สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
Hi, I’m your host, Alyssa Grenfell. Before the episode begins, we have a few notes for listeners. This podcast is hosted by me and veteran attorney Tim Kosnoff, but you’ll also hear other voices from our production team introducing topics and guests.
Our team produced this podcast with the mission to educate people on the issue of child abuse in the LDS community. Help victims of abuse, and encourage us all to work together to help fix this issue.
We occasionally use excerpts of speeches by leaders of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, publicly available on their website. These excerpts are used under fair use for the purposes of commentary and public interest.
If you’re listening and anything you hear feels close to home, please know it should not have happened to you. You are not alone. There are people who believe you, and we can help. Episode transcripts, resources, and our contact form are available on our website: ArchitectureOfAbuse.com
This podcast contains discussions of child sexual abuse. Please listen with care.
This is Architecture of Abuse and I’m your host, Alyssa Grenfell. Episode 5: Repression.
Natasha Helfer
Yeah, it becomes your worldview, and anytime you have a worldview, it's like a fish and water. How are you going to ask a fish what water feels like? Because it's all you know.
Steven Hassan
You are made to feel shameful, guilty. “You're a sinner, you have to
pray harder, you have to fast more,” etcetera, instead of, “This is my
DNA.”
Tim Kosnoff
This Church believes that child sexual abuse is a matter of sin.
Natasha Helfer
Are there things that Mormon/LDS culture have kind of, again,
internalized and integrated that exacerbate some of these potential
issues? Yes, absolutely.
Alyssa Grenfell
These are instances that make Mormon youth want to end their lives because the guilt is so severe, and then they've learned to hide it because they know their parents will be so upset. And so it festers and it becomes uglier and worse.
Tim Kosnoff
The level of sexual repression in this Church is just so beyond the pale, in my mind.
Natasha Helfer
There's one path. The path is being heterosexual. And anything that
deviates from that, including even just fantasy or thought, is
considered a threat, or a sin, or potentially could lead to sin, right?
Tim Kosnoff
My policy and position is: this stuff is ugly, and it's hideous, and I'm not going to sanitize it by using euphemistic language. You know, call it what it is. People need to hear it, if we're ever going to change. The problem is people don't want to think about it. You know, I— you just have to march right into the living room of their mind and say, “No, you're going to look at this. It's ugly.”
Alyssa Grenfell
For LDS Members, strict sexual purity is a foundational piece to their moral framework and personal worthiness. Any threat to that strictness is accompanied with institutionalized shame and guilt. Things like modesty, chastity, and approved forms of sexual expression become external measurements by which internal self-worth can be judged. For high authoritarian organizations, control of sexuality is a primary way in which their goals are met.
Dr. Steven Hassan, expert on the subject of undue influence, discussed high-demand structures in episode three. We’ll hear more from him, alongside therapist Natasha Helfer, as they explore the impact of sexual repression in the LDS Church.
Steven Hassan
I think you've seen my Influence Continuum graphic. So on the
healthy side— and I'm a parent of a 22 year
old, I should say— a healthy parent recognizes that child is a unique
being— I'm Jewish, by the way— a unique soul. And my job as a
good parent is to help steward that child to adulthood. And that
includes not over-parenting, or neglecting and under-parenting, but
having consistent love, and encouraging experimentation, play,
trying out new things, and encouraging a spirit of curiosity and
questioning, including questioning authority.
But when you're on the other side of the Influence Continuum,
which I talk about under the BITE Model— you know, the Behavior,
Information, Thought, and Emotional control of authoritarian groups
like the LDS organization, the Mormons— the idea is authority. So it's
a pyramid structure with the prophet at the top and the hierarchy
goes down. And the goal of the organization is to keep the
organization going, and that means power, money, control of B.I.T.E.,
including sexuality.
Natasha Helfer
Yes, I would say that there is a correlation between any religious organization that has higher than average sexual issues— I do think that is correlated with repressive and oppressive means of trying to control people's sexuality. Yes, I do.
My name is Natasha Helfer, and I am a licensed marriage and family therapist. I'm also a certified sex therapist by the organization AASECT, and then, of course, I grew up in the LDS/Mormon community.
So it happened to be that when I became a therapist, usually not living in Utah or Utah-esque spaces, I was one of the only Mormon therapists in the general regions, so a lot of LDS folks started seeing me, and pretty quickly that became the majority clientele for me. And that was a long time ago— 25+ years ago— and then over time, we've seen a lot of faith transitioning, and mixed-faith marriages, and lots of sexuality concerns, which is why I became interested in the sex therapy piece. And so, my intersection now really resides in what I call this trifecta of mental health, sexuality and religion, and how those three interface and interact with one another. And it's fascinating, and I love my work. So, that's about me.
I guess this also intersects a little bit with my own personal journey, right? Because as an LDS person myself, I think I took on that persona of, “We have the Gospel, we have the truth, and therefore all is well.” And I think, you know— even though I had had some issues growing up LDS, especially in the realm of
Load full transcript
sexual shame and, you know, kind of just my own story on premarital sex and things of that nature— when you're in the world view of it, you're not really taught to see those challenges as problems, you're taught to see those— they're challenges as trials that you're going to grow from, or as trials that you have brought on to yourself. So the only reason why you're suffering is because you have done something wrong, not the system that is kind of, you know, working, you know, I guess their (quote unquote) “magic” on you.
BYU-Idaho Campus Devotional speech: Larry Richman
Much suffering comes as a direct result of sin. When we use our
agency to disregard the commandments of God, we follow Satan's
plan of misery rather than God's plan of happiness.
Natasha Helfer
I kind of am different from a lot of LDS women, in that I went to school and I did prioritize getting my master's degree and even my license prior to having children, so I did that whole work experience prior to becoming a mom and being a stay-at-home mom. And so then— so I'm pretty young— I'm pretty young, and quite frankly, naive and stupid when I'm going through these initial things.
And so as I'm starting to meet with LDS clients, I don't know, I'm expecting them to have outside problems, right? “Outside problems” meaning, you know, oh, you got unemployed, or, you know, you have depression that runs in your family. But then I started hearing from my clients what I call “inside problems.” Like, “I'm a feminist and I don't feel supported at Church,” you know? And quite frankly, where I was back then, is, I'm like— I knew what a feminist was, I didn't have to ask that question, but I was like, “Wait, aren't we all feminists at Church?” Like, I was just very naive as to the problems and to the issues. And of course, LGBTQ folks started showing up very early in my practice, and seeing how either they were asking for things that I had never even thought were possible to ask for, or two, they were complying with things that even me, in my very believing stance, was uncomfortable with. Like, wait a minute, that means you're never going to have sex? You're never going to be in a romantic relationship? You're never going to be able to experience what I kind of take for granted, you know? So even as a believing therapist, I was kind of uncomfortable with them having goals that felt unhealthy to me, right? Obviously with my mental health lens on.
So I think my journey was very much tied to my own kind of growth and my own personal development. My own personal spirituality tied to so many things that people were bringing in that, quite frankly, at Church, we never talk about as legitimate potential problems just because we are members of the Church, you know?
So one of the things that, as a family therapist, I might ask a couple or a family or even individual who's coming in is, “Let's start thinking about what the roles and rules of your system are.” And when we talk about family rules, they are hardly ever spoken rules. They are rules that you figure out pretty early on in life by just noticing the people around you, noticing what other people are getting in trouble for, right? It's like, “Oh, if I ask my mom that question, is she freaked out? Well, then I better not ask her the even harder question that I was actually going to ask. But I'm so glad I asked that smaller question because she freaked out at that level, so I know I can't even go to her for this other question.” Right? And kids oftentimes are doing those things that are testing us. They're observing us. They're learning the rules of the system. And so then, yeah, it becomes your worldview, and anytime you have a worldview, it's like a fish and water. How are you going to ask a fish what water feels like? Because it's all you know.
And so of course it's going to affect how you treat not just your immediate family members, but it's going to affect any profession you really go into, as far as how you're assuming what people are about, how people change, what you can expect from people. Even this kind of, you know, simple idea that as LDS folks, we are more apt to have spiritual revelation— we're blessed because we've accepted certain things about God's “true way”— that is going to automatically set you up to interact with people in different ways, whether they're members of the Church or not. And so lawyers are affected by that, dentists, doctors, teachers— we're all affected with how we interact with others, dependent on what we're thinking we have privilege to, what we have a right to, what we think other people don't have that we have, and quite frankly, yeah, I kind of was always sad for non-members of the Church because I was like, “Well, you're missing out,” or “You don't have the fullness of the truth,” or “Well, I get that you don't think that makes you unhappy, but it probably does make you unhappy.” But I did that, and I know lots of people are doing that.
LDS Church General Conference speech: Quentin L. Cook
We are free to choose and act, but we do not control the
consequences. “Choices of good and righteousness lead to
happiness, peace, and eternal life, while choices of sin and evil
eventually lead to heartache and misery.” As Alma said, “Wickedness
never was happiness.”
Natasha Helfer
Yeah. So in the Mormon Church, it really is the path. It’s the path, it's the one path, and that— and even though we talk about having “diversity” (and I think what we mean by that is, obviously, different peoples of different races or cultures are welcome to join the Church), we're not really looking at diversity in sexuality at all. There's one path. The path is: being heterosexual. And anything that deviates from that, including even just fantasy or thought, is considered a threat, or a sin, or potentially could lead to sin.
On top of it, it's not just a heterosexual box, it's a marital box, right? So the only time that you should even explore your sexuality at all is if
you are in a heterosexual marriage. So, there's not a lot of room to either identify as anything other than that or to behave in any particular ways. And even once you're married, now you have to decide how you're going to define “holy sex,” right? “Righteous sex.” Lots of LDS couples are going to have a lot of different answers to those things. Yeah, I think Mormon sex is righteous sex— it’s very heteronormative and pretty vanilla, right? As far as what there's “permission” for.
I don't think any box is inherently bad. It's when you're forcing people into boxes that I think is bad. So, I mean, it's when people are forced to either fit into that box or, even though that box maybe works okay for them, they're interested in looking into other boxes too and not allowed to, I think that's where it becomes prohibitive.
So there's a difference even in the in the damage, I think, done to, for example, a gay member of the Church or a lesbian member of the Church, who the box never even fit them to begin with, versus a couple who maybe is having an okay time, you know, in their little vanilla heterosexual box but then they also want to explore with bi-curiosity or ethical non-monogamy or just fantasy play. Now they may be damaged too, but kind of, I think, at a different level than when it's your core identity that's being challenged.
Lindsay Hansen Park
Just a note from me, Lindsay, Executive Producer of this podcast. As we move into the next section, we’ll be candidly discussing sex and sexual expression. This is important because avoiding clear, accurate, and mature conversations around these topics can lead to a culture where people are unequipped to engage with real-world experiences in a healthy, informed way.
If discomfort arises during the following discussion, we encourage listeners who choose not to continue to ask themselves why that discomfort exists. But in the spirit of honest, informed dialogue around sexual expression and sexual repression, we hope you’ll choose to engage.
Alyssa Grenfell
Based on the stats we've heard, it seems that a large portion of child sexual abuse in this country happens within the home or just a larger family setting. Given your experience, how do we even begin to talk about this subject?
Tim Kosnoff
Sure. My policy and position is: this stuff is ugly, and it's hideous, and I'm not going to sanitize it by using euphemistic language. You know, call it what it is. So: incest, rape, penetration. It's— yeah, people need to hear it if we're ever going to change. The problem is people don't want to think about it. You know, I— you just have to march right into the living room of their mind and say, “No, you're going to look at this. It's ugly.”
Incest is probably— and I believe it's statistically borne out— is the most common circumstance under which the sexual victimization of children occurs in this country, whether it’s parent-child, older sibling-child, cousin-child, extended family-child. That goes on, and that’s not unique in any way to the Mormon Church. And many of the difficulties that somebody in a situation like that faces, the perpetrator (the father) is the breadwinner. So if a report is made to the police and he is arrested, removed from the home, the family, you know, has immediately lost maybe the sole source of income. So you get these situations where mother becomes enabler. She’s aware of it. She can't really stop it because she is powerless in the relationship and in the family, but she also has other children and she knows what’s going to happen if she goes to the police. He’ll be removed, and then what will the family do? So she’ll turn a blind eye and it continues. And I’ve handled many cases like that.
Natasha Helfer
The first thing I want to say is interfamilial sexual abuse is the most common type of sexual abuse that's happening nationwide, hands down. So this is not particularly a Mormon issue or a Catholic issue or Jewish issue. It is happening even in secular homes all over the United States. And it is the biggest secret that we keep keeping, and it's the biggest thing that we keep not talking about as a whole system here in the United States and I think in many other countries as well. So this is a human family issue. And I just want to start off with that.
Tim Kosnoff
Incest is the most damaging form of sexual abuse. The betrayal of trust when, say, a trusted adult abuses you is bad, but when it’s your parent or sibling that does that— that is such a profound betrayal of trust and exponentially more confusing to the child who, oftentimes, don’t even understand what it is, don’t even— and it’s years later that they come to learn the language that, “My god, I was sexually abused. That's— that’s what it was. You know, he told me he loved me and this is the way fathers express their love to their daughters.” Or male-on-male, you know— cases where father was sodomizing his son or sons. Very, very damaging.
We haven’t talked about various outcomes for abuse survivors, and it’ll vary because each individual has, you know, certain resiliency factors and certain vulnerabilities. But clearly, when a forensic psychologist is examining and preparing to render an opinion as to the nature and extent of the damages that your client has experienced as a result of the sexual abuse, they look at factors like the nature of the abuse. The more intrusive— that’s a negative factor. Incest is a highly negative factor. And what they're getting at is a probability scale for how bad of an outcome you would anticipate. Incest is the most damaging form of sexual abuse.
Natasha Helfer
Now, are there things that Mormon/LDS culture have kind of, again, internalized and integrated that exacerbate some of these potential issues? Yes, absolutely.
One is the authority structure. And an authority in our Church isn't just authority, like leadership authority. It is Godly authority, right? So I have the right to get personal revelation, which is kind of this nice
thing because I get a direct contact with God, which hasn't always been in the history of Christianity, right? The Catholics in particular really controlled that kind beeline to God. But— so we can have direct contact with God, however, with caveats. Like, if God tells me something that my father, who's a priesthood holder— especially me as a woman, like a young girl— that my father would disagree with, and he’s the priesthood leader in our home— now my personal revelation is in question, right? Because why would God tell me something that my priesthood leader wouldn’t agree with?
And so that goes up all the way— not just my father, but then it's my bishop, then it's my stake president, then, of course, it's the prophet at the end of the line of that. And so there's very little room for me to have a valid experience. It's going to be validated by the community that does not fall in line with what, really, the elders and the leaders are saying , which are typically older white men in our culture, right? So, that's problem number one.
Tim Kosnoff
In the Mormon Church, let’s say that it’s not above the national average. I believe it is. I think it’s probably grossly underreported in Utah, but the reason is based on what I know about the structure of the Mormon Church and how the Mormon bishop is almost a sort of third parent in the family— they’re almost treated like that. And almost— he stands above both the father and the mother. And the way the Church inserts itself through the bishop, into the life of the family, and so he becomes, oftentimes the, you know, first responder— the first non-responder, in the case of the Mormon Church.
But because he interacts with the children during worthiness interviews and so forth— a child may not even understand what he or she is saying, but it’s pretty clear, you know, “Daddy is coming into my room at night and he touches me, and he showed me his, you know, his pee-pee, and—“ I mean, these are all things where it's just screaming: this is an abuse situation.
And bishops hear this kind of information and what's their reaction? Similar reaction to, you know, is the mother: “Oh, you know, if I report this to the police, he's going to get removed. No, it's better that we work with him internally through prayer and repentance and try and get him to stop it, rather than pick up the phone and call 911.”
They also hear, “Danger! We don't like these kinds of unhappy things because this is a happy place where bad things never happen and everybody’s good and honest and don’t do these unimaginable things to children.” So, aside from the Mormon overlay, there’s this need to deny because it’s just so horrible to accept the reality of what it is that you now know.
And so, what do you do? And so, a bishop that's wanting to do the right thing but doesn't know what that is— “Well, the Church has said we have a Help Line. Call this 1-800 number.” Does it result in help for that child? No.
Natasha Helfer
Problem number two—
and this just came out again, really, in the children's manual, trying to explain polygamy— is that both “lying for the Lord” and feeling crappy within yourself for the Lord are kind of okay things to do or to feel. Like, that's what we're actually teaching children and that this is what we have many accounts of, you know, historically, for not just polygamy, but lots of things that people didn't really want to do— how they were spending their money back, and, you know, it was it they had to give everything to the Church, or whether or not they wanted to join a militia, or whether or not— yeah, whether or not they were going to become the new polygamous wife or not, right? These all were things that you were taught explicitly to ignore your inner discomfort because your body and your discomfort are not as important— or as, I don't know, inspired— as a leader who has a job for you on the Lord's behalf.
First of all, we're teaching people to ignore our instinct of danger and two, where can you go to get help or support, right? So like, for example, I went through an excommunication process I did not agree with the reasons that they were going to excommunicate me for. Who came to me and said that they were going to excommunicate me? Well, the stake president did. And so I'm like, “Okay, well, I don't agree with you, Stake President.” So who am I going to go to? Am I going to go to the sheriff? Who has leadership authority to do anything about this thing within my Church community?
No, the next person I could go to was the area authority. I went to my bishop. My bishop kind of didn't wholly agree with it all, but he's like, “Sorry, he's my boss,” right? So— oh, okay, so I can't go to that authority. I have to go to the bigger authority. Then the bigger authority that you go to is going to say, “Well, but he's got the priesthood and I've got the priesthood.” They're going to support each other's power. So there's no checking, there's no way of having another authority actually come to your side to represent you, right? So these are called— we use a lot of legal language in these kind of “disciplinary courts,” right? Like, court. It's called “a court.” There's no actual representation. There's nobody representing me. There's nobody, like, fighting and— you know, and then the judge has to make a decision. It's like, no, that the— you're pretty much already told, “This is what you've done wrong. We've decided and this is your punishment.”
Eric Phillips
Executive Producer Eric, here, with a quick note. We're about to play a video from the LDS Church's website. This video is designed to teach children about the practice of plural marriage. The dialogue, accompanied by cartoons, is meant to instruct children about what the LDS Church wants them to know about its history of polygamy. As we know from our previous episode on LDS Church history, and numerous scholarly sources, lacks significant context and accuracy.
Since its publishing in December of 2024, it
has already been revised.
LDS Church Scripture Stories - Illustrated for Children. Plural Marriage: A Commandment for a Time.
While the Prophet Joseph was studying the Bible, he read about
prophets like Abraham and Moses, who had been married to more
than one wife. Joseph had a lot of questions, so he decided to pray
and ask the Lord. The Lord said that usually a man should have only
one wife, but sometimes the Lord commanded a man to be married
to more than one wife.
This was called “plural marriage.” The Lord told Joseph that his
people should only be in plural marriages if He commands it. Years
later, the Lord told Joseph and some other saints to be in plural
marriages. It was not easy to live this commandment. The
government made laws against plural marriage. Some Saints,
including Church leaders, were put in prison.
In 1890, the Lord told Wilford Woodruff, the President of the Church,
that men should not marry more than one wife any more. The
leaders of the Church shared this commandment with the Saints.
This is still the Lord's commandment today: a man should be
married to only one wife.
Natasha Helfer
Yeah. So I guess my first thought is, I would not call what's in the Children's Handbook around polygamy right now “low-key grooming.” I would call it “grooming,” straight out. And so then you have to think, “Well, what is grooming? How do we define grooming?”
And typically, grooming is a fairly manipulative action. It requires you to know certain things and to only choose to share certain things and for specific reasons— which, the Church has a lot more knowledge than they put into that story, obviously, right? And then it has to have an agenda, and the agenda there is to make sure that those kids have information in a way that they would not want to question authority. They would not want to question authority. So how do they create the story? “Oh, he felt uncomfortable. Oh, poor Joseph Smith. Darn it. But sometimes the Lord wants you to do hard things.”
So then when that kid is in the bishop's office and is saying things like— even things that have nothing to do with polygamy— like, “Well, I don't know if I want to go on a mission.” “Well, but the Lord wants you to do hard things, so stop listening to those inner things that really are just temptations from Satan, because what we want for your life, and what we think is best for your life, is much more important than what you want for your life.” And a sexual predator— a groomer— is going to have all the same tactics, and what they think is best for that kid is to be vulnerable for their sexual predation. And that starts early and young, and it happens over and over again, because just like the story at Church that we learn, if you drop a bunch of frogs or whatever into a boiling pan, they'll all jump out. But if you warm it up slowly and slowly, the frog will boil. They teach us that story at Church, but then they turn around and do that to us from day one, because they're
telling you very small things, at a developmental level, that you don't have the ability to even think differently than what they're telling you.
And by the time they're teens and emerging adults, you have now set it up so that they're like, “Oh yeah, that feeling of discomfort? Oh, I know what I need to do with that. I need to push it away. I need to ignore it. I need to put on a smile and I need to go forward with whatever it is they're asking me to do.” That's what we have groomed, you know, a lot of conservative religious people to do, but in particular, you know, I'm talking about Mormons.
Alyssa Grenfell
Yeah, I think there's a wall of religion separating you from you and your parents, and as a child, how that manifests, in my opinion, is being terrified to bring anything disfavorable to your parents because you're worried about how it might change their view of you.
So if you see something— you know, maybe you hear a swear word at school. I still have the memory very early on of coming home and asking my family around the dinner table, maybe when I was first or second grade, “What does bitch mean?” And the way that the silverware clattered to the table and, “Who said that? Are you friends with them? Well, you better stop talking to them if they're saying words like that.” And like, that is my religion fundamentally coming between the natural reaction of a loving parent to their child. And when you have enough of those instances, it teaches you to just hide things. You know, hide— hide it, even if it's something that happens to you, something that you hear in passing.
And so I think that, you know, when you have things like missionaries not being able to use the first names— when you have things like calling, you know, all the people around you “Brother” and “Sister Last Name”— it sets up this sense that, in every human interaction you have, the Church is always the the membrane through which the relationship has any sort of a transaction. I think that that kind of self-isolation that takes place between you and the rest of the world from when you're a very young child, keeps you from sharing, you know, if you had an instance of child sexual assault, you've already— you know, imagine— if that's my family's reaction to me asking, “What does the word bitch mean,” to bring something that is so a thousand times much more serious to your parents and having— you know, having the blow-up, and so I'd rather keep the secret. You know, I'm— “Here I am on Sunday. Here's my appearance of goodness.” That is safer, ultimately, than having anything that is, you know, not contributing to the spirit of happiness and joy within my family.
Tim Kosnoff
As an outsider, I mean, what you describe, this level of repression— and that's what it is. It's human repression.
Alyssa Grenfell
Well, and when you look at the real harm caused by a swear word, the damage is actually fairly minimal.
Tim Kosnoff
Yes.
Alyssa Grenfell
You know, when you look at real, tangible damage that I can point to, to show who was harmed by this vocalization, there's really not even any true damage.
Tim Kosnoff
That's— in my opinion, that's just the— completely the wrong— I mean, that's not the way you raise children. You know, you have to prepare them for the world. And, “Yes, you know, we believe that it's inappropriate for you to use that language. But you're going to be out there in the world with people that are going to use words like that and they may still be good people.”
It reminded me— I mean, for years I would go to various trial litigation seminars and trainings, and they'd bring in, you know, successful, accomplished trial lawyers and they would give a mock opening statement or closing statement. And I remember some of these guys, they were so good, but they were— everything, their movements, their words— were so controlled. And I would just marvel at how they were able to maintain this absolute control. I mean, it was just— it was almost robotic. I mean, it was beautiful, but at the same time, I would notice that they were so controlled that they couldn’t control absolutely everything and it had to sneak out.
So there’d be like a little twitch by the corner of their eye or like— a little something, you know? So it’s going to come out when you repress the human personality— spirit— that way, it’s not going to make them a better person. That’s not how you help them become a better person. It’s just— to me, it’s just the— repression is wrong, and I fight against it all the time.
Natasha Helfer
So any time we're facing shame for an aspect of who we are or what we are about— or even inappropriately for things that we're doing, behaviors that we're doing— that is going to have a very intense effect in your system because we are wired as pack animals to really get along with other people. More than anything, we want acceptance and love and feeling safe with some type of pack. You know, whether you call that a tribe or a group or a family or, you know, whatever chosen family— whatever it is, we're all desperately needing that for basic instinctual safety. And so when a group that you belong to says, “Well, this part of you is not accepted,” and even that— more than not accepted, it's not deemed righteous by a God who created you, and the only explanation they give is kind of, quite frankly, Satanic, then you have a lot of things to try to make sense of.
First of all, more than likely, when you're first hearing these things, you're not sure you can even talk about it with anybody. It's like, “Uh oh, I am hearing that something about me is obviously not okay. And if I say I'm even potentially thinking about that, then maybe I'm already going to be ostracized, right? From the group. Or it may come at a high cost, or I may be punished.” Other people may go the other extreme, which is like, “Oh my gosh, I'm doing something really wrong. So I'm going to tell everybody so that they can punish me and set me straight.” Right? And
we see that a lot in, like, conversion therapy with, you know, gay and lesbian people. And a lot of times the gay and lesbian people were not going to conversion therapy due to their own anxiety, but their parents’ and their priesthood leaders’— ecclesiastical leaders’— anxiety, so they were forced into those types of treatments. So now you have an inner struggle where, “Oh, okay. Something about me is not okay,” but that thing still remains. It's there. So you're trying to find explanations of why it's there, why it's not okay. “What am I going to do about it? Why isn't it going away? Especially with prayer and fasting and being a good member?” And that's true of, really, sexuality in general.
I mean, even things that as a society we have decided, “Yes, you may have those proclivities, you're still not allowed to act upon them,” like pedophilia, right? Or certain types of criminal fetishes, like voyeurism, right? There's no consent. We have all decided as a culture, you're not allowed to behave in those ways. But even with things like that— there's no changing them. We have not found a way in current human development to change people's sexuality. So people who are in those kinds of positions where what we've decided is criminal, they have to find other ways to express their sexuality, and then in those ways that that still is there to handle it and deal with it. And that's very difficult. It's very difficult to be oriented, for example, as a pedophile, however, we expect that person to do that.
Now, we have decided, as religious cultures, to add exponentially to that group of people who can't behave in certain ways, right? And so this is, you know, homosexuality, consensual-philias— this, you know, BDSM and kink, non-monogamy. We've decided, “No, all of— all those things are not okay.” And, just like with the more serious things, they're not going away. They don't go away. So people usually either repress things— and when you repress and suppress things without adequate support, what I say happens is: things get “leaky.” Things start “leaking out” in ways that are harmful, even if they would have never been harmful, if they would have just been able to develop.
For example, mixed-orientation marriage, where a gay man has married a woman and he's been having, you know, kind of closeted affairs for 20+ years, but is hiding that from his Church community, is hiding that from his wife, is hiding that from his children. And now he's outed and there's this big family catastrophe. Well, was it him being gay that caused the catastrophe? No, it was suppressed gayness that caused that catastrophe for everybody involved in that story. And that's a systemic issue. That's not his issue alone to take the blame for that, right? And so when we suppress sexuality— I forget who said this great quote, and I won't even say the quote right, but it's basically something along the lines of, if you go to war with your sexuality, you will lose.
Alyssa Grenfell
I got an email from— because I get emails all the time. It was an anonymous email of a boy— you know, seemed to be a young teenage boy who was upset that I was (quote) “attacking the Church.” And he said he wanted to share his personal experience with the Church to prove how true it was. And he shared that he had had a “pornography addiction” as a young boy, and it had made him suicidal. And he had really had a desire to kill himself for many years— you know, sounded like maybe from age 10 to age 15. And that through the power of the Atonement and talking with his bishop, he had overcome his addiction, and now he was no longer viewing pornography, and this was evidence that the Church was true— because it had healed him.
I think it was interesting to note that the Church had kind of created the problem that it had then solved. And it was really sad that this, to him, was a success story. You know— “This is proof God lives, because He healed me of my pornography addiction,” which is a very strong word to use for a child. Also, I know from talking to men who have been out of the Church, that often a (quote) “pornography addiction” is— can be as benign as hiding a Victoria's Secret catalog to look at once a month.
And so I think that, in in light of the broader conversation about kind of the inability to move through the world without seeing things through a Mormon lens, it means that you just have such a supreme amount of guilt and such a supreme amount of self-deprecation for the most human and— like, basic human urges, you know, masturbation, what it— like, whatever the repressed feelings are, that it makes a— it does make a lot of young people suicidal because they are trying to cope with what is a fairly benign human experience. Whether it's, you know, swearing, occasionally lying on a test, cheating on an exam, viewing a girl in underwear in a magazine— you know, these are instances that make Mormon youth want to end their lives because the guilt is so severe. And then they've learned to hide it because they know their parents will be so upset, and so it festers and it becomes uglier and worse.
Tim Kosnoff
The level of sexual repression in this Church is just so beyond the pale, in my mind. I mean, when I began coming to Salt Lake 35 years ago, during these cases, you know, there were the clinics you could— I forgot what street it was on, where they did the same-sex attraction “treatment,” you know, where they were going to— they were going to “cure” your homosexual impulses. I mean, it was— it was— it was bizarre. I've heard that they've banned— they backed off that, but nevertheless, I mean the— I mean, forget the ignorance, but the arrogance to think that something that is so primal as one’s sexual hardwiring, that you, driven by your religious beliefs, can impose this kind of requirement on an individual? I mean, it was just— it was like something out of a medieval torture chamber. And this is done in the name of religion?
Eric W. Phillips
We
want to take a moment to provide context about this deeply troubling practice— what's commonly known as conversion therapy and what’s clinically referred to by the American Psychological Association and American Medical Association as aversion therapy. Much like other difficult topics, the realities and trauma associated to this practice have often been downplayed or skirted by those who implemented them.
Common techniques included pairing the so-called “undesirable behavior” (in this case, homosexual attraction) with electric shocks, nausea-inducing drugs, and foul odors, all designed to create aversion and reduce the behavior. Though it originated in medical circles in the 1950s, and saw widespread use during the 1960s and 70s, this mentally and physically harmful treatment isn’t ancient or rare. Some listeners may be shocked to learn that this was still happening at Brigham Young University as recently as 1995. Over the course of several decades, hundreds were subjected to these methods, sometimes at the direction of LDS Health and Family Services, after members with same-sex orientation were encouraged to seek “therapeutic help,” unaware of what that would actually involve.
This wasn't exclusive to the LDS Church. Major institutions like Harvard Medical School, the University of Pittsburgh, and the University of Wisconsin also conducted aversion therapy research, many using electroshock techniques. In the documentary 8: The Mormon Proposition, Bruce Barton recalled his experience at BYU in the 1970s. He said (quote), “They made me take my clothes off. They gave me 60CC's of ipecac. And so, about the time I was throwing up, they put electrodes on me— on my wrists, on a strap on my chest and on my genitals. I was told if I didn't push the button strongly enough, they would push it for me” (end quote).
In a 2006 interview with the Church Newsroom, Elder Dallin H. Oaks, who was president of BYU from 1971-1980, said (quote), “The aversive therapies that have been used in connection with same-sex attraction have contained some serious abuses that have been recognized over time within the professions. While we have no position about what the medical doctors do, we are conscious that there are abuses and we don't accept responsibility for those abuses” (end quote).”
As recently as 2019, the LDS Church publicly opposed a Utah state proposal that banned conversion therapy. And then in 2020, the Church Handbook was updated to include this statement: “The Church opposes any therapy— including conversion or reparative therapy for sexual orientation or gender identity— that subjects a person to abusive practices.” House Bill 228 codified the state's ban on conversion therapy for minors into law. According to The Trevor Project's 2022 US National Survey on LGBTQ Youth Mental Health, 24% of LGBTQ youth in Utah reported being threatened with or subjected to conversion therapy in the past year.
After taking in the scope and recency of aversion therapy practices, it may put survivors of this abuse closer to our average listener than they might think.
Steven Hassan
And to answer your question, my elevator definition is: a pyramid structured, authoritarian group that uses deception, and recruitment, and controls behavior, information, thoughts, and emotions to create an identity that's dependent and obedient. And where this particularly creates issues is when people are, for example, gay and the group says, “Well, the scriptures say that it's a sin to be gay.”
So you— if you're gay, then you've got to be put through conversion therapy, which is brainwashing attempts to make you straight. Well, we know that doesn't work. The largest group that was doing it for decades— Exodus, like, disbanded because they realized it doesn't work. But my former cult, the Moonies, Jehovah's Witnesses, so many other groups, including the Mormons, have had their boot camps and conversion therapy camps to try to make everybody straight.
It just isn't, you know, human. So if you are attracted to the same sex, you are made to feel shameful, guilty, you're a sinner, you have to pray harder, you have to fast more, etcetera, instead of, “This is my— this is my DNA.” And some of our greatest brilliant inventors, innovators have been gay, so like, hey, maybe we should reform the dogma that says it's such an evil sin.
And by the way, I'm going to give you a quick factoid, being Jewish— do you know the same word in Hebrew for being gay and how “bad” it is, is also applying for shellfish? Yeah. So it's the same level of sin to eat a shrimp or a lobster as it is to be gay, if you really want to quote fundamentalist, you know, mentality from the Old Testament or what's known as the Torah. You know, when you have an ideology, you pick and choose what fits your ideology and you ignore everything else, including the context— including the historical context. And there are real problems with trying to take literature from 2000 years ago or 3000 years ago and say that we have to be literalists because we live in a different language, much less a different time.
Tim Kosnoff
Too often I've seen these situations— I mean, this is reported by my clients, and it’s so common— where, you know, the 12-year-old has disclosed and the bishop says, you know, “Well, what we're going to have to discuss is your complicity in this.” What? Excuse me? This 12-year-old was— you know, is being molested by her father or his father or some other ward member, and you're treating this as a— “Me committing the sin of homosexuality? That's what you think this is, Bishop?” But of course you don't say that to a bishop. But it's like, how confusing! “I came here for help. I want— I thought you should know. And now I'm— I'm guilty?”
Through discovery, I get access to these reports of Church court action. If they have— you know, there's been previous Church discipline related to child sexual abuse, they have to produce that. And they, you know— at the end of the
case, you know, they want those back. So I've had them. I've seen them. I make notes. It’ll identify who the members of the stake high council were, that sat on it. It'll identify who the individual was, and so on and so forth. And then there'll be a box, which is, you know: “Describe the nature of the offense.” Sometimes it would say, you know, “child abuse” or “child sexual abuse.” Many times it said “homosexual acts” and the— but you read down and it's this 35-year-old man was molesting and raping, you know, a 12- or 13-year-old Scout. I mean, it should’ve read “child rape” but— you read the narrative, it's clearly what it was, but it's the caption that's put in there is “homosexual activity.”
So do they really believe that? That an adult— a male adult that molests a boy— that that's homosexuality? Is that really what they believe? Apparently. Because these are supposed to be filled out accurately, because then the ward clerk has to sign them and date them. It shows what the disposition of the disciplinary court is (probation and excommunication, or what have you) and then these have to be transmitted to Church Headquarters, where they're retained forever.
Alyssa Grenfell
You know, homosexuality is doctrinally a much more clear-cut (quote) “sin” in the Church, there's a clear repentance process, and also they're equally participating parties. And it just reclassifies it as, “This is a sin and not a crime.” And maybe that also allows them to put some distance between what they view as their responsibility to report a crime versus their responsibility as a religious leader to help someone seek repentance for the sin that they participated in.
It reminds me of how growing up all the leaders would say “necking” and “petting.” And I never even knew what necking and petting was. And, you know, there's a pamphlet called “To Young Men Only” that is nicknamed the “Little Factories Pamphlet,” where they use a euphemism to describe the little factory in a boy's body and what happens when he reaches adolescence. And all of these euphemisms make it so that it's actually impossible for people to even comprehend what the commandments are.
Like, when I was growing up, I always was terrified that I would be involved in necking and petting because I had no idea— I literally had no idea what it was, just that it was something that happened between a boy and a girl. And I think as you're describing something like— you know, using the word “homosexuality” to describe child rape, male-on-male child rape, I think my reaction is just that, obviously it reveals a fundamental misunderstanding of human sexuality.
Tim Kosnoff
Can I relate something— and it sort of relates back to the Boy Scouts, but it’s— it fits into this. So in the 1980s, the Boy Scouts, you know, had had many, many claims brought, and the insurance companies would pay these claims quietly. So the insurance carriers said, “Look, you need to deal with this.” And so they consulted experts, and they came up with a program, and they called it the Three R's: Recognize, Resist and Report. And it was a pamphlet and it was a little orientation at Scout— you know, the first Scout meeting in the fall.
When they instituted that program, the number of disclosures that a Scoutmaster or some adult in the program was abusing a child tripled. And I could tell that because I got ahold of all the files eventually, and I could see that they had been opening up a file— like one every 3 or 4 days. And once they instituted this program, they were opening up a confidential file once every other day.
What that showed is that: that works. When you empower a child with information and that this is a thing? Child sexual abuse, it’s not your fault, you know? And these earnest little Cub Scouts that get this, and they get a little pamphlet, they took it to heart. They’re Boy Scouts. And they followed it. And, you know, it was— it didn’t solve the problem, but it mitigated it. Great program.
Mormon Church— sponsors 40% of Boy Scout troops in the country at that time— wouldn't allow the Three R’s program to be used within LDS wards. I got this directly from the individual who was involved in establishing this program. And there’s a quote in a book called Scout’s Honor: Sexual Abuse in America’s Most Trusted Institution by Patrick Boyle, where he says that they are the largest sponsor of Scouting in the United States, and Church officials took the position that sexual matters are within the exclusive province of the Church and they are not going to allow the Boy Scouts to use their materials in Mormon wards.
Now, if you had been any other sponsor, you would lose your charter immediately. “You’re going to use this program”— and they insisted it was a prerequisite, except for the largest, most powerful sponsor of Scouting in the entire organization, the Mormon Church. So even when it was brought to them— you know, and this was developed by the experts in the field, a man named Dr. Finkelhor. He ran a— the biggest institute at the University of New Hampshire, you know, full of PhDs that do nothing but study various aspects of the phenomenon. You know, the Three R’s, or something similar to that, is so easy. I mean, to me, it’s just so simple, so common sense.
Alyssa Grenfell
Well, it's especially sad to realize that you as a lawyer have more interest in the individual than the organization who constantly is saying how much they care about the individual. You know, the fact that you— you would have to come in and say, “I'm actually going to stand by this person,” when all the messages I received growing up would always have led me to believe that the organization was doing that— was standing up for me, was protecting me, was having my best interest at heart.
Tim Kosnoff
And when that— when that hits? It's crushing to realize that their church now perceives them as the threat. “They didn't protect me. And now, because I want accountability, or I was hurt and you were
responsible, and— now you’re treating me like I’m the criminal? You’re showing up in court to back the man who raped me? And you're all lining up on his side of the courtroom, and getting up and speaking at sentencing and telling the judge what a good man he is, and so on and so forth. And I'm sitting over here, and I'm the victim, and nobody's sitting behind me from the ward.” You know? How faith-promoting is that?
Natasha Helfer
Correct. Which— I have sat with many families throughout many years, where parents actually did the right thing and advocated for their child, and when they started realizing all the ways that they were getting shut down, led to their exit to the Church— which is kind of a healthy story. It's a sad story, but it's a healthy story because one, they chose their child and two, when they were not able to advocate for their child appropriately within our system, they opted out of the system.
But that speaks to the crappy stuff we have to fix in our system if we're ever going to be a healthy, you know, church community. And then you've got— because of all that authority, and because everybody's speaking for God, supposedly, then it can be very difficult to believe a less-authority-status person in the community, that a higher-status person could have done something, especially sexually inappropriate, right? So this is tragically a very common story, where people do come forward and say, “I was abused by my Young Men's leader, or by the bishop, or by my dad, or my stepdad, who happens to be a high councilman, right, in the Church. And then everybody that— again, the cognitive dissonance doesn't compute. That's a man of God. That's a man who has authority of God. That's a man who is— has direct, revelatory power from God. How could they also be doing this? So it must be you that's lying, right? You that's lying.
LDS Church General Conference speech: Richard G. Scott
The victim must do all in his or her power to stop the abuse. Most
often, the victim is innocent because of being disabled by fear or the
power or authority of the offender. At some point in time, however,
the Lord may prompt the victim to recognize a degree of
responsibility for abuse. Your priesthood leader will help you assess
your responsibility so that, if needed, it can be addressed. Otherwise
the seeds of guilt will remain and sprout into bitter fruit. Yet no
matter what degree of responsibility, from absolutely none to
increasing consent, the healing power of the atonement of Jesus
Christ can provide a complete cure. Forgiveness can be obtained for
all involved in abuse.
Natasha Helfer
And of course, this is, again, not just a Mormon issue. There are many family systems that don't believe the victim because believing the victim disrupts the nice story that everybody wants to believe is their family system, right? Nobody wants to believe that they're the ones that are having a problem.
Tim Kosnoff
To me, it’s just— you know, as much as I want to make peace in my heart with this Church, it’s just, I’ve just seen too much. And it’s not even just my clients who were victimized as a result, with the callousness and negligence, it’s everything we’ve been talking about. I just don’t understand— I mean, I’m impressed with people who can come through this process and still be standing, you know, and heal from it and, “Yeah, I’m moving on, I’m doing it. Yeah, it hasn’t been easy, but I’m doing it.” And it’s, like, brother, I’m proud of you.
Natasha Helfer
If I'm going to stick with kind of a story like mine, where you're going from one worldview to another, typically what shifts that is life experience. There has to be an experience that changes you. It's not usually information, which is where we all get stuck because we figure, “Oh, if I teach you then you will automatically see the logic and change your ways.” And people both in and out of the Church are trying to do this to each other all the time, right? The people in the Church are trying to teach us how to be in the Church, and the people out of the Church are trying to teach how to be out of the Church. And everybody gets grumpy with each other and everybody's mad, and nobody's changing anything. That's so that's not typically how we change minds.
How we change minds is by changing hearts. And the only way you can change your heart is if you have empathy and can listen to other people's experiences, right? And I think, really, what happened to me— I listened to so many stories that they changed my heart, right? And another reason why I have very little empathy for the higher-ups in the Church leadership, because I know that they have listened to stories— many, many stories— as well. I'm having a harder time understanding why hearts aren't being changed, you know, in the echelons of the Church, right?
And so when we think about even the arc on the LGBTQ journey in LDS-land, I believe some of the current polls are saying that there's quite a few LDS people, I think even more than half, who are affirming of gay people, but our doctrine is not, right? And our leaders are kind of doubling down and, you know, even though they're having lots of experiences with people who are gay that are clamoring to say, “Hey, I'm being hurt by this,” they're not able to shift that. Those experiences are not shifting. It's kind of like doubling down their experiences.
But a lot of mama dragons, you know, and papa dragons, and a lot of people who have family or who have loved ones or who lost a child to suicide, or now something has significantly happened where the old story, the old worldview is coming into question and they're having to wrestle with that, right? We call this kind of “cognitive dissonance” and it's like one of your truths is not aligning with another truth that you've just experienced, and you're trying to make sense of that. And so this leads people usually to those first questions or maybe to nuancing their faith— maybe not leaving their faith, but nuancing things— having more room to see the gray.
Alyssa Grenfell
Thank you for listening to this episode of Architecture of Abuse. Engaging with clarity, maturity and empathy is an important step toward understanding how we can support survivors. In our next episode, we'll be joined by therapist Malia Burgess, Director of Operations at Encircle Utah, to explore the topic of healing and the ways our community can support that process on both individual and collective levels.
Malia Burgess
Certainly, when we’re talking about trauma, we can’t undo what has
been done, but we can find a new way to interact with it and try to
resolve some of the feelings we have about what occurred.
Alyssa Grenfell
I was too afraid, so often, to ask for help because I was worried what it
might reveal about my worthiness.
Julie Hanks
And it’s a lot more than just, like, knowing what happened. It’s
processing the emotions, and yeah, therapists trained to do that, so
come see us.
Tim Kosnoff
If you’d like to discuss a potential claim, you can contact me via my website: Kosnoff.com.
If you are not a survivor but still want to do something to help our community, you can make an impact. Here are some things you can do to help:
If someone shares their experience with you, the most important thing you can do is listen with empathy and guide them toward professional resources for support. Support them but let them decide what is best for them. Contact your local legislators and emphasize your support for removing the clergy penitent privilege in child sexual abuse situations. Churches need to report child abuse to those with the knowledge, training and authority to deal with these crimes. It is the only way of breaking the chain of abuse. Urge your local legislators to support a “look back window” law to give child abuse victims additional time to pursue justice and publicly identify their abusers. Cutting off child sexual abuse survivors’ access to the courts at age 21 is unrealistic and wrong-headed because most surivors have not processed the trauma by that age sufficient to take that step.
Thank you for listening.
This episode of Architecture of Abuse was hosted by Alyssa Grenfell and Tim Kosnoff. Executive producers are Lindsay Hansen Park and Eric W. Phillips. Produced, edited, and mixed by Lizzy Bean. Research and fact-checking by Emily Sellers. Music by Ian Post, licensed through Artlist.
Show notes, transcripts, and additional resources are available at ArchitectureofAbuse.com. You can follow us on all platforms @architectureofabuse. If this episode resonated with you, please consider leaving a review and sharing it with someone who might benefit from the conversation.
Via email, we asked the LDS Church for comment and although we didn’t get a response, we did inform them we’d include their standard policy, that “abuse of any kind is not tolerated in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.”