สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
00:00:00:02 - 00:00:22:07
Speaker 1
Welcome to the making sense of MarTech. The rabbit hole goes deeper than the headlines. This is a show that pressure tests ideas, not just platforms. On the hot seat today, we have Anna Morale on. This new book argues that marketers who lead martech projects and sink in systems build careers that get stronger with every disruption. In the Netflix show The Queen's Gambit.
00:00:22:08 - 00:00:42:12
Speaker 1
Beth Harmon is a chess prodigy who sees the whole board. It makes her unbeatable. It also leaves her alone at the table. Today we're going to pressure test that, train what it costs to see the whole board and which small loses are actually worth it. Don't forget to subscribe to the podcast and our newsletter. A little bit about Anna first.
00:00:42:13 - 00:01:07:00
Speaker 1
She is a brand side global CRM manager and a customer data advisor and a close personal friend. She has spent 15 plus years in martech at fortune 500 companies, including three Charles Schwab and Starwood Hotels. Her new book is The Strategic Marketing Skills How to build technology driven expertise that delivers Business Value. Full disclosure I am quoted in it.
00:01:07:01 - 00:01:14:23
Speaker 1
However, that does not make things easier for her. Or me for that matter. Welcome, Anna. Thank you so much for being here.
00:01:15:04 - 00:01:16:18
Speaker 2
Thank you so much for having me.
00:01:16:19 - 00:01:34:18
Speaker 1
That makes me so happy. And also, Anna was like the first encourager of me starting to write essays. And so I am super grateful. Just we're fans of each other. So before we dive in, we're going to start the episode like we always do with some rapid fire. First and foremost, what was your first martech tool?
00:01:34:19 - 00:01:43:03
Speaker 2
I'm going to sound like a fossil here, but it was web trends. Woo!
00:01:43:05 - 00:01:44:23
Speaker 1
That is a throwback.
00:01:45:00 - 00:01:50:07
Speaker 2
Yeah, in the Jurassic time of Mars that was using my brain.
00:01:50:07 - 00:01:59:10
Speaker 1
So nice. Okay, this is related to our episode that we'll get into. But has a boss ever called you difficult instead of strategic?
00:01:59:11 - 00:02:20:16
Speaker 2
I think that for the most part, when I have had those type of issues with any boss and I'm talking years, many years ago before where I am now, I would say that it was mostly because I had a very hard time explaining myself, and I work with things that are kind of technical, right, and the intersection of marketing and technology.
00:02:20:16 - 00:02:38:05
Speaker 2
So I think that wasn't that I was considered difficult, but I was like, okay, you know, she's technical and I'm not really understanding what she means or what benefit that would bring. I think that was more the miscommunication that I have had in the past.
00:02:38:07 - 00:02:56:13
Speaker 1
That makes sense. And that translation is, I think, really the hardest part of our industry and being able to speak to every different audience and meet them weren't there at. It's hard to say. Takes practice. Okay. And one line, what will your book have gotten wrong a year from now?
00:02:56:14 - 00:03:17:08
Speaker 2
I try to write a very evergreen book, right? So hopefully where it gets wrong a year from now is that a lot of what I advise concerning, like how do you communicate with the other teams and how you make sure that marketers are leading projects? Are martech projects are not need anymore because marketers are needing the market projects.
00:03:17:09 - 00:03:35:22
Speaker 2
Right? And everything is going as it should be. All the teams working together around business objectives, right? So I hope that my book can make itself. I hope then my book makes itself obsolete at the end, because it will mean that marketers are really like leading those conversations.
00:03:35:23 - 00:03:44:19
Speaker 1
I love that goal. It's kind of the goal of always trying to automate yourself out of a job, and that is the goal. Exactly, exactly.
00:03:44:21 - 00:03:47:11
Speaker 2
Continuous improvement through, through.
00:03:47:11 - 00:03:52:23
Speaker 1
And okay. What do you consider the most overrated metric on a marketing dashboard?
00:03:53:00 - 00:04:13:13
Speaker 2
I would say Roas the return over at retirement, specially because sometimes we take into consideration media, but we may not take into consideration like the the costs around creative right or the time of people involved. So I think it's always like tricky. It's a tricky metric.
00:04:13:13 - 00:04:19:15
Speaker 1
As well. Systems thinking or analysis paralysis. Which do you most commonly see.
00:04:19:17 - 00:04:49:08
Speaker 2
Unfortunately analysis paralysis. Sometimes we are situations where we see just one piece of the puzzle or few pieces of the puzzle, and then we're like, okay, so what should I do? And you get stuck on how do you start or how you proceed. And when you see, like more of the system, the entire system that enables you to say, okay, I think I can see the leverage that I push here, or I can understand what these changes may represent in the future.
00:04:49:09 - 00:04:54:02
Speaker 2
Right? As we go through the whole system and the whole processes, for instance.
00:04:54:03 - 00:04:58:10
Speaker 1
Makes sense. All right. Last but not least, what is your hottest take.
00:04:58:10 - 00:05:23:00
Speaker 2
So actually I have two. One is what I mentioned already that marketers should lead martech projects and martech conversations. Right? MarTech stands for Marketing technology. And if it's marketing technology, marketers must be highly involved and they should lead some of those conversations. And I think a lot of marketers actually miss this opportunity because they may think that, you know, oh, no.
00:05:23:01 - 00:05:49:04
Speaker 2
It will set it up for me. Other teams will set up ops will take care. But actually the knowledge of the marketer is needed as
Load full transcript
well, right? That in that use case, that context. So that's one. And then the second which is related to the first, is that by going through that process, by leading those marketing technology projects, marketers can actually make their own careers antifragile.
00:05:49:08 - 00:06:19:23
Speaker 2
And I use here the antifragile term that I borrowed from the labs, black swan theory, because it's not only about making the career more resilient. It's actually making sure that your career, your marketing career, gets better after each disruption and does not depend on one specific technology. Right? So I think the two things go together. And by doing my writing of the book and researching of my book, I ended up realizing this.
00:06:20:00 - 00:06:30:00
Speaker 2
Like, if you go through this processes to make the most out of technology, marketing technology for your company, you already making your career more resilient and more antifragile.
00:06:30:00 - 00:06:56:06
Speaker 1
I couldn't agree more to set the stage. You have made a career out of seeing the whole board, really systems thinking. While everyone around you is likely defending just a single tiny bit of the situation. Now you've put that view in a book. Now let's pressure test this together. Your book leans on Daniella meadows. Change the relationships between components, not the components.
00:06:56:11 - 00:07:01:23
Speaker 1
What does that look like inside a CDP program? And not just on a very pretty slide?
00:07:02:04 - 00:07:19:23
Speaker 2
This means that you are going to make the most with what you have, right? So it's not about like, oh no, I'm going to wait until we have the new technology, or I'm only capable of doing such and such with this platform. Well, perhaps you won't be able to use the platform that you want or that you prefer, right?
00:07:20:00 - 00:07:51:09
Speaker 2
And you have to work with what you have. That's the the very high level idea. You're making the most out of what you have. Right. So in the case of like a CDP project or any other type of like large market project, it's really about understanding how that technology, that platform can help you not only with all the activities that our customer facing, right, everything that generates more conversion, engagement, etc. but also how can they help your own operations, right?
00:07:51:09 - 00:08:12:11
Speaker 2
How can they help? Maybe your team pains go to market faster. It can help you be more iterative and lounge more faster, or be able to share those insights that you learn in a better way with the other teams that are involved, and create a feedback loop that helps everyone. Right. So how is it that those platforms can help you on both ends?
00:08:12:11 - 00:08:37:14
Speaker 2
Because again, and I think sometimes marketers over index right. And everything that is customer facing, which of course awesome. It's what we need to do. But they need the opportunity, right. To improve processes or decrease onto market or decrease dependencies on external vendors while they're also going through those platforms or developing the processes around it, the governance around it.
00:08:37:14 - 00:08:52:12
Speaker 2
So I think that's what I mean by that. And that's what I address in the book. How is it that you make you take advantage of all those opportunities, whichever way they present themselves? Right. That's the idea.
00:08:52:13 - 00:09:02:12
Speaker 1
Yeah. It's making perfect the enemy of good. And that is not helpful in these situations. What was the first component in relationship you changed and what did it cost?
00:09:02:13 - 00:09:25:02
Speaker 2
I think that the cost was really making sure that the governance was in place. So it was about like making sure that if whenever we had this stack that had to collect data, unify data, and then make the data ready for activation. So what I had to do, what I helped do, was really like making sure that there were processes around it.
00:09:25:02 - 00:09:54:16
Speaker 2
And those processes helped the business. Stakeholders, like the marketers, also be accountable for the quality of the data entering the stack, because if the data comes as clean as possible, it's going to be ingested, digested and unified much faster and be ready for the activation that the business stakeholder wants to do way faster. So it was that realization that business stakeholders could also be the co-owners of the data quality.
00:09:54:16 - 00:10:11:16
Speaker 2
And that was really, really helpful. And it's something that helped us really make sure that we had our governance in place and that governance is very portable as well. Right. Depending we can change the components, the governance states. So that's the beauty.
00:10:11:17 - 00:10:23:10
Speaker 1
It's kind of like total cost of ownership but in a different perspective. Yes. And it's not something that's typically considered when you know, you're crunching the numbers to calculate something, to determine if it's the right approach. We don't think about that.
00:10:23:11 - 00:10:24:03
Speaker 2
Exactly.
00:10:24:03 - 00:10:37:12
Speaker 1
So for you. Where's the line between systems thinking and never shipping anything? Because we're just too pie in the sky. We we know how it will disrupt what exists or what we seek and aspire to.
00:10:37:13 - 00:11:01:14
Speaker 2
So the system thinking should really be put in place to support the business objectives. You have to make sure that the system will deliver against that. If the system that you were thinking of or designing or implementing does not deliver against those two pillars of business objectives, so to speak, then yes, it's it's not worth it. It's going to be the sky.
00:11:01:15 - 00:11:15:10
Speaker 2
So it needs to be very practical, even though it's something that seems more subjective at the end. It needs to be very practical. It needs to to match against the business objectives that you have.
00:11:15:11 - 00:11:20:23
Speaker 1
Love that pragmatism. So how would you tell your boss the difference if they're inquiring?
00:11:20:23 - 00:11:43:20
Speaker 2
So I would tell my boss what the the system thinking would bring if we go that way, if we think of all those components together as a system, instead of just thinking them on their own, we can ship faster. The next container, for instance. Or we can make sure that we can implement more tests and with that, get more insights to create a feedback loop.
00:11:43:20 - 00:12:05:23
Speaker 2
Or we can be faster in creating content and test it to understand what engages our client the most. And then from there, we can develop a new plan and make sure that we use what performed best. Right. So all of those things, I think that sometimes our bosses, people that are not on the day to day, they may not see.
00:12:06:04 - 00:12:28:16
Speaker 2
So it's really up to us to make them see and then get their feedback, because once they can picture that, they're like, okay, I understand. So this is what I think, and this is where I think we could make the most impact. And then it becomes really a collaboration. And it's not just you thinking by yourself, it's something that it's you, your boss, the team, etc. and it's much more engaging and much more fun.
00:12:28:17 - 00:12:54:07
Speaker 1
You have to shared language and perspective. Exactly. And so in my opinion, seeing all of this is the easiest part and it's not an easy thing to do, but saying it out loud is where things can get really difficult. And to that whole total cost of ownership concept, expensive? Yes, as well. In terms of our industry, I want to dive into maybe something unpopular about it.
00:12:54:08 - 00:13:14:14
Speaker 1
Your book calls integration the most in-demand capability in marketing. If that is true, you would expect integrators to be rather protected. So let's find out whether they are who resists and what they're trying to protect. So is it silos. Vendors brawl. Visible, busy work.
00:13:14:14 - 00:13:20:16
Speaker 2
When you integrate at the end, you are going to change the way someone works. Something will change.
00:13:20:17 - 00:13:21:23
Speaker 1
A change is hard.
00:13:22:00 - 00:13:42:20
Speaker 2
Exactly. Usually human beings are like against change because it's going to change your day to day the way you're used to work top down like, oh, I came and communicated innovation. Go do it. No, it's something like, okay, if we see things this way. What are the benefits? Right. So can we start with something small or can we start with a small test?
00:13:42:22 - 00:13:50:12
Speaker 2
Right. It may be that you cannot, like go and do the system and all. All the martech, everything at once. No. That's okay. You can start.
00:13:50:13 - 00:13:52:22
Speaker 1
It would be so much more fun.
00:13:53:00 - 00:14:14:12
Speaker 2
But sometimes you have to go and get a small piece and say, okay, I'm going to get this small piece. Let's think holistically, let's think as a system, and let's see how that could benefit our customers and our processes. And then we can test there. Did it work? Yes. Okay. So now we can do something bigger or we can go and see the review the entire stack.
00:14:14:13 - 00:14:25:01
Speaker 2
Throughout those lenses, it's going to be a lot of like even take for the integrator to be able to integrate. Really in my opinion and in my experience.
00:14:25:01 - 00:14:56:18
Speaker 1
It's so interesting. We're so in demand, and yet we get the most resistance when we actually do the work. We're good. Yes. And it's really yeah, the job is connecting things, integrating things, the technicality. But it's actually really the change management and the interpersonal management more than any other, in my opinion, any other component of any business. It is unique, difficult in that regard.
00:14:56:19 - 00:15:18:13
Speaker 2
Yes, absolutely. It's it's way more difficult than like the technology itself or even the architecture. We think that there is going to be like, oh no, I have to put the paces here and the components in this way. But the hardest part, that's the part that's the easiest part. The hardest part is the change management, making sure that the processes serve the stack and vice versa.
00:15:18:17 - 00:15:25:03
Speaker 2
Right. That everything. It's only like a virtual cycle loop. So that's really the hardest part for sure.
00:15:25:05 - 00:15:54:07
Speaker 1
I agree in the phrase of like people, process and tools, it's almost always the people. It's the hardest part. We humans are complex and difficult and not by nature systems thinkers, at least not in our current modern era. So for the folks who are successful in these roles. How are they protected? How are they not seen as negative Nancy's or naysayers of, oh, this isn't going to work well?
00:15:54:09 - 00:16:23:07
Speaker 2
Well, I hope they are protected, right? There are no guarantees, unfortunately. But what I would say is what helps them is that they show the benefits. So they're the ones who come, suggest the changes, help implement the changes, and then bring the learnings and then iterate upon it. I think that these people, they they do this whole process, and then they come with the insights and they already suggest a new hypothesis to test.
00:16:23:08 - 00:16:51:01
Speaker 2
So they created that virtual cycle they created and they run it. And this is what I think a lot of companies realize and they cannot name it properly. Maybe it's not something that it's like, oh, it's on my review or no. But being able to put those little or even big virtual cycles in place where the technology, the people and the processes, they're all feeding off each other and it's compounding because you're getting more insights.
00:16:51:01 - 00:17:18:12
Speaker 2
Those insights come back as a feedback loop and you're in reaching the data and the processes are better. And this allows the
company to make better creative. That engages more, for instance. Right. So when that becomes clear then it's like wow, wow. Because that is something that again it compounds, it leaves beyond the person even. It goes like beyond the company sometimes through relationship with vendors, different types of vendors.
00:17:18:12 - 00:17:37:19
Speaker 2
So that's the beauty right? The beauty is go through the entire process. And that's hard because sometimes we start to the problem, then we don't see the results and then we give up. We're not able to communicate the results well. And then things kind of die, die off. And there is no iteration. There is no like next steps.
00:17:37:21 - 00:17:58:06
Speaker 2
So you have to go through this even when it's like a hard and you're not seeing it. Let's try to make it in a way where if you're not seeing yet the results on the customer facing stuff, you're already seeing some results on the operational side, vice versa, right? So that you always have something that you can work with and continue and by trading, etc..
00:17:58:11 - 00:18:23:18
Speaker 1
Agreed. It's almost like a daily practice. One be solution oriented. Yes, address the problems, but you can't harp on them too much. And instead, like we've got the solution, we have to just rally and make it possible. It's always finding, like the silver lining of a mistake, an issue, a problem. And I hate it because it is not.
00:18:23:19 - 00:18:51:19
Speaker 1
It shouldn't be our job, but it's like we have to market. Exactly to everyone. In addition. And so I think the folks who struggle probably the most with this outside of maybe politics, bureaucracy, you know, the things that get baked in is those who've never been marketers before as well. Because if you've only ever been a technologist or systems integrator and you don't understand everyone that is, you know, you're the nexus point in the center of that universe.
00:18:51:23 - 00:18:59:17
Speaker 1
If you don't understand everyone that you're serving, how are you supposed to get everyone on the same page? I don't know exactly.
00:18:59:18 - 00:19:15:02
Speaker 2
So, yes. So and I think this is the opportunity for those marketers who live in the intersection of marketing technology, be that person, be the one doing this, be the one communicating and going after this and carrying that torch, so to speak.
00:19:15:03 - 00:19:36:10
Speaker 1
That's the opportunity. That's being a kind of quelling fears, change management. Have you ever accidentally intimidated a boss by accident? What did they do? How did they respond? Because that's one of the downfalls of being a systems thinkers. You think big picture and I can be a threat.
00:19:36:10 - 00:20:00:04
Speaker 2
I would say that throughout my career before what I'm doing now, where I am now, at this point, I don't think that I intimidated. I think the change itself is intimidating. So sometimes I would say things like, okay, let's do this and break
the silo. And it's like, whoa! They would say, well, you know, I see that the intention is good, but I'm concerned how we go about it, right?
00:20:00:05 - 00:20:21:17
Speaker 2
So I think that change management part of it, it's what is really concerning and scary. And sometimes you're the one delivering it. Right. So it's hopefully I didn't take that personally. And I was like, no, I understand because it's the change management is hard. So that's how we can we could do it. But not all companies. Sometimes you can do it right.
00:20:21:18 - 00:20:34:08
Speaker 2
In some companies they won't be able to do it at point to do the whole system thinking it's going to be one piece or so. You have to also understand the environment you're in in that sense.
00:20:34:09 - 00:20:57:11
Speaker 1
Well, especially if you're thinking such big picture like it is kind of overwhelming. It is if you're just being informed of all of these issues that aren't one small fire drill, except it is, it can be taken in a larger context. I think I've intimidated a few bosses unintentionally. It's not like I'm ever trying to intimidate anyone or anything.
00:20:57:11 - 00:21:25:19
Speaker 1
I just get told that I'm that. And I did have one boss early in my career. It will always respect the ownership of it. Not that we need to be friends, but the person made my life a living hell for six weeks. This person had to approve that change in the transition meeting. This person owned that. They were intimidated by me and gave me hell.
00:21:25:19 - 00:21:43:00
Speaker 1
And it was the first time when I was like, oh, okay, we can like, truly apologize for our behavior and I deeply respect the person. Don't need to be friends, but I respect that they owned and acknowledge their own.
00:21:43:00 - 00:21:43:17
Speaker 2
Yes.
00:21:43:19 - 00:21:45:04
Speaker 1
Stuff because it wasn't me.
00:21:45:05 - 00:21:49:20
Speaker 2
Yes, that's very much. And that's very mature of the person. I would say.
00:21:49:21 - 00:22:09:05
Speaker 1
I think a lot of in our industry specifically, especially if we're broad thinkers, we can get labeled as trying to do something when it's like, actually, there shouldn't be ego in that. And we all have our own echo, and sometimes our egos get in the way of progress.
00:22:09:07 - 00:22:31:11
Speaker 2
For sure. And in those cases, what I would say also is also have this like long term view of your career. So if in a place you are not able to do it because of boss or what have you, you still try. You still like putting the wraps. You exercise your muscles, you did your part. Even if that doesn't bear fruit.
00:22:31:11 - 00:22:53:09
Speaker 2
Stare where you are right now. You are making that happen for you, for your career. So don't be discouraged. Even if you cannot apply it right away, you will be able to. So put in the racks. Try get yourself out there on the system thinking on having that systemic view of marketing, because that is going to benefit you in the medium and long term for sure.
00:22:53:09 - 00:22:55:09
Speaker 2
So keep up.
00:22:55:10 - 00:23:21:00
Speaker 1
It's also a signal of how it's being received, either by your delivery or is it a reflection of the individual you're delivering it to? Or thirdly, is it a reflection of what the company's philosophy is and if it's a fit and not? And not every company is a fit, and if you are in the place and have the privilege of maybe I'll look elsewhere while I have a job.
00:23:21:01 - 00:23:22:11
Speaker 2
Be more receptive.
00:23:22:12 - 00:23:36:20
Speaker 1
You want to be in a place where your thoughts ideas are received in a manner with which it is not taken as a personal attack, but as a solution to an institutional issue. And it can be big. It can be small.
00:23:36:21 - 00:23:37:15
Speaker 2
Exactly.
00:23:37:15 - 00:23:48:03
Speaker 1
But you want to be somewhere where you're valued. And hopefully we all are in a place where that will happen because we're forever needed, whether they're willing to admit it or not.
00:23:48:04 - 00:23:49:01
Speaker 2
Absolutely.
00:23:49:02 - 00:24:07:21
Speaker 1
So to this greater discussion of like being a systems thinker is, in my opinion, one single most important components of our role in the industry. It can also be a double edged sword. So you can win the argument but lose the room. It's like winning the battle, losing the war. This episode is brought to you by our sponsors.
00:24:08:00 - 00:24:32:21
Speaker 1
A touch is an a marketing platform that reinvents the lifecycle marketing workflow. Making an AI first in warehouse native. As far as like gum tech, moneyline and full span House have reduced campaign timelines from weeks of work across 6 to 10 teams to days or even hours with Lifecycle Studio. If you're not sure what to make of all of this acquisition news in the email and marketing space, they'd love to talk to you and show you how they can help.
00:24:32:22 - 00:24:37:03
Speaker 1
What high touch can do for you at a high touch?
00:24:37:05 - 00:25:02:02
Speaker 1
Raise yourself. Marketers Salesforce is buying grace and change might be coming whether you plan for it or not. The good news is you get to choose what comes next. If you're a retailer, choosing an AI company for personalized customer engagement is a must. Bloom reach powers brands like American Eagle, Pandora, and Benefit Cosmetics who win the inbox. The secret is Lumi bloom reaches intelligence layer are in every email you send.
00:25:02:06 - 00:25:32:07
Speaker 1
It personalizes each message to the person reading it, delivers it when they're most likely to open, and can build entire campaigns from a single prompt. The result is email that feels 1 to 1 at the scale the it in action at bloom. Recom. And now back to the episode. Next question is whether your career survives the next disruption moment that either it's a complete system change or you recognize something more needs to be addressed.
00:25:32:10 - 00:26:05:10
Speaker 1
And so it's kind of a complex gambit you're put into. And I think there's a there's a lot of help with the framework you've built. And your framework is really on experimentation and small bets. Capped downside. Something learned either way and having folks aligned along for the ride. To your point, some people will call that antifragile fair. And I want to say it your way, but it makes me think of in chess The Queen's Gambit.
00:26:05:16 - 00:26:27:13
Speaker 1
It gives up a pawn early to take the center. Obviously great TV show, but it just reminds me of that same idea. A small, deliberate loss for a better long term position is a small bet with cap downside your version of anti fragility, or if you had to encapsulate how you approach things.
00:26:27:14 - 00:26:59:04
Speaker 2
Well, the Queen's Gambit analogy. Thank you so much. I would say that having those small gambits right, it's actually putting the ramps to become fragile. Developing the hypothesis, testing the hypothesis, bringing that back to the appropriate teams, sharing that insights. Right. That is the wrap. And if you do that over and over again, you are really, really, really like putting the wraps to think as a system thinker regardless of the technology.
00:26:59:05 - 00:27:30:10
Speaker 2
Again, the technology may change, but it will still be able to develop your own hypothesis and help with and in practice and bring back the insights and learn. So I would say that that's the foundation from for the antifragile fragility. But the anti fragility will be a way of like developing our career thinking in two ways. Right. What helps me right now on my day to day and what helps me in the future, what helps me throughout my career.
00:27:30:11 - 00:27:50:07
Speaker 2
The big picture thinking. The automation is coming. AI is taking a lot of that operational, so you don't want to be like corner in that position, right? But on the other hand, you also don't want to be the by this guy that we're just thinking like holistically. But it doesn't apply on the day to day. So you have to be mixing both.
00:27:50:07 - 00:27:59:02
Speaker 2
So by mixing both and having the wrap of the small bets, I think that's how you make the the career antifragile.
00:27:59:04 - 00:28:28:01
Speaker 1
You have someone more senior than you who maybe isn't as experience in our space. The easiest example is I want to have this email sent as a fully designed, image based went to look perfect and exactly like what our designer wants, and then doing a 5050 test with the exact same content, just either completely simple plain text or just pared down.
00:28:28:01 - 00:28:58:12
Speaker 1
So it's it's the experiment is literally okay, let's see what the numbers pull where who wins. And so my favorite thing is disproving people with data and knowing you might have to be a little upset that you're wasting, quote unquote, a campaign on something you know won't deliver. But it also
builds credibility of see, I can meet you halfway, but also we're going to learn about our audience.
00:28:58:12 - 00:29:15:15
Speaker 1
And then we have this historical reporting of, yeah, it doesn't work for our audience. How about we try this and then you iterate on, okay, now let's try plain text versus just a pared down, you know, hero image. I don't need to win this, but I will win something.
00:29:15:20 - 00:29:36:08
Speaker 2
And plus it makes it long personal. The customers are telling us what they prefer. Sometimes your hypotheses be tested. Sometimes your hypothesis will be disproven. Yay! And now I know that it doesn't work right. So it's having that. I think that mind frame that I need to write that also helps because we're like, okay, it's not personal. Let's put it out there.
00:29:36:08 - 00:29:55:11
Speaker 2
Whatever wins wins. And we learned, right? So you go back to the person that had the idea of the holy Mayo as an image and said, you know what? We tested it and the customer told us otherwise. So great, now we know. So that they feel encouraged to come with those ideas again, because you also don't want people to be discouraged.
00:29:55:13 - 00:30:19:16
Speaker 2
You're like, oh no, but what if my hypothesis disproves on no, bring it over, let's do it. That's the beauty of it. The process of the beauty. Right? So putting that mind frame out there, I think also really helps, especially for the non-technical people, so that they feel encouraged to bring those ideas and to test them. And they're like, yes, I tested my idea and now I have data to show me that.
00:30:19:17 - 00:30:26:12
Speaker 2
And I think that when you do that, they take pride in those with you. And that's the beautiful thing to see.
00:30:26:13 - 00:30:27:19
Speaker 1
It's a collaboration.
00:30:27:19 - 00:30:42:17
Speaker 2
All of a sudden you have like all those hypotheses you test and that's that's where you want to be, that of being like, oh, nobody, you know, we're just going to do this or no, it's my word versus her words. I couldn't convince her. No, no need for convincing. Test it. Go. I think it's because it's new knowledge.
00:30:42:17 - 00:31:06:00
Speaker 2
And again change management is a hardest part. Right? I think it's more towards that because I even I hear the same feedback of like, how do I communicate that from male coworkers as well in other industries. So they also have the same difficulties? A lot of times I understand because again, you're changing things, but what the the approach that I usually have is the following.
00:31:06:00 - 00:31:27:04
Speaker 2
Right. So you are trying a test. You're trying a hypothesis. Right. So we're getting insights out of it. So you want to make sure that those other people, those other teams doing it for you can be the heroes of that story. So whenever things work out or whenever there's an insight, it's like, hey, we got an insight because of you.
00:31:27:05 - 00:31:50:07
Speaker 2
You helped us get there, right? So sharing the winnings, I think it's super important because then I think that takes the or may help with this perception of manipulation, because why am I manipulating? If I want you to be a hero and what I want is things to get better, and it's going to help you choose that seeks usually how I try to overcome those issues.
00:31:50:08 - 00:31:53:18
Speaker 1
Yeah, it's like positive reinforcement opposed to loving.
00:31:53:19 - 00:31:54:04
Speaker 2
Yes.
00:31:54:05 - 00:32:02:06
Speaker 1
And I mean that's what works for children. It works for animals. Why wouldn't it work? For what? Words of affirmation.
00:32:02:09 - 00:32:08:18
Speaker 2
Exactly. It's almost like an affirmation. But with your coworkers, like, we can do it. We can do it. I'll help you get there.
00:32:08:19 - 00:32:23:18
Speaker 1
What do you consider in martech to be what? Fake it til you make it look like. Is it dashboard theater tool collecting vanity KPIs like working on this go wrong and someone is not earnestly looking to improve things.
00:32:23:18 - 00:32:52:21
Speaker 2
So I think that the a siloed view can take us there. Right. If you're just thinking, okay, I, I'm just thinking about my processes here, my operations, my little side of the house. But I'm not thinking bigger and not seeing how getting to Rex with other teams in order to make our processes better or communication better, etc.. So I think that anything that makes people stay in that place would be the faking until you make it right.
00:32:52:22 - 00:33:12:01
Speaker 2
On the other hand, I think there's a positive side to the fake it into your making, right? Which is if you're putting the reps. Because if you put in the reps that we're discussing, even if the company is not, the mindset is not there yet. If you are putting the reps, you are also going to be kind of faking it until it makes it gets there.
00:33:12:01 - 00:33:35:16
Speaker 2
So there is a positive aspect of putting your reps because it will happen and you will be able to show the results and reap the benefits, but don't stay just in your lane. Don't see just your area. Think laterally. Think bigger. Right? Because if you see on your area, then yes, you're faking to make it on the on the wrong side, like on the bad side of it where you are.
00:33:35:17 - 00:33:42:09
Speaker 2
It seems like movement and evolution, but it doesn't really move the needle to where it needs to be.
00:33:42:10 - 00:33:55:00
Speaker 1
Exactly. And this is a perfect kind of tie into how you end a chapter on career resilience, which is the antifragile component. Like where's the line between the two? For someone in these roles.
00:33:55:00 - 00:34:26:13
Speaker 2
I think the line would be, okay, what do you were doing? Does it show an impact, positive impact against company goals, right. If you can show that if you even if it's like indirect right. It's not like, okay, what I'm doing here has like this much affecting sales.
No. But if you can show that even indirectly there was a lift, there was an improvement, there was a benefit to the customer or to the marketing organization itself and how it interacts with the other teams in the business.
00:34:26:15 - 00:34:54:17
Speaker 2
I think that is that is showing that, yes, you are really thinking about you are really putting the wraps to become antifragile, and you are not only surviving the disruption, right? You are making the disruption also help you. But you need to take the reins, right? You need to be the one over there and say, okay, so how do I make sure that if I go through this new process, if I review this new process, if I work with this new team, with this new problem.
00:34:54:18 - 00:35:08:15
Speaker 2
How is it that I make sure that I'm thinking holistically, how to improve everything, as I said, the two pillars, right. And that that helps also the business objectives. And by doing that you already made your career antifragile.
00:35:08:16 - 00:35:32:01
Speaker 1
Agreed. Yeah, I normally do it after the fact because I just it's not my first instinct. I'm realizing, no, I should think of it in advance. And so this actually is a really nice tie in to Beth in The Queen's Gambit, who is the main protagonist and main character when she is in control of navigating all of the life's difficulties.
00:35:32:01 - 00:35:50:02
Speaker 1
It is very different than when she's out of control and we're not going to get too dark because this is a martech podcast. But she struggles for a significant portion of the the series, and then in the end, she is triumphant. Yes. I don't know if that is going to work in the end, but it just made me think about it.
00:35:50:02 - 00:36:15:15
Speaker 1
But everything we've been talking about and so far has assumed that the competition is human, and it isn't any more. Not always at least. So these 3 a.m. questions always come up for me, and every shift in the stack lands on a person. AI does not replace a job title. It replaces a way of thinking. And then the person who only had that one way of thinking.
00:36:15:16 - 00:36:37:10
Speaker 1
So teams make progress with agents, building hierarchies of specialized micro agents with shared data context, hopefully in governance. And it's not just one all powerful oz, all powerful agent. So what do you foresee the human job inside of that structure if you need to think systemically? Oh.
00:36:37:11 - 00:37:00:10
Speaker 2
I would say that the the human here will be the architect of that system. Right. So understand which agents sequence of such set agents understand the context that the agents will have. Right. Understand what if the output is good? Who is responsible? Who is the owner if anything goes wrong? Okay. Who are we going to talk to? Right.
00:37:00:10 - 00:37:25:13
Speaker 2
So all those decisions around those agents are still human. And whenever the agents are within marketing, guess who should be leading those conversations? Marketers. Right. And again, I think that sometimes marketers miss that opportunity because they say, you know what the agents came configured or the anti team configured for me, but then what. So which context that they're going to use there.
00:37:25:13 - 00:37:52:19
Speaker 2
Are they going to is the agent the AI agent considering an engaged customer the same way you consider an age customer marketer or your marketing organization does. So all of those things still must be reviewed by a human at this point. And that's where I see the opportunity for marketers right to be the ones leading those, to be involved in those, and to be asking those questions and not just be like, oh, I got a new platform and I'm going to like plug and play.
00:37:52:20 - 00:38:13:20
Speaker 2
Well, you bet you might. But then again, you may be limiting the benefits that you can reap from the platform, or you may become just like a cog in the system that can be automated, kind of borrowed a term from programing that is the meat proxy. So someone who is the meat proxy, that's kind the moniker meat proxy.
00:38:13:21 - 00:38:23:18
Speaker 2
Right. And a meat proxy, someone who gets the output from AI and just passes along. Right. So you're just like passing when they were just routing and it's like, no.
00:38:23:20 - 00:38:30:02
Speaker 1
You have no agency. It's like you have an agent and you've given away agency to the agent. And they're not.
00:38:30:02 - 00:38:45:22
Speaker 2
Built for that. No, don't do it right. You have to check the output. You have to make sure that it matters. Whatever prompt or idea or, or what the other person is expecting. Right. It's not just don't just like pass it along. So I'm telling markets don't be the meat proxy.
00:38:45:23 - 00:39:10:13
Speaker 1
Yeah. And everything you're saying is also making me think of people processing tools. You have to think through, how is this agent going to receive this information based off of how you input it, as well as the process with which it's supposed to think about it? So is it meant to be hierarchy and structured in a certain order and basically thinking of it like a filter flow chart map of okay.
00:39:10:14 - 00:39:35:11
Speaker 1
Think about this first if here here's the decision tree. Keep going, keep going. And it's just like a microcosm of what we in our roles specifically are overseeing. And so you have to to your point, you can't plug and play, but you lose all agency because you're not overseeing the process or how the agent is acting as a human.
00:39:35:12 - 00:39:42:17
Speaker 1
The tools that it's thinking of, the silos it could be overcoming. So hopefully folks start taking some more agency out.
00:39:42:22 - 00:40:09:22
Speaker 2
And I think that actually this already happened, right? Even before AI, you have marketers who give this agency to vendors, external vendors, right? It's like you do it and I'm like, no, I would have been part of it. I think that
even before I was in the picture, I think that a lot of marketers would need to rethink what what their relationship is with this whole system, right, and become more of architects in that sense.
00:40:09:22 - 00:40:13:14
Speaker 1
To your point, they need to be a little less fragile. That's fragile.
00:40:13:16 - 00:40:16:00
Speaker 2
For sure.
00:40:16:01 - 00:40:24:07
Speaker 1
Your chapter ends on judgment that AI cannot replicate. How would you know when it can replicate judgment.
00:40:24:07 - 00:41:00:20
Speaker 2
For for the AI to be able to form any judgment, it will need a lot of context, right? It will need a lot of our knowledge. It's not exactly that that piece is not in the book, but if it were, it could risk being obsolete very quickly as well. But that's the way I see it now. I don't think I can just like get there by itself because I have judgment on like complex marketing operations by itself at this point, especially because it depends company to company, even inside the company, it may depends on the different groups, teams involved.
00:41:00:23 - 00:41:13:09
Speaker 2
Right. So there's a lot of specificity in, in a lot of things that are very subjective, right. For AI to be able to like, understand right away without our help. That's the way I see it at least.
00:41:13:11 - 00:41:41:12
Speaker 1
Agreed. And our subjectivity with objectivity is where we need the most. We are able to discern between the two. Well, we've been talking about all of these different things. And it's interesting because systems to me get rebuilt in quarters, but careers in getting good at your job gets built and rebuilt over and over, but over years it is not a one.
00:41:41:16 - 00:42:01:23
Speaker 1
It's a daily practice, kind of how we've been speaking in so many respects and so on that end. Anna, thank you so much for making a case and defending it before let go. Is there anything one we didn't cover that you were like, we should mention it for anything that you want to say.
00:42:02:00 - 00:42:25:19
Speaker 2
My book you won't find like playbooks. The whole idea is that the framework behind the book gives you a compass, right? And with that compass, you can always find your to north, for your career, for your business objectives. And then you can get there. Right. So that's the idea. The idea is that every partly changed, as you mentioned, we may go through this every quarter.
00:42:25:20 - 00:42:53:01
Speaker 2
This gives you the opportunity of putting the reps. Tommy. Hey. Right. I have the opportunity to put in the reps again to try to be more of a system thinker again and to be a little more this better this time. Do a little more at this time. And then again compounding. Right. So what you do in a smaller time frame, so to speak, technically or in your day to day work, will help you with this long term career view.
00:42:53:03 - 00:43:10:20
Speaker 2
Right? So they are not contradictory, right? They help each other. So see it that
way. I think that's an opportunity as well for Marcus to see, oh I'm doing this again. Oh actually it gives me the opportunity to do it a little better, to be a little more inquisitive, to talk to teams that I haven't spoken to before.
00:43:10:21 - 00:43:25:01
Speaker 2
Yay. Right. This adds to my long term view and my reps. And being this architect of marketing system instead of just the operator. And that helps your career actually be.
00:43:25:01 - 00:43:28:17
Speaker 3
A system thinker of your own career as well, right?
00:43:28:18 - 00:43:34:18
Speaker 2
Not only the martech stack, but of your own career. I think that's the the main takeaway here.
00:43:34:21 - 00:44:01:06
Speaker 1
Without a doubt. Anna, thank you for making this case and defending it because it deserves critiques criticisms, but also deserves actual practical advice that is applied to everyday life and more. Systems thinkers really need people saying this out loud to thank you. It was a pleasure having you on. But before I let you go, who is someone we should also have on the podcast?
00:44:01:07 - 00:44:34:02
Speaker 2
Two suggestions if I mate, right? One is Jazz Graham, right? I think she has a very interesting perspective on AI and the buying agents and buying agents, removing the serendipity of buying and how that will affect brands and the way we consume. I think it's a very interesting point of view. And also Nicole Xander, she wrote the book about ethical AI in marketing, and I think we are not talking about this enough as marketers.
00:44:34:02 - 00:44:57:15
Speaker 2
And she has a framework around what that would look like, and she gives a lot of examples, use cases, etc. so I would suggest both. I used a lot of Nicole's book in my own book as well, because I wanted to also cover that. Right. So within metrics and what we measure, I put that part, that framework for ethical AI as well, right?
00:44:57:16 - 00:45:02:17
Speaker 2
So that we are thinking about it and measuring against it as well. So those are my recommendations.
00:45:02:18 - 00:45:09:18
Speaker 1
Love it. I will gladly take an introduction. Thank you so much. Where can folks find you? Where can they purchase your book?
00:45:09:19 - 00:45:34:22
Speaker 2
And you can find me on LinkedIn. I'm very active on LinkedIn and you can buy my book on Amazon, bookshop.org or at Kogan Page website. You can use the promo code Kogan Page 25 to get 25% off your purchase, and you can even use it for the bundle where you can get the print book and the book at the same time.
00:45:35:00 - 00:45:39:00
Speaker 1
Love a physical and digital copy. Love.
00:45:39:02 - 00:45:56:00
Speaker 2
No no no. You can also, like Find me on Substack. I have a newsletter there, the Experimental Marketer Newsletter, and for my friends from Brazil. I also have a newsletter in Portuguese called Ice List. And you can also sign up there and here for me.
00:45:56:00 - 00:45:59:06
Speaker 1
Well, on that note, O'Brien. Thank you.
00:45:59:07 - 00:46:02:09
Speaker 2
Oh, Jackie.
00:46:02:11 - 00:46:28:13
Speaker 1
Before we wrap, here's where I want people to actually walk away with. Not the headline, but underneath it. Margaret should lead martech and AI projects instead of handing them to it. Which means you define what engaged customer means and who owns the output before anything goes live. Systems thinking only earns its keep when it delivers a customer outcome and an operational one, which means pitch every change that way and start with one small slice.
00:46:28:15 - 00:46:50:16
Speaker 1
Lastly, antifragile careers come from small, repeated bets, which means treat each quarterly change as another rep and run low stakes tests that keep it on personal. Thank you so much for tuning in to the making sense of Marta. See you next time. A special thank you to Christine Murtaugh, who edited this episode, and an extra special thank you to Jenna Carter for believing in this passion project meets business.
00:46:50:17 - 00:46:51:16
Speaker 1
Stay curious.