UTSKRIFT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:09.272 --> 00:00:10.917
Do you the other moderation?
00:00:13.496 --> 00:00:19.032
Let's first switch to English so that we don't hassle with the first opening.
00:00:19.032 --> 00:00:19.932
speak English.
00:00:19.932 --> 00:00:21.073
You cannot.
00:00:22.475 --> 00:00:24.838
So I can do the opening if you want to?
00:00:24.838 --> 00:00:25.128
Sure.
00:00:25.128 --> 00:00:26.539
Okay.
00:00:27.440 --> 00:00:30.021
Shall we give you a start point?
00:00:30.283 --> 00:00:31.423
No, just go ahead.
00:00:31.423 --> 00:00:32.664
Let's go ahead.
00:00:32.962 --> 00:00:41.966
Hello and welcome to Decode AI, your podcast when it comes to AI to learn, understand and get forward with everything you do with AI.
00:00:41.966 --> 00:00:47.490
Today we have a special guest here, one of our MVP colleagues.
00:00:47.490 --> 00:00:49.621
But first let me say hello, Michael.
00:00:49.621 --> 00:00:51.351
Hello, Ralf.
00:00:51.351 --> 00:00:54.594
Yes, I am in this podcast as well.
00:00:55.130 --> 00:01:12.260
And I just realized we haven't had any proper introduction over the last episode, so please check out our website decodeai .de to get more insights about ourselves if you want to have a face to our voices.
00:01:12.768 --> 00:01:18.480
So, but now I think we can start and jump into our discussion with our guest.
00:01:18.480 --> 00:01:20.522
Yeah, we have a guest here.
00:01:20.522 --> 00:01:29.344
and its name is Raphael and Raphael, maybe you can introduce you shortly so that we get a good picture about you.
00:01:29.566 --> 00:01:30.825
Shortly.
00:01:32.126 --> 00:01:33.908
Enough of introduction.
00:01:35.549 --> 00:01:37.028
Okay.
00:01:37.549 --> 00:01:39.010
Yeah, my name is Raphael.
00:01:39.010 --> 00:02:10.858
I'm leading a Microsoft partner and law company I'm one of these MVPs and Microsoft Video Directors and yeah, I'm more regulation and compliance guy instead of the developer guy that knows something about development but more the lawyer, the compliance officer, the officer, of these parts and that's very funny to see on another view on these topics.
00:02:10.858 --> 00:02:15.490
So I'm here and I'm happy to be here.
00:02:16.042 --> 00:02:17.443
And now it's your turn.
00:02:17.443 --> 00:02:19.286
What's your questions?
00:02:19.286 --> 00:02:21.018
Thanks for following our invitation.
00:02:21.018 --> 00:02:21.919
It's great to have you.
00:02:21.919 --> 00:02:23.800
Yeah, for sure.
00:02:23.800 --> 00:02:34.021
It is crucial and very important to see the law perspective and the responsible perspective of AI these days and to understand it.
00:02:34.021 --> 00:02:37.444
And I guess that companies have many questions to you.
00:02:38.385 --> 00:02:43.912
regarding some things happening within the regular series for these days as well.
00:02:43.912 --> 00:02:52.139
But first of all, you gave us a little insight of what your daily doing is, but can you expand that little insight a little bit more?
00:02:52.139 --> 00:02:53.762
Load full transcript
So what's your daily doing?
00:02:53.762 --> 00:02:58.105
when it comes to a usual week, how does it look like?
00:02:58.253 --> 00:02:59.234
That's very interesting.
00:02:59.234 --> 00:03:09.873
My week is 50 % of consulting and 50 % of I'm a concern head of data privacy or a concern DPO worldwide.
00:03:09.973 --> 00:03:21.617
And yes, we are talking with AI on both sides, but AI and all of these, it's more 60 % of my weekly work.
00:03:21.617 --> 00:03:30.358
Now it rises a little bit up because everyone talks about this topic and we have more and more regulatory like the AI Act since last week.
00:03:30.358 --> 00:03:46.217
more and not only in Europe, have also in China, in South Korea, we have no AI Act, no new ones and more and more regulation in this area and it's very interesting and that's what is it.
00:03:46.512 --> 00:03:57.092
work today is data privacy, answering questions like is it allowed to block and posting pictures of people?
00:03:57.211 --> 00:04:01.132
So a little bit low level things and on the other side all of the innovation things.
00:04:01.132 --> 00:04:36.370
have AI in this company, how we can use it, how it is allowed to use it, how it is in a data privacy confirmed way to use it and all of this and yeah this is my daily work so 70% of work but fun of these parts and 30 % of community work and like these podcasts and all of these conferences and more and more people are asking me about is it allowed to use AI in these part of idea in these processes of personal data?
00:04:37.089 --> 00:04:39.449
yeah, this is my daily work.
00:04:39.449 --> 00:04:41.610
Classical question and.
00:04:41.867 --> 00:04:49.702
Yeah, it's a little bit, and this is last time for me, it's a little bit since six months like I'm back at university.
00:04:49.882 --> 00:05:07.173
Because in regulatory everything is new and we started with what is AI as a definition and we have a lot of parts in science at universities, professors, we have a lot of papers we are writing.
00:05:07.670 --> 00:05:37.887
to try to define rules and to try to that all of these use cases we have some terms of use and regulatory and it's very very hard and it's yeah it's a new time since this year in these parts so a new era yeah a new era but i'm very happy a lot of courts and legal guys are very happy about it, so they have a new topic.
00:05:38.168 --> 00:05:42.178
So, often it's, yeah, we have a lot of experts now.
00:05:42.178 --> 00:05:48.091
So called experts.
00:05:48.091 --> 00:05:55.233
but yeah, that's my daily work since some months with all of these questions.
00:05:56.452 --> 00:06:10.004
And you just mentioned in a In a part of your statement what you are doing, you are already in this interesting topic AI.
00:06:10.425 --> 00:06:14.747
What was your first touch, what was your first experience with AI?
00:06:14.908 --> 00:06:22.613
My really first experience, is now five years old, five to six years.
00:06:22.850 --> 00:06:32.454
because I'm thinking
about with Microsoft together and LexisNexis is a legal database.
00:06:33.915 --> 00:06:41.877
A part of this is part of the German governments and we are thinking about to create a digital judge.
00:06:42.259 --> 00:06:42.658
Okay.
00:06:42.658 --> 00:06:50.422
And we're using the typical chatbot framework and then Q &A framework.
00:06:50.577 --> 00:06:57.105
and using all the legal parts, the law and everything put it in.
00:06:57.206 --> 00:07:03.752
And we're starting from this typical Q &A with AI, a little bit like an AI search.
00:07:03.752 --> 00:07:14.802
And yes, we know AI six years ago, but in the beginning and starting, okay, how we create a Yeah, it's more an helper for judges.
00:07:14.802 --> 00:07:15.740
I can advocate.
00:07:15.740 --> 00:07:24.562
Yeah, that they know, for example, they we started with all the legal topics around traffic and cars.
00:07:24.562 --> 00:07:26.822
it is in the legal area.
00:07:26.822 --> 00:07:35.221
Typically, when you drive 10 kilometers too fast, you get a fine of 20 euros and two points, like for example.
00:07:35.221 --> 00:07:42.896
So we have a lot of points which are numbers and computer things.
00:07:42.896 --> 00:07:49.005
So we started with this and this was very funny that we have, for example, a use case, a legal case.
00:07:49.005 --> 00:08:05.115
So you drive on the the Autobahn 50 kilometers too fast and you have a little accident and all of this and we put it in and the result was okay, this is your fine and you have you don't have to go to jail, but you have these to pay and this how much points.
00:08:05.115 --> 00:08:08.055
So it was really good, but not perfect.
00:08:08.055 --> 00:08:18.069
But I think our idea was that judges in Germany have a green line in their judgment.
00:08:18.069 --> 00:08:30.208
that they said, not in Munich, for example, in Bavaria, you get more fines than in Niedersachsen, for example, for the same thing.
00:08:30.208 --> 00:09:19.129
And that we said, okay, with this bot, we tried that every lawyer, also yours, and judges said, okay, we see we have the same made us all over in Germany and this was my first part of trying to put AI into to help to help in this use case and yeah today I see there are a lot of startups trying to do this we have ideas five years before and like every time at Microsoft we are five years ahead but not with this marketing thing already a little bit about what use cases you dealt with a few years ago.
00:09:19.129 --> 00:09:25.121
When we look to nowadays, are there any use cases you can talk about?
00:09:25.518 --> 00:09:31.677
Yeah, we have use cases today into two parts or two spaces.
00:09:31.677 --> 00:09:37.217
The first space is the typical copilot for Microsoft 365.
00:09:37.217 --> 00:09:40.238
Help me to write a text, help me to write an email.
00:09:40.238 --> 00:09:43.217
You have a text, make it more formal or like this.
00:09:43.217 --> 00:09:52.857
And for me, the more interesting part in a kind of the same with the legal bot and legal tech is to analyze a contract.
00:09:52.857 --> 00:09:53.587
Okay.
00:09:53.587 --> 00:09:59.764
To analyze for example, processing order agreement or like this.
00:09:59.764 --> 00:10:09.402
So what I see today in the first space, AI is not very good to create contracts or create data privacy risk assessments or like this.
00:10:09.402 --> 00:10:14.645
They can this but it's not on the level that we need it.
00:10:14.957 --> 00:10:22.197
The structure is not the structure we want, but as an analytics tool, we see more and more it will be better.
00:10:22.197 --> 00:10:37.697
So yes, we have to read everything and we have to read every sentence, but these legal tools, and you can start with Copalite for Microsoft 365 with a prompt like, give me the highlights of the contract or give me the risks of the contract.
00:10:37.741 --> 00:10:54.111
And with OpenAI when you create this for your own, it's typically good that you get 10 points of this contract and you see, you take beware of owner, you have to read these parts of the contract better.
00:10:54.111 --> 00:10:59.682
So for example, and this is a really challenge for us, we have contracts about 100 sites.
00:10:59.885 --> 00:11:57.155
pages or 20 pages or 50 pages and with this AI tool we said okay now we have the highlights the 10 points on page 1, 10, 100, 150 and then have a closer look at these parts so this is what I see more and more and I think this helps every one of us to better views and the in this second space third use case is the Insurance use case so we see it in with Google cloud with Microsoft cloud that insurance company said okay, you have an accident and your car has yeah problems on the front side or the backside the glasses are broken or whatever you make a picture and then the helps you to set okay these accidents the result is you need€850 to repair the glass.
00:11:57.296 --> 00:12:07.765
then a lot of, some, not a lot, some of these insurance companies said, okay, we give these €850 directly to the people.
00:12:07.765 --> 00:12:12.316
So we are faster, we see smaller accidents or smaller parts.
00:12:12.316 --> 00:12:20.956
So I think these are some use cases out of my surrounding area, which are really interesting and we will see what happens in the future.
00:12:20.956 --> 00:12:26.442
And I think we take care of it, what happens with it.
00:12:26.594 --> 00:12:37.096
because we had the same discussion two years before with smart contracts, smart contracts and all of these parts.
00:12:37.096 --> 00:12:40.557
And now we will see how it works with AI.
00:12:40.557 --> 00:12:43.307
So smart contracts, we don't have smart contracts today.
00:12:43.307 --> 00:12:51.461
So, but we will see what happened with the same dealing or we will have AI next year in this area we will see.
00:12:51.461 --> 00:12:56.542
But smart contracts, no, it's not part of daily work.
00:12:57.080 --> 00:12:59.610
Yep, this is some examples of...
00:12:59.610
--> 00:13:10.094
Pretty cool to see such use cases like cost estimation for insurance companies and summarizations and top highlights of out of contracts.
00:13:10.094 --> 00:13:13.214
cool use cases beside the copilot one.
00:13:15.514 --> 00:13:18.875
Copilot is like a tool for me, it's not a use case.
00:13:19.876 --> 00:13:25.278
So I feel pretty interesting to listen up to something like this.
00:13:25.505 --> 00:13:30.234
These insurance stuff is a really cool thing.
00:13:31.658 --> 00:13:36.083
with that said, what is the meaning of the AI act?
00:13:36.844 --> 00:13:44.677
to you and to companies these days, especially for Germany, if you can say anything about that.
00:13:44.677 --> 00:13:50.580
AIACT is a little bit like now we have GDPR, now we have the AIACT.
00:13:50.580 --> 00:13:58.504
So in the part of questions of the companies of we don't know what happened now, we don't know what we have to do.
00:13:58.504 --> 00:14:02.725
So this is the same period like in the beginning of GDPR.
00:14:02.966 --> 00:14:06.287
And today we have the same two groups.
00:14:06.778 --> 00:14:07.528
of people.
00:14:07.528 --> 00:14:10.701
The first one said the AI Act, this is very bad.
00:14:10.701 --> 00:14:12.652
We don't have any innovations in Europe.
00:14:12.652 --> 00:14:15.673
We don't have any innovations in Germany.
00:14:15.673 --> 00:14:27.701
All of our companies have to go to US or have to go to South Africa that they can work with AI, that they can have new companies, new ideas and dealing with AI.
00:14:27.701 --> 00:14:33.164
This is the first group that said, OK, this regulation is too much and it's over-regulated.
00:14:33.245 --> 00:14:42.307
And we have the other groups that said, OK, this regulation not to less, but this regulation is in the right part, but it's not finished.
00:14:42.307 --> 00:14:47.447
We have to optimize this regulation the next years, but we have a regulation.
00:14:47.628 --> 00:14:53.207
it is a little bit AI act or AI regulation is faster than GDPR, for example.
00:14:53.207 --> 00:14:59.288
we have AI and we have to see after two years, two and a half years, we have an AI act.
00:14:59.288 --> 00:15:02.607
This is totally fast for the legal area.
00:15:02.607 --> 00:15:06.607
Normally we need 10 years about it to have a regulation.
00:15:06.607 --> 00:15:24.340
But here in this part, political parts of our society knows that they have that they need a regulation in this area in the context of ethics, for example, that was a main part of access and to use AI in a good way.
00:15:24.340 --> 00:15:31.384
And a little bit out of my perspective is also because we have more and more elections this year and next year.
00:15:31.784 --> 00:15:44.211
And also our political friends and parties, they're a little bit afraid so that they have a lot of fake news and AI is posting more on X or Twitter and LinkedIn and everything.
00:15:44.211 --> 00:15:54.107
So we need a regulation to deal with it and for me We will see how it works in practical.
00:15:54.107 --> 00:15:58.609
So we have AI Act since last week.
00:15:59.110 --> 00:16:01.360
there are no use cases.
00:16:01.360 --> 00:16:09.453
AI, there are use cases a lot, but there are no judgments or there are a lot of we have a lot of paperwork now.
00:16:09.453 --> 00:16:12.956
We have a lot of books and about AI Act.
00:16:12.956 --> 00:16:17.118
We have six legal books about AI Act.
00:16:17.518 --> 00:16:21.476
Yeah, they work with the draft and publish it now.
00:16:21.476 --> 00:16:26.197
Okay, the draft is only 10 % on the last version of the paper.
00:16:26.197 --> 00:16:27.337
So, okay, here's our book.
00:16:27.337 --> 00:16:29.798
Here's our working book to AIX.
00:16:29.798 --> 00:16:32.778
So we have the first time in legal area working books.
00:16:32.778 --> 00:16:35.898
We don't know this about how to deal with AI.
00:16:35.898 --> 00:16:49.384
And then for me, it is very interesting that, yeah, we have the first time fast legal regulation, which defines some of our I want to say some of our borders.
00:16:49.384 --> 00:16:54.437
So for example, we have the first time fast definition of AI.
00:16:54.958 --> 00:16:56.400
So we have a legal definition.
00:16:56.400 --> 00:16:57.721
What is AI?
00:16:58.470 --> 00:17:02.822
But for me the legal definition in the AI Act is not perfect.
00:17:02.822 --> 00:17:06.095
So for IT guys I say that's not AI.
00:17:06.194 --> 00:17:10.998
So what I try to test is for example, that's what I also told in my sessions.
00:17:10.998 --> 00:17:21.194
I go to my grandma or to someone who don't know anything about AI and I read the definition, the legal definition of AI Act to them and they give me the answer.
00:17:21.194 --> 00:17:23.226
Okay, you mean the Bible.
00:17:25.609 --> 00:17:28.269
Every time, 90%.
00:17:28.269 --> 00:17:29.789
You mean the Bible.
00:17:29.789 --> 00:17:30.750
10 %?
00:17:30.750 --> 00:17:36.150
I think it was something of this new AI thing, think, but a lot of people say it is the Bible.
00:17:36.230 --> 00:17:42.220
So I think that is a little bit where we have to think about it to find a better definition of AI.
00:17:42.220 --> 00:17:46.490
And this is what I said to everyone in your company, find the definition of AI.
00:17:46.490 --> 00:17:47.769
What is AI for you?
00:17:47.769 --> 00:17:50.670
And where are the borders of AI?
00:17:50.869 --> 00:18:02.383
Because this is hopefully something which will the AI will help because more and more companies using AI for marketing reasons.
00:18:02.383 --> 00:18:03.743
Also Microsoft.
00:18:03.743 --> 00:18:07.006
The cognitive services are AI services.
00:18:07.278 --> 00:18:10.117
So no, that's not everything is AI.
00:18:10.117 --> 00:18:14.958
for example, I talked to a company yesterday.
00:18:14.958 --> 00:18:26.938
They told me, yeah, they have a new program for exchange server with logic apps and now with AI to have rules to transport emails to the right people.
00:18:26.938 --> 00:18:28.978
And there's now everything with AI.
00:18:28.978 --> 00:18:30.907
And I said, okay, what are you using on AI?
00:18:30.907 --> 00:18:33.417
No, we have only 50 rules.
00:18:33.417 --> 00:18:36.657
Okay, these rules are not AI, that's rules.
00:18:37.291 --> 00:18:45.480
And this is what I see, okay, we need to talk more about AI, about the definition, what is AI, but with AI we have a definition.
00:18:45.480 --> 00:18:54.166
And what we also have and what we get with AI, act, is also we have four classes of.
00:18:55.849 --> 00:18:56.319
AI.
00:18:56.319 --> 00:19:05.013
So what I mean is we have AI use cases and now we have to bring these use cases under these four classes.
00:19:05.134 --> 00:19:06.193
So what we have?
00:19:06.193 --> 00:19:18.960
have minimal AI systems, we have restricted AI systems, have high confidential, high restricted AI systems and we have forbidden AI systems.
00:19:18.960 --> 00:19:22.181
So it's not allowed to use these AI systems.
00:19:22.181 --> 00:19:33.737
And it's very interesting that all of these four classes and I think this is that was an intelligent way that they said, okay, we have a lot of use cases, millions of use cases.
00:19:33.737 --> 00:19:38.980
And now we bring these in these four categories or better as categories in these four categories.
00:19:38.980 --> 00:19:48.288
And now when these, for example, is in the high risk category, we have more regulation in the result of it.
00:19:48.288 --> 00:19:56.345
So high risk category is for example using AI in the health sector, using AI for example in the justice.
00:19:56.345 --> 00:20:06.436
So the lawyer bot the beginning five years ago is today a high -risk AI system.
00:20:06.436 --> 00:20:14.520
and also when, for example, the town Leipzig will use AI, it is a high -risk.
00:20:14.520 --> 00:20:23.275
So we have in this category who is using AI, so in which area, and we have which data we use in this AI.
00:20:23.275 --> 00:20:29.407
So we have two parameters and then out of this parameter we can go to these four categories.
00:20:29.728 --> 00:21:02.228
are like and this is also a very first part in this Germany government since today and it starts today or it starts yesterday the BSI the is the national security authority they have a website that helps you, which is this AI, how you can classify it and has building a little program application to help the companies with this regulation.
00:21:02.228 --> 00:21:19.240
And this is the first time in my life that I see that we have a regulation and three days later we have from our authority a tool which helps us to deal with this regulation and to help with the questions what happens with my AI.
00:21:19.470 --> 00:21:44.619
tool what happens with my AI use case what we have to do and the leader of yeah the leader of these national authorities are posting in this morning after one day we have more than 13 000 users of this new tool and we see okay This money from my
tax in this area is perfectly done.
00:21:44.619 --> 00:21:53.031
They have to do more like this and they see how much people are afraid about AI and how much company don't know what to do.
00:21:53.031 --> 00:21:54.813
And now we have these.
00:21:55.019 --> 00:22:10.701
little tools, have the support from BSI, from this government and we need more of this because now we have these AI Act, have these four categories, we have to talk to deal with, we need to think about how to deal with it.
00:22:11.079 --> 00:22:15.884
For example, and this is what I see, we need new processes.
00:22:16.065 --> 00:22:17.766
So the first result...
00:22:18.286 --> 00:22:29.246
Out of the AI Act, in the most companies is in the IT demand process or in the development process of an AI tool, we need to categorize these AI tools to the AI Act.
00:22:29.246 --> 00:22:39.625
And when it is, for example, a high -risk AI system, we have now one year, a little bit more, with high restricted AI systems.
00:22:39.625 --> 00:22:42.806
We have two years to 2020.
00:22:43.146 --> 00:22:54.559
It's like it's a little bit of time period to prepare for the AI act to to say okay, what is the the parameter for this AI system?
00:22:54.559 --> 00:23:06.884
So it must be stable, secure, all what we know from NIST2ACT or what are our principles to build an AI tool now.
00:23:06.884 --> 00:23:10.008
And now we see, okay, we need more transparency and all of this.
00:23:10.008 --> 00:23:32.445
And for me, it is very, interesting because in these parts legal, justice and health sector, the government and also cities and also all of us say, okay, in these areas we need more digitalization and maybe AI will help to be faster, have better results at the end.
00:23:32.448 --> 00:23:40.832
But I think what we need in this AI a little bit more is that we have the people point in it.
00:23:40.832 --> 00:23:49.453
So at the end we need people who knows AI, who knows how AI works to control the AI.
00:23:49.453 --> 00:23:54.233
Because we all know we're putting something into the air and we have results.
00:23:54.233 --> 00:23:59.657
We put in 100 times, but we 80, 90 times another result.
00:23:59.657 --> 00:24:02.678
So we have to think about how to deal with it.
00:24:02.678 --> 00:24:05.738
But this is a little bit what we will see in the next year.
00:24:05.738 --> 00:24:10.438
when we have a look and I have my table here because it is very different.
00:24:10.438 --> 00:24:19.178
So we have see the AI Act now, but it will be released in August 2025.
00:24:19.662 --> 00:24:23.602
but we have three parts of the AI Act which will be released on other dates.
00:24:23.602 --> 00:24:37.006
So for example, the general terms of AI, including of the definition, and the forbidden AI systems are part of the 2nd of February 2025.
00:24:37.006 --> 00:24:41.625
So we have only a half year that forbidden items are forbidden.
00:24:41.625 --> 00:24:44.306
You can't prepare, but they are forbidden.
00:24:44.306 --> 00:24:46.405
You are not allowed to use them.
00:24:46.405 --> 00:24:59.546
The second one is the 2 of August is the main part of the AI Act, like the what is an AI model and use cases, government, fines and responsibility and all of this.
00:24:59.546 --> 00:25:06.665
And then and what I said is to 2 August of 2027 is this high risk.
00:25:06.720 --> 00:25:14.592
AI level so they split a little bit so that companies and also we can deal a little bit better with this regulation.
00:25:15.451 --> 00:25:19.394
Let me quickly jump in.
00:25:19.394 --> 00:25:34.606
When you're talking about forbidden AI and you were talking about categories of risk and stuff, who is going to say that an AI should be forbidden and what's the reason for that?
00:25:34.847 --> 00:25:41.593
That's a very good question because in Germany we have the discussion who is the authority for the AI.
00:25:42.690 --> 00:25:59.877
We don't know it's the BSI set, maybe we, but we have more and more of the data privacy offices, also national data privacy, for example, from Bavaria, from Niedersachsen, from Baden -Württemberg, also from North Rhine -Westphalia.
00:25:59.877 --> 00:26:04.039
They said, we are the new authority for AI Act.
00:26:04.039 --> 00:26:05.580
We will be the authority.
00:26:05.580 --> 00:26:11.002
So we have a fight between our authorities who is responsible for AI Act.
00:26:11.022 --> 00:26:29.921
And currently it's a interesting that the first time that the authorities fight who is responsible for AI, who is the authority who said, okay, you get a fine or whose authority said, okay, it's forbidden and we come to you and it's not forbidden and you do this and you deal with this forbidden AI, you get a fine.
00:26:29.921 --> 00:26:35.823
So it's very interesting in this you say that there is not yet a list with forbidden AIs?
00:26:35.823 --> 00:26:37.854
Yes, have, no, we don't have a list.
00:26:37.854 --> 00:26:40.164
We have a definition what is a forbidden AI.
00:26:40.164 --> 00:26:56.256
For example, the definition of the category is we need very clear risk in this AI for the security of Germany for example for security of people.
00:26:56.256 --> 00:27:00.847
So it's not allowed to use AI to shoot people, example, with a drone or like this.
00:27:00.847 --> 00:27:02.367
This is forbidden AI.
00:27:02.367 --> 00:27:09.430
And it's not only the heels of the people, it's only the ethics, the internal heels of the people.
00:27:09.430 --> 00:27:14.271
It's also the basement of living of these people.
00:27:14.271 --> 00:27:17.972
And all of AIs in these parts are forbidden.
00:27:17.972 --> 00:27:20.773
The same are manipulation AIs.
00:27:20.773 --> 00:27:23.255
What I said was fake news in the election.
00:27:23.255 --> 00:27:24.675
This is also forbidden.
00:27:24.675 --> 00:27:40.086
And also it's forbidden for example that you're putting people in front of this AI system and the AI system said okay now you have to work this part and
this tool and this tool and put these together so that the AI controls the people.
00:27:40.086 --> 00:27:41.727
This is also forbidden.
00:27:41.727 --> 00:27:51.233
So these are these scoring, manipulation, high risk and security parts which are forbidden and it's very interesting.
00:27:51.605 --> 00:28:00.833
We have the AI since last week, but in the Microsoft terms of use for OpenAI, these are already forbidden.
00:28:00.833 --> 00:28:07.498
So the Microsoft looking in the draft of AI Act and putting this in their contracts.
00:28:07.498 --> 00:28:13.902
So it's not allowed to use AI to know the faces of the people.
00:28:13.933 --> 00:28:25.134
putting decisions over these people, for example, not allowed to use to film the faces and make a decision, for example, shoot these people or kill these people or like this.
00:28:25.134 --> 00:28:26.074
This is not allowed.
00:28:26.074 --> 00:28:33.273
So we have these these regulation and this regulation with these forbidden as to 27.
00:28:33.273 --> 00:28:42.079
But in the use cases of Microsoft, AWS, Google, these forbidden use cases are in their contracts.
00:28:42.079 --> 00:28:48.556
So in real life, most of these use cases are today in the contracts of AI tools.
00:28:48.615 --> 00:28:53.780
But not every AI tool we can use is a part of these global players.
00:28:53.780 --> 00:29:00.487
You have AI tools from GitHub, which is for free, which is open source, and you can run on your laptop.
00:29:00.688 --> 00:29:03.931
But also, this is also dealing with this part.
00:29:03.931 --> 00:29:05.531
So very interesting.
00:29:07.403 --> 00:29:10.595
You mentioned the categories.
00:29:10.595 --> 00:29:15.556
They are very important and one of the benefits we get from the AI Act.
00:29:16.316 --> 00:29:24.999
What are the main pillars actually where we can benefit or may have some restrictions from the AI Act?
00:29:24.999 --> 00:29:49.759
The target of the AI Act and the main pillars is that the AI Act brings us a border which defined, give us the hints and the guideline which AI use cases we can use or which AI use cases are allowed in our society.
00:29:49.759 --> 00:29:58.484
So what we are seeing is the AI act is a result of discussion of lawyers, IT guys, experts and everything.
00:29:59.584 --> 00:30:03.817
This is of the knowledge of the last year and the beginning of this year.
00:30:03.817 --> 00:30:08.099
We will see how the AI will be changing in the next years.
00:30:08.099 --> 00:30:17.186
But the main pillar is that we have now the borders in which we can deal and which is forbidden, which is a part outside of the border.
00:30:17.227 --> 00:30:24.972
And the main target and also the main pillar in this area is that, OK, we know this, we know how to deal, we know how to deal with AI.
00:30:24.972 --> 00:30:43.464
But the main pillar is that everyone and also me, want the target and we want the goal at the end, that AI is not in a use case like destroying the society, destroying,
killing us.
00:30:43.464 --> 00:30:52.368
It's a little bit like we have dynamite, dynamite in a positive way, we get gold and everything, but with dynamite you can kill people.
00:30:52.368 --> 00:30:53.829
That's the same here.
00:30:54.351 --> 00:30:58.980
It's forbidden to use AI to kill people, but it's possible.
00:30:59.115 --> 00:31:00.727
You can use an AI.
00:31:00.727 --> 00:31:02.208
We have these scenarios.
00:31:02.208 --> 00:31:04.009
We see it in Ukraine today.
00:31:04.009 --> 00:31:06.359
We have our industry.
00:31:06.359 --> 00:31:15.315
They have these use cases and there is AI with, for example, you can use the reply robot dock with a gun on it.
00:31:15.315 --> 00:31:19.979
And there's AI for who is the people we need to kill, who is the people.
00:31:19.979 --> 00:31:22.690
And this is forbidden.
00:31:22.690 --> 00:31:25.321
it is for me, that is the main pillar.
00:31:25.324 --> 00:31:33.738
We know now how to use AI and we get a guideline to use AI in a way that we don't destroy our society.
00:31:33.738 --> 00:31:35.528
Got it.
00:31:35.528 --> 00:31:36.838
Sorry.
00:31:36.838 --> 00:31:51.296
So that's very interesting because it's good to understand that's a kind of guidelines instead of something like you said at the very beginning, you have a fine catalog or something like that.
00:31:51.296 --> 00:31:59.730
It's a law which some fines, some borders.
00:31:59.730 --> 00:32:12.340
It's more about the general understanding and a common way to identify, specify AI in general and clarify some questions.
00:32:12.340 --> 00:32:29.839
But what are the use cases for AI to get good for the society instead of you can go and use AI for almost everything without any limitations.
00:32:29.880 --> 00:32:34.321
So that's an interesting one for me to understand.
00:32:34.321 --> 00:32:41.836
Feels like it is in framework where we can work with like the Responsible AI framework from Microsoft.
00:32:41.836 --> 00:32:45.877
And as you said, it matches the whole time together.
00:32:45.877 --> 00:32:48.528
So that's cool to know that.
00:32:48.528 --> 00:33:03.904
So to our audience out there, if you've acted within the Responsible AI of you should be very safe for your applications that you don't have to fear the EU AI act at that stage.
00:33:03.904 --> 00:33:05.435
That's pretty cool.
00:33:05.435 --> 00:33:10.897
And Microsoft is working with authorities together in this responsible AI topic.
00:33:11.577 --> 00:33:28.088
And also at the beginning, the head of legal of Microsoft, Smith is also going to everywhere and Microsoft also speaking to bring this responsible AI on a level that we can deal with it, that is the basement of bringing your ideas to life.
00:33:28.513 --> 00:33:30.134
but not every idea.
00:33:30.214 --> 00:33:58.587
So apart, and this is what I like, and I'm talking to Sarah, who's the owner of the Azure Safety API system, that we have these Azure Safety API systems, not only from Microsoft Tools, it's also possible you have your AI on AWS, tunnel it and bring it to Azure Safety API and bring it back, so we have this control and filter system, but on the other side, we have these two groups, the first group set, every filter system and everything crash our AI.
00:33:58.587 --> 00:34:20.197
our AI innovation and they said okay we need a little bit of controlling what happened there that AI is also on the on the street and it goes not on from the street from the street in the dark parts of the wood nearby the street yes we will see it I think there are dark parts of the street when you go into the darknet.
00:34:20.197 --> 00:34:27.938
Today you can buy for $50 AI tools with hacking components and everything.
00:34:27.938 --> 00:34:32.157
But this is what we don't want in our society to bring it more.
00:34:32.266 --> 00:34:47.922
bring the value of AI into front and when something happens we have the fines and the sanctions but now we will see which authority will come and say okay now it's not allowed but now you get a fine and now you have to stop this working.
00:34:49.282 --> 00:34:54.103
I like the idea of getting some rules and a general understanding.
00:34:55.164 --> 00:34:59.806
Do you think that will change anything for our personal life?
00:35:00.192 --> 00:35:29.981
like we already clarified it's in some or let's say many of these large company contracts already so it's nothing it sounds like it's nothing new we just have an official paper to get this do you think it makes any impact for our personal life and gets more protection or something like that yes it it's and then this is a very good question in a part of We have the EU AI Act.
00:35:29.981 --> 00:35:36.199
We have acts in China where we said China is only allowed to use AI out of China.
00:35:36.199 --> 00:35:38.733
So it's not allowed to use OpenAI in China.
00:35:39.461 --> 00:35:47.750
Microsoft hopefully won't want to deploy OpenAI, that's your part, deploy AI in the China government's cloud, but today it's not available.
00:35:47.750 --> 00:35:48.740
So that's not allowed.
00:35:48.740 --> 00:35:50.492
And South Korea is the same.
00:35:50.492 --> 00:35:54.416
So in APEC, we have more of these restricted regulations.
00:35:54.416 --> 00:35:59.280
In Europe, we have a regulation, but not so much restricted, like in China in this part.
00:35:59.280 --> 00:36:03.244
So in China, it's forbidden to use AI outside of the country.
00:36:04.960 --> 00:36:14.860
I think with these regulations and AI, we have a fight of the economical systems in the world via these AI regulations and AI tops.
00:36:14.860 --> 00:36:25.750
So we see, for example, we see today and I think we see it more and more with this AI question in our daily life that we use an application out of US or Europe.
00:36:25.887 --> 00:36:42.074
And we use an application out of India or out of Russia or whatever that will have another functions that will be maybe more free or it will deal with more high risk
functionality.
00:36:42.074 --> 00:36:44.735
And we will say, okay, we will see more.
00:36:44.735 --> 00:36:49.268
Okay, we use a tool from here, we use a tool from here.
00:36:49.268 --> 00:36:53.130
But yeah, we will see more and more differences.
00:36:53.385 --> 00:36:55.106
and we have to decide what we want.
00:36:55.106 --> 00:36:57.376
But what is the solution at the end?
00:36:57.376 --> 00:36:58.067
We don't know.
00:36:58.067 --> 00:37:03.389
That is a high discussion of our society.
00:37:03.389 --> 00:37:13.311
And it's very interesting that only with the topic AI and these new tools, we're coming to this high -level discussion of fight between the social systems.
00:37:13.871 --> 00:37:20.014
I don't talk about this in one of these podcasts, but at the end, it is a question of...
00:37:20.289 --> 00:37:30.384
how to protect your society or how open you are and which commercial or which society system will deal best with it.
00:37:30.445 --> 00:37:37.230
Do I know the solution if Europe is better, US, Brazil, China or South Korea, the epic part?
00:37:37.230 --> 00:37:39.110
we will see what happens at the end.
00:37:39.110 --> 00:37:40.809
is a good question.
00:37:40.809 --> 00:37:43.369
But let me give you the question to you.
00:37:43.369 --> 00:37:44.409
What do you think?
00:37:44.409 --> 00:37:49.510
Is it better to have an open system where you can create every AI users you want?
00:37:49.510 --> 00:37:51.550
Or is it better you have a border?
00:37:51.550 --> 00:37:59.849
Or is it better you have so small borders that only 10 % of use cases are allowed, like in China?
00:38:00.949 --> 00:38:01.829
What do you think?
00:38:01.829 --> 00:38:04.650
What is better for AI innovation?
00:38:05.001 --> 00:38:14.809
I personally prefer there are some guidelines and orders to avoid misuse of all these.
00:38:14.809 --> 00:38:26.155
And I think, if it's too restrictive, then we lose some or we miss some chances to get more innovative technology.
00:38:26.155 --> 00:38:34.702
But to just specify it like harm any human life.
00:38:34.893 --> 00:38:48.748
or something like that to create some deep fakes to, I don't know, use for illegal parts like something I heard about the story.
00:38:48.909 --> 00:39:25.541
Someone was in a video call with sea level of the whole company multiple people but no one was real all was deep fake and they decided to spend money or move money to a legal account this is the manipulation AI and is a forbidden AI exactly so that's something which should be regulated from my personal point of view and then already aware there is a dark net for today's technologies and there will be a dark AI net or something like that.
00:39:25.782 --> 00:39:37.173
So yeah, from my point of view, long story short, I'm absolutely for the regulated, but not to crush everything and restrict it on a very low level.
00:39:37.173 --> 00:39:42.117
We should be open to work with AI and get more ideas about that.
00:39:42.369 --> 00:39:45.512
Yeah, I see it on a very same way like you.
00:39:45.512 --> 00:39:50.416
I like the idea of having a framework that gives some guidelines on how to do it.
00:39:50.496 --> 00:40:11.173
And I also like that there is a possibility to estimate whether you are going to risk or not, that there are some estimates where you can follow on to put it into one of those columns to say whether this is a risk position or not.
00:40:11.626 --> 00:40:22.831
Also having an idea about where the data is going to be treated and how the data is going to be treated and what that system means to a human or to an employee within a company.
00:40:23.172 --> 00:40:26.922
I think all those points are very, very valid.
00:40:26.922 --> 00:40:56.905
What I also like is that the EU, the EU AI Act is also taking care of that there is still freedom to be innovative and that they are enforcing and encouraging the economics and the citizens to be creative, to create something fancy and cool or to have a production support and assistance or whatever what you called an advocate or so.
00:40:56.905 --> 00:40:59.726
So this is really crucial and important.
00:41:00.027 --> 00:41:13.032
I wouldn't say that the better way is to have like the China or the APEC does it to hardly strict it and regulate it down.
00:41:14.250 --> 00:41:25.597
that stops innovation and that, from my understanding of how the world is running for the moment, will stop also economics at that point, on a certain point.
00:41:25.639 --> 00:41:29.141
We will see what happens.
00:41:29.141 --> 00:41:35.224
But when we bring it back to your question from the beginning, what happens now for the companies?
00:41:36.172 --> 00:41:41.393
We have to think about it who is responsible in the company for these AI topics.
00:41:41.393 --> 00:41:45.420
And we are talking about it, about regulation, ethics and everything.
00:41:45.583 --> 00:41:46.923
And I think the...
00:41:47.329 --> 00:41:49.951
Data privacy officer for all of this?
00:41:49.951 --> 00:41:50.351
No.
00:41:50.351 --> 00:41:51.911
The compliance officer?
00:41:51.911 --> 00:41:55.153
No, that's more aberration contract and all this.
00:41:55.153 --> 00:41:56.494
The CSO?
00:41:56.494 --> 00:41:59.275
Is it a CSO -thema?
00:41:59.275 --> 00:42:01.096
It's every single part of it.
00:42:02.436 --> 00:42:06.639
like me and some others said, okay, we need an AI officer in the company.
00:42:06.639 --> 00:42:10.641
Like DSB, compliance officer, we need an AI officer.
00:42:10.641 --> 00:42:27.414
They deal all of these topics and talk with every legal IT security and data privacy department and bringing AI on this regulated compliant way that we have some people they deal with it.
00:42:27.414 --> 00:42:33.641
And that's very interesting that I don't have the definition for this AI officer for example.
00:42:33.978 --> 00:43:04.853
But the idea comes from from legal guys comes from the companies that said okay, we need someone who do this So the
companies today starting with people two or three they searching or shopping AI use cases in the company and I think some of these people bring them to the knowledge that they are an AI officer not on sea level but on on a like like a seasonal level on this level to bring AI and to deal with AI and the company because to be a you can ask.
00:43:04.853 --> 00:43:08.614
So for example I'm in the HR and I want to use AI.
00:43:08.614 --> 00:43:12.538
Okay, go to the AI officer and ask, okay I want to use this.
00:43:12.597 --> 00:43:13.528
Is it allowed?
00:43:13.528 --> 00:43:18.802
Can you help me to create a data flow diagram for the privacy officer?
00:43:18.802 --> 00:43:20.983
Can you help me with the security one?
00:43:20.983 --> 00:43:22.143
Can you help me?
00:43:22.143 --> 00:43:22.914
Is it allowed?
00:43:22.914 --> 00:43:31.990
Do we need to ask our employees that is allowed to use their data for this AI or is it a part of the working contract or whatever?
00:43:31.990 --> 00:43:33.851
Can we deal with the working council?
00:43:33.851 --> 00:44:13.132
in this part so I think we at the company we need to think more more about the this person call it AI officer or call it like you want for me is it these these these part of AI officer that you you help the company to bring AI on a effectively way because I see more and more and all of us we see it starting the companies with company GPD GPD or EAP program of Microsoft 365 Copilot and we see now in this area the most equation and please make a podcast to this topic.
00:44:13.132 --> 00:44:14.891
Podcast idea or for self?
00:44:14.891 --> 00:44:19.521
But I think this is too much for today but the question of...
00:44:19.521 --> 00:44:26.817
how to see parameters if AI is effectively for this company.
00:44:26.817 --> 00:44:34.371
So works AI in this part for this company, help these people, or is it only nice try?
00:44:34.371 --> 00:44:37.983
And is it AI that we can use?
00:44:37.983 --> 00:44:46.199
So is it okay to bring this money into these AI topics that AI at the is good for the company.
00:44:46.199 --> 00:44:53.416
So this matrix is AI effectively is one of the very big questions.
00:44:53.416 --> 00:44:54.639
We have this regulatory.
00:44:54.639 --> 00:44:55.128
Okay.
00:44:55.128 --> 00:45:01.876
We have an AI part which is okay with the AI Act, with data privacy and everything.
00:45:01.876 --> 00:45:07.161
But at the end, what is the matrix that this AI help the people?
00:45:07.434 --> 00:45:18.722
And our digital minister said AI will help every employee and will bring more free time for the employees because with AI they can work faster.
00:45:18.987 --> 00:45:21.478
but what means they work faster.
00:45:21.478 --> 00:45:22.340
Yeah.
00:45:22.340 --> 00:45:24.521
And this is very interesting.
00:45:24.521 --> 00:45:39.016
And out of my perspective, I think I that I will bring a lot efficiency into a company if it is used right and they use it to automate, for instance,
toil processes, which have a large running stuff and so on.
00:45:39.016 --> 00:45:45.269
So there can be a very benefit, beneficial thing for for the employee.
00:45:45.269 --> 00:46:09.235
I think within a company, it should be a council to AI questions not only one person as I would say as you've explained there are many different topics to be discussed and such it should be a council of these people to decide at the end of the day whether it will...
00:46:09.235 --> 00:46:22.878
In Germany we say Lenkungskreis, typical German word for a working group with decision people I mean, there's the work council, there's the data protection guy, there is the CSO.
00:46:23.740 --> 00:46:29.286
But the guy or the woman who organized this can be the AI officer, okay?
00:46:29.286 --> 00:46:36.132
I'm making a lot of advertising for this, but this is the thing about it's too much for...
00:46:36.525 --> 00:46:42.106
I'm working at the, for example, the plant manager and I'm dealing also with AI.
00:46:42.106 --> 00:46:44.726
No, as a plant manager, we have a lot of to do.
00:46:44.726 --> 00:46:46.005
can't deal with AI.
00:46:46.005 --> 00:46:59.005
AI for me is too big for someone that we said, okay, you have a hundred percent position and 80 % is your normal work and 20 % or 10 % is AI.
00:46:59.005 --> 00:47:02.858
So this is for me, It's not 20%.
00:47:02.858 --> 00:47:08.237
I must be 100 % or 80 % position.
00:47:08.858 --> 00:47:16.068
And this would be a thing, a very hard question for the companies today because we don't find these people.
00:47:16.068 --> 00:47:17.108
Where are these people?
00:47:17.108 --> 00:47:19.237
We have no universities.
00:47:20.038 --> 00:47:26.657
We have no stadiums, some that we have that these people will be trained.
00:47:26.697 --> 00:47:31.612
So what information do I need or what are the people?
00:47:31.612 --> 00:47:32.972
For example, get good question.
00:47:32.972 --> 00:47:34.893
What are these people?
00:47:35.092 --> 00:47:38.554
Who are dealing with AI a company will be searching.
00:47:38.554 --> 00:47:40.934
What is the profile of these people?
00:47:40.974 --> 00:47:42.306
That is very very interesting.
00:47:42.306 --> 00:48:02.570
So we have AI but in in Germany, for example, we don't have the background We don't have schools and everything they trained us to be an AI guy or AI officer or AI knowledge people or do we have a lot of we have some some AI Studying Ganger?
00:48:02.570 --> 00:48:03.389
don't know.
00:48:03.389 --> 00:48:04.570
But you know what I mean.
00:48:04.570 --> 00:48:12.070
But you know, at the beginning of the era of search engines, had the same, no one had any experiences with that.
00:48:12.070 --> 00:48:17.329
So we will grow in this and the companies will learn how to work with it.
00:48:17.869 --> 00:48:31.985
I really second that it's necessary to have someone who will have a dedicated focus on AI, maybe not someone who's using it on 100 % level at the beginning.
00:48:31.985 --> 00:48:33.226
at the beginning.
00:48:33.266 --> 00:48:45.552
think it will grow and I think it makes sense to go this way and use it, get more experience with that, and you will get more questions in the companies.
00:48:45.632 --> 00:48:58.099
Like, can we use it for this use case or this use case, not only for the legal part, not only for the compliance part, but also for what kind of AI technology can be used.
00:48:58.099 --> 00:49:06.163
And so you need someone who is familiar with this topic, and this is nothing you can do just as a side hustle.
00:49:06.543 --> 00:49:09.704
That's the point I definitely echo that.
00:49:09.704 --> 00:49:13.903
Also the question how to define the AI use case.
00:49:13.903 --> 00:49:16.063
What is the AI use case?
00:49:16.083 --> 00:49:18.643
Those 50 rules you mentioned before.
00:49:18.643 --> 00:49:20.623
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:49:20.623 --> 00:49:22.824
But this is also very interesting.
00:49:22.824 --> 00:49:31.474
And this is, for example, for me as a data privacy guy and maybe a little bit of AI people, a little bit, only a little bit.
00:49:31.474 --> 00:49:34.143
I'm not the 100 % AI guy, but a little bit.
00:49:34.143 --> 00:49:36.724
But this is very interesting.
00:49:37.686 --> 00:49:40.367
I'm asking every time what is the use case?
00:49:40.688 --> 00:49:51.456
And everyone, it's very hard to define a use case also for using Microsoft Teams, Word for tools we are using every day.
00:49:51.655 --> 00:49:54.568
But now they have to define use cases for AI.
00:49:54.568 --> 00:50:02.673
I think this is one step for and with these use cases, I can say, okay, it's a part of AI.
00:50:02.673 --> 00:50:05.005
We can categorize this, but we need these.
00:50:05.184 --> 00:50:07.795
detailed use case description.
00:50:07.795 --> 00:50:14.456
So please define what is air in your company and make these use case definitions.
00:50:15.396 --> 00:50:26.380
Why you want, for what, why, why, why, why, for what, what is the target when you use it, so parameters, is it effectively or not?
00:50:26.380 --> 00:50:35.139
And then we can check which data, which personal data, which data you will deal in which area, and then you will see if we didn't deal with it.
00:50:35.139 --> 00:50:43.666
Yeah, to me it's as always when it comes to a project where something must be developed and that's the case with AI.
00:50:44.208 --> 00:50:45.989
It's not only to have a use case.
00:50:45.989 --> 00:50:52.735
mean, you can find a ton of use cases out there, but it's to me also a question about a business case.
00:50:52.735 --> 00:50:55.338
So without a business case, don't...
00:50:55.438 --> 00:51:01.659
don't start thinking about it because the use case will pay the bills at the end of the day.
00:51:02.221 --> 00:51:14.505
So you were pretty much impressed by the speed of the government, the EU government on how they quickly came up with that EU AI Act.
00:51:14.541 --> 00:51:24.862
Do you think
that German companies are catching up that fast as well with all this AI stuff around or do you think that they are lot behind?
00:51:24.862 --> 00:51:26.961
Clear answer, no.
00:51:26.961 --> 00:51:31.681
Because we see it and we can compare it with GDPR.
00:51:31.681 --> 00:51:34.262
We have GDPR since 2018.
00:51:34.262 --> 00:51:36.702
We have now 24.
00:51:37.722 --> 00:51:39.541
It's long day.
00:51:39.541 --> 00:51:40.092
For sure.
00:51:40.092 --> 00:51:42.402
And the companies are not GDPR ready.
00:51:42.673 --> 00:52:24.509
many companies are not yeah many companies are not gdpr ready so now we have the act we have one year the one year is too short yeah and most many company has to deal with gdpr they have to deal with t -sugs they have to deal with the data with the other u regulations in this too we have the data act we have a lot of regulations import and export rules and all of these new rules and everything every to the same time to same part and now we all have to deal with it and this will be a highly hard challenge and I think many companies will say what is a fine?
00:52:24.509 --> 00:52:28.262
Okay we don't deal with it, do it.
00:52:28.483 --> 00:52:36.670
So do you expect that this will slow down the innovation hub of AI within the German economics?
00:52:37.175 --> 00:52:43.929
For some companies like in the insurance, finance and banking sector, the regulated sector, yes.
00:52:43.929 --> 00:53:02.958
But I think it is a chance for the middle market because in the middle market, they are in these innovative cases, they have the chance to say our risk is lower, not totally less, but lower and the fines are okay, we can deal with it, do it.
00:53:03.106 --> 00:53:05.338
So it's more of these do it thing.
00:53:05.338 --> 00:53:10.213
And you know, in an enterprise company, you need a long IT demand process.
00:53:10.213 --> 00:53:22.764
I think, and I go to the middle market companies as my last sentence, please, KMUs, middle market companies, use AI to come into the front of the economics.
00:53:22.905 --> 00:53:24.346
It can be a chance.
00:53:24.621 --> 00:53:25.583
For the middle market.
00:53:25.583 --> 00:53:27.664
For the middle market, yeah.
00:53:27.664 --> 00:53:28.324
Definitely.
00:53:28.324 --> 00:53:29.534
For small and medium businesses.
00:53:29.534 --> 00:53:33.527
Yeah, for small and medium businesses it's be a chance to do it.
00:53:33.547 --> 00:53:41.152
I see that some enterprise companies founding now AI companies to bring this momentum into an enterprise company.
00:53:41.152 --> 00:53:44.713
But I think it's now the chance for the middle market companies.
00:53:44.713 --> 00:53:45.164
Cool.
00:53:45.164 --> 00:53:46.275
Definitely.
00:53:46.534 --> 00:53:51.735
And you think there's a positive impact from this AI act?
00:53:51.735 --> 00:53:54.418
for those growing number of companies?
00:53:54.418 --> 00:53:58.831
Yes, definitely they can deal better with it than an enterprise company.
00:53:58.831 --> 00:54:03.333
Yes, we have this regulation and they have to deal with the regulation, what I mean is...
00:54:03.746 --> 00:54:09.889
They are more in this part that they don't need to fulfill everything of the regulation.
00:54:09.889 --> 00:54:14.860
I don't want to say middle market go and don't think at the regulations, but you know what I mean.
00:54:14.860 --> 00:54:23.155
That's more a part that it's not so critical when they don't fulfill everything diplomatically in this part.
00:54:23.155 --> 00:54:24.565
So yes, fulfill everything.
00:54:24.565 --> 00:54:26.217
That's totally fine.
00:54:26.217 --> 00:54:28.527
it's flexible, more flexible.
00:54:28.527 --> 00:54:31.389
And it's more the part that you can deal with it.
00:54:31.389 --> 00:54:35.440
And maybe you can be faster than the enterprise companies.
00:54:35.440 --> 00:54:38.543
And we see this in the electric car builder part.
00:54:38.543 --> 00:54:41.284
We have Tesla, small one, now big.
00:54:41.284 --> 00:54:48.869
We have, for example, in Germany that the post company said, okay, we are creating our own e -cars because no one does.
00:54:48.896 --> 00:54:52.969
Now they are one of the biggest e -car builder in Germany.
00:54:52.969 --> 00:55:03.916
So we see now the part of the middle market and startups to bring AI on the level that we have some enterprise use cases we don't need.
00:55:04.038 --> 00:55:10.161
For example, very easy part newspapers.
00:55:10.862 --> 00:55:14.425
are hundreds of people there writing text and everything.
00:55:14.699 --> 00:55:20.465
And there's a startup, they're using AI to create your personal newspaper.
00:55:22.967 --> 00:55:31.820
to select the content, bringing the content together and create your own newsletter, your own newspaper, your own news of the day.
00:55:32.221 --> 00:55:34.811
So you don't need a big paper company.
00:55:34.811 --> 00:55:37.322
It's a company with...
00:55:37.603 --> 00:55:44.244
You would still need some content creators or journalists to have a good...
00:55:44.244 --> 00:55:44.715
correct.
00:55:44.715 --> 00:55:49.045
But this combining and putting IT is faster.
00:55:49.550 --> 00:56:18.797
Individually and this is not what the the big newspapers can do today and all we all know 80 % of the most newspapers local ones are copying DPA content and bringing these together and only the middle part two pages are written by by journalists But I think in this area we see very fast the results of AI and also in porno sector.
00:56:19.659 --> 00:56:37.764
Yeah, would say wouldn't matter these days, but I see there a risk that the the information for the citizens is at risk because I mean, people are not reading newsletters anymore or newspapers anymore.
00:56:37.764 --> 00:56:50.208
They are more and more consuming like TikTok, Instagram, social media stuff and are more related to that than having like official news and stuff.
00:56:50.208 --> 00:56:52.429
So that will bring up another risk
here.
00:56:52.429 --> 00:57:00.516
And I would be curious to see the development of that when just AI is writing something and another AI starts to copy it.
00:57:00.536 --> 00:57:06.201
copy it and When that circuit starts, it would be funny to see the story evolving like.
00:57:08.436 --> 00:57:24.715
we say that I can be like GDPR can be a chance to bring the younger people there on TikTok, Instagram, everything to create smaller parts of news and bring it to them.
00:57:25.094 --> 00:57:26.646
So not the whole story.
00:57:26.646 --> 00:57:36.360
They don't watching Arte or Dreisatz the whole week, but bringing it on a smaller pieces and bring it in these channels.
00:57:37.438 --> 00:57:38.538
Why not?
00:57:40.298 --> 00:57:47.702
So I would say we're almost at the end of the podcast.
00:57:47.702 --> 00:57:48.161
Yes.
00:57:48.161 --> 00:57:53.893
It was a very, very interesting talk and I thank you a lot for the insights you gave here.
00:57:53.893 --> 00:57:57.244
Thank you very much.
00:57:57.784 --> 00:57:58.945
I think it's...
00:58:00.846 --> 00:58:12.766
a topic which will have the effects of doing the next years and we will stay in touch and maybe you can give us an update in a couple of months or...
00:58:12.766 --> 00:58:16.626
How AI works after 100 days.
00:58:16.626 --> 00:58:18.206
AI act works after 100...
00:58:18.206 --> 00:58:18.596
Yeah.
00:58:18.596 --> 00:58:19.005
Yeah.
00:58:19.005 --> 00:58:19.545
Why not?
00:58:19.545 --> 00:58:20.155
Why not?
00:58:20.155 --> 00:58:20.985
Yeah.
00:58:21.025 --> 00:58:21.655
Good idea.
00:58:21.655 --> 00:58:22.346
interesting.
00:58:22.346 --> 00:58:23.106
Yeah.
00:58:23.106 --> 00:58:24.795
I'm very interested into that.
00:58:24.795 --> 00:58:28.385
So I couldn't wait to have you as our guest here.
00:58:29.750 --> 00:58:37.969
So you now get some one sentence for our audience.
00:58:37.969 --> 00:58:40.661
for you, what you want to shout out to them.
00:58:43.722 --> 00:59:00.456
one Great sentence.
00:59:00.456 --> 00:59:02.527
can grave this somewhere.
00:59:06.369 --> 00:59:07.550
This is a great one.
00:59:07.550 --> 00:59:10.411
Thanks for being our guest, Raphael.
00:59:10.411 --> 00:59:15.052
It was really a pleasure to talk to you and to listen to all the insights you gave to us.
00:59:15.353 --> 00:59:21.655
You covered almost the whole area, including use cases, new use cases to our audience.
00:59:21.655 --> 00:59:27.498
Especially you catched up with how to understand the EU AI Act at this stage.
00:59:27.498 --> 00:59:33.581
Michael and would say We're very, very happy to follow up with him then in a few months.
00:59:34.061 --> 00:59:34.721
Absolutely.
00:59:34.721 --> 00:59:39.222
And I'm really happy you made some good explanations in this topic.
00:59:39.222 --> 00:59:44.862
thought, we will talk about a lot of stuff.
00:59:44.903 --> 00:59:51.425
But I think it's important and you gave us the opportunity to understand it a little bit better.
00:59:51.425 --> 00:59:52.885
Thank you very much.
00:59:52.885 --> 00:59:53.786
Thank you.
00:59:53.786 --> 00:59:54.545
So.
00:59:55.992 --> 00:59:57.972
Thank you for listening our podcast here.
00:59:57.972 --> 01:00:01.365
Stay tuned, stay interested, sign up.
01:00:01.365 --> 01:00:02.106
Here we go.
01:00:02.106 --> 01:00:02.686
Bye bye.
01:00:02.686 --> 01:00:03.856
Take care all.
01:00:03.856 --> 01:00:05.608
Thanks for listening.
01:00:05.608 --> 01:00:06.018
Bye.
01:00:06.018 --> 01:00:07.128
Bye bye.
01:00:10.228 --> 01:00:11.244
Thank