สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.330 --> 00:00:04.230
Support for TVW podcasts provided by the Washington State Association
2
00:00:04.269 --> 00:00:09.039
of Counties and the Washington Indian Gaming Association. This week
3
00:00:09.179 --> 00:00:12.779
on Inside Olympia, we debate the constitutionality of Washington's new
4
00:00:12.880 --> 00:00:15.820
tax on people making more than a million dollars a year.
5
00:00:15.839 --> 00:00:18.780
It's on the ballot. It's also likely to end up
6
00:00:18.820 --> 00:00:22.089
before the courts. On the program, Jackson Maynard, Executive Director
7
00:00:22.190 --> 00:00:25.390
and Counsel for the Olympia-based Citizen Action Defense Fund, and
8
00:00:25.469 --> 00:00:33.289
Paul Lawrence of Pacifica Law Group in Seattle. From the
9
00:00:33.329 --> 00:00:42.009
TVW studio, it's Inside Olympia with host Austin Jenkins. Welcome
10
00:00:42.030 --> 00:00:45.469
to Inside Olympia. This November, Washington voters will decide whether
11
00:00:45.509 --> 00:00:48.380
to keep or reject the new income tax on people
12
00:00:48.420 --> 00:00:51.240
making more than a million dollars a year. But there
13
00:00:51.280 --> 00:00:54.259
is a parallel legal effort to overturn the tax on
14
00:00:54.340 --> 00:00:57.920
constitutional grounds. Opponents want the Supreme Court to find that
15
00:00:57.960 --> 00:01:01.579
the tax violates an existing ban on graduated income taxes
16
00:01:02.000 --> 00:01:05.079
in the state. Supporters hope the court will revisit its
17
00:01:05.079 --> 00:01:08.959
1933 decision that ruled income as a form of property
18
00:01:09.040 --> 00:01:12.000
subject to a uniform rate. This hour, we are going
19
00:01:12.040 --> 00:01:14.939
to dig into the legal and constitutional arguments on either
20
00:01:14.980 --> 00:01:18.280
side of this case. Joining me now is Jackson Maynard,
21
00:01:18.340 --> 00:01:22.659
executive director and counsel for the Olympia-based Citizen Action Defense Fund,
22
00:01:22.700 --> 00:01:26.680
which is helping to finance the legal challenge, and attorney
23
00:01:26.780 --> 00:01:30.250
Paul Lawrence of Pacifica Law Group in Seattle, who supports
24
00:01:30.280 --> 00:01:32.950
the tax, and was an intervener in a previous case
25
00:01:32.989 --> 00:01:35.760
that upheld Washington's capital gains tax. Welcome, both of you,
26
00:01:35.769 --> 00:01:37.609
to Inside Olympia. Thank you. Thank you, Austin. This should
27
00:01:37.629 --> 00:01:40.450
be an interesting hour and interesting debate. Before we begin,
28
00:01:40.489 --> 00:01:43.510
some background on this tax and the legal fight. The
29
00:01:43.549 --> 00:01:46.590
tax in question is a 9.9% tax on income above
30
00:01:46.590 --> 00:01:51.109
$ 1 million. It is estimated that around 25,000 Washington households
31
00:01:51.209 --> 00:01:52.930
would pay the tax and that it would bring in
32
00:01:53.090 --> 00:01:57.659
around $ 3. 5 billion per year. The Supreme Court precedent in
33
00:01:57.719 --> 00:02:00.780
question is the 1933 Culleton case, in which a divided
34
00:02:00.840 --> 00:02:03.599
Supreme Court found that income is a form of property.
35
00:02:04.239 --> 00:02:07.260
Article 7 of the state constitution says property means everything,
36
00:02:07.620 --> 00:02:11.650
whether tangible or intangible, subject to ownership. Article 7 also
37
00:02:11.659 --> 00:02:14.810
says taxes shall be uniform upon the same class of property.
38
00:02:15.349 --> 00:02:18.710
Was that decision sound or flawed? That is a key
39
00:02:18.729 --> 00:02:21.530
question in this case. First, a trial judge will rule
40
00:02:21.569 --> 00:02:23.789
on the constitutionality of the law. That could happen on
41
00:02:23.830 --> 00:02:26.810
summary judgment without a trial. And from there, the losing
42
00:02:26.849 --> 00:02:29.280
side could appeal to the Supreme Court, which has the
43
00:02:29.289 --> 00:02:33.879
power to revisit past precedent. It's a high wire act
44
00:02:33.919 --> 00:02:38.340
for a non-attorney to be explaining legal matters with a
45
00:02:38.360 --> 00:02:39.840
couple of attorneys at the same table. So you can
46
00:02:39.860 --> 00:02:41.919
correct me if I got anything wrong or a little
47
00:02:41.939 --> 00:02:44.500
bit off there. But let's start just by sort of
48
00:02:44.539 --> 00:02:47.120
setting the table for who each of you is and
49
00:02:47.159 --> 00:02:49.860
why you're here speaking on this topic. And I'll start
50
00:02:50.379 --> 00:02:55.180
with you, Jackson. the Citizen Action Defense Fund, what it is,
51
00:02:55.319 --> 00:02:57.180
what role you have in this litigation.
52
00:02:57.580 --> 00:02:57.860
Sure.
53
00:02:58.000 --> 00:03:00.860
The Citizen Action Defense Fund is a legal nonprofit. We've
54
00:03:00.879 --> 00:03:05.759
been around since 2020, and we are champions for hope
55
00:03:05.819 --> 00:03:10.000
and accountability. We fight for constitutional government. We fight to
56
00:03:10.039 --> 00:03:12.199
make sure that the government plays by the rules like
57
00:03:12.259 --> 00:03:15.159
everybody else. So that's kind of our core mission. We
58
00:03:15.199 --> 00:03:17.979
have a number of cases pending in addition to the
59
00:03:18.039 --> 00:03:23.090
income tax involving constitutional issues and Public Records Act violations
60
00:03:23.150 --> 00:03:23.710
by the government.
61
00:03:23.889 --> 00:03:25.930
And as it relates to this specific case, who are
62
00:03:25.949 --> 00:03:28.050
the players, who are the actors, who are the plaintiffs?
63
00:03:28.689 --> 00:03:29.889
What's the role of your organization?
64
00:03:30.009 --> 00:03:33.659
We're really incredibly proud of our plaintiffs. We have some
65
00:03:33.689 --> 00:03:37.960
individual plaintiffs that are farmers. We have a builder.
66
00:03:37.979 --> 00:03:38.939
We have a trucker.
67
00:03:39.379 --> 00:03:41.979
These are folks that work their fingers to the bone
68
00:03:42.020 --> 00:03:45.699
to take
Load full transcript
care of their families and their businesses. We
69
00:03:45.780 --> 00:03:49.960
also have large and small business associations throughout the state
70
00:03:50.020 --> 00:03:53.379
representing a cross-sectioned of industries that are affected. We have
71
00:03:53.400 --> 00:03:57.020
the Building Industry Association of Washington, which is the largest
72
00:03:57.120 --> 00:04:01.819
business association in the state. We have the Yakima Klickitat
73
00:04:01.879 --> 00:04:05.719
Farm Association for all the farmers that are affected. And
74
00:04:05.759 --> 00:04:10.930
we have the National Federation of Independent Businesses representing over 6,000 businesses.
75
00:04:11.560 --> 00:04:14.009
And one of the other groups that we're most proud
76
00:04:14.090 --> 00:04:16.389
of to be associated with this effort is the Ethnic
77
00:04:16.410 --> 00:04:20.310
Chamber of Commerce Coalition. Their membership, a lot of them
78
00:04:20.490 --> 00:04:24.610
are folks that came to this country to pursue the
79
00:04:24.629 --> 00:04:27.449
American dream, build their businesses. They wanted to be able,
80
00:04:27.850 --> 00:04:30.769
after a lifetime, to pass those businesses on to their children,
81
00:04:30.870 --> 00:04:32.129
and this tax threatens that.
82
00:04:32.490 --> 00:04:36.490
And then in terms of your organization, you have retained
83
00:04:37.629 --> 00:04:40.589
Rob McKenna, the former Republican attorney general, and Phil Talmadge,
84
00:04:40.730 --> 00:04:43.769
a Democrat who's a former Supreme Court justice, to be
85
00:04:43.850 --> 00:04:48.459
attorneys for... in this case, trying this case, on behalf
86
00:04:48.490 --> 00:04:49.110
of these plaintiffs.
87
00:04:49.439 --> 00:04:49.579
Correct.
88
00:04:49.610 --> 00:04:51.350
You'll also have a seat at the table, is that right?
89
00:04:51.399 --> 00:04:55.209
And then I'll also counsel representing the plaintiffs as well. So, yeah,
90
00:04:55.269 --> 00:05:01.910
it's a bipartisan effort. Phil Talmadge actually supports the income tax.
91
00:05:01.949 --> 00:05:04.189
He just thinks it should be done constitutionally through a
92
00:05:04.230 --> 00:05:07.829
constitutional amendment rather than asking the court to rewrite the
93
00:05:07.850 --> 00:05:09.069
language in the Constitution.
94
00:05:09.269 --> 00:05:11.310
I often ask this question is where is the funding
95
00:05:11.370 --> 00:05:16.079
coming to mount this effort? I know your organization does
96
00:05:16.120 --> 00:05:17.899
not disclose its donors, at least as far as I
97
00:05:17.920 --> 00:05:20.420
can tell. But I did see a donation at one
98
00:05:20.480 --> 00:05:24.160
point from Project 42, which I believe was co-founded by
99
00:05:24.199 --> 00:05:27.110
Brian Haywood, who runs Let's Go Washington, which is mounting
100
00:05:27.550 --> 00:05:31.170
the ballot challenge. So just help us understand the relationships
101
00:05:31.209 --> 00:05:32.149
and the funding, if you can.
102
00:05:32.329 --> 00:05:38.509
Our donor information, like most nonprofits... is included in our 990,
103
00:05:38.509 --> 00:05:41.990
but there's a way that you display that where the
104
00:05:42.050 --> 00:05:45.889
donors are not displayed, and that's true of most legal nonprofits.
105
00:05:46.069 --> 00:05:50.709
For instance, the Northwest Justice Project, the ACLU, you know,
106
00:05:50.810 --> 00:05:53.930
other nonprofits don't disclose their donors. That's kind of a
107
00:05:53.970 --> 00:05:57.529
constitutional right and a principle that the U.S. Supreme Court
108
00:05:57.550 --> 00:06:02.209
has upheld, and that's to not chill donations, but, you know,
109
00:06:02.329 --> 00:06:05.009
I have said publicly we have been overwhelmed since we've
110
00:06:06.060 --> 00:06:11.629
announced this case with small donations throughout the state. And
111
00:06:11.709 --> 00:06:17.129
so we've just been inundated with support from folks of
112
00:06:17.250 --> 00:06:20.540
all industries throughout the state, small and large donors.
113
00:06:20.720 --> 00:06:25.040
Is there a relationship or funding involving Brian Haywood or
114
00:06:25.060 --> 00:06:26.870
Project 42?
115
00:06:26.870 --> 00:06:33.600
We definitely have a relationship with Project 42. We're affiliated organizations,
116
00:06:33.720 --> 00:06:38.420
but not necessarily a formal legal one with them.
117
00:06:39.319 --> 00:06:42.600
Paul Lawrence, it's a slightly different scenario here because you're
118
00:06:42.639 --> 00:06:45.110
not a party to, you're not the state. The state
119
00:06:45.129 --> 00:06:48.730
attorney general will be defending this law. But you have
120
00:06:48.769 --> 00:06:51.310
a long history in the state. You were an intervener
121
00:06:51.329 --> 00:06:55.050
in the capital gains tax case. Help us understand Pacifica
122
00:06:55.110 --> 00:06:58.790
Law Group. your role, and sort of what brings you
123
00:06:58.850 --> 00:07:01.550
into a position where you are willing to kind of
124
00:07:01.649 --> 00:07:03.850
mount a legal defense, at least on the set of
125
00:07:03.870 --> 00:07:05.379
Inside Olympia for this law? Sure.
126
00:07:06.060 --> 00:07:10.439
So we as a firm, and myself in particular, have
127
00:07:10.680 --> 00:07:14.540
been working for many, many years with interest groups that
128
00:07:14.579 --> 00:07:18.439
are interested in addressing the economic inequality in the state
129
00:07:18.459 --> 00:07:22.430
of Washington, as well as the extremely unfair taxing system
130
00:07:22.470 --> 00:07:25.699
in the state of Washington, where The richest members of
131
00:07:25.759 --> 00:07:28.120
our community pay the fewest taxes, and the middle and
132
00:07:28.160 --> 00:07:31.439
lower class pay much more as a percentage of their income.
133
00:07:31.480 --> 00:07:34.899
So we've worked, as you mentioned, with respect to the
134
00:07:36.319 --> 00:07:38.939
capital gains tax to support that effort, which was a
135
00:07:38.980 --> 00:07:41.480
step in the right direction. We've also worked with other
136
00:07:42.379 --> 00:07:45.379
organizations that have looked at other various kinds of tax
137
00:07:45.430 --> 00:07:49.550
reform issues in Washington, and we worked with groups that
138
00:07:49.589 --> 00:07:53.689
were supporting the millionaire's tax that was adopted and have
139
00:07:53.910 --> 00:07:56.959
worked to help them down both in Olympia and are
140
00:07:57.000 --> 00:08:00.279
prepared to help in terms of the pending case about
141
00:08:00.399 --> 00:08:01.220
the millionaire's tax.
142
00:08:01.540 --> 00:08:05.680
Regarding the pending case, are you seeking to become an
143
00:08:05.720 --> 00:08:07.060
intervener in this case?
144
00:08:07.500 --> 00:08:09.600
We will be seeking to intervene in the case, correct.
145
00:08:09.680 --> 00:08:12.959
And would that be on behalf of whom? Who would
146
00:08:12.980 --> 00:08:13.779
the client be?
147
00:08:14.560 --> 00:08:18.899
We are talking to different entities and individuals who are
148
00:08:19.050 --> 00:08:21.329
considering whether they want to participate or not. So at
149
00:08:21.350 --> 00:08:24.790
this point, I can't really say exactly who the clients
150
00:08:24.810 --> 00:08:25.050
will be.
151
00:08:26.069 --> 00:08:29.490
I should note that it's a coalition of largely public
152
00:08:29.529 --> 00:08:33.649
sector unions who are very invested in keeping this tax
153
00:08:33.769 --> 00:08:37.590
alive and are pushing back on the ballot measure. Am
154
00:08:37.649 --> 00:08:39.909
I correct that your law firm, just again sort of
155
00:08:39.929 --> 00:08:42.090
in the interest of full disclosure, has done some legal
156
00:08:42.450 --> 00:08:46.809
analysis of the ballot measure and this law on behalf
157
00:08:46.870 --> 00:08:49.629
of the union coalition that's trying to keep it intact?
158
00:08:50.019 --> 00:08:52.159
Yeah, I mean, it's a combination.
159
00:08:52.450 --> 00:08:55.789
I wouldn't say it's just state union workers, but unions,
160
00:08:56.049 --> 00:09:01.049
educational interests are very concerned about taxing WEA and school
161
00:09:01.090 --> 00:09:05.009
districts because of the amount of funding that will become
162
00:09:05.049 --> 00:09:08.389
available to school interests as a result of the millionaire's tax.
163
00:09:08.429 --> 00:09:09.909
And yes, we've analyzed.
164
00:09:09.529 --> 00:09:13.889
Both the millionaire's tax issues as well as the constitutionality
165
00:09:13.950 --> 00:09:18.279
and other issues related to the no campaign of 645.
166
00:09:18.279 --> 00:09:20.580
And just to be clear, if you become an intervener,
167
00:09:21.279 --> 00:09:23.250
the funding for that would be on behalf of groups,
168
00:09:23.690 --> 00:09:25.950
perhaps like these unions we've just mentioned, who are trying
169
00:09:25.970 --> 00:09:28.169
to preserve this, both on the ballot and in the courts.
170
00:09:28.789 --> 00:09:29.090
Correct.
171
00:09:30.289 --> 00:09:32.509
With that sort of established, and thank you for that,
172
00:09:32.669 --> 00:09:34.820
let's launch in. And I want to hear just from
173
00:09:34.860 --> 00:09:38.960
a top-line perspective from each of you, your sort of
174
00:09:39.620 --> 00:09:43.059
best opening argument for, in the case of you and
175
00:09:43.080 --> 00:09:47.049
your side, why this is unconstitutional. and should not be upheld.
176
00:09:47.149 --> 00:09:49.580
And then Paul will give you a chance to argue
177
00:09:49.799 --> 00:09:52.960
the opposite side. But what is it, Jackson Maynard, about
178
00:09:53.600 --> 00:10:00.720
this quote-unquote millionaire's tax that is unconstitutional? And we're not
179
00:10:00.740 --> 00:10:03.539
talking about whether it's good policy, bad policy. That'll be
180
00:10:03.580 --> 00:10:05.940
for voters to decide, right? Lawmakers did and now voters.
181
00:10:06.179 --> 00:10:08.539
But why should the courts toss it out?
182
00:10:09.149 --> 00:10:11.850
Well, I mean, there is some overlap with the policy,
183
00:10:11.909 --> 00:10:14.490
which we'll get to because one of the things if
184
00:10:15.169 --> 00:10:18.070
Paul and his folks want to try to overturn the precedent,
185
00:10:18.090 --> 00:10:20.690
they've got to demonstrate as harm. And so I'm sure
186
00:10:20.809 --> 00:10:23.629
we'll talk about that in a minute. But the main
187
00:10:24.269 --> 00:10:28.470
issue here is that this clearly violates Article 7, Sections
188
00:10:28.470 --> 00:10:32.610
1 and 2 of the state constitution, the uniformity clauses,
189
00:10:32.870 --> 00:10:38.169
and then the 1% cap on property taxes. And going
190
00:10:38.220 --> 00:10:41.399
back almost 100 years, there's that Culleton decision that you
191
00:10:41.440 --> 00:10:44.789
mentioned in the opening, in which the state Supreme Court
192
00:10:44.850 --> 00:10:49.480
very clearly held that income was property and therefore subject
193
00:10:49.639 --> 00:10:53.519
to those restrictions, it has upheld that not once, not twice,
194
00:10:53.580 --> 00:10:56.519
but five times, the most recent one in 2019.
195
00:10:56.519 --> 00:11:00.179
And so, you.
196
00:10:58.779 --> 00:11:04.470
Know, by that well-established precedent that the court continues to
197
00:11:04.669 --> 00:11:07.429
uphold and where they've said, look, you can change this
198
00:11:07.509 --> 00:11:10.190
if you want to, you can change this very broadly
199
00:11:11.049 --> 00:11:15.279
language of anything tangible and intangible that constitutes property, but
200
00:11:15.320 --> 00:11:18.220
you need to amend the Constitution. We're not going to
201
00:11:18.259 --> 00:11:24.200
do it for you. Arguably, they did it, the issue
202
00:11:24.259 --> 00:11:27.279
came up in 2023 with the Quinn decision.
203
00:11:27.299 --> 00:11:30.700
Which was the estate tax, sorry, the capital gains tax.
204
00:11:30.750 --> 00:11:35.549
Capital gains tax. And I believe that the interveners that
205
00:11:35.610 --> 00:11:37.990
Paul represented in that case tried to get the court
206
00:11:38.419 --> 00:11:40.970
to overturn it, and not a single state Supreme Court
207
00:11:41.009 --> 00:11:46.629
justice bid at that. Obviously, they upheld the tax on
208
00:11:46.750 --> 00:11:47.389
other grounds.
209
00:11:47.450 --> 00:11:48.919
Yeah, they found it was an excise tax.
210
00:11:48.950 --> 00:11:53.210
But they did not overturn it and overturn that very strong,
211
00:11:53.309 --> 00:11:58.009
longstanding precedent. And then I would also mention that every
212
00:11:58.070 --> 00:12:01.610
time that this has been presented, either by constitutional amendments
213
00:12:01.710 --> 00:12:04.289
in the six times that that's been presented or by
214
00:12:04.340 --> 00:12:07.120
initiative the four times, the voters of the state have
215
00:12:07.159 --> 00:12:11.539
voted that down. Now, that's more of a political argument
216
00:12:11.559 --> 00:12:14.120
than a legal argument, but I think it's significant and
217
00:12:14.200 --> 00:12:17.440
something that the court needs to take into account.
218
00:12:17.460 --> 00:12:20.320
You're pointing to sort of legal precedent and perhaps political
219
00:12:20.379 --> 00:12:24.899
or precedent. Paul Lawrence, I hear this often from the
220
00:12:24.960 --> 00:12:27.370
opponents of this, that there's sort of the plain language
221
00:12:27.399 --> 00:12:31.470
of the Constitution and the way that Article 7 is
222
00:12:31.809 --> 00:12:36.490
written seems to capture just about anything and makes it property.
223
00:12:36.990 --> 00:12:39.720
And furthermore, we've got the Supreme Court case on the book.
224
00:12:39.769 --> 00:12:42.940
So what is the best argument of supporters of this
225
00:12:43.039 --> 00:12:46.960
law that this is constitutional, should be upheld? Or is
226
00:12:47.019 --> 00:12:49.600
it not constitutional, but the court was wrong somehow and
227
00:12:49.919 --> 00:12:52.600
therefore needs to change its mind and find that it's
228
00:12:52.639 --> 00:12:54.600
constitutional based on a new precedent?
229
00:12:55.860 --> 00:12:58.779
The court error, the Culleton Court just made some very
230
00:12:58.840 --> 00:13:03.230
substantial errors. And the notion that the way property is
231
00:13:03.289 --> 00:13:07.269
defined in the 14th Amendment would include income an income
232
00:13:07.309 --> 00:13:10.769
tax just isn't supported by the history of the amendment
233
00:13:11.149 --> 00:13:13.309
or what was going on in the state at the time.
234
00:13:13.909 --> 00:13:15.590
So I'm going to start a little bit with that
235
00:13:15.649 --> 00:13:19.179
history and then go into Culleton. So you have to
236
00:13:19.220 --> 00:13:23.000
go back to the late 1920s where a lot of
237
00:13:23.019 --> 00:13:26.840
things were changing in terms of the cost of government
238
00:13:27.039 --> 00:13:29.659
and income that was going into
government. Washington state relied
239
00:13:29.740 --> 00:13:32.960
primarily on a real property tax and the cost of
240
00:13:33.000 --> 00:13:37.940
government was relatively small. But starting in the late 1920s,
241
00:13:38.809 --> 00:13:41.750
there was a huge amount of investment out of real
242
00:13:41.789 --> 00:13:45.860
property into stocks and bonds, which are what traditionally intangible
243
00:13:45.889 --> 00:13:50.580
property is. And revenue, as property values went down as
244
00:13:50.620 --> 00:13:53.360
we headed into the Depression, revenue to the government went
245
00:13:53.419 --> 00:13:57.299
significantly down. So the government, Washington state government, was facing
246
00:13:57.360 --> 00:14:01.039
a problem. They commissioned a group to look at it,
247
00:14:01.059 --> 00:14:04.620
and that group, recommended the adoption of a business and
248
00:14:04.679 --> 00:14:11.110
personal income tax. Amendment 14 was adopted in 1930, so
249
00:14:11.350 --> 00:14:14.830
it was supported by many groups who supported an income
250
00:14:14.870 --> 00:14:18.919
tax because people did not think at the time that
251
00:14:18.940 --> 00:14:21.120
it would include an income tax. When they talk about
252
00:14:21.279 --> 00:14:24.840
adding tangible property to the definition of real property, what
253
00:14:24.879 --> 00:14:26.960
was at issue, and you can look at the voters pamphlets,
254
00:14:26.980 --> 00:14:29.379
you can look at what people talked about, were stocks
255
00:14:29.450 --> 00:14:34.350
and bonds and that types of real property, intangible real property,
256
00:14:34.409 --> 00:14:36.549
which were not at that time being taxed. So that
257
00:14:36.570 --> 00:14:39.379
was the purpose of the 14th Amendment. And we know
258
00:14:39.419 --> 00:14:43.080
that because the year after the 14th Amendment was adopted,
259
00:14:43.340 --> 00:14:46.600
there was an initiative who did pass to adopt a
260
00:14:47.379 --> 00:14:52.279
personal income tax supported by the same groups that supported
261
00:14:52.539 --> 00:14:56.730
the Amendment 14 to the state constitution. So that tells
262
00:14:56.789 --> 00:14:59.389
you that in terms of what the people thought they
263
00:14:59.429 --> 00:15:01.350
were doing and what the people wanted at the time,
264
00:15:01.909 --> 00:15:04.700
It really wasn't a clear question. In fact, I think
265
00:15:04.740 --> 00:15:08.279
it's a wrong assumption to assume that the new definition
266
00:15:08.340 --> 00:15:11.639
or the broad definition of property includes an income tax
267
00:15:11.759 --> 00:15:14.980
because that question is an income tax, a property tax
268
00:15:15.120 --> 00:15:17.639
is an open question, which takes us to Culleton.
269
00:15:18.120 --> 00:15:20.120
Maybe before we get to Culleton, though, I should just,
270
00:15:21.539 --> 00:15:23.570
can we just spend a moment about and give you
271
00:15:23.590 --> 00:15:26.559
each a chance to sort of address this? Sure. If
272
00:15:26.659 --> 00:15:31.279
the Constitution says everything, whether tangible or intangible, subject to
273
00:15:31.460 --> 00:15:37.080
ownership is property, where does that leave, from your perspective,
274
00:15:37.100 --> 00:15:41.059
where does that leave income? Or why would that leave
275
00:15:41.159 --> 00:15:41.700
out income?
276
00:15:41.820 --> 00:15:46.019
So let's talk about that. So what is owned? When
277
00:15:46.059 --> 00:15:48.659
you buy something, you buy a piece of property, you
278
00:15:48.700 --> 00:15:51.200
buy a stock, you buy an investment, you buy a bond.
279
00:15:51.360 --> 00:15:54.679
Those are things that you own, that you can buy
280
00:15:54.799 --> 00:15:58.039
and sell There's a market for them. That is what
281
00:15:58.220 --> 00:16:02.700
property is. Income is something that you may earn from property.
282
00:16:04.039 --> 00:16:06.940
Selling real estate, that's going to generate income. You invest
283
00:16:07.000 --> 00:16:09.139
in bonds and stocks because you hope that you value
284
00:16:09.179 --> 00:16:13.179
your investments growing up. But income itself is not property
285
00:16:13.230 --> 00:16:16.049
that you own. Income is something that's earned from an
286
00:16:16.210 --> 00:16:18.429
individual's own efforts.
287
00:16:19.470 --> 00:16:20.289
I'm not property.
288
00:16:20.690 --> 00:16:23.110
I can't be brought and sold, but it's my efforts
289
00:16:23.149 --> 00:16:26.950
that are creating and building income. It's different than real property.
290
00:16:27.070 --> 00:16:29.389
It's different than a stock. It's different than a bond.
291
00:16:29.470 --> 00:16:33.600
It's different than a CD. So the fundamental issue is
292
00:16:34.039 --> 00:16:36.840
whether or not an income tax is a tax on property,
293
00:16:37.059 --> 00:16:38.460
and we think it clearly is not.
294
00:16:38.559 --> 00:16:39.879
So we will get to Colton in a moment, but
295
00:16:39.899 --> 00:16:41.779
let me have you address that because it seems so
296
00:16:41.799 --> 00:16:43.100
crucial and kind of core to this.
297
00:16:43.159 --> 00:16:46.899
Yeah, I think Paul is relying heavily on the Hugh
298
00:16:46.919 --> 00:16:49.659
Spitzer article and, you know, disagreeing.
299
00:16:49.679 --> 00:16:51.419
And we should note that Hugh is a Washington State
300
00:16:51.779 --> 00:16:56.000
constitution expert, and I think emeritus law professor at UW
301
00:16:56.059 --> 00:16:58.220
and sort of viewed as the leading expert.
302
00:16:58.379 --> 00:17:00.720
He is an expert, and I will say disagreeing with
303
00:17:00.759 --> 00:17:03.919
Hugh Spitzer about the state constitution is a little like
304
00:17:03.960 --> 00:17:06.599
disagreeing with the Apostle Paul about the gospels. He didn't
305
00:17:06.619 --> 00:17:09.180
write them, but he knows a lot about them. That said,
306
00:17:09.319 --> 00:17:12.670
I think the article that sort of lays out this
307
00:17:13.329
--> 00:17:17.910
revisionist theory of how this tax came to, I'm sorry,
308
00:17:17.950 --> 00:17:20.490
how the provision came to pass is just, it's deeply
309
00:17:20.569 --> 00:17:26.279
flawed in at its central core, it is asserting that
310
00:17:26.359 --> 00:17:32.539
language that was incredibly broad, that they did intend to
311
00:17:32.619 --> 00:17:35.039
not have that apply to income tax in terms of
312
00:17:35.079 --> 00:17:38.890
the cap. When they had specific examples, if they wanted
313
00:17:39.410 --> 00:17:44.849
to pass an income tax, they had examples in the
314
00:17:44.869 --> 00:17:48.789
Cullison case, they mentioned the Wisconsin state constitution, where they
315
00:17:48.849 --> 00:17:51.589
mentioned an income tax by name. They had the U.S.
316
00:17:51.690 --> 00:17:54.589
Constitution that was amended to provide for an income tax.
317
00:17:55.089 --> 00:17:57.319
So this idea that you're going to provide for an
318
00:17:57.359 --> 00:18:01.220
income tax by providing this incredibly broad definition of property
319
00:18:01.660 --> 00:18:04.759
without actually mentioning an income tax and then subjecting it
320
00:18:04.799 --> 00:18:07.440
to these caps, I think just it doesn't make sense.
321
00:18:07.779 --> 00:18:09.920
And your question to him kind of got at the
322
00:18:09.940 --> 00:18:10.420
root of that.
323
00:18:10.519 --> 00:18:12.220
But if the courts are going to be asked to
324
00:18:12.279 --> 00:18:15.059
sort of revisit this history and his side is going
325
00:18:15.079 --> 00:18:18.309
to point out, well, look, first— they did the amendment,
326
00:18:18.789 --> 00:18:21.319
and then that same kind of group or groups of,
327
00:18:21.339 --> 00:18:24.819
you know, then went for an income tax, doesn't that
328
00:18:24.900 --> 00:18:27.000
suggest that they didn't intend to cleave off?
329
00:18:27.059 --> 00:18:29.380
I think you're still stuck with the plain language of
330
00:18:29.400 --> 00:18:32.900
the Constitution that's been consistently interpreted, and while there may
331
00:18:32.920 --> 00:18:36.019
be efforts to try to, you know, create this revisionist
332
00:18:36.039 --> 00:18:39.460
history for what the context of that was, and again,
333
00:18:39.480 --> 00:18:41.369
a lot of these same arguments were raised in the
334
00:18:41.410 --> 00:18:44.170
Quinn case and not adopted by a single state Supreme
335
00:18:44.190 --> 00:18:47.700
Court justice, we are hopeful that the court will be
336
00:18:47.740 --> 00:18:53.000
consistent with that recent precedent and will continue to reject
337
00:18:53.099 --> 00:18:56.319
this kind of effort to rewrite the Constitution and the
338
00:18:56.359 --> 00:18:58.200
history surrounding that initiative.
339
00:18:58.440 --> 00:19:00.509
Well, let's now go back to, we'll go back in
340
00:19:00.529 --> 00:19:03.049
time again to Culleton, nearly 100 years ago, 90 plus.
341
00:19:03.210 --> 00:19:04.630
Just a quick note on Quinn.
342
00:19:04.829 --> 00:19:07.630
We argued that it was an excise tax, but we
343
00:19:07.670 --> 00:19:10.710
did alternatively said, if you think it's not an excise tax,
344
00:19:11.150 --> 00:19:13.369
then you should consider whether it's an income tax. Since
345
00:19:13.410 --> 00:19:15.759
they said this is an excise tax, Of course, they
346
00:19:15.799 --> 00:19:16.799
didn't reach the other issue.
347
00:19:17.180 --> 00:19:19.180
And in this case, nobody's going to be trying to
348
00:19:19.200 --> 00:19:20.019
argue it's an excise tax.
349
00:19:20.079 --> 00:19:20.440
Right.
350
00:19:20.539 --> 00:19:22.519
And this is actually relatively unique.
351
00:19:22.539 --> 00:19:23.119
Or maybe they will.
352
00:19:23.200 --> 00:19:25.279
Actually, the state is going to argue that it's an
353
00:19:25.349 --> 00:19:28.710
excise tax, which is interesting to me. I'm sorry.
354
00:19:28.750 --> 00:19:29.309
Go ahead.
355
00:19:29.990 --> 00:19:32.509
It's interesting to me because the same attorneys that are
356
00:19:32.549 --> 00:19:36.190
now representing the state in the lawsuit, in December 5th,
357
00:19:36.269 --> 00:19:39.539
in a memo to the state legislature, it was Dan
358
00:19:39.559 --> 00:19:43.140
Jensen and Chuck Zaleski. They're great attorneys. They're doing their job.
359
00:19:43.549 --> 00:19:48.529
But they tried to warn the legislature. They said, in
360
00:19:48.589 --> 00:19:51.309
our view, the proposal would almost certainly be characterized by
361
00:19:51.349 --> 00:19:54.799
lower Washington courts as a property tax, not an excise tax,
362
00:19:55.150 --> 00:19:57.480
like the state's B & O and capital gains taxes.
363
00:19:58.000 --> 00:20:00.599
And yet, now that the state has passed it and
364
00:20:00.619 --> 00:20:02.900
the AG's office has to defend it, they are now
365
00:20:03.019 --> 00:20:06.240
arguing that it is essentially an excise tax and a
366
00:20:06.279 --> 00:20:08.880
tax on the transaction of receiving your income.
367
00:20:09.380 --> 00:20:09.519
Okay.
368
00:20:10.210 --> 00:20:10.609
Go ahead, Paul.
369
00:20:11.009 --> 00:20:12.029
I don't know where to start.
370
00:20:13.150 --> 00:20:17.039
Let me go to Culleton first and then start us,
371
00:20:17.099 --> 00:20:18.660
then sort of get to where you are in the
372
00:20:18.720 --> 00:20:22.640
court system nowadays. Okay. So Culleton was a case, it
373
00:20:22.799 --> 00:20:27.099
was decided in 1933, overturned the initiative that was adopted
374
00:20:27.160 --> 00:20:30.559
by the people to oppose an income tax. And it
375
00:20:30.779 --> 00:20:34.200
was a five to four vote. So it wasn't overwhelming.
376
00:20:34.240 --> 00:20:37.329
It was a very close vote. And if you look
377
00:20:37.450 --> 00:20:40.720
and you read the case, the case said, There's this
378
00:20:40.839 --> 00:20:45.119
earlier case that we decided called Aberdeen Savings, which definitively
379
00:20:45.180 --> 00:20:49.859
decided in our state
that an income tax is a
380
00:20:49.900 --> 00:20:52.319
property tax. So you have to go back and read,
381
00:20:52.400 --> 00:20:56.619
what did Aberdeen actually decide? The issue that was decided
382
00:20:56.660 --> 00:20:59.920
in that case was whether the tax at issue violated
383
00:20:59.980 --> 00:21:03.880
the Equal Protection Clause of the United States Constitution. The
384
00:21:03.960 --> 00:21:07.069
court in Aberdeen never reached the question of whether the
385
00:21:07.109 --> 00:21:11.619
tax was okay or not under the 14th Amendment. And
386
00:21:11.819 --> 00:21:14.519
in holding that the tax was not okay under the
387
00:21:14.599 --> 00:21:18.740
Equal Protection Clause of the Washington Constitution, the court cited
388
00:21:18.779 --> 00:21:21.720
a U.S. Supreme Court case that had come out recently.
389
00:21:22.140 --> 00:21:22.799
Well, that U.S.
390
00:21:22.819 --> 00:21:25.660
Supreme Court case that was cited and relied upon by
391
00:21:25.839 --> 00:21:31.460
Aberdeen and therefore cited and relied upon by Culleton was overturned.
392
00:21:31.000 --> 00:21:31.660
By the U.S.
393
00:21:31.680 --> 00:21:38.519
Supreme Court in 1976. And in overturning the case, the U.S.
394
00:21:38.559 --> 00:21:41.480
Supreme Court said this case is a relic of a
395
00:21:41.559 --> 00:21:42.660
bygone era.
396
00:21:43.160 --> 00:21:46.240
It's out of date. It's wrong. Throw it out.
397
00:21:46.880 --> 00:21:49.970
And that's what we're asking our state Supreme Court to
398
00:21:50.009 --> 00:21:55.190
do because they relied on a premise that is wrong
399
00:21:55.230 --> 00:21:58.390
that the Aberdeen Court made this decision. Now, there are
400
00:21:58.410 --> 00:22:02.500
a couple other problems with the Culleton case. They made
401
00:22:02.559 --> 00:22:07.359
another mistake. They said We've looked at other states and
402
00:22:07.380 --> 00:22:11.019
the clear majority of other states treat an income tax
403
00:22:11.160 --> 00:22:16.640
as a property tax. That also was a wrong statement. Commentators,
404
00:22:16.740 --> 00:22:19.640
not just Hugh Spitzer, but other commentators have looked at
405
00:22:20.380 --> 00:22:23.299
tax stuff all over the country, have said that simply
406
00:22:23.420 --> 00:22:26.339
wasn't the case back then. And in fact, where we
407
00:22:26.460 --> 00:22:29.980
are now, we are like one of two states in
408
00:22:30.000 --> 00:22:33.690
the nation that still treat an income tax as.
409
00:22:33.650 --> 00:22:34.549
A property tax.
410
00:22:34.630 --> 00:22:35.650
Is Pennsylvania the other one?
411
00:22:35.670 --> 00:22:36.089
Yes.
412
00:22:36.890 --> 00:22:40.839
So the idea that the court was relying on what
413
00:22:40.890 --> 00:22:45.960
they thought the judicial majority of the states owned, that
414
00:22:46.420 --> 00:22:50.059
simply was wrong. So we're in a situation where there
415
00:22:50.119 --> 00:22:54.480
are strong arguments why the Culleton case was wrongly decided.
416
00:22:55.400 --> 00:22:58.400
relied on law that has since been overturned, which are
417
00:22:58.519 --> 00:23:01.660
criteria you look at when you want to revisit a case,
418
00:23:02.000 --> 00:23:04.660
when you ask a court to revisit a case. And
419
00:23:04.700 --> 00:23:07.410
then you also look at what is the harm that's
420
00:23:07.450 --> 00:23:10.410
going on caused by this case. And that's something that
421
00:23:10.470 --> 00:23:14.390
really has been exacerbated in the last few decades because
422
00:23:15.009 --> 00:23:19.730
we know two things about Washington. We have one of
423
00:23:19.789 --> 00:23:22.859
the most regressive tax systems in the country.
424
00:23:23.460 --> 00:23:24.420
That meaning the.
425
00:23:24.359 --> 00:23:27.380
Middle class and the lower class pay a much higher
426
00:23:27.420 --> 00:23:32.029
percentage of their income in taxes than people who are
427
00:23:32.069 --> 00:23:34.490
very well off, and certainly than the millionaires who would
428
00:23:34.509 --> 00:23:38.589
be subject to this tax. So that is harming our
429
00:23:38.670 --> 00:23:42.049
ability as a state both to be fair and both
430
00:23:42.130 --> 00:23:45.450
to raise sufficient income on a regular basis to pay
431
00:23:45.529 --> 00:23:48.740
for the state's needs. An income tax is traditionally understood
432
00:23:49.180 --> 00:23:52.690
will always be a more regular flow of income then
433
00:23:52.730 --> 00:23:54.210
a B & O tax, which.
434
00:23:54.089 --> 00:23:55.279
The state relies on, and a property tax.
435
00:23:55.289 --> 00:23:56.750
And just to be clear, is that an argument you
436
00:23:56.769 --> 00:23:58.710
would make if you were before the Supreme Court?
437
00:23:59.210 --> 00:24:01.470
One of the issues in deciding whether or not to
438
00:24:01.559 --> 00:24:03.920
overturn a case is showing of harm. What is the
439
00:24:04.000 --> 00:24:06.400
harmfulness of the decision?
440
00:24:06.420 --> 00:24:08.279
So you would be saying not only was this a
441
00:24:08.500 --> 00:24:10.700
flawed decision, but it has caused harm.
442
00:24:10.880 --> 00:24:11.660
It has caused harm.
443
00:24:12.119 --> 00:24:14.480
And all we want to do is open up the question.
444
00:24:14.960 --> 00:24:16.589
We can get back to the argument about what the
445
00:24:16.609 --> 00:24:18.890
original intent was. We can get back to the argument
446
00:24:18.910 --> 00:24:21.630
about what people said in in 1930 when this was
447
00:24:21.690 --> 00:24:23.910
passed and all that. We just want the court to
448
00:24:23.950 --> 00:24:26.950
look at those things and then make a decision based
449
00:24:27.130 --> 00:24:32.049
on the weight of judicial precedent across the country including
450
00:24:32.069 --> 00:24:34.589
the United States Supreme Court and what went on in
451
00:24:34.650 --> 00:24:37.869
Washington and then decide is an income tax in Washington
452
00:24:37.930 --> 00:24:40.589
really a property
tax that's impacted by the 14th Amendment.
453
00:24:40.730 --> 00:24:42.930
Is your side saying to the Supreme Court, look at
454
00:24:42.970 --> 00:24:45.660
your precedent, you've got the Culleton decision, that should be
455
00:24:45.740 --> 00:24:49.380
kind of binding or holding and move on? Or are
456
00:24:49.410 --> 00:24:52.720
you similarly saying, delve into the reasoning, and it was
457
00:24:53.059 --> 00:24:55.599
actually good reasoning, unlike what Paul Lawrence has just said?
458
00:24:55.640 --> 00:24:59.079
Yeah, I think the reasoning is sound. I think the
459
00:25:00.140 --> 00:25:04.140
language is incredibly broad, and I'll just have to respectfully
460
00:25:04.200 --> 00:25:08.640
disagree that the legal underpinnings have changed. I mean, you
461
00:25:08.680 --> 00:25:12.960
mentioned at least one other state that recognizes that income
462
00:25:13.259 --> 00:25:14.480
is property, and so.
463
00:25:15.710 --> 00:25:19.309
What about the argument that their decision was based on,
464
00:25:19.349 --> 00:25:22.849
for instance, in part the Aberdeen case, and then the
465
00:25:24.529 --> 00:25:27.440
flaws he's arguing then existed in that line of reasoning?
466
00:25:27.680 --> 00:25:33.680
Yeah, I think, again, the court did rely on, and
467
00:25:34.140 --> 00:25:37.839
the Aberdeen court did decide in that case that income
468
00:25:37.880 --> 00:25:40.460
was property. I think we're kind of cherry picking. I
469
00:25:40.500 --> 00:25:43.750
know there was some additional conclusions out of that that
470
00:25:43.789 --> 00:25:49.279
were changed. But again, the way that the court analyzes
471
00:25:49.339 --> 00:25:53.240
constitutional provisions, the pole star, the north star is you
472
00:25:53.279 --> 00:25:56.240
look at the plain language and affect that. And over
473
00:25:57.039 --> 00:26:00.589
five times, including back in 2023, when this has been
474
00:26:00.609 --> 00:26:04.390
looked at, the court has declined invitations to overturn that
475
00:26:04.450 --> 00:26:09.910
precedent and has applied the plain language to efforts to
476
00:26:09.950 --> 00:26:14.150
try to get it to revisit that. So I think
477
00:26:14.170 --> 00:26:16.430
the case law on that is well established. I would
478
00:26:16.470 --> 00:26:19.309
like to talk about harm, though, and I don't know
479
00:26:19.349 --> 00:26:21.329
if there's time to do that now.
480
00:26:21.430 --> 00:26:23.410
No, we should do. I mean, if it's sort of
481
00:26:23.490 --> 00:26:26.210
a two-pronged test, let's bring that second-pronged test. Sure.
482
00:26:26.369 --> 00:26:27.910
So it is a two-pronged test. They have to show
483
00:26:27.950 --> 00:26:31.150
it's incorrect and harmful. I don't think that you can
484
00:26:31.210 --> 00:26:37.910
establish that Washington State has been harmed by the fact
485
00:26:37.950 --> 00:26:40.990
that we have not had an income tax Our state
486
00:26:41.009 --> 00:26:43.730
budget has doubled over
the last 10 years. It was
487
00:26:43.730 --> 00:26:50.240
$ 33 billion in 2015. In 2025, it rose to $ 80 billion.
488
00:26:50.859 --> 00:26:54.380
We have had an incredible benefit in terms of a
489
00:26:54.400 --> 00:26:57.900
competitive advantage over the last several decades in not having
490
00:26:57.940 --> 00:27:01.869
an income tax. So it has been an incredible advantage
491
00:27:01.910 --> 00:27:05.890
to the state not to have an income tax.
492
00:27:06.029 --> 00:27:06.690
In fact....
493
00:27:07.930 --> 00:27:14.329
Former governors Gregoire and Gary Locke both have criticized Olympia
494
00:27:14.430 --> 00:27:16.269
and said, look, they don't have a revenue problem. They
495
00:27:16.309 --> 00:27:19.339
have a spending problem. They're spending far more than they
496
00:27:19.359 --> 00:27:21.559
take in. And as long as they're doing that, it
497
00:27:21.599 --> 00:27:25.859
won't matter how much revenue they have. And so, you know,
498
00:27:26.119 --> 00:27:28.819
to the extent that not having that revenue is a harm,
499
00:27:28.859 --> 00:27:29.900
that just doesn't hold water.
500
00:27:30.299 --> 00:27:34.400
What about the idea that the legislature has all along
501
00:27:34.460 --> 00:27:38.329
had at its disposal, the option to do a constitutional amendment.
502
00:27:38.710 --> 00:27:41.349
It could also do a flat income tax, a uniform
503
00:27:41.410 --> 00:27:45.349
income tax. I can imagine the justices pushing back a
504
00:27:45.390 --> 00:27:48.089
little bit and saying, yeah, this locked them out of
505
00:27:48.230 --> 00:27:52.029
one particular tax, which is a graduated income tax, but
506
00:27:52.250 --> 00:27:56.170
not out of doing income tax writ large across the board.
507
00:27:56.869 --> 00:27:58.549
So there are a couple of things there.
508
00:27:59.349 --> 00:28:03.690
First of all, obviously, there is a much more significant
509
00:28:03.779 --> 00:28:07.369
bar to amending the state constitution than there is.
510
00:28:07.410 --> 00:28:11.349
It's a two-thirds vote in the legislature and ratification by
511
00:28:11.369 --> 00:28:11.789
the voters.
512
00:28:12.230 --> 00:28:14.609
I think what's being missed here, I mean, the harm
513
00:28:15.150 --> 00:28:20.170
I think is real because you cannot dispute the inequities
514
00:28:20.230 --> 00:28:22.930
in our tax system relative to every other state just
515
00:28:22.990 --> 00:28:27.009
about in the nation. But all that opens up if
516
00:28:27.089 --> 00:28:30.069
this case is overturned is the ability of the people
517
00:28:30.109 --> 00:28:33.089
to speak and the people to act. It's not the
518
00:28:33.130 --> 00:28:36.319
Supreme Court that's adopting an income tax. the Supreme Court
519
00:28:36.359 --> 00:28:39.160
will be upholding the right of the legislature to adopt
520
00:28:39.200 --> 00:28:42.240
an income tax, or the people through the initiative, or
521
00:28:42.279 --> 00:28:44.339
the people through the initiative to
repeal.
522
00:28:44.119 --> 00:28:44.920
An income tax.
523
00:28:45.079 --> 00:28:48.680
It actually throws the issue back to the people to
524
00:28:48.740 --> 00:28:51.660
decide what they want for our state, rather than relying
525
00:28:51.880 --> 00:28:56.890
on a 1930s decision by the type of judges who
526
00:28:56.930 --> 00:28:59.410
were existing and sitting on the Supreme Court, men of
527
00:28:59.450 --> 00:29:04.069
property back in 1930, who have cut off this option
528
00:29:04.410 --> 00:29:07.190
and maybe They're right that the people don't want it,
529
00:29:07.230 --> 00:29:08.730
and they can vote it out, and they can vote.
530
00:29:08.589 --> 00:29:09.589
Out their legislatures.
531
00:29:10.130 --> 00:29:12.869
But right now, we have two-thirds, you know, we had
532
00:29:13.710 --> 00:29:16.059
a vast majority of state legislature and the people they
533
00:29:16.119 --> 00:29:19.380
represent saying we want an income tax. And this is
534
00:29:19.390 --> 00:29:23.200
really the first case that has so specifically said, here's
535
00:29:23.240 --> 00:29:25.599
an income tax state Supreme Court. You need to go
536
00:29:25.640 --> 00:29:27.559
back and look at the issues. And all we're asking
537
00:29:27.579 --> 00:29:29.759
to do is look at that, look at the history.
538
00:29:30.299 --> 00:29:32.420
If he's right about the history, maybe we won't win.
539
00:29:32.460 --> 00:29:34.420
If we're right about the history, maybe we do win,
540
00:29:34.460 --> 00:29:36.750
but it's going to open up. The opportunity for the
541
00:29:36.789 --> 00:29:40.559
people to decide through their legislatures and through the initiative
542
00:29:40.910 --> 00:29:44.059
process whether they want an income tax and what it
543
00:29:44.099 --> 00:29:44.660
will look like.
544
00:29:45.339 --> 00:29:50.440
Can I briefly respond on the regressivity issue? The argument
545
00:29:50.500 --> 00:29:54.069
that we have a regressive tax system is premised on
546
00:29:54.089 --> 00:29:58.849
outdated studies that don't take into account the benefits that
547
00:29:58.890 --> 00:30:01.890
we provide to citizens. They only look at the sales
548
00:30:01.970 --> 00:30:06.019
tax and other property taxes and the impact that has
549
00:30:06.299 --> 00:30:10.220
on lower incomes without taking into account the benefits that
550
00:30:10.240 --> 00:30:13.579
we offer. So, you know, I don't think that's necessarily true.
551
00:30:13.599 --> 00:30:14.700
Yeah.
552
00:30:16.099 --> 00:30:16.259
Okay.
553
00:30:16.500 --> 00:30:17.859
I do want to, let's do this. Let's take a
554
00:30:17.880 --> 00:30:19.859
quick break. We'll come back because there's much more I
555
00:30:19.880 --> 00:30:22.339
want to ask you about. But brief break. When we return,
556
00:30:22.359 --> 00:30:26.029
we continue the debate over the constitutionality and perhaps the
557
00:30:26.049 --> 00:30:28.549
harms or not harms of Washington's new tax on people
558
00:30:28.569 --> 00:30:31.319
making more than a million dollars a year back after this.
559
00:30:31.799 --> 00:30:34.759
Stolen vehicles are a problem. We need a solution.
560
00:30:35.119 --> 00:30:36.700
Pursuits are not the solution to that.
561
00:30:36.940 --> 00:30:38.319
Just hit another vehicle.
562
00:30:38.599 --> 00:30:41.019
With the current pursuit law, you can literally have someone
563
00:30:41.079 --> 00:30:44.180
steal a vehicle and drive through a school zone actively
564
00:30:44.220 --> 00:30:45.839
at 100 miles an hour back and forth, and no
565
00:30:45.880 --> 00:30:47.099
one will be able to do anything about that.
566
00:30:47.400 --> 00:30:48.180
Passing by school.
567
00:30:51.920 --> 00:30:54.170
Welcome back to Inside Olympia. Joining me once again are
568
00:30:54.210 --> 00:30:57.809
attorneys Paul Lawrence and Jackson Maynard to debate the constitutionality
569
00:30:57.829 --> 00:31:01.130
of Washington's new income tax on people making more than
570
00:31:01.170 --> 00:31:03.190
a million dollars a year. One of the questions I
571
00:31:03.210 --> 00:31:06.009
want to present to both of you is about the
572
00:31:06.049 --> 00:31:10.170
importance of precedent. This has been the precedent in this
573
00:31:10.190 --> 00:31:17.150
state for many decades now. It's sort of an institutional question.
574
00:31:17.910 --> 00:31:21.390
When should the court revisit and under what circumstances should
575
00:31:21.450 --> 00:31:25.259
it correct or reverse or change its precedent. Maybe I'll
576
00:31:25.279 --> 00:31:28.420
start with you, Paul Lawrence, on this. I can imagine
577
00:31:30.440 --> 00:31:32.500
the side that wants this struck down to say it
578
00:31:33.940 --> 00:31:36.220
should be a very high bar and a very unusual
579
00:31:36.420 --> 00:31:39.019
circumstance that you would go in and overturn nearly 100
580
00:31:39.019 --> 00:31:39.579
years of precedent.
581
00:31:40.079 --> 00:31:41.740
Yeah, I mean, I think it is a high bar,
582
00:31:41.799 --> 00:31:43.430
and we think we meet it.
583
00:31:43.460 --> 00:31:46.799
Essentially, there are two different ways to, the Supreme Court
584
00:31:46.819 --> 00:31:49.400
has said, there are two different ways that you can argue.
585
00:31:50.220 --> 00:31:53.160
First is when the this is their language, I don't
586
00:31:53.299 --> 00:31:56.480
like to be sound, overly lawyer, lawyerly, when the legal
587
00:31:56.559 --> 00:32:00.140
underpendings of the precedent have changed or disappeared altogether. And
588
00:32:00.180 --> 00:32:04.019
that's why the importance of the U.S. Supreme Court overturning
589
00:32:04.119 --> 00:32:07.019
this case as a, you know, relic of a time
590
00:32:07.859 --> 00:32:12.079
long ago is particularly important because that's the ultimate case.
591
00:32:12.099 --> 00:32:14.109
The case you were referring to that Aberdeen was.
592
00:32:14.140 --> 00:32:17.160
That relied on. The second....
593
00:32:18.019 -->
00:32:21.440
Showing that it's an alternative is that it is incorrect
594
00:32:21.700 --> 00:32:25.049
and harmful. Again, these are not supposed to be easy tests,
595
00:32:25.089 --> 00:32:26.650
and we don't want it. We don't think it should
596
00:32:26.670 --> 00:32:29.809
be an easy test, but we do think that, as
597
00:32:29.869 --> 00:32:34.430
I explained, Culleton is wrong. It's just incorrect because it.
598
00:32:34.789 --> 00:32:35.890
Relied on a.
599
00:32:38.029 --> 00:32:41.529
Wrong understanding of what the majority of courts held about
600
00:32:41.630 --> 00:32:45.720
an income tax and was based on the Aberdeen case,
601
00:32:45.759 --> 00:32:48.660
which was wrong. So we just think that the court
602
00:32:48.759 --> 00:32:52.109
needs to step back and look at these types of
603
00:32:52.450 --> 00:32:56.509
historical stuff that we talked about, look at what has
604
00:32:56.569 --> 00:33:00.529
happened to the other 48 states and the U.S. Supreme
605
00:33:00.609 --> 00:33:04.920
Court in terms of dealing with an income tax since 1930,
606
00:33:04.920 --> 00:33:09.430
and make a decision based on all those incidents matters,
607
00:33:09.750 --> 00:33:13.069
including the language of the 14th Amendment, and decide whether
608
00:33:13.190 --> 00:33:15.730
an income tax is covered by that or whether it's
609
00:33:15.769 --> 00:33:17.319
something else than a property tax.
610
00:33:17.890 --> 00:33:19.599
What would you say, Jackson, about the role of precedent
611
00:33:19.880 --> 00:33:21.000
in this particular case?
612
00:33:21.160 --> 00:33:24.079
I think precedent is incredibly important. And the fact that
613
00:33:24.099 --> 00:33:27.039
a precedent is old, I mean, Brown v. Board of
614
00:33:27.099 --> 00:33:30.240
Education was only decided about 20 years after this. And obviously,
615
00:33:30.279 --> 00:33:35.210
that's an incredibly important precedent. So the fact that a
616
00:33:35.230 --> 00:33:38.539
case has been around for a while you know, shouldn't
617
00:33:38.559 --> 00:33:41.329
cut one way or the other. I would say the
618
00:33:41.369 --> 00:33:43.430
court has said it's a high bar and that it's
619
00:33:43.569 --> 00:33:46.990
not something that should be done lightly. And there aren't
620
00:33:47.029 --> 00:33:50.910
two ways. There's two elements that someone has to establish.
621
00:33:51.009 --> 00:33:54.869
It has to be both incorrect and harmful. And it
622
00:33:54.970 --> 00:33:58.029
should be hard to do this. Like amending the Constitution,
623
00:33:59.029 --> 00:34:01.710
Paul was saying earlier that, you know, gosh, it's kind
624
00:34:01.730 --> 00:34:03.730
of hard to amend the Constitution. It should be hard.
625
00:34:03.819 --> 00:34:11.050
You that the state operates, that restrain policymakers. And it
626
00:34:11.150 --> 00:34:16.670
should be difficult to change those rules and guidelines in
627
00:34:16.730 --> 00:34:24.199
order to remove those restraints. So I think, you know,
628
00:34:25.440 --> 00:34:28.360
in terms of the importance of precedent, you know, I
629
00:34:29.300 --> 00:34:30.840
do want to make it clear, the U.S. Supreme Court
630
00:34:30.880 --> 00:34:34.280
has never overturned Culleton. And, you know, it is not
631
00:34:34.380 --> 00:34:38.929
unusual for cases cited in a particular opinion, maybe those
632
00:34:39.130 --> 00:34:43.349
are decided differently by other courts. But the core principle
633
00:34:43.449 --> 00:34:46.909
in Culleton has never been overturned by the U.S. Supreme Court.
634
00:34:46.929 --> 00:34:48.929
They wouldn't have a cause to review it. And it
635
00:34:48.969 --> 00:34:51.409
has been upheld multiple times by the state Supreme Court.
636
00:34:51.469 --> 00:34:54.670
And there is a reliance interest under the rule of law.
637
00:34:54.750 --> 00:34:57.829
As I said earlier, businesses and people have come to
638
00:34:57.869 --> 00:35:01.070
rely on that and the fact that they can They
639
00:35:01.110 --> 00:35:03.190
have certainty in the law and that we have this
640
00:35:03.250 --> 00:35:06.940
constitutional provision and it's been interpreted that way. And when
641
00:35:06.980 --> 00:35:13.019
you overturn that and change that, that has dramatic repercussions that, frankly,
642
00:35:13.039 --> 00:35:15.420
we're already starting to see with the passage of this
643
00:35:15.519 --> 00:35:20.199
income tax. This state is bleeding people and jobs. We
644
00:35:20.239 --> 00:35:23.219
have 7,500 fewer people here than there were a year
645
00:35:23.260 --> 00:35:26.909
ago last June. We have less people migrating to the
646
00:35:26.989 --> 00:35:31.030
state in terms of in-migration than during the pandemic. And
647
00:35:31.230 --> 00:35:35.250
thousands of companies are fleeing the state. And so I
648
00:35:35.289 --> 00:35:37.849
would argue that the harm of having an income tax
649
00:35:37.889 --> 00:35:41.980
and the threat of overturning that precedent is actually far
650
00:35:42.059 --> 00:35:44.719
greater than any benefit from having an income tax.
651
00:35:45.699 --> 00:35:50.179
Paul Lawrence, one of the arguments with respect to the
652
00:35:50.260 --> 00:35:53.710
ballot measure is that this is the camel's nose under
653
00:35:53.750 --> 00:35:55.929
the tent. It's a tax on people making more than
654
00:35:55.969 --> 00:35:58.590
a million dollars a year today. But if it's upheld,
655
00:35:59.650 --> 00:36:01.880
they're going to come for people making less than a
656
00:36:01.880 --> 00:36:09.079
million dollars next. So that's a political argument. But I
657
00:36:09.099 --> 00:36:12.280
could also imagine that if we're talking about harm and
658
00:36:12.320 --> 00:36:14.429
how you define that, that maybe Rob McKenna stands up
659
00:36:14.449 --> 00:36:18.050
in the Supreme Court and says, look, if you uphold this,
660
00:36:18.690 --> 00:36:21.489
you're essentially opening up the doors to an income tax
661
00:36:21.550 --> 00:36:26.889
on every Washingtonian, not just wealthy Washingtonians. That could be
662
00:36:26.929 --> 00:36:30.210
viewed as a form of harm. certainly seems, you know,
663
00:36:30.269 --> 00:36:33.590
I could see him also saying that's a policy decision that,
664
00:36:33.840 --> 00:36:37.300
you know, has implications. So how are you thinking about
665
00:36:37.340 --> 00:36:40.380
that argument, which is that the supporters of this have
666
00:36:40.440 --> 00:36:43.460
designed this to get it before the Supreme Court to
667
00:36:43.519 --> 00:36:46.380
try to get Culleton overturned and to then impose a
668
00:36:46.409 --> 00:36:48.650
graduate income tax on all Washingtonians?
669
00:36:49.269 --> 00:36:52.369
Well, obviously speculation. There's no evidence of that.
670
00:36:53.170 --> 00:36:56.429
Governor Ferguson has said he would veto any additional tax,
671
00:36:56.510 --> 00:37:00.190
income tax, that was more expansive than this tax. So
672
00:37:01.510 --> 00:37:05.550
there's nothing, I don't think that there's anything there. But again, ultimately,
673
00:37:05.750 --> 00:37:09.739
what overturning the case would allow is the people to
674
00:37:09.800 --> 00:37:13.000
control their taxes. And if the people of Washington don't
675
00:37:13.019 --> 00:37:17.780
want an income tax, 649, sorry, 645, they can vote
676
00:37:17.860 --> 00:37:22.639
on it. And so I think that's where we're going
677
00:37:22.659 --> 00:37:24.630
to end up. And I think that's not a place
678
00:37:24.670 --> 00:37:26.969
of harm. That's a place of empowerment to the people
679
00:37:27.469 --> 00:37:31.320
of the state. The fact that this is a 100-year-old case,
680
00:37:32.139 --> 00:37:32.940
that doesn't mean anything.
681
00:37:33.000 --> 00:37:33.420
Brown v.
682
00:37:33.440 --> 00:37:38.809
Ford overturned a 100-year-old precedent in Dred Scott. So sometimes
683
00:37:39.289 --> 00:37:41.030
it's clearly the right thing to do, and we think
684
00:37:41.090 --> 00:37:43.550
it's clearly the right thing to do here and return
685
00:37:43.989 --> 00:37:47.650
the discussions about harm and policies and stuff to the
686
00:37:47.690 --> 00:37:48.489
people to decide.
687
00:37:48.670 --> 00:37:50.650
As an intervener in the Quinn case, which was the
688
00:37:50.670 --> 00:37:54.050
capital gains tax, is that case implicated here at all?
689
00:37:54.679 --> 00:37:57.199
other than the court did not use it as an
690
00:37:57.239 --> 00:37:58.679
opportunity to revisit Culleton?
691
00:37:59.400 --> 00:38:03.460
Yes, because I think one of the fundamental flaws in
692
00:38:04.519 --> 00:38:07.800
the thinking behind Culleton and the thinking about the people
693
00:38:07.820 --> 00:38:11.579
who are trying to support Culleton is the notion that
694
00:38:12.360 --> 00:38:16.079
income is being used as the basis for the taxation
695
00:38:16.179 --> 00:38:19.539
as opposed to the measure of the taxation. And that
696
00:38:19.579 --> 00:38:23.449
was the key argument in the Quinn case because obviously
697
00:38:23.489 --> 00:38:27.360
the capital gains tax is based on the net income
698
00:38:27.579 --> 00:38:33.179
that you gain from the sale of an asset. And so,
699
00:38:33.380 --> 00:38:35.380
and even the B & O tax, it's not a
700
00:38:35.469 --> 00:38:38.789
net thing, it's a sales, but again, it is money
701
00:38:38.829 --> 00:38:42.969
that's generated from an activity is being used as the
702
00:38:43.050 --> 00:38:46.340
way to measure what the tax will be. And so
703
00:38:46.429 --> 00:38:51.110
looking at income, it's really a measure of which is
704
00:38:51.170 --> 00:38:55.070
different than what is the fundamental underlying tax that's at issue.
705
00:38:55.170 --> 00:38:58.500
And I think that supports the notion, and I don't
706
00:38:58.519 --> 00:39:02.099
know the answer whether it's an excise tax, I think
707
00:39:02.119 --> 00:39:03.579
it could be an excise tax, but it could also
708
00:39:03.599 --> 00:39:08.099
be something unto itself. But the notion of it being
709
00:39:08.139 --> 00:39:12.289
an excise tax wrecks on the fact that we as
710
00:39:12.469 --> 00:39:15.530
a people rely on a lot of government services. We
711
00:39:15.550 --> 00:39:17.489
rely on police protection. We rely on all those things
712
00:39:17.510 --> 00:39:20.489
that come from government. So how are those things paid for?
713
00:39:21.340 --> 00:39:24.190
And if you are somebody who's expecting those services, can
714
00:39:24.230 --> 00:39:27.550
you measure a tax based on income? And I think
715
00:39:27.610 --> 00:39:31.019
Quinn answered that question, yes. So the fact that this
716
00:39:31.099 --> 00:39:33.800
is measured on net income doesn't tell us what is
717
00:39:33.840 --> 00:39:36.980
the basis of the tax, whether it's for the benefit
718
00:39:37.059 --> 00:39:39.679
of having, you know, the protection of the state, whether
719
00:39:39.699 --> 00:39:42.139
it's because this is not a piece of property that you,
720
00:39:42.469 --> 00:39:43.989
I'm not a piece of property that you can buy
721
00:39:44.030 --> 00:39:46.849
and sell, and I'm the one who's generating that income.
722
00:39:47.150 --> 00:39:48.429
There are a lot of different ways you can look
723
00:39:48.489 --> 00:39:51.510
at it, but it's, again, The vast majority, almost every
724
00:39:51.570 --> 00:39:54.409
other state's U.S. Supreme Court have come to this conclusion
725
00:39:54.449 --> 00:39:55.989
that it's not a property tax.
726
00:39:56.349 --> 00:40:01.690
What do you think of Jackson's view that the state may,
727
00:40:01.929 --> 00:40:04.559
the AG's office may bring up or may make the
728
00:40:04.639 --> 00:40:08.219
argument that the tax on people making more than a
729
00:40:08.219 --> 00:40:09.460
million dollars is in fact an excess tax?
730
00:40:09.500 --> 00:40:09.960
That's fine.
731
00:40:10.440 --> 00:40:11.679
Do you think that that's
likely, though?
732
00:40:12.079 --> 00:40:12.900
That they'll bring that up?
733
00:40:12.940 --> 00:40:13.159
Yeah.
734
00:40:13.239 --> 00:40:13.559
I think so.
735
00:40:13.599 --> 00:40:14.500
Or that that'll be an avenue of.
736
00:40:14.900 --> 00:40:15.480
I think because.
737
00:40:15.500 --> 00:40:16.739
And so then could it be like the Quinn case
738
00:40:16.760 --> 00:40:19.000
where if the court decided, well, yeah, we agree, then
739
00:40:19.019 --> 00:40:21.409
they don't have to revisit Colton once again?
740
00:40:21.989 --> 00:40:24.929
I think given the directness of this tax that it
741
00:40:25.090 --> 00:40:26.690
is calling itself.
742
00:40:26.789 --> 00:40:30.289
I mean, all these other cases, they....
743
00:40:30.630 --> 00:40:32.570
So that could be dispensed with fairly quickly. It might
744
00:40:32.590 --> 00:40:34.730
be an argument that's made, but maybe not get them
745
00:40:34.769 --> 00:40:35.150
very far.
746
00:40:35.389 --> 00:40:37.530
Yeah, I think you can hold... The fact that you
747
00:40:37.889 --> 00:40:39.300
would hold at the end of the day that this
748
00:40:39.380 --> 00:40:44.099
is an excise tax would require... require you to overturn Culleton.
749
00:40:45.079 --> 00:40:47.079
I want to ask you the same question about the
750
00:40:47.119 --> 00:40:49.980
Quinn case and kind of how it's implicated here, or
751
00:40:50.000 --> 00:40:50.519
to what extent.
752
00:40:51.300 --> 00:40:51.699
Glad to.
753
00:40:51.800 --> 00:40:55.159
I just want to respond briefly to the idea that
754
00:40:55.579 --> 00:40:58.579
the loss of jobs and the people moving from the
755
00:40:58.619 --> 00:41:01.760
state is speculation. It is not speculation. In the last
756
00:41:01.860 --> 00:41:05.519
few months, Starbucks has lost 104 jobs, T-Mobile 77 jobs.
757
00:41:05.599 --> 00:41:06.860
They've closed seven stores.
758
00:41:06.920 --> 00:41:07.400
Amazon, 2,000 jobs.
759
00:41:11.039 --> 00:41:13.519
So there are real people being harmed by the fact
760
00:41:13.559 --> 00:41:16.969
that this income tax is here. It's creating economic uncertainty.
761
00:41:16.989 --> 00:41:19.500
Do you attribute all of that to this as opposed to.
762
00:41:19.530 --> 00:41:21.610
Yeah, I mean, it's happening all over the tech industries
763
00:41:21.670 --> 00:41:24.889
in every state of the union. And also, what I
764
00:41:24.949 --> 00:41:27.130
said was speculative was the idea that this would lead
765
00:41:27.190 --> 00:41:29.190
to an income tax on people earning $ 100, 000 a year.
766
00:41:29.230 --> 00:41:34.300
They're fleeing to states that have a much more tax-favorable climate.
767
00:41:34.519 --> 00:41:39.809
And I don't think it's it can be doubted that Texas, Florida,
768
00:41:39.969 --> 00:41:43.210
and Tennessee are all benefiting tremendously, and you only need
769
00:41:43.230 --> 00:41:46.710
to hear from the CEOs of those companies as to
770
00:41:46.750 --> 00:41:49.849
why they're making those decisions. They've been very open about it,
771
00:41:49.909 --> 00:41:53.550
so it's the worst-kept secret in Olympia as to why
772
00:41:53.929 --> 00:41:56.650
that seems to be happening. As far as the Quinn case,
773
00:41:56.690 --> 00:42:01.230
I have the Quinn case here, and the Quinn court
774
00:42:01.289 --> 00:42:04.230
was very clear. They said, This tax, meaning the capital
775
00:42:04.269 --> 00:42:07.860
gains tax, is wholly unlike the broad-based net income taxes
776
00:42:07.900 --> 00:42:12.420
we previously invalidated under Culleton. Those taxes applied to the
777
00:42:12.619 --> 00:42:16.679
taxpayer's aggregate net income and were untethered to any specific
778
00:42:17.000 --> 00:42:21.690
taxable activity. Rather, the taxable incident was the receipt of
779
00:42:21.750 --> 00:42:25.050
income itself. I have the bill in Section 201 of
780
00:42:25.070 --> 00:42:30.710
the bill, 6346, It says, beginning January 1st of 2028,
781
00:42:30.690 --> 00:42:35.750
a tax is imposed on the receipt of Washington taxable income.
782
00:42:36.409 --> 00:42:42.769
So the state legislature directly used the language in the
783
00:42:43.130 --> 00:42:46.360
Quinn case that they said fell under the Colleton case.
784
00:42:46.389 --> 00:42:49.119
So in order for the court to find that this
785
00:42:49.199 --> 00:42:53.280
is not an income tax, they would have to go
786
00:42:53.360 --> 00:42:57.199
contrary to their decision in 2023 and work around that.
787
00:42:57.320 --> 00:42:59.960
Well, and maybe that's another question then for you, Paul.
788
00:43:00.199 --> 00:43:04.820
Is there a scenario where the court does not overrule
789
00:43:05.119 --> 00:43:09.579
or modify Culleton and finds that this tax is constitutional?
790
00:43:09.699 --> 00:43:12.519
Or is the agreement going in the door that based
791
00:43:12.599 --> 00:43:16.239
on current precedent and presuming this isn't an excise tax,
792
00:43:16.679 --> 00:43:18.619
that it isn't constitutional?
793
00:43:18.780 --> 00:43:20.360
So there are two things to consider.
794
00:43:20.639 --> 00:43:22.519
One, the courts can say whatever they want to say
795
00:43:22.760 --> 00:43:25.800
and regardless of what the intent of the legislature was
796
00:43:25.860 --> 00:43:28.300
here But I think it's very clear that the intent
797
00:43:28.340 --> 00:43:32.320
of the legislature was to adopt a tax that would
798
00:43:32.440 --> 00:43:36.989
bring into question the Culleton case. Could the court find
799
00:43:37.030 --> 00:43:40.230
a way to avoid it? Constitutional avoidance is a fundamental
800
00:43:40.590 --> 00:43:43.429
premise of the courts. We'll avoid constitutional questions if we can,
801
00:43:43.769 --> 00:43:46.269
and maybe they'll see a way to do that. But
802
00:43:46.389 --> 00:43:50.960
I think this is the most clear effort to raise
803
00:43:51.219 --> 00:43:54.380
the viability of Culleton than there has been since Culleton
804
00:43:54.400 -->
00:43:55.019
was adopted.
805
00:43:55.610 --> 00:43:59.449
And then do you, on your side, if the court
806
00:44:00.699 --> 00:44:07.900
agrees and invalidates this, does that mean that Washington can
807
00:44:07.940 --> 00:44:12.210
never impose? An income tax? A graduated income tax?
808
00:44:12.289 --> 00:44:13.889
Well, a graduated income tax.
809
00:44:13.929 --> 00:44:16.010
They can impose an income tax tomorrow. They can do
810
00:44:16.030 --> 00:44:16.530
a flat tax.
811
00:44:16.650 --> 00:44:19.010
They could do as long as it was 1% applied
812
00:44:19.070 --> 00:44:22.719
to everyone. Then they could pass an income tax tomorrow,
813
00:44:22.780 --> 00:44:25.840
which would probably generate quite a bit of income, despite
814
00:44:25.880 --> 00:44:31.179
the fact that they've had double-digit budget increases over the
815
00:44:31.199 --> 00:44:34.170
last 10 years. So, no, they can do the tax.
816
00:44:34.289 --> 00:44:36.909
If they don't like the current restraints in the language
817
00:44:36.949 --> 00:44:39.510
of the Constitution, you amend the Constitution.
818
00:44:39.750 --> 00:44:42.309
You just said something interesting, which was you mentioned the
819
00:44:42.489 --> 00:44:45.469
Quinn Court. You were referring to the justices who decided
820
00:44:45.510 --> 00:44:49.280
that decision. We're about to have not just an election
821
00:44:49.519 --> 00:44:52.739
on this particular tax, but for several seats that are
822
00:44:52.800 --> 00:44:55.400
up on the Supreme Court. I'm going to ask you
823
00:44:55.420 --> 00:44:59.239
to sort of put on your legal analyst hats, I guess,
824
00:44:59.300 --> 00:45:03.619
here and ask the question– What does the potential for
825
00:45:03.659 --> 00:45:06.610
a very different court than the court that decided the
826
00:45:06.639 --> 00:45:09.210
Quinn case mean for this case? I know you can't
827
00:45:09.250 --> 00:45:10.510
predict who's going to be in the court or how
828
00:45:10.530 --> 00:45:12.909
that will decide, but it's a wild card in this
829
00:45:12.949 --> 00:45:15.050
where we can't just look at the court and say, well,
830
00:45:15.090 --> 00:45:17.829
we kind of know how they might lean or how
831
00:45:17.849 --> 00:45:20.409
they might go. It's going to be a new court.
832
00:45:20.449 --> 00:45:22.750
So what does that do for the plaintiffs in this case?
833
00:45:23.340 --> 00:45:26.440
Yeah, I think democracy is a beautiful thing, and the
834
00:45:26.480 --> 00:45:29.500
fact that we have elected justices, I think that was
835
00:45:29.519 --> 00:45:35.159
a great way to have those offices selected under our
836
00:45:35.199 --> 00:45:37.940
state constitution. I think the fact that we have the
837
00:45:37.960 --> 00:45:41.969
first time that I'm aware of in state history since 1889,
838
00:45:41.969 --> 00:45:44.909
a majority of the court on the ballot because of
839
00:45:45.050 --> 00:45:50.880
retirements and some appointments is an extraordinary opportunity for citizens
840
00:45:50.920 --> 00:45:54.179
of the state to make sure that the current justices
841
00:45:54.260 --> 00:45:57.159
reflect their values in light of the important cases that
842
00:45:57.199 --> 00:46:00.800
get decided. And I think it's healthy that there is
843
00:46:00.840 --> 00:46:02.820
a debate about the role of the courts and the
844
00:46:02.880 --> 00:46:07.840
importance that they have in our constitutional system. So, you know,
845
00:46:08.539 --> 00:46:11.429
I think that this is a great thing. Ultimately, as
846
00:46:11.469 --> 00:46:15.860
I pointed out, assuming I disagree a little bit with
847
00:46:15.900 --> 00:46:17.780
Paul in that the court can do whatever it wants.
848
00:46:17.800 --> 00:46:20.539
I mean, the court is bound by precedent. It should
849
00:46:20.579 --> 00:46:23.599
be applying at precedent. The personnel on the court should
850
00:46:23.639 --> 00:46:27.800
not really change the decisions that much if the court
851
00:46:27.860 --> 00:46:30.550
is doing its job and applying the law and the
852
00:46:30.610 --> 00:46:33.230
facts that are before it in the plain language of
853
00:46:33.250 --> 00:46:38.349
the Constitution. And the fact that in 2023 in Quinn,
854
00:46:40.190 --> 00:46:43.329
none of the Supreme Court justices were interested in overturning
855
00:46:43.369 --> 00:46:46.599
that precedent. I think, is significant.
856
00:46:47.139 --> 00:46:48.980
What do you think about this potential for a very
857
00:46:49.039 --> 00:46:51.260
different court to show up in January?
858
00:46:51.570 --> 00:46:52.239
We tend to agree.
859
00:46:52.280 --> 00:46:55.010
I can say we agree on this point, that this
860
00:46:55.110 --> 00:46:57.809
is an unique opportunity, and it is a great thing.
861
00:46:58.130 --> 00:47:01.369
Washington has this long history of election of judges, and
862
00:47:02.929 --> 00:47:06.449
I think there's been a history of people paying not
863
00:47:06.489 --> 00:47:08.610
enough attention to those elections in the past. People are
864
00:47:08.630 --> 00:47:12.389
paying attention this year. and they should look at what
865
00:47:12.409 --> 00:47:16.260
are the judicial philosophies, what are the qualifications, what are
866
00:47:16.320 --> 00:47:22.599
the experiences that these candidates have, and have that guide
867
00:47:22.619 --> 00:47:24.460
their vote. I don't think they should be trying to
868
00:47:24.539 --> 00:47:27.760
anticipate the decision in any one particular case like this
869
00:47:27.840 --> 00:47:32.190
case because many, many important issues come before the court,
870
00:47:32.570 --> 00:47:34.710
and it's important to have judges who are going to
871
00:47:34.789 --> 00:47:37.349
adhere to the rule of law who are going to
872
00:47:37.570 --> 00:47:42.369
bring some good life experience to their perceptions and their decisions,
873
00:47:43.070 --> 00:47:46.480
but do so without bias and do so in a
clear-headed,
874
00:47:46.760 --> 00:47:47.639
thoughtful way.
875
00:47:49.099 --> 00:47:53.019
What is the, as you think about this sort of
876
00:47:53.059 --> 00:47:55.400
the process, I mentioned at the beginning, I should have
877
00:47:55.500 --> 00:47:57.820
probably noted that this case was filed in Klickitat County
878
00:47:57.860 --> 00:48:02.510
in South Central Washington. I think some of the plaintiffs
879
00:48:02.769 --> 00:48:06.110
live down there, is that right? And then I said
880
00:48:06.130 --> 00:48:08.090
that the expert, this is where I was wondering if
881
00:48:08.139 --> 00:48:09.579
I was out over my ski tips a little bit,
882
00:48:09.619 --> 00:48:12.840
but the expectation is the trial judge will have to
883
00:48:12.880 --> 00:48:14.960
do something with this. Do you agree that summary judgment
884
00:48:15.019 --> 00:48:15.460
is likely?
885
00:48:15.800 --> 00:48:16.940
Oh, yeah.
886
00:48:17.679 --> 00:48:18.559
No reason to have a trial?
887
00:48:18.659 --> 00:48:23.769
There probably isn't because just any trial court, King County,
888
00:48:23.869 --> 00:48:26.789
no trial judge has the authority to overrule a state
889
00:48:26.809 --> 00:48:29.449
Supreme Court precedent. That's something that rests with the state
890
00:48:29.469 --> 00:48:30.070
Supreme Court.
891
00:48:30.090 --> 00:48:31.969
So we're going to get a decision today. out of
892
00:48:32.260 --> 00:48:33.119
Klickitat County.
893
00:48:33.139 --> 00:48:35.019
I don't think anyone is going to be surprised that
894
00:48:35.039 --> 00:48:37.820
they will strike the tax, and then that will have
895
00:48:37.840 --> 00:48:40.519
to go up to the state Supreme Court, and I'm
896
00:48:40.559 --> 00:48:41.480
sure they'll take the case.
897
00:48:42.059 --> 00:48:43.539
And skip the Court of Appeals.
898
00:48:43.800 --> 00:48:46.750
Yeah, I mean, not just because of the nature of
899
00:48:46.769 --> 00:48:49.510
the case, just one of the criteria that they apply
900
00:48:49.550 --> 00:48:55.070
when taking cases directly is, does a decision strike down
901
00:48:55.449 --> 00:48:57.809
a statute? That's a typical situation that would take a
902
00:48:57.840 --> 00:48:58.360
case directly.
903
00:48:58.679 --> 00:49:00.780
I'm glad to hear that Paul anticipates the trial court
904
00:49:00.800 --> 00:49:01.800
will strike down the tax.
905
00:49:01.940 --> 00:49:02.639
That's good.
906
00:49:02.940 --> 00:49:05.099
If I understood you correctly.
907
00:49:05.320 --> 00:49:07.429
I'm being... I don't think they have any choice.
908
00:49:08.219 --> 00:49:13.469
So we agree on that. And I do think as well, yeah,
909
00:49:14.090 --> 00:49:16.929
this is ripe for summary judgment. I don't think we're
910
00:49:16.949 --> 00:49:19.360
going to be dragging legislators to click a tab for
911
00:49:19.400 --> 00:49:21.659
a trial to find out what they intended to pass.
912
00:49:21.860 --> 00:49:26.699
Here's another question that I imagine people
are wondering is, okay, well,
913
00:49:26.760 --> 00:49:29.639
we've got this question on the ballot. Let's say voters
914
00:49:29.739 --> 00:49:34.150
repeal this tax in November. What happens to the lawsuit?
915
00:49:34.309 --> 00:49:37.489
What happens to the the legal side of this? Does
916
00:49:37.510 --> 00:49:39.750
this go away because now there's no tax to fight
917
00:49:39.809 --> 00:49:40.320
over anymore?
918
00:49:40.659 --> 00:49:44.059
Well, I think it'll be an interesting predicament for the
919
00:49:44.099 --> 00:49:46.880
Attorney General's office because technically they would be in a
920
00:49:46.920 --> 00:49:50.119
position of both defending the existing law and a challenge
921
00:49:50.159 --> 00:49:53.059
in our case, and then having to defend an initiative,
922
00:49:53.099 --> 00:49:57.650
which the AG's office does when it passes, which repeals
923
00:49:57.690 --> 00:50:00.460
the tax. So they would have to sort of argue
924
00:50:00.519 --> 00:50:03.159
both sides, assuming that there is some sort of legal
925
00:50:03.199 --> 00:50:04.059
challenge to the initiative.
926
00:50:04.099 --> 00:50:06.820
But do you think that the plaintiffs could still find
927
00:50:06.840 --> 00:50:14.360
a foundation, a reason for pursuing this if the tax disappears?
928
00:50:14.420 --> 00:50:16.039
Yeah, I mean, it would not.
929
00:50:16.059 --> 00:50:17.960
Standing is the word I was looking for.
930
00:50:17.980 --> 00:50:21.099
Yeah, I think you can still have standing because it's
931
00:50:21.139 --> 00:50:24.039
a matter of great public importance. And obviously, in light
932
00:50:24.079 --> 00:50:25.940
of the fact that with the stroke of the pen,
933
00:50:25.980 --> 00:50:29.050
the legislature can change the threshold... Of this tax, it
934
00:50:29.070 --> 00:50:31.530
would be great for the state to know whether or
935
00:50:31.570 --> 00:50:35.849
not these types of taxes are unconstitutional. So getting that
936
00:50:35.869 --> 00:50:38.750
clarification from the court, I think, would be very helpful. But,
937
00:50:39.269 --> 00:50:43.050
you know, assuming the initiative passes and then at that
938
00:50:43.090 --> 00:50:45.489
time we have to think through the strategy of the
939
00:50:45.510 --> 00:50:48.510
case and figure out what the best way to get
940
00:50:48.590 --> 00:50:50.650
the important issues resolved by the courts are.
941
00:50:50.920 --> 00:50:53.019
What do you think about this question? Again, if it
942
00:50:53.039 --> 00:50:55.699
were repealed at the ballot, not upheld, what happens?
943
00:50:55.719 --> 00:50:58.500
First of all, let's be clear. The initiative is not
944
00:50:58.539 --> 00:51:01.739
a strict repeal. It has other provisions in it, and
945
00:51:01.920 --> 00:51:04.300
so I think there are going to be real questions
946
00:51:04.380 --> 00:51:07.710
about the constitutionality of that initiative if it gets passed.
947
00:51:07.769 --> 00:51:10.130
We don't think it will get passed, but if it does.
948
00:51:10.610 --> 00:51:12.309
If it had been a straight repeal, then I think
949
00:51:12.349 --> 00:51:15.170
the question becomes a little bit more straightforward. But you're
950
00:51:15.190 --> 00:51:18.099
going to end up having, I guess, two lawsuits going on,
951
00:51:18.780 --> 00:51:21.650
one challenging the initiative, one challenging the tax.
952
00:51:22.130 --> 00:51:25.510
And why don't you just clarify when you say it's
953
00:51:25.550 --> 00:51:26.449
not a straight-up repeal?
954
00:51:27.110 --> 00:51:29.889
Well, you could have done this. I mean, there were,
955
00:51:30.210 --> 00:51:33.369
I don't know how many different variations of the initiative
956
00:51:33.409 --> 00:51:34.869
that were out there, but you could have done just
957
00:51:34.949 --> 00:51:38.449
a straight, this law is repealed, period. But instead, you
958
00:51:38.489 --> 00:51:41.670
have a partial repeal. So in other words, the 9.9%
959
00:51:41.670 --> 00:51:48.800
tax is repealed, but the other taxes that were reduced
960
00:51:48.820 --> 00:51:52.639
to help offset and make it fairer, those taxes are
961
00:51:52.659 --> 00:51:55.360
going to stay in place. And then there are additional
962
00:51:55.420 --> 00:51:59.949
provisions that are intending to create barriers to the adoption
963
00:51:59.989 --> 00:52:02.230
of anything that looks like an income tax that might
964
00:52:02.389 --> 00:52:07.230
actually impact the capital gains tax. It might impact many
965
00:52:07.250 --> 00:52:10.960
of the other taxes that are assessed by the state.
966
00:52:11.000 --> 00:52:13.000
So there are a lot of questions about 645 that
967
00:52:15.460 --> 00:52:17.579
will not have to be answered in court.
968
00:52:17.699 --> 00:52:21.880
But you're saying if 645 passes, you anticipate a challenge
969
00:52:21.920 --> 00:52:24.710
to that initiative? I do. And then where does that
970
00:52:24.809 --> 00:52:26.170
leave the case?
971
00:52:26.250 --> 00:52:28.230
That leaves two cases going on at the same time.
972
00:52:28.269 --> 00:52:30.130
And do you think that the case that they're bringing
973
00:52:31.750 --> 00:52:34.650
still has viability and that they'll still be standing for
974
00:52:34.690 --> 00:52:36.570
it and the court might still get to Culleton, even
975
00:52:36.590 --> 00:52:39.139
in a case where the tax on people making more
976
00:52:39.159 --> 00:52:40.699
than a million dollars is voted down by the people?
977
00:52:41.079 --> 00:52:43.980
I think that it is quite possible that they would
978
00:52:44.000 --> 00:52:47.400
still take that up. I mean, it's a controversial issue.
979
00:52:47.500 --> 00:52:48.159
Income tax.
980
00:52:48.219 --> 00:52:52.739
It's not one that they probably want to deal with politically.
981
00:52:52.820 --> 00:52:55.489
But I think given the fact that it's likely that
982
00:52:55.510 --> 00:52:57.949
there will be a challenge to 645 at the same time,
983
00:52:58.030 --> 00:53:00.150
it would still be viable for them to address it.
984
00:53:00.389 --> 00:53:02.750
I did just want to briefly say my organization is
985
00:53:02.829 --> 00:53:04.230
not involved with the initiative.
986
00:53:05.190 --> 00:53:06.150
We didn't draft that.
987
00:53:06.210 --> 00:53:07.250
We don't have any involvement.
988
00:53:07.329 --> 00:53:09.650
Fair enough. Let's just do 30 seconds each, kind of
989
00:53:09.690 --> 00:53:12.380
a closing statement. statement. Paul Lawrence, I'll start with you.
990
00:53:12.699 --> 00:53:14.599
What would you just want to leave us with as
991
00:53:14.619 --> 00:53:17.889
we think about Culleton, about this particular tax, and the
992
00:53:17.929 --> 00:53:18.989
court fight ahead?
993
00:53:19.090 --> 00:53:22.690
All we want is our Supreme Court to address actually
994
00:53:22.849 --> 00:53:26.690
what the people enacted in the 14th Amendment, and that
995
00:53:26.809 --> 00:53:30.769
hasn't happened in the court. Instead, the court has looked
996
00:53:31.050 --> 00:53:35.139
and misinterpreted a case, has looked at some precedent that's
997
00:53:35.159 --> 00:53:39.260
been overturned, and has put itself way out of step
998
00:53:39.420 --> 00:53:41.980
with the rest of the country. So we're just asking,
999
00:53:42.340 --> 00:53:45.159
let's have this addressed directly by the state Supreme Court
1000
00:53:45.239 --> 00:53:47.260
in a way that they've never done it before and
1001
00:53:47.300 --> 00:53:51.050
get an answer as to whether the 14th Amendment bars
1002
00:53:51.119 --> 00:53:51.889
an income tax.
1003
00:53:53.250 --> 00:53:57.010
Yeah, the income tax is bad law and bad policy.
1004
00:53:57.449 --> 00:54:02.610
It's bad law because it violates the state constitution. It
1005
00:54:02.690 --> 00:54:07.730
is not uniformly applied. It is not capped at 1%.
1006
00:54:07.730 --> 00:54:12.969
That is under the 100 years of precedent, clearly violative
1007
00:54:13.010 --> 00:54:15.639
of the state constitution. And it's bad policy because the
1008
00:54:15.679 --> 00:54:18.940
state is bleeding jobs and people as long as this
1009
00:54:19.440 --> 00:54:24.519
is pending. And we need to have it struck down
1010
00:54:24.860 --> 00:54:26.880
so that the law is clear. Okay.
1011
00:54:27.000 --> 00:54:28.940
I'm going to stop you there. Jackson Maynard, Executive Director
1012
00:54:28.960 --> 00:54:30.760
and Counsel, Citizen Action Defense Fund. Thank you so much
1013
00:54:30.780 --> 00:54:33.340
for coming in. Paul Lawrence, Senior Litigation Partner at Pacifica
1014
00:54:33.360 --> 00:54:35.400
Law Group. Thanks for making the trip down. Appreciate it.
1015
00:54:35.679 --> 00:54:37.889
And thank you for watching Inside Olympia. We will see
1016
00:54:37.929 --> 00:54:38.670
you again next week.