สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Thanks for joining us on this Thursday, the third day of September. Hope we find you well. On the show today, a council green dream to transform Adelaide's light square could create a traffic nightmare, with modelling warning some CBD streets could face traffic increases of, believe it or not, 700%. Two redevelopment options are being considered by the Adelaide City Council aimed at creating more green space and improving access for pedestrians and cyclists. We're going to speak with former Councillor Henry Davis about that a little bit later on this morning. New Australia Institute research shows states and territories have been short-changed more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in GST payments just since 2000. In South Australia, the projected shortfall over the next two years could fully fund the new Women's and Children's Hospital. We'll take a look at that. Could retirement villages help solve Australia's aged care crisis? Australia's hospitals are under pressure, we know that. Aged care is under pressure and thousands of older Australians are stuck waiting for support. So are we overlooking part of the solution? We'll take a look at that too. Being Thursday, Johnston Withers lawyers will be in the studio to answer your legal questions. Tim Downey, we welcome back. Kaitlin Walkington is back from baby leave, maternity leave. It'd be great to see Caitlin in the studio. So if you have any legal questions, the number to ring, 8223 0000. And later, we're going to look at the common heart attack symptom that many women ignore. Lots to talk about. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. Well, South Australian Premier Peter Malinowskis has called for a reckoning against social media giants over the damage they can do to children. I think that's fair enough. But there's an uncomfortable question for the Premier. Because while he's talking tough about Meta, His own Labour Party and political campaign have been spending hundreds of thousands of dollars advertising on Meta's Facebook and Instagram platforms. At the recent News 24 Bush Summit, the Premier accused social media platforms of contributing to bullying and harm among young people, including suicide. He pointed to a major US settlement as evidence Meta knew about the risks. Let's face it, his words were pretty strong. He said, where we see companies who are doing people harm, particularly children, and they know about it, there should be reckoning. Well, I think that's fair. I think we'd all agree with that. So where does that leave Labor? Figures from the Meta Ad Library show South Australian Labor spent $ 384, 534 on Facebook and Instagram advertising between August 2020 and August 26. Peter Malinowska's own political advertising accounted for another $ 225, 425 over the same period. believed to have come from labour or campaign resources. The government says there's nothing inconsistent about this. It says the proposed age restrictions are about protecting children, not stopping adults using social media. And let's face it, that's a reasonable argument. Governments, businesses, politicians and community organisations need to communicate with people where they are, and that today is often on social media. But here's the uncomfortable bit. If Meta is doing enough to harm children to warrant a reckoning, Why is Labor continuing to put big sums of money into Meta's pockets? You can't tell Meta it has a serious problem while at the same time handing it hundreds of thousands of dollars. Mind you, there's a difference between government advertising and political advertising. A government may argue it needs Facebook and Instagram to communicate with the public. A political party making a choice. If a state government department says or pays Meta to promote something such as, well, a health campaign, emergency warnings, road safety information, public services, the government can argue, well, we aren't endorsing Meta, we're using a communication channel that hundreds of South Australians, or hundreds of thousands, in fact, of South Australians can use, and that's perfectly reasonable. But if it's political advertising, that's different. If SA Labor or the Premier's campaign pays Meta to promote Labor's political messages, that isn't an essential government communication, it's a political choice. So here's the question for Peter Malinowskis. If Meta is sufficiently harmful to children to deserve a reckoning, when does Labor decide its own money should stop supporting the platform? Because otherwise, this starts to look less like reckoning and more like political hypocrisy. Your thoughts, love to hear them. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. As I said, lots to talk about today. One of the concerning things for me is the Light Square plan, or one of the plans that would see some of our streets facing traffic increases of 700%. In fact, I think the exact figure was 741%, which would be absolutely ludicrous. Hopefully that is not the plan that will go any further. Anyway, we'll speak with former Councillor Henry Davis about that later. Something I found interesting, if you had to toss up to side, would you choose an overseas holiday or a new EV? Now, the figures show that Australia's economy is still growing. but the latest figures suggest it's hardly firing on all cylinders. Australian Bureau of Statistics figures show GDP increased by just 0.4% in the June quarter. That took annual growth to 2.1%. One of the more surprising findings was where Australians are putting their money. With overseas travel hit by higher airfares and fuel costs linked to the Middle East conflict, households instead went shopping for electric and hybrid cars. Vehicle purchases jumped 10% in three months, accounting for about three quarters of the quarter's increase in consumer spending. But there is a bigger concern. GDP per person fell 0.1% during the quarter, while productivity remains weak. GDP per hour work dropped 2.2% over the pier. So the
Load full transcript
economy is growing, but population growth, rather than rising productivity, is doing much of the heavy lifting. Your thoughts, like to know them? Join us on 8223 0000. Back shortly. 17 past nine, 5AA, this Thursday morning. Hope we find you well. Shortly, we'll be having a chat with Angus Taylor, opposition leader, about the coalition's plan to slash tobacco tax. But firstly, from the text line, OGG, hypocrisy is the middle name of many pollies. What about the obsession with expensive renewables to save the planet, while at the same time magnificent grand trees are felled and every possible gas-guzzling motorsport is brought to the state? Andrew says, having five world leaders attending the pre-cop event in the South Pacific shows what a flop it is. And Albo deflects it back on the journalist questioning the attendance number and waste of taxpayer money, saying he was being disrespectful to the dignitaries of the region. Albo is just so tied up in this work, delusional ideology, that he's now completely out of touch with his electorate. Thank you very much for that. Well, there's no question that illegal tobacco is one of the big issues facing the nation. A future coalition government says it would slash the tobacco excise by 80%, legalise and tax vapes and nicotine pouches, and bolster law enforcement to shut down the illicit trade. So how would it exactly work? Joining us now is Liberal leader Angus Taylor. Angus, thanks for joining us today. How would you cut the illicit tobacco trade?
00:07:31
Speaker 2: Well, we've got a.
00:07:32
Speaker 3: National organised crime crisis which is being funded by illicit tobacco right now, and we have to smash the business model. That means taking away the profits, taking away the customers. and hitting what is left with the full force of the law. An 80% cut in excise, we know from the work we've done carefully since the beginning of the year, will smash that business model, will put the illicit tobacco business out of business and re-establish a legal market and stop funding organised crime in this country with illegal tobacco.
00:08:08
Speaker 1: Don't you fear that that will see a lot of people take up smoking that haven't smoked in the past?
00:08:12
Speaker 3: No, because we already know people can get access to packs of illegal cigarettes at $ 10 or $ 15 a pack.
00:08:18
Speaker 2: So the horse has bolted on this.
00:08:20
Speaker 3: The market now for illegal tobacco is over 80% of the total and rising.
00:08:27
Speaker 2: So the horse has bolted on this one.
00:08:29
Speaker 3: We've got policy right now, which is the worst of all worlds. We've got more smoking, more organised crime and less revenue for the government. And we've got to turn it fast. And that's exactly what this policy is.
00:08:40
Speaker 2: Intended to do.
00:08:42
Speaker 1: Do you see that returning more money to the government coffers?
00:08:45
Speaker 3: It will, about $ 8 billion over four years. So not only can we smash organised crime and the business model that's supporting it, but we can also increase tax revenues to the government. So, yeah, we can turn this around, but it's got to be done quickly. We see Labor state premiers supporting this, like Chris Mings in New South Wales. He knows it's the right answer. Bill Shorten, other Labor luminaries supporting who said this is the right thing to do, and it is the right thing to do, because the current policy is failing dismally.
00:09:18
Speaker 2: We're all paying for it.
00:09:19
Speaker 3: Every day we see another firebombing, and it just doesn't end. It's because it's being funded by $ 7 billion, or as much as $ 7 billion of profits from illegal tobacco.
00:09:30
Speaker 1: And yet the government continues to say raising the price of cigarettes is one of the most effective ways to reduce smoking rates.
00:09:36
Speaker 3: Well, it's nonsense because all it's doing is pushing people into the illegal market.
00:09:40
Speaker 2: I mean, the numbers are clear.
00:09:41
Speaker 3: You have to pay $ 50 or so for a packet of legal cigarettes.
00:09:45
Speaker 2: You can get illegals for under $ 15.
00:09:47
Speaker 3: So people are choosing the cheaper option. That's happening every day. And we see it in the numbers now with the wastewater numbers that are telling us that over 80% of the market and rising fast is illegal. So we've lost a legal market. We've got to re-establish it. And the only way to do that is smash the profits. of organised crime in these illegal channels and get back to a legal market and hit the illegal market with law enforcement. $ 200 million of that extra revenue generated will immediately go into joint federal and state work across agencies to hit these organised crime gangs hard.
00:10:34
Speaker 1: If the government is continually saying that they believe their policy is the right thing, you've said that Chris Minns in New South Wales effectively supports what you want to do. What if you can't get the support of the other states?
00:10:45
Speaker 3: Well, you know, we're going to do this anyway, regardless. And if the states don't want to work with us on law enforcement, that'll be on them.
00:10:53
Speaker 2: That'll be on them. But this is their chance to smash this business model.
00:10:57
Speaker 3: I'm in Melbourne right now, ground zero for this, but we're seeing it everywhere.
00:11:01
Speaker 2: We're seeing it everywhere.
00:11:02
Speaker 3: And if state premiers don't want to get on board with smashing organised crime, then they're going to have to explain to their voters, to their people, why they're unwilling to take on what is a rampant and rotten business model.
00:11:17
Speaker 1: And you want to institute an education campaign to stop young people smoking.
00:11:22
Speaker 3: Yeah, exactly right. As part of that, because we can raise extra money from this, we can fund law enforcement activities. and we can fund awareness campaigns and ensure that we get the best of all
possible worlds, which is.
00:11:35
Speaker 2: Lower rates of smoking. I'm not a fan of smoking.
00:11:39
Speaker 3: I want to see lower rates of smoking, but we can also smash organised crime and the funding of organised crime.
00:11:44
Speaker 2: In this country.
00:11:46
Speaker 1: So what would happen, assuming that you get to power, you institute these policies, what if, say, after a couple of years, the black market doesn't shrink, it's still operating? What would you do?
00:11:56
Speaker 3: Well, we've set into the policy a review after two years, but we're confident we can. We've been working closely with experts. We've been working closely with the Parliamentary Budget Office. We've come to the conclusion that 80% is the right number to take the profits out of this business, this illegal business, the criminal gangs. And so we are confident this is the right level and it's the right approach, the right strategy. But I've got to say, we'll be watching it very closely and that's why we've instituted a review as a critical.
00:12:29
Speaker 2: Part of the policy.
00:12:30
Speaker 1: On another matter, what did you make of the Secret Bay results?
00:12:34
Speaker 3: Oh, look, you know, I mean, this was a safe Labor seat and obviously it's gone to One Nation. And the moral of the story is there's no safe seat anymore. You've got to fight for every vote. You've got to fight for every seat. Australians are prepared to switch their vote if they feel they're not getting what they want. I mean, there was a degree of protest in this. There's no question about that. But the anger and frustration that's driving that is real. I recognise it. I acknowledge it. And my job is to be out there saying there is a better way. We need change. But it's got to be a plan for change that can work, including in areas like organised crime. We've got to kill the organised crime in this country. The money that's feeding it, you kill the profit, you kill the business. And that's what we need to do when it comes to organised crime.
00:13:22
Speaker 4: So.
00:13:23
Speaker 1: Stepping back from the Secret Bay result and the polls showing One Nation is still incredibly strong, is your battle mainly with the government or with One Nation?
00:13:32
Speaker 3: No, my number one fight is with a rotten government in this country that's taking us in the wrong direction. An economy that is on life support, we've seen more and more evidence of this with get news this week that we're likely to see another interest rate increase. We had a government that told us that they've beaten inflation and interest rates. It keeps going up.
00:13:54
Speaker 2: They're putting in.
00:13:55
Speaker 3: Place higher taxes, 30 businesses a day going out of, Business, homes that can't afford to pay their mortgages anymore, households, families that can't pay their mortgages. I mean, this is an economic disaster. It needs to be fixed. And our way of life is under threat. Organised crime. We've seen
the rampant anti-Semitism, of course, and yet they run this complete farce of a Royal Commission. Time and time again, we see this government is not serious about dealing with the issues we face as a country. We need a new direction. We have a plan for change, and we're going to keep talking about that plan all the way through.
00:14:32
Speaker 2: The next election.
00:14:34
Speaker 1: So if your plan is so good, why aren't people switching back to you? Why are they still strong for One Nation?
00:14:41
Speaker 3: Well, look, you know, I'm not going to get into commentary on the polls.
00:14:44
Speaker 2: There's all sorts of numbers running around.
00:14:46
Speaker 3: But what I will say is people are angry and frustrated, and I understand that. They want change and they need change and they want us fighting for change. And that's what I will keep doing every single day. But we need a plan. Australia is a great country, the greatest country on earth. It just doesn't feel like that for so many Australians right now. And the way through is not to blow the place up, but to fix it.
00:15:10
Speaker 2: And we can.
00:15:11
Speaker 1: Angus Taylor, thanks so much for your time. So what do you think, folks? Would you think that would be a good plan? Coalition Cutting. 80% the illicit tax on tobacco. Would that make a difference? Craig says, hi, Gigi, I'm not bothered by someone buying cheap smokes as the government losing taxes. What bothers me is trying to pay my power bills. It's up, up, up. Need to smash this unicorn dream, Albo and Chris Bowen, that they have. I think it's a crack pipe dream. Thank you for that. And Bell says, the Australian government is spending $ 147. 8 million from taxpayer funds on the UN pre-COP climate conference and a broader Pacific diplomacy package. This is before the actual COP, with 3,000 to 4,000 people from Australia attending the event, paid for by taxpayers. A total farce. Thank you for that, Bill. Your thoughts, like to hear them on 8223 0000. Coming up shortly, the quarter of a trillion dollar GST shortfall that's leaving the states and territories scrambling. We know the states, other than Western Australia, aren't happy with the GST carve-up, but according to left-wing think tank, the Australian Institute, they believe that there's a quarter of a trillion dollars being left on the table that we should have. Also, in the next half hour, we'll get the latest from Nepal. I believe a number of Australian families have gone over there to help in the search for lost relatives. We'll catch up with the 5AA Canberra correspondent in Nepal, Nelson Scott, today. And are retirement villages the answer to the aged care crisis? We know that we're falling so far behind in providing aged care beds in this state and, in fact, around the nation, but there is a suggestion that retirement villages could fill the gap. And, of course, we have our legal segment this morning at 10.30pm. For Johnston Withers lawyers, if you have any legal questions, I used to get in early, 8223 0000. Tim Downey and Caitlin Walkington will be in the studio.
00:17:08
Speaker 5: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings. 29 to 10, 5AA. Graeme says, On Angus Taylor interview, sorry Angus, too late, too late. No more chances for the uni party. Vote One Nation to save Australia. We don't believe a word anymore. What comes out of Angus or Alwo's mouth? And Steve says Angus Taylor has no idea. He is not convincing. Well, my next guest is Matt Gruddoff, the Australia Institute Senior Economist.
00:17:38
Speaker 1: Matt, good morning to you.
00:17:41
Speaker 5: Are you there, Matt?
00:17:42
Speaker 6: Yes, I'm here.
00:17:43
Speaker 5: Can you hear me?
00:17:44
Speaker 1: I can hear you loud and clear. Now, you've come up with some startling figures regarding GST. Please explain.
00:17:51
Speaker 6: So originally the GST was brought in by Howard and Costello. And they brought it in so that the states would have their own revenue source. So they wouldn't have to constantly come to the federal government, cap in hand for money. And they envisaged, as Costello said when he introduced it, that it would grow with the economy. That is, it would be an ongoing revenue source. But it simply hasn't grown fast enough. It hasn't grown with the economy. It's grown really slowly. And now, just in the last year, for example, it's $ 24 billion short of where it should be And that's why a lot of state governments are really struggling to fund the basic services like health and education that they need.
00:18:33
Speaker 1: So why hasn't it grown at the rate expected?
00:18:36
Speaker 6: Well, it's because of inequality, basically. So, for example, housing... that is not subject to the GST, and it shouldn't be. So things like rents and mortgage repayments. And because we're spending so much more money on housing, we've got less money to spend on all the other things, and it's the other things that are subject to the GST. So we're not spending as much buying the stuff that is subject to the GST, so we're not collecting as much revenue.
00:19:04
Speaker 1: So you talk about a quarter of a trillion dollar GST shortfall?
00:19:08
Speaker 7: That's right.
00:19:09
Speaker 6: So over the last 25 years, 26 years since it was introduced, We're basically a quarter of a trillion dollars less revenue than Howard and Costello thought it would collect. And just in the last year, that equates to $ 2. 3 billion for South Australia.
00:19:25
Speaker 1: Wow, that is quite considerable. So we're not talking about the carve up between the states here. And we know that Western Australia are happy with their deal. The other states are not. This is a separate issue altogether.
00:19:34
Speaker 7: Exactly right.
00:19:35
Speaker 1: Yes, exactly right.
00:19:36
Speaker 6: So, you know, absolutely, the one state that probably is doing quite well is Western Australia, but that's because they got that sweetheart deal. What we're talking about is there
hasn't been enough revenue flowing into the states and territories. And we can fix this. by adding other taxes to the GST. For example, we could introduce a 25% tax on gas exports. That would raise $ 17 billion a year. That could be treated the same as the GST, go into that same pool of funds and be distributed in the same way. and that would almost completely make up for that shortfall in revenue, and it would mean that South Australians would have better access to health, better access to education, or it could pay for the Women's and Children's Hospital. It would only take two years to fully pay for the Women and Children's Hospital. That's how much revenue we're talking about.
00:20:29
Speaker 1: People will say there are only so many dollars in the economy. So you put them through the GST, they've got to come from, there have to be some area of the economy that would suffer.
00:20:38
Speaker 7: Yeah, absolutely.
00:20:39
Speaker 6: But like, if we're talking about taxing international gas companies, then what we're talking about is taxing revenue that otherwise would have flown to the mostly foreign owners of those gas companies. About 80% of gas companies is foreign owned. And so, What we're really doing is stopping profits from flowing overseas and allowing Australia to get their fair share of that resource funding.
00:21:03
Speaker 1: So what does it take to change the GST rules? Does it need an agreement from the states? Is it just an act of legislation in Canberra?
00:21:11
Speaker 6: Yeah, absolutely. So it needs the state premiers to come together and petition the federal government to introduce new revenue sources other than the GST to say, look, the GST system isn't working. It isn't growing fast enough. We need more funding. We can either have a fight every year about funding. We can argue about a recent NDIS system where the federal government is trying to force the states to spend more on the disability support with thriving children. You know, that's one area that they wouldn't have to worry as much about if the state governments actually got the revenue that they need in order to fund the services that South Australians are demanding.
00:21:58
Speaker 1: The GST was initially at 10%. In fact, to this very day, it's 10%. There have been calls at times to increase that to 12.5% or 15%. Would that be of an advantage?
00:22:10
Speaker 6: Look, that would certainly bring in more revenue in the short term. But the problem is, is the GST is slow growing and that's not likely to change. and so all we do is we increase the revenue for a little while, but then it slowly drifts again, and over time we end up in exactly this position again. What we need to do is put more revenue from taxes that will actually grow, and there's a whole different host of things we could be taxing, but, you know, a gas export tax is one option, and these taxes then grow over time and we don't come back here in 10 or 15 years' time with the same problem.
00:22:53
Speaker 1: Do you think the original concept of the GST and how it was redistributed and how the states would spend the money has sort of been lost in time?
00:23:01
Speaker 7: I think so.
00:23:02
Speaker 6: I think we've forgotten about the purpose of it. The reason that Howard and Costello set it up, it was basically to give the states their own source of revenue. The problem with the Australian Constitution is that the federal government has all the tax-raising powers. It has all the big taxes and the ability to raise revenue. But the state governments have really big spending responsibilities. Housing, education, health, infrastructure, these are all state government funding issues. And so what we need, that mismatch means that the federal government needs to collect revenue and then give it to the states. It would be much easier if the federal government collected the revenue and gave it directly to the states the way the GSC has done. We just need to add some other taxes to that.
00:23:47
Speaker 1: Well, you've suggested a gas export tax. That seems to have fallen on deaf ears in Canberra so far.
00:23:53
Speaker 6: Yeah, but it's very popular with the general public. And I think that it can be popular with the state premiers if they thought that that was additional revenue. Can you imagine if you're a state premier and you're constantly having to cut education and health, which is making people angry? simply because you can't raise the right amount of revenue because you don't have the power to do so. This is an opportunity for state governments to basically have the power to be able to do what they need to do without constantly having an argument with Canberra.
00:24:25
Speaker 1: What is the single most important message that you'd like policymakers and the public to take from your research?
00:24:31
Speaker 6: We can have nice things. We can have nice things like a women's and children's hospital. We're not a poor country. We're just not collecting the amount of revenue that we need to fund the services that Australians are demanding. And, you know, this is not a problem that we cannot solve. We have a massive resource sector. If we tax that better, not excessively, but just, you know, like the rest of the world taxes their resource sector, then we can have nice things.
00:25:03
Speaker 1: I think, yeah, putting up the GST redistribution and all that is well and good. but we've got to find a new source of revenue and obviously touching the resource sector is one way of doing that or the way of doing it.
00:25:15
Speaker 2: Absolutely.
00:25:16
Speaker 6: And then state governments can be in control of what they need to be in control of and they can focus on funding health and education and hospitals and infrastructure and housing. We have a huge housing affordability crisis. Imagine how many new affordable homes that the state government could build if it had an extra $ 2. 3 billion every year.
00:25:40
Speaker 1: It would be
handy. Matt, moving on to other matters, yesterday's GDP figures, what did you make of them?
00:25:47
Speaker 6: The economy is slowing down. Yes, it grew a little bit quicker than what the market thought it would, but it's still, on an annual basis, less than it was in recent quarters. And that's because the economy started slowing down when interest rates started increasing. So it's not a surprise about what is happening. And the cause of the inflation that caused these interest rates to go up is basically fuel costs overseas, which is something that we don't control. So I don't think that the Reserve Bank should increase interest rates on the basis of this. I think that if they continue to slug Australian consumers... all that's going to happen is the Australian economy will continue to slow and families will continue to struggle.
00:26:36
Speaker 1: You don't think the Reserve Bank should increase interest rates, but do you think they will?
00:26:41
Speaker 6: I think that the market thinks they will. And unfortunately, I think that the RBA often listens to what the market is saying more than they probably should. Look, if this was homegrown inflation, if this inflation was just caused by massive demand, consumers out there recklessly spending, businesses out there spending lots of money, That doesn't describe the economy that we saw in the figures that were released yesterday. It's being caused by high fuel costs, which is being caused by a war in the Middle East that we have no control over. The RBA can't control this inflation. They need to accept that and they just need to let it wash through the economy and not increase interest rates.
00:27:21
Speaker 1: What about public government spending? Do you think that's too high?
00:27:25
Speaker 6: Well, the figures that came out yesterday showed that over the last six months, the government spending has added zero to growth. It hasn't added anything to the growth in the economy or to the growth in spending. So it's been net zero. So it clearly isn't the cause of this inflation. This inflation is very clearly being caused by high oil prices.
00:27:54
Speaker 1: Matt, thanks for your insight. Great to chat. Thank you. Matt Grudnoff, on GST, the changes, would you like to see changes? They suggest that we're not getting enough. We've been shortchanged by a quarter of a trillion dollars because the way the GST is structured, not so much about the carve-up, which obviously is beneficial to Western Australia and the rest of the states seem to suffer, but this is a fact that we are not collecting enough via GST. And the Institute suggests that a gas export tax of 25% would be a bonus to all the states, and particularly here in South Australia. Wouldn't he suggest $ 2. 3 billion over the next couple of years? That would be very handy. Andrew says, we have a treasurer. Why isn't he working on implementing policies like a gas export tax for not only today, but for the future? That's his job. He's literally asleep at the wheel. Andrew, I take your point. But the government has already battered away the suggestion of a gas export tax. And the disturbing thing is the coalition is in concert. They also seem to suggest that if there was a gas export tax, that would be a disincentive to a major resource industry and they would not invest here or mine here or whatever. But it works in other countries. They tax their exports of minerals and seem to still get a lot of investment. I'd like to know your thoughts. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. Bill says, why on earth would we want to increase the GST rate to 12.5 or 15%? It would just mean that almost everything would go up in price in a cost of living crisis that we're currently in. Why would we want that? Well, Bill, I don't think it is being foreshadowed, but it has in the past been talked about because when it was first instituted, the GST, it was at 10%. and 20 or so years have progressed since then. So maybe it is time for a change. Not at this very moment, not at this very moment at all, but maybe into the future. Hi, Darren says, talking GST, how much does overseas online purchasing affect GST? Fair question. Don't know if we have an answer for that.
00:29:59
Speaker 5: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
00:30:05
Speaker 1: Ah, don't worry. Be happy. Not always easy. 13 to 10, 5AA. Taking a look at the stock market, the All Ords up by nine points this morning. ASX 200 up by seven. Dow Jones was up by 295. The NASDAQ was up by 118 overnight. As for oil, Brent Crude, 95.6 US dollars a barrel. West Texas crude, 90.6 US dollars a barrel. I think fuel prices around town are pretty stable, aren't they? Not too bad. Well, anything under $ 2 these days is considered not too bad. Gold at the moment, $ 4, 384 US dollars an ounce. The Aussie dollar currently buying 71 US cents. We'll keep you updated on anything that does happen out of the ordinary with the stock market as the morning progresses. What would you pay for a toothbrush? Do you regularly change your toothbrush? Do you change it as often? Do you have an electric toothbrush? Well, Dyson has reinvented the electric toothbrush with the CameraJet smart device. It features a 100,000 pixel macro camera, machine learning. It scans 28 images per second to detect gaps between the teeth in real time. Within 100 milliseconds, it fires a gentler conical jet of mouth rinse precisely into the spaces. It combines brushing, flossing and rinsing in one system. Sounds great, doesn't it? It was developed over six years by more than 600 engineers and 38 patents. It uses variable sonic oscillation, contoured bristles, and an anti-gravity 12.5 milliliter tank. So do you want your Dyson camera jet toothbrush?
00:31:40
Speaker 4: $ 799.
00:31:41
Speaker 1: Oh yes, a toothbrush for $ 799. Maybe you think, well, if I get this toothbrush, I won't need to go to the dentist. I don't think that's probably a good idea, but I don't mind paying a little more for a really
good toothbrush, an electric toothbrush, but $ 799? I'm sure some people will buy it. They're on sale already. I think, is it Harvey Norman are selling them? But I'd be very interested to know how many they sell. Would you buy an electric toothbrush with a 100,000 pixel macro camera to $ 799? Just, just remarkable. Charlie says, hi, Graham. Just received notification that elective surveys at Flinders cancelled. Are we saying elective surgery at Flinders cancelled? And just no room at all for patients, plus over 30 nurses away sick. This is a state disaster. Why is the media showing this up? Or are you suggesting why isn't the media? Well, Charlie, I wasn't even aware it was happening, but we'll certainly look into it. Thank you very much for that. Well, the horrors of Nepal keep unfolding. Joining us now is 5AA Canberra correspondent in Nepal, Nelson Scott. Nelson, thanks so much for your time.
00:32:54
Speaker 7: My pleasure, Graeme.
00:32:55
Speaker 5: Good morning.
00:32:57
Speaker 1: What is happening? Are there any developments in the last 24 hours?
00:33:01
Speaker 8: Yeah, so in the last few hours or so, we've had an update from the Australian perspective. We saw yesterday, of course, the RAF aircraft arrive here at Kathmandu Airport.
00:33:15
Speaker 7: I was there for that.
00:33:17
Speaker 8: That was carrying part of what has now become an $ 11 million federal government aid package.
00:33:22
Speaker 7: That plane delivering yesterday.
00:33:24
Speaker 8: Over 1,000 hygiene kits, including toothbrushes, water containers, menstrual hygiene management kits.
00:33:33
Speaker 7: As well, as well as over 2,000 solar lights.
00:33:36
Speaker 8: That was designed to address the risk of waterborne diseases that we're seeing in the country's north following these floods.
00:33:44
Speaker 7: And also the frequent.
00:33:46
Speaker 8: Power outages as well, which is continuing to hamper rescue efforts. But now Australia is also deploying a 15-person disaster assistance response team. This will include specialist drone operators from certain states to assist with the rapid search and rescue mapping. They're joining 19 personnel from Australia already here. That includes consular officials, federal police, defence personnel and humanitarian officers. Unfortunately, we still have 38 Australians who remain unarmed unaccounted for um we wait and see what what happens of course with them we've had some good news over the last few days with five citizens confirmed safe yesterday one of those in nepal one in tibet three outside the crisis area uh that unfortunately of course graham is the Situations like this develop and days go on.
00:34:49
Speaker 7: We're now eight days after the flooding began.
00:34:52
Speaker 8: The chance of survival becomes less likely, but the whole nation, both.
00:34:57
Speaker 7: Here in Nepal and back in Australia, are hoping for more miracles.
00:35:01
Speaker 1: And I guess even when they retrieve bodies, it must be so hard to identify them.
00:35:07
Speaker 8: Yeah, and this is becoming an issue on the ground here. So what we've seen now is there's, because of the decomposition and disfiguration of these bodies and, you know, river currents carrying victims far downstream, some of them are left to be in other countries now, they're becoming unrecognisable, they decompose, there's physical traumas and the like, and it It means that it's.
00:35:37
Speaker 7: Hard to identify people.
00:35:39
Speaker 8: So what's happening here now is– I was at the Kathmandu Police Hospital yesterday where they've established a facility where the relatives of victims– provide DNA samples as well as passport photos of their family members in the hope to identify them.
00:35:59
Speaker 7: And bring some closure.
00:36:00
Speaker 8: I was able to confirm yesterday looking at records that at least one Australian has given a DNA sample at that hospital so far and there are Australians, I understand, back at home which are sending DNA samples over here and It's critical at this point because there's also limited morgue capacities at this point.
00:36:23
Speaker 7: There's shallow graves.
00:36:25
Speaker 8: Being established in the country's north to try and preserve the remains of victims.
00:36:31
Speaker 7: And it's also.
00:36:32
Speaker 8: A sign, Graeme, that as this tragedy continues to unfold, there's a sense here now that reality is starting to.
00:36:41
Speaker 7: Dawn on some of the families involved. see their loved ones. But, you know, it's interesting, Graeme, it's a very.
00:36:50
Speaker 8: Spiritual country, Nepal, and, of course, a Hindu country for the most part. Many of the people that have gone missing were here on pilgrimages. And, of course, key to Hinduism is the idea of reincarnation. A local told me yesterday that he had lost their brother while They may not be here in the form that they knew them in.
00:37:15
Speaker 7: Their spirit remains, but it's in a different body now.
00:37:18
Speaker 8: Yeah.
00:37:18
Speaker 1: I mean, it's a tragic circumstance. A number of Australians have gone there. And you can understand, you know, if you're a relative or a family of someone missing, you want to do something. But really, just getting there, there's not really much anyone can do.
00:37:33
Speaker 7: Exactly right.
00:37:33
Speaker 8: And the big issue that they've got, and this is going to be an issue too with the aid that Australia has delivered, is just bridges have been destroyed, roads as well. Most of the hardest hit areas are only accessible by air and helicopter.
00:37:52
Speaker 7: So getting deliveries to where it's needed. is very difficult.
00:37:56
Speaker 8: I went to an aid facility last week where they were telling me helicopters are being booked out, and this is a facility where locals are donating their.
00:38:06
Speaker 7: Goods, medicine, clothes, water, food. They can't get it.
00:38:12
Speaker 8: They've got drones operators coming in from
other parts of the country, but it's It's a very, very slow process. You're working here with a lack of resources and just the scale of the disaster is making things so difficult.
00:38:27
Speaker 7: It's also interesting, too, from.
00:38:29
Speaker 8: A local perspective over here, that some people I've spoken to have thought that the Nepali government was too slow to ask for some foreign aid that includes some of the aid we're providing already in terms of sanitation kits and food and water, but also with foreign rescue teams. They're saying if that aid had been asked for earlier, it might already be on the ground.
00:38:51
Speaker 7: So a bit of anger towards the Nepali government here as well.
00:38:55
Speaker 1: And I guess coordinating a search of this magnitude would be incredibly difficult.
00:39:01
Speaker 2: Certainly.
00:39:02
Speaker 8: Again, it's the topography here. I'm here at the moment in Kathmandu. Kathmandu is this bowl of a city at the foothill of the Himalayas, vast, expansive, surrounded by mountains. So it's very difficult to get there in the first place. A lot of these areas are quite remote. Resourcing is just, is unfortunately, uh, not there. Um, but we're starting to get some good.
00:39:33
Speaker 7: News stories now. We're starting to get a little bit more information.
00:39:36
Speaker 8: But it's certainly slower than what everyone here would like.
00:39:41
Speaker 1: Nelson, thanks so much for your time today.
00:39:44
Speaker 9: My pleasure.
00:39:44
Speaker 7: Thank you.
00:39:45
Speaker 1: 5AA Canberra correspondent in Nepal, Nelson Scott, with that, uh, Pretty grim report, isn't it? And it's not going to get any better, unfortunately. And as Nelson said, eight days after the flooding, the hope of finding more survivors alive is diminishing as the hours progress. From the text line regarding the Dyson $ 799 toothbrush, Richard says, Dyson must be employing the year-old marketing strategy that a fool and their money are easily parted. Mary comes from a different angle. Graham, how many starving children could be fed with $ 700? Cannot understand how anyone could spend this amount of money. Well, Mary, I'm afraid they will. I'm afraid some people think it's a good idea. We're going to take a break for news. Then after the news, are retirement villages the answer to the aged care crisis?
00:40:38
Speaker 5: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
00:40:41
Speaker 1: Good morning to you. 8 past 10, 5AA on this Thursday morning. Well, could retirement villages help solve Australia's aged care crisis? The Retirement Living Council seems to think so and joining us now is Executive Director Daniel Gannon. Daniel, good morning to you. Graeme, good morning. There's no disputing that aged care is a major issue nationally and in particular in this state.
00:41:02
Speaker 7: Yeah, that's right.
00:41:03
Speaker 10: It's actually really hard at the moment to look across the country and discuss the state of aged care. Mark Butler,
in fact, I think on your program, Graeme, Mark Butler in recent times declared that we need to, as a country, open a new residential aged care facility every three days for the next 20 years to meet current demand. Now, you know, that tells us that, you know, everywhere we look right now, demand is up. You know, there's increased demand for aged care beds. there's increased demand for hospital beds, for retirement villages, for home care.
00:41:34
Speaker 5: And why?
00:41:35
Speaker 10: Obviously, because our population's been ageing. Every jurisdiction in the country has been caught flat-footed, and not because of decisions that are taken by governments today, but because of inaction that have been years in the making. So that's the problem that we've got right now. There's not enough supply for the demand that we're currently feeling in the market. And I read some data recently, Graeme, that looks at 2022. In fact, in 2022, there are about 60 South Australians who are medically ready to leave hospital that have been given the green light to leave, but they couldn't because they were waiting for an aged care bed that wasn't available. Fast forward four years, we've had a 700% increase to 470 patients who are trapped right now in hospital beds because there's not enough supply of aged care facilities, and that's causing a massive backlog for everyone who needs care.
00:42:24
Speaker 1: As you said, this hasn't crept up on us. I mean, you just have to do the sums. The baby boomers were always going to hit retirement age at the same time, critical ages at the same time, and yet little has been done. So are retirement villages genuinely part of the solution? Well, they need to be.
00:42:40
Speaker 10: So the Retirement Living Council produces what we call a retirement census every year with PwC. What this census has told us this year, and we released this data just a couple of weeks ago, what that census tells us this year is that there's almost 27,000 waitlist applications for retirement villages right across the country right now. Now, almost 5,000 of those applications are in South Australia. Of those 5,000, about 4,000 are in metropolitan Adelaide. So we know that the demand is strong. We know that people are interested in moving into a retirement village. One of the reasons why, what we now know from this census, is that 73% of retirement villages are now providing federally regulated care and support services, home care, into retirement villages. So three in four retirement villages now provide home care. Now, that's a game changer, I think, given the state of home care in this country. There's about 150,000 people either waiting to be assessed for their home care package or waiting to receive their home care right across the country. So when you think about the fact that almost three in four retirement villages now provide care directly to people living in these communities, care is becoming one of the great value propositions for people considering moving into a retirement village.
00:43:52
Speaker 1: So it's not a quantum leap to see that retirement villages could bridge the gap.
00:43:57
Speaker 10: Well, look, they need to, and the market has been responding. Now, obviously, demographers for decades, any demographer worth a grain of salt for decades has been warning about these changes. As you say before, the baby boomers were hitting the same age at the same time, and that was always going to cause a massive glut. But we have seen more retirement operators. In fact, 45% of operators across the country reported are now registered home care providers. So retirement villages are meeting the moment. They are meeting the demand. And, you know, in terms of people out there in suburban Australia right now getting worried about whether they can access their care now or into the future, there's a safety net that three and four retirement villages are now providing for people who can access care when they need it, if they need it, if they are considering moving into a retirement community.
00:44:46
Speaker 8: So.
00:44:48
Speaker 1: The older people moving into the aged care or out or not able to move into aged care facilities but into retirement villages, would all the necessary care be there for them? Yeah, look, that's right.
00:45:00
Speaker 10: Now, obviously, there is a big difference between a retirement village and an aged care facility. Aged care facilities provide high levels of care for a lot of people now that dementia is the leading cause of death in this country. Dementia care is a very different high level of care that you do see in aged care facilities. And we are starting to see that increasingly in retirement communities. But for retirement villages, they're about lifestyle, they're about independence, they're about social connection. But at the same time, they are also providing care. Now, I went go-karting with 25 residents from a retirement village in Sydney recently, Graeme. But for me, it was the best metaphor, right? Because there was this guy called Don He was early 80s. He needed a little bit of help to get into the go-kart. But once he was in, he was away, and he was operating under his own power. He was downright scary out there on the track, I'll tell you that much. But for me, that was the perfect metaphor for retirement villages because care is there when you need it, just little bits of care along the way to make sure that you can extend your independence for as long as possible without it becoming a clinical aged care setting, which, of course, retirement villages are not.
00:46:03
Speaker 1: So it's bridging the gap. You know, as people age between where they're quite comfortable in a retirement village and before they need an aged care facility.
00:46:12
Speaker 10: That's exactly right, because you might just need little bits of daily care in terms of meal preparation, a little bit of assistance around the home to do some cleaning.
00:46:20
Speaker
1: Now, of course.
00:46:21
Speaker 10: That care does escalate right up to much higher acuity levels of care that people need as they are ageing. Now, that type of care is obviously available in retirement villages as well, but we are starting to see a lot more communities... retirement communities, particularly on the Eastern Seaboard, now also providing palliation. You know, you can move into a retirement community to get the care that you need right up until the time where you unfortunately pass away. So retirement communities are meeting the moment, they are meeting that demand, and they're going to have to keep doing that because governments have been caught and left flat-footed. There are too many people who need care right now, today, right across the country, and they can't get it. Now, last year, unfortunately, almost 5,000 people passed away while they were waiting to be assessed for home care or waiting for the care to arrive at their door. Now, that is an awful conversation that we're having in Australia. That shouldn't happen in our country, but it is. And there's more than 150,000 people waiting for that care or waiting for that assessment today because of the inaction decades in the making from governments right across the country.
00:47:26
Speaker 1: Well, retirement villages aren't aged care. You're saying they can provide that sort of transitionary service. Are they totally receptive to your concept?
00:47:33
Speaker 9: Yeah, they are.
00:47:34
Speaker 10: Now, look, 20 years ago, 30 years ago, retirement villages were certainly not about care. It was more about real estate. It was more about the property play. But the market has changed. The baby boomer generation has redefined and redesigned everything that they've ever come into contact with. And that care and wellbeing support services being provided in retirement villages is no different. And so when we look at communities right across the country, there are different.
00:48:01
Speaker 11: Levels of support.
00:48:02
Speaker 10: The care continuum is quite broad from things like bringing sporting or community hubs in to hosting community events inside these communities, running intergenerational programs, specialist dementia support programs, mental health, fitness programs, visiting rooms for allied health professionals, you name it. That care continuum is long and it's broad, but it's also obviously injecting more home care services into these communities to keep people healthier and happier for longer, to keep people away from the GP, out of the hospital system, and, of course, delaying entry into aged care facilities. That's what's being provided right now in retirement communities.
00:48:41
Speaker 1: Now, Daniel, I don't know if you could answer this, but Bill has texted saying, hasn't the federal government approved financial incentives to aged care providers to build more retirement villages ASAP?
00:48:52
Speaker 10: Yeah, look, there has been some taxpayer funding in recent times for aged care providers to build more. Now, unfortunately, messages from the federal government in recent times have been a bit mixed. We've seen some aged care funding announcements this week. It's only a 2.6% funding increase at the same time that wages have gone up by almost 5%. Inflation is running at about 3.5%. So a 2.5% funding rise for aged care operators.
00:49:19
Speaker 1: It's actually a cut. in real terms.
00:49:21
Speaker 10: Providers will have less purchasing power next year than they do today. And that is part, I think, of a broader pattern. We have seen cuts recently to the private health insurance rebate for over 65s. We're now seeing aged care funding fail to keep pace with costs. Yes, there is some funding for aged care operators to build more aged care facilities. But as Mark Butler said, we need to open a new aged care facility every three days for the next 20 years to meet current levels of demand. And then when, of course, it comes to retirement village development applications, we are seeing too much congestion in the planning pipeline. What developers want, whether they're building retirement villages or homes.
00:49:59
Speaker 1: Is a quick yes or a quick no.
00:50:01
Speaker 10: Now, we've heard awful stories of retirement village operators waiting three years to have a development application completed. Now, if you were to lodge a development application today for a retirement village and have it approved in three years' time, the number of people over 75 in South Australia would have grown by 21,000 people. So that's what we're staring down right now, red tape getting in the way of the type of supply that we need that's not just freeing up homes in the middle of the market for younger homebuyers, but the type of housing that's also keeping people out of the hospital system.
00:50:35
Speaker 1: Final question, Daniel. If retirement villages can keep people healthier and independent living for longer, why isn't it already part of the much bigger Australia aged care strategy?
00:50:46
Speaker 7: Look, this is a great question.
00:50:48
Speaker 10: Unfortunately, we do see incredible ministerial churn. You know, like at a state level, there's ministers who are responsible for planning, for treasury, for human services, for health, for aged care. Obviously, At a federal level, the same applies with social services and other federal portfolios. The frustration that I have with retirement living is that at a state and federal level, this particular industry, retirement living, it's everyone's portfolio responsibility, but sometimes it actually becomes no one's policy priority because everyone's got a little bit of retirement living in five, six, seven, eight different portfolios. Now, that is a great frustration for this sector. It's a great big problem that we are seeing. So we have been talking to the federal government in recent times about how we can provide or at the very least remove financial
barriers that are actually discouraging more people from right-sizing into something that's more appropriate for their age, which of course is good for the younger end of the housing market, but it's also good for older people too because they therefore will be able to move into an age-friendly community with three and four retirement villages now providing care and support services that's keeping more people more healthy more of the time.
00:51:57
Speaker 1: Daniel, thanks so much for your time. Daniel Gannon, the Executive Director of Retirement Living Council Australia. What do you think about that, folks? Love to hear from you on 8223 0000. 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings. 22 past 10. A reminder that after the 10.30 headlines, we'll have our friends from Johnson Withers Lawyers in the studio to answer your legal questions on 8223 0000. Your calls in a moment on 8223 0000 also. Um, Zanya says, in relation to the $ 799 camera jet toothbrush, Temu will have knock-offs of that toothbrush at around $ 80 price point, sending audio and video straight to our government's overlords in China. Zanya, love a good conspiracy theory. And, hi, Gigi, I'm all for a 15% GST. Those with more funds usually buy high-end goods, and those with less might consider their spending choices, which isn't a bad thing, to be honest. Also, A safety note applies for those who are really on their bare bones, so to speak. Enjoy your show. Kind regards. Jim, good morning.
00:53:05
Speaker 2: G'day, Graeme.
00:53:06
Speaker 12: How are you, mate?
00:53:06
Speaker 1: Good, thanks.
00:53:08
Speaker 3: That's good.
00:53:09
Speaker 12: Just a quick one for you. I was just listening to you about retirement villages.
00:53:13
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:53:13
Speaker 12: My in-laws went into retirement villages 25 years ago, and for the last 25 years, I couldn't speak any more highly of the facilities and the comfort and the security the people have got around them.
00:53:25
Speaker 9: But my word of warning.
00:53:27
Speaker 2: I.
00:53:27
Speaker 12: Just really wish people look at the exit fees when it comes to time to leave because that's where this thing is really in the tail. I've just lost faith in it because they lose over 50% of their money they put in to live there. So it's definitely, as they say, it's not an investment, it's a lifestyle choice. But I just want people to be aware of it. There's plenty of stories on YouTube going around, all around the different states and that, about this thing of, Easy entry in, but very expensive getting out. And the only reason why I feel strongly about that is my poor father-in-law now is struggling to get some money out so he can put it into his aged care facility now. Because obviously aged care, they need a deposit too. So just a word of warning to people. It is fantastic, but just be aware of the contracts, guys. I'm sure they've improved from 25 years ago. But yeah, that's how I feel.
00:54:24
Speaker 1: Good advice. Thank you for that,
Jim. Jenny says, I wonder if these retirement villages will turn into nursing homes and the older person who now gets support at home funding will be forced to sell their home and go into a retirement village, which in essence will be a glorified nursing home. Of course, they will need to purchase their unit and pay maintenance fees, et cetera, and pay for the help they need. Edwin, good morning to you. Good morning, Graeme.
00:54:52
Speaker 13: I'd like to relate an experience I had recently. I was in hospital for about three weeks or so, and I came home the day before yesterday, and I've got a letter from AGL saying that my electricity price is going from $ 51 a fortnight to $ 60 a fortnight, and I haven't been home for about at least three weeks.
00:55:13
Speaker 1: So, now, is this the bill for power used or the service fee?
00:55:19
Speaker 13: I assume it's the power used, but that's what... I was told in the letter. But I haven't been here for... I haven't used any electricity for at least three weeks.
00:55:32
Speaker 1: Well, would anything have been continuously operating, like power for, you know, hot water or anything like that?
00:55:39
Speaker 3: No, no, no, nothing.
00:55:41
Speaker 1: So your bill's gone up and you weren't there for two weeks?
00:55:45
Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, for three weeks, yeah.
00:55:46
Speaker 1: Yeah. Look, I don't know what to say with the prices. All I'd say is... Might be a time to shop around. Good on you, Edwin. Thanks for your call. 8223 0000 is the number. John says the state should be swimming in GST revenue. The problem is Marxist idiots running Victoria and Western Australia waste billions on major projects that are always a stuff up. Imagine giving Victoria under Labor more revenue. They just pass it on to the CFMEU criminals. WA spent $ 580 million on COVID rat tests, which most were thrown out. As for schools, the more revenue shows less results. Thank you for that, John. Julie, good morning.
00:56:26
Speaker 14: Hi, I just wanted to agree with the gentleman before that was talking about retirement villages and the exit fees. My parents were in a retirement village for quite a while, probably 30 years really, and they had a plan. Exiting out was a nightmare. And I watched other people come in very much later in life who were older, thinking this would be where they would be safe for a while. but then found that their health deteriorated and they're only there for a year or two and they would lose 50% of what they had and then found it very difficult to find appropriate aged care facilities because they didn't have enough bond and there was no consideration for that at all. And even dealing with the retirement community, the government agencies to say that there was issues at times where people were bullied by the owners, etc., They weren't interested. They talked a good talk but didn't actually respond to that. So I would be very wary. Yes, it's ideal if you're not expecting to get your money back at the end like you do in aged care. You pay a bond, et cetera. The quality of the carers, they had carers from outside who come in from all sorts of agencies, RDNS, I don't know, ACH, all those aged care facilities. specialised agencies that did home care that had packages and they got wonderful care in there, but anybody can get that now. But I would be very wary for older people that are thinking their health's deteriorating and they'll go in and possibly they're in their 80s or late 80s. I would highly recommend just closing rooms in your house, staying at home and getting home care in the home that you know with the neighbours around you that that you know as well.
00:58:12
Speaker 1: Yeah, good on you, Julie. Thank you very much for that. Appreciate it. Reminder that coming up after the 10.30 headlines, we have our legal eagles in the studio. Any questions on the legal matter, 8223 0000 is the number to ring. And after 11 this morning, the common heart attack symptom that many women are ignoring.
00:58:31
Speaker 5: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
00:58:39
Speaker 1: And for Johnston Withers Lawyers, we welcome into the studio Tim Downey and welcome back Caitlin Walkington. Caitlin, how are you?
00:58:46
Speaker 15: I'm very well, thank you. Happy to be back.
00:58:48
Speaker 1: Yeah, it's great to have you back. How old is Bub now?
00:58:51
Speaker 15: She is nine months old.
00:58:53
Speaker 5: Wow.
00:58:53
Speaker 15: Yes, time's gone very, very quickly.
00:58:55
Speaker 1: Developing her own real personality, I bet she is.
00:58:58
Speaker 15: She is, yes. She keeps me on my toes.
00:59:00
Speaker 16: We have her in just filing documents at this stage.
00:59:04
Speaker 11: Just starting her slowly, nothing too much. She won't be in court for years.
00:59:08
Speaker 1: Harriet the legal eagle.
00:59:09
Speaker 4: She is on the phone, so if anyone needs me, call up and speak to her and she'll pass the message on.
00:59:17
Speaker 11: They'll get more sense calling her than me, I reckon.
00:59:20
Speaker 1: Get them young. 8223 0000 if you have a legal question. The first thing, and I was going to talk football. No, I'm not going to talk football.
00:59:28
Speaker 9: Oh, no.
00:59:29
Speaker 1: Because your big game's coming, isn't it? Yeah, big game.
00:59:32
Speaker 4: Yeah.
00:59:33
Speaker 11: Big, big game and a big game for you on Saturday night.
00:59:36
Speaker 1: More football later. And you've got your joke of the week prepared, I hope.
00:59:40
Speaker 5: Of course.
00:59:41
Speaker 1: We're getting lots of suggestions.
00:59:43
Speaker 6: Yeah.
00:59:44
Speaker 16: No, I'm, well, just so everyone knows, most of your listeners, of course, would be avid listeners of The Breakfast Show.
00:59:50
Speaker 11: So they're doing a week of dad jokes.
00:59:52
Speaker 1: Oh, okay.
00:59:53
Speaker 11: I'm running with a dad joke. A dad joke.
00:59:56
Speaker 1: A dad legal joke or just a dad joke?
00:59:58
Speaker 2: Oh, no.
00:59:58
Speaker 11: Yeah, it's a dad legal joke.
01:00:00
Speaker 9: Oh, dear.
01:00:00
Speaker 11: Yeah, yeah.
01:00:02
Speaker 1: It's bad. It's really bad. Look, before we get into calls, 8223 0000, a story that caught my eye comes out of Victoria about a 92-year-old signing a will that has very... Odorous, onerous overtones.
01:00:18
Speaker 5: Yes.
01:00:18
Speaker 4: Unfortunately, it's not an unfamiliar story that you hear these days. But in this case out of Victoria, what happened is a 92-year-old ended up having to go into some respite care. And the idea was that he was going to go in just for the winter months just to have some additional help with meals.
01:00:36
Speaker 15: And things like that. He'd only been there for.
01:00:39
Speaker 4: A number of days when he came across a nurse, and apparently they seemed to get on quite well because within a matter of days, she had taken it upon himself to, you know, do errands for him, including take him home to get some cash and take him into the local post office to buy a home will kit, which she then filled out for him, unsurprisingly, leaving his.
01:01:02
Speaker 15: Entire estate to her.
01:01:04
Speaker 2: Jeez.
01:01:05
Speaker 4: Um she got some of her um staff members she was quite high up at the nursing home so she organized some staff members to come in and sign the will um in front of him now when interestingly when they got told to sign it their will was all folded up so they couldn't actually see what the contents were or anything like that they just got told put your signature here uh get it done um one of them wasn't even in the room with the uh 92 year old when they signed and um What turned out was he passed away and she received his entire estate.
01:01:39
Speaker 14: Wow.
01:01:39
Speaker 15: She actually got away with it for a bit as well.
01:01:41
Speaker 4: So she managed to get that will through the probate system over in Victoria. And it actually only came out when one of the nurses who signed her lodged a complaint with the Nursing Admin Authority over in Victoria and it ended up being heard through disciplinary proceedings in VCAT, which is South Australia's equivalent of SACAT. Now, when they went through that, they found out the details of this will signing and said, You know, we think that she's someone who has a deeply flawed character. She, you know, is not professional. Her conduct actually amounted to professional misconduct, and she was barred from being a nurse for a long time. But all of that evidence came out, and at the end of it, VCAT actually was so troubled by it that they referred the matter, which happens occasionally, but they referred the matter back to the probate registry where they said... actually, we've got some evidence and we've got some concerns about this will that you need to know about. Now, at time to time, you know, the court systems can refer matters between themselves because obviously BCAT have no jurisdiction to make a determination.
01:02:56
Speaker 15: About a will. So they let the probate registry know about it.
01:03:00
Speaker 4: And that's when the probate registry started looking into that.
01:03:03
Speaker 15: They notified BCAT.
01:03:06
Speaker 4: The beneficiaries of his estate if that will weren't in place. Now, he didn't have an earlier will, so it was actually the beneficiaries upon an intestacy. He didn't have a wife or any children, and his parents had passed, understandably, being 92.
01:03:23
Speaker 15: So the beneficiaries of his estate.
01:03:26
Speaker 4: Were his cousins because he had quite removed family ties. The cousins all came forward and they actually had a close relationship with him during his lifetime.
01:03:38
Speaker 15: They just never had.
01:03:39
Speaker 4: Any expectation to receive a benefit from him, which is why they didn't take anything further after his passing.
01:03:46
Speaker 15: But it started.
01:03:48
Speaker 4: In the court and the court said, all right, well, there's actually enough suspicion around the creation of this will that it removes the presumption that that's a valid will. So the starting point when you have a will is is that it's a presumption that it's a valid will and there has to be circumstances that come about to create suspicious circumstances and then the onus of proof is actually reversed, which means that it's then up to the beneficiaries to prove to the court, no, that is a valid last will. So that's how it comes about.
01:04:22
Speaker 9: Yeah.
01:04:23
Speaker 1: Do these things happen all that often?
01:04:25
Speaker 15: They do and they don't.
01:04:26
Speaker 4: So the probate registry's job is to make sure that they're satisfied that.
01:04:30
Speaker 15: That is a valid last will. Now, ordinarily, if there's two... two witnesses who have signed the document.
01:04:38
Speaker 4: It might be that the probate registry really just want a statement or affidavit from one of those witnesses to say, yes, we were there.
01:04:44
Speaker 15: They wanted us to sign it. They understood.
01:04:47
Speaker 4: And usually once you've got that, the registry is satisfied. But they do come about from time to time. It might be that the details in the will.
01:04:56
Speaker 15: Make no sense.
01:04:57
Speaker 4: It might be that a family member comes forward and says, no, that's actually not what my.
01:05:02
Speaker 15: Loved one ever intended. And I think that there's something suspicious here.
01:05:06
Speaker 4: We hear a lot in this space about fraud and suspicious undue influence, you know, where someone has actually said, you know, put pressure on you to make a will. But before you get to any of those things, because they're really defences in arguing why that will shouldn't be valid, this case only got so far as to say, all right, well, there's suspicious circumstances. So, nurse, you are now required to prove to the registry that that is a valid last will. And to do that, she had to prove the
will was executed in accordance with the law, which is it was signed by him in front of two independent witnesses at the same time, which didn't happen, so she couldn't prove that. He had testamentary capacity, so she had to prove that. Now, he was in a nursing home in 92, so that in and of itself raises red flags and that's something that she had to get over, and that he knew and approved what was in the will. Now, she couldn't put on any evidence on any of these things. You know, she couldn't prove that he understood or knew what was in the will. She couldn't even get those witnesses to come forward and give evidence in support of the fact that they signed the will with him at the time. So in the end, the probate registry said, well, you fail on the first hurdle. You know, you can't even prove that this is a valid will. So we're revoking it from probate. This will is like it didn't exist. And his estate ended up passing to his cousins as it should have.
01:06:30
Speaker 1: So when people witness a will, do they need to know the contents of the will?
01:06:34
Speaker 15: They don't.
01:06:35
Speaker 4: It's not for the witnesses to go through and, you know, question the deceased or the willmaker and say, you know, is.
01:06:41
Speaker 15: This actually what you want?
01:06:42
Speaker 4: But they do need to be satisfied that the deceased has read.
01:06:45
Speaker 15: The will and the deceased is asking them to sign it.
01:06:48
Speaker 4: So if you had your colleague run up to you and said, hey, Graham, can I just grab you and grab you a signature? I just need a witness. With a will, you should ask, you know, what am I signing?
01:06:57
Speaker 15: What is the purpose? Is this what you want?
01:07:01
Speaker 4: And if they do, great, you put your signature on it. It's not your job to sit there and examine it and say, oh, are you sure you want to leave everything to, you know, the Adelaide Football Club? which I'm sure is the case. But, you know, so as a witness, you don't need to do that. But it's one of the bare minimum requirements for a will to satisfy the probate registry is that it was signed in front of two independent witnesses. So if you are the executor or the beneficiary of the will, you actually can't be a witness to it. If you are, which happens time to time with home will kits, it's one of the flaws that we.
01:07:37
Speaker 15: See, then you actually need to.
01:07:41
Speaker 4: Bring an informal will application where the presumption that it's a valid will isn't there and you've got to prove to the court that that is a will that should be omitted to probate.
01:07:51
Speaker 1: If you have a question on wills or comment on what Caitlin's had to say, give us a call, 8223 0000.
01:07:56
Speaker 16: Yeah, what's your advice in terms of people that might have an elderly relative like in that situation? She was 92 and they are in a nursing home, so they've got, if you like, exposure to... third parties and other people around, and in that case, someone that wanted to take advantage of the situation. But what's the best way, I suppose, that we can advise people to protect their loved ones against that?
01:08:26
Speaker 4: I think it's having open and frank conversations and remembering that the willmaker needs.
01:08:30
Speaker 15: To have the agency in the situation.
01:08:32
Speaker 4: So if you are pressuring someone to prepare a will in any circumstances, you know, that's obviously not the right thing to do. But if they do want to take steps in, you know, making a will for themselves, book them an appointment with a qualified and specialist solicitor. Because a qualified and specialist solicitor, if a solicitor came into this situation and they sat down with the deceased and the deceased, explained that they had very limited family and they met this person, they've just clicked and they really, really want to provide for them in the will. If the lawyer was satisfied that they had capacity, that they had an understanding and made the connection and they did that will without any you know, fraud or undue influence, then that's a completely valid will that could have got up.
01:09:15
Speaker 15: So I think, you know, it's having a valid.
01:09:19
Speaker 4: Will prepared by a qualified solicitor because that solicitor can then go give evidence on your behalf.
01:09:24
Speaker 1: Okay, let's take a call.
01:09:26
Speaker 2: Helen.
01:09:27
Speaker 8: Oh, hello.
01:09:28
Speaker 14: I hope you're all well.
01:09:31
Speaker 17: Yeah, I was just wondering about the probate.
01:09:34
Speaker 14: How long should it take? We've been waiting about 11 months.
01:09:37
Speaker 5: Okay.
01:09:37
Speaker 18: Okay.
01:09:39
Speaker 4: It's a question where it's a bit like how long is a piece of string, Helen?
01:09:43
Speaker 15: 11 months is pretty extreme though.
01:09:46
Speaker 4: So probate isn't required for all estates. It really depends on what the assets of the estate actually are and what the assets actually are kind of would give me a better indication of how long probate were to take.
01:10:01
Speaker 15: For example if the deceased had a number of.
01:10:03
Speaker 4: You know complicated affairs um you know business connections interest in trusts and companies where you know accountants needed to update financial records and things like that that's obviously going to take a lot longer than if for example the deceased just had an interest in the property and a bank account um so and the reason that um it is relevant what assets they have, is that when you submit the application to the probate registry, you have to let the probate registry know what assets and liabilities the deceased had on the date of their passing.
01:10:37
Speaker 15: And it's a very strict requirement to get that.
01:10:39
Speaker 4: So sometimes getting that information and completing that for the application can take a little bit longer depending on what the assets are. If, Helen, you are a beneficiary
of an estate where there has been a delay, particularly of 11 months, you're entitled to have information provided to you by the executor as to the status of it and the reasons for the delay and the expected timeframe. And given that it has taken that long, I would be recommending probably following up and asking those questions.
01:11:10
Speaker 1: Of course, if you.
01:11:12
Speaker 14: Sorry, yeah, my husband is the executive and he asked for contact with them a couple of months ago and they sort of said, oh, you're still going through and that's all the information we got.
01:11:21
Speaker 4: Yeah, well, they really probably do need to give you further information for that. So I would be requesting details about whether probate has been applied for, for example, what the assets and liabilities are, what is the delay. If the executive isn't forthcoming for that information, it would, I think, be warranted at this stage for your husband to get a lawyer to probably write that letter on his behalf. And if he needs assistance with that, then he's welcome to contact me at the office and we can help him out further.
01:11:52
Speaker 11: Yes, ka-ching, ka-ching.
01:11:56
Speaker 1: Good on you, Helen. Thanks for your call. 8223 0000. If you have a question for Legal Eagles, call us now. Back shortly.
01:12:04
Speaker 5: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
01:12:06
Speaker 1: 10 to 11, 5AA, still time to get through to our lawyers, 8223 0000. Tim or Caitlin, who's back from maternity leave. I thought you might bring young Harriet into the studio, but no?
01:12:20
Speaker 15: No, she's back at the office taking calls.
01:12:22
Speaker 1: Oh, of course, that's right. You did say that.
01:12:23
Speaker 5: Yes.
01:12:24
Speaker 4: So if anyone needs any help, Harriet's on the phone lines and she'll get you sorted.
01:12:27
Speaker 1: We've got to, it's that ka-ching, ka-ching. We don't work for free.
01:12:31
Speaker 6: Ha, ha, ha.
01:12:33
Speaker 1: Money for nothing, but the drinks are free. That's it. We have a caller. Damien, good morning.
01:12:37
Speaker 9: Good morning.
01:12:38
Speaker 3: How are you?
01:12:39
Speaker 17: I have a question of the legal team. Personally owned insurance policies, do they ordinarily form part of a deceased person's estate?
01:12:54
Speaker 15: They can, Damien.
01:12:55
Speaker 4: It really depends, though, what type of insurance it is and whether the deceased made a binding death nomination attached to that insurance or it doesn't always need to be a binding death nomination. Sometimes you can just pick a nomination. So there are particular insurance policies where you can nominate who would be the beneficiary upon your passing. They not all offer that option, but a lot do. So if someone has passed away, that is one of the questions that an executor would be responsible for doing is reaching out to that insurance company and finding out the details of the particular policy and who the beneficiary of it is.
01:13:38
Speaker 18: Right.
01:13:39
Speaker 17: So in the case of applying for probate, who disseminates that point about an insurance policy?
01:13:47
Speaker 16: Right.
01:13:47
Speaker 15: Yeah, so it's the executor's job.
01:13:50
Speaker 4: So the first thing when someone passes away, the executor needs to step in and manage all of their affairs and find out what all of their assets and liabilities are and what the value of those were on the date of their passing. So the executor would reach out to the insurance company with a copy of the death certificate.
01:14:10
Speaker 15: And, you know, usually the will.
01:14:13
Speaker 4: If there's not a will, then explaining that they are the person under the Succession Act who has the authority to manage the estate. And then with that, the insurance company would give the information about the policy, you know, the value of it, who the beneficiary is, etc.
01:14:29
Speaker 15: And importantly, their requirements to release the money, of course.
01:14:33
Speaker 8: Right.
01:14:34
Speaker 9: Can I ask.
01:14:35
Speaker 17: How does that apply in relation to insurance bonds? So a personally owned insurance bond, which is an investment value, but I believe operates under the Insurance Act.
01:14:50
Speaker 4: Yeah, it should work exactly the same, Damien, and it would be you'd get those particulars from the insurance company at the time when you're requesting all of those particular information as executor to be able to administer the estate.
01:15:04
Speaker 9: Okay.
01:15:05
Speaker 1: Thanks for your call, Damien. We'll move on. John, you have a question regarding wills?
01:15:11
Speaker 9: Yes.
01:15:13
Speaker 18: Can you tell me, please, what happens to the proceeds of a will if the recipient passes away before those funds are distributed?
01:15:23
Speaker 15: Good question, John.
01:15:24
Speaker 4: Well, first of all, it depends on the timing, and then second of all, it depends on the wording of the will. So, for example, if a beneficiary of the estate passes away, before the deceased then they're not around you know after to receive it it means that that you know that interest or that gift will fail and then it will go to the next person in line if there's not a next person in line then it goes to intestacy If, however, the person, the beneficiary survives the decease.
01:15:53
Speaker 15: But it's only, you know, a short period of time after.
01:15:57
Speaker 4: So, for example, there has been, you know, cases where husband and wife have been involved in a car accident. say husband dies on impact and the wife might pass away a couple of days later in hospital, most wills require the beneficiaries to survive 28 days from the disease. And if they don't survive that period of time, then it goes to the backup option, like I just explained. The third option is if that beneficiary has actually survived the deceased for some time, is entitled to the estate, but before the money is available because of the
probate process and the time it takes, they pass away. Well, then what actually happens is the money then needs to be paid from the first deceased estate to the beneficiary's deceased estate.
01:16:47
Speaker 15: So I don't mean to confuse you, John.
01:16:49
Speaker 4: It really depends on the wording of the will and the timing of who's passed away then and when. So if you would like to call me off air, then you can tell me about the particulars and I can answer the specifics of that question for you, if you'd like.
01:17:05
Speaker 1: Good night, John.
01:17:05
Speaker 18: I appreciate that. Thank you very much.
01:17:09
Speaker 11: My pleasure.
01:17:10
Speaker 1: Thanks for your call. Our Andrew on the text line says, Hi, guys. My wife and I are off to Johnston Withers on Monday to do our wills, advanced care directive, executor, power of attorney. Thanks to 5AA and this segment for the great advice to do this. Looking forward to fulfilling this important part of life. Andrew, Happy Valley.
01:17:27
Speaker 11: Good on you, Andrew.
01:17:28
Speaker 15: Our pleasure to be able to help.
01:17:30
Speaker 1: That's an unsolicited commendation. Yeah, that's why I live in Happy Valley.
01:17:35
Speaker 4: And, I mean, I guess these stories about the 92-year-old are a good reminder for everyone is that, you know, you need to have your will in place and those documents to really protect yourself. And, you know, the biggest complaint that we see from clients or family members is, oh, but they didn't think that they.
01:17:51
Speaker 15: Would need those documents just yet.
01:17:52
Speaker 4: Well, the unfortunate reality of life is we never know when we'll need those documents.
01:17:57
Speaker 15: So it's best to just have.
01:17:58
Speaker 4: Them in place, you know, put them there, put them out of your mind, and then you know that you and your family are protected.
01:18:04
Speaker 9: Yeah.
01:18:04
Speaker 1: Before we go today, the mushroom killer, captured headlines around the nation for a long period of time, is trying to appeal. Is she likely to be freed?
01:18:15
Speaker 16: She has appealed and the appeal's been heard. I think she had about seven or eight appeal points. They're pretty interesting, I thought. And also the prosecution also appealed because they appealed the sentence. So they felt that 33 years was.
01:18:34
Speaker 16: Manifestly inadequate on the basis of what she had been found guilty of which yeah was interesting the the in that case the judge was very much well she's going to literally have to live on a own because she's so notorious. She's, you know, She'll have a terrible time in jail. And on that basis, he sort of almost reduced it to 33 years, which is interesting. I mean, I think she's early 50s, so that would make her coming out in mid-80s.
01:19:09
Speaker 11: So I did think that was interesting.
01:19:11
Speaker 16: Her appeal points were effectively a.
01:19:15
Speaker 1: Couple of things.
01:19:16
Speaker 16: The main one is that the jury, which I thought was really interesting, was sequestered.
01:19:22
Speaker 11: In the same hotel. as the media and the police.
01:19:26
Speaker 16: So they were all in a hotel together because there really was only one big hotel in the town that could keep everyone. And that's a really, I thought, you know, that is an interesting one. There was no CCTV, um, evidence provided. So in other words of like jury people, you know, having drinks with the, with the journalists, having a catch up or the police buying, um, you know, apple strudels and coffee for the jury, which would have really caused some issues.
01:19:58
Speaker 11: But it had been raised. It was raised near the end of the trial, I think.
01:20:01
Speaker 16: They said, look, we've got an issue here because, you know, the jury is in here with the journos and the cops.
01:20:07
Speaker 11: But no one really did anything about it.
01:20:10
Speaker 16: And so at the end of the day, she's not going to be freed on the basis of that. And there are some other appeal points involved. um of interest like one of them is things like um the using the mobile um towers was felt to be you know that evidence wasn't what shouldn't have been adduced for various technical reasons blah blah blah so anyway she's not going to be let out um what the issue would be is whether um effectively all of those problems created an unsound judgment And if that's the case, then they'll roll it on again and do it all over. And there is no way in the world will they find a jury that's not prejudiced, right? So I suspect it'll have to be judge alone unless they have it at the back of, I don't know, Timbuktu, somewhere where no one's heard of this case.
01:21:00
Speaker 19: Good luck.
01:21:01
Speaker 4: And I guess that's the key thing. If she's, you know, with this appeal, it's not to say, oh, I didn't do it. You know, that's not what the appeal is, you know. hearing, it's to say whether or not she needs another trial to determine whether or not she did it.
01:21:15
Speaker 9: Yeah.
01:21:16
Speaker 4: So it could start the whole process again. And we know how many weeks that first trial took.
01:21:19
Speaker 1: Yeah, exactly.
01:21:20
Speaker 16: And we've had cases in Australia, we've had cases in South Australia where, you know, juries have heard the same evidence three times. Three different juries heard the same stuff three times. And eventually, you know, there's a conviction and that's it.
01:21:34
Speaker 1: That's it for the show today. Oh, look, you don't have a lawyer joke. You're substituting a dad joke. Is that right?
01:21:41
Speaker 15: Or a dad lawyer joke.
01:21:43
Speaker 16: This is for the brekkie team so I can go in the competition to win the prize.
01:21:48
Speaker 1: Don't know what it is.
01:21:49
Speaker 11: What did the judge say to the dentist?
01:21:52
Speaker 1: What did the judge say to the dentist? No idea.
01:21:55
Speaker 11: I want the tooth, the whole tooth
and nothing but the tooth.
01:22:00
Speaker 8: Bingo.
01:22:01
Speaker 5: Thank you.
01:22:02
Speaker 1: And on that note, folks, Tim, Caitlin, lovely to have you in the studio again. When experience matters, trust Johnston Withers lawyers with over 75 years legal experience, johnstonwithers.com.au. 9 past 11, 5AA this Thursday morning. Hope we find you well. Heart attacks. I think it's fair to say they're synonymous with crushing chest pains. But for women, it can be very different. Joining me now is Advara Heart Care CEO and cardiologist, Dr. David O'Donnell. Doctor, good morning to you.
01:22:37
Speaker 9: Good morning, Graeme.
01:22:39
Speaker 1: All of us, I think, at some stage in our lives realise that heart attacks are a serious issue. It's still... These are the biggest killer of Australians?
01:22:47
Speaker 9: Well, it's the number one killer of Australians, both male and, importantly, female.
01:22:52
Speaker 6: Yeah.
01:22:53
Speaker 9: And that's really what we need to talk about, is that this is a female condition as well as a male condition.
01:22:57
Speaker 1: Most definitely. Well, as I mentioned, crushing chest pain we see is synonymous, but apparently in women that is not necessarily a symptom.
01:23:08
Speaker 9: Now, look, again, let's be clear that the most common symptom in both men and women is chest pain. But we've noted that increasingly women can present with slightly different presentations leading into a heart attack. And the recent research is actually in the days and weeks prior to a heart attack, you can have what we call prodromal symptoms. And they don't necessarily include pain. They can be shortness of breath. It could be breathing problems, nausea. And the one that's pretty pronounced is this extreme fatigue. And that's what the latest findings are really interesting. This extreme fatigue is much more common in women leading into a heart attack.
01:23:45
Speaker 1: That is an interesting point because I guess all of us, male or female, often, as we get older anyway, experience fatigue. fatigue at certain levels. So at what level do you think this could be a danger sign?
01:23:59
Speaker 9: Look, it's really a very important question and one that's actually quite hard to answer. I'd like to say that there's a difference between extreme fatigue and tiredness. Tiredness is when you've had a difficult night's sleep and you wake up feeling a bit washed out. Extreme fatigue is unexplained. There's no reason for it. And it's not just tiredness. It's an inability to get out of bed. It's your arms and legs just feel so heavy you really can't move them. It's brain fog. It's probably what you feel at the height of the worst flu you've ever had or the worst COVID you've ever had, but you're having it without any of the infectious symptoms going alongside it. It's not specific to a heart attack, but it is a sign that something's not right in the body and you should just seek medical attention.
01:24:42
Speaker 1: So can a
woman have a heart attack without experiencing any chest pain at all?
01:24:46
Speaker 9: Yes, certainly both men and women can have heart attacks without chest pain. It's far less common. The message I'd really like to get out there, and all cardiologists like to get out there, is we don't want to be seeing you when you're having a heart attack, whether you're having symptoms or not. We want to know your heart risk well before you have a heart attack. We want to know your heart risk five, ten years before the heart attack. And so for men, and particularly for women, very good at getting their bowel cancer screening, very good at getting their breast screening. Get your heart screening done at the same time because heart disease remains the number one killer in Australia and it's also the one that's most preventable. We can treat this to stop you having a heart attack and we think that 90% of heart attacks could be prevented if we saw people in time.
01:25:32
Speaker 1: At what age should men and women be tested for the heart?
01:25:38
Speaker 9: Again, this is a discussion with your GP or ideally with a cardiologist. For someone without any other known risk factors, most of us would recommend that for men, this is about 45 years of age, they should start having their heart assessed. And for women, it's typically post-menopausal or around 55 years of age. But if you're diabetic, if you've got a family history of premature heart disease, if you've had problems for women, particularly if you've had problems during pregnancy with preeclampsia, high blood pressure or diabetes, If you're known to have other health risks, then you need to get this checked earlier. And we are increasingly seeing people in their late 30s and early 40s coming for significant heart checks. And this starts with a blood test, a history examination. But these days, access to imaging of your coronary arteries through a CT or a calcium score is something we would strongly recommend to risk stratify people. Do you have heart disease or not is the question. And we can get that assessment pretty easily done these days.
01:26:37
Speaker 1: So let's get back to the symptoms then. You say with women, there's extreme tiredness. I mean, you're talking absolutely extreme fatigue. With men, the chest pressure. What other early signs are there of heart problems?
01:26:53
Speaker 9: So what we're talking about, we do need to separate the prodrome of what happens prior to the artery actually blocking. So prior to the artery blocking, there's actually inflammation And there's autonomic disturbance, so nervous disturbance. And that can lead to shortness of breath. It can lead to palpitations or a racing heart. It can lead to feelings of pain. It can lead to nausea. Another symptom that's actually quite common is a profound feeling of anxiety without any known reason for it. And fatigue fits in that group. And they can often exist, as I say, for days to weeks.
01:27:25
Speaker 2: Before the heart attack.
01:27:27
Speaker 9: When the heart attack actually starts, still, to this day, the most common symptom is pain in the chest. But that pain can also be in the jaw, it can be in the teeth, it can be in the upper back, or it can even be in the abdomen. And in some people, there isn't any pain at all. It's just nausea, tightness, or discomfort. The real message here is if you know you're at elevated risk and you're getting some of these symptoms, you need to be seeking urgent medical attention.
01:27:52
Speaker 1: So why is it that heart attacks can present differently in men and women?
01:27:57
Speaker 9: Look, there's a lot of theories around this. And they are theories. There is no proven one reason. Now, part of this actually gets down to anatomy. Women have smaller chest. Their heart is in a slightly different position. The nervous inputs into the heart are slightly different. So the representation can be quite different. There is no doubt that there is a hormonal impact on this as well. And I think there's probably a psychosocial impact on this as well. Women are probably less likely to think of pain they get in their chest as being a heart attack. For a man, it's almost been ingrained over 30 years that if you get central chest pain, it's a heart attack. Women will often try and put that down. And to be honest with you, doctors were also doing this 10 years ago. They'd put it down as indigestion. They'd put it down as muscle pain. They'd put it down as lung problems, not realizing that a heart attack is a very significant problem. More men than women still have heart attacks. But the perspective I like to put here is as a 50-year-old woman, you are significantly more likely to die of a heart attack than breast cancer. And that doesn't diminish the screening for breast cancer. It just puts your heart attack screening beside that.
01:29:05
Speaker 1: If a woman has unexplained fatigue for several days or, for that matter, for several weeks, when should she stop saying, you know, it's my age, stress, I've just had a lack of sleep? When should she really take it seriously?
01:29:17
Speaker 9: Again, this is a question that you really want to be answered with your medical professional. So getting in to see your GP early on is important. If I see someone who has no other explanation for the fatigue, we're going to be very keen in assessing their heart at an early stage in this. It's a very difficult question to answer generally because one of the most common symptoms is that GPs face these days is tiredness. And I like to say that this is not tiredness. It is something different. It's not you don't like to sleep. It's not because you've had some stresses. It's not because you drank too much on the weekend. It's an unexplained fatigue that is the prodromal symptom of a heart attack. But if it's persisting beyond a couple of days, if you haven't developed other symptoms of flu-like illness or other symptoms of infection, then you ought
to be getting in to see your general practitioner. And if you can't get in to your general practitioner, you know, there's Medicare urgent care clinics that will be able to tell you if this is something that needs more attention. What you really need is you need someone to do a blood test, an ECG, and perhaps even an ultrasound of your heart to make sure this isn't a heart problem.
01:30:25
Speaker 1: And I guess it's always best to err on the side of caution. It's best to, you know, if you're not sure, have a test anyway, and then you can walk away if there's no problem. But if you do have a problem, you're catching it early.
01:30:37
Speaker 9: Look, it's something we say repeatedly. There's no harm in attending. to see a doctor or an emergency department and be told it's a false alarm. But there's a big problem if you stay at home. The chance of surviving a heart attack in the home is significantly lower than if you're actually getting medical attention. If you have a heart attack in my cath lab, the chance of surviving is very high. If you have a heart attack at home, the chance of surviving is very low. So err on the side of caution. But again, if you know your heart risk, this can really determine how urgent you need to stay. If you know you're at elevated risk, you develop these symptoms, you need to seek attention urgently. If you know you're at very low risk, you could perhaps give it a little longer before you seek attention for these nonspecific symptoms. But anyone developing central chest pain needs to be seeking attention urgently.
01:31:27
Speaker 1: Doctor, thanks so much for your timely advice.
01:31:29
Speaker 5: Dr.
01:31:29
Speaker 1: David O'Donnell, cardiologist and Advara Heart Care CEO. So there it is, particularly for women, and that was the angle we were looking at. But the symptoms for women can be vastly different. And, you know, whereas men can usually feel crushing chest pain or pressure, but for women it can be unexplained fatigue. So you have been told, check with your GP. 18 past 11, 5AA.
01:31:56
Speaker 5: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
01:32:02
Speaker 1: 22 past 11, 5AA. Thanks for dropping by. Anything happening in your neck of the woods? Traffic hold-up? Accidents? Burst water main, something you think the 5AA audience would like to know about or should know about, give us a call. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. Well, Australians are being urged to don their footy colours in September in support of the Fight Cancer Foundation. The CEO of the Fight Cancer Foundation, Ron Whelans. Rod, good morning to you. Thanks for your time today.
01:32:29
Speaker 5: Good morning, Graeme.
01:32:30
Speaker 1: So tell us what is behind this push to get Australians to don their footy colours.
01:32:36
Speaker 20: Well, Footy Cars Day is a fantastic activation that we do in September. It's the biggest fundraiser for the Fight Cancer Foundation, and Fight Cancer Foundation is an incredibly important charity which helps families stay together when they're having their cancer treatments.
01:32:52
Speaker 1: So in what way does it operate? What do you provide?
01:32:56
Speaker 20: So it's very easy to register. So it's basically a charity tool that we work on together together You can do your own event. It can be a barbecue. A lot of schools get behind the program. In fact, we've actually emailed every single school in Australia. But they can bring a gold coin donation, wear your footy colours, have some fun, and raise some important money for our charity.
01:33:19
Speaker 1: And I guess it doesn't have to be footy. It can be other sports too?
01:33:22
Speaker 2: Yeah.
01:33:23
Speaker 20: Footy is our primary word that we use in our marketing. AFL, NRL, soccer. You can do, we've got some of our supporters who do charity bike rides or have other type of events as well. Footy is our big theme and our big focus.
01:33:39
Speaker 1: Now, this is your flagship fundraising campaign. What does the money go towards?
01:33:44
Speaker 20: It goes towards our two properties we have currently. One's in North Melbourne, right near the VCCC, next to the Cancer Centre, and one's up in Albury, which supports all of our regional families who have to travel a long way to get their cancer treatment done. And we try to keep families and our cancer patients, and we call them guests, and these people are guests who are staying in our house. We try to give them the best care and support and love in a family-type environment whilst they're going through the toughest times of their lives. And the funding that we raise through 40 Colours a Day goes directly towards supporting those two properties, keeping the lights on, keeping the families together when they're having a cancer trip. But most people know someone who's had a... and direct impact or direct involvement with cancer, and that's what we do. That's our primary focus.
01:34:34
Speaker 1: And there's no question people impacted by cancer from regional centres are often doing it tough because they have to travel more, they're further away from specialists, they need special assistance.
01:34:46
Speaker 20: Absolutely. I can't imagine travelling 100 kilometres or two or three hours a day to try to get cancer treatment and then try to return home We try to avoid it as best as possible. So in that BMDR house in Melbourne, most of our guests stay for three or four months to get a bone marrow transplant, for example, or having a chemo or radiation treatment. And we want them to be well and living in a nice, safe, comfortable, homely place that's not a hospital ward or a hospital bed so that they don't have to... They can stay together with their family rather than actually.
01:35:24
Speaker 20: Getting on the roads and avoiding potholes.
01:35:26
Speaker 1: So if anyone wants to take part in Footy Colours Day, what do they need to do?
01:35:31
Speaker 20: Look, it's really easy. Jump on our website, which is www.footycoloursday.com.au
or Google the words Footy Colours Day. You'll come to our website. You can do a quick registration. That creates for you, gives you a whole lot of information and tools, including posters and flyers you can put around your store or your business or a family group. and you register, you'll get a unique link to set up your charity page, your fundraising page, and all donations over $ 2, of course, are tax-deductible.
01:36:03
Speaker 7: Excellent.
01:36:04
Speaker 1: Rod, great to chat, and good luck for Footy Colours Day. Rod Whelans, the Fight Cancer Foundation CEO. It's now 26 past 11, 5AA. Andrew says, your guest saying council red tape is a huge barrier in having retirement housing built is in concert to what Bruce Gite said yesterday. that council's blocking or slowing approvals for housing developments is now one of the biggest barriers to fixing the housing shortage. Surely the SA government needs to intervene in this. There's so many areas that we see that the housing, and for whatever purpose, construction is held up by so much red tape. And more red tape, of course, more cost. Jane says, hi, Gigi, I'm more for taxing gas companies and a fairer share of the GST across states. I thought we were all one country. Let's do that before increasing the GST. About time government taxed elsewhere other than Citizen Joe. And John says, the state should be swimming in GST revenue. The problem is Marxist idiots running Victoria and Western Australia who are wasting billions. And on the subject of the census, Glenn says, why bother to fill out the census form? It seems the info is ignored for forward planning. Don't know if that is the case, Glenn. I'm sure a lot of the information is used. But I think it's fair to say that a lot of it seems to be overlooked as well. Back after news headlines, we're going to talk about this light square proposed development that could cause absolute traffic mayhem in the city.
01:37:31
Speaker 5: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
01:37:35
Speaker 1: 29 minutes to 12, 5AA this Thursday morning. I'd still like to get your feelings on this wonderful toothbrush. Do you have a good toothbrush at home? Have you ventured into an electric toothbrush? I have. I think they're pretty good. They're certainly worth the added expense. Well, Dyson has reinvented the electric toothbrush. It has a camera jet. It has a mouth rinse. It detects gaps between your teeth. It fires gentle conical mouth rinse. It does wonderful things. Only one little problem. It has a $ 799 price tag. Would you, would you pay $ 799 for a toothbrush? Well, it appears some people are. What benefits? I've heard that some people say, well, if I have this toothbrush with all the whiz-banger-y and so forth, I won't need to floss. I won't really need to go to the dentist. It'll all be just terrific. But 799 i don't know if dentists would be recommending it they're on sale if you're really interested and if anyone's got one out there have you bought one please give
us a call i'd like to know how it fires up 799 for a toothbrush what do you reckon Well, a council green dream to transform Adelaide's light square could create a traffic nightmare. We've talked about this before with Henry Davis, a former Adelaide councillor and Lord Mayor candidate. He joins us now. Henry, good morning to you.
01:38:57
Speaker 21: Good morning.
01:38:58
Speaker 5: Thank you for having me.
01:38:59
Speaker 1: It might be going back a year or more, two years, in fact, that there was this suggestion about changing light square. You signalled the alarm bells back then, but what is in the planning now?
01:39:10
Speaker 21: Yeah, well, now it seems like the council's moving forward on what is clearly a mad idea. And you know what? When you look at this data, what I'm really concerned about fundamentally is that there's some people on council who look at the traffic congestion and go, great, this is a way to force people onto their bikes and to stop using cars. And that's what I'm actually quite worried about because if you look at the numbers in the proposal, the cost of it and the outcomes of it, there's no way that any sensible person would agree to advance this forward. The only way that I can reconcile that this is still being entertained is the idea that people.
01:39:47
Speaker 7: Generally want to make.
01:39:50
Speaker 21: Commuting harder into the city and that they want people to ride their bikes into the city and force them into that action.
01:39:56
Speaker 1: Well, I mean, some of the planning, the figure I saw, it could increase traffic, what, 741% in certain areas. I mean, that's just a catastrophic number.
01:40:07
Speaker 2: Well, absolutely.
01:40:08
Speaker 7: I think there was an east.
01:40:10
Speaker 21: It's actually quite a detailed report and some of it seems a bit... Strange to me, but going east-west, sometimes the commuter can go up to 14 minutes to get through. But what this is going to do is add, I think it was a minute and 15 onto the average commute for everyone. But we're talking about 55,000 people. all adding an extra minute and 15, if you're lucky. That's the best case scenario. It's actually 38 years worth of commuter time every single year. It's actually so much time. And what that's going to do is then push pressure onto every other road in the city. And it's absolutely mad. The city council should be looking at how can we make our central business district boom? How can we encourage people to come into the city? And in my view, this is a way to make it impossible for people to drive so that they have to take a bike or they have to catch the bus rather than encouraging and making those forms of transport acceptable. And what I feel will happen is people just won't come in. They'll take more days working from home, less people coming to the city and our city will die.
01:41:16
Speaker 1: Well, I use LightSquare every day, or Monday to Friday. Admittedly, it's early morning, and we're not peak period, but I can only imagine what it'll be like restricting the traffic as the way they're suggesting.
01:41:30
Speaker 21: Yeah, it's wild, because the benefit that the advocates, and there are councillors who are advocating and want to push forward on this, but we're talking about spending in excess of $ 20 million, I would say. That's my guess. They haven't even costed this, by the way. Notwithstanding the fact the council doesn't have the.
01:41:47
Speaker 19: Money, they've now spent about $ 280, 000 investigating a proposal that would give an extra couple of thousand square metres of grass when $ 20 million invested in.
01:42:02
Speaker 21: The western parklands or even cleaning up our river torrents would go a much, much further way. And so in my mind, how can you possibly... advance or support a proposal for a couple of thousand square metres worth of park, millions of dollars, and council can't afford it, the only thing that I can really see is that they actually just don't want people driving their cars into the city, which is absolutely mad.
01:42:25
Speaker 2: There's no other way to spin this.
01:42:28
Speaker 9: Now, there were.
01:42:29
Speaker 21: Some safety things which I think would be beneficial, but we're talking about getting rid of nine lanes of traffic, of turning lanes, through Light Square, which would just make the entire Western approach into the city a nightmare.
01:42:41
Speaker 1: Yeah, that's the way I come in from the West. I mean, I see the more ambitious option one would shift northbound traffic on Morford Street to the eastern side of Light Square, allowing the existing road space to become a shared pedestrian and cycling path.
01:42:55
Speaker 16: Yeah. Yeah, no.
01:42:58
Speaker 9: No.
01:42:58
Speaker 21: And the thing is, it's only for like 100 metres. If you're a cyclist out there and you want this, right, my proposal would be to have a continuous loop around the entire city. have a continuous loop which we could use for marathons and actually use it as a tourist attraction, do up the parklands, invest in them, clean up the River Torrens, get all the rubbish out of there. If we have this much money, why would we ever consider changing a giant roundabout and moving a little bit of road from one.
01:43:26
Speaker 7: Side to the other?
01:43:27
Speaker 21: It absolutely makes no sense. And if you're a resident living in the area... this is going to make your life a living hell. You won't be able to get into your apartment building. And the thing is that about a year ago, they did a survey, a consultation. They got 220 responses. The businesses that I spoke to in the square had no idea what was happening. And 80% were in favor of it.
01:43:47
Speaker 2: But within.
01:43:47
Speaker 21: And this took them a month to do. But within two.
01:43:49
Speaker 2: Days, there was a petition.
01:43:52
Speaker 21: with over 800 signatures in two days opposed to it, saying, please do not do this to Light Square. And so
the consultation process that goes through councils, I think, seriously needs to.
01:44:02
Speaker 1: Be looked at. There is an option, too, which would retain the existing road layout while narrowing lanes. Modelling suggests the impact on traffic would be far more modest, most changes staying within 10%. Would that be acceptable?
01:44:15
Speaker 7: No, because then what's the point?
01:44:18
Speaker 21: You know, so the whole point is to create, the whole point is to create, you know, a Vista without cars going through, you know, Light Square, because Light Square has, it's a roundabout and it has traffic on one side or the other.
01:44:31
Speaker 7: Why would you.
01:44:32
Speaker 21: Ever consider spending millions and millions of dollars on a council that has literally spent 98% of its borrowing capacity, 98%, there's 2% room in its budget, its long-term financial plan to have a consultation now, on creating the exact same thing? It makes absolutely no sense. And the question for me is, if you want to advance cycling, if you want to spend $ 30 million on cycling, there are much better ways to create cycling connectivity within the city. I am concerned about the pedestrian safety. I absolutely think that that could be improved. But at the same time, when the council receives these reports, there's been quite a few people who've been hit by vehicles in light squares. We don't actually really understand what were the circumstances around that.
01:45:17
Speaker 2: Was it 2 a.m.
01:45:17
Speaker 21: In the morning and someone ran in front of a car? Or is it in the morning where somebody wasn't paying attention? We don't understand that. And so this idea that we're pushing safety without the understanding of what the cause of it was, I think is also problematic. But I just cannot believe that after all of this, the council is still considering it. It just shows the council that's anti-city, anti-business.
01:45:39
Speaker 1: Anti-drivers, anti-cars.
01:45:42
Speaker 21: And anti-pedestrians. an anti-cyclist, right? If you were pro-cyclist, this is not the proposal you would advance. This is not how you would spend $ 20 million.
01:45:53
Speaker 19: And if I.
01:45:54
Speaker 21: Was a cyclist, I would be furious because if there is a budget for this to actually improve connectivity in the city, this 100 meters worth of area is not the way to do it. And which then goes back to well, why would anybody logically think that this is a good outcome? And I think that the problem is that many councillors are coming in to not solve problems but advance an existing ideology. And I think in this case, the existing ideology is no one should drive their cars ever and everyone should ride their bikes. And so when you look at proposals like this that increase traffic congestion, I can only conclude that they would be happy to see the congestion. They would be happy to see people not be able to move through the city because they don't want them to.
01:46:37
Speaker 1: Do you know who was consulted on this? I mean, were pedestrians consulted? Were motorists consulted? Were cyclists consulted? Were residents consulted?
01:46:46
Speaker 2: Yeah, okay.
01:46:47
Speaker 21: This is really interesting. Because a lot of that data isn't available. So when they do the consultation originally for the two proposals, 220 people gave a submission. But when I actually went and spoke to the business owners who are on the square, there's a brain injury unit which uses disabled car parks, which would disappear under these options. They didn't have any idea about it. The businesses around there absolutely had no idea. But then they went and spent a considerable amount of money full-time staff members, an entire month to then not tell the people who are directly impacted by it. And then within two days, those people put together a petition of 800 signatures.
01:47:30
Speaker 15: It's a little bit wild.
01:47:32
Speaker 21: And I question because we actually don't have the data of where these people actually come from. So I suspect what happens, and you'll see this across the state, is that They'll do consultations on, say, bike infrastructure, and then every single person, no matter where they are in the state, they have groups, they all jump on and say what a great job it is. And the council staff go, oh, everyone's in favour of this proposal, when the local residents actually weren't told and have actually no idea about it. Same thing happened with Hutt Street.
01:47:58
Speaker 7: Yeah.
01:47:58
Speaker 1: So there are two redevelopment options before the council. What happens now? When are we likely to get some decision?
01:48:06
Speaker 9: Well... This is what I think.
01:48:07
Speaker 21: So what the council is in the habit of doing is creating uncosted proposals, but there is no budget for it. So like I said, the council goes, you know, on its credit card, it goes to 98%.
01:48:16
Speaker 9: So how.
01:48:19
Speaker 21: And there's now been talk that the council is going to get another credit card. And the problem with that is that the council is about to go into huge amounts of debt, unprecedented amounts of debt. And so from here, the council will decide whether they want to get that allocation in the budget. I do think that there's about a million and a half dollars worth of really good spending that would improve the square considerably. But apart from that, my view is that it shouldn't progress, and I can't believe the council will continue to spend money on it. But apart from that, the council would then choose on a design. They would then engage consultants to do the design, which can cost millions of dollars.
01:48:56
Speaker 9: Yeah.
01:48:56
Speaker 21: And then they would make an allocation in a long-term budget. But I think what the administration were doing is looking at trying to get a bid from state or federal government to fund the thing.
01:49:06
Speaker 1: Let's hope the government take a very,
very serious look at it because on the surface, I'm yet to be convinced that this is a smart move.
01:49:13
Speaker 4: Yeah.
01:49:14
Speaker 21: But I think my biggest concern is that the argument the council primarily rests on is all about safety. You know, and they say, oh, they try and convince other departments it's a good idea because of a safety principle. And yet you look at schools, there's 10,000 students that come into the city every day, and there's $ 36 million worth of recommendations for school safety, but the council doesn't want to allocate any more than about $ 2 million to that, or about $ 1. 5 million of its own thing. So they'll count safety, and yet there's no money for actual school students getting to school safely on their bikes or otherwise.
01:49:51
Speaker 1: Henry Davis, thanks for your time today. Former Adelaide City Councillor, Lord Mayoral Candidate. What are your thoughts, folks, on this council green dream, transforming Adelaide's light square? Modelling suggests that some CBD streets could face traffic increases of more than 700%. Do we need it and why? Bill says we need to know which councillors support this idea and then vote them out at the next council election. John, what are your thoughts?
01:50:19
Speaker 9: Oh, hi, Grant. Excuse me. Hi, Grant.
01:50:21
Speaker 22: As we know, councils are full of... Thank God for Henry, by the way. Councils are full of these woke, left-wing, green, you know, ideal idiots that think that carbon dioxide is going to kill us all.
01:50:32
Speaker 2: They're so dumb.
01:50:33
Speaker 22: Anyway, Tony, Henry mentioned something about a track right around the city.
01:50:37
Speaker 16: Yes.
01:50:37
Speaker 22: I was talking to a mate of mine who said he just came back from New York or Manhattan and there was a dedicated walking bike track the whole way around Manhattan Island.
01:50:47
Speaker 9: Have you ever heard of that?
01:50:49
Speaker 1: No, I haven't.
01:50:50
Speaker 22: It's about 60 kilometres long.
01:50:52
Speaker 9: Yeah.
01:50:52
Speaker 17: How about that?
01:50:53
Speaker 1: So, yeah.
01:50:54
Speaker 22: So I want you to go and check it out for.
01:50:55
Speaker 2: Me, Graeme.
01:50:57
Speaker 1: Look, John, just send the air tickets and accommodation money. Where would you like.
01:51:02
Speaker 12: To stay, Graeme?
01:51:05
Speaker 1: Somewhere on Times Square. Nothing fancy.
01:51:07
Speaker 22: Okay.
01:51:09
Speaker 9: Can be arranged.
01:51:10
Speaker 1: If we win the grand final. Oh, yeah. Well, that's just a cakewalk, walk in the park. Good on you, John. Thanks for that. I'm happy to go to New York to check out their ring bike lane around Manhattan. Most capital cities have one-way streets through the CBD. If we had this, there would be four lanes in each direction and that would improve traffic flow drastically. How about doing things to ease congestion, not worsen it? Yeah, I get a little bit confused or concerned about this over-accommodating bike
lanes. I think bike lanes are a good thing, but I must say, How often are they used? I don't know if there are any figures on how many people use the bike lanes, and I'm not saying get rid of them, but where they put in areas that reduce the number of lanes for cars, and you get five bikes per hour going along these bike lanes, and you get thousands and thousands of cars having to queue up because they used to have two lanes. I'm talking about Frome Roadie, I think a bad example there, or a good example of where bike lanes have effectively token over.
01:52:18
Speaker 8: 822-300-00.
01:52:18
Speaker 1: If you have an opinion, give us a call.
01:52:21
Speaker 5: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
01:52:23
Speaker 1: 11 to 12, 5AA. Shortly, we'll be having a chat with Lee Forrest about what he's got on the show today. Bell says, Hi, Graeme. Let's not forget that many councillors are supported by state labour and their agendas, or state labour and their agendas, many who then move into state politics. Regards, Bell. Thank you for that. And regarding bike tracks and so forth, somebody says 500 cyclists a day versus... 55,000 motorists. Don't know if that's the exact figure, but it does seem that way. Hi, Victoria Square lights really bad when crossing on green, the person on the side in front of the state admin building. Cars turn thinking us pedestrians are in the wrong and when they need to make sure no oncoming traffic and pedestrians are not crossing. I've sent photos in the past to 5AA to explain. I and others avoid taking pictures and take the longer way across Victoria Square. Also not a smart move with safety. Thank you for that. Earlier this morning, we were talking about the illicit tobacco trade. A future coalition government says it would slash the tobacco excise by 80%, and we spoke to Opposition Leader Angus Taylor about that.
01:53:34
Speaker 3: Well, we've got a national organised crime crisis which is being funded by illicit tobacco right now, and we have to smash the business model. That means taking away the profits, taking away the customers, and hitting what.
01:53:48
Speaker 2: Is left with the full force of the law.
01:53:51
Speaker 3: An 80% cut in excise, we know from the work we've done carefully since the beginning of the year, will smash that business model, will put the illicit tobacco business out of business. and re-establish a legal market and stop funding organised crime in this country with illegal tobacco.
01:54:10
Speaker 1: Don't you fear that that will see a lot of people take up smoking that haven't smoked in the past?
01:54:15
Speaker 3: No, because we already know people can get access to packs of illegal cigarettes.
01:54:19
Speaker 2: At $ 10 or $ 15 a pack. So the horse has bolted on this.
01:54:23
Speaker 3: The market now for illegal tobacco is over 80% of the total and rising.
01:54:30
Speaker 2: So the horse has bolted on this one.
01:54:32
Speaker 3: We've got policy right now, which is the worst of all worlds. We've got more smoking, more organised crime and less revenue for the government.
01:54:40
Speaker 2: And we've got to turn it fast. And that's exactly what this policy is intended to do.
01:54:44
Speaker 1: Do you see that returning more money to the government coffers?
01:54:48
Speaker 3: It will, about $ 8 billion over four years. So not only can we smash organised crime and the business model that's supporting it, but we can also increase tax revenues to the government. So, yeah, we can turn this around, but it's got to be done quickly. We see Labor state premiers supporting this, like Chris Mings in New South Wales. He knows it's the right answer.
01:55:11
Speaker 7: Bill Shorten, other Labor luminaries.
01:55:14
Speaker 3: They've said this is the right thing to do, and it is the right thing to do, because the current policy is failing dismally. We're all paying for it. Every day we see another firebombing, and it just doesn't end. It's because it's being funded by $ 7 billion, or as much as $ 7 billion of profits from illegal tobacco.
01:55:34
Speaker 1: Angus Taylor speaking with us this morning on illicit tobacco trade, the fact that they would cut the tobacco excise by 80%. And on the text line, somebody says, if they take the tobacco excise off or lower it, I'll start smoking again. Would you really? Would you seriously? Morning, Graham. If I had a huge lot of windfall, a leaky toothbrush saves having to talk to my personal groom or worry about my robot man servant. Well, plotting against me. Thank you. Okay. Thank you for that, Zanya. The robot toothbrush, just a pittance at $ 799. Does that Oh, I'd love that. Does that appeal to you?
01:56:14
Speaker 9: Oral-B?
01:56:14
Speaker 1: Nothing like a good toothbrush, though. No, this is by Dyson. You know the vacuum cleaner people?
01:56:17
Speaker 9: Oh, yeah.
01:56:17
Speaker 1: Hey, we're all over Dysons.
01:56:19
Speaker 4: Yeah.
01:56:19
Speaker 1: Oh, they make wonderful vacuum cleaners. I don't know if I'll stick them in my mouth, though. No, probably not.
01:56:24
Speaker 23: Although, when you've got golden retrievers, you invest in a good vacuum because there's a lot of vacuuming to do every day.
01:56:31
Speaker 1: Two dogs, lots of hair. Yeah, I used to have one King Charles Cavalier Spaniel, and Dino used to shed. Like there was no tomorrow. Oh, it's outrageous. We bought a vacuum. It was particularly called a cat and dog vacuum. I don't think the brand. Big one.
01:56:46
Speaker 11: Yeah.
01:56:46
Speaker 4: Miele.
01:56:47
Speaker 1: Miele. Cat and dog.
01:56:48
Speaker 23: So we purposely made it our most expensive investment in the house because we figured it's the thing we'll use the most. And then Jessica bought one of those robot, the circular ones that sort of buzz around while you do just to help out. And then we had greyhounds here the other week and they don't have any hair at all that sheds. And I thought, what a world.
01:57:05
Speaker 1: Aren't you
jealous?
01:57:06
Speaker 23: We've gone from German shepherds to golden retrievers, possibly the two hairiest shedding dogs of all time. But it wouldn't happen any other way.
01:57:14
Speaker 1: Of course. You know those robot vacuum cleaners that people tap into them because it maps out floor plan of your house.
01:57:21
Speaker 7: Yes.
01:57:21
Speaker 1: And evidently, if you're savvy with Bluetooth, you can tap into that and would-be thieves know exactly the layout of your house, where everything is. And some of them have cameras, and they tap into that too, so they know where you're keeping all your goodies. Oh, that's smart. So maybe you need to detune your robo-vacuum cleaner. Yeah, I have to do that.
01:57:41
Speaker 23: Somebody did tell me, we got a text the other day about it, some great nicknames for your robot vacuum, like Dustbin Hoffman.
01:57:48
Speaker 1: Which I didn't mind. I thought that was quite good. That's good.
01:57:50
Speaker 23: So it cleans a lot. There was a great one that will come to me in a second. The subconscious will work on it.
01:57:57
Speaker 1: Stacey had a good one. What was that? What was Stacey's? Orlando Broom. Orlando Broom. How good is that?
01:58:03
Speaker 7: Excellent.
01:58:03
Speaker 1: That is really good.
01:58:04
Speaker 23: Because I think you give nicknames. Like everyone has a nickname for their car sometimes.
01:58:08
Speaker 9: No.
01:58:10
Speaker 1: Didn't you ever? You never had a nickname for your car?
01:58:12
Speaker 7: No. Okay.
01:58:13
Speaker 1: I had a friend who had a car, and they called it Princess, and they sold it to a friend of ours.
01:58:19
Speaker 7: Yep.
01:58:19
Speaker 1: And he sort of, he was, oh, you're still looking after Princess? And he didn't see it. It's a princess any longer, so the poor old car was.
01:58:28
Speaker 23: I think some people call their cars like the beast, you know, like being muscular.
01:58:32
Speaker 1: The brute. That's right, the brute. Mongrel. We might take calls on that. Do you actually name your car or your vacuum? Well, people name parts of their body too. Do they?
01:58:42
Speaker 5: Oh, yes.
01:58:44
Speaker 1: What time are we on?
01:58:46
Speaker 2: Oh, well, look.
01:58:46
Speaker 9: Oh, yeah.
01:58:47
Speaker 1: I don't know that. There was a famous... What do they call them? New York broadcaster, Don Imus. Yeah, I know. Imus in the morning.
01:58:53
Speaker 9: Yep.
01:58:54
Speaker 16: And.
01:58:55
Speaker 1: He called a certain part of his body Big Reg.
01:58:59
Speaker 22: Really?
01:59:00
Speaker 5: Wow.
01:59:00
Speaker 1: No, I didn't know that.
01:59:01
Speaker 23: I don't know which part of his body it was, but I'll leave it to your imagination. Yeah, no, Don used to work at the same radio station as Howard Stern. He was that legendary New York broadcaster.
01:59:08
Speaker 7: Yes, yes.
01:59:09
Speaker 1: Well, I used to love listening to Don Imus, Imus in the Morning, but I used to listen to it at about midnight.
How did you do it?
01:59:15
Speaker 5: Oh, really?
01:59:16
Speaker 1: Did one of the stations play it here? No, it was online.
01:59:18
Speaker 9: Online?
01:59:18
Speaker 5: Online, yeah.
01:59:19
Speaker 1: I used to love that. Remember Rick Dees?
01:59:21
Speaker 5: Oh, yeah.
01:59:22
Speaker 1: Weekly Top 40, and then you had Casey Kasem. Casey's Coast to Coast.
01:59:25
Speaker 23: You used to get that sometimes through the Adelaide radio stations. Yeah, those iconic American broadcasters of the day.
01:59:31
Speaker 1: That was fun. Yeah, good old days.
01:59:34
Speaker 23: After 1 o'clock, we're going to talk about prostate cancer. We had a text yesterday that we did some digging on where a number of prostate nurses are losing their jobs because the government, Mark Butler, is shifting prostate cancer care to... to the McGrath Foundation, which we know and love. But I think it's going to be a big issue in terms of numbers of nurses and also the qualifications. The nurses for the McGrath Foundation don't necessarily know how to deal with prostate cancer. And I didn't realise, but prostate cancer is the number one cancer in Australian men, South Australian men.
02:00:07
Speaker 9: Yeah.
02:00:07
Speaker 1: It's interesting you mentioned, I had a text on that very matter the other day and said, will you take it up with Mark Butler? Because we have him on the show regularly. I'm not sure when he's coming on, but it'll be interesting to track that down. Yeah, so we'll talk about that this afternoon. And if anyone's affected by that, we'll also have the team from SportsMed here. So if you've got any issues with your feet or your ankles.
02:00:24
Speaker 23: Oh, where do I start? Oh, feet, back, ankles. I can't talk about feet. I love the team from SportsMed, but to me, feet are just, I can't do it. I don't understand how people go through medicine. and university and then decide which field and they choose feet. I think feet are the ugliest body part that we have.
02:00:43
Speaker 1: They're best covered up, aren't they? They are.
02:00:45
Speaker 23: I don't own a pair of thongs or a pair of sandals, nothing. You will never see my feet because I'm repulsed by them, Graeme. I'm not going to make you have a look at them either.
02:00:54
Speaker 1: Oh, thanks for that.
02:00:56
Speaker 23: I was a bit worried that you started to take one of your shoes off. No, no, I'm a sneakies guy. So we'll talk to them as well. And we have a segment where we get some great 5AA announcers back to revisit their time here, the great Rex Leverington's dropping by.
02:01:08
Speaker 1: Oh, Rex, give him my best. What a legend. I was looking at– he worked for every radio station in town.
02:01:13
Speaker 9: He did?
02:01:13
Speaker 23: I think most people did. But even when you worked at 5AN– Voice for hire.
02:01:18
Speaker 11: That's it.
02:01:18
Speaker 1: He was at five.
02:01:19
Speaker 23: You've been everywhere, I think. So K-A-A-D-A-A. Because when I first started here, he had Rex's quiz on the weekend, which was huge.
02:01:27
Speaker 1: That's right. So Rex is going to drop by to say hello, which will be a lot of fun. We'll see you after one. Good on you, Leith. John says on the text line, we have a robot vacuum called Marvin. Named after Marvin, the paranoid robot in Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. So there you go. Everybody has... Name your parts. Ring Leith about this. That's it for today. Meryl Sweep. Meryl, I love it. I love it. See you tomorrow.