สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
0:00
we have these very stereotypical ideas of what I need to look like or what of the behaviors and eating disorder. But actually there's a lot more things that we have normalized that are actually very, very disordered Did you know that trying to lose weight is actually one of the biggest predictors of weight gain over time? I find it really interesting because health experts, and especially longevity gurus, keep telling us that if we want to stay healthy, we must lose weight or we must keep our weight down. This might be true out of context, but what they don't tell us is that dieting, just like Ozempic, can have really serious side effects like weight cycling and disordered eating and so much more. And by the way, they also don't tell us that other aspects of life, like meaningful connections, can have much more of an impact on our health and well-being than food. So how did food become such a hot, sexy topic? Why is that? Almost the only thing we talk about when we talk about health? I suspect that it has to do with food becoming tangled up with feelings of guilt and control, which is understandable. So to help shed light on this topic, I'm joined today by Chris Sandal, who is a nutritionist and a host of Real Health Radio, and he will share his évoque on what constitutes real long term health. Check it out. you know, you are very different nutritionists in the landscape of people who who do this work. Usually I see women and usually they have had like eating disorders or some issues with food in their past, which drove them to this profession. So it's refreshing to see another another type of nutritionist. So I'm curious to hear like what what led you to this path? How like if you can briefly kind of share a story. Sure. And so I think like growing up, I really had no interest in food. I think as a as a kid, I didn't really I didn't really care about eating very much. I just wanted to get on with with other things. And it was probably like quite a picky eater as a kid. But my parents sort of handled it well and just allowed me to eat what I wanted to to eat. And then as time went on, I sort of grew out of that. And by 17, 18, 19, I sort of a wide range of a range of views, but I just didn't really pay any attention to it. And then I moved from Sydney to the UK and was living in London. And the first place that I moved into and the couple that I was living with that the girlfriend in that couple, she was very much into eating and healthy eating and that kind of thing. And I started to read about it. I started to change some of my eating and just was kind of fascinated with it. And at that stage I didn't really know what I wanted to do. I'd done a business degree before leaving Sydney and then moved over to to the UK for what I thought would be two years and it's now been 20 and I've never left. But I kind of came over. I thought I'd do a little traveling and figure out what I wanted to do and just started reading more about nutrition and the topic and had that moment of like, maybe this is something I would like to pursue. And so I went and studied and study for it for three years. And when I then finished that studying, I was still unsure of in what area I want to use this. And so to start with it was just I will I will help any everyone in any if you've got digestive issues or you're having trouble with your sleep or whatever it may be, I'll, I will help whoever, whoever wants it to come here. And what I found over the next couple of years and I actually had this, this very short period where I had a number of people all at once where actually it wasn't so much about food. It was actually about their relationship with food and how they thought about food and also how they thought about their their own body. And I really loved working with those clients. I've kind of reflected, I think if growing up there had been someone in my life who was a psychologist, I probably would have entered into that into that field. And so I think in a sense, I started to discover I really liked the messy side of nutrition. I didn't get so jazzed about, let's look at how much magnesium you need or you're getting enough calcium or that kind of thing. It was more yet talking about people's relationship with food and their relationship with body and how all these things kind of connected. And so I then just started writing about that more. And so I started to attract more of those kind of clients. And I think the trajectory was that initially it was people who had been dieting and really wanted to get off that that dieting rollercoaster, and then it became more disordered eating and then it became more eating disorders and now more sort of very long standing eating disorders where people have had this going on for for ten and 20 and 30 years and just all over those sort of 15 years, me continuing to do more and more education around different areas. Yes, getting better in terms of my understanding of nutrition and physiology. And I while I think I probably would have gone down that route, as I said, if I'd known someone who was a psychologist, I'm very glad that that I did the way that I did it, because with eating disorders and disordered eating as well, like having a real grounding in physiology and understanding how the body works is really important because while these are mental illnesses, there is a huge biological component connected to it, there's a huge physiological component connected to it. And so having that grounding has been really important and then just learning lots of other areas that are that are really important in terms of helping someone to to fully recover if they're recovering from disordered eating or an eating disorder and how to change someone's relationship with with food and body and how they relate to those things. So that's kind of how I came to this. And yeah, I've never had an eating disorder. I've never had struggles personally with food. I think the closest I can
Load full transcript
come to this is that I was always someone who was really small. If I look at my my photos from when I was in in high school when I was in year eight and, you know, like it looks like I'd been put in the wrong right, Like I am just that much smaller compared to other people. And I had a lot of insecurities and worries around that. I just because of the era in which I grew up, I grew up in that in the mid nineties there wasn't social media. The Internet was still at the very, very early stages of things. I didn't have this message that had if you start to change your diet, you can you can really change your body. And I wasn't getting that message at home. And so even though I was smaller and I had insecurities around that, it was just like, this is just this is just what it is like. That's that's what happens. This is this is your lot in life. And let's let's kind of get on with dealing with that. I didn't feel like, if I start taking in more protein, any of our stock going to the gym, more that all these things will change. Right? They would have been totally different. It's so funny to think about it. I actually have a similar story. I was a really, really tiny kid and very, very skinny. And also kind of became my identity. And I think for girls it's kind of more of a pop. I don't know if it was a positive thing, but it was like it was wasn't didn't see it as, I mean, anything bad. And the moment puberty hit that my body changed. I was like the first in line for the like first diets to, like, fix it. So it's interesting to think of a world where you don't know that you can fix it and you just you just accept it and get on with your life. That would have been nice. Yeah. And I look, I do I so can you explain what does it mean to be weight neutral? What does it mean to be a nutritionist who doesn't believe in diets? So what it means is that people can be healthy and unhealthy all across the weight spectrum. And the thing within our society and the very myopic view that we have from from my perspective, is that we focus so much on weight as being a predictor for health and that if people want to increase their their health and increase their longevity. And on this, one of the most important things they need to lose is is lose weight and control their weight. And I disagree with that for a number of reasons. And so one is that, as I said, people can be healthy all across the spectrum. So we know that there are people who are in small bodies. We know people who are in large bodies. We know people who are in very large bodies, who are who are healthy. And so it's not just to do with the size of someone's body. And it's not that I don't think we can have any bearing on someone's health, but I think it has a much, much, much smaller bearing on people's health than we then we tend to make out and we really struggle to understand how much is the weight versus how much is the stigma that we that we put on those kind of people. Because if we're living in a society where we're told, like the worst thing you can be is being a larger body, like that's going to have an impact on on someone. And so when we're seeing that someone has higher cholesterol or they're having high blood pressure or they're having all of these things, like how much of that is down to someone's extra fat stores on the body versus we're living in a society where they're told that that their body is wrong. And so I think that's, I think, a big piece that people really miss of like, we can't really know exactly how much what which is doing which because there isn't this amnesty for people. There isn't these this area where there are people with these larger bodies where everyone's like, well that's a that's a a fantastic thing or even just a neutral thing. And so I think that's that's the first thing. But the second thing is we don't really have any good ways of helping people to lose weight and keep that that weight off. And so the success rate of people doing this over the long haul is really is really small. And so, yes, if we look at what's happened after six months time or even years time, yeah, there's there's people who can keep that off. But once we once we go out to five years, the success rate is, is pretty small. And if we look at that, the percentage of people who are successful with that and then the percentage of people who have disordered eating or eating disorders in our society, I would say that a large segment of those people who are able to maintain that that weight loss are then doing it in very disordered or really unhelpful, unhelpful ways and unhelpful when we're thinking about that, their physical health but also their mental health. And so we really don't have ways of being able to do that effectively, despite the fact that this is really the first bit of advice that so many people are given. And what we do have good evidence on and we can look at this in terms of things like health at every size or intuitive eating, is that people can really improve their health while not focusing on losing weight. And there are so many things that people can then be able to do to support their their health, whether that is like they're doing movement that they genuinely enjoy. And that movement isn't to to change the size or shape of their body. It's because they actually enjoy doing that thing. And maybe adults changed it the size or shape of their body as a and they get stronger or that they're playing tennis more. And that has more of an impact. But that's not the predominant reason. And after two months of their body not changing, they're not saying, hey, okay, this this sport obviously isn't for me. I need to to find something else. And that can be things like sleep, They can be things like relationships. There is so many things that people can do and I do again, I think we get very myopic that this all has to be just food and exercise based when there are many, many, many different things that people could do, as
well as understanding that there are many things that are completely out of the control of of so many people. There are so many structural things that have an impact on the quality of people's health. And when you are at a certain echelon or standard of living, there are so many invisible things that you just don't recognize that all the people are having to go through. And so I, I do believe that people have some amount of ownership and can do things to support themselves and there's a lot of things that are just completely outside of of one's control, depending on on where someone is in terms of socioeconomics and lots of other factors that that come into this. And I think also people have the assumption that if someone has a bigger body they cannot like, That necessarily means like that's an indicator of how or how much they eat. And from what I understand that that's not that it's anybody's business, but it's also not necessarily, you can't really know by the by the size of a body like how the person eats. Is that correct? That is definitely correct. And just there are people who come in different shapes and sizes and we have this very kind of moral panic around someone who is in a in a larger body. Like we're not chastising a man or a woman because they wear a size 14 shoe and like, how dare you have such a big foot? But we definitely do the same with someone who is in a larger body. And there was a bit of research that that looked at the the food pyramid or the food plate or whatever the current thing is in terms of the the recommendations of what people should be eating, in terms of the amount of protein and and legumes and fruits and vegetables and all of all of that. And when they looked at this across the different weight spectrums, it's about 10% of people follow the actual guidelines. And so that's true, whether someone is living in a a underweight body, whether someone is living in a a normal BMI, living in a in a overweight BMI, living in an obese, a BMI like that, there's about 10% people who are doing it across the board. And so we have this idea that, okay, if someone's living in a in a larger body, that they must be doing these things differently. And it's not that there aren't people who are living in a large body who are eating unhealthier foods like that. That is true, but it's also true of people who are in her and smaller bodies who are who are also doing those things. And for the person in the smaller body, they're not getting chastised about this by the person in the larger body is or we make assumptions that they must be doing that even though we have absolutely no idea whether that is that is true or not. And I suppose sometimes it's also a self-fulfilling prophecy, right, that if a person was came to the world bigger and all of their lives, they heard that their body is not okay. This is a risk factor for developing eating disorders, and then you might actually end up gaining more weight than you would otherwise because you're dieting your whole life. Definitely, definitely kind of set someone up for failure because you're in this larger, larger body. You're more likely, especially when you're you're younger as well. Like the amount of clients that I work with where they reflect on the fact that as a kid they felt bigger or chubby or something along those lines, and that could be because of different experiences they've had, whether that be with other kids at school or with things that their parents said. And the really heartbreaking thing is often they look back on those photos and they're like, I was just a normal kid. Like, I don't understand where this feeling came from because I really did feel it. And I can remember the comments of were made. And it's those kids that so often were were taken to to Weight Watchers with their with their mom. And that happened at age 12. And they're really indoctrinated into this thing where we applaud people when they when they lose weight. We sort of brainstorm and question why someone hasn't been losing weight like there is this learning that that happens very sort of implicitly and explicitly in those environments. And so, yeah, from that very young age, this becomes something that is really important. Like my self-worth is very much tied to this thing. And one of the biggest predictors of future weight gain is is dieting. And so if we want people to put on weight, like get them dieting, like that's what that's what happens. And it just sort of ratchets up someone's weight set point because we've got to think about this from from an evolutionary perspective or everybody's perspective. It doesn't know that someone is eating less to fulfill some standards of beauty, desire or something along those lines. The body doesn't recognize that, hey, we're not getting enough energy for what we need. Like there is potentially a famine that is that is going on or is about to happen depending on how much restriction is is happening. And the body's way of dealing with this is we need to turn down some functions. We need to turn off other functions and at the same time is doing that. We need to increase someone's drive towards eating. And so you get into this situation where we've been dieting for for a little bit and the body is now like, okay, we really need to to get some food in. And then when someone stops that, that dieting and starts to get the food in preferentially in that moment, the body's like, let's put on more fat stores. It makes sense to to carry a little bit extra because we've just gone through this this famine experience And so the body before it kind of reaches its it's its peak. The peak is now at a at a slightly higher level. And so what often happens is, okay, we got to that slightly higher level getting towards that and then we go on the next diet. And so over time you slowly increase the body's set point because it's trying to just use the feedback that it's getting from from the environment to work out,
okay, what is the safe thing for us to be able to to do? What is the best thing for us to be able to to do to help someone's longevity, to to help someone survive with the environment that it's being exposed to? Yeah, that makes sense. And also I'm like, I'm thinking this is really this doesn't only hurt people who suffer from the stigma that I think about my dad, who he had diabetes, he was very skinny, but he had like morbidities that like I know if he were an overweight person, I'm sure they would blame the weight and that would be like the message. And they would encourage him to to do more healthful things. But in the case of my dad, he seemed healthy because he was in like normal body size. So they never second guessed his lifestyle. They never challenged him like, do you eat well? Do you move? Do you support? Well, there is a broader range of behaviors, but it's almost like if the person is in the right way. Strange. The assumption is that they live a like a healthy lifestyle. And then yes, and in the case of my dad, I think it would have been helpful if someone actually encouraged him to live more healthy. this is actually something that I come up with a lot with with clients as well. And so a lot of the work I've done, I do it now, but I did a lot more of this in the past. I was working with people with Hypothalamic Amenorrhea, and so this is women who have lost their periods. And if we think about the the order of priorities with the body reproduction kind of low down, if the body is not getting enough energy, like as a female, it's an inordinate amount of energy that you're going to need to to grow as a human to then that that human. And so the body wants to do that at a point where there is good amount of energy coming in on a on a regular basis and so if you're in a situation where that has come down as under eating over exercising the body just makes the decision of reproduction now is not so important. And what I've had happened many times is people who are in bodies that are thin or desirable, they would go to a doctor and the doctor's like, we just don't know why this is happening. But that really keep up the the exercise that you're doing. You're obviously eating really healthy. Keep doing that as well. And these are people who are in their mid twenties or early thirties. They're not getting a period. They go for a DEXA scan. They've got osteoporosis or osteopenia. Like at a point in your life where your bones should be at their absolute maximum. These people are having bones that are associated with someone who is who is much, much, much, much older than them. And yet they're told because they fit up to some esthetic norms that we like and because they're doing things that we think of as quote unquote, healthy, they're just told like, this is this is some blip. We really don't understand why this this is happening, that that keep doing what you're doing. And so, yeah, I definitely think that people who are in a larger body suffer way more in our society and people across the weight spectrum are hampered and and suffer because of our biases around this stuff completely. And this is very similar to my case. I was I had an eating disorder from puberty throughout my twenties. And it's really a blur. It's it's it's sad really, that that so many years have been spent that way. But I was that kind of person who comes to a doctor at well, I don't know why I don't get my period. It's a mystery. And the doctors, I think they I don't know, maybe they don't get enough education on this to kind of you see a young woman and it's like it should be one of the things that you suspect, especially if she's pretty thin or But I know that it can also happen in different sizes. But yeah, and it was never suggested to me that that was the reason it was, maybe you have PCOS. I'm like sending your chest. And I have I have now a friend who recently told me that she hadn't realized she had bulimia. She convinced herself that she had the digestive issues and digestive issue, and that's why she needed to do it. It's kind of our mind splitting play play tricks on us. And she went to so many doctors and knows no one doctor who who tried to understand better what it means that she feels uncomfortable. They just sent her to the million tests and they diagnosed her with lactose intolerance. And so it went on and on and on. And only recently she herself had to, like, face it and realized that, but with no really no professional help that she had a problem. And it's it's hard and it takes so long to identify that people suffer so and I know like you know, all the whole world is now filled with gluten free treats. And I always think that it could be that many people are sensitive to gluten. But in my head I'm like, Yeah, well, there is, I don't know, such a small percentage of people who actually have celiac. And I suspect that usually when people decide to restrict something, it's because they want to control something. So I think that's kind of the crazy world we live in, right? It's it feels like and that's maybe makes it maybe more difficult for your clients because you come out to you try to recover into a world that is a bit disordered in general. Like that's the norm right now. Yeah, totally. And it does make it really difficult because in a lot of ways that the things that people need to do for recovery is in stark contrast to everything that is being recommended, that they're having to eat more energy dense food or calorie dense food or things that we think of as unhealthy food. They're they're having to to gain weight as part of that recovery. They're having to take time off exercise as part of the recovery, like doing all of these things that society really deems as like bad and unhealthy. And yet these are the things that are most important for that person to be able to recover. And so it does make it a lot more challenging because of the society we live in and the narratives that we have
and people just bumping up against someone thinking that it's completely okay to to talk about their diet or to talk about their new hit routine or whatever it may be. And for someone who is in that that state and trying to recover, that can be, yeah, very triggering for them. It can be very difficult for them to deal with because there is just so much that that is connected to that eating disorder, especially if this is something that you developed when you were a teenager and you're now in your in your mid-forties and you're trying to deal with days like this as being something that is taken up so much of of your your life. And when I'm working with with people, I will often talk about you need to create this bubble. You need to create this bubble to start with to really reinforce that idea of actually what you are doing is correct. Like I understand that the world is is telling everyone that they need to eat less, but actually you need to be doing something very different. And I want like the end goal is that someone is very resilient and they can hear that information and it just doesn't have an impact on them. Or what often happens is it that they hear that information and their feeling is no longer like, Wow, I wish I wish I could go back there. I wish I could be the one who gets to do that. It's more like, my God, I'm so glad that that's not me anymore. Like, I'm so happy that I'm not the one who's having to to to do that or those things. I have so much freedom here and that that is the end goal. I'm wanting that resilience for people, and that's really the way that I think about overcoming an eating disorder is really developing resilience in all of these different areas. But in the beginning, yeah, you really need to create this bubble and have things that are constantly reinforcing. I'm doing the right thing here because it is it is so challenging. So what's your diagnosis? It's like because I know you talk about the phenomenon of being like I recovery, which is and you encourage your client, like don't settle for not suffering as much as you have, but to really find freedom and like, you know, the way we describe society today, it feels like it's almost like the come complimentary quasi disorder. It's it seems like at the end, like everybody is in that space of not being complete, maybe not being disorder to the level that it completely takes over your life. But also but, but, but I know from my circle around me that food is one of the main things people think about, especially women. It's it's, it's like an I'm going to do this now and I was bad and I'll do that. And it's just such a huge part of people's lives. how do you explain this? Where do you see it going in terms of our culture? And so, I mean, there are days that I have a lot of hope and there are days that I, I despair about this. But I, I think at the extremes, like I'll use something like the carnival diet, like how the carnival diet hit the mainstream is just mind boggling to me. Like to have a situation where there are a huge percentage of people where they're eating a meat only diet like that is like to to think like, I've been doing this as a chef for 15 years. And yes, there is always like with diets as you as you actually pay attention, this it is all very cyclical. So there will always be a period where carbs the bad guy, there will be a period where we're worried about fat. Like it just kind of comes and goes in this in this cycle of diets. But it seems like something with a carnival diet is like taking it up a whole notch. And to think that there are a huge percentage of the population that then got on board with that and kind of gave that a go and quite a substantial go like that. That is alarming because I if I, if I think if we went back 20 years ago or 30 years ago or 40 years ago, like that's just not just not what the the the mass were doing. And so there's moments like that where I'm like, okay, this is incredibly alarming. And then there are also things where if I look at the world's understanding of health at every size, for example, it is a lot more well understood, It's a lot more accepted. Even though it's not accepted mainstream, mainstream. There are a lot more people getting on board with the same with something like intuitive eating. There's a lot more understanding around that. And when I say intuitive eating, I'm not just, let's use your intuition in terms of what we eat. I'm meaning it in the way that there's a book by Evelyn Tremblay and Elise Rush, and they wrote the first edition of this and 20 years ago, it's now up to the fourth edition. And so over the last I'd say sort of five, six, seven years, there's been a lot more awareness of this. There's been a lot of research connected to this. And so, yeah, I have moments of like things are really moving in the right direction. And then I have moments of like, wow, how do we have such extremes really hitting, hitting the mainstream. I would like to push back a little bit I'm coming from this place of I had an eating disorder. I worked really hard to recover. I built a bubble for myself and that career path stuff, I somehow found myself really, really involved and passionate about longevity science. and the more I get into this and get into conversations, it seems like instead of focusing on the cool, cool science that really needs funding, most people who are longevity enthusiasts are really focused on what to eat, to live, to, to be healthy, what to eat and what not to eat. And it's so and I must admit that got me really confused because it's like, okay, I'm not at the place where I want to be, where I will. I don't think like I'm not the place where I do something because I want to control my body. But I didn't expect like that, like the strong temptation of they say that if I don't fast for at least 16 hours, I'm increasing my chances to have dementia. So it's like, how can I not do intermittent fasting now? So so this is just
kind of to give a context. But first of all, just as we were like to close that wait, wait conversation. So every time I speak with a scientist and I speak with people who seem to be very educated on this stuff, they always explain to me that weight is one of the like if you want to be healthy or live longer, like weight is really important. Like don't be, don't be obese, there is some of them do hint that okay maybe it's not maybe the weight is just a proxy of a metabolic issue. But still, the bottom line is if you want to be healthy, you need to keep your weight, like at the normal range. It's really, really, really important to keep your weight. Like all we know is that you need to exercise and not gain weight. And I with all of what you said and all like what I know, it really it is really hard, difficult to hear, first of all, because even if it's true, as we know, diets don't work. So why is it helpful to tell people to lose weight or not gain weight if it's just going to make them a diet and gain more weight? But I was also wondering if in terms of the science, if you can tell me otherwise, like is there a certainty justified? Can it be that their certainty is justified, that weight is really in itself or the metabolic issues that cause weight gain are in themselves health risks? So as I said earlier, I think the big variable that comes into this is the the stigma of stigma piece and where being in a larger body is very demonized within now within our society. And so it's not like we have people who are where we have this complete neutrality around the size of someone's body. And we're just looking at the what happens from a from a physiological standpoint. And we know from from research with with other groups. So in terms of this thing called minor minority threat and like just looking at the stress of being in a in a body that society tells you is is not the right body to be like that has an impact on your stress response that has an impact on your blood pressure, that has an impact on like so many systems within the body. And so so we've got that that is going on that we that we need to factor in. I would also like to say that people who are in a larger in a larger body, for example, what is their dieting history like? It could be that a lot of the people that we're seeing in the in their smaller bodies don't necessarily have a dieting history, that this is the body that they were naturally in for for over their their life. It's not that there aren't people who are in bodies that are smaller than where their body wants to be. But there could be a lot more of people who are out there who haven't been dieting, who haven't been restricting like, yeah, they may healthy, they may move their body, but it's very much within the band that their body wants to to be in versus someone who is in a in a heavier body. Let's say they're in their forties and they've been dieting since they were they were 14 like that constant dieting, that weight going
down, weight going up. This cyclical nature of that has an impact on on their metabolism, for example, it has an impact on how their their different systems and an organ function. And so I think when we're looking at comparing two groups, it would be really interesting to be looking at, okay, what are the people's dieting history with with with this? Because we could be seeing a lot of the what we're chalking up to someone being in a larger body is actually the ramifications of the stress of being in a in a body that society deems is bad as well as all of the cumulative effect of of the weight cycling that has occurred as people have gone on and off diets all throughout their their life. And so I think it's it's very hard for us to say all this is all about the size of someone's body, and this is all about the amount of weight this has on the body. And as I said earlier, it's not that I'm I'm against the fact that weight can have some impact. It's not that like it has absolutely no impact. I don't believe that to be true. But I think when we make a lot of assumptions around this, I mean, the other piece connected to this and again, I would love to to see what are the the socioeconomic factors between these two groups because. Yeah if you're if you're growing up in in poverty or you're in a situation where you're socioeconomically unstable versus people who have had a very different experience, that's going to have an impact on someone's the functioning of someone's bodies. And so I think what often happens when we say, hey, we're comparing these to two groups and this group is in a smaller body and this group is in a larger body, We make out like the only two variables. They are the size of their body. When there is so many other factors that could be there that are having a really big impact on how the body functions and the kinds of things that that person does, the kind of like just how someone feels about the food that they eat can be equally important as what they eat. And you can have two people who. Are eating. The exact same things, but they have a very different impact because of someone's feelings about that. We know of the strength of the the placebo effect and you can do they talk about doing sham surgeries. So if someone has a bad knee, you you take control group and you cut open the knee, you do no surgery, you close it back up and people like that surgery was amazing and then no longer having the pain, they're able to to have this full range of movement. Like everything changed, even though there was no surgery done. And we can have the opposite of that, which is the nocebo effect where okay, because of the beliefs that someone has about certain food or about their body or certain things, this has then an impact on its functioning. And so, again, if someone's living in this body that they're being told by society is is bad, that could be a new SIBO effect that is having an impact here. And it's not that there are just one of these
things, like I've given an examples of a few of them, but there are literally hundreds of these little things that when you stack them all together can make a huge difference. And yet we talk about it as being, it's just about the the White. How how do you see the observation that we have more people of a heavier weight, the obesity epidemic, and that we like foods are too palatable so something is wrong with our food culture and that there is a change where people gain more and more weight and a larger part of the population is at a higher weight. How do you explain that or do you agree with that? So, I mean, yes, I do agree that that people are living in larger bodies than they were before. And again, I think there can be a number of factors that have have driven this. It's not that there is just going to be one thing that is as had an impact on this. And so one of the things I mean, have already talked about, like there is a lot of dieting going on and there's a lot more dieting going on now than than ever before. And you take someone who does not have a dieting history like, I'll use myself, like I can be surrounded by chocolates and cakes and all of these highly palatable foods and it's not that I don't eat those things. I can I can eat those things. I can enjoy those things, but they don't have this power over me. It's like if I have those things around me, like day to day three, day five, like after a while it's like, okay, the novelty of this stuff is has worn off. Like I always use the example of going to a buffet, like staying at a resort and you're there for a week. First I had gone to the buffet is incredible because there is all of this novelty these connected to. It's like, Great, I can have pancakes. I can then also have bacon and then also go get someone to make me an omelet. There is a donut here. There are all of these things. And so on first day of buffet, I ate more than than I ordinarily would, and probably quite a bit more than I ordinarily would, because there is all this novelty that is connected to it. Day two eating a little less, day three by day five or day six or by seven, like I'm back to pretty much eating what I would eat at home because the novelty of all those things has has worn off. And so the fact that there is that highly palatable food around it doesn't over the long haul, make that much of an impact with me. It does in those moments where it's it's novel. So if I go out for a birthday dinner or if I'm out hanging out with some friends or whatever it may be, but it then kind of just comes back down to down to normal. And the problem with dieting is it keeps those things normal for a long longer and it keeps those things normal for a lot longer. Because when someone is then eating those things, there is this I'm eating these and I shouldn't be eating these. Like if I made a buffet, I'm not telling myself like, you shouldn't be having a donut with your breakfast. It's like I'm having a donut with my breakfast.
But if I've been someone who has been depriving myself and I've put these foods into a category of bad foods, I'm eating them while also saying I shouldn't eat them. Like there's this very heightened experience that comes along with that. And so it takes someone a lot longer to be able to to normalize those those food. And all the time they don't get normalized because you do that for for a handful of days, then you're like, okay, right, New diet starts tomorrow. And so you then start to restrict again and then at some point it's too much and Friday rolls around. And so I then have these foods and you set up this situation where those foods are, Yeah, put put up on, on a pedestal, but also are thought about as being forbidden and it creates this whole connection to it. And so yeah, if you're in that cycle, then yeah, you can be, you can over the long haul, you can be eating more, more food than you, than you otherwise than you otherwise would. And also you can be having an impact on in terms of your metabolism because you're having periods where there's a lot more coming in and there's a lot more periods of of restriction that then that then lead up to to that. So that would be kind of like one explanation for another is that not everyone has the same option or availability to to food. And so yeah, there are certain places where there is a lot more of these things that are available and there's not a lot of other options that are available. And so it's not that there's this wide range of options and that people then get to pick whatever they want from those options. It's like there's a much narrower range of options and this is all I've got to choose from. We're now in a situation where there's a lot more situations where both parents are working versus previously there was someone staying at home who was doing all of the cooking. And so yeah, we do have much more of a a time squeeze where people are picking up more fast food or whatever it may be. And so there's just lots of different reasons. I mean, another one is we have a lot more artificial life. Like if you compare what was going on in the 1930, 1940s versus today, like we didn't have the the lights in the house in the same way that we do now in terms of not just lights but like huge massive televisions that are that are in everyone's everyone's home and that people are watching before going to bed and how that starts to have an impact on circadian rhythm and and that connection in terms of how much food someone someone eats. And so there are all of these different factors that then come into this. But I would also say at the same time that everyone has got in heavier bodies. We're also taller. And when we're not having this huge emergency crisis of like the world getting so much taller, what are we going to do about this? So it's framed instantly, like the fact that people are in bigger bodies. This must be a bad thing and we must do something about it because we have this assumption that
that is something that we need to to fix versus when we're not having a summer around like do we how do we fix the fact that people are taller? I think it's important to realize that it's not that it's a woke thing of like be be respectful to all people kind of statement, although that, of course, goes without saying. But it's really practically and logically that just makes sense. And I'm wondering about fixing in general because like we're all about optimizing these days. Right? Optimizing our and so we hear a lot of advice and let's say a person has never dieted, you know, it's like, is it? It makes me laugh because there are like those tech pros that like, yeah, it's just like technical. I do this, I do this with food and like, it's so funny to see, like someone who has no emotional connection to food, but it's like in a world where, let's say there is a piece of advice that is actually true, although I want to get in it with you about like how nutrition science is difficult to study and how much it has changed and the advice has changed. But let's say there is something that is recommended and a person can do it without it being triggering. And this is considered healthy. Where do you draw the line between that and between the murky area of, okay, this is it can get into a disorder or maybe that's it's not helpful Sure. I mean, there's a couple of things that that come up with this. So one is like context matters. And so really understanding the individual that's in front of me or I mean, when I say in front of me, irony really work now with eating disorders, so it's not going to necessarily be in front of me. But the individual like what happens when I start to make this kind of change? Because I think there can be a lot of things that are promised as a as an upside. And there can also be downsides to doing this and to use kind of a slightly different example like it could be the research around alcohol consumption is is not great in terms of is it really true that having one glass of wine is is better than no glass of wine? But let's make the assumption that having one glass of wine is better for your health and having having nothing. If someone who has the propensity to develop as a as an alcoholic hearing that advice for them, no, alcohol is a better option. And so I think about this in in the same way of like when I start to make these changes, what then happens to me? What happens to my physiological health, what happens to my psychological health, What happens to emotional health? Because I think there are definitely people who can do all of these things and they are the better for it, and it doesn't have an impact on them in the negative way that it does for other people. And so it's not that like no one is allowed to do these things. It's just that from my perspective, eating disorders are a lot more common than we really think that they they are. We make out like it's is tiny fraction of a percentage that that it affects when it is
a much bigger percentage. There was a recent study in the UK looking at it and for the the ages between I think it was 17 and 19, it was somewhere around 20%. That is a very high percentage age when we're thinking about something as deadly as as an eating disorder. So it's not something that is like just this tiny, rare thing that can occur. It's something that is much more commonplace. And for most people it doesn't appear is that the stereotypical emaciated person or it doesn't like we have these very stereotypical ideas of what I need to look like or what of the behaviors and eating disorder. But actually there's a lot more things that we have normalized that are actually very, very disordered behaviors. And so just kind of coming back to the question, like, yeah, I think that there are things that people can do, but that there needs to be some level of of an awareness of of where are I noticing benefits here, but also what are, what are the drawbacks? And the difficulty that is, it's often when you are a lot further down the line into disordered eating that you start to notice the downsides. And so that's why I guess from my perspective, I'm often a a lot more cautious with these kind of things because I think what we can think of initially is as a huge amount of can then turn into something that is not right. And so there are many people that I've worked with, especially people who are either athletes or hobby athletes who are like the times that I was getting the best times in my races, I'm doing the best. PB And I thought I was absolutely in the best shape of my life. Everything worked fine. That was just when everything then tipped over the edge and it got really, really bad. And that was then when I got the injury. That was then when things started to really go down downhill. And so there can be this misunderstanding of like all everything feels like it's working really well is often the point where we've actually gone past where things are working well and you just haven't haven't noticed it quite yet. And so I think that that can be one of the tricky things with with this. I guess my other thing is that I feel like a lot of the the recommendations connected to this stuff can be, again, can be quite myopic about what are the things that we really need to to maximize versus other things that really make a difference. I often reference the Harvard, the Harvard study that is a study that's been going on, I think it started in the 1930s or 1940s, and it's been going on for for a number of generations now. And it started by looking at some some men who went to Harvard and then another control group of other guys just living in Boston. It's now been extended. So it's now the family of those men and then the kids of those men. And so it's kind of continuing on. And when they look at all of the data around this, the thing that is most predictive of longevity is relationships, having healthy relationships. And so rather than looking at, okay, what was their cholesterol markers at age 50, it's like what was their quality of their relationships like at age 50? And so I guess some of my my annoyance with this stuff is we get into the weeds about things and then can miss some much bigger, more important things that could make a real difference in in one's life. And so, yeah, if can be focusing on these all the things, you're going to get a much bigger bang for your buck then like, I got really into finding out about this very niche thing. And the more you're all about niche things to optimize your health, I'm sure like it doesn't, doesn't help the relationship piece of your life and but it's it is it does feel like today it's much easier as you say like yes kind of almost to not know that you are in the disorder like you have reached like you're now into this order zone because like today, like I'm also like a product of the nineties and I remember having like you would be really really feeling really lame saying something like, I'm like trying to lose weight. It's like the whole idea was to pretend like you eat pizza all day and you don't care and like, and like today it's like, it's so weird to because Yes, because, yes, when I, when I was disordered, I was so shamed. I would never have anybody see me eat or know what I eat. And today, like, it's completely normal. Like it would be completely normal. Nobody would have known that. It's that I have an issue. It's like it's and it's so, so, so yes, so so I think it's definitely true what you say about the mislabeling of success as well. And and we do also kind of lie to ourselves. Sometimes we feel like we figure this thing out, but actually even this little percentage of people who do succeed within the lifestyle change and maybe lose weight, they might be have to maintain a really disordered way of living or way of thinking to maintain it. And we just don't know it. We just I think because everybody because it's so prevalent, we lost the ability to recognize it. Maybe. Yeah, sure. And I guess one of the things I didn't mention before when I when I talked about the dieting piece and so I said, okay, someone diets and then they can't keep it off and so they they stop and you get into this, this cycle with, with dieting there are people where that doesn't happen and actually they just go on to develop an eating disorder. And there are many factors that go on that that pretty predispose someone to an eating disorder. And there is a genetic component, though there is a biological component. And so for a we take 100 people, most of those people who who go on a diet, it's after a while it becomes pretty unpleasant and there's like, I'm getting quite hungry or I'm craving this thing and it's just not enjoyable for someone who has the propensity to develop an eating disorder at some point that doesn't become uncomfortable, that comes enjoyable. And there is some some sensation, whether it can be this feels like euphoria or this feels very
calming. That can be something that actually there is a benefit for them not eating a benefit outside of just all this is going to make me thinner. Like there is some physiological change, a change in the nervous system. There is something that actually there is this period where this actually feels much, much better and there is a window of that and there's like a honeymoon period connected to that until the the energy debt that they're now accruing and the fact that the body is not able to function properly and repair starts to catch up with someone. And so there they are in this situation where. Okay, I'm now getting a lot of symptoms connected to this. I'm not able to sleep properly. I've lost my period. My digestion has got a lot worse. I'm feeling cold all the time. My hair's falling out like the symptoms can be can be a blast. And yet because of how eating disorders then affect the brain, they're in this situation where they're damned if they do and they damned if they don't like it. It feels so hard to now make the changes to start to bring in this extra food or to stop exercising, even if they are able to recognize like this is really affecting my my life, this is really negatively affecting my life. I want to have better quality relationships. I don't want to spend all my time thinking about food. The the amount of effort to actually then make that changes is really is really huge. And I think of eating disorders as being anxiety disorders. And so you get into this situation where you're avoiding lots of lots of things. And actually the way to to overcome that is through exposure and doing the thing that's really challenging, but it's actually a really hard thing to do. And I think there's going to be this real misunderstanding with this of like, come on, just eat it, just eat a sandwich, just get over it. Whereas actually for that person to do that is a very, very difficult thing. Like the analogy I'll often use, it takes someone who doesn't have an eating disorder, put them in a room, and that whole room is just filled with with snakes or filled with scorpions or filled with spiders and then here is your plate of food. Just get on with eating it. That is the experience for that person. It feels like they're crawling out of their skin to to eat this food and they can logically know it's just a sandwich. And yet the the nervous system reaction to that is to see that food as as a as a threat and so this is then the place that someone then then find themselves in when they go on to to develop an eating disorder. And that's I mean, even just as I'm describing it sounds horrible. I don't want to have that as my experience every time I eat a meal. And the good news is that someone can can get their way out of that situation and that by exposing themselves, by getting out of that debt, like things started to change. And in in a sense, the eating disorder that has been switched on in their brain is able to be to be switched off. But yeah, that
that is what what happens. And this is again, as I said, this happens a lot more frequently than we like to imagine. And so I don't want people to be experiencing that. And so when we're recommending all of these things that we talk about as just being harmless and innocuous and it doesn't what what's the problem with someone who is doing some intimate of fasting and what's the problem with someone just really cutting out all these foods like that is the problem is that actually this is this is there's a high percentage that chance that someone can go on to develop this this eating disorder. And we know that there are all the ways that someone could focus on on their health. what kills me away is that it's not just influencers, it's Harvard professors who say, like, you have to fast if you want to. If you if you don't want to like, let it fall apart. When you grow older, you have to fast. And then like, then you look at the data and you see that there is no there is no evidence that intermittent fasting does anything. It's it's it's kind of complicated, but it's been kind of it's correlated with caloric restriction, which supposedly does extend lifespan. But also in some cases it actually instead of extending their standard shorten slides then so we just don't know. But somehow the information that makes it to the masses is that for example, like now for a billion years now, intermittent fasting is good for you is important. If you want to survive, you have to to do it. And so many people are on this lifestyle train unnecessary really. But it makes me wonder if as someone who is and you say said you also you like the combination of the psychology and the biology with this difficult science that is, from my understanding, so difficult to study. We actually I had Stephen Brackman talk about it, who coined the term orthorexia about how hard it is to to study, if at all possible to study nutrition. But first of all, how should, how should we digest this kind of information that we hear, especially when it comes from more reputable institutions? And second, is there anything you feel about nutrition? I mean, like literally nutrition, food, eating that, you know, for certain that is a good recommendation. terms of the first question, in terms of like how should the layperson approach this, I would say approaching it as much with an with an open mind as possible, because I think the thing is typically when you read a book and it's written by an expert and look, I'm saying this for me as well, Take take what I say as a a grain of salt or a pitcher or whatever the expression is like, because everyone has their biases. Everyone has like even the people who are like, look, you've just got to look into the data. This is what the data said. Like, there is someone who is then saying the opposite of that of that person and they're able to say, Hey, looking at the data, this is what the data sets. And so we all come to this stuff without with our biases. And I think it's it's very healthy to remember to remember that. And I guess coming back to that, that context piece is also really important because you need to know you and you need to know what happened for you when you start to spend more of your time thinking about this stuff and playing around with this stuff, like does it truly add to the quality of your life? And as I said before, this can be a really hard one to parse because it takes sometimes time for things that feel like they're good to then turn out to be very obviously nefarious and not so, so good for you. So I guess my my suggestion with this is like when you're reading something, just because you read it doesn't necessarily make it true. And maybe it's good to to be a little bit skeptical about sort of absolutely everything connected to nutrition science just because it is like one. It is such an invitation in terms of the science in in the whole scheme of things where at the very, very early stages with it and it's very hard to do good science on this stuff because there are just so many variables connected to it. And I mean there are so many biases, as I said, that we already have around what is healthy and what's not healthy. So any biases around weight. And so I think it can be very difficult to do good research connected to this. And so, again, just like being aware, being aware of that and like I'm saying this as a nutritionist, I think we overblow how important food is a lot and that there are so many other variables that are really important for people to to pay attention to. And so, yeah, you can make some changes in your health connected to food, undoubtedly. And there are a lot of other things that can can make a significant difference in your life and probably a lot more significant difference in your life. And again, a lot of those you have absolutely no control over, like the parents that you were born into, the house that you were born in to where you born. All of these have a really big impact on you. And we can often forget that there's a great bit of research looking at the Mediterranean diet and the Mediterranean diet of your like high socioeconomic status makes a difference. And if you're not that, it doesn't make a difference at all because again, we're looking at, okay, there different things that are going to be more important for for for different people at different stages of of life and for for some person, if you're unable to pay the rent that is going to be having a much bigger impact on you then did I eat enough broccoli or legumes or whatever this this week and so I think we really need to remember that when we are looking at the science that, okay, there are all of these different variables that are going to have have an impact on on that pace. And so I'm now trying to remember the second part of your question. Okay. So was any any anything that you felt you knew for for certain? That is good advice about food that people can can adopt. And I mean, it's hard not like I don't know anything that is true for absolutely everybody because I will tell you something even very, very which seems like a truth that it's better to be eating a lot of vegetables like most people would think, okay, that is that is going to be completely true and that that's what everyone should be doing. And I have clients where actually there are a lot of vegetables that they really shouldn't be eating because they just don't digest them very well. And when they're having a high amount of salads or they're having a lot of cauliflower or broccoli or whatever, they just it shows is a huge amount of bloating for them and they don't actually benefit from that. And so I think that there are very few real truths when it comes food, which is true for absolutely everybody, because there are either edge cases or there are more than edge cases where there is actually a good chunk of the population, it could be that there's either 10% of the population actually who really shouldn't be having salad or really shouldn't be having cauliflower or whatever it may be, just because of where their digestive capacities is at. And so, yeah, again, this comes back to context and being aware of, okay, what, what works for you? completely. Context is the word. I completely agree. It makes so much sense. I'm so I'm so glad to to be reminded about this. And really, I would love to see a debate between someone like you and and some of those longevity folks who have really good intentions. But I think there are definitely some blind spots because those to those two areas, like usually don't overlap those two areas I think of the profession.