anything existing beyond itself, but simply felt pain when
1706
01:31:51.130 --> 01:31:54.369
the body was hurt, or pleasure when anything beneficial to
1707
01:31:54.390 --> 01:31:56.949
the body occurred, or if the body was so highly
1708
01:31:57.010 --> 01:32:00.170
affected that it was neither greatly benefited nor hurt, the
1709
01:32:00.210 --> 01:32:06.630
mind experienced the sensations we call tastes, smells, sounds, heat, cold, light, colors,
1710
01:32:06.710 --> 01:32:09.949
and the like, which in truth are representative of nothing
1711
01:32:10.029 --> 01:32:12.909
existing out of our mind, and which vary according to
1712
01:32:12.949 --> 01:32:15.090
the diversities of the parts and mode in which the
1713
01:32:15.130 --> 01:32:18.800
body is affected. The mind at the same time also
1714
01:32:18.859 --> 01:32:22.439
perceived magnitudes, figures, motions, and the like, which were not
1715
01:32:22.500 --> 01:32:25.180
presented to it as sensations, but as things or the
1716
01:32:25.239 --> 01:32:28.500
modes of things existing, or at least capable of existing
1717
01:32:28.600 --> 01:32:31.069
out of thought, although it did not yet observe this
1718
01:32:31.109 --> 01:32:35.100
difference between these two kinds of perceptions. and afterwards when
1719
01:32:35.140 --> 01:32:37.859
the machine of the body, which has been so fabricated
1720
01:32:37.899 --> 01:32:40.270
by nature that it can of its own inherent power
1721
01:32:40.350 --> 01:32:43.729
move itself in various ways, by turning itself at random
1722
01:32:43.810 --> 01:32:47.149
on every side, followed after what was useful, and avoided
1723
01:32:47.170 --> 01:32:50.760
what was detrimental, the mind, which was closely connected with it,
1724
01:32:51.170 --> 01:32:54.760
reflecting on the objects it pursued or avoided, remarked for
1725
01:32:54.800 --> 01:32:57.600
the first time that they existed out of itself, and
1726
01:32:57.640 --> 01:33:01.359
not only attributed to them magnitudes, figures, motions, and the like,
1727
01:33:01.810 --> 01:33:04.310
which it apprehended either as things or the modes of
1728
01:33:04.390 --> 01:33:08.560
things but in addition attributed to them tastes odours and
1729
01:33:08.579 --> 01:33:11.300
the other odours of that sort the sensations of which
1730
01:33:11.359 --> 01:33:14.420
were caused by itself and as it only considered other
1731
01:33:14.520 --> 01:33:17.140
objects insofar as they were useful to the body in
1732
01:33:17.180 --> 01:33:19.819
which it was immersed, it judged that there was greater
1733
01:33:19.920 --> 01:33:23.180
or less reality in each object, according as the impressions
1734
01:33:23.260 --> 01:33:25.640
it caused on the body were more or less powerful.
1735
01:33:26.279 --> 01:33:28.619
Hence arose the belief that there was more substance or
1736
01:33:28.689 --> 01:33:31.329
body in rocks and metal than in air or water,
1737
01:33:31.770 --> 01:33:35.810
because the mind perceived in them more hardness and weight. Moreover,
1738
01:33:35.829 --> 01:33:38.109
the air was thought to be merely nothing so long
1739
01:33:38.170 --> 01:33:40.689
as we experienced no agitation of it by the wind.
1740
01:33:41.159 --> 01:33:43.960
or did not feel it hot or cold. And because
1741
01:33:44.020 --> 01:33:46.550
the stars gave hardly more light than the slender flames
1742
01:33:46.590 --> 01:33:49.409
of candles, we suppose that each star was but of
1743
01:33:49.449 --> 01:33:52.770
this size. Again, since the mind did not observe that
1744
01:33:52.789 --> 01:33:55.750
the earth moved on its axis, or that its superficies
1745
01:33:55.789 --> 01:33:58.060
was curved like that of a globe, it was on
1746
01:33:58.100 --> 01:34:01.020
that account more ready to judge the earth immovable and
1747
01:34:01.060 --> 01:34:04.239
its surface flat. And our mind has been imbued from
1748
01:34:04.300 --> 01:34:07.119
our infancy with a thousand other prejudices of the same
1749
01:34:07.220 --> 01:34:09.930
sort which afterwards in our youth we forgot we had
1750
01:34:09.970 --> 01:34:13.850
accepted without sufficient examination and admitted as possessed of the
1751
01:34:13.909 --> 01:34:16.159
highest truth and clearness as if they had been known
1752
01:34:16.199 --> 01:34:18.600
by means of our senses or implanted in us by
1753
01:34:18.659 --> 01:34:23.720
nature seventy two that the second cause of our errors
1754
01:34:23.800 --> 01:34:27.609
is that we cannot forget these prejudices And although now,
1755
01:34:27.710 --> 01:34:30.270
in our mature years, when the mind, being no longer
1756
01:34:30.329 --> 01:34:32.770
wholly subject to the body, it is not in the
1757
01:34:32.789 --> 01:34:35.720
habit of referring all things to it, but also seeks
1758
01:34:35.760 --> 01:34:39.020
to discover the truth of things considered in themselves, we
1759
01:34:39.060 --> 01:34:41.399
observe the falsehood of a great many of the judgment
1760
01:34:41.439 --> 01:34:44.739
we had before formed. Yet we experience a difficulty in
1761
01:34:44.800 --> 01:34:47.479
expunging them from our memory, and so long as they
1762
01:34:47.520 --> 01:34:51.989
remain there, they give rise to various errors. Thus, for example,
1763
01:34:52.069 --> 01:34:54.510
since from our earliest years we imagined the stars to
1764
01:34:54.550 --> 01:34:57.430
be a very small size, we find it highly difficult
1765
01:34:57.470 --> 01:35:00.840
to rid ourselves of this imagination, although assured by plain
1766
01:35:00.859 --> 01:35:04.539
astronomical reasons that they are of the greatest. So prevailing
1767
01:35:04.600 --> 01:35:06.539
is the power of preconceived opinion.
1768
01:35:06.539 --> 01:35:08.539
73.
1769
01:35:08.560 --> 01:35:12.819
The third cause is that we become fatigued by attending
1770
01:35:12.859 --> 01:35:15.359
to those objects which are not present to the senses.
1771
01:35:15.880 --> 01:35:17.899
and that we are thus accustomed to judge of these
1772
01:35:17.979 --> 01:35:22.699
not from present perception but from preconceived opinion besides our
1773
01:35:22.750 --> 01:35:25.989
mind cannot attend to any object without at length experiencing
1774
01:35:26.050 --> 01:35:28.989
some pain and fatigue and of all objects it has
1775
01:35:29.029 --> 01:35:31.770
the greatest difficulty in attending to those which are present
1776
01:35:31.840 --> 01:35:35.069
neither to the senses nor to the imagination whether for
1777
01:35:35.090 --> 01:35:37.090
the reason that this is natural to it from its
1778
01:35:37.210 --> 01:35:39.930
union with the body, or because in our early years,
1779
01:35:40.310 --> 01:35:44.069
being occupied merely with perceptions and imaginations, it has become
1780
01:35:44.170 --> 01:35:47.569
more familiar with and acquired greater facility in thinking in
1781
01:35:47.609 --> 01:35:51.020
those modes than in any other. Hence it also happens
1782
01:35:51.060 --> 01:35:54.220
that many are unable to conceive any substance except what
1783
01:35:54.260 --> 01:35:58.260
is imaginable and corporeal, and even sensible. for they are
1784
01:35:58.319 --> 01:36:01.699
ignorant of the circumstance that those objects alone are imaginable,
1785
01:36:01.779 --> 01:36:04.869
which consist in extension, motion, and figure, while there are
1786
01:36:04.890 --> 01:36:08.470
many others beside these that are intelligible, and they persuade
1787
01:36:08.489 --> 01:36:12.029
themselves that nothing can subsist but body, and finally that
1788
01:36:12.050 --> 01:36:15.010
there is no body which is not sensible. And since
1789
01:36:15.069 --> 01:36:17.689
in truth we perceive no object such as it is
1790
01:36:17.770 --> 01:36:21.050
by sense alone, but only by our reason exercised upon
1791
01:36:21.090 --> 01:36:24.710
sensible objects, As will hereafter be clearly shown, it thus
1792
01:36:24.750 --> 01:36:28.010
happens that the majority during life perceive nothing unless in
1793
01:36:28.050 --> 01:36:33.569
a confused way. 74. The fourth source of our errors
1794
01:36:33.689 --> 01:36:36.000
is that we attach our thoughts to words which do
1795
01:36:36.039 --> 01:36:39.939
not express them with accuracy. Finally, since for the use
1796
01:36:39.979 --> 01:36:42.579
of speech we attach all our conceptions to words by
1797
01:36:42.619 --> 01:36:45.600
which to express them, and commit to memory our thoughts
1798
01:36:45.680 --> 01:36:48.640
in connection with these terms, and as we afterwards find
1799
01:36:48.680 --> 01:36:50.920
it more easy to recall the words than the things
1800
01:36:50.960 --> 01:36:54.600
signified by them, we can scarcely conceive anything with such
1801
01:36:54.680 --> 01:36:58.260
distinctness as to separate entirely what we conceive from the
1802
01:36:58.300 --> 01:37:01.770
words that were selected to express it. On this account,
1803
01:37:01.829 --> 01:37:05.130
the majority attend to words rather than to things, and
1804
01:37:05.149 --> 01:37:08.350
thus very frequently ascend to terms without attaching to them
1805
01:37:08.489 --> 01:37:11.670
any meaning, either because they think they once understood them,
1806
01:37:12.170 --> 01:37:14.479
or imagine they received them from others by whom they
1807
01:37:14.520 --> 01:37:18.060
were correctly understood. This, however, is not the place to
1808
01:37:18.119 --> 01:37:20.689
treat of this matter in detail. seeing the nature of
1809
01:37:20.710 --> 01:37:23.649
the human body has not yet been expounded, nor the
1810
01:37:23.710 --> 01:37:27.899
existence even of body established. Enough, nevertheless, appears to have
1811
01:37:27.939 --> 01:37:30.340
been said to enable one to distinguish such of our
1812
01:37:30.380 --> 01:37:33.399
conceptions as are clear and distinct from those that are
1813
01:37:33.460 --> 01:37:37.000
obscure and confused.
1814
01:37:37.000 --> 01:37:37.939
75.
1815
01:37:37.939 --> 01:37:40.770
SUMMARY OF WHAT MUST BE OBSERVED IN ORDER TO
PHILOSOPHIZE
1816
01:37:40.810 --> 01:37:45.100
CORRECTLY Wherefore, if we would philosophize in earnest, and give
1817
01:37:45.140 --> 01:37:47.479
ourselves to the search after all the truths we are
1818
01:37:47.520 --> 01:37:50.760
capable of knowing, we must, in the first place, lay
1819
01:37:50.819 --> 01:37:54.000
aside our prejudices. In other words, we must take care
1820
01:37:54.100 --> 01:37:57.399
scrupulously to withhold our assent from the opinions we have
1821
01:37:57.460 --> 01:38:01.340
formerly admitted, until, upon new examination, we discover that they
1822
01:38:01.380 --> 01:38:04.510
are true. We must, in the next place, make an
1823
01:38:04.619 --> 01:38:07.050
orderly review of the notions we have in our minds,
1824
01:38:07.510 --> 01:38:10.069
and hold as true all and only those which we
1825
01:38:10.109 --> 01:38:14.060
will clearly and distinctly apprehend. In this way we will observe,
1826
01:38:14.239 --> 01:38:16.649
first of all, that we exist insofar as it is
1827
01:38:16.689 --> 01:38:19.149
our nature to think, and at the same time that
1828
01:38:19.170 --> 01:38:22.109
there is a God upon whom we depend. And after
1829
01:38:22.170 --> 01:38:25.130
considering his attributes, we will be able to investigate the
1830
01:38:25.229 --> 01:38:28.010
truth of all other things, since God is the cause
1831
01:38:28.050 --> 01:38:30.880
of them. Besides the notions we have of God and
1832
01:38:30.920 --> 01:38:33.539
of our mind, we will likewise find that we possess
1833
01:38:33.560 --> 01:38:37.140
the knowledge of many propositions which are eternally true, as,
1834
01:38:37.300 --> 01:38:41.380
for example, that nothing cannot be the cause of anything, etc.,
1835
01:38:41.619 --> 01:38:46.640
and also of certain sensations that affect us, as of pain, colours, taste, etc.,
1836
01:38:46.789 --> 01:38:48.649
although we do not yet know the cause of our
1837
01:38:48.689 --> 01:38:52.180
being so affected. And comparing what we have now learned
1838
01:38:52.500 --> 01:38:55.350
by examining those things in their order, with our former
1839
01:38:55.390 --> 01:38:58.210
confused knowledge of them, we will acquire the habit of
1840
01:38:58.250 --> 01:39:01.130
forming clear and distinct conceptions of all the objects we
1841
01:39:01.170 --> 01:39:04.510
are capable of knowing. In these few precepts seem to
1842
01:39:04.550 --> 01:39:07.590
me to be comprised the most general and important principles
1843
01:39:07.649 --> 01:39:08.489
of human knowledge.
1844
01:39:08.489 --> 01:39:10.489
76.
1845
01:39:11.449 --> 01:39:14.510
That we ought to prefer the divine authority to our perception,
1846
01:39:15.029 --> 01:39:17.609
but that, apart from things revealed, we ought to ascend
1847
01:39:17.649 --> 01:39:21.500
to nothing that we do not clearly apprehend. Above all,
1848
01:39:21.619 --> 01:39:24.500
we must impress on our memory the infallible rule that
1849
01:39:24.560 --> 01:39:28.300
what God has revealed is incomparably more certain than anything else,
1850
01:39:28.859 --> 01:39:30.979
and that we ought to submit our belief to the
1851
01:39:31.020 --> 01:39:34.760
divine authority rather than to our own judgment, even although
1852
01:39:34.800 --> 01:39:37.720
perhaps the light of reason should, with the greatest clearness
1853
01:39:37.779 --> 01:39:41.270
and evidence, appear to suggest to us something contrary to
1854
01:39:41.310 --> 01:39:44.479
what is revealed. But in things regarding which there is
1855
01:39:44.520 --> 01:39:47.270
no revelation, it is by no means consistent with the
1856
01:39:47.310 --> 01:39:49.869
character of a philosopher to accept as true what he
1857
01:39:49.930 --> 01:39:52.729
has not ascertained to be such, and to trust more
1858
01:39:52.770 --> 01:39:56.310
to the senses, in other words, to the inconsiderate judgment
1859
01:39:56.350 --> 01:40:01.119
of childhood, than to the dictates of mature reason. Recording
1860
01:40:01.159 --> 01:40:08.359
by phone Part 2 of The Principles of Material Things 1.
1861
01:40:08.359 --> 01:40:11.119
The Grounds on which the existence of material things may
1862
01:40:11.159 --> 01:40:15.420
be known with certainty. Although we are all sufficiently persuaded
1863
01:40:15.479 --> 01:40:18.939
of the existence of material things, yet since this was
1864
01:40:19.000 --> 01:40:22.140
before called in question by us, and since we reckon
1865
01:40:22.159 --> 01:40:25.100
the persuasion of their existence as among the prejudices of
1866
01:40:25.159 --> 01:40:28.460
our childhood, it is now necessary for us to investigate
1867
01:40:28.479 --> 01:40:31.520
the grounds on which this truth may be known with certainty.
1868
01:40:32.380 --> 01:40:34.659
In the first place, then, it cannot be doubted that
1869
01:40:34.739 --> 01:40:37.819
every perception we have comes to us from some object
1870
01:40:37.859 --> 01:40:40.399
different from our mind. for it is not in our
1871
01:40:40.439 --> 01:40:44.439
power to cause ourselves to experience one perception rather than another,
1872
01:40:44.859 --> 01:40:48.319
the perception being entirely dependent on the object which affects
1873
01:40:48.399 --> 01:40:52.090
our senses. It may indeed be matter of inquiry whether
1874
01:40:52.119 --> 01:40:55.510
that object be God or something different from God, but
1875
01:40:55.569 --> 01:40:59.470
because we perceive, or rather, stimulated by sense, clearly and
1876
01:40:59.489 --> 01:41:04.270
distinctly apprehend, certain matter extended in length, breadth and thickness,
1877
01:41:04.770 --> 01:41:07.460
the various parts of which have different figures and motions,
1878
01:41:08.000 --> 01:41:12.270
and give rise to the sensation we have of colour, smells, pain, etc.,
1879
01:41:12.539 --> 01:41:15.920
God would, without question, deserve to be regarded as a deceiver,
1880
01:41:16.270 --> 01:41:18.829
if he directly and of himself presented to our mind
1881
01:41:18.869 --> 01:41:21.890
the idea of this extended matter, or merely caused it
1882
01:41:21.949 --> 01:41:24.510
to be presented to us by some object which possessed
1883
01:41:24.569 --> 01:41:28.600
neither extension, figure, nor motion. For we clearly conceive this
1884
01:41:28.640 --> 01:41:32.220
matter as entirely distinct from God, and from ourselves or
1885
01:41:32.340 --> 01:41:35.750
our mind. and appear even clearly to discern that the
1886
01:41:35.829 --> 01:41:38.300
idea of it is formed in us on occasion of
1887
01:41:38.399 --> 01:41:41.300
objects existing out of our minds, to which it is
1888
01:41:41.340 --> 01:41:45.199
in every respect similar. But since God cannot deceive us,
1889
01:41:45.420 --> 01:41:48.159
for this is repugnant to his nature, as has already
1890
01:41:48.199 --> 01:41:52.020
been remarked, we must unhesitatingly conclude that there exists a
1891
01:41:52.060 --> 01:41:56.029
certain object extended in length, breadth, and thickness, and possessing
1892
01:41:56.130 --> 01:41:59.270
all those properties which we clearly apprehend to belong to
1893
01:41:59.310 --> 01:42:02.689
what is extended. and this extended substance is what we
1894
01:42:02.729 --> 01:42:08.050
call body or matter. 2. How we likewise know that
1895
01:42:08.090 --> 01:42:11.850
the human body is closely connected with the mind. We
1896
01:42:11.970 --> 01:42:14.470
ought also to conclude that a certain body is more
1897
01:42:14.510 --> 01:42:17.789
closely united to our mind than any other, because we
1898
01:42:17.850 --> 01:42:21.630
clearly observe that pain and other sensations affect us without
1899
01:42:21.729 --> 01:42:25.369
our foreseeing them, and these, the mind is conscious, do
1900
01:42:25.409 --> 01:42:29.029
not arise from itself alone, nor pertain to it, insofar
1901
01:42:29.130 --> 01:42:32.069
as it is a thing which thinks. but only insofar
1902
01:42:32.170 --> 01:42:35.149
as it is united to another thing extended and movable,
1903
01:42:35.569 --> 01:42:38.359
which is called the human body. But this is not
1904
01:42:38.399 --> 01:42:43.439
the place to treat in detail of this matter. 3.
1905
01:42:43.439 --> 01:42:45.960
That the perceptions of the senses do not teach us
1906
01:42:46.020 --> 01:42:49.300
what is in reality in things, but what is beneficial
1907
01:42:49.380 --> 01:42:52.000
or hurtful to the composite whole of mind and body.
1908
01:42:53.079 --> 01:42:55.430
It will be sufficient to remark that the perception of
1909
01:42:55.470 --> 01:42:58.090
the senses are merely to be referred to this intimate
1910
01:42:58.229 --> 01:43:01.029
union between of the human body and mind and that
1911
01:43:01.050 --> 01:43:04.449
they usually make us aware of what in external objects
1912
01:43:04.829 --> 01:43:07.890
may be useful or adverse to this union but do
1913
01:43:07.930 --> 01:43:10.210
not present to us these objects as they are in
1914
01:43:10.250 --> 01:43:15.649
themselves unless occasionally and by accident for after this observation
1915
01:43:15.949 --> 01:43:18.869
we will without difficulty lay aside the prejudices of the
1916
01:43:18.909 --> 01:43:22.569
senses and will have recourse to our understanding alone on
1917
01:43:22.609 --> 01:43:26.279
this question by reflecting carefully on the ideas implanted in
1918
01:43:26.340 --> 01:43:31.409
it by nature 4. That the nature of body consists
1919
01:43:31.510 --> 01:43:35.520
not in weight-hardness, colour and the like, but in extension alone.
1920
01:43:36.680 --> 01:43:38.920
In this way we will discern that the nature of
1921
01:43:39.000 --> 01:43:42.560
matter or body, considered in general, does not consist in
1922
01:43:42.640 --> 01:43:46.020
its being hard or ponderous or coloured, or that which
1923
01:43:46.079 --> 01:43:49.229
affects our senses in any other way, but simply in
1924
01:43:49.310 --> 01:43:52.390
its being a substance extended in length, breadth and depth.
1925
01:43:53.119 --> 01:43:55.720
For with respect to hardness, we know nothing of it
1926
01:43:55.779 --> 01:43:58.479
by sense farther than that the parts of hard bodies
1927
01:43:58.859 --> 01:44:01.539
resist the motion of our hands on coming into contact
1928
01:44:01.600 --> 01:44:04.579
with them. But if every time our hands moved towards
1929
01:44:04.720 --> 01:44:07.600
any part, all the bodies in that place proceeded as
1930
01:44:07.680 --> 01:44:10.979
quickly as our hands approached, we should never feel hardness,
1931
01:44:11.399 --> 01:44:13.659
and yet we have no reason to believe that bodies
1932
01:44:14.050 --> 01:44:17.069
which might thus proceed would on this account lose that
1933
01:44:17.130 --> 01:44:20.930
which makes them bodies. The nature of body does not, therefore,
1934
01:44:21.050 --> 01:44:24.489
consist in hardness. In the same way, it may be
1935
01:44:24.529 --> 01:44:27.789
shown that weight, colour, and all other qualities of this sort,
1936
01:44:28.149 --> 01:44:31.470
which are perceived in corporeal matter, may be taken from it,
1937
01:44:31.670 --> 01:44:35.579
itself meanwhile remaining entire. It thus follows that the nature
1938
01:44:35.619 --> 01:44:40.180
of body depends on none of these. 5. That the
1939
01:44:40.239 --> 01:44:43.109
truth regarding the nature of body is obscured by the
1940
01:44:43.189 --> 01:44:47.250
opinions respecting rarefaction and a vacuum with which we are preoccupied.
1941
01:44:48.279 --> 01:44:51.060
there still remain two causes to prevent its being fully
1942
01:44:51.119 --> 01:44:54.600
admitted that the true nature of body consists in extension alone.
1943
01:44:55.340 --> 01:44:58.520
The first is the prevalent opinion that most bodies admit
1944
01:44:58.560 --> 01:45:02.470
of being so rarefied and condensed that, when rarefied, they
1945
01:45:02.510 --> 01:45:05.949
have greater extension than when condensed, and some even have
1946
01:45:05.989 --> 01:45:08.569
subtilised to such a
degree as to make a distinction
1947
01:45:08.609 --> 01:45:11.590
between the substance of body and its quantity, and between
1948
01:45:11.670 --> 01:45:15.520
quantity itself and extension. The second cause is this, that
1949
01:45:15.600 --> 01:45:18.640
when we conceive only extension in length, breadth and depth,
1950
01:45:19.020 --> 01:45:20.850
we are not in the habit of saying that body
1951
01:45:20.899 --> 01:45:24.489
is there, but only space and further void space, which
1952
01:45:24.550 --> 01:45:29.770
the generality believes to be a mere negation. 6. In
1953
01:45:29.810 --> 01:45:34.430
what way rarefaction takes place? But with regard to rarefaction
1954
01:45:34.470 --> 01:45:37.949
and condensation, whoever gives his attention to his own thoughts,
1955
01:45:38.149 --> 01:45:40.800
and admits nothing of which he is not clearly conscious,
1956
01:45:41.300 --> 01:45:44.260
will not suppose that there is anything in those processes
1957
01:45:44.720 --> 01:45:47.300
further than a change of figure in the body rarefied
1958
01:45:47.359 --> 01:45:51.000
or condensed, so that, in other words, rare bodies are
1959
01:45:51.039 --> 01:45:53.869
those between the parts of which there are numerous distances
1960
01:45:53.970 --> 01:45:57.489
filled with other bodies, and dense bodies, on the other hand,
1961
01:45:58.050 --> 01:46:01.449
those whose parts approaching each other either diminish these distances
1962
01:46:01.550 --> 01:46:04.130
or take them wholly away, in the latter of which
1963
01:46:04.189 --> 01:46:08.520
cases the body is rendered absolutely dense. The body, however,
1964
01:46:08.619 --> 01:46:12.430
when condensed, has not, therefore, less extension than when the
1965
01:46:12.470 --> 01:46:15.800
parts embrace a greater space, owing to their removal from
1966
01:46:15.840 --> 01:46:19.479
each other, and their dispersion into branches. For we ought
1967
01:46:19.539 --> 01:46:21.899
not to attribute to it the extension of the pores
1968
01:46:21.960 --> 01:46:24.699
or distances which its parts do not occupy when it
1969
01:46:24.779 --> 01:46:28.500
is rarefied, but to the other bodies that fill these interstices.
1970
01:46:29.050 --> 01:46:31.109
Just as when we see a sponge full of water
1971
01:46:31.270 --> 01:46:33.930
or any other liquid, we do not suppose that each
1972
01:46:34.010 --> 01:46:37.210
part of the sponge has on this account greater extension
1973
01:46:37.569 --> 01:46:40.529
than when compressed and dried. but only that its pores
1974
01:46:40.590 --> 01:46:43.449
are wider, and therefore that the body is diffused over
1975
01:46:43.489 --> 01:46:49.590
a larger space. 7. That rarefaction cannot be intelligibly explained
1976
01:46:49.710 --> 01:46:53.210
unless in the way here proposed. And indeed I am
1977
01:46:53.310 --> 01:46:55.939
unable to discover the force of the reasons which have
1978
01:46:55.989 --> 01:46:58.699
induced some to say that rarefaction is the result of
1979
01:46:58.739 --> 01:47:02.239
the augmentation of the quantity of body, rather than to
1980
01:47:02.300 --> 01:47:05.060
explain it on the principle exemplified in the case of
1981
01:47:05.119 --> 01:47:08.739
a sponge. For although when air or water is rarefied,
1982
01:47:09.020 --> 01:47:10.840
we do not see any of the pores that are
1983
01:47:10.880 --> 01:47:13.600
rendered large, or the new body that is added to
1984
01:47:13.659 --> 01:47:16.859
occupy them, it is yet less agreeable to reason to
1985
01:47:16.880 --> 01:47:19.899
suppose something that is unintelligible for the purpose of giving
1986
01:47:19.939 --> 01:47:24.270
a verbal and merely apparent explanation of the rarefaction of bodies,
1987
01:47:24.710 --> 01:47:27.810
than to conclude, because of the rarefaction, that there are
1988
01:47:27.850 --> 01:47:30.850
pores or distances between the parts which are increased in
1989
01:47:30.890 --> 01:47:34.500
size and filled with some new body nor ought we
1990
01:47:34.539 --> 01:47:38.079
to refrain from assenting to this explanation because we perceive
1991
01:47:38.119 --> 01:47:40.649
this new body by none of our senses for there
1992
01:47:40.699 --> 01:47:43.210
is no reason which obliges us to believe that we
1993
01:47:43.250 --> 01:47:46.390
should perceive by our senses all the body in existence
1994
01:47:47.189 --> 01:47:49.430
and we see that it is very easy to explain
1995
01:47:49.470 --> 01:47:53.500
rarefaction in this manner but impossible in any other For
1996
01:47:53.600 --> 01:47:55.899
in fine there would be, as appears to me, a
1997
01:47:56.380 --> 01:48:00.279
manifest contradiction in supposing that any body was increased by
1998
01:48:00.300 --> 01:48:03.939
a quantity or extension which it had not before, without
1999
01:48:03.979 --> 01:48:07.149
the addition to it of a new extended substance, in
2000
01:48:07.199 --> 01:48:10.329
other words of another body, because it is impossible to
2001
01:48:10.369 --> 01:48:13.909
conceive any addition of extension or quantity through a thing
2002
01:48:14.270 --> 01:48:17.970
without supposing the addition of a substance having quantity or extension,
2003
01:48:18.369 --> 01:48:23.199
as will more clearly appear from what follows eight that
2004
01:48:23.279 --> 01:48:27.779
quantity and number differ only in thought from that which
2005
01:48:27.819 --> 01:48:32.159
has quantity and is numbered for quantity differs from extended
2006
01:48:32.199 --> 01:48:35.899
substance and number from what is numbered not in reality
2007
01:48:35.979 --> 01:48:39.289
but merely in our thought so that for example we
2008
01:48:39.329 --> 01:48:42.750
may consider the whole nature of corporeal substance which is
2009
01:48:42.810 --> 01:48:45.659
comprised in a space of ten feet although we do
2010
01:48:45.699 --> 01:48:48.479
not attend to this measure of ten feet for the
2011
01:48:48.539 --> 01:48:51.140
obvious reason that the thing conceived is of the same
2012
01:48:51.199 --> 01:48:53.430
nature in any part of that space as in the
2013
01:48:53.470 --> 01:48:56.449
whole and on the other hand we can conceive the
2014
01:48:56.489 --> 01:49:00.069
number 10 as also a continuous quantity of 10 feet,
2015
01:49:00.529 --> 01:49:03.920
without thinking of this determinate substance, because the concept of
2016
01:49:03.939 --> 01:49:07.140
the number 10 is manifestly the same whether we consider
2017
01:49:07.199 --> 01:49:09.859
a number of 10 feet or 10 of anything else,
2018
01:49:10.479 --> 01:49:13.380
and we can conceive a continuous quantity of 10 feet
2019
01:49:13.739 --> 01:49:17.079
without thinking of this or that determinate substance, although we
2020
01:49:17.100 --> 01:49:19.939
cannot conceive it without some extended substance of which it
2021
01:49:20.000 --> 01:49:24.310
is the quantity. It is in reality, however, impossible that any,
2022
01:49:24.600 --> 01:49:27.729
even the least part, of such quantity or extension can
2023
01:49:27.770 --> 01:49:30.890
be taken away, without the retrenchment at the same time
2024
01:49:31.010 --> 01:49:33.789
of as much of the substance, nor, on the other hand,
2025
01:49:33.949 --> 01:49:36.649
can we lessen the substance, without at the same time
2026
01:49:36.720 --> 01:49:41.760
taking as much from the quantity or extension. 9. That
2027
01:49:41.800 --> 01:49:46.340
corporeal substance, when distinguished from its quantity, is confusedly conceived
2028
01:49:46.420 --> 01:49:51.149
as something incorporeal. Although perhaps some express themselves otherwise on
2029
01:49:51.159 --> 01:49:54.250
this matter, I am nevertheless convinced that they do not
2030
01:49:54.270 --> 01:49:57.260
think differently from what I have now said. For when
2031
01:49:57.300 --> 01:50:01.390
they distinguish corporeal substance from extension or quantity— They either
2032
01:50:01.430 --> 01:50:04.649
mean nothing by the word corporeal substance, or they form
2033
01:50:04.720 --> 01:50:08.199
in their minds merely a confused idea of incorporeal substance,
2034
01:50:08.600 --> 01:50:12.119
which they falsely attribute to corporeal, and leave to extension
2035
01:50:12.159 --> 01:50:15.920
the true idea of this corporeal substance, which extension they
2036
01:50:15.939 --> 01:50:19.279
call an accident, but with such impropriety as to make
2037
01:50:19.340 --> 01:50:21.640
it easy to discover that their words are not in
2038
01:50:21.699 --> 01:50:26.970
harmony with their thoughts. 10. What space or internal place
2039
01:50:27.149 --> 01:50:31.270
is Space or internal place and the corporeal substance which
2040
01:50:31.329 --> 01:50:34.449
is comprised in it are not different in reality, but
2041
01:50:34.489 --> 01:50:36.329
merely in the mode in which they are wont to
2042
01:50:36.350 --> 01:50:39.689
be conceived by us. For, in truth, the same extension
2043
01:50:39.770 --> 01:50:43.840
in length, breadth and depth which constitutes space constitutes
body,
2044
01:50:44.310 --> 01:50:47.140
and the difference between them lies only in this, that
2045
01:50:47.239 --> 01:50:50.560
in body we consider extension as particular and conceive it
2046
01:50:50.600 --> 01:50:53.720
to change with the body, whereas in space we attribute
2047
01:50:53.739 --> 01:50:57.119
to extension a generic unity, so that after taking from
2048
01:50:57.159 --> 01:50:59.899
a certain space the body which occupied it, we do
2049
01:50:59.939 --> 01:51:02.260
not suppose that we have at the same time removed
2050
01:51:02.300 --> 01:51:05.229
the extension of the space, because it appears to us
2051
01:51:05.279 --> 01:51:08.109
that the same extension remains there so long as it
2052
01:51:08.189 --> 01:51:10.850
is of the same magnitude and figure, and preserves the
2053
01:51:10.890 --> 01:51:14.210
same situation in respect to certain bodies around it, by
2054
01:51:14.270 --> 01:51:18.270
means of which we determine this space.
2055
01:51:18.270 --> 01:51:18.850
11.
2056
01:51:18.850 --> 01:51:22.199
How space is not in reality different from corporeal substance
2057
01:51:23.060 --> 01:51:25.239
And indeed, it will be easy to discern that it
2058
01:51:25.319 --> 01:51:28.000
is the same extension which constitutes the nature of body
2059
01:51:28.100 --> 01:51:30.939
as of space, and that these two things are mutually
2060
01:51:30.979 --> 01:51:33.800
diverse only as the nature of the genus and species
2061
01:51:33.899 --> 01:51:37.260
differs from that of the individual, provided we reflect on
2062
01:51:37.300 --> 01:51:39.960
the idea we have of any body, taking a stone
2063
01:51:40.000 --> 01:51:43.180
for example, and reject all that is not essential to
2064
01:51:43.199 --> 01:51:46.739
the nature of body. In the first place then, hardness
2065
01:51:46.779 --> 01:51:49.779
may be rejected, because if the stone were liquefied or
2066
01:51:49.840 --> 01:51:53.140
reduced to powder, it would no longer possess hardness. and
2067
01:51:53.180 --> 01:51:56.279
yet would not cease to be a body. Colour also
2068
01:51:56.319 --> 01:51:58.819
may be thrown out of account, because we have frequently
2069
01:51:58.880 --> 01:52:02.520
seen stones so transparent as to have no colour. Again,
2070
01:52:02.539 --> 01:52:06.079
we may reject weight, because we have the case of fire, which,
2071
01:52:06.159 --> 01:52:09.329
though very light, is still a body. And finally, we
2072
01:52:09.529 --> 01:52:12.829
may reject cold, heat, and all other qualities of this sort,
2073
01:52:13.310 --> 01:52:15.649
either because they are not considered as in the stone,
2074
01:52:16.170 --> 01:52:19.149
or because, with the change of these qualities, the stone
2075
01:52:19.229 --> 01:52:21.369
is not supposed to have lost the nature of body.
2076
01:52:22.260 --> 01:52:25.060
After this examination, we will find that nothing remains in
2077
01:52:25.079 --> 01:52:28.039
the idea of body, except that it is something extended
2078
01:52:28.119 --> 01:52:31.600
in length, breadth and depth, and this something is comprised
2079
01:52:31.680 --> 01:52:34.390
in our idea of space, not only of that which
2080
01:52:34.470 --> 01:52:36.789
is full of body, but even of what is called
2081
01:52:36.850 --> 01:52:37.689
void space.
2082
01:52:37.689 --> 01:52:39.689
12.
2083
01:52:40.609 --> 01:52:43.289
How space differs from body in our mode of conceiving
2084
01:52:43.390 --> 01:52:46.829
it There is, however, some difference between them in the
2085
01:52:46.869 --> 01:52:49.859
mode of conception, for if we remove a stone from
2086
01:52:49.880 --> 01:52:52.739
the space or place in which it was, we conceive
2087
01:52:52.779 --> 01:52:56.010
that its extension also is taken away, because we regard
2088
01:52:56.050 --> 01:53:00.390
this as particular and inseparable from the stone itself. But meanwhile,
2089
01:53:00.470 --> 01:53:02.779
we suppose that the same extension of place in which
2090
01:53:02.840 --> 01:53:05.939
the stone was remains, although the place of the stone
2091
01:53:05.979 --> 01:53:09.279
be occupied by wood, water, air, or by any other body,
2092
01:53:09.720 --> 01:53:13.149
or be even supposed vacant, because we now consider extension
2093
01:53:13.189 --> 01:53:17.229
in general. and think that the same is common to stones, wood, water, air,
2094
01:53:17.289 --> 01:53:20.569
and other bodies, and even to a vacuum itself, if
2095
01:53:20.609 --> 01:53:23.430
there is any such thing, provided it be of the
2096
01:53:23.470 --> 01:53:26.770
same magnitude and figure as before, and preserve the same
2097
01:53:26.829 --> 01:53:30.449
situation among the external bodies which determine this space.
2098
01:53:30.449 --> 01:53:32.449
13.
2099
01:53:33.489 --> 01:53:37.409
What external place is? The reason of which is that
2100
01:53:37.470 --> 01:53:40.880
the words place and space signify nothing really different from body,
2101
01:53:40.979 --> 01:53:43.699
which is said to be in place, but merely designate
2102
01:53:43.779 --> 01:53:47.750
its magnitude, figure, and situation among other bodies. For it
2103
01:53:47.810 --> 01:53:51.369
is necessary, in order to determine the situation, to regard
2104
01:53:51.449 --> 01:53:55.029
other bodies which we consider as immovable, and according as
2105
01:53:55.069 --> 01:53:57.529
we look to different bodies, we may see that the
2106
01:53:57.569 --> 01:54:00.039
same thing at the same time does and does not
2107
01:54:00.140 --> 01:54:03.600
change place. For example, when a vessel is being carried
2108
01:54:03.659 --> 01:54:06.239
out to sea, a person sitting at the stern may
2109
01:54:06.279 --> 01:54:08.970
be said to remain always in one place, if we
2110
01:54:09.010 --> 01:54:11.529
look to the parts of the vessel. since with respect
2111
01:54:11.550 --> 01:54:14.510
to these he preserves the same situation, and on the
2112
01:54:14.550 --> 01:54:17.180
other hand, if regard be had to the
neighbouring shores,
2113
01:54:17.529 --> 01:54:20.340
the same person will seem to be perpetually changing place,
2114
01:54:20.880 --> 01:54:24.340
saying he is constantly receding from one shore and approaching another.
2115
01:54:24.359 --> 01:54:27.720
And besides, if we suppose that the earth moves, and
2116
01:54:27.760 --> 01:54:29.979
that it makes precisely as much way from west to
2117
01:54:30.100 --> 01:54:32.760
east as the vessel from east to west, we will
2118
01:54:32.840 --> 01:54:35.300
again say that the person at the stern does not
2119
01:54:35.340 --> 01:54:38.260
change his place, because this place will be determined by
2120
01:54:38.319 --> 01:54:41.899
certain immovable points, which we imagine to be in the heavens.
2121
01:54:42.579 --> 01:54:44.960
But if at length we are persuaded that there are
2122
01:54:45.000 --> 01:54:48.300
no points really immovable in the universe, as will hereafter
2123
01:54:48.340 --> 01:54:51.079
be shown to be probable, we will then conclude that
2124
01:54:51.140 --> 01:54:54.060
nothing has a permanent place unless insofar as it is
2125
01:54:54.100 --> 01:55:02.210
fixed by our thought. Of the Principles of Material Things 14.
2126
01:55:02.210 --> 01:55:07.189
Wherein Place and Space Differ The terms place and space, however,
2127
01:55:07.369 --> 01:55:12.149
differ in signification, because place more expressly designates situation than
2128
01:55:12.170 --> 01:55:15.470
magnitude or figure, while on the other hand, we think
2129
01:55:15.489 --> 01:55:18.090
of the latter when we speak of space. For we
2130
01:55:18.130 --> 01:55:21.090
frequently say that a thing succeeds to the place of another,
2131
01:55:21.489 --> 01:55:24.470
although it be not exactly of the same magnitude or figure,
2132
01:55:24.909 --> 01:55:27.270
but we do not therefore admit that it occupies the
2133
01:55:27.289 --> 01:55:30.609
same space as the other, and when the situation is changed,
2134
01:55:30.689 --> 01:55:33.409
we say that the place is also changed. although they
2135
01:55:33.430 --> 01:55:36.409
are the same magnitude and figure as before, so that
2136
01:55:36.449 --> 01:55:38.850
when we say that a thing is in a particular place,
2137
01:55:39.149 --> 01:55:41.869
we mean merely that it is situated in a determinate
2138
01:55:41.909 --> 01:55:44.890
way in respect of certain other objects, and when we
2139
01:55:45.010 --> 01:55:47.659
add that it occupies such a space or place, we
2140
01:55:47.720 --> 01:55:50.920
understand besides that it is of such determinate magnitude and
2141
01:55:50.960 --> 01:55:55.340
figure as exactly to fill this space.
2142
01:55:55.340 --> 01:55:55.960
15.
2143
01:55:55.960 --> 01:55:59.119
How external place is rightly taken for the superficies of
2144
01:55:59.159 --> 01:56:03.140
the surrounding body. And thus we never indeed distinguish space
2145
01:56:03.239 --> 01:56:07.180
from extension in length, breadth, and depth. We sometimes, however,
2146
01:56:07.300 --> 01:56:09.890
consider place as in the thing placed, and at other
2147
01:56:09.930 --> 01:56:13.390
times as out of it. Internal place indeed differs in
2148
01:56:13.430 --> 01:56:16.649
no way from space, but external place may be taken
2149
01:56:16.710 --> 01:56:20.619
for the superficies that immediately surrounds the thing placed. it
2150
01:56:20.699 --> 01:56:23.159
ought to be remarked that by superficies we do not
2151
01:56:23.199 --> 01:56:26.479
here understand any part of the surrounding body, but only
2152
01:56:26.510 --> 01:56:29.770
the boundary between the surrounding and surrounded bodies, which is
2153
01:56:29.810 --> 01:56:32.289
nothing more than a mode, or at least that we
2154
01:56:32.329 --> 01:56:34.949
speak of superficies in general which is no part of
2155
01:56:35.050 --> 01:56:38.770
one body rather than another, but is always considered the same,
2156
01:56:39.109 --> 01:56:42.609
provided it retain the same magnitude and figure. For although
2157
01:56:42.649 --> 01:56:45.850
the whole surrounding body with its superficies were changed, it
2158
01:56:45.890 --> 01:56:48.130
would not be supposed that the body which was surrounded
2159
01:56:48.170 --> 01:56:51.199
by it had therefore changed its place, if it meanwhile
2160
01:56:51.239 --> 01:56:54.050
preserved the same situation with respect to the other bodies
2161
01:56:54.359 --> 01:56:57.770
that are regarded as immovable. Thus, if we suppose that
2162
01:56:57.810 --> 01:57:00.069
a boat is carried in one direction by the current
2163
01:57:00.090 --> 01:57:02.390
of a stream, and impelled by the wind in the
2164
01:57:02.449 --> 01:57:05.569
opposite with an equal force, so that its situation with
2165
01:57:05.609 --> 01:57:08.479
respect to the banks is not changed, we will readily
2166
01:57:08.560 --> 01:57:11.239
admit that it remains in the same place, although the
2167
01:57:11.279 --> 01:57:14.420
whole superficies which surrounds it is incessantly changing.
2168
01:57:14.420 --> 01:57:16.420
16.
2169
01:57:17.409 --> 01:57:20.010
That a vacuum or space in which there is absolutely
2170
01:57:20.069 --> 01:57:23.609
no body is repugnant to reason with regard to a
2171
01:57:23.649 --> 01:57:26.939
vacuum in the philosophical sense of the term that is
2172
01:57:26.960 --> 01:57:29.659
a space in which there is no substance it is
2173
01:57:29.760 --> 01:57:32.970
evident that such does not exist Seeing the extension of
2174
01:57:33.029 --> 01:57:36.090
space or internal place is not different from that of body.
2175
01:57:36.770 --> 01:57:39.449
For since from this alone, that a body has extension
2176
01:57:39.529 --> 01:57:42.460
in length, breadth and depth, we have reason to conclude
2177
01:57:42.520 --> 01:57:46.180
that it is a substance, it being absolutely contradictory that
2178
01:57:46.220 --> 01:57:49.300
nothing should possess extension, we ought to form a similar
2179
01:57:49.380 --> 01:57:53.220
inference
regarding the space which is supposed void, that is,
2180
01:57:53.359 --> 01:57:56.039
that since there is extension in it, there is necessarily
2181
01:57:56.140 --> 01:58:01.819
also substance. Seventeen that a vacuum in the ordinary use
2182
01:58:01.859 --> 01:58:05.159
of the term does not exclude all body and in
2183
01:58:05.239 --> 01:58:08.170
truth by the term vacuum in its common use we
2184
01:58:08.210 --> 01:58:10.060
do not mean a place or space in which there
2185
01:58:10.100 --> 01:58:13.039
is absolutely nothing, but only a place in which there
2186
01:58:13.100 --> 01:58:16.319
is none of those things we presume ought to be there. Thus,
2187
01:58:16.539 --> 01:58:18.949
because a pitcher is made to hold water, it is
2188
01:58:18.989 --> 01:58:21.529
said to be empty when it is merely filled with air,
2189
01:58:22.090 --> 01:58:24.010
or if there are no fish in a fish pond,
2190
01:58:24.369 --> 01:58:26.510
we say there is nothing in it, although it be
2191
01:58:26.569 --> 01:58:29.199
full of water. Thus, a vessel is said to be
2192
01:58:29.279 --> 01:58:31.779
empty when, in place of the merchandise which it was
2193
01:58:31.840 --> 01:58:35.000
designed to carry, it is loaded with sand only, to
2194
01:58:35.079 --> 01:58:38.399
enable it to resist the violence of the wind. And finally,
2195
01:58:38.430 --> 01:58:40.489
it is in the same sense that we say space
2196
01:58:40.569 --> 01:58:44.189
is void when it contains nothing sensible, although it contain
2197
01:58:44.250 --> 01:58:47.569
created and self-subsisting matter, for we are not in the
2198
01:58:47.609 --> 01:58:50.850
habit of considering the bodies near us, unless insofar as
2199
01:58:50.869 --> 01:58:53.909
they cause in our organs of sense impressions strong enough
2200
01:58:53.979 --> 01:58:56.890
to enable us to perceive them. And if, in place
2201
01:58:56.930 --> 01:58:58.930
of keeping in mind what ought to be understood by
2202
01:58:58.970 --> 01:59:02.560
these terms a vacuum and nothing, we afterwards suppose that
2203
01:59:02.640 --> 01:59:04.699
in the space we call the vacuum there is not
2204
01:59:04.819 --> 01:59:08.119
only no sensible object, but no object at all, we
2205
01:59:08.140 --> 01:59:10.619
will fall into the same error as if, because a
2206
01:59:10.659 --> 01:59:13.079
picture in which there is nothing but air is, in
2207
01:59:13.119 --> 01:59:16.119
common speech, said to be empty, we were therefore to
2208
01:59:16.159 --> 01:59:18.810
judge that the air contained in it is not a substance.
2209
01:59:19.449 --> 01:59:20.529
Res subsistens.
2210
01:59:22.729 --> 01:59:23.069
Eighteen.
2211
01:59:23.670 --> 01:59:26.539
How the prejudice of an absolute vacuum is to be corrected.
2212
01:59:27.640 --> 01:59:30.079
We have almost all fallen into this error from the
2213
01:59:30.159 --> 01:59:33.579
earliest age, for, observing that there is no necessary connection
2214
01:59:33.640 --> 01:59:36.539
between a vessel
and the body it contains, we thought
2215
01:59:36.579 --> 01:59:38.899
that God, at least, could take from a vessel the
2216
01:59:38.939 --> 01:59:42.119
body which occupied it, without it being necessary that any
2217
01:59:42.220 --> 01:59:44.729
other should be put in the place of the one removed.
2218
01:59:45.289 --> 01:59:47.090
But that we may be able now to correct this
2219
01:59:47.130 --> 01:59:50.109
false opinion, it is necessary to remark that there is,
2220
01:59:50.210 --> 01:59:52.789
in truth, no connection between the vessel and the particular
2221
01:59:52.829 --> 01:59:55.640
body which it contains. but that there is an absolutely
2222
01:59:55.699 --> 01:59:59.170
necessary connection between the concave figure of the vessel and
2223
01:59:59.210 --> 02:00:02.170
the extension considered generally which must be comprised in this
2224
02:00:02.189 --> 02:00:05.520
cavity so that it is not more contradictory to conceive
2225
02:00:05.560 --> 02:00:08.359
a mountain without a valley than such a cavity without
2226
02:00:08.399 --> 02:00:11.600
the extension it contains or this extension apart from an
2227
02:00:11.659 --> 02:00:15.600
extended substance for as we have often said of nothing
2228
02:00:15.760 --> 02:00:18.819
there can be no extension and accordingly if it be
2229
02:00:18.960 --> 02:00:21.090
asked what would happen were god to remove from a
2230
02:00:21.119 --> 02:00:24.510
vessel all the body contained in it without permitting another
2231
02:00:24.550 --> 02:00:27.310
body to occupy its place the answer must be that
2232
02:00:27.350 --> 02:00:29.869
the sides of the vessel would thus come into proximity
2233
02:00:29.909 --> 02:00:32.729
with each other for two bodies must touch each other
2234
02:00:32.789 --> 02:00:35.500
when there is nothing between them and it is manifestly
2235
02:00:35.560 --> 02:00:38.850
contradictory for two bodies to be apart in other words
2236
02:00:38.930 --> 02:00:41.340
that there should be a distance between them and this
2237
02:00:41.359 --> 02:00:44.560
distance yet be nothing for all distance is a mode
2238
02:00:44.579 --> 02:00:48.640
of extension and cannot therefore exist without an extended substance
2239
02:00:50.260 --> 02:00:55.710
nineteen that this confirms what was said of rarefaction after
2240
02:00:55.750 --> 02:00:58.449
we have thus remarked that the nature of corporeal substance
2241
02:00:58.510 --> 02:01:01.460
consists only in its being an extended thing and that
2242
02:01:01.500 --> 02:01:04.270
its extension is not different from that which we attribute
2243
02:01:04.310 --> 02:01:07.569
to space however empty it is easy to discover the
2244
02:01:07.630 --> 02:01:10.350
impossibility of any one of its parts in any way
2245
02:01:10.390 --> 02:01:13.890
whatsoever occupying more space at one time than at another
2246
02:01:13.909 --> 02:01:17.060
and thus of being otherwise rarified than in the way
2247
02:01:17.189 --> 02:01:20.479
explained above and it is easy to perceive also that
2248
02:01:20.500 --> 02:01:22.880
there cannot be more matter or body in a vessel
2249
02:01:23.239 --> 02:01:25.600
when it is filled with lead or gold or any
2250
02:01:25.659 --> 02:01:28.319
other body however heavy and hard than when it but
2251
02:01:28.380 --> 02:01:31.239
contains air and is supposed to be empty for the
2252
02:01:31.279 --> 02:01:33.720
quantity of the parts of which a body is composed
2253
02:01:34.039 --> 02:01:36.760
does not depend on their weight or hardness but only
2254
02:01:36.819 --> 02:01:39.649
on the extension which is always equal in the same
2255
02:01:39.710 --> 02:01:44.970
phase twenty that from this the non-existence of atoms may
2256
02:01:45.010 --> 02:01:49.489
likewise be demonstrated we likewise discover that there cannot exist
2257
02:01:49.689 --> 02:01:52.000
any atoms or parts of matter that are of their
2258
02:01:52.100 --> 02:01:55.869
own nature indivisible for however small we suppose these parts
2259
02:01:55.909 --> 02:01:59.430
to be yet because they are necessarily extended we are
2260
02:01:59.510 --> 02:02:02.050
always able in thought to divide any one of them
2261
02:02:02.170 --> 02:02:05.569
into two or more smaller parts and may accordingly admit
2262
02:02:05.609 --> 02:02:08.949
their divisibility for there is nothing we can divide in
2263
02:02:08.989 --> 02:02:11.600
thought which we do not thereby recognise to be divisible
2264
02:02:12.149 --> 02:02:15.479
and therefore were we to judge it indivisible our judgment
2265
02:02:15.539 --> 02:02:17.619
would not be in harmony with the knowledge we have
2266
02:02:17.659 --> 02:02:20.359
of the thing and although we should even suppose that
2267
02:02:20.439 --> 02:02:23.470
god had produced any particle of matter to a smallness
2268
02:02:23.510 --> 02:02:26.229
so extreme that it did not admit of being further
2269
02:02:26.289 --> 02:02:30.880
divided It would nevertheless be improperly styled indivisible, for though
2270
02:02:30.920 --> 02:02:33.239
God had rendered the particle so small that it was
2271
02:02:33.279 --> 02:02:35.460
not in the power of any creature to divide it,
2272
02:02:35.920 --> 02:02:38.479
he could not, however, deprive himself of the ability to
2273
02:02:38.520 --> 02:02:41.760
do so, since it is absolutely impossible for him to
2274
02:02:41.819 --> 02:02:47.279
lessen his own omnipotence, as was before observed. Wherefore, absolutely speaking,
2275
02:02:47.300 --> 02:02:51.100
the smallest extended particle is always divisible, since it is
2276
02:02:51.140 --> 02:02:56.170
such of its very nature. 21 it is thus also
2277
02:02:56.229 --> 02:03:00.029
demonstrated that the extension of the world is indefinite. We
2278
02:03:00.069 --> 02:03:03.779
further discover that this world, or the whole, universitas, of
2279
02:03:03.840 --> 02:03:08.300
corporeal substance, is extended without limit, for wherever we fix
2280
02:03:08.340 --> 02:03:11.260
a
limit, we still not only imagine beyond its spaces
2281
02:03:11.380 --> 02:03:15.640
indefinitely extended, but perceive these to be truly imaginable, in
2282
02:03:15.680 --> 02:03:18.479
other words, to be in reality such as we imagine them,
2283
02:03:18.979 --> 02:03:22.770
so that they contain in them corporeal substance indefinitely extended.
2284
02:03:23.279 --> 02:03:26.100
for as has already been shown at length, the idea
2285
02:03:26.159 --> 02:03:29.359
of extension, which you conceive in any space whatever, is
2286
02:03:29.399 --> 02:03:35.510
plainly identical with the idea of corporeal substance. 22. It
2287
02:03:35.569 --> 02:03:37.770
also follows that the matter of the heavens and earth
2288
02:03:37.869 --> 02:03:40.529
is the same, and that there cannot be a plurality
2289
02:03:40.569 --> 02:03:43.710
of worlds, and it may also be easily infirmed from
2290
02:03:43.770 --> 02:03:45.720
all this that the earth and heavens are made of
2291
02:03:45.770 --> 02:03:48.180
the same matter. and that even although there were an
2292
02:03:48.279 --> 02:03:51.420
infinity of worlds they would all be composed of this matter,
2293
02:03:51.899 --> 02:03:55.039
from which it follows that a plurality of worlds is impossible,
2294
02:03:55.420 --> 02:03:58.100
because we clearly conceive that the matter whose nature consists
2295
02:03:58.260 --> 02:04:02.159
only in its being an extended substance already wholly occupies
2296
02:04:02.300 --> 02:04:05.800
all the imaginable spaces where these other worlds could alone be,
2297
02:04:06.180 --> 02:04:08.500
and we cannot find in ourselves the idea of any
2298
02:04:08.560 --> 02:04:13.649
other matter. 23. That all the variety of matter, or
2299
02:04:13.670 --> 02:04:17.340
the diversity of its forms, depends on motion. There is
2300
02:04:17.380 --> 02:04:19.939
therefore but one kind of matter in the whole universe,
2301
02:04:20.279 --> 02:04:23.479
and this we know only by its being extended. All
2302
02:04:23.500 --> 02:04:26.659
the properties we distinctly perceive to belong to it are
2303
02:04:26.699 --> 02:04:29.779
reducible to its capacity of being divided and moved according
2304
02:04:29.800 --> 02:04:32.859
to its parts, and accordingly it is capable of all
2305
02:04:32.880 --> 02:04:35.659
those affections which we perceive can arise from the motion
2306
02:04:35.699 --> 02:04:38.619
of its parts. For the partition of matter in thought
2307
02:04:38.979 --> 02:04:41.680
makes no change in it, but all variation of it
2308
02:04:41.859 --> 02:04:45.930
or diversity of form depends on motion. The philosophers even
2309
02:04:45.970 --> 02:04:48.909
seem universally to have observed this, for they said that
2310
02:04:48.970 --> 02:04:51.850
nature was the principle of motion and rest, and by
2311
02:04:51.930 --> 02:04:55.149
nature they understood that by which all corporeal things become
2312
02:04:55.210 --> 02:05:00.529
such as they are found in experience. 24. What motion is,
2313
02:05:00.810 --> 02:05:05.529
taking the term in its common use. But motion, that is, local,
2314
02:05:05.710 --> 02:05:08.109
for I can conceive no other kind of motion, and
2315
02:05:08.130 --> 02:05:10.430
therefore I do not think we ought to suppose there
2316
02:05:10.470 --> 02:05:13.390
is any other in nature. In the ordinary sense of
2317
02:05:13.449 --> 02:05:16.069
the term— is nothing more than the action by which
2318
02:05:16.109 --> 02:05:19.130
a body passes from one place to another. And just
2319
02:05:19.189 --> 02:05:21.289
as we have remarked above that the same thing may
2320
02:05:21.329 --> 02:05:23.470
be said to change and not to change place at
2321
02:05:23.510 --> 02:05:26.270
the same time, so also we may say that the
2322
02:05:26.310 --> 02:05:29.810
same thing is at the same time moved and not moved. Thus,
2323
02:05:29.979 --> 02:05:32.609
for example, a person seated in a vessel which is
2324
02:05:32.649 --> 02:05:35.239
setting sail thinks he is in motion if he looks
2325
02:05:35.279 --> 02:05:37.560
to the shore that he has left and consider it
2326
02:05:37.640 --> 02:05:40.340
as fixed, but not if we regard the ship itself,
2327
02:05:40.600 --> 02:05:43.699
among the parts of which he preserves always the same situations.
2328
02:05:44.510 --> 02:05:47.109
moreover because we are accustomed to suppose that there is
2329
02:05:47.170 --> 02:05:50.050
no motion without action and that in rest there is
2330
02:05:50.109 --> 02:05:53.180
the cessation of action the person thus seated is more
2331
02:05:53.229 --> 02:05:56.260
properly said to be at rest than in motion seeing
2332
02:05:56.319 --> 02:06:00.359
he is not conscious of being in action twenty five
2333
02:06:00.939 --> 02:06:04.579
what motion is properly so called but if, instead of
2334
02:06:04.680 --> 02:06:08.319
occupying ourselves with that which has no foundation, unless in
2335
02:06:08.399 --> 02:06:11.119
ordinary usage, we desire to know what ought to be
2336
02:06:11.180 --> 02:06:13.939
understood by motion according to the truth of the thing,
2337
02:06:14.460 --> 02:06:17.199
we may say, in order to give it a determinate nature,
2338
02:06:17.460 --> 02:06:20.060
that it is the transporting of one part of matter,
2339
02:06:20.420 --> 02:06:23.199
or of one body, from the vicinity of those bodies
2340
02:06:23.260 --> 02:06:26.359
that are in immediate contact with it, or which we
2341
02:06:26.430 --> 02:06:30.439
regard as addressed, to the vicinity of other bodies. by
2342
02:06:30.500 --> 02:06:32.960
a body as a part of matter i understand all
2343
02:06:33.020 --> 02:06:36.449
that which is transferred together although it be perhaps composed
2344
02:06:36.489 --> 02:06:40.310
of several parts which in themselves have other motions and
2345
02:06:40.390 --> 02:06:42.649
i say that it is the transporting and not the
2346
02:06:42.689 --> 02:06:46.050
force or action which transports with the view of showing
2347
02:06:46.069 --> 02:06:49.050
that motion is always in the moveable thing not in
2348
02:06:49.090 --> 02:06:51.689
that which moves for it seems to me that we
2349
02:06:51.760 --> 02:06:54.880
are not accustomed to distinguish these two things with sufficient
2350
02:06:54.960 --> 02:06:58.060
accuracy Further, I understand that it is a mode of
2351
02:06:58.100 --> 02:07:01.500
the movable thing, and not a substance, just as figure
2352
02:07:01.579 --> 02:07:04.100
is a property of the thing figured, and repose of
2353
02:07:04.140 --> 02:07:10.100
that which is at rest. Recording by phone Part 3.
2354
02:07:10.100 --> 02:07:14.760
Of the Visible World 1. That we cannot think too
2355
02:07:14.819 --> 02:07:18.960
highly of the works of God. Having now ascertained certain
2356
02:07:19.000 --> 02:07:22.220
principles of material things, which were sought not by the
2357
02:07:22.260 --> 02:07:25.189
prejudices of the senses, but by the light of reason,
2358
02:07:25.569 --> 02:07:28.109
and which thus possess so great evidence that we cannot
2359
02:07:28.149 --> 02:07:30.949
doubt of their truth, it remains for us to consider
2360
02:07:31.010 --> 02:07:34.029
whether from these alone we can deduce the explication of
2361
02:07:34.109 --> 02:07:37.270
all the phenomena of nature. We will commence with those
2362
02:07:37.310 --> 02:07:40.460
phenomena that are of the greatest generality, and upon which
2363
02:07:40.500 --> 02:07:44.079
the others depend, as, for example, with the general structure
2364
02:07:44.140 --> 02:07:47.060
of this whole visible world. But in order to our
2365
02:07:47.079 --> 02:07:50.640
philosophizing aright regarding this, two things are first of all
2366
02:07:50.680 --> 02:07:53.300
to be observed. The first is that we should ever
2367
02:07:53.359 --> 02:07:56.119
bear in mind the infinity of the power and goodness
2368
02:07:56.159 --> 02:07:58.930
of God, that we may not fear falling into error
2369
02:07:59.270 --> 02:08:02.539
by imagining his works to be too great, beautiful, and perfect,
2370
02:08:03.000 --> 02:08:05.680
but that we may, on the contrary, take care less
2371
02:08:05.840 --> 02:08:07.939
by supposing limits to them of which we have no
2372
02:08:07.979 --> 02:08:10.859
certain knowledge, we appear to think less highly than we
2373
02:08:10.960 --> 02:08:15.199
ought of the power of God. 2. That we ought
2374
02:08:15.220 --> 02:08:18.039
to beware less in our presumption, we imagine that the
2375
02:08:18.140 --> 02:08:20.710
ends which God proposed to him in the creation of
2376
02:08:20.729 --> 02:08:24.229
the world are understood by us the second is that
2377
02:08:24.250 --> 02:08:27.270
we should beware of presuming too highly of ourselves as
2378
02:08:27.350 --> 02:08:29.840
it seems we should do if we supposed certain limits
2379
02:08:29.880 --> 02:08:33.220
to the world without being assured of their existence either
2380
02:08:33.279 --> 02:08:36.720
by natural reasons
or by divine revelation as if the
2381
02:08:36.760 --> 02:08:39.399
power of our thought extended beyond what god has in
2382
02:08:39.439 --> 02:08:43.239
reality made but likewise still more if we persuaded ourselves
2383
02:08:43.279 --> 02:08:45.909
that all things were created by God for us only,
2384
02:08:46.489 --> 02:08:48.869
or if we merely supposed that we could comprehend by
2385
02:08:48.909 --> 02:08:51.890
the power of our intellect the ends which God proposed
2386
02:08:51.909 --> 02:08:56.760
to himself in creating the universe. 3. In what sense
2387
02:08:56.840 --> 02:08:59.039
it may be said that all things were created for
2388
02:08:59.060 --> 02:09:02.920
the sake of man? For although, as far as regards morals,
2389
02:09:03.140 --> 02:09:05.439
it may be a pious thought to believe that God
2390
02:09:05.479 --> 02:09:08.300
made all things for us, saying we may thus be
2391
02:09:08.340 --> 02:09:11.779
incited to greater gratitude and love toward him and although
2392
02:09:11.819 --> 02:09:14.239
it is even in some sense true because there is
2393
02:09:14.279 --> 02:09:16.699
no created thing of which we cannot make some use
2394
02:09:17.199 --> 02:09:19.689
if it be only that of exercising our mind in
2395
02:09:19.729 --> 02:09:22.930
considering it and honouring god on account of it it
2396
02:09:22.989 --> 02:09:25.529
is yet by no means probable that all things were
2397
02:09:25.569 --> 02:09:27.850
created for us in this way that god had no
2398
02:09:27.949 --> 02:09:31.180
other end in their creation and this supposition would be
2399
02:09:31.220 --> 02:09:34.840
plainly ridiculous and inapt in physical reasoning, for we do
2400
02:09:34.880 --> 02:09:38.180
not doubt but that many things exist, or formerly existed
2401
02:09:38.260 --> 02:09:40.760
and have now ceased to be, which were never seen
2402
02:09:40.859 --> 02:09:43.279
or known by man, and were never of use to him.
2403
02:09:43.300 --> 02:09:48.520
Of what is to be borrowed from disquisitions on animals
2404
02:09:48.539 --> 02:09:58.939
and man to advance the knowledge of material objects? I
2405
02:09:58.979 --> 02:10:01.319
should add nothing farther to this the fourth part of
2406
02:10:01.359 --> 02:10:04.420
the principles of philosophy, that I purpose carrying out my
2407
02:10:04.479 --> 02:10:07.460
original design of writing a fifth and sixth part, the
2408
02:10:07.539 --> 02:10:10.680
one treating of things possessed of life, that is, animals
2409
02:10:10.760 --> 02:10:13.930
and plants, and the other of man. But because I
2410
02:10:13.979 --> 02:10:16.489
have not yet acquired sufficient knowledge of all the matters
2411
02:10:16.529 --> 02:10:18.489
of which I should desire to treat in these two
2412
02:10:18.550 --> 02:10:21.069
last parts, and do not know whether I shall ever
2413
02:10:21.130 --> 02:10:24.210
have sufficient leisure to finish them, I will here subjoin
2414
02:10:24.250 --> 02:10:27.109
a few things regarding
the objects of our senses, that
2415
02:10:27.149 --> 02:10:29.130
I may not, for the sake of the latter, that
2416
02:10:29.170 --> 02:10:32.100
lay too long the publication of the former parts, or
2417
02:10:32.149 --> 02:10:34.619
of what may be desiderated in them, which I might
2418
02:10:34.659 --> 02:10:37.640
have reserved for explanations in those others. For I have
2419
02:10:37.680 --> 02:10:40.979
hitherto described this earth, and generally the whole visible world,
2420
02:10:41.380 --> 02:10:43.119
as if it were merely a machine in which there
2421
02:10:43.159 --> 02:10:45.659
was nothing at all to consider except the figures and
2422
02:10:45.699 --> 02:10:48.710
motions of its parts, whereas our senses present to us
2423
02:10:48.770 --> 02:10:52.869
many other things, for example colours, smells, sounds, and the like,
2424
02:10:53.390 --> 02:10:55.489
of which, if I did not speak at all, it
2425
02:10:55.510 --> 02:10:57.750
would be thought I had omitted the explication of the
2426
02:10:57.770 --> 02:11:03.029
majority of the objects that are in nature.
2427
02:11:03.029 --> 02:11:03.729
189.
2428
02:11:03.729 --> 02:11:09.109
What perception, senses, is, and how we perceive. We must know, therefore,
2429
02:11:09.210 --> 02:11:11.800
that although the human soul is united to the whole body,
2430
02:11:12.220 --> 02:11:15.479
it has, nevertheless, its principal seat in the brain, where
2431
02:11:15.539 --> 02:11:19.079
alone it not only understands and imagines, but also perceives.
2432
02:11:19.760 --> 02:11:21.939
and this by the medium of the nerves, which are
2433
02:11:22.000 --> 02:11:24.880
extended like threads from the brain to all the other members,
2434
02:11:25.260 --> 02:11:27.239
with which they are so connected that we can hardly
2435
02:11:27.279 --> 02:11:30.199
touch any one of them, without moving the extremities of
2436
02:11:30.260 --> 02:11:32.840
some of the nerves spread over it, and this motion
2437
02:11:32.899 --> 02:11:35.300
passes to the other extremities of those nerves which are
2438
02:11:35.359 --> 02:11:37.659
collected in the brain round the seat of the soul,
2439
02:11:38.140 --> 02:11:40.819
as I have already explained with sufficient minuteness in the
2440
02:11:40.859 --> 02:11:44.390
fourth chapter of the dioptrics. But the movements which are
2441
02:11:44.430 --> 02:11:47.250
thus excited in the brain by the nerves variously affect
2442
02:11:47.270 --> 02:11:50.460
the soul or mind, which is intimately conjoined with the brain,
2443
02:11:50.800 --> 02:11:54.140
according to the diversity of the motions themselves. And the
2444
02:11:54.180 --> 02:11:57.199
diverse affections of the mind or thoughts that immediately arise
2445
02:11:57.220 --> 02:12:01.189
from these motions are called perceptions of the senses, sensu
2446
02:12:01.229 --> 02:12:05.789
in perceptiones, or, as we commonly speak, sensations, senses.
2447
02:12:05.789 --> 02:12:07.770
190.
2448
02:12:07.770 --> 02:12:12.819
Of the distinction of the senses and, first, of the internal,
2449
02:12:13.159 --> 02:12:16.460
that is, of the affections of the mind, passions, and
2450
02:12:16.479 --> 02:12:21.229
the natural appetites. The varieties of these sensations depend, firstly,
2451
02:12:21.569 --> 02:12:24.670
on the diversity of the nerves themselves, and secondly, of
2452
02:12:24.710 --> 02:12:28.069
the movements that are made in each nerve. We have not, however,
2453
02:12:28.170 --> 02:12:30.979
as many different senses as there are nerves. We can
2454
02:12:31.020 --> 02:12:34.300
distinguish but seven principal classes of nerves, of which two
2455
02:12:34.359 --> 02:12:36.840
belong to the internal, and the other five to the
2456
02:12:36.939 --> 02:12:41.039
external senses. The nerves which extend to the stomach, the esophagus,
2457
02:12:41.159 --> 02:12:44.359
the fosses, and the other internal parts that are subservient
2458
02:12:44.390 --> 02:12:47.789
to our natural wants, constitute one of our internal senses.
2459
02:12:48.470 --> 02:12:53.189
This is called the natural appetite, appetitos naturales. The other
2460
02:12:53.250 --> 02:12:57.569
internal sense, which embraces all the emotions, commotiones, of the
2461
02:12:57.609 --> 02:13:01.239
mind or passions and affections as joy, sadness, love, hate
2462
02:13:01.319 --> 02:13:04.000
and the like, depends upon the nerves which extend to
2463
02:13:04.020 --> 02:13:06.260
the heart and the parts about the heart, and are
2464
02:13:06.319 --> 02:13:09.939
exceedingly small. For, by want of example, when the blood
2465
02:13:09.979 --> 02:13:12.739
happens to be pure and well-tempered so that it dilates
2466
02:13:12.779 --> 02:13:16.170
in the heart more readily and strongly than usual, it
2467
02:13:16.189 --> 02:13:19.649
is so enlarged and moves small nerves scattered around the orifices,
2468
02:13:20.090 --> 02:13:22.609
that there is thence a corresponding movement in the brain,
2469
02:13:22.939 --> 02:13:25.699
which affects the mind with a certain natural feeling of joy,
2470
02:13:26.140 --> 02:13:28.199
and as often as these same nerves are moved in
2471
02:13:28.220 --> 02:13:31.340
the same way, although this is by other causes, they
2472
02:13:31.399 --> 02:13:35.560
excite in our mind the same feeling, senseless sentiment. Thus,
2473
02:13:35.770 --> 02:13:38.470
the imagination of the enjoyment of a good does not
2474
02:13:38.529 --> 02:13:41.390
contain in itself the feeling of joy, but it causes
2475
02:13:41.449 --> 02:13:43.550
the animal spirits to pass from the brain to the
2476
02:13:43.590 --> 02:13:46.979
muscles in which these nerves are inserted. and thus dilating
2477
02:13:47.000 --> 02:13:49.970
the orifices of the heart, it also causes these small
2478
02:13:50.020 --> 02:13:52.310
nerves to move in the way appointed by nature to
2479
02:13:52.390 --> 02:13:56.409
afford the sensation of joy. Thus, when we receive news,
2480
02:13:56.510 -->
02:13:58.710
the mind first of all judges of it, and if
2481
02:13:58.729 --> 02:14:01.930
the news be good, it rejoices with that intellectual joy,
2482
02:14:01.949 --> 02:14:07.689
gaudium intellectuale, which is independent of any emotion, commotio, of
2483
02:14:07.729 --> 02:14:10.130
the body, and which the Stoics did not deny to
2484
02:14:10.180 --> 02:14:13.199
their wise man, although they supposed him exempt from all passions.
2485
02:14:13.920 --> 02:14:16.239
but as soon as this joy passes from the understanding
2486
02:14:16.279 --> 02:14:19.119
to the imagination, the spirits flow from the brain to
2487
02:14:19.140 --> 02:14:21.800
the muscles that are about the heart, and there excite
2488
02:14:21.840 --> 02:14:24.140
the motion of the small nerves, by means of which
2489
02:14:24.220 --> 02:14:26.520
another motion is caused in the brain, which affect the
2490
02:14:26.560 --> 02:14:31.220
mind with the sensation of animal joy, laetitia animalis. On
2491
02:14:31.239 --> 02:14:33.470
the same principle, when the blood is so thick that
2492
02:14:33.510 --> 02:14:36.619
it flows blood-sparingly into the ventricles of the heart, and
2493
02:14:36.699 --> 02:14:39.609
is not there sufficiently dilated, it excites in the same
2494
02:14:39.670 --> 02:14:43.189
nerves a motion quite different from the preceding, which, communicated
2495
02:14:43.250 --> 02:14:46.199
to the brain, gives to the mind the sensation of sadness,
2496
02:14:46.619 --> 02:14:49.100
although the mind itself is perhaps ignorant of the cause
2497
02:14:49.149 --> 02:14:52.149
of its sadness. And all the other causes which move
2498
02:14:52.170 --> 02:14:54.369
these nerves in the same way may also give to
2499
02:14:54.390 --> 02:14:57.229
the mind the same sensation, but the other movements of
2500
02:14:57.270 --> 02:15:03.010
the same nerves produce other effects, as the feelings of love, hate, fear, anger, etc.,
2501
02:15:03.170 --> 02:15:05.390
as far as they are merely affections or passions of
2502
02:15:05.430 --> 02:15:07.949
the mind. In other words, as far as they are
2503
02:15:07.989 --> 02:15:10.729
confused thoughts which the mind has not from itself alone,
2504
02:15:10.890 --> 02:15:13.350
but from its being closely joined to the body, from
2505
02:15:13.390 --> 02:15:16.630
which it receives impressions. For there is the widest difference
2506
02:15:16.689 --> 02:15:19.449
between these passions and the distinct thoughts which we have
2507
02:15:19.489 --> 02:15:22.729
of what ought to be loved or chosen or shunned, etc.,
2508
02:15:22.869 --> 02:15:26.630
although these are often enough found together. The natural appetites,
2509
02:15:26.789 --> 02:15:30.430
as hunger, thirst, and the others, are likewise sensations excited
2510
02:15:30.470 --> 02:15:33.310
in the mind by means of the nerves of the stomach, falsies,
2511
02:15:33.380 --> 02:15:36.210
and other parts, and are entirely different from the will
2512
02:15:36.250 --> 02:15:38.630
which we have to eat, drink, and to do all
2513
02:15:38.670 --> 02:15:41.300
that which we think proper for the conservation of our body,
2514
02:15:41.760 --> 02:15:45.260
but because this will or appetition almost always accompanies them,
2515
02:15:45.640 --> 02:15:55.350
they are therefore named appetites. We commonly reckon the external
2516
02:15:55.390 --> 02:15:58.470
senses five in number, because there are as many different
2517
02:15:58.510 --> 02:16:00.970
kinds of objects which move the nerves and the organs,
2518
02:16:01.409 --> 02:16:04.310
and an equal number of kinds of confused thoughts excited
2519
02:16:04.350 --> 02:16:07.270
in the soul by these emotions. In the first place,
2520
02:16:07.369 --> 02:16:09.630
the nerves terminating in the skin of the whole body
2521
02:16:10.029 --> 02:16:13.340
can be touched through this medium by any terrain, objects, whatever,
2522
02:16:13.359 --> 02:16:16.479
and moved by these holes, in one way by their hardness,
2523
02:16:16.680 --> 02:16:19.460
in another by their gravity, in a third by their heat,
2524
02:16:19.760 --> 02:16:23.119
in a fourth by their humidity, etc., and in as
2525
02:16:23.159 --> 02:16:25.770
many diverse modes as they are either moved or hindered
2526
02:16:25.810 --> 02:16:29.369
from their ordinary motion, to that extent are diverse sensations
2527
02:16:29.470 --> 02:16:32.069
excited in the mind, from which a corresponding number of
2528
02:16:32.110 --> 02:16:36.250
tactile qualities derive their appellations. Besides this, when these nerves
2529
02:16:36.309 --> 02:16:39.190
are moved a little more powerfully than usual, but not
2530
02:16:39.229 --> 02:16:41.319
nevertheless to the degree by which your body is in
2531
02:16:41.420 --> 02:16:45.159
any way hurt, there thus arises a sensation of titillation,
2532
02:16:45.520 --> 02:16:48.440
which is naturally agreeable to the mind, because it testifies
2533
02:16:48.479 --> 02:16:50.520
to it of the powers of the body with which
2534
02:16:50.600 --> 02:16:53.120
it is joined, in that the latter can suffer the
2535
02:16:53.229 --> 02:16:56.719
action causing this titillation without being hurt. but if this
2536
02:16:56.819 --> 02:16:59.159
action be strong enough to hurt our body in any way,
2537
02:16:59.520 --> 02:17:02.200
this gives to our mind the sensation of pain, and
2538
02:17:02.219 --> 02:17:05.530
we thus see why corporeal pleasure and pain, although sensations
2539
02:17:05.590 --> 02:17:09.809
of quite an opposite character, arise nevertheless from causes nearly alike.
2540
02:17:09.809 --> 02:17:11.510
192. Of Taste.
2541
02:17:14.680 --> 02:17:17.020
In the second place, the outer nerves scattered over the
2542
02:17:17.059 --> 02:17:19.799
tongue and the parts in its vicinity are diversely moved
2543
02:17:19.840 --> 02:17:22.600
by the particles of the same bodies, separated from each
2544
02:17:22.659 --> 02:17:25.040
other and floating in the saliva in the mouth, and
2545
02:17:25.100 --> 02:17:28.399
thus cause sensations of diverse tastes according to the diversity
2546
02:17:28.420 --> 02:17:29.700
of figure in these particles.
2547
02:17:29.700 --> 02:17:31.620
193. Of Smell.
2548
02:17:34.920 --> 02:17:38.069
Thirdly, two nerves also, or appendages of the brain, for
2549
02:17:38.090 --> 02:17:39.989
they do not go beyond the limits of the skull,
2550
02:17:40.430 --> 02:17:43.670
are moved by the particles of terrestrial bodies, separated and
2551
02:17:43.709 --> 02:17:46.969
flying in the air, not indeed by all particles indifferently,
2552
02:17:47.309 --> 02:17:49.950
but by those only that are sufficiently subtle and penetrate.
2553
02:17:49.950 --> 02:17:45.040
194.
2554
02:17:40.049 --> 02:18:07.110
Of Hearing Fourthly, there are two nerves within the ears,
2555
02:18:07.510 --> 02:18:10.620
so attached to three small bones that are mutually sustaining,
2556
02:18:11.000 --> 02:18:13.200
and the first of which rests on the small membrane
2557
02:18:13.219 --> 02:18:15.819
that covers the cavity we call the tympanum of the ear,
2558
02:18:16.260 --> 02:18:19.379
that all the diverse vibrations which the surrounding air communicates
2559
02:18:19.420 --> 02:18:22.379
to this membrane are transmitted to the mind by these nerves,
2560
02:18:22.780 --> 02:18:26.340
and these vibrations give rise, according to their diversity, to
2561
02:18:26.360 --> 02:18:28.100
the sensations of the different sounds.
2562
02:18:28.100 --> 02:18:29.850
195. Of Sight.
2563
02:18:32.809 --> 02:18:35.909
Finally, the extremities of the optic nerves, composing the coat
2564
02:18:35.950 --> 02:18:38.430
in the eyes called the retina, are not moved by
2565
02:18:38.450 --> 02:18:41.350
the air nor by any terrestrial object, but only by
2566
02:18:41.370 --> 02:18:44.069
the globules of the second element, whence we have the
2567
02:18:44.110 --> 02:18:46.590
sense of light and colours, as I have already at
2568
02:18:46.610 --> 02:18:53.299
sufficient length explained in the Dioptrics and the Treatise of Meteors.
2569
02:18:53.299 --> 02:18:53.899
196.
2570
02:18:53.899 --> 02:18:56.340
That the soul perceives only insofar as it is in
2571
02:18:56.360 --> 02:18:59.819
the brain. it is clearly established however that the soul
2572
02:18:59.879 --> 02:19:01.739
does not perceive in so far as it is in
2573
02:19:01.819 --> 02:19:04.120
each member of the body but only in so far
2574
02:19:04.219 --> 02:19:06.239
as it is in the brain where the nerves by
2575
02:19:06.260 --> 02:19:09.100
their movements convey to it the diverse actions of the
2576
02:19:09.229 --> 02:19:11.629
external objects that touch the parts of the body in
2577
02:19:11.649 --> 02:19:14.649
which they are inserted for in the first place there
2578
02:19:14.690 --> 02:19:17.930
are various maladies which though they affect the brain alone
2579
02:19:18.329 --> 02:19:21.250
yet bring disorder upon or deprive us altogether of the
2580
02:19:21.370 --> 02:19:24.750
use of or senses just as sleep which affects the
2581
02:19:24.790 --> 02:19:27.600
brain only and yet takes from us daily during a
2582
02:19:27.639 --> 02:19:30.579
great part of our time the faculty of perception which
2583
02:19:30.700 --> 02:19:34.049
afterwards in our waking state is restored to us the
2584
02:19:34.069 --> 02:19:36.629
second proof is that though there be no disease in
2585
02:19:36.649 --> 02:19:38.989
the brain or in the members in which the organs
2586
02:19:39.030 --> 02:19:42.190
of the external senses are it is nevertheless sufficient to
2587
02:19:42.229 --> 02:19:44.350
take away sensation from the part of the body where
2588
02:19:44.370 --> 02:19:46.930
the nerves terminate, if only the movement of one of
2589
02:19:46.969 --> 02:19:49.129
the nerves that extend from the brain to these members
2590
02:19:49.489 --> 02:19:51.909
be obstructed in any part of the distance that is
2591
02:19:51.950 --> 02:19:54.559
between the two. And the last proof is that we
2592
02:19:54.590 --> 02:19:57.620
sometimes feel pain as if uncertain of our members, the
2593
02:19:57.639 --> 02:19:59.979
cause of which, however, is not in these members where
2594
02:20:00.020 --> 02:20:03.180
it is felt, but somewhere nearer the brain, through which
2595
02:20:03.239 --> 02:20:05.579
the nerves pass that give to the mind the sensation
2596
02:20:05.639 --> 02:20:09.260
of it. i could establish this fact by innumerable experiments
2597
02:20:09.700 --> 02:20:12.190
i will here however merely refer to one of them
2598
02:20:12.770 --> 02:20:14.969
a girl suffering from a bad ulcer in the hand
2599
02:20:15.090 --> 02:20:17.750
had her eyes bandaged whenever the surgeon came to visit
2600
02:20:17.790 --> 02:20:20.030
her not being able to bear the sight of the
2601
02:20:20.090 --> 02:20:23.690
dressing of the sore and the gangrene having spread after
2602
02:20:23.719 --> 02:20:26.700
the expiry of a few days the arm was amputated
2603
02:20:26.760 --> 02:20:30.399
from the elbow without the girl's knowledge linen cloths tied
2604
02:20:30.579 --> 02:20:32.860
one above the other were substituted in place of the
2605
02:20:32.879 --> 02:20:35.889
part amputated so that she remained for some time without
2606
02:20:35.920 --> 02:20:38.950
knowing that the operation had been performed and meanwhile she
2607
02:20:38.989 --> 02:20:42.209
complained of feeling various pains sometimes in one finger of
2608
02:20:42.250 --> 02:20:44.780
the hand that was cut off and sometimes in another
2609
02:20:44.799 --> 02:20:48.000
the only explanation of this is that the nerves which
2610
02:20:48.040 --> 02:20:50.649
before stretched downwards from the brain to the hand and
2611
02:20:50.670 --> 02:20:53.420
then terminated in the arm close to the elbow, were
2612
02:20:53.450 --> 02:20:55.680
there moved in the same way as they required to
2613
02:20:55.739 --> 02:20:57.899
be moved before in the hand for the purpose of
2614
02:20:57.979
--> 02:21:00.500
impressing on the mind residing in the brain the sensation
2615
02:21:00.540 --> 02:21:03.299
of pain in this or that finger, and this clearly
2616
02:21:03.360 --> 02:21:05.200
shows that the pain of the hand is not felt
2617
02:21:05.250 --> 02:21:07.350
by the mind insofar as it is in the hand,
2618
02:21:07.709 --> 02:21:12.649
but insofar as it is in the brain.
2619
02:21:12.649 --> 02:21:13.250
197.
2620
02:21:13.250 --> 02:21:15.250
That the nature of the mind is such that from
2621
02:21:15.270 --> 02:21:18.079
the motion alone of body the various sensations can be
2622
02:21:18.110 --> 02:21:21.159
excited in it. In the next place, it can be
2623
02:21:21.219 --> 02:21:23.219
proved that our mind is of such a nature that
2624
02:21:23.260 --> 02:21:25.879
the motions of the body alone are sufficient to excite
2625
02:21:25.920 --> 02:21:28.979
in it all sorts of thoughts, without it being necessary
2626
02:21:29.020 --> 02:21:31.399
that these should in any way resemble the motions which
2627
02:21:31.459 --> 02:21:34.159
give rise to them, and especially that these motions can
2628
02:21:34.200 --> 02:21:39.239
excite in it those confused thoughts called sensations, senses sensationes.
2629
02:21:39.979 --> 02:21:42.340
For we see that words, whether uttered by the voice
2630
02:21:42.420 --> 02:21:45.200
or merely written, excite in our minds all kinds of
2631
02:21:45.260 --> 02:21:48.340
thoughts and emotions. On the same paper, with the same
2632
02:21:48.399 --> 02:21:50.700
pen and ink, by merely moving the point of the
2633
02:21:50.739 --> 02:21:53.280
pen over the paper in a particular way, we can
2634
02:21:53.340 --> 02:21:55.280
trace letters that will raise in the minds of our
2635
02:21:55.319 --> 02:21:58.549
readers the thoughts of combats, tempests, or the furies, and
2636
02:21:58.569 --> 02:22:01.629
the passions of indignation and sorrow, in place of which,
2637
02:22:01.790 --> 02:22:04.149
if the pen be moved in another way hardly different
2638
02:22:04.170 --> 02:22:07.129
from the former, this slight change will cause thoughts widely
2639
02:22:07.190 --> 02:22:11.010
different from the above, such as those of repose, peace, pleasantness,
2640
02:22:11.170 --> 02:22:14.540
and the quite opposite passions of love and joy. Someone
2641
02:22:14.579 --> 02:22:17.440
will perhaps object that writing and speech do not immediately
2642
02:22:17.500 --> 02:22:20.659
excite in the mind any passions or imaginations of things
2643
02:22:20.719 --> 02:22:23.670
different from the letters and sounds, but afford simply the
2644
02:22:23.709 --> 02:22:26.870
knowledge of these, on occasion of which the mind... Understanding
2645
02:22:26.889 --> 02:22:30.110
the signification of the words afterwards excites in itself the
2646
02:22:30.159 --> 02:22:33.579
imaginations and passions that correspond to the words. But what
2647
02:22:33.600 --> 02:22:36.200
will be said of the sensations of pain and titillation?
2648
02:22:36.219 --> 02:22:39.100
The motion merely of a sword cutting a part of
2649
02:22:39.139 --> 02:22:42.000
our skin causes pain, but does not on that account
2650
02:22:42.069 --> 02:22:44.309
make us aware of the motion or figure of the sword.
2651
02:22:45.010 --> 02:22:47.610
And it is certain that this sensation of pain is
2652
02:22:47.649 --> 02:22:50.290
not less different from the motion that causes it, or
2653
02:22:50.370 --> 02:22:51.969
from that of the part of our body which the
2654
02:22:52.010 --> 02:22:55.340
sword cuts. than are the sensations we have of colour, sound,
2655
02:22:55.500 --> 02:22:58.579
odour or taste. On this ground we may conclude that
2656
02:22:58.639 --> 02:23:01.020
our mind is of such a nature that the motions
2657
02:23:01.120 --> 02:23:04.020
alone of certain bodies can also easily excite in it
2658
02:23:04.159 --> 02:23:06.909
all the other sensations, as the motion of a sword
2659
02:23:06.989 --> 02:23:11.309
excites in it the sensation of pain. Recording by phone
2660
02:23:12.649 --> 02:23:17.649
Of the Earth 198 That by our senses we know
2661
02:23:17.709 --> 02:23:22.379
nothing of external objects beyond their figure or situation, magnitude,
2662
02:23:22.579 --> 02:23:26.469
and motion. Besides, we observe no such difference between the
2663
02:23:26.520 --> 02:23:28.690
nerves as to lead us to judge that one set
2664
02:23:28.709 --> 02:23:31.090
of them convey to the brain from the organs of
2665
02:23:31.129 --> 02:23:34.870
the external senses anything different from another, or that anything
2666
02:23:34.930 --> 02:23:37.530
at all reaches the brain besides the local motion of
2667
02:23:37.569 --> 02:23:40.850
the nerves themselves, and we see that local motion alone
2668
02:23:40.989 --> 02:23:43.899
causes in us not only the sensation of titillation and
2669
02:23:43.940 --> 02:23:47.010
of pain, but also of light and sounds. For if
2670
02:23:47.049 --> 02:23:49.469
we receive a blow on the eye of sufficient force
2671
02:23:49.530 --> 02:23:52.190
to cause the vibration of the stroke to reach the retina,
2672
02:23:52.569 --> 02:23:56.069
we see numerous sparks of fire, which nevertheless are not
2673
02:23:56.149 --> 02:23:58.370
out of our eye, and when we stop our ear
2674
02:23:58.409 --> 02:24:01.250
with our finger, we hear a humming sound, the cause
2675
02:24:01.290 --> 02:24:03.510
of which can only proceed from the agitation of the
2676
02:24:03.629 --> 02:24:07.010
air that is shut up within it. Finally, we frequently
2677
02:24:07.090 --> 02:24:10.530
observe that heat, hardness, weight, and the other sensible qualities,
2678
02:24:10.950 --> 02:24:13.110
as far as they are in objects, and also the
2679
02:24:13.149 --> 02:24:15.969
form of those bodies that are purely material, as for
2680
02:24:16.030 --> 02:24:18.909
example the forms of fire, are produced in them by
2681
02:24:18.950 --> 02:24:21.850
the motion of certain other bodies, and that these, in
2682
02:24:21.889 --> 02:24:25.930
their turn likewise, produce other motions in other bodies. and
2683
02:24:25.950 --> 02:24:28.209
we can easily conceive how the motion of one body
2684
02:24:28.250 --> 02:24:31.030
may be caused by that of another, and diversified by
2685
02:24:31.069 --> 02:24:33.909
the size, figure, and situation of its parts, but we
2686
02:24:33.969 --> 02:24:38.379
are wholly unable to conceive how these same things, that is, size, figure,
2687
02:24:38.459 --> 02:24:41.620
and motion, can produce something else of a nature entirely
2688
02:24:41.680 --> 02:24:45.780
different from themselves, as, for example, those substantial forms and
2689
02:24:45.819 --> 02:24:48.979
real qualities which many philosophers suppose to be in our bodies,
2690
02:24:49.559 --> 02:24:52.360
nor likewise can we conceive how these qualities or forms
2691
02:24:52.440 --> 02:24:55.790
possess force to cause motions in other bodies. but since
2692
02:24:55.829 --> 02:24:58.139
we know from the nature of our soul that the
2693
02:24:58.170 --> 02:25:00.860
diverse motions of body are sufficient to produce in it
2694
02:25:00.959 --> 02:25:03.579
all the sensations which it has, and since we learn
2695
02:25:03.620 --> 02:25:06.780
from experience that several of its sensations are in reality
2696
02:25:06.840 --> 02:25:09.659
caused by such motions, while we do not discover that
2697
02:25:09.780 --> 02:25:13.040
anything besides these motions ever passes from the organs of
2698
02:25:13.079 --> 02:25:15.989
the external senses to the brain, we have reason to
2699
02:25:16.049 --> 02:25:19.129
conclude that we in no way likewise apprehend that in
2700
02:25:19.209 --> 02:25:23.159
external objects which we call light, colour, smell, taste, sound,
2701
02:25:23.440 --> 02:25:27.299
heat or cold, and the other tactile qualities, or that
2702
02:25:27.340 --> 02:25:29.979
which we call their substantial forms, and less as the
2703
02:25:30.000 --> 02:25:32.930
various dispositions of these objects which have the power of
2704
02:25:33.010 --> 02:25:39.110
moving our nerves in various ways. 199. That there is
2705
02:25:39.149 --> 02:25:42.329
no phenomenon of nature whose explanation has been omitted in
2706
02:25:42.370 --> 02:25:45.459
this treatise, and thus it may be gathered from an
2707
02:25:45.500 --> 02:25:48.899
enumeration that is easily made, that there is no phenomenon
2708
02:25:48.940 --> 02:25:51.819
of nature whose explanation has been omitted in this treatise.
2709
02:25:52.479 --> 02:25:55.200
For beyond what is perceived by the senses, there is
2710
02:25:55.280 --> 02:25:58.440
nothing that can be considered a phenomenon of nature. But
2711
02:25:58.540 --> 02:26:02.100
leaving out of account motion, magnitude, figure, and the situation
2712
02:26:02.120 --> 02:26:04.620
of the parts of each body, which I have explained
2713
02:26:04.680 --> 02:26:07.510
as they exist in body, we perceive nothing out of
2714
02:26:07.610 -->
02:26:11.510
us by our senses except light, colours, smells, tastes, sounds,
2715
02:26:11.670 --> 02:26:14.790
and the tactile qualities. And these I have recently shown
2716
02:26:14.850 --> 02:26:17.059
to be nothing more at least so far as they
2717
02:26:17.100 --> 02:26:20.170
are known to us than certain dispositions of the objects
2718
02:26:20.549 --> 02:26:25.850
consisting in magnitude figure and motion two hundred that this
2719
02:26:25.930 --> 02:26:29.700
treatise contains no principles which are not universally received and
2720
02:26:29.719 --> 02:26:32.440
that this philosophy is not new but of all others
2721
02:26:32.479 --> 02:26:35.989
the most ancient and common But I am desirous also
2722
02:26:36.129 --> 02:26:38.450
that it should be observed that, though I have here
2723
02:26:38.489 --> 02:26:40.920
endeavoured to give an explanation of the whole nature of
2724
02:26:40.979 --> 02:26:44.540
material things, I have nevertheless made use of no principle
2725
02:26:44.879 --> 02:26:47.780
which was not received and approved by Aristotle, and by
2726
02:26:47.819 --> 02:26:51.250
the other philosophers of all ages, so that this philosophy,
2727
02:26:51.389 --> 02:26:53.770
so far from being new, is of all the others
2728
02:26:53.809 --> 02:26:56.739
the most ancient and common, for I have in truth
2729
02:26:56.829 --> 02:27:00.440
merely considered the figure, motion, and magnitude of bodies, and
2730
02:27:00.500 --> 02:27:03.219
examined what must follow from their mutual concourse on the
2731
02:27:03.260 --> 02:27:07.200
principles of mechanics, which are confirmed by certain and daily experience.
2732
02:27:07.959 --> 02:27:10.280
But no one ever doubted that bodies are moved, and
2733
02:27:10.299 --> 02:27:13.250
that they are of various sizes and figures, according to
2734
02:27:13.280 --> 02:27:16.450
the diversity of which their motions also vary, and that
2735
02:27:16.489 --> 02:27:19.829
from mutual collision, those somewhat greater than others are divided
2736
02:27:19.889 --> 02:27:23.989
into many smaller, and thus change figure. We have experience
2737
02:27:24.010 --> 02:27:26.620
of the truth of this, not merely by a single sense,
2738
02:27:26.780 --> 02:27:30.659
but by several, as touch, sight and hearing. We also
2739
02:27:30.719 --> 02:27:34.069
distinctly imagine and understand it. This cannot be said of
2740
02:27:34.170 --> 02:27:36.469
any of the other things that fall under our senses,
2741
02:27:36.709 --> 02:27:39.549
as colours, sounds and the like, for each of these
2742
02:27:39.610 --> 02:27:42.530
affects us. one of our senses, and merely impresses upon
2743
02:27:42.569 --> 02:27:46.600
our imagination a confused image of itself, affording our understanding
2744
02:27:46.639 --> 02:27:48.139
no distinct knowledge of what it is.
2745
02:27:48.139 --> 02:27:49.799
201.
2746
02:27:49.799 --> 02:27:55.520
That sensible bodies are composed of insensible particles. But I
2747
02:27:55.600
--> 02:27:58.260
allow many particles in each body that are perceived by
2748
02:27:58.299 --> 02:28:00.659
none of our senses to and this will not perhaps
2749
02:28:00.739 --> 02:28:02.739
be approved of by those who take the senses for
2750
02:28:02.760 --> 02:28:06.520
the measure of the knowable. We greatly wrong human reason, however,
2751
02:28:06.680 --> 02:28:08.579
as appears to me, if we suppose that it does
2752
02:28:08.620 --> 02:28:11.659
not go beyond the eyesight. For no one can doubt
2753
02:28:11.680 --> 02:28:13.700
that there are bodies so small as not to be
2754
02:28:13.760 --> 02:28:17.229
perceptible by any of our senses, provided he only consider
2755
02:28:17.270 --> 02:28:19.510
what is each moment added to those bodies that are
2756
02:28:19.549 --> 02:28:22.309
being increased little by little, and what is taken from
2757
02:28:22.350 --> 02:28:25.239
those that are diminished in the same way. a tree
2758
02:28:25.299 --> 02:28:28.079
increases daily and it is impossible to conceive how it
2759
02:28:28.139 --> 02:28:30.840
becomes greater than it was before unless we at the
2760
02:28:30.879 --> 02:28:33.329
same time conceive that some body is added to it
2761
02:28:34.079 --> 02:28:36.930
but who ever observed by the senses those small bodies
2762
02:28:36.989 --> 02:28:38.950
that are in one day added to a tree while
2763
02:28:38.969 --> 02:28:42.409
growing among the philosophers at least, those who hold that
2764
02:28:42.469 --> 02:28:45.889
quantity is indefinitely divisible, ought to admit that in the
2765
02:28:45.930 --> 02:28:48.270
division the parts may become so small as to be
2766
02:28:48.309 --> 02:28:51.510
wholly imperceptible, and indeed it ought not to be a
2767
02:28:51.530 --> 02:28:54.559
matter of surprise that we are unable to perceive very
2768
02:28:54.620 --> 02:28:57.299
minute bodies, for the nerves that must be moved by
2769
02:28:57.379 --> 02:29:01.040
objects to cause perception are not themselves very minute, but
2770
02:29:01.100 --> 02:29:03.979
are like small cords, being composed of a quantity of
2771
02:29:04.040 --> 02:29:07.079
smaller fibres, and thus the most minute bodies are not
2772
02:29:07.149 --> 02:29:10.350
capable of moving them. nor do I think that anyone
2773
02:29:10.389 --> 02:29:12.649
who makes use of its reason will deny that we
2774
02:29:12.690 --> 02:29:15.409
philosophize with much greater truth when we judge of what
2775
02:29:15.450 --> 02:29:18.629
takes place in those small bodies which are imperceptible from
2776
02:29:18.670 --> 02:29:22.059
their minuteness only, after the analogy of what we see
2777
02:29:22.139 --> 02:29:24.959
occurring in those we do perceive, and in this way
2778
02:29:25.059 --> 02:29:27.399
explain all that is in nature as I have essay
2779
02:29:27.440 --> 02:29:29.920
to do in this treatise, than when we give an
2780
02:29:30.079 --> 02:29:34.209
explanation of the same things by inventing I-know-not-what novelties that
2781
02:29:34.250 --> 02:29:37.319
have no relation to the things we actually perceive, as
2782
02:29:37.379 --> 02:29:40.329
first matter, substantial forms, and all that grand array of
2783
02:29:40.389 --> 02:29:43.780
qualities which many are in the habit of supposing, each
2784
02:29:43.840 --> 02:29:46.329
of which is more difficult to comprehend than all that
2785
02:29:46.389 --> 02:29:48.309
is professed to be explained by means of them.
2786
02:29:48.309 --> 02:29:49.989
202.
2787
02:29:49.989 --> 02:29:54.290
That the philosophy of Democritus is not less different from
2788
02:29:54.430 --> 02:29:57.370
ours than from the common. But it may be said
2789
02:29:57.510 --> 02:30:02.010
that Democritus also supposed certain corpuscles that were of various figures, sizes,
2790
02:30:02.090 --> 02:30:05.360
and motions, from the heaping together and mutual concourse of
2791
02:30:05.399 --> 02:30:09.319
which all sensible bodies arose. And nevertheless, his mode of
2792
02:30:09.340 --> 02:30:13.500
philosophizing is commonly rejected by all. To this I reply
2793
02:30:13.540 --> 02:30:16.520
that the philosophy of Democritus was never rejected by anyone,
2794
02:30:16.879 --> 02:30:19.540
because he allowed the existence of bodies smaller than those
2795
02:30:19.559 --> 02:30:24.030
we perceive, and attributed to them diverse sizes, figures, and motions,
2796
02:30:24.430 --> 02:30:27.250
for no one can doubt that there are in reality such,
2797
02:30:27.489 --> 02:30:30.250
as we have already shown. But it was rejected in
2798
02:30:30.270 --> 02:30:33.920
the first place, because he supposed that these corpuscles were indivisible,
2799
02:30:34.219 --> 02:30:37.239
on which ground I also rejected. In the second place,
2800
02:30:37.319 --> 02:30:40.059
because he imagined there was a vacuum about them, which
2801
02:30:40.120 --> 02:30:43.989
I showed to be impossible. Thirdly, because he attributed gravity
2802
02:30:44.020 --> 02:30:46.389
to these bodies, of which I deny the existence in
2803
02:30:46.489 --> 02:30:49.670
any body, insofar as the body is considered by itself,
2804
02:30:50.129 --> 02:30:52.430
because it is a quality that depends on the relations
2805
02:30:52.469 --> 02:30:55.909
of situation and motion which several bodies bear to each other.
2806
02:30:56.559 --> 02:30:59.260
And finally, because he has not explained in particular how
2807
02:30:59.379 --> 02:31:02.579
all things arose from the concourse of corpuscles alone, or
2808
02:31:02.739 --> 02:31:04.940
if he gave this explanation with regard to a few
2809
02:31:04.979 --> 02:31:07.899
of them, his whole reasoning was far from being coherent,
2810
02:31:08.399 --> 02:31:10.690
or such as would warrant us in extending the same
2811
02:31:10.770 --> 02:31:14.129
explanation to the whole of nature. This, at least, is
2812
02:31:14.149 --> 02:31:17.010
the verdict we must give regarding his philosophy, if we
2813
02:31:17.049 --> 02:31:19.229
may judge of
his opinions from what has been handed
2814
02:31:19.270 --> 02:31:21.870
down to us in writing. I leave it to others
2815
02:31:21.909 --> 02:31:25.639
to determine whether the philosophy I profess possesses a valid coherency,
2816
02:31:26.170 --> 02:31:28.430
and whether on its principles we can make the requisite
2817
02:31:28.489 --> 02:31:32.809
number of deductions, and inasmuch as the consideration of figure, magnitude,
2818
02:31:32.870 --> 02:31:35.850
and motion has been admitted by Aristotle and by all
2819
02:31:35.879 --> 02:31:39.100
the others, as well as by Democritus, and since I
2820
02:31:39.139 --> 02:31:42.559
reject all that the latter has supposed, with this single exception,
2821
02:31:43.000 --> 02:31:45.440
while I reject generally all that has been supposed by
2822
02:31:45.479 --> 02:31:48.299
the others, it is plain that this mode of philosophizing
2823
02:31:48.340 --> 02:31:50.670
has no more affinity with that of Democritus than of
2824
02:31:50.760 --> 02:31:56.750
any other particular sect. 203 how we may arrive at
2825
02:31:56.790 --> 02:31:59.590
the knowledge of the figures, magnitudes, and motions of the
2826
02:31:59.649 --> 02:32:04.889
insensible particles of bodies. But since I assign determinate figures, magnitudes,
2827
02:32:04.930 --> 02:32:08.129
and motions to the insensible particles of bodies, as if
2828
02:32:08.190 --> 02:32:10.750
I had seen them, whereas I admit that they do
2829
02:32:10.790 --> 02:32:14.190
not fall under the senses, someone will perhaps demand how
2830
02:32:14.270 --> 02:32:16.659
I have come by my knowledge of them. To this
2831
02:32:16.739 --> 02:32:19.239
I reply that I first considered in general all the
2832
02:32:19.299 --> 02:32:22.280
clear and distinct notions of material things that are to
2833
02:32:22.319 --> 02:32:25.629
be found in our understanding— and that, finding no others
2834
02:32:25.690 --> 02:32:28.809
except those of figures, magnitudes, and motions, and of the
2835
02:32:28.870 --> 02:32:31.649
rules according to which these three things can be diversified
2836
02:32:31.709 --> 02:32:34.649
by each other, which rules are the principles of geometry
2837
02:32:34.690 --> 02:32:37.709
and mechanics, I judge that all the knowledge man can
2838
02:32:37.770 --> 02:32:40.829
have of nature must of necessity be drawn from this source,
2839
02:32:41.370 --> 02:32:43.850
because all the other notions we have of sensible things,
2840
02:32:44.250 --> 02:32:47.079
as confused and obscure, can be of no avail in
2841
02:32:47.139 --> 02:32:50.219
affording us the knowledge of anything out of ourselves, but
2842
02:32:50.280 --> 02:32:54.200
must serve rather to impede it. Thereupon, taking as my
2843
02:32:54.219 --> 02:32:56.600
ground of inference the simplest and best known of the
2844
02:32:56.659 --> 02:32:59.280
principles that have been implanted in our minds by nature,
2845
02:32:59.799 --> 02:33:03.059
I considered the chief differences that could
possibly subsist between
2846
02:33:03.079 --> 02:33:07.290
the magnitudes and figures and situations of bodies, insensible on
2847
02:33:07.350 --> 02:33:10.229
account of their smallness alone, and what sensible effects could
2848
02:33:10.250 --> 02:33:12.870
be produced by their various modes of coming into contact.
2849
02:33:13.409 --> 02:33:15.659
And afterwards, when I found like effects in the bodies
2850
02:33:15.700 --> 02:33:18.360
that we perceive by our senses— I judged that they
2851
02:33:18.420 --> 02:33:21.260
could have been thus produced, especially since no other mode
2852
02:33:21.280 --> 02:33:24.309
of explaining them could be devised. And in this matter
2853
02:33:24.389 --> 02:33:27.110
the example of several bodies made by art was of
2854
02:33:27.170 --> 02:33:30.370
great service to me, for I recognized no difference between
2855
02:33:30.389 --> 02:33:33.409
these and natural bodies beyond this, that the effects of
2856
02:33:33.469 --> 02:33:35.870
machines depend for the most part on the agency of
2857
02:33:35.909 --> 02:33:39.350
certain instruments, which, as they must bear some proportion to
2858
02:33:39.389 --> 02:33:41.870
the hands of those who make them, are always so
2859
02:33:41.930 --> 02:33:44.870
large that their figures and motions can be seen. in
2860
02:33:44.909 --> 02:33:47.760
place of which the effects of natural bodies almost always
2861
02:33:47.799 --> 02:33:51.520
depend upon certain organs so minute as to escape our senses.
2862
02:33:52.239 --> 02:33:54.500
And it is certain that all the rules of mechanics
2863
02:33:54.540 --> 02:33:57.000
belong also to physics, of which it is a part
2864
02:33:57.059 --> 02:34:00.629
or species, so that all the artificial is withal natural,
2865
02:34:01.250 --> 02:34:03.670
for it is not less natural for a clock made
2866
02:34:03.729 --> 02:34:06.430
of the requisite number of wheels to mark the hours,
2867
02:34:06.870 --> 02:34:08.969
than for a tree which has sprung from this or
2868
02:34:08.989 --> 02:34:11.780
that seed to produce the fruit peculiar to it.
2869
02:34:11.760 --> 02:34:12.489
204.
2870
02:34:12.489 --> 02:34:14.469
That touching the things which our senses do not perceive,
2871
02:34:14.530 --> 02:34:16.409
it is sufficient to explain how they can be, and
2872
02:34:16.430 --> 02:34:43.319
that this is all that Aristotle has essayed. But here
2873
02:34:43.399 --> 02:34:46.639
someone will perhaps reply, that although I have supposed causes
2874
02:34:46.700 --> 02:34:49.920
which could produce all natural objects, we ought not on
2875
02:34:49.940 --> 02:34:52.700
this account to conclude that they were produced by these causes.
2876
02:34:53.340 --> 02:34:56.450
For just as the same artisan can make two clocks, which,
2877
02:34:56.569 --> 02:34:59.350
though they both equally well indicate the time, and are
2878
02:34:59.370 --> 02:35:03.170
not different in outward appearance, have nevertheless nothing resembling in
2879
02:35:03.190 --> 02:35:06.809
the composition of their wheels. So, doubtless, the supreme maker
2880
02:35:06.850 --> 02:35:10.030
of things has an infinity of diverse means at his disposal.
2881
02:35:10.520 --> 02:35:12.180
by each of which he could have made all the
2882
02:35:12.239 --> 02:35:14.399
things of this world to appear as we see them,
2883
02:35:14.799 --> 02:35:17.079
without it being possible for the human mind to know
2884
02:35:17.469 --> 02:35:19.489
which of all these means he chose to employ. I
2885
02:35:20.229 --> 02:35:22.870
most freely concede this, and I believe that I have
2886
02:35:22.909 --> 02:35:25.309
done all that was required if the causes I have
2887
02:35:25.350 --> 02:35:28.670
assigned are such that their effects accurately correspond to all
2888
02:35:28.690 --> 02:35:31.739
the phenomena of nature, without determining whether it is by
2889
02:35:31.780 --> 02:35:34.889
these or by others that they are actually produced. and
2890
02:35:34.969 --> 02:35:36.829
it will be sufficient for the use of life to
2891
02:35:36.870 --> 02:35:40.239
know the causes thus imagined, for medicine, mechanics, and in
2892
02:35:40.280 --> 02:35:42.620
general all the arts to which the knowledge of physics
2893
02:35:42.700 --> 02:35:45.639
is of service, have for their end only those effects
2894
02:35:45.659 --> 02:35:48.440
that are sensible, and that are accordingly to be reckoned
2895
02:35:48.500 --> 02:35:52.159
among the phenomena of nature. Unless it should be supposed
2896
02:35:52.180 --> 02:35:55.649
that Aristotle did, or professed to do, anything more than this,
2897
02:35:56.110 --> 02:35:58.770
it ought to be remembered that he himself expressly says,
2898
02:35:59.190 --> 02:36:01.329
at the commencement of the seventh chapter of the first
2899
02:36:01.389 --> 02:36:04.620
book of the Meteorologies, that with regard to things which
2900
02:36:04.680 --> 02:36:07.420
are not manifest to the senses, he thinks to adduce
2901
02:36:07.469 --> 02:36:10.930
sufficient reasons and demonstrations of them, if he only shows
2902
02:36:10.969 --> 02:36:12.829
that they may be such as he explains them.
2903
02:36:12.829 --> 02:36:14.530
205.
2904
02:36:14.530 --> 02:36:18.690
That nevertheless there is a moral certainty that all the
2905
02:36:18.729 --> 02:36:21.129
things of this world are such as has here been
2906
02:36:21.170 --> 02:36:24.649
shown they may be. But nevertheless that I may not
2907
02:36:24.690 --> 02:36:27.370
wrong the truth by supposing it less certain than it is,
2908
02:36:27.829 --> 02:36:30.930
I will here distinguish two kinds of certitude. The first
2909
02:36:30.969 --> 02:36:33.899
is called moral. that is, a certainty sufficient for the
2910
02:36:33.940 --> 02:36:36.569
conduct of life, though if we look to the absolute
2911
02:36:36.590 --> 02:36:40.510
power of God, what is morally certain may be false. Thus,
2912
02:36:40.670 --> 02:36:43.149
those who never visited Rome do not
doubt that it
2913
02:36:43.229 --> 02:36:45.629
is a city of Italy, though it might be that
2914
02:36:45.729 --> 02:36:48.979
all from whom they got their information were deceived. Again,
2915
02:36:49.090 --> 02:36:51.899
if anyone, wishing to decipher a letter written in Latin
2916
02:36:51.940 --> 02:36:55.239
characters that are not placed in regular order, bethinks himself
2917
02:36:55.299 --> 02:36:57.680
of reading a B wherever an A is found and
2918
02:36:57.719 --> 02:37:00.069
a C wherever there is a B, and thus of
2919
02:37:00.110 --> 02:37:02.850
substituting in place of each letter the one which follows
2920
02:37:02.930 --> 02:37:05.110
it in the order of the alphabet, and if by
2921
02:37:05.129 --> 02:37:07.950
this means he finds that there are certain Latin words
2922
02:37:07.989 --> 02:37:10.510
composed of these, he will not doubt that the true
2923
02:37:10.559 --> 02:37:13.520
meaning of the writing is contained in these words, although
2924
02:37:13.540 --> 02:37:16.360
he may discover this only by conjecture, and although it
2925
02:37:16.399 --> 02:37:18.500
is possible that the writer of it did not arrange
2926
02:37:18.520 --> 02:37:21.459
the letters on this principle of alphabetical order, but on
2927
02:37:21.500 --> 02:37:24.840
some other, and thus concealed another meaning in it. For
2928
02:37:24.860 --> 02:37:27.909
this is so improbable, especially when a cipher contains a
2929
02:37:27.969 --> 02:37:31.420
number of words, as to seem incredible. But they who
2930
02:37:31.479 --> 02:37:34.239
observe how many things regarding the magnet, fire, and the
2931
02:37:34.280 --> 02:37:36.770
fabric of the whole world are here deduced from a
2932
02:37:36.809 --> 02:37:39.549
very small number of principles, though they deemed that I
2933
02:37:39.610 --> 02:37:42.489
had taken them up at random and without grounds, will
2934
02:37:42.530 --> 02:37:45.090
yet perhaps acknowledge that it could hardly happen that so
2935
02:37:45.129 --> 02:37:47.829
many things should cohere if these principles were false.
2936
02:37:47.829 --> 02:37:49.590
206.
2937
02:37:49.590 --> 02:37:55.040
That we possess even more than a moral certainty of it. Besides,
2938
02:37:55.100 --> 02:37:58.079
there are some, even among natural things, which we judge
2939
02:37:58.120 --> 02:38:02.440
to be absolutely certain. Absolute certainty arises when we judge
2940
02:38:02.479 --> 02:38:04.920
that it is impossible a thing can be otherwise than
2941
02:38:04.979 --> 02:38:07.989
as we think it. This certainty is founded on the
2942
02:38:08.020 --> 02:38:11.190
metaphysical ground that, as God is supremely good and the
2943
02:38:11.229 --> 02:38:14.530
source of all truth, the faculty of distinguishing truth from
2944
02:38:14.649 --> 02:38:17.959
error which he gave us, cannot be fallacious so long
2945
02:38:18.040 --> 02:38:21.420
as we use it aright, and distinctly perceive anything by it.
2946
02:38:22.120 --> 02:38:25.680
Of this character are the demonstrations of mathematics, the knowledge
2947
02:38:25.700 --> 02:38:28.760
that material things exist, and the clear reasonings that are
2948
02:38:28.780 --> 02:38:31.680
formed regarding them. The results I have given in this
2949
02:38:31.729 --> 02:38:34.049
treatise will perhaps be admitted to a place in the
2950
02:38:34.090 --> 02:38:37.290
class of truths that are absolutely certain, if it be
2951
02:38:37.329 --> 02:38:40.030
considered that they are deduced in a continuous series from
2952
02:38:40.049 --> 02:38:44.379
the first and most elementary principles of human knowledge. especially
2953
02:38:44.399 --> 02:38:47.079
if it be sufficiently understood that we can perceive no
2954
02:38:47.139 --> 02:38:50.469
external objects unless some local motion be caused by them
2955
02:38:50.569 --> 02:38:53.389
in our nerves, and that such motion cannot be caused
2956
02:38:53.430 --> 02:38:56.549
by the fixed stars, owing to their great distance from us,
2957
02:38:57.170 --> 02:38:59.649
unless a motion be also produced in them and in
2958
02:38:59.709 --> 02:39:02.829
the whole heavens lying between them and us. For these
2959
02:39:02.909 --> 02:39:05.969
points being admitted, all the others, at least the more
2960
02:39:06.010 --> 02:39:09.340
general doctrines which I have advanced regarding the world or earth,
2961
02:39:09.959 --> 02:39:14.690
For example, the fluidity of the heavens, part 3, section 46,
2962
02:39:14.690 --> 02:39:17.790
will appear to be almost the only possible explanations of
2963
02:39:17.829 --> 02:39:21.670
the phenomena they present.
2964
02:39:21.670 --> 02:39:22.469
207.
2965
02:39:22.469 --> 02:39:25.670
That, however, I submit all my opinions to the authority
2966
02:39:25.709 --> 02:39:29.670
of the Church. Nevertheless, lest I should presume too far,
2967
02:39:29.989 --> 02:39:33.219
I affirm nothing, but submit all these my opinions to
2968
02:39:33.239 --> 02:39:35.239
the authority of the Church and the judgment of the
2969
02:39:35.260 --> 02:39:38.459
more sage. and I desire no one to believe anything
2970
02:39:38.540 --> 02:39:41.209
I may have said unless he is constrained to admit
2971
02:39:41.250 --> 02:39:43.229
it by the force and evidence of reason.