UTSKRIFT 🔗
1
00:00:00,720 --> 00:00:02,910
- Historian, author,
2
00:00:02,910 --> 00:00:06,300
and one of the most requested
guests on this program.
3
00:00:06,300 --> 00:00:09,390
Stephen Kotkin on Uncommon Knowledge. Now
4
00:00:19,140 --> 00:00:20,610
welcome to Uncommon Knowledge.
5
00:00:20,610 --> 00:00:22,890
I'm Peter Robinson, the historian
6
00:00:22,890 --> 00:00:25,380
and author, Stephen Kotkin
is now completing the third
7
00:00:25,380 --> 00:00:28,500
and final volume of his
definitive biography
8
00:00:28,500 --> 00:00:32,250
of Joseph Stalin, a professor
emeritus at Princeton.
9
00:00:32,250 --> 00:00:36,450
Dr. Kotkin is now a fellow
here at the Hoover Institution.
10
00:00:36,450 --> 00:00:40,080
We've done a number of programs
entitled Five Questions
11
00:00:40,080 --> 00:00:41,670
with Stephen Kotkin,
12
00:00:41,670 --> 00:00:45,810
and they have proven Among our
most popular programs today.
13
00:00:45,810 --> 00:00:49,320
Five more questions with Stephen Kotkin.
14
00:00:50,490 --> 00:00:52,980
Stephen number one, Iran.
15
00:00:52,980 --> 00:00:54,390
I'll just give you two quotations
16
00:00:54,390 --> 00:00:56,010
and see what you do with them.
17
00:00:56,010 --> 00:00:57,720
By the way, as we sit
here, I should note that
18
00:00:57,720 --> 00:01:00,630
as we record this show, president Trump,
19
00:01:00,630 --> 00:01:03,300
the Trump administration
is negotiating with Iran.
20
00:01:03,300 --> 00:01:04,800
The outcome of the negotiation
21
00:01:04,800 --> 00:01:07,170
as we sit here is completely unclear.
22
00:01:07,170 --> 00:01:09,690
Two quotations. Here's the editorial board
23
00:01:09,690 --> 00:01:12,060
of the New York Times writing recently.
24
00:01:12,060 --> 00:01:15,450
While President Trump seems
eager for negotiated truce,
25
00:01:15,450 --> 00:01:17,490
Iran's leaders do not.
26
00:01:17,490 --> 00:01:21,960
Somehow the weaker
nation is in the stronger
27
00:01:21,960 --> 00:01:23,850
negotiating position.
28
00:01:23,850 --> 00:01:25,410
Here's the second quotation.
29
00:01:25,410 --> 00:01:27,660
This is Secretary of State Marco Rubio.
30
00:01:27,660 --> 00:01:31,320
Earlier this very month of May,
as President Trump has said,
31
00:01:31,320 --> 00:01:34,050
and as the facts clearly bear out
32
00:01:34,050 --> 00:01:37,350
the United States holds
all the cards close quote,
33
00:01:38,730 --> 00:01:41,430
who's really winning
and how does this end?
34
00:01:42,870 --> 00:01:44,250
- Peter, it's great to be back.
35
00:01:44,250 --> 00:01:48,030
- Thank you.
- It's been nine months, so both
36
00:01:48,030 --> 00:01:50,610
of us could have had a child
since the last time I was on.
37
00:01:51,930 --> 00:01:54,360
You've had some amazing
guests in the meantime,
38
00:01:54,360 --> 00:01:56,160
I've learned quite a bit.
39
00:01:56,160 --> 00:02:01,020
Really big shows you've
had, this is a tough one.
40
00:02:02,400 --> 00:02:04,230
It's where we are now.
41
00:02:04,230 --> 00:02:07,050
It might not
Load full transcript
be the
place I myself would've
42
00:02:07,050 --> 00:02:08,310
chosen to put us.
43
00:02:09,840 --> 00:02:12,570
There's this old joke
that's not very funny.
44
00:02:12,570 --> 00:02:14,520
Someone is in Ireland
45
00:02:14,520 --> 00:02:17,880
and gets lost trying to get to Dublin,
46
00:02:18,900 --> 00:02:21,900
knocks on neighbor's door.
47
00:02:21,900 --> 00:02:23,130
The neighbor opens the door,
48
00:02:23,130 --> 00:02:24,870
and person explains, we're lost.
49
00:02:24,870 --> 00:02:26,070
We're trying to get to Dublin.
50
00:02:27,300 --> 00:02:30,780
And the Irishman says, oh,
if I were going to Dublin,
51
00:02:30,780 --> 00:02:32,220
I'd never start from here.
52
00:02:34,980 --> 00:02:39,120
Alright, so neither would
I, but this is where we are
53
00:02:39,120 --> 00:02:40,500
and we're trying to get to Dublin.
54
00:02:44,280 --> 00:02:48,690
The problem for us is we need things
55
00:02:48,690 --> 00:02:53,070
that the Iranian regime
either refuses to deliver,
56
00:02:53,070 --> 00:02:57,210
cannot deliver, or cannot
sustain over a period of time.
57
00:02:59,890 --> 00:03:02,170
And so we're sort of negotiating
58
00:03:02,170 --> 00:03:03,490
with ourselves at this point.
59
00:03:05,710 --> 00:03:07,390
If you think about Iran
60
00:03:07,390 --> 00:03:09,550
and the Iranian problem
in the Middle East,
61
00:03:10,480 --> 00:03:13,450
the main problem was for Israel
62
00:03:14,470 --> 00:03:17,320
that Iran was an existential threat.
63
00:03:18,580 --> 00:03:22,990
It wasn't only the nuclear
program, which we, along
64
00:03:22,990 --> 00:03:24,970
with the Israelis inflicted very major
65
00:03:24,970 --> 00:03:26,410
damage on back in June.
66
00:03:27,310 --> 00:03:29,380
It was also the ballistic missiles.
67
00:03:29,380 --> 00:03:32,320
Yes, it was also the proxies everywhere,
68
00:03:33,730 --> 00:03:35,920
not just Hamas and Gaza,
69
00:03:35,920 --> 00:03:39,760
but of course Hezbollah in Lebanon,
70
00:03:39,760 --> 00:03:42,160
Syria, and one could go on.
71
00:03:43,210 --> 00:03:46,000
So this was an existential
threat to the Israelis.
72
00:03:46,960 --> 00:03:51,910
And after October 7th, they
were not gonna let this persist.
73
00:03:52,810 --> 00:03:55,090
Iran had encroached more
74
00:03:55,090 --> 00:03:58,510
and more surrounding
Israel with the proxies
75
00:03:58,510 --> 00:04:02,290
and with the strike
capabilities to make the threat
76
00:04:02,290 --> 00:04:04,390
to Israel intolerable.
77
00:04:04,390 --> 00:04:07,660
And October 7th proved to
the Israelis that they needed
78
00:04:07,660 --> 00:04:09,850
to change the strategic situation
79
00:04:11,650 --> 00:04:16,650
for the Israelis degrading
Iran's military abilities
80
00:04:16,780 --> 00:04:20,890
is number one, what might
be a long-term solution,
81
00:04:20,890 --> 00:04:23,470
how we might get to a better place.
82
00:04:23,470 --> 00:04:25,690
That's not necessarily the goal,
83
00:04:25,690 --> 00:04:27,730
- But they had to eliminate
the immediate threat. So
84
00:04:27,730 --> 00:04:29,110
- They have ballistic missiles.
85
00:04:29,110 --> 00:04:31,720
We have to reduce their
ballistic missile threat, right?
86
00:04:31,720 --> 00:04:34,870
They have proxies. We have
to reduce the proxy threat.
87
00:04:34,870 --> 00:04:38,500
And that's been done, that's
been done on an immense scale
88
00:04:39,400 --> 00:04:41,020
in what can only be described
89
00:04:41,020 --> 00:04:43,720
as remarkable tactical operations.
90
00:04:43,720 --> 00:04:47,200
Just stunning the
performance of our military
91
00:04:47,200 --> 00:04:50,020
and the Israeli military
that we can't lose that
92
00:04:51,280 --> 00:04:53,710
fact in our discussion.
93
00:04:53,710 --> 00:04:56,020
But that's enough for the Israelis.
94
00:04:56,020 --> 00:04:57,700
They call this mowing the lawn.
95
00:04:58,840 --> 00:05:01,570
Mowing the lawn is a terrible euphemism.
96
00:05:01,570 --> 00:05:05,200
What it means, again, is
degrading the enemy's capabilities
97
00:05:05,200 --> 00:05:06,200
- For now.
98
00:05:06,200 --> 00:05:09,490
- And then if the enemy builds
back the capabilities you
99
00:05:09,490 --> 00:05:12,160
have to go back and degrade again.
100
00:05:12,160 --> 00:05:16,420
So you're buying time, how
much time you're buying,
101
00:05:16,420 --> 00:05:18,190
you maybe can't be choosy.
102
00:05:18,190 --> 00:05:20,410
You're buying as much as possible.
103
00:05:20,410 --> 00:05:23,470
So for the Israelis, this
is a major strategic game
104
00:05:24,400 --> 00:05:28,720
that Iran has been this
degraded for the United States,
105
00:05:28,720 --> 00:05:31,570
the grand strategy has to be much broader.
106
00:05:31,570 --> 00:05:33,250
Mowing the lawn is insufficient.
107
00:05:34,450 --> 00:05:37,180
It's not just degrading for now,
108
00:05:37,180 --> 00:05:39,520
Iran's ballistic missile capabilities
109
00:05:39,520 --> 00:05:43,210
or degrading for now their
nuclear capabilities.
110
00:05:43,210 --> 00:05:47,980
We need the Iranian regime to stop being
111
00:05:47,980 --> 00:05:50,770
what it is in that region.
112
00:05:50,770 --> 00:05:52,750
And we need that for ourselves
113
00:05:52,750 --> 00:05:56,740
because for 47 years
they've been at war with us.
114
00:05:56,740 --> 00:05:58,040
We need it for our friends
115
00:05:58,040 --> 00:06:01,160
and partners in the region,
not just Israel of course,
116
00:06:01,160 --> 00:06:02,930
but the Gulf Arabs.
117
00:06:02,930 --> 00:06:05,570
We need it for our partners
in the Indo-Pacific
118
00:06:05,570 --> 00:06:07,940
who are reliant on Gulf energy.
119
00:06:08,840 --> 00:06:13,670
And we need it for our
gasoline prices at home
120
00:06:13,670 --> 00:06:16,880
for affordability and standard
of living for our Americans.
121
00:06:18,290 --> 00:06:22,160
And I could go on. And
so what you've got here
122
00:06:22,160 --> 00:06:26,840
is a slight divergence
between an Israeli strategy
123
00:06:26,840 --> 00:06:29,270
of
mowing the lawn, which is more
124
00:06:29,270 --> 00:06:32,120
or less successful on their terms.
125
00:06:32,120 --> 00:06:33,950
They would like to mow it more.
126
00:06:33,950 --> 00:06:35,870
They would like to degrade even further.
127
00:06:35,870 --> 00:06:38,540
But if this is the
extent of the degradation
128
00:06:39,410 --> 00:06:40,988
they've won from they live
point of view, they can with
129
00:06:40,988 --> 00:06:43,730
that, for us, we need something else.
130
00:06:44,570 --> 00:06:46,700
And that's been elusive so far.
131
00:06:47,570 --> 00:06:50,990
And again, maybe we didn't
understand this going in.
132
00:06:52,130 --> 00:06:55,610
So for example, if you
think that the nuclear
133
00:06:57,590 --> 00:06:59,360
question is first
134
00:06:59,360 --> 00:07:03,140
and foremost, you would
wanna plan a commando raid
135
00:07:03,140 --> 00:07:04,820
that's ready to go
136
00:07:04,820 --> 00:07:08,990
to extract the nuclear materials
when Iran is distracted
137
00:07:08,990 --> 00:07:11,150
by the attacks on its leadership compound.
138
00:07:12,080 --> 00:07:13,340
So you would say, okay,
139
00:07:14,510 --> 00:07:17,810
let's take it while they're distracted,
140
00:07:17,810 --> 00:07:20,300
while they're being pummeled by us,
141
00:07:20,300 --> 00:07:23,600
and then we hold the cards.
142
00:07:23,600 --> 00:07:27,260
Instead, the assumption seems to have been
143
00:07:27,260 --> 00:07:30,320
that well will decapitate the regime
144
00:07:30,320 --> 00:07:32,870
and their replacements
will negotiate with us
145
00:07:32,870 --> 00:07:34,610
and just hand us the stuff
146
00:07:34,610 --> 00:07:39,200
because we will have so
struck them with such force
147
00:07:39,200 --> 00:07:41,630
that they will see our power and might and
148
00:07:41,630 --> 00:07:44,090
therefore will bend the knee to us.
149
00:07:44,090 --> 00:07:47,960
So there was no commando
raid to take the nuclear,
150
00:07:47,960 --> 00:07:52,490
the enriched uranium
at whatever grades the
151
00:07:52,490 --> 00:07:53,840
high 60%.
152
00:07:53,840 --> 00:07:56,630
That's really dangerous, but also the 20%.
153
00:07:56,630 --> 00:07:59,540
Now, that wouldn't have
been an easy operation,
154
00:07:59,540 --> 00:08:02,630
but that's the kind of thing
you would've planned to do,
155
00:08:02,630 --> 00:08:05,390
which is now immensely
more difficult to do
156
00:08:05,390 --> 00:08:07,670
because they're not distracted.
157
00:08:07,670 --> 00:08:08,727
- So,
- So, so go ahead.
158
00:08:08,727 --> 00:08:10,790
What we're trying to get to Dublin,
159
00:08:10,790 --> 00:08:12,980
and we wouldn't start from here.
160
00:08:12,980 --> 00:08:16,340
So what do you do? What's the
solution? What's the outcome?
161
00:08:17,390 --> 00:08:22,250
A lot of debates about this,
and I'm not an expert on Iran,
162
00:08:22,250 --> 00:08:24,830
although I know something
about authoritarian regimes
163
00:08:25,790 --> 00:08:28,730
for us, the Iranian regime has failed.
164
00:08:28,730 --> 00:08:30,110
It's failed its own people.
165
00:08:31,430 --> 00:08:36,430
The supreme leader position in
the regime is now destroyed,
166
00:08:36,830 --> 00:08:38,510
likely forever.
167
00:08:38,510 --> 00:08:42,050
People say that the sadden
has replaced the father
168
00:08:42,050 --> 00:08:44,810
who was assassinated in the strikes.
169
00:08:44,810 --> 00:08:48,620
No one has seen or heard
from the son since then.
170
00:08:48,620 --> 00:08:50,810
But even if he's still alive,
171
00:08:50,810 --> 00:08:54,800
and even if he hasn't lost
his face, literally in the,
172
00:08:56,070 --> 00:08:59,550
the position that he occupies
will not be the same,
173
00:08:59,550 --> 00:09:03,030
a supreme arbiter of all
the factions in Iran.
174
00:09:03,030 --> 00:09:06,360
So what you're left with is
the scorpions in the bottle
175
00:09:06,360 --> 00:09:09,000
problem where they don't trust each other.
176
00:09:10,050 --> 00:09:11,850
They are all jockeying.
177
00:09:11,850 --> 00:09:14,640
And moreover, they
can't feed their people.
178
00:09:14,640 --> 00:09:16,440
They don't have any water,
179
00:09:16,440 --> 00:09:19,860
they don't have any
petrol, you know, gasoline.
180
00:09:19,860 --> 00:09:21,120
They don't have any money.
181
00:09:22,170 --> 00:09:23,850
So lacking legitimacy
182
00:09:23,850 --> 00:09:27,570
and lacking all the
fundamentals of basic survival.
183
00:09:27,570 --> 00:09:31,050
So if that regime had to
deal with its own situation,
184
00:09:32,880 --> 00:09:35,400
they would potentially
be in serious trouble.
185
00:09:36,300 --> 00:09:40,050
And so figuring out a
way to force the regime
186
00:09:40,050 --> 00:09:41,910
to confront its failures
187
00:09:41,910 --> 00:09:43,530
and its illegitimacy in front
188
00:09:43,530 --> 00:09:47,310
of its people should be
the way forward for us.
189
00:09:47,310 --> 00:09:49,350
So degrading a little bit more here,
190
00:09:49,350 --> 00:09:51,090
degrading a little bit more there,
191
00:09:51,090 --> 00:09:53,490
buying a little bit more time here,
192
00:09:53,490 --> 00:09:56,400
buying a little bit
more time there at costs
193
00:09:56,400 --> 00:10:01,050
that we don't know what they
might be versus saying, okay,
194
00:10:01,050 --> 00:10:04,890
you own this mess now this is your mess.
195
00:10:04,890 --> 00:10:06,360
Let's see what you can do with it.
196
00:10:07,710 --> 00:10:11,100
And so that turning the
regime in on itself,
197
00:10:12,120 --> 00:10:15,570
the regime strategy has
been a little bit judo,
198
00:10:15,570 --> 00:10:20,570
where the strength of your
opponent becomes your ability
199
00:10:20,850 --> 00:10:23,670
to destabilize your opponent,
200
00:10:23,670 --> 00:10:26,040
turning the tables on your opponent.
201
00:10:26,040 --> 00:10:29,310
We need to do the same thing
with the Iranian regime.
202
00:10:29,310 --> 00:10:33,720
And so I'm not exactly
sure where we're going
203
00:10:33,720 --> 00:10:37,260
because
our own government is
not sure where it's going. So
204
00:10:37,260 --> 00:10:42,240
- Stephen, could I ask,
this is the mistake here.
205
00:10:42,240 --> 00:10:43,680
I won't even call it a mistake.
206
00:10:46,140 --> 00:10:49,980
We have Donald Trump, a
business guy from Queens,
207
00:10:50,910 --> 00:10:54,240
and it feels to me, I'm
putting this though in the form
208
00:10:54,240 --> 00:10:55,980
of a question, correct me.
209
00:10:55,980 --> 00:10:59,580
It feels to me as though at
some basic level he's saying,
210
00:10:59,580 --> 00:11:02,040
why won't these guys come to the table?
211
00:11:02,040 --> 00:11:04,350
We've got an obvious deal to do here.
212
00:11:04,350 --> 00:11:06,870
If they were nice to me,
they let the oil flow
213
00:11:06,870 --> 00:11:10,440
through Horus again, they
turn over the RA uranium,
214
00:11:10,440 --> 00:11:12,840
we can find ways to help them rebuild.
215
00:11:12,840 --> 00:11:13,950
We can do a deal.
216
00:11:15,570 --> 00:11:18,780
But Donald Trump hasn't spent
his life the way you've spent
217
00:11:18,780 --> 00:11:21,450
your life looking at archives, dealing
218
00:11:21,450 --> 00:11:25,260
with authoritarians like of
the likes of Joseph Stalin.
219
00:11:26,460 --> 00:11:30,150
The notion of the these,
the kinds of people who
220
00:11:30,150 --> 00:11:34,290
populate the Iranian regime
are the kinds of people
221
00:11:34,290 --> 00:11:38,670
who are willing to machine
gun 30,000 of their own people
222
00:11:38,670 --> 00:11:40,620
as they did in protests a few months ago,
223
00:11:40,620 --> 00:11:42,570
before the war began.
224
00:11:42,570 --> 00:11:45,870
Even as Stalin is willing to
wipe out the higher reaches
225
00:11:45,870 --> 00:11:50,250
of his own party in purge after purge,
226
00:11:50,250 --> 00:11:54,190
and to submit people, that kind of person,
227
00:11:54,190 --> 00:11:58,690
the determined ideologue, who
really is in some basic way
228
00:11:59,650 --> 00:12:01,180
willing to choose death first.
229
00:12:01,180 --> 00:12:02,290
He'll choose death for millions
230
00:12:02,290 --> 00:12:03,700
of his own people if he has to.
231
00:12:04,540 --> 00:12:07,240
But this is just not the kind of person
232
00:12:07,240 --> 00:12:08,800
who will sit down and do a deal.
233
00:12:08,800 --> 00:12:10,900
Is that correct? And if that's correct,
234
00:12:12,940 --> 00:12:14,680
it makes everything harder.
235
00:12:14,680 --> 00:12:17,020
- Sadly, I think you're spot on.
236
00:12:20,170 --> 00:12:22,600
What would a deal entail for them?
237
00:12:22,600 --> 00:12:27,070
They live for the destruction of US power
238
00:12:27,070 --> 00:12:28,540
and the destruction of Israel.
239
00:12:30,250 --> 00:12:33,730
This is the Islamic revolutionary guards.
240
00:12:35,050 --> 00:12:40,050
This is not Iranian. Even
this is something beyond Iran.
241
00:12:40,630 --> 00:12:42,400
- They, they're not trying
to recapture the great
242
00:12:42,400 --> 00:12:43,510
power of Persia.
243
00:12:44,740 --> 00:12:48,310
- They would have different
policies if they were pro Iran.
244
00:12:50,590 --> 00:12:54,940
And so yes, they don't want a deal
245
00:12:56,020 --> 00:12:58,770
the way that we understand
a deal, which is
246
00:12:58,770 --> 00:13:01,210
to say we concede something.
247
00:13:01,210 --> 00:13:02,440
They concede something.
248
00:13:04,960 --> 00:13:07,030
And so our ability to negotiate
249
00:13:07,030 --> 00:13:10,990
with them has always been
limited by our inability
250
00:13:10,990 --> 00:13:14,110
to understand who they
are and what they are.
251
00:13:14,950 --> 00:13:17,470
That's not to say that this
was the right approach.
252
00:13:18,310 --> 00:13:21,520
I'm not a regime change type, but
253
00:13:21,520 --> 00:13:25,480
nor am I a capitulation type
where you can't do anything.
254
00:13:25,480 --> 00:13:27,490
So I've been arguing for years
255
00:13:27,490 --> 00:13:31,600
that you turn these regimes
against themselves, right?
256
00:13:31,600 --> 00:13:36,600
You try to make them see that
257
00:13:36,700 --> 00:13:41,440
the factions inside the regime
258
00:13:41,440 --> 00:13:46,440
who are disappointed, either
from thwarted ambition,
259
00:13:46,750 --> 00:13:51,370
they're not the ones at feeding
at the trough their rivals
260
00:13:51,370 --> 00:13:54,700
are, or because they're
generally see seeing
261
00:13:54,700 --> 00:13:56,800
that the strategy is failing.
262
00:13:56,800 --> 00:14:00,790
You try to appeal to them to
turn against their own regime.
263
00:14:01,750 --> 00:14:06,490
So the success in Venezuela, which has
264
00:14:06,490 --> 00:14:08,650
yet to be accompanied by elections,
265
00:14:08,650 --> 00:14:10,840
we have not imposed elections on them,
266
00:14:10,840 --> 00:14:12,490
which I think was a mistake.
267
00:14:13,330 --> 00:14:17,050
But the fact that we were able
to turn that regime on itself
268
00:14:17,050 --> 00:14:21,070
and change its strategy oriented from
269
00:14:21,070 --> 00:14:25,630
anti-US to dealing with
the US on US terms.
270
00:14:27,760 --> 00:14:28,900
And then the,
271
00:14:28,900 --> 00:14:31,690
the final stage would be
confronting their own people,
272
00:14:31,690 --> 00:14:33,310
their own illegitimacy
273
00:14:33,310 --> 00:14:36,460
and unpopularity through
an electoral process
274
00:14:36,460 --> 00:14:40,690
that may come still, that
success misled us into thinking
275
00:14:40,690 --> 00:14:43,000
that the Iranian regime was similar
276
00:14:43,000 --> 00:14:45,460
and had similar motivations.
277
00:14:45,460 --> 00:14:48,310
Also, we don't really
understand what a regime is.
278
00:14:49,150 --> 00:14:52,880
We think a regime as just a
bunch of at the top right,
279
00:14:52,880 --> 00:14:54,650
but a regime is a society.
280
00:14:55,700 --> 00:14:59,330
So sure Iran's 90 plus million people
281
00:15:00,170 --> 00:15:02,300
predominantly against this regime.
282
00:15:02,300 --> 00:15:04,490
They hate this
regime and for good reason.
283
00:15:05,390 --> 00:15:07,520
So let's say that that's 70 million
284
00:15:07,520 --> 00:15:10,250
or 80 million, it's hard to say,
285
00:15:10,250 --> 00:15:14,840
but it's some very large number
of Iranians, Iranian society
286
00:15:14,840 --> 00:15:16,040
that detest the regime.
287
00:15:17,120 --> 00:15:20,180
But the problem is
there's still 20 million,
288
00:15:20,180 --> 00:15:24,020
or at least 10 million
who are pro regime willing
289
00:15:24,020 --> 00:15:25,730
to die for the regime.
290
00:15:25,730 --> 00:15:29,120
That's the society that
constitutes the regime.
291
00:15:29,120 --> 00:15:32,750
I once wrote a book called
Uncivil Society about
292
00:15:32,750 --> 00:15:33,770
this very problem.
293
00:15:35,030 --> 00:15:38,960
And so it's not just
decapitating this leader
294
00:15:38,960 --> 00:15:41,720
or that leader, it's uprooting
295
00:15:41,720 --> 00:15:45,980
or co-opting the society
that represents the regime.
296
00:15:45,980 --> 00:15:49,820
Remember these, for these
people in the bo for example,
297
00:15:49,820 --> 00:15:53,090
the paramilitaries that
did a lot of that killing
298
00:15:53,090 --> 00:15:55,370
that you referred to earlier, for them,
299
00:15:55,370 --> 00:15:58,070
this is upward mobility,
this is social mobility.
300
00:15:58,070 --> 00:16:00,560
They don't have a lot of life choices.
301
00:16:00,560 --> 00:16:01,730
Joining the regime
302
00:16:01,730 --> 00:16:02,870
and becoming part
303
00:16:02,870 --> 00:16:06,230
of the regimes repressive
apparatus is a ticket
304
00:16:06,230 --> 00:16:10,370
to a better way of life for many people in
305
00:16:10,370 --> 00:16:12,500
dead end situations.
306
00:16:12,500 --> 00:16:14,420
And then there are many
people in the regime
307
00:16:14,420 --> 00:16:18,320
that are ideologically committed,
as you said, to the death
308
00:16:18,320 --> 00:16:21,230
of the United States, the death of Israel.
309
00:16:21,230 --> 00:16:22,520
This is what they live for,
310
00:16:22,520 --> 00:16:26,000
and this is their soul, all legitimacy.
311
00:16:27,350 --> 00:16:30,860
Without that, what can they fall back on?
312
00:16:30,860 --> 00:16:34,130
They didn't raise the standard
of living, they depressed it.
313
00:16:34,130 --> 00:16:37,190
They didn't make Iran a great
power. Iran's a weak power.
314
00:16:38,450 --> 00:16:42,680
And so for a large part
of Iranian society,
315
00:16:43,940 --> 00:16:47,450
the regime and the society are one.
316
00:16:47,450 --> 00:16:52,450
And so if you are trying to uproot this
317
00:16:52,880 --> 00:16:57,880
anti-US phenomenon that is ruling Iran,
318
00:16:58,100 --> 00:17:00,260
it's deeper than you think.
319
00:17:00,260 --> 00:17:02,900
It has roots that you don't understand.
320
00:17:02,900 --> 00:17:07,760
And 10 million loyalists
with guns is a lot
321
00:17:07,760 --> 00:17:12,760
to overcome, especially when
the civilians don't have guns.
322
00:17:12,920 --> 00:17:15,230
-
And when we don't want to commit troops,
323
00:17:15,230 --> 00:17:19,190
- Well, they know that we don't
wanna pay costs like that.
324
00:17:19,190 --> 00:17:21,980
And remember, this is
not our first time there.
325
00:17:21,980 --> 00:17:24,320
We did it on one side of Iran
326
00:17:24,320 --> 00:17:26,660
and then we did it on
the other side of Iran.
327
00:17:26,660 --> 00:17:28,040
And we all know,
328
00:17:28,040 --> 00:17:30,530
and the Iranians too,
how those worked out,
329
00:17:30,530 --> 00:17:33,260
whether you're talking about
Iraq or Afghanistan, right?
330
00:17:34,100 --> 00:17:38,120
And so that regime is
in really big trouble.
331
00:17:38,120 --> 00:17:41,480
They've been, they were
not in good shape before
332
00:17:41,480 --> 00:17:44,000
and they've been hurt very badly.
333
00:17:44,000 --> 00:17:46,250
And so how could we use the trouble
334
00:17:46,250 --> 00:17:48,560
that they're in against them?
335
00:17:48,560 --> 00:17:50,880
That's gotta be the
strategy going forward.
336
00:17:50,880 --> 00:17:53,190
It should have been the
strategy at the beginning.
337
00:17:53,190 --> 00:17:54,930
Again, we are where we are.
338
00:17:54,930 --> 00:17:57,930
We still need to get the Dublin from here.
339
00:17:57,930 --> 00:18:01,410
And so we need to turn
that regime against itself.
340
00:18:01,410 --> 00:18:06,120
When they first went to
Pakistan for the negotiations,
341
00:18:06,120 --> 00:18:07,890
this is an incredible story.
342
00:18:09,030 --> 00:18:12,000
Iran got the bomb from Pakistan.
343
00:18:13,590 --> 00:18:17,250
That's where they got the
bomb from the Pakistanis.
344
00:18:17,250 --> 00:18:21,360
And now they're going to Pakistan
to negotiate their nuclear
345
00:18:22,260 --> 00:18:24,840
program with us.
346
00:18:24,840 --> 00:18:27,420
They're going to the place
that they got the bomb from,
347
00:18:27,420 --> 00:18:29,520
and we're hoping they're
now gonna give up the bomb
348
00:18:29,520 --> 00:18:32,460
that they got from Pakistan
while back in Pakistan.
349
00:18:33,630 --> 00:18:37,770
So that seemed to me highly
improbable, especially
350
00:18:37,770 --> 00:18:40,620
because many people have drawn the lesson
351
00:18:40,620 --> 00:18:44,280
that having a nuclear bomb is
the only way the regime can
352
00:18:44,280 --> 00:18:47,730
guarantee it won't be attacked
like we see in the North
353
00:18:47,730 --> 00:18:49,110
Korean case, as you know.
354
00:18:49,110 --> 00:18:53,340
Well. And so here they are,
they've gone to Pakistan
355
00:18:53,340 --> 00:18:57,240
where they got the bomb to
supposedly negotiate the bomb
356
00:18:58,620 --> 00:19:03,450
wherever they took 70 people
who brings a delegation
357
00:19:03,450 --> 00:19:06,090
of 70 people to negotiate something.
358
00:19:07,050 --> 00:19:09,300
It's clear that they
don't trust each other.
359
00:19:09,300 --> 00:19:11,520
They're watching each other.
360
00:19:11,520 --> 00:19:14,250
And in fact, when the
leader of their delegation,
361
00:19:14,250 --> 00:19:19,020
the Speaker of Parliament,
Libba, got back to Iran,
362
00:19:19,950 --> 00:19:22,200
the hardliners reprimanded him
363
00:19:22,200 --> 00:19:26,280
for allowing the Iranian
nuclear program to be part
364
00:19:26,280 --> 00:19:27,900
of the discussions he made.
365
00:19:27,900 --> 00:19:30,390
No concessions, but just
the fact that he allowed it
366
00:19:30,390 --> 00:19:32,070
to be part of the discussions.
367
00:19:32,070 --> 00:19:36,330
And so there was quite
a internal struggle over
368
00:19:36,330 --> 00:19:37,710
that very question.
369
00:19:37,710 --> 00:19:39,750
And he himself is a hardliner being
370
00:19:39,750 --> 00:19:41,280
attacked by the other hard line.
371
00:19:41,280 --> 00:19:45,270
So that's our moment of
opportunity that we have to realize
372
00:19:45,270 --> 00:19:49,860
with the Iranian regime that
they are in big trouble.
373
00:19:49,860 --> 00:19:51,960
And we shouldn't lift them out of trouble.
374
00:19:53,070 --> 00:19:55,260
We shouldn't give them a hand so
375
00:19:55,260 --> 00:19:57,600
that they can fight another day.
376
00:19:57,600 --> 00:20:01,860
We should make them
confront their own failures
377
00:20:01,860 --> 00:20:05,970
with their own society and
their own mal governance.
378
00:20:05,970 --> 00:20:07,380
That's gotta be our strategy.
379
00:20:08,460 --> 00:20:11,640
- China, in the New York
Times earlier this month,
380
00:20:11,640 --> 00:20:16,440
Ross Dovid cites a number of
China's gathering problems,
381
00:20:16,440 --> 00:20:19,980
sinking fertility, raked slowing economy,
382
00:20:20,940 --> 00:20:24,030
so forth, slowing economic growth
383
00:20:24,030 --> 00:20:26,730
and slowing, relative
slowing even more relative
384
00:20:26,730 --> 00:20:28,740
to the growth of our own economy.
385
00:20:28,740 --> 00:20:32,730
And then Ross doubt it writes,
quote, it seems reasonable
386
00:20:32,730 --> 00:20:35,940
to bet that Beijing's power is peaking.
387
00:20:35,940 --> 00:20:39,360
Now, I would expect the
Chinese to have a plan
388
00:20:39,360 --> 00:20:42,390
for confrontation very, very soon.
389
00:20:44,250 --> 00:20:49,180
The Chinese moment, the moment
maximum danger for Taiwan
390
00:20:49,180 --> 00:20:53,590
and for us is right now,
Steven, you buy that.
391
00:20:55,300 --> 00:20:57,580
- By the way, I have to
say that I don't know
392
00:20:57,580 --> 00:20:59,260
what questions you're gonna ask me.
393
00:20:59,260 --> 00:21:00,735
- You don't even ask to,
394
00:21:00,735 --> 00:21:02,500
- I, you don't wanna
discuss it. I have no idea.
395
00:21:02,500 --> 00:21:04,330
- This is the mark of a real pro, Steven.
396
00:21:04,330 --> 00:21:06,190
- And so you come in, sit
- Down, and off we go.
397
00:21:06,190 --> 00:21:08,230
- You ask really difficult questions
398
00:21:08,230 --> 00:21:10,150
with these fabulous quotes and,
399
00:21:10,150 --> 00:21:13,300
and I'm now on the spot to try to come up
400
00:21:13,300 --> 00:21:14,650
with something intelligent.
401
00:21:14,650 --> 00:21:18,190
I, that's one of the great
reasons I love this show
402
00:21:19,660 --> 00:21:21,580
because of the preparation that you do,
403
00:21:21,580 --> 00:21:23,920
but also that you, I'm
sort of thrown, I more
404
00:21:23,920 --> 00:21:26,110
- Or less refuse to permit you to prepare.
405
00:21:26,110 --> 00:21:27,940
- I'm sort of thrown to the lions here.
406
00:21:31,030 --> 00:21:34,420
One person is making
the decisions in China,
407
00:21:34,420 --> 00:21:37,870
and we don't know how that person thinks.
408
00:21:37,870 --> 00:21:40,060
We have a lot of suppositions about
409
00:21:40,060 --> 00:21:42,310
how the person might be thinking.
410
00:21:42,310 --> 00:21:45,375
We take this indicator
and that indicator and,
411
00:21:45,375 --> 00:21:48,550
and then we think, how would we
412
00:21:48,550 --> 00:21:52,570
react in those situations
with those facts?
413
00:21:52,570 --> 00:21:55,390
It might well be that he
doesn't think like us,
414
00:21:56,950 --> 00:21:59,980
that his calculus is very, very different.
415
00:21:59,980 --> 00:22:02,440
That his indicators are
very, very different.
416
00:22:02,440 --> 00:22:05,470
That his information is
very, very different.
417
00:22:06,610 --> 00:22:11,200
So what we can do is not
speculate about the one person's
418
00:22:11,200 --> 00:22:16,200
decision possibilities,
but about capabilities
419
00:22:16,870 --> 00:22:20,680
and where things stand in terms of
420
00:22:21,940 --> 00:22:23,020
their capabilities.
421
00:22:23,020 --> 00:22:26,050
Our capabilities, our friends and allies
422
00:22:26,050 --> 00:22:27,490
and those trendlines.
423
00:22:29,260 --> 00:22:32,230
China clearly is
424
00:22:32,230 --> 00:22:35,080
obsessed with Taiwan.
425
00:22:35,080 --> 00:22:38,860
That's true of the society,
let alone the leadership.
426
00:22:38,860 --> 00:22:41,740
And the top leader himself
427
00:22:41,740 --> 00:22:46,030
has exhibited this behavior
publicly that we can see
428
00:22:46,030 --> 00:22:47,590
of fixation on Taiwan.
429
00:22:48,490 --> 00:22:51,640
He wants Taiwan, they want Taiwan.
430
00:22:51,640 --> 00:22:53,710
So if he were to pass away tomorrow,
431
00:22:54,610 --> 00:22:56,560
they would still want Taiwan.
432
00:22:56,560 --> 00:23:00,820
Mao wanted Taiwan. Deng
Xing wanted Taiwan.
433
00:23:00,820 --> 00:23:04,090
Chiang Kai-shek the nationalist leader
434
00:23:04,090 --> 00:23:06,640
before the Chinese won the Civil War.
435
00:23:06,640 --> 00:23:07,900
He wanted Taiwan.
436
00:23:08,740 --> 00:23:12,760
So this is a fundamental
challenge for us, regardless of
437
00:23:12,760 --> 00:23:16,270
who the leader is, but it,
especially with this leader,
438
00:23:16,270 --> 00:23:17,890
given his public statements.
439
00:23:18,970 --> 00:23:21,880
But they don't wanna pay any price for it,
440
00:23:21,880 --> 00:23:23,350
they just want it for free.
441
00:23:25,000 --> 00:23:27,040
They wanna win the war without fighting.
442
00:23:29,260 --> 00:23:34,240
And so they want us and or the
Taiwanese to hand it to them.
443
00:23:35,470 --> 00:23:38,590
They wanna use coercive economic pressure,
444
00:23:38,590 --> 00:23:40,270
coercive diplomacy
445
00:23:41,740 --> 00:23:44,530
and trades where they trade us.
446
00:23:44,530 --> 00:23:48,080
Nothing. You know,
president Trump will buy
447
00:23:48,080 --> 00:23:49,820
those soybeans, right?
448
00:23:49,820 --> 00:23:51,320
For the third time,
449
00:23:51,320 --> 00:23:55,070
the same soybeans in exchange potentially
450
00:23:55,070 --> 00:23:57,890
for some public statement on Taiwan
451
00:23:57,890 --> 00:24:00,740
or for slowing down
452
00:24:00,740 --> 00:24:04,730
or even canceling the agreed
weapon sales to Taiwan, which
453
00:24:04,730 --> 00:24:09,560
of course the Congress would not abide the
454
00:24:09,560 --> 00:24:11,930
termination of those weapon sales.
455
00:24:11,930 --> 00:24:14,690
But all I'm saying is
they want this for free.
456
00:24:14,690 --> 00:24:17,360
Either they want a Taiwanese leader
457
00:24:17,360 --> 00:24:20,690
who is freely elected
from the opposition party
458
00:24:21,620 --> 00:24:26,570
to quote, negotiate Taiwan's entrance into
459
00:24:27,680 --> 00:24:28,790
communist China.
460
00:24:29,990 --> 00:24:31,400
Or they want us
461
00:24:31,400 --> 00:24:34,400
to push a Taiwanese
leader in that direction.
462
00:24:36,380 --> 00:24:38,840
They will fight to take it.
463
00:24:38,840 --> 00:24:41,960
If Taiwan declares its independence
464
00:24:43,820 --> 00:24:46,970
and they are clearly
465
00:24:46,970 --> 00:24:49,610
communists are clearly gonna lose Taiwan,
466
00:24:49,610 --> 00:24:51,260
then they will have no choice
467
00:24:51,260 --> 00:24:54,320
but to pay any price
to physically take it.
468
00:24:55,760 --> 00:24:59,990
But in the meantime,
they want it for free.
469
00:24:59,990 --> 00:25:03,050
They certainly will
take it if the threat is
470
00:25:03,050 --> 00:25:06,590
that Taiwan will be not
def facto independence,
471
00:25:06,590 --> 00:25:08,120
but Dejure independence
472
00:25:08,120 --> 00:25:10,250
that we would recognize
their independence.
473
00:25:10,250 --> 00:25:12,410
In the meantime, they
have the capabilities
474
00:25:12,410 --> 00:25:14,600
to take it potentially.
475
00:25:14,600 --> 00:25:16,100
Now, they haven't tried it yet.
476
00:25:16,100 --> 00:25:18,560
They haven't fought a war in a long time,
477
00:25:18,560 --> 00:25:21,680
but Taiwan Strai is a very big theater.
478
00:25:21,680 --> 00:25:24,890
It's the size of the
Mediterranean Theater for those
479
00:25:24,890 --> 00:25:26,300
who know their geography.
480
00:25:27,170 --> 00:25:29,540
And so maybe they can,
and maybe they can't,
481
00:25:29,540 --> 00:25:32,000
but they're building the
capabilities to do this.
482
00:25:32,000 --> 00:25:33,800
And this is the main thing
483
00:25:33,800 --> 00:25:37,220
that they've been doing this
massive military modernization.
484
00:25:37,220 --> 00:25:40,310
So what are we doing in response
485
00:25:40,310 --> 00:25:42,740
or what should we do in response to that?
486
00:25:44,990 --> 00:25:49,460
Well, we need stocks of
certain types of weapons,
487
00:25:49,460 --> 00:25:54,080
for example, to make sure that
488
00:25:54,080 --> 00:25:58,940
they perceive very high costs
for moving against Taiwan.
489
00:25:59,810 --> 00:26:02,750
Well, we expended those stocks in Iran.
490
00:26:04,220 --> 00:26:08,030
So the, the global inventory
491
00:26:08,030 --> 00:26:12,980
of patriot missile
interceptors, one of the best
492
00:26:12,980 --> 00:26:16,820
missile interceptors ever built.
493
00:26:16,820 --> 00:26:20,180
The global inventory
prior to the Iran war that
494
00:26:21,680 --> 00:26:23,180
we controlled, not our friends
495
00:26:23,180 --> 00:26:27,560
and allies controlled that
we controlled was maybe 1800,
496
00:26:27,560 --> 00:26:30,710
somewhere between 1800, 1900, probably
497
00:26:32,630 --> 00:26:36,920
we expended more than 1200 in a month.
498
00:26:36,920 --> 00:26:41,210
- Two third two gone.
- Not only did we expend about
499
00:26:41,210 --> 00:26:46,020
1200 of the, we only bill 600
500
00:26:46,020 --> 00:26:47,190
or six 50 a year.
501
00:26:48,840 --> 00:26:51,570
So replenishing those stocks takes time.
502
00:26:52,440 --> 00:26:55,800
Plus a patriot missile
interceptor costs about
503
00:26:55,800 --> 00:26:59,100
$3.6 million each.
504
00:27:00,540 --> 00:27:04,380
And a suicide drone
505
00:27:04,380 --> 00:27:08,460
or a Shah head Iranian drone,
Shah head martyr drone,
506
00:27:10,080 --> 00:27:12,390
It costs in the neighborhood of 30,000.
507
00:27:13,290 --> 00:27:16,110
So you take a $3.6 million
508
00:27:18,000 --> 00:27:22,620
missile that knocks
something out of the sky
509
00:27:22,620 --> 00:27:24,840
and that thing costs 30,000.
510
00:27:24,840 --> 00:27:25,890
And you do that once.
511
00:27:25,890 --> 00:27:30,600
You do that twice, you do
that a thousand plus times,
512
00:27:30,600 --> 00:27:32,880
it's not really a good
calculus for you, is it?
513
00:27:34,170 --> 00:27:36,720
Even before you get to the
issue of replenishing them,
514
00:27:37,980 --> 00:27:42,240
Japan agreed to purchase 400
tomahawk missiles from the
515
00:27:42,240 --> 00:27:44,880
United States in two batches, 200
516
00:27:44,880 --> 00:27:48,240
and 200 by around 2028 delivery.
517
00:27:49,500 --> 00:27:53,130
That's not enough. But
it's really important.
518
00:27:53,130 --> 00:27:57,510
Japan has agreed to acquire
long strike capabilities
519
00:27:57,510 --> 00:28:01,740
to be able to hit China
from the Japanese mainland.
520
00:28:01,740 --> 00:28:03,330
And that's what the tomahawks do.
521
00:28:03,330 --> 00:28:05,610
They can reach the Japanese coast.
522
00:28:05,610 --> 00:28:07,530
That's a fabulous deterrent.
523
00:28:07,530 --> 00:28:10,050
And Japan had prohibitions
against this,
524
00:28:10,050 --> 00:28:12,750
and they've broken through
the prohibitions in a
525
00:28:12,750 --> 00:28:14,490
remarkable story.
526
00:28:14,490 --> 00:28:19,290
Well, we just told the Japanese
that those 400 tomahawks
527
00:28:19,290 --> 00:28:20,700
that we've agreed to sell them
528
00:28:21,540 --> 00:28:24,000
will not be delivered on time.
529
00:28:24,000 --> 00:28:26,580
They'll be delivered
with significant delay.
530
00:28:27,450 --> 00:28:29,280
We're not sure exactly how long,
531
00:28:29,280 --> 00:28:33,660
but certainly way beyond
the original 2028.
532
00:28:33,660 --> 00:28:35,670
And I could go on. Yeah, so,
533
00:28:35,670 --> 00:28:37,320
so if you're looking at all the stuff
534
00:28:37,320 --> 00:28:42,090
that we should be doing, not
knowing China's intentions,
535
00:28:42,090 --> 00:28:44,580
but seeing their capabilities.
536
00:28:44,580 --> 00:28:47,310
If you're looking at the
stuff we should be doing,
537
00:28:47,310 --> 00:28:51,000
expending munitions in the Middle East
538
00:28:52,170 --> 00:28:55,800
versus building up stockpiles
539
00:28:56,640 --> 00:28:59,670
for the Indo-Pacific,
if you weighed those,
540
00:28:59,670 --> 00:29:02,940
I'm sure like me, you'd
come out on the side
541
00:29:02,940 --> 00:29:04,170
of not expending.
542
00:29:05,100 --> 00:29:09,660
And by the way, Ukraine
has very cost effective
543
00:29:09,660 --> 00:29:13,500
and battlefield effective
anti drone technology
544
00:29:15,000 --> 00:29:18,540
that our Gulf Arabs
are now buying at scale
545
00:29:18,540 --> 00:29:21,210
to ramp up Ukrainian production
546
00:29:21,210 --> 00:29:24,360
that are really good at knocking
these Iranian drones outta
547
00:29:24,360 --> 00:29:27,450
the sky, but at really reasonable cost,
548
00:29:27,450 --> 00:29:31,920
unlike a $3.6 million patriot interceptor,
549
00:29:31,920 --> 00:29:34,110
of which we produce too few.
550
00:29:34,110 --> 00:29:39,110
So why aren't we going
to Ukraine, the Walmart
551
00:29:39,150 --> 00:29:41,200
of defense tech
552
00:29:41,200 --> 00:29:43,750
and buying up everything we can,
553
00:29:44,650 --> 00:29:48,010
investing in their production processes,
554
00:29:48,010 --> 00:29:52,150
licensing their technology to
build it not just in Ukraine,
555
00:29:52,150 --> 00:29:54,220
expand their production capabilities,
556
00:29:54,220 --> 00:29:55,840
which are mostly underground,
557
00:29:55,840 --> 00:29:58,180
but build them elsewhere
558
00:29:58,180 --> 00:30:02,320
with Ukrainian technology
through licensing.
559
00:30:02,320 --> 00:30:05,530
We are agreeing to raise
our military budget
560
00:30:05,530 --> 00:30:08,680
to $1.5 trillion a year.
561
00:30:08,680 --> 00:30:10,690
What should we be buying with that?
562
00:30:10,690 --> 00:30:15,460
Shouldn't we be buying
precision mass, low cost,
563
00:30:15,460 --> 00:30:18,310
cost effective, battlefield effective,
564
00:30:19,150 --> 00:30:23,080
massive volume effective weapons
565
00:30:23,080 --> 00:30:25,090
for the 21st century?
566
00:30:25,090 --> 00:30:29,830
And so Ukraine is a
massive asset in the story
567
00:30:29,830 --> 00:30:31,870
of the Indo-Pacific,
568
00:30:31,870 --> 00:30:35,445
where we think they're
mutually exclusive, right?
569
00:30:35,445 --> 00:30:37,780
And, and so I have
570
00:30:37,780 --> 00:30:40,840
to say things are a little
bit backwards the way we're
571
00:30:40,840 --> 00:30:42,190
approaching them right now.
572
00:30:42,190 --> 00:30:43,900
- Let's go to Ukraine.
573
00:30:43,900 --> 00:30:47,020
Early in the war, you
argued, I'm quoting you here
574
00:30:47,020 --> 00:30:51,580
for an armistice, and we did
a couple of shows on this
575
00:30:51,580 --> 00:30:53,500
and you and I had conversations
over lunch about it.
576
00:30:53,500 --> 00:30:56,380
You were arguing, you
argued that the long armes
577
00:30:56,380 --> 00:30:58,090
that is now taking place in Korea
578
00:30:59,350 --> 00:31:02,950
had resulted in a vibrant
democratic South Korea,
579
00:31:02,950 --> 00:31:06,160
which was a huge victory for the West.
580
00:31:06,160 --> 00:31:07,780
And again, let me quote
you, here you are in an
581
00:31:07,780 --> 00:31:08,950
interview with the New Yorker.
582
00:31:08,950 --> 00:31:11,200
We need an arm, I'm quoting
you. We need an armes.
583
00:31:11,200 --> 00:31:13,060
We need the Ukrainians to get some type
584
00:31:13,060 --> 00:31:14,830
of security guarantee,
585
00:31:14,830 --> 00:31:17,440
which is about not just deterring Russia,
586
00:31:17,440 --> 00:31:20,170
but enabling a successful
society in Ukraine.
587
00:31:21,400 --> 00:31:22,510
That quotation
588
00:31:22,510 --> 00:31:25,030
and that interview in the
New Yorker was in 2023.
589
00:31:25,030 --> 00:31:26,770
So about two years ago.
590
00:31:26,770 --> 00:31:28,870
Here's Walter Russell Mead
writing in the Wall Street
591
00:31:28,870 --> 00:31:32,650
Journal about his visit to
Ukraine earlier this month.
592
00:31:32,650 --> 00:31:36,520
I'm quoting Walter quote,
the so-called realists need
593
00:31:36,520 --> 00:31:39,100
to recalibrate Ukraine is matching
594
00:31:39,100 --> 00:31:41,410
and often surpassing
Russia's best efforts in
595
00:31:41,410 --> 00:31:42,700
military technology.
596
00:31:42,700 --> 00:31:43,900
This is the point you just made.
597
00:31:43,900 --> 00:31:45,940
- Yes,
- Russian power and the authority
598
00:31:45,940 --> 00:31:50,560
and integrity of the Putin
estate is being ground down.
599
00:31:50,560 --> 00:31:54,190
Ukraine, by contrast, appears
to be gaining close. Quote.
600
00:31:56,320 --> 00:31:58,960
This is, we used to talk,
not, not you and me,
601
00:31:58,960 --> 00:32:00,310
but we used
602
00:32:00,310 --> 00:32:03,190
to talk in the United States
about the Ukrainian forces
603
00:32:03,190 --> 00:32:04,570
being ground down.
604
00:32:04,570 --> 00:32:05,830
And here's Walter Russell Mead
605
00:32:05,830 --> 00:32:06,940
flipping this
and saying this.
606
00:32:06,940 --> 00:32:09,280
Now the Russians who
are being ground down,
607
00:32:09,280 --> 00:32:11,410
do we still need an pharmacist?
608
00:32:11,410 --> 00:32:14,770
Is Ukraine somehow in a
position, have things changed
609
00:32:14,770 --> 00:32:17,680
so much that Ukraine could win?
610
00:32:17,680 --> 00:32:20,020
What, what, what, what has happened there?
611
00:32:20,020 --> 00:32:22,540
It sounds like very good news,
but what does it mean for us?
612
00:32:24,610 --> 00:32:28,690
- Yeah. So I've been talking
about this since 2022,
613
00:32:30,190 --> 00:32:33,460
and people have come around
614
00:32:33,460 --> 00:32:38,290
or came around to the South
Korean, the Armistice,
615
00:32:38,290 --> 00:32:40,130
south Korean analogy,
616
00:32:41,510 --> 00:32:46,010
and that became a big BA bandwagon
that everybody jumped on.
617
00:32:46,010 --> 00:32:49,880
And now again, we're back to 2023.
618
00:32:49,880 --> 00:32:54,140
Ukraine's gonna win, which
didn't work in 2023. Correct?
619
00:32:54,140 --> 00:32:58,730
So the problem is defining
the war in terms of territory.
620
00:32:59,870 --> 00:33:01,700
That's been the problem
from the beginning.
621
00:33:02,600 --> 00:33:05,540
So I was telling people
that Russia won the war,
622
00:33:06,650 --> 00:33:11,650
and they won it already
in 2014 by taking Crimea
623
00:33:11,930 --> 00:33:14,720
and part of Eastern
Ukraine, so-called Donbass
624
00:33:16,160 --> 00:33:19,640
without Ukrainian
resistance, and with European
625
00:33:19,640 --> 00:33:24,640
and American capitulation
626
00:33:24,650 --> 00:33:27,890
in those facts, those
that Russian land grabbed.
627
00:33:27,890 --> 00:33:31,340
And then Russia at 2022
grabbed more land so
628
00:33:31,340 --> 00:33:34,100
that they now had a land
bridge between the two pieces
629
00:33:34,100 --> 00:33:36,230
that they grabbed in 2014.
630
00:33:36,230 --> 00:33:39,650
So now they have this
full Eastern corridor
631
00:33:39,650 --> 00:33:41,780
- From the donbas around
down to the Crimea.
632
00:33:41,780 --> 00:33:43,670
- Yeah, they took the littoral.
633
00:33:43,670 --> 00:33:45,950
And that's what happened in 2022.
634
00:33:45,950 --> 00:33:47,810
So that's been, that's happened.
635
00:33:48,920 --> 00:33:53,060
That's why the idea of
negotiation is not Munich.
636
00:33:53,060 --> 00:33:57,290
You see what happened at
Munich in 1938 is Chamberlain
637
00:33:57,290 --> 00:33:59,390
and Dier of France.
638
00:33:59,390 --> 00:34:03,860
They gave Hitler the
sate and lot right here.
639
00:34:03,860 --> 00:34:07,010
Nobody's given anybody anything Putin.
640
00:34:07,010 --> 00:34:09,230
He took it, he has it.
641
00:34:09,230 --> 00:34:11,690
And if you can't get it
back on the battlefield,
642
00:34:11,690 --> 00:34:13,550
what are you gonna do about it?
643
00:34:13,550 --> 00:34:16,760
Expand lives and treasure
644
00:34:16,760 --> 00:34:19,880
and not rebuild your country
in the meantime, trying
645
00:34:19,880 --> 00:34:21,530
to get back this territory.
646
00:34:22,940 --> 00:34:27,260
And so I said, Russia's won
the war in territorial terms,
647
00:34:29,210 --> 00:34:32,180
but this is not a territorial battle.
648
00:34:33,620 --> 00:34:35,120
This is a battle for sovereignty.
649
00:34:37,010 --> 00:34:40,070
And Ukraine won the battle
for sovereignty when they
650
00:34:40,910 --> 00:34:45,680
stopped Russia from seizing
the capital Kiev, that was it.
651
00:34:47,150 --> 00:34:50,390
They lost the territorial
battle in the east.
652
00:34:50,390 --> 00:34:53,750
They won the bigger battle of sovereignty.
653
00:34:53,750 --> 00:34:55,880
So now let's take that victory
654
00:34:55,880 --> 00:35:00,500
and consolidate it by
stopping the fighting,
655
00:35:00,500 --> 00:35:05,090
because we cannot get back to
territory at acceptable cost.
656
00:35:05,090 --> 00:35:07,610
That's what each year has proven.
657
00:35:07,610 --> 00:35:09,380
We may get it back eventually.
658
00:35:10,220 --> 00:35:14,090
Russia may collapse from its own failures,
659
00:35:15,110 --> 00:35:18,020
therefore, do not concede the territory.
660
00:35:19,395 --> 00:35:22,850
Do not allow Russia's
annexation of the territory
661
00:35:22,850 --> 00:35:24,680
to be legalized.
662
00:35:24,680 --> 00:35:28,040
Just stop the fighting
at the line of contact,
663
00:35:29,360 --> 00:35:32,330
which is the current battlefield location.
664
00:35:32,330 --> 00:35:34,520
That's what an armistice does.
665
00:35:34,520 --> 00:35:37,590
You don't say, okay, the
territory is yours now you see,
666
00:35:37,590 --> 00:35:39,300
I can't get it back in the meantime,
667
00:35:39,300 --> 00:35:41,130
but we're gonna stop the fighting.
668
00:35:41,130 --> 00:35:43,890
And the advantage of stopping
the fighting is I get
669
00:35:43,890 --> 00:35:45,600
to rebuild my country.
670
00:35:45,600 --> 00:35:48,390
Yes, the parts that I control
671
00:35:48,390 --> 00:35:53,100
and launch myself on the
pathway to South Korea,
672
00:35:53,100 --> 00:35:57,270
which would be the best
possible outcome for Ukraine.
673
00:35:57,270 --> 00:35:59,130
This territory in the east
674
00:35:59,130 --> 00:36:02,310
that I cannot regain
militarily on the battlefield
675
00:36:03,720 --> 00:36:05,160
is a moonscape.
676
00:36:07,020 --> 00:36:09,750
It's not valuable territory.
677
00:36:09,750 --> 00:36:12,960
It was rust belt industry before the war.
678
00:36:14,730 --> 00:36:18,600
What I have that's really
valuable is I have this country
679
00:36:18,600 --> 00:36:22,560
called Ukraine and I
defended its sovereignty.
680
00:36:22,560 --> 00:36:26,550
And I have really entrepreneurial,
ingenious, brave people
681
00:36:27,600 --> 00:36:31,170
who are showing in the
defense industrial complex
682
00:36:31,170 --> 00:36:34,020
that they've built
largely underground, just
683
00:36:34,020 --> 00:36:35,820
how amazing they are
684
00:36:35,820 --> 00:36:39,900
and how they're iterating on
the battlefield in, in a week,
685
00:36:39,900 --> 00:36:41,340
sometimes in a day.
686
00:36:41,340 --> 00:36:43,710
Mm, with software updates.
687
00:36:43,710 --> 00:36:47,370
We are still thinking about
a software update for some
688
00:36:47,370 --> 00:36:49,710
of our stuff that's as old as we are.
689
00:36:49,710 --> 00:36:52,560
- So Stephen, you are saying
there's been a huge growth
690
00:36:53,400 --> 00:36:58,050
in human capital in
Ukraine during the war.
691
00:36:58,050 --> 00:36:59,460
In some basic way,
692
00:36:59,460 --> 00:37:04,020
Ukraine is richer today than
it was richer, more modern,
693
00:37:04,020 --> 00:37:05,160
more integratable
694
00:37:05,160 --> 00:37:07,920
with the West than it
was when Putin invaded in
695
00:37:07,920 --> 00:37:09,540
2022. Is that correct?
696
00:37:09,540 --> 00:37:12,810
- Yes. That's what Putin has lost.
697
00:37:12,810 --> 00:37:14,700
But I wanna consolidate that.
698
00:37:14,700 --> 00:37:15,990
- You wanna take it to the bank?
699
00:37:15,990 --> 00:37:19,860
- Yes. And I don't want it
to be only defense tech.
700
00:37:19,860 --> 00:37:24,300
I want it to be civilian
industry. I want it to be housing.
701
00:37:24,300 --> 00:37:26,730
I want it to be new schools.
702
00:37:26,730 --> 00:37:31,140
I want it to be a Ukraine
that looks more like Poland
703
00:37:32,070 --> 00:37:34,290
rather than a battlefield.
704
00:37:34,290 --> 00:37:37,170
Poland is the greatest success
705
00:37:37,170 --> 00:37:39,570
of modern Europe in our lifetimes.
706
00:37:40,440 --> 00:37:45,440
Sweden is competing with
Poland at a smaller scale
707
00:37:45,900 --> 00:37:48,600
because Sweden rolled
back its welfare state
708
00:37:48,600 --> 00:37:49,770
- And joined nato.
709
00:37:49,770 --> 00:37:53,640
- Yes. And so Sweden is a
remarkable success story too,
710
00:37:53,640 --> 00:37:55,680
at a smaller scale than Poland
711
00:37:55,680 --> 00:37:59,070
and the Nordics in general,
the Baltics as well.
712
00:37:59,070 --> 00:38:02,670
There's a northeastern transformed Europe
713
00:38:02,670 --> 00:38:03,780
that is breathtaking.
714
00:38:04,800 --> 00:38:08,340
The Europe that we have in
our mind that's stagnant,
715
00:38:08,340 --> 00:38:10,410
that strangles with regulation,
716
00:38:10,410 --> 00:38:11,940
- Italy, France, now the uk,
717
00:38:11,940 --> 00:38:15,600
this stagnant political
situation in the uk.
718
00:38:15,600 --> 00:38:18,180
- There's a different
Europe that's emerged
719
00:38:18,180 --> 00:38:21,960
that Ukraine could be a
part of that's inspiring.
720
00:38:21,960 --> 00:38:25,080
But I need to stop the battlefield
721
00:38:26,010 --> 00:38:28,200
armistice at the front line.
722
00:38:28,200 --> 00:38:30,150
So Putin went to Trump.
723
00:38:30,150 --> 00:38:32,370
Trump offered Putin a lot,
724
00:38:32,370 --> 00:38:35,920
and Putin didn't take it,
which just goes to show you
725
00:38:35,920 --> 00:38:38,650
that he's gonna do this
until his last breath.
726
00:38:38,650 --> 00:38:43,120
Potentially. What Trump did
727
00:38:43,990 --> 00:38:47,950
was he said, okay, this
is a land deal again,
728
00:38:47,950 --> 00:38:50,475
like a real estate magnet,
you know, like dealing
729
00:38:50,475 --> 00:38:52,120
with the Iranian mulls
730
00:38:52,120 --> 00:38:56,290
and A-I-R-G-C,
731
00:38:56,290 --> 00:38:58,480
A mentality that doesn't correspond
732
00:38:58,480 --> 00:39:00,160
to who's on the other side of the table.
733
00:39:01,090 --> 00:39:04,600
And he said, well, we'll give
you the rest of the donbas.
734
00:39:04,600 --> 00:39:07,300
Is that enough? And then
you'll stop the fighting.
735
00:39:09,940 --> 00:39:13,000
And so the Ukrainians objected to this
736
00:39:13,000 --> 00:39:16,630
because the Ukrainians are killing 15
737
00:39:16,630 --> 00:39:19,150
to 20,000 Russians a month.
738
00:39:20,740 --> 00:39:24,970
About 30 to 35,000 Russian casualties
739
00:39:24,970 --> 00:39:26,920
with a much higher proportion of,
740
00:39:26,920 --> 00:39:31,120
of dead than is normally
the case in casualties
741
00:39:31,120 --> 00:39:33,940
to move inches on the battlefield,
742
00:39:34,810 --> 00:39:36,940
maybe even being pushed backwards.
743
00:39:37,960 --> 00:39:41,380
So Ukraine says the space
that Putin is asking Trump
744
00:39:41,380 --> 00:39:46,330
to hand over to him is
space that the Russians,
745
00:39:46,330 --> 00:39:49,750
if they take it, it
would be years from now
746
00:39:49,750 --> 00:39:51,790
and it would be 800,000
747
00:39:51,790 --> 00:39:56,260
or another million Russian
casualties to get that space.
748
00:39:56,260 --> 00:39:59,410
So that's U Ukrainian strategy right now,
749
00:39:59,410 --> 00:40:03,280
- Make them pay
- Exact, the highest possible price
750
00:40:03,280 --> 00:40:06,220
for every inch of territory
751
00:40:06,220 --> 00:40:09,250
rather than hand over that territory.
752
00:40:09,250 --> 00:40:12,340
So my argument has never
been to hand over anything.
753
00:40:13,270 --> 00:40:18,270
It has always been to stop the
fighting at the current line.
754
00:40:18,640 --> 00:40:20,920
Maybe in the future they'll get it back,
755
00:40:20,920 --> 00:40:24,160
but in the meantime, it's
advantageous for Ukraine
756
00:40:24,160 --> 00:40:25,450
to get its country back
757
00:40:25,450 --> 00:40:28,120
and to build that, use that ingenuity
758
00:40:28,120 --> 00:40:31,990
and that human capital above
ground rather than just
759
00:40:31,990 --> 00:40:34,060
below ground in the defense industrial.
760
00:40:34,060 --> 00:40:36,490
So Ukraine has come to this realization
761
00:40:37,360 --> 00:40:41,560
that territory might not be the
most important consideration
762
00:40:42,580 --> 00:40:44,710
and that their sovereignty
in their country
763
00:40:44,710 --> 00:40:47,890
and their future is the most
important consideration.
764
00:40:47,890 --> 00:40:50,830
What they achieve that I got wrong,
765
00:40:51,820 --> 00:40:53,650
and I got it wrong in a big way,
766
00:40:54,550 --> 00:40:57,430
is they've massively reduced
767
00:40:57,430 --> 00:41:00,250
their own casualties on the battlefield.
768
00:41:01,090 --> 00:41:05,140
I was looking at the casualty
numbers for a small country
769
00:41:05,140 --> 00:41:08,740
that had peaked at about
50 million population
770
00:41:08,740 --> 00:41:12,700
and is now about 27 million with six
771
00:41:12,700 --> 00:41:14,440
or seven in exile,
772
00:41:14,440 --> 00:41:17,770
including school children in
their fifth year of school
773
00:41:17,770 --> 00:41:19,600
or fourth year of school
in a foreign language,
774
00:41:19,600 --> 00:41:20,740
- Learning other languages,
775
00:41:20,740 --> 00:41:24,070
- And therefore maybe not
maybe lost to Ukraine's future.
776
00:41:24,070 --> 00:41:26,140
- Yes.
- Because they're, they've been in school
777
00:41:26,140 --> 00:41:29,770
for four years in Polish
or in German, or in English
778
00:41:29,770 --> 00:41:30,940
or or in, you name it.
779
00:41:32,110 --> 00:41:35,900
And so I was at that calculation
saying a war of attrition
780
00:41:35,900 --> 00:41:39,380
where Ukraine was losing less than Russia,
781
00:41:39,380 --> 00:41:41,420
but not that much less
than Russia, you know,
782
00:41:41,420 --> 00:41:42,710
fewer casualties,
783
00:41:42,710 --> 00:41:46,010
but still high casualties that this was an
784
00:41:47,120 --> 00:41:48,560
emergency and
785
00:41:48,560 --> 00:41:51,890
therefore they desperately
needed this armistice to preserve
786
00:41:51,890 --> 00:41:54,170
that human capital for their future,
787
00:41:54,170 --> 00:41:55,850
including their 20 year olds.
788
00:41:57,020 --> 00:41:59,750
And so what they've done,
which I did not anticipate
789
00:41:59,750 --> 00:42:04,220
and got wrong, was they
have not had to use
790
00:42:04,220 --> 00:42:09,220
as many people to degrade
Russia more recently
791
00:42:09,470 --> 00:42:14,120
because of their drone
mastery, not just in the air,
792
00:42:14,120 --> 00:42:16,370
but also on the ground.
793
00:42:16,370 --> 00:42:21,320
So they now have these
little sort of buggies
794
00:42:22,250 --> 00:42:25,430
that are completely
autonomous on the battlefield
795
00:42:26,360 --> 00:42:29,600
that can blow themselves
up like a kamikaze,
796
00:42:29,600 --> 00:42:31,790
like a suicide drone, right?
797
00:42:31,790 --> 00:42:34,730
But blow them up on land
798
00:42:34,730 --> 00:42:37,580
or retrieve bodies so that they don't have
799
00:42:37,580 --> 00:42:41,960
to send risk lives to
bring back their dead
800
00:42:41,960 --> 00:42:45,860
or their wounded, which
every great army does.
801
00:42:45,860 --> 00:42:49,640
Yes. It doesn't leave their
people on the battlefield
802
00:42:49,640 --> 00:42:51,470
wounded or even dead.
803
00:42:51,470 --> 00:42:55,280
And so they've been able to
do this autonomously now.
804
00:42:55,280 --> 00:42:59,900
And so Ukraine has
drastically reduced the amount
805
00:42:59,900 -->
00:43:03,650
of casualties it is suffering
in the battle with Russia.
806
00:43:03,650 --> 00:43:06,650
So that's another
accomplishment. Give them credit.
807
00:43:06,650 --> 00:43:09,710
And again, I say, I admit
that I got that part wrong,
808
00:43:10,670 --> 00:43:15,470
but the part that I insist I
got right was not territory,
809
00:43:15,470 --> 00:43:20,470
but sovereignty and rebuilding
Ukraine with the armistice.
810
00:43:20,540 --> 00:43:23,720
Again, if Russia collapses, great,
811
00:43:23,720 --> 00:43:27,230
and if Russia loses that
territory, retreats flees from
812
00:43:27,230 --> 00:43:29,750
that territory, fabulous.
813
00:43:29,750 --> 00:43:33,980
But starting yesterday,
let's rebuild Ukraine,
814
00:43:33,980 --> 00:43:38,600
get it on that trajectory,
South Korea, the pinnacle,
815
00:43:38,600 --> 00:43:40,555
or Poland, the neighboring example,
816
00:43:42,080 --> 00:43:45,560
and integrate Ukraine
into those structures
817
00:43:45,560 --> 00:43:48,650
as an asset rather than a liability.
818
00:43:48,650 --> 00:43:51,500
If you were looking at the
US assets across the world
819
00:43:51,500 --> 00:43:55,430
and doing an inventory, Ukraine
820
00:43:55,430 --> 00:43:59,180
and Taiwan would be up
there really, really high
821
00:43:59,180 --> 00:44:03,470
as major US assets, phenomenal assets
822
00:44:03,470 --> 00:44:06,590
that we could benefit
even more from Taiwan.
823
00:44:06,590 --> 00:44:07,850
It's pretty clear because
824
00:44:07,850 --> 00:44:09,560
of the semiconductor industry, right?
825
00:44:10,550 --> 00:44:13,370
Ukraine, it's the defense tech industry.
826
00:44:13,370 --> 00:44:16,190
We keep talking about the
defense innovation unit,
827
00:44:16,190 --> 00:44:18,500
which is right outside this door.
828
00:44:18,500 --> 00:44:21,260
We talk about all of the great
829
00:44:22,460 --> 00:44:26,630
tech driven software
driven new companies in the
830
00:44:26,630 --> 00:44:27,650
space like and drill
831
00:44:27,650 --> 00:44:31,110
- Down in El Segundo,
- Andal, Palantir.
832
00:44:31,110 --> 00:44:34,950
And one could go on and that
they've been the leading edge
833
00:44:34,950 --> 00:44:37,890
and others are following
in their footsteps.
834
00:44:37,890 --> 00:44:39,570
That's what Ukraine is already.
835
00:44:39,570 --> 00:44:42,060
And Andel and Palantir are in Ukraine
836
00:44:42,060 --> 00:44:43,320
collaborating with them.
837
00:44:43,320 --> 00:44:46,260
Exactly. And we need global scale there
838
00:44:46,260 --> 00:44:50,040
and it certainly will get
the attention of our friends,
839
00:44:50,040 --> 00:44:53,340
right, not just in Moscow,
but also in Beijing.
840
00:44:53,340 --> 00:44:56,490
- You just mentioned American
assets around the world.
841
00:44:56,490 --> 00:45:00,270
So let me take you from Iran and China
842
00:45:00,270 --> 00:45:03,330
and Ukraine to the
United States of America
843
00:45:04,290 --> 00:45:06,840
and our standing in the world
to quotations once
again.
844
00:45:06,840 --> 00:45:10,080
- Hmm.
- Christopher Caldwell
845
00:45:10,080 --> 00:45:13,380
and the Claremont review
of books this spring quote,
846
00:45:13,380 --> 00:45:16,260
it is tempting to ask where in the process
847
00:45:16,260 --> 00:45:20,760
of imperial decline the United
States now finds itself.
848
00:45:20,760 --> 00:45:22,650
It certainly has elements in common
849
00:45:22,650 --> 00:45:26,550
with Britain a century
ago, de industrializing,
850
00:45:26,550 --> 00:45:28,425
overcommitted, complacent.
851
00:45:30,325 --> 00:45:32,340
Victor Davis Hansen, our friend
852
00:45:32,340 --> 00:45:36,630
and colleague writing
just last week quote.
853
00:45:36,630 --> 00:45:41,100
Supposedly we are like an
exhausted British empire in 1945
854
00:45:41,100 --> 00:45:43,440
and China is the new superpower.
855
00:45:43,440 --> 00:45:46,770
Yet according to nearly every
historical measure of power,
856
00:45:46,770 --> 00:45:51,000
the US leads China by
sizable margins in wealth,
857
00:45:51,000 --> 00:45:55,500
economic output, fuel,
food, military strength.
858
00:45:55,500 --> 00:45:56,760
Close quote,
859
00:45:58,500 --> 00:46:02,100
Britain seeded its role in
the world to the United States
860
00:46:03,030 --> 00:46:05,670
just so the United States
is now seeding its role
861
00:46:05,670 --> 00:46:08,460
to China or not.
862
00:46:08,460 --> 00:46:10,140
Steven.
863
00:46:10,140 --> 00:46:12,840
- Yeah, I think you're
not gonna be surprised
864
00:46:12,840 --> 00:46:15,270
that I'm gonna side with Victor here.
865
00:46:15,270 --> 00:46:19,320
Alright? But this is a complicated story
866
00:46:19,320 --> 00:46:21,810
that we can't really do in soundbites.
867
00:46:21,810 --> 00:46:23,880
Like those great quotes
that you just read,
868
00:46:24,990 --> 00:46:26,550
Britain didn't seed anything.
869
00:46:27,540 --> 00:46:30,960
We took it, we took it from them.
870
00:46:32,340 --> 00:46:36,240
Everyone knows Sue, as
in 56 when the British
871
00:46:36,240 --> 00:46:39,450
and the French decided they
were gonna do something
872
00:46:40,410 --> 00:46:41,760
and Eisenhower said no.
873
00:46:43,140 --> 00:46:47,040
So they didn't seed,
they went reluctantly.
874
00:46:47,040 --> 00:46:50,610
And we seized that position, we seized it
875
00:46:50,610 --> 00:46:54,450
because we are 25%
876
00:46:54,450 --> 00:46:59,450
of global GDP 150 years.
877
00:46:59,550 --> 00:47:03,330
That unheard of in global history
878
00:47:03,330 --> 00:47:07,710
that a power has sustained
for that length of time,
879
00:47:07,710 --> 00:47:10,470
such a position economically.
880
00:47:10,470 --> 00:47:13,470
We're only 5% of global population
881
00:47:13,470 --> 00:47:17,190
and 25% of global GDP
since 1880 and pulling
882
00:47:17,190 --> 00:47:20,070
- Away,
- We were a bigger economy
883
00:47:20,070 --> 00:47:21,780
when Britain ran the world.
884
00:47:23,700 --> 00:47:28,410
So nobody seeded anything.
Alright, that's one thing.
885
00:47:28,410 --> 00:47:30,400
But here's your challenge.
886
00:47:30,400 --> 00:47:34,480
You see there's an
anomalous period from 1946
887
00:47:34,480 --> 00:47:35,620
to 1960.
888
00:47:37,390 --> 00:47:40,990
We were not 25% of global GDP,
889
00:47:40,990 --> 00:47:45,990
we were 40% of global GDP
in the 46 to 60 period
890
00:47:46,330 --> 00:47:48,520
and 50% of global manufacturing.
891
00:47:50,320 --> 00:47:52,570
There's never been anything like that.
892
00:47:52,570 --> 00:47:53,890
And there may never be again.
893
00:47:55,090 --> 00:47:58,720
So it's an anomalous period
even by US standards,
894
00:47:58,720 --> 00:48:01,960
which are phenomenal, 40% of global GDP
895
00:48:01,960 --> 00:48:05,835
and 50% of global manufacturing
because of World War II
896
00:48:05,835 --> 00:48:07,450
and the destruction of Europe
897
00:48:07,450 --> 00:48:09,640
and the destruction of East Asia.
898
00:48:09,640 --> 00:48:13,240
It was that anomalous
period where we decided
899
00:48:13,240 --> 00:48:16,180
to take on responsibility
for the whole world.
900
00:48:18,490 --> 00:48:22,030
And when you're 40% of global
GDP and half of manufacturing,
901
00:48:22,030 --> 00:48:24,070
and for a time you have
a nuclear monopoly,
902
00:48:24,070 --> 00:48:27,760
and I could go on, you can make
a speech like Kennedy did in
903
00:48:27,760 --> 00:48:30,850
his inaugural of bearing any burden
904
00:48:30,850 --> 00:48:32,350
- Opposing any foal.
905
00:48:32,350 --> 00:48:33,730
- What a great speech that is.
906
00:48:33,730 --> 00:48:35,830
It's one of the great speeches
that you didn't write,
907
00:48:38,050 --> 00:48:43,050
but okay, so that wasn't gonna last.
908
00:48:43,240 --> 00:48:45,460
That anomalous period wasn't gonna last.
909
00:48:45,460 --> 00:48:49,270
And in fact we reverted to the 25% again,
910
00:48:49,270 --> 00:48:50,560
which is already phenomenal.
911
00:48:52,000 --> 00:48:54,970
But we didn't readjust
our global commitments.
912
00:48:58,120 --> 00:49:00,160
Not only did we revert back
913
00:49:00,160 --> 00:49:04,870
to the 25% astonishing
number from the 40%,
914
00:49:04,870 --> 00:49:06,280
but that was the plan.
915
00:49:07,960 --> 00:49:09,160
That was our intention.
916
00:49:09,160 --> 00:49:13,240
That was the post-war
order led by America.
917
00:49:13,240 --> 00:49:15,820
That was its reason for being.
918
00:49:15,820 --> 00:49:18,730
We were gonna lift everybody back up
919
00:49:18,730 --> 00:49:22,330
because that was gonna guarantee
our peace and prosperity.
920
00:49:23,290 --> 00:49:27,550
And so Marshall Plan and
reintegrating Japan as a friend.
921
00:49:27,550 --> 00:49:28,600
So Hitler
922
00:49:28,600 --> 00:49:33,280
and Hirohito Japan became our
two most important allies.
923
00:49:33,280 --> 00:49:35,500
And we had just fought an existential war
924
00:49:35,500 --> 00:49:37,000
to the death against both of them.
925
00:49:37,840 --> 00:49:39,640
When has that ever happened?
926
00:49:39,640 --> 00:49:44,640
So the plan was to revive our foes,
927
00:49:44,710 --> 00:49:48,070
our wartime enemies and
the rest of the world, and
928
00:49:48,070 --> 00:49:52,570
therefore self-consciously
to reduce our proportion.
929
00:49:53,530 --> 00:49:57,940
So not only was it gonna
happen organically over time,
930
00:49:57,940 --> 00:50:01,870
but it was gonna happen
with the positive outcome
931
00:50:01,870 --> 00:50:03,940
that our friends would rise.
932
00:50:03,940 --> 00:50:08,410
So we did that and it succeeded
beyond our wildest dreams,
933
00:50:08,410 --> 00:50:12,130
but we didn't adjust our commitments.
934
00:50:13,660 --> 00:50:17,920
We only kept gaining more
and more commitments.
935
00:50:19,240 --> 00:50:22,630
You saw the trouble in
the seventies when Nixon
936
00:50:22,630 --> 00:50:26,125
and Kissinger came up with Deante, right?
937
00:50:26,125 --> 00:50:28,970
Deante is not a strategy of strength,
938
00:50:28,970 --> 00:50:30,110
- Right? Right.
939
00:50:30,110 --> 00:50:32,840
- Deante is when you
feel like maybe you can't
940
00:50:32,840 --> 00:50:34,490
handle everything anymore.
941
00:50:34,490 --> 00:50:36,380
- Detant is buying for time,
- Playing for
942
00:50:36,380 --> 00:50:37,380
- Time.
943
00:50:37,380 --> 00:50:40,130
- Maybe you have to adjust
your commitments a little bit.
944
00:50:40,130 --> 00:50:43,130
There were some specific
circumstances of weakness having
945
00:50:43,130 --> 00:50:46,070
to do with the fiasco in Vietnam.
946
00:50:46,070 --> 00:50:51,070
And we, a war we lost
having to do with the
947
00:50:51,170 --> 00:50:54,650
first oil shock of 73,
948
00:50:54,650 --> 00:50:57,170
which we didn't inflict on ourselves,
949
00:50:57,170 --> 00:51:00,710
but were afflicted by the
Gulf Arabs in response to
950
00:51:01,790 --> 00:51:05,210
the war against Israel in 73.
951
00:51:05,210 --> 00:51:06,680
That hurt us really badly.
952
00:51:06,680 --> 00:51:08,930
The the oil shock and the rust belt
953
00:51:08,930 --> 00:51:13,760
and Nixon's mischief or criminality,
954
00:51:13,760 --> 00:51:17,150
however you wanna define it,
which led to his resignation
955
00:51:17,150 --> 00:51:18,380
before he was impeached.
956
00:51:18,380 --> 00:51:20,780
The great role that Barry Goldwater
957
00:51:20,780 --> 00:51:22,130
played in that of course.
958
00:51:23,300 --> 00:51:27,740
But then we got this
second wind out of nowhere,
959
00:51:28,640 --> 00:51:33,620
a governor from California,
a former movie actor,
960
00:51:33,620 --> 00:51:35,750
decided it was mourning in America
961
00:51:35,750 --> 00:51:40,640
and applied exactly what was
needed to reinvigorate us.
962
00:51:40,640 --> 00:51:44,450
And the Soviet Union decided to collapse
963
00:51:45,740 --> 00:51:49,340
doing us this massive
favor, collapsing more
964
00:51:49,340 --> 00:51:50,780
or less peacefully, yes,
965
00:51:50,780 --> 00:51:54,350
allowing German unification
on Western terms.
966
00:51:54,350 -->
00:51:56,810
Just a shocking, amazing outcome.
967
00:51:57,650 --> 00:52:00,290
So who needed to readjust commitments?
968
00:52:01,250 --> 00:52:04,340
It looked like we could
have the whole world
969
00:52:04,340 --> 00:52:06,800
like in 1940s and fifties.
970
00:52:07,970 --> 00:52:11,570
And so we went from
enlargement to containment
971
00:52:11,570 --> 00:52:16,250
as the Clinton National Security
Strategy was titled from
972
00:52:16,250 --> 00:52:17,330
the mid nineties.
973
00:52:18,440 --> 00:52:20,660
We were the whole world enlargement from
974
00:52:20,660 --> 00:52:22,280
containment to enlargement.
975
00:52:23,900 --> 00:52:25,970
By the way, there were
20 something drafts of
976
00:52:25,970 --> 00:52:30,380
that national security document,
which is forgotten now,
977
00:52:32,960 --> 00:52:37,220
but again at 25% of global GDP.
978
00:52:37,220 --> 00:52:40,580
Is that possible? Let's remember
979
00:52:40,580 --> 00:52:44,810
that our doctrine in the Cold War was
980
00:52:46,010 --> 00:52:50,600
fight two major wars in two
major theaters simultaneously.
981
00:52:52,100 --> 00:52:53,930
That we had a big enough military,
982
00:52:53,930 --> 00:52:56,875
a dominant enough military
that we could fight
983
00:52:56,875 --> 00:53:00,890
to the death against two
gigantic foes in two the
984
00:53:00,890 --> 00:53:02,450
like we had in World War II in World War
985
00:53:02,450 --> 00:53:04,400
- Ii, Pacific and Europe at the same time.
986
00:53:04,400 --> 00:53:08,810
- Yes, our commitments have
been in more than two theaters
987
00:53:08,810 --> 00:53:11,480
this whole time, but we were ready
988
00:53:11,480 --> 00:53:14,480
for those two simultaneous major wars
989
00:53:14,480 --> 00:53:16,670
while having commitments
in more than two theaters.
990
00:53:18,020 --> 00:53:21,920
Along comes John Deutsch,
our colleague, genius
991
00:53:22,790 --> 00:53:24,500
Emeritus, MIT professor
992
00:53:24,500 --> 00:53:27,750
and Hoover fellow who was a CIA director
993
00:53:27,750 --> 00:53:32,340
and big honcho in the
defense department as well.
994
00:53:32,340 --> 00:53:36,870
And he inserts this adverb
nearly simultaneously.
995
00:53:37,800 --> 00:53:42,510
Two major wars in two major
theaters, nearly simultaneously.
996
00:53:42,510 --> 00:53:43,620
So that's the beginning.
997
00:53:44,730 --> 00:53:48,510
And then along comes
President Obama and it's 1.5.
998
00:53:49,380 --> 00:53:51,660
And along comes Trump won and it's won.
999
00:53:52,500 --> 00:53:55,410
So the United States
is officially committed
1000
00:53:55,410 --> 00:53:58,620
to fighting one major
war in one major theater
1001
00:53:58,620 --> 00:54:00,180
simultaneously.
1002
00:54:00,180 --> 00:54:02,280
You wanna go fight in the Middle East?
1003
00:54:02,280 --> 00:54:04,115
Go right ahead. But that's it then.
1004
00:54:04,115 --> 00:54:05,880
- That's it.
- That's all you can do
1005
00:54:05,880 --> 00:54:07,920
by your own doctrine, right?
1006
00:54:07,920 --> 00:54:11,400
So either we rebalance
American power in the world
1007
00:54:12,750 --> 00:54:17,040
or we run into self-sabotage.
1008
00:54:18,120 --> 00:54:20,940
And so Victor is right.
1009
00:54:20,940 --> 00:54:23,880
We are an economic superpower, a science
1010
00:54:23,880 --> 00:54:27,120
and tech superpower, an energy superpower,
1011
00:54:28,530 --> 00:54:33,480
an immigration superpower, a
soft power superpower no matter
1012
00:54:33,480 --> 00:54:36,090
how much damage we do to ourselves.
1013
00:54:36,090 --> 00:54:38,580
We are a superpower in every domain.
1014
00:54:38,580 --> 00:54:40,470
And there's never been
any power like that.
1015
00:54:40,470 --> 00:54:41,940
And we're not in decline,
1016
00:54:42,840 --> 00:54:46,530
but we're absolutely,
1017
00:54:46,530 --> 00:54:49,050
there's no way to escape.
1018
00:54:49,050 --> 00:54:50,460
We are in a situation,
1019
00:54:50,460 --> 00:54:53,880
we must rebalance American
power in the world.
1020
00:54:53,880 --> 00:54:56,520
Now it's finally
happening under Trump too.
1021
00:54:57,420 --> 00:55:00,450
This isn't the way Peter
Robinson would do it.
1022
00:55:00,450 --> 00:55:03,870
This isn't the way the guests
on your show would recommend
1023
00:55:03,870 --> 00:55:08,490
that we do it symbolically, nastily,
1024
00:55:08,490 --> 00:55:10,500
you know, with the bullying.
1025
00:55:10,500 --> 00:55:13,080
This is the way our system
is figured out how to do
1026
00:55:13,080 --> 00:55:16,980
after all of the pivoting
and the, the rebalancing
1027
00:55:16,980 --> 00:55:19,350
and statements by former presidents
1028
00:55:19,350 --> 00:55:22,440
and then papers at the
Brookings Institution.
1029
00:55:22,440 --> 00:55:23,700
Finally it's underway.
1030
00:55:23,700 --> 00:55:27,840
- So Steven, we have our NATO allies
1031
00:55:28,830 --> 00:55:30,210
take Poland for example.
1032
00:55:30,210 --> 00:55:32,220
Poland's being very polite about it.
1033
00:55:32,220 --> 00:55:35,010
The Germans less so, the
French, much less so.
1034
00:55:35,010 --> 00:55:36,420
But essentially the Europeans
1035
00:55:36,420 --> 00:55:40,410
and the Japanese are saying,
whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.
1036
00:55:40,410 --> 00:55:42,720
We can't depend on the
United States anymore.
1037
00:55:42,720 --> 00:55:45,420
We better do this and this and this.
1038
00:55:45,420 --> 00:55:48,450
You just gave a specific
instance where the Japanese
1039
00:55:48,450 --> 00:55:51,600
have agreed to, I don't ignore parts
1040
00:55:51,600 --> 00:55:53,640
of their own constitution to take on,
1041
00:55:54,540 --> 00:55:56,310
- They're passing laws to change more.
1042
00:55:56,310 --> 00:56:00,810
- All right? Yeah. So,
but that's good. Not bad.
1043
00:56:00,810 --> 00:56:03,090
That's exactly the kind of rebalancing
1044
00:56:03,090 --> 00:56:04,890
where we remain allies,
1045
00:56:05,730 --> 00:56:09,750
but they take more of the
burden of defending themselves
1046
00:56:09,750 --> 00:56:12,515
and, and, and police. I don't
1047
00:56:12,515 --> 00:56:14,280
- The the remain allies part,
1048
00:56:14,280 --> 00:56:17,550
the remain allies part is
not a hundred percent clear.
1049
00:56:17,550 --> 00:56:18,900
- It's not. That's
- You see,
1050
00:56:18,900 --> 00:56:22,650
because the way we're going
about the rebalancing,
1051
00:56:22,650 --> 00:56:27,370
we are putting at risk
the alliance superpower,
1052
00:56:27,370 --> 00:56:30,010
which is the fundamental superpower along
1053
00:56:30,010 --> 00:56:32,020
with immigration superpower
1054
00:56:32,020 --> 00:56:34,690
that nobody has ever had in world history.
1055
00:56:34,690 --> 00:56:36,700
There have been economic superpowers,
1056
00:56:36,700 --> 00:56:38,500
there have been innovation superpowers,
1057
00:56:38,500 --> 00:56:40,390
there have been military superpower.
1058
00:56:40,390 --> 00:56:42,580
China is all of those things.
1059
00:56:42,580 --> 00:56:47,580
But there hasn't been a
immigration superpower like us
1060
00:56:47,920 --> 00:56:50,020
or an alliance superpower.
1061
00:56:50,020 --> 00:56:53,620
There's this anecdote when Xi Jinping went
1062
00:56:53,620 --> 00:56:57,250
to pay his respects and he's
rising, he's about to be,
1063
00:56:57,250 --> 00:57:00,460
or he was just named
the top leader in China.
1064
00:57:00,460 --> 00:57:04,360
And he goes to Qua Yu in
Singapore, the elder statesman
1065
00:57:05,500 --> 00:57:09,640
of East Asia of Asia,
and pay his respects.
1066
00:57:10,690 --> 00:57:15,310
And so the anecdote goes
that Xi Jingping bragged
1067
00:57:15,310 --> 00:57:18,940
that they were gonna, China
was gonna win the competition
1068
00:57:18,940 --> 00:57:23,380
because they had 1.3
billion people to choose to,
1069
00:57:23,380 --> 00:57:25,120
to select talent from.
1070
00:57:25,120 --> 00:57:27,160
They had the biggest talent surprise,
1071
00:57:27,160 --> 00:57:28,160
- Plausible.
1072
00:57:28,160 --> 00:57:30,370
- And the elder statesman
qua, you said, you're wrong.
1073
00:57:32,290 --> 00:57:35,680
You have 1.3 billion to draw from,
1074
00:57:35,680 --> 00:57:40,060
but the United States has
8 billion to draw from,
1075
00:57:40,060 --> 00:57:43,270
and so they have the upper
hand and don't forget that.
1076
00:57:44,230 --> 00:57:47,950
And so how many immigrants should we have?
1077
00:57:47,950 --> 00:57:50,980
How should our borders be controlled?
1078
00:57:50,980 --> 00:57:54,430
Should immigration only be
legal rather than illegal?
1079
00:57:54,430 --> 00:57:57,550
At what level, what skill level?
1080
00:57:57,550 --> 00:58:00,790
Those are legitimate debates
for any country to have.
1081
00:58:01,660 --> 00:58:05,350
But if you look around at the
big companies that we have
1082
00:58:05,350 --> 00:58:10,120
and the striver culture
that gets introduced
1083
00:58:10,120 --> 00:58:13,630
by immigrants, it's just phenomenal what
1084
00:58:13,630 --> 00:58:14,860
that contribution is.
1085
00:58:14,860 --> 00:58:19,150
Again, it's a legitimate
debate what size that should be
1086
00:58:19,150 --> 00:58:21,100
and how it should be done.
1087
00:58:21,100 --> 00:58:22,870
I have no trouble with that debate,
1088
00:58:22,870 --> 00:58:27,220
but the idea that we should
give up the immigration
1089
00:58:27,220 --> 00:58:28,660
superpower is hard to believe.
1090
00:58:28,660 --> 00:58:31,750
But the alliance superpower
story is all at risk.
1091
00:58:33,010 --> 00:58:37,780
The Greenland stuff,
Canada, 51st state, all of
1092
00:58:37,780 --> 00:58:41,080
that gratuitous trolling that wasn't real.
1093
00:58:41,080 --> 00:58:44,260
When Trump is tweeting in the middle
1094
00:58:44,260 --> 00:58:46,120
of the night about Greenland,
1095
00:58:46,120 --> 00:58:48,040
he was moving assets to Venezuela.
1096
00:58:49,630 --> 00:58:52,390
So why he's doing the Greenland thing
1097
00:58:52,390 --> 00:58:55,000
when he's not moving
assets vis-a-vis Greenland,
1098
00:58:55,000 --> 00:58:58,210
but he was moving them vis-a-vis
Venezuelan in real time.
1099
00:58:58,210 --> 00:59:01,030
Anyway, you'll have to ask him
that when he is on your show.
1100
00:59:02,020 --> 00:59:05,530
My point being is that the rebalancing
1101
00:59:05,530 --> 00:59:09,280
that's underway is very
good, like you say.
1102
00:59:09,280 --> 00:59:13,870
But the way it's being done,
we potentially are paying costs
1103
00:59:13,870 --> 00:59:15,430
that we shouldn't be paying.
1104
00:59:15,430 --> 00:59:20,080
So take Europe, Europe was
1105
00:59:20,990 --> 00:59:24,950
33% of global GDP bigger than us
1106
00:59:26,630 --> 00:59:29,780
in the sixties, I'm
sorry, in, in the eighties
1107
00:59:31,070 --> 00:59:35,810
when Reagan forced the
missiles into the equation,
1108
00:59:35,810 --> 00:59:38,960
which was a big message,
the missiles into Europe,
1109
00:59:38,960 --> 00:59:41,360
which was a big message to the Soviets,
1110
00:59:41,360 --> 00:59:42,830
and everybody got that message.
1111
00:59:42,830 --> 00:59:46,700
It was amazing what Reagan was able
1112
00:59:46,700 --> 00:59:47,840
to do in that regard.
1113
00:59:47,840 --> 00:59:52,670
Europe was still serious
place that as late as 1992,
1114
00:59:52,670 --> 00:59:55,700
Europe was 30% at global GDP.
1115
00:59:55,700 --> 01:00:00,700
It's now 17. Wow. Europe
and UK together is 17%.
1116
01:00:00,950 --> 01:00:03,440
They missed the software revolution.
1117
01:00:03,440 --> 01:00:05,990
- They have no tech sector
- And the AI revolution,
1118
01:00:05,990 --> 01:00:07,610
they have a tech sector that's it's in
1119
01:00:07,610 --> 01:00:08,610
- Ukraine.
1120
01:00:08,610 --> 01:00:12,170
- Yeah, that's just not on the
level that it should be at.
1121
01:00:12,170 --> 01:00:14,030
They're on trajectory for 10%
1122
01:00:14,030 --> 01:00:16,820
of global GDP under current trends.
1123
01:00:16,820 --> 01:00:20,360
Currently it's 17, so
they've gone from 30 to 17
1124
01:00:21,440 -->
01:00:22,820
when we've held at 25.
1125
01:00:25,040 --> 01:00:28,160
So that's a problem for
them in the first instance.
1126
01:00:28,160 --> 01:00:33,020
It's also a problem for us to
carry that Japan went from 18%
1127
01:00:33,020 --> 01:00:36,620
of global GDP in the early
nineties to 4% today.
1128
01:00:37,610 --> 01:00:41,990
So somebody's in decline.
It's just not us.
1129
01:00:41,990 --> 01:00:45,500
So Victor is correct there, but Europe
1130
01:00:45,500 --> 01:00:50,300
and our allies in East Asia
have declined proportionately
1131
01:00:50,300 --> 01:00:51,920
because of the rise of China.
1132
01:00:51,920 --> 01:00:55,250
China has taken from Europe
1133
01:00:55,250 --> 01:00:59,060
and Japan, among others,
the rise of China, which
1134
01:00:59,060 --> 01:01:02,870
by the way, of course, the
US led order facilitated.
1135
01:01:02,870 --> 01:01:05,960
Yes, China was part of that story
1136
01:01:05,960 --> 01:01:10,880
of lifting the other boats,
becoming part of our peace
1137
01:01:10,880 --> 01:01:13,580
and prosperity because we diverged
1138
01:01:14,450 --> 01:01:18,380
after the Cold War, Soviet
capitulation, it used
1139
01:01:18,380 --> 01:01:21,200
to be under the gat, the
global agreement of tariffs
1140
01:01:21,200 --> 01:01:23,960
and trade, that you had to be part
1141
01:01:23,960 --> 01:01:26,750
of US security architecture to be
1142
01:01:26,750 --> 01:01:29,480
inside the US economic order
1143
01:01:30,500 --> 01:01:32,210
with the WTO.
1144
01:01:32,210 --> 01:01:34,280
We severed that connection.
1145
01:01:34,280 --> 01:01:37,400
So you, you were not part
of US security architecture.
1146
01:01:37,400 --> 01:01:40,220
In fact, you could be
against the United States,
1147
01:01:40,220 --> 01:01:44,120
but we allowed you into
the economic kingdom
1148
01:01:44,120 --> 01:01:46,760
whether you complied
or not with the rules.
1149
01:01:46,760 --> 01:01:49,730
So that divergence was
a mistake in my view.
1150
01:01:49,730 --> 01:01:52,370
We could argue about who did it and why,
1151
01:01:52,370 --> 01:01:53,870
or maybe it wasn't a mistake.
1152
01:01:53,870 --> 01:01:55,340
Maybe it was a, a bet
1153
01:01:55,340 --> 01:01:58,100
that was a good calculation
that didn't pan out.
1154
01:01:58,100 --> 01:02:00,800
But where we are today is a return
1155
01:02:00,800 --> 01:02:04,520
to something more like
the get where the security
1156
01:02:04,520 --> 01:02:07,880
and the economics need
to be coming together.
1157
01:02:07,880 --> 01:02:11,060
Again, that's what's
underway in the world.
1158
01:02:12,020 --> 01:02:14,330
The challenge is the way it's underway,
1159
01:02:14,330 --> 01:02:17,540
the remain allies part
of your quote, right,
1160
01:02:17,540 --> 01:02:21,450
is not a guarantee A in Europe,
1161
01:02:21,450 --> 01:02:23,790
they're fed up and they,
1162
01:02:23,790 --> 01:02:24,790
- They're fed up with us.
1163
01:02:24,790 --> 01:02:26,580
- They, they wanted an alternative.
1164
01:02:27,780 --> 01:02:30,000
In East Asia, they're fed up,
1165
01:02:30,000 --> 01:02:32,250
but they're still betting
on the United States.
1166
01:02:33,300 --> 01:02:35,370
It's a very different attitude.
1167
01:02:35,370 --> 01:02:39,780
We impose tariffs on the
Japanese, we delay the orders
1168
01:02:39,780 --> 01:02:40,860
of military equipment.
1169
01:02:40,860 --> 01:02:42,870
We're supposed to send them.
1170
01:02:42,870 --> 01:02:47,100
We go promise things to China
behind the Japanese back,
1171
01:02:47,100 --> 01:02:51,210
and I could go on, and yet the
Japanese are still with us.
1172
01:02:51,210 --> 01:02:55,050
They still are a hundred percent committed
1173
01:02:55,050 --> 01:02:58,680
to the US alliance that
goes for the Philippines,
1174
01:02:58,680 --> 01:03:02,340
which has no energy right
now because of the Gulf.
1175
01:03:02,340 --> 01:03:04,710
And they're, they're closed
1176
01:03:04,710 --> 01:03:07,530
during weekdays now they
just shut down the country
1177
01:03:07,530 --> 01:03:12,120
during one day a week because
they lack sufficient energy
1178
01:03:12,120 --> 01:03:15,480
because the supplies from the
Gulf have been interdicted
1179
01:03:15,480 --> 01:03:18,845
over our war with Iran.
1180
01:03:19,830 --> 01:03:23,880
And so I'm worried about
the we remain allies part.
1181
01:03:23,880 --> 01:03:27,540
I'm not worried about
us decline as a power.
1182
01:03:27,540 --> 01:03:30,750
I'm more worried about
the US domestic political
1183
01:03:30,750 --> 01:03:32,100
scene as you know.
1184
01:03:32,100 --> 01:03:35,010
- Fifth, this brings us to
the fifth and final question,
1185
01:03:35,010 --> 01:03:36,450
and again, two quotations.
1186
01:03:37,350 --> 01:03:41,460
Xi Jinping. This is a 2016
speech marking the 95th
1187
01:03:41,460 --> 01:03:43,710
anniversary of the founding
1188
01:03:43,710 --> 01:03:45,930
of the Chinese Communist Party quote
1189
01:03:46,860 --> 01:03:48,840
from the day it was
founded, the Communist party
1190
01:03:48,840 --> 01:03:53,250
of China made realizing
communism its highest, ideal
1191
01:03:53,250 --> 01:03:57,870
and ultimate goal, and it has
never wavered in this ideal.
1192
01:04:00,150 --> 01:04:02,280
Here's a document I
think you will recognize
1193
01:04:03,300 --> 01:04:08,190
in Congress July 4th, 1776 quote.
1194
01:04:08,190 --> 01:04:10,230
We hold these truths to be self-evident
1195
01:04:10,230 --> 01:04:13,140
that all men are created
equal, that they're endowed
1196
01:04:13,140 --> 01:04:16,050
by their creator with
certain unalienable rights.
1197
01:04:16,050 --> 01:04:18,030
That among these are life, liberty,
1198
01:04:18,030 --> 01:04:19,230
and the pursuit of happiness.
1199
01:04:20,220 --> 01:04:23,760
Now, we've been talking
about power, politics, about
1200
01:04:23,760 --> 01:04:25,350
to use the old phrase, the correlation
1201
01:04:25,350 --> 01:04:26,880
of forces throughout the show.
1202
01:04:28,440 --> 01:04:32,340
How do
you assess the
conflict between their values
1203
01:04:33,420 --> 01:04:34,440
and ours?
1204
01:04:35,850 --> 01:04:40,440
Has China invented a new set of values
1205
01:04:40,440 --> 01:04:45,240
that can lead to economic growth and power
1206
01:04:45,240 --> 01:04:46,740
and human fulfillment?
1207
01:04:46,740 --> 01:04:48,600
Have they created a new ideal
1208
01:04:49,770 --> 01:04:53,250
or to 250 years after it was written?
1209
01:04:53,250 --> 01:04:55,440
Does the Declaration of
Independence sound merely
1210
01:04:55,440 --> 01:04:59,760
sentimental or does it sound
like a clear-eyed statement
1211
01:04:59,760 --> 01:05:02,010
about the nature of
human beings and reality?
1212
01:05:03,480 --> 01:05:05,760
- China's a remarkable civilization.
1213
01:05:06,930 --> 01:05:09,120
They predate us by millennia.
1214
01:05:11,070 --> 01:05:16,070
They invented paper, the Compass
1215
01:05:16,380 --> 01:05:18,790
printing, and I could go on,
1216
01:05:20,950 --> 01:05:22,000
it's just breathtaking.
1217
01:05:22,990 --> 01:05:27,220
China is, words can't
capture how amazing China is.
1218
01:05:28,660 --> 01:05:33,130
We're talking about a political
regime that's dedicated
1219
01:05:33,130 --> 01:05:38,130
to Unfreedom, knows it's
illegitimate, never has submitted
1220
01:05:38,140 --> 01:05:40,870
to free and fair Elections
in its own country,
1221
01:05:40,870 --> 01:05:44,530
has murdered its own
people on a scale of tens
1222
01:05:44,530 --> 01:05:45,820
and tens of millions
1223
01:05:48,640 --> 01:05:51,010
and is afraid of its own people
1224
01:05:51,880 --> 01:05:54,940
and its own people wanna
go elsewhere to be free.
1225
01:05:56,050 --> 01:05:59,770
And what happened in Hong Kong
is yet another illustration
1226
01:05:59,770 --> 01:06:02,500
of this British Hong Kong,
1227
01:06:02,500 --> 01:06:05,770
which became the most important
international financial
1228
01:06:05,770 --> 01:06:08,440
center based on the rule of law
1229
01:06:08,440 --> 01:06:10,900
and allocation of market principles
1230
01:06:10,900 --> 01:06:15,010
for the Chinese communists,
yes, without Hong Kong,
1231
01:06:15,010 --> 01:06:18,520
no Chinese economic miracle,
and it was British Hong Kong,
1232
01:06:20,260 --> 01:06:23,350
and when they got it
back, what did they do?
1233
01:06:23,350 --> 01:06:26,680
Strangle it. So that's who this regime is.
1234
01:06:27,520 --> 01:06:30,070
That's what they represent.
That's what their values are.
1235
01:06:33,310 --> 01:06:35,980
And so when we go up against them, we have
1236
01:06:35,980 --> 01:06:37,720
to use our values.
1237
01:06:37,720 --> 01:06:40,180
We have to use our legitimacy.
1238
01:06:40,180 --> 01:06:41,890
We have to use our soft power.
1239
01:06:44,440 --> 01:06:46,330
We're based upon different values
1240
01:06:46,330 --> 01:06:48,820
and ideals compared to that regime.
1241
01:06:48,820 --> 01:06:52,180
Even though we're young in Chinese terms,
1242
01:06:52,180 --> 01:06:54,010
ridiculously young,
1243
01:06:54,010 --> 01:06:56,800
we are still the oldest constitution based
1244
01:06:56,800 --> 01:06:58,060
republic on the planet.
1245
01:06:59,080 --> 01:07:03,970
250 years is a long time for a republic
1246
01:07:03,970 --> 01:07:05,530
if you can keep it, and we have,
1247
01:07:07,630 --> 01:07:09,430
so this competition is one
1248
01:07:09,430 --> 01:07:13,210
that we can win the competition
on the level of values
1249
01:07:13,210 --> 01:07:14,685
and institutions.
1250
01:07:14,685 --> 01:07:17,080
It's our biggest strength.
1251
01:07:17,080 --> 01:07:21,160
Ultimately, once we factor in all
1252
01:07:21,160 --> 01:07:23,620
of the hard powers you
described at the correlation
1253
01:07:23,620 --> 01:07:26,140
of forces, this is the stuff
1254
01:07:26,140 --> 01:07:27,970
that makes us better and different.
1255
01:07:29,290 --> 01:07:33,280
All of that is under siege
right now in our country.
1256
01:07:34,420 --> 01:07:36,010
It's been under siege before.
1257
01:07:36,880 --> 01:07:40,840
It's never been an easy
story in the United States.
1258
01:07:40,840 --> 01:07:43,900
Even if you bracket the
Civil War, which is hard
1259
01:07:43,900 --> 01:07:46,390
to bracket 600,000 dead,
1260
01:07:48,250 --> 01:07:50,020
even if you take out the Civil War,
1261
01:07:50,920 --> 01:07:55,420
you can just throw in Andrew
Jackson or one could go on.
1262
01:07:55,420 --> 01:07:58,330
Any student of American
history could pick their epoch
1263
01:07:59,200 --> 01:08:02,050
of craziness, of instability.
1264
01:08:02,950 --> 01:08:05,230
Now we live in the social media age
1265
01:08:06,160 --> 01:08:07,690
and now it's much more visible.
1266
01:08:07,690 --> 01:08:10,060
It was always there
1267
01:08:10,060 --> 01:08:13,060
what Philip Roth called the
indigenous American berserk.
1268
01:08:14,020 --> 01:08:17,210
That's always been, but
now it's much more visible.
1269
01:08:17,210 --> 01:08:18,440
It's not the whole country.
1270
01:08:19,610 --> 01:08:21,620
It's not even a majority in the country.
1271
01:08:23,060 --> 01:08:27,110
In the Republican coalition,
the MAGA element is probably
1272
01:08:27,110 --> 01:08:31,160
around 50% of Republicans,
registered Republicans,
1273
01:08:31,160 --> 01:08:34,040
and then those who lean
Republican but are independence.
1274
01:08:35,510 --> 01:08:37,700
That's a 40% number.
1275
01:08:37,700 --> 01:08:39,410
So MAGA is about 50%
1276
01:08:39,410 --> 01:08:42,800
of Republicans registered
Lean Republicans.
1277
01:08:42,800 --> 01:08:45,380
Registered independents is about 40%,
1278
01:08:45,380 --> 01:08:50,000
so MAGA is something like 20%
of the country, something like
1279
01:08:50,000 --> 01:08:52,430
that has always been
there, but we didn't see it
1280
01:08:52,430 --> 01:08:54,800
before because we lacked.
1281
01:08:54,800 --> 01:08:57,680
They lacked the tools to
make themselves visible.
1282
01:08:59,780 --> 01:09:01,280
On the hard left side,
1283
01:09:02,690 --> 01:09:07,580
we also have Democratic
Party is no more than 40%
1284
01:09:07,580 --> 01:09:09,710
of the country registered plus lean
1285
01:09:09,710 --> 01:09:11,930
Democrats and the hard left.
1286
01:09:11,930 --> 01:09:15,320
There is not a majority
among the Democrats either.
1287
01:09:16,340 --> 01:09:18,980
And so if you add up
the hard left Democrats
1288
01:09:18,980 --> 01:09:20,990
and the maga, I'm not
making them equivalent.
1289
01:09:20,990 --> 01:09:25,940
I'm just saying if you add them
up, there's 60% of leftover,
1290
01:09:25,940 --> 01:09:27,110
which is called America.
1291
01:09:28,670 --> 01:09:32,900
That's 60% are people
1292
01:09:32,900 --> 01:09:36,620
like the ones sitting at the
table here where we recognize
1293
01:09:36,620 --> 01:09:39,110
that there are legitimate grievances
1294
01:09:39,110 --> 01:09:43,190
and legitimate aspirations among those
1295
01:09:43,190 --> 01:09:46,730
who are farther to the right
or farther to the left.
1296
01:09:46,730 --> 01:09:48,740
That's what a democracy is for.
1297
01:09:48,740 --> 01:09:50,510
It's to allow that and it's
1298
01:09:50,510 --> 01:09:53,360
to adjudicate those
differences peacefully.
1299
01:09:54,740 --> 01:09:59,660
We have, however, with the
social media age disrupted,
1300
01:09:59,660 --> 01:10:04,550
our social solidarity and
trust and our competent
1301
01:10:04,550 --> 01:10:06,710
and compassionate leadership.
1302
01:10:06,710 --> 01:10:10,010
It was happening before the
communications revolution,
1303
01:10:10,010 --> 01:10:12,200
but it has accelerated since then.
1304
01:10:13,550 --> 01:10:17,180
And so we need to figure out
how to assimilate as a free
1305
01:10:17,180 --> 01:10:18,830
and open society.
1306
01:10:18,830 --> 01:10:21,410
This phenomenon called social media
1307
01:10:21,410 --> 01:10:25,190
and now the AI revolution,
that's a real challenge.
1308
01:10:25,190 --> 01:10:29,510
We did it with radio
was very destabilizing.
1309
01:10:29,510 --> 01:10:31,940
We did it with images plus sound known
1310
01:10:31,940 --> 01:10:34,670
as television was very destabilizing.
1311
01:10:34,670 --> 01:10:37,130
It's much more destabilizing now
1312
01:10:37,130 --> 01:10:40,490
because you don't need
to own a radio station.
1313
01:10:41,810 --> 01:10:45,740
You have a radio station
of your own in your pocket
1314
01:10:45,740 --> 01:10:48,680
or a TV station, if you will.
1315
01:10:48,680 --> 01:10:52,370
So it's harder, but a free society can't
1316
01:10:52,370 --> 01:10:55,700
prohibit openness.
1317
01:10:55,700 --> 01:10:58,885
It has to assimilate these
technologies that we've invented
1318
01:10:59,750 --> 01:11:01,640
and figure out how to make them work
1319
01:11:02,480 --> 01:11:06,740
to enhance social solidarity
and trust competence
1320
01:11:06,740 --> 01:11:08,660
and compassionate leadership.
1321
01:11:08,660 --> 01:11:13,440
Instead, we're going through
convulsions over this.
1322
01:11:13,440 -->
01:11:15,180
The convulsions are symptomatic
1323
01:11:15,180 --> 01:11:17,340
of our difficulty assimilating this.
1324
01:11:18,690 --> 01:11:22,860
We also have the epic
corruption, epic, even
1325
01:11:22,860 --> 01:11:24,300
by American standards.
1326
01:11:25,290 --> 01:11:27,300
It breaks your heart to see the level
1327
01:11:27,300 --> 01:11:28,530
of corruption that we have.
1328
01:11:30,240 --> 01:11:35,100
People who were complaining
about the grift of Hunter Biden,
1329
01:11:36,150 --> 01:11:39,360
which was real, and their
complaints were legitimate.
1330
01:11:39,360 --> 01:11:41,970
I'd like to know what
their complaints are now in
1331
01:11:41,970 --> 01:11:43,380
comparison to scale.
1332
01:11:44,370 --> 01:11:48,240
Having a $1.8 billion slush fund
1333
01:11:48,240 --> 01:11:52,860
to reward people who
assaulted cops is not my idea
1334
01:11:52,860 --> 01:11:56,190
of July 4th, 1776.
1335
01:11:56,190 --> 01:11:59,520
And so we need to regain that equilibrium
1336
01:11:59,520 --> 01:12:02,820
where we have corrective
mechanisms, renewal,
1337
01:12:02,820 --> 01:12:07,530
mourning in America,
integrity, competence,
1338
01:12:07,530 --> 01:12:09,780
learning from mistakes.
1339
01:12:09,780 --> 01:12:12,480
This is across the whole
political spectrum.
1340
01:12:13,410 --> 01:12:16,110
This is not a partisan comment.
1341
01:12:16,110 --> 01:12:20,490
This is not a comment about
being disappointed by voting
1342
01:12:20,490 --> 01:12:24,870
for this person or that person
or calling for this party
1343
01:12:24,870 --> 01:12:27,420
or that party to get in the ascendancy.
1344
01:12:27,420 --> 01:12:30,480
I want Congress, back when you
1345
01:12:30,480 --> 01:12:33,690
and I were growing up, there
was something called Congress,
1346
01:12:33,690 --> 01:12:36,210
and we know how important it was including
1347
01:12:36,210 --> 01:12:38,220
for the Reagan revolution.
1348
01:12:38,220 --> 01:12:40,230
A democratic controlled Congress was
1349
01:12:40,230 --> 01:12:41,940
for the Reagan revolution.
1350
01:12:41,940 --> 01:12:43,200
I want Congress back.
1351
01:12:43,200 --> 01:12:47,670
My judiciary is still
functioning my public sphere.
1352
01:12:47,670 --> 01:12:50,190
Media landscape is messy.
1353
01:12:50,190 --> 01:12:55,190
The business model is outrage,
extremism, conspiracy.
1354
01:12:55,320 --> 01:12:59,640
I need a business model that
rewards our better angels.
1355
01:12:59,640 --> 01:13:03,060
Somehow maybe AI can
help us in this regard.
1356
01:13:03,060 --> 01:13:07,080
I'm cautiously optimistic
that that might be the case.
1357
01:13:07,080 --> 01:13:10,920
Despite the slop and
all and and the fakery
1358
01:13:10,920 --> 01:13:12,510
and all of the other things from ai,
1359
01:13:12,510 --> 01:13:15,150
we see it pushing towards the middle
1360
01:13:15,150 --> 01:13:17,790
in many ways in the incentive structure.
1361
01:13:17,790 --> 01:13:22,790
So we need to regain the greatness
1362
01:13:22,890 --> 01:13:26,400
that was set down 250 years ago.
1363
01:13:26,400 --> 01:13:29,160
That has been a struggle
for 250 years, right?
1364
01:13:30,960 --> 01:13:33,750
The beauty of America was
1365
01:13:33,750 --> 01:13:36,570
citizenship empowerment.
1366
01:13:36,570 --> 01:13:40,110
It was about the people, we the people,
1367
01:13:40,110 --> 01:13:41,790
it was a citizen's government.
1368
01:13:41,790 --> 01:13:45,090
It was not a government
given from the king
1369
01:13:45,090 --> 01:13:47,130
or divine right of kings.
1370
01:13:47,130 --> 01:13:51,750
It was our government. Not
everyone was a citizen.
1371
01:13:51,750 --> 01:13:56,370
Citizenship was universal in theory,
1372
01:13:56,370 --> 01:13:58,320
but exclusionary in practice.
1373
01:13:59,400 --> 01:14:01,860
So for example, if you were a male,
1374
01:14:01,860 --> 01:14:03,900
but you didn't own property,
1375
01:14:03,900 --> 01:14:06,810
you didn't have full
citizenship rights if you were a
1376
01:14:06,810 --> 01:14:09,000
female, whether you owned property
1377
01:14:09,000 --> 01:14:12,100
or not, you didn't have
citizenship rights if you were a
1378
01:14:12,100 --> 01:14:15,730
slave or descendant of slaves,
you didn't have citizen.
1379
01:14:15,730 --> 01:14:19,300
But all of that was corrected
over time through struggle.
1380
01:14:19,300 --> 01:14:24,100
And the category citizenship
over 250 years became
1381
01:14:24,100 --> 01:14:29,100
universal in practice, not
just universal in principle.
1382
01:14:29,320 --> 01:14:31,150
That's been an amazing story too.
1383
01:14:31,150 --> 01:14:33,190
We remember the civil rights movement
1384
01:14:34,120 --> 01:14:37,360
and civil rights as we experienced,
1385
01:14:37,360 --> 01:14:41,350
it was about getting America
to live up to its ideals.
1386
01:14:42,880 --> 01:14:46,660
It wasn't about race-based
1387
01:14:46,660 --> 01:14:48,850
quotas, et cetera, identity
1388
01:14:48,850 --> 01:14:49,850
- Politics.
1389
01:14:49,850 --> 01:14:51,730
- It was about American ideals.
1390
01:14:51,730 --> 01:14:56,380
And everybody here belonged
and should be recognized
1391
01:14:56,380 --> 01:14:58,360
and not discriminated against.
1392
01:14:58,360 --> 01:15:00,520
And that was correct,
and that was a struggle.
1393
01:15:00,520 --> 01:15:03,310
And that's the 250 year story.
1394
01:15:03,310 --> 01:15:05,650
If we were regain that type
1395
01:15:05,650 --> 01:15:09,460
of renewal, we're unbeatable.
1396
01:15:09,460 --> 01:15:12,280
But if we continue on
the current trajectory,
1397
01:15:13,570 --> 01:15:18,490
which is semi self-defeating
up against the Chinese,
1398
01:15:18,490 --> 01:15:21,970
they're a match for us, even
though they're illegitimate
1399
01:15:21,970 --> 01:15:24,430
and their ideals are false.
1400
01:15:24,430 --> 01:15:27,250
And so this is not a simple process.
1401
01:15:27,250 --> 01:15:29,980
It's not a one administration process.
1402
01:15:29,980 --> 01:15:34,980
It's a multi-generational
process. We've done it before.
1403
01:15:35,230 --> 01:15:38,140
You were on the inside
the last time we did it,
1404
01:15:38,140 --> 01:15:39,610
so we can do it again.
1405
01:15:39,610 --> 01:15:42,520
There were episodes prior to that as well.
1406
01:15:42,520 --> 01:15:46,240
There have been deep crises,
but there's been renewal.
1407
01:15:46,240 --> 01:15:48,700
It's not gonna happen automatically.
1408
01:15:48,700 --> 01:15:51,760
It's not just gonna happen self-generated.
1409
01:15:52,930 --> 01:15:55,450
The possibility is there,
but it has to be seized.
1410
01:15:56,590 --> 01:16:01,060
As citizens, we have to seize
the power that we were given
1411
01:16:01,060 --> 01:16:04,810
and that we gave ourselves in 1776.
1412
01:16:04,810 --> 01:16:08,830
So you can only be optimistic
with that type of inheritance
1413
01:16:08,830 --> 01:16:12,910
with this 250th anniversary,
but you can't be complacent.
1414
01:16:13,840 --> 01:16:16,660
Optimistic, yes, but complacent, no.
1415
01:16:17,650 --> 01:16:19,660
And where's it gonna come from?
1416
01:16:19,660 --> 01:16:22,960
The last time came from a strange place
1417
01:16:22,960 --> 01:16:24,310
that nobody would've predicted.
1418
01:16:25,690 --> 01:16:27,250
And that's where it might come from.
1419
01:16:27,250 --> 01:16:31,930
Again, communities, municipalities,
1420
01:16:31,930 --> 01:16:35,740
state level, and then of
course the federal level.
1421
01:16:37,240 --> 01:16:41,770
And if we do that, I'm confident
1422
01:16:41,770 --> 01:16:43,630
that whatever might happen in the world,
1423
01:16:43,630 --> 01:16:46,750
whatever decisions might or
might not be taken in Beijing,
1424
01:16:48,010 --> 01:16:51,130
however our friends might regain
1425
01:16:51,130 --> 01:16:54,735
or not regain productivity
and economic growth.
1426
01:16:54,735 --> 01:16:57,790
And we'll be okay. We're America.
1427
01:16:58,720 --> 01:17:03,160
- Stephen Kotkin. Thank
you for Uncommon Knowledge,
1428
01:17:03,160 --> 01:17:05,590
the Hoover Institution and Fox Nation.
1429
01:17:05,590 --> 01:17:06,550
I'm Peter Robinson.