สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
Welcome back to the magistrate on the EM network. I am Josh Howard. Join us always by my good friend of co-host James Baird. James, good to see you brother. Good to see you Josh. Today we're going to be talking about a chart. And among other things, we're going to be talking about what should the government do, what must the government do, what ought the government do. James is going to have a little bit of a walk through to dice through what I think or some of the things that they get us into a lot of quantities. We have these discussions where somebody thinks either the government ought to do everything and criminalize every given sin or that the government ought to do none of these things. And James is going to walk us into what I hope is a very historic argument, which is typically what we try to aim for here on the magistrate, walking through what Protestants have thought about this. Christians in general thought about this over the years. So we're going to walk into that. James has a chart which, again, I love charts. It's not a Venn diagram, but it's a chart. So it's still going to be good stuff. Do want to mention our sponsors for we jump in though. Rockwallbibles.com. Rockwallbibles does amazing work. They've been sponsors of our channel for quite some time. Really appreciate them. Family-owned Christian business out of the Ozarks. Reach out to Rockwall. Check out their listings and also use the Codium 10 and your checkout. I also want to mention steadfast cigars, good friends of our channel and long time encourages as well as supporters. So appreciate them and what they do. But James, I want you to set the table. I want you to, they once told me in sermon preparation, this is back in seminary. They said, you need to tell the people why they should care about the sermon. And of all the things that I fail at and I think most pastors fail at is setting the table of like, why this should actually matter to you? Why you should care about, in my case, Judges, chapter 11 that we're coming up on on Sunday. But why is this important, James? If you're not on Twitter, let's assume. Because if you're on Twitter, you should really know why this is important. But that's right. So, well, I think it's important to mention today. Today is November 4th, the day after the Republicans got absolutely slaughtered for the nation. We record these a week before him. And I tweeted, don't black pill. Amen. Don't black pill, never black pill. Because providence is on the side of righteousness. And so what would be a better way to respond to respond to the election yesterday than to talk about principles for Christian government? We're not going to black pill. We're going to keep marching forward. And I think you need to care about this because if it wasn't obvious before, it will be obvious in a year, two years, three years, four years that we need Christian government. Christian government. And so let's go ahead and start building the resources right now for the
Load full transcript
uprising that will happen. Of Christians continuously trained up and involved in governments. Can I, by the way, just just, I've seen a few people, you know, this is typical post-election sort of reaction. A lot of Christians opposed to Christ. He's still king. He's still on his throne. Those aren't just, or I hope they're not just platitudes. Those are truths. Part of the thing for Christians too is not just to think through what should be, what ought to be, not to just think through those things when it seems like they can be, but to think through those things, even when it doesn't seem like it's on the near horizon. I don't think we're in a spot, at least where I am. I don't think we're in a spot where we're going to see a preponderance and majority of Christian leadership and God's values being venerated in all the halls of power. However, what Christians are supposed to, in fact, compel to be about the task of is thinking, what should be? And trying to encourage those things, such that if God is pleased to give that sort of blessing to a nation that we have the groundwork to operate from in those cases. So yeah, good work. Yeah, that's right. We've got a build for the long term. We've got to focus on 50-year wins. I mean, I want next year wins. I want next week wins, but we've got to be doing all of it. And a huge part of that is going to be doing something that we haven't done well for 100 years, and that is Christian political discipleship. And so one area in which we have, I think, failed to do a good job is to think about the relationship between divine law and government action. What's the relationship between what God has commanded and what the government must do? And so what I've tried to do is put a very simple chart together. It's a work in progress, so feedback from everyone that will help map the relationship between God's commandments and government action. And so that's what this chart is meant to do. And obviously, isn't this something that everyone should care about? I mean, what is the relationship between what God has told us in his word and what our civil leaders and authorities should do? How do you evaluate whether or not an action is appropriate, whether or not an action is good? How do you know when you must obey the government, may obey the government, or can't obey the government? I mean, these are going to be questions we need a very crystal clear answer to. And I'm frankly a little unsatisfied with the models that are popularized out there today, the ones people tend to use. And I think that some of the people doing the best work in recovering reformed politics haven't yet communicated this in a way that's easy for people to understand. So that's the vote. Yeah, no, that's fair. And this is something like James, like you were saying, as far as like, why should people think about these things and care about these things? Number one, with any sort of governance authority structure, whether it's in the home, that of the household, whether it's in the state, whether it's in the church, I mean, I think most Christians are pretty conversant, I would hope, at least, at least reformed Christians, which is primarily our context, are pretty conversant with what are the not only responsibilities of the church, but also the limits of the church. What has got to test the church with is the church supposed to tell you, you know, what sort of colored shirt to wear on a Sunday. Where do those lines come in? So I think we're pretty good at that. I think we've neglected it with the household. That's something that I've been spending a lot of time thinking about and researching. I think we've also, like you said, even more to our detriment, neglected this with the state. And that's going to be important for Christians, because again, if you're pleased to punch with the election results, that's great. If you found some cause for dismay in the election results, that's very understandable. Any government we're going to have to navigate. And again, six years ago taught us this. Any government has taught us that you have to navigate times in which you cannot simply operate on the emotions or whims of the moment and say, I'm not going to obey the government on this because I just don't like it. You know, I have this personal version to this thing. You need a grid work. And this is why we're walking through a little bit of a sort of rubric for how to vote as a Christian. This, I think, is really pushing in on that realm. How do you actually work through these things? And I'll affirm just having looked at your chart and thought about it a little bit since you shared it with me. I do think this is an area that is severely deficient. I think Christians are all or nothing on their thinking on this. I know you're going to get into that. I don't want to jump the shark too much on that. But yes, well, let's go ahead and dive in. I requested share access there. Josh, I have allowed your screen share. If you are listening on audio, you're just going to have to use your imagination. You're just going to have to go pull up YouTube. Yeah, pretty much. All right. So I've made this chart. It's a work in progress. But I'm going to try and explain it to you. So first of all, on this axis, we have God's law. And God's law does three things for any particular action that someone may do. But either forbids that action, requires that action, or is indifferent. It allows it. You can do it or not do it. So God forbids worshiping false gods. God requires us to worship the one true God. Right? Very straightforward. God allows you to decide which language you do that worshiping in, for example, right? It doesn't require one language or another. That's one example. We can keep going down it. God's law forbids you to forbids unjust killing. It requires you, as far as you are able, to promote and preserve life. Okay? God allows the government to decide whether or not it has an autobahn or, let's say, a speed
limit to try and reduce needless killing and promote life. Right. That's kind of how things go. There's things God forbids. Things God requires. Things the God allows. Now, that's what's going on on this axis there. On the top axis, we have different actions that the government could take to help order us towards God's law. In other words, things the government can do to help us as a people follow God's law. And on the left side is the strongest things the government can do against an action that we may do. And on the right side is the strongest things that the government can do for an action that we may perform. So let's walk through each of these. The strongest thing that the government can do against an action we may take is to proscribe it. That's not a word we're used to today, but basically it means penalizing an act. You do something. You're going to get penalized for it. Okay? That could be death penalty. It could be fine. It could be jail time. Right? But it basically forbids you from doing that action and punishes you for doing it. The next thing the government may do is just disadvantage it. Technically, you're not getting like it's not a crime or misdemeanor, but the government sets up some sort of incentive structure so that if you do that thing, you're highly disadvantaged. The next thing it can do is just disfavor it. Technically, there's not an official disadvantage. Technically, it's not a misdemeanor or a crime, but you're going to lose some sort of social standing probably if you do that thing. You're going to be looked down upon. The magistrate will discount and ensue you know? That's kind of the idea there. So those are the strongest actions the government can do against an action, right? Or the government could take no action. It doesn't really disfavor it. It doesn't disadvantage it. It certainly doesn't penalize it or proscribe it. Next the government can take actions for something. It can favor it. Meaning yeah, you don't get an official aid or benefit for doing something, but your social status increased. The next thing it can do is it give you an official benefit for doing something. That's an advantage. Okay. Then the last one it can do is prescribe it. You have to do this thing and if you don't do it, you will be punished. So one that jumps out is paying your taxes. That's a prescription. You got to pay your taxes. If you don't pay your taxes, you will be penalized. Those are basically the seven things that the government can do. Edit. Questions, thoughts about that? So here's a couple of initial thoughts because one thing I really like about this chart, I mean number one, I like charts. I'm a visual guy. James, I think you're a visual guy. So just see if I can lay it out like this. I can play with it in my mind and kind of think about it. So I like that. One of the things that I like about this chart, it seems to be really addressing something that you brought up in your King of Kings book, which was that one little
word that so many people tripped over, which is that the government should promote the true religion. Yes. People had questions and push back and thoughts about like, well, what does promote? Does it just promote? Does that mean that the government is executing everyone that is not of the true faith by the sword? No, no, no, no, no, there's a lot of different variants and promote in the way that can be assessed out. So this to me is kind of flushing a lot of those categories out. What does it mean for the government to either promote something or to disfavor something? I think it's super helpful. That's right. Yeah. And one thing to point out is that I have never called for the government to proscribe a false religion. In other words, make it illegal, right? Not too. Right. I have said that in principle, it is permissible for the government to disadvantage it. So the example I gave is, hey, only Christian churches can have, you know, if a, if a locality said. The church will be the tallest building downtown, okay? Because we want everyone to know we are a Christian community, okay? So the steeple and this is a law that they actually had at Princeton University is that the tallest building, the guy who gave them the money for the chapel there said the chapel will always be the school has to agree that the chapel will be the tallest building here. Period point blank. Hey, Drew. And so when they built their library, they had to build it down into the ground. So it goes like stories down in the ground because it can't be taught in the chapel. That is advantage, advantage in Christianity. Now of course, that all went to pot because then they made this a multi-religion chapel. It's not a Christian chapel. Right. Really annoying. But the idea was to try and advantage Christianity. Not prescribe it. Didn't have to be Christian to be a student there, for example, okay? But they did advantage Christianity in that way. Right? And it helps you understand kind of what it means to promote. And there's basically three different things they can do. Favor, advantage or prescribe, okay? So I like that part. I do have, and I've got a lot of thoughts on this one, James. Go for it. Kind of kind of kind of just scatter brain thoughts. So I don't want to interrupt your flow of thought. One of the things that did give me pause just looking at this. And this is probably just, this is probably a little bit nerdy. When you said that God allows things indifferent. That you said the word indifferent to me, that was one of the little sticking points. Many of us, especially again, I know I mentioned this so many times during any given episode. But just from a reformed context. And most of those in reformed contexts are familiar with like the Lutheran doctor and a vadi offer or not doctor and a vadi offer. But understanding of vadi offer, that's more applied to regularity of principle and how worship is certain. This sort of thing. But in general, it's talking about things that
are indifferent. And I think sometimes when Christians hear that, I always have a little bit of a check with that word because it can imply that it's almost a realm that doesn't matter or that's in place when it can carry a lot more water than I think you're implying that indifference carries there. So that was just one thing that kind of popped out to me on the chart. Yes. Great. So great point. The best way to think about it is that it's things indifferent in themselves, but they're not indifferent under certain circumstances. So what do I mean by that? So what I have for lunch in itself is indifferent. Okay. There's many different things I could possibly have for lunch. But if I have a kidney disease or something and I'm on a strict diet, then actually God's law requires me to be a good steward of the temple of my body. Right. And not eat things. So it's indifferent in itself. It's not a sin to have a hamburger. Right. But under certain circumstances, it could be a sin. Right. Okay. So this just means that whereas eating human flesh would be forbidden. Yeah. Okay. Can't ever do that. No. That's right. Right. But eating a hamburger is in itself indifferent. But under certain circumstances could be forbidden. Yeah. So this is things indifferent in themselves. Okay. And we'll unpack this a little bit. But yes, maybe I could do a better job communicating this row right here because this row is actually extraordinarily important. I was about to say, yeah, that center row to me is really, I mean, this is not unlike, you know, whenever we do, I mean, we teach it in new members classes at our church. We address it in various. And it's essentially that idea of theological triage, whether you're on board with the whole schema of theological triage or not, just simply packing out that there's certain doctrinal categories that are vital to the Christian faith. You simply have to believe this to be a Christian. There are certain doctrinal categories that divide churches. Like we don't say that they're heretics or non-Christians, but you can't just do church with us. It's not going to work real well. And then there's those things of, and this is where the word play comes in. In difference, like what do you call like? I can believe that it is good and godly to wear a suit every Sunday. I'm probably not going to impose that on my neighbor, but I'm allowed to believe those things. So what you must believe, what you may believe in what you, or what you must believe, what we believe in what you may believe is kind of the way we suss it out. But that's usually where I, in my experience, the rub comes in. And that's why I keyed in immediately on that middle row of yours because that is, that is a heavy, heavy lifting category. Yeah. So let's talk about that. I would say this would even in my debate with Levi Secorde or C.C.C.C.D. I'm not sure where the emphasis goes. The wrong level. Yeah. And the wrong level. We debated a lot of this stuff. You know, what action
may the government take toward things that are indifferent in themselves? And I've made the case that there's a lot of things the government is must do under certain circumstances. So notice that there is a exception clause here. It says, first of all, the stuff that is indifferent in themselves, government is required to take no action regarding those things unless the public good warrants an act against or for it. Okay. Government, so should government should be hands off unless the public good requires it to take an act. Right. If the public good requires it to take an act, then it may require you to do that act. Or it may forbid you from doing that act on thread of penalty if the public good requires it. Okay. And we could think of lots of examples there. Pretty much anything that obviously a community needs that isn't directly prescribed or forbidden in God's work. Okay. So what's a good example? Oh, voting. You know, let's say. Yeah. Let's say the government required you to vote. Man, maybe a terrible idea. But let's say there's a scenario where it's like actually we really need everyone to vote. The future of the Commonwealth depends on it. God's word doesn't say you have to vote. But the government does. It says we're going to penalize you. Officially penalize you if you don't go and vote. Well, depending on the circumstances, that could be perfectly fine for the government to do. The government. So lots of examples. I'm trying to think of another one. Basically, the government may or may not take an action against the things that God's law allows depending on the circumstances of the people. Okay. Technically, let's say, imminent domain may be a good one. You know, no, God's law doesn't require you to give up, you know, three yards on your lot of land. But the government actually compels you, right? It compensates you. It also compels you to give up three, three yards of grass because it needs a road. Okay. The government's allowed to do that for the sake of the public good. Maybe a good idea, maybe a bad idea, that maybe other factors are just saying in principle, the government is allowed to do something like that. Makes sense? It makes sense. One thing just to point out about this chart and this may be just very obvious to the viewer, but you're approaching, you're approaching the relationship between God's law and government action. I'm seeing two things. You're approaching this all from a moral framework. Yes. There's morality involved in all of these governmental decisions and the way the government potentially passes laws and enforces those laws and et cetera, et cetera. But you're also not falling into the trap of making everything on that either a sin or a virtue. That's right. I think it's just a very important thing to point out. It should be obvious from the chart, but this is an inherently moral statement on governance. Yet it's also not relegating everything to the categories of sin or virtue. Yes, that's exactly right. Yep, there's lots of stuff that just require what's our favorite word? Prudence. No, prudence. Okay, so I think the biggest thing I learned from here, because a law, this is for me to get feedback, is I should make sure that I'm not going to be a good person. Make that clear that this row, this row probably needs to be a different color or different shapes, something to accentuate what we just described. Yeah. But let's jump up to the things that God's law forbids. Okay. Here's one thing the government cannot do. It cannot do this. It may not favor given official advantage and it certainly may not prescribe on threat of penalty. Anything that God's law forbids. Can't do that. Can't do that. Should be pretty straightforward there. Yeah, as much as I say, all God's people say men, yeah, we don't want the government saying thou shalt murder. That's right. Yeah, can't do that. Government can't and it certainly can't say if you don't murder your neighbor, then we're going to throw you in prison. No, sorry, can't do that. Government can't say you got a man. We really like for you to worship false gods. Man, isn't worshiping a false god great? That's awesome. Okay. No, government can't do that. The more interesting thing for people, that should be obvious. Okay. The more interesting thing is can the government require you to avoid what God's law forbids? Do you hear that? This would be the trick. This is your lower left quadrant. This is my upper left quadrant. Oh, there's the upper left quadrant here. The green one that says required just to the right of God's law forbids. God's law forbids you to worship false gods. Is the government therefore required to penalize you for worshiping false gods? Certainly, the government can't require you to do what God forbid. And when you say penalize, you're talking about take action against whether it's disfavoring, disadvantaging or proscribing or you talking only about the proscribing. Right now, I'm just talking about proscribing. Okay. Very good. Procribing. Can the government disadvantage you from doing what God's law forbids? Can the government disfavor you from doing what God's law forbids? I think we want to say, yes, in principle, in principle, this is at least the classic Protestant answer. Okay. We may want to qualify it. But this is the classic Protestant answer is the government can proscribe, in principle, it can proscribe you from doing what God's law forbids. Okay. Porsche been false gods. So just to give the classical example that gets batted around on socials, it was not sinful. And understanding that Israel was theocratic and a way that was unique and God was through civil and ceremonial law. There was something a little bit different going on with Israel and the Old Testament at times. And yet at the same time, they were not in sin to say that God disfavors and in fact hates the worship of idolatry. Therefore, we will proscribe against idolatry. That was not a sinful act. Now you could say based
on wisdom and prudence, maybe you ought only disadvantage or disfavor those things. That's right. It's sinful for a given society based on wisdom and prudence to proscribe against something that God forbids and says he hates. It's not sinful in itself. Yeah, exactly. Right. So that's why these have these great qualifications. So listen to this. According to this chart, the government is required to proscribe what God's law forbids and proportion to the sins weight in itself and under the circumstances, unless acting against the sin would cause a greater evil than not acting against the sin. Very important qualifications. So first of all, it's to proscribe what God's law forbids and proportion to the sins weight in itself and under the circumstances. So there could be tiny sins. Tiny sin, it's a tiny sin in itself and under the circumstances, it didn't hurt that many people. Every sin hurt somebody, but it didn't hurt that many people. And it would be silly for the government to do like the death penalty on that. So you stole a stick of gum. Right. Good. Versus murder. Well, that is a graveston, weighty sin that hurts the public good in so many different ways. So that should definitely be proscribed. Right. But can you imagine a scenario where the president actually shows clemency, mercy on someone who murdered someone else? So it's a graveston, heavily weighted. But for one reason or another, the government realizes if we executed this person, it might actually cause some sort of knock on effect. The best example would be when you're after the Civil War, lots of people in the north who viewed the South as traders. And so if they're traders, you know, Jefferson Davis deserves what? Death. Death. Death. Death. But Grant doesn't do that. Okay. Instead, basically they forgive them. Forgive all the southerners pretty much. And why was that? Because they wanted reunification. So even if you thought the southerners committed treason, there's very good reason not to do the death penalty because acting against the sin would cause a greater evil. Namely it would keep people from having a reunification of the South with the North. So it has to be the prescription, basically the penalty for the act, has to be in proportion to the sin's weight and it has to consider the circumstances both. How bad is this thing in itself? Is it murder? Is it stealing a stick of gum? And like what are the extenuating circumstances? You know, okay. So you want my little pushback on this one? Yes. Okay. So because I am agreeing with the principles you're laying out, I'm thinking of the, I think inevitable roadblock with communicating this, especially to most Christians. Two things I can think of. Number one, you sort of have this like sliding graph between lesser sins and graversons. One of the things that is just endemic to our current setting and our current cultural understanding of sin at least within Christianity is, you know, this is, this is the meme that goes around where, you know, how we see sins and it's, you know, like a long graph. And it's like how God sees sins and it flips it all. So just helping Christians, which again, or, you know, if you're from a Westman, steering context or our catacasms alone walk you through these in a way that would deny what we just kind of laid out in the meme. However, just walking Christians through the fact that there are, though every sin is damning before a holy God, there are actually sins which are obviously worse than other sins. It is bad to murder in your heart. It is worse to murder with your hands and your heart. These things are different. So that's one part of that roadblock. Then I think maybe like the murder of a stick of gum is pretty obvious for most Christians if you can get past that little hurdle. But then walking through, well, what does constitute a grave or sin? And again, a lot of this is going to be situationally based and it's going to be based on not to just regurgitate this phrase, but wisdom and prudence. A lot of these things are going to be weighed in their specific context and yet understanding what might a grave or sin be. I think a lot of the application rub is going to come in there. I think it's a good principle. I'm just saying like I do think that's where a lot of the friction is going to come in. That's right. I totally agree. This is one reason why I want to teach people this chart is to overturn some of those that thinking. Right. But yeah, there's two ways to figure out whether or not a sin is worse than another sin. One is just human reason. Okay. Just like think about it, obviously, isn't that worse than God? Give you the image of God, which helps you make moral judgments. The other one is to just look at how other cultures treat that sin. That can help sometimes. And where do you see the consent of the nation? Everyone's like, yeah, that's worse. Then the third one is look at God's law itself. It's there to teach you wisdom. What punishment did God give to that sin in the Old Testament? Maybe that punishment isn't the right one for us to enact today, but it teaches you how seriously God took that offense. This is where Calvin, in my mind, Calvin's through use is so helpful. I mean, it's not just Calvin, but I prefer the way he lays it out. Just thinking about God's law specifically in its relationship to revealing the will of God for us. If God so hated idolatry that he wiped nations off the map, we ought to say that seems serious. And then way it accordingly, God's law has so much to teach us about how God views things. Because God does not change and his ways do not change. You don't have to fall into some sort of clunky, theocratic vision just to say if God hates this thing with such a passion throughout scripture, we ought to regard it as such with the same opposition. That's right. That's right. Now the death penalty, for example, for something may not be the right thing to do, but the government should at least disfavor
it. Right. Okay. Should at least like bare minimum, the government must disfavor it. And try to disadvantage it. And depending on what it is. So for example, let's say that we said death penalty for everyone who isn't press material. Well, that's insane. Why is that insane? Obviously. That's right. That's right. For all of our detractors, no one is lobbying for this. Let's just get that out there for the cultural zeitgeist. No one's lobbying for this. Right. Right. Right. So the fact that what everyone has learned throughout history is, yes, start doing that. And it just totally goes, hey, why are all like it just goes horribly wrong. Right. Woroughly wrong. So don't do it. Don't do that. Why? It causes a greater evil. Causes a greater evil. Right. Just witch hunts go horribly. All right. So that's the idea there. So you also can imagine situations where it's like, yeah, I'm not sure if you're Let's say you're a reformed press material and all of a sudden you get elected as mayor of New York. Well, it could very well be that if you do anything at all, then it would cause a greater evil. Right. In which case, it's permissible to take no action. Right. So you're allowed to take no action when acting against the sin would cause a greater evil than not acting against the sin. You may never favor it or advantage it or prescribe it. Okay. But you may take no action if a greater evil would result from taking any action. Okay. So that's where the prudence comes in. Right. You got to consider the weight of the sin in itself. You got to understand the circumstances and you got to understand the need of the moment. Okay. And understand that when acting against a sin would cause a greater evil than not acting against it. And if you're in that scenario, you may do take no action. Does that make sense? Yep. I'm sticking with you so far. All right. It's the exact opposite on the bottom row here. All right. The you the government is required to take some action for to support or promote. You might say what God's law requires in proportion to the duties, weight in itself and under the circumstances. Okay. So God's law requires you to take care of your kids. And in fact, it actually prescribes that at some level. Namely, if you don't take care of your kids, you're going to get punished. We'll be taking away from you. You may get drawn upon charges for neglect or abuse. Okay. And then there's other things that God's law requires. The government just looks favorably, favorably upon it. You know, right now that's voting. You know, you're considered a good citizen if you vote. Okay. God's law technically doesn't require that. But so let me think of another another example. Something God's law requires. Well, at least it used to be going to church. No, it used to be, you know, 1960s. You know, you went to church, you're considered an upstanding citizen. Right. Government kind of favored it. You might even run that in your campaign. You know, man, you know, I've been a
member of first Baptist church for 40 years. My family laid the cornerstone, you know, like, ah, yes, that may actually unlock some doors for you. This is if we lived in positive world as Aaron Ren talked about it. Right. Or there might be like certain advantages. So one of be having children, you know, you get a tax benefit, you know, God's law actually requires if you're able to have kids be fruitful, multiply. Right. And you will be a little tax advantage. Right. If you do that, that's good. That's great. So the government should take some action for it in proportion to the duties weight in itself and under the circumstances. So what's kind of required unless acting for the duty would cause a greater evil than not acting for the duty. Okay. So, you know, used to be the government, you know, may compel you to go to church. Okay. Um, can it do that? Well, technically we may, on the classical model, at least we may say yes, that could do that, but oh man, with the people rebel, right, causing greater evil than not acting for the duty. Okay. So they get another extreme example that it's like, yeah, that would cause a greater evil. So we're not calling for that. So there you go. I think that one interesting thing, well, thoughts, thoughts about that. Um, Mr. Howard. I think, I think I really like it. I like the, I like the graph. I like that you're tracing out, um, especially the government action, like I said, of pro scrubbing, listing up through seven different actions to prescribing, I think is really helpful for people to think of. Um, I think, I think the wisdom and prudence is going to be one of the larger sticking points. And again, I don't think that's a fault of your chart. I think that's just a fault of us reasoning through things with wisdom and prudence. Why does that always say? Well, right. This is just a challenge. So I think that charts helpful. I think they're still, they're still obviously those, uh, those circumstantial decisions that one must make. But yeah, overall, I'm, I'm liking it. Yep. Yep. So, uh, one interesting thing is to think about like, so this is again, this is the classical model, classical Protestant model, more or less. Um, now what people today want to say is that when it comes to religion, okay. The government may neither proscribe here or prescribe. Right. Right. Let's say most evangelicals would say that. And we would certainly say that's the case. Prudentially. I mean, they would say in principle, if it's related to religion, the government may not prescribe or proscribe, understand that position. Totally. Um, but then the real thing is, okay, we'll may advantage it. Right. What advantage it can disadvantage? False religion, for example. And the more and more things that you say the government can't do related to religion, kind of the more and more liberal you are. Yeah. Right. So the most liberal person would say if it has to do with religion, the government can't even favor it. They can't say, isn't God good? You know, no action. The president can't say, man, isn't it awesome that God created us and gave us all these gifts, not even like Christian, just theistic, right? Right. Like, no, okay. Well, I think all like Bible-believing Christians would have to affirm these three that it may disfavor with the Bible forbids in favor with the Bible commands. Okay. Um, I would say if you think there can be actual advantage, advantages or disadvantage like official ones, now you're going to get called, now you're probably some version of like a Christian nationalist. Grab. Okay. If you think that the government should proscribe or prescribe, well, now you're just like old school European. Right. Old school way of doing things. But what I'm calling for is disadvantage or advantage. Right. You'll aid to the act, official burden to the act. Right. Right. If you want to kill heretics, well, now you've really gone all the way back over to these edges. Right. Um, so anyway, I think it's also a useful way to kind of map different views of church and state government and religion. Yeah. Uh, I think, I think it's going to be interesting thinking through this. If you have a moral framework like this, um, one of the things that you have to navigate and, and again, you're, you're, you're giving, you're giving a framework and a guidance for what is actually true, what the true religion, the true faith, what God has actually laid things out. I think it's interesting though because it is inherently moral. So this is inherently a moral grid work and a moral understanding of governance. Um, it's interesting how to distinguish between moral, moral requirements, uh, from competing worldviews of different moral structures. So when you do, when you do find yourself in that place, just as a normal Christian, let's not even say you're a Presbyterian trying to make, uh, you know, Idaho Presbyterian or something like that. You're just a Christian and you're in governance and yet you have competing moral views for what is not only what is good, but what is sin and what, what is, what is proscriptive and prescriptive governmental action. That's an interesting interaction. I think at a governmental level. And again, this is not, this is not blackpilling or being overly negative to say that seems like it, especially in certain corners of our country is going to be an increasing interaction of Christians and especially those in politics. Yeah. So, and let's also talk about this. So the role, what's the role of a constitution? Hmm. So the role of a constitution is to put more meat on this bones. Okay. And to set limits going both directions. So not just limiting what the government may not do, but requiring the government to do certain things. Right. So we had a constitution that said, you know, we could add in the constitution that the government has to hold a worship service once a year. We could add that. Okay. Now, morally is the government under all circumstances required to hold
a worship service? You know, we're sponsor, we might say sponsor a worship service. Well, no, not under all circumstances. But if it's in the constitution, well, now we've all agreed that we are going to do this every year. Right. Or your constitution could say, hey, you know what? Here, here, proscribing any active worship, right? Proscribing any active worship is actually according to our constitution illegal. Okay. So we kind of say like, yeah, morally, there's lots of options here, but our constitution is going to particularize God's law for this land, right? And provide, provide further limits and specifications on what we want to make sure the government is doing. So that all of this stuff, which is technically permissible and moral, isn't left up to the personal judgment of whoever happens to be holding office at that time. Right. Right. It actually puts some guardrails, right? So that you're not just always hoping you get someone good in charge, right? So that's the role of constitution. So constitution could say, okay, let's say, let's say you agree. We do think that like technically it's okay for the government to find people who don't go to church. We're technically fine, but our constitution says that's almost always going to lead to a greater evil. Right. Okay. So in our constitution, you can't do that. You can't do that. And it's like, yeah, that's what constitutions are for. This is why constitutions are good. Okay. Or in your constitution, you could say, it could require a positive act. You always have to give the death penalty to every murder, you know, first degree murder. Okay. So I go, all right. Yeah. It's really technically. Maybe there could be exceptions, but once it's in the constitution, no more exceptions. Like you got to do it every time. If that's what the constitution says with no exceptions, right? Right. Right. That's the role of constitution. It's a further specify what's allowed to happen. Or must happen on the show. How about this? I know, I know there's a lot to walk through on this chart, but I'm just thinking toward a lot of the conversations that we've had in recent years with Christians have been along the lines of, you know, so-called incrementalism versus, well, let me think of the abortion debate, right? Yeah. Do you, do you satisfy yourself in a rejoice in small steps toward limiting abortion? Or do you say, along with the abolitionists, no, it has to be all or nothing. Right. Essentially, like we cannot tolerate. I'm thinking toward without trying to wander down that trail too far, but I'm thinking toward Christians, how does this chart or does this chart help them understand to what extent is it to promote or support evil just by simply not acting against it or or even maybe tolerating its existence or so like when does complicity with evil come into the scheme of exactly. So this does help us figure out the abortion abolitionist versus incrementalist debate. First of all, I would say I appreciate the, I would say the moderate abortion abolitionists who are pushing up against, which might call pro-life ink, that has been two lacks. Right. So I appreciate that, but, you know, I'd say the strongest version of abortion abolitionist is in his wrong, which that idea is that the government may not take any incremental steps. It must proscribe under every circumstance, you know. It's like, well, I don't think that's actually the case. You got to, certainly the sin is weighty in itself. Okay. Under our circumstances, it's not as weighty as it would have been because we've gotten used, we've already deep down into the whole. Okay. If abortion never been legal, allowing one abortion, okay. But under those circumstances, being incredibly weighty because you've now, there's a gap in the door that a shoe can get in, a wedge can get in there now, right. But then you also got to think, acting against the sin, would that cause a greater evil in the sense that if you do this super duper strict law against abortion, which is certainly in itself very good, would cause every single Republican to lose every election, and the law is just going to immediately get overturned. Right. Okay. Well, that might actually create more abortions rather than fewer. Okay. So you got away the circumstances and the potential outcomes of your action as well. That's helpful. Yeah. I'm still thinking through that one, but that's at least a helpful way to approach it. I think I want to put more thought under that one. Yeah. Let's say, you know, on my, on this model, okay. It's not absolutely required that let's say there's a death penalty for every doctor who prescribes an abortion pill, right. That there is room to be a little bit more prudent in how you enact those laws. Right. Okay. No, that's good. Any other, any other major take on, you certainly can't, you certainly can't favor it. This is important. You cannot favor it. You cannot advantage it. You cannot prescribe it. Right. And if you are, which by the way, just just for our friends that are in that particular debate, even that would be a humongous step. The government not favoring or advancing a similar abortion would be a tremendous step. So certainly. The government is actually required, okay. To take some action against it when it can. Does that make sense? Yeah. So if in fact, a strict abortion law would not cause a greater evil, then you must do it. Right. Right. You must do it. Right. I like, I like the graph, James. This is going to be, this is going to be a good topic for conversation. Is there any, is there any other major facets of the graph that you wanted to cover today? No, more work for me to do on it. I think you've really helped me see some areas to improve it. If you put the font in, oh man, ruined my own joke. What's that goofy font? Sans Serif. That's what you do. Sans Serif. I already did like papyrus here. Papyrus. Pretty close. No. I like this. For those viewers, if you have feedback on this or thoughts on this, reach out to us. James would love to hear from you. I think it would be a good thing to develop because I do think this gives you a basic grid work of all the things that I think Christians, when we talked about again, the rubric last week, I think Christians have just lost some of those simple operating categories such that when we get into these debates, it becomes an all or nothing thing. And do you want to execute heretics in the town square? And it's like, there's a lot more going on here that's actually not that complicated. I mean, it's complicated, I suppose, but it's very basic and simple for... Here's a grid work for how to approach this thing that I think would take a lot of the window of the sales of we have to go all or nothing on everything. So yeah. Right. And it's important to remember, even historically, you know, I think that when Americans are saying government may not prescribe or proscribe religious worship, doesn't mean that the government can't disadvantage false worship or advantage true worship. Certainly didn't mean the government can't disfavor false worship and favor true worship. Right. So it helps us get more specific about what we're trying to communicate. Yep. Very good. We can wrap it up there for today then. I think this is a good introduction. I'm looking forward to seeing more of this work coming out. I think this might intersect with something that I've been working on that maybe we could delve into next week. It might actually pair. We'll see how it goes. But anyway, if you've got any thoughts on this, reach out to us. EschatologyMatter is one at gmail.com. You can leave a comment in the YouTube's or the... I don't even know where this all gets shared on the on the interwebs and the socials and the what nots. But yeah, reach out to us. We'd love to hear back from you and James. As always, man, pleasure talking to you, brother. You too, Josh. Love you, brother. Our sponsors. steadfastsigars.com promo code eschatology10 rockwallbibles.com bonaface media grace and truth press grace and truth records