สำเนาบทสนทนา 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:31.067 --> 00:00:32.567
Welcome to American POTUS.
00:00:32.652 --> 00:00:34.010
I'm your host, Alan Lowe.
00:00:34.307 --> 00:00:38.982
On this episode, I'm very pleased to welcome back Harold Holzer for his second appearance on our podcast.
00:00:39.579 --> 00:00:44.167
As you will recall, Harold is an award-winning scholar who serves currently as the Jonathan F.
00:00:44.168 --> 00:00:49.272
Fanton Director of Hunter College's Roosevelt House Public Policy Institute.
00:00:50.120 --> 00:01:00.874
The recipient of the National Humanities Medal in 2008, the Gilder Lehrman Lincoln Prize in 2015, and many other awards and recognitions, Harold is a sought-after commentator.
00:01:01.106 --> 00:01:18.906
He's been widely published, and he's the author or editor of nearly 60 books, such as Lincoln and the Power of the Press, The War for Public Opinion, which was the topic of our last conversation, and the book we'll discuss today, Brought Forth on This Continent: Abraham Lincoln and American Immigration.
00:01:19.371 --> 00:01:21.259
Harold, welcome back to American POTUS.
00:01:21.780 --> 00:01:22.433
Thank you, Alan.
00:01:22.433 --> 00:01:24.331
Thank you for having me back so soon
00:01:24.707 --> 00:01:26.060
Yeah, it's very good to see you.
00:01:26.397 --> 00:01:27.173
I love this book.
00:01:27.216 --> 00:01:31.602
So many important things you say in this book, uh, learn even more about Lincoln.
00:01:32.182 --> 00:01:34.459
Let's talk about his ancestry to start.
00:01:34.489 --> 00:01:39.031
What do we know about his ancestry and when his forebears first immigrated to America?
00:01:40.025 --> 00:02:12.700
Well, we know that they lived, in a town called Lincoln in England, we know that, his direct,, forebearer many times removed was a weaver's apprentice and, came here, to Massachusetts in the early 1600s and, went right into his weaving trade here established a family and the lineage that eventually, at least among the successors, the direct successors and descendants, headed south and then west through Virginia and Kentucky.
00:02:12.700 --> 00:02:21.670
And about, nearly 200 years later, the result of all of that resettlement, and immigration I might add, was Abraham Lincoln
00:02:22.221 --> 00:02:22.413
Yeah.
00:02:22.514 --> 00:02:25.944
Very, very lucky they made that trip across the ocean, that's for sure.
00:02:26.536 --> 00:02:28.450
So let's skip ahead a few years.
00:02:28.759 --> 00:02:38.661
As a young politician, how did Lincoln respond to what was a growing influx of immigrants into the US, and how did his views at that point correspond with those of his Whig Party?
00:02:38.963 --> 00:02:39.248
Right.
00:02:39.673 --> 00:03:05.349
As you point out, he was a member of the Whig Party, which,, was not entirely sympathetic toward immigrants, mainly because when immigrants arrived, they tended to align themselves with the Democratic Party Perhaps because most early immigrants were Catholics and, the Whigs were not particularly tolerant of Catholicism.
00:03:06.179 --> 00:03:16.987
But, from a very political point of view, also because the Democratic Party made more of an effort to welcome and recruit, Catholic immigrants than the Whigs did.
00:03:17.266 --> 00:03:20.010
So it's like a cart before the horse situation.
00:03:20.858 --> 00:03:26.853
The Whigs are angry that immigrants are enrolling in the Democratic Party, so they don't want more of them here, basically.
00:03:27.256 --> 00:03:33.870
And, um, it's their indifference or hostility that drove them to the Democratic Party in the first place.
00:03:34.033 --> 00:03:35.300
So that's just the background.
00:03:35.545 --> 00:03:39.164
Lincoln is a very strong Whig most of his political career.
00:03:39.645 --> 00:03:41.227
He's a Whig, not a Republican.
00:03:41.227 --> 00:03:42.609
That comes much, much later.
00:03:43.158 --> 00:03:47.413
And as a young man, he harbored at best an indifference toward immigrants.
00:03:47.768 --> 00:03:50.504
He lived in a kind of a pluralistic Springfield.
00:03:50.504 --> 00:03:53.777
It was more diverse than we had come to believe.
00:03:53.777 --> 00:04:01.858
There were Irish people there, German people, Black,, pockets, of homes within walking distance in Springfield.
00:04:02.500 --> 00:04:07.800
But Lincoln had really not had much exposure himself to the foreign born.
00:04:08.932 --> 00:04:22.486
Really none until he was about 20 and went down Mississippi River on a flatboat with his, cousin and buddy to sell goods in the big city downriver.
00:04:22.983 --> 00:04:35.709
And lo and behold, he sees French people and Creole people and Black people speaking with French accents, and others who have congregated in this international port.
00:04:36.161 --> 00:04:38.014
He'd never seen anything like it before.
00:04:38.683 --> 00:04:45.124
I think that's his first that there's a wider world outside of, central Illinois.
00:04:45.427 --> 00:04:50.144
But I still haven't answered your question'cause I was just setting the table probably with too much silverware.
00:04:50.321 --> 00:04:54.513
But, there is a crisis point in 1844.
00:04:55.063 --> 00:05:11.504
Anti-Catholic riots break out in Philadelphia, and probably the Irish who, were really the suffered the most, instigated the violence by attacking a, Protestant speaker in a Catholic neighborhood.
00:05:11.964 --> 00:05:16.764
It was all over what Bible should be used to do morning prayers in schools.
00:05:17.219 --> 00:05:20.789
And, um, we have the same arguments today.
00:05:21.364 --> 00:05:22.629
but it was a flashpoint.
00:05:23.067 --> 00:05:27.059
People were killed, churches were burned, books were burned.
00:05:27.813 --> 00:05:35.945
Whigs finally realized they had to speak out or they were gonna be branded as a party of prejudice and intolerance.
00:05:36.160 --> 00:05:49.557
And Lincoln drafted the resolutions that year in Springfield that defended the idea of peoples becoming citizens in the
Load full transcript
United States, the foreign-born were welcome, that the process needed to be orderly.
00:05:50.490 --> 00:05:52.774
But that's the first word we have from him.
00:05:53.009 --> 00:05:55.485
Was he enthusiastic about Democratic Catholics?
00:05:55.486 --> 00:05:55.850
No.
00:05:56.174 --> 00:05:58.440
Not because they were Catholic, but because they were Democrats.
00:05:59.219 --> 00:06:01.510
he sympathetic Irish?
00:06:01.527 --> 00:06:04.596
Not particularly, because again, they were preponderantly Democratic.
00:06:05.028 --> 00:06:18.027
But he had set the bar of tolerance for himself and his local party, and that's kind of the, responsible and responsive way he behaved for the next 21 years of his life
00:06:18.480 --> 00:06:26.011
And skipping to the time when he's helping establish the new Republican Party, there's also the Know Nothing or American Party out there.
00:06:26.229 --> 00:06:28.769
How does he engage with the members of that party?
00:06:29.503 --> 00:06:47.948
Well, it's a great question because, again, Irish and German by then voters are potentially tipping points in several Western states, as were called then, Illinois, Missouri, Indiana, huge influx and huge numbers of people.
00:06:48.530 --> 00:06:50.899
The Know Nothings have enormous power.
00:06:50.964 --> 00:06:59.717
They get 20% of the popular vote in 1856, a year after Lincoln joins the Republicans, so they were a force to be reckoned with.
00:07:00.073 --> 00:07:02.096
And here's what Lincoln decides.
00:07:03.503 --> 00:07:27.769
never going to embrace their anti-foreigner stance, but he's never going to say,"We're never gonna welcome you into the Republican Party." What he does say instead is that the Republicans are a broad tent, and if one-time Know Nothings are willing to fight slavery expansion, they will in fact be welcome.
00:07:28.022 --> 00:07:39.797
Lincoln says,"I'll fuse with anybody, if it's on the right grounds." And whether that's a great thing on his record or a sketchy thing on his record, that's what we've been debating ever since my book came out.
00:07:39.797 --> 00:07:46.523
But, again, he opens the doors for participation, but on his terms, which is anti-slavery
00:07:47.479 --> 00:07:52.658
So in those years leading up to his election as president, how was he engaging with ethnic groups?
00:07:52.664 --> 00:07:54.746
So was it part of a plan or was it more ad hoc?
00:07:56.770 --> 00:08:00.942
Well, he's engaging, in a pretty organized way with the German community.
00:08:01.727 --> 00:08:12.248
First of all, he tries to learn German himself because he has a notion that maybe, it would be advantageous and useful to speak to these voters in their native tongue.
00:08:12.965 --> 00:08:15.072
he's a total mess at German classes.
00:08:15.383 --> 00:08:21.410
The, the one witness we have who remembered it said that he made so many jokes in the class.
00:08:21.410 --> 00:08:28.207
It was like an after-school program for professionals, and they
were tired, and he was still at full tilt as a humorist.
00:08:28.340 --> 00:08:32.975
He made so many jokes that nobody learned German at all, so that didn't help.
00:08:33.851 --> 00:08:40.552
But he did befriend politicians from his Whig days forward.
00:08:40.554 --> 00:08:43.086
So he made allies, he made friends.
00:08:43.577 --> 00:09:00.009
Carl Schurz, the leading German politician of the day, who hailed from Missouri but originally from Germany, became a strong Republican defender in the 1850s, and Lincoln made sure to keep open to him.
00:09:00.350 --> 00:09:15.268
And at the end of the 1850s, talking about how well-organized he was, he spends$500, that's a lot of money 1859, to acquire presses of a newspaper that had gone bankrupt.
00:09:15.723 --> 00:09:31.008
He acquires it and partners with its editor and writes his own contract, which lawyers I know are not supposed to do, or they have a fool for a client, but Lincoln did he didn't wanna make any money from this enterprise.
00:09:32.316 --> 00:09:49.809
He simply wanted to guarantee that this paper, once it was revived, adhere to Republican platform principles for the next two years, meaning through the presidential election of 1860, or he would confiscate the printing press and the hot type.
00:09:50.673 --> 00:09:58.062
And they stayed true to that agreement, and he gave the whole shebang to the editor, actually gave him a government job, so he didn't really need it.
00:09:58.937 --> 00:10:23.370
so he did have an official German language organ, as they called it, and encouraged in the presidential election of 1860, the creation of what was called the Foreign Relations Office the Republican National Committee, headed by Carl Schurz, who barnstormed all over the West and the East to give speeches in German for Lincoln
00:10:24.191 --> 00:10:24.221
Mm-hmm.
00:10:24.625 --> 00:10:28.083
I know the Republican Party that year had a very pro-immigration stance.
00:10:28.083 --> 00:10:31.242
Was Lincoln involved in setting that part of the plank for the platform?
00:10:31.577 --> 00:10:32.511
Yeah, that's a good question.
00:10:32.511 --> 00:10:34.341
I don't think he really did.
00:10:34.346 --> 00:10:42.206
I don't think candidates, had as big a role in platform creation or even selection of vice presidents as they do today.
00:10:42.600 --> 00:10:59.017
And there was a big platform fight on the immigration plank, ended up saying explicitly that the foreign born were welcome to come to the United States and establish citizenship and voting rights, and Lincoln swore allegiance to the platform.
00:10:59.017 --> 00:11:03.456
That's what you did in those days, or you didn't accept the nomination.
00:11:04.824 --> 00:11:18.290
I should say just at one point what those requirements were, because, we are still engaged in the great civil wars, like I might put it, about immigration and citizenship status.
00:11:19.450 --> 00:11:25.978
In the 19th century, after Adams, you could just, enter the United States on a ship.
00:11:27.090 --> 00:11:32.162
All you had to do was register your entry in the ports in the East mostly.
00:11:32.162 --> 00:11:34.975
It was New York, Boston, Philadelphia, Savannah.
00:11:35.665 --> 00:11:47.528
Preponderantly the North, because that's where opportunities were for laborers and new entrepreneurs in the North, not the South, which is why the immigration was so Northern centric.
00:11:48.205 --> 00:11:50.978
You registered, no questions asked.
00:11:51.877 --> 00:11:55.263
If you became a public burden, there was sometimes a question.
00:11:55.358 --> 00:11:57.850
If you went right into a charity ward, there were questions.
00:11:58.639 --> 00:12:09.064
But five years later, you could go back the immigrant office basically become a citizen of the United States with the right to vote.
00:12:09.629 --> 00:12:09.798
Hmm.
00:12:09.864 --> 00:12:11.074
That's how simple it was.
00:12:11.559 --> 00:12:18.821
And some states protested, even Massachusetts, which then as now can be called the most progressive state in the country.
00:12:19.903 --> 00:12:28.473
They tried to expand it to 10, maybe 15 years, and there was lots of pressure for a 10 or 15 year maximum from the Know Nothing party.
00:12:28.850 --> 00:12:30.411
But, Lincoln resisted it.
00:12:30.500 --> 00:12:42.170
And it didn't change until the Supreme Court got involved and Congress got involved when Eastern Europeans began following Western Europeans into the country in the 1880s and'90s.
00:12:42.422 --> 00:12:47.322
And of course, the Chinese Exclusion Act that banned Asian immigration
00:12:47.726 --> 00:12:50.768
As you say, it's still, a very, very hot debate today.
00:12:51.175 --> 00:12:54.887
Let's talk about the immigrant vote in, 1860.
00:12:54.887 --> 00:13:01.711
So how important were those recent citizens, new citizens to the US in electing Lincoln?
00:13:03.061 --> 00:13:04.017
It's hard to tell.
00:13:04.031 --> 00:13:08.952
There have been attempts to study election district by election district.
00:13:10.396 --> 00:13:16.182
late friend William Gienapp doing a lot of that ED by ED work.
00:13:16.196 --> 00:13:19.333
He died much too young, never completed that work.
00:13:19.841 --> 00:13:24.899
I think the, the vote was important in Indiana, in Illinois.
00:13:25.877 --> 00:13:34.494
You know, as big a German vote as Lincoln got in Missouri in 1860, it didn't stop Missouri from going to another candidate, in terms of electoral votes.
00:13:34.745 --> 00:13:37.656
So was it dispositive?
00:13:37.657 --> 00:13:39.408
No, but it was important.
00:13:39.412 --> 00:13:50.346
And it also a lot of momentum around the country, because campaigning in those days was not on, uh, MSN and Fox.
00:13:50.346 --> 00:13:54.480
It was done on street corners and in literature and newspapers.
00:13:55.024 --> 00:14:00.701
And, German and Irish, political voices were heard throughout that campaign.
00:14:01.014 --> 00:14:09.341
I don't think Lincoln
loses New York City two and a half to one if it wasn't for a unified Irish vote that opposed him.
00:14:10.105 --> 00:14:13.110
So, he barely won New York State in 1860.
00:14:13.110 --> 00:14:18.651
He did even worse in 1864 when he felt he had an even tougher race on his hands.
00:14:19.500 --> 00:14:20.622
So, I don't think we know.
00:14:20.623 --> 00:14:22.774
There were no polls, so it's hard to know.
00:14:22.791 --> 00:14:33.142
But in terms of creating excitement, and in terms of, creating momentum, I think the foreign-born and first-generation vote was pretty important
00:14:33.511 --> 00:14:46.050
Now these energized groups of, Germans and others around the country soon were at war, and you show how many of those immigrants from a variety of backgrounds fought in the Union Army, sometimes creating their own battalions.
00:14:46.100 --> 00:14:51.048
How did Lincoln encourage those recent immigrants to serve, and how impactful were they?
00:14:51.500 --> 00:14:56.700
Well, here I think we can be more secure in saying that the impact was enormous.
00:14:57.005 --> 00:15:04.237
And Lincoln, brilliant, brilliant because starts and he knows two things from the outset.
00:15:04.254 --> 00:15:13.091
One is that it cannot be a Republican war exclusively, so he goes after Democrats to lead units.
00:15:13.094 --> 00:15:22.224
In those days, politicians raised regiments and took the field with or without military experience, and we know what the results were in the first two years of the war.
00:15:22.487 --> 00:15:29.628
But forgetting about the military mistakes, the political genius of this mass recruitment, was manifest.
00:15:30.120 --> 00:15:46.733
So in addition to political generals, Lincoln realized from the outset that he had a huge advantage in foreign-born communities, and ethnic units were the next logical step, or really a simultaneous logical step.
00:15:47.845 --> 00:15:53.927
So he encouraged, German units to form in the west and wherever they could form.
00:15:54.412 --> 00:15:59.463
Carl Schurz rushes to New York to form a German unit, but he finds he's too late.
00:15:59.463 --> 00:16:03.586
Already several have been formed and no more Germans left to recruit.
00:16:04.027 --> 00:16:19.567
But where Lincoln is the most brilliant and tolerant, I think, is in his appeal to Irish Catholic Democrats Not his constituency, he realizes the war can't be won a divided home turf.
00:16:20.417 --> 00:16:30.133
And here, from where I speak in New York City, about 60 blocks south of where I'm sitting, was an enormous rally the week after the Sumter attack.
00:16:31.261 --> 00:16:38.639
100,000 New Yorkers at Union Square in front of the famous equestrian statue of George Washington.
00:16:39.632 --> 00:16:41.753
And two rallies.
00:16:41.755 --> 00:16:47.672
One was elites like Roosevelts and Verplancks and Vanderbilts, and they had their own pro-Union rally.
00:16:48.059 --> 00:16:53.072
And on the west side of the square, there was an ethnic rally for Germans and Irish.
00:16:53.994 --> 00:16:58.598
And it's amazing to read those speeches, which were printed verbatim in the papers the next day.
00:16:59.340 --> 00:17:04.253
The Irish say,"We didn't vote for Lincoln, but this is our country.
00:17:04.255 --> 00:17:05.307
We love our country.
00:17:05.662 --> 00:17:11.191
We don't prefer him politically, but political stuff aside, we're all in."
00:17:11.779 --> 00:17:11.789
Mm-hmm.
00:17:11.789 --> 00:17:16.627
So the 7th Regiment filled with elites goes to war right away, but so does the Irish Brigade.
00:17:18.180 --> 00:17:33.574
Lincoln actually works with the Archbishop of New York, John Hughes, a friend of his Secretary of State, William Seward, to put together a list of potential commanders who could command Irish units.
00:17:33.966 --> 00:17:44.755
And they come up with Michael Corcoran, who was under court martial at the time to rally the Irish regiment to greet the Prince of Wales on a visit to New York.
00:17:45.071 --> 00:17:56.072
He said,"We're never going to rally to meet the heir to the throne that oppresses Ireland." They said, after Fort Sumter, they never heard of the court martial.
00:17:56.242 --> 00:17:58.256
Just these guys going.
00:17:58.617 --> 00:18:06.903
Thomas Francis Meagher, his lieutenant, was a wanted man, wanted in England for escaping prison in Australia.
00:18:07.612 --> 00:18:14.885
And He even recruited the California man with whom he'd once fought a duel in Illinois over Irish slurs.
00:18:15.256 --> 00:18:17.346
everyone's contribution was welcome.
00:18:17.535 --> 00:18:20.939
And you're right, Alan, there were multi-ethnic regiments.
00:18:21.368 --> 00:18:23.518
The Garibaldi Brigade is my favorite,
00:18:23.934 --> 00:18:24.387
Mm-hmm.
00:18:24.575 --> 00:18:30.458
here in New York by a Hungarian, who turned out to be,, a German.
00:18:30.460 --> 00:18:40.817
He was using a false name because he'd been, convicted of stealing horses in Germany, and he organized this multi-ethnic brigade, Hungarians, Italians, French.
00:18:41.735 --> 00:18:47.881
His assumed name was Frederick Dutassi, and he wasn't a bad commander according to his superiors.
00:18:48.302 --> 00:18:55.774
But, army camps were filled with the one thing he could not resist, horses, so he began stealing them.
00:18:56.688 --> 00:19:08.135
um, after about a year in service, he was transferred to a new unit called Sing Sing, and he spent the rest of the war in prison, for horse, stealing.
00:19:08.471 --> 00:19:22.987
It's a mixed bag, but it's a brilliant outreach, even if the results on the field were than Lincoln got when he turned to West Point-trained professionals like Grant and Sherman
00:19:23.384 --> 00:19:36.202
You also show in this terrific book, Harold, that speaking of the brilliance on the battlefield, but also brilliance and innovation, that two of the most important innovations developed during this time that had an impact on the war were developed by
immigrants.
00:19:36.539 --> 00:19:39.933
One was Francis Lieber, who developed the Lieber Code.
00:19:39.933 --> 00:19:44.865
So can you tell us what was that and why is it still held today as a significant development?
00:19:46.221 --> 00:19:55.133
Lincoln and others in the North wanted there to be restraints and formalities in the laws of war.
00:19:56.961 --> 00:20:02.681
so he asked Francis Lieber, who came from a very divided American family.
00:20:02.681 --> 00:20:08.992
Yes, he was, uh, born abroad, but part of his family was loyal to the South and held slaves.
00:20:09.482 --> 00:20:15.171
Lieber, spent most of his time teaching at what was the forerunner of Columbia University.
00:20:16.226 --> 00:20:21.294
engineered a, an honorary degree for Abraham Lincoln during the early days of the war.
00:20:21.501 --> 00:20:32.168
And he devised this humane, realistic code that really has evolved into the international code of conduct of war.
00:20:32.850 --> 00:21:00.105
And, it became really important after Black enlistment began in 1863 because Confederate forces, which had been imprisoning Union captives just like the Union was imprisoning Confederate prisoners of war, um, vowing to shoot or re-enslave or just enslave Black troops if they were captured.
00:21:00.557 --> 00:21:08.612
And they began killing Black soldiers,, at the crater at Olustee who had thrown down their weapons and raised their hands in surrender.
00:21:08.960 --> 00:21:23.130
And Lincoln cited this code as, commanders in chief have cited it in the 200 years since, threatening at one point to kill a Confederate prisoner for every Black soldier who was executed contrary to the code.
00:21:23.366 --> 00:21:31.125
So yeah, that was, a huge and lasting impact on our conduct, by a foreign-born American.
00:21:31.408 --> 00:21:41.342
Yeah., Another immigrant, a Swedish-born immigrant, John Ericsson, designed the first ironclad, and I was really shocked how that was not received well.
00:21:41.625 --> 00:21:44.823
How was Lincoln key to it getting accepted into the Navy?
00:21:44.934 --> 00:21:50.312
Oh, the Navy Board as, the deciding votes,, was not keen on it.
00:21:50.733 --> 00:21:58.603
As you say, Lincoln attended the meeting and saw the half model, which I've held in my hands.
00:21:58.795 --> 00:22:00.039
Oh my goodness.
00:22:00.073 --> 00:22:25.956
Don't know how you could look at this and say,"It's our salvation." But Lincoln, he never liked to overrule, his military men, so he said,"You know, this reminds me of the story of the beautiful woman who put on a pair of stockings." they all looked at him and said,"What do you mean?" And he said,"Well, all the observers who watched that display said,'I think there's something in it.'" And then he left.
00:22:26.431 --> 00:22:33.986
And the military board members looked at each other and said,"Well, what the heck do you think he meant?" They said,"Well, I think he thinks there's something in this proposal.
00:22:33.990 --> 00:22:38.929
We better green-light it." And they green-lit it double time.
00:22:39.634 --> 00:22:50.988
was built, across the East River in Brooklyn, New York, fitted out at the Brooklyn Navy Yard, and got to Hampton Roads, this little ironclad.
00:22:51.191 --> 00:22:52.207
Really not so little.
00:22:52.356 --> 00:22:59.444
If, you've had the opportunity to stand on the scale model at the Mariners' Museum in Newport News, you know it's not a cheese box.
00:22:59.446 --> 00:23:00.096
It's pretty big.
00:23:00.338 --> 00:23:01.808
It's just not as big as a destroyer.
00:23:02.086 --> 00:23:03.749
But it, it's pretty substantial.
00:23:04.129 --> 00:23:18.664
And, on March, 8th, 1862, the Confederate refitted iron-hulled ship CSS Virginia or Merrimack sunk or disabled three wooden warships at Hampton Roads.
00:23:19.488 --> 00:23:23.511
If the Monitor hadn't gotten there the next day, it would've wreaked more havoc.
00:23:23.842 --> 00:23:32.827
But instead, they engaged in the famous first duel of iron ships and fought to a draw, and launched a revolution.
00:23:32.836 --> 00:23:40.246
Not only ironclad vessels, which still the norm, but turrets, gun turrets, which Ericsson designed.
00:23:40.525 --> 00:23:43.315
Now, it malfunctioned at Hampton Roads.
00:23:43.635 --> 00:23:46.139
The turret kept turning and no one could stop it.
00:23:46.909 --> 00:23:50.159
it only shot at the Merrimack, think of something rotating.
00:23:51.068 --> 00:23:54.441
it came back into view, boom, then it would go around slowly.
00:23:54.768 --> 00:23:58.126
But once they perfected it, it was a deadly instrument of war.
00:23:58.212 --> 00:24:01.066
Swedish-born John Ericsson perfected it.
00:24:01.066 --> 00:24:03.673
And you see these contributions all through the war.
00:24:03.678 --> 00:24:08.329
Allan Pinkerton, who was the first military spy, was born in Scotland.
00:24:08.656 --> 00:24:12.709
Mathew Brady, who photographed the war, said he was born in Albany.
00:24:12.710 --> 00:24:17.478
I think he was born on a ship from Ireland, or in Ireland itself.
00:24:17.482 --> 00:24:19.153
For some reason, he didn't like to say that.
00:24:19.525 --> 00:24:24.236
His most famous, assistant, Alexander Gardner, was born in Scotland.
00:24:25.325 --> 00:24:26.716
It's just look up and down.
00:24:27.621 --> 00:24:38.779
You know, 25% of the Union Army, at least, spoke with some kind of foreign accent in the Beginning, the German troops, could not take commands in English.
00:24:39.231 --> 00:24:45.961
There had to be a chain of command that included an interpreter, which was a risky thing not be able to give direct...
00:24:46.116 --> 00:25:01.293
And that's why, I digress, that's why camp musicians were trained to transmit orders in code on the drums or in the bugle to skip that step of,"What did he say?" Say it in English.
00:25:01.517 --> 00:25:16.057
So during the war, despite, having very good relationships with some of these ethnic groups, there were issues an
opposition discontent including riots in New York, uh, that were blamed on Irish Catholic immigrants.
00:25:16.346 --> 00:25:21.966
What then were the sources of this discontent, and how did Lincoln try to address them during the war?
00:25:23.175 --> 00:25:30.448
Well, here I am trying to promote all these great New York accomplishments, and I sort of knew you would get to the draft riots.
00:25:30.585 --> 00:25:31.137
Right
00:25:31.510 --> 00:25:34.480
there were draft riots in, in, in other cities, by the way.
00:25:34.693 --> 00:25:38.418
It's just that New York always has to have the biggest and bloodiest of everything.
00:25:38.418 --> 00:25:40.367
So yes, we had a deadly,
00:25:40.914 --> 00:25:40.992
Mm.
00:25:41.285 --> 00:25:46.639
draft riot, anti-press riot, race riot all rolled up into one.
00:25:46.804 --> 00:25:55.584
And it really began with the Conscription Act of, 1863, which was not a, popular move to say the least.
00:25:55.991 --> 00:25:59.771
But there had been 90-day recruitment, there had been two-year recruitments.
00:26:00.442 --> 00:26:07.804
Union Army desperately needed, manpower, as did the Confederate Army, which embarked on the same of a draft.
00:26:08.706 --> 00:26:12.115
The problem was that the bill was badly crafted.
00:26:12.235 --> 00:26:22.035
It exempted, eligible people who could pay a$300 bounty,'cause the Union needed money as well as it needed men.
00:26:22.477 --> 00:26:37.375
And that ignited the charge it was, a rich man's war but a poor man's fight and remember, newspapers of the day were very, very, politicized and partisan.
00:26:37.853 --> 00:26:45.985
The Democratic press in New York erupted with charges that Lincoln was a tyrant, that he was oppressing poor whites for the benefit of Blacks.
00:26:46.294 --> 00:26:58.543
Because as everybody now knew, starting in January, this war was not really about bringing the country back together again the way it was before secession, as we always warned, and I'm paraphrasing the Democratic press.
00:26:58.816 --> 00:27:00.153
This was about Black people.
00:27:00.158 --> 00:27:08.239
This was about giving them freedom and power, and by the way, they're gonna leave the South, they're gonna come up here to New York and other northern cities.
00:27:08.555 --> 00:27:12.226
They're gonna our jobs take work for less money.
00:27:12.486 --> 00:27:27.684
So it was a toxic, explosive situation fanned into violence by Democratic newspapers and by Democratic politicians who saw it as an opportunity, to beat Lincoln, a year later in the election.
00:27:28.431 --> 00:27:32.056
was also, the conditions were hot.
00:27:32.871 --> 00:27:35.187
And so when the first draft names are called.
00:27:35.239 --> 00:27:44.067
About 10 blocks from here, where I am, somebody threw a rock through a window at a draft office and, a provost marshal's office, and the riot started.
00:27:44.221 --> 00:27:47.719
It was a volatile situation, Democrats versus Republicans.
00:27:47.719 --> 00:27:53.104
It was definitely an Irish I don't think anyone can deny that.
00:27:53.105 --> 00:27:55.418
The archbishop had to kinda stop it.
00:27:56.948 --> 00:27:58.113
how did Lincoln handle it?
00:27:58.802 --> 00:27:59.457
Not great.
00:27:59.597 --> 00:28:00.761
That's my shorthand answer.
00:28:01.327 --> 00:28:03.923
I don't think he realized the gravity of it at first.
00:28:03.934 --> 00:28:06.796
He didn't immediately order an armed response.
00:28:07.540 --> 00:28:08.903
thought it would just die down.
00:28:10.615 --> 00:28:18.415
he joked about it, which is kinda his way when he's nervous uh said,"What general do you want to send?" And he said,"How about General Kilpatrick?
00:28:19.210 --> 00:28:19.410
it?
00:28:19.428 --> 00:28:20.490
Kill Patrick."
00:28:21.575 --> 00:28:21.864
God.
00:28:22.191 --> 00:28:23.557
you know, nobody thought that was funny
00:28:23.850 --> 00:28:24.192
Yeah.
00:28:24.760 --> 00:28:24.920
Mm-hmm.
00:28:24.977 --> 00:28:27.399
His own son was trapped in New York City.
00:28:27.480 --> 00:28:28.653
I, I shouldn't say trapped.
00:28:29.202 --> 00:28:30.419
He kinda got off on it.
00:28:30.431 --> 00:28:46.630
He was en route home from Harvard Lincoln wanted him to get home fast because his wife, Robert's mother, Mary, had been seriously injured in a carriage accident, a week before, and her wounds had become infected.
00:28:47.615 --> 00:28:51.663
And He couldn't pay attention because Mary was at the soldiers' home north of the city.
00:28:51.778 --> 00:28:53.846
He was managing the Battle of Gettysburg.
00:28:53.977 --> 00:29:02.855
He was hoping that General Meade would go after Lee's army and trap it, and Robert is just having a ball watching all this action in New York.
00:29:03.065 --> 00:29:07.750
So that's one of the reasons why Lincoln, I think, did not take it as seriously as he should have.
00:29:08.144 --> 00:29:19.673
Eventually, some of the, soldiers who had been at Gettysburg but not been engaged, were dispatched north on trains and, put down the riots forcibly here,
00:29:20.055 --> 00:29:20.250
Hmm.
00:29:20.250 --> 00:29:20.260
Mm-hmm.
00:29:20.303 --> 00:29:21.836
as did the bishop eventually
00:29:22.223 --> 00:29:28.581
During his presidency, as Lincoln looked at immigration, there's really historic legislation that he supported.
00:29:28.601 --> 00:29:30.586
What were the terms of that legislation?
00:29:31.258 --> 00:29:36.803
Well, it was, the equivalent of the State of the Union message in December,, of'63.
00:29:37.463 --> 00:29:40.723
But in those days, presidents did not give those speeches in person.
00:29:40.791 --> 00:29:50.229
That was a policy that Adams had done, and Jefferson had stopped, and was not to be resumed until Woodrow Wilson delivered the speech in person.
00:29:50.241 --> 00:29:55.533
They would send messages, Lincoln was plenty sick when he wrote this message.
00:29:55.533 --> 00:29:59.795
He could not, I think, have gone and intoned it himself.
00:29:59.796 --> 00:30:13.863
He had come down with smallpox Gettysburg, right after, on the trip home, and it's I believe a much more serious case than historians have He was down for the count for two, two, three weeks.
00:30:15.084 --> 00:30:24.344
Although he said,"You know, send all the office seekers into my bedroom'cause now I have something I can give to everybody." But writing was hard.
00:30:24.344 --> 00:30:30.894
We don't have a copy of this proposal in his writing,'cause I think he just dictated it, he was so wobbly.
00:30:32.284 --> 00:30:35.995
he wanted an act to expand immigration.
00:30:36.106 --> 00:30:46.903
It was specifically the language of his proposal, he wanted the, Homestead Act to extend to immigrants, which was a pretty radical proposal.
00:30:47.341 --> 00:31:07.949
He wanted a new immigration department in the government speed immigration, to make it safer, the ships safer, many of those ships that were bringing people here you know, just kinda overhauled or not so overhauled cargo ships, filled with vermin and bad food, and Lincoln wanted some regulations on that.
00:31:08.367 --> 00:31:15.646
And, he was responding to a need, as he told people and I think the precise language is an act to encourage immigration.
00:31:15.924 --> 00:31:23.908
But as he told Congress, there are shortages not only in the army, but on the farms, in the mines, and in the factories.
00:31:25.062 --> 00:31:26.521
Because we're halfway through the war.
00:31:26.521 --> 00:31:31.829
There's gotta be a couple of hundred thousand people dead or wounded young men.
00:31:32.246 --> 00:31:34.141
He's gotta get some replenishment.
00:31:34.832 --> 00:31:38.389
I also think he wanted immigration, which had dwindled during the war.
00:31:38.448 --> 00:31:41.944
Nobody wants to enter a country that's consumed by a revolution.
00:31:42.382 --> 00:31:44.527
That's what you flee from, not into.
00:31:44.909 --> 00:31:52.597
So Lincoln really felt he needed to stimulate immigration, but he uses the same language he uses for emancipation.
00:31:52.600 --> 00:31:57.586
He never says he is emancipation because Blacks have suffered too long.
00:31:57.953 --> 00:32:06.666
He announces emancipation because the Confederates won't give up the rebellion, and we're gonna punish them by taking away their property in human beings.
00:32:07.459 --> 00:32:11.278
he doesn't think the country will go along with a philanthropic rationale.
00:32:11.640 --> 00:32:13.136
He does the same thing with immigration.
00:32:13.941 --> 00:32:19.459
not doing it because America is the home of freedom and opportunity, which he said not countless times before.
00:32:19.509 --> 00:32:24.447
He's doing it'cause we need more soldiers, more factory workers, more miners, more farmers.
00:32:24.703 --> 00:32:35.502
Um, radically of all, he thinks that there's a case to be made for the federal government to pay for the passage, the ocean voyage of immigrants.
00:32:36.289 --> 00:32:41.668
And that was the bridge too far, I guess, no pun intended, because even the Republicans shied away from that.
00:32:42.545 --> 00:32:46.409
said it would bring in the refuse from the sinks and sewers of Europe.
00:32:46.429 --> 00:32:47.457
They were pretty adamant.
00:32:47.823 --> 00:33:10.314
So Lincoln did not get his way on that, but he did get the other reforms, and he did instruct his government to encourage the creation of a kind of, glossy indenture system so that immigrants could borrow the money for their ocean passage, and then repay it out of their wages or investments over the next five to 10 years.
00:33:10.577 --> 00:33:10.963
Mm-hmm.
00:33:11.209 --> 00:33:14.521
a mortgage on freedom, and opportunity.
00:33:14.710 --> 00:33:15.839
I should have said that in the book.
00:33:15.856 --> 00:33:16.789
It's not a bad line.
00:33:16.799 --> 00:33:24.487
But anyway, immigration is replenished, and Lincoln supported refinements in the act the next year as well.
00:33:24.692 --> 00:33:43.938
And he gets to sign the new bill on July 4th, 1864, and you know he chose it because he wanted to make the case that this was the land of opportunity for people from abroad as well as here, and that the idea that all men are created equal applied to immigrants as well as the native-born
00:33:44.521 --> 00:33:49.687
You state that after his assassination, he was gone, but the immigration plan lived on.
00:33:49.689 --> 00:33:53.045
So how do you see that long-term impact of what he did?
00:33:53.275 --> 00:34:05.758
Well, it lived on immediately because the new bill that he proposed was passed, signed after he died by Andrew Johnson, probably the most sympathetic thing he did as the 17th president.
00:34:06.030 --> 00:34:19.953
I think it was pretty evident to people watching the events of Mid to late April 1865, Lincoln died in the home of a German-born his assassin was killed by a native of Great Britain.
00:34:20.012 --> 00:34:21.706
And commanded by an Irishman.
00:34:21.726 --> 00:34:27.251
You know, Englishmen don't listen to the Irish, so he shot Booth instead of doing what he was told.
00:34:27.679 --> 00:34:41.822
In his New York funeral, his coffin was watched over by Francis Meagher, the Irish colonel who had taken over the 69th Regiment, who had been dismissed for ineptitude and maybe drinking by Ulysses S.
00:34:41.823 --> 00:34:42.143
Grant.
00:34:42.143 --> 00:34:44.771
You know he had to be a drinker if Grant objected.
00:34:45.371 --> 00:34:50.812
And he was serenaded by a German chorus singing, from Wagner operas.
00:34:50.820 --> 00:34:58.584
So it was in everybody's mind that it was a multinational increasingly multiracial society.
00:34:59.062 --> 00:35:02.410
And this sense of opportunity for immigrants did persevere.
00:35:03.092 --> 00:35:09.554
Again in the'80s, Chinese exclusion, which by the way, Lincoln did not object to in his own time.
00:35:09.554 --> 00:35:13.259
He signed a bill reprehensibly called the Coolie Act
00:35:13.598 --> 00:35:13.853
Hmm.
00:35:13.943 --> 00:35:22.620
1862 because his argument was, Chinese laborers are being shipped over in the manner of slave ships, and he wanted to prevent that.
00:35:22.620 --> 00:35:28.665
But I think he also was responding to in California who said,"We don't want any more Chinese
00:35:29.265 --> 00:35:29.433
Mm-hmm.
00:35:29.777 --> 00:35:30.997
undercutting our workforce."
00:35:31.362 --> 00:35:31.814
Mm-hmm.
00:35:32.040 --> 00:35:37.930
uh, he was not always, at the top of his game in terms of sympathy, with immigration.
00:35:37.933 --> 00:35:40.168
And then, it lived on until the'80s.
00:35:40.170 --> 00:36:08.061
And the shocking thing is that the bill that Andrew Johnson signed right after Lincoln's death was the last pro-immigration legislation in America until 100 years later, Lyndon Johnson Signed an act, that at the very least allowed the Southeast Asians who had supported America during the Vietnam War to come to the United States,'cause they certainly were doomed where they were.
00:36:08.641 --> 00:36:22.568
And,, it ended a lot of quotas that had persisted since the 1920s but here we are 61 years after that immigration act with still no further consensus on immigration.
00:36:22.788 --> 00:36:24.052
And there's a lesson here.
00:36:24.052 --> 00:36:24.907
We shouldn't wait.
00:36:25.384 --> 00:36:27.511
You know, if I can expound, I'm not-
00:36:28.188 --> 00:36:29.536
Nice
00:36:30.264 --> 00:36:37.169
any specific policy, but I do think ignoring the issue does not help the United States.
00:36:37.823 --> 00:36:45.782
And, it's time we look to Lincoln again for an example of facing the issue and dealing with it rationally and a little bit sympathetically.
00:36:46.003 --> 00:36:55.759
There's a reason why people wanna come to America, we are the greatest country in the world, and there's a reason why we're the greatest country in the world, because these people came to America
00:36:56.274 --> 00:36:56.548
Yeah.
00:36:56.704 --> 00:37:06.216
Well, well put, and you can do no better than going to Lincoln for advice, and certainly history gives us that perspective, that understanding that we need to address issues like that that still continue.
00:37:06.217 --> 00:37:36.485
So I encourage all of our listeners to go out and buy,"Brought Forth on This Continent: Abraham Lincoln and American Immigration." So at the end of our conversation here, Harold, I'm gonna pivot just for a moment to our previous discussion on"American POTUS" and your book,"Lincoln and the Power of the Press: The War for Public Opinion." After that, you continued and expanded that topic with another book,"The Presidents Versus the Press: The Endless Battle Between the White House and the Media." And I know that Peter Baker fairly recently featured you in The New York Times.
00:37:36.501 --> 00:37:38.151
Peter's been on"American POTUS" as well.
00:37:38.180 --> 00:37:39.272
Oh, he's a good man
00:37:39.547 --> 00:37:44.884
oh, he is, regarding the current White House's actions vis-a-vis certain press outlets.
00:37:45.286 --> 00:37:55.369
And though I have studiously avoided, turning this into a current events podcast, I wonder if you could just tell us a bit about how you believe those current actions fit or don't fit within a historical context.
00:37:55.739 --> 00:38:25.105
Well, I always say whatever President Trump has done does not come near the press pushback that previous presidents have conducted, by whom I mean John Adams, encouraged and signed a law that made it possible to imprison editors who made fun of the president of the United States, and Abraham Lincoln, who imprisoned 60 or 70...
00:38:25.142 --> 00:38:50.932
Well, not he personally, he only imprisoned two, but his administration and his military closed down newspapers, imprisoned editors the Civil War, arguing that they had crossed the line between dissent and treason, and that a rebellion gave him the authority in the Constitution to suspend the writ of habeas corpus and suppress speech and press opinion that was a threat.
00:38:51.859 --> 00:39:03.818
But I also said to Peter Baker and to everyone that, that no one has ever imposed a ban on, a class of journalists that they perceive to be one thing or another.
00:39:03.821 --> 00:39:23.230
In the age of the press conference or the press grip, by the way, my second man, Franklin Roosevelt, in whose New York home I work every day, used to invite the press two times a week into the Oval Office,, and, spar with them 998 times in 12 years.
00:39:23.239 --> 00:39:30.150
Sometimes overseas, sometimes in ships, sometimes in Georgia, sometimes at Hyde Park, but nearly 1,000 press conferences.
00:39:30.308 --> 00:39:33.215
He never said the New York Times can't come.
00:39:34.271 --> 00:39:37.195
He certainly never said CNN can't come because there was no CNN.
00:39:37.355 --> 00:39:37.877
Right
00:39:37.968 --> 00:39:38.255
glib.
00:39:38.472 --> 00:39:43.329
He never banned who opposed him, and there were plenty.
00:39:43.679 --> 00:39:58.404
Chicago Tribune, hated FDR, and what he tried to do was charm them, not fight with them., And that's the lesson of what works because journalists still write the first draft of history in this country.
00:39:59.177 --> 00:40:03.718
Maybe they'll do it electronically or whatever, atmospherically, artificially,
00:40:04.013 --> 00:40:04.023
Right
00:40:04.265 --> 00:40:07.670
artificial intelligence, super intelligence, but they still get to write it.
00:40:07.685 --> 00:40:08.709
Somebody gets to write it.
00:40:09.096 --> 00:40:17.993
And I think presidents do much better in history when they allow for unmitigated access to them
00:40:18.611 --> 00:40:24.563
And again, Harold, you show that your books, um, talking about Abraham Lincoln, but they're extraordinarily current and important today.
00:40:24.563 --> 00:40:26.255
So, thank you for that.
00:40:26.256 --> 00:40:28.875
Thank you for joining us again on American POTUS.
00:40:29.098 --> 00:40:30.751
Are you working on something new right now?
00:40:30.764 --> 00:40:31.765
What's next for you?
00:40:32.400 --> 00:40:35.313
You know, I've got two or three projects in hand.
00:40:35.323 --> 00:40:43.570
One is a book an amazing collector named Robert Turner, who has amassed, an archive of Lincoln's life in Illinois.
00:40:44.440 --> 00:40:48.611
that's gonna be like an album kind of a book published by the University of Illinois Press.
00:40:49.364 --> 00:41:01.398
also doing a book about the journalism, created by a Lincoln artist named Francis Carpenter, who produced the famous painting of Lincoln's reading of the Emancipation Proclamation.
00:41:02.210 --> 00:41:11.819
also produced 80,000 words of journalism even before he wrote a memoir, and I'm putting that together with analysis of how impactful his writing was.
00:41:12.119 --> 00:41:31.098
And then I'm finally getting to my book, about Lincoln from life, about all the artists who portrayed Lincoln, what their interpretive works meant the period and to history and to Lincoln, and how Lincoln was to say,"I'm the homeliest man in Illinois.
00:41:31.837 --> 00:41:38.410
Uh, why do you want my picture?" While absolutely encouraging creation and distribution of his image
00:41:39.923 --> 00:41:42.695
Harold, you make me feel really, really lazy, I must admit.
00:41:42.712 --> 00:41:44.542
Those are a lot of projects you have going on
00:41:44.822 --> 00:41:49.176
It's a lot, but fortunately they're in different stages, so I kinda keep them alive in my head.
00:41:49.466 --> 00:41:49.864
Okay
00:41:50.034 --> 00:41:52.588
people want me to write a memoir.
00:41:52.588 --> 00:41:57.161
I'm not sure anybody else except my best friends care, but I don't know.
00:41:57.498 --> 00:42:07.238
I have a lot of people to write about who are more recent, the people I've encountered, and you know, I'm thinking about that, but that would be a closing chapter for sure
00:42:07.586 --> 00:42:08.904
I will buy that book, Harold.
00:42:08.905 --> 00:42:10.189
Put me on that list, please.
00:42:10.195 --> 00:42:10.464
So
00:42:10.596 --> 00:42:13.535
Okay, I think that, that makes it about eight people so far.
00:42:13.878 --> 00:42:14.876
yes, yes.
00:42:14.904 --> 00:42:15.444
Very good.
00:42:15.864 --> 00:42:17.240
Harold, uh, thank you.
00:42:17.252 --> 00:42:20.569
Thanks for joining us again, and I wanna thank all of our listeners as well.
00:42:20.903 --> 00:42:31.047
Please check out all of our"American POTUS" episodes, as well as episodes of"American FLOTUS," the podcast we produce in partnership with the First Ladies Association for Research and Education.
00:42:31.648 --> 00:42:32.471
Thank you very much.
00:42:32.530 --> 00:42:34.480
I'll see you next time on"American POTUS."