สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
WEBVTT
00:02.825 --> 00:06.936
Welcome to Bytes of Experience, where 2 retired Canadian
00:07.436 --> 00:11.046
higher ed CIOs share unfiltered insights on campus tech,
00:11.271 --> 00:14.819
strategy, and leadership. Serious experience
00:14.883 --> 00:15.895
with a lighter touch.
00:27.067 --> 00:30.353
Welcome back to Bytes of Experience, where we explore the systems, strategies,
00:30.385 --> 00:33.638
and stories behind higher ed transformation. I'm Beau Wanschneider,
00:33.654 --> 00:36.859
joined as always by Dana Sanderson. Today's episode is about hope,
00:37.259 --> 00:40.528
not as a feeling, but as something you can build into an institution and
00:41.028 --> 00:44.294
what that means for the people who run its technology. Our guest today is Dr.
00:44.374 --> 00:47.643
Jessica Riedel, Shakespeare scholar at Bishop's University,
00:48.076 --> 00:51.617
3M National Teaching Fellow, and founder of Hope Circuits Institute.
00:52.322 --> 00:55.399
I first met Jessica when she came to UPEI to give the Shannon K.
00:55.463 --> 00:58.636
Murray Lecture on Hope and the Academy, and I was in the
00:59.136 --> 01:02.273
room for a workshop she led with our leadership team. I walked out of that
01:02.773 --> 01:05.847
session genuinely inspired. One of the ideas from her book,
01:06.023 --> 01:10.189
Hope Circuits, has stuck with me ever since. The times are urgent.
01:10.654 --> 01:14.596
Let us slow down. And for a campus in 2024 that felt pressured
01:15.096 --> 01:17.993
to fix everything at once, that was exactly what we needed to hear.
01:18.586 --> 01:22.056
Over our first season, we kept coming back to one idea. The CIO
01:22.556 --> 01:25.589
role was never really about the technology. It's about the people, trust,
01:25.670 --> 01:29.219
and culture. Jessica has spent years asking how you rewire
01:29.283 --> 01:32.544
a whole university around those things. So we want to hear her vision
01:32.817 --> 01:36.013
and ask what it expects from CIOs. So welcome,
01:36.029 --> 01:39.563
Jessica. Thank you so much for the invitation, and thank you so
01:40.063 --> 01:43.514
much for hosting this conversation. I think the CIOs are
01:44.014 --> 01:47.878
some of the my most beloved guides in systems
01:47.975 --> 01:52.049
thinking. You see across those systems, you see both the urgency
01:52.065 --> 01:55.802
and the opportunity, and you also have to exercise
01:56.011 --> 01:59.941
deep grace for the imperfect, flawed humans within
02:00.441 --> 02:04.657
the systems, where sometimes the answer is, have you unplugged
02:05.157 --> 02:09.213
it and plugged it back in? Not just for your laptop, but for
02:09.790 --> 02:13.223
our visioning, our work. And Dana, that back to
02:13.255 --> 02:17.010
that notion of the times are urgent, let us slow down. It works for humans
02:17.026 --> 02:20.721
too, right? Let's unplug and plug it back in and see if we can,
02:20.946 --> 02:24.898
we can get moving again. For Hope Circuits, you spoke with
02:25.398 --> 02:28.994
hundreds of people across higher ed. Can you take
02:29.494 --> 02:32.914
us back to the start? What were you seeing that made you begin this work
02:33.235 --> 02:36.930
and why borrow the term hope circuit from neuroscience?
02:37.733 --> 02:42.488
Oh, Dana, thank you for asking about the origin story. I accidentally
02:42.988 --> 02:46.546
wrote this book. This was not planned. It demanded of
02:46.594 --> 02:49.752
me to come into the world through conversation.
02:50.201 --> 02:54.161
So if we go all the way back to, um, early 2020,
02:54.674 --> 02:58.200
I had just finished a book with 2 fellow Shakespeareans,
02:58.216 --> 03:01.807
one of them the Shannon K. Murray Lecture is named after, and we'd
03:02.307 --> 03:05.719
written a book called Shakespeare's Guide to Hope, Life, and Learning. And our
03:06.219 --> 03:09.663
premise was that a perfectly designed classroom, a perfectly designed
03:10.163 --> 03:14.119
theater, and a perfectly designed democracy all share the same conditions.
03:14.632 --> 03:17.697
That there's not one person telling you what to think,
03:17.985 --> 03:21.226
that we are creating a world that unfolds together in
03:21.290 --> 03:25.173
real time, in bodies, in space, with all of the messiness
03:25.221 --> 03:28.076
and imperfection, and everybody is hoping for a happy ending.
03:28.525 --> 03:32.729
So if you think about a classroom, I don't stand behind a podium
03:32.985 --> 03:36.499
and give a lecture about 1,000 years of
03:36.531 --> 03:39.788
literature. I stand in a circle with
03:39.820 --> 03:43.317
students who are deeply curious, asking questions about what it means
03:43.413 --> 03:46.928
to be human. And these are questions we've been thinking about for thousands
03:47.041 --> 03:49.401
of years, but they're vivid and important now.
03:50.316 --> 03:53.639
And then of course, the notion of a theater is you show up and a
03:53.687 --> 03:56.947
Shakespeare play can't happen without you showing up as well.
03:57.091 --> 04:00.976
You have to harness your imagination and
04:01.185 --> 04:04.781
immerse yourself in a world. And the same for a democracy.
04:04.861 --> 04:08.939
It has to be creative. A democracy that we treat as monolithic
04:09.439 --> 04:12.856
or as an institution removed from our everyday encounters is one
04:12.872 --> 04:16.787
that will already start to disintegrate. And we're seeing
04:17.445 --> 04:20.591
what the consequences of us imagining that democracy
04:21.091 --> 04:25.036
is somebody else's job happening both in our own national
04:25.325 --> 04:28.631
landscape, but also around the world. So I was writing
04:28.695 --> 04:31.856
this book with these 2 amazing humans and we were theorizing what
04:31.969 --> 04:34.889
critical hope was. And then as you remember,
04:35.178 --> 04:38.966
March 13th, 2020, every Canadian university and
04:39.466 --> 04:42.914
college closed. It was a Friday. I remember it vividly.
04:43.123 --> 04:46.734
I was
Load full transcript
sitting in Senate virtually as we decided
04:47.234 --> 04:51.003
to close our institution for the first time since 1843.
04:51.485 --> 04:54.903
So when we talk about COVID being unprecedented, it certainly was
04:55.000 --> 04:58.177
for our institution and our communities. And so all
04:58.226 --> 05:01.403
of a sudden, everywhere I located hope, the classroom,
05:01.821 --> 05:05.224
the theater, and society, On one day, everything closed.
05:05.690 --> 05:09.511
I lost where I located, the ways in which we co-created
05:09.543 --> 05:13.606
meaning together. And so I started to reach
05:13.702 --> 05:17.572
out to people. My kids were 4 and 6 at the time they came home.
05:17.652 --> 05:20.879
I was parenting, workload tripled,
05:21.409 --> 05:24.845
and within a week, my husband was diagnosed with life-threatening lung
05:24.877 --> 05:28.137
cancer. So it was vivid, both professionally,
05:29.774 --> 05:34.413
in our communities, but it also felt deeply personal. And I didn't
05:34.429 --> 05:37.077
know how to get out of bed in the morning. So, I started to ask
05:37.577 --> 05:41.234
folks that. I wasn't setting out to write a book. I was setting out to
05:41.734 --> 05:44.909
figure out what this world meant when we have
05:45.567 --> 05:48.488
all of a sudden and overnight lost the playbook,
05:48.697 --> 05:52.741
lost the blueprints, lost the ability to predict the future.
05:53.191 --> 05:56.946
And so, one conversation after another turned into 300 conversations
05:57.043 --> 06:01.169
over 2 years, where I interviewed people about how they
06:01.554 --> 06:05.359
built hope as a verb, as something you do that's
06:05.568 --> 06:09.309
entangled in our systems, our structures, our policies,
06:09.743 --> 06:13.597
but also mapped onto our institutional cultures and the
06:13.661 --> 06:17.819
relational infrastructure. So I didn't have any answers
06:17.996 --> 06:21.207
and Beau and Dana, I am sorry to report that I
06:21.707 --> 06:26.088
have fewer answers and more questions. But that really was that origin
06:26.120 --> 06:30.134
story, was that deep curiosity about how people are
06:30.214 --> 06:33.939
understanding the convergences between the structural,
06:34.453 --> 06:37.696
the relational, and the cultural. And then if that's where the
06:38.196 --> 06:41.870
messiness happens, that's also where the magic can happen. And that really
06:41.935 --> 06:45.130
became the thinking behind Hope Circuits,
06:45.162 --> 06:48.292
not as a destination. You asked about neuroscience.
06:48.822 --> 06:52.495
It's a circuit. Reiterative, that hope has to be large enough so that you can
06:52.527 --> 06:56.775
despair and you can howl into the abyss and you can say,
06:56.919 --> 07:00.382
why are these systems so broken? And that's not the antithesis
07:00.882 --> 07:04.325
of hope. That's just part of the hope circuit. That's like, okay, all right,
07:04.534 --> 07:07.724
here's why it's really hard. Let's not avert our gazes.
07:07.820 --> 07:12.180
Let's sit with the trouble and then let's come back into curiosity
07:12.261 --> 07:16.493
so we can think about what we can do together to make the
07:16.993 --> 07:21.229
future better, more inclusive, more just. And so that circuit is
07:21.309 --> 07:24.214
really an indicator that it's not— you can rewire.
07:25.322 --> 07:28.885
Neuroscience found that your brain can rewire
07:29.013 --> 07:32.480
towards hope, that your default response is despair,
07:32.785 --> 07:36.044
your default response is helplessness, but they found
07:36.156 --> 07:39.992
in your brain synapses that you can build with
07:40.492 --> 07:43.861
the neuroplasticity of becoming more hopeful. And so
07:44.262 --> 07:48.388
I borrowed that from neuroscience and thought if the brain is the most complex
07:48.773 --> 07:52.675
system that we still haven't entirely mapped, can we use those ideas
07:52.755 --> 07:56.512
for other complex systems like universities in
07:56.608 --> 08:00.381
order to think about how to build deliberate and intentional
08:00.798 --> 08:04.619
connections and synapses across this living ecosystem?
08:05.117 --> 08:08.906
That's awesome. I'm really liking where this is going. And we
08:09.406 --> 08:12.675
talked beforehand and, you You talked about being unplugged and unfiltered. And I think,
08:12.979 --> 08:15.944
you know, Dana and I are going to go there and maybe we'll go for
08:16.444 --> 08:18.924
a little bit of a journey. I'm glad you also brought up, you know,
08:19.309 --> 08:22.610
COVID, and that's something we've talked about in previous episodes. And it was something I
08:23.091 --> 08:26.488
really struggled with. And we've talked about
08:26.696 --> 08:30.173
it in different things and had some guests on. What I want to do now
08:30.237 --> 08:32.865
is I want to ask you a little bit about what you were talking about
08:33.365 --> 08:37.016
there. And something that really resonated with me in your work was this
08:37.516 --> 08:41.282
notion of building community intentionally and relationships,
08:41.363 --> 08:44.923
trust, solidarity, and shared purpose and how they matter.
08:44.971 --> 08:48.228
And you're sort of starting to talk about that there. And it's not about having
08:48.340 --> 08:51.259
isolated heroics. As a CIO, I've always said,
08:51.532 --> 08:55.028
you know, we shape norms and build consensus and that's
08:55.157 --> 08:58.942
the role. So, maybe you wanna talk a little bit about that? Absolutely. Well,
08:58.990 --> 09:02.615
and you're the key influencers, right? You are sort of, you see the
09:03.115 --> 09:06.562
systems, you see how we interface. You see the possibilities.
09:06.610 --> 09:10.688
You also see a lot of the threats that we don't see, right? That you
09:10.737 --> 09:13.948
are managing. There are external threats, there are internal threats,
09:14.895 --> 09:18.396
and that has created, I think, on campuses that I have visited, I have visited
09:18.813 -->
09:21.912
100 colleges and universities over the last
09:22.040 --> 09:25.123
2 and a half years and engaged with
09:25.155 --> 09:28.447
50 associations and organizations. And I can tell you
09:28.463 --> 09:32.058
that we have a COVID hangover. We have
09:32.298 --> 09:35.777
a set of communities with unprocessed grief.
09:36.322 --> 09:39.416
We have hypervigilance. We have fraying
09:39.673 --> 09:43.360
trust within our campus communities. And so, I love that
09:43.860 --> 09:47.335
you understand that role as a CIO, as somebody who's building that
09:47.448 --> 09:50.814
relational trust. When you encounter technology, when it doesn't
09:50.894 --> 09:54.918
work, me personally, I go into nervous system dysregulation.
09:55.142 --> 09:58.749
I get frustrated. I get sad. Full of fear. I come back
09:58.765 --> 10:02.244
to my default, I panic, and my laptop doesn't turn on. It is the
10:02.356 --> 10:06.235
end of the world. And the first person I contact,
10:06.684 --> 10:10.659
one of my favorite thought partners, is our CIO at Bishop's University.
10:10.708 --> 10:14.683
His name is Scott Stoddard, and he is one of my favorite thinkers
10:14.875 --> 10:18.963
about systems change and the relational infrastructure that
10:19.463 --> 10:22.922
you're shaping norms and influencing the ways in which we connect with one
10:22.970 --> 10:26.389
another. That we connect to our research, that we connect to governance,
10:26.502 --> 10:30.307
that we understand financial literacy. And now more than ever,
10:30.741 --> 10:34.337
really investing in sitting in curiosity,
10:34.867 --> 10:38.480
sitting as learners, is an invitation that we need to
10:39.122 --> 10:42.623
solicit all of their constituents across
10:43.123 --> 10:47.102
the campus ecosystem. What I find so interesting in
10:47.375 --> 10:50.905
higher education is that And I make the joke in Hope Circuits
10:51.405 --> 10:55.249
that we're really good at studying everything but ourselves. And the
10:55.749 --> 10:59.609
second part of that, I think, is that we all came to higher education because
10:59.625 --> 11:03.232
we were curious learners, because we experienced what
11:03.732 --> 11:07.432
I call epistemic humility, which is the, like, I don't know any of
11:07.480 --> 11:11.648
the answers. I'm, you remember when you were an undergraduate and you kind of encountered
11:12.148 --> 11:14.870
an idea for the first time and you realized that you didn't know anything and
11:15.370 --> 11:19.373
you were sort of understanding, looking into the unknown and you wanted to
11:19.873 --> 11:23.892
know more. I wonder in higher education
11:24.405 --> 11:28.620
if we have done many of the humans within our ecosystems
11:28.716 --> 11:32.321
disservice by calling them experts and authorities where they have
11:32.821 --> 11:36.969
to have the right answer instead of sitting together and wondering and
11:37.049 --> 11:41.279
imagining together at this moment of rupture,
11:41.857 --> 11:45.114
of disruption, of uncertainty. We can
11:45.162 --> 11:48.693
no longer predict the future, but we can participate
11:49.193 --> 11:52.432
in inventing it, which requires us to sit as learners.
11:52.865 --> 11:55.979
It requires us to sit in curiosity. It requires us
11:56.479 --> 12:00.456
to get into a room even as we think differently and
12:00.809 --> 12:04.468
engage in the civic imagination necessary to
12:04.564 --> 12:08.159
meet this moment of civilizational transition.
12:08.688 --> 12:12.524
There are so many ways we could spin off of that
12:12.589 --> 12:16.216
conversation, those things, Jessica. I'm going to
12:16.716 --> 12:20.614
go back to what I started with about, you know, the times are urgent
12:20.630 --> 12:23.936
and we must slow down. And you spoke to it about
12:24.436 --> 12:28.382
a little bit about CIOs, and CIOs kind of live in this permanent
12:28.574 --> 12:32.170
urgency where there's incidents and projects and
12:32.250 --> 12:35.924
now AI. And So, what does slowing down
12:36.341 --> 12:40.031
actually look like for a leader whose phone never stops and
12:40.531 --> 12:44.266
whose inbox is constantly overfilled? Yeah, Dana, that's such
12:44.378 --> 12:47.891
an important question, and it's one that really rearranged the furniture
12:48.391 --> 12:51.965
in my brain when I first encountered the concept via the
12:52.465 --> 12:55.462
Nigerian scholar and poet Bayo Akomolafe.
12:55.527 --> 12:59.280
And he gave this talk that said, the times are urgent, let us slow down.
12:59.842 --> 13:02.808
And I understood the first part of that statement,
13:02.824 --> 13:06.317
which is the times are urgent. So, my response, I'm probably
13:06.509 --> 13:09.762
wired to be a CIO, except that technology terrifies me sometimes,
13:10.259 --> 13:12.791
is to run in the direction of the fire,
13:13.240 --> 13:17.374
right? To run as fast as I can, to work harder, to hustle
13:17.390 --> 13:20.980
harder, to build task forces, to create coalitions,
13:21.428 --> 13:25.162
to speed up. My response
13:25.662 --> 13:29.059
to crisis is to speed up. And so when I heard this
13:29.573 --> 13:32.928
sort of phrase, I understood the times are urgent because we're feeling
13:32.960 --> 13:36.588
that our nervous systems are responding to urgency.
13:36.652 --> 13:39.847
And we know this, we know that our attention spans are
13:40.347 --> 13:44.214
narrowing, our bandwidth is diminishing, mental health is an
13:44.714 --> 13:48.018
increasing worry for us across the ecosystem.
13:48.452 --> 13:52.000
We are exhausted, we're burning out, people are leaving the
13:52.500 --> 13:55.707
sector in higher and higher numbers than we ever reported before.
13:56.541 --> 14:00.552
So we know that we feel an urgency and a nervous system dysregulation.
14:01.130 --> 14:04.242
And when we run towards a crisis,
14:04.579 --> 14:07.194
our executive function goes offline,
14:07.691 --> 14:12.039
right? And we're flooded with all kinds of
things that make
14:12.539 --> 14:16.290
us impatient, make us make default decisions. We reproduce
14:16.790 --> 14:20.349
machine logic, we dehumanize, we categorize,
14:21.280 --> 14:24.395
Slowing down, and slowing down I think is really important,
14:24.475 --> 14:26.932
especially in higher education, not as stopping,
14:27.526 --> 14:31.090
not as analysis paralysis, not as stagnation,
14:31.620 --> 14:35.153
not as refusing to make a decision. I think that's really
14:35.653 --> 14:39.777
important to differentiate. Slowing down and pausing allows
14:39.889 --> 14:43.390
for just a moment to surface the systems,
14:43.823 --> 14:47.275
to see how those systems are operating, To understand the
14:47.775 --> 14:51.498
convergences of where and how a perfect storm has
14:51.611 --> 14:55.304
happened, or what's the opposite of a perfect storm? A perfect
14:55.804 --> 14:58.884
moment, because we have to stop and slow down and pay attention to
14:58.916 --> 15:03.380
those moments, to those winds, to those beautiful flourishing
15:03.830 --> 15:07.828
moments. But to slow down and to pause and to surface the
15:08.328 --> 15:12.339
systems gets us back into curiosity, where if
15:12.387 --> 15:16.447
you're constantly responding to urgency, your executive function can
15:16.495 --> 15:19.849
go offline and you can reproduce the conditions you seek
15:20.349 --> 15:23.973
to upend, right? That you actually become part
15:24.473 --> 15:28.017
of the machine logic that you are trying to, as Beau, as you said,
15:28.113 --> 15:31.980
build relational trust and humanness
15:32.060 --> 15:35.960
in these ecosystems. And so that slowing down and pausing allows
15:36.072 --> 15:39.602
for the curiosity to come back in and to sit and say,
15:39.682 --> 15:43.288
okay, this is really hard. What am I supposed to learn from this moment?
15:43.768 --> 15:47.021
What is in my sphere of control? What is in my sphere of
15:47.214 --> 15:50.274
influence? And what is in my sphere of care?
15:51.156 --> 15:54.713
So I think that is a really important way of
15:54.729 --> 15:58.094
creating decision-making trees for people who are facing crisis
15:58.594 --> 16:02.004
and urgency to be able to discern, to engage
16:02.036 --> 16:05.882
in discernment, to sort of sift out this, what's signal
16:06.382 --> 16:09.872
is and what the noise is, to be able to see something clearly, to understand
16:10.372 --> 16:15.543
the systems, and then to be able to move swiftly in data-informed,
16:15.736 --> 16:18.988
evidence-based, relationally rich
16:19.501 --> 16:23.698
decisions that have much more nuance, but are much more
16:24.147 --> 16:27.608
important for the longer-term sustainability of our organizations.
16:28.393 --> 16:31.854
That's, yeah, this is great to hear. And I wish I'd heard some more
16:31.902 --> 16:34.257
about this like 5, 10 years ago.
16:34.946 --> 16:38.039
And then I do want to pick up on one sidebar sort of comment where
16:38.071 --> 16:41.517
you made the comment that you said, well, you know, I'm sort of wired to
16:42.017 --> 16:45.252
be a CIO, but I don't really like technology. A lot of
16:45.752 --> 16:49.275
the CIOs in Canada in higher ed don't have technology backgrounds.
16:49.467 --> 16:52.914
I'm a social scientist. Dana is— what's
16:53.414 --> 16:57.081
your background? I have a degree in business administration and took one computer
16:57.581 --> 17:00.703
science course and turned in and failed it. Yeah. Hey, surprise.
17:01.088 --> 17:04.551
And I'm going to say some of my best staff or employees
17:04.599 --> 17:07.871
over the years have been humanities,
17:08.287 --> 17:11.735
have backgrounds in the humanities or the social sciences. So it's, it's not
17:12.235 --> 17:16.178
always about the technology. So you never know. Let's try it to
17:16.226 --> 17:18.888
see if we can go down this path here. So paint a picture for us.
17:19.064 --> 17:22.287
You know, if we walked into a Hope Circuit University 10 years from now,
17:23.121 --> 17:26.601
what would look different? You know, governance decisions, how are decisions
17:26.649 --> 17:29.986
made? How do students and staff experience the place? Can you talk a
17:30.034 --> 17:34.097
little bit about that? Yes. And I think that designing
17:34.193 --> 17:37.951
for creative futures is really important. And I also think that looking
17:38.770 --> 17:42.078
in our own ecosystems right now for those glimmers and
17:42.578 --> 17:46.301
those pockets of flourishing is also really important, right? Because it's happening in
17:46.397 --> 17:48.998
real time, not in a utopian future,
17:49.384 --> 17:53.527
but we are seeing pockets of flourishing happen across our campuses
17:54.105 --> 17:56.016
and across the landscape of higher education.
17:57.573 --> 18:02.061
I always want to live sort of in the present and then the near future,
18:02.302 --> 18:05.396
right? What is possible for us? What can we do
18:05.668 --> 18:09.307
this week, this month, this year in order to get us into the near
18:09.420 --> 18:13.091
futures of flourishing? And what that means is
18:13.203 --> 18:16.954
for the work that I'm doing across our campuses is
18:17.454 --> 18:20.625
how to move towards flourishing. And by flourishing, my definition
18:21.058 --> 18:23.592
of flourishing is being tapped into purpose.
18:24.282 --> 18:27.891
So I'm going all the way back talking about humanities grads. I'm gonna sneak
18:28.391 --> 18:31.693
in a little Aristotle right now. Aristotle, thousands of years
18:31.805 --> 18:35.527
ago, was writing about telos, and he said that every single
18:35.575 --> 18:39.313
one of us is born and put on this earth with a purpose,
18:39.827 --> 18:43.340
and it's a telos, it's an endpoint. And when you start
18:43.840 --> 18:47.447
off and you, you know, when you encounter 18-year-olds, they're not far along on
18:47.947 --> 18:49.965
their telos, so they wanna know the answers. They want to know, am
I going
18:50.465 --> 18:52.677
to get a job? Am I going to participate in society? Am I going to
18:52.725 --> 18:56.672
contribute to something larger than myself? Is it going to work out?
18:56.816 --> 19:00.330
I'm 48 years old and I'm a little closer to my telos.
19:00.667 --> 19:04.181
And I reassure all of the young humans,
19:04.213 --> 19:07.486
like, don't be impatient. Enjoy these moments.
19:08.368 --> 19:11.320
Be okay with a messy nonlinear journey.
19:12.074 --> 19:15.973
But I can say that because I've seen a little bit longer of a trajectory
19:16.310 --> 19:20.146
of tapping into my purpose. And so, Aristotle says that you can't know your
19:20.322 --> 19:23.838
purpose, your endpoint until you get there, but you get clues,
19:24.256 --> 19:27.498
you get indicators. And those indicators, he uses a Greek
19:27.998 --> 19:32.186
word called eudaimonia, which is translated into flourishing.
19:32.700 --> 19:36.200
So when you're tapped into your purpose, you feel a kind
19:36.312 --> 19:39.619
of elation. When you ask Dana what he loves,
19:39.748 --> 19:42.734
or, you know, Beau, if I have more time with you and be like,
19:43.135 --> 19:46.361
tell me what gets you outta bed in the morning. You will tell
19:46.861 --> 19:50.387
me a story and it won't just be a cognitive story. It won't just
19:50.419 --> 19:53.724
be something that lives in your head. You, I will be able to see
19:53.964 --> 19:57.558
your whole body illuminate because you are tapping into your edumonia.
19:57.878 --> 20:01.424
You're tapping into your flourishing. So that is a long way
20:01.924 --> 20:05.562
around answering your question to create systems and structures
20:05.915 --> 20:09.573
where we as universities and colleges are intentionally
20:10.070 --> 20:13.181
designing spaces for people to who find,
20:14.015 --> 20:18.071
excavate, and exercise the edumonia of
20:18.103 --> 20:21.934
their purpose. And what is so fascinating about purpose is it's not
20:22.434 --> 20:26.038
just about individual success or prosperity or affluence.
20:26.600 --> 20:30.239
Purpose is something larger than yourself. We know this. I can
20:30.271 --> 20:33.605
tell you that the reports of young people now
20:34.118 --> 20:37.261
and why they're going to university, it used to be to get
20:37.761 --> 20:40.707
a job, to make over $100,000 a year, to be able to buy a home
20:41.207 --> 20:44.955
before I'm 25, da, da, da. None of those things are showing up in the
20:45.019 --> 20:49.010
top 5 anymore. It's, can I serve a larger purpose?
20:49.426 --> 20:52.584
Can I be part of making the world better? So,
20:52.648 --> 20:55.901
we are seeing high levels of purpose
20:56.174 --> 20:59.924
being reported in this demographic that is coming through
20:59.940 --> 21:03.113
our institutions. And I find that absolutely
21:03.226 --> 21:06.543
both exciting and compelling that
21:06.591 --> 21:10.341
we need to design for purpose. We're designing for resilience right
21:10.841 --> 21:15.215
now. We're designing for continuity. We talk about grit and academic buoyancy
21:15.407 --> 21:18.806
and resilience in deteriorating conditions. In the near
21:18.935 --> 21:22.462
future of the universities that I work with, I want
21:22.526 --> 21:26.375
us to intentionally design for flourishing because resilience,
21:27.016 --> 21:30.993
Latin etymology of the word resilience is to spring back or
21:31.025 --> 21:34.568
recoil to status quo. I don't
21:35.068 --> 21:39.042
think we're using the word resilience super well, and I certainly don't think
21:39.542 --> 21:42.474
we're using it when we talk about students who need just to be a little
21:42.507 --> 21:46.502
bit more resilient instead of figuring out what those deteriorating
21:46.598 --> 21:50.529
conditions are that force them to be resilient and go upstream and
21:51.029 --> 21:54.171
change those conditions. So for me, that Hope Circuits
21:54.219 --> 21:57.573
project is to go onto campuses and to work with
21:58.073 --> 22:02.531
them on their structures, their systems, their policies, their practices to
22:02.627 --> 22:06.750
create the condition where we more intentionally tap into
22:07.250 --> 22:10.793
our purpose, not just as individuals, but also as communities
22:10.905 --> 22:14.128
and to equip the humans going out into the world
22:14.176 --> 22:17.687
with a clear sense of purpose and the tools necessary to go and make the
22:17.784 --> 22:21.488
world better. And I, I see that, I see
22:21.988 --> 22:24.983
that within reach. I see that as not new resources.
22:25.512 --> 22:28.767
I see that as really a mindset shift and
22:28.927 --> 22:32.263
one that there's an increasing appetite for. Wow.
22:33.577 --> 22:37.153
Okay. So a couple of things there before I get to the next question.
22:37.698 --> 22:39.994
I'm a little bit older than 48,
22:40.716 --> 22:44.745
number one. But what you just said there just like
22:45.245 --> 22:49.095
struck with me so much of the last 18 months since
22:49.595 --> 22:51.776
I've been rewired, I'd like to say, and not retired,
22:52.290 --> 22:56.351
about what is it that I'm doing or that we're doing that's allowing
22:56.383 --> 22:59.834
us to flourish and what is your purpose? And maybe I'm just getting a little
23:00.334 --> 23:03.654
bit older to the end of my life and wondering what your purpose has really
23:03.687 --> 23:07.202
been all about. Like that is, that's fascinating. That's so
23:07.702 --> 23:11.033
fascinating to me. To be thinking of that. Oh,
23:11.066 --> 23:15.232
to be 48 again. Anyway, so you argue hope
23:15.472 --> 23:18.885
can be strategic infrastructure, and Beau and
23:18.901 --> 23:22.811
I spent our whole careers building infrastructure, whether it be networks or systems
23:22.843 --> 23:26.192
or data centers or whatever. But what
23:26.692 --> 23:30.294
does the infrastructure of hope actually consist of, and who
23:30.374 --> 23:33.803
builds it and who maintains
it? And what
23:34.303 --> 23:36.831
would actually undermine its existence?
23:37.585 --> 23:40.743
Yeah. Oh, such a, that's a whole hour
23:40.775 --> 23:45.279
of conversation, Dana, that I hope that we have soon. So the, this is connected
23:45.779 --> 23:49.095
to Beau's question about what does a future university look like that is
23:49.127 --> 23:52.718
based in flourishing and what does a systems level approach look
23:53.218 --> 23:58.248
like? And I do think that, you know, in terms of where I see work
23:58.985 --> 24:02.641
that we need to do is to build the bench strength and
24:02.993 --> 24:06.761
the brain trust on our campuses for governance
24:07.261 --> 24:09.615
literacy, for financial literacy,
24:10.289 --> 24:13.656
for operations literacy, and for management
24:14.156 --> 24:17.231
literacy. And by that, I mean that we are immersed in these
24:17.328 --> 24:21.496
complex organizations and CIOs see it in a very specific,
24:21.673 --> 24:25.826
you know, as you just gave me a wonderful list of designing infrastructure.
24:26.643 --> 24:30.700
We have, and, you know, we haven't even talked about the deferred maintenance
24:31.200 --> 24:35.194
of the physical infrastructure of our campuses. In 2021,
24:35.290 --> 24:38.773
there was a study done by Cabot where it's estimated
24:39.273 --> 24:43.107
that we are $17.9 billion in deferred maintenance of
24:43.607 --> 24:47.231
our physical campuses. We have deferred maintenance in
24:47.280 --> 24:50.811
our strategic infrastructure as well. We have not
24:51.311 --> 24:54.935
spent time on governance literacy, which means what is the difference
24:55.192 --> 24:58.371
between leadership, management and governance. What is
24:58.435 --> 25:02.112
ours to tend? What is ours to cultivate? What are the decisions that need
25:02.612 --> 25:06.127
to be made? How is resource allocation determined?
25:06.592 --> 25:10.751
How do we close read a budget? We don't have those capacities.
25:11.249 --> 25:15.070
And I don't think that we have invited people
25:15.680 --> 25:19.502
to navigate these systems that are really based on rigid
25:19.534 --> 25:22.729
vertical hierarchies. I love that I'm in the US right
25:22.745 --> 25:26.194
now and the the narratives of
25:26.694 --> 25:29.832
higher ed are like, oh, you're all left-wing and you're all hippies and you all
25:29.944 --> 25:33.934
read philosophy and drink coffee. I'm like, we are actually
25:34.431 --> 25:38.661
not. We are rigid vertical hierarchies. We are small-c conservative.
25:38.710 --> 25:42.780
We are change resistant. And what we need to adapt
25:43.280 --> 25:47.363
and to respond in real time to this moment of civilizational transition and rupture
25:48.052 --> 25:51.723
is to have the capacity to have systems systems-wise
25:52.316 --> 25:56.148
understanding so that we are immersed in systems that
25:56.229 --> 25:59.917
often we can't see, especially if those systems are designed for
26:00.077 --> 26:03.701
us. They're seamless, they're frictionless. We can navigate
26:04.201 --> 26:08.239
the world without ever encountering a brick wall. And yet
26:08.271 --> 26:11.927
for folks who are trying to change those systems, who are trying to pull
26:11.959 --> 26:15.118
them or transform them or innovate them,
26:15.647 --> 26:19.526
we get stuck in these resilient systems. That are designed to recoil
26:19.750 --> 26:23.003
or to spring back to status quo. So, if you're a changemaker,
26:23.019 --> 26:26.448
if you're an innovator, if you see the opportunities and
26:26.948 --> 26:30.614
possibilities of universities that is still outside of reach and
26:30.630 --> 26:34.123
you're exhausted, your exhaustion is the sign that the systems
26:34.155 --> 26:38.257
are resilient. You're getting stuck in the recoiling and the
26:38.497 --> 26:43.224
snapping back to status quo. And I don't think that we're having candid
26:43.724 --> 26:47.086
and rumbly enough conversations about people's exhaustion.
26:47.936 --> 26:51.110
And so, we hear terms like, this is the way we've always
26:51.142 --> 26:55.166
done it, right? As a resistance
26:55.471 --> 26:58.517
to this moment that is calling upon us
26:59.017 --> 27:02.365
to do different things. But I think, Dana, one of the things that I've noticed
27:02.865 --> 27:07.302
is that we haven't engaged people in developing capacities
27:07.415 --> 27:10.092
for system-wise thinking.
27:10.926 --> 27:14.308
And this is why CIOs, I think, are such brilliant
27:14.808 --> 27:18.813
systems thinkers, as you can see what the limit conditions of limitation are,
27:19.101 --> 27:23.189
what it looks like, what is possible, what is possible longer
27:23.689 --> 27:26.908
term, but also what is possible in the next right step or the
27:27.408 --> 27:30.499
next set of decisions that have consequences that can
27:30.999 --> 27:34.683
reverberate. So I really feel like all of us should go back
27:34.763 --> 27:38.802
and do a kind of workshop on what does systems-wise
27:38.995 --> 27:42.906
capacity look like? How do we surface the systems that we
27:42.922 --> 27:45.776
are immersed in? How do we see them more clearly?
27:46.144 --> 27:49.529
And then how do we give the humans within systems who are often
27:50.059 --> 27:52.998
not showing up as their best selves in broken systems,
27:53.287 --> 27:56.755
some grace, some empathy, and some care.
27:57.670 --> 28:01.363
And then how do we change those systems together? That's awesome. As you,
28:01.443 --> 28:05.024
as you said, the one statement in there, uh, you know, we've always done
28:05.056 --> 28:08.556
it that way. I heard that so many times and it would just
28:08.926 --> 28:11.511
drive me absolutely crazy, right? I'd be,
28:12.073 --> 28:15.140
I'd be just wanting to like, no, that's not,
28:15.494 --> 28:18.706
that's not the way we're gonna approach this. So it's interesting to hear
28:19.206 --> 28:22.063
that. Dana, why don't you take the next question? If
you happen to have one
28:22.159 --> 28:25.773
of those systems thinking workshops and you have an open seat for somebody
28:26.273 --> 28:29.500
to sit in, I'd love to sit in. And if you allow
28:30.207 --> 28:33.612
questions or points from the floor, my mouth might open
28:33.981 --> 28:37.338
and you might need to quiet me down. But anyways, that's for
28:37.838 --> 28:40.503
a different time at a different future. You know,
28:40.952 --> 28:44.358
we talked a little bit earlier actually about the CIO is really,
28:44.968 --> 28:48.021
to some extent, the chief influential officer. You know, the person who sees
28:48.521 --> 28:52.069
across the whole institution, as you've spoken about. And in your Hopes University,
28:52.615 --> 28:56.663
or Hopes Circuits University, like what is the CIO's role and where
28:56.712 --> 29:00.471
do they sit and who should they most closely be
29:00.551 --> 29:04.471
working with? Oh, I love that. Well, influence suggests that it's everybody
29:04.487 --> 29:08.085
in the ecosystem, right? That it is a kind of convening
29:08.262 --> 29:12.020
role as well as how do you gather people and sit in curiosity
29:12.036 --> 29:15.312
at this moment to metabolize rupture and
29:15.344 --> 29:18.669
to make sense of it? And that influencing is also sensemaking.
29:19.424 --> 29:23.117
I think that the Chief Influencing Officer should be your new
29:23.617 --> 29:27.406
title. And I do think, you know, we should also be pairing you
29:27.470 --> 29:30.730
with Chief Flourishing Officers, right? People who are really
29:30.923 --> 29:34.921
looking across the system, to say, how are
29:35.421 --> 29:39.272
these policies, structures, and statutes driving human behavior?
29:39.673 --> 29:43.655
What are the intended consequences or unintended consequences of
29:44.104 --> 29:47.829
a policy? We're really good at coming up with policies, right? And putting
29:47.861 --> 29:52.035
them through and then not revisiting them and not asking, well, we did, we developed
29:52.535 --> 29:55.840
this policy for a particular moment at a particular time for a
29:55.889 --> 29:59.645
particular set of conditions, but those conditions have changed.
30:00.143 --> 30:03.046
And we don't have a clear sense of policy development,
30:03.431 --> 30:07.714
right? What the origin story of a policy is. We don't have a clear
30:07.746 --> 30:11.532
understanding of practice. How is it equitably and consistently
30:12.158 --> 30:15.816
deployed across the system? And then we don't really understand what
30:15.928 --> 30:19.698
those policies are doing to create precedent so that what are the
30:20.198 --> 30:22.922
principles of a policy? How are they developed?
30:23.628 --> 30:27.222
What is the process? How are they operationalized? And how are they
30:27.238 --> 30:31.190
actually driving behavior and systems? That for
30:31.690 --> 30:35.173
chief influencing officers, but also for chief flourishing
30:35.350 --> 30:39.366
officers, have
to be fundamental questions because we haven't
30:39.866 --> 30:43.574
renewed and reviewed many of the things that are hiding in plain sight.
30:43.639 --> 30:47.012
And though I think I hear the howl into the abyss about this
30:47.512 --> 30:50.176
is the way we've always done it, that's where good ideas go to die,
30:50.787 --> 30:54.256
right? That is, and we have become punchlines in higher education.
30:54.320 --> 30:57.767
There's the book by an American named Brian Rosenberg,
30:57.847 --> 31:01.839
whose title of the book is Whatever It Is, I'm Against
31:02.339 --> 31:05.029
It: Change Resistance in Higher Education.
31:05.766 --> 31:08.635
And it's hilarious, but we're the punchline.
31:09.389 --> 31:13.396
We are the punchline. We are the joke. And I don't think
31:13.701 --> 31:17.019
that we can continue to be the joke. I think we need to be the
31:17.519 --> 31:21.379
storyteller. And I go into spaces,
31:21.507 --> 31:25.210
it's so interesting across an ecosystem. And I,
31:25.659 --> 31:28.897
because I'm a full professor, because I'm an endowed chair,
31:29.346 --> 31:32.856
because I'm a 3M National Teaching Fellow, because I'm a member
31:33.356 --> 31:37.361
of the Royal Society of Canada, I'm not a consultant. I don't come
31:37.861 --> 31:40.967
in from the outside. I'm an insider advocate of higher education. So,
31:41.048 --> 31:44.702
I get to show up in places that might not have
31:45.119 --> 31:48.903
entry for people from the outside. So, I get to talk to staff
31:49.384 --> 31:53.286
and managers, and I get to talk to faculty
31:53.398 --> 31:56.449
and students and senior leaders and board.
31:56.931 --> 32:00.961
And what I have noticed is that every single group
32:01.089 --> 32:04.445
that I engage says, yes, we understand this is
32:04.461 --> 32:08.058
no longer sustainable. Yes, we need to rewire our systems.
32:08.555 --> 32:12.329
Yes, we need social movement building. Yes, we need
32:12.829 --> 32:15.954
to respond to this moment. But they won't let me.
32:16.435 --> 32:20.201
And it doesn't matter who says it, it's always somebody
32:20.345 --> 32:24.496
else is going to block us from doing that. And it's othering
32:25.554 --> 32:30.073
who is responsible for change, which means it's ceding agency
32:30.362 --> 32:33.872
and responsibility, which I think is
32:34.561 --> 32:37.878
very human. It's our default response and we need a second
32:37.990 --> 32:41.692
learned response. Where are we right now in our sphere
32:41.821 --> 32:46.053
of influence, in our sphere of care, and in our year of action
32:46.647 --> 32:50.481
now. We cannot wait for, you know, and it's so funny because senior
32:50.981 --> 32:54.332
leaders like, we wanna change, but the faculty won't. Faculty are like, we would
32:54.832 --> 32:57.894
love to change, but the administration won't. The board's like, we wanna change,
32:57.942 --> 33:00.654
but the union won't. The union says, we wanna change,
33:00.927 --> 33:04.601
but
you know, the board won't let us. Like, it doesn't
33:04.681 --> 33:08.516
matter where in the ecosystem you talk with,
33:09.254 --> 33:13.057
it's that other group won't let me. And I have the benefit
33:13.557 --> 33:17.451
of of saying, I've been at those other tables and they also
33:17.595 --> 33:20.386
want it. So what does it mean to get us into a room? This is
33:20.482 --> 33:24.106
back to your chief influencing officer, to get us into a room,
33:24.186 --> 33:27.634
to sit with curiosity, to understand the systems, to understand
33:27.698 --> 33:32.124
what our sphere of control is and what the next right step is across,
33:32.284 --> 33:35.748
lit up that kind of circuit board of energy of
33:36.248 --> 33:39.164
our complex, beautiful, imperfect, deeply inefficient,
33:39.790 --> 33:43.546
gorgeous institutions where everybody without
33:43.594 --> 33:47.158
fail has goodwill and high senses of purpose and
33:47.447 --> 33:51.636
deep frustration with the intractability of change
33:52.086 --> 33:55.521
and the old systems that haven't been renewed and reimagined.
33:55.938 --> 33:59.390
I wish you could have sat around some of the CIO tables when
33:59.890 --> 34:02.103
we have Cuccio meetings and we, at the end of the day, we go for
34:02.135 --> 34:05.747
a beer because this is the exact conversations that we have, right? It's this notion
34:06.247 --> 34:10.082
of cultural change and And how do we drive that? And sort
34:10.582 --> 34:13.695
of looking at it from all those different angles and seeing how everybody has this
34:14.195 --> 34:17.228
different view, but it's all about the culture that sits in the middle. And I
34:17.728 --> 34:20.873
think that's fascinating. We've got a couple more questions here,
34:21.065 --> 34:24.325
and then we'll go quickly to the rapid fires. So the first
34:24.373 --> 34:28.115
one, we gotta delve into AI. We just recently talked to Mark Daly,
34:28.147 --> 34:30.989
and it ties into some of the stuff that you've been talking about here.
34:32.161 --> 34:36.015
But this whole notion of remembering the human that you talk about in
34:36.515 --> 34:39.993
the time of generative AI, And I think it's something the CIOs
34:40.345 --> 34:43.790
are thinking about because we're under a lot of pressure to roll out AI
34:43.854 --> 34:48.037
very, very fast. And, and, you know, AI sometimes is a solution
34:48.537 --> 34:51.402
looking for a problem, which is kind of funny to say, but I think we're
34:51.902 --> 34:55.311
still there. So how would a hope-centered approach to AI on campus
34:55.811 --> 34:59.558
look like? And where should the CIO push back on this, this notion
35:00.058 --> 35:02.810
that we have to go, go, go, go, go? Yeah. Oh, and I love that
35:02.842 --> 35:06.259
you've interviewed Mark Daly. He and I are, um, part of a collaborative book
35:06.291 --> 35:10.694
project where we are playing with Shakespeare and art
35:11.272 --> 35:14.342
and AI at this particular moment. And you said to,
35:14.583 --> 35:18.455
he and I are working on a chapter on Love's Labour's Lost, a Shakespeare
35:18.503 --> 35:23.003
play that is deeply mediocre, but it's
35:23.083 --> 35:26.554
a really funny, weird play that asks some of
35:27.054 --> 35:30.587
the questions we are now coming back to, which is what is our purpose?
35:31.117 --> 35:34.726
As universities in order to figure
35:34.806 --> 35:38.240
out remembering the human, but also how to human and
35:38.272 --> 35:41.833
how to human as a verb. What is it the human condition
35:42.363 --> 35:46.325
can do in a way that we have seen historical human
35:46.373 --> 35:50.191
activity being replaced and rendered obsolete
35:50.544 --> 35:54.475
almost overnight? We're seeing the computer science departments across Canada
35:54.539 --> 35:58.052
collapse. We're seeing accountants, have complete
35:58.552 --> 36:01.855
heart attacks. We're seeing lawyers who now contracts are being put
36:02.355 --> 36:06.154
together and case precedents. We're not even seeing this blue-collar
36:06.331 --> 36:09.603
automation of AI. We're seeing it
36:09.700 --> 36:13.053
with my friend's a radiologist and she's a specialist in
36:13.085 --> 36:17.063
reading breast cancer scans. 3 years ago, she was
36:17.095 --> 36:20.513
the expert. Now she's using
36:20.689 --> 36:23.961
AI to pick up anomalies she can't see herself.
36:24.009 --> 36:27.632
So we're in this moment of, wait a second, what does
36:27.696 --> 36:31.767
it mean to be human? How can we use AI to
36:32.267 --> 36:35.855
free up our time in the ethics of efficiency to do
36:35.919 --> 36:39.573
high-purpose work? And I do think what a remarkable
36:39.621 --> 36:43.180
moment for us to be alive with technology that what I
36:43.228 --> 36:45.921
really want, Bo and Dane, if you can figure this out, is like, I want
36:46.097 --> 36:49.127
AI to do my dishes and my laundry so I have more time to write
36:49.143 --> 36:52.815
poetry and go to plays. And I do, you know,
36:52.831 --> 36:56.409
okay, I'm going to try this out. This is your unplugged and without filter.
36:57.259 --> 37:00.596
So I'm going to try something silly out, but I think that we as
37:00.693 --> 37:04.768
humans at this particular moment in our society
37:04.960 --> 37:08.795
want to gather and to remember how to human because our
37:08.891 --> 37:12.469
art and our information and our news
37:12.886 --> 37:16.351
is increasingly AI'd, right? Frictionless.
37:16.576 --> 37:20.736
User experience, digestible, it's easy. And so I
37:20.768 --> 37:24.591
call it the Taylor Swift effect where I could
37:25.169 --> 37:28.943
download Taylor Swift's album and listen to it in my kitchen and
37:28.959 --> 37:33.023
it would cost me just my regular monthly streaming service.
37:33.376 --> 37:37.199
But people are going 50,000 people at a time
37:37.392 --> 37:40.732
to gather together, to congregate, to watch
37:40.925 --> 37:44.602
somebody make art in real time and
37:45.102 --> 37:48.342
to be in community with one another where even the lines of the bathroom are
37:48.936 --> 37:52.868
makerspaces where you are trading bracelets and you're
37:52.884 --> 37:56.448
dressing up and you're telling stories. And that
37:56.576 --> 38:00.027
everybody, I've never been to a Taylor Swift concert, but the folks who
38:00.527 --> 38:03.478
go to a Taylor Swift concert have reported back to me that they feel like
38:03.978 --> 38:07.668
Taylor Swift is singing directly to them. It is a tailored
38:08.133 --> 38:11.344
effect. And my question is, how do we build our
38:11.844 --> 38:15.261
relationships in higher education to provide a Taylor
38:15.761 --> 38:19.291
Swift effect, right? That you're congregating to create
38:19.791 --> 38:23.514
something that can't be mediated by technology,
38:23.787 --> 38:27.753
that you feel you're part of something greater than yourself, that you are gathering in
38:27.865 --> 38:32.104
community and you're feeling a one-on-one connection, a tailored
38:32.216 --> 38:35.476
experience. What does that mean for us to human?
38:35.652 --> 38:38.692
And I think that You know, and AI policy,
38:40.539 --> 38:45.092
frankly, we showed our worst selves when ChatGPT
38:45.592 --> 38:49.811
first came out in higher education because our minds immediately went
38:50.330 --> 38:54.045
like, not, this is the most amazing predictive technology that we can
38:54.710 --> 38:58.360
use to make the world better. We immediately went,
38:58.441 --> 39:02.729
those students are cheating. We immediately went to deficit. We immediately
39:02.794 --> 39:06.558
went to policing and surveillance. We immediately went
39:06.590 --> 39:10.365
to punish these humans, not, hey,
39:10.445 --> 39:13.706
guess what? The ways that we've been massifying education
39:14.059 --> 39:17.416
and assessing has not been a good measure of
39:17.432 --> 39:20.789
transformative learning, because that's really what happened.
39:20.837 --> 39:23.664
If they can game a system with AI, they've been gaming systems.
39:23.712 --> 39:27.776
People have been gaming systems for 2,000 years. Come on. But that
39:27.968 --> 39:31.165
first default response was policing and surveillance
39:31.245 --> 39:34.722
and deficit. And I think that a
39:35.222 --> 39:38.792
second response is possible, how to human, how to create
39:39.292 --> 39:42.926
these communities, how to use technology in ethical ways,
39:43.263 --> 39:46.483
how to have conversations about AI ethics. When do you use
39:46.983 --> 39:51.066
it and when do you not? When do you create something instead
39:51.566 --> 39:54.944
of just— and I fundamentally believe that we can no
39:54.976 --> 39:58.741
longer predict the future, but we can participate in inventing it.
39:59.463 --> 40:03.279
We have predictive technology that can predict things based on what
40:03.295 --> 40:06.950
has been, right? That's, that's a kind of toxic continuity.
40:07.014 --> 40:10.654
It's a closed system. It can only imagine what has already
40:10.766 --> 40:14.373
been. We as humans can invent. We do unexpected
40:14.454 --> 40:16.714
things. We put weird things together. We,
40:17.259 --> 40:20.947
instead of going straight into everyone's predicting you're going to go straight, we veer left,
40:21.188 --> 40:25.965
right? We start again at a different place. We are absolutely creative
40:26.222 --> 40:30.084
in our human condition. How do we use technology
40:30.790 --> 40:34.010
for efficiency, create the ethics of when and how we
40:34.170 --> 40:37.823
use that to tap into our purpose more often and intentionally,
40:38.657 --> 40:42.021
while also deliberately and spending lots
40:42.521 --> 40:45.514
of time thinking about what it means to be human in rumbly,
40:45.627 --> 40:49.841
relational, peculiar, weird, inventive ways.
40:49.953 --> 40:53.510
And I think we need both. And I think we need to have a conversation
40:53.542 --> 40:58.097
that moves beyond policing and surveilling. Into co-creation
40:58.354 --> 41:01.309
ethics and the ethics of efficiency.
41:01.983 --> 41:04.553
That is so great. And it ties into some of the things that we were
41:05.053 --> 41:08.873
talking to Mark Daly about. And I loved your sort of comparison
41:09.211 --> 41:12.696
of your music subscription and Taylor Swift, you know, live concert.
41:12.744 --> 41:15.314
And I was really fortunate, you know,
41:15.474 --> 41:19.586
around the time of the pandemic, I ran into somebody named Pete Bombaci who
41:19.971 --> 41:24.064
oversees the Genoa Project and got to know him and And we did
41:24.564 --> 41:27.800
a show with him and, and, you know, basically, you know, he talks about human
41:27.832 --> 41:31.407
connection and social interaction and the importance, and it's just as important
41:31.423 --> 41:34.694
as having a proper diet and as having an exercise regime. And,
41:35.271 --> 41:38.734
and so that really relates. We're going to jump.
41:39.055 --> 41:42.197
I think it's time that we just jump to our rapid fires, Dana. So why
41:42.697 --> 41:46.462
don't we do that? And let's see. Yeah. And these just for Jessica,
41:46.510 --> 41:50.117
for your own, this is quick answers, whatever comes to your head fast.
41:50.743 --> 41:53.631
Oh, finish the sentence. Hope. Is badass.
41:54.514 --> 41:58.111
I love it. That's great. How about your
41:58.127 --> 42:01.370
favorite Shakespeare line for a leader having a hard week? Ooh,
42:02.077 --> 42:06.091
the readiness is all, from Hamlet. Nice. I like
42:06.591 --> 42:10.394
that. A CIO listening right now is inspired by your vision, and besides
42:10.426 --> 42:14.296
reading your books, which I strongly advise, what do they need
42:14.344 --> 42:17.828
to do to support it, you know, this month and over
42:18.328 --> 42:22.302
the next year? Well, I think creating some communities of practice where folks get
42:22.802 --> 42:25.846
into a room and talk about this, right? We can't figure
this out on our
42:25.974 --> 42:29.422
own. We have the co-creative spaces to build
42:29.922 --> 42:33.815
conversation. There are lots of thoughtful people who, when they're invited to do visioning,
42:34.248 --> 42:38.065
can really do some powerful things. You need to build some thought partners,
42:38.161 --> 42:41.448
intentional community, create some rumbles, create a read and
42:41.948 --> 42:46.001
rumble once a month where you get folks to share breakfast, on a Friday morning
42:46.338 --> 42:49.735
and have a short piece of something to read or to look
42:49.863 --> 42:53.149
at and then to rumble on it. I guarantee you it'll be the highlight
42:53.245 --> 42:56.386
of your monthly calendar. Who inspires you as a leader?
42:57.011 --> 43:00.760
Oh, so many. I love CIOs. Like, Scott Stoddard
43:01.260 --> 43:05.023
is one of my favorite humans. He's so generous. People who think
43:05.408 --> 43:10.007
with epistemic humility, who are like, I'm not too sure I'm right, but together,
43:10.392 --> 43:14.013
we can figure out some really interesting things. So,
43:14.061 --> 43:18.131
the leaders that really inspire me are the ones who are just deeply
43:18.163 --> 43:21.496
curious. What brings you joy? So many
43:21.528 --> 43:24.492
things. Being in conversation with beautiful humans. So, thank you.
43:24.717 --> 43:28.098
My children bring me joy. They hold me to
43:28.598 --> 43:32.520
a level of integrity and ego decentering that is absolutely
43:32.665 --> 43:36.062
fundamental, right? Where they say, Mom, you said this one thing,
43:36.110 --> 43:39.915
but you're doing this one thing. So, They keep me present
43:40.385 --> 43:43.992
and attentive and full of integrity because they can
43:44.008 --> 43:47.530
see me and they can also call me into
43:48.368 --> 43:51.912
joyful, messy life. By the way,
43:51.928 --> 43:55.440
they'll do that after they're 10 and 12. They'll do that when they're in their
43:55.474 --> 43:59.073
30s too, just so you know, FYI. You just
43:59.122 --> 44:00.598
watch the teen years. Yeah.
44:02.365 --> 44:05.123
And last one here. Do you have a book recommendation?
44:05.717 --> 44:09.195
Ooh, you know what? I just read Cory Doctorow's The Reverse
44:09.227 --> 44:12.786
Centaur's Guide to Life After AI, and I thought it gave one
44:13.286 --> 44:17.852
of the most compelling overviews of the dominant narrative of our time of inevitabilism,
44:18.381 --> 44:21.699
which is the tech bros and the tyrants saying the future is already written.
44:21.827 --> 44:25.113
Just get on board. Just give up. Let's just,
44:26.139 --> 44:29.762
you know, keep going because we've already decided. And You
44:29.778 --> 44:33.385
know, Dr. Rose says we need to be challenging the narratives of
44:33.885 --> 44:37.344
inevitabilism, that the future is not yet written, that it unfolds
44:37.441 --> 44:40.839
as we walk it. And so, anybody who's, you know,
44:40.983 --> 44:44.590
selling certainty is usually a tyrant or a
44:45.090 --> 44:49.335
dictator. We need to sit in that co-creative space of resisting inevitabilism
44:49.720 --> 44:52.653
and moving into co-creating creative futures.
44:53.150 --> 44:56.452
That's a great book choice. Our colleague, Katie Tuck from University of
44:56.952 --> 45:00.364
Fraser Valley, is actually— well, she's done. She was telling me, you need to read
45:00.864 --> 45:04.322
this book. So, it's great to hear a second source. Jessica,
45:04.966 --> 45:08.171
thank you. Thank you so much. And hearing you describe
45:08.187 --> 45:12.145
the CIO as someone who helps a university stay human
45:12.370 --> 45:16.114
and not just stay online is
45:16.227 --> 45:19.762
so meaningful, especially when CIOs are trying to deal with so many things at
45:20.262 --> 45:23.440
this point. And that we need to remember to manage our spheres,
45:23.699 --> 45:26.877
you know, our sphere of control, our sphere of influence, and our sphere of care.
45:27.523 --> 45:30.493
Yeah, I just, I want to thank you. I was so looking forward to this
45:30.993 --> 45:33.624
episode. I, you know, I got up this morning and I think I linked,
45:33.929 --> 45:37.541
connected with you on LinkedIn just to tell you how excited I was. And it's
45:38.041 --> 45:40.785
been fantastic. There's so much in here and it ties into some, you know,
45:40.849 --> 45:44.044
the episodes we've done, the one we just did with Marie-Claude from Queen's
45:44.544 --> 45:48.523
University last week. And then I'm thinking of the one we did with Megan Kerwin,
45:48.556 --> 45:51.927
who's just amazing and who sort of has been my mentor
45:52.427 --> 45:55.969
in a lot of these areas. I love talking about trust. It comes up again
45:56.017 --> 45:58.534
and again and again. And, and being,
45:59.127 --> 46:02.830
having sort of a background from the Nordics, I always sort of admire the Nordics
46:03.330 --> 46:05.636
because they, they seem to start from a position of trust in a lot of
46:06.136 --> 46:09.227
things that they do. And here in North America, we tend
46:09.727 --> 46:12.096
to start from a position of distrust. And I think higher ed is like that.
46:12.353 --> 46:15.639
And, and if we just started from that other side, I think
46:16.139 --> 46:19.487
it would be great. So I'm going to take your flourishing comments. And I'm gonna
46:19.987 --> 46:22.581
flourish for the rest of the day and, and do something interesting and fun.
46:22.629 --> 46:26.012
It's a beautiful fall day here in Kingston. So thank
46:26.512 --> 46:29.571
you so much for joining us. Well, thank you for the invitation. It was
46:29.747 --> 46:33.291
absolutely wonderful. As always, if you've got feedback, questions, or stories
46:33.791 --> 46:37.058
of your own, drop us a line at feedback@bytesofexperience.ca.
46:37.619 --> 46:41.162
That's bytesofexperience.ca, or visit us at
46:41.788 --> 46:45.138
bytesofexperience.ca. And special thanks to Pixabee and
46:45.638 --> 46:48.473
The Grand Project for the music and to the Cuccio LDP for their support.
46:49.083 --> 46:52.035
We'll see you next time on Bites of Experience, where the insights are unfiltered and
46:52.535 --> 46:53.543
the coffee is strong.