สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:02.319
The claim in the context of this lawsuit is that
00:00:02.319 --> 00:00:06.320
Big Food knowingly engineered ultra -processed
00:00:06.320 --> 00:00:08.539
foods to make them more addictive. The government
00:00:08.539 --> 00:00:12.460
didn't really act to protect us. until a series
00:00:12.460 --> 00:00:16.399
of state lawsuits were filed in the 1990s. So
00:00:16.399 --> 00:00:19.239
you're looking at, at minimum, a 40 -year gap
00:00:19.239 --> 00:00:21.500
from when it was obvious that this was dangerous
00:00:21.500 --> 00:00:23.519
to when the government actually did something.
00:00:23.579 --> 00:00:26.219
If you're waiting for the government to protect
00:00:26.219 --> 00:00:28.899
you from a potentially dangerous product, you're
00:00:28.899 --> 00:00:31.100
probably doing yourself a major disservice and
00:00:31.100 --> 00:00:34.119
you're likely to be harmed by a dangerous product
00:00:34.119 --> 00:00:36.259
well before the government ever asked. Listen,
00:00:36.380 --> 00:00:38.939
corporations put profit above everything. And
00:00:38.939 --> 00:00:41.659
history has demonstrated that time and time again.
00:00:41.820 --> 00:00:45.380
There was an internal memo within a tobacco company
00:00:45.380 --> 00:00:48.399
that recognized for the first time that nicotine
00:00:48.399 --> 00:00:50.799
was an addictive substance. And they actually
00:00:50.799 --> 00:00:53.560
acknowledged that they were in the business of
00:00:53.560 --> 00:00:55.740
selling an addictive drug. And they provided,
00:00:56.000 --> 00:00:58.399
they just, they lied in a congressional order.
00:00:59.079 --> 00:01:02.340
All right. Welcome to Kern Case by Case, a Chain
00:01:02.340 --> 00:01:05.120
Cone Clark podcast with Bakersfield Injury Attorneys.
00:01:05.280 --> 00:01:09.489
I'm Matt Clark. This is our second episode. Today,
00:01:09.609 --> 00:01:11.810
we've got an interesting topic. We're going to
00:01:11.810 --> 00:01:15.390
unpack a new lawsuit that was filed by the city
00:01:15.390 --> 00:01:17.750
of San Francisco against what we're going to
00:01:17.750 --> 00:01:20.989
call Big Food. This is a lawsuit against some
00:01:20.989 --> 00:01:23.189
of the food brands you all know and love, things
00:01:23.189 --> 00:01:25.969
like Kraft Heinz, things like General Mills,
00:01:26.250 --> 00:01:29.450
things like Mars Candy, PepsiCo. All of them
00:01:29.450 --> 00:01:32.530
are in the lawsuit. It's a very interesting case.
00:01:33.159 --> 00:01:35.000
In order to break it down, we're going to bring
00:01:35.000 --> 00:01:37.540
in a special guest today. We're going to be chatting
00:01:37.540 --> 00:01:41.180
with a local dietician. She's going to talk to
00:01:41.180 --> 00:01:43.799
us about ultra -processed foods, what they are,
00:01:44.000 --> 00:01:47.739
how they can impact our health, how dangerous
00:01:47.739 --> 00:01:51.659
are they. And the whole point of this is to,
00:01:51.760 --> 00:01:56.140
Load full transcript
one, keep you all informed, and two, to talk
00:01:56.140 --> 00:01:58.900
about what we believe to be is a really interesting
00:01:58.900 --> 00:02:02.420
case. This is a case that closely parallels tobacco
00:02:02.420 --> 00:02:05.079
litigation that we probably have all heard about
00:02:05.079 --> 00:02:07.299
at some point in our lives. You know, this is
00:02:07.299 --> 00:02:09.819
a case that's particularly interesting here locally.
00:02:10.419 --> 00:02:14.039
As many of you know, Kern County and Bakersfield
00:02:14.039 --> 00:02:17.919
especially, we have problems with obesity in
00:02:17.919 --> 00:02:20.139
our community. We have problems with people who
00:02:20.139 --> 00:02:22.099
have poor health. If you look statistically,
00:02:22.460 --> 00:02:25.099
we have some of the poorest health in the state
00:02:25.099 --> 00:02:28.300
here in Bakersfield, California. And so we think
00:02:28.300 --> 00:02:30.919
it is a case that is relevant to our community,
00:02:31.060 --> 00:02:32.719
and we're going to break it down for you today.
00:02:32.900 --> 00:02:36.960
And today we're talking about... A case that
00:02:36.960 --> 00:02:39.319
was filed out of the city of San Francisco. Wait,
00:02:39.979 --> 00:02:41.939
what is that I hear, Chris? A lot of boos from
00:02:41.939 --> 00:02:44.039
the folks in our community. Hissing and booing
00:02:44.039 --> 00:02:47.039
because the case. No, this is a case that was
00:02:47.039 --> 00:02:50.199
filed out of the city of San Francisco. And it's
00:02:50.199 --> 00:02:53.120
a very interesting case. And it's one that we
00:02:53.120 --> 00:02:57.039
want to spend this entire podcast talking about.
00:02:57.300 --> 00:03:00.080
It's a case against what we'll call big food.
00:03:00.180 --> 00:03:01.939
Well, first of all, let's start out by saying
00:03:01.939 --> 00:03:05.680
like we we don't have any. position one way or
00:03:05.680 --> 00:03:08.080
the other, right, on the case. I think we just
00:03:08.080 --> 00:03:09.780
looked at it and thought, and we'll talk about
00:03:09.780 --> 00:03:11.180
this, we're getting a little ahead of ourselves,
00:03:11.319 --> 00:03:13.680
but considering the history and how we got to
00:03:13.680 --> 00:03:16.659
where we are with big food, it was just interesting
00:03:16.659 --> 00:03:18.900
to us to kind of look at it. And it's the first
00:03:18.900 --> 00:03:22.719
ever. Yeah, I think, I think what's, I think.
00:03:23.000 --> 00:03:24.979
Yes, we need to make it very clear. We take no
00:03:24.979 --> 00:03:27.659
position on this case. We're no experts when
00:03:27.659 --> 00:03:31.180
it comes to food. I personally am no expert when
00:03:31.180 --> 00:03:34.639
it comes to healthy eating habits. In fact, I
00:03:34.639 --> 00:03:36.620
could use a lot of improvement in that regard.
00:03:37.360 --> 00:03:40.180
So what we want to do is just talk about the
00:03:40.180 --> 00:03:41.979
issues in the case because we think they're interesting
00:03:41.979 --> 00:03:44.319
and we especially think they're interesting in
00:03:44.319 --> 00:03:46.759
light of some historical significance. Right,
00:03:46.960 --> 00:03:50.879
right. Just as a reminder. I'm Matt Clark. I'm
00:03:50.879 --> 00:03:53.159
the managing partner with the Law Offices of
00:03:53.159 --> 00:03:55.759
Chain Cone and Clark. Chris? I'm Chris Hagan.
00:03:55.840 --> 00:03:57.479
I'm Matt's partner, one of the partners here
00:03:57.479 --> 00:04:02.800
at Chain Cone Clark. So let's just start by talking
00:04:02.800 --> 00:04:05.919
about, in kind of a nutshell, the case, right?
00:04:06.039 --> 00:04:09.620
So we've got a lawsuit that has been filed by
00:04:09.620 --> 00:04:12.080
the attorney for the city of San Francisco, a
00:04:12.080 --> 00:04:17.490
guy by the name of David Chu. Mr. Chu is... As
00:04:17.490 --> 00:04:20.110
I understand, a Harvard -educated lawyer. I believe
00:04:20.110 --> 00:04:22.110
he graduated from Harvard Law School in 1995.
00:04:23.370 --> 00:04:29.569
And late last year, so late 2025, he filed a
00:04:29.569 --> 00:04:34.529
lawsuit against a number of corporations, many
00:04:34.529 --> 00:04:37.050
of which are multinational corporations, that
00:04:37.050 --> 00:04:39.769
make up Big Food. And we'll describe what that
00:04:39.769 --> 00:04:44.709
is here in a minute. But what this really is,
00:04:44.790 --> 00:04:51.560
right, is... It's a way for the law to try to
00:04:51.560 --> 00:04:56.279
control risk associated with what some people
00:04:56.279 --> 00:04:58.800
believe to be are dangerous products. Is that
00:04:58.800 --> 00:05:00.339
a fair statement? I think that's a fair statement.
00:05:00.579 --> 00:05:03.819
And you and I talked about this this morning,
00:05:03.839 --> 00:05:06.699
actually. We practice products liability law.
00:05:06.819 --> 00:05:09.040
In fact, we've litigated products liability cases
00:05:09.040 --> 00:05:13.300
here. We've sued the manufacturers of what we
00:05:13.300 --> 00:05:17.449
believe to be. dangerous products, right? You
00:05:17.449 --> 00:05:19.389
think this is a traditional products liability
00:05:19.389 --> 00:05:21.389
case? You know, it's interesting having that
00:05:21.389 --> 00:05:23.350
conversation today. And I think the answer is
00:05:23.350 --> 00:05:26.029
no, right? I mean, it does involve a product,
00:05:26.149 --> 00:05:28.389
right? We're talking about ultra processed foods.
00:05:28.449 --> 00:05:31.350
That's the product. However, it's not a products
00:05:31.350 --> 00:05:37.129
liability case in its traditional sense. Right.
00:05:37.470 --> 00:05:39.529
Right. So let's make it clear. What we're talking
00:05:39.529 --> 00:05:42.069
about here is Big Food. They make foods that
00:05:42.069 --> 00:05:44.730
have now been classified as ultra -processed
00:05:44.730 --> 00:05:47.470
foods. We call them UPFs. At least that's what
00:05:47.470 --> 00:05:50.689
they say in the industry. We're
going to go through
00:05:50.689 --> 00:05:52.730
in time here and talk about what is the definition
00:05:52.730 --> 00:05:54.769
of an ultra -processed food? How did this come
00:05:54.769 --> 00:05:57.829
about? Why are these things believed to be dangerous?
00:05:58.870 --> 00:06:01.569
How is it impacting communities? But I think
00:06:01.569 --> 00:06:05.959
before we get there, you're correct. This is
00:06:05.959 --> 00:06:08.439
not a traditional products liability case. But
00:06:08.439 --> 00:06:11.699
if you think of products liability case law and
00:06:11.699 --> 00:06:15.839
products liability statutory law, the purpose
00:06:15.839 --> 00:06:18.800
of those things is to protect a consumer from
00:06:18.800 --> 00:06:20.639
an unsafe product, correct? Yeah, absolutely.
00:06:20.939 --> 00:06:24.279
And so although this is not a case founded in
00:06:24.279 --> 00:06:26.120
strict products liability, which is something
00:06:26.120 --> 00:06:29.519
that you and I deal with, it is in fact a case
00:06:29.519 --> 00:06:33.060
that's trying to protect consumers from a product
00:06:33.060 --> 00:06:37.959
that... many scientists and dieticians and doctors
00:06:37.959 --> 00:06:39.800
believe to be dangerous. Think that's right?
00:06:39.939 --> 00:06:43.259
I think that's fair. So I'm going to ask you
00:06:43.259 --> 00:06:47.360
the first question then, right? Isn't it the
00:06:47.360 --> 00:06:51.000
government's responsibility to protect us as
00:06:51.000 --> 00:06:53.779
consumers from an unsafe product? Isn't that
00:06:53.779 --> 00:06:55.500
what the government's supposed to do? Typically,
00:06:55.560 --> 00:06:57.850
right. Typically, it is the government's responsibility.
00:06:57.990 --> 00:07:00.350
But can't you argue that isn't that what the
00:07:00.350 --> 00:07:02.410
government's doing here? Because it is the government.
00:07:02.610 --> 00:07:05.449
It's the city of San Francisco that's filed the
00:07:05.449 --> 00:07:08.870
lawsuit against a dozen or so big food companies.
00:07:09.129 --> 00:07:12.110
True, true. But the way I'm thinking of it is
00:07:12.110 --> 00:07:15.189
in terms of the FDA, right? So the Food and Drug
00:07:15.189 --> 00:07:17.449
Administration at the federal government, as
00:07:17.449 --> 00:07:21.269
best I can tell, it's their job to protect us
00:07:21.269 --> 00:07:25.350
from... ingesting, eating, taking drugs, whatever
00:07:25.350 --> 00:07:28.750
it may be, things that are unhealthy or bad for
00:07:28.750 --> 00:07:34.269
us. And it's their job to prevent us from being
00:07:34.269 --> 00:07:36.910
sold these products. But look historically at
00:07:36.910 --> 00:07:39.089
what's happened in the context of cases similar
00:07:39.089 --> 00:07:40.990
to this. to this. And it's not the government
00:07:40.990 --> 00:07:43.389
that's pursued the claims in order to protect
00:07:43.389 --> 00:07:45.470
the consumer and the people. It's been a private
00:07:45.470 --> 00:07:47.930
action that's been filed, right? And we're going
00:07:47.930 --> 00:07:49.649
to talk about this a little bit in the tobacco
00:07:49.649 --> 00:07:52.930
cases. It wasn't the FDA pursuing the tobacco
00:07:52.930 --> 00:07:55.310
companies to protect the consumer, right? And
00:07:55.310 --> 00:07:58.269
then in connection with the opioid crisis, it
00:07:58.269 --> 00:08:01.449
wasn't the government going after the drug manufacturers
00:08:01.449 --> 00:08:03.310
in order to protect the public. Again, it was
00:08:03.310 --> 00:08:06.089
a private, not a private, it was a civil lawsuit
00:08:06.089 --> 00:08:08.129
that was filed against them in order to protect
00:08:08.129 --> 00:08:10.600
the public. I think the tobacco cases are particularly
00:08:10.600 --> 00:08:14.160
interesting and have like eerie similarities
00:08:14.160 --> 00:08:16.339
to the case that's been filed out of the city
00:08:16.339 --> 00:08:19.100
of San Francisco. But before we get to tobacco,
00:08:19.399 --> 00:08:21.339
I think your point's well taken, right? It's
00:08:21.339 --> 00:08:24.019
like, hey, if we really just relied on the government
00:08:24.019 --> 00:08:27.839
to protect us from an unsafe product, well, it
00:08:27.839 --> 00:08:30.689
was. fairly well established in the 1950s and
00:08:30.689 --> 00:08:33.850
certainly by the 1960s that tobacco was unsafe.
00:08:33.909 --> 00:08:36.330
It was addictive. I think there was a study,
00:08:36.370 --> 00:08:39.690
and we can talk about this, but like 96 .5 %
00:08:39.690 --> 00:08:44.029
of lung cancer patients, and this is in the 1950s,
00:08:44.029 --> 00:08:46.350
were found to have been moderate or heavy smokers.
00:08:46.450 --> 00:08:50.029
And yet the government didn't really act to protect
00:08:50.029 --> 00:08:54.330
us until a series of state lawsuits were filed
00:08:54.330 --> 00:08:58.299
in the 1990s. So you're looking at, at minimum,
00:08:58.360 --> 00:09:01.059
a 40 -year gap from when it was obvious that
00:09:01.059 --> 00:09:03.360
this was dangerous to when the government actually
00:09:03.360 --> 00:09:05.279
did something. I think asbestos is another good
00:09:05.279 --> 00:09:08.139
example of this, right? I mean, we knew, I did
00:09:08.139 --> 00:09:10.299
a little digging around, you know, they knew
00:09:10.299 --> 00:09:12.720
asbestos was dangerous in the 1920s and early
00:09:12.720 --> 00:09:16.159
30s. Like, they knew it, hands down, okay? And
00:09:16.159 --> 00:09:21.779
yet, it took OSHA until the 1970s, this is fed
00:09:21.779 --> 00:09:25.179
OSHA, to really begin regulating the use of asbestos.
00:09:25.610 --> 00:09:27.389
So I think that that's just another example of
00:09:27.389 --> 00:09:30.210
if you're waiting for the government to protect
00:09:30.210 --> 00:09:33.870
you from a potentially dangerous product, you're
00:09:33.870 --> 00:09:36.029
probably doing yourself a major disservice and
00:09:36.029 --> 00:09:39.529
you're likely to be harmed by a
dangerous product
00:09:39.529 --> 00:09:41.649
well before the government ever asked. I mean,
00:09:41.669 --> 00:09:43.490
don't we have that same issue here, right? I
00:09:43.490 --> 00:09:45.950
mean, it's been how many decades that people
00:09:45.950 --> 00:09:49.190
have known and that the scientific data has shown
00:09:49.190 --> 00:09:51.289
that these ultra processed foods are dangerous
00:09:51.289 --> 00:09:54.289
and not good for you. But the government did
00:09:54.289 --> 00:09:56.549
nothing to step in to protect the end consumer
00:09:56.549 --> 00:09:58.730
and to protect the people. You know, in my mind,
00:09:58.769 --> 00:10:01.070
I started to draw some similarities, right? You
00:10:01.070 --> 00:10:05.110
look at smoking, you look at asbestos, right?
00:10:05.330 --> 00:10:10.370
And these were products that didn't have an instantaneous
00:10:10.370 --> 00:10:13.169
impact on human health, right? In other words,
00:10:13.250 --> 00:10:15.490
you're exposed to cigarette smoke. You're not
00:10:15.490 --> 00:10:16.990
going to be diagnosed with lung cancer tomorrow.
00:10:17.480 --> 00:10:21.259
OK, you're exposed to asbestos. You're not going
00:10:21.259 --> 00:10:24.480
to be diagnosed with mesothelioma tomorrow. Right.
00:10:24.559 --> 00:10:28.860
These are these are products that took a great
00:10:28.860 --> 00:10:31.460
deal of exposure over time. And there was a latency
00:10:31.460 --> 00:10:34.820
in the onset of the symptoms. And I think that's
00:10:34.820 --> 00:10:37.679
very similar to what's happening with ultra processed
00:10:37.679 --> 00:10:39.639
foods. That's a conclusion I drew in my head.
00:10:39.720 --> 00:10:41.419
I mean, the way I looked at it was it almost
00:10:41.419 --> 00:10:44.299
took like an epidemic for something to be done
00:10:44.299 --> 00:10:46.870
about it. Right. right but i also think the fact
00:10:46.870 --> 00:10:49.049
that you can consume these foods like you know
00:10:49.049 --> 00:10:51.620
if i eat And I'll probably end up using this
00:10:51.620 --> 00:10:53.860
example a lot because I like them. And that is
00:10:53.860 --> 00:10:57.019
the Oreo cookie, right? If I eat a sleeve of
00:10:57.019 --> 00:10:59.299
Oreo cookies, which I have been known to do at
00:10:59.299 --> 00:11:02.960
times, that's not going to just instantly make
00:11:02.960 --> 00:11:04.899
me sick. I might have a stomachache, but it's
00:11:04.899 --> 00:11:07.059
not going to instantly make me sick, right? I
00:11:07.059 --> 00:11:09.480
mean, one sleeve of Oreo cookies is not going
00:11:09.480 --> 00:11:12.299
to turn me into a type 2 diabetic. But if I do
00:11:12.299 --> 00:11:14.980
that over and over and over and over again for
00:11:14.980 --> 00:11:17.840
a period of years. If you look at these studies,
00:11:17.899 --> 00:11:21.620
at least, and you believe them, there is an increased
00:11:21.620 --> 00:11:25.480
likelihood. The science supports it, right? I
00:11:25.480 --> 00:11:27.419
mean, we're getting ahead of ourselves. But I
00:11:27.419 --> 00:11:29.080
mean, you know, some of the studies I looked
00:11:29.080 --> 00:11:30.919
at talked about the fact that they used to refer
00:11:30.919 --> 00:11:35.840
to it as adult onset diabetes. But they don't
00:11:35.840 --> 00:11:37.879
have it anymore because people are developing
00:11:37.879 --> 00:11:40.379
diabetes as a result of their eating habits at
00:11:40.379 --> 00:11:42.899
a much younger age. And in fact, all of the studies,
00:11:42.940 --> 00:11:44.379
well, not all of them, but the studies we were
00:11:44.379 --> 00:11:47.980
looking or I was looking at. show the kids developing
00:11:47.980 --> 00:11:51.399
diabetes, type 2 diabetes, at a very, very, very
00:11:51.399 --> 00:11:53.059
young age. Yeah, I mean, we can talk about it
00:11:53.059 --> 00:11:54.919
in the lawsuit itself, but they cite the studies
00:11:54.919 --> 00:11:57.019
that say, and these are older studies that go
00:11:57.019 --> 00:11:59.779
back to kind of the earlier 2000s, where if you
00:11:59.779 --> 00:12:02.080
look over time, since ultra -processed foods
00:12:02.080 --> 00:12:06.279
have really made it to market, the increase in
00:12:06.279 --> 00:12:09.940
childhood onset of type 2 diabetes has more than
00:12:09.940 --> 00:12:12.440
doubled, right? And so that's where they're really
00:12:12.440 --> 00:12:14.919
attributing it to these ultra -processed foods.
00:12:15.929 --> 00:12:17.909
All right, Chris, so the second question directed
00:12:17.909 --> 00:12:19.350
at you, right, I'm putting you on the spot here.
00:12:19.649 --> 00:12:22.950
I asked you, you know, does the government have
00:12:22.950 --> 00:12:27.049
our interests at heart when protecting our health,
00:12:27.070 --> 00:12:29.529
right, from a dangerous product? How about corporations?
00:12:30.440 --> 00:12:33.379
You know, what have you seen? OK, I think I know.
00:12:34.240 --> 00:12:36.480
Listen, we all know the answer to this question.
00:12:36.559 --> 00:12:38.720
And the answer is no. Listen, corporations put
00:12:38.720 --> 00:12:42.279
profit above everything. And history has demonstrated
00:12:42.279 --> 00:12:44.960
that time and time and time again. Again, we're
00:12:44.960 --> 00:12:47.480
going to talk about tobacco. We're going to talk
00:12:47.480 --> 00:12:49.460
about the ultra processed food business. And
00:12:49.460 --> 00:12:51.799
again, we're going to we've seen it here. The
00:12:51.799 --> 00:12:54.000
corporations are putting profit above health.
00:12:54.409 --> 00:12:57.570
You're telling me that corporate America is not
00:12:57.570 --> 00:13:00.149
most concerned about my health? Yeah, they could
00:13:00.149 --> 00:13:01.909
care less about your health than mine. Yeah,
00:13:01.970 --> 00:13:03.769
I mean, look, I don't mean to be anti -corporate,
00:13:03.769 --> 00:13:06.169
right? In fact, I would point out that you and
00:13:06.169 --> 00:13:10.110
I are a
corporation. So I don't mean to be anti
00:13:10.110 --> 00:13:12.950
-corporate. But I think, you know, as a consumer,
00:13:13.169 --> 00:13:16.269
right, if I'm concerned or if I have any concern
00:13:16.269 --> 00:13:18.049
whatsoever about making sure that I'm healthy,
00:13:18.230 --> 00:13:21.559
I don't think you trust what... The corporation
00:13:21.559 --> 00:13:23.620
that's selling you the product is telling you
00:13:23.620 --> 00:13:25.519
about the product. Right. I mean, read the labels.
00:13:26.360 --> 00:13:28.679
Well, we're going to get into that. And when
00:13:28.679 --> 00:13:31.059
our guest gets here, we'll talk to her about
00:13:31.059 --> 00:13:33.320
it. I'm not even sure the labels are accurate
00:13:33.320 --> 00:13:35.320
all the time. Well, not only are they accurate,
00:13:35.440 --> 00:13:38.059
but how does the end consumer, the everyday Joe,
00:13:38.279 --> 00:13:42.279
you know, grab a box of whatever off the shelf
00:13:42.279 --> 00:13:44.860
and look at the ingredients and really, really
00:13:44.860 --> 00:13:47.860
understand what it is that they're putting into
00:13:47.860 --> 00:13:50.620
their body? Because they're assuming, look. It
00:13:50.620 --> 00:13:52.840
is on the shelf in the grocery store, right?
00:13:52.980 --> 00:13:55.539
You mentioned earlier, FDA is out there to protect
00:13:55.539 --> 00:13:58.820
me. If it wasn't safe to eat, why would they
00:13:58.820 --> 00:14:00.740
be selling it at the grocery store? Well, and
00:14:00.740 --> 00:14:02.879
that, you know, listen, we've seen this in the
00:14:02.879 --> 00:14:06.200
news a lot lately, especially, and I'm going
00:14:06.200 --> 00:14:08.460
to maybe say something here that a lot of people
00:14:08.460 --> 00:14:11.399
wouldn't expect me to say, but this case out
00:14:11.399 --> 00:14:14.779
of the city of San Francisco is weirdly aligned.
00:14:15.610 --> 00:14:18.070
with the, I think we've coined it the Maha movement,
00:14:18.230 --> 00:14:23.370
right? RFK Jr.'s plan to make Americans healthy
00:14:23.370 --> 00:14:26.269
again, right? And, you know, he has really been
00:14:26.269 --> 00:14:29.210
out there beating the drum about these additives
00:14:29.210 --> 00:14:31.309
in foods, things like dyes and preservatives
00:14:31.309 --> 00:14:33.210
and the other chemicals that you can never pronounce
00:14:33.210 --> 00:14:34.929
that are on the label of these foods, right?
00:14:35.979 --> 00:14:39.120
And so there is kind of, you know, you think
00:14:39.120 --> 00:14:41.779
if San Francisco filed a lawsuit, you would think
00:14:41.779 --> 00:14:43.740
that the current administration would be totally,
00:14:43.820 --> 00:14:46.840
you know, would disavow that at all costs. But
00:14:46.840 --> 00:14:48.460
I don't know that that's true here. I think in
00:14:48.460 --> 00:14:51.519
a weird way, they are aligned. I think, yeah,
00:14:51.620 --> 00:14:53.000
I think you're absolutely right. I think it would
00:14:53.000 --> 00:14:55.919
certainly align with RFK's agenda. Yeah. Without
00:14:55.919 --> 00:15:00.039
a doubt. And so that begs the question, right?
00:15:00.139 --> 00:15:02.620
And I think just so that we all understand this,
00:15:02.779 --> 00:15:07.360
this is a case filed. by a lawyer for the city
00:15:07.360 --> 00:15:09.659
of San Francisco. Right. But can this impact
00:15:09.659 --> 00:15:12.860
all Californians? Yeah, because we're going to
00:15:12.860 --> 00:15:14.700
see that, you know, we talked about this also.
00:15:14.779 --> 00:15:16.399
We're going to see the trickle down effect. Right.
00:15:16.480 --> 00:15:19.360
Because if they if they achieve the desired outcome,
00:15:19.539 --> 00:15:21.659
we're going to talk about what they're after.
00:15:22.080 --> 00:15:25.299
It will perhaps cause change within the food
00:15:25.299 --> 00:15:28.139
industry. However. What I expect that we're going
00:15:28.139 --> 00:15:30.299
to see, and we saw this in the tobacco cases,
00:15:30.460 --> 00:15:34.059
is once this lawsuit gains traction, you're going
00:15:34.059 --> 00:15:36.980
to see similar cases filed in other states. Yeah,
00:15:37.059 --> 00:15:39.919
100%. And whether that's by city attorneys or
00:15:39.919 --> 00:15:42.320
attorneys general, right, there will be other
00:15:42.320 --> 00:15:44.600
lawsuits in other states filed against big food
00:15:44.600 --> 00:15:46.960
companies. And as I understand it, if the city
00:15:46.960 --> 00:15:49.159
of San Francisco is successful in this particular
00:15:49.159 --> 00:15:52.169
lawsuit, and they were to get an injunction or
00:15:52.169 --> 00:15:55.730
some sort of a finding of liability, that that
00:15:55.730 --> 00:15:57.870
would apply to the entirety of the state of California.
00:15:57.950 --> 00:15:59.529
The lawsuit is on behalf of the people of the
00:15:59.529 --> 00:16:02.350
state of California, not just the people of the
00:16:02.350 --> 00:16:04.809
city of San Francisco. In fact, you and I both,
00:16:04.909 --> 00:16:08.509
we have a copy of the 64 -page lawsuit, and it
00:16:08.509 --> 00:16:11.009
says, by the way, I don't know if people can
00:16:11.009 --> 00:16:13.470
see it on camera, but you and I may as well be
00:16:13.470 --> 00:16:17.090
brothers in the way that we independently flag
00:16:17.090 --> 00:16:21.940
and document. complaint. Yeah. So the name of
00:16:21.940 --> 00:16:24.100
the plaintiff in the lawsuit is the people of
00:16:24.100 --> 00:16:26.659
the state of California acting by and through
00:16:26.659 --> 00:16:29.419
San Francisco City Attorney David Chu. Yeah.
00:16:29.460 --> 00:16:34.159
So you mentioned just a second ago the tobacco
00:16:34.159 --> 00:16:38.419
lawsuits. OK. And I think it's important that
00:16:38.419 --> 00:16:41.320
for historical context, let's just take a minute
00:16:41.320 --> 00:16:43.840
and talk about the history of those lawsuits.
00:16:44.299 --> 00:16:46.820
Should we talk about
this lawsuit and what it
00:16:46.820 --> 00:16:49.519
is that they're claiming? I mean, am I getting
00:16:49.519 --> 00:16:52.919
ahead of where we want to go? Because I do think
00:16:52.919 --> 00:16:55.840
it's relevant in the tobacco cases. Yeah, right.
00:16:55.919 --> 00:16:58.940
So the claim in the context of this lawsuit is
00:16:58.940 --> 00:17:02.860
that Big Food knowingly engineered ultra processed
00:17:02.860 --> 00:17:06.079
foods to make them more addictive. Right. And
00:17:06.079 --> 00:17:08.680
use deceptive marketing practices, particularly
00:17:08.680 --> 00:17:11.700
to market the product to children in order to
00:17:11.700 --> 00:17:15.119
get the children addicted at a young age, thereby
00:17:15.119 --> 00:17:17.950
creating a public health crisis. Correct. And
00:17:17.950 --> 00:17:19.910
there's two legal theories upon which they're
00:17:19.910 --> 00:17:22.390
pursuing this. One is a theory under the Business
00:17:22.390 --> 00:17:25.670
and Professions Code, basically that the big
00:17:25.670 --> 00:17:28.630
food industry is committing fraud, right, and
00:17:28.630 --> 00:17:31.069
misrepresenting their product. Yeah, basically
00:17:31.069 --> 00:17:33.369
using deceptive business practices to sell their
00:17:33.369 --> 00:17:35.710
product. The other legal theory, and I think
00:17:35.710 --> 00:17:37.210
it's quite interesting, we'll talk about it more
00:17:37.210 --> 00:17:39.710
towards the end, is they filed a public nuisance
00:17:39.710 --> 00:17:43.579
claim. Right. And so we'll talk about that. What
00:17:43.579 --> 00:17:48.180
I find so interesting is the way that the industry,
00:17:48.299 --> 00:17:55.619
as well as the evolution of the science, and
00:17:55.619 --> 00:17:59.759
now this particular case, mirrors that of the
00:17:59.759 --> 00:18:03.710
tobacco cases dating back into the 1950s. And
00:18:03.710 --> 00:18:06.490
so, I mean, just as a matter of history, right,
00:18:06.609 --> 00:18:10.549
it was in 1950 that an American scientist published
00:18:10.549 --> 00:18:14.789
a report that 96 .5 % of lung cancer patients
00:18:14.789 --> 00:18:19.589
were moderate to heavy smokers. In 1954, that
00:18:19.589 --> 00:18:23.670
was the first time an individual plaintiff sued
00:18:23.670 --> 00:18:25.730
one of the tobacco companies. A woman by the
00:18:25.730 --> 00:18:28.309
name of Eve Cooper sued R .J. Reynolds. She lost,
00:18:28.549 --> 00:18:33.569
okay? She couldn't prove causation, right? Causation
00:18:33.569 --> 00:18:35.609
is something that you and I talk about all the
00:18:35.609 --> 00:18:39.190
time. What is causation? Yeah, so in the context
00:18:39.190 --> 00:18:42.170
of a negligence case, right, it's that the person's
00:18:42.170 --> 00:18:45.809
act caused the other individual harm. Was it
00:18:45.809 --> 00:18:48.009
a substantial factor? We could spend an hour
00:18:48.009 --> 00:18:49.890
talking about what that means. Was it a substantial
00:18:49.890 --> 00:18:52.910
factor in causing the person's harm? Doesn't
00:18:52.910 --> 00:18:54.390
have to be the only factor. It doesn't have to
00:18:54.390 --> 00:18:55.829
be the only factor, right? That's what the jury
00:18:55.829 --> 00:18:57.829
instruction says. But what's interesting about
00:18:57.829 --> 00:19:00.390
this case is do they have to prove causation?
00:19:00.910 --> 00:19:03.509
No, no, they don't. Not at least on the first
00:19:03.509 --> 00:19:06.289
cause of action. Right, right. OK, so anyway,
00:19:06.470 --> 00:19:09.009
1954, first lawsuit against one of the tobacco
00:19:09.009 --> 00:19:12.829
companies. 1963, this was discovered, obviously,
00:19:12.829 --> 00:19:15.170
many, many years later. There was an internal
00:19:15.170 --> 00:19:19.069
memo within a tobacco company that recognized
00:19:19.069 --> 00:19:22.029
for the first time that nicotine was an addictive
00:19:22.029 --> 00:19:24.789
substance. And they actually acknowledged that
00:19:24.789 --> 00:19:27.250
they were in the business of selling an addictive
00:19:27.250 --> 00:19:30.430
drug. OK, can I actually read the quote? Because
00:19:30.430 --> 00:19:33.250
it's interesting. So this came, so it was R .J.
00:19:33.250 --> 00:19:35.029
Reynolds Company, and this was their manager
00:19:35.029 --> 00:19:40.690
of biochemical research. Why does a cigarette
00:19:40.690 --> 00:19:43.910
company or tobacco company have biochemical researchers
00:19:43.910 --> 00:19:46.089
back in the 60s? So you might ask the same question
00:19:46.089 --> 00:19:47.970
about a food company. Well, sure. And they all
00:19:47.970 --> 00:19:50.009
have them, right? And this is what they said.
00:19:50.309 --> 00:19:53.309
It is easy to characterize R .J. Reynolds merely
00:19:53.309 --> 00:19:56.970
as a tobacco company. In a broader and much less
00:19:56.970 --> 00:19:59.549
restrictive sense, however, R .J. Reynolds is
00:19:59.549 --> 00:20:02.809
in the flavor business. Yeah. That's going to
00:20:02.809 --> 00:20:04.970
have some relevance when we get our guest on
00:20:04.970 --> 00:20:06.690
because I have a lot of questions about that.
00:20:06.829 --> 00:20:08.910
Well, hold on. Can I read the rest of it? He
00:20:08.910 --> 00:20:12.170
went on to say many flavorants for tobacco would
00:20:12.170 --> 00:20:16.349
be useful in food, beverage, and other products
00:20:16.349 --> 00:20:20.569
with large financial returns. Yeah. Well, that
00:20:20.569 --> 00:20:24.660
gets back to do corporations. have our best health
00:20:24.660 --> 00:20:28.380
interests at heart. 1964, Surgeon General of
00:20:28.380 --> 00:20:30.799
the United States issues the first report citing
00:20:30.799 --> 00:20:33.440
health risks associated with smoking. I'm going
00:20:33.440 --> 00:20:37.400
to fast forward because 1964 all the way up till
00:20:37.400 --> 00:20:41.950
1993. basically nothing happens. I mean, there's
00:20:41.950 --> 00:20:44.910
a little bit of regulation in
regards to cigarette
00:20:44.910 --> 00:20:48.630
advertising. It was in the early 1970s that the
00:20:48.630 --> 00:20:51.609
law was passed that you could no longer advertise
00:20:51.609 --> 00:20:54.509
cigarettes on broadcast TV. There were a few
00:20:54.509 --> 00:20:56.730
other limitations put in place, but basically
00:20:56.730 --> 00:20:59.670
nothing. And by the way, statistically, about
00:20:59.670 --> 00:21:03.529
the same number of people smoked from the 1950s
00:21:03.529 --> 00:21:06.609
all the way up until the early 1990s. Despite
00:21:06.609 --> 00:21:10.220
all of this evidence, that smoking was bad for
00:21:10.220 --> 00:21:15.930
you. And it wasn't until 1993. A paralegal working
00:21:15.930 --> 00:21:19.190
for a law firm, I believe, in the city of Louisville.
00:21:19.609 --> 00:21:22.049
They were representing one of the major tobacco
00:21:22.049 --> 00:21:25.089
companies at the time, Brown and Williams. This
00:21:25.089 --> 00:21:28.470
paralegal, who I think was getting laid off if
00:21:28.470 --> 00:21:32.130
I read the story correctly, she stole a bunch
00:21:32.130 --> 00:21:36.150
of documents, internal scientific documents from
00:21:36.150 --> 00:21:42.230
Brown and Williams that. really laid the foundation
00:21:42.230 --> 00:21:45.509
for what was to quickly come thereafter. So right
00:21:45.509 --> 00:21:49.490
after that, you've got a scientist within Brown
00:21:49.490 --> 00:21:51.930
and Williams, a guy by the name of Jeffrey Wigand,
00:21:52.049 --> 00:21:56.150
who became a whistleblower. And really, that
00:21:56.150 --> 00:22:00.130
was the beginning of, if you consider now the
00:22:00.130 --> 00:22:02.569
end, right? It was the beginning of the end for
00:22:02.569 --> 00:22:06.710
tobacco as we know it in the United States. As
00:22:06.710 --> 00:22:12.769
soon as 1995, 1996, 1997, I believe all 50 states
00:22:12.769 --> 00:22:16.809
and two U .S. territories filed suit against
00:22:16.809 --> 00:22:19.849
all of the major tobacco companies. That ultimately
00:22:19.849 --> 00:22:22.609
culminated in a settlement. I wrote down the
00:22:22.609 --> 00:22:25.609
amount because it's pretty astounding. By June
00:22:25.609 --> 00:22:30.230
1997, so remember, the paralegal stole the documents
00:22:30.230 --> 00:22:33.730
in 1993. The whistleblower comes out in 1994.
00:22:35.079 --> 00:22:40.220
By June of 1997, Big Tobacco said, uncle, and
00:22:40.220 --> 00:22:44.599
settled with the states for $368 .5 billion,
00:22:44.980 --> 00:22:49.059
effectively putting them out of business to a
00:22:49.059 --> 00:22:52.440
great extent. Several of them went under. What
00:22:52.440 --> 00:22:55.559
I found interesting about that is as late as
00:22:55.559 --> 00:23:00.880
1994, seven of the Big Tobacco CEOs testified
00:23:00.880 --> 00:23:05.589
under oath before Congress. that nicotine was
00:23:05.589 --> 00:23:08.609
not addictive. Right. Despite the fact that they
00:23:08.609 --> 00:23:10.569
had all of the studies, right? And they knew
00:23:10.569 --> 00:23:13.650
that it was. And that was what some of the documentation
00:23:13.650 --> 00:23:17.210
showed that the paralegal had taken, right? Correct.
00:23:17.309 --> 00:23:21.789
And they provided, well, they lied in a congressional
00:23:21.789 --> 00:23:26.509
hearing is what they did. 100%. And so by 1997,
00:23:26.890 --> 00:23:31.109
right before they settled, okay, or right around
00:23:31.109 --> 00:23:34.900
the time they settled, These same CEOs, many
00:23:34.900 --> 00:23:38.099
of the same CEOs were brought back before Congress
00:23:38.099 --> 00:23:41.480
where they modified their testimony. We can we
00:23:41.480 --> 00:23:46.720
can we can say redacted, modified, changed. I
00:23:46.720 --> 00:23:48.980
don't know what would be another good adjective
00:23:48.980 --> 00:23:52.039
for what they did. In any event, they now have
00:23:52.039 --> 00:23:55.400
come out and said as of 1998 that nicotine is
00:23:55.400 --> 00:23:58.559
addictive and smoking may cause cancer. Right.
00:23:58.599 --> 00:24:04.809
OK. So the. The legal theory in all those cases
00:24:04.809 --> 00:24:07.250
was the same, really, that the tobacco companies
00:24:07.250 --> 00:24:09.430
committed fraud and engaged in conspiracy to
00:24:09.430 --> 00:24:12.390
conceal and misrepresent the dangers associated
00:24:12.390 --> 00:24:16.789
with smoking. I think that's an important background
00:24:16.789 --> 00:24:20.349
to the discussion of this new case against Big
00:24:20.349 --> 00:24:23.609
Food because the legal theories are almost identical.
00:24:24.869 --> 00:24:28.109
Right? Yeah, they're virtually the same. I mean,
00:24:28.109 --> 00:24:30.490
the same arguments are going to get made on both
00:24:30.490 --> 00:24:32.680
sides of the coin, right? A hundred percent.
00:24:33.299 --> 00:24:37.319
So with that said, we have a guest. I think we
00:24:37.319 --> 00:24:39.019
should bring her in. All right. So I brought
00:24:39.019 --> 00:24:41.740
with us today a guest, Nicole Jamar. Nicole,
00:24:41.880 --> 00:24:43.680
thank you for coming. Thanks for having me. So
00:24:43.680 --> 00:24:45.720
in full disclosure, I've known you for a long
00:24:45.720 --> 00:24:49.079
time, at least 20 years now. You are married
00:24:49.079 --> 00:24:51.440
to one of my very, very good friends who I've
00:24:51.440 --> 00:24:54.990
known. essentially my entire life. But that's
00:24:54.990 --> 00:24:57.809
not why we asked you to come on. We asked you
00:24:57.809 --> 00:25:00.269
to come on because you're an expert and you have
00:25:00.269 --> 00:25:03.450
some expertise that I think is particularly relevant
00:25:03.450 --> 00:25:06.069
to this case filed out of the city of San Francisco.
00:25:06.569 --> 00:25:09.490
You are a registered dietitian, right? Yes. What
00:25:09.490 --> 00:25:12.269
is that? So a registered dietitian is somebody
00:25:12.269 --> 00:25:14.630
with an
advanced degree in nutrition. Mine is
00:25:14.630 --> 00:25:16.829
a master's of science in nutrition sciences.
00:25:17.230 --> 00:25:20.650
And as a registered dietitian, I help educate
00:25:21.289 --> 00:25:24.250
patients, clients, individuals on evidence -based
00:25:24.250 --> 00:25:28.630
nutrition and eating patterns to manage, prevent
00:25:28.630 --> 00:25:33.430
chronic diseases. And so how long have you been
00:25:33.430 --> 00:25:36.529
doing this? Over 20 years. And you are currently
00:25:36.529 --> 00:25:39.390
working with Bakersfield Family Medical Care,
00:25:39.430 --> 00:25:40.869
as I understand it. Medical group, yep. Yeah.
00:25:40.869 --> 00:25:44.569
And you see patients on a daily basis, right?
00:25:44.710 --> 00:25:49.059
And so... How often, okay, here's a trick question.
00:25:49.660 --> 00:25:55.599
How often do you have to advise people as to
00:25:55.599 --> 00:25:58.420
their consumption, and we're going to talk about
00:25:58.420 --> 00:26:00.559
this a lot, but as to their consumption of an
00:26:00.559 --> 00:26:04.039
ultra -processed food? All the time. Okay. So
00:26:04.039 --> 00:26:07.779
this is not a unique situation. No. Can you tell
00:26:07.779 --> 00:26:11.200
us what is an ultra -processed food? Well, so
00:26:11.200 --> 00:26:13.079
there's varying degrees of processing, right?
00:26:13.160 --> 00:26:16.660
All food is processed to some degree in order
00:26:16.660 --> 00:26:20.059
to make it safe for consumption, right? So the
00:26:20.059 --> 00:26:23.839
minimally processed, like the packaged. Greens
00:26:23.839 --> 00:26:25.279
that you would buy in the grocery store that
00:26:25.279 --> 00:26:27.039
are ready to eat, like the spinach. They've been
00:26:27.039 --> 00:26:29.519
washed. They've been washed, right. Or say your
00:26:29.519 --> 00:26:31.980
canned diced tomatoes that you would add into
00:26:31.980 --> 00:26:33.980
a recipe. That would be a minimally processed
00:26:33.980 --> 00:26:36.819
food. They've been cooked and canned, right?
00:26:36.880 --> 00:26:39.059
Maybe a little bit of salt added to it. Your
00:26:39.059 --> 00:26:43.279
chicken breasts that you buy from the meat section,
00:26:43.500 --> 00:26:45.599
right? Those kinds of things are still processed
00:26:45.599 --> 00:26:48.079
foods. Ultra processed foods are sort of in a
00:26:48.079 --> 00:26:50.970
whole different category because they... I like
00:26:50.970 --> 00:26:53.390
to describe it as there's many steps between
00:26:53.390 --> 00:26:56.190
farm to fork in an ultra processed food. Right.
00:26:56.210 --> 00:26:57.970
There's a lot more steps. There's a lot more
00:26:57.970 --> 00:27:00.609
ingredients. So and most of the time, those ingredients
00:27:00.609 --> 00:27:03.029
are not things that you would find in your home
00:27:03.029 --> 00:27:05.170
kitchen. Right. These are things that have been
00:27:05.170 --> 00:27:06.789
cooked up by a scientist. Right. And these are
00:27:06.789 --> 00:27:09.950
industrial sweeteners, thickeners, stabilizers,
00:27:10.069 --> 00:27:13.009
emulsifiers, fats, protein isolates, those kinds
00:27:13.009 --> 00:27:16.670
of things that add flavor. They add thickness,
00:27:16.829 --> 00:27:19.869
stability. You know, there's a purpose for these
00:27:19.869 --> 00:27:22.150
ultra -processed foods to some degree. They do,
00:27:22.269 --> 00:27:25.289
yes, they enhance flavor, but they actually improve
00:27:25.289 --> 00:27:29.789
shelf life. They can make food accessible to
00:27:29.789 --> 00:27:33.190
a lot more people. So there are some, you know,
00:27:33.210 --> 00:27:35.470
pluses and minuses to these types of foods. So
00:27:35.470 --> 00:27:38.589
the lawsuit we're talking about was filed against
00:27:38.589 --> 00:27:42.349
a number of defendants, right? We've been referring
00:27:42.349 --> 00:27:44.930
to that as big food, kind of like big tobacco.
00:27:45.130 --> 00:27:48.079
Is big food... Is that an actual phrase used
00:27:48.079 --> 00:27:52.359
in the industry? I would. We do use that occasionally.
00:27:52.559 --> 00:27:54.920
Sure. Let's talk about it specifically. Right.
00:27:54.980 --> 00:27:58.559
OK. So Kraft Heinz, they're a defendant. Just
00:27:58.559 --> 00:28:00.180
as an example, these are the people that are
00:28:00.180 --> 00:28:02.420
making your Oscar Mayer hot dogs, your Kool -Aid,
00:28:02.480 --> 00:28:05.299
your Capri Suns, your Weight Watchers, frozen
00:28:05.299 --> 00:28:07.859
meals, Jell -O, Philadelphia cream cheese, on
00:28:07.859 --> 00:28:12.099
and on and on. OK. Mondelas. I don't know if
00:28:12.099 --> 00:28:14.680
I pronounced that right. Mondelas. Is that it?
00:28:14.779 --> 00:28:18.650
OK. I'd never heard of these guys. So until I
00:28:18.650 --> 00:28:21.869
looked into this lawsuit, I guess they're a subsidiary
00:28:21.869 --> 00:28:24.269
or they were part of the Kraft group and they
00:28:24.269 --> 00:28:27.529
broke off. But anyway, that includes Nabisco,
00:28:27.630 --> 00:28:30.029
Oreo. I've been talking about those, my favorite.
00:28:30.269 --> 00:28:33.430
Ritz, I also like those. Triscuits, I like those.
00:28:33.509 --> 00:28:35.450
And Wheat Thins, man, these guys have got a high
00:28:35.450 --> 00:28:38.420
number. Yeah, they've got my Fig Newtons we were
00:28:38.420 --> 00:28:40.480
talking about. So that's the kind of foods that
00:28:40.480 --> 00:28:43.099
they make. Post Holdings, we all know Post, the
00:28:43.099 --> 00:28:45.819
cereal company, includes things like Chips Ahoy
00:28:45.819 --> 00:28:48.440
and Cocoa Wheats and Golden Crisps, on and on
00:28:48.440 --> 00:28:52.740
and on. PepsiCo, right? PepsiCo is a huge processed
00:28:52.740 --> 00:28:55.359
food manufacturer, a UPF manufacturer, all processed
00:28:55.359 --> 00:28:59.000
food. Everything from their Frito -Lay brands,
00:28:59.160 --> 00:29:01.849
which would be things like Cheetos and... my
00:29:01.849 --> 00:29:05.750
personal
favorite, Doritos, on and on to all
00:29:05.750 --> 00:29:07.910
the Pepsi products, right? And then you've got
00:29:07.910 --> 00:29:11.029
General Mills, massive corporation. They do all
00:29:11.029 --> 00:29:16.990
the cereals, Chex Mix, things like Old El Paso,
00:29:16.990 --> 00:29:20.690
the salsa. I didn't realize that they did that.
00:29:21.289 --> 00:29:24.990
And so Yoplait yogurt. I read something interesting.
00:29:25.190 --> 00:29:27.369
Let me ask you a question. Is Yoplait good for
00:29:27.369 --> 00:29:30.119
you? Well, just like everything in nutrition,
00:29:30.319 --> 00:29:32.799
Matt, it's very nuanced. There's a lot of gray
00:29:32.799 --> 00:29:35.099
area. I want you to explain that. It depends.
00:29:35.519 --> 00:29:39.519
But I read something that suggested that Yoplait
00:29:39.519 --> 00:29:41.960
yogurt has within it, and they've formulated
00:29:41.960 --> 00:29:46.640
it as such, to have as much sugar as like an
00:29:46.640 --> 00:29:52.289
Oreo cookie. Okay. And the theory that's sort
00:29:52.289 --> 00:29:54.849
of mentioned in the lawsuit is that they've increased
00:29:54.849 --> 00:29:57.690
that sugar content to make it more appealing
00:29:57.690 --> 00:29:59.569
and possibly more addicting. We'll talk about
00:29:59.569 --> 00:30:02.430
that, too. But is that something that in kind
00:30:02.430 --> 00:30:04.849
of food science or in the world of nutrition,
00:30:05.109 --> 00:30:07.410
is that something that's recognized that these
00:30:07.410 --> 00:30:10.009
companies are fudging their products, formulas
00:30:10.009 --> 00:30:13.670
to make them addictive? Well, to be honest, I
00:30:13.670 --> 00:30:18.250
can't speak to the actual intention behind it.
00:30:18.940 --> 00:30:20.819
Well, you don't have the internal documents.
00:30:21.059 --> 00:30:23.940
Exactly. You've got to get that paralegal to
00:30:23.940 --> 00:30:27.079
store the documents from the tobacco companies
00:30:27.079 --> 00:30:30.259
that they don't know, right? But we know, obviously,
00:30:30.339 --> 00:30:33.819
things that have high sugar and are very sweet
00:30:33.819 --> 00:30:36.119
taste really good, and it makes you want to eat
00:30:36.119 --> 00:30:40.279
more of them. So, you know, those are things
00:30:40.279 --> 00:30:43.700
that we try to watch out for and try to reduce
00:30:43.700 --> 00:30:47.059
our intake of. The other defendants are Nestle.
00:30:48.690 --> 00:30:52.130
Kellogg's, Mars, the candy bar company, Con Agro,
00:30:52.150 --> 00:30:54.049
which makes all kinds of stuff, everything from
00:30:54.049 --> 00:30:58.809
your Slim Jims to your Jiffy Pop to your Chef
00:30:58.809 --> 00:31:01.130
Boyardee. I don't know that I've had Chef Boyardee
00:31:01.130 --> 00:31:08.009
in a long time. That's true, 100%. So one of
00:31:08.009 --> 00:31:10.849
the things that's cited in the lawsuit is to
00:31:10.849 --> 00:31:14.410
a study that was... done by, as I understand
00:31:14.410 --> 00:31:17.309
it, a Brazilian scientist named Carlos, probably
00:31:17.309 --> 00:31:18.970
going to butcher this poor guy's name, Monteiro,
00:31:19.170 --> 00:31:21.869
where he developed something called the Nova
00:31:21.869 --> 00:31:24.309
Scale. Are you familiar with that? Is that something
00:31:24.309 --> 00:31:27.009
that in your industry you talk about? So the
00:31:27.009 --> 00:31:30.390
Nova Scale was kind of one of the first attempts
00:31:30.390 --> 00:31:34.089
to try to classify processed foods based on,
00:31:34.210 --> 00:31:37.490
you know, how much a food is processed and what
00:31:37.490 --> 00:31:40.529
they're processed with. You know, it's a... I
00:31:40.529 --> 00:31:42.970
think it's a good start. It does sort of miss
00:31:42.970 --> 00:31:45.549
some of the nuances in nutrition. You know, a
00:31:45.549 --> 00:31:48.890
lot of the minimally processed foods would be
00:31:48.890 --> 00:31:51.369
in that group one. And then it kind of goes up
00:31:51.369 --> 00:31:53.470
from there to group four being those UPS, those
00:31:53.470 --> 00:31:55.690
ultra processed foods with all those industrial
00:31:55.690 --> 00:31:58.430
ingredients. And so it's the Nova group four
00:31:58.430 --> 00:32:00.450
that we're really concerned with in this lawsuit.
00:32:00.549 --> 00:32:03.549
That's what it sounds like to me. Yes. And I
00:32:03.549 --> 00:32:06.359
think I think most of us. probably know when
00:32:06.359 --> 00:32:08.539
we see an ultra processed food, right? You know,
00:32:08.579 --> 00:32:11.819
Doritos and Oreos and those really sugary cereals.
00:32:11.819 --> 00:32:13.759
You mean the Doritos aren't covered with all
00:32:13.759 --> 00:32:15.980
natural flavoring? Well, and even if they were,
00:32:16.079 --> 00:32:18.180
they'd still be ultra processed. Good point.
00:32:18.920 --> 00:32:23.200
So in the lawsuit, they spend a great deal of
00:32:23.200 --> 00:32:27.900
time at the outset. talking about a food industry
00:32:27.900 --> 00:32:30.440
insider, a guy by the name of Michael Mudd. I'm
00:32:30.440 --> 00:32:32.579
not going to quiz you on who that is, okay? But
00:32:32.579 --> 00:32:36.940
he was a vice president for Kraft. And in 1999,
00:32:37.279 --> 00:32:43.420
so 26, 27 years ago now, he, in front of his
00:32:43.420 --> 00:32:46.500
colleagues at some big food convention, I feel
00:32:46.500 --> 00:32:48.460
like this is like when the mafia would get together
00:32:48.460 --> 00:32:51.769
for their... But that is some food convention
00:32:51.769 --> 00:32:55.250
actually hosted by Pillsbury, if I read it right.
00:32:56.130 --> 00:33:00.670
He lost his job shortly after he made these comments.
00:33:00.849 --> 00:33:04.349
He talked about the devastating health consequences
00:33:04.349 --> 00:33:07.349
known within the industry when people consume
00:33:07.349 --> 00:33:11.500
too many UPFs, ultra processed foods. He said
00:33:11.500 --> 00:33:15.559
that UPFs had caused childhood obesity rates
00:33:15.559 --> 00:33:18.279
to double, and that was as of 1999, so I can't
00:33:18.279 --> 00:33:21.400
imagine. Gone up since then. Yes. That it was
00:33:21.400 --> 00:33:25.940
costing, and this is in 1999 dollars, $100 billion
00:33:25.940 --> 00:33:28.920
per year to treat health conditions in the United
00:33:28.920 --> 00:33:33.660
States caused by UPFs. Mind you, again, so everybody's
00:33:33.660 --> 00:33:37.579
clear, this is the insider, right? is saying
00:33:37.579 --> 00:33:40.099
that $100 billion per year to treat conditions
00:33:40.099 --> 00:33:44.220
caused by UPFs, and by his estimation, 300 ,000
00:33:44.220 --> 00:33:48.559
Americans died each year based on consuming too
00:33:48.559 --> 00:33:50.940
many of these ultra -processed foods. I looked
00:33:50.940 --> 00:33:52.980
that up, by the way. That's close to the number
00:33:52.980 --> 00:33:56.599
of U .S. soldiers killed in World War II. Wow.
00:33:56.819 --> 00:33:59.160
Yeah, and that was over many years. This is over
00:33:59.160 --> 00:34:03.839
a year. And so he said, look, this is a public
00:34:03.839 --> 00:34:06.880
health crisis. We as an industry need to address
00:34:06.880 --> 00:34:10.480
this. He talked about the industry putting profits
00:34:10.480 --> 00:34:14.659
over people's health. And he was summarily lost
00:34:14.659 --> 00:34:16.920
his job shortly thereafter. And it doesn't appear
00:34:16.920 --> 00:34:20.599
that anything has changed in the last 27 years.
00:34:22.659 --> 00:34:25.260
What have you, that's about the period of time
00:34:25.260 --> 00:34:27.320
you've been in the industry. So what have you
00:34:27.320 --> 00:34:29.679
observed over that period of time? Well, there
00:34:29.679 --> 00:34:33.280
definitely, I've seen a much more proliferate.
00:34:33.900 --> 00:34:35.880
Higher proliferation of people consuming ultra
00:34:35.880 --> 00:34:38.880
processed foods. Absolutely. Definitely more
00:34:38.880 --> 00:34:42.300
kids that their entire diet revolves around ultra
00:34:42.300 --> 00:34:44.780
processed foods. You know, things like having
00:34:44.780 --> 00:34:49.949
a granola bar for breakfast and having a. some
00:34:49.949 --> 00:34:52.909
kind of, oh, what are those, Smucker's sandwiches,
00:34:53.210 --> 00:34:57.630
the Cristobals for lunch, and then having a frozen
00:34:57.630 --> 00:34:59.630
pizza for dinner. So yeah, it definitely has
00:34:59.630 --> 00:35:02.769
increased and seeing a lot more of it, for sure.
00:35:03.070 --> 00:35:05.889
Are you seeing, in terms of patients, are you
00:35:05.889 --> 00:35:08.070
seeing more in the way of pediatric patients
00:35:08.070 --> 00:35:11.050
because of that? I do see some. I see mostly
00:35:11.050 --> 00:35:14.030
adults, but I do see some kids. And a lot of
00:35:14.030 --> 00:35:16.530
kids, yes, are eating these foods. Because one
00:35:16.530 --> 00:35:20.219
of the claims in the lawsuit is that The ultra
00:35:20.219 --> 00:35:22.099
-processed food
manufacturers, the defendants
00:35:22.099 --> 00:35:25.039
in the lawsuit, are really unfairly targeting
00:35:25.039 --> 00:35:27.179
children with their advertisement campaigns.
00:35:27.280 --> 00:35:30.639
Sure. But kids don't buy their groceries. This
00:35:30.639 --> 00:35:33.360
is a good point, right? But kids probably have
00:35:33.360 --> 00:35:35.019
some influence over the parent who is buying
00:35:35.019 --> 00:35:38.179
the groceries. Most likely, yes. And, you know,
00:35:38.260 --> 00:35:43.019
I don't play video games, but I read within the
00:35:43.019 --> 00:35:46.260
lawsuit as well as some of the documents cited
00:35:46.260 --> 00:35:50.699
to in the lawsuit. I mean, they're going as far
00:35:50.699 --> 00:35:52.579
as putting product placement advertisements in
00:35:52.579 --> 00:35:55.619
video games for things like Go -Gurt, for things
00:35:55.619 --> 00:36:02.119
like Doritos and the various sugary beverages.
00:36:02.179 --> 00:36:03.980
I mean, it's great advertising, right? Right,
00:36:04.000 --> 00:36:05.699
right. Exactly. Because kids are glued to the
00:36:05.699 --> 00:36:13.380
video game. And so, I mean, from a public health
00:36:13.380 --> 00:36:17.449
perspective, are we seeing... At the ground level,
00:36:17.489 --> 00:36:20.409
an increase in things like childhood onset type
00:36:20.409 --> 00:36:23.250
2 diabetes. Yes, type 2 diabetes, high cholesterol
00:36:23.250 --> 00:36:25.510
levels in kids. High cholesterol in kids? Yes.
00:36:26.030 --> 00:36:29.670
High blood pressure, fatty liver related to excess
00:36:29.670 --> 00:36:32.530
calorie intake, usually coming from ultra processed
00:36:32.530 --> 00:36:34.909
foods. Is it fatty liver something that used
00:36:34.909 --> 00:36:37.210
to really just be associated with alcoholism?
00:36:37.230 --> 00:36:40.210
Yes, but they actually have changed the definitions
00:36:40.210 --> 00:36:42.449
of how we classify fatty liver. We used to call
00:36:42.449 --> 00:36:45.920
it if it was not related to alcohol intake. Because
00:36:45.920 --> 00:36:49.079
if somebody had central adiposity around their
00:36:49.079 --> 00:36:51.980
internal organs, we would call it non -alcoholic
00:36:51.980 --> 00:36:54.639
fatty liver. Now we call it metabolic -associated
00:36:54.639 --> 00:36:58.460
fatty liver because it's not related to alcohol
00:36:58.460 --> 00:37:02.280
intake. It is related to a metabolic issue from
00:37:02.280 --> 00:37:04.860
excess calorie intake, usually from excess sugar
00:37:04.860 --> 00:37:07.099
intake, ultra -processed foods. And that can
00:37:07.099 --> 00:37:09.699
be fatal. And you can get cirrhosis and other
00:37:09.699 --> 00:37:13.079
diseases. And you're seeing this in children.
00:37:13.460 --> 00:37:18.079
Yes. Okay. I think I know what your answer to
00:37:18.079 --> 00:37:21.079
this question is going to be. Are ultra -processed
00:37:21.079 --> 00:37:24.500
foods bad for us? I'm not asking your opinion.
00:37:24.699 --> 00:37:29.559
I'm asking as an industry, when it comes to nutrition
00:37:29.559 --> 00:37:32.559
science, is there a conclusion that we really
00:37:32.559 --> 00:37:35.420
shouldn't be consuming these things? There's
00:37:35.420 --> 00:37:38.099
a lot of gray area to this, right? Tell me about
00:37:38.099 --> 00:37:41.809
that. So ultra processed foods in general, they're
00:37:41.809 --> 00:37:44.670
not great for us. But in the context of a healthy
00:37:44.670 --> 00:37:49.889
diet with other things in mind, like somebody's
00:37:49.889 --> 00:37:52.510
budget, their access to food, their ability and
00:37:52.510 --> 00:37:56.650
time to prepare food and meals, ultra processed
00:37:56.650 --> 00:38:00.469
foods can have a place in a healthy diet. That
00:38:00.469 --> 00:38:02.230
doesn't mean they should take up the majority
00:38:02.230 --> 00:38:04.690
of somebody's diet. So it shouldn't be the example
00:38:04.690 --> 00:38:06.530
you just gave me where the kid has a granola
00:38:06.530 --> 00:38:10.170
bar for breakfast, a... Uncrustable for lunch
00:38:10.170 --> 00:38:13.429
and a frozen pizza for dessert. No. OK. Every
00:38:13.429 --> 00:38:16.210
day. Correct. Should not be that. We know that.
00:38:16.230 --> 00:38:18.510
Do we know that that will lead to a negative
00:38:18.510 --> 00:38:21.849
health outcome? Depending on that child's genetics,
00:38:22.090 --> 00:38:25.849
we we can surmise that, yes, it probably is not
00:38:25.849 --> 00:38:27.409
going to be great for their health. In terms
00:38:27.409 --> 00:38:30.050
of like as a lawyer, I'll speak as a lawyer since
00:38:30.050 --> 00:38:33.670
it's what I do once in a while. Is it more likely
00:38:33.670 --> 00:38:36.659
true than not? that that's going to have a negative
00:38:36.659 --> 00:38:38.460
health impact on somebody if all you consume
00:38:38.460 --> 00:38:40.320
is these ultra -processed foods. All you consume
00:38:40.320 --> 00:38:42.300
is ultra -processed foods. You lead a sedentary
00:38:42.300 --> 00:38:44.920
lifestyle. It is more likely that it is going
00:38:44.920 --> 00:38:50.239
to cause health problems, yes. Is there an opinion
00:38:50.239 --> 00:38:53.420
within the nutrition industry or nutrition science
00:38:53.420 --> 00:38:57.179
about the addictiveness of these foods? Because
00:38:57.179 --> 00:39:00.000
what the lawsuit is asserting, and I'm not claiming
00:39:00.000 --> 00:39:02.179
this is correct, okay, but what it's asserting
00:39:02.179 --> 00:39:06.389
is... that these foods have been, I'll use the
00:39:06.389 --> 00:39:11.150
word fudged in their formulation, to make them
00:39:11.150 --> 00:39:13.769
more desirable to people, to make it so that
00:39:13.769 --> 00:39:16.030
people want to consume more. There's, in fact,
00:39:16.030 --> 00:39:19.670
a study cited in the lawsuit that says these
00:39:19.670 --> 00:39:23.449
foods have been developed in such a way as to
00:39:23.449 --> 00:39:28.210
mask
or cover up a person's sensation of being
00:39:28.210 --> 00:39:31.750
full, so they eat too many of them. Is that something
00:39:31.750 --> 00:39:33.920
that's... accepted within the industry, like
00:39:33.920 --> 00:39:37.019
as true? Yeah, because a lot of these foods,
00:39:37.119 --> 00:39:41.019
you know, they're high in fats and sugars and
00:39:41.019 --> 00:39:43.780
salts, right? All of those things, fat, sugar,
00:39:43.840 --> 00:39:47.239
salt, all taste good, right? They are also very
00:39:47.239 --> 00:39:50.119
low. Sounds like my lunch. Don't tell me what
00:39:50.119 --> 00:39:53.699
you ate. You would want to know. And they're
00:39:53.699 --> 00:39:56.659
also, these foods are largely low in fiber. Fiber
00:39:56.659 --> 00:39:59.840
adds to satiety. So when these foods, they taste
00:39:59.840 --> 00:40:01.800
really good. Most of them, you know, they're
00:40:01.800 --> 00:40:04.880
soft. They're easy to eat. They get broken down
00:40:04.880 --> 00:40:07.599
and digested and absorbed really fast. And so,
00:40:07.619 --> 00:40:11.440
yeah, the satiety factor really goes down. They're
00:40:11.440 --> 00:40:14.619
easy to eat a lot of. So, yes, it's easy to overdo.
00:40:14.880 --> 00:40:18.500
There's a study cited in the lawsuit where they
00:40:18.500 --> 00:40:23.920
had rats. We can all debate as a rat. a proper,
00:40:24.079 --> 00:40:26.199
well, I guess a lot of medications and other
00:40:26.199 --> 00:40:28.039
things are tested with rats to begin with. But
00:40:28.039 --> 00:40:30.900
they put an ultra -processed food with artificial
00:40:30.900 --> 00:40:34.039
sweetener on one side and methamphetamine on
00:40:34.039 --> 00:40:37.800
the other side. And the rats preferred the ultra
00:40:37.800 --> 00:40:39.719
-processed food. And what actually, what they
00:40:39.719 --> 00:40:42.239
did is they made it such that if it got the ultra
00:40:42.239 --> 00:40:44.139
-processed food, it would get an electric shock.
00:40:44.420 --> 00:40:47.159
So sort of a, hey, don't go do that. It would
00:40:47.159 --> 00:40:50.329
still go eat the ultra -processed food. With
00:40:50.329 --> 00:40:53.190
artificial sweeteners more than a methamphetamine,
00:40:53.289 --> 00:40:55.849
the authors of that study, of course, concluding
00:40:55.849 --> 00:40:59.590
that these foods can be addictive like a methamphetamine.
00:40:59.849 --> 00:41:03.750
Yeah, I think the consensus on food addiction
00:41:03.750 --> 00:41:08.250
is, there's not 100 % consensus either way. There's
00:41:08.250 --> 00:41:10.670
some evidence that some people may be more likely
00:41:10.670 --> 00:41:13.050
to become addicted to food. And there are even
00:41:13.050 --> 00:41:15.789
certain eating disorders where... That food addiction
00:41:15.789 --> 00:41:19.289
is sort of part of that. But it is hard to be
00:41:19.289 --> 00:41:22.190
addicted to something that we need for survival,
00:41:22.489 --> 00:41:25.190
right? Usually with like a drug addiction, you
00:41:25.190 --> 00:41:27.050
would treat by having the person abstain from
00:41:27.050 --> 00:41:29.210
drugs or alcohol, right? You can't really abstain
00:41:29.210 --> 00:41:32.010
from food. Can we abstain from ultra -processed
00:41:32.010 --> 00:41:37.090
foods? Yeah, potentially. The parallel that I
00:41:37.090 --> 00:41:38.969
think they're trying to draw with this San Francisco
00:41:38.969 --> 00:41:41.670
case when we compare it to the tobacco cases.
00:41:42.199 --> 00:41:44.519
is that addictive nature of the food, right?
00:41:44.579 --> 00:41:46.719
And they're trying to draw this parallel between
00:41:46.719 --> 00:41:50.960
nicotine and, be it artificial sweeteners, fats,
00:41:51.119 --> 00:41:54.219
salts, at a level that people find particularly
00:41:54.219 --> 00:41:59.320
appealing. It sounds to me like, at least within
00:41:59.320 --> 00:42:01.820
your industry, there hasn't been a conclusion
00:42:01.820 --> 00:42:05.659
yet that... OK, this is just like nicotine, right?
00:42:05.739 --> 00:42:08.239
We haven't drawn that conclusion yet. Not necessarily,
00:42:08.340 --> 00:42:10.599
because I think, like I said, there is a lot
00:42:10.599 --> 00:42:12.860
of nuance. And when especially when I counsel
00:42:12.860 --> 00:42:15.139
patients, I have to take into account not just
00:42:15.139 --> 00:42:16.940
what they're eating, but why they're eating it.
00:42:17.000 --> 00:42:18.900
You know, what goes into their food decisions
00:42:18.900 --> 00:42:21.280
or their food buying decisions? And that can
00:42:21.280 --> 00:42:23.360
be, you know, their budget and their access.
00:42:23.880 --> 00:42:26.280
And of course, you know, a lot of these foods,
00:42:26.380 --> 00:42:28.340
they are really cheap because a lot of those
00:42:28.340 --> 00:42:31.059
inputs are heavily subsidized by our government,
00:42:31.159 --> 00:42:34.730
corn and wheat. soy. So all these ultra processed
00:42:34.730 --> 00:42:37.650
foods are really cheap. And for a lot of people
00:42:37.650 --> 00:42:40.070
that drives those buying decisions. Yeah, I think
00:42:40.070 --> 00:42:45.909
I read that 70 % of all food products in your
00:42:45.909 --> 00:42:49.289
average grocery store are manufactured by one
00:42:49.289 --> 00:42:51.349
of the defendants in this case. Interesting.
00:42:51.449 --> 00:42:54.420
Yeah. That's an astounding figure when you really
00:42:54.420 --> 00:42:56.340
think of it. So what does that leave? Just the
00:42:56.340 --> 00:42:58.000
fruit and vegetable aisle and the meat aisle,
00:42:58.099 --> 00:43:01.019
basically? Right. Which, to be fair, can be very
00:43:01.019 --> 00:43:02.659
expensive for some people when they're looking
00:43:02.659 --> 00:43:06.719
at, say, a bag of Doritos, which they may get
00:43:06.719 --> 00:43:08.980
more bang for their calorie buck, so to speak,
00:43:09.119 --> 00:43:12.420
than buying a bag of apples. Right. Yeah, makes
00:43:12.420 --> 00:43:15.960
sense. Let me follow up with this. One of the
00:43:15.960 --> 00:43:19.860
phrases that I see cited in the lawsuit is that
00:43:20.230 --> 00:43:23.750
Big food, right? These defendants are putting
00:43:23.750 --> 00:43:26.969
into their product something that they call reinforcing
00:43:26.969 --> 00:43:30.949
agents, okay? With the definition of a reinforcing
00:43:30.949 --> 00:43:36.550
agent being a flavor profile, could be a sweetness
00:43:36.550 --> 00:43:41.170
or a salty profile that they have done in -depth
00:43:41.170 --> 00:43:44.809
studies to determine that this is what people
00:43:44.809 --> 00:43:46.969
will crave and make them buy more and more of
00:43:46.969 --> 00:43:49.630
it. Is that something that's accepted within
00:43:49.630 --> 00:43:51.130
the community or is that something that's still
00:43:51.130 --> 00:43:52.769
up in the air? I think that's something that's
00:43:52.769 --> 00:43:55.789
still up in the air. You know, of course, you
00:43:55.789 --> 00:43:59.110
know, that that's sort of enhancer and making
00:43:59.110 --> 00:44:01.409
things taste really good. You know, it goes back
00:44:01.409 --> 00:44:04.400
to the, you know, the corporate profit. driven
00:44:04.400 --> 00:44:08.239
market that we have in big food, right? Right.
00:44:08.340 --> 00:44:10.579
It's better to have somebody eat a sleeve of
00:44:10.579 --> 00:44:14.719
Oreos than two. Exactly. I mean, if we all practice
00:44:14.719 --> 00:44:16.980
moderation, Oreo sales are going to go down.
00:44:17.619 --> 00:44:22.380
Well, that would be devastating to me, but probably
00:44:22.380 --> 00:44:27.420
be better for my health. So, and then lastly,
00:44:27.719 --> 00:44:31.960
and I think we kind of touched on this, but is
00:44:31.960 --> 00:44:36.369
there evidence that Big food is manufacturing
00:44:36.369 --> 00:44:41.969
these food products in such a way that it bypasses
00:44:41.969 --> 00:44:44.570
the signals our bodies send to us to tell us
00:44:44.570 --> 00:44:46.820
we're full. Because that's a big component of
00:44:46.820 --> 00:44:48.579
the case. Yeah. So when we look at the ultra
00:44:48.579 --> 00:44:50.659
-precious foods and what is in them, the sugar,
00:44:50.760 --> 00:44:52.619
the fat, the salt, we also have to look at what's
00:44:52.619 --> 00:44:55.400
not in them. You know, fiber, vitamins, minerals,
00:44:55.699 --> 00:44:57.360
you know, for a lot of these foods, protein,
00:44:57.639 --> 00:45:00.500
you know, fiber and protein make foods more satiating.
00:45:01.219 --> 00:45:03.360
Meaning I feel full. You feel full. And I stop
00:45:03.360 --> 00:45:05.920
eating. Exactly. Okay. Yeah. So without those
00:45:05.920 --> 00:45:08.820
things, without fiber, without protein, say in...
00:45:09.269 --> 00:45:11.829
Doritos or Oreos. I'm sorry that we're not I'm
00:45:11.829 --> 00:45:15.190
not trying to pick on those foods. But but without
00:45:15.190 --> 00:45:18.949
that, yeah, it is easy to overconsume. So somebody
00:45:18.949 --> 00:45:21.650
told me one time it's like, OK, sit down and
00:45:21.650 --> 00:45:25.690
eat four eggs. OK, and then sit down and try
00:45:25.690 --> 00:45:28.090
to eat the same number of calories in something
00:45:28.090 --> 00:45:30.690
like Oreos and see what you're more full with.
00:45:30.789 --> 00:45:33.650
Yeah. And it's like you will continue to eat
00:45:33.650 --> 00:45:36.500
those Oreos. Right. where the fifth egg is probably
00:45:36.500 --> 00:45:38.920
unnecessary in most cases. Sure, and it's that
00:45:38.920 --> 00:45:42.960
satiety factor. And yes, a lot of that sugar,
00:45:43.019 --> 00:45:45.099
salt, fat, it's hitting pleasure centers in our
00:45:45.099 --> 00:45:47.900
brain that drive us to want to eat. And then
00:45:47.900 --> 00:45:49.539
we have to think about the context in which we're
00:45:49.539 --> 00:45:52.320
eating these foods, right? Are we eating them
00:45:52.320 --> 00:45:56.219
with a nice, healthy, maybe a sandwich or a salad?
00:45:56.579 --> 00:45:58.920
Or are we eating them maybe while we're watching
00:45:58.920 --> 00:46:01.739
TV or while we're doing some work or we're not
00:46:01.739 --> 00:46:04.199
really paying attention to how much we're eating?
00:46:04.170 --> 00:46:06.710
eating. And, you know, before we know it, the
00:46:06.710 --> 00:46:09.590
sleeve of cookies is gone. Yeah, well, I would
00:46:09.590 --> 00:46:12.030
just tell you personally, it's me standing at
00:46:12.030 --> 00:46:15.809
the kitchen counter and you can't stop. I mean,
00:46:15.829 --> 00:46:18.530
I defy you. Eat one Oreo. You're a better person
00:46:18.530 --> 00:46:23.110
than I am. So to sum things up, it sounds like
00:46:23.110 --> 00:46:27.510
the claims made in this lawsuit have some basis
00:46:27.510 --> 00:46:29.769
in fact. But a lot of these things are still
00:46:29.769 --> 00:46:31.750
kind of up in the air. Sure. Yeah. I mean, we
00:46:31.750 --> 00:46:34.010
know that ultra processed foods that are high
00:46:34.010 --> 00:46:37.389
in fats, particularly saturated fat, added sugars,
00:46:37.489 --> 00:46:40.150
added salts are not good for our health in the
00:46:40.150 --> 00:46:43.710
long term when consumed in excess. There was
00:46:43.710 --> 00:46:46.369
an interesting parallel also that was drawn between
00:46:46.369 --> 00:46:49.329
the tobacco cases and this ultra processed food
00:46:49.329 --> 00:46:52.889
case, at least in my mind. OK. And that is that
00:46:52.889 --> 00:46:55.610
a lot of these ultra processed food manufacturers
00:46:55.610 --> 00:46:58.869
really have their roots. in being owned by the
00:46:58.869 --> 00:47:01.650
tobacco company. That is interesting. Yeah. I
00:47:01.650 --> 00:47:04.670
mean, like R .J. Reynolds, they were the first
00:47:04.670 --> 00:47:06.230
one to get in the business. This is like in the
00:47:06.230 --> 00:47:09.170
1960s, if I recall correctly. They bought Hawaiian
00:47:09.170 -->
00:47:12.590
Punch, okay? And it was around that time that
00:47:12.590 --> 00:47:15.670
they said, listen, we know flavor. Like, because
00:47:15.670 --> 00:47:18.590
we have all these flavor scientists that work
00:47:18.590 --> 00:47:21.739
on concocting our cigarettes. We know flavor.
00:47:21.940 --> 00:47:25.300
And so they quickly realized that they could
00:47:25.300 --> 00:47:27.780
profit in the food industry by being experts
00:47:27.780 --> 00:47:29.699
in flavor. So it started with Hawaiian punch.
00:47:30.199 --> 00:47:33.739
I think Kool -Aid came next. And then it was,
00:47:33.760 --> 00:47:37.420
you know, Kraft was eventually bought by one
00:47:37.420 --> 00:47:42.019
of the big tobacco companies. And a lot of these
00:47:42.019 --> 00:47:44.980
processed food manufacturers were at one point
00:47:44.980 --> 00:47:49.099
in time owned by big tobacco. And I don't know.
00:47:49.099 --> 00:47:53.639
I find that interesting. Um, from a nutrition
00:47:53.639 --> 00:47:58.539
standpoint, um, this, this concept of modifying
00:47:58.539 --> 00:48:01.820
flavor to make it more appealing. Okay. I know
00:48:01.820 --> 00:48:06.340
we've talked about salt, fat, sugar, right? But
00:48:06.340 --> 00:48:09.320
other flavors by modifying those flavors to make
00:48:09.320 --> 00:48:11.099
them more appealing. Is there any science in
00:48:11.099 --> 00:48:16.409
that area? There is. Um, and I think there. You
00:48:16.409 --> 00:48:19.710
know, we can find research to show us many different
00:48:19.710 --> 00:48:23.469
conclusions. Artificial flavors, you know, whether
00:48:23.469 --> 00:48:26.230
or not they increase that bliss point, so to
00:48:26.230 --> 00:48:30.210
speak. Sure, they might. But I think the jury's
00:48:30.210 --> 00:48:34.670
still out on their impacts on health. I think
00:48:34.670 --> 00:48:37.730
we're looking more at the sugar, salt, fat contents
00:48:37.730 --> 00:48:40.449
because that is a little bit more conclusive
00:48:40.449 --> 00:48:44.150
as to the chronic disease risk. What about...
00:48:44.960 --> 00:48:46.619
artificial colors? Because that's been in the
00:48:46.619 --> 00:48:48.579
news a lot lately. Yeah, that's pretty debated.
00:48:49.480 --> 00:48:53.239
The general consensus, at least among nutrition
00:48:53.239 --> 00:48:56.400
professionals, is that, of course, we find artificial
00:48:56.400 --> 00:48:59.659
colors in ultra -processed foods, right? If we
00:48:59.659 --> 00:49:03.070
take them out and replace them with plant -derived
00:49:03.070 --> 00:49:07.389
or more naturally derived colors, it's still
00:49:07.389 --> 00:49:09.710
an ultra -processed food. It's not changing the
00:49:09.710 --> 00:49:12.389
nutritional profile with regard to the sugar,
00:49:12.489 --> 00:49:16.610
salt, and fat. There are some people, some children
00:49:16.610 --> 00:49:18.469
in particular, that might be more sensitive to
00:49:18.469 --> 00:49:21.630
those artificial colors and may have behavior
00:49:21.630 --> 00:49:26.489
changes when they eat them. So those individuals
00:49:26.489 --> 00:49:30.349
should avoid them. But generally speaking, Getting
00:49:30.349 --> 00:49:33.050
rid of artificial colors is not really going
00:49:33.050 --> 00:49:35.449
to change the health profile of a food. That's
00:49:35.449 --> 00:49:38.170
interesting because I was reading that there's
00:49:38.170 --> 00:49:40.670
been a big debate over Skittles. In fact, I think
00:49:40.670 --> 00:49:42.929
I've even heard politicians directly talk about
00:49:42.929 --> 00:49:45.570
Skittles in the last couple of years and the
00:49:45.570 --> 00:49:48.489
various artificial colors they're using in Skittles.
00:49:51.179 --> 00:49:53.519
chemicals used, I guess, to have manufacture
00:49:53.519 --> 00:49:56.519
a Skittle is titanium dioxide. It's what makes
00:49:56.519 --> 00:49:58.920
the inside of the Skittle white, which allows
00:49:58.920 --> 00:50:00.900
them to apply the color coding over the top.
00:50:01.420 --> 00:50:06.079
And Mars Candy Corporation voluntarily pulled
00:50:06.079 --> 00:50:07.800
that out of the product for a very short period
00:50:07.800 --> 00:50:09.960
of time. Then they put it right back in. Probably
00:50:09.960 --> 00:50:12.280
because sales went down. Probably. And now they're
00:50:12.280 --> 00:50:14.500
pulling it out again. And I think the issue,
00:50:14.639 --> 00:50:17.599
if I understand correctly, is that the actual
00:50:17.599 --> 00:50:21.280
candy looks more dull in color. People don't
00:50:21.280 --> 00:50:23.440
want it. They don't want it. And there have been
00:50:23.440 --> 00:50:28.019
attempts in the past by – I can't remember if
00:50:28.019 --> 00:50:32.380
it was Fruit Loops changed their artificial colors
00:50:32.380 --> 00:50:35.699
and they went to a more natural color. It was
00:50:35.699 --> 00:50:38.840
not as vibrant, a little more dull. Consumers
00:50:38.840 --> 00:50:44.380
didn't like it. So it's tricky because food manufacturers
00:50:44.380 --> 00:50:47.360
are responding to consumer demand to some degree.
00:50:48.250 --> 00:50:50.469
I thank you very much for coming on. Thanks for
00:50:50.469 --> 00:50:52.170
having me. We really appreciate it. And your
00:50:52.170 --> 00:50:55.570
expertise lends itself to us better understanding
00:50:55.570 --> 00:51:00.170
not just the lawsuit, but what processed foods
00:51:00.170 --> 00:51:02.309
are and how they impact our health. And so thank
00:51:02.309 --> 00:51:05.110
you very much. You're welcome. Well, Chris, you
00:51:05.110 --> 00:51:07.969
know, Nicole, I think, interestingly enough,
00:51:08.230 --> 00:51:11.210
you know, here we have a nutritionist and she's
00:51:11.210 --> 00:51:14.469
not completely against ultra processed food.
00:51:14.530 --> 00:51:16.650
I mean, I think that what I took from that is.
00:51:17.280 --> 00:51:19.360
Yes, in excessive amounts, these things are bad
00:51:19.360 --> 00:51:20.900
for
you. It's like that old saying, right? All
00:51:20.900 --> 00:51:22.480
is good and everything's okay in moderation.
00:51:22.880 --> 00:51:25.280
I kind of live by that. So you can continue to
00:51:25.280 --> 00:51:27.760
have the Doritos. And my Oreos, which is not
00:51:27.760 --> 00:51:30.500
a sleeve. But I think the point in the lawsuit,
00:51:30.659 --> 00:51:36.280
to kind of bring this full circle, is that it's
00:51:36.280 --> 00:51:39.420
not about eating an ultra -processed food once
00:51:39.420 --> 00:51:42.480
in a while or even in moderation, right? It's
00:51:42.480 --> 00:51:45.099
about, at least the allegations and the complaint
00:51:45.099 --> 00:51:49.199
are, These products are made in such a way as
00:51:49.199 --> 00:51:55.460
to encourage people, addict people to eat excessive
00:51:55.460 --> 00:51:58.760
amounts. Yeah, that's exactly right. And they
00:51:58.760 --> 00:52:00.500
tied it back to the tobacco company, right? And
00:52:00.500 --> 00:52:04.000
said that Big Food is using the exact same playbook
00:52:04.000 --> 00:52:07.780
that the tobacco companies used in order to create
00:52:07.780 --> 00:52:10.840
the addiction to tobacco products. Yeah, yeah.
00:52:10.920 --> 00:52:12.940
So that's what the lawsuit says. So I think it's
00:52:12.940 --> 00:52:14.820
important. Let's just kind of sum this up if
00:52:14.820 --> 00:52:17.730
we can. Here are the claims in the case, right?
00:52:17.769 --> 00:52:20.150
The actual causes of action mean what are the
00:52:20.150 --> 00:52:22.969
basis upon which the lawsuit's been filed? The
00:52:22.969 --> 00:52:26.030
first is violation of unfair competition law,
00:52:26.130 --> 00:52:29.789
right? Yeah, B &P Code Section 17200. That's
00:52:29.789 --> 00:52:32.389
it. Yeah, right. It goes on. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:52:32.550 --> 00:52:37.590
And so the theory there is that... The defendants
00:52:37.590 --> 00:52:40.269
in the case, these big food, as we've been calling
00:52:40.269 --> 00:52:43.150
them, used unfair, fraudulent or deceptive practices
00:52:43.150 --> 00:52:45.170
that they knew the food they were selling is
00:52:45.170 --> 00:52:47.630
harmful to people, even as they claimed it was
00:52:47.630 --> 00:52:50.230
safe and healthy. Right. Period. Right. What
00:52:50.230 --> 00:52:52.610
makes that claim easy and what I think is pretty
00:52:52.610 --> 00:52:55.550
brilliant on the city of San Francisco's part
00:52:55.550 --> 00:52:59.690
is they do not have to prove causation, meaning
00:52:59.690 --> 00:53:02.929
they don't have to prove that consuming those
00:53:02.929 --> 00:53:07.099
foods caused some. person or a population of
00:53:07.099 --> 00:53:10.239
people to develop a certain disease. Is that
00:53:10.239 --> 00:53:11.619
your read of it? Yeah, I mean, right. They just
00:53:11.619 --> 00:53:14.639
have to demonstrate that they use these deceptive
00:53:14.639 --> 00:53:18.360
business practices to sell the product. The second
00:53:18.360 --> 00:53:20.380
claim, public nuisance. Now, this is a little
00:53:20.380 --> 00:53:23.599
strange, right? I'd wrap my head around this
00:53:23.599 --> 00:53:25.320
one a little bit, because when we think of nuisance
00:53:25.320 --> 00:53:28.059
law, I always think of, you know, my neighbor.
00:53:29.710 --> 00:53:32.110
Has a dog that won't stop barking? Well, there's
00:53:32.110 --> 00:53:36.030
the classic example, right? Or in a more public
00:53:36.030 --> 00:53:40.170
nuisance sense, somebody comes and builds an
00:53:40.170 --> 00:53:43.389
industrial plant next to a neighborhood, and
00:53:43.389 --> 00:53:45.690
now the neighborhood's inundated with smells
00:53:45.690 --> 00:53:48.090
and odors and gases from this industrial plant.
00:53:48.289 --> 00:53:51.690
That's a public nuisance, right? And we've got
00:53:51.690 --> 00:53:53.690
a whole body of law that has developed around
00:53:53.690 --> 00:53:57.030
that. This is a little different. They're claiming
00:53:57.030 --> 00:54:04.769
that... that the sale and the marketing of these
00:54:04.769 --> 00:54:07.989
ultra -processed foods is a nuisance to the people
00:54:07.989 --> 00:54:11.949
of the state of California. Yeah, listen, I think
00:54:11.949 --> 00:54:15.550
it's creative, undoubtedly. And we talked about
00:54:15.550 --> 00:54:18.289
this before we got started. I kind of foresee
00:54:18.289 --> 00:54:20.849
that being the real challenge to their lawsuit.
00:54:20.869 --> 00:54:24.760
I think that particular cause of action. is going
00:54:24.760 --> 00:54:27.280
to be a difficult one for the city. I think it
00:54:27.280 --> 00:54:31.019
will be attacked and undergo scrutiny at the
00:54:31.019 --> 00:54:33.260
pleading stage where they just attack the allegations
00:54:33.260 --> 00:54:35.139
and the complaint. You know, before there's any
00:54:35.139 --> 00:54:36.739
testimony, there's no witnesses that are going
00:54:36.739 --> 00:54:39.880
to testify. He just attacked the complaint as
00:54:39.880 --> 00:54:42.400
a whole. Well, and unlike the unfair competition
00:54:42.400 --> 00:54:46.619
claim, the nuisance claim does require a show
00:54:46.619 --> 00:54:48.199
of conscience. Yeah, right. And I think that's
00:54:48.199 --> 00:54:49.880
going to be a big hurdle for them to get over.
00:54:49.980 --> 00:54:51.500
Right. I mean, look, I'm just thinking of the
00:54:51.500 --> 00:54:55.059
defenses. OK, so first of all, we know they're
00:54:55.059 --> 00:54:56.820
going to attack the pleadings. So Big Food's
00:54:56.820 --> 00:54:58.119
going to attack the pleadings. They'll be either
00:54:58.119 --> 00:55:01.320
a motion to strike, demur, you know, something
00:55:01.320 --> 00:55:03.139
to try to just throw the case out immediately.
00:55:04.059 --> 00:55:06.300
Assuming the city gets past that, I see a motion
00:55:06.300 --> 00:55:08.619
for summary judgment, dispositive motion at some
00:55:08.619 --> 00:55:11.559
point down the
road. Right. Assuming the city
00:55:11.559 --> 00:55:16.980
gets past that, then I see, look, we're just
00:55:16.980 --> 00:55:19.969
following the law. The FDA doesn't outlaw any
00:55:19.969 --> 00:55:22.650
of this stuff. They don't tell us we can't sell
00:55:22.650 --> 00:55:24.730
these things. They're the arbiter of what's safe.
00:55:25.409 --> 00:55:28.730
But we saw that, didn't we? In the tobacco cases.
00:55:28.949 --> 00:55:31.250
I mean, those were the same defenses that the
00:55:31.250 --> 00:55:33.570
tobacco cases or the tobacco industry asserted.
00:55:33.650 --> 00:55:36.110
But I suspect we're going to see those same defenses.
00:55:36.130 --> 00:55:39.610
Absolutely. I think that when it comes to the
00:55:39.610 --> 00:55:42.349
nuisance claim where they've got to prove causation,
00:55:42.530 --> 00:55:45.710
I think what we're going to see is arguments
00:55:45.710 --> 00:55:50.030
that, look, you can't. scientifically prove that
00:55:50.030 --> 00:55:54.110
our product consumed at these levels, whatever
00:55:54.110 --> 00:55:56.210
it may be, and that'll be a fight in and of itself,
00:55:56.449 --> 00:55:59.650
you know, is the reason that people develop diabetes
00:55:59.650 --> 00:56:02.030
and cancers and all these other things. You mean
00:56:02.030 --> 00:56:03.949
it has nothing to do with like sedentary lifestyle
00:56:03.949 --> 00:56:05.789
like Nicole was talking about, right? I mean,
00:56:05.809 --> 00:56:07.710
look at the kids nowadays. Or genetics. Yeah,
00:56:07.730 --> 00:56:10.860
genetics, kids. Not going outside and having
00:56:10.860 --> 00:56:13.079
a good time playing, riding bikes, scooters,
00:56:13.099 --> 00:56:15.099
they're behind. Stress, lack of physical activity,
00:56:15.300 --> 00:56:17.960
all of those things are also factors. So I assume
00:56:17.960 --> 00:56:21.679
they're going to rely on that. Lots of money
00:56:21.679 --> 00:56:23.820
could be at stake in this thing, though. Well,
00:56:23.860 --> 00:56:25.780
if you look at what the tobacco industry paid
00:56:25.780 --> 00:56:27.719
off, billions. I mean, hundreds of billions.
00:56:28.780 --> 00:56:31.860
Yeah. I mean, look, if the city wins, right?
00:56:31.960 --> 00:56:34.340
So if this thing goes all the way through to
00:56:34.340 --> 00:56:37.360
a trial and the city wins, I mean, I think you
00:56:37.360 --> 00:56:39.340
could see. Certainly you could see an injunction
00:56:39.340 --> 00:56:42.780
against the deceptive marketing, right? You know,
00:56:42.780 --> 00:56:45.039
they'll no longer be able to tell you that Cheerios
00:56:45.039 --> 00:56:47.639
are healthy, I assume would be one of the claims.
00:56:48.300 --> 00:56:50.619
I assume there'd be new warnings put on these
00:56:50.619 --> 00:56:55.599
products. I think you could see some type of
00:56:55.599 --> 00:56:58.739
an injunction as to the formulation of these
00:56:58.739 --> 00:57:01.380
ultra -processed foods to the extent that they
00:57:01.380 --> 00:57:06.289
not be as... or they don't cause people to just
00:57:06.289 --> 00:57:08.849
sort of endlessly consume them. Right. I could
00:57:08.849 --> 00:57:11.309
see all those things happen in a win. And then
00:57:11.309 --> 00:57:16.630
on the nuisance claim, there could be major damages.
00:57:17.329 --> 00:57:19.530
Well, I think there could be major damages and
00:57:19.530 --> 00:57:21.610
they're not really damages. The civil penalties
00:57:21.610 --> 00:57:25.050
under the unfair business practices claim. Right.
00:57:25.070 --> 00:57:28.739
What we looked at it today was. $2 ,500 per violation.
00:57:28.900 --> 00:57:31.260
And so I don't know, what would a violation here
00:57:31.260 --> 00:57:34.099
be? For sale, like Doritos? Would it be per sale,
00:57:34.139 --> 00:57:37.500
per package, per chip, like per advertisement,
00:57:37.699 --> 00:57:40.980
all of those things? Yeah, yeah. I mean, it would
00:57:40.980 --> 00:57:43.900
be very interesting if, because one of the other
00:57:43.900 --> 00:57:48.820
things that they could win, right, is actual
00:57:48.820 --> 00:57:52.250
abatement, meaning. hey, the state of California
00:57:52.250 --> 00:57:55.329
has had to expend X amount of dollars in Medicaid
00:57:55.329 --> 00:57:59.130
money, for example, Medi -Cal in our state, to
00:57:59.130 --> 00:58:02.650
treat people who have developed disorders related
00:58:02.650 --> 00:58:05.570
to their consumption of ultra -processed foods.
00:58:05.750 --> 00:58:08.110
We want that money back. That's no different
00:58:08.110 --> 00:58:11.630
than what the tobacco industry did. They had
00:58:11.630 --> 00:58:15.289
to pay for what states were spending on, frankly,
00:58:15.389 --> 00:58:17.710
treating people for things like lung cancer and
00:58:17.710 --> 00:58:21.579
emphysema and stuff like that. Under that circumstance,
00:58:21.920 --> 00:58:24.239
we're talking about billions and billions and
00:58:24.239 --> 00:58:28.639
billions of dollars. I saw at one point the cost
00:58:28.639 --> 00:58:32.780
to abate the public nuisance for one year in
00:58:32.780 --> 00:58:37.940
California is $30 billion. For one year, just
00:58:37.940 --> 00:58:40.699
in California. So you could imagine what the
00:58:40.699 --> 00:58:42.300
cost would be if this catches on nationwide.
00:58:42.780 --> 00:58:47.980
So to sum things up, right, we... decided to
00:58:47.980 --> 00:58:51.280
talk about this today because this is an interesting
00:58:51.280 --> 00:58:53.940
case. It's something that's unusual. And because
00:58:53.940 --> 00:58:57.039
this is the first case of its kind filed in the
00:58:57.039 --> 00:59:00.139
country, it's really a bellwether case. That's
00:59:00.139 --> 00:59:02.659
what we talk about in our industry. Meaning if
00:59:02.659 --> 00:59:06.139
this case is successful, you could end up seeing
00:59:06.139 --> 00:59:09.860
every other state follow suit in time, right?
00:59:09.940 -->
00:59:11.480
Which is exactly what happened in the Tibetan
00:59:11.480 --> 00:59:15.039
cases. And so it's an interesting case. I don't
00:59:15.039 --> 00:59:17.019
know that they're going to succeed. I frankly
00:59:17.019 --> 00:59:20.000
think they probably have a bit of an uphill battle.
00:59:20.659 --> 00:59:24.000
They have corporate interests with billions and
00:59:24.000 --> 00:59:25.800
billions and billions and billions of dollars
00:59:25.800 --> 00:59:30.139
at stake. So I suspect, you know, there will
00:59:30.139 --> 00:59:33.420
be, this is like a full employment act for some
00:59:33.420 --> 00:59:35.880
defense attorneys for the coming years, right?
00:59:36.079 --> 00:59:38.500
Yeah, listen, and I mean, look at it as compared
00:59:38.500 --> 00:59:42.239
to the big tobacco litigation, right? The number
00:59:42.239 --> 00:59:44.960
of defendants in this case, I think, pales in
00:59:44.960 --> 00:59:47.460
comparison to the number of defendants in the
00:59:47.460 --> 00:59:51.400
tobacco cases. And so, listen, the city attorney
00:59:51.400 --> 00:59:54.619
has his work cut out for him. Yeah, yeah. And
00:59:54.619 --> 00:59:56.980
I think, again, you know, we've talked about
00:59:56.980 --> 00:59:59.900
this parallel with the tobacco cases throughout
00:59:59.900 --> 01:00:04.079
this podcast, but look at how long it took those
01:00:04.079 --> 01:00:07.019
tobacco cases to ultimately change things, right?
01:00:07.139 --> 01:00:09.800
You're looking at somewhere in the realm of 40
01:00:09.800 --> 01:00:13.329
years. 40 plus years. You and I may be retired
01:00:13.329 --> 01:00:18.010
by the time this is totally done. We can be retired
01:00:18.010 --> 01:00:20.849
before this single case is done, right? I mean,
01:00:20.849 --> 01:00:23.409
that's how long these things can take. But for
01:00:23.409 --> 01:00:26.289
the whole, you know, if this were to go the whole
01:00:26.289 --> 01:00:28.170
road of the tobacco cases, you're going to have
01:00:28.170 --> 01:00:30.789
all 50 states involved. Yeah, you're looking
01:00:30.789 --> 01:00:33.869
at potentially decades before that were to happen.
01:00:33.989 --> 01:00:37.039
By the way, we're not going anywhere soon. Oh,
01:00:37.059 --> 01:00:39.940
I hope not. Yeah, well, I hope not. I'll tell
01:00:39.940 --> 01:00:41.360
you what I am going to do, though. When we're
01:00:41.360 --> 01:00:43.079
done with this today, I'm going to go home and
01:00:43.079 --> 01:00:45.380
I'm going to use a sleeve of Oreos. Milk or no
01:00:45.380 --> 01:00:47.940
milk? Oh, I'm a milk guy. Yeah. I'm not an Oreo
01:00:47.940 --> 01:00:50.119
guy. I'm a milk guy. And I'm not a milk guy either.
01:00:50.340 --> 01:00:53.179
I'm the worst of the worst. I am an Oreos and
01:00:53.179 --> 01:00:57.380
a whole milk guy. So, well, I'm glad Nicole has
01:00:57.380 --> 01:00:59.679
left. Otherwise, she'd be very disappointed to
01:00:59.679 --> 01:01:02.219
hear that. Wait, wasn't her husband your friend,
01:01:02.340 --> 01:01:04.880
your childhood friend that, didn't you guys think?
01:01:05.210 --> 01:01:08.210
catch a uh like a vacant lot on fire oh you gotta
01:01:08.210 --> 01:01:13.010
bring that out yes we did yes we did but doesn't
01:01:13.010 --> 01:01:14.949
that you ran so we're good that you ran a long
01:01:14.949 --> 01:01:17.429
time ago uh he's not gonna be happy that you
01:01:17.429 --> 01:01:20.690
brought that up um he may still have trauma from
01:01:20.690 --> 01:01:22.409
that event i think i still have trauma from that
01:01:22.409 --> 01:01:27.110
event um so uh with that said Thank you all for
01:01:27.110 --> 01:01:30.130
watching. We appreciate it. Again, this is Kern
01:01:30.130 --> 01:01:33.429
Case by Case presented by Chain Cone Clark. If
01:01:33.429 --> 01:01:35.969
any of you have any comments, questions, things
01:01:35.969 --> 01:01:37.869
that you'd like us to bring up on a future episode,
01:01:37.949 --> 01:01:40.050
please comment. We really appreciate the feedback
01:01:40.050 --> 01:01:42.570
and we'll see you on the next one. Thanks, everybody.
01:01:42.750 --> 01:01:43.130
Take care.