РАСШИФРОВКА 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.680 --> 00:00:03.279
Hi, I'm Wendy Zuckerman and you're listening to Science Versus.
2
00:00:06.139 --> 00:00:10.500
Earlier this year, there was this huge news that scientists
3
00:00:10.900 --> 00:00:13.460
had brought back the dire wolf.
4
00:00:14.699 --> 00:00:22.000
Meet Remus and Romulus, the first two dire wolves since
5
00:00:22.019 --> 00:00:23.120
the Pleistocene era.
6
00:00:23.800 --> 00:00:26.820
This is a promotional video from the company that made
7
00:00:26.839 --> 00:00:30.620
these wolves, Colossal. And in the video, you can see
8
00:00:30.679 --> 00:00:33.060
these gorgeous little white pups.
9
00:00:33.740 --> 00:00:36.670
At just 15 days old, the pups take their first
10
00:00:36.750 --> 00:00:39.490
wobbly steps before a much needed nap time.
11
00:00:44.070 --> 00:00:46.850
The pups, who are now more than six months old,
12
00:00:47.070 --> 00:00:49.509
were made by taking the DNA of a gray wolf
13
00:00:49.990 --> 00:00:54.390
and then tweaking 14 genes in it to make them bigger,
14
00:00:54.549 --> 00:00:58.399
give them lighter coats, have larger teeth and jaws than
15
00:00:58.420 --> 00:01:02.840
a gray wolf would have. And when folks found out
16
00:01:02.939 --> 00:01:07.299
about these animals, there was this huge media buzz with
17
00:01:07.359 --> 00:01:10.980
headlines plastered all over the place. One of the wolves
18
00:01:11.120 --> 00:01:15.319
even made the cover of Time magazine with the line, quote,
19
00:01:15.799 --> 00:01:16.609
But is that right?
20
00:01:16.620 --> 00:01:16.689
Yes.
21
00:01:29.120 --> 00:01:32.120
Did scientists really bring back the dire wolf?
22
00:01:33.019 --> 00:01:33.920
What exactly is.
23
00:01:33.859 --> 00:01:36.180
Going on here? And is this a good idea or
24
00:01:36.959 --> 00:01:42.239
could it have dire consequences? That's what our friends over
25
00:01:42.299 --> 00:01:45.650
at Today Explained wanted to know. So today we're going
26
00:01:45.670 --> 00:01:49.170
to share their episode looking into this. After the break,
27
00:01:49.409 --> 00:01:53.709
co-host of Today Explained, Sean Ramaswaran, will take it from here.
28
00:02:10.009 --> 00:02:10.629
Direwolves.
29
00:02:11.090 --> 00:02:13.530
Not just a thing from Game of Thrones. Not just
30
00:02:13.590 --> 00:02:18.180
Jon Snow's best friend. Direwolves walked the Americas for millennia,
31
00:02:18.479 --> 00:02:22.900
up until about 14,000 years ago when maybe their primary
32
00:02:22.979 --> 00:02:26.039
food source dried up or humans hunted them to extinction.
33
00:02:26.090 --> 00:02:28.349
No one was taking notes. But we know they were
34
00:02:28.389 --> 00:02:31.370
a bit bigger than gray wolves. They ate a lot
35
00:02:31.490 --> 00:02:35.659
of meat. and their bite could crush bones. And now
36
00:02:35.719 --> 00:02:43.039
we know that apparently direwolves are back? A startup called
37
00:02:43.099 --> 00:02:46.830
Colossal says they've brought these pups back from extinction. They
38
00:02:46.889 --> 00:02:50.550
say they've got three of them, but are these direwolves
39
00:02:50.590 --> 00:02:54.849
they brought back actually direwolves? And whether they are or aren't,
40
00:02:54.909 --> 00:02:57.870
should we be trying to bring direwolves back?
41
00:02:57.969 --> 00:02:58.870
Like, why?
42
00:03:03.789 --> 00:03:05.729
Not a lot of people have seen these direwolves that
43
00:03:05.770 --> 00:03:08.569
have come back from extinction up close and personal. Like
44
00:03:08.689 --> 00:03:11.689
DT Maxx from The New Yorker is one of the
45
00:03:11.830 --> 00:03:12.990
few who has.
46
00:03:13.830 --> 00:03:15.830
Okay, so first of all, we just got to get
47
00:03:15.870 --> 00:03:18.349
this out there. We either have to put direwolves in
48
00:03:18.409 --> 00:03:21.090
quotes or we have to give them a name. Like,
49
00:03:21.110 --> 00:03:22.689
I don't know, we could do anything like.
50
00:03:23.569 --> 00:03:25.439
How about Diet Direwolves?
51
00:03:25.479 --> 00:03:26.580
Yes, exactly.
52
00:03:27.830 --> 00:03:32.030
These so-called direwolves were created by extracting DNA from a 72,000-year-old
53
00:03:32.090 --> 00:03:36.629
direwolf inner ear bone and a 13,000-year-old direwolf tooth.
54
00:03:36.870 --> 00:03:40.199
They determined its closest living relative is the gray wolf,
55
00:03:40.460 --> 00:03:43.560
so then they made 20 edits to gray wolf DNA
56
00:03:43.939 --> 00:03:46.360
to include those direwolf-specific genes.
57
00:03:46.560 --> 00:03:49.759
That animal looks like a direwolf, it will behave like
58
00:03:49.800 --> 00:03:54.199
a direwolf, and it is a direwolf. This is insane, actually.
59
00:03:54.520 --> 00:03:56.860
These are not direwolves by any definition.
60
00:03:59.199 --> 00:04:01.490
But the other point is it doesn't really matter when
61
00:04:01.500 --> 00:04:05.409
you're seeing them because, you know, you're seeing something, you know,
62
00:04:05.430 --> 00:04:09.569
that's absolutely amazing. I mean, you're seeing something that... So
63
00:04:09.909 --> 00:04:13.189
there's two bright white wolves. I did not see them
64
00:04:13.219 --> 00:04:15.020
where they live. I saw them where they were brought
65
00:04:15.060 --> 00:04:17.000
to be seen, which was far, far away.
66
00:04:17.439 --> 00:04:19.980
And you can't tell us where that was, but it's somewhere...
67
00:04:20.139 --> 00:04:22.300
somewhere in the northern United States, I've read.
68
00:04:22.540 --> 00:04:25.319
Yeah, look, I do hold bigger secrets as a journalist,
69
00:04:25.360 --> 00:04:29.430
but I'm not supposed to tell you where. But so
70
00:04:29.459 --> 00:04:32.769
what happens, okay, so first of all, I see a
71
00:04:32.790 --> 00:04:34.769
couple of people I know from the reporting on the piece.
72
00:04:34.829 --> 00:04:39.149
I see George Church, who looks as much like Gandalf
73
00:04:39.189 --> 00:04:42.060
as any human being on this planet who holds tenure.
74
00:04:42.480
Load full transcript
--> 00:04:44.459
And I also see Ben Lamb, the guy who founded
75
00:04:44.480 --> 00:04:47.399
the project, looks a lot like, it's Johnny Snow, right?
76
00:04:47.600 --> 00:04:47.939
Yeah.
77
00:04:48.639 --> 00:04:50.939
The point is, like, it's the perfect setup. And then
78
00:04:50.959 --> 00:04:55.779
there are these two bright white teenage wolves. So, you know,
79
00:04:55.939 --> 00:04:58.430
even any wolf is impressive. So it's not, I mean,
80
00:04:58.449 --> 00:05:02.129
I have actually seen wolves before for another article, strangely enough.
81
00:05:02.189 --> 00:05:06.290
So a wolf carries its own weird kind of authority
82
00:05:06.350 --> 00:05:08.629
with it. But these, they do look different. And again,
83
00:05:08.689 --> 00:05:12.250
I'm not an animal morphologist. So, you know, I've been
84
00:05:12.269 --> 00:05:16.860
told pale, but they're white. And they're... They're like celebrities.
85
00:05:17.000 --> 00:05:19.730
I mean, there's no other way to describe it that
86
00:05:20.139 --> 00:05:27.029
they're delightfully, blissfully heedless of how much money and effort
87
00:05:27.050 --> 00:05:29.860
has gone into the creation of them. They're basically in
88
00:05:29.879 --> 00:05:35.389
this enclosure of They are doing little things wolves do
89
00:05:35.470 --> 00:05:39.120
and dogs sometimes do. One pees, the other rolls in it. But,
90
00:05:39.199 --> 00:05:45.139
you know, they're majestic. They are going about their quasi-meta
91
00:05:45.180 --> 00:05:48.959
direwolf existence. Blissful disregard for any controversy about what you
92
00:05:48.990 --> 00:05:52.370
want to call them. Or blissful disregard of whether they
93
00:05:52.389 --> 00:05:54.639
should have been brought back. In the first place.
94
00:05:55.100 --> 00:05:58.990
Tell us more about this company that brought back the
95
00:05:59.589 --> 00:06:01.769
Diet Direwolf.
96
00:06:01.170 --> 00:06:02.370
Version that you saw.
97
00:06:02.889 --> 00:06:07.310
We could do this all day. It's called Colossal. It's
98
00:06:07.329 --> 00:06:09.029
run by a dude named Ben Lamb.
99
00:06:09.290 --> 00:06:09.870
Who is he?
100
00:06:10.230 --> 00:06:11.170
What is he trying to do here?
101
00:06:11.850 --> 00:06:16.170
So, I mean, Ben Lamb is kind of amazing. I
102
00:06:16.230 --> 00:06:18.689
am pretty much in awe of Ben Lamb. Here's a
103
00:06:18.709 --> 00:06:23.170
guy who's maybe 40-something. He's already had... like four or
104
00:06:23.310 --> 00:06:26.339
five successes by which he started up four or five
105
00:06:26.379 --> 00:06:29.620
companies and they were bought out. by larger companies, which
106
00:06:29.720 --> 00:06:31.519
is kind of what you want to do when you're
107
00:06:31.540 --> 00:06:35.079
a startup guy. And then, you know, one day he
108
00:06:35.139 --> 00:06:39.720
meets a guy named George Church, Church being the Gandalf
109
00:06:39.759 --> 00:06:43.579
of our earlier narrative, if that survives. And Church is
110
00:06:43.639 --> 00:06:47.519
a Harvard professor, a guy who's gotten a million patents
111
00:06:47.610 --> 00:06:50.430
and loves to do deep thinking. He's a big kind
112
00:06:50.470 --> 00:06:52.250
of what-if guy, like, what if we were to bring
113
00:06:52.290 --> 00:06:53.350
back the Neanderthals?
114
00:06:53.370 --> 00:06:54.089
Yeah.
115
00:06:54.430 --> 00:06:56.889
And then the press goes, ah! And then George Church goes,
116
00:06:56.990 --> 00:06:59.410
I was just considering it. I was just thinking about it.
117
00:06:59.529 --> 00:07:04.540
You guys calm down. So, George Church and Ben get
118
00:07:04.600 --> 00:07:07.420
together and they, basically what Ben says is, if you
119
00:07:07.439 --> 00:07:10.500
had all the money in the world, George, what would
120
00:07:10.540 --> 00:07:12.139
you bring back? What would you want to do with
121
00:07:12.180 --> 00:07:14.819
your time? And George says, I'd bring back the woolly mammoth.
122
00:07:15.480 --> 00:07:15.759
Sick.
123
00:07:16.259 --> 00:07:18.629
I mean, I don't know if it's responsible, but it
124
00:07:18.689 --> 00:07:19.370
sounds cool.
125
00:07:20.050 --> 00:07:20.750
Right, right.
126
00:07:20.829 --> 00:07:23.680
Exactly. And You know, they get together. It's like, let's
127
00:07:23.699 --> 00:07:26.519
put on a show, right? And, you know, this being
128
00:07:26.579 --> 00:07:32.569
Ben Lamb, super talented, perfectly adapted modern entrepreneur, and he
129
00:07:32.629 --> 00:07:34.949
raises money. Basically, I don't know the details. I think
130
00:07:34.970 --> 00:07:37.629
he raises money with a phone call because he's got
131
00:07:37.670 --> 00:07:41.689
a great second idea. And his second idea is, while
132
00:07:41.730 --> 00:07:45.189
we learn how to de-extinct these animals, we're going to
133
00:07:45.209 --> 00:07:49.519
learn an awful lot of interesting biomedical tech, and that
134
00:07:49.560 --> 00:07:53.600
we could sell. That's where we make our money. We're
135
00:07:53.620 --> 00:07:56.019
not going to make our money. He's very firm on this.
136
00:07:56.199 --> 00:07:59.750
There will be no Jurassic Park. We will not display
137
00:07:59.790 --> 00:08:03.850
these animals. Let's check back in in five years. But
138
00:08:03.889 --> 00:08:06.089
we will spin off the biotech. And the biotech is
139
00:08:06.129 --> 00:08:09.910
honestly probably worth even more than what is Disney World
140
00:08:10.089 --> 00:08:11.269
charged now or Disneyland?
141
00:08:11.389 --> 00:08:12.569
Hundreds. Hundreds.
142
00:08:12.970 --> 00:08:14.990
All right. So maybe I take that back. Maybe the
143
00:08:15.029 --> 00:08:16.350
better business is displaying them.
144
00:08:16.470 --> 00:08:17.100
Ha, ha, ha, ha.
145
00:08:18.850 --> 00:08:21.509
How much money have they raised to do this? And
146
00:08:21.589 --> 00:08:25.250
how much is this company that they're running, Colossal, worth
147
00:08:25.300 --> 00:08:25.879
at this point?
148
00:08:26.339
--> 00:08:29.639
All right, so they've now raised over $ 400 million, and
149
00:08:29.699 --> 00:08:33.759
their valuation, which is a kind of complicated metric involving
150
00:08:33.960 --> 00:08:37.580
what shares are worth, is over $ 10 billion, which puts
151
00:08:37.659 --> 00:08:41.279
it at the size level of Moderna. They've had an
152
00:08:41.779 --> 00:08:43.710
insane first few years.
153
00:08:44.029 --> 00:08:46.710
And I ask you this not because, like, Paris Hilton
154
00:08:47.110 --> 00:08:51.450
or Peter Jackson... I'm planning on investing in this company,
155
00:08:51.509 --> 00:08:54.669
but because I wanted to establish that people are taking
156
00:08:54.730 --> 00:08:58.870
these people seriously. And now that we've established that, do
157
00:08:58.929 --> 00:09:01.230
us a favor and tell us just how hard it
158
00:09:01.450 --> 00:09:05.019
is to do what this company says it wants to do.
159
00:09:08.299 --> 00:09:10.580
The dire wolf, you know, is not... Let me just
160
00:09:10.600 --> 00:09:13.519
get this out there for everybody. The dire wolf is not...
161
00:09:13.799 --> 00:09:16.590
There's a difference between being extinct for 40 million years.
162
00:09:17.350 --> 00:09:17.509
and.
163
00:09:17.450 --> 00:09:21.000
Being extinct for 14,000 years. They both sound like a
164
00:09:21.009 --> 00:09:24.899
long time to us, but, you know, it's just not comparable.
165
00:09:25.039 --> 00:09:28.440
So you can get, you can get, I can't get,
166
00:09:28.539 --> 00:09:33.879
you can't get, but Beth Shapiro could get viable ancient DNA. Now,
167
00:09:34.440 --> 00:09:36.620
what you do with that DNA is you read the
168
00:09:36.639 --> 00:09:40.039
genetic sequences, and then you recreate them, right? And you're
169
00:09:40.059 --> 00:09:41.940
going to put that DNA in the cells, and the
170
00:09:41.980 --> 00:09:43.539
cells are going to replicate, and you're going to have
171
00:09:43.559 --> 00:09:46.360
an animal Ultimately, once you put in an embryo and
172
00:09:46.379 --> 00:09:48.600
then implant it in a womb, you're going to have
173
00:09:48.620 --> 00:09:53.389
an animal that has those genes being acted on. That
174
00:09:54.009 --> 00:09:56.470
makes it sound like you or I could probably do
175
00:09:56.529 --> 00:09:58.669
it with just a little bit of help, but it's
176
00:09:58.769 --> 00:10:01.980
not that easy because there are problems, you know, at
177
00:10:02.299 --> 00:10:04.200
every step of the way. And it's a little bit
178
00:10:04.259 --> 00:10:07.330
like if I described to you how to hit a
179
00:10:07.370 --> 00:10:10.049
home run, you'd be like, yeah, okay, there's the force
180
00:10:10.110 --> 00:10:13.210
and there's the counterforce and there's the angle of the swing,
181
00:10:13.669 --> 00:10:15.169
but most people don't hit home runs.
182
00:10:19.429 --> 00:10:24.889
You mentioned someone named Beth Shapiro, who's now, I think,
183
00:10:25.029 --> 00:10:28.289
one of the leading scientists over at Colossal. And someone
184
00:10:28.309 --> 00:10:32.110
like Beth Shapiro comes from, I believe, UC Santa Cruz
185
00:10:32.149 --> 00:10:37.220
out in California, where she was doing versions of this
186
00:10:37.360 --> 00:10:40.820
kind of work, if not trying to revive the woolly mammoth.
187
00:10:41.340 --> 00:10:47.279
Can Colossal work faster than your, I don't know, typical
188
00:10:47.480 --> 00:10:48.919
elite university lab?
189
00:10:50.320 --> 00:10:52.240
Yeah, I mean, I don't think you can get that
190
00:10:52.299 --> 00:10:55.740
much money going at a university lab without a fair
191
00:10:55.759 --> 00:10:58.100
amount of grant writing. I mean, grant writing is slow
192
00:10:58.159 --> 00:11:02.960
and getting funded is slow. There's a guy named Lova Dahlen,
193
00:11:03.059 --> 00:11:07.019
who's a Swedish woolly mammoth guy. And I think he
194
00:11:07.059 --> 00:11:08.990
made a really good point in my piece that nobody's
195
00:11:09.000 --> 00:11:11.710
really picked up on. And I think it's about the money,
196
00:11:11.730 --> 00:11:13.450
which he said, like, the people who invested in this
197
00:11:13.509 --> 00:11:15.909
company weren't going to give, you know, I'm paraphrasing him,
198
00:11:15.909 --> 00:11:19.610
$ 100 million to the World Wildlife Fund. Like, you know,
199
00:11:19.730 --> 00:11:22.990
they're tech people. They probably would have bought Bitcoin with
200
00:11:23.049 --> 00:11:27.070
it otherwise. Like this, you know, Peter Jackson said that owning,
201
00:11:27.269 --> 00:11:29.029
being a part of Colossus was as much fun as
202
00:11:29.070 --> 00:11:36.470
movie making. I, I could do that. You know, I
203
00:11:36.529 --> 00:11:38.809
think that kind of tells you something. I don't think
204
00:11:38.850 --> 00:11:41.309
if they'd been doing this in Bess Shapiro's old lab
205
00:11:41.370 --> 00:11:44.610
at the University of California, Santa Cruz, he'd have thought
206
00:11:44.649 --> 00:11:48.419
it was as much fun You know, as moviemaking... To.
207
00:11:48.360 --> 00:11:52.700
Bring this back to where we started, DT, with Romulus
208
00:11:52.899 --> 00:11:57.830
and Remus, these two diet direwolves, what happens to them?
209
00:11:57.850 --> 00:11:58.110
You love that.
210
00:11:58.389 --> 00:11:58.710
I do.
211
00:11:58.789 --> 00:12:00.100
I'm going to stick with it.
212
00:12:00.509 --> 00:12:02.610
What happens to them? Where do they go?
213
00:12:03.250 --> 00:12:06.690
You know, never say never, but I think they're expected
214
00:12:06.750 --> 00:12:09.909
to live out their lives. I think a wolf gets
215
00:12:10.029 --> 00:12:13.809
the same 15 years, I think, that a smaller dog gets.
216
00:12:14.470 --> 00:12:14.549
Um.
217
00:12:15.259 --> 00:12:18.919
live out their lives. You know, they will not hunt.
218
00:12:20.059 --> 00:12:21.960
They will be given, like, I don't know if you've
219
00:12:21.980 --> 00:12:23.500
ever been to a zoo and seen
what they feed
220
00:12:23.559 --> 00:12:26.519
the lions and tigers. They feed them, like, something they
221
00:12:26.559 --> 00:12:30.070
would have hunted, but they didn't hunt it. Like, just oozing, bleeding,
222
00:12:31.090 --> 00:12:33.549
massive amounts of meat. And I think that's what the
223
00:12:33.590 --> 00:12:38.070
dire wolves are going to get. But they're not planning
224
00:12:38.110 --> 00:12:41.830
to breed them, which I don't entirely understand. Colossal talks
225
00:12:41.889 --> 00:12:45.210
a lot about, like, reintroducing some of their animals into
226
00:12:45.250 --> 00:12:48.750
the ecosystem to do environmental good. I don't think the
227
00:12:48.769 --> 00:12:52.610
dire wolf was conceived by them with that as a possibility.
228
00:12:52.629 --> 00:12:54.350
First of all, I mean, people don't want dire wolves
229
00:12:54.370 --> 00:12:55.230
in their backyard.
230
00:12:55.769 --> 00:12:58.600
When you realized that these diet wolves would just die out,
231
00:12:58.679 --> 00:13:01.100
did that bum you out? What did you make of that?
232
00:13:01.740 --> 00:13:01.980
Yes.
233
00:13:02.659 --> 00:13:08.879
Yes, I did. It was absolutely, you know, there were
234
00:13:08.899 --> 00:13:12.490
a number of sad moments in reporting the I mean,
235
00:13:12.610 --> 00:13:14.049
first of all, you have to kind of come to
236
00:13:14.090 --> 00:13:17.889
grips with the immensity of the damage that humans have
237
00:13:17.929 --> 00:13:21.690
done and for how long we've been doing it because
238
00:13:21.710 --> 00:13:25.370
the dire wolf is essentially driven extinct mostly by human activity,
239
00:13:25.389 --> 00:13:30.409
you know, 14,000 years ago. But I don't know. When
240
00:13:30.429 --> 00:13:33.429
you realize that this whole thing is kind of to
241
00:13:33.529 --> 00:13:38.330
show we can, yeah, it becomes sad because it isn't
242
00:13:38.409 --> 00:13:40.269
one of the reasons that we used to drive humans
243
00:13:40.710 --> 00:13:45.309
animals extinct because we could, because there was money in it.
244
00:13:46.240 --> 00:13:49.360
And isn't it kind of weird that we're now de-extincting
245
00:13:49.379 --> 00:13:51.679
an animal, you know, kind of because we now have
246
00:13:51.720 --> 00:13:56.509
this technology that can reopen the door that we thought
247
00:13:56.549 --> 00:14:03.210
that we had absolutely and, you know, incontrovertibly closed before.
248
00:14:03.230 --> 00:14:05.529
So the whole thing leaves you a little bit blue.
249
00:14:09.799 --> 00:14:15.309
DT Maxx, read his profile of the direwolves over at newyorker.com.
250
00:14:15.730 --> 00:14:18.809
The ethics of de-extinction, when today explained, is back.
251
00:14:30.730 --> 00:14:33.320
Hey, it's Wendy from Science Versus, and I want to.
252
00:14:33.299 --> 00:14:35.200
Tell you about a podcast that I.
253
00:14:35.179 --> 00:14:36.620
Love, Science Friday.
254
00:14:36.799 --> 00:14:39.059
They cover all sorts of amazing things.
255
00:14:38.820 --> 00:14:41.809
In the weird and wonderful world of science, from how
256
00:14:42.190 --> 00:14:45.529
concussions affect our brain to the inner secrets of a
257
00:14:45.710 --> 00:14:48.639
snake with a spider on its It's a lot of
258
00:14:48.700 --> 00:14:50.519
news that you can use and.
259
00:14:50.460 --> 00:14:52.519
Some that you can't, but you're going to love anyway.
260
00:14:52.759 --> 00:14:56.470
It's hosted by Ira Flato and Flora Lichtman, who is
261
00:14:56.509 --> 00:14:59.250
an old friend of the show and loves a pun
262
00:14:59.370 --> 00:15:02.070
as much as we do. Science Friday is on every
263
00:15:02.090 --> 00:15:04.139
day wherever you get your podcasts.
264
00:15:19.889 --> 00:15:22.070
You're listening to Today Explained.
265
00:15:23.769 --> 00:15:27.500
I'm Robert Klitzman. I'm a professor of psychiatry and director
266
00:15:27.639 --> 00:15:31.620
of the online and in-person Masters of Bioethics programs at
267
00:15:31.679 --> 00:15:37.580
Columbia University and the author of Designing Babies, How Technology
268
00:15:37.620 --> 00:15:39.500
is Changing the Ways We Create Children.
269
00:15:39.980 --> 00:15:42.639
And when we look at these diet direwolves in the
270
00:15:42.700 --> 00:15:46.480
northern United States somewhere by way of colossal, do we
271
00:15:46.539 --> 00:15:48.250
feel more good or bad?
272
00:15:48.730 --> 00:15:48.990
I think.
273
00:15:49.590 --> 00:15:52.570
There is a lot of excitement. It's definitely cool to
274
00:15:52.610 --> 00:15:55.649
bring back extinct species, but there's a lot of questions
275
00:15:55.730 --> 00:16:00.110
we have about where these animals will live, what their
276
00:16:00.289 --> 00:16:03.389
lives will be like, why we're doing this, what the
277
00:16:03.460 --> 00:16:06.200
long-term view or vision is, and a lot of that
278
00:16:06.240 --> 00:16:09.159
depends on how the technology is then used and what happens.
279
00:16:09.919 --> 00:16:12.639
Well, let's talk about, to start with, what do you
280
00:16:12.659 --> 00:16:16.360
think of the ethics of the process by which these
281
00:16:16.399 --> 00:16:19.909
dire wolves have come to be? Obviously, Let's just think
282
00:16:19.980 --> 00:16:24.679
about whatever animal it was that birthed these direwolves, not
283
00:16:24.700 --> 00:16:25.889
a direwolf, I assume.
284
00:16:26.129 --> 00:16:26.370
Right.
285
00:16:28.169 --> 00:16:31.179
So there's a few issues that come up. One is
286
00:16:31.399 --> 00:16:35.120
we're making a bunch of dogs pregnant to produce them.
287
00:16:35.740 --> 00:16:39.700
And I have concerns about the dire wolves. But more importantly,
288
00:16:39.759 --> 00:16:42.899
the company has said that its longer term plan is
289
00:16:42.940 --> 00:16:46.340
to produce or reproduce or to create a woolly mammoth.
290
00:16:46.940 --> 00:16:49.860
And with that, there are even bigger concerns because that
291
00:16:50.259 -->
00:16:53.779
you'd have to take elephants. You'd have to get many elephants,
292
00:16:53.879 --> 00:16:58.149
female elephants and anesthetize them. You'd have to stick probes
293
00:16:58.269 --> 00:17:04.390
up their vagina. to extract eggs you'd have to then
294
00:17:04.529 --> 00:17:10.670
get many elephants pregnant hopefully some will not miscarry some
295
00:17:10.710 --> 00:17:13.490
will miscarry then you'll have to do c-sections on the
296
00:17:13.569 --> 00:17:17.779
elephants to get the woolly mammoths out so that's going
297
00:17:17.799 --> 00:17:20.019
to be very cumbersome and it's going to hurt a
298
00:17:20.059 --> 00:17:23.480
lot of elephants so dire wolves we have three of
299
00:17:23.519 --> 00:17:25.720
them that were created i should say they're not really
300
00:17:25.799 --> 00:17:29.799
dire wolves they're uh gray wolves that have had about
301
00:17:29.799 --> 00:17:33.900
15 of their genes changed. So of 80 potential genes
302
00:17:33.920 --> 00:17:37.609
that could be changed, they've changed 15. And when we're
303
00:17:37.650 --> 00:17:41.109
mucking around with nature and changing genes, mistakes get made.
304
00:17:41.619 --> 00:17:45.000
Genes have multiple functions that we don't always know about. So,
305
00:17:45.079 --> 00:17:47.859
for instance, five of the genes that Colossal was going
306
00:17:47.880 --> 00:17:51.900
to change because they were in dire wolves but not
307
00:17:52.059 --> 00:17:56.140
in gray wolves, the researchers decided not to change because
308
00:17:56.240 --> 00:18:01.269
these genes would create deafness and blindness in the dire wolf.
309
00:18:01.710 --> 00:18:05.390
So we don't always know when we're altering genes what
310
00:18:05.410 --> 00:18:07.750
the effects are going to be. Genes have multiple effects.
311
00:18:11.400 --> 00:18:15.400
About five years ago, Dr. He Jiankui in China genetically
312
00:18:15.460 --> 00:18:19.390
engineered three children. He took the embryos and he wanted
313
00:18:19.490 --> 00:18:23.380
to disable a gene called the CCR5 gene to prevent
314
00:18:23.660 --> 00:18:26.559
HIV from getting in the cells. because he was going
315
00:18:26.579 --> 00:18:30.180
to work with HIV-positive fathers. But in disabling that gene,
316
00:18:30.839 --> 00:18:33.369
other viruses are more likely to enter the cell. So
317
00:18:33.380 --> 00:18:35.869
West Nile virus is more likely to enter the cell.
318
00:18:35.910 --> 00:18:38.150
So you may disable a gene because you want one
319
00:18:38.190 --> 00:18:40.829
thing or put a mutation in or change a gene
320
00:18:40.849 --> 00:18:42.890
because you want one thing, but other things may happen.
321
00:18:42.930 --> 00:18:45.470
So these wolves may end up having other kinds of
322
00:18:45.509 --> 00:18:46.309
medical problems.
323
00:18:46.950 --> 00:18:47.809
These are big animals.
324
00:18:47.950 --> 00:18:52.410
They're 150 pounds. Colossal has them on about three square miles,
325
00:18:52.490
--> 00:18:56.529
whereas normally they usually live in areas between 50 and 1,000
326
00:18:56.529 --> 00:18:59.940
square miles. So we're keeping them in a very constricted space.
327
00:19:00.519 --> 00:19:03.140
They're at risk of other diseases. So I'm concerned about
328
00:19:03.180 --> 00:19:03.859
their welfare.
329
00:19:04.359 --> 00:19:07.799
So it sounds like you have a host of concerns.
330
00:19:07.940 --> 00:19:11.369
And And throughout listening to you describe many of them,
331
00:19:11.869 --> 00:19:16.529
I hear the potential for death lurking at every corner,
332
00:19:16.630 --> 00:19:19.339
which is, I guess, an irony of this process known
333
00:19:19.390 --> 00:19:22.180
as de-extinction, is that it sounds like you sure got
334
00:19:22.200 --> 00:19:24.680
to kill a lot of animals to get to the
335
00:19:24.720 --> 00:19:27.940
point of bringing back an animal that, as we heard
336
00:19:28.000 --> 00:19:32.250
from DT earlier, might end up simply just dying off again.
337
00:19:33.589 --> 00:19:38.660
which I guess gets to the point of cruelty. Where
338
00:19:39.059 --> 00:19:42.799
is the regulation when it comes to this process of
339
00:19:42.859 --> 00:19:43.579
the extinction?
340
00:19:46.809 --> 00:19:51.140
Well, there are no regulations, and that could create problems.
341
00:19:51.200 --> 00:19:55.119
So there had been guidelines that were developed before we
342
00:19:55.180 --> 00:19:58.279
actually had any extinct animals to look at. There was
343
00:19:58.460 --> 00:20:01.819
one animal, a goat in the Pyrenees, the mountains between
344
00:20:01.880 --> 00:20:04.140
Spain and France, that was brought back and lived for
345
00:20:04.140 --> 00:20:07.200
10 minutes there. So the guidelines we have aren't very
346
00:20:07.240 --> 00:20:09.099
good and we don't really have any, we have no
347
00:20:09.140 --> 00:20:14.740
government regulations on this. And in fact, the Trump's, President
348
00:20:14.779 --> 00:20:19.859
Trump's Secretary of the Interior, Doug Borgum, came out the
349
00:20:19.900 --> 00:20:22.420
other day and said, it's great that Colossus is doing
350
00:20:22.440 --> 00:20:25.259
this because now we don't have to worry about driving
351
00:20:25.400 --> 00:20:27.269
other animals into extinction.
352
00:20:27.289 --> 00:20:32.460
If we're going to be in anguish about losing a species,
353
00:20:32.500 --> 00:20:34.380
and now we have an opportunity to bring them back.
354
00:20:34.420 --> 00:20:37.079
I mean, pick your favorite species and call up Colossal,
355
00:20:37.119 --> 00:20:40.400
and instead of raising money to get animals on the
356
00:20:41.140 --> 00:20:43.049
endangered species, let's figure out a way to get them off.
357
00:20:43.089 --> 00:20:45.880
And this is one tool, biodiversity, what it can do
358
00:20:45.980 --> 00:20:46.420
for everybody.
359
00:20:46.460 --> 00:20:46.880
Let them go.
360
00:20:46.940 --> 00:20:51.049
We don't need regulations, was his point, to
protect animals.
361
00:20:51.130 --> 00:20:53.839
Any animal that disappears, we'll just clone it back. And
362
00:20:53.980 --> 00:20:57.380
I think a lot of the company, Colossal, is worth
363
00:20:57.380 --> 00:21:01.200
$ 10 billion. It'd be great if we can help animals
364
00:21:01.240 --> 00:21:04.329
that are on the verge of extinction and help them survive,
365
00:21:05.049 --> 00:21:08.130
given that we are losing, as Colossal says, we're losing
366
00:21:08.170 --> 00:21:10.829
a lot of animals every year. And we will be
367
00:21:10.869 --> 00:21:13.400
losing more, partly due to climate change. Let's work on
368
00:21:13.460 --> 00:21:16.220
protecting those animals that are still here and have a
369
00:21:16.279 --> 00:21:16.859
place to live.
370
00:21:19.279 --> 00:21:21.180
We've talked about a lot of the risks here, a
371
00:21:21.319 --> 00:21:23.339
lot of the drawbacks. I want to talk about some
372
00:21:23.359 --> 00:21:28.309
of the potential benefits. Do you see some good there
373
00:21:28.470 --> 00:21:32.930
if we do indeed get some medical or scientific breakthroughs
374
00:21:33.029 --> 00:21:35.069
out of this company's work? I mean, there's been talk
375
00:21:35.170 --> 00:21:41.900
of rebalancing habitats, fixing mutations in endangered pink pigeons, vaccinating
376
00:21:42.039 --> 00:21:47.599
elephants against herpes, sharpening our tools for fighting diseases. There's
377
00:21:47.660 --> 00:21:48.960
apparently some potential there.
378
00:21:49.910 --> 00:21:53.599
So unfortunately at the moment, President Trump has been cutting
379
00:21:53.660 --> 00:21:58.140
back hugely on research at NIH. And the National Institutes
380
00:21:58.180 --> 00:22:02.119
of Health has funded immense amounts of research that have
381
00:22:02.180 --> 00:22:06.549
led to immense human benefit, partly because it's been available for,
382
00:22:07.329 --> 00:22:10.089
in the public domain, research is published, which this company
383
00:22:10.130 --> 00:22:14.069
hasn't published many of its key findings yet. So you
384
00:22:14.109 --> 00:22:17.789
could argue that there is a greater need to, A,
385
00:22:18.029 --> 00:22:21.210
focus public dollars on this, on research, which are now
386
00:22:21.250 --> 00:22:25.839
being drastically cut back. And secondly, a question is whether
387
00:22:25.859 --> 00:22:30.359
or not the prime aim here is to help nature,
388
00:22:30.400 --> 00:22:34.140
help endangered species, or to make money, right? And if,
389
00:22:34.460 --> 00:22:36.640
I think, as DT wrote in his piece, the company
390
00:22:36.680 --> 00:22:39.519
only plans to create maybe three or five dire wolves,
391
00:22:40.000 --> 00:22:44.109
what's the point? Is it to develop science that they
392
00:22:44.150 --> 00:22:46.250
can then sell, or is it to create these animals
393
00:22:46.299 --> 00:22:49.240
which create huge publicity? And this has been the front
394
00:22:49.319 --> 00:22:52.700
cover of Time magazine. It's been on every major news network.
395
00:22:52.779 --> 00:22:55.759
It's been on every major newspaper. They're trying, as I understand,
396
00:22:55.819 --> 00:22:58.880
to raise more money. So this gives them great profile.
397
00:22:59.019 --> 00:23:01.789
We're going to bring back these five animals. But is
398
00:23:01.849 --> 00:23:04.950
it to help nature, or is it to raise more money?
399
00:23:05.009 --> 00:23:07.329
And this is sort of the poster child for them.
400
00:23:08.170 --> 00:23:12.289
The woolly mammoth, too, which is their long-range goal, they say, well,
401
00:23:12.349 --> 00:23:16.390
it could lead to meat and fur and tusks, and
402
00:23:16.430 --> 00:23:22.069
they may decrease global warming by tamping down permafrost. Well,
403
00:23:22.089 --> 00:23:27.359
there's decreasing amounts of tundra, icy tundra, for them to live.
404
00:23:28.980 --> 00:23:33.039
To have an industry of mammoth fur and meat, you
405
00:23:33.059 --> 00:23:35.480
need a lot of these animals, and we don't have
406
00:23:35.500 --> 00:23:39.640
the space for them. Maybe Russian Siberia somewhere does. Good
407
00:23:39.680 --> 00:23:42.750
luck with that. The Russians aren't exactly our best buddies
408
00:23:42.789 --> 00:23:46.869
at the moment. And even if these animals do, wherever
409
00:23:46.910 --> 00:23:49.549
they walk, press down snow, the snow is going to
410
00:23:49.569 --> 00:23:51.970
melt further because of climate change. So you're not getting
411
00:23:52.009 --> 00:23:55.410
at the source of climate change. So I'm not sure
412
00:23:55.490 --> 00:23:59.410
how much the end result is going to be actually
413
00:23:59.549 --> 00:24:02.349
helping animals versus making money.
414
00:24:02.869 --> 00:24:03.089
Dr.
415
00:24:03.109 --> 00:24:05.559
Klitzman, I thought of one silver lining in all of this.
416
00:24:06.309 --> 00:24:09.099
If what you're saying is true, someone still cares about
417
00:24:09.130 --> 00:24:10.819
being on the cover of Time magazine.
418
00:24:11.539 --> 00:24:12.779
You mean that we still have magazines?
419
00:24:13.259 --> 00:24:13.619
Yes.
420
00:24:15.319 --> 00:24:17.900
And I should say, I realize I'm coming across as
421
00:24:17.940 --> 00:24:20.460
very negative. I don't mean to come across as negative.
422
00:24:20.940 --> 00:24:26.000
I think that science is very important. I think given
423
00:24:26.079 --> 00:24:30.789
decreasing amounts of money for science... It would be great
424
00:24:30.829 --> 00:24:33.809
as we as a society could spend it where it's
425
00:24:33.829 --> 00:24:35.509
going to lead to the most bang for the buck.
426
00:24:35.910 --> 00:24:38.390
We're at the cusp of, for instance, new vaccines, all
427
00:24:38.430 --> 00:24:42.029
kinds of new vaccine research that NIH was about to
428
00:24:42.109 --> 00:24:46.930
start is now ending. I think that near term or
429
00:24:47.009 --> 00:24:50.990
low hanging fruit is there that we can invest in
430
00:24:51.029 --> 00:24:53.930
that will be able to help millions of people.
431
00:25:00.960 --> 00:25:04.730
Dr. Robert Klitzman, Columbia University.
432
00:25:04.869 --> 00:25:05.230
Dr.
433
00:25:05.289 --> 00:25:06.910
Devin Schwartz made our show today.
434
00:25:07.349 --> 00:25:10.349
He was edited by Jolie Myers, fact-checked by Laura Bullard,
435
00:25:10.369 --> 00:25:13.809
and mixed by Andrea Christen's daughter and Patrick Boyd.
436
00:25:14.369 --> 00:25:17.430
My name's Sean Ramos. The show is Today Explained.
437
00:25:18.579 --> 00:25:23.339
Today Explained.
438
00:25:31.210 --> 00:25:34.809
That was Today Explained, which is made by Vox. Today
439
00:25:34.849 --> 00:25:38.079
Explained comes out every day and digs into all sorts
440
00:25:38.119 --> 00:25:41.859
of stuff in the news, from direwolves to doomsday preppers,
441
00:25:42.480 --> 00:25:46.799
allergies to baby Botox. You can find them wherever you
442
00:25:46.839 --> 00:25:50.640
get your podcasts. I'm Wendy Zuckerman, and regular Science Versus
443
00:25:50.740 --> 00:25:53.000
will be back next week. I'll fact you then.