สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
WEBVTT
00:09.569 --> 00:12.198
Thanks for listening to the Hey Alicia podcast,
00:12.535 --> 00:16.302
where together we consider the truth of Christianity episode by episode,
00:16.446 --> 00:19.348
week by week. Regardless of where you are in your journey,
00:19.588 --> 00:23.099
whether you're someone who's not sure what's true about God, or maybe once believed but
00:23.599 --> 00:27.106
have since changed, I'm glad you've chosen a few minutes of your day to
00:27.123 --> 00:30.890
learn alongside me as we discuss Christianity and how
00:31.390 --> 00:34.412
it brings clarity to the the understanding of our existence, truth,
00:34.834 --> 00:37.995
and our current cultural topics. Don't forget to
00:38.495 --> 00:41.740
go to apologetics.org and submit your questions and comments. And welcome
00:42.050 --> 00:42.851
to Hey Alicia.
00:48.631 --> 00:52.210
Hello and welcome to the Hey Alicia podcast, where we take a few
00:52.259 --> 00:55.759
minutes to consider the case for Christianity. I'm your host,
00:55.824 --> 00:58.389
Emily Marasco, and in this episode,
00:58.665 --> 01:01.834
Alicia will be answering this question: how
01:02.334 --> 01:06.003
can Christians think their personal religious experiences with God
01:06.324 --> 01:10.252
are any more true than those of adherents to other belief
01:10.752 --> 01:14.453
systems? Yes. Okay, so this question
01:15.143 --> 01:19.681
of personal religious experiences and
01:19.793 --> 01:23.288
which one to believe, uh, is a great one.
01:23.946 --> 01:27.297
This is something that where people— it's phrased in a lot of ways.
01:27.490 --> 01:30.648
People say, well, I have this particular
01:31.148 --> 01:33.631
religion, and I have had this experience with God. So if you are a Mormon,
01:33.663 --> 01:37.110
for example, Mormons will have this experience with God that they refer
01:37.610 --> 01:40.317
to as this burning in the bosom, where they ask God, show yourself to me.
01:40.477 --> 01:44.069
Show me if you are real. Show me the truth about you
01:44.967 --> 01:48.366
versus the other religions. Show me this is the true religion. And they get this
01:48.415 --> 01:52.022
burning, this sense, this experience in their bosom that this is the
01:52.522 --> 01:56.079
true faith to follow. And other people will have other experiences.
01:56.672 --> 02:00.599
Around the world based on whatever religion they have that somehow this— they've connected
02:01.099 --> 02:03.901
with the spiritual, they've connected with the divine. And Christians wouldn't be any different in
02:03.949 --> 02:07.299
that way. So I do think that this is something— it's a good
02:07.315 --> 02:10.810
question because people would think,
02:10.922 --> 02:14.785
okay, if somebody has a religious experience and nobody else does, then that might
02:15.285 --> 02:18.792
say the person with the religious experience might be onto something. But if I'm
02:18.856 --> 02:22.014
finding that everybody's having religious experiences, then either
02:22.514 --> 02:26.391
something's wrong with the experiences Or the God or gods is playing games
02:26.891 --> 02:30.015
with everybody and making them think different things or whatever,
02:30.031 --> 02:33.510
just causing confusion. So let me just
02:34.504 --> 02:37.807
maybe lay a little bit of a framework here and just say, yes,
02:37.936 --> 02:40.950
I recognize that experiences are subjective.
02:41.560 --> 02:46.210
Okay? So if I have an experience with God that
02:46.274 --> 02:49.785
is very meaningful or special to me, it's going to be really hard
02:49.881 --> 02:53.105
for me to convince Emily of how, let's just say,
02:53.186 --> 02:56.636
amazing God is because I had this experience that just changed my
02:57.136 --> 02:59.348
view of him and I think he's amazing. It's going to be really hard for
02:59.848 --> 03:03.215
me to convince Emily of that same amazement.
03:04.098 --> 03:07.628
What I can do is share it with
03:08.128 --> 03:12.555
her. I can talk about it with her. I can try
03:12.844 --> 03:16.679
and describe it the best I can. And Emily can do her best to find
03:17.179 --> 03:20.834
connection there or to relate to it. Or to share in what I'm telling
03:20.850 --> 03:24.763
her, but she can't really get
03:24.796 --> 03:27.891
the full experience because it wasn't hers.
03:28.901 --> 03:32.013
Experiences are not transferable. And so
03:32.513 --> 03:35.685
it's really hard to get somebody to jump
03:35.766 --> 03:39.374
on and get as excited about experience as you. So here's just a simple example
03:39.454 --> 03:43.320
of that. Let's say that I
03:43.820 --> 03:46.976
was with some friends today and somebody told this super, super funny joke,
03:46.992 --> 03:50.361
right? And then we just all just crying laughing, just thought it was so,
03:50.377 --> 03:53.329
so funny. So then I see Emily later on in the day and I'm like,
03:53.345 --> 03:55.751
Emily, guess what? Let me tell you this joke that we heard today. And I
03:56.251 --> 03:59.505
tell it to her and she's like, oh, okay, yeah, that's pretty funny. But she's
04:00.005 --> 04:03.003
not— she's just being polite, you know? Yeah, that's funny. She doesn't really get it.
04:03.452 --> 04:06.019
What is the thing that we often say when this happens? Is we say,
04:06.099 --> 04:09.292
never mind, you just had to be there. Okay?
04:09.548 --> 04:12.998
In other words, this idea that I can only transfer
04:13.498 --> 04:16.253
my experience to you only but so much.
04:17.327 --> 04:20.132
In order for you to really capture this experience, you had to be there.
04:20.196 --> 04:23.707
In other words, the experience— you had to be part of the original experience.
04:24.364 --> 04:27.810
And so, yeah, so experiences are subjective. They don't transfer from one
04:27.907 --> 04:31.065
person to the next. And, and so we need to keep all that in mind
04:31.565 --> 04:34.639
when we're looking at this question. But we also need to keep in
Load full transcript
mind that
04:35.139 --> 04:38.518
experiences don't always convey truth. Okay,
04:39.112 --> 04:42.878
just because I had an experience does
04:43.006 --> 04:47.800
not mean that it is telling me— it's
04:48.300 --> 04:53.682
giving me full clarity of what might be there. So it is completely possible that,
04:53.924 --> 04:57.798
um, let's say I asked for a particular feeling about
04:57.814 --> 05:00.531
God and I get that feeling,
05:02.351 --> 05:06.934
but it may— I may think that's God But
05:07.367 --> 05:10.979
many Christians, me included, also believe that if there's God
05:11.479 --> 05:14.335
who's good, there's also something that is bad that exists.
05:15.314 --> 05:19.681
So that feeling may have actually happened, but it doesn't mean it came from the
05:20.181 --> 05:23.389
true God. It may have come from some sort of
05:23.517 --> 05:27.611
demonic, dark spiritual force. So just
05:28.111 --> 05:31.368
because I have an experience and I'm saying I want there, I want this
05:31.868 --> 05:35.315
experience or this feeling to tell me that the true God exists,
05:36.502 --> 05:40.030
there could be a demonic type force or spirit,
05:40.046 --> 05:43.990
spirit being that is actually swaying me in a different direction, giving me
05:44.490 --> 05:47.967
this feeling, making me think that it's the true and good divine, but it's
05:48.467 --> 05:53.035
actually the demonic. And this is why we've got to be really careful with experience,
05:53.275 --> 05:56.883
because experiences give us an indication that there is a
05:57.383 --> 06:01.181
supernatural, that there's something more than the natural physical world. It can
06:01.213 --> 06:04.946
tell us, it can, it can point that, okay, there's something that heard
06:05.059 --> 06:08.248
this prayer that I said in my head or this request I made in my
06:08.264 --> 06:12.126
head, and it has clearly responded to
06:12.626 --> 06:15.603
me. Okay, so it can give us this indication that there's a supernatural, but it
06:15.635 --> 06:19.801
doesn't necessarily give you clarity as to what in the supernatural
06:20.301 --> 06:23.423
gave you the experience. Was it demonic?
06:23.888 --> 06:27.846
Was it a divine good being? Was it
06:28.055 --> 06:30.972
a good being, a bad being, whatever words you want to use there?
06:31.885 --> 06:35.396
It doesn't give you the full revelation of
06:35.508 --> 06:39.323
where that actual feeling came from. And so this is
06:39.435 --> 06:42.737
why I would say that I would be hesitant to talk about a supernatural experience
06:43.987 --> 06:47.209
fully and 100% of the time pointing us to a
06:47.609 --> 06:50.975
greater truth that actually exists. And when I say truth, a greater
06:51.475 --> 06:55.126
capital T truth. So I'm hesitant to say that every experience that
06:55.626 --> 06:58.346
people go through, um, you know,
06:58.490 --> 07:01.727
that people, different people, all these different experiences around the world, I don't
07:02.227 --> 07:05.523
think that they're all pointing towards the same capital T truth.
07:06.036 --> 07:09.144
I think that some are pointing to the, to a capital T truth,
07:09.256 --> 07:12.893
and I think others are pointing more towards a demonic dark truth as
07:12.989 --> 07:16.401
well. And I don't talk much about that on the podcast. We don't get
07:16.785 --> 07:20.198
much in terms of the spiritual realm in terms of
07:20.698 --> 07:23.770
questions, but I definitely do believe in the, in the, in the dark and in
07:23.818 --> 07:28.855
the demonic and, you know, and these ideas of of spiritual
07:29.355 --> 07:33.046
beings that are in collaboration with God and spiritual beings that are at war
07:33.546 --> 07:36.836
with God. And the demonic obviously being at war with God.
07:37.479 --> 07:40.642
So I think the supernatural experience can help us recognize that there's something
07:40.674 --> 07:44.143
supernatural there, but I think we still need to do the legwork to find out
07:45.412 --> 07:48.913
what actually is there. And so now you're back to the same thing
07:48.961 --> 07:52.414
as which God is it? Okay, if you've had an experience and there's some
07:52.914 --> 07:55.883
pointing to some sort of supernatural, then the next question is what supernatural being?
07:57.294 --> 08:00.884
Is out there? Um, was the feeling I got from a
08:00.980 --> 08:04.907
good being or from a bad being? Uh, what is— how can I
08:05.407 --> 08:08.273
figure out what is true? How can I figure out what direction I'm going with?
08:08.353 --> 08:11.687
Like, you know, like, these are going to be your classic questions of like,
08:11.703 --> 08:14.636
how do you know God exists? How do you know which God is real?
08:15.165 --> 08:18.451
How do you know what religion is true? How do you know
08:18.951 --> 08:22.378
what text is accurate, etc., etc., etc.? So I would say
08:22.442 --> 08:25.618
the, the experience that you may have with God gives an indication of
08:25.650 --> 08:28.026
a supernatural, but I think you still need to do,
08:29.504 --> 08:33.711
uh, some sort of quest for truth that
08:34.211 --> 08:37.789
is not based on a subjective type thing such as an
08:38.289 --> 08:41.402
experience. Hopefully that makes some sense. So we always want to
08:41.466 --> 08:44.068
remind you guys that, you know, if you ever have a question about something I
08:44.568 --> 08:48.114
say or you disagree with something I say, submit those Say Whats. I love hearing
08:48.130 --> 08:51.759
from people, and so feel free to submit those and challenge me or give
08:52.259 --> 08:55.610
me some different perspectives maybe that I hadn't thought about. So definitely feel free to
08:56.110 --> 08:59.930
do that. Just go to apologetics.org and you can fill out the form and
09:00.430 --> 09:02.530
make sure you mark it as a Say What so that we can know that
09:03.030 --> 09:06.870
that's what you're doing. So yeah, so hopefully some bits in there were really helpful
09:07.370 --> 09:08.710
to you, and we'll see you next time on Hey Alicia.
09:12.780 --> 09:16.610
Thank you for tuning in to Hey Alicia, where we take a
09:17.110 --> 09:20.610
few minutes to consider the case for Christianity. To submit your questions
09:21.110 --> 09:24.277
and comments, go to apologetics.org or click the link in in the show