РАСШИФРОВКА 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:05.057 --> 00:00:11.784
Welcome to Physio Discuss, the podcast where we dive deep into the world of physiotherapy with leading experts in the field.
00:00:12.083 --> 00:00:17.289
And today we have two incredible guests to talk through lower limb tendinopathy.
00:00:17.649 --> 00:00:19.030
They are none other than Dr.
00:00:19.089 --> 00:00:20.310
Seth O'Neill and Dr.
00:00:20.451 --> 00:00:21.211
Ebony Rio.
00:00:21.652 --> 00:00:21.812
Dr.
00:00:21.832 --> 00:00:33.281
Seth O'Neill, the Director of Research, Deputy Head of School and Associate Professor at the University of Leicester, holds a PhD on Achilles tendinopathy and is one of the world's foremost tendon specialists.
00:00:33.722 --> 00:00:50.299
His passion for advancing Thank you very much.
00:01:04.975 --> 00:01:29.481
In today's episode, we will be covering lots, including the current evidence for managing lower limb tendinopathy, how to differentiate between various lower limb tendon issues, some of the common rehab exercises used for tendinopathy, the role of inflammation, and we'll look at the future, what is in stake for tendinopathy management, and are there any exciting developments on the horizon.
00:01:29.822 --> 00:01:41.817
Stick around because by the end of this episode, you'll have a clearer understanding of the latest approaches to managing these challenging injuries and will reveal some surprising insights that could change the way you approach tendon care.
00:01:42.218 --> 00:01:44.941
I'm James Armstrong and this is Physio Discussed.
00:01:47.885 --> 00:01:52.393
Ebony, Seth, thank you so much for coming on to Physio Discussed today.
00:01:52.412 --> 00:01:54.956
I've been super excited about this as we chatted off air.
00:01:54.977 --> 00:02:00.144
You're going to have loads of questions for me just as an interested listener apart from the host today.
00:02:00.183 --> 00:02:01.286
So thank you for joining us.
00:02:01.730 --> 00:02:02.070
Pleasure.
00:02:02.111 --> 00:02:03.313
Thanks for having me.
00:02:03.632 --> 00:02:04.954
And I'm sure everyone needs to say the same.
00:02:05.876 --> 00:02:06.677
Yeah, thank you.
00:02:06.697 --> 00:02:07.418
It's going to be fun.
00:02:07.920 --> 00:02:14.831
I'm sure the listeners will be very aware of your roles in this lower limb tendinopathy, which is what we're going to be talking about today.
00:02:14.931 --> 00:02:16.854
Both of you are big names in this field.
00:02:16.895 --> 00:02:23.205
So I think the listeners are going to be really excited about listening to what you've got to say and some of the points that will probably come up from today's episode.
00:02:23.457 --> 00:02:24.580
So I thought we'll dive straight in.
00:02:24.659 --> 00:02:31.693
I kind of wanted to pick your brains around where we are currently with the evidence around management of lower limb tendinopathy.
00:02:32.032 --> 00:02:37.342
It's a broad subject, but I thought we can pinpoint kind of the current state of play in that.
00:02:37.682 --> 00:02:39.205
Seth, do you want to kick us off with that?
00:02:39.810 --> 00:02:41.731
That's a hard question to start with as well.
00:02:42.312 --> 00:02:49.078
I guess in overall summary, the evidence is really a lot of the adjuncts don't seem to offer a huge benefit.
00:02:49.618 --> 00:02:59.627
And then progressive loading particularly seems to be the mainstay from a physiotherapeutic perspective, at least, maybe some difference of opinion in sports and exercise medicine fields.
00:02:59.706 --> 00:03:02.969
But I think that's really where we're at in the nutshell of it.
00:03:03.069 --> 00:03:04.131
And it doesn't really matter.
00:03:04.151 --> 00:03:11.336
We will look at the higher tendons as we just discussed, so that the proximal ones around the hip or our sort of air Yeah, I
00:03:11.377 --> 00:03:12.298
agree.
00:03:12.358 --> 00:03:13.879
I think that's a really nice summary.
00:03:13.979 --> 00:03:19.144
And I think one of the biggest challenges with bringing together the research is you can't read like one paper.
00:03:19.163 --> 00:03:25.229
You know, we can't do, you know, one of the other questions that you have for us around, you know, is there the right exercise?
00:03:25.449 --> 00:03:26.389
No, there isn't.
00:03:26.610 --> 00:03:27.852
There's not one exercise.
00:03:28.032 --> 00:03:30.753
And so we need to stop going, is this better than this?
00:03:30.894 --> 00:03:32.355
That's so short-sighted.
00:03:32.675 --> 00:03:39.641
If you've got someone in front of you that wants to run a marathon or play with their kids, you know, their start point and their goals are completely different.
00:03:39.777 --> 00:03:43.884
So we need to be informed by the evidence, but we can't just pick up a recipe.
00:03:43.945 --> 00:03:50.116
And probably a really good clinical example of that is the heavy slow resistance programs are fantastic.
00:03:50.377 --> 00:03:57.229
You know, they really give us an insight into that early loading, but they're both the Bayer and the Kongsgaard programs are both double leg.
00:03:57.689 --> 00:04:03.842
And we know that people are asymmetrical and need to load on each leg to change that asymmetry.
00:04:04.193 --> 00:04:10.399
And secondly, as sets fit, they don't have that progressive energy storage in stage.
00:04:10.498 --> 00:04:19.026
So when we're reading research and trying to get across the current state of play, we have to understand that what we're reading is the researcher has asked a really specific question.
00:04:19.307 --> 00:04:20.668
You know, how does this compare to this?
00:04:20.949 --> 00:04:23.990
Or how does something change over a finite period of time?
00:04:24.050 --> 00:04:27.314
But the person in front of us is goal-based, not time-based.
00:04:27.394 --> 00:04:30.997
They will come and see you until you sort of help them back to where they want to be.
00:04:31.016 --> 00:04:37.223
It's the nuance of being informed by the evidence, But trying to put it
Load full transcript
all together is the challenge.
00:04:37.644 --> 00:04:48.761
And I think part of what we discussed at the last training conference as well of the groups that are in the research don't necessarily sort of meet our typical patients that we see, depending on our niche areas that we all work in.
00:04:48.860 --> 00:05:26.574
So whether this is typical national health service provision in the UK, whether it's comparing with elite sports and then what elite sports groups we're talking about in terms of jumping athletes field-based sports and comparing football by that i mean soccer with sort of any other footy that exists in the world so aussie or american or rugby and the various codes the athletes are very different and even within something like rugby a prop versus one of the backs that they're grossly different athletes just physically in terms of size the demands of the game there's some debate about whether actually there is that a bigger difference there but That's part of the nuance of the patients we've got to manage.
00:05:26.634 --> 00:05:28.416
It needs to be individualized care.
00:05:28.437 --> 00:05:33.244
And that's probably the big gap in the literature again at the moment of it's a case of his program.
00:05:33.305 --> 00:05:40.035
Everyone gets the same thing, but actually the nuance of how and where that may best be applied might be very different.
00:05:40.095 --> 00:05:46.766
And we all want to do an RCT, but let's face it, RCTs aren't really what help us manage a patient on a Monday in the clinic.
00:05:46.865 --> 00:05:49.490
So that's the bit, again, we just need to think about as well.
00:05:50.050 --> 00:05:56.380
It's both saying there's a limitation to all research in this field, isn't there, in the sense that it can only tell us so much.
00:05:56.802 --> 00:06:04.074
And in my eyes, we're talking about there's no right exercise, but quite often in the research, we're looking at a certain stage of that rehab.
00:06:04.435 --> 00:06:11.045
And as we know with tendons and a lot of the athletes who might be thinking, there's a long program here and we need to get them to an end goal, don't we?
00:06:11.286 --> 00:06:13.571
And that's very hard to carry out in one RCT.
00:06:14.192 --> 00:06:15.293
And a lot of the...
00:06:15.586 --> 00:06:41.432
interventions are quite unidimensional because of the nature of research that they're not eclectic like our hopefully anyway like our normal clinical interventions are so they'll focus on the muscle or the tendon they won't actually often look holistically at the person and how to manage the person and that creates a big sort of mismatch then in the research it's relatively biomedically focused instead of being biopsychosocially focused and That's the problem we've got.
00:06:41.471 --> 00:06:43.615
Again, it's not how we should manage individuals.
00:06:43.677 --> 00:06:57.843
It's not how most of hopefully do manage them, but it's the research doesn't tell us how best to manage those individuals that might have a much more psychological domain as has certainly come out in the Achilles literature from Karen Silbernagel's group and stuff with these subgroups that seem to exist.
00:06:57.923 --> 00:07:00.408
So yeah, a lot of questions need to be asked around that.
00:07:00.449 --> 00:07:03.033
And that's maybe a start of individualization.
00:07:03.521 --> 00:07:09.567
I agree, but what we're both not saying is that people should just be like gurus and just do whatever they think.
00:07:10.187 --> 00:07:19.096
You can still be informed by the evidence and understand rate of loading as it helps you for diagnosis, understand rate of loading as it helps you for exercise progression.
00:07:19.196 --> 00:07:25.261
So that's really feeding back to the point around being evidence informed, but not recipe based.
00:07:25.380 --> 00:08:11.470
And one more thing that I like, Seth was talking about the different sports, even for people that don't work in elite sport, you need to really think about about the context of how you're applying that intervention as well so let's say exercise so you need to think about is this person in season now that could be occupationally in season they're currently at work they're a nurse they're on their feet 12 hours a day applying a eccentric only program to an in-season athlete that is an in-season athlete we know they do poorly so what we need to do is always think about the context of the exercise you know am I rehabilitating someone do I had the ability to manipulate their sporting loads, their loads in life, or am I just managing them at the moment because that's where they're at?
00:08:11.949 --> 00:08:24.826
So even with some of the great research that has been done, we can't apply that blanketly to all of the contexts, let alone, as Seth said, the individuals and their own kind of nuances and other health challenges and all of that stuff.
00:08:25.326 --> 00:08:27.850
That's a very long-winded answer to your very first question.
00:08:28.225 --> 00:08:29.367
I think we've covered it really well.
00:08:29.548 --> 00:08:39.461
The takeaway there is there's shortfalls in the research, but that doesn't mean the research can't influence what we do and support what we do with our patients with a patient-centered care approach, essentially.
00:08:39.942 --> 00:08:51.158
And learn from other areas where the research is totally applicable to tendon patients, like back pain research on biopsychosocial management, for example, or lifestyle interventions that we might utilize for patients.
00:08:51.239 --> 00:09:10.354
And we can pull from some of the osteoarthritis research then and apply the same approach to tendons even if the exact disease pathology may differ slightly it's got huge huge amount of similarities and actually changes some of those metabolic components probably absolutely crucial but we lack a bit of detail around the research there
00:09:10.754 --> 00:09:12.956
there's a human at the
end of of every tendon
00:09:14.739 --> 00:09:17.201
that's where you need to look up above them so remember that
00:09:17.522 --> 00:09:29.437
absolutely absolutely i want to go on to the next point here actually and ebony some of your master classes for the the physio network have highlighted this one as something that I've really taken away and changed my practice.
00:09:29.758 --> 00:09:31.178
And that's differential diagnosis.
00:09:31.759 --> 00:09:42.956
When we're looking at tendons, I've certainly looked back at my practice and thought, my word, I have treated so many patients as a tendinopathy and they may not well have been a tendinopathy.
00:09:43.475 --> 00:09:44.037
Oh, me too.
00:09:45.740 --> 00:09:47.361
And it really was an eye-opener.
00:09:47.701 --> 00:09:51.827
So let's talk a bit more about the, I suppose, the importance of differential diagnosis.
00:09:52.168 --> 00:09:53.090
Ebony, let's start with you.
00:09:53.570 --> 00:09:54.418
Is it important?
00:09:54.640 --> 00:09:55.591
I think we're going to guess it is.
00:09:55.631 --> 00:09:57.249
Talk to us a bit more about that.
00:09:57.761 --> 00:09:58.081
Yeah.
00:09:58.101 --> 00:10:03.947
So if we take the Achilles, there is a lot going on back there and the devil's in the details.
00:10:03.966 --> 00:10:11.754
So if we just think of the tendon and the peritendin, if we just ignore the joint for a minute and we ignore the superficial bursa, we ignore the sural nerve.
00:10:12.014 --> 00:10:24.205
If we just think of tendon and peritendin, we've already got two conditions that respond completely differently, the loading and present completely differently and need clearly different paths.
00:10:24.524 --> 00:10:25.586
And I'm going to explain why.
00:10:25.605 --> 00:10:31.452
If you have someone with tendon they're aggravated by higher rate of loading.
00:10:31.894 --> 00:10:42.249
So the faster activities are more provocative, but we know that characteristically they warm up only to be worse the next day, but they had this warmup phenomenon and they have quite focal pain.
00:10:42.288 --> 00:10:49.899
When you have someone who's irritated the outside sonobulae, the peritendin layers, they get worse the longer you go.
00:10:50.419 --> 00:10:53.465
So it's a sliding, gliding, it's a sheer force.
00:10:53.705 --> 00:10:57.049
It might be that they swim, they row, they cycle.
00:10:57.505 --> 00:11:00.250
Or it might be your runner that doesn't warm up.
00:11:00.289 --> 00:11:01.652
They get worse the longer they go.
00:11:01.672 --> 00:11:03.214
And that's because they start running.
00:11:03.254 --> 00:11:04.775
Their calf isn't too bad.
00:11:04.816 --> 00:11:07.759
As they fatigue, they overload the peritendin layers.
00:11:08.139 --> 00:11:09.842
What they have is this diffuse pain.
00:11:10.202 --> 00:11:13.508
But critically, they actually have a very, very different pathology.
00:11:13.548 --> 00:11:16.150
So the pathology is different.
00:11:16.491 --> 00:11:18.333
The nociceptive driver is different.
00:11:18.654 --> 00:11:19.816
But forget all that.
00:11:20.057 --> 00:11:20.998
The rehab's different.
00:11:21.217 --> 00:11:29.388
For someone with mid-portion Achilles, I hope they leave everyone's clinical practice with some sort of calf loading program in some way.
00:11:29.748 --> 00:11:35.094
I almost don't even care how it looks, but I want them to have had some sort of calf exercise intervention.
00:11:35.114 --> 00:11:36.075
That's best practice.
00:11:36.436 --> 00:11:45.046
But if you have someone with a hairy tendonitis, and even though it's not inflammatory, I'm purposefully using that word because I want everyone to differentiate it from tendinopathy.
00:11:45.086 --> 00:11:51.849
If you have someone with an Achilles, hairy tendonitis, or carotene on issue, they're interchangeable terms.
00:11:52.249 --> 00:11:55.711
If you give them calf raises, that is their provocative load.
00:11:56.111 --> 00:11:57.933
Movement is their provocative load.
00:11:58.254 --> 00:11:59.195
So they'll get worse.
00:11:59.514 --> 00:12:08.763
So the person in your clinical practice who isn't doing well with an Achilles program, you have to really consider that it might be the differential diagnosis.
00:12:09.183 --> 00:12:15.328
So I think it's critical because it's the education we give people when to listen, how to progress.
00:12:15.649 --> 00:12:18.731
It determines the exercises we might start someone on.
00:12:18.831 --> 00:12:27.123
But every time someone thinks they've got a tricky tendon, it's very likely that would be something in, you know, some of these conditions coexist.
00:12:27.243 --> 00:12:34.773
You can have a peritendinitis with an underlying tendinopathy, but you have to know you've got that so that you can appropriately manage them.
00:12:35.153 --> 00:12:40.500
And they don't do well with the general exercise is good for you, you know, do great at exercise program.
00:12:40.640 --> 00:12:41.942
It needs to be very specific.
00:12:42.003 --> 00:12:46.789
And that's where the bio in the biopsychosocial really highlights how important it is.
00:12:47.522 --> 00:12:48.883
Seth, do you want to add anything more to that?
00:12:49.683 --> 00:12:54.708
Yeah, no, I think differential diagnosis is a massive component of these.
00:12:55.269 --> 00:13:01.216
As Ebony was just talking about with the peritoneum disorder, they're often triggered by excessive external compression.
00:13:01.696 --> 00:13:10.966
So boots or footwear that's high with a stiff heel counter or even actually strapping that we've applied to our athletes during football and rugby games, trying to stabilize the ankle.
00:13:10.985 --> 00:13:20.707
So there's often that element and actually part of what we need to do is remove the compressive components and the positions that are maybe causing that around the external compression of the sheath on the tendon.
00:13:20.807 --> 00:13:22.068
So you reduce the friction.
00:13:22.629 --> 00:13:23.932
So yeah, really critical.
00:13:24.032 --> 00:13:25.913
I can't stress that enough with it.
00:13:25.994 --> 00:13:42.974
And then again, just sticking within the tendon, there's so many different categories of disorder within the tendon that is evidence that the zone of tendinopathy being like the ventral or dorsal surface might have some different pain presentations in terms of the impacts on their functional capabilities and the severity of the pain.
00:13:43.457 --> 00:13:48.926
There's not a huge amount of evidence about that, but where it's been looked at, there seems to be some evidence around that.
00:13:49.567 --> 00:13:53.011
And then within the tendon, we might have a plantaris induced Achilles problem.
00:13:53.493 --> 00:13:55.495
People promote removing them.
00:13:56.056 --> 00:13:58.320
Again, we've always had the plantaris in that position.
00:13:58.360 --> 00:14:02.765
We don't necessarily need to run to removal, but it might be these don't respond in the same way.
00:14:02.826 --> 00:14:04.408
So it's a consideration there.
00:14:04.869 --> 00:14:08.094
And then a whole variety of splits and tears that can occur in the tendon.
00:14:08.134 --> 00:14:39.846
And again, in my hands, I make a lot of worse if we load them particularly if we load them early in quite aggressively so they need i think a very different nuanced intervention and unfortunately in the literature they all just get chucked together it's the case you've got a sore tendon we've got an insertional and mid portion as well as the paratina and chucked in as well and they all get thrown together and then the insertional groups you can split into okay is it bursa predominantly is it bone predominantly the Haglund deformity or actually bony edema, or is it the tendon?
00:14:39.886 --> 00:14:42.049
Or actually, normally, obviously, it's a combination of all of them.
00:14:42.110 --> 00:14:45.134
It's all internal compressive loads on that region.
00:14:45.173 --> 00:14:48.778
And the management just doesn't get considered or split out.
00:14:48.798 --> 00:14:51.422
They all get amalgamated together under the umbrella term.
00:14:51.442 --> 00:14:54.745
And it's often the important bit is the nuance.
00:14:55.187 --> 00:15:01.153
And as Ebony was saying, some of these people have been Managed for ages using regimes that are often not always appropriate.
00:15:01.193 --> 00:15:04.437
And we've all done it in the past as we've been learning.
00:15:04.498 --> 00:15:09.183
And hopefully then you get past it, but you still have mess up where something gets missed.
00:15:09.264 --> 00:15:13.168
And a bit later on you go, damn, yeah, if I'd spotted that early on, I would have done something different.
00:15:13.188 --> 00:15:14.530
And actually you tried the different thing.
00:15:14.571 --> 00:15:17.514
And lo and behold, they actually get better in a reasonable timeframe.
00:15:17.554 --> 00:15:18.735
So it happens.
00:15:20.193 --> 00:15:35.758
We haven't got time to go down this route now, but surely as well, the attention is in the details and the attention of your assessment as well, because there's some key things that are going to tell you what's going on in your assessment if you're looking for it in terms of a tendon, in terms of its high load, what is a high load and that sort of stuff.
00:15:35.798 --> 00:15:42.206
And again, I've got a lot of this from Ebony's masterclass, and I think that's really worth checking out because it goes into a lot more detail around that.
00:15:42.587 --> 00:15:48.998
And obviously a lot of the work, Seth, you've done in terms of that loading of what a tendon actually responds to and how you might see that.
00:15:49.346 --> 00:15:52.831
And you mentioned insertional and mid-portion.
00:15:53.071 --> 00:15:59.740
Seth, do you want to just briefly, for those listeners who have come across those terms, just sort of highlight the differences and what we might see between those two?
00:16:00.402 --> 00:16:05.168
Yeah, I guess the insertional bit is not often considered the true attachment.
00:16:05.227 --> 00:16:14.701
So where you've got sharpies fibers and actually the insertion into the bone proper is where the tendon actually gets compressed over the superior sort of aspect of the calcaneum.
00:16:14.913 --> 00:16:16.480
during dorsiflexion, for example.
00:16:16.519 --> 00:16:21.017
Most insertional tendinopathies have a clear bony cam that compresses into tendons.
00:16:21.578 --> 00:16:27.182
And again, this is why we often see bony spurs forming or calcification within the tendon.
00:16:27.222 --> 00:16:30.027
It's the body's way of coping with high compressive loads.
00:16:30.486 --> 00:16:37.876
It lays down bone that the tenocytes morph into more of a chondral cell or actually an osteocyte starts to produce bone or carthage.
00:16:38.418 --> 00:16:43.404
So it's all part of that mechanism and gives us the evidence that compressive loads are part of it.
00:16:43.725 --> 00:16:44.966
And it's not just against the bone.
00:16:44.986 --> 00:16:47.190
There's an internal compressive element as well.
00:16:47.629 --> 00:16:53.437
When you pull on the tendon, so as the muscle contracts, you're going to get some internal squashing.
00:16:53.570 --> 00:16:58.557
Add in then a bony element, it seems to create a bigger response in the tendon.
00:16:58.897 --> 00:17:03.243
Now, equally, this is healthy and it's normal and the tendons are perfectly robust and able to cope.
00:17:03.283 --> 00:17:14.417
So that's always got to be a key message because what we see commonly now in patients is they're attending, having listened to podcasts and blogs, sometimes misinterpreted it, sometimes actually taking verbatim what was said.
00:17:14.753 --> 00:17:16.776
that these things are bad and we need to reduce it.
00:17:16.836 --> 00:17:17.698
And it's not the case.
00:17:17.958 --> 00:17:24.085
We may just limit it or try to reduce the amount of time in those positions in the early phases is often how it's turned.
00:17:24.144 --> 00:17:29.192
But really we're talking about a highly irritable tendon, not an early phase or a late phase thing.
00:17:29.231 --> 00:17:30.432
It's about irritability.
00:17:30.894 --> 00:17:33.757
So it's a good old fashioned sin factor is really part of this.
00:17:33.817 --> 00:17:35.578
And that's the bit often we forget.
00:17:35.980 --> 00:17:40.806
And again, sometimes it doesn't always get taught very well now on modern undergraduate courses as well.
00:17:41.089 --> 00:17:52.325
clinical reasoning and subjective skills as ebony and yourself just talked about absolutely crucial to all of our assessments and really is the biggest factor in any clinical consult we ever do
00:17:53.126 --> 00:18:04.301
yeah definitely and as ebony just said a minute ago in terms of listening to sort of what does aggravate it what are the irritants is going to tell you an awful lot of information if you're prepared to open your ears and listen which is really important
00:18:04.673 --> 00:18:06.518
So I can summarize that in a quote.
00:18:06.597 --> 00:18:14.776
So Sir William Osler said, I think he was like an 18th or 19th century physician, if you listen to a patient, they'll tell you what's wrong.
00:18:15.057 --> 00:18:17.221
If you really listen, they'll tell you how to get them better.
00:18:17.473 --> 00:18:19.817
And that is so true when it comes to tendons.
00:18:19.917 --> 00:18:22.041
They will tell you what is provoking them.
00:18:22.402 --> 00:18:27.611
If it's the superficial bursa and they're getting compressed or irritated by their shoes, they'll tell you.
00:18:27.631 --> 00:18:36.326
So we need to not be fixated on what we're calling it because often that takes us down a path of this is what we need to do.
00:18:36.346 --> 00:18:38.829
And as Seth said, sometimes we're not on the right track.
00:18:39.131 --> 00:18:46.204
If we go back to the person who is really provoked in dorsiflexion, then you think, okay, what do I need to do?
00:18:46.586 --> 00:18:53.546
Even if I have never heard of plantaris before, I need to limit their dorsiflexion in those irritable stages, as Seth said.
00:18:53.926 --> 00:18:59.060
So just really honing in on what someone's telling you is just so helpful.
00:18:59.490 --> 00:18:59.971
Definitely.
00:19:00.050 --> 00:19:03.596
And I suppose that comes into nicely what we're going to talk about in a minute is exercise.
00:19:03.895 --> 00:19:13.489
And I suppose that prescription of exercise around ags and eases and what the patient's telling you, rather than a diagnosis, I've read a paper, it told me to do this, let's do this.
00:19:13.888 --> 00:19:16.432
You can actually tailor it to the individual that's in front of you.
00:19:16.752 --> 00:19:29.170
So rehab exercises, I think it's important we go through sort of this heavy, slow resistance, isometrics, eccentrics, concentrics, because haven't we been around the houses in terms of
research of where we're going to go and what we should be doing?
00:19:29.473 --> 00:19:36.025
And it can be a bit of a minefield, especially probably to some of the students and more newly graduated physios out there.
00:19:36.605 --> 00:19:38.087
What are your takes on all of that?
00:19:38.188 --> 00:19:43.016
I know we've talked a little bit at the beginning about where we are, but specifically around rehab exercise.
00:19:43.836 --> 00:19:50.166
The exercise does need to be tailored to what you're trying to actually return the person to, to some degree and where their deficits lie.
00:19:50.627 --> 00:19:56.617
And one of the biggest bits is around the lack of testing around the deficits that exist in neuromuscular function.
00:19:56.961 --> 00:19:59.625
or neuro tendon as well, I guess, with tricking with it.
00:19:59.904 --> 00:20:00.965
It's a book bear in mind.
00:20:01.006 --> 00:20:05.050
So we'll trick exercises at people, but we won't think what we're trying to do with the exercise.
00:20:05.090 --> 00:20:08.555
And it's the case of really, are we trying to adapt the tendon?
00:20:08.575 --> 00:20:10.336
Are we trying to adapt the muscle?
00:20:10.396 --> 00:20:16.502
So in terms of hypertrophy or tissue alteration and mechanics, are we trying to improve the neuromuscular performance?
00:20:17.003 --> 00:20:18.365
And then is that at high speed?
00:20:18.826 --> 00:20:24.031
Let's say high strain rates, is it actually just high force and actually load rates that we're after?
00:20:24.592 --> 00:20:25.973
Is it accumulative stress?
00:20:26.561 --> 00:20:28.345
Where is it that we're working towards?
00:20:28.404 --> 00:20:31.009
So I often just simplify it and target three things.
00:20:31.048 --> 00:20:34.994
You go for accumulative stress, peak load, and the rate of the load.
00:20:35.515 --> 00:20:37.218
And they're the three sort of key bits.
00:20:37.278 --> 00:20:44.288
And the biggest challenge for tendons, as everyone always says, it's the faster activities where you've got shorter contact times on the floor.
00:20:44.327 --> 00:20:48.515
So bigger tendon demands, they're what tend to provoke and irritate the most.
00:20:48.575 --> 00:20:50.577
So often that can be a tricky bit.
00:20:50.657 --> 00:20:52.740
And your exercises need to work around those.
00:20:52.800 --> 00:20:56.006
And whichever you're focusing on at that time point is the key aim.
00:20:56.258 --> 00:20:59.883
And Ebony's just said it, the patients tell you which one's the biggest factor for them.
00:20:59.923 --> 00:21:08.796
If we can make that particular movement or activity better, we've made the patient better, or I should say, help them make themselves better, because that's really all we're doing.
00:21:09.036 --> 00:21:15.526
And if we can empower them to get themselves better, and they can focus on the activities that are most problematic, it's a win-win.
00:21:15.874 --> 00:21:16.875
I agree 100%.
00:21:17.155 --> 00:21:25.049
If we consider tendons about the faster, the rate of loading, then by definition, anything static or slow for a tendinopathy is really safe.
00:21:25.431 --> 00:21:27.815
And so, you know, do they have to start with isometrics?
00:21:27.915 --> 00:21:28.616
Of course they don't.
00:21:28.936 --> 00:21:30.840
What they need to do is address their deficits.
00:21:31.382 --> 00:21:37.853
But we need to go away from like this one exercise to rule them all, even if we're thinking of like a calf raise.
00:21:38.306 --> 00:21:46.568
A standing calf raise doesn't necessarily ensure, particularly if we're giving an endurance set, you know, we're not targeting strength.
00:21:47.230 --> 00:21:54.089
We're not targeting anything in a bent knee position, which athletes really need for that change of direction and that eccentric soleus.
00:21:54.402 --> 00:22:01.355
So even if we're thinking of the calf, they might get seated calf, standing calf, standing calf endurance.
00:22:01.375 --> 00:22:02.939
They might get seated calf endurance.
00:22:03.138 --> 00:22:05.063
They might get an isometric sled push.
00:22:05.363 --> 00:22:11.875
There's so many different things where we go, okay, how does that person need to or want to use their calf?
00:22:11.915 --> 00:22:12.718
How do they want to function?
00:22:13.218 --> 00:22:15.824
And it's likely to include all of those things.
00:22:16.444 --> 00:22:25.445
So it's about clinicians being really thoughtful, not giving 7,000 exercises, as Seth said, being really clear on what my focus is at this point.
00:22:25.767 --> 00:22:29.394
And your focus might change, but that's why you test and that's why you reassess.
00:22:29.976 --> 00:22:36.851
So someone early on, you know, you might, start with three different calf exercises, but they're really specific.
00:22:37.412 --> 00:22:44.980
One is for endurance, one is for strength, and one is for top height if they're a football player that needs to kick in full range, you know, plantar flexion.
00:22:45.340 --> 00:22:47.943
But it's thoughtful and it's really targeted.
00:22:48.064 --> 00:22:57.955
Just giving the one exercise, you kind of do nothing well if you try and just be so generic that you're trying to cover off all bases.
00:22:57.996 --> 00:22:59.438
You sort of cover off none of them.
00:23:27.043 --> 00:23:45.406
So that scattergun approach it is, or just that thoughtlessness, I suppose, or just thinking we'll just give this because it's a diagnosis and this comes back to again listening to the patient their demands where they need to be where they are now and how are you going to take them on that journey with specifics of your your prescription i suppose
00:23:46.007 --> 00:24:40.722
i was just gonna say james everybody wants a recipe for how to manage these folk and it doesn't exist there is no sort of approach that works there never will be there'll never be one best exercise one best intervention one best program it's nuanced and it's individualizing the approach for
each person we've got and it really needs to be very thoughtful like well you gotta do with an elite athlete versus the dad that fits in the odd weekend run versus the person that sort of walks down to the bus 50 yards from their front door and then sits at office all day and doesn't do any exercise it's hugely different and to give them all the same type of exercise and the same dosage not great but equally we need to dose it appropriately as well and we get lots of folk who are totally underdosed and one of my Real bugbears is actually seated soleus work or seated sort of calf work because it's just often absolutely minuscule in comparison of what the person can lift.
00:24:40.763 --> 00:24:46.373
And often when I'm teaching, I'll say, okay, well, what weight am I going to lift on the machine in somebody with like 50, 60 kilos, that's high.
00:24:46.794 --> 00:24:53.627
And I'll say, well, come sit on my knee then and we'll sit sort of the bigger person in the room on my knee and you'll be able to lift them perfectly fine.
00:24:53.987 --> 00:24:55.610
And it's the equivalent there.
00:24:55.670 --> 00:25:04.805
And I know there's some elements of physics within the lever arm of the machine that you might use that amplify the stress a bit, but ultimately gets the message across.
00:25:05.146 --> 00:25:11.276
We can lift 100 plus kilos easily versus the 30 to 50 kilos that we were probably doing on that same machine.
00:25:11.317 --> 00:25:14.141
So let's be realistic with our dosage as well.
00:25:14.982 --> 00:25:16.044
That's really interesting.
00:25:16.064 --> 00:25:17.647
Ebony, did you have something you wanted to add as well?
00:25:18.083 --> 00:25:25.717
So when I've done podcasts, I'll often say at the start, you know, my least favorite question on a podcast is what's better, isometrics or eccentrics?
00:25:25.958 --> 00:25:27.300
Because it's the wrong question.
00:25:27.903 --> 00:25:30.967
We should be saying, what does that person need at what time?
00:25:31.007 --> 00:25:31.849
They need both.
00:25:31.889 --> 00:25:39.083
So much of what we do is quasi-isometric, but actually we need our muscle and our tendon to be exceptional eccentrically.
00:25:39.491 --> 00:25:43.937
Seth made a great point then around setting up objective markers for people.
00:25:44.057 --> 00:25:50.545
We often base things on pain and really what we should be doing is respecting symptoms absolutely.
00:25:50.645 --> 00:25:59.798
So, you know, people's stiffness and pain and teaching people about managing that because it's not all just getting rid of pain, it's actually managing it while we improve function.
00:26:00.077 --> 00:26:03.802
But setting up objective markers so we're setting people up for success.
00:26:03.842 --> 00:26:44.528
You know, if you want to be an elite athlete, we have some reasonable criteria ideas around the parameters of where you need to be and they're high but they should be because they're putting unbelievable loads through their body and we can titrate that down for the people in front of us for the mum or dad that does the weekend run so we can manipulate those up or down but I agree with Seth most of the people that I see that I'm asked to do second and third opinions are just not being loaded as much as they're capable of and what the needs demand for what they're trying to do and so they're constantly in this state of overload in terms of not having the capacity to tolerate the loads.
00:26:45.068 --> 00:26:49.437
Overloaded, underloaded, or loaded in non-relevant positions.
00:26:50.038 --> 00:26:53.304
So the other sort of thing is we often call it the Purdom effect.
00:26:53.365 --> 00:27:35.257
So Craig Purdom, who Ebony obviously used to work with a lot, came up with a bit of a nuance around just putting them in positions that replicate on field demands and really it's one of the key bits you've got to think about with all your rehab is we love our gym based exercises but it has no bearing in what position that the tendon gets stressed on field so make sure our exercises work towards that and you pretty much guarantee with your patients that they'll have a position that hurts them they avoid it especially if they're a skilled mover they manage to work around that and never go into that position or not so often until they're in the competitive play conditions and that then keeps provoking it so you It's having that chat, finding these positions that hurt and working towards that to clear it in order to get them better.
00:27:35.637 --> 00:27:39.123
And as soon as you start doing that with your patients, it expedites the whole process.
00:27:39.543 --> 00:27:47.076
You're loading the tissue in the way that actually hits the lesion and that will start to then get some modifications that we want in and around that area.
00:27:47.395 --> 00:27:49.980
this is then the benefit that we're getting from a clinical perspective.
00:27:50.019 --> 00:27:54.765
But also it's showing them it's safe because you're provoking pain, showing them it's not going to flare up.
00:27:55.086 --> 00:28:01.214
That has a massive central sort of reduction in their pain experience as well and just de-threatens it massively.
00:28:01.254 --> 00:28:02.596
It's a win-win really.
00:28:03.036 --> 00:28:07.743
Do you think sometimes as physiotherapists, we let our patients, these patient group go too early?
00:28:08.083 --> 00:28:11.007
As in we finish our treatment, is it like too early?
00:28:11.048 --> 00:28:13.371
We don't take them to the point where they actually need to be?
00:28:13.955 --> 00:28:14.336
Totally.
00:28:14.496 --> 00:28:27.251
I mean, my PhD data, I looked at that and despite excellent clinical recovery, like a 30 point shift on a B's or A's score, we were still massively miles away from their normal neuromuscular function when we compare it to control groups.
00:28:27.551 --> 00:28:29.594
And obviously Karen Silbernagel has done work around that.
00:28:29.615 -->
00:28:36.342
I can't remember if there's any other real good quantified bits, whether you've done stuff on that, but basically that's where there is big deficits.
00:28:36.382 --> 00:28:42.923
We've still got And the other factor is often their healthy side's not actually great, depending on what measures you use.
00:28:43.003 --> 00:28:50.259
So in my stuff using isokinetics, the good leg is the same as the bad leg, statistically speaking.
00:28:50.459 --> 00:29:01.803
So it might be a few kilos better or a few newton meters better, but there's not often a huge difference unless you're the person's in quite profound pain, then you'll see a side-to-side unilateral deficit.
00:29:01.843 --> 00:29:05.407
And so this creates a problem of we always use the good leg as the target.
00:29:05.728 --> 00:29:12.958
The good leg is probably not where strength and endurance deficits, performance deficits that exist well after symptom resolution.
00:29:13.478 --> 00:29:16.884
And some of this is probably why we see relapses in these individuals.
00:29:17.324 --> 00:29:23.792
In my data set, the actual plantar flexor strength didn't exceed a known previously published risk factor level.
00:29:24.173 --> 00:29:33.117
So you just then start to go out hang on a minute, we rehabbed them, we hit 49 newton meters as the average, but below 50 has been identified as a risk factor in other studies.
00:29:33.157 --> 00:29:35.442
And it's like, well, that's probably why we have a relapse.
00:29:35.781 --> 00:29:41.389
It should be, we know, certainly for Achilles, much more likely to get problems on that good leg in the next year.
00:29:41.429 --> 00:29:44.433
So we've just got to be careful when we're using targets as well.
00:29:44.493 --> 00:29:54.048
And this is partly why we spend a lot of time looking at sort of normative data, trying to get a big data set on what a healthy person looks like, but it has to be linked to specific sports.
00:29:54.147 --> 00:30:03.680
because comparing everyone in my village, let's say, the demands they have is profoundly different and you can't really then come up with a meaningful target.
00:30:03.942 --> 00:30:07.346
And I totally appreciate norms aren't a great option always as well.
00:30:08.067 --> 00:30:08.807
Ebony, anything
00:30:08.827 --> 00:30:09.488
to add to that talk?
00:30:10.029 --> 00:30:12.472
I think your point's really valid around objective targets.
00:30:12.693 --> 00:30:19.542
Most people that you assess, when you assess each side, they're down because they've had this kind of period of unloading or dysfunction.
00:30:19.622 --> 00:30:24.485
So making sure that everyone sets clear markers that apply to each leg.
00:30:24.906 --> 00:30:32.617
We know that from a neuro perspective, you actually have bilateral changes to your motor control, even with a unilateral presentation.
00:30:32.918 --> 00:30:38.666
We've seen this in the ACL literature, the limb symmetry index improves because the control leg gets worse.
00:30:39.007 --> 00:30:40.750
So that's not a good outcome for either leg.
00:30:41.230 --> 00:30:47.439
So just having those objective markers, but to go back to your first point around, do we sort of follow people through?
00:30:47.459 --> 00:31:08.163
One of the ways I think we can work towards that both in research but also in clinical practice is Laura Mimosley's four questions of self-efficacy so people want to know what's wrong with me how long will it take what can I do about it what can you do about it And if people are really clear from the start on what their end goal is, then that helps.
00:31:08.244 --> 00:31:13.308
Because I think what happens in research and clinical practice is people actually change their end goal.
00:31:13.668 --> 00:31:20.314
So people have actually stopped doing some of their provocative activity because of pain, dysfunction, life gets in the way.
00:31:20.334 --> 00:31:22.336
So they've altered their ceiling.
00:31:22.356 --> 00:31:23.957
They've changed their endpoint.
00:31:24.358 --> 00:31:26.439
And sometimes you see it with gluteal tendinopathy.
00:31:26.459 --> 00:31:36.671
You know, I've had people that are profoundly dysfunctional and their goals are very conservative because they just can't see the light at the end of the tunnel.
00:31:36.932 --> 00:31:45.564
Angie Ferron's work shows that the average time to diagnosis for gluteal tendinopathies, 18 months, these women present to the ED department.
00:31:45.664 --> 00:31:46.626
They're in so much pain.
00:31:47.107 --> 00:31:48.529
That is a failure on us.
00:31:48.849 --> 00:31:50.351
Like that is unbelievable.
00:31:50.492 --> 00:31:55.379
How is this happening that people are turning up at emergency department because their pain is so bad?
00:31:55.419 --> 00:32:04.046
So allowing people to have those lofty goals and helping them get there and not overselling the adjuncts.
00:32:04.586 --> 00:32:09.190
Circling right back to what Seth said at the start, there is not great evidence for adjuncts.
00:32:09.511 --> 00:32:25.044
And so if people early on have spent a fortune on all the injections, all the shockwave, all the things, it can be even harder to engage them in the long-term kind of process to get back to where they want to be because they're financially and kind of emotionally a bit burnt.
00:32:25.725 --> 00:32:25.985
Brilliant.
00:32:26.485 --> 00:32:29.368
Brilliant summary for both of you there.
00:32:29.868 --> 00:32:32.011
Really, You mentioned injections.
00:32:32.512 --> 00:32:40.887
We're not necessarily going to talk about adjuncts, but I did want to just touch on the issue around inflammation, its role in tendinopathy.
00:32:41.168 --> 00:32:47.419
And if we look back maybe several years, a lot of people may still hear it referred to as a tendinitis.
00:32:47.980 --> 00:32:53.771
Where is inflammation now and how are we seeing it in tendons and tendon injury?
00:32:54.243 --> 00:32:58.009
Yeah, I think it's still a contentious
issue in many respects.
00:32:58.049 --> 00:33:01.034
So there is still a difference of opinions that exist out there in the literature.
00:33:01.054 --> 00:33:04.839
But I used to sit on the camp that it was purely degenerative.
00:33:05.201 --> 00:33:13.032
And part of that is because it's not prostaglandin-driven inflammation like we learn about at an undergraduate study like you with a knee sprain, ankle sprain.
00:33:13.733 --> 00:33:20.043
But the more you get into it, the more you realize that there's a huge amount of interleukins involved, which are these cytokines.
00:33:20.063 --> 00:33:22.186
So these are inflammatory mediators.
00:33:22.819 --> 00:33:29.811
It's got differences to typical big scale inflammation that we think about with knee sprains and similar elements.
00:33:29.932 --> 00:33:35.180
But these interleukins are a huge part of what stimulates the cell and creates the negative effect.
00:33:35.241 --> 00:33:44.637
And work from people like Neil Miller, Steph Dakin, they've published some fantastic sorts of papers showing how these chemicals are excreted by the cells.
00:33:44.697 --> 00:33:48.083
And this leads to the breakdown in the tendon structure.
00:33:48.387 --> 00:33:49.869
and everything that goes with it.
00:33:49.929 --> 00:33:58.938
So whether that's cell numbers, some low-grade inflammatory cells that come in as a consequence, and then the near vessels that all occur as a consequence.
00:33:58.958 --> 00:34:01.942
So the evidence around that, I think, is pretty robust there.
00:34:02.342 --> 00:34:04.644
But it triggers a degenerative cascade.
00:34:04.724 --> 00:34:06.346
It's just actively mediated.
00:34:06.406 --> 00:34:08.748
And I think this is where we all get pet up about it.
00:34:08.829 --> 00:34:13.675
But it just depends on your view of what we define, I think, as inflammation.
00:34:13.695 --> 00:34:16.197
And if you're looking at it from a three eyes perspective.
00:34:16.217 --> 00:34:20.887
So this is about the university group that specialise in infection, immunology and inflammation.
00:34:21.288 --> 00:34:23.030
It's clearly inflammation.
00:34:23.351 --> 00:34:26.998
But if you look at it sometimes from a clinical physio hat, we sort of say no.
00:34:27.320 --> 00:34:29.563
And it's just nuance around that, I think, really.
00:34:29.956 --> 00:34:30.416
I agree.
00:34:30.436 --> 00:34:33.019
I think it's really complicated or complex.
00:34:33.239 --> 00:34:37.121
And I think the cytokines have multiple roles.
00:34:37.181 --> 00:34:39.304
So I think it's kind of two parts to it.
00:34:39.623 --> 00:34:46.569
When we used to use anti-inflammatory for an early hamstring strain, brilliant, we're blocking inflammation.
00:34:47.050 --> 00:34:49.932
Some of those cytokines had really important roles in scar.
00:34:50.193 --> 00:34:53.596
And what happened was it was associated with an increased recurrence.
00:34:53.996 --> 00:35:03.086
So I think because it is so complex in terms of the pathology, it's unlikely that an interleukin that we block doesn't have other signaling roles.
00:35:03.266 --> 00:35:09.677
And so even if we find the pathology, it will be interesting to see what we do with it and whether or not that's clinically helpful.
00:35:09.797 --> 00:35:16.368
And I think I agree, the work they've done is outstanding and I think it's really working towards a better understanding of what we can do with it.
00:35:16.708 --> 00:35:24.732
But for me, where we're at at the moment, what we've got to avoid is the public perception of that this is inflammatory.
00:35:24.893 --> 00:35:38.185
And that's why I rally against the term tendonitis, because if people think it's inflamed, their disconnect, their underlying understanding of what they need to do is rest ice anti-inflammatories, probably an injection, maybe a boot.
00:35:38.545 --> 00:35:43.670
And so that is so far away from what we're trying to encourage people as best practice.
00:35:43.991 --> 00:35:49.576
And there's a great systematic review by Nickel in 2017, which manipulated terminology.
00:35:49.876 --> 00:35:56.074
And if you tell people that they have a fracture, 56% of people think that they need a plaster cast.
00:35:56.434 --> 00:36:01.219
For the same injury, if you say cracking the bone, 13% of people think they need a plaster cast.
00:36:01.659 --> 00:36:14.230
So every time we're choosing a term or allowing people to say a term that we don't kind of go, oh, actually, this is a better term, they are updating their understanding of their condition and more importantly, what they need to do about it.
00:36:14.610 --> 00:36:17.413
So I think the debate around inflammation is fantastic.
00:36:17.552 --> 00:36:20.915
I think it's currently one for the research and the academic world.
00:36:20.935 --> 00:36:25.924
I think from a very important language and implication point of view.
00:36:25.944 --> 00:36:32.078
We have to stay well away from it or there's a disconnect between what people think they need to do and what we're offering.
00:36:32.118 --> 00:36:34.202
Therein lies the nuance, I think.
00:36:34.659 --> 00:36:35.460
I think you're right.
00:36:35.540 --> 00:36:40.964
But then equally, you have to be careful about the generative terminology as well, because that triggers exactly
00:36:41.025 --> 00:36:41.465
the same stuff.
00:36:41.726 --> 00:36:41.985
I agree.
00:36:42.346 --> 00:36:43.407
I hate that term.
00:36:43.527 --> 00:36:44.447
It's so bad.
00:36:44.489 --> 00:36:48.211
This is again where they'll read a whole variety around.
00:36:48.291 --> 00:36:59.040
So one of my opening questions is with the patient is, okay, so you said you think you've got an Achilles tendinopathy, let's say, or if they've used tendinitis or tendinosis, they don't normally, they don't normally use tendinopathy.
00:36:59.300 --> 00:37:00.922
So what do you understand that is?
00:37:01.163 --> 00:37:02.324
And what does that mean to you?
00:37:02.403 --> 00:37:42.025
Because that's the key bit of unpicking our yellow flags really in working out the impact of their belief on their sort of self-management, self-efficacy, and what's then going to be acceptable from our management perspective.
00:37:42.045 --> 00:37:46.092
And if we don't unpick it, we can't actually break through.
00:37:46.152 --> 00:37:51.019
And these are the biggest barriers to then doing something that is really a behavior change intervention.
00:37:51.380 --> 00:37:55.307
We're trying to get them involved to what they do to actually improve their behavior.
00:37:55.599 --> 00:37:57.282
Yeah, capacity to get better.
00:37:57.523 --> 00:38:02.454
And exercise, we know from our own experiences, I'm sure, is quite hard to adhere to.
00:38:03.095 --> 00:38:04.278
And that's the challenge.
00:38:04.298 --> 00:38:07.304
So we've got to be careful about the wording we use, absolutely.
00:38:08.226 --> 00:38:08.706
Oh, for sure.
00:38:08.847 --> 00:38:12.273
And just to your point around their understanding of the condition.
00:38:12.313 --> 00:38:16.784
So we did a study, so Rick Clementi and I, a few years ago, says...
00:38:17.135 --> 00:38:20.119
440 odd Achilles included, self-reported.
00:38:20.159 --> 00:38:28.606
And we asked people if they could do three calf raises and people that had higher kinesiophobia chose not to do three calf raises.
00:38:28.925 --> 00:38:40.135
So think about that in your clinical practice, not just that you might actually be prescribing that as an exercise without even thinking, you probably asked them to do it as your assessment and people are thinking, are you sure that's safe?
00:38:40.295 --> 00:38:45.179
And so the language we use and how we frame the intervention is so important.
00:38:45.240 --> 00:38:48.222
And to circle back to your point around inflammation.
00:38:48.262 --> 00:38:49.204
I'm with Seth.
00:38:49.485 --> 00:38:53.349
The term degenerative is as awful for me.
00:38:53.389 --> 00:38:54.470
I never use it.
00:38:54.809 --> 00:39:02.699
And I spend some time like Seth on not just their understanding of their condition, but if they've brought an imaging report, don't say to them, don't worry about your imaging.
00:39:02.759 --> 00:39:03.800
That's so dismissive.
00:39:04.220 --> 00:39:10.507
Take the time to actually talk them through it and try and help them understand it so that they feel empowered.
00:39:10.567 --> 00:39:14.411
But if you say, oh, don't worry about the imaging, they'll worry about the imaging and they'll Google it.
00:39:15.112 --> 00:39:15.192
Yeah.
00:39:15.211 --> 00:39:18.856
I mean, I literally just, I was teaching last week that last two days, last week abroad.
00:39:18.916 --> 00:39:25.249
And it was one of the things that we came up with was imaging and the importance around it because of what it triggers.
00:39:25.309 --> 00:39:29.476
And therapists or clinicians need to see the imaging.
00:39:30.057 --> 00:39:37.351
It's not acceptable really to just accept the report you get given because the report hasn't always got a clinical slant on it.
00:39:37.583 --> 00:39:47.842
There's some fantastic radiologists out there who will do a clinical assessment and give you a then clinical meaning for this and represent how that sits with the patient's age, let's say for RA or something.
00:39:47.882 --> 00:39:54.556
But what happens is you get reported, identify a whole load of factors, but it's the context of the patient, their presentation.
00:39:54.864 --> 00:40:02.653
And actually, does it actually show a significant problem or are we actually really talking about a very mild, typical sort of presentation?
00:40:02.932 --> 00:40:04.335
And that suddenly threatens it.
00:40:04.414 --> 00:40:11.342
And yeah, we all use case studies to sort of identify how that has a massive impact on these individuals and the fear it can induce.
00:40:11.382 --> 00:40:16.588
You get told you've got an arthritic complaint that your back's crumbling or whatever.
00:40:16.628 --> 00:40:17.690
It's terrible.
00:40:17.809 --> 00:40:19.092
It's exactly the same for tendons.
00:40:19.211 --> 00:40:20.894
And we hear the same terminology.
00:40:20.934 --> 00:40:22.836
You've got the tendon of an 80-year-old.
00:40:23.088 --> 00:41:12.532
or it's going to snap if we don't do this procedure and these are some of the sort of things that we hear that patients get told regularly and that's what we've got to unpick because it is just yeah fear of movement it triggers this belief that they're fragile they're going to suddenly snap doing something and snapping or rupturing the tendons that most of the people's biggest concerns and as ebony was talking about how patients modify their long-term aspiration ruptures is where we see that the most people actually say they've had a great recovery and score well on some of the outcome measures when they're actually terrible but it's just they've modified what they're accepting as norm so originally they're doing sports they're then not doing anything at all and look if they're walking sorts of decent distances on hills and they're accepting that and scoring those really good recoveries so there's a lot to work around that
00:41:13.072 --> 00:41:24.662
We've got a systematic review at the moment that show that most people with either current or past tendinopathy don't even meet the minimum requirements for physical activity, like less so than the general population, which is expected.
00:41:25.001 --> 00:41:38.094
But just on Seth's point around the imaging, you know, one of the things that I often say to people is this radiologist has done a fantastic job because it's their job to see every little thing and it's our job to explain to you which bits are relevant.
00:41:38.534 --> 00:41:43.999
So I think that can be a really nice way of people framing it to say, don't worry, you've got three-page report.
00:41:44.059 --> 00:41:52.893
That is a very detail-oriented, exceptional report and well done and
thank you to the person that now allows us to interpret it because they haven't missed anything.
00:41:52.932 --> 00:41:54.675
But I agree with Seth, you've got to look at the pictures.
00:41:55.396 --> 00:41:56.659
I love that idea actually.
00:41:56.699 --> 00:42:07.434
Yeah, when you get a big report with lots of findings, is actually put the positive on it from the patients and reassure them that actually they've done a really good job here, but let's unpick this together at what's meaningful to you.
00:42:07.474 --> 00:42:08.476
That's fantastic.
00:42:08.516 --> 00:42:09.398
Yeah, really like that.
00:42:09.717 --> 00:42:16.603
What's the future of Like for lower limb tendinopathy, where are we going and where would you like to see us go?
00:42:16.643 --> 00:42:31.271
So I think we need to, for us in the UK, we need to research patients that actually replicate the patients that we see regularly from an NHS perspective, which is most people's clinical practice, because it does not match that.
00:42:31.632 --> 00:42:35.797
And the interventions that we then develop need to be co-designed with the patients.
00:42:36.418 --> 00:42:43.505
They need to encompass behavior change techniques that are evidence-based and not just sort of the whims of ourselves.
00:42:44.186 --> 00:42:46.789
And we need to look a bit broader than just the tandem.
00:42:46.809 --> 00:42:59.367
We need to look at general lifestyle interventions and really unpick the influence of multiple morbidity, which is really what we've identified in the work we've done over the last five years or so in the UK.
00:42:59.407 --> 00:43:11.989
And that's the biggest bit for us, is making sure the research is fit for purpose with the people that most of the clinicians in the UK see regulate, alongside then some of the sports stuff that we do that is a bit more niche.
00:43:12.590 --> 00:43:13.010
Brilliant, sir.
00:43:13.050 --> 00:43:13.472
Thank you.
00:43:13.972 --> 00:43:15.215
Ebony, where are we going?
00:43:15.956 --> 00:43:20.182
Ideally, where we're going is that tendon research is...
00:43:20.624 --> 00:43:35.869
really well funded it's really hard to get funding and we we know that as seth said people end up often with consequences of their tendinopathy that then impact their general health, which then has a downward spiral.
00:43:35.909 --> 00:43:41.496
So, you know, a really common presentation is an older person with Achilles pain or, you know, glute med pain.
00:43:41.536 --> 00:43:43.177
They put on extra weight.
00:43:43.278 --> 00:43:44.699
They become pre-diabetic.
00:43:44.759 --> 00:43:46.041
They just get into this cycle.
00:43:46.121 --> 00:43:52.347
And we know from the diabetes research that their bills increase for the eight years before diagnosis.
00:43:52.528 --> 00:43:55.371
And one of the earliest presentations is musculoskeletal.
00:43:55.728 --> 00:44:07.847
So we are seeing people that have tendinopathy that then has this consequence, but we can't make an argument for that the way the joint folk do, because that has a...
00:44:08.400 --> 00:44:27.195
surgical outcome and so that's where funding bodies see being able to save money is delaying or preventing surgery but because these people bounce around they cost a lot of money and they have a lot of impact on their life but it's really difficult to get funding to research this.
00:44:27.777 --> 00:44:35.621
My future is that we somehow manage to be relevant on a world stage the way osteoarthritis is.
00:44:35.742 --> 00:44:59.579
It is as debilitating as osteoarthritis but for my mind it's because there's no surgical consequence and rupture is relatively uncommon compared to joint replacement and stuff and even now with the conservative option for post-rupture it's really difficult to be relevant on a world stage and by think we've got some ways we can work together and do that.
00:44:59.720 --> 00:45:03.329
I think we need to better define what tendinopathy is.
00:45:03.409 --> 00:45:06.394
It's not even on like the who classification.
00:45:06.536 --> 00:45:07.938
We sort of don't appear anywhere.
00:45:07.999 --> 00:45:13.572
So I think as a kind of disease or injury, we need to work together.
00:45:14.000 --> 00:45:17.505
I didn't answer your question, but that's my little rant around funding.
00:45:18.066 --> 00:45:25.836
I think, I mean, the Dutch studies have identified that lower limb tendinopathy is more prevalent and has a higher incidence rate than lower limb osteoarthritis.
00:45:26.217 --> 00:45:27.639
That's not taught at universities.
00:45:28.380 --> 00:45:34.250
And the consequence of something like gluteal tendinopathy is actually in a progression to osteoarthritis with Vanjie's work.
00:45:34.871 --> 00:45:36.333
But it's maybe not.
00:45:36.753 --> 00:45:39.438
We need some bigger data sets to really hammer that point home.
00:45:39.818 --> 00:45:40.960
And this is, I think, where...
00:45:41.391 --> 00:45:42.394
Research needs to go.
00:45:42.717 --> 00:45:44.182
It needs to be international.
00:45:44.583 --> 00:45:47.632
We need to do, this is what other areas do where I work.
00:45:47.954 --> 00:45:52.719
They'll do cohort in Australia, cohorts in Europe, cohort in sort of America.
00:45:52.759 --> 00:45:56.523
So you get these multiple cohorts all pointing in the same direction.
00:45:56.583 --> 00:46:00.068
You certainly got a much bigger numbers case and that really helps.
00:46:00.148 --> 00:46:09.282
And health economics need to be part of this as I've been able to talk about the cost of this downstream on the individual, their quality of life and the economy in the area.
00:46:09.302 --> 00:46:10.744
It is huge.
00:46:11.385 --> 00:46:12.827
And that's the big gap.
00:46:13.047 --> 00:46:19.596
And that's where we've all done our own little side work and need to actually come together on something like an EU horizon project.
00:46:19.760 --> 00:46:23.827
that actually brings in a multinational group of us to do something.
00:46:23.847 --> 00:46:25.789
And I think that is happening in the tendon world.
00:46:25.889 --> 00:46:27.572
It's the ISTS group.
00:46:28.014 --> 00:46:38.590
It's now the core outcome set out there to go, hey, this is what tendon research should include and discuss when you do an RCT or whatever trial you do, but the key things to report.
00:46:38.972 --> 00:46:42.938
So we're starting to get some cohesion, I think, and that will really help as well.
00:46:43.358 --> 00:46:43.720
Brilliant.
00:46:44.208 --> 00:46:45.309
And then we've got to prevent it.
00:46:45.369 --> 00:46:46.211
That's the last thing.
00:46:46.751 --> 00:46:48.275
We must prevent adenopathy.
00:46:48.615 --> 00:46:49.637
That's it, done, sorry.
00:46:50.838 --> 00:46:51.059
Brilliant.
00:46:51.079 --> 00:47:05.483
I think it's a really, really good point to finish on because it just highlights how vital our role is in correctly and assessing these patients, treating them as best we possibly can with the most up-to-date kind of knowledge and evidence.
00:47:06.000 --> 00:47:18.191
People listening to this, I'm sure, will go away straight away with a much better understanding of how they can manage their patients and an understanding of how important it is, as you said in the latter stages of this, of the repercussions of these patients going round and round and round.
00:47:18.231 --> 00:47:20.733
It's not just a tendon at the end, is it?
00:47:20.972 --> 00:47:24.235
It actually can end up being something far more life-changing for a patient.
00:47:24.376 --> 00:47:27.298
So I think that's quite a profound place to stop today.
00:47:27.338 --> 00:47:29.740
Thank you both so much for your time.
00:47:29.780 --> 00:47:31.382
Seth, go and get some sleep.
00:47:31.842 --> 00:47:34.164
Ebony, have a good working day.
00:47:34.204 --> 00:47:41.570
Thank you so much for both of you joining me on the physio disgust podcast our listeners are really i'm sure gonna be very grateful of your time as am i
00:47:41.610 --> 00:47:42.494
thank you
00:47:42.554 --> 00:47:44.061
thank you very much for having us