สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
Patrick: Hey Rita McGrath, welcome to Disruption Lab.
Rita McGrath: It's a pleasure to see you again.
Patrick: It's great to see you. You and I were talking ahead of time. It's been a few years.
Rita McGrath: I can't believe it and so much has changed in that time.
Patrick: It has I was actually on your website preparing for this. I'm like, how is Rita so prolific? You put out s I mean, am I right? You I mean you're of course, am I right? You're gonna go, Yes, Patrick, I'm so prolific, but you put out a lot of content. It's pretty amazing.
Rita McGrath: Well, I find it's a great way for me to learn. And you know, I think unlike some of our other fields, you know, accounting hasn't changed that much in the last few decades. And finance sort of follows the same rules, but in strategy, if you're not on top of what happened yesterday, you know, people
Patrick: Yeah.
Rita McGrath: are gonna say, What what what you're you're out of touch. So I think it's really important to stay on top of that.
Patrick: And it is interesting too in strategy how the the topic de jour is still the topic de jour, but at one moment we're all wanting to embrace AI and using it everywhere, and at other points we're going, wait, no, no, it's not getting the return we want, and at other points we're saying, well it's really risky, and we're kind of taking these topics and seeing them from different angles. Yeah.
Rita McGrath: Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
Patrick: So you build a career studying disruption and strategy and innovation. What's a disruption in your own life or career that looking back turned out to be a gift?
Rita McGrath: Probably st getting admitted to the social science systems program at Wharton. I was I believe I was their last full time doctoral student. and when I say it was a disruption, what I mean by that is this was Russ Akoff, who you may remember, he was a very well regarded management theorist, and this was sort of his effort to change the way that a business academia functioned from within. and it eventually got overwhelmed by the forces of tradition and whatnot, and the school ended up merging it, into another department. But why I thought that was such an interesting kind of disruption thing was it gave me the freedom to look across departments for what might be interesting. And that's what I ran into Ian McMillan, who had just come to Wharton from NYU, where he had set up the entrepreneurship program there. And so this would have been in the late 80s. And those of us old enough to remember this, Entrepreneurship at the beginning of the eighties was not seen as this hot and heavy career. It was seen as this thing that weird smelly guys from Silicon Valley who messed around with, you know, computer chips did.
Patrick: In the garage.
Rita McGrath: yeah. And it really wasn't until I would argue the Reagan administration, where Reagan really, for all the things that I might disagree with him on, I think he was really right on this one, which is he No, it's
Load full transcript
know, and a a society that can support entrepreneurs is really gonna be one that thrives. And Mac embraced that. He was recruited by NYU away from Columbia, where he'd been working, and then started their entrepreneurship center. And then was recruited again by Wharton to start their entrepreneurship center because it became kind of all the rage. And so he was very actively looking for doctoral students to work on his research. So before that, I had been working for the city of New York. And we did this incredibly glamorous thing called computerization. We were taking,
Patrick: Mm-hmm.
Rita McGrath: today we would call it digital transformation or Whatever. But back then it was basically taking paper processes and trying to introduce some automation to them. And it was a huge change for the organization, as you can imagine.
Patrick: yeah.
Rita McGrath: The procurement process of the city of New York. I mean, it's been muddling along since eighteen sixty one when the city was incorporated. had the Mimeo pages. Remember the pink Mimeo pages? Yep.
Patrick: Back when the back when a word call back when a word called doing things in triplicate made sense. If you don't know what that is, folks, look up triplicate. sure, of course.
Rita McGrath: Anyway, so I got fascinated by this idea of How do you introduce that really shocking change to large organizations? And so Mac was trying to recruit me to work at his center. And he said, So, what do you think you want to do your dissertation on? And I said, I think I'd love to do it on the science of implementation. And the room kind of went quiet. And he looks at me and he says, I can't think of anything more boring to study than the science of implementation. And fortunately for the two of us, a bit of good luck came my way because there was a very senior executive at Citibank named Ira Rimmerman. And what he was intrigued by at the time was that the bank had had these businesses where they just knocked it out of the park. consumer credit cards, their international businesses. They were among the first to probe various kinds of institutional lending. I mean, huge successes on the one hand, and then huge disasters on the other. they had this ill-fated venture into point of sale systems, they continuously struggled in Latin America, and and and so he was very interested to learn what. Why? why did some of them really, really work and why did they not? Well, right, yeah.
Patrick: Yeah, sure. And why why did it swing so radically from one yeah.
Rita McGrath: as he put it in our one of our entry interviews, he said, we're not a low variance organization, which I thought was very interesting. and so he gave Max Center a grant. I think it was $100,000 for three years, because he said, Look, I don't just want this to be a two-month superficial study. I really want you to get in there, I want you to talk to people. I want you to look at ventures that are in progress, not just the ones that we know what happened. and
you know, d pull together a picture. and so I got to be the project manager for that. And if you think about it, it's not too big a step from the science of implementation to how you innovate in a large organization. So Mac was happy, I was happy, and that laid the groundwork for a lot of things to come.
Patrick: Well, speaking of things to come, I one book I really liked that you wrote was Seeing Around Corners. And in that book, i you talk about this idea about inflection points and th that how those often show up and we start to see that like old assumptions start stop working. Could you tell us a little bit about that and maybe help the listener think about when these early signs might show up, how they start to change their world?
Rita McGrath: So I define a strategic inflection point, following Andy Grove, who initi coined the term as something that creates, you know, an order of magnitude shift in what's possible. So ten times or a hundred times cheaper, better, faster, easier, you know, whatever it is. And the thing about business is that any business that's successful has formed a recipe for that success. So that y you you figure it out, right? That's the innovation process. Then once you've got something that's working, now you're in the situation, a lovely situation. You turn the crank and money comes out, and that's great. And that process then finds its way into how you operate, how you're measured, how you're rewarded, oftentimes how you're regulated. so it it it it becomes the reality that you live in. And what an inflection point does is it changes the constraints that made that reality so workable. Now it doesn't do it overnight, as I like to say in the book. It it it it comes gradually, gradually, gradually, and then suddenly. But let's go back to our earlier example. If I take mimeograph pages, right? I mean, they were brilliant in the sense that you could now have three copies of something without having to like handwrite it over the way that monks did back in the Middle Ages. But if you compare the convenience of that to plain paper copying, it it it doesn't compare at all. And so once Xerox figured out plain paper copying, now all of a sudden you could run offices in a really different way. You could have identical copies of the same document. You didn't have to deal with a sixth version of something that some poor secretary was typing her way through. And I mean it's a subtle sounding sort of thing, but it had the effect of really changing how an organization could operate and at what speed. Right
Patrick: Sure. Yeah.
Rita McGrath: so I think you know we we love to talk about high tech, but I think some of these inflection points don't have to be digital or high tech or anything that happens to be the dominant technology of our particular moment in history. But what history tells us is these things just change what what's possible. And that gets very interesting because the incumbents often have a vested interest in what's
possible not changing. And the new entrants are often riding the wave of what's now newly possible. And so you have this interesting tension around the newcomers that are saying, hey, wait a minute, now we can do blah, blah, blah, whatever it is. And the incumbents saying, no, hang on, we don't really want to do that. And so you y it's one of the predictable tensions of going through an inflection.
Patrick: Well, it seems like right now, and maybe maybe it's just we always like to think our time's unique, right? But certainly sitting with it with AI and what's happening there, may maybe it's showing up in a way where everybody's a little bit more aware of it than maybe some things that might disrupt an industry over the course of time. It just doesn't sh land on my desk or I don't hear about it. But we all have varying degrees of access to AI and we hear about it a lot. So maybe just a little bit more energy going on around it or talk going on around it. But it is another Transformation. It is another inflection point and we're going to see what plays out from there. But what we do know is that oftentimes, and you write about this, smart people, smart organizations, they see the signals and then they still explain them away. I don't know if they feel like their moat is big enough or they're just so entrenched in their in their way they do things, but what is it about the status quo that might cause them to do that?
Rita McGrath: You I think there we go all the way back to Machiavelli, who who wrote in The Prince that there's no more perilous or hazardous an undertaking for a young prince than to try to change the established order of things, because the people who will benefit from the new ways do not yet know how it's going to benefit them, and the people who have benefited from the old system are going to fight you tooth and nail. So I think there's a lot of truth to that, and that was true in the 1500s, and it's true today. but if think about change in history, and I again I think you're right, we always like to say, our times are so different. think about this. We fought World War One on horseback and ended World War Two with the nuclear bomb. I mean, you know, talk about massive change in what's possible.
Patrick: Yeah, that's so true. That that is that is wild. My dad was born in nineteen thirty one and I'll talk to him about like what is he seen change in his lifetime and it's it's phenomenal. I mean, it's just it's unbelievable. We don't even know what it's gonna be like going forward when we're talking ten X, a hundred X, a thousand X change and things.
Rita McGrath: Yeah, I think about my husband's father, who I think was born in nineteen eleven. so if you think about the Wright brothers, their historic first flight at Kitty Hawk was nineteen three. And here's an interesting factoid. It took five years for any reputable news organization to go and try to find out what the Wright brothers were up to. because it was so inconceivable to people at the time that manned flight had been accomplished. And then of course, once they did, the floodgates opened. But so if you think about my husband's father, he would have, you know, been A young man, a teenager in the t twenties and thirties, and flight was just becoming something that was accessible to ordinary people. and so for him it was a complete revolution in anything that had been possible in his lifetime before. The idea that you could you could go across the ocean and it
Patrick: Yeah.
Rita McGrath: not in a boat and it you could do it in hours and not weeks. I mean, he was baffled by that.
Patrick: So what do you think, okay, let's say for example we we start to see that okay, a disruption's real, something's happening here. What's the move in your mind or the thinking perhaps that separates people who turn it into something you know, into something amazing and others who are just trying to survive it?
Rita McGrath: well, a couple of things. I think people who are curious, people who are comfortable with ambiguity. So because you know, when a new thing arrives, it doesn't come with a recipe book. You it it it it it you need to kind of figure out how it's relevant. So when I see effective, I'll call them entrepreneurs, but you they could be corporate people, they could be people, but but people who are seeing the new thing and saying, Hey, what could we do with that? I I think There's that sense of curiosity, that sense almost of playfulness. now I do think there's some things that have to go with it. I don't think you're gonna be welcoming a disruption if you're already feeling economically pressured. You know, if you're feeling frightened, if you're feeling put upon, if you're feeling threatened. that's not a recipe for being curious and playful and moving forward. So I think there's almost a security that we need to build in companies. And I often get asked, well, why is it that So many talented people in successful organizations are unwilling to take on the innovation function. And I think it's that. I think that, you know, if if if I succeed, let's say, at being innovative, my company benefits, you know, maybe my shareholders benefit, maybe my suppliers, whoever benefits. and that's if I succeed. So the the benefit is very diffuse, you know. And maybe it'll be good for my career, but maybe not. If I fail, it's all on me. Right?
Patrick: Mm.
Rita McGrath: And so I think there's, you know, the perfectly logical reason why Smart people would say, Well yeah, I'm not so sure I'm up for that.
Patrick: Yeah, sometimes why why set the big goal? If I do that I'm I'm naked at that moment. I'm vulnerable.
Rita McGrath: Yeah.
Patrick: as opposed to just soldiering along in that moment. it certainly
Rita McGrath: Uh-huh. Uh-huh.
Patrick: feels a little bit a little bit safer for sure. at least it feels that way.
Rita McGrath: It's funny, I just wrote a I just wrote a monthly newsletter, and I I try to put a little bit of content right
at the beginning just to reflect. And this particular newsletter was on AI, but it was about in any big change like that, there's all these people making all these heroic assumptions. And the example I used in the newsletter was the case of Klarna, which you may remember. their their CEO, Sebastian Sieman Symantawek, I think that's how he pronounces his name. made a huge deal about how he was going all in on AI in twenty twenty four and they had these AI agents that were doing the work of seven hundred human beings and he completely stopped hiring, they completely stopped, you know, recruiting, any of that stuff. and of course there was debate at the time about whether he was just doing that to goose his numbers to look good for the pending IPO. but you know, i it could have I don't know, I don't have any insider knowledge. And he seemed a perfectly sensible guy. So they go IPO in twenty 25, I want to say, at a price of forty dollars per share. well, they're now down to 13, which
Patrick: Mm.
Rita McGrath: you know, doesn't to me translate as an IPO success story. So it's like, well, what are the assumptions that you're making? And the assumptions are things like, well, a bot can handle the kind of complicated service calls a company like Klarna would get. So for people that aren't familiar with Klarna, it's a buy now, pay later service out of Sweden. And so you you know, you buy your pair of jeans or whatever, and you can break up your payments into a number of smaller ones. It's not a big commitment all at once. And then they take a little cut of the proceeds. and for some people, they find that very helpful. but you know, what they're finding now is customer satisfaction went down. people began to say you, you know, your company's just too difficult to deal with, but now they're public, and so they're much more exposed than when they were private. And
Patrick: Right.
Rita McGrath: so the whole article was about assumptions. And I had a friend write to me, he said, I can't believe this dirty something years after you started writing about this, we're still talking about testing assumptions.
Patrick: Absolutely. Well you talk about is it discovery driven planning, is that right?
Rita McGrath: Yes. huh.
Patrick: And and how to treat a new plan as a set of assumptions to test as opposed to a forecast, right? Yeah. Can you talk a little bit more about that?
Rita McGrath: sure. So discovery-driven planning had its origins in a puzzle, which is still happening today, which is you look at these companies and they're smart and they've got good people and they've got assets and they've got resources and they've got distribution channels and they have all these things that a a startup would kill for, right? And yet they get into these new areas and it's a disaster. So back in the day it would have been things like Euro Disney, which nearly took the whole company down. more recently you had Anheuser Busch and and Kerry. Creating this sort of love child of
adventure, which was alcohol pods, so it was drinkworks, it was called. And so the idea was kind of coffee pods in the morning and alcohol pods at night. What could possibly go wrong with
Patrick: yeah.
Rita McGrath: that? And when I developed these case studies, so I have this file at home I call my flops file. and the deal is you have to lose your parent company at least $50 million to get into my flops file. and today that's looking almost paltry. But anyway, so what I found when you looked at these businesses that Supposedly smart companies knew something about. It was untested assumptions taken as facts, very few opportunities to say, hey, let's let's plan to the limit of what we know, and then let's stop and you know assess what we've learned, and then decide whether it makes sense to continue or decide whether it makes sense to redirect. but let's take this huge monolithic 18-month plan and break it down into manageable pieces, which we can learn a lot about for each one.
Patrick: So I recently saw your new HBR work around strategic centering. And I'm I'm I'm thinking there's a connection point between these because the idea of an organization finding its center could what what do we mean by that? Why does it matter, especially when things around it tend to be shifting?
Rita McGrath: Yeah, so and this is not I'm I'm not claiming this is a brand new idea that nobody's ever thought of. there's a lot of great work that's been done on how you how you find purpose, how you find meaning. where I started to struggle with a lot of those established concepts, and not that they're not useful, they are, but but look purpose doesn't always help you make choices. And if you think about strategy, strategy's fundamentally about making the best choices under conditions of competition and limited resources. So You have to choose. And somehow a purpose could be very broad, but there could be lots of ways of getting at a purpose, right? So let's just say you wanted to establish excellent customer service. Well, you could do that through focusing exclusively on a kind of customer, and we're going to just surround them with love. And there are companies that do that. Or you could say, hey, we have the best technology to solve your problems. But it's two different ways of getting at providing excellence in your customer service. So the other thing that I think is going on is where In a context in which things that used to be safely anchored to physical goods. So I was a railroad company, or I was a library, or I was a, you know, I made aerospace parts or whatever it was, physical things. More and more and more of the assets of the largest corporations are actually intangible. So their software, their patents, their know-how, their customer relationships, they're not things that you know are like inventory and plant and property and equipment. And it feels to me that it you need some concept that makes it clear where it makes sense to play and where it doesn't in a world that's kind of dematerializing. So in the article I talk about the choices facing Novartis. And Novartis, when Vasanara Simhan, who's currently their CEO, took over in twenty eighteen, they were like most pharma companies, big global pharma. So they had a pharma arm, and then they also had a consumer products group and they had a group that did I care. And then they had a group that did generic and this grab back in. The theory of business at the time was that when your patents went over a cliff and therefore your profitability got pressured, you could rely on your nice safe consumer products and go back and and and that would get you through that sort of period in between your
Patrick: Yeah, sure.
Rita McGrath: drugs getting to market. And Voss actually went back and looked at it and he said, You know, I don't think that theory holds up. when we stumbled, you know, what got us back to Health was the science every time. And he said, so I'm going to really center on this mission of creating innovative medicines that are possible breakthroughs. And you know, human biology is wickedly difficult. And so he's not setting his company up for an easy task. But he said, you know, I'd rather have my scientists working on really big important problems that could make a big difference. So I'll give you a specific case. So imagine you're in the Capitol Committee and you have two conflicting proposals. And one proposal is an over-the-counter painkiller. And what's great about that is you know what the totable addressable market is, you know how many you're likely to sell, you know how to market it, you know how to and I mean you know a lot, right? So uncertainty has really been eliminated. Plus, Novartis has strong experience in that. So they're not likely to screw up when they're building a plant or anything like that. So it's likely to be very low in failure. However, it's a super core business. Those kinds of painkillers have been around for decades. It's not likely to change anybody's life in a material way. so at the same time, then you have a proposal for getting into something like radioligand therapy. Now, this is wicked stuff. This is you're attaching nuclear particles to a carrier cell, which goes into the body, it's injected, and then it can go straight to the side of the cancer cell and specifically kill the cancer cell with pinpoint precision. Now,
Patrick: Well.
Rita McGrath: for diseases like prostate cancer, this is revolutionary because the existing Treatments for prostate cancer are all horrible. you could get chemotherapy,
Patrick: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Rita McGrath: which is awful and it kills healthy tissues. You could have radiation therapy, which is the same, or surgery, which is life changing and not in a good way. and so this this has, you know, enormous potential to really save people's lives for a disease that most men in Western society are gonna have some brush with it. That that's that's what if if you live long enough, it's
the kind of thing that's eventually gonna happen.
Patrick: Yeah, that's what they say. Live long enough, yeah.
Rita McGrath: So, so what do you do? You know, the radio ligand stuff's brand new. You as a company have zero experience in it. So you're gonna have to get it by making some acquisitions, which are likely to be expensive. The manufacturing process is wicked, because this is nuclear stuff. You can't have it sitting around on a shelf. So from from like getting it out of the factory into a patient is I I forget the exact number, but it's not long. It's like a week or two. and and and and and and but what do you do? Well, if you don't have a center, right? And I'm sure you sat in these meetings, right? You it's arguing back and forth, and my spreadsheet's more robust than yours, and we can predict the outcome of this other stuff. We don't even know it's gonna be approved for end any indications besides prostate cancer. So why are we in this? now once you found a center, and your center is innovative medicines, then the ch y you don't even have to have the conversation. It's like, of
Patrick: Yeah.
Rita McGrath: course we're gonna do radio legends, you know? and so that to me was the moment of sort of aha about the concept, which is If you had chosen another center, then no way would you touch radio legance, right? If your thing was we're gonna make sure that everyday consumers, if you're like Procter and Gamble, right? Everyday consumer is the boss and we just wanna make that everyday moments that matter, matter, and matter, matter to the customers we wanna serve, then you'd probably go with the over-the-counter painkiller, right? So I'm not saying one answer is right and the other answer is wrong. What I'm saying is is until you've chosen a center, it's really hard to make those decisions.
Patrick: It seems to me that to some extent, although there's always going to be robust debate, hopefully, in organizations where we're talking about things like this or anything else, but there is a bit of, well, we make the decision once and we know what the center is, and then we have the ability to make future choices based upon that, not going back and renegotiating that a lot. But sometimes
Rita McGrath: Yep, I think that's true.
Patrick: organizations do that, right? sometimes people do that. We think we know what our center is or what our organization's center is, and then we hit something new and we find ourselves. not debating should we do X or Y. We're debating whether or not the center was right. How do how do how do we how do we know when we go back and revisit the center or how do we know when we go like we made that decision. Let's move forward.
Rita McGrath: Right. Well, I think a couple of things on centering, which I've learned in the time that I've been working with companies on it. the first thing I would observe is I think centers are actually discovered for most established firms. I don't think they're declared. I think it is the kind of repertoire of things we pay attention to, the things we think are important, the decisions from the past that have you can almost think of it like the organizational equivalent of case law, right? So you go back in time in in in a case law situation, you say, well, how did the judge decide that case? And that that sets the precedent for the next thing. I think in any organization that's at all competent, you have this consistency of action that provides almost the organizational equivalent of case law. So if you're having a debate about what your center is, I think what you have to do is the way I do it practically is, you know, some pre-work, and then we get a group of decision makers together where we say, okay, let's let's talk about a couple of different things. So firstly, What what do you think? And usually people come in and they're all over the map. there'll be the people that are in marketing, of course, think it's all about customers, and the guys that are in tech think it's all about technology, you know, and so forth. And it's all legitimate, right? But then when you really probe and you say, okay, well, when we had the last three or four important decisions to make, what pushed us over the edge to do A and not B? if we were choosing between this customer or that customer to prioritize, which would it be and why? where were we most proud of what we accomplished? Even if it wasn't necessarily the most profitable thing we could have done for that two-year period, but where did it really make us feel like we were delivering? And through the course of those conversations, what you'll often find is there's is this rich pattern. Now, where it's more difficult is let's say you've got two organizations that merged and they're completely differently centered. So I'll give you an example which I thought was hilarious. So ATT years ago bought I think it was ATT, one of the big phone companies anyway. bought I want to say Time Warner, some some company that was very much in the entertainment space, right? And for many years again, this was one of those things that crept into the industry lore, which was, we don't want to be just dumb pipes, right? We we we don't want everybody to go over the top and all we're doing is the commodity part of the business. We want to have content, we want to have things to offer that leverage our pipes. So so I was I was in class and one of the guys from Time Warner came to me, I think it was Time Warner It was an entertainment company anyway. And he said, I have to tell you, this is gonna be problematic. I said, What do you mean? He said, Well, the ATT HR people all turn up at our premises and they wanna run through with us their HR policies, you know. And now let's remember, ATT, among many other things, runs really dangerous facilities. I mean, you've got guys up on the in storms on the top of telephone poles with electric, you know, with lightning going on around them, and you've got to keep them safe
and you've got to make sure that everything's done exactly as it's supposed to be. and so there's a very solid reason why you would have HR policies that are very strict about things like drug use and frequent drug testing, and you know, people have to be very precise in how they do stuff and training and all that. And now think about the movie business, you know, and who are
Patrick: Yeah.
Rita McGrath: these people that are in like rock and roll music and movies? And you're
Patrick: Yeah.
Rita McGrath: gonna come in there and you're gonna say, we wanna do drug testing and we wanna make sure you don't deviate from the corporate I mean I know that's just
Patrick: Yeah, talk about a sh missing missing going right past each other on that one.
Rita McGrath: Yeah. And so I think, you know, you got one center which is all around safe, reliable, efficient operations for the benefit of masses of people. And you've got another whole operation that's all about those tales of the distribution where that rare three percent of creative output pays for everything else, two completely different business logics.
Patrick: Yeah. How much of you know, there's people listening to the podcast who are here because they're in organizations or, you know, they're kind of maybe maybe in a position where the they are making strategic decisions for the organization and other people are elsewhere in their career and in their life, but how much have you found that what you study translates to the individual as far as their own career, their own choices, their own lives?
Rita McGrath: A lot. Quite a lot. More than more than I would have originally thought. Now, it as an individual, you tend to be better at winning the arguments about what we should do next. So one of you is gonna win, right? If
Patrick: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Rita McGrath: if you're your own person, you can get away with that. But you know, even I'm sh angels and devils, right?
Patrick: Although I have robust I have robust discussions going on in in my gray matter. Exactly.
Rita McGrath: but even as an individual, you're negotiating with your family, you know, you're negotiating with your community, you've got other stakeholders that they're not working with you, but they're They've got an interest in what you decide. so I think a lot of it, I think, with, for example, with strategic inflection points, and you and I were just discussing previously, when those moments come where you have to leave behind something that you were doing that was great, it was successful, but it's kind of run its course, you really are ready for the next challenge, you're just kind of getting stale. one of the scariest things is that initial period of making that decision often feels either a decline or a sideways move. it doesn't feel like a smooth leap to your next
Patrick: Yeah, right.
Rita McGrath: S curve, right? It feels like, wow, I'm in a strange situation. I don't know what I'm doing. This is all new to me and whatever. I'll never
forget my first year in my PhD program. I well, I'd been managing. So at the age of I don't know, the city of New York's insane sometimes. So I was like twenty-five or twenty-six years old, and I managed a group of like dozens of consultants, and I had 12 people reporting to me and you would think I knew a thing or two about management just from having been thrown off the deep end like that. Because the thing is, if you're young and you're capable in government, you can get enormous responsibility very young. And so I get to Warden, and you know, I got a little, I was very proud, I got a little carol in the library there. And I'm I'm I'm doing my assigned coursework, my f my first management class, and I'm reading this article by a guy named John Child, who subsequently became a good friend of mine. He's a very well-known academic. And the article was, the title was something like Management Actually Does Matter. And I'm looking at this article and I'm like, well, if I didn't think management mattered, why would I be giving up four years of my life to study this thing? Like what? And what I didn't know at the time, and this is the kind of tribal wisdom that anybody making a change is going to run up against, was at the time a very popular strand in management theory was a thing called organizational ecology. And the concept was that you're going to treat organizations like bugs. That what explains their durability is not anything about what managers do, but rather did they were they born into fertile environments? Were they able to get enough resources from those environments that they could now survive on their own, even if there were setbacks? And then the the population studies all look like some niche opens up, everybody goes charging in, then you have a shakeout, and then the survivors survive robustly, and everybody else goes out of business. and and that was very, very popular, I think because it was very mathematical. time and we we in management often have a lot of physics envy we want p p values and statistics and correlations and so what john child was basically saying was no actually management matters and and let's not all go over the cliff on on just thinking of bugs. the other by the way just d as as a as an aside I actually went back and looked at a bunch of those studies. specifically I looked at every business that opened up or shut in the Princeton area. And I was aided and abetted in this by a wonderful reporter. Who was just passionate about local businesses. And what she did was she had this column in our local paper, and it was called Comings and Goings. And in the paper, what she did was she actually said, here's this company, and they've moved to town, and here's where they're from, and here and here's this company, and they're leaving town, and yada yada yada. But the thing that she had that a lot of these big data sets don't have is she had the explanation of why the companies were doing what they were doing.
Patrick: yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Rita McGrath: And so if you're just looking at a directory of phone books, you don't know that. You know that, you know, ABC Company. Is no longer listed in the phone book, but it Exactly. So
Patrick: They were in the phone book for three years and then they weren't anymore. That's all Yeah.
Rita McGrath: and and in that body of research, those events were always interpreted as a mortality event, meaning if your listing went away, you must have gone away. And what I find when you look at the actual data is that's Totally far from the truth. What'll happen is you get some entrepreneur, he started a biotech, Merck goes and buys him and invests, you know, ten million dollars in his company. That's not a mortality event, nor is it a failure event. It's
Patrick: No, that that's a win.
Rita McGrath: a big win, right? Or some guy decides for tax reasons he's gonna move from New Jersey to Pennsylvania. His company's still there and thriving, but it's no longer in the New Jersey directory. So what I found was p s depending on the on the Slice it that you were looking at anywhere between 25% and 50% of these so called mortality events actually weren't.
Patrick: Isn't that wild? It's funny. I I'm in the process, I had told you on the front end, of of starting another part of a study on disruption. And it it when you start and then we're very early on in the stage of just what question do we want to answer? So we're just doing that right now. And it's interesting because w you you you can cut you can shut yourself down if you don't watch out because you'll start saying, Well, let's let's talk about this qu an this question we'd like to answer, and you go, Well, how are we gonna possibly find, you know, the data for data associated with making an argument or a decision around that? But that's But when you start looking at that, you go, you run into things like you're talking about. Well, why did this business go away? We we don't know. We can't just assume w one thing. Or might say like, we want to study how senior leaders make a decision and how well those decisions are informed by frontline employees' observations, right? Where are you gonna find those things? If you're looking at historical historical moves of companies, they're not always in minutes of saying, Joe Schmoe. was working on this project, saw this thing and somehow it got fed up to the senior executives. It just does doesn't doesn't exist in that manner.
Rita McGrath: You can't learn a lot from calendar studies. And and this
Patrick: That's true. Yeah.
Rita McGrath: is one where I actually think this sort of corporate curse in many cases of you know, everybody's calendar being electronic and visible and everybody. But I think there's actually some interesting research potential there.
Patrick: Well, just AI alone will sometimes I'll ask it to take a look at my calendar and give me some insights on things. And it's amazing just on your own calendar what it tells
you you do. good and bad. No,
Rita McGrath: It can be really depressing.
Patrick: good and bad. There's some good things in there too. Yeah, absolutely. Well, hey Rita, thank you so much for joining us today. I've really enjoyed the conversation. We have one question we always wrap up with. My my my producer Jess, she said to me one time, listeners know this, that she said, Patrick, you go to the same place and get the same drink all the time. If you're traveling on the road or home, you always go to the same chain restaurant. coffee shop and buy your same coffee. Can you mix it up a little bit? So I've been mixing it up and I've landed on this question to ask guests. Rita, is there a perfect food or drink that you're currently in pursuit of or have you found it? And if so, let us know about it.
Rita McGrath: Perfect food or drink. Wow. And I love to cook, so that's a that's a big question. well I guess if I were to
Patrick: You might have the per you might have the perfect ingredient. I have no idea.
Rita McGrath: I you know, there's a a wonderful German recipe for something called Rulaten, which is a rolled up beef with sort of bacon and onions and mustard and sometimes pickles and whatever. and as a little girl I kind of that was our special occasion food, right? And now I've sort of passed that on to my kids. And so when we can get it, and what's interesting about it is it provides just enough difficulty that it's not easy. So when
Patrick: Ha ha.
Rita McGrath: I actually secure the ingredients, I feel like I've triumphed in the hunt because it requires a specially cut sort of top round fillet and not many, not many grocery stores carry it. Yes, yes, I am I am the I am the lioness. I am gonna go get this thing
Patrick: You're literally out foraging for the Rulatin. Yes.
Rita McGrath: down and and and you know it yeah I I go to things like I'll I'll look up German butchers or whatever.
Patrick: Do you ever find one a r roulatin you said, correct? Do you ever yeah do you ever find
Rita McGrath: Ruladen it's called, yeah.
Patrick: one made in the wild at a restaurant or someplace? You're like, That's actually really good. That's a really good one.
Rita McGrath: sure, yeah, yeah. It would be very typical. If you went to a German restaurant, that would be a very typical thing that they would serve. but you know, it's not it it wouldn't be common to many other cuisines. Now, there are cuisines that have their own variety, like Italians would have braccioli, and then that kind of thing. So but I think if I were to my family were to pick something that they see as kind of a special food that that that they enjoy because the other thing is it's not It's not like two seconds to make. You have to pound the beef, you have to cut everything up, you have to lay it all
Patrick: of course not. Yeah, yeah.
Rita McGrath: out, you have to grind it, get the wine, cook it in. it's, it's an effort. but it's very worth it.
Patrick: Yeah, that's awesome. That's awesome. Well, if I'm ever at your house, I'm gonna be looking you up for this one. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Come on, get out of you gotta go there and find this stuff and get to work. Awesome. Well hey Rita, thanks so much. Great seeing you again.
Rita McGrath: Hey, let give just I just need advanced notice, right? I gotta get Shotzi the butcher to Shotzi the Butcher's gotta do stuff for me there. Thank you.
Patrick: I hope our paths cross real soon. probably next time I'm in New York. Take care.
Rita McGrath: Thank you. I I love that. Thanks a lot.