РАСШИФРОВКА 🔗
Christy Branham: Because what we found in our pieces is that they manipulated the data in a way that was deceptive to the public.
Dane Smith: Yeah, absolutely. And actually, KSTP TV and some other mainstream media have drawn attention to the gross, gross overstatement of nine billion. And even Trump just gratuitously added another 10 billion, made it 19 billion.
Christy Branham: Welcome to the Politics Chicks podcast. I'm Kristi Branham.
Renee Herskovitz: And I'm Renee Herskovitz.
Christy Branham: Monica is unable to be here today, but I am so excited to have Renee riding shotgun. Renee is our investigative editor and a Minnesota citizen researcher, and we credit her with all of the primary research behind our fraud articles. Renee, we're so excited to welcome you to the Politics Chicks team and for being my co-host today.
Renee Herskovitz: Thank you, Kristi. I'm so excited to be here.
Christy Branham: Let's get this rolling. When somebody steals public money, we should follow every dollar. But when politicians tell us who's to blame, we should follow the whole story, too. Who wrote the rules? Who's supposed to enforce them? And what do those big numbers actually mean? Our guest spent three decades reporting on government politics for the Star Tribune and the St. Paul Pioneer Press. Dane Smith knows the difference between covering a political accusation and investigating whether it actually holds up.
Renee Herskovitz: Dane has explored Minnesota's fraud narrative in a Star Tribune commentary, a MinnPost essay, and a companion fact sheet. His MinnPost commentary, hard data and context are missing from the Minnesota's overblown fraud furor, challenges the claim that Minnesota is uniquely bad at preventing fraud. He also points readers to the data, research, and legislative decisions behind the headlines. We'll talk about his years in the newsroom, the context he says is missing, and what accountability should look like for everyone involved. Dane, welcome to the Politics Chicks.
Dane Smith: Well, thanks. And it's a real honor to be invited. I've been plugged in, you guys, just recently. I'm just so impressed by the work you do. It's so careful and responsible, and you bring brains and heart to the whole public debate, and you're really, really needed in these times.
Christy Branham: Well, thank you. Thank you. We appreciate that. We were just giddy when you gave us a little call-out in one of your pieces, and then again on the Spin Sisters, and it's been kind of a mutual admiration society because your work is just so substantial as well. So I think the two bodies of work kind of complement each other, and I think it's not being talked about enough.
Dane Smith: Yeah, for sure.
Christy Branham: And Dane, you covered government and politics for both the Star Trib and the Pioneer Press. Can you take us inside both those newsrooms? So what did working for the two papers teach you about recognizing when a politician was handing you a story instead of answering your question?
Dane Smith: Well, you know, first of all, I wasn't really an investigative reporter. I was almost entirely throughout my career what's called a beat reporter.
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
Dane Smith: So I, and I actually didn't work in newsrooms. I worked in bureaus. Like, there's little offices in St. Paul City Hall where the press would work all day, and it was actually right next to the council chamber. So I did that for a few years. I was in the, I was a Washington correspondent for the Pioneer Press, so I had some offices with other national reporters from other newspaper newspapers in Washington. And then I was 20 years in the bowels of the state capitol, tiny little office with other reporters from all other news media. So my experience was, again, not a, not a Woodward or Bernstein guy, just a regular reporter covering politics and government, looking at the AP daybook, seeing what's press conferences are coming up today. But I did carve out kind of a specialty as for analytical writing, big picture, political stuff. Yeah. And, and a lot of that involved looking at the hard facts of a situation and numbers rather than just being a stenographer for what politicians were saying. And I got to say this, I became less cynical as time went on about politicians. I don't, I don't, I don't have contempt for them the way some reporters do and many other people do. You can't have democracy without politicians.
Christy Branham: Right. We need the fourth estate.
Dane Smith: Exactly. And I think most of them, even the terribly wrongheaded ones, and God knows there's a lot of those, think they're doing the best for people. And so I just want to make that clear. It's an honorable calling politics and politicians is, and I'm glad you're, you're the politics chicks and you, and you come at it that way. There is, I think too much selfishness and ego in politics. And I think there's not enough honest appraisal of what's really good for everyone in the long run. It's more about my interest groups. That is a big problem. But this could be said about people in America in general. And I don't want to get off into that, but, but that's, that's what my background was. Again, analytical, big picture stuff, not so much, you know, adversarial gotcha journalism or bringing people down. And that's, that's, that's where I come from.
Renee Herskovitz: Yeah. I would say I agree with so much of what, what you just said there, especially with the big picture and actually becoming less cynical. Can you give us an example from your reporting years when the documents changed the story that you thought you had? You know, that happened to me a lot. And what did you find and what did it teach you about covering people who know how to work with the press?
Dane Smith: I think the best answer to this question is it wasn't so much that people were providing we with documents that didn't show what they said it showed, but just demanding to see
Load full transcript
documentation for their claims often changed a story. And, and it's like, it's like, let's see the details of, of, of what you're alleging here. Let's see it. Um, and, and, and a lot of times that would make the story either evaporate or change it a lot. And, and that's kind of my theme in this piece that I wrote. There is precious little documentation for any comparisons from Minnesota to other places. And, in a broader sense, uh, I think my story here is one of, I kind of bought in early on as a watchdog of government. And that's what we do. The media is often a terrific watchdog on government and a lapdog for the private sector, actually, and business.
Christy Branham: Sadly, yes.
Dane Smith: But, um, uh, I, I kind of bought into the idea that government, this, this baseline narrative that government is a problem, that it's taxes are bad and government's bad. And so we have to, you have to just keep after it and, and, and, and persecute it almost, or, or constantly be, writing essentially negative stories about what government does. I got a Stanford fellowship in the middle of my career and took this course called public sector economics from a terrific economist named Stiglitz, Nobel Prize winning guy. And it really opened my eyes as to how the best thing going in the world is civil liberties and liberal democracies that actually. Had higher taxes and more government that provided. For more equitable distribution of the resources that we all produce. And it was just a, it was just really eye opening to, to, to get into that. Um, the details of what's working in the world and which countries has the better people who are better off. And it ends up being, uh, democracies again with civil liberties, uh, and with a, and then put an emphasis on, on equality and a higher, a better safety net and, um, and, and sharing, uh, the wealth.
Christy Branham: Yeah. And when we, when that documentation is so
Dane Smith: overwhelming, it's so persuasive.
Christy Branham: Yeah. Yeah. And when we talk, talked briefly, um, the first time we were in contact with each other, you brought up Norway and the quality of life there. And the fact that taxes, yes, are higher there, but the quality of life and people are, are statistically happier there because their basic needs are being met in a way that they're not being met in our country.
Dane Smith: So, and that's, that is a foundational thing about what my later career was, which was, uh, leading a progressive think tank here in Minnesota called growth and justice, which focused on the, uh, on the equality imperative.
Christy Branham: Yeah. Yeah. And now let's just jump into the fraud because that's kind of what the whole discussion, the rest of the discussion is going to cover today. You've written about it. We've written about it. Um, back when you first started, you were asking about Minnesota's ranking, um, in, in April of 2025 and what changed by your August, 2026 men post pieces. And what do you think still needs reporting? Because you acknowledge like we do, you acknowledge the real fraud failures and the failures of oversight, but argue the public is getting a distorted picture. So what made you return to the story?
Dane Smith: Well, the Star Tribune actually did a piece, taking a look at trying to take a look at the national perspective and discovering there wasn't much data there. Um, and so, uh, basically that piece, that earlier piece said, yeah, where is the documentation for this massive, historic, worst in the nation fraud? And, uh, and, uh, and, uh, and, uh, and a year later it was still conventional truth and we still hadn't really seen much new data. Um, and I, let me just explain my renewed interest in it in a broader context. And that's, um, uh, you know, the, the fraud piece that I wrote is part of a larger series called debunking the defamation of Minnesota, which is. Um, and, uh, you know, a lot of people, uh, could see that Trump and MAGA were really going after Minnesota, put a big bullseye on us, villainize our state and, uh, everything we've stood for demonizing black and brown immigrants, um, as the most important issue. And the immediate reason I went to men post, uh, was to, to, to, to, to hit on those issues. And there was a big piece, a big slick documentary called, uh, the precarious state. Uh, we still don't know who the donors were that produced this, but it created a very dark picture of Minnesota and Minneapolis in particular as a dystopian socialist hellhole and just everything, everything bad, uh, and no balance whatsoever. So there was, there was, there was that that was going on and I, and I could see that there was, they were going to emphasize the fraud as a, as a point as, as their main weapon in this assault. Uh, so I went to Scott Gillespie and I, uh, who is the editor of, uh, commentary for pop, for men post and said, how about the series? And he, he thought it was a good idea. So I, I launched it. And so the, I had prepared the first piece that just listed all the rankings from every source I could find that show Minnesota socioeconomic condition. And especially how, especially high we ranked in the condition of working people and people who, uh, were on the bottom half or bottom two thirds, even of the income scale. Right. And, you know, I think that was, it was just overwhelming. And, um, so I wrote that piece first, but then the ice invasion happened before it even ran. And so with the storm troopers here, Scott says, let's do something on immigration first. So that was the first piece I did. And that was the easiest. It just, the data was overwhelming about them. Yeah.
Christy Branham: Could they have made it more easy to find everything? Of immigrants.
Dane Smith: Yes. And it was, uh, and the business community was so strongly, uh, pro immigrant until they weren't. And we also saw how kind of cowardly they were when the moment came and they finally issued some statement. But, but so, so that
piece ran first and then the second piece was just amassing the rankings. Um, it's showing, you know, Minnesota was actually, uh, the least precarious state. And, and, and I summarized that in a Star Tribune article, uh, pointing out all these numbers. Uh, and I was kind of vindicated a week or two after that, uh, Tulane University did a big, comprehensive, one of the best, state of the states, um, analyses I've seen with both international and national perspective. And guess what? Minnesota ended up not top 10, not top five, number one as a best place to live. I mean, why is this not relevant to this whole debate? Um, so, so then finally I got around to the fraud narrative as the third piece in this series. And, um, so, uh, you know, that I almost regret that I didn't do it first because it too much time elapsed. And, and this all out effort to make fraud, the only story in the midterm elections for Minnesota. And they've been way too successful at that. Um, and I could, and so in a way it's timely and a way it's kind of, I hope not too, too little too late, but, um, we're on it now at least. Yeah.
Renee Herskovitz: And like we said before, you're so gracious to compliment us in, uh, our research in your MinnPost piece. Uh, and we really appreciate that. Was there anything in the legislative history that changed or sharpened your understanding of, of the big picture? Yeah, I, I knew instinctively,
Dane Smith: instinctively from all, all my years covering the legislature that there had to be shared responsibility for things. Mainly because for, uh, in the last 16 years of DFL control, Republicans have control. They've only had, I think two bienniums of trifecta. Yeah. Which means that, uh, 12 out of those 16 years, Republicans were in control of the House or Senate oversight committees, uh, human services, et cetera, with responsibility for oversight. And you guys, you guys really nailed that. Um, and what you did with your piece was, was just painstakingly show exactly how it happened. You, you, you named some names and, and you really chart it, uh, uh, really, really well. You know, and the other thing that you, that you hit on is that conservatives for years have been trying to shrink state government and privatize functions or delegate that responsibility to other players. Many of whom make a profit when they do it. Um, and so, you know, this is a thousand points of light that George Herbert Walker Bush hailed as the answer to the answer. To our problems. Let that philanthropy and charity take care of it. It hasn't really worked. Um, and, um, but, uh, in addition to you folks, I don't know if I'm sure you've seen David Schultz's piece. I think it was in the Minneapolis Tribune, which is kind of an online paper and it's kind of crabby centrist folks, but he really did do a good job also of, uh, delineating some shared responsibility for it going back many decades. So, so yeah, I think, uh, it was, uh, a really important thing that you added
there and congratulations for it. I hope you can keep it up. Well, thank you.
Christy Branham: And, you know, we were very cognizant of not trying to completely vindicate, vindicate the Republicans because they do are the Democrats. I'm sorry, because the Democrats do have some, some on us in, in this whole thing, but we wanted to actually shine a light on the fact that had the Republicans not set the stage for it, perhaps it wouldn't have been able to happen at the scale that it did. Right. And so let's talk about the numbers and unpack those a little bit because we've both touched upon those in our pieces and we hear fraud, improper payments and overpayments and billions at risk. And like, you know, so people's ears perk up because it's the, they basically created them into buzzwords in Minnesota. And it's an every attack ad that you see on TV, especially against Amy Klobuchar, you know, Cape Ellison, um, and they're used almost interchangeably. What happens when this, when an estimate or paperwork error gets presented as money somebody proved was stolen? Because what we found in our pieces is that they manipulated the data in a way that was deceptive to the public.
Dane Smith: Uh, yeah, absolutely. And actually KSTP T KSTP TV and some other mainstream media have drawn attention to the, to the gross, gross overstatement of 9 billion. And even in Trump, just gratuitously throw added another 10 billion, made it 19 billion. So, so, so, uh, it's been undercovered this whole, this whole, uh, inflation of the, of the scale. Um, but, um, you know, I, I think that, you know, the other numbers that I tried to bring some proportion to are this, are the total fraud we know so far as a percentage of total human service and pandemic spending over the last five years. And by the way, these numbers are always over several years. That gets kind of mixed up in people's minds with stolen yesterday or the last year.
Christy Branham: Right. They don't, they don't give the time context. So stuff that's data that covers three to four years, they think it happened last week. Exactly.
Dane Smith: So, so I, I tried to bring some perspective to that and show that less than 1%, I think it's less than a half percent of the total fraud that we have so far. That's what it is as a percentage of total pandemic and human service spending over the last five years, which I think is up around $200 billion. I mean, it was, it was, it was a lot of money. And of course the spirit behind a lot of that pandemic money was to get it out and don't ask questions. And that started with Trump. Right. But the, you know, the other numbers that, that I brought to bear on it, and I think this is important as a comparison with, you know, fraud has always been a problem in every human society since, since money was invented. And, and, and the, the numbers for the private sector are by all apparent, to all apparent, to all appearances, worse. So, private sector fraud from consumers in and among the private sector, corporations cheating each other and, and their, and their consumers, all kinds of, uh, behavior that can only be described as fraud is, and, and the whole cybersphere. Fraud is running amok in the cybersphere, all the, and I list about 10 different ways that it's happening. This is important context. I think the public sector may be doing a better job at preventing fraud than the private sector. Yet we worship, we revile the, the former and worship the latter. Um, so, uh, you know, and one other thing I noticed that, uh, on one of the audit, uh, autism programs, there was a star tribute story showing that it wasn't really fraud. It was an, they were serving children, uh, but they were using money specifically earmarked for autism to address other problems that kids had health. Uh, you know, um, mental health problems that does not strike me as the crime of the century. And, and the flexibility that some agencies have been able to use with streams of money is, is not maybe a generally accepted accounting principle, but it's often not what we would consider a crime or fraud at all. And this is, this is an area for you guys to further explore. I'm going to make a note of
Christy Branham: that.
Renee Herskovitz: Oh yeah. Yeah. And it actually brings up one of the questions I was going to ask as far as, um, you know, when you're looking at all the numbers and seeing what, uh, the, the federal fraud numbers are that they're putting out. And it within my research, finding that a lot of that. Isn't actually, um, proven fraud. Some of it is from coding changes, like billing code changes or from other human error that ends up not actually being fraud, but they just keep lumping this one big number together. Um, what do you think, uh, reporters or, um, anybody reporting on that could do to get more of that information out and to parse that from the large fraud number? Yeah.
Dane Smith: Yeah. You, you, you actually know more about these details and the, and the way the system works at the grand, at the micro level than, than I do. Um, and I'm not sure exactly how to answer that question, but it is, it is really important. And I will admit to being pretty confused myself as to, as to what the grand numbers actually represent. You drew it. I think you drew attention to my GAO, um, report that had total fraud estimates for the whole country and all programs. Yeah. And, and it wasn't clear to me whether that was, uh, fraud fraud or, um, improper payments or what we might call abuse. Um, and so separating all that out and explaining it is infinitely complicated. Yeah. And you're always torn between trying to get to the essential truth of something and getting so bogged down in things that you lose people. Right. But, um, it's, uh, it is, it is complicated and we, we just can't give up on it because of its complexity. I, I do think that everybody agrees that we need to reform and, and, and improve, uh, Minnesota human services. I
think that's, it's a real concern there and has been for a long time. Yeah. Going back 20 years. Um, yeah, I'm really encouraged by some, some things I see, um, in the works. Uh, I think, uh, Amy Kovachar has actually put forth more substantive stuff on, on what she hopes to do and intends to do and processes that she sets up. Then I've seen from anybody else. So go.
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
Christy Branham: I would second what you said, um, about the state, how the state there's room for improvement, because we actually interviewed a former county worker on background. And she shared with us that they would report, they would send reports of fraud up to the, the, you know, county level and state level, but they weren't being investigated because they were getting lost or there just wasn't the manpower to be able to investigate, um, the number of reports that were coming in. And, you know, that that's, it's hard to, they're understaffed and they don't, you know, I was at an event, um, and I was sitting next to Cedric Frazier at the event. It was a fundraiser for Amy, uh, for Amy, uh, Kelly Morrison. And we were talking, the computer system that they have is literally old fashioned computers. Yeah. In the state, they're not working even on modern equipment. That's how outdated everything is. So the systems aren't even talking to each other, which is just creating another problem.
Dane Smith: Yeah.
Christy Branham: As it is. So, yeah.
Dane Smith: Yeah. And we'll, yeah. The state systems have all these privacy concerns and, uh, you know, it's just, they have, they have to meet standards that other people don't with their computer systems, you know? Right. And so I think that, that is a, that's, that's an area that could certainly be improved. And I've just heard that there's a bad morale in human services. I would agree. I heard the word snake bit. And my God, we got to turn that around. There's just no question about it. Public service should be honorable and even fun, you know? Yeah.
Renee Herskovitz: And, uh, yeah, it brings me to, oh, sorry. To your point of the bigger picture too, because all of the issues that, you know, we've been just laying out with being understaffed, not having, you know, enough people to research it, having old computer systems. And that can all be tracked legislatively. So I really appreciate that. You really like looking at that big picture reporting on the big picture because, um, you know, I think a lot of people don't understand why it's understaffed or why we don't have new computer systems. Did you, do you find that in your reporting that that message gets lost in the, in the big picture?
Dane Smith: Well, yeah, I, it does. It gets lost. I, there have been most Star Tribune, other media have talked about this issue about the old equipment. I think, uh, Steve Elkins, a legislator has written about it in the op-eds. Other, other really thoughtful, constructive, uh, ideas about redoing, uh, county responsibility. I mean, we apparently farm out more human services to counties than other states, but the state really is in charge of it. And maybe we're not such a big state that the state can't do it. And, uh, and just the whole issue of, of doing too much government work through profitable operations. A lot of the Somali, uh, fraudsters were actually businesses, not nonprofits. That's a whole question that needs to be, uh, pursued. And, and, um, you know, in general, I think, uh, uh, uh, just a thorough overhaul and kind of an honest, constructive analysis is, is necessary. It's gotta happen. And I think it will either way. Yeah.
Christy Branham: Yeah. And when it comes down to it, the numbers that we came up with pretty much aligned with yours, that the national fraud rate, average fraud rate is 6. 12%. Minnesota's is at 2.16% with one of the highest prosecution rates for fraud amongst states this size. And I think that nuance is also getting lost as well.
Dane Smith: It is. I think, I think nobody's taking a look at whether Minnesota might, we've always had a famously aggressive and smart legislative auditor's office. Uh, and I've, I've known enough about comparative state governments to know that we've, we've been ahead of the game on that. So it might, it's part of this might be a case of just having that particularly aggressive office. We, there may be a lot of undetected fraud in other states that we don't know anything about.
Unidentified speaker: Right.
Dane Smith: And I think we probably are ahead of the country right now in terms of, uh, alertness, prosecution. We've gone too far in many cases. We've cut off good programs, thrown them too much baby out with the bathwater. And, uh, uh, you know, the other point to make is that this was the, the actions were initiated by a U.S. Attorney General appointed by a Democrat. And, uh, the state government and Keith Ellison, uh, pursued it vigorously once they got to it too late, but they pursued, pursued it vigorously. And we have probably more prosecutions and convictions for fraud than any other state all under democratic control. But, um, uh, again, this is, this is kind of a myopia here. It's like just Minnesota. Well, and let's, let's move
Christy Branham: back to the legislative record. Um, because Renee did such a fabulous job of going through all of the primary documents that, that took place in back way back in 2017. When house Republicans rejected rejected, rejected, they're the ones who took it out of the bill, stronger billing documentation requirements for waiver services and governor Dayton also vetoed vetoed a health budget. Um, and he warned that. And it would affect 80s. They were going to get rid of 87 additional DHS positions that would have investigated fraud. So Renee, you did such a great job of finding all of that information and laying out those proposed cuts and why they were vetoed. So Jane, what does that history tell us about the priorities of people now
describing fraud solely as a democratic failure? Because to me, it's coming across as me, me thinks she does protest too much and every accusation is a confession. Yeah.
Dane Smith: Could, could you maybe come back at the, at, with that question? And what exactly are you asking? Is it, what does it say about it? I mean, I think what is sort of speaks for itself, but yeah.
Christy Branham: So what do you think? Clearly the purpose is political, right? Because they, they've used, as you said earlier, they're using this as a running there as a plank in their platform, democratic fraud, democratic fraud, democratic fraud. We're seeing the attack ads every single day against Ellison and Amy Klobuchar. So did you find that in your research as well? Yes.
Dane Smith: Actually, I learned a lot of it from you, more from you than anything I knew before about exactly how they have been involved in the oversight. And, and the, you know, the characters like Mac Dean and Michelle Benson, I was not actually aware of that, of their, of their specific role in oversight. And it's, it's frustrating that the media has just not picking up on it at all. It doesn't seem like, I don't know whether you have gone to the news media and tried to start to view NPR and others or not.
Christy Branham: Oh, we did. Yeah. We did. They all turned us down.
Unidentified speaker: Really?
Dane Smith: Mm-hmm. That's, that's discouraging. Yeah.
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
Renee Herskovitz: One, one thing I would like to know is since you've been in the political sphere of reporting for so long, was it ever, can you ever remember a time where there was a story that involved more of the legislative process or players behind the scenes? Yeah. And was that reported before and has that changed now? Yeah.
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
Dane Smith: Um, yeah, it has. Um, here's what's happened to the news media. Nationally, we have 75% fewer reporters and editors covering the process. Yeah. Doing the grunt work than we had 25 years ago. We used to go deep into the weeds on process and, and how it was shaking out, who the interest groups were, what the arguments were, Q and A's, uh, even more personality profiles of, of, of the shapers, the movers and shakers. Um, and, uh, there was just more watchdogs, um, on, on the job. And that's been really reduced. Um, there's almost no stories that really do deep explanatory stuff. And, and it's, uh, and it's, uh, it's, it's really concerning. You may not. And here's the, here's the, here's the, here's the even weirder little angle. Minnesota probably has, I think one of the strongest mainstream media, um, presence in the country. It's, it's actually much worse in other states. Um, we have a, the Star Tribune is one of the healthiest, as, as diminished as it is, one of the healthiest newspapers in the country in terms of staff and, um, uh, viability as a, as an enterprise. Um, but we have a big problem with, with information being crowded out by disinformation and misinformation. It's, it's a full blown national and international panic. It's just not enough people doing journalism. And so that's part of the reason why your, uh, your efforts to get your story out have, are not going anywhere, not going anywhere so far. You know, I, I, and I do have to say this about the media. I have to, I'm pretty, I'm getting to be pretty critical of, of something that would always happen. Once you get invested in a narrative, once you get invested in a story that are a big, a big thing that is going to be a big thing. You're reluctant to publish a news story that discounts it or, or, or, or, or cast doubt on the whole thing. And this happened, this is herd mentality. It happens all the time in the media at all. And it, it has happened in the past. And it, it, I think it's getting worse now. Um, so, uh, you know, I've been able to get the star tribune to publish my stuff and I'm going to partly because I just have this institutional connection, but, um, I think on this fraud thing in particular, the, the, this, their, their minds made up on what the story is. And, um, and they're not too interested in committing resources to, uh, undercutting it. And, um, I, this happened to me personally, I, because I was a beat reporter and I always maintained personal relationships with reporters. The investigative reporters would come in and do something good, great, but it was so harsh sometimes that they had me come in and do stories that kind of cleaned it up. Yeah. So, uh, that's just, uh, interesting dynamic that I noticed a couple of times. I remember we did a report that was just really harshly critical of, uh, of a farmer in Anoka County who was mistreating his immigrant workers and it, and it wasn't, they left out some important stuff. And so I would come along and do a story that kind of correct some things. Yeah.
Christy Branham: And, and what we're seeing in the twin cities now, um, care 11 has been bought. Tegna was bought out by next star. Um, paramount owns, is it WCCO? Yes. Is that the CBS affiliate? And then. CCO is CBS.
Dane Smith: Yeah. And then.
Christy Branham: Uh, and then.
Dane Smith: Oh, CCO is CBS radio. And I think they. Well, whatever. Yeah.
Christy Branham: And KSTP is Hubbard Broadcasting. And all three of those are conservative outlets. And we interviewed a former, um, FBC attorney, um, or FTC attorney. I'm sorry. Um, who was worked in communications. And what he told us is that going forward, the game plan is to have all local news for those networks, especially on next star across the country to originate from youth news max, which is a really scary thought. If you think about it. Oh, I've heard that.
Dane Smith: Oh man. Yeah.
Christy Branham: I'll send you the link to our article. It was kind of terrifying. Yeah. Um, when we talked to him about the consolidation of local news and we're all already seeing under reporting. Monica is not here today because she's supposed to be on
vacation this week. Um, she was scheduled to leave for Hawaii. Um, on Wednesday, I believe Wednesday, she was supposed to leave for Hawaii. Her, her plans have changed and they're going to be staying in California because there was a hurricane in Hawaii and they were experiencing power failures and gas shortages. How aware of you guys that there was a major hurricane that, that nearly destroyed Kauai in Hawaii, just out of curiosity.
Renee Herskovitz: I have a friend that lives in Hawaii. It's the only reason I know.
Dane Smith: That is my point.
Christy Branham: Exactly.
Dane Smith: Inside the A section stories about this long nor'easter here or something in Hawaii. Yeah. But what you're saying about, uh, really corporate, complete corporate billionaire oligarchy control of the media is just frightening. There's so much frightening stuff going on, but this is, this is really, really huge. You know, the, the fact is that American media newspapers, uh, have always been owned by the richest guy in town or part of the, you know, it's, it's always been a capitalist enterprise itself. Right. Which is a problem actually. And they've never really seriously questioned the, the, you know, the principles that, uh, that the best way to do things is through profit making and competition and et cetera. Uh, but now it's really getting worse. It's really, really worse. At least in the past, there was a lot of smaller independent wealthy guys in town running it and often in conflict with another wealthy guy who was running a different paper. And there was, you know, there was, there was such a multiplicity of independence that, that the media actually produced pretty good, healthy, factual, um, honest, reporting about things. But that's, now it's getting consolidated in a, just a scary way.
Christy Branham: Uh, I would agree.
Dane Smith: The, uh, they're just moving towards total control and the, and the, there's just very few, increasingly fewer voices that challenge the oligarchy's narrative, um, in a fundamental way. Yeah.
Renee Herskovitz: Yeah. And which I think kind of answers one of the questions I had for you. And I think we kind of all know the answer to it, but, um, you know, when it comes to the whole fraud narrative and we know that there are, uh, health insurance companies, health insurance plans, you know, private MCOs, nonprofit, you know, they kind of fall under all of these different titles. And so you can get into the weeds with it, um, really easily. That was probably one of the hardest parts of the research I did. Um, but they're never mentioned in, uh, any of the reporting. Um, even though, you know, there's these private companies that are nested inside of a nonprofit that have oversight responsibilities, but that part's never talked about. What do you think, um, the reason is for that?
Dane Smith: You, you guys did a really great job of holding their feet to the fire on this, uh, on this decision to allow profit making for MCOs. Um, yeah, that's, that was something I was not even really all that up on. So I, I hope you keep going after that. And here's the thing in the whole healthcare area, by far, by far, uh, the, the amount of money that is, um, taken as profit, um, and the amount of, uh, improper and semi fraudulent behavior from, uh, overbilling. Um, all of the, you add up all these things together that are happening in managed care, uh, the wasteful competition between managed care organizations, um, amounts to many, many, many times more. The amount of, uh, outright fraud at the bottom from, from people who are, uh, you know, uh, actually, uh, small fry. And, uh, and this is never added as context. I mean, I think, um, if I were going to, uh, assign a project, a courageous project for investigative reporters, it would be a full on analysis of the history and the behavior of United Healthcare. Uh, which is not only one of the largest corporations in the world and one of the most profitable corporations in the world. Uh, I think it's top 10. Yeah. And, uh, Fortune 500 based right here in Minnesota. Um, it, you know, that's, that is a largely unexamined story.
Renee Herskovitz: Um, let me know when you want to put a crew together. Yeah.
Christy Branham: Did you see, did you see, did you see Bernay's ears perk up? She's like, she's like, what did you say? Let's look at that. Yeah.
Dane Smith: And actually, if you count everything they have done against as, as, as some sort of, you know, fraud, waste and abuse, Minnesota might actually be. Right. Yeah. Right. But in fact, I saw a kind of a brain dead report, uh, recently about most federal, Hennepin County getting more federal government money than any other place in America. And I was like, wait, wait a minute, you know, this, and then I thought immediately, well, they must be talking about, um, United Healthcare. I don't know.
Christy Branham: Yeah. Yeah. And I think the most egregious thing that we uncovered when we were, when, when Renee was doing this research and Monica and I were both kind of like mortified by it is that key players in this, like Michelle Benson and Dean went to work as lobbyists for companies. that profited from this and Benson actually went because there was legislation to then since since all this has gone down Minnesota has gone back to only allowing non-profit HMOs to operate in Minnesota but Michelle Benson actually appeared in committee to try to argue against that legislation what year did they go back 2025 just now well yeah
Renee Herskovitz: I think it went into effect then it passed during the last trifecta 2023-24 session yeah yeah I do
Dane Smith: recall that now but yeah this is material um uh it's it is important and in the and in the past again journalists and the media would we're harder on the revolving door and uh I don't I don't think Minnesota actually even has a law about uh or a or a you know a two one or two year period of where you can't lobby after coming out of
the legislature um I'm on the board of a group called clean elections Minnesota and we are discussing um making that a priority pushing for that kind of thing it's a little hard though to to accuse I think it's you have to be careful of accusing people of outright corruption on this we're a citizen legislature everybody who worked at the legislature hasn't made a job
Christy Branham: 100 percent and
Dane Smith: a lot of people uh take lower pay at the legislature because they know the expertise they get there will help them make money in the future and um so it's it's uh as with everything it's uh it's it's not uh not as simple as it sounds I do think it's important to just have this transparency around things and have it more widely known uh where people have been and and where they are now in terms of policy and benefiting from it yeah and I just want to
Christy Branham: underscore what you just said being a state legislator and then going and working for as a lobbyist for a company that whole that none of there's nothing there's nothing illegal about any of that it's completely legal it's the propriety and it's the you look at it and it it has an improper appearance to it and I think that's part of the
Dane Smith: problem yeah yeah absolutely I like to see say that lots of things are perfectly legal and also wrong yeah yeah and and and vice versa well let's let's just um
Christy Branham: circle this back around and and talk about one final thing before we get into something a little bit more light lighthearted so listeners listening to us and and viewing us today may say I don't care which party wrote the rules I care that the money was stolen what's your response to that and how do you think we can demand consequences for fraud and failed oversight while challenging the leap from those failures to just blaming the democrats because there's account there's accountability and it needs to be accepted by everybody right
Dane Smith: right well I come on we all care we do care that money was stolen and nobody nobody disputes this it's everybody's the mea culpa's have been flowing like crazy um you know walls is acknowledged that he screwed up and he it cost him he couldn't he dropped out of the race right um so and so the comeback to that is you also have to care about the context i mean you just you um and and if you're so furious about this why aren't you also interested in the larger fraud and corruption outright corruption that is going on unchecked all around us at a national level on a on a scale we never even imagined was possible self-deer uh piling up money direct direct payback uh for for contributions to actually pardon fraudsters multi-billion dollar scale fraudsters um i mean let's uh if if you don't care about which side or who's responsible for it um or which party wrote the rules um you know that's that's ridiculous not to care and not to be not to and not to apply an equal standard to both parties
Christy Branham: i agree so
are you ready to do
Renee Herskovitz: the word of the year yeah yeah
Christy Branham: so many are you ready to do some lightning round questions are you ready for some lightning round questions dane thanks for
Dane Smith: sending me these in advance because i'm terrible at lightning round okay news
Christy Branham: room habit i always think like
Dane Smith: fall on the other hand yeah newsroom habit you never lost following the
Christy Branham: money love that yeah one
Renee Herskovitz: question politicians least like to be asked what do
Dane Smith: your big donors get from you in
Christy Branham: return i love that too dude you're speaking our language today the first thing you look for when someone hands you a dramatic statistic
Dane Smith: in what way might this be too good or too bad to be the essential truth love that uh
Renee Herskovitz: one minnesota story you wish people understood more well i'm just
Dane Smith: uh i'm just a crazy history buff i love reading deep history and and you know personal stories and just the the what life was like and um i to me the i've i wish more people understood that the historic influence of radical equity-minded equality- minded communitarian reformers had on our state's basic political culture i've written a lot about this but i always like to say that many of the things we now value were ridiculed as socialist unworkable too expensive impractical uh and yet uh through persistence uh equality-minded minnesotans made these things happen and we can go all the way back to everything from our role as leading abolitionist state to progressive party uh very anti- establishment teddy roosevelt took on the capitalists in those in the progressive area farmer labor party hugely important in minnesota's history again openly socialist um and they provided us with an income tax and investment in education and all kinds of public good uh that we now take for granted so so that's that's the big thing for me is i wish people knew more about that
Christy Branham: and we asked this of all of our guests what's giving you hope right now
Dane Smith: well the energy and intelligence of uh people like you um i i really am getting to know and admire the young left in this state um yes and i'm and i'm seeing rapidly declining support for all the ways that uh maga and project 2025 are doing to undermine democracy and equality in this country and so that's certainly hopeful but man they got a lot of money and they are powerful and they're coming at us uh every which way they can and so we i'm i'm enthused about this and you know i was hoping for a quiet retirement but um um i think we all are monica
Christy Branham: retired she was they're invading my state and destroying my
Dane Smith: country and it's actually i think it's going to keep me alive longer okay
Renee Herskovitz: so where should listeners go to read all three fraud pieces uh your start to view and commentary the men post essay um yeah just go to
Dane Smith: the men go to men post there's no um paywall there and uh it's all it's all available and to just look for my name and def defamation of minnesota again i i wrote just one piece and a sidebar fact thing on fraud the other two are about immigration and rankings and a general theme of debunking uh defamation of minnesota well dane
Christy Branham: thank you so much for bringing your reporting experience to this conversation and renee thank you for all your research and co-hosting today i just admire both of you so much because i i know the depth and the um the scale of this investigation and i just admire both of you for spending the time to research it and deign for you to also write about it because i truly believe that the more people that are writing and reporting on this the more likely we are for this to break through to the public so they have a better understanding of what's actually happening well
Dane Smith: the mutual the admiration is mutual you folks are really providing a fresh uh new energy and and and uh breathing some life into the into the uh the uh loyal opposition here uh on on what's on mega and and the uh the real threat that we see coming coming at us fast and furious
Christy Branham: yeah yeah and to our listeners if you're finding meaning in the stories we're sharing if something moves you challenges you or makes you see the world a little differently please like comment and share it helps more than you know and follow us everywhere at the politics chicks on sub stack threads blue sky instagram tick tock and facebook thanks for being a part of our community keep shining your light so we can find each other in the dark and remember we're stronger together renee thank you so much for co-hosting today for your first podcast thank you thank you and thank you dane for coming on today and sharing your expertise and your your knowledge and and your your point of view i think it was a great conversation today