สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
00:00:15
Speaker 1: Pushkin from BBC Studios and Pushkin Industries. This is Big Lives Ami Manual Jochi, And on this show, what we do is we take a single culture icon and we break down their legacy with the help of the treasure trove that is the BBC Archive. And today, Kai, I have a trick for you, which is we have a guest with us, and our guest today is the one and only such a call. She's a writer at Slate. She is the host of the podcast Scamfluencers. She's the author of like two books, including her latest Sucker Punch and I Gotta stop this off by also saying she is my favorite person to argue with and is consistently mean to me on a daily She's the only person I let me mean to me on a daily basis.
00:01:11
Speaker 2: Hi hi Sachi?
00:01:13
Speaker 3: What is it about? He's weak? What do you mean like? He's like this? This person's my favorite to argue with. Anybody could do that, anybody could be mean to him. The breeze goes by the wrong way, his feelings are hurt. What am I supposed to do?
00:01:27
Speaker 2: Anyway?
00:01:28
Speaker 1: All of this is to say that she's one of my best friends.
00:01:34
Speaker 3: Oh man, come on doc Get Some New Friends. That sucks.
00:01:37
Speaker 2: It's the truth. I am who I am.
00:01:41
Speaker 1: Anyways, you are on this show embarrassing me in front of movies listeners because Sachi, you wrote to me recently about somebody you wanted to dive into with us.
00:01:52
Speaker 3: I did.
00:01:52
Speaker 4: I have a lot of affection for what I call publicly horny women.
00:01:58
Speaker 2: Publicly horny women.
00:01:59
Speaker 4: Okay, yes, as one myself obviously, and a horny woman I've been thinking a lot about in terms of past and present has been Madonna.
00:02:08
Speaker 3: You know, she was coming back pretty soon. She's got another.
00:02:11
Speaker 4: Album that's like a sequel to a record that came out I think like twenty twenty five years ago, twenty one years ago.
00:02:18
Speaker 3: Jesus Christ, I'm so old. I am taking to the sea as soon as this is over. But that record is so interesting.
00:02:25
Speaker 4: The resurgence of her is so interesting as like kind of this like sexy older lady, this powerful person, this like cultural behemoth. It was making me think a lot about Madonna. In the eighties and nineties, I grew up watching VH one documentaries and all of them were about like the sex panic around Madonna, and like that Toronto concert she had that where the police almost came and arrested her because she was too horny for stage, which badge of honor as a Canadian. Again, doesn't take much to be too horny in Toronto and public.
00:02:57
Speaker 3: But it's so interesting to think.
00:02:59
Speaker 4: About how the ajia around her and her sexual politics, what.
00:03:04
Speaker 3: It looked like in the eighties and nineties, what it.
00:03:07
Speaker 4: Looked like sort of before the proliferation of the Internet, and what it looks like now, and how it's changed between now in her sixties and you know, back then when she was in her thirties and forties.
00:03:17
Speaker 3: So I've been thinking about this so much.
00:03:19
Speaker 4: I feel like I see this undulation of how we treat women and how we treat their sexuality all the time that we're really mad at them about it, and then we're totally cool with it and we think it's great and oh my god, she's mother, and like it goes back and forth. I wish we could get ahead of it, but we as a society are too stupid, so we can't. But I do love playing a game of hindsight. So that's what I'm thinking about.
00:03:39
Speaker 1: Okay, amazing, well, Okay, Madonna, amazing thinger icon otherwise known as the Queen of Pop, the best selling female artist of all time. Kai you've been stuggling and laughing along. Is thought he's been talking about. Is what is your relationship to Madonna?
00:04:13
Speaker 5: Oh goodness, I can only think about her in eras of my own life, okay, you know, like, and she's had mini eras, and I've had many eras.
00:04:23
Speaker 6: There's the like I'm a little boy in the eighties when she's emerging and she is, yeah, uncomfortably sexual for the eighties when I'm like, you know, and then there's high school when the whole like a prayer period where she becomes obsessed with black people and you know, and like uh, and there was that era for me, and then the like you know, Confession is I mean the reason why I know when it came out, you know, I mean that run of album she had from the late nineties to the early aughts.
00:04:57
Speaker 7: I was like a gay man in my twenties.
00:05:01
Speaker 5: This was you know, this is the soundtrack of that era.
00:05:05
Speaker 2: You know.
00:05:08
Speaker 6: So it's ages of my life. I can't separate my daughter from stages of my life.
00:05:12
Speaker 2: I love it.
00:05:13
Speaker 1: Well, Okay, my relationship her was literally just like, oh, I really liked her music playing in my mom's car, and she was occasionally in the news as a kid, Like I don't I don't really have a bigger one beyond that, except like stuff that I've learnt as an adult. But I have to say, like when you wrote to me, Sachi and you told me about how being too horny for Toronto, I went back to that moment. I went back through a bunch of the archive, and the thing that stuck out to me is someone who didn't know that much about this particular period of Madonna's life. It's just like you said, Kay, this is a person who seems to just be like grasping at and also diving headfirst into as many different culture wars as possible in a very short space of time.
00:05:57
Speaker 4: Yeah, in two different like varying degrees of success. Frankly, like some of them are completely absurd.
00:06:04
Speaker 3: And still don't land right.
00:06:05
Speaker 4: And then other times you're like, well, you know why everybody was wearing kebba bracelets?
00:06:10
Speaker 3: It was that one lady. And I'll tell you.
00:06:14
Speaker 4: As a Hindu in junior high, seeing everybody
Load full transcript
show up to school with red thread on their wrist one day.
00:06:19
Speaker 3: I was like, what the hell has happened today. Happened Madonna has happened today.
00:06:27
Speaker 1: What the thing we're going to focus on today is her particular brand of sexuality and then sh she's making just like this perfect combination of things that her critics are just so perfectly equipped to respond to. And we're going to get into all of that after the break. Welcome back to Big Lives. Today we are talking about Madonna, and we're joined as well by our guests Sacha call hi guys. Okay, So before we get to talking about like the height of Madonna's controversy, I just want to talk about where she's arriving from at that moment, because I do think where she's come from is like particularly important, just in case for people who don't know like Madonna, she's known by that singular name, but her full birth name is Madonna Luise Chicone. She's from Michigan, from Bay City. She got raised in the Detroit suburbs. Her mom died of breast cancer when she was just five, and so she grows up basically parented by her dad, and her dad is quite a character. But I think the one thing that I think you need to know about Madonna, but I think is really interesting to me about where we're going is that she grew up pretty religious. I'm just going to play this clip of her talking about her childhood in a BBC interview that she did in nineteen eighty six.
00:07:53
Speaker 8: I went to Catholic schools for most of my life.
00:07:56
Speaker 9: My father was very a real disciplinarian, very strict, and you know, was get up every morning, go to church before you go to school, and wear a uniform. And when we got home from school, we changed her clothes. We did our chores, get our homework, we ate dinner, we weren't allowed to watch television, and it was a very kind of regimented life until we got older. You know, my father was very much into working. You know, he didn't like us to have idle time. If we didn't have school work to do, then he found work for us to do around the house. He thought that we should always be productive and make good use of our time. He was very adamant about that. So I'm sure that had a lot to do with it.
00:08:36
Speaker 1: I think I've talked about this in the show before, but maybe or not. I am also a.
00:08:40
Speaker 3: Catholic now we know, man.
00:08:46
Speaker 2: And I relate to a lolos.
00:08:48
Speaker 1: She said that because there was a culture in Cropholicism which is just adherence to the strict protocol. And I mean it's importantly guilt about not following that protocol all the time.
00:08:58
Speaker 5: It is the first thing I remember about her.
00:09:00
Speaker 6: I mean, you know, because and and it's so profound and so pointed, like I mean, I'm talking about I was in you know, I was an elementary school kid. I was elementary school, junior high. So it's not like I had some sophisticated understanding of the world. But you couldn't exist
in the eighties and not know that Madonna was like in an argument with Catholicism. You know that she was like the good Catholic girl who refused to be the good.
00:09:23
Speaker 7: Catholic girl like in public. That was her whole thing was it was actually.
00:09:27
Speaker 2: Uncomfortable, uncomfortable in what way.
00:09:31
Speaker 6: Just like because you knew it was wrong, right, Like there was a sense of like if as a kid, you're like, oh, wow, she's really violating the rules in public, you know, Like her song Like a Virgin, it just felt like it felt lude to your points.
00:09:46
Speaker 5: She like she felt like it felt she felt lude as a little.
00:09:49
Speaker 4: Boy maybe I'm telling on myself and my particular upbringing, but Madonna was my entry point into Catholicism.
00:09:56
Speaker 3: I didn't know what.
00:09:57
Speaker 4: It was until I started seeing her. I mean, my brother had her record. I grew up in a very Christian area, in a really white area, but we didn't have a lot of Catholics, and so I did not really fully understand the difference. You know, I was born in the early nineties, so she was already kind of on the scene by the time I was conscious. All I remember was like, what is this sick ass religion? They have the best esthetic, and like, you just get to be mad.
00:10:21
Speaker 3: All the time. Why don't I have that?
00:10:25
Speaker 4: But like, her art is inherently tied to that guilt and to that refusal to play by these puritanical rules, these sexual rules, these body rules, these female rules. But also she wore really great outfits and really figured out what to do with the jewelry. And I still I still remember going to my mom and being like, can I have one of those necklaces that's like a cross and her being like what, yeah, Like because she it was part of her things. She had like a bedazzled corset and bra cone bra and then have a giant crucifix necklace and I was like, that's a sick piece of jewelry.
00:11:08
Speaker 3: There's nothing wrong with me where that.
00:11:11
Speaker 6: And you gotta remember this is like she's emerging in those first albums in the eighties alongside MTV right and so music video, like I'm interacting with her and most of the world's interacting with her visually. It's not just the music, it is what she looks like. And uh, and she does not look appropriate for a young Catholic woman.
00:11:31
Speaker 1: One hundred and I want to talk about interview movie awards. So in nineteen eighty four, at this point, Madonna's already had like her first debut album. That debut album is basically considered like one of the greatest debutbums of all times, sort of eponymous, like it's just named Madonna has like a bunch of hits and it borderline Lucky Star Holiday. In eighty four, she's getting ready to launch like or be her second album, like Virgin, and she's trying to avoid basically like the typical artist sophomores like slump basically, and so what she does is go on TV four will be the first ever MTV Video Music Awards, and this performance actually does.
00:12:16
Speaker 2: It's incredible, and.
00:12:19
Speaker 1: I just want to take a moment to talk about this, Like, imagine you're at home watching TV and maybe you don't have to imagine, maybe you were watching it.
00:12:27
Speaker 2: Guy, I don't know.
00:12:28
Speaker 5: I'm remembering this girl.
00:12:30
Speaker 1: She emerges on stage like atop a giant wedding cake in like this wedding gown. She like descends onto the stage. And this whole performance is weird because you can tell, like the crowd does not know what to do with anything that it's watching. And she sings like a virgin. But what's interesting about she's basically making love to the ground.
00:12:56
Speaker 4: While singing this song British that's so British to the ground. Oh my god, trying man, She's.
00:13:06
Speaker 6: Gonna come for you that.
00:13:10
Speaker 4: What do you want me to say any other confidence of words?
00:13:14
Speaker 2: She is hunting the ground? Thank you, we're adults, okay whatever.
00:13:19
Speaker 4: Fox newsification of Donna's sexual acts on MTV.
00:13:24
Speaker 3: God you are Catholic.
00:13:27
Speaker 2: Yes, she is hunting the ground.
00:13:30
Speaker 1: And basically at the end of the song, she more or less climaxes and rolls over like she's just finished coming and like the audience does this weird thing where they're like the sort of clap but clap, and then they're like as the saying good job, you know, and then people are like, oh, okay, it's the end of the show and it moves on. And I just want to talk about this particular moment in the context within which this is happening. Right, this is nineteen eighty four, and this is kind of like peak Reagan's America, whose presidency in this country is really ushered in variots of religious right. Like to become president in nineteen eighty Reagan, like he tries to panda to boastalts of Christians.
00:14:12
Speaker 6: I think of Reagan as along for the ride on this moment, right, like the evangelical right is born in the wake of Jimmy Carter because they feel betrayed by Jimmy Carter. And alongside the evangelical rights birth is and this is what's relevant to Madonna is a very specific effort to start to reverse the advancements of feminist politics of the seventies.
00:14:38
Speaker 5: So it's Roe v.
00:14:39
Speaker 6: Wade and it's but it's the beginning of the culture war around certain kinds of people need to go back.
00:14:47
Speaker 7: Into private space and certain like.
00:14:51
Speaker 5: Gay men, enough with y'all with this.
00:14:53
Speaker 6: You know, we're not going to talk about AIDS, and these women need to like get back in their space.
00:14:59
Speaker 7: And along comes this young woman.
00:15:03
Speaker 6: Who is, as Sacchi has described, is walking around in you know, these outfits, is you know, fucking the stage at if your music awards. I won't be polight about.
00:15:17
Speaker 3: It, thank god, you
know, And who is.
00:15:20
Speaker 6: Like deliberately provoking people around religious iconography and her sexuality.
00:15:28
Speaker 7: They hated her, It really was.
00:15:31
Speaker 6: She was my first memory of culture wars is admit something, what you thought about Madonna. She was the embodiment of like where you stood on what kind of society we were supposed to have.
00:15:44
Speaker 1: It's such a rejection of like the politics of the sixties and seventies. But what's interesting to me is like listening back to the way in which these religious right figures are talking about it. Obviously they don't say all of that as explicitly as you do, right, They say things that now just sound kind of wild, like just petty you know where, but just like like, well, she's not dressed this way and she's not dancing this way like previous people who have dressed and danced this way, right, even though we're coming out of the seventies, They're saying, she's dancing this way, she's dressing this way, not for entertainment or not because it's artsy, but deliberately make us horny, and we don't want to be horned. It is the thing that they are like really honing in on in this major way.
00:16:31
Speaker 4: Yeah, fear of horniness, Uh, fear of joy.
00:16:35
Speaker 3: It's like, it's it.
00:16:36
Speaker 4: She transformed everybody into like the town in footloose, like no dancing, no dancing, the devil will come.
00:16:45
Speaker 1: And when I say like, it seems petty and small, the way that the discourse manifests itself, like down to the where she dresses. I just want to pay you a cip of her talking about some of that from an interview she did in the eighties.
00:16:56
Speaker 9: I mean, the way I dressed was the way all my girlfriends dressed in New York. I mean, but that's not the way everybody in the US of the United States dresses. I've always dressed with a sort of tongue in cheek kind of sense of more about it at all, and everybody took it so seriously, you know, I.
00:17:13
Speaker 10: Mean, you were held up at one point almost as being the scarlet woman, the thing for all females to be aware of, you.
00:17:18
Speaker 8: Know, yeah, or male wary of.
00:17:21
Speaker 10: Was that a good thing or a bad thing? Do you think?
00:17:24
Speaker 8: To what what?
00:17:24
Speaker 11: Well?
00:17:25
Speaker 9: It ended up getting lots of attention, so I suppose it's not.
00:17:27
Speaker 8: It's not a bad thing.
00:17:29
Speaker 5: That clip makes me remember.
00:17:31
Speaker 6: Part of it was also that she was taught she was considered fake right from the beginning, which is the thing that we've always we continue to talk about with a bandada and some of it's true, but part of the initial sort of reaction to her was like, this isn't who you really are.
00:17:45
Speaker 7: You're doing this as a provocation.
00:17:48
Speaker 5: You know.
00:17:49
Speaker 6: It's that part where she refers to her gut girlfriends in New York, you know, and she's a Catholic
girl from Michigan, right like, you know, which is not to say she wasn't in New York, but you know, like people were like.
00:18:00
Speaker 5: That's not who you really are.
00:18:01
Speaker 6: You're putting on airs just to proo, you're provoking us, just for provocation sake. Was one of your first critiques of her, because people just couldn't wrap their minds around some a woman who was I'm not apologetically sexual in.
00:18:14
Speaker 4: Public, but that's also part of it. What's wrong with provocating people for the sake of it?
00:18:20
Speaker 2: That's right.
00:18:21
Speaker 4: That's the thing I always go back to, which is like, well, what is the provocation.
00:18:25
Speaker 3: Being again being horny? That is not a It's not actually a provocation.
00:18:31
Speaker 4: I can understand being offended by somebody who's and this is happening a lot these days, provoking people through the auspices of race or gender, just trying to rage bait get in a fight. She's like wearing a little skirt and singing like, dad, don't be mad at me, Like, and that's what everybody's so mad about. It feels so mundane in a contemporary context. And then again it asks the question like, if you are offended by her provoking people for the sake of it, why what are you so worried about? It seems like a lot of people felt like she was going to unlock a door for girls and we were all gonna run in and you know, start to be slaw and unlock another door for men and create these like broken homes across Well.
00:19:16
Speaker 6: It's multiple doors that she's going to unlock actually because there's that, but you have also.
00:19:21
Speaker 12: White girls and white men, and it's like the whole of the evangelical project at that time, and the real threat of both feminist and race politics at that time was that it up ended the white suburbs, right, Like, the whole point of the white suburbs from the mid century forward.
00:19:45
Speaker 6: Was to create an opportunity for young white people to be innocent. And you know, white women have always been the embodiment of innocence in that conception of whiteness. So it's also then not coincidental how race becomes part of her refusal to be the innocent white girl in the suburbs of Michigan, and that is, I argue, the real thing that people are reacting to with her is like, you're supposed to be an innocent white girl and you refuse to do it, and that challenges.
00:20:17
Speaker 2: All of us.
00:20:17
Speaker 4: Yeah, yeah, I think even I was thinking too. You guys are talking about, like, you know, the Jerry Fowwells of the world, kind of using her as an icon to be afraid of. When you do that to somebody, it still elevates them, It makes them famous, It gives them a new echelon of awareness and the culture.
00:20:37
Speaker 3: You're never going to do that with a black girl.
00:20:39
Speaker 4: You're not going to do that to her because you don't actually want her to be in that position because it does create celebrity. They
would only do it with someone like Madonna because she's white. And that's why later we have her ripping off every subculture because she can do it right right. They're not actually going to go after like gay black men in the eighties as she's voguing or whatever, because that elevates a group of people that they are genuinely afraid of. But they can be a little afraid of Madonna in a way that's like, ah, but I could still like knock her over and I'm not like afraid of her in that way, And if she does explode, there's always still a chance we could get her back because she's still a white girl from Michigan.
00:21:17
Speaker 1: Definitely, And you can hear it in a lot of the interviews from this time, honestly, which is like one day, infinitize her like a ton, like it's wild, but they're also trying to put her back into this box that you can sort of like that adhere to their archetyps of who she should be and what they think like a good white girl should be.
00:21:38
Speaker 2: You know.
00:21:39
Speaker 1: So like a common thread is like these male interviewers taking this position of like like gross paternal concern, like oh, you're in the middle of a storm, and like what the way they frame that storm is by asking, well, like what even men in your life think about this? I want to play an example of this. This is from a nine and eighty six interview that she does with radio hosts Simon Bates.
00:22:02
Speaker 10: The people like your ballet teacher, your father, who saw you change, you had this the wonderful image because I remember the whole of Britain being stunned that America was horrified by the idea of your neighbor being on display at one stage, and.
00:22:17
Speaker 2: How did they feel about that? But were they my father, Well, I was thinking all the people you.
00:22:21
Speaker 10: Cared about, your ballet teacher, your friends, Well.
00:22:23
Speaker 9: My ballet teacher, I can honestly say I would be pleased with anything I did.
00:22:30
Speaker 8: I mean, he's a real adventurous spirit.
00:22:32
Speaker 9: You know. I can't say that my father had the same reaction. My father is a very modest guy.
00:22:37
Speaker 10: You know, When did they first see you dressed up.
00:22:40
Speaker 9: Like that, probably my record, like the publicity photos that came out from with my first album. You know, I never dressed that way around the house. But I left home when I was seventeen, you know, and I didn't go back that often.
00:22:55
Speaker 1: I just want to preface this by saying that what they're talking about is literally just showing how bet.
00:23:04
Speaker 4: But what an absurd question too, Like I don't care what your dad thinks about this.
00:23:09
Speaker 3: I don't care about your dad at all.
00:23:11
Speaker 4: This reminds me so much of I remember I watched this documentary about Jenna Jamison, who's a very famous peorgn actress in the US, and she they kept.
00:23:19
Speaker 3: Asking her what her dad thought, And I'm like, what do
you think.
00:23:22
Speaker 2: He's watching it?
00:23:24
Speaker 3: What? What kind of a question is that?
00:23:26
Speaker 4: Like, I'm not I'm sure he's not thrilled in the same way that like, I.
00:23:30
Speaker 3: Don't know my dad wasn't thrilled when I became a writer. He's like, surely there are other jobs.
00:23:35
Speaker 4: But it's just such a it's such a it's so patronizing, this like what does daddy think?
00:23:41
Speaker 3: She's an adult?
00:23:42
Speaker 4: At a certain point, we have to stop asking women like what does your father think about your life? Come on, I mean there's still people still ask questions like that of Madonna now about her children.
00:23:53
Speaker 3: They never went away.
00:23:54
Speaker 4: First they asked it about her dad. Then it was about all whatever guy she was going out with. God, thank god she's not with that guy rich anymore. I don't want to deal with that anymore. But like then, then it became about her kids. And now with this new album Rolette, you can tell it's like, I wonder what her sons think about her.
00:24:10
Speaker 6: She's sixty seven years old and on stage and tight.
00:24:14
Speaker 4: Disgusting, right, And the idea that there's always a man who is her keeper, which there probably is, but it's a record executive whose name I don't even know, right, And it's not like her twenty year old son who's probably like, there goes mom, right.
00:24:31
Speaker 1: And I think that's particularly important because around the time I was interview, this interview I just played for you that clip happens in eighty six. In nineteen eighty five, Penthouse and Playboy published nude photos of Madonna that she took like years earlier, kind of before her like thin career took off.
00:24:49
Speaker 2: When she was not model.
00:24:51
Speaker 1: They rushed to publish these photos, and you can tell the whole situation is primed basically for her to be publicly shamed and like humiliated, like look at this femfatale, who's this big temptress and all this stuff, but like, actually, we're gonna shame her, and we're also gonna like lost after her, and she handles it really mastered. It's just kind of like, literally, I'm not a shamed well.
00:25:16
Speaker 6: I will say, I mean her refusal to take on shame.
00:25:20
Speaker 7: And we've talked about this with other artists from.
00:25:22
Speaker 5: The eighties previously on the show.
00:25:26
Speaker 6: Just this sort of shame or lack of shame around sexuality, and she is the poster person for the eighties at the which I again I think is the onset of the culture Wars is you know, she is one of the first battlegrounds.
00:25:43
Speaker 5: And part of why.
00:25:46
Speaker 6: Certainly in queer communities, but in many different communities she is mother, you know, and is so owned, is that she was one of the first people in the culture Wars to be like you won't shame me.
00:25:58
Speaker 5: You can ask me about Daddy all you want. Like, in fact, if you.
00:26:02
Speaker 6: Want to think I got you thought that was bad, I got something for you.
00:26:05
Speaker 5: You know, she will escalate every single time. Uh, and that is part of her appeal.
00:26:12
Speaker 4: I think that that way of handling shame is also really it's it's probably inspired a lot of other pop stars who came after her. I've been thinking a lot about Lady Gaga, who I don't know if you remember, there were all these interviews with her when she first came out that was like do you have a penis? Everybody thinks you have a penis? And you don't remember this? Oh I, oh yeah, so you yeah, and good for you. Unfortunately it lives forever in my brain. But there were all these there were there were rumors that she was like intersex effectively, and it was and this had actually come up around Madonna too.
00:26:47
Speaker 3: There had been a lot of talk about like what.
00:26:48
Speaker 4: Madonna's body looked like under the whatever limited clothing she was wearing. And when this came of Lady Gaga, her response would always be like, well what if I do?
00:26:56
Speaker 3: And like is that so bad? What would it mean if I did?
00:26:59
Speaker 4: And that is such an interesting response instead of being like what a foolish and crazy thing to say about me? Instead of getting defensive she was like, well, what would what would.
00:27:08
Speaker 3: Be the problem?
00:27:09
Speaker 4: Lady Gaga did an interview I think in the last couple of years saying she answered it like that on purpose because she's like, what if somebody was watching that interview and did and was in her sect or did who was trans and and felt like, well, I don't want the pop star that I love.
00:27:23
Speaker 3: And again, these are two icons of queer community.
00:27:26
Speaker 4: The pops are that I love. To respond that way, I feel like you can almost see it in like in Madonna's response, which is like, why should I be so ashamed of having this body? The people that I'm speaking to like it. A lot of them have this kind of body. A lot of them are engaging insects the way I engage in it. So why would I now balk because you think that this photo of me is lascivious?
00:27:49
Speaker 1: Yeah, I'm going to do a sac religious thing here and skip ahead, like a little bit of time paused a huge album that is true Blue.
00:27:58
Speaker 5: We only have so much time.
00:27:59
Speaker 6: If we're going to go through all of Madonna's eras and albums, we are going to be here all day.
00:28:04
Speaker 1: And honestly, I'm just here because I want to talk about like a praise and Sachi, what is your relationship to like a prayer?
00:28:13
Speaker 2: As a song, as a music video.
00:28:15
Speaker 3: It's a good song.
00:28:16
Speaker 4: I liked it, and we were allowed to play it in our house. I don't think my parents really had any relationship with any of it. My brother was a big Madonna fan. Weirdly enough, it was like the one I don't know, It's like the only pop music he ever
listened to.
00:28:30
Speaker 3: We had that.
00:28:30
Speaker 4: I remember seeing that blue album all through our house. It was in the car, like, but we listened to it and I was like cool.
00:28:38
Speaker 3: And then later I'd be like, Wow, everyone's really mad about this song. That means nothing to me.
00:28:45
Speaker 4: I don't get it. She's like talking about like horny at church. What's the problem? And I still, I still, honestly am a little perplexed.
00:28:53
Speaker 5: Ome on No, I mean I'm not.
00:28:55
Speaker 2: I mean it is.
00:28:58
Speaker 5: Quite a propagation, right it it?
00:29:00
Speaker 3: I think it is if you're steeped in it, right.
00:29:03
Speaker 4: But without the context, it doesn't mean as much. And so for me it was completely stripped of context. I only have that context in my adulthood. Frankly, or now I'm like, oh yeah, I guess I see that, but it's a it's a bang, it is a bank.
00:29:18
Speaker 1: I go. I go to agree with you, Sacchi in the sense of I think I was seven or eight when I first heard this song. Yeah, I just thought it was probably because there's like a gospel quiet in it.
00:29:30
Speaker 2: I just thought it was a real kind of religious song.
00:29:33
Speaker 3: Yeah, me too. I think I probably did.
00:29:35
Speaker 6: But see, here's the thing, guys, again, you gotta remember this is the This is the height of the music video and the song. Like the way this entered the world was through the video as much as the song and the video.
00:29:48
Speaker 5: If again, if you're from Mars and somehow you've not seen.
00:29:50
Speaker 6: The video, you know it is just it's almost like a grab bag of provocations, you know. I mean it opens with like some crime scene that is a little weird, and then a madonna is suddenly in a black church.
00:30:06
Speaker 2: Okay, we're gonna we gotta back his bath.
00:30:09
Speaker 5: No, that's literally how it happens.
00:30:11
Speaker 2: Yes, you're right, opens of a crime scene.
00:30:13
Speaker 6: She runs into a black church. You're not clear why is this woman running into a black church? And I think that is relevant, Like you're confused, and she immediately encounters a black Jesus, who is like behind bars.
00:30:27
Speaker 1: I used to call them like plastic saints when I was a kid, kind of figurettes that are like behind sort of bars and all behind glass in churches.
00:30:37
Speaker 5: And what becomes clear over the course of the video is they.
00:30:40
Speaker 6: Start switching back and forth between that image and the image of a very attractive black.
00:30:45
Speaker 2: Man played by Leon That's right.
00:30:49
Speaker 6: Sorry, it's really important who is in jail, you know, for some crime, and it's going back and forth. You're the black Jesus is supposed to represent the black man in jail. At one point, she kisses the Black Jesus' feet in this like long which of course is religious, but it's also you're like, is this what am I watching? Am I watching like foot fetish or am I watching religion right now?
00:31:15
Speaker 10: Like?
00:31:16
Speaker 5: And it feels deliberately blurred.
00:31:18
Speaker 6: And then you do find out like that he's been wrongly convicted of like attacking a white woman another provocation, you know, and it ends with her dancing in front.
00:31:27
Speaker 5: Of burning crosses.
00:31:28
Speaker 6: Yeah, Like it is just so many images and y'all, this is the late nineteen eighties, Like it is not like I am here to tell you like this was so big to enter the culture at that moment, and I was fifteen.
00:31:45
Speaker 5: I remember the like literally being.
00:31:48
Speaker 6: On the edge of my chair watching that when it debuted, like literally being on the edge of my seat, like what is.
00:31:53
Speaker 5: Happening right now? It is? It was a lot.
00:31:57
Speaker 1: I rewatched it again ahead of this, like if he's in a culture wolves, she's driving to Vaja the enemy's cats, that's rid it. Also, we should just take a second and just talk about like Catholics, we're weird when it comes to sex, but we're also obsessed with it, even like our devotion to Mary, like the stories that we focus in on. So for example, Madonna grew up Catholic. Her confirmation saint is Saint Veronica. Veronica is famous and sort of like Havlic stories for being the woman who, when Jesus is making his way to be crucified and he's carrying across and is being whipped, wipes his face with a towel and the story is told in this sort of like this person who performs this active kindness. But there is, in this weird way, like something desiring about all of these stories about women who interact with Jesus in this way from her to Mary Magdalen and onwards that I feel like it's really captured that Madonna plays with in that video.
00:32:56
Speaker 5: Interesting. I don't know any of this.
00:32:58
Speaker 1: The kissing of his feet, this idea that if you become a nun, for example, you are pledging yourself to Jesus, and it's effective enough messaging that the Vatican Pope jump full of the second officially condemns this video.
00:33:15
Speaker 3: They have nothing better to do. This is proof that we got to give the popes more work.
00:33:20
Speaker 4: You if if that's what you're up to, oh my god, we need like get a hobby, start sweeping the steps or something.
00:33:27
Speaker 3: When are you talking about so embarrassing?
00:33:30
Speaker 2: Investigate real crimes happening in your church.
00:33:33
Speaker 5: Yes, if y'all want to talk about sex.
00:33:35
Speaker 4: Like around this time, I think Shenead o' connor is gonna rip up a photo of the Pope on es and l so like they have some work to do. I don't think Madonna wiggling around in a church is like top priority, but it is really a testament to like, I think like that the Catholic Church did not have a good priority set on what they needed to focus on.
00:33:56
Speaker 3: This was the culture ward that they decided they wanted to get into exactly.
00:33:59
Speaker 4: And now I think in hindsight, it feels absurd.
00:34:04
Speaker 3: It feels absurd.
00:34:05
Speaker 4: She has survived it in so many ways, and the action that she's performing it feels so mundane, like that's it. That's it, Black Jesus, that's like our that's the that's it.
00:34:17
Speaker 2: God.
00:34:17
Speaker 3: I could do worse.
00:34:18
Speaker 5: Than that, I guess because I lived through it.
00:34:20
Speaker 6: Like I hear you as a fact, like it's factually the case, this is ridiculously mundane, But I just have the emotional memory of it being really.
00:34:30
Speaker 2: Really big.
00:34:31
Speaker 1: We've got to talk about the Blonde Ambition Tour that comes basically immediately after this, because all of this moment of her independence, of her pushing back in this way sets the stage for what will be her most provocative tour yet, which is the Blonde Ambition Tour in nineteen ninety. And this is kind of where we get to what we were talking about at the very beginning of this sagi uh and this tour, it's describe it. It is a global phenomenon that she also documents in real time, like she brings a film crew along for this tour for what will eventually become like this seismic documentary about her called Madonna Truthful Dare but the name Yes, which is just this real expose of like a whole life. At this time, she's just like I'm just gonna put it all out there in this big way, and the tour is like a big backdrop to what's happening.
00:35:27
Speaker 2: Uh.
00:35:28
Speaker 1: And a key part of this tour is this performance of like a virgin that she does. And how do I describe the way she performs like a virsion on this tour. It's like the vibes are really Middle Eastern, but not Middle Eastern in a kind of way, like you feel like someone's gonna jump out and say Oriental or Arabian Nights or something like that's kind of a vibe. And she's on a bed. She's wearing like this gold corset that's like heavily structured with like conical sort of breast cups, and she's singing like a version in this sort of remixed way, and they're like these two male dancers sort of moving around her, caressing her. She's arriving on this bed singing, and at the climax of this song right at the end, of it. She simulates like she's basically masturbating like on stage, and law enforcement officials in Toronto get word that this is what she's doing as.
00:36:29
Speaker 2: Part of her show.
00:36:32
Speaker 1: And so there's a famous scene in this documentary where she gets word basically from the staffer that like, oh, the police in Toronto, they might arrest you if you if you do this, and she immediately is just like, I'm not changing my fucking show.
00:36:50
Speaker 4: Ah.
00:36:50
Speaker 1: And so she does this thing I love, which is just before she goes out on stage. And this was a feature of that tour, you know, an feature of a lot of tools, since it's you know, before the performance, everyone in the band or whatever gathers around in the circle and you know, they center themselves before going out on stage. On this tour, Madonna always sets this up as a group prayer basically and in an typical Madonna patch, and she opens with this line which is like, dear Lord, this is our last night in a fascist state of Toronto. And she concludes basically by praising the United States for protecting free speech. Rich is whatever, but she performs anyways. The whole thing is captured in this and I just want to pay you this clip of her talking about that in like this ninety four interview she does with Terry Wogan.
00:37:35
Speaker 13: I don't think there's anything in a movie that the use of America or Europe for that matter.
00:37:41
Speaker 9: Are not aware of or exposed to already when in parts of the film the Toronto police want to ban you and all the rest.
00:37:49
Speaker 6: And the thing that's surprising about that is it seems to me anyway that you're quite surprised that they should want to banu.
00:37:56
Speaker 5: You.
00:37:56
Speaker 13: Well, I certainly know that that some people are outraged by my behavior, but I was quite surprised to find out that I may possibly be arrested for my behavior.
00:38:06
Speaker 8: You know, after all, it is a performance.
00:38:07
Speaker 13: It's a theatrical performance, and it's not like I'm going out on the street, you know, running around without my clothes on, you know what I mean.
00:38:15
Speaker 11: I was shocked to.
00:38:16
Speaker 13: Know that that in the in the context of a performance, that someone would find it so offensive.
00:38:25
Speaker 1: And I would say I was similarly to Terry Wogan. I was sort of like, what's given what she's in the middle of all that, what she's been going through, But.
00:38:36
Speaker 6: I mean that they're going to arrest her, you know, I mean, it just feels so like we're in the fifties, you know, and this is nineteen ninety is shocking.
00:38:47
Speaker 5: That is shocking, Like that is shocking to remember, Like.
00:38:50
Speaker 1: Yeah, and I should said they don't actually arrest her like that, that's not what happens, but they threaten is why.
00:38:57
Speaker 5: The police have come up at all, you know.
00:38:59
Speaker 4: But as a Canadian, it feels like, oh, of course, like we would be the ones to be like Madonna, don't, don't do that. But it's also funny because this is like this is pretty smartphone, so when you're doing something on stage, it's not like it it gets proliferated immediately in the culture.
00:39:17
Speaker 3: It takes a second.
00:39:18
Speaker 4: So I think it's also shocking because it's like, well that means that she does it at the show and then a bunch of people talk about it in town and it gets back to the cops.
00:39:26
Speaker 3: Like it's like a very different mechanism.
00:39:29
Speaker 4: But I remember I watched that documentary That's how I know about this, and I was like.
00:39:35
Speaker 3: Totally tickled by it.
00:39:36
Speaker 4: It's it's fun
like it's the streisand effect again and again with her, where like if they had just left it alone, it wouldn't We probably wouldn't know that much about what she did on that tour.
00:39:48
Speaker 3: If you know, these like.
00:39:52
Speaker 4: Evangelicals did not run at her all the time, probably wouldn't think too much about a lot of her of her work. But because they're obsessed with her and remain obsessed with her, they have bolstered everything she's done.
00:40:05
Speaker 6: It's funny when you say it that last like you to think about, Like, I wonder if we would have been robbed of a lot of great Madata art had they left her alone, back to the night we went for if they had just let you know that album be an album?
00:40:19
Speaker 4: Yeah, I mean, resistance is the best form of advertising. It's the best motivator to make anything. I mean, the only reason I make anything is because I'm mad. So like that's that they gave her a gift and.
00:40:33
Speaker 2: Is at this juncture.
00:40:34
Speaker 1: But I want to talk about a gap that Mandonia gives us, which is a sex book which was released in nineteen ninety two.
00:40:43
Speaker 4: The book the book, Yes, yeah, I again, having been raised by a television I don't know where my parents were watch nothing but watch nothing but VH one documentaries, and so the sex book was like this big thing. She'd released this coffee table book of like no, it's.
00:41:03
Speaker 3: I suppose portographic photos of herself.
00:41:06
Speaker 4: Again, in a contemporary context, it is I have seen worse things on NBC after nine point thirty, So I don't know what everybody was so upset about.
00:41:17
Speaker 5: But at the time again but.
00:41:19
Speaker 3: At the time, yes, at the time, it was huge.
00:41:22
Speaker 6: It's also like just the physicality of the book. I mean, she was by this point so clear about the relationship with the media that you're describing Sashi that like she could do things to get a reaction from them that would make the things she was doing larger, and like that became almost part of performance art, like she was almost doing by this point.
00:41:45
Speaker 5: To me, it.
00:41:46
Speaker 6: Seemed like she was engaged in performance art in the dance with conservatives. Reaction to her itself was part of what she was doing, and that was kind of the context of the book because again, like the like a prayer video, it just did the most.
00:42:02
Speaker 5: I mean, it was a metal.
00:42:03
Speaker 6: Book, like you know, like the book itself was almost kink you know, like never mind the content, you know, like just the item itself was like and so to buy the book, and it was expensive as I recall, like and sort to buy the book I have the book was like.
00:42:18
Speaker 7: A statement about where you sat in the culture war. So it's struck a genius in that way.
00:42:23
Speaker 6: I don't even know, come to think of it, if I've ever even looked at the inside of the book.
00:42:29
Speaker 4:
I just remember the photo of her like hitchhiking in that book and everyone being like, would you believe I'm like, that's it, boobies, what are we doing?
00:42:38
Speaker 5: Also, haven't we already done with Donnas?
00:42:41
Speaker 3: Haven't we done? We done boobs as a community already?
00:42:45
Speaker 4: And hers in particular, like, do you know what it actually?
00:42:49
Speaker 3: Do you guys remember this one?
00:42:52
Speaker 2: No?
00:42:52
Speaker 4: Actually, okay, this is Kim Kardashian's book that came out I think like ten years ago now called Selfish, and it's just photos of herself. It's just selfie, And like, listen, I think this was this, This is genius. It's a weird totem of a particular time, but it kind of to me had like a really similar response, which was sexual panic about this woman releasing photos of herself, A lot of agitation about how navel gazing it is. Madonna taught me that word. I know what naval gazing is because people used it so much about her that I was like, what does that even mean? But the idea that it was a problem for a woman to have the body and then photograph the body, put the body in a commodified package, and then have it available for sale for her profit, all of that was unacceptable. And I feel like this reminded me of this. Kim Kardashian book reminded me of that, which is like, but.
00:43:50
Speaker 3: Isn't that what you came for?
00:43:52
Speaker 4: Like you're mad about it now, but isn't that what we've been doing this whole time?
00:43:55
Speaker 3: Like all right, girl, go sell it.
00:43:57
Speaker 4: I hope you sell a billion copies if we're dumb enough to buy a coffee table book of photos.
00:44:01
Speaker 6: The critiques of Madonna through this period are specific in a really important way, right, Like, first, she's fake, she's not a real woman. She's not doing, you know, her refusal to be the innocent white girl in the suburbs, Like that's not real. You're a disappointment to your family and two particularly men. And then, as you point out, we arrive at oh, you're just selfish, Like you're selfish because you refuse to play your role in whiteness. You know, you refuse to be this particular kind of white woman that you're supposed to be, and so you're just obsessed with yourself and that's the problem with you. And I just think that journey of critique of her tell tells.
00:44:43
Speaker 7: You what we're actually arguing about with Madada.
00:44:45
Speaker 1: The other thing I just want to point out is, like the other thing that's happening in terms of his cultural wars is that she's being literally framed in like this Madonna Hale kind of complex because at the same time that like, you know, all of this conversation around like how sexual she is, people in interviews keep asking her about like her motherhood and her desire to be a mother. She does an interview with that journalist who we've paid a little bit from, Simon Bates, and you know, he's it comes up even in just like sort of
kind of throwaway questions, is what people sort of become sessed with, Like he's just asking her hear about like her relationship to her backup dancers, many of whom are like gay and queer men. And the whole point, as we know, is she's mother, right, Like she's taken a lot of like these queer men under her ringing on.
00:45:36
Speaker 7: Tour queermit of color importantly.
00:45:39
Speaker 2: Right, And he sort of asked her about it.
00:45:42
Speaker 10: You're talking about mothering the dances. I may be reading too much under this. I got the impression you are very supportive. Yes, okay, Yes, is that true?
00:45:50
Speaker 8: Yes?
00:45:51
Speaker 11: Yeah?
00:45:52
Speaker 10: And that actually was a very enveloping thing. I mean it looked and it's a value judgment, which is risky because I've only seen the movie once, ldn't see the movie being made. I got the impression that you very much, very much did protect them.
00:46:03
Speaker 8: Yes, I did.
00:46:04
Speaker 9: I'm supportive of I probably identify and feel protective about in general because a I find them to be in general, more sensitive than straight people are, especially gay men. I think they're much more open to ideas, they are much more willing to be sensitive to explore the feminine side of themselves. But I also feel their persecution in society, and so I sympathize with that and I feel protective of them.
00:46:33
Speaker 2: But then he says his next thing, I just want to play for you.
00:46:36
Speaker 10: I'm going to ask you probably a dumb question, but bear with me, because I'm a man and I think men are rather insensitive and things like that. Am I reading too much into it in thinking that in mothering them you might even be a little Broodi at times yourself? For children want children?
00:46:51
Speaker 11: Absolutely?
00:46:52
Speaker 10: Yeah, Oh he's not a dumb question. And I thought it might be an offensive one.
00:46:55
Speaker 11: No.
00:46:55
Speaker 9: I mean the thing is I've mothered people throughout my life and in my career. Obviously I have an instinct for mothering. What I've done right now has turned it on the people that I work with. But I would like to have my own child that doesn't, you know, disappear when the tour is over.
00:47:14
Speaker 3: Why does she have a Transatlantic accent?
00:47:18
Speaker 1: Okay, so you're going to back up. You're gonna address a lot of things.
00:47:22
Speaker 3: She sounds like Catherine Hepburn. What's wrong? What's going?
00:47:25
Speaker 1: She does do this thing for a period of time, and my I have to say, as a kid, I thought she was maybe British.
00:47:33
Speaker 3: I did for a long time. I was like, there's she lived in on the moon.
00:47:37
Speaker 6: She took on a lot, she has taken on and will continue to take on a lot of personalities and a lot of voices, and a lot of things in like the performance are of the concept of Madata can, he asked her, is this if every word you have said, sir is offensive?
00:47:54
Speaker 5: Everything about what you're doing here is offensive?
00:47:57
Speaker 4: Yes, I mean, but honestly that's better than like what he could have said, which is you're a disgusting whore who will ever have children with you?
00:48:04
Speaker 2: Which is the.
00:48:05
Speaker 4: Subtext of this question all the time. That's really what he's asking, which is you are so an Orthodox and I cannot envision you as a mother.
00:48:16
Speaker 3: Do you envision yourself as a mother?
00:48:18
Speaker 2: Life?
00:48:19
Speaker 4: And I'll also say to the sex panic around moms is so funny to me, how do you think you got here? Like everybody's acting as if like they're shocked any time a sexual woman, especially a vocal woman about sex, ends up having kids. It's so puritanical, it's so childish.
00:48:40
Speaker 3: But it is this push pull.
00:48:41
Speaker 4: That I think a lot of white people are engaged in, certainly Catholics are, which is, you have to do this, but not in this way. So you need to be a sexual object as a white woman certainly, and as a straight white woman to your husband, like you're supposed to do whatever he wants. The problem is she's doing what she wants, and she's doing it in public.
00:49:04
Speaker 2: Yeah, exactly, She's doing it in public with.
00:49:06
Speaker 3: A British accent.
00:49:07
Speaker 4: Also again offends me more than anything else that's happening here.
00:49:11
Speaker 2: Yeah that is.
00:49:12
Speaker 1: But no, you're right, like I played you a lot of hypt Her father definitely has spouse arguments from one side of a culture war which she's being in front of with And after the break, we're going to give from her interact with somebody who actually aligns with her in this and you actually get to keep Madonna, I think in a way that you don't really get to hear her be which is just open. Welcome back to Big Lives today we're talking about Madonna with our special guests such a call. And let me just set the scene for this next interview. It's nineteen ninety four and his interview takes place in a Paris hotel room. Well more specifically, it happens on a bed in a Paris hotel room, which is the signature thing that the interview of a person who's interviewing Madonna does. And this is a person named Ruby Wax. Do either of you know who this is? Do you have any relationship to Ruby Rack? Sort of?
00:50:10
Speaker 3: This sounds familiar, but I can't place it.
00:50:12
Speaker 1: Wooby Rax for me as a kid was sort of my first exposure to like Americans on a regular basis, because she was this American interviewer and presenter living in the UK who would sort of fashion like this niche for herself at this very sort of flamboyant interviewer and she's like super brash and like self deprecating and all those things. And this technique totally works on Madonna, although the whole time this interview starts, you can sort of meet but Donna being like, wait, you're talking like this, and there are cameras around, like
is this as they started the thing we're doing, And it basically starts with both of them like, uh, just like on a bed and Madonna giving tips to Ruby about how to look good on camera.
00:50:56
Speaker 8: Look into the light.
00:50:57
Speaker 11: That's your life. Be very difficult to leave your chin up? All right? All right? And now ready for my first question.
00:51:02
Speaker 8: You never want to get a Shelley. Winteresting happened?
00:51:04
Speaker 14: I have a Shelley?
00:51:07
Speaker 11: Never keep your chain down?
00:51:08
Speaker 2: All right?
00:51:08
Speaker 11: So is this good for me? That's good? How zooming close?
00:51:11
Speaker 8: Let me see zooming close?
00:51:12
Speaker 11: Good? Where was she working? Seven?
00:51:14
Speaker 8: Don't come in closer than that. No closer, and keep.
00:51:17
Speaker 11: Your chin up. I can't talk to you like this, Yes you can. Everyone does. So we'll just speak here casually like this. Everybody does very casual. Like really, I'd be so happy.
00:51:28
Speaker 14: If we just kind of went really loudy angle and I think that's funny.
00:51:33
Speaker 11: That's comedy. It's true. It's comedy, all right, And you can have a much longer.
00:51:37
Speaker 8: Career because can I be funny and pretty?
00:51:40
Speaker 11: Nobody's ever done it.
00:51:41
Speaker 8: That's not true.
00:51:42
Speaker 11: Who who?
00:51:43
Speaker 8: Luci O?
00:51:44
Speaker 11: Paul was pretty? Yeah? For how long? Fifteen women?
00:51:48
Speaker 6: Right?
00:51:49
Speaker 11: Anyway, you don't have to be pretty, you're chalented. You really are fine. Thank you.
00:51:52
Speaker 1: Yeah, this is a very different kind of interview than the other ones that.
00:51:56
Speaker 2: We've listened to.
00:51:56
Speaker 1: If you're going to already tell it's not like a male patriarch kind of fearing more panic like interrogation of Madonna. It's just like two kind of funny women chatting together. And it's interesting because Ruby does ask some of the same questions, but she just asked him in a completely different way. So like Ruby asked her the question that everyone else asks about Madonna may be wanting to be a mother or whatever. But this time it's not like, how can you be a sex symbol and the mother. It's kind of different.
00:52:29
Speaker 14: I know you want to have kids, but you have to really kiss goodbye to that stomach. You do seriously kiss it because it's flat net and it's hard.
00:52:38
Speaker 11: Now I'm laughing.
00:52:40
Speaker 14: I already picture the stretch marks will be on your sacks.
00:52:44
Speaker 11: Excellent.
00:52:44
Speaker 14: You really have to give glamor the he felt. I mean, that's where you let go of all dignity, all right. I think maybe that that'll be what kicks. That'll be the push, that'll be the push that pushes you out of the right lighting.
00:52:55
Speaker 11: All right.
00:52:55
Speaker 14: Once you're pregnant and the ankles are the size of your.
00:52:58
Speaker 8: Thighs, that's something to look forward to.
00:53:01
Speaker 11: Do you really want kids?
00:53:02
Speaker 8: Yeah, you really, definitely. I wish all three of them were sitting on the bed with us right now.
00:53:06
Speaker 11: I was going to do that.
00:53:07
Speaker 14: I was going to give you my youngest daughter because I thought you could give her a better life.
00:53:11
Speaker 11: I couldn't feed.
00:53:12
Speaker 1: Her though, no, And yeah, so like yeah, this interview is like so different from some of the other ones that we've heard, and part of it, as you said, such is like we're hearing from like two like just two women frankly, but also I don't know if this interview is happening at a time where like we're moving into this era pre sex in the city, where we're talking more about women and their bodies and sex, and we're also really in like the third wave of feminism here. I mean, you have pro sex feminists like Camille Palia who are like viewing Madonna as like, literally, I think she says, quote finally a real feminist, right, like somebody teaching young women that you can be fully female and sexual while exercising like full control basically over your life. And that's that's that's what's undergirding this interview that now today seems you know, not commonplace, but it seems like very much of the discourse that were used to But at the time it was like such a big deal.
00:54:09
Speaker 2: I'm going to play you.
00:54:10
Speaker 1: It's it's next glip of ruby wax kind of continuing down this path and just talking with Madonna about about sex, do you know?
00:54:17
Speaker 14: And one thing I just have to ask you is when you fake an organism, I never have You've never faked never.
00:54:25
Speaker 8: I'm not getting out of the bed until he makes me come.
00:54:27
Speaker 14: Really, that's right, that's amazing. And you tell him this is what you have to do. See, I'm too embarrassed.
00:54:34
Speaker 11: I am booklets you do, I swear to I can't say.
00:54:38
Speaker 8: Well, your husband must be watching this, learned a lesson here.
00:54:42
Speaker 11: He knows because you don't trained him.
00:54:43
Speaker 13: Trained because you've told him on TV in front of thousands of people.
00:54:46
Speaker 11: I never told him on TV. He already knows what.
00:54:48
Speaker 14: But I'm talking about like for all the two likes, I could never tell them. So you don't just fake it and go, oh, I'd just rather eat a pizza. No, really, no, God, you're much more sexual than I.
00:54:58
Speaker 8: I don't think that it's that I am more sexual. Maybe I just feel more comfortable saying it.
00:55:03
Speaker 4: I remember that clip that I haven't seen this for sure, but I've heard it somewhere. But that's like kind of revolutionary. I mean, like the the thing too, is like they kept making Madonna be interviewed by men. Yes, and part of that is because like white men were and still for some reason are everywhere despite my best efforts, but also like proliferating
music journalism. So those were the guys who are the late night hosts, the magazine interviewers, the radio guys, like that's who's going to talk to her. But of course they are speaking to her like they have found They all sound like Attenborough being like and now in the.
00:55:40
Speaker 3: Wild, we have found this.
00:55:42
Speaker 4: Yeah, like and don't approach her too fast, you'll by like it's it's really othering and this is a this is a very like in conversation between like two weird bitches, which I obviously appreciate, and it's but it's not really for anybody else kind of it is just it's for the girls and the gays.
00:56:00
Speaker 5: Which is new, right, Like this is what did you say? This is ninety four.
00:56:04
Speaker 6: Something like that, Like now we understand it, right, Like there is plenty of for us by US media that reaches a mass audience that was not a thing in nineteen ninety four, you know. And so yeah, to be able to have a space where two women are talking honestly about sex and even going back to that first cript when she's when you're talking about her become a mother, like I built into the way they're talking about it is a presumption that, yeah, we want to look good, what of it?
00:56:33
Speaker 5: You know?
00:56:33
Speaker 6: Like it's the fact that they're joking about the way pregnancy will change Madonna's sexy body, you know, built into that as an exumption that it's okay, she's yeah, she wants her sexy body, which is not how she's talked to it by any of these men before that.
00:56:50
Speaker 1: And I just want to pay you this of a bit of it because reb wixx does an actually very intimate thing, which is she stops going through Madonna's hambag to see what's in it.
00:57:01
Speaker 6: I mean, this is this is this is a hit last today by the way, you know, yeah, yeah.
00:57:06
Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah, that is a great idea.
00:57:08
Speaker 4: And that is all I ever want to do with anybody famous is just be like, what's in your pocket?
00:57:12
Speaker 3: Can I have it?
00:57:15
Speaker 2: Well, he's hey, I'll play it for you.
00:57:19
Speaker 8: What else is in my purse?
00:57:21
Speaker 10: Wait?
00:57:21
Speaker 2: Wait?
00:57:21
Speaker 11: Oh wait? Oh? Is this seriously with you carry in your purse?
00:57:25
Speaker 8: Actually? I always carry an extra pair of hands.
00:57:28
Speaker 11: I think your panties.
00:57:31
Speaker 14: I can wait a minute, I'm sorry, Can we just show this because I think where's the There's got to be a crotch, there's got to be how do.
00:57:39
Speaker 11: You know where they're here? So you don't have to take them off to go to the loo, which I think is a convenient thing.
00:57:45
Speaker 9: It is especially when you have garter belts on, because then it's hard to take your underpants off when you have.
00:57:49
Speaker 11: Because I wear garden belts so much. That's nice. And this is a kind of another gel for dry lips. Dry lips, Yeah, look at those. You can hardly tell us apart.
I'll get out of my light.
00:58:00
Speaker 9: Well you all right, look exact whose lips are more moist minor hearts.
00:58:06
Speaker 11: And which area?
00:58:09
Speaker 5: Yes, ruby wax, that's.
00:58:17
Speaker 1: Exactly like it makes all the other discourse around her just sounds so I don't know.
00:58:24
Speaker 4: I know everyone was like they're like mad because she's humping the stage, she's out here wearing crotchless underwear.
00:58:31
Speaker 3: Being like, hun, take a bite, like who cares? We live free?
00:58:40
Speaker 2: But I guess I don't know.
00:58:41
Speaker 1: I'm curious, Sachi like having heard all of this and rerevisiting Madonna with us, like obviously we listen to this and we're sort of like, oh my gosh, it's kind of wild to think. But I do feel like in a lot of ways we're in a similar place right now.
00:58:56
Speaker 3: Do you guys believe in astrology.
00:58:58
Speaker 2: Yes, okay, unfortunately great.
00:59:02
Speaker 3: I was thinking about this.
00:59:03
Speaker 4: We're in a placement right now that hasn't happened since the mid eighties, and everyone's sort of talking about how the things that happen and that are starting to happen again, you know, economically, socially, blah blah blah.
00:59:14
Speaker 3: Obviously, there's a lot of pressure.
00:59:16
Speaker 4: Points that feel very reaganesque. I think we are in for repetition. I think generally, as a society, we repeat in order to not remember.
00:59:27
Speaker 3: I think we don't want to.
00:59:29
Speaker 4: Actually adjudicate our failures as a collective because that's painful, and so instead we just do it again. And I think we're in for like another cycle of Madonna sex panic. And it's going to be in this like different shade now because she's older and so it isn't like the young, impish girl from wherever who is about to like fuck things up because she doesn't care.
00:59:52
Speaker 3: Now it is like the experienced woman with an.
00:59:55
Speaker 4: Interesting amount of power and a lot of agency and money, which is, you know, the biggest piece of it all, and she still doesn't fucking care. But I think the response is going to be kind of similar, which is like big success. People really like it. They run after it. I think you're already seeing it. Madonna's like front row at all of the fashion shows. Now she's doing these big interviews again. She's talking about doing blow in a bathroom.
01:00:20
Speaker 5: She did a grinder takeover for her like album b Lonch.
01:00:24
Speaker 2: Yeah, exactly.
01:00:25
Speaker 4: She's going back to the well a little bit where she was and engaging in it in sort of a similar way. And I think the panic is going to research. I mean, like we are in a new phase of purity politics. We see it with like younger people all the time. Apparently no one's having sex. That's unfortunate for them.
01:00:43
Speaker 3: It might not be everyone.
01:00:45
Speaker 4: You know, Madonna's going to get arrested for simulating sex at a
concert, because we are you know, to some degree, we are over some of these things. But I do think there will be I don't know, Trump is going to say something about her, and I will have to finish this rocket ship that I am building to leave because I can't do that.
01:01:03
Speaker 3: I cannot do that.
01:01:04
Speaker 5: Interesting because here's the thing.
01:01:06
Speaker 6: Also, what we haven't said in all of this, obviously we're here to talk about her impacting the culture.
01:01:10
Speaker 5: This woman has made.
01:01:12
Speaker 7: A lot of music and a lot of hits.
01:01:15
Speaker 6: Like ps throughout all of this, like all of those albums in the eighties, that run of albums in the late nineties or late I mean, these have been.
01:01:24
Speaker 5: Big, big, successful albums.
01:01:26
Speaker 6: But now to hear what you're saying, so I see, I'm like setting aside the music, like we need Madonna in the culture right now, like we need You're absolutely right, like we need that spirit of like fuck you I got on Crotchless Panties and.
01:01:42
Speaker 3: That record too.
01:01:43
Speaker 4: I remember a lot of the discourse back then being like, oh my god, she's so old. I can't believe she's not wearing pants. Well guess what she got old wearing pants? So like thinking about how like I rep that, Like when the Hung Up music video came out and there was legitimate discourse being like, she's too old to be doing this. Oh, old girl is almost seventy and she still doing it. I'll take some non racist controversy for once.
01:02:14
Speaker 2: Let's mix it up.
01:02:15
Speaker 5: Give it time, it up, give it time.
01:02:17
Speaker 2: Well, thank you so much for joining us today, Sauta. This was a treat.
01:02:20
Speaker 4: Thanks for having me.
01:02:21
Speaker 3: It was fun.
01:02:22
Speaker 1: So Kai, I don't take a moment to acknowledge we've done twenty episodes.
01:02:26
Speaker 5: Twenty conversations like this.
01:02:29
Speaker 1: It's been such a fantastic journey. But we're going to be taking a break a little bit. If you consider this sort of like the end of office season essentially.
01:02:37
Speaker 5: Put a period on it, you know.
01:02:39
Speaker 6: And the thing that people keep telling me about this show, Emmanuel, is just that it's been nice to hear us find our way to being empathetic in public for people, you know, as we've got to get to know these these figures and these people that we've talked through that it's an act of public empathy in some ways.
01:03:02
Speaker 5: I don't know, man, I hate to get all high brow and sentimental.
01:03:04
Speaker 2: About it, but hey, what are we doing here?
01:03:07
Speaker 6: It's been fun, but it's also reminded me of all these stories and all of these ways in which people just like, whether you're rich and famous or you're just like eat me and you you know, you got to find your way. People just got to find their way through life and be honest about and honesty is the thing that'll get you through. That's been a through line of a lot of our stories. So I don't know, it's been great to have these conversations with you.
01:03:28
Speaker 1: Yeah, it really really has. And what we ask is that in the meantime, as we sort to take this break and figure out what's next, like, but you keep actually sharing episodes of your friends and writing us reviews. I know that sounds so corny and so tired, but I'm gonna say the thing that every podcast host says when they ask you to do this, which is it really was. So tell a friend and yeah, keep listening.
01:03:51
Speaker 7: Keep listening, keep sharing, and we'll talk to you again.
01:03:57
Speaker 1: Big Lives is a production of BBC Studios and Pushkin Industries. It's hosted by me Manuel Jochi and Kai Wright. Our team over at BBC Studios includes a producer and a reverel archive producer Samir Chowdery, sound designed by Melvin Rickerby, and our executive producer is James Robinson. Our production coordinator is Galen Davis Connolly, our apprentice is Amy Woods, and our production manager is Mabel Finnegan Wright. The team over at Pushkin Industries includes executive producer Costanzo Goyardo, producer Daphne Chen. Our legal advisor is Jake Flanagan, and our marketing team includes Morgan Ratner and Jordan McMullen.