РАСШИФРОВКА 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Hey, this episode of the Chuck Todd cast is brought to you by Prenuvo. Now I'm the type of person who's a big data guy. I want real data about my health. So I have gotten a closer look. I got the whole body MRI at Prenuvo. And here's what getting a whole body MRI is actually like. There's no radiation. There's no needles. It's about an hour. That was my Prenuvo scan. And afterwards, you get this detailed report and a review call with a Prenuvo provider. And you get your own doctor involved too. They can see the results as well. You find out, you understand what you've seen. And Prenuvo offers memberships that will bundle MRI scans, blood panels, personalized results review to track your health year after year after year. And look, I'm glad I did it. I had a neighbor who died of brain cancer. who didn't know it until it was too late, right? And you know, in some of these things, there's a little bit of a peace of mind that comes with it. I'm not gonna get into my personal health details, but there's a small thing that we did know I had an issue with, but the scan found and now we're tackling it. I love exit polls. I want as much data in advance to prepare myself for what's likely to be. So to learn more about Pernuvo and get $ 300 off your whole body MRI, go to Pernuvo.com slash Chuck Todd and use the code Chuck Todd. That's P-R-E-N-U-V-O.com slash Chuck Todd. Terms and conditions apply. Receive $ 300 off Pernuvo whole body scans and executive and comprehensive memberships through January 31st. For full details, visit Pernuvo's website to read their terms and conditions and purchase Privacy notice. Pernuvo gifted me a whole body scan. A Pernuvo scan is a screening service. It is not diagnostic. Diagnosis and treatment are determined by your health care provider. Well, these days... The sign of being authentic in politics apparently is connected with the number of times you curse. I have kid, but it does feel as if something has changed in the last decade. Perhaps it is social media. Perhaps it is the flattening and the eradication of the media gatekeepers. There certainly was a time when you had to be careful. The FCC could fine you as a news organization if you were certainly in the broadcast room. And there's still some of those restrictions that exist today. I'll share a story that I was a part of before I bring in my next guest here, but it is all about the issue of profanity. One of my most infamous YouTube moments is me flipping the bird while getting ready to go on Morning Joe. I didn't know the camera was on me. I was mortified at the time. These days, it is served as a laugh line. The clip is more than 10 years old, but it does get reincarnated every now and then. But at the time, I felt like I had to apologize to a whole bunch of people and et cetera, et cetera. Well, my next guest has written a fascinating fun book. And hey, we're post-election. Before we get into the 2028, we want to have a little fun here. And this
Load full transcript
is a great holiday season. So be thinking about this one with my My friend here, Stephen Jaffe, he's written a book called Four Letter Nation, The Long Dirty History of American Profanity, even with an F asterisk U right on the cover. It's a wonderful cover. Let me hold it up for folks here. I love it. It's Uncle Sam. Not flipping the bird, but you could have done that too, right, Stephen?
00:03:35
Speaker 2: Yes, yes. Well, I can't take credit for that cover. The cover designer at Simon & Schuster came up with that, and we all immediately started you know, guffawing and saying, oh, you know, he hit it out of the park this time. And now the book, yeah, go ahead.
00:03:51
Speaker 1: No, let me start with your, look, you have a history of being a museum curator. You're a historian in many ways. How'd you end up writing a book about profanity? You know, they're too short. I'll give you two different short answers. The first is, quite frankly, that I've been fascinated by the power of what we would call dirty words since basically elementary school. You know, I went to PS41 in Greenwich Village in Manhattan and around fourth grade or so. And I will not name, I still can identify the culprit, but I will not since I'm friends with him on Facebook to this day. And it was basically the dozens or or or the toasting or signifying, as it's known for a long time in African-American culture. The interesting thing.
00:04:56
Speaker 2: Was this this this friend of mine was not African-American. And it and that in itself. I mean, I recognize that these words, some of the words I knew, some of them I didn't know, but I recognize the tone and the context. I remember blushing. actually, and in anger and kind of humiliation. I had nothing to top him with or even match him with verbally. That's a vivid, that's one of those childhood memories. I have cleaner childhood memories as well. That's one that stuck with me and maybe over the decades, it kind of informed my interest in history, my training and education in American history. And one of the broader themes in American history that's turned out to be quite interesting to me is this question of What are the rules, culturally? What are the rules societally? What are the rules? What does it mean to break them? And how do they change? And in essence, that's what the book is trying to narrate over the centuries.
00:06:08
Speaker 1: You just triggered one of my favorite episodes of It's Always Sunny. And it's a, they really do a good job of this sort of testing the lines.
00:06:17
Speaker 2: What's appropriate?
00:06:18
Speaker 1: What is it? They do this whole thing about the gang turns black and it's this whole sort of, and there's this whole song with Danny DeVito. What are the rules? What are the rules? And it's fun, but it gets at the point which, you know, what are the rules at any given time, right? And I'll take, So I remember during the Bush-Cheney campaign, Bush points
out a reporter Dick Cheney is overheard saying, and the reporter is a New York Times reporter, and he says, oh, yeah, that guy's a major league asshole. And it was, oh, my God.
00:06:52
Speaker 2: Yes, yes, yes, yes.
00:06:54
Speaker 1: The next vice president, cursed, called a reporter an a-hole. Yeah, right, right, right. We were all like, oh, heavens to mercatoids, right?
00:07:03
Speaker 2: Yeah, right, right.
00:07:04
Speaker 1: And yet, of course, all of us in a newsroom have spoken this way. We only speak this way.
00:07:08
Speaker 2: Of course.
00:07:09
Speaker 1: We have to edit ourselves to prevent it, but- It was. And then I think of one other moment when Joe Biden whispers to Barack Obama at the passage of Obamacare, the Affordable Care Act, and he says, hey, this is a BFD. And he didn't just say F. And now we're like, so it was our vice presidents. Right.
00:07:28
Speaker 2: Yeah. Really? Yeah.
00:07:30
Speaker 1: Biden, who's the right.
00:07:31
Speaker 2: Right. Broke, broke, broke through. Yeah.
00:07:34
Speaker 1: But they were both caught. It felt. You know, it was weird. It was like, oh, you know, should we really have done this? Did you just erase the line that we're going to wish we had back?
00:07:44
Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, I think it's, you know, I will even submit to you that this has been, and you're of course spot on with what you were saying initially about the, you know, social media issues. And the change in our popular culture. I mean, look, it's always sunny in Philadelphia being a prime example among many over the last, what, two, three, four decades, really. But, you know, politically, I would submit to you that you can look at Obama's dreams from my father. which was published in 1995. Now, he's still a law professor then. But obviously, the wheels are turning with Chicago. So that's a book where he drops the MF bomb. He uses the P word for female anatomy, that kind of thing. And clearly, there had to be some calculation or some sense of, well, This is edgy. What do I want to do with this? And the book sold seven million copies over time. And I think that even in one of the audio book versions, you can hear Barack Obama reading his book, you know, several ten years later and voicing those words.
00:09:09
Speaker 1: And so the great badge of honor I have is yes. I think it was at, I participated in a little gag with him at a white house correspondence dinner, a little thing. And I think he said, Hey, fuck you, Chuck Todd. Um, you know, and it was part of the punchline.
00:09:25
Speaker 2: Right.
00:09:26
Speaker 1: You know, I remember before, like, you know, somebody comes up to me from his shop. Hey, you know, you okay with this? I'm like, sure. Fine. You know, like, was it going to be a big deal, but it was sort of like, you know, it was, it landed. Cause you're like, wow. You know, uh, and, uh, But it was funny. It's sort of like this is a 21st century evolution. I mean, we knew Bill Clinton cursed
like a sailor.
00:09:50
Speaker 2: Yes, yes.
00:09:51
Speaker 1: That we know. And yet, you know, he was always very careful. And you never– there were rare occasions you ever heard him actually use– use profanity.
00:10:02
Speaker 2: Exactly. And that's been a gradual erosion. Of course, we can mention a certain current.
00:10:08
Speaker 1: No, I mean, in that sense, Trump is obliterated at all.
00:10:13
Speaker 2: Right. He's blown down the walls. He's Lenny Bruce. That's right. He's the Lenny Bruce of the presidency. You know, the thing, the paradox, if you think about it, the paradox of dirty words is that you are, what are you doing? You are speaking the unspeakable. Yeah. Right. And that's always been taboo. And, you know, we can go back to the 1600s, which the book does do, you know, and all the way forward. What's happened in the 20th century? And I see it as sort of a gradual peeling back of the taboo. I even want to argue that and I do in the book that that it kind of starts with Mark Twain. in the post civil war where he starts poking fun, not at the, not at the S bomb or the F bomb. Cause that's, that's taboo for public. Although he writes some very raunchy things in, in, in private that don't come out until after his death. But when it came to things like, so, you know, a classic Twainism in the 1870s in his book, roughing it, He's talking about getting to the far west. I think what to him was the far west. Maybe the Great Plains. And he gets out there, and he's having lunch with somebody. And the guy goes, something to the effect of, pass the salt, you son of a skunk. Now, this gets published. But the next line in the book is, hmm, actually, I'm not quite remembering that right. He didn't quite say skunk. And he then goes on, nudge, nudge, wink, wink. Anybody, even in Victorian America, late 19th century America, knows what he's saying, son of a bitch. And yet he's teasing around the edges of it. What happens in the 20th century that sets up Obama, Trump, Biden, Cheney, etc.? is the gradual, two things really, I would say it's two factors. One is that cursing becomes much more public. People always curse, the colonists curse, the revolutionaries curse. They kept it out as much as possible out of earshot, out of print, not always successfully, but largely successfully. Well, in the 20th century, first you have the novelists like Hemingway and Mailer breaking through in various ways with language that gets published. You've got the wars, the modern wars, which read a kind of cynicism and a kind of gruff language in millions of veterans. And then you get the 60s and 70s where let's let it all hang out. And, you know, all you have to look at is a couple of issues of the East Village Other from 1967 or the Los Angeles Free Press or any of the underground sort.
00:13:15
Speaker 1: Of rising alternative papers that really took off in the 70s.
00:13:19
Speaker 2: Exactly. And then they feed the new journalism of Rolling Stone with Hunter S.
Thompson and Tom Wolfe and so forth and so on. So the culture is beginning to open up to this because why? And in a more public way, why? Because the other point is it signals, it signifies authenticity. It signifies realness, honesty, candor, a kind of edginess, a kind of ballsy-ness, being a badass. There's a macho thing that's interwoven in it. But it's– when it becomes public, you may be looking around and seeing what the reaction is if you're a politician. But it's become sort of– it's crept closer to the center of the public culture incrementally over the decades.
00:14:07
Speaker 1: Look, I was watching Game Day a couple weeks ago, and Nick Saban just said, you know, they just played like shit.
00:14:13
Speaker 2: Right.
00:14:14
Speaker 1: And I was like, Nick Saban? He's in his 70s? I would expect that he would– want to be careful now. He's a football coach. Football coaches curse like the sailor. Of course. They always have. In some ways, it's amazing how many football coaches have gone on TV over the last 40 years and not ended up creating FCC issues for broadcast networks. And so, no, there is a casualness, but I want to go back because you do write about sort of our puritanical ways.
00:14:41
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:14:42
Speaker 1: And I want to do it through the prism of Of British culture. OK, because I've had I've had a couple of Brits who've been bosses and they.
00:14:52
Speaker 2: Curse like crazy.
00:14:54
Speaker 1: And it's a very there's you know, it's funny, even though they don't have a right to free speech, technically in the UK, there is a very looser, very loose language always has been looser language. Um, but I also think about, they've also been gambling on elections out in the open for decades and we're having this, you know, we're clutching our pearls over it. And it's like, yeah, you know, the Brits who we all look up to in the fanciness.
00:15:18
Speaker 2: And the puritan and this and that, you know.
00:15:21
Speaker 1: Are we just behind the rest of the world? I mean, I and on all of the vices like we've just because basically the UK got rid of all of its Puritans, sent them over to us and planted this seed that we were sort of the the the prudes longer than really much pretty much anybody in the Western world.
00:15:44
Speaker 2: Well, it's interesting. I'll tell you, there is a survey that was done, and it seems reputable, that was done. Unfortunately, I'm going to blank on what platform did it, but you can download the PDF and so forth. It was 2024, I think. And I don't know what their metric was. I can't vouch for them. It all looks very, very scientific, so to speak. But this project sought to rank the nations as accurately as possible into who curses more. So it's a fun thing to try to do, right? But also interesting. So they came up. They argue we, the US, still curses more. Britain, the UK is second, followed by Australia. New Zealand. So that's what the top four or five. And then you get in the next five, you start getting- Yeah, the Canadians, they're too polite.
00:16:38
Speaker 1: No way they care. They're too polite.
00:16:40
Speaker 2: Then you get Mexico, Dominican Republic, and some Asian countries. So it's funny that you should say that about the Brits, because I have a friend, an American friend who's living right now temporarily in England. And he just texted or emailed me yesterday and said, The English, like they curse more than we do.
00:17:01
Speaker 1: A thousand percent. And it's all in the white collar world.
00:17:05
Speaker 2: Right.
00:17:05
Speaker 1: You know, it's not, it is absolutely, whether it's in finance, whether it's in media, I have, I have, experienced it myself even British politicians I think.
00:17:17
Speaker 2: It has something to do I mean apart from you know it's all relative so like of course but we both we curse and they curse okay the pond separates us but cursing does not or something um uh I think for the Brits and I, you know, I wrote about America. I would love to delve more deeply into the British thing, because, of course, after all, we got our most of our curses from them. You know, I mean, the F word, the S word, those are old, old English words originally just being denotative for the. physical activities that they refer to. But I think it's the class system and what happened over the last, say, century or so in the class system in England, where really starting about 100 years ago, really World War I, you can see the English themselves saying, Everyone's using the F word. In fact, it got to in the trenches on the Western Front with the British soldiers. There's a famous story, which I do refer to, where a sergeant, he's got his guys in the trench and it's the mud, the incessantness of it, the artillery, the bleakness. When is this thing going to end? And the sergeant, this is the verbal environment by 1915, 1916, the British Tommies, as they were called, the soldiers.
00:18:39
Speaker 1: We're in.
00:18:40
Speaker 2: The sergeant wants to go on a routine patrol with a detail of 10 men. He says to them, using the actual word, grab your effing rifles. You know, I'll say, grab your fucking rifles.
00:18:55
Speaker 1: If.
00:18:56
Speaker 2: If he suddenly, on another day, if he turns to them and says, grab your rifles, these guys know something's up, that maybe the Germans are actually coming over. In other words- The F-bomb is just part of your ordinary, it became so much a part of speech in the trenches. And guys came out, and you think about the 20th century and how all of those Victorian illusions or high rhetorical ideals about, reverence and piety and politeness, they kind of start going out the window in the 20th century, partly because the 20th century was so, let's face it, great things, but awful. World War one world war two you know uh so so but the brits i think have this thing of um uh very much then wanting to break through the class divide so that people in white collar whether
they were born in the in in upper class or middle class or even working class and they've climbed up whatever it's um it's it's Being authentic, and it's saying, because the working class in America and in Britain has been, again and again, the sort of cradle or incubator, or at any rate, the people who hold on to the bad language, and it becomes a kind of badge to use it. I'm authentic, and I'm a real man, you know?
00:20:31
Speaker 1: This episode of the Chuck Todd cast is brought to you by Soul. So if you love that end of the day unwind, but hate the hangover, Soul's Out of Office is for you. These sparkling THC drinks and gummies give you the same relaxed social feeling without the alcohol, without the calories, and without the crash. Soul is a wellness brand that believes feeling good should be fun and easy. Soul specializes in delicious hemp-derived THC and CBD products designed to boost your mood and help you unwind. Their best-selling out-of-office gummies were designed to provide a mild, relaxing buzz, boost your mood, and enhance creativity and relaxation. With five different strengths, you can tailor the dose to fit your vibe. So also has a variety of products specifically designed to help you get a better night's rest, including their top-selling Sleepy Gummies, a fan favorite for deep, restless sleep. Look, I have made no secret. I am a believer in this stuff, in cannabis and hemp-derived. I do not partake in alcohol for the most part. I think this stuff is a lot safer than alcohol, a lot less addictive than alcohol. And yes, I have to say, I love these drinks. It is the glass of wine. And you know, after work, that's what this is. So no hangover and no excess calories like this. I'm a big fan. So bring on the good vibes and treat yourself to Soul today. Right now, Soul is offering my audience 30% off your entire order. Go to GetSoul.com and use the word TODCAST. That's GetSoul.com, promo code TODCAST for 30% off. And yes, I too am a customer. You know, I've seen this debate. Well, if you curse, it means you don't have a large vocabulary. And I would. Yeah, I curse. So everybody understands what I'm.
00:22:16
Speaker 2: Yeah, right. Right.
00:22:17
Speaker 1: Like it's almost the most common language.
00:22:22
Speaker 2: Right.
00:22:22
Speaker 1: If I want to make a point very emphatically and I want an aristocrat, a bougie guy to get it and a woman to get it. And I want, you know, a guy who showers after work, not before work. I'm going to use that word. Why dress it up and not be able to communicate to the large cross section of people that make up the United States?
00:22:48
Speaker 2: And it's, and you get their attention and you break through, you break through something. I mean, oh, it's rude. It's impolite. It's ignorant. It's limit. You don't have the right word. You don't, you know, you don't have the right words to use, but think about what else it does by breaking that rule, which of, of politeness, let's say, um, which is what we all have in the back of our heads when we hear the language, um, We, you know, we, we, you immediately, it's a, it's a soft slap or, or not a soft slap. It's a gentle slap of some kind. You know what I mean? It's a slap.
00:23:24
Speaker 1: It's cold water in your face. Hey, pay attention.
00:23:27
Speaker 2: Exactly. Pay it, pay attention. But also listen, this is serious. This is not, I'm not, I'm not bullshitting you. I'm telling you something you need to listen to. Um, and there's also a down to earthness to it and informality, which, which breaks through, um, you know any kind of hierarchical or or a sense of distance all right so all those things are there.
00:23:50
Speaker 1: Give me the uh history of the f word how did it become.
00:23:53
Speaker 3: That's a very interesting how did that how did that word come to mean what we've chosen you know i i i have this vision i remember there was this great you know remember before there was email you just made people would would clip and save stuff and pass it around to friends.
00:24:12
Speaker 1: And there was the, you know, all the different ways you could use the F word as an adjective, as an adverb, as a, you know, it was what, it was just a beautiful like list of things.
00:24:22
Speaker 2: Right. Yes.
00:24:23
Speaker 1: But I guess why, you know, if, if we decided frigging, was the F word and fuck was frigging, we would be like, you know, F would stand for that. So how did this, this, give, give me that word. You're give me the museum curator.
00:24:39
Speaker 2: I'll try to give you the, the cliff, the cliff notes version of it, because it's a, it's a long intricate and fascinating history. And, and people have written entire books about that. Just, just parenthetically. I mean, there's a great book, uh, by Jesse Scheidlauer, who was a lexicographer for the Oxford English Dictionary called The F Word, which.
00:24:58
Speaker 1: Is- Say that again, lexica- I love this.
00:25:00
Speaker 2: Lexicographer, lexicographer.
00:25:02
Speaker 1: A lexicographer. Somebody who compiles dictionaries. Sure, right.
00:25:08
Speaker 2: It's a great word.
00:25:09
Speaker 1: What a great title.
00:25:10
Speaker 2: But anyhow, yeah, The F Word, and I encourage anyone interested to consult it. But anyhow, so- The F word begins in Northern European language. This is like getting deep dive. I want this. Back in the medieval and even pre-medieval period in Northern Europe, a number of languages like sort of old and middle English, early Dutch, early German. Perhaps some of the– in fact, yes, some of the early Scandinavian languages. And so you can see the Vikings in this. It just becomes– it's the literal word for sexual intercourse. It's just the word everybody uses because it's not your– no one's in college. They don't learn these highfalutin Latin words.
00:25:57
Speaker 1: And who is it that came up with this word? Like where did it first show up? We still don't know that.
00:26:01
Speaker 2:
We don't know. With the history of words, especially the farthest back you go, it's in the mists of time, and no one really knows. What scholars do is, oh, suddenly they're looking at some 12th century manuscript somewhere, and it's like, is that what I think it says? And then they have to figure out. Now, the problem with the F word is it initially means a bunch of different things. It means... to strike, to hit, to move back and forth, get it. In other words, it's almost like an analogy for the physical act. It probably starts as like, I'm effing you, I'm hitting you. And then it becomes a metaphor for sexual intercourse. And it seems like for the longest time, for centuries and centuries, It's just one of the words people use. In fact, you can find it in the colonies. There's like, there are cases where people are using the F bomb and they're not using it to say F you, or I'm going to F with you or, you know, whatever. It's just like, well, I saw an adultery case. Yeah. Yeah. There's an adultery case in Maryland in the 1600s, which, and God bless court transcripts because in the earth throughout our history people might not want to say these words in court but it's like okay wait a minute who said what what what actually happened who said what and so this woman who's a farm servant and clearly quite possibly illiterate you know without any much or any education because i saw you know him f her and he and he stuck his p into her c is the way she puts it. So it's just unsophisticated, so to speak, rustic language that everyone shares. And it's class really social class that distances people. In other words, the elite know that word, but by the point in the middle of ages in England or early, or even Shakespeare's day in England, right, right on the cusp of, of, you know, the new world being populated by, by English colonists. Um, You know, to be elite means that you want to be refined, you want to seem educated, be educated, and then you're circulating in certain circles with trained doctors and lawyers who know Latin. And in Latin... you have this tendency to take these blunt English monosyllables, or sometimes they're two syllables, and da-da-da-da-da-da-um. It's like lexicographer. Not dictionary maker, it's lexicographer.
00:28:52
Speaker 1: Lexicographer, yeah.
00:28:54
Speaker 2: So what happens is that becomes a badge of sophistication. To be able to say not effing, but copulation. or sexual intercourse. I mean, how many syllables do you need to distance yourself from the bluntness and the directness of F, right? sexual intercourse, just the same way that privy parts or private parts becomes a way. You don't have to say that he's stuck in. I saw his privy member is what they say in the court documents. So getting back to F, what happens? It appears that the first times we can really see F evolving into the way we start... use it today is the mid-19th century. So in the Civil War, this is an F'd up company. And we know this, again, from court documents, from court martial papers. Guy gets drunk, and he disses his sergeant or his lieutenant. And he says, oh, yeah? Yeah. you're effing with me, or you eff-faced SOB. And so you're reading this, and it's 1863, somewhere in a Union Army camp in Virginia, or sometimes a Confederate camp, What starts happening, I think, so why? And then actually you can peel this back or reel it forward, I should say, so that, and this is what I love about lexicography, is that there are people who have actually traced the fact that... uh the the fu as a as a as something spoken to somebody in anger at all in any form but in anger it happened in the first one that's recorded is a court case in 1905 in new york city.
00:30:50
Speaker 1: Okay with a with a right i mean that's the bronx chair of course it better be new york city yeah.
00:30:56
Speaker 2: Um but mfr emerges in Texas in 1888. I don't know. Oh, interesting.
00:31:03
Speaker 1: I don't know what Senator- So before New York, boy, that's something Texas would feel proud of, that they were before New York.
00:31:09
Speaker 2: Yes, right. Yeah, exactly. So you see the F word emerging in the mid 19th century now so why is this happening and it's in other words it's becoming a thing to use not just to refer in this narrow way to the physical act right but it's an insult it's something to say if you're angry at somebody um it's.
00:31:32
Speaker 1: So that's a real transition in that early 20th century that it becomes well more of an insult than a description Right.
00:31:40
Speaker 2: And it becomes more direct with F-U. And it's interesting, by the time of the Civil War, no one has come up with, seemingly, has come up with F-U yet. But they're saying, you're F-ing with me. Or you're F-ing. So this all has a history. And the only way to figure it out... or to trace this, is you've got to find it in the documents. It's got to be somewhere now. There might have been people saying it's 20 years earlier than that and never ended up getting.
00:32:06
Speaker 1: So you used a lot of court records to try to find- Court.
00:32:11
Speaker 2: Records, diaries, private letters. I mean, before the 20th century, it's not public. So you have to delve, find the nooks and crannies.
00:32:19
Speaker 1: So I want to talk about that, right? Because obviously when we come up with the FCC and we create standards, that's one thing. But we didn't have that. Right. Before we were worried about spectrum and all of that and the whole radio and TV revolution. This was just publishers making their own decision. I mean, it was a you know, how was it just the fact that we were a more religious society and there was a belief that you. You just if you couldn't say it in church, you shouldn't write it in a newspaper.
00:32:51
Speaker 2: Something like that. Yes. I mean, it's a larger cultural issue beyond, you know, more narrow issues.
00:32:58
Speaker 1: Because you couldn't find it. I'm guessing if you had found it. in the press
in the 1850s with the petty press or any of that, which were very common people stuff, right? So in theory, it should have been there and it wasn't.
00:33:14
Speaker 2: It was not. It's still sort of the accepted and shared cultural code is that there are certain things that there are beyond the pale except there always was porn. We forget that before movies, before the internet, before anything, there's printed porn. going back to England in the late 1600s, and certainly in the 1700s. And some of that stuff gets sent over here on boats, on ships. But in the mid-19th century, there is this sub-genre of urban newspapers called the flash press. And they are an offshoot of the penny press, which is, as you were saying, the great demotic, populist newspapers. Right, exactly. But there is this sort of shadowy world of newspapers with names like the weeklies, the New York Scorpion, and the New York Whip, and the New York Flash.
00:34:07
Speaker 1: And it's- Man, bring these titles back. They sound terrific, right? Like, who wouldn't pick up a copy of the New York Whip? Let me see what they got today.
00:34:16
Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, really. And you start getting some of that. You get some of the language in there. But the other thing they do is, of course, there's one Flash- paper where a guy who's a bigamist is quoted as saying, and they make this stuff up. I mean, it's basically semi-porn, you know, for people to read and men, men primarily, as far as we know. But so they're quoting this guy who's a bigamist and he goes, I F them all, I F them all. And it's literally I F dash, dash, dash, you know, them all. So you can, we've always got to remember, you can suggest things without I mean, if you bleep somebody, your listeners are going to know what basically, usually what the bleep was.
00:35:04
Speaker 1: I have never understood the bleep for that reason. And I mean, I get it. with you had to for FCC purposes, if you were an actual broadcast.
00:35:13
Speaker 2: It's legally mandated.
00:35:14
Speaker 1: Legally mandated. But to just bleep it, to bleep it, if it's not legally mandated, I kind of think you almost signpost it. Because then suddenly when you tell somebody something's taboo, they're more interested in it. If we just started using the F word very casually, people would stop hearing it. In fact, I'll give you an example.
00:35:34
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:35:35
Speaker 1: My grandmother went blind in her last few years, big reader, loved, loved reading and read all sorts of, you know, would read high minded and, you know, romance stuff and all sorts of mystery novels, you know, plenty of stuff filled with F-bombs here and there. And then in her last few years, she had to do a lot of more audio books. And I remember her saying to me, she goes, I just don't understand why there's so much F word in these books. I think it's changed. And I said, oh, grandma, I said, these books have always had F words in it. You just chose not to say it out loud to yourself as you read it. It's here. Reading it is one thing.
00:36:11
Speaker 2: Yes, yes.
00:36:12
Speaker 1: Hearing it is another. And then when you tell somebody it's taboo, it suddenly has a magnet to it, doesn't it?
00:36:18
Speaker 2: Well, it's like, yes. And it's like, I think Vince Neil of, who I think is in Motley Crue, saying after the tipper stickers- you know, were implemented in 1990 saying, oh, like that was the best gift to us. That'd be, you know, the kids, the teenagers.
00:36:34
Speaker 1: I grew up in Miami in the late eighties, early nineties. We had two live crew.
00:36:38
Speaker 2: Okay.
00:36:38
Speaker 1: We had Luther Campbell. I'm, you know, I'm friendly with him to this day. And here he was this, he had no idea he was becoming a free speech advocate. He just was doing, he was just trying to make music that more people would pay attention to. Tipper Gore slaps on the E, the local sheriff comes after him.
00:36:59
Speaker 2: It becomes a bestseller.
00:37:00
Speaker 1: Yeah, right, right, right.
00:37:01
Speaker 2: Now, that's why this is a no-win thing, ultimately. And the brain scientists will tell you this, that- It's deeply rooted in what's known as the limbic system of the brain. They can actually tell you which parts of the brain, physically, if we had a diagram of the brain, they'd be pointing to this, this, and this. That's the limbic system. That controls deep emotion, like raw emotion, the most powerful feelings you have. And to some extent filters it, but it's not always so filtered. And it's a release of physiological tension. It's a release of psychological tension. And so there's an argument to be made that cursing is actually universal, that the language has yet to be found. Of all the 7,000 known languages, I think it is, in the world that have survived, I don't think a language has... And people will sometimes try to say, well, Japanese is more polite, or Finnish, or there are certain languages. But then it turns out, well, okay, so they don't say F or S, the equivalents in their language, but there's some other deeply... upsetting or transgressive rule breaking thing that people say. You're just not alert to the nuances of.
00:38:26
Speaker 1: Their culture and language.
00:38:28
Speaker 2: But, you know, in a certain way, it's it's exactly right. Is that that, you know, the bleep is think about the the how the bleep.
00:38:37
Speaker 1: Right.
00:38:38
Speaker 2: As you were describing it is the latter day incarnation of saying sexual intercourse instead of F.
00:38:45
Speaker 1: Right. Right.
00:38:47
Speaker 2: It's a softening. But because everyone knows you're talking about the same. I mean, it's the same thing, but somehow the expression of it as heard, maybe sometimes even is written, softens it, distance it, keeps it at arm's length.
00:39:04
Speaker 1: This episode of the Chuck Todd cast is brought to you by Quince. You know, the best pieces in your closet are the ones you can count on,
whether you're heading to work, going out or keeping things a bit casual. And this time of year, Quince makes finding something great for everyone else just as easy. The holiday season is coming. That's right. We're under 90 days, folks. It's where I'm shopping for myself and everyone else on my list because I know Quince. delivers. Nobody's ever disappointed in stuff they get from Quince.
00:39:34
Speaker 2: Why?
00:39:34
Speaker 1: Quince focuses on high quality staples made with premium materials like 100 percent Mongolian cashmere, 14 karat gold and Italian leather. Their cashmere sweaters start at just 60 bucks. And the lineup doesn't stop there. They have premium down jackets, wool outerwear, cashmere accessories, everything you and your loved ones need to stay warm and look put together all season long without breaking the bank. Everything at Quince's price, 50 to 80% less than similar brands. How do they do this? Well, they work directly with factories and not just any factories, ethical factories. They cut out the middleman or the middle person, And so you can count on you getting your sort of luxury quality pieces without paying that luxury price tag. You know, it sounds like ad copy, but Quince is responsible for sort of the stuff I just grab and go, the stuff that I know I can just throw on that works well. I get these two pairs of shorts from Quince. The shorts are both warm. They're kind of khaki, but they're kind of not. They're just easy. They're just easy to wear. And if You know, frankly, I'm wearing a pair of those shorts right now as I'm taping this podcast. So when it comes to gifting, Quince is a lot more than clothing too. By the way, they've got fine jewelry, leather bags, hotel quality bedding, chef grade cookware. People love a nice piece of, you know, equipment to play with in the kitchen these days. Five-star luggage, plenty of ways to find something special for everyone on your list. So give the gift. of quality this holiday season. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to quince.com. You get free shipping on your order, 365-day return. Now available in Canada and the UK, too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, please let them know it was the Chuck Todd cast. It's the best way to support the show and the best way to make sure you're getting every discount you deserve. your friend in the uk lets you know that there's so there's a fairly common word that the britch use one of the c words uh c word for women yes that britch use all the time all the time in all sorts of different ways yes that we would it's funny there's still taboo words and for me the I feel like that's one of our tasks. Like if George Carlin came back, I'd say, okay, buddy, there's still one. You had seven words. We're probably down to two that you can't say at this point. And they're both the C.
00:42:17
Speaker 2: Words, right? Right, right. That's right. And although the overarching argument would be, and several people have said this, and I actually was mindful of this in my very foul-mouthed book, is that The word that is considered perhaps most obscene in our culture is the N-word. And that's an argument that's been made. And all you have to do is think about all of the very furious arguments.
00:42:45
Speaker 1: No, that's a word we now use less all the time across the board. And that is one where you be judged.
00:42:54
Speaker 2: Oh, yes.
00:42:54
Speaker 1: If you use it, there's not a single, there might not be another word out there. I mean, look, there's a few words for Jews, but if you used it, I certainly, my ear would turn up, you know, the K word in particular. Like for me, that would- But I know that's an older one. And for some people, that's an older word.
00:43:12
Speaker 2: Well, and their pejoratives are Latino.
00:43:14
Speaker 1: Yeah, that's the line that we don't want to cross is the slurs against ethnic demographic groups.
00:43:22
Speaker 2: But what I would say is one of the patterns over time that I'm trying to trace is if you were to sort of do this in the most broad-based way, okay, what's changed over the 400 years since the 1600s? Okay. The short answer, and the longer answer would have to qualify it, and there are all kinds of nuances and so forth. But okay, they came in the 1600s, and profanity to them literally meant profanity. God damn you. In other words, it's taking the Lord's name in vain or cursing someone.
00:44:00
Speaker 1: I got a friend who will use the F word, the S word, and will put an asterisk when they put God in an email.
00:44:06
Speaker 2: Well, they're probably right. Asterisk D. It's a religious thing. Yes. It's a religious thing. And now, that's not to say that in the 1600s, 1700s, they didn't have words. They used S in various ways as an insult. The word bugger or buggerer, which is another one which the British have, which is never, or at least since the revolution, hasn't had the same kind of impact on us, was the dirty word of the 1700s. And the Boston Massacre, the British Redcoats, before they're shooting the crowd, the mob in Boston are yelling, come at us, you Yankee buggers.
00:44:49
Speaker 1: Which in today's culture, they might say, you Yankee bastards.
00:44:54
Speaker 2: Well, that's right. That's right. Or the CS word, which is like three syllables, I guess.
00:45:02
Speaker 1: Right.
00:45:04
Speaker 2: So all of these things have history. Okay, so profanity. 19th century is... Where the scatological and sexual stuff that we were talking about in the Civil War and so on comes to center stage. Probably because people are, in general, the culture is getting somewhat more secular. So people are less afraid of hellfire. It's also because the Victorians, by the 1820s, 30s, 40s, the culture is so uptight about the body. It's so all of those notions of crudery about sex and excretion. So that those become the words that really sting. I mean, saying, I damn you is less, it's like losing its
punch. And so you say F, you start saying, you know, F off or you F faced, whatever. And then, and so that's been, and that of course still has power for us. The argument has been made, and I think it's plausible, is that the new obscenity since the 1960s and 70s and on into our own day is the slurs. whether it's racial, gender, the C word for women, as you pointed out, you know, issues of sexual identity. And so all of those things have gained those kinds of insults, slurs, expletives, pejoratives now have a sting that they didn't have. They just didn't have.
00:46:34
Speaker 1: I mean, think about- There'd be a news story if a candidate for president were overheard saying the N-word, nobody would care if a candidate for president was overheard saying the C-word, frankly. Let alone the F word.
00:46:47
Speaker 2: Well, a certain candidate said something about grabbing him by the pee. At an earlier moment in American history, maybe not that far for that, that would have been bye-bye. It wasn't in 2016. It wasn't. And that was sort of the point where you're saying, wow, this is a watershed moment in a way.
00:47:11
Speaker 1: So you've identified what's still Teppu. And it's basically derogatory, right? It's sort of the person, it's going after somebody's identity using language.
00:47:22
Speaker 2: That's right.
00:47:23
Speaker 1: If George Carlin came back to life today and Lenny Bruce, look, part of their shtick was to make you uncomfortable. That's right. You know, I, I enjoy a good comedian that will make me uncomfortable and I won't quote everything they say.
00:47:39
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:47:39
Speaker 1: Right.
00:47:40
Speaker 2: Right.
00:47:40
Speaker 1: That doesn't mean they may not make me laugh or they may go, wow, well, that was edgy, you know, and, and, you know, I, I, I, that was interesting. What is the new frontier of edginess? If we're going to You know, we basically keep moving this and you and I both know, no matter what, there's still a desire for somebody to push the envelope. What's the envelope now going forward, do you think?
00:48:06
Speaker 2: You know, I'm a historian. I look backwards and I'm not a futurist. So it's a very hard, and one thing I've learned in looking through the four centuries, and this is my out, this is my, you know, sort of my dodge. Yeah, dodge. None of it seems predictable when you look. When I look at the 1600s, 1700s, 1800s, in 18... Well, I could give you an example of the difference. People are writing hate mail to Thomas Jefferson. And he saved it. As president, you're the damnedest fool God ever breathed life into. 50 years later, they're writing to Lincoln, suck my pee, the male pee.
00:48:53
Speaker 1: That was the change. So that was the change. By the way, talk about a fun way to have done this history. You just did letters to the president. I think it's a book.
00:49:03
Speaker 2: It's hate mail to the president. I have to credit Jack McLaughlin, who's a historian who wrote a book actually about the letters to Jefferson, because Jefferson kept all the mail. that was sent to him, good, bad, neutral. And so it's a fascinating idea. But no, hate mail to the presidents would be good. I want to actually go back and look at some of the earlier court martial records from the Mexican War and the War of 1812, which I don't think... Because I think we can maybe back that, then you backdate some of that. But your point, your question, getting back to your question, what's coming? I don't know. Generation A, B, C, D, E, F are coming up with some rather gross phrases for... physical functions that weren't even in anyone's vocabulary, let alone, and part of that's about porn and the way that's changing sexual mores, of course. But I will say one thing. I mean, people will say, and it's a very logical, understandable thing to say, is, Well, the way you hear the people say F now or S, you're on a commuter train, you're on the city bus, you're in a restaurant. It's just like you're used to it. And you're saying, so if that's the case, something new has to come. And that may well be, and some of these grosser words I'm not going to even go to. I mentioned a few of them in what I wrote, of course, towards the end of the book. But the one caveat or cautionary note is, about thinking that F and S are, you know, well, they're going to be so boring and you won't even hear them. You're not even here.
00:50:47
Speaker 1: We're going to hear them in an inauguration speech.
00:50:50
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:50:50
Speaker 1: Right.
00:50:51
Speaker 2: That's right. Right. And then it's like, well, that's so normalized that.
00:50:55
Speaker 1: You know, And it will no longer have the meaning that people want it to have.
00:51:00
Speaker 2: Right. But here's what, here's the counter argument. If you think about the fact that okay, someone can say the word so much that you don't even hear it anymore, but you still hear it in certain contexts. You will hear it fresh. And I think that's, in terms of the quote-unquote danger or edginess or rule-breaking aspect of saying F or S or C or whatever, right, is... is those things are rooted in the brain in other words we we associate intense physical sensations of various kinds with not only pleasure but with shame and that's nurture in nature that's culture and it's culture and um and and brain you know by physiology um and i think that um We will come back to those. We will always come back to those. I mean, even in the colonial period, the S word was there for certain kinds of insults. So I think that the demise of the S bomb and the F bomb are probably greatly oversold.
00:52:15
Speaker 1: So you see this as that there's an ebb and flow sometimes, and we may actually retreat in our use of some profanity over a period of time. for all we know i mean yeah.
00:52:28
Speaker 2: Symptoms can become obscene the n-word there's a time now there was always a time when when when african-americans of course if whites were
speaking the n-word um that's the raw the most raw offensive you know ugly but.
00:52:42
Speaker 1: I'll give you one look cracker was considered a derogatory word when i was growing up in florida but i don't but i'm i don't feel offense to it if somebody calls me a cracker it's interesting um But it was meant to be derogatory. I know that.
00:52:57
Speaker 2: Yeah. You know, it's so interesting how the nuances of a culture, how they reflect class, racial understanding. You know, I mean, another one that just again, the oddest one to me is the British. And it's now it's now it's gone away. But for centuries, especially in the 19th and early 20th centuries, the word.
00:53:19
Speaker 1: Bloodied It was so obscene.
00:53:25
Speaker 2: And no one can really say, well, is it about menstruation?
00:53:29
Speaker 1: Well, I was just going to say now you just use the word bloody. I'm trying to do a British accent. So if I say bloody, it'll sound like I'm doing a British.
00:53:35
Speaker 2: Accent, right?
00:53:36
Speaker 1: Like it's used more as a way to authenticate a Brit.
00:53:42
Speaker 2: Around 19, I think it's 1913, 19, I could show you how this changes. And around, I don't want to say it's 1913 or 1914, it's just before the outbreak of World War I. George Bernard Shaw, the great Anglo-Irish... you know, playwright, wits, political commentator. Well, he wrote Pygmalion, which, of course, My Fair Lady, you know, the musical gets based on it. It's the same story with Henry Higgins and Eliza Doolittle. Now, they're staging this in the West End of London. He's already a celebrated figure and playwright. They're staging this in the West End in London in some fancy theater. And the word gets out that in the script of this play, Shaw has Eliza Doolittle use the word, the phrase, not bloody likely. Oh my, oh my. It became a thing. It became a thing. Like people are waiting, are crowding into the opening night and she says it and it's like, and nothing, I mean, people have debated and so forth, but then it, It remains a sort of, it's almost like Mark Twain. It becomes a less stinging thing. But the real thing was, why was bloody so obscene, considered so unspeakable? Because it's a working class word in a society that was still profoundly class bound. And at that point, pre the Beatles.
00:55:17
Speaker 1: So the real insult was to use a working class word to describe it.
00:55:21
Speaker 2: That's right.
00:55:21
Speaker 1: That was the real insult.
00:55:22
Speaker 2: And remember, this is before the Stones. It's before the Beatles. It's before everything. And it's a time when they're kind of emerging out of the Victorian era, which then World War I blasts them straight out of. But this is one of these little strange things that doesn't cross the Atlantic. It just doesn't.
00:55:43
Speaker 1: Well, Stephen- This book is not full of shit. I think it's fucking terrific.
00:55:49
Speaker 2: Well, it actually is full.
00:55:51
Speaker 1: It's actually full of the words. It may be full with the words of shit, but it is not shit.
00:55:58
Speaker 2: Thank you.
00:55:59
Speaker 1: Anyway, and you are a mensch.
00:56:02
Speaker 2: Thank you.
00:56:03
Speaker 1: This was fun. I mean, look, you're a museum curator and you're a historian. I mean, is this a book you've always wanted to tackle? Do you want to tackle others in the culture like this? Or is this sort of a.
00:56:15
Speaker 2: This was the one for, for whatever reason, because it's so easy to collect, you know, you become like sort of a, a, a, a museum collector in an, in a sense of.
00:56:25
Speaker 1: You have like the world's most cluttered basement.
00:56:28
Speaker 2: I have a bad basement, man. My attic is even worse.
00:56:32
Speaker 1: I was just going to say, you've been a curator, I think, of four different museums. There has to be so much. The best stuff is the stuff that's never out. I always say this.
00:56:40
Speaker 2: That's right.
00:56:41
Speaker 1: I got it. I went into the bowels of the Smithsonian for their convention stuff once.
00:56:45
Speaker 2: Unbelievable.
00:56:45
Speaker 1: And I'm like, what? I'd rather be in here than any of the stuff you're putting on display. I could only imagine what, you know.
00:56:52
Speaker 2: No, that's exactly right. It's like you're the kid in the candy store, you know, and who's watching me, you know, that kind of thing. But no, exactly. But also collecting words is what I mean. It's sort of like once I got this idea that this is something real, and I should say, I mean, I could not have written this book without, you know, generations of scholars. Of course. lexicographers, linguists.
00:57:20
Speaker 1: Are you a linguist now by writing this book?
00:57:23
Speaker 2: No, I'm a historian interested in language, not a linguist interested in history. We've been diagrammed, we overlap, but it's two different things I found out. They have a different take, a different lens for it.
00:57:36
Speaker 1: Well, it's terrific. And like I said, you know, it's also a book you give that person that you know they're into politics, but you're not sure which side of the aisle they're on. So with that too, you can get some enjoyment out of it, whether you're on Team Red or Team Blue. Hey, Stephen, congratulations. Thanks for coming on.
00:57:53
Speaker 2: Thank you so much, Chuck. It was fun.