สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
00:00:23
Speaker 1: Welcome one and all to the Hammer Territory Podcast. My name is Sean Coleman. Hope wherever you are and wherever you are listening, I hope that you are having a great week. Part of me wanted to see the offseason start today. Part of me wanted to see, hey, a better World Series. But overall, the Brewers and the Rays are playing a pretty competitive World Series, even though it seems the Brewers are on the brink of winning their first World Series title. And of course, when they do, that means that everybody's offseason is going to be underway. Many teams are going to hit the ground running. But for each team, I think they have their offseason plan. But there may be one or two hypotheticals that they may not consider to actually be realistic, but in the right scenario could come true. We're going to discuss one of those hypotheticals today when it comes to the Braves and their offseason. And of course, here with us, one of the best when it comes to breaking down the Braves, Stephen Tolbert. Stephen, good to see you again, sir. Yeah, what's up, buddy?
00:01:14
Speaker 2: So people will probably be able to tell by the title. of this video and the thumbnail that we used. Now we are going to talk about a hypothetical. Brad and Scott did kind of a similar show on Sunday where they broke down. You know, somebody had asked, is it time to rebuild? And the guys, again, while we're waiting for the offseason to start, we're kind of doing a few of these hypotheticals. Was it time to start a rebuild? And so today we're going to do a very similar hypothetical, a question that we've gotten a bunch, especially since the postseason ended. Is it time to trade Ronald? And, you know, that's going to be a shocking probably question to some. And there are parts of it that are pretty outlandish. And there are parts of it that do make some sense. And so what we're going to do today is just kind of go through the list of reasons why it might make sense and reasons why it doesn't. And just kind of let you guys decide which one you think is the most accurate.
00:02:10
Speaker 1: And I think the more reasonable question is, is it time to trade Ronald? That's what we're going to discuss. I think it's more than clear it's time to talk to Ronald. And that is where this whole scenario kind of stems from. Ronald Acuna Jr. has two years left on his deal that he signed years ago with the Braves. That breaks down to two $ 17 million team options. One for 2027, one for 2028. You have to think that neither.
00:02:37
Speaker 1: Or a no-brainer, barring another catastrophic injury. But the reason why I say that talks need to happen now is because the Braves need to really get more certainty on whether or not they see a future with Ronald Acuna Jr. We'll talk about that a little bit later on in the show. I think that there are more reasons to than not really explore that to see maybe if an extension makes sense or what have you. But the other thing that comes from these talks is that If you either don't feel good about the physical future of Robert Petunia Jr., or you get the sense from him that he's just going to ask for a number that the Braves are just not comfortable coming anywhere close to, With two years left on his deal, now is the time to, if it's pretty clear that there's not going to be an extension, right now probably from a financial standpoint is where Ronald carries the most value since he has two years left. So I'm not saying that that creates the reason to trade him. I'm just saying that I feel that that brings logic. Once you talk with him and kind of gather more information on what a future may look like, then if another team comes calling and it makes sense, Maybe the logic's there to get something done.
00:03:50
Speaker 2: Yeah. So we're kind of going to do the case for in the first segment and do the case against in the second segment. So if you're trying to build a case for like, you know, somebody comes to you and says, Hey, create me the absolute best argument you can create to trade Ronald Acuna Jr. This is how I would start it. Ronald is in that kind of sweet spot in terms of his contract where he You know, when he first signed his contract, it was for so long and for so cheap that he was honestly the number one trade value asset in all of baseball. In fact, Fangraphs has a trade value series they do every year. And Ronald spent almost the entirety of his career as like number one or two on that list. Almost to the point where he was such a valuable asset, he was almost untradeable because there was no team that really had enough to even, you know, even tempt you into it. But now as we've gotten through most of Ronald's contract, he's got two years left, both team options, still very cheap. And because Ronald's dealt with injuries, we've kind of entered this sweet spot where he's still got positive trade value. I think when they did the list this year, he came in at like 43 on the list. So still a very positive trade value asset where you would get a lot in return, but he's not so insanely valuable that it's not even possible to even contemplate it. And because you only have two years of team control left, if you don't feel like you can get an extension done, then you can have that conversation where he's not a one-year rental yet, which was going to cut his value in a trade scenario. He's still got two years. And then the other case you would make is if you were concerned about the injuries, if you were concerned that the injuries are going to cause Ronald to age, at a faster rate than maybe the number says he's going to. Like Ronald's still under 30. He's still on the right side at 30, but his lower half has gone through so much. His injuries have been so significant that it is possible that he's going to age quicker than other people that are his same age, right? So, and if you don't feel like you're going to get an extension done, if you don't feel like Ronald's going to age
Load full transcript
well, and listen, it needs to be said at this point in the show, You know, outfield is not a place where people grow old in baseball. Outfield is a place where you put young, athletic, you know, strong defender. Like, you don't see a lot of old outfielders. It's just not a place where people age. As people age in baseball, they usually move to the infield, right? We've seen Bryce Harper move to the infield. We've seen Mookie Betts move to the infield. So, like, it's tough to have somebody aging in right field. You know, the defense is already kind of a question that you ask on a yearly basis with Ronald. And if the legs take any more injuries, you know, there is a world where it does make sense, right? Where his value is still high enough where you can get something significant for him. But the questions are also legitimate enough where you have to wonder, is our best move to potentially move one of these guys? And we've said the core of the team is already getting stale, right? Maybe you do it as a way to shake things.
00:07:05
Speaker 3: Up, right?
00:07:06
Speaker 2: You know that again, we will, I'll lay out kind of my against reasons in the second half of the show. But if you said Steven make the best case possible for doing it, those are the reasons I would start with the injuries, the contract, the fact that he still has value. The fact that the core does probably need something new, something, you know, injected into it. That's not as quite as stale. That's probably where I would start my argument.
00:07:32
Speaker 1: And the other part of it is that the Braves probably need to change course a bit when it comes to how they handle their star-to-superstar-level free agents that move on to other teams. When you think of examples of that since the World Series run, Freddie Freeman after the 21 season, you've got Danza B. Swanson after the 22 season, and Max Green after the 24 season. When the Braves did good to handle the departure of Freddie Freeman, they got Matt Olsen. But what are our two... arguably our two biggest needs right now. It's shortstop and another legit top of the order rotation member. We've not been able to, you know, you don't necessarily look to replace Stansby, but we've not found a long-term solution. You don't necessarily look to replace Max directly, but if you're not going to sign him, you look to find something that, you know, could fill that gap. And the Braves have not done that for either Swanson or Freed's departure. Again, I'm not sitting here discussing whether or not they should have resigned him, but they've not been successful in finding suitable replacements for them. And so with Ronald Acuna Jr., when it comes to these free agents, you really come down to three questions. Do I consider this person a part of my future? If not, do I potentially move on from them before they move to free agency to get value for them? And what is my plan to replace their production once they've gone? I don't think the Braves can afford for the answer to all three of those questions when it comes to Ronald Acuna Jr. to be no. So if the answer is no to him being a part of your future, then you certainly need to try to look into getting value for him now because did that help answer the third question, how are you going to replace his production once he's moved on?
00:09:13
Speaker 4: Yeah.
00:09:14
Speaker 2: And another part of it is, you know, and we won't know until they say something about it, but like internally, like what do they think of Eric Hartman?
00:09:23
Speaker 3: Right.
00:09:24
Speaker 2: Because Eric Hartman's an outfielder. They have a center fielder who's locked up for the next like six or seven years. You know, do they believe Hartman's position of the future is right field, which right now it certainly looks like it would be. He's the Braves number one prospect. He's still probably a year away. So the timeline doesn't work out perfectly. And we've talked about Hartman before, about how he struggled in AA once he got there. And in 2027 is probably not a wise, you know, best guess for when he's going to make an impact. But there, you know, the fact of the matter is the best prospect they have in their entire minor league series. is almost certainly going to play right field when he comes up. So that matters. That's part of the discussion. But more than anything with Ronald, he still has enough value now where a trade would make sense, where you would get a lot of positive value back, which is not the case for a lot of the guys on their team.
00:10:20
Speaker 4: Right?
00:10:21
Speaker 2: Austin Riley is not, you know, one thing a lot of fans do is they say, you know, if somebody's bad, trade them, but that's not how it works. Teams don't want your bad players. They want your good players and teams certainly don't want your bad players on bad contracts like Riley. So, you know, in order to get value back, you actually have to trade somebody while their trade value is still in the surplus. It's still in the green instead of in the red. So, Ronald is still there. Even though people think Ronald had a disastrous season, Ronald just put up a 120 WRC plus. He had 20 stolen bases. He had 20 homers. He did not have a good postseason. And that's got a lot of people in their feelings about Ronald. And that's one of the reasons we've been asked this question about 6,000 times since the playoffs ended. But around the league, Ronald still has a lot of positive value. So you would get a really good return. So you have to ask, is that good return worth If I'm not going to resign him, and only the Braves know the answer to that, only the Braves know where they are in that logic, are we going to try to resign him? If they know for a fact that they're not, that they're too scared of the injuries, and they have another right fielder potentially coming down the pipe pretty soon, if you know you're not, and the guy you're potentially looking to trade does have a pretty
strong amount of trade value right now, you do have to at least consider it. You do have to at least explore it. I'm not saying the Braves are going to do it because, again, we're going to have a whole second half of this show of us explaining why we wouldn't do it. But there is an argument to be made that if you're not going to re-sign him and he still has a lot of positive trade value right now, that you do probably at least need to explore what it would look like.
00:12:04
Speaker 1: If re-signing him is not part of the future, then the reality shifts to how can you use him in the present to get most value? Is that over the next two years you clearly feel that keeping him is what's going to give you the best chance to be able to make a World Series run? Or do you look at a more long-term focus and you're like, hey, he's provided what he's provided. We can't thank him enough, but if he's not part of the future, we feel the best move for our future is getting future value for him now while he still is certainly an attractive player now. for a team that may overpay. And a couple of things to this as we end this segment. I want to position it to where when we say we see the logic in it, when we say that it's at least a consideration, again, this doesn't mean Alex Adopolis and the Braves are calling teams to gouge interest in Ronald Acuna Jr. This is if a team comes calling and they're willing to overpay, then the Braves should at least be open to it if they don't feel Ronald Acuna Jr. is a part of their future. That is, I feel, a parameter that I want to put on this. That's kind of where we stand. But we've discussed the logic. potentially looking at trading Ronald Acuna Jr., but does it really make sense? Is it more sensible to keep him and move forward with what you got? More on that in just a moment after a word from our partners.
00:13:18
Speaker 4: Seat Geek is the official ticket marketplace for Major League Baseball. And anytime you want to go to a game, you should go to Seat Geek. I used to call the director of team travel. I used to call the traveling secretary, whatever they want to be called, KP, to try to get a seat. But on Seat Geek, I can pick my own seat and I can pick where I want to sit instead of being told where to sit.
00:13:37
Speaker 3: Yeah, it's a great option. And summer is coming to an end here soon. I'm going out and finding all the day games possible, all the warm weather cities. So I could stay in this tank top. I can watch very competitive baseball. As the calendar turns into fall, I want to make sure that I get the most out of this tank top and warm weather. And SeatGeek is where I would go and get my seats.
00:14:02
Speaker 4: You can use code TERRITORY10 for 10% off your next set of MLB tickets at SeatGeek. That's 10% off MLB tickets with promo code TERRITORY10. Make sure you click the link in the description to download the app and have the code automatically added to your account so you can use it later.
00:14:19
Speaker 1: So now that we've applied the logic in, you know, at least the team having reason to consider in the right scenario looking to move on from Ronald Acuna Jr., let's discuss why it makes sense to keep him. And I think that it starts very easily. What it comes down to, I for years now have mentioned that to me the biggest single factor in the Braves truly being a contender is Ronald Acuna Jr. being Ronald Acuna Jr. Now, The frequency of that occurring has dwindled. It's lessened in recent years. And unfortunately, it also has not showed up in the playoffs. All of that is true. But we have discussed ad nauseum for years now, and going into this offseason, again to quote Stephen Tolbert, The certainty of the offense is more of a concern than the uncertainty of the pitching staff. The future certainty of the offense is more unsettling than the future uncertainty of the pitching staff. And it's an absolute true case. So to me, it comes down to one question. If the clear top need for this team is additional quality offense, why would you then look to move your singular most impactful source of offense and someone who that has continued to prove when healthy again, since the start, since he returned from his ACO injury for all batters with over 800 plate appearances, Ronald is ninth to WRC plus since the start of 2025. Why would you trade your singular most impactful source of offense when it's offense that you clearly need to add this off season?
00:15:57
Speaker 4: Yeah.
00:15:58
Speaker 2: So, Again, on the flip side, if somebody came to me and said, all right, Steven, make the very best case you can for not trading Ronald, the first place I would start. And I don't really get into the emotional side of he's the star player, fans love him. That stuff doesn't really register with me because I don't think teams can make decisions based on that. Just from a pure black and white baseball sense, not only is offense the biggest need for the Braves right now, which I think we've covered quite a bit. It's my number one concern. But offense from the right-handed side of the plate is a massive concern for this team right now. So, you know, Austin Riley has just fallen off a cliff. Sean Murphy is just not the hitter you hoped he would be when you made that trade a few years ago. You know, your next three best hitters, Baldwin, Olsen, Michael Harris, are all left-handed. Ozzie is not getting any younger. You know, you don't have a set shortstop, you know, a right-handed... Like, you don't have much at all from the right-handed side of the plate. So not only do you need offense in this lineup, but you need a right-handed offense. So if that is the case, if your number one need is right-handed offense, then trading Ronald Acuna Jr. is kind of batshit crazy, to be honest with you. Unless what you're getting back includes more than what you're sending out in terms of not just value, but specifically right-handed offense, I don't know how you could justify it. you know, again, Ronald had a down year in 2026 and he had a 120 WRC plus. I want to make sure I'm clear about that. Ronald had a down year, a down year, and he had a 120 WRC plus. Michael Harris had one of the best years of his career last year and he had a 121 WRC plus. That's the difference in expectations we're talking about. Matt Olson had a 122 WRC plus last year. So Ronald almost had the best on the team and this was a down year for him. So like, The potential, not only the talent, but the potential of Ronald is just so unbelievably high, even with the injuries. Again, I mean, it was only last year, 2025, where he put up like a 160. So the potential is still there. You would be selling low on Ronald because he's coming off one of his worst seasons, which again is still better than most guys' average or best seasons. you know, so you're not exactly selling high on an asset that you've had for a long time, whose value has been much higher than it is right now. So, you know, from that perspective, just from a pure like value perspective, it doesn't make sense to pull that trigger at the moment. You know, if that's something like you even want to explore, just, you know, theoretically you could at least wait till like the all-star break, or you could wait till the trade deadline, or you could wait till next off season and trade him as a rental. If you really don't feel like you have any chance of resigning him, you know, I can make a case for all of those things make more sense than trading him right now. When your number one concern is right-handed offense, you need right-handed offense. And honestly, you're not the only one because if you look around baseball, Right-handed hitters had a weird year in 2026. Like it was weird that so many of the best hitters in baseball were left-handed and so many right-handed hitters who typically have good years struggled. So, you know, that is an argument for why trading in might make sense because so many teams need right-handed hitting, but why it doesn't make sense is because you're one of the teams that need, right? You need more of it. You don't need less of it. So, you know, again, I know he's everybody's favorite player. I know he sells a million jerseys, but even outside and above all that, just purely from a baseball perspective, purely from a building, a lineup perspective, trading Ronald Acuna Jr. would, would, I, I would have a hard time believing that it would actually help more than it would hurt. I think it would hurt significantly more because he does the thing you need the most at the moment.
00:20:04
Speaker 1: The second thing that stands out to me, Stephen, is finding a deal that makes sense from the Braves' perspective. It would be so hard to find because there's so many factors that have to be in place, so many boxes that have to be checked for a deal to make sense. Number one, if you're trading Ronald Acuna Jr., it's clearly not the Braves waving the flag and saying, hey, It's
time to rebuild. That would clearly not be their goal. Their goal would be to not change where they are in terms of the expected contender tiers when you go into next season. But with that being said, it's very hard to imagine there being many teams who would be able to trade the level of Major League talent that it would take to get Ronald Acuna Jr. and yet still have it make sense on their end to trade for him. Why would I trade a bunch of major league talent to the Braves for Ronald Acuna Jr. when I'm trying to add him to what I've already got to be a contender? That's from another team's perspective. So there's that box that would be hard to check. And the Braves are wanting value. They're wanting as much value as possible if they trade Ronald Acuna Jr. A lot of that would be coming from prospects. So unless you have a team that is just ready to overpay, I know that I've seen Seattle being an example that a few teams have used, and I could see that. But you would have to have significant major league talent coming back, like multiple players who feel needs for the Braves coming back, plus significant minor league talent. for it to make sense from the Braves' perspective. And that should be the case. The Braves should, if they're going to look to trade Ronald Acuna Jr., they should. And I know that his trade value is a bit down because of performance and injuries and things like that. But if they're looking to trade him, they're going to sit there and focus on what he can do when he's healthy. And I don't think they expect just to get an absolute haul, but they're going to want significant major league talent in return, plus also some future value as well. And that's just very hard to find anywhere. from teams out there who are looking to acquire him. So the second thing that stands out to me is that if it just seems like it's too hard to make something work, a lot of the time that means that you shouldn't make it work and you should go with what you got. Yeah.
00:22:17
Speaker 2: So trading away major league talent while trying to contend is a very tough needle to thread. Most teams don't do it. You know, Milwaukee is probably the most famous example of a team that does it consistently. They traded away Freddy Peralta. They traded away Corbin Burns. They traded away Josh Hader. They've traded away a bunch of stars and have basically contended the whole way through. They do it because of payroll limitations. They have to, basically. The Rays do it as well, but again, for the same reason. Teams like the Braves, who spend a ton of money, don't typically do this. They don't trade away Major League talent while contending. And Nishan just laid out the reason. if you're trading to a team, they're trying to add major league talent. So they don't want to give away any major league talent. They want to give you prospects. But if your team like the Braves trying to contend, you don't want prospects. You want team, you want somebody that's going to help
you win this year because you have a 37 year old ace, right? You have one of the oldest teams in baseball. And that's, that's my next big reason why it doesn't make sense. The Braves have one of the oldest teams in baseball, right? This is not the time to be subtracting from your major league team. This is the time to be adding to your major league team. And you don't have the, you know, they're not in a position where there can even like really, you know, even kind of pivot because again, the best player on their team right now is 37 year old ace Chris sale. So you have to squeeze whatever value and however many wins you can get out of probably the next year or two, honestly, probably 2027, 2028 is when is probably the longest you can expect Chris sale to still be at this level. That might even be too long. It might just be 2027. Um, you know, you're kind of on Chris's timeline. And as long as Chris is the best player on this team, like he was last year, then your timeline needs to match up with that. And that means there's no rebuilding. There's no resetting right now. In a couple of years, we could have that conversation. But of course, by that time, Acuna will be, you know, either a free agent or signed to an extension. We'll see which one they do. But yeah, they're just not in a situation right now where they can pivot or they can reset. where they can restructure. Chris Sale is just too old for that. They need to push chips in this year. And that would mean if you're going to trade Ronald, it would be a major league player for major league players kind of trade. And those are just extremely difficult because it's tough to find teams where they feel like they're getting what they need and you feel like you're getting what you need when you're both trying to contend. Those kind of trades just don't happen a lot. So, It is a very tough needle to thread. It's almost an impossible needle to thread, which is like what Sean just said. If it's that hard to do, then it probably just means you shouldn't be doing it. It's like the universe telling you, hey, cool it with this. We don't need to force the issue here. So yes, that is the next big one is the Braves timeline just doesn't match up for an Acuna trade right now. You need to be pushing chips into the middle. for the next, you know, 2027, maybe 2028, and see if you can win something big while Chris Sale is still an ace. Because he's not going to be an ace for that much longer. He's just father time doesn't work like that.
00:25:32
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:25:33
Speaker 1: And this would be a different conversation if over, you know, the past two years of coming back from his, you know, second ACL surgery, you had seen Ronald Acuna Jr. clearly have a lower level ceiling than he'd had previously. But even this year, from when he took the day off on August 27th, from August 28th through September 22nd, Ronald had a 200 WRC +, which was fourth in baseball over that time. He then fouls the ball off his leg, and that evidently leads to more leg injuries. Steven has said it himself. I think that two things need to happen this offseason. One, you need to go to Ronald Acuna Jr., and you need to figure out, if you have a leg injury, either we need to extend the time until you come back to ensure you're 100%, or we need to change up the training to where, or the rehab, to where even if your leg's not 100%, you do not just completely fall off the map like we saw him do in the playoffs. That's conversation one. But to me, conversation two is, what's the extension look like? And I'll save that for another show. I do feel, as we wrap up this edition of the Hammer Territory podcast, where I stand is, I agree with Steven, it does more harm than health. to trade Ronald Acuna Jr. right now for a team that clearly wants to contend, but yet Ronald Acuna Jr. internally... is the biggest asset that you have to answer the questions that are out there about yourself. When you look at a healthy Ronald Acuna Jr., he, besides Chris Sale, is the only other aspect that when you look at the Braves facing the Dodgers or the Braves facing the Brewers or Cubs or something like that, what about the Braves could make them overcome those guys in the series? It's a healthy Ronald Acuna Jr. And I think as long as that is the truth, that's why you keep him. And probably, in my opinion, look to extend him. So while the logic is there in the right situation to consider trading Ronald Acuna Jr., the most sense is keeping him, especially when you're going to look to continue to continue throughout the time that you know you have remaining with him over the next two years.
00:27:42
Speaker 2: Yeah, that's where I land as well. Again, just ignoring all the emotional stuff, just from a pure baseball perspective. The things that Ronald does right now, which is hit from the right side and get on base, are two things that the Braves don't do well right now overall. And they need to get better at. The Braves need more on base percentage. They need more production from the right side. So trading away a right-handed hitter who gets on base just doesn't make sense. Because you're not going to get somebody of that level in return. You're probably going to get prospects in return. And again, we just talked about the timeline difference. It doesn't make sense for prospects right now. So I understand everybody who freaked out about the, the playoff, you know, production or the lack thereof from Ronald. And I was, you listen, you know, I'm not going to defend Ronald. Ronald was awful in the post season. I do. I know he was hurt, but you know, and I've said this before, we got to figure out a way that when Ronald is not a hundred percent, you know, from the waist down, we got to figure out a way where he can still be productive. We got to figure out a way where he can not be a hundred percent of his legs and and he can still hit a baseball at a decent level. We can't just live and die by whether or not Ronald's 100%, because he's just so rarely 100%. But that doesn't change the fact that the two things he does is he gets on base at a consistent clip, and he produces from the right side are two things that the Braves desperately need right now, and they desperately need more of, not less. So I would absolutely land on not trading him. Some of it, of course, is tied to what are the offers, and we will never know the answer to that question. Never know what teams offer, right? And there is probably a trade out there that makes sense for every player on your team. Because some team just said, hey, I'm going to give you a crazy amount for this guy. In which case, you'd be crazy to say no. So I'm not going to say there's no trade out there where it would make sense to trade Ronald. But from what we know, what we can know on, you know, from this side of things, I just have a hard time believing that a guy who gets on base and produces from the right side, you're going to be better off trading away that guy when that's exactly what you're trying to get more of as we get moving to 2027. So yeah, I would have to see, it would have to be an amazing, amazing offer for me to pull the trigger on trading Ronald Acuna Jr.
00:29:59
Speaker 1: And you just, it's hard to see those type of things happening. They do happen, but it's hard to see those type of things happening. But, you know, hey, this is the first of, you know, several, you know, aspects of the Ronald and Junior conversation that we can have. So if we know that we're not looking to trade him, what does it look like potentially, you know, extending him? Or, you know, how could he go about getting back to being himself? We've got the whole offseason to certainly discuss that. And also, Landon, this point, this of all offseasons is probably not the best setup to try to figure out the Ronald Acuna Jr. long-term answer with the fact that you've got so many other moving parts with the potential lockout coming up. For Stephen Tolbert, you can find him at B underscore Outliers on Twitter slash Jax. My name's Sean Coleman. You can find me at StatsSAC, the same place. Hammer Territory across all forms of social media or the Foul Territory family of podcasts. Until next time, go Braves. We'll talk to you again soon here on Hammer.