สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
WEBVTT
NOTE
This file was generated by Descript
00:00:00.080 --> 00:00:03.320
Isabelle Roughol: Hey, it's Isabelle,
back with some uncut unedited early
00:00:03.320 --> 00:00:06.680
interviews from the Borderline
podcast for your holiday break.
00:00:07.920 --> 00:00:13.710
Today, I am rerunning my very early
conversation with Colin Yeo, who
00:00:13.710 --> 00:00:17.460
is a British immigration lawyer,
the founder of free movement.org.
00:00:17.850 --> 00:00:22.380
And, uh, we talked about the hostile
environment, how that came to be
00:00:22.590 --> 00:00:28.470
and the genesis of the incredibly
tough immigration system in the UK.
00:00:28.470 --> 00:00:31.740
It was really an enlightening
conversation that helps you understand
00:00:32.130 --> 00:00:35.250
everything else that's happening in
British politics at the moment, such
00:00:35.250 --> 00:00:37.090
as the Nationality and Borders bill.
00:00:37.090 --> 00:00:40.350
So it's very much, very much
a current conversation even
00:00:40.350 --> 00:00:41.550
though this dates back...
00:00:42.300 --> 00:00:43.920
a year and a half almost now.
00:00:44.310 --> 00:00:49.650
Have a listen, here is Colin Yeo in our
full unedited conversation from 2020.
00:00:51.152 --> 00:00:53.522
Well, thank you for doing this.
00:00:53.582 --> 00:00:55.742
Um, I read the book last night.
00:00:56.792 --> 00:00:59.462
I don't recommend it as a bedtime read.
00:00:59.852 --> 00:01:02.042
It really gets your blood pressure up.
00:01:02.522 --> 00:01:05.222
Um, but, but it was really interesting.
00:01:05.372 --> 00:01:09.092
What is it like launching
a book mid pandemic?
00:01:10.302 --> 00:01:11.622
Colin Yeo: Yeah, well, that's interesting.
00:01:11.622 --> 00:01:14.012
Cause it's, um, you know, I
don't really know and lots of
00:01:14.012 --> 00:01:15.582
about publishing and things.
00:01:15.582 --> 00:01:17.022
This is my, this is the
first book I've written.
00:01:17.042 --> 00:01:20.262
It's been quite, quite interesting
experience of going through the writing
00:01:20.262 --> 00:01:22.272
process and the, the kind of launch bit.
00:01:22.662 --> 00:01:25.362
But, um, yeah, we, we had to
have an online launch, which,
00:01:25.362 --> 00:01:26.262
which kind of went, okay.
00:01:26.262 --> 00:01:26.442
I think.
00:01:27.197 --> 00:01:30.467
Probably more people tuned in for
that than we would have done if we'd
00:01:30.467 --> 00:01:32.087
done it in person, which was nice.
00:01:32.477 --> 00:01:35.747
Um, but yeah, man, bookshops
are barely open people.
00:01:35.747 --> 00:01:37.217
Aren't sort of going to the shops.
00:01:37.277 --> 00:01:41.417
Um, the online distributors aren't
necessarily ordering in many copies of
00:01:41.417 --> 00:01:44.597
books because they're understandably
focusing on, you know, slightly more
00:01:44.597 --> 00:01:47.207
vital needs than, than, than reading.
00:01:47.537 --> 00:01:49.367
Um, so yeah, it's a slightly,
it's a slightly strange.
00:01:50.332 --> 00:01:55.792
Isabelle Roughol: Yeah, I bet bet as
it must be to be an immigration lawyer
00:01:55.822 --> 00:01:58.852
in a pandemic, how has that gone?
00:01:59.152 --> 00:02:03.772
Has things sort of ground to a halt
or on the contrary, is it been really.
00:02:05.162 --> 00:02:09.092
Colin Yeo: Well, it's a quite strange
time because, um, in, in the very short
00:02:09.092 --> 00:02:12.512
term, there's basically no need for an
immigration lawyer, which is, which is
00:02:12.512 --> 00:02:17.132
kind of great, um, because the, uh, lots
of countries and the UK is doing this
00:02:17.132 --> 00:02:19.262
as well are basically saying that if.
00:02:20.117 --> 00:02:24.677
Um, if you're a migrant and you're
in the country, then your permission
00:02:24.677 --> 00:02:28.037
to stay there will be extended
automatically in the meantime.
00:02:28.397 --> 00:02:31.967
Um, so people, you know, there
aren't that many flights available
00:02:31.967 --> 00:02:34.637
at the moment and sometimes flights
just aren't available at all.
00:02:34.877 --> 00:02:36.797
So people can't really move.
00:02:37.127 --> 00:02:40.577
And also people, you know, people are
having to face some difficult choices
00:02:40.577 --> 00:02:45.317
about what country to bunker down in
effectively, you know, should they be.
00:02:45.992 --> 00:02:49.592
In the country of nationality or should
they be in the country that they happen
00:02:49.602 --> 00:02:52.832
to find themselves in, perhaps they're
with family members or that they're
00:02:52.832 --> 00:02:54.512
working goals or something like that.
00:02:54.812 --> 00:02:59.822
So in the short term, people don't
really need the help of an immigration
00:02:59.822 --> 00:03:03.152
lawyer because things are being handled
automatically, but there's also.
00:03:03.902 --> 00:03:06.302
Um, a sort of huge demand for information.
00:03:06.302 --> 00:03:09.842
And, um, certainly I don't know how
it's been handled in other countries,
00:03:09.842 --> 00:03:13.172
but here in the UK, the information
that's been provided by the governments
00:03:13.172 --> 00:03:18.992
has been pretty sketchy at times and
not that easy to access or understand.
00:03:19.262 --> 00:03:23.852
So there's a huge, huge demand for,
for information, if not for the actual
00:03:23.852 --> 00:03:25.532
sort of business of making application.
00:03:26.882 --> 00:03:28.772
Isabelle Roughol: Yeah, I've,
I've wondered about that.
00:03:28.772 --> 00:03:29.312
Actually.
00:03:29.312 --> 00:03:30.572
I, um, decided.
00:03:31.307 --> 00:03:37.007
Early on in March to go spend a
lockdown in my country of residence.
00:03:37.577 --> 00:03:40.667
And I found myself
counting the days because.
00:03:41.852 --> 00:03:45.992
Um, you know, six months out of
every 12 months in the country,
00:03:45.992 --> 00:03:51.572
residency requirement to get settled
status, which I still don't have.
00:03:51.572 --> 00:03:56.642
And so, yeah, I found myself counting
days and being very unclear as do
Load full transcript
00:03:56.672 --> 00:04:00.242
you know what happens if, because
of the pandemic you go over.
00:04:00.662 --> 00:04:04.622
Um, I decided to not chance
it and come back to the UK.
00:04:04.622 --> 00:04:08.822
So I imagine there's a lot
of these tricky situations.
00:04:09.787 --> 00:04:12.037
Colin Yeo: Yeah, well, in the
future, And we still just don't
00:04:12.037 --> 00:04:13.167
know how it's going to work out.
00:04:13.337 --> 00:04:17.167
And like you say, there are residency
requirements for various different
00:04:17.167 --> 00:04:19.627
types of visas where you've got
spend a certain amount of time.
00:04:19.867 --> 00:04:21.487
It also has tax implications.
00:04:21.487 --> 00:04:24.457
I, not something I know nothing
about basically, but I know
00:04:24.457 --> 00:04:25.447
that there's an issue there.
00:04:25.807 --> 00:04:30.547
Um, and again, we don't really have very
much clarity at the moment about how
00:04:30.547 --> 00:04:32.647
these things work out in the long run.
00:04:33.037 --> 00:04:36.247
And you know, another, another
example of that is that in the UK,
00:04:36.247 --> 00:04:38.547
and I think in quite a few other
countries, we've got various.
00:04:39.392 --> 00:04:41.432
Income requirements for migrants.
00:04:42.167 --> 00:04:45.227
Migrants are kind of, this goes back away.
00:04:45.227 --> 00:04:51.737
Now migrants tend to be valued in
rather, um, basic utilitarian kind
00:04:51.737 --> 00:04:53.447
of terms in the United Kingdom.
00:04:53.477 --> 00:04:55.157
You know, what are they worth to us?
00:04:55.247 --> 00:05:00.437
Um, in, in, in fiscal terms
rather than cultural or social
00:05:00.437 --> 00:05:02.087
terms, which is very unfortunate.
00:05:02.652 --> 00:05:06.942
Um, and one of the ways that manifests
itself in the rules is that migrants
00:05:06.942 --> 00:05:08.262
have to earn a certain amounts.
00:05:08.322 --> 00:05:10.122
Otherwise they have to leave basically.
00:05:10.572 --> 00:05:14.382
And, you know, during a global pandemic,
when incomes have been hit, there's
00:05:14.442 --> 00:05:18.012
a lockdown that's been imposed by
the government and people are being
00:05:18.072 --> 00:05:21.792
laid off and having their incomes
reduced in various different ways.
00:05:22.362 --> 00:05:25.392
We don't really know how that's
going to play out in the longer run.
00:05:25.452 --> 00:05:28.152
So it it's, it's a time of
real uncertainty for us.
00:05:28.807 --> 00:05:33.187
Isabelle Roughol: um, and we've seen
that migrants also overly represented
00:05:33.847 --> 00:05:39.787
these frontline essential jobs that ended
up being very exposed to the pandemic.
00:05:39.787 --> 00:05:42.907
That was this story on the, uh,
the cleaners of the ministry of
00:05:42.907 --> 00:05:45.277
justice that made a bit of a scandal.
00:05:45.277 --> 00:05:45.427
This.
00:05:46.417 --> 00:05:46.837
Colin Yeo: Yeah.
00:05:46.987 --> 00:05:52.297
They've suddenly find themselves going
from low valued, um, supposedly low,
00:05:52.297 --> 00:05:56.317
skilled, um, roles to suddenly being
key workers, which is, which is nice.
00:05:56.347 --> 00:05:59.647
But, um, it doesn't really count
for anything in the long run if the
00:05:59.647 --> 00:06:01.297
rules don't change to reflect that.
00:06:01.627 --> 00:06:05.107
But it's, it's interesting cause
it, it feels like it could be a time
00:06:05.407 --> 00:06:07.027
where people are thinking again about.
00:06:08.767 --> 00:06:13.537
About the value of migrants and just
that sort of priorities in life, perhaps.
00:06:13.597 --> 00:06:16.657
And it's maybe a little
optimistic and naive on my part.
00:06:16.657 --> 00:06:19.447
I don't know, but it feels like it could
be a time when people think, well, hang
00:06:19.447 --> 00:06:23.287
on a minute, you know, they're the people
who've kept our country running, kept
00:06:23.287 --> 00:06:25.417
the supply chains functioning and so on.
00:06:25.687 --> 00:06:27.727
Maybe they are actually
quite important after all.
00:06:27.727 --> 00:06:30.487
And maybe it would be a struggle
if we had to cope without them.
00:06:31.622 --> 00:06:31.952
Isabelle Roughol: right.
00:06:31.952 --> 00:06:38.882
We've been clapping for the NHS, which
is by a lot of migrants and, and cashiers
00:06:38.882 --> 00:06:41.822
and delivery people and, and all of that.
00:06:42.992 --> 00:06:43.352
Yeah.
00:06:43.352 --> 00:06:47.222
Does this have weights in an
application to the home office?
00:06:47.612 --> 00:06:50.792
I don't know, not at this point,
I guess maybe in the future.
00:06:51.427 --> 00:06:52.687
Colin Yeo: Well, it's
certainly not at the moment.
00:06:52.747 --> 00:06:57.847
Um, and what we see at the moment
is, is that the home office plans
00:06:57.847 --> 00:07:03.397
before the pandemic were basically
to prevent the entry of what were
00:07:03.397 --> 00:07:06.127
previously called low skilled workers.
00:07:07.607 --> 00:07:09.137
It was never really back low skill.
00:07:09.137 --> 00:07:11.957
It was always about low salary and
they're quite few skilled roles
00:07:11.957 --> 00:07:13.787
that don't necessarily earn a lot.
00:07:13.907 --> 00:07:16.577
Um, but that was the kind of
language that was being used.
00:07:17.027 --> 00:07:22.157
And in particular, the end of free
movement rights for European citizens
00:07:22.487 --> 00:07:26.267
would have meant that, um, unless some
sort of new scheme was introduced.
00:07:26.987 --> 00:07:31.097
It would be that there'd be a lot less,
um, it'd be a lot harder for those
00:07:31.097 --> 00:07:36.137
kinds of people to come to the UK to
pick fruit or work in the NHS or work
00:07:36.137 --> 00:07:37.937
in supply chains, work in coffee shops.
00:07:38.237 --> 00:07:40.067
There'd just be, wouldn't be
a route for them to come to
00:07:40.067 --> 00:07:41.387
the UK to do that in future.
00:07:41.897 --> 00:07:46.067
Um, and as far as we know,
that's still the home office
00:07:46.067 --> 00:07:48.737
policy for after June, 2021.
00:07:48.737 --> 00:07:51.127
When we're told there's
going to be new immigration.
00:07:53.537 --> 00:07:59.057
Isabelle Roughol: So you mentioned
the, the income requirement, which
00:07:59.717 --> 00:08:02.147
I think leads to one of the more.
00:08:03.212 --> 00:08:07.802
Unjust and, and, and frustrating
situation of all the unjust and
00:08:07.802 --> 00:08:12.452
frustrating situations to that you
discuss in the book, which is the
00:08:12.452 --> 00:08:18.122
separation of family and the, and the
pushing into exile, pretty much of even
00:08:18.122 --> 00:08:19.892
British citizens and British children.
00:08:20.552 --> 00:08:23.432
Um, can you tell me a bit
about, about how that works in,
00:08:23.432 --> 00:08:24.632
how we got to that situation?
00:08:25.827 --> 00:08:26.187
Colin Yeo: Yeah.
00:08:26.217 --> 00:08:32.892
So, so back in 2012, um, a new rule was
introduced by then home secretary, Theresa
00:08:32.892 --> 00:08:36.477
May, and it requires, um, a person in the.
00:08:36.917 --> 00:08:39.377
You sponsoring a spouse or partner.
00:08:39.797 --> 00:08:44.357
It requires the UK based person to
be earning at least 18,600 pounds.
00:08:44.987 --> 00:08:46.817
Now that's quite a lot of money.
00:08:46.907 --> 00:08:50.987
Um, you know, it's a lot more than
the minimum wage was at that time.
00:08:50.987 --> 00:08:54.347
Although the minimum wages has gone
up since then, it's still a bit more.
00:08:54.887 --> 00:08:58.577
Um, but it's particularly a lot
of money for certain people.
00:08:58.637 --> 00:09:04.612
So if you're living in working outside
London, If you, um, if you're a woman,
00:09:04.612 --> 00:09:09.332
if you're part-time, if you're young, you
know, there's the whole groups of people.
00:09:09.352 --> 00:09:12.772
Um, if you're an ethnic minority,
you know, you'll pay on average,
00:09:12.772 --> 00:09:14.122
is it ends up being lower.
00:09:14.632 --> 00:09:17.122
Um, so there whole groups of
people who are affected by that.
00:09:17.122 --> 00:09:18.112
So you find it very different.
00:09:18.872 --> 00:09:21.842
To sponsor, um, a spouse or partner.
00:09:22.172 --> 00:09:24.992
And it means that either they
have to go and live in another
00:09:24.992 --> 00:09:29.252
country to be together as a family,
um, or they have to live apart.
00:09:29.342 --> 00:09:33.272
And, um, you know, one of the parents
is going to be basically a single
00:09:33.272 --> 00:09:37.832
parent and you get what was previously
being called a Skype family, where,
00:09:38.162 --> 00:09:41.462
you know, the children only really
know one of their parents through,
00:09:41.492 --> 00:09:43.202
through video calls, which is just.
00:09:44.647 --> 00:09:48.457
Isabelle Roughol: And so only in, in a
lockdown, I think it gave a lot of people,
00:09:48.577 --> 00:09:54.367
a window into what that means to only be
able to reach your family through Skype.
00:09:54.907 --> 00:09:59.047
Um, do you think that would
change people's attitudes, make
00:09:59.047 --> 00:10:01.687
them care a little bit more
about this or is this something.
00:10:02.447 --> 00:10:06.047
Really only people who have their
own experience of immigration
00:10:06.047 --> 00:10:07.907
are going to be aware of.
00:10:09.197 --> 00:10:09.797
Colin Yeo: I don't know.
00:10:09.907 --> 00:10:10.617
I don't know who I knew.
00:10:10.617 --> 00:10:15.407
I could see that perhaps more thoughtful,
um, people with a bit more empathy might
00:10:15.407 --> 00:10:18.317
realize how inadequate video calls are.
00:10:19.097 --> 00:10:23.567
Substitute for, for a hug for
actual meaningful family life and
00:10:23.567 --> 00:10:25.427
engagement between parents and child.
00:10:25.847 --> 00:10:28.817
Um, but others might well just
say, well, you know, we cope during
00:10:28.827 --> 00:10:30.797
lockdown, so, so they can cope.
00:10:31.007 --> 00:10:35.777
You know, I, I don't know, it, it,
it's often things, you know, we might
00:10:35.777 --> 00:10:39.887
hope that things will be different in
future, but people often revert to type.
00:10:39.887 --> 00:10:42.407
I think that's, that's what, um,
this will be experience of life.
00:10:42.407 --> 00:10:42.677
Tell them.
00:10:44.465 --> 00:10:45.365
Isabelle Roughol: And it's a type of.
00:10:46.490 --> 00:10:51.290
Um, a bit ironic because it's coming
from a conservative government, which
00:10:51.320 --> 00:10:56.450
for whom, you know, family values is
usually a big part of, of their platform.
00:10:57.050 --> 00:11:01.790
Um, and, and thinking more broadly, not
just about the UK, uh, I think family
00:11:01.790 --> 00:11:08.660
separation has been a big issue as well in
the U S immigration system the past or so.
00:11:09.080 --> 00:11:13.520
And, and now we're seeing the U S really.
00:11:14.405 --> 00:11:20.375
Uh, really restrict immigration
to, to a trickle, in the pandemic.
00:11:20.435 --> 00:11:24.065
Um, ha uh, wondering sort of what
your reaction to, I mean, this, this
00:11:24.065 --> 00:11:28.415
week we heard about international
students essentially asked to leave.
00:11:29.842 --> 00:11:32.152
Colin Yeo: Yeah, I, I saw the
announcements on that and it,
00:11:32.152 --> 00:11:34.852
it, it does seem extraordinary.
00:11:35.382 --> 00:11:38.212
There's a chapter in, in, in the book,
which I think we're going to talk
00:11:38.212 --> 00:11:43.882
about, about, um, students and basically
how, how valuable they are to, to the
00:11:43.882 --> 00:11:46.312
country and to an economy and how.
00:11:47.117 --> 00:11:50.567
How important it is to
proactively attract them's one.
00:11:50.567 --> 00:11:54.017
I think one of the mistakes that we
see being made here in the UK and
00:11:54.287 --> 00:11:59.747
perhaps also in future in the us,
um, is the assumption that people
00:11:59.777 --> 00:12:02.327
will want to come to our country.
00:12:02.417 --> 00:12:04.707
So if you make it possible for people to.
00:12:05.427 --> 00:12:06.327
Then they will come.
00:12:06.387 --> 00:12:10.347
Um, the kind of, um, it's a bit of an
obscure reference this, but the kind of
00:12:10.347 --> 00:12:12.177
Kevin Cosmo field of dreams build it.
00:12:12.177 --> 00:12:15.147
They will come type thing, and it, it
doesn't necessarily work like that.
00:12:15.147 --> 00:12:19.767
You actually have to proactively attract
people and make your country a welcoming
00:12:19.767 --> 00:12:23.517
place to get the kind of migrants to come.
00:12:23.517 --> 00:12:26.607
Who, who, who people design these
policies are kind of aiming it at.
00:12:26.607 --> 00:12:28.617
So the sort of internationally mobile.
00:12:29.352 --> 00:12:34.272
Um, very talented, potentially highly,
highly skilled, highly paid individuals.
00:12:34.692 --> 00:12:37.962
And if you have policies that, um, are.
00:12:38.792 --> 00:12:40.232
Generally tough on immigration.
00:12:40.262 --> 00:12:43.532
If you use anti-immigrant rhetoric.
00:12:43.892 --> 00:12:49.082
And if you have arbitrary policies,
which make the future uncertain
00:12:49.082 --> 00:12:52.052
for people, then they'll think
twice about moving to that country.
00:12:52.472 --> 00:12:54.152
Um, and it's not the lowest.
00:12:54.742 --> 00:12:56.422
Migrants who get put off.
00:12:56.512 --> 00:12:59.932
It's the high skilled migrants who
get put off because they've got
00:12:59.932 --> 00:13:01.462
a choice about where they go to.
00:13:01.462 --> 00:13:03.952
There's lots of countries
who are interested in sort
00:13:03.952 --> 00:13:05.002
of trying to attract them.
00:13:05.362 --> 00:13:10.462
And, um, you know, it's, um, I,
I saw something, I saw something
00:13:10.462 --> 00:13:14.332
interesting where I'm a former minister,
Boris Johnson's brother actually,
00:13:14.662 --> 00:13:18.322
um, has written the introduction
to a report on foreign students.
00:13:18.682 --> 00:13:20.692
And he just mentioned in passing that.
00:13:21.517 --> 00:13:26.077
And Theresa May was, um, was known
as agent may by, um, by the Canadian
00:13:26.317 --> 00:13:30.697
university people, because she was so
helpful to their recruitment efforts
00:13:30.697 --> 00:13:34.087
because she was putting international
students off, coming to the UK.
00:13:34.387 --> 00:13:37.027
It was actually a drive to reduce
the number of international
00:13:37.027 --> 00:13:38.377
students coming to the UK.
00:13:38.847 --> 00:13:41.617
And that was great for other countries,
which were then able to attract them.
00:13:43.000 --> 00:13:45.760
Isabelle Roughol: Yeah, I just
did an episode recently on,
00:13:45.760 --> 00:13:47.110
on international students.
00:13:47.110 --> 00:13:52.150
And it's a, was striking that, uh,
you know, in fact, most international
00:13:52.150 --> 00:13:53.470
students come in from Asia.
00:13:54.100 --> 00:13:57.160
But they now also mostly go to Asia.
00:13:57.430 --> 00:14:03.550
Um, and the, the appeal of American
or UK universities has really declined
00:14:03.750 --> 00:14:07.150
as part of that, that
rhetoric
and, and the whole rhetoric around.
00:14:08.180 --> 00:14:11.870
Um, you know, oh, we're we only
want highly skilled people.
00:14:12.740 --> 00:14:13.010
yeah.
00:14:13.010 --> 00:14:17.300
As you said, the problem is when
you, when your, your rhetoric is,
00:14:17.390 --> 00:14:23.420
is aggressively anti-immigrant,
um, the, the, you know, wealthy,
00:14:23.420 --> 00:14:28.880
professional, highly skilled immigrants,
um, are also turned off, right?
00:14:29.092 --> 00:14:29.272
Colin Yeo: Yeah.
00:14:29.632 --> 00:14:30.412
Yeah, absolutely.
00:14:30.502 --> 00:14:31.012
Absolutely.
00:14:31.372 --> 00:14:33.712
It's like a, it's like a market,
um, you know, you're, you're
00:14:33.712 --> 00:14:34.942
trying to attract people.
00:14:35.302 --> 00:14:39.862
Um, and in fact, politicians on
the right are often doing yeah.
00:14:39.882 --> 00:14:42.562
Saying that they want the brightest
and best, but at the same time,
00:14:42.562 --> 00:14:46.042
introducing policies and using language
that, that puts those people off.
00:14:46.295 --> 00:14:48.365
Isabelle Roughol: and then the first
ones to leave because they can,
00:14:48.755 --> 00:14:49.685
because they have options.
00:14:50.045 --> 00:14:50.255
Yeah.
00:14:51.565 --> 00:14:57.305
I was struck reading the book, uh,
by the phrase hostile environment,
00:14:57.815 --> 00:15:02.075
which I would have thought, you know,
it was just a way for opponents to
00:15:02.075 --> 00:15:04.175
describe the system, but is actually.
00:15:05.000 --> 00:15:09.920
The actual policy, uh, that,
that willingly, um, the home
00:15:09.920 --> 00:15:12.020
office is, is putting forward.
00:15:12.020 --> 00:15:14.690
So, so what did they mean
by, by hostile environment?
00:15:14.690 --> 00:15:15.500
And what's the goal
00:15:16.477 --> 00:15:19.027
Colin Yeo: Well, there's a bit of
a sort of backgrounds to the, to
00:15:19.027 --> 00:15:20.317
the words, hostile environment.
00:15:21.077 --> 00:15:22.787
That was developed in the home office.
00:15:23.147 --> 00:15:27.077
In this early years of, at the
millennium abarrotes and it was used
00:15:27.107 --> 00:15:29.237
for terrorists in the first place.
00:15:29.237 --> 00:15:32.957
The idea was that instead of catching
them and prosecuting them and putting
00:15:32.957 --> 00:15:36.497
them in prison, you'd kind of try
and deter them and keep them away by
00:15:36.497 --> 00:15:39.857
attacking their, their finances, their
support base and things like that.
00:15:40.367 --> 00:15:43.667
And it was kind of extended
to serious organized crime.
00:15:43.967 --> 00:15:46.457
And then just bizarrely,
it was extended to.
00:15:47.077 --> 00:15:52.597
So immigrants, um, from about 2010
onwards and you actually see that phrase
00:15:52.597 --> 00:15:56.617
being deployed and used deliberately by
ministers, like to resume, who was home
00:15:56.617 --> 00:16:01.357
secretary at the time, the committee,
um, cabinet committee that was set
00:16:01.357 --> 00:16:03.637
up to look at various different ways.
00:16:04.497 --> 00:16:07.867
Deterring illegal migrants and then
trying to drive them out to the
00:16:07.867 --> 00:16:08.817
country and stop them coming in.
00:16:08.817 --> 00:16:12.147
The first place was actually called
the hostile environment working group.
00:16:12.207 --> 00:16:16.917
Um, it was eventually retitled because I
think, um, the, the coalition partners,
00:16:16.917 --> 00:16:19.647
the liberal Democrats at the time thought
I was a little bit just too sinister.
00:16:19.947 --> 00:16:22.797
Um, you know, that, that was the, there
was a clear intent there, and that was
00:16:22.797 --> 00:16:25.557
the deliberate language of, of ministers.
00:16:25.917 --> 00:16:29.457
They've renamed it out that, that
compliance environment, which sounds.
00:16:30.242 --> 00:16:34.292
Not that unseen sinister, if you see
what I mean, frankly, but, but sort of
00:16:34.292 --> 00:16:37.232
less overtly hostile because it doesn't
actually have the word hostile in it,
00:16:37.592 --> 00:16:40.682
but a lot of us still refer to it as the
hostile environment, because that was
00:16:40.682 --> 00:16:45.482
the name the policy was labeled with by,
by the government itself at the time.
00:16:46.540 --> 00:16:49.960
Isabelle Roughol: sounds like something
out of quite sinister, bureaucratic
00:16:49.960 --> 00:16:51.940
department of naming things.
00:16:53.795 --> 00:16:59.375
So, so what is the consequence of
the hostile environment and does
00:16:59.375 --> 00:17:01.295
it achieve what it's intended to.
00:17:02.672 --> 00:17:05.042
Colin Yeo: Well, and you can
use words in different ways.
00:17:05.042 --> 00:17:07.742
So, um, a lot of people when they're
talking about the hostile environment
00:17:07.802 --> 00:17:11.852
and they're talking about just being
nasty to immigrants, basically, and there
00:17:11.852 --> 00:17:16.082
certainly is a lot of that know, we've
seen a lot of anti-immigrant rhetoric in
00:17:16.082 --> 00:17:19.922
the UK over the last few years, started
to change a little bit, to be fair,
00:17:19.982 --> 00:17:21.992
um, with, with Brexit coming along.
00:17:22.052 --> 00:17:26.342
Um, but, um, When, when I, when I
use the word hostile environment,
00:17:26.342 --> 00:17:30.092
I'm often referring to quite
specific set of policies, which,
00:17:30.302 --> 00:17:34.022
which is quite wide ranging, but
it's basically a barracks introduce.
00:17:34.727 --> 00:17:39.707
Sitters and on citizen immigration
checks, so that employers have
00:17:39.707 --> 00:17:41.267
to check your immigration status.
00:17:41.567 --> 00:17:43.907
Landlords have to check
your immigration status.
00:17:44.027 --> 00:17:46.487
So do banks and building
societies, which are, you know,
00:17:46.487 --> 00:17:47.897
they're not immigration offices.
00:17:48.287 --> 00:17:50.777
And then it also extends to
two other public services.
00:17:51.457 --> 00:17:56.617
Um, civil servants, um, who are working
for
different government departments
00:17:56.617 --> 00:18:00.637
also have to look at immigration status
and people working in local governments,
00:18:00.667 --> 00:18:04.507
check your immigration status, the
NHS checks your immigration status.
00:18:04.837 --> 00:18:09.337
Um, so you get this kind of culture of
checking everybody's immigration status.
00:18:09.367 --> 00:18:11.917
That's, that's been spread
by various different laws.
00:18:12.277 --> 00:18:14.647
People are fined if they
fail to do it properly.
00:18:15.037 --> 00:18:17.287
Um, and, and the, the effect that it has.
00:18:18.032 --> 00:18:23.432
Kind of similar to identity cards, but,
but in my view, a lot worse actually,
00:18:23.432 --> 00:18:28.322
because what you're doing with the hostile
environment is you're forcing people
00:18:28.442 --> 00:18:31.022
to prove their right to be in the UK.
00:18:31.682 --> 00:18:37.772
And, um, the fines only kick in if the
person turns out not to have a right to be
00:18:37.772 --> 00:18:44.222
in the UK and therefore a lot of private
individuals and civil servants and so on.
00:18:45.272 --> 00:18:48.212
Take a shortcut and they think what
if you're white and you've got a
00:18:48.212 --> 00:18:51.752
local accent, then I don't really
need to check your status because I'm
00:18:51.752 --> 00:18:52.922
pretty sure you've got a right to be.
00:18:53.747 --> 00:18:58.997
But if you're black or Asian or you've
got a foreign sounding name or something
00:18:58.997 --> 00:19:02.357
like that, then I will check your status
because I'm not quite so sure about that.
00:19:02.837 --> 00:19:06.827
And it's one thing for white middle class.
00:19:06.857 --> 00:19:09.797
Middle-aged male, like me to
be asked to show my passport.
00:19:09.977 --> 00:19:11.777
It's not particularly intrusive.
00:19:11.777 --> 00:19:17.057
It doesn't threaten me in any meaningful
way, but to ask somebody who's, who's
00:19:17.057 --> 00:19:20.687
black to prove their status in the
UK, because you're not sure about.
00:19:21.367 --> 00:19:22.867
That's a very different experience.
00:19:22.867 --> 00:19:26.617
I think it's much more challenging
and existential, frankly,
00:19:26.617 --> 00:19:27.727
and it's much more offensive.
00:19:28.207 --> 00:19:31.507
Um, but that's what this
policy is, is all about us.
00:19:31.507 --> 00:19:35.407
The whole point of this policy is, is to
have people's immigration status checked
00:19:35.407 --> 00:19:37.117
by other citizens and civil rights.
00:19:38.530 --> 00:19:39.790
Isabelle Roughol: is that your case?
00:19:39.790 --> 00:19:44.350
Immigration policy racist
intentionally or accidentally?
00:19:46.427 --> 00:19:47.567
Colin Yeo: It's a really
difficult question.
00:19:47.567 --> 00:19:50.117
I think it is intentional in the end.
00:19:50.207 --> 00:19:55.157
Um, and I think ministers would deny that,
um, that they'd say it wasn't intentional,
00:19:55.547 --> 00:19:57.077
but it's, in some ways it's also.
00:19:57.947 --> 00:20:01.427
It's also the wrong question,
because I don't think it matters
00:20:01.517 --> 00:20:03.347
whether it's intentional or not.
00:20:03.377 --> 00:20:05.177
What really matters is the impact.
00:20:05.567 --> 00:20:07.997
And there's it, there's a huge
amount of evidence to show that
00:20:07.997 --> 00:20:09.227
whatever the intention is before.
00:20:10.022 --> 00:20:13.262
It is racist in the way that
it operates on the ground.
00:20:13.712 --> 00:20:17.252
And there was a lot of evidence
beforehand, and frankly, it doesn't
00:20:17.252 --> 00:20:20.342
take much to think it through to
realize that it was going to have racist
00:20:20.342 --> 00:20:23.192
consequences, um, and, and ministers.
00:20:23.252 --> 00:20:27.182
And, you know, I think to an extent
civil servants as well, simply
00:20:27.242 --> 00:20:31.202
ignored, or didn't look at that
evidence or weren't bothered by it.
00:20:31.502 --> 00:20:32.912
And they went ahead anyway.
00:20:33.002 --> 00:20:34.022
And that's what.
00:20:34.782 --> 00:20:39.612
Triggered the, the kind of Windrush
scandal to bubble to the surface and
00:20:39.612 --> 00:20:42.882
that the causes of that were very
long-term potentially, you know,
00:20:43.482 --> 00:20:47.072
immigration policies over the last
sort of few decades that, that, that
00:20:47.082 --> 00:20:49.212
caused it to happen in the first place.
00:20:49.452 --> 00:20:52.962
But it, people weren't being
turfed out of their jobs and homes.
00:20:53.537 --> 00:20:59.177
Until really from 2010 onwards, by
real ramping up of enforcement of these
00:20:59.177 --> 00:21:02.987
laws and a spread of these laws to,
to other areas than just employment,
00:21:02.987 --> 00:21:04.577
which is where I applied previously.
00:21:05.385 --> 00:21:08.445
Isabelle Roughol: and then in of
enforcement that essentially deputized.
00:21:09.905 --> 00:21:14.135
Uh, landlords employers, the
entire British population and into
00:21:14.135 --> 00:21:15.845
checking the immigration status,
00:21:16.235 --> 00:21:23.735
um, since our audience is global, let's
just give people a summary of, of, you
00:21:23.735 --> 00:21:27.395
know, who to when rush generation are
and, and what that scandal was about.
00:21:28.272 --> 00:21:28.512
Colin Yeo: Yeah.
00:21:28.722 --> 00:21:32.352
So the Windrush generation, that's a
label that, that somebody particularly
00:21:32.352 --> 00:21:35.832
campaigners is Patrick Vernon kind
of invented re quite recently.
00:21:36.102 --> 00:21:41.232
And, um, it's a label that's sort
of broadly includes basically that
00:21:41.232 --> 00:21:46.452
the post-war generation of people
who came to the United Kingdom from.
00:21:47.067 --> 00:21:51.177
The old, British empire, what was,
what was then named the Commonwealth.
00:21:51.597 --> 00:21:55.167
And when they came to the
UK, they came as citizens.
00:21:55.437 --> 00:21:59.157
So they weren't really migrants in,
in that sense, they actually had a
00:21:59.157 --> 00:22:02.247
citizenship of the United Kingdom
and colonies as it was called.
00:22:02.517 --> 00:22:06.927
And that was the same citizenship as
people born in the United Kingdom itself.
00:22:07.407 --> 00:22:12.057
And they came from the Caribbean,
from the Indian sub-continent and
00:22:12.057 --> 00:22:14.547
from Africa in the 1950s and sixties.
00:22:15.317 --> 00:22:20.057
And then gradually over the 1960s and
seventies, um, once they graduate,
00:22:20.057 --> 00:22:24.467
it was, it was fairly sudden actually
from, from 1962 onwards, um, new
00:22:24.467 --> 00:22:28.667
rules were introduced, which kind of
created a two tier type of citizenship
00:22:28.697 --> 00:22:32.987
where basically new entrants weren't
going to be allowed in very easily,
00:22:33.137 --> 00:22:36.617
but the people who had already
come, um, would be allowed to stay.
00:22:36.617 --> 00:22:38.927
There was no talk about toughing
them out or anything like that.
00:22:39.637 --> 00:22:43.777
But they weren't issued with status
papers at the time, they were just
00:22:43.867 --> 00:22:46.867
sort of a law was passed basically
saying that they were lovely
00:22:46.867 --> 00:22:50.827
resident, but they didn't necessarily
have documents issued to prove it.
00:22:51.337 --> 00:22:54.547
And for decades they didn't need
those documents because nobody
00:22:54.547 --> 00:22:57.157
was checking their immigration
status on a day-to-day basis.
00:22:57.887 --> 00:23:01.847
But from 2010 onwards with this,
this incoming conservative government
00:23:02.717 --> 00:23:06.857
immigration checks became an everyday
part of life in the United Kingdom.
00:23:07.247 --> 00:23:11.237
And that meant that people suddenly found
themselves losing their jobs, losing
00:23:11.237 --> 00:23:16.277
their homes and facing deportation to
countries that they'd, they'd come from as
00:23:16.277 --> 00:23:18.347
tiny children, you know, decades before.
00:23:19.690 --> 00:23:26.380
Isabelle Roughol: And many did, and I
sinkewitz, what's probably most uncommon
00:23:26.410 --> 00:23:30.070
incomprehensible to people looking at
the Windrush scandal from the outside.
00:23:31.040 --> 00:23:35.900
Is that there seemed that there was no
way to prove your good faith, that, you
00:23:35.900 --> 00:23:43.190
know, amount of, of having clearly been
educated and lived in the UK for decades
00:23:43.190 --> 00:23:50.150
and, and having worked in having, um,
pay stubs and, and whatever, know, which
00:23:50.180 --> 00:23:52.220
who has pay stubs from the seventies.
00:23:52.610 --> 00:23:54.980
Um, it seemed like it didn't matter.
00:23:55.430 --> 00:23:59.120
Was there a policy of disbelief on.
00:24:00.682 --> 00:24:00.832
Colin Yeo: Yeah.
00:24:00.842 --> 00:24:04.192
W w lawyers and campaigners often talk
about there being a culture of discipline.
00:24:04.622 --> 00:24:05.252
Same office.
00:24:05.312 --> 00:24:08.522
And that that's a phrase that's been
in circulation for quite some time.
00:24:08.522 --> 00:24:13.502
And it's very accurately describes the
general approach of officials at the home
00:24:13.502 --> 00:24:17.882
office, who simply assume that you're
lying unless you can prove otherwise.
00:24:18.362 --> 00:24:20.972
And that kind of very.
00:24:21.992 --> 00:24:28.472
Um, cynical approach was just
astonishingly, also applied to
00:24:28.502 --> 00:24:29.912
Windrush generation migrants.
00:24:29.912 --> 00:24:33.632
Who'd been, you know, obviously
living here for decades and had
00:24:33.902 --> 00:24:36.002
obviously good proof to show it.
00:24:36.302 --> 00:24:40.502
And officials were just applying then
the normal standards of proof, which
00:24:40.502 --> 00:24:45.452
are incredibly hard to meet to, to these
people in a completely inappropriate way.
00:24:45.842 --> 00:24:49.652
Um, and I just, it just beggars
belief really that those officials.
00:24:50.327 --> 00:24:54.317
Couldn't see that what they were
doing was wrong, but that was,
00:24:54.317 --> 00:24:57.377
that was the approach that they're
kind of policy documents and so on.
00:24:57.377 --> 00:24:58.397
Talk them to.
00:25:00.340 --> 00:25:01.690
Isabelle Roughol: where
does that come from?
00:25:01.690 --> 00:25:06.850
Is there, you know, do they
have, numbered goals to hit?
00:25:06.880 --> 00:25:11.950
Do they, I am fascinated by, by
organizational culture and sort of how
00:25:11.950 --> 00:25:14.240
you get, you know, a bunch of people.
00:25:14.770 --> 00:25:19.660
Decent people individually,
uh, to, to somehow, you know,
00:25:19.660 --> 00:25:23.110
become this, this hostile force.
00:25:24.010 --> 00:25:27.670
How does that work in
and how do we change it?
00:25:27.700 --> 00:25:29.530
Do we burn the home office to the ground?
00:25:29.560 --> 00:25:36.400
Metaphorically, obviously not advocate
advocating but how do we, how do we change
00:25:36.400 --> 00:25:38.380
or do we just have to start from scratch?
00:25:39.397 --> 00:25:43.687
Colin Yeo: Well, I, I'm not sure that
simply abolishing the home office.
00:25:44.147 --> 00:25:44.887
Sorry the way forward.
00:25:44.887 --> 00:25:46.987
And you know, there are people
out there who, who say we should
00:25:46.987 --> 00:25:48.127
just abolish the home office.
00:25:48.607 --> 00:25:52.927
Um, th th the reason I think that
is that, um, all the functions that
00:25:52.927 --> 00:25:55.057
the home office currently sort of.
00:25:56.087 --> 00:26:01.067
Um, follows or is responsible for,
um, those would all have to be done
00:26:01.067 --> 00:26:04.787
by somebody and they probably end up
being done by homo festival servants.
00:26:04.787 --> 00:26:08.537
They'd just be redistributed to other
departments or a new department of
00:26:08.537 --> 00:26:09.857
immigration or something like that.
00:26:10.157 --> 00:26:13.667
And I don't think that would necessarily
achieve cultural change, but w w what
00:26:13.667 --> 00:26:18.857
we've seen is leadership from the top of
the home office that says that
immigration
00:26:18.857 --> 00:26:20.687
is a bad thing and needs to be reduced.
00:26:21.232 --> 00:26:25.792
And famously that that comes from the net
migration targets set by David Cameron
00:26:25.882 --> 00:26:28.492
as leader of the opposition in 2010.
00:26:28.822 --> 00:26:32.932
And it was an official government
policy and basically ministers.
00:26:34.127 --> 00:26:39.407
And that, that, that policy was announced
as a short-term political measure, I
00:26:39.407 --> 00:26:44.897
think, um, in order to, um, position
the conservative party, um, with the
00:26:44.897 --> 00:26:48.857
electorate and also to position David
Cameron within the conservative party
00:26:48.857 --> 00:26:50.477
and to keep, keep certain people happy.
00:26:50.897 --> 00:26:53.897
Um, but it turns out when you get into
government that reducing immigration
00:26:53.927 --> 00:26:57.017
isn't as straightforward as you might
think, and that, you know, which
00:26:57.017 --> 00:26:58.757
migrants do you want to, to get rid of?
00:26:58.787 --> 00:26:58.967
Is it.
00:26:59.567 --> 00:27:02.927
The highly skilled ones who are coming
in, in which case the economy suffers
00:27:02.987 --> 00:27:05.957
and GDP falls and employers are unhappy.
00:27:06.287 --> 00:27:09.377
Is it families, in which case
families ended up being split?
00:27:09.767 --> 00:27:13.277
Is it refugees in which case you're,
you're being very inhumane and your
00:27:13.277 --> 00:27:14.537
international reputation suffered.
00:27:15.127 --> 00:27:18.367
Um, is it international students who
are incredibly valuable and, and sort
00:27:18.367 --> 00:27:20.737
of heavily subsidized domestic students?
00:27:21.067 --> 00:27:23.887
Um, so suddenly you've got all these
hard choices about what, what you're
00:27:23.887 --> 00:27:26.437
going to do, and what they decided is
that they were just going to try and
00:27:26.437 --> 00:27:30.067
do it, reducing immigration across
the board, pulling every available.
00:27:30.792 --> 00:27:34.722
Trying to make things as difficult
as possible for migrants apparently.
00:27:34.722 --> 00:27:37.752
And the policy was never
really spelled out.
00:27:37.752 --> 00:27:39.822
So you have to kind of read
between the lines to see what they
00:27:39.822 --> 00:27:40.992
were hoping to achieve with it.
00:27:41.412 --> 00:27:44.772
And it seems to me that it was to
try and put people off, coming to the
00:27:44.772 --> 00:27:50.772
UK in the first place, and also to
encourage people to leave the UK and
00:27:50.772 --> 00:27:52.482
to make their lives in sufferable.
00:27:53.072 --> 00:27:57.032
Um, but one of the things I talk about in
the book is that there's no evidence that
00:27:57.032 --> 00:28:02.372
it actually achieves that what it does do
is it forces people out of legal status.
00:28:02.402 --> 00:28:06.302
Once they're in the UK, the kind of
complexity of the rules there that
00:28:06.332 --> 00:28:11.582
arbitrariness that the cost of the rules
or the income thresholds, and so on these.
00:28:12.482 --> 00:28:16.052
Sometimes people can't meet
the rules and they don't leave.
00:28:16.232 --> 00:28:18.512
They just become illegally resident.
00:28:18.662 --> 00:28:23.222
And we've now got this potentially very
substantial unauthorized population in the
00:28:23.222 --> 00:28:25.892
United Kingdom and estimates vary hugely.
00:28:25.892 --> 00:28:30.452
It could be between guesses
range between 600001.2 million.
00:28:30.852 --> 00:28:31.892
And these are people that.
00:28:32.327 --> 00:28:36.377
I have no proper status, but they're
not also not being forced out of the
00:28:36.377 --> 00:28:40.367
country, which is just, it's really
an intolerable situation for them.
00:28:40.367 --> 00:28:42.257
And I think that for us as a society,
00:28:43.640 --> 00:28:43.850
Isabelle Roughol: right.
00:28:43.850 --> 00:28:48.680
And they've been pushed to the
margins and into, um, potentially,
00:28:48.680 --> 00:28:53.180
you know, abusive situations with,
with landlords who, you know, don't
00:28:53.180 --> 00:28:55.040
look too closely it's et cetera.
00:28:55.340 --> 00:28:59.300
Is the solution a, an amnesty
for a lot of these people.
00:28:59.300 --> 00:29:02.600
Is it a case by case regularization?
00:29:03.575 --> 00:29:04.175
Of these
00:29:04.737 --> 00:29:06.147
Colin Yeo: Well, I don't
think you can remove them.
00:29:06.207 --> 00:29:08.157
That's that's the start.
00:29:08.457 --> 00:29:11.647
You know, if you, if you look at the
number of removals from the UK, you,
00:29:11.907 --> 00:29:15.417
I think people think that there are
more removals now than they used to be.
00:29:15.537 --> 00:29:20.847
So, um, the, the labor government that
was in place before 2008, Isn't are
00:29:20.847 --> 00:29:22.647
regarded as being soft on immigration.
00:29:22.647 --> 00:29:26.607
Whereas the conservative and coalition
governments from 2010 onwards have
00:29:26.607 --> 00:29:28.227
regarded as being tough on immigration.
00:29:28.497 --> 00:29:32.097
But actually the number of enforced
removals from the UK is, has fallen
00:29:32.157 --> 00:29:34.017
since 2010, quite substantially.
00:29:34.287 --> 00:29:37.257
So there's less than 10,000
migrants in arrow, subject to
00:29:37.257 --> 00:29:39.087
an enforced removal every year.
00:29:39.507 --> 00:29:42.447
And we also know from the
statistics that an increasing
00:29:42.447 --> 00:29:44.877
proportion of them are EU citizens.
00:29:44.937 --> 00:29:47.427
Who've committed quite minor
crimes and it kind of looks.
00:29:48.617 --> 00:29:49.967
Officials are plumping.
00:29:50.837 --> 00:29:54.467
Even falling numbers with, with,
you know, low risk removals
00:29:54.467 --> 00:29:55.847
that are easy to carry out.
00:29:56.117 --> 00:29:58.427
So I don't think you
can, you can remove them.
00:29:58.427 --> 00:30:00.437
That's just, you'll be inhumane.
00:30:00.497 --> 00:30:05.987
It will require building detention camps,
tearing families and communities
apart.
00:30:05.987 --> 00:30:06.677
It would be horrendous.
00:30:06.977 --> 00:30:09.347
So that leaves when, if they're
going to stay here, can you
00:30:09.347 --> 00:30:10.397
just ignore the problem?
00:30:10.637 --> 00:30:12.737
And I don't think we really can or should.
00:30:13.297 --> 00:30:15.367
Um, or do you want to deal with it?
00:30:15.607 --> 00:30:17.347
And there are two ways of dealing with it.
00:30:17.347 --> 00:30:21.697
One is to try and bring as many
people within the law as possible
00:30:21.697 --> 00:30:24.607
with a kind of one-off amnesty
or something of that nature.
00:30:24.847 --> 00:30:28.987
But if you were to do that, um, it just
potentially doesn't deal with the problem
00:30:28.987 --> 00:30:32.977
in the long-term and it recurs you also
have to address the rules that are forcing
00:30:32.977 --> 00:30:35.107
people into illegality in the first place.
00:30:35.467 --> 00:30:35.997
And also.
00:30:36.707 --> 00:30:38.747
Uh, route to, to regular status.
00:30:38.777 --> 00:30:41.657
So I don't think it's an either or
I think you need an amnesty because
00:30:41.657 --> 00:30:45.467
there's just such a huge number of
people who seem to be here without proper
00:30:45.467 --> 00:30:47.177
lawful status, which is bad for them.
00:30:47.177 --> 00:30:51.737
And it's, it's bad for lawful
residents as well, but also you want
00:30:51.737 --> 00:30:55.787
to look at the rules more widely
so that they're not forced into
00:30:55.787 --> 00:30:57.017
that status in the first place.
00:30:57.047 --> 00:30:58.787
And there is a root
activity in the longer term.
00:31:00.650 --> 00:31:05.390
Isabelle Roughol: So I want to talk
about the EU settlement scheme, and
00:31:05.390 --> 00:31:09.680
Brexit, uh, because you suddenly
have millions of people who never
00:31:09.680 --> 00:31:13.730
really thought of themselves as
immigrants who are realizing that they
00:31:13.730 --> 00:31:16.580
are, um, where, where are we with?
00:31:17.405 --> 00:31:20.585
The scheme, which is
entering its last year now.
00:31:20.585 --> 00:31:24.155
So people are eligible if they're
here before December 31st of
00:31:24.155 --> 00:31:28.865
this year, and they have to apply
before the end of June, 2021.
00:31:28.865 --> 00:31:31.055
So there's a little under a year left.
00:31:31.505 --> 00:31:35.995
Um, where are we in terms of, um,
the number of people who've applied,
00:31:36.005 --> 00:31:41.345
number of people who have obtained
status, uh, and, and does it look
00:31:41.345 --> 00:31:42.905
like it's going to be success?
00:31:44.002 --> 00:31:44.182
Colin Yeo: Yeah.
00:31:45.072 --> 00:31:47.082
Can't say whether it's
going to be successful?
00:31:47.322 --> 00:31:50.412
Uh, no, nobody can because one
of the I'll come back to this.
00:31:50.412 --> 00:31:50.712
One of them.
00:31:51.497 --> 00:31:54.347
Problems with this scheme is
that we'll never know how many
00:31:54.347 --> 00:31:58.607
people didn't apply and who were
in the UK unlawfully as a result.
00:31:59.147 --> 00:32:02.687
Um, but we, we know the latest
statistics say that there have been,
00:32:02.687 --> 00:32:05.387
I think 3.7 million applications.
00:32:05.447 --> 00:32:06.857
And I think status has been granted.
00:32:07.497 --> 00:32:12.237
And something like 3.5 million
of those cases, um, around 40% of
00:32:12.237 --> 00:32:15.927
people are getting what's called
pre settled status, which is, it
00:32:15.927 --> 00:32:19.377
puts them on a kind of five-year
route to being settled in the UK.
00:32:19.827 --> 00:32:23.807
And then the other 60% have been
granted settled status, which is
00:32:24.117 --> 00:32:25.647
permanent residence in the UK.
00:32:25.917 --> 00:32:29.247
Although you can still be deported if you
commit criminal offenses in, in future.
00:32:29.817 --> 00:32:33.537
Um, there was a tiny number of
refusals, although that has started
00:32:33.537 --> 00:32:34.977
to jump up quite considerably.
00:32:34.977 --> 00:32:35.157
So.
00:32:35.752 --> 00:32:36.532
Last month.
00:32:36.622 --> 00:32:40.222
I think it was an ounce, there'd be
900 refusals, which know in terms
00:32:40.222 --> 00:32:43.792
of percentages is an absolutely
minuscule number of refusals.
00:32:44.182 --> 00:32:46.912
Um, but this month has
jumped by further 1,400.
00:32:47.272 --> 00:32:51.742
So it looks like, you know, the number of
refusals is going up and we think that's
00:32:51.742 --> 00:32:55.252
because the was quite a backlog of cases.
00:32:55.642 --> 00:33:00.252
And a lot of the cases in the backlog
were considered complex and somebody who.
00:33:00.902 --> 00:33:04.262
It doesn't seem to meet the requirements
of the scheme or who has committed
00:33:04.262 --> 00:33:07.562
criminal offenses and declared them,
or those are considered complex cases.
00:33:07.562 --> 00:33:10.112
So the homeowner have been sitting on
those for a while and it's finally gotten
00:33:10.112 --> 00:33:11.342
around to actually dealing with them.
00:33:11.402 --> 00:33:13.022
And it is refusing a
certain number of them.
00:33:13.562 --> 00:33:16.202
So there's a high number of
application has been made.
00:33:16.532 --> 00:33:19.952
We don't know how many use
systems that are in the UK though.
00:33:20.032 --> 00:33:21.332
They've never been counted.
00:33:21.332 --> 00:33:23.552
There isn't a mechanism for
counting them here in this country.
00:33:24.002 --> 00:33:28.692
Um, and so the, the problem is that no
matter how many applications that are.
00:33:29.392 --> 00:33:33.292
We think that there will be many
people who don't make applications, who
00:33:33.292 --> 00:33:38.002
could have, and those people are going
to end up basically as unauthorized
00:33:38.002 --> 00:33:39.742
migrants, once the deadline passes.
00:33:40.192 --> 00:33:43.432
And we, we just, we just have no
idea how many that's going to be.
00:33:43.432 --> 00:33:46.612
It could be tens of thousands, you know,
a small percentage of the estimate.
00:33:47.402 --> 00:33:51.602
Three or 4 million EU citizens is still
a very substantial number of people
00:33:51.872 --> 00:33:55.112
and they will be subject to all of the
hostile environment policies we were
00:33:55.112 --> 00:33:58.052
talking about earlier, where they,
they're not able to work properly.
00:33:58.052 --> 00:33:59.552
Their bank accounts get shut down.
00:33:59.552 --> 00:34:01.482
They have to get turfed
out by their landlords and.
00:34:03.260 --> 00:34:03.620
Isabelle Roughol: Yeah.
00:34:03.650 --> 00:34:07.460
And get the emails from the home
office on the settlement scheme.
00:34:07.460 --> 00:34:10.940
And there was a, a tiny line
at the bottom of the last email
00:34:10.940 --> 00:34:12.320
that, that really chilled me.
00:34:13.160 --> 00:34:16.100
It said, don't forget
to apply for children.
00:34:16.940 --> 00:34:19.970
And I wonder if, you know,
give it another 10 years, we're
00:34:19.970 --> 00:34:21.410
going to have a situation like.
00:34:22.910 --> 00:34:28.970
In the U S where you have a bunch
of children who one applied for they
00:34:28.970 --> 00:34:32.990
couldn't speak for themselves and, and
will find themselves without status.
00:34:33.020 --> 00:34:33.860
When they're adults.
00:34:34.662 --> 00:34:37.212
Colin Yeo: Yeah, I think it's almost
inevitable that it's going to happen.
00:34:37.302 --> 00:34:39.522
Um, so other EU countries
that are dealing with.
00:34:40.337 --> 00:34:42.497
British citizens in a different way.
00:34:42.497 --> 00:34:46.307
You know, some countries are basically
doing what the UK did for the Windrush
00:34:46.337 --> 00:34:50.057
generation in, in previous decades
and passing a law, saying you are
00:34:50.087 --> 00:34:55.067
automatically lawfully resident, and then
trying to sort out the documents later.
00:34:55.607 --> 00:34:59.237
Um, and other, some other countries
like the UK are saying, well, those
00:34:59.237 --> 00:35:00.277
who are resident have to apply.
00:35:01.052 --> 00:35:02.372
Otherwise there'll be unlawful.
00:35:02.882 --> 00:35:05.162
And neither of those
is a perfect solution.
00:35:05.192 --> 00:35:07.322
They're the only two available solutions.
00:35:07.382 --> 00:35:11.372
Um, but the neither of them is perfect
because if you pass a law saying
00:35:11.372 --> 00:35:14.372
people are lawfully residents, but
don't issue them with documents,
00:35:14.402 --> 00:35:16.472
then they can have problems later on.
00:35:16.742 --> 00:35:18.272
Although I'd say it's
a bit of a different.
00:35:18.947 --> 00:35:23.057
Problem being lawful, but not being
able to prove it easily isn't as
00:35:23.057 --> 00:35:27.407
bad as being unlawful and having no
legal status and just being deported.
00:35:27.497 --> 00:35:31.787
Um, which is what the UK is, is
essentially doing to a very large number.
00:35:31.817 --> 00:35:33.317
We think of a used systems.
00:35:33.317 --> 00:35:36.857
It could be like I say, tens, maybe even
hundreds of thousands of people with.
00:35:38.545 --> 00:35:42.055
Isabelle Roughol: and that's a distinction
you make very early on in a book.
00:35:42.085 --> 00:35:47.935
You, you choose to use the word
unauthorized migrants, uh, Cause
00:35:47.935 --> 00:35:49.135
because you can have people.
00:35:49.695 --> 00:35:54.225
With legal status, but just not
the papers to prove it reading it.
00:35:54.255 --> 00:36:00.075
I realized a, I think I'm an
undocumented Mike, um, because I have
00:36:00.075 --> 00:36:03.975
pre settled status and all I got is
an email that made very clear that
00:36:03.975 --> 00:36:06.495
this was not legal proof of my status.
00:36:06.495 --> 00:36:10.305
So the EU settlement scheme does
not in fact provide documents.
00:36:11.007 --> 00:36:13.647
Colin Yeo: Well, yeah, you should
be very reassured that you've got a
00:36:13.647 --> 00:36:17.187
little number on a database, somewhere
in the home office that employers
00:36:17.247 --> 00:36:21.417
and landlords and banks and building
societies and doctors and so on.
00:36:21.747 --> 00:36:23.877
Can, uh, if they, if they can be.
00:36:24.817 --> 00:36:28.017
Um, they have to sort of phone up
the home office or, or get to the
00:36:28.027 --> 00:36:32.497
home office website check whether
you've got a, a black mark or a
00:36:32.497 --> 00:36:34.117
tick against your name, basically.
00:36:34.447 --> 00:36:37.627
And, um, and then they can
provide the service to you
00:36:37.657 --> 00:36:39.157
without fear of being fined.
00:36:39.187 --> 00:36:39.727
If you have.
00:36:40.302 --> 00:36:43.152
And it's one of the big problems
with the EU settlement scheme and
00:36:43.152 --> 00:36:44.112
there's lots of problems with it.
00:36:44.112 --> 00:36:47.172
But the biggest one is that
it forces people to apply.
00:36:47.172 --> 00:36:49.242
And some people won't for
various different reasons.
00:36:49.482 --> 00:36:53.112
But another problem is that no
physical documents are being issued.
00:36:53.232 --> 00:36:57.492
Um, and it means that say, for example,
if you're an employer in the UK,
00:36:57.792 --> 00:36:59.262
um, or a landlord, and you've got.
00:37:00.047 --> 00:37:03.437
Several people who apply for a
job or for a tendency or whatever.
00:37:03.857 --> 00:37:07.697
And some of them have got easy to
understand proof of their residency, like
00:37:07.847 --> 00:37:12.647
a British passport, and they can just
show it to you and others of them don't.
00:37:12.767 --> 00:37:15.647
And as the, as the employer or a
landlord, you've got to go away and
00:37:15.857 --> 00:37:19.997
check with the home office, whether
somebody has status or hasn't, that
00:37:19.997 --> 00:37:23.147
is going to lead to discrimination
against the citizens almost inevitably.
00:37:23.357 --> 00:37:26.597
Um, and that isn't what the
government say they want, but that's
00:37:26.627 --> 00:37:27.947
obviously what's going to happen.
00:37:28.750 --> 00:37:31.930
Isabelle Roughol: And they charge
you for that check to when,
uh,
00:37:31.960 --> 00:37:33.430
when you're trying to get a place.
00:37:34.570 --> 00:37:40.960
Um, I want to talk about the Hong
Kong situations, which I know you'll,
00:37:40.960 --> 00:37:46.210
you'll tell me, but it, it sounds like
it's actually, um, quite different.
00:37:46.270 --> 00:37:50.740
Uh, you know, we've talked about
this very hostile environment and
00:37:50.740 --> 00:37:53.260
all of a sudden, you know, the
prime minister is essentially.
00:37:54.230 --> 00:37:56.900
Potentially opening the door
to, I don't know, 3 million
00:37:56.900 --> 00:37:58.760
people, is that what's happening?
00:37:58.760 --> 00:38:00.590
What, what is it that's being offered?
00:38:01.652 --> 00:38:03.392
Colin Yeo: Yeah, I'd be
cautious about saying opening
00:38:03.392 --> 00:38:04.382
the door to 3 million people.
00:38:04.382 --> 00:38:05.042
Cause it's like saying.
00:38:05.882 --> 00:38:08.522
I don't know how many million people
there are, who live in the EU.
00:38:08.762 --> 00:38:12.932
Um, and yet obviously free movement
rights opened our doors to all those
00:38:12.932 --> 00:38:15.692
millions of people, but only a small
number of them actually want to come.
00:38:15.752 --> 00:38:16.052
You know?
00:38:16.532 --> 00:38:19.892
Um, and it's, it's like we
talked about earlier, it's
00:38:19.892 --> 00:38:21.032
kind of, it's not just about.
00:38:21.842 --> 00:38:25.592
Allowing people it's also about whether
they, whether they want to, or not.
00:38:25.982 --> 00:38:31.022
Now, Hong Kong is a bit different because
there are what, what, uh, a sociologist
00:38:31.022 --> 00:38:32.762
or an academic might call push factors.
00:38:32.792 --> 00:38:34.172
That's very neutral way of putting it.
00:38:34.172 --> 00:38:36.332
You know, there's some, some
pretty awful things going on
00:38:36.332 --> 00:38:37.472
in Hong Kong at the moment.
00:38:37.772 --> 00:38:40.142
And that may well drive
people to want to leave.
00:38:40.592 --> 00:38:47.372
Um, and the, the group of people that the
UK is saying can move narrow to the UK
00:38:47.722 --> 00:38:50.342
are called British nationals overseas.
00:38:51.452 --> 00:38:55.592
British nationality law is a real mess.
00:38:55.622 --> 00:38:56.132
Basically.
00:38:56.132 --> 00:39:00.322
It's kind of, it's a, it's an after
effect of, um, the withdrawal of
00:39:00.332 --> 00:39:02.192
the United Kingdom from its empire.
00:39:02.582 --> 00:39:06.572
And there are several different
types of nationality status, which
00:39:06.572 --> 00:39:08.372
have the word British in them.
00:39:08.702 --> 00:39:12.032
One of them is British citizen
and that allows you to live and
00:39:12.032 --> 00:39:13.892
work in the United Kingdom itself.
00:39:14.192 --> 00:39:14.902
But there are several.
00:39:15.727 --> 00:39:17.917
Um, one of which is
British national overseas.
00:39:18.277 --> 00:39:21.307
And it's really, basically
just a piece of paper.
00:39:21.397 --> 00:39:23.107
I already said it was
just a piece of paper.
00:39:23.107 --> 00:39:25.117
It didn't allow you to
live in the United Kingdom.
00:39:25.177 --> 00:39:29.587
It gave you a few minor advantages
over other categories of migraines,
00:39:29.617 --> 00:39:31.657
but it didn't give you a right
to live in the United Kingdom.
00:39:32.257 --> 00:39:35.167
And what the UK is saying is
that, that they're not changing.
00:39:36.002 --> 00:39:37.652
Basic requirements.
00:39:37.652 --> 00:39:40.262
So they're not giving what's called
the right of a boat, which would
00:39:40.262 --> 00:39:43.412
allow people freely to move to the
United Kingdom if they wanted to.
00:39:43.712 --> 00:39:47.702
But they are going to say that you
can get a visa and that's that the UK
00:39:47.702 --> 00:39:50.732
will charge you a lot for that visa,
but there will be a visa available and
00:39:50.732 --> 00:39:54.062
you can come to the UK if you want to,
you'll be allowed to work and you'll
00:39:54.062 --> 00:39:55.052
be allowed to settle after five.
00:39:56.795 --> 00:39:57.035
Isabelle Roughol: Right.
00:39:57.035 --> 00:40:04.355
That's something we don't talk about a
lot, but the fees are incredibly high.
00:40:04.565 --> 00:40:09.515
So not only do you have an income
requirement to get to the UK, but it
00:40:09.515 --> 00:40:15.545
can cost you a small fortune to get
to the point of legal settlement.
00:40:16.987 --> 00:40:17.227
Colin Yeo: Yeah.
00:40:17.287 --> 00:40:17.497
Yeah.
00:40:17.627 --> 00:40:19.177
It's, uh, it's very expensive.
00:40:19.177 --> 00:40:24.277
The, the home office is trying
to make the whole border system,
00:40:24.337 --> 00:40:30.457
essentially self financing, so that
migrants have to pay, um, enough money
00:40:30.457 --> 00:40:33.457
that it basically funds all of the
home office, immigration function.
00:40:34.382 --> 00:40:37.922
And it ends up operating as a kind of
double taxation because migrants who come
00:40:37.922 --> 00:40:42.632
to the UK often, you know, most of them
are working here and they pay their taxes,
00:40:42.752 --> 00:40:47.402
but they also pay these really substantial
fees, which are by as a standard.
00:40:47.402 --> 00:40:50.102
Usually it's at least a
thousand pounds for any kind of
00:40:50.102 --> 00:40:51.272
application you have to make.
00:40:51.662 --> 00:40:53.732
And depending on the route that you're on.
00:40:54.387 --> 00:40:57.867
You might have to make a number of
different applications and it can be a lot
00:40:57.867 --> 00:40:59.907
more expensive for some routes as well.
00:41:00.147 --> 00:41:05.067
And the one that really just gets me
is it particularly counter intuitive
00:41:05.367 --> 00:41:08.367
is one right at the end of the
process, which is the fee for service.
00:41:09.167 --> 00:41:12.167
Because it costs, I think over
1,300 pounds to apply for British
00:41:12.167 --> 00:41:15.887
citizenship, I said, well, some people
might think, oh, well, it's a, it's
00:41:15.887 --> 00:41:17.207
a privilege to be a
British citizen.
00:41:17.207 --> 00:41:18.737
And therefore you should
have to pay a lot for it.
00:41:18.947 --> 00:41:22.457
But don't we want people who
are long-term residents in the
00:41:22.457 --> 00:41:24.287
United Kingdom to become citizens.
00:41:24.347 --> 00:41:27.617
Wouldn't we encourage them to do that
and charging them a small fortune.
00:41:28.592 --> 00:41:32.492
Th to, to do that just seems like
a really insane policy to me,
00:41:32.822 --> 00:41:36.752
particularly where their children
and, and even children have to pay a
00:41:36.752 --> 00:41:38.462
substantial amount to be registered.
00:41:38.762 --> 00:41:42.272
And we come across families where
the parents simply can't afford it.
00:41:42.302 --> 00:41:45.032
So the children never become British
citizens, even though they are entitled
00:41:45.032 --> 00:41:49.292
to it or that the parents have to pick
one of their children to be British.
00:41:49.352 --> 00:41:52.952
And the others don't become British
because the parents just can't afford it.
00:41:52.952 --> 00:41:53.852
It's just ridiculous.
00:41:55.445 --> 00:41:56.735
Isabelle Roughol: Yeah, but do we want.
00:41:57.875 --> 00:42:01.835
People to become British if it's
a system that is as you're right.
00:42:02.285 --> 00:42:06.265
Um, set up to maintain
the, I forget how you are.
00:42:06.265 --> 00:42:12.875
You phrased it, maintain the, um, ethnic
composition or integrity of, of what the
00:42:12.875 --> 00:42:18.455
UK used to be in, in a certain, nostalgic
phishing of what the UK used to be.
00:42:19.277 --> 00:42:24.287
Colin Yeo: Well, I think if you have
closed citizenship laws where you've got
00:42:24.377 --> 00:42:28.957
high costs and it's difficult to become a
citizen, particularly for migrants that.
00:42:29.777 --> 00:42:34.787
The effect of that is that it's,
it tends to preserve the existing,
00:42:34.967 --> 00:42:37.367
ethnic composition of the population.
00:42:37.367 --> 00:42:38.837
I'm putting that as neutrally as I can.
00:42:38.867 --> 00:42:39.017
Yeah.
00:42:39.407 --> 00:42:40.877
It's racist basically.
00:42:40.877 --> 00:42:45.137
You know, it's about stopping migrants
who are generally speaking, not
00:42:45.137 --> 00:42:50.537
white from becoming citizens and
whether that's the overt intention
00:42:50.567 --> 00:42:52.757
or not, that certainly the effect.
00:42:53.147 --> 00:42:53.597
And so.
00:42:54.362 --> 00:42:59.792
I would say that making citizenship
easier to get, or at least not easier
00:42:59.792 --> 00:43:05.462
in sense of lower standards or something
like that, but just less reducing the
00:43:05.462 --> 00:43:09.242
barriers to citizenship, you know, not
having these ridiculously high costs,
00:43:09.602 --> 00:43:13.622
um, not making it so difficult for
migrant children to become citizens.
00:43:14.317 --> 00:43:17.407
Um, even restoring what, what
we call birthright citizenship.
00:43:17.407 --> 00:43:20.287
So in the U S if you're born
on the territory of the us,
00:43:20.437 --> 00:43:21.517
you're automatically a citizen.
00:43:21.517 --> 00:43:24.757
And that was a rule we used to have
in the United Kingdom until 1983.
00:43:24.967 --> 00:43:27.847
That, that kind of thing, it
hasn't affected diversifying
00:43:27.847 --> 00:43:31.027
the population, which, which is
surely, surely good and healthy.
00:43:32.690 --> 00:43:37.190
Isabelle Roughol: I wonder, you know,
what it is that makes us hold onto a
00:43:37.190 --> 00:43:43.700
system that sees more interested in, in
punishing, um, people who are, who are
00:43:43.700 --> 00:43:50.510
trying to, to make it in this country as
opposed to a system that actually works.
00:43:51.050 --> 00:43:54.830
And you mentioned in
the book, uh, China's.
00:43:55.655 --> 00:43:57.905
Migrants as citizens and waiting.
00:43:58.295 --> 00:44:01.895
And, um, now I wonder if you could talk a
little bit about that and you know, what
00:44:01.895 --> 00:44:07.805
it does to someone who will eventually be
a British citizen to have been abused by
00:44:07.805 --> 00:44:12.875
their own society and their own government
many years before they get there.
00:44:13.977 --> 00:44:14.187
Colin Yeo: Yeah.
00:44:14.217 --> 00:44:17.517
It's so that, that phrase systems
in waiting is one that that's,
00:44:17.547 --> 00:44:22.107
um, I borrowed from, um, from
the U S essentially where the.
00:44:22.857 --> 00:44:24.417
Status of American in waiting.
00:44:24.417 --> 00:44:26.907
It was actually, it was quite a
really interesting bit of sort of
00:44:26.907 --> 00:44:29.847
us citizenship, law, and history.
00:44:30.267 --> 00:44:32.787
And it's a, it's a different
way of seeing migrants.
00:44:32.787 --> 00:44:35.367
So at the moment we've got in the
United Kingdom, we've got all of these
00:44:35.367 --> 00:44:40.217
policies, really, which flow from,
I think the net migration targets of
00:44:40.257 --> 00:44:42.087
basically reducing the number of migrants.
00:44:42.357 --> 00:44:43.587
We've got all these policies.
00:44:44.387 --> 00:44:47.177
I've collectively called
deterrent policies.
00:44:47.177 --> 00:44:50.387
And the idea is that it stopped
people from coming and it encourages
00:44:50.387 --> 00:44:51.767
them to leave essentially.
00:44:52.097 --> 00:44:54.737
And that's the cost, the
complexity, or these income
00:44:54.737 --> 00:44:56.387
thresholds and, and, and so on.
00:44:56.927 --> 00:44:58.067
Um, and.
00:44:58.892 --> 00:45:00.212
W what it, what it does.
00:45:00.212 --> 00:45:02.072
I sort of talked about
it a little bit earlier.
00:45:02.132 --> 00:45:05.882
It, it doesn't actually deter
people from coming quite often.
00:45:06.242 --> 00:45:10.892
Um, at least it doesn't deter, um, any,
but the most internationally mobile, it
00:45:10.892 --> 00:45:15.002
can deter them, but it, but it doesn't
deter most migrants from coming, but
00:45:15.032 --> 00:45:18.632
it does make their lives very difficult
once they're in the United Kingdom
00:45:19.022
--> 00:45:20.612
and this things like double taxation.
00:45:21.127 --> 00:45:24.667
Well, th the effect of that
in real life is that a migrant
00:45:24.667 --> 00:45:29.047
family has a lot less disposable
income than a comparable family.
00:45:29.047 --> 00:45:30.037
That's already resident.
00:45:30.457 --> 00:45:33.787
They can't take holidays, they
can't afford, you know, new
00:45:33.787 --> 00:45:36.277
clothes and nice things in the
same way that other families.
00:45:37.097 --> 00:45:40.727
And they're in extreme cases, they,
they can't afford the fees that
00:45:40.727 --> 00:45:44.357
they're being charged and they end
up becoming unauthorized migrants.
00:45:44.537 --> 00:45:47.447
But even when they don't, even when
they can't afford the fees, it's
00:45:47.477 --> 00:45:49.367
financially punishing for them.
00:45:49.757 --> 00:45:51.767
And it, it hampers their life chances.
00:45:52.562 --> 00:45:57.812
And yet we also say that they should be
integrating into our society and they
00:45:57.812 --> 00:45:59.882
should be grateful to be here and so on.
00:46:00.212 --> 00:46:03.902
And you say, well, that doesn't
match with those deterrent policies.
00:46:03.932 --> 00:46:08.072
You know, how, how is it, how is it
encouraging people or facilitating.
00:46:08.747 --> 00:46:12.947
The integration, if you make
their lives here, so deliberately
00:46:13.097 --> 00:46:14.807
difficult in the first place.
00:46:15.257 --> 00:46:19.997
And if it did have the effect of deterring
people or forcing them out, then you could
00:46:19.997 --> 00:46:22.127
see that there's a certain logic to it.
00:46:22.127 --> 00:46:24.617
I don't like it, but at least I
can see there's a certain logic
00:46:24.617 --> 00:46:26.597
to it, but it doesn't do that.
00:46:26.597 --> 00:46:29.627
There's no evidence at all that it
actually does force people I hurt.
00:46:29.837 --> 00:46:31.457
So they end up living here anyway.
00:46:32.317 --> 00:46:35.197
Um, and, and what's the point of that?
00:46:35.507 --> 00:46:38.677
Just, it just doesn't make any
sense on a public policy level.
00:46:39.007 --> 00:46:43.897
So if, instead we were to see migrants
as future citizens, as citizens in
00:46:43.897 --> 00:46:46.597
waiting and, you know, a small number.
00:46:47.602 --> 00:46:51.052
Mike commit criminal offenses and might
end up being deported and removed.
00:46:51.382 --> 00:46:56.692
But most who come here for work or
for family, or for refuge, for asylum,
00:46:57.112 --> 00:47:02.272
they will be allowed to stay in the
longterm either as a sort of unlawful
00:47:02.302 --> 00:47:08.502
unauthorized, but strangely tolerated
group, or as, as lawful resident.
00:47:09.172 --> 00:47:13.252
Wouldn't it be better to be helping
them to become active parts of
00:47:13.252 --> 00:47:17.962
society and ultimately citizens
rather than, or hampering them in this
00:47:17.962 --> 00:47:24.202
way, which has know w w w we're all
talking a bit more openly about race.
00:47:24.532 --> 00:47:26.662
It has racist effects.
00:47:26.722 --> 00:47:31.522
You know, a lot of migrants are
from, um, from, from black and ethnic
00:47:31.522 --> 00:47:36.652
minority groups and to, to be hampering
their life chances and creating them.
00:47:37.697 --> 00:47:44.087
Um, almost sort of an underclass
or servant class of, of migrants
00:47:44.147 --> 00:47:48.527
in a, in a society is just really
unhealthy unhelpful thing to be.
00:47:49.895 --> 00:47:51.785
Isabelle Roughol: And you're
talking about a change policy that
00:47:51.785 --> 00:47:54.905
doesn't have to mean big numbers.
00:47:55.505 --> 00:47:58.985
It's just about how you treat
them the numbers that we do have
00:47:59.497 --> 00:47:59.677
Colin Yeo: Yeah.
00:47:59.677 --> 00:48:02.767
And I I'm, I like to think of
myself as being liberty-minded.
00:48:02.767 --> 00:48:05.257
I don't, I don't really mind how
many migrants come to the UK.
00:48:05.497 --> 00:48:06.967
I welcome immigration.
00:48:06.967 --> 00:48:08.317
I'm an immigration lawyer, I think.
00:48:08.527 --> 00:48:12.217
But, um, you know, it it's,
I'm not that bothered about the
00:48:12.217 --> 00:48:13.537
numbers when it comes down to it.
00:48:13.567 --> 00:48:13.987
If.
00:48:14.972 --> 00:48:18.332
Rules are introduced that stop people
from coming in the first place.
00:48:18.332 --> 00:48:22.562
If we stop skilled workers from coming
to the UK or whatever, that that's kind
00:48:22.562 --> 00:48:27.812
of economically self-harming, but I
haven't got a particular problem with it.
00:48:27.822 --> 00:48:29.462
I'd argue against it on a policy level.
00:48:29.612 --> 00:48:32.312
What I've got a real problem
with, which I just think is just
00:48:32.342 --> 00:48:34.712
unconscionable is treating people who do.
00:48:35.447 --> 00:48:41.087
It without respect and as this kind of
beasts of burden, almost with this really
00:48:41.087 --> 00:48:46.607
starkly, utilitarian fiscal approach to,
to their, their worth as human beings.
00:48:46.847 --> 00:48:51.587
And that's just, it's really wrong
and it's counterproductive and it does
00:48:51.587 --> 00:48:53.707
not lead to, uh, a healthy society.
00:48:56.270 --> 00:48:58.820
Isabelle Roughol: That's an important
point that, that we can end on.
00:48:58.970 --> 00:49:02.360
We could talk forever about
how broken the system is.
00:49:02.750 --> 00:49:07.520
I wonder if you have sort of a parting
thoughts on, on how we fix it and how
00:49:07.520 --> 00:49:13.280
we get people who, you know, British
citizens who do not have a personal
00:49:13.280 --> 00:49:17.300
or family experience of immigration,
um, to care about this and about what
00:49:17.300 --> 00:49:19.130
their government is doing in their name.
00:49:20.627 --> 00:49:22.997
Colin Yeo: I can't help on that
last thing, how to make people
00:49:22.997 --> 00:49:24.437
care is, is very difficult.
00:49:24.437 --> 00:49:25.667
And I think the.
00:49:26.437 --> 00:49:30.517
Evidence
suggests that the more
contact people have with migrants,
00:49:30.517 --> 00:49:31.867
the more sympathetic they are.
00:49:32.167 --> 00:49:34.987
And that that's something that
happens over time, essentially.
00:49:35.377 --> 00:49:39.997
Um, the, the areas that were our most
hostile to immigration tend to have
00:49:39.997 --> 00:49:42.067
the lowest levels of immigration.
00:49:42.377 --> 00:49:47.897
So ironically, um, um, One of the things
that we have seen over the last few years
00:49:47.897 --> 00:49:51.647
is that concern about immigration has
plummeted since the Brexit referendum.
00:49:51.947 --> 00:49:53.717
Um, we're not quite sure why that is.
00:49:53.717 --> 00:49:56.567
Maybe it's because it's in the papers
last, maybe it's because people
00:49:56.567 --> 00:50:00.587
think that immigration is magically
under control as a result of the,
00:50:00.587 --> 00:50:02.117
the vote or something like that.
00:50:02.117 --> 00:50:04.157
Even though immigration
policy hasn't changed yet.
00:50:04.347 --> 00:50:08.297
Don't know, but immigration concern
has really plummeted and people are
00:50:08.297 --> 00:50:09.617
much more worried about other things.
00:50:09.647 --> 00:50:14.117
And that was even before the pandemic,
um, in terms of making things better.
00:50:15.932 --> 00:50:21.092
Quite concrete short term wins,
like reducing the cost of the
00:50:21.092 --> 00:50:25.022
system and the cost of applications
I just think is, is wrong.
00:50:25.022 --> 00:50:28.682
And it has all sorts of, um,
brilliant, nasty effects.
00:50:29.072 --> 00:50:33.632
Um, also I think creating proper
routes to regularization is as campaign
00:50:33.632 --> 00:50:37.682
is called it so that people who are
here unlawfully come become lawful.
00:50:37.682 --> 00:50:42.752
So amnesty and also proper routes to
regularization, um, in the longer term.
00:50:43.442 --> 00:50:47.852
We, yeah, we don't want people to
start getting upset or feel that
00:50:47.972 --> 00:50:52.652
migration is, is sort of an unknown
thing or out of control in some way.
00:50:53.072 --> 00:50:57.992
And I, I sort of reluctantly advocating
favor of an ID card system in the book.
00:50:58.502 --> 00:51:02.082
So I just think that the way the
hostile environment works with.
00:51:02.847 --> 00:51:06.507
Immigration checks is just again,
I've used the word unconscionable.
00:51:06.507 --> 00:51:07.227
I'm going to use it again.
00:51:07.377 --> 00:51:08.277
It's just wrong.
00:51:08.417 --> 00:51:12.147
It's racist, encourages
discrimination, and it's just,
00:51:12.147 --> 00:51:14.367
it's an appalling system, I think.
00:51:14.427 --> 00:51:15.867
And identity card system where.
00:51:16.637 --> 00:51:20.897
People's identity is checked rather
than their immigration status.
00:51:21.257 --> 00:51:24.077
And where, for example, if you're
an employer, instead of being
00:51:24.077 --> 00:51:28.037
fined, if the person turns out to
be illegal, you get fined for not
00:51:28.037 --> 00:51:30.077
carrying out checks on anybody.
00:51:30.107 --> 00:51:31.787
So it's a proper universal system.
00:51:32.147 --> 00:51:34.607
I think that would be
significantly better.
00:51:35.147 --> 00:51:35.357
It.
00:51:36.602 --> 00:51:39.782
I'm not a, I don't close my eyes
to the fact that it might well
00:51:39.812 --> 00:51:41.212
result in some discrimination.
00:51:41.232 --> 00:51:45.092
You know, if, if, if, if you're forced
to carry ID cards, know other countries,
00:51:45.092 --> 00:51:48.422
show that please disproportionately
stop and check you if you're, if you're
00:51:48.422 --> 00:51:52.022
black and ethnic minority and so on,
but it would be a huge improvement on
00:51:52.022 --> 00:51:53.252
the hostile environment was just, is.
00:51:53.887 --> 00:51:57.337
It's just wrong and should never have
been introduced in the first place.
00:51:57.697 --> 00:52:01.927
Um, and then there are other Simon was a
long-term complex things like simplifying
00:52:01.957 --> 00:52:06.907
the rules, making them less arbitrary
and reforming citizenship laws as well, I
00:52:06.907 --> 00:52:12.027
think is important to make citizenship bit
more, um, accessible for, for those who.
00:52:12.782 --> 00:52:17.762
Oh here and actually having a proper
think even about our citizenship policy.
00:52:17.762 --> 00:52:20.342
Cause we don't really seem to have
a citizenship policy in the UK.
00:52:20.672 --> 00:52:24.972
Like is citizenship reward for
integrating or is it a step to,
00:52:24.972 --> 00:52:26.012
to, to encourage you to grow?
00:52:26.042 --> 00:52:26.842
I don't, I don't know.
00:52:27.062 --> 00:52:29.552
W we just haven't really sort
of talked about these things.
00:52:29.912 --> 00:52:34.142
Um, so yeah, it was kind of a range
of things that I'm trying to push
00:52:34.142 --> 00:52:35.102
in the book, some of which are.
00:52:35.767 --> 00:52:40.027
Quite easy to do in a way where
the public opinion agrees with
00:52:40.027 --> 00:52:41.317
them is, is, is a different actor.
00:52:41.317 --> 00:52:43.177
But legally there'd be very easy to do.
00:52:43.567 --> 00:52:47.227
Others of them would have to be a bit more
long-term because it involves a bit more
00:52:47.227 --> 00:52:53.037
thought, a bit more consultation and has
longer term, more profound consequences.
00:52:53.840 --> 00:52:54.140
Isabelle Roughol: Okay.
00:52:54.260 --> 00:52:56.120
Well, thank you so much, Colin.
00:52:56.120 --> 00:52:57.980
Thank you for carrying that message.
00:52:58.550 --> 00:52:59.750
I really recommend the book.
00:52:59.750 --> 00:53:04.040
I think, especially to people who
do not have a personal experience
00:53:04.040 --> 00:53:08.310
of immigration, I want to know it,
what it's like in this country.
00:53:08.740 --> 00:53:09.320
Um, thank you.
00:53:10.537 --> 00:53:11.227
Colin Yeo: Well, thanks for having me.