РАСШИФРОВКА 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.040 --> 00:00:04.511
Today we're diving into an explosive discussion on contemporary American politics.
00:00:04.511 --> 00:00:18.907
This includes the dysfunctionality within our political system, the flaws of both moderates and bipartisanship, the political realignment among certain demographics, extremism within the political system and much more.
00:00:18.907 --> 00:00:24.852
Welcome to Overcoming the Divide, a platform dedicated to insightful political discourse and debate.
00:00:24.852 --> 00:00:35.253
Today, we're joined by Corey Nathan, a creative businessman and entrepreneur who seeks to mend political, religious and social divides through his collaborative and creative work.
00:00:35.253 --> 00:00:44.930
He is the host of the Talkin' Religious and Politics podcast that brings on guests of all different backgrounds to engage in debate and productive conversation.
00:00:44.930 --> 00:00:54.212
If you enjoy this conversation, I'd please ask you to hit that subscribe button in the bomb right hand corner and share with a friend who you think will also enjoy the conversation.
00:00:54.212 --> 00:01:06.156
Thank you, welcome to the show, corey.
00:01:06.156 --> 00:01:07.665
It's really a pleasure to have you here today.
00:01:08.200 --> 00:01:09.706
Oh man, thanks so much for having me.
00:01:09.706 --> 00:01:12.084
I'm really thrilled that.
00:01:12.084 --> 00:01:20.087
It's just an honor that you consider to have me as part of the conversation, so thanks for having me 100%.
00:01:20.780 --> 00:01:22.340
Yeah, I appreciate the compliment as well.
00:01:22.340 --> 00:01:30.284
When you get things kicked off, you host the Talking Politics and Religion podcast or Talking Religion Politics podcast.
00:01:30.284 --> 00:01:34.790
What do you see and what do you plan to accomplish with that podcast?
00:01:34.790 --> 00:01:37.027
What's the ultimate goal there when you start out?
00:01:38.159 --> 00:01:42.546
Well, first of all, one of my first goals is getting people to say the title right Talking, it's not talking.
00:01:42.546 --> 00:01:46.192
You're being all proper Dang it come on, they're like it's talking, Talking.
00:01:47.962 --> 00:01:58.126
No, I'm just kidding, but in a way we specifically started with some informality because it's kind of a we're pointing in the direction of what it's all about.
00:01:58.126 --> 00:02:25.552
I realized a long time ago actually that when people were talking about others that they didn't agree with, a lot of times they didn't know what they were talking about, but they kind of thought they did because they were listening to their favorite radio show host or whatever, and they were developing all these ideas because who they were listening to or watching on TV, very entertaining, and all that started filling their head with ideas about all those people.
00:02:25.552 --> 00:02:35.531
So if one of those people are in your midst like, oh, you voted for that guy or you voted for that one, then all of a sudden you think you know them but you really don't.
00:02:35.531 --> 00:02:48.864
And what that does is it breaks down the possibility of us being able to actually talk to each other Because you automatically assume you kind of tack on any number of assumptions If you get you know.
00:02:48.864 --> 00:03:03.945
I'll make a silly example If I think you're a Yankees fan, I'm a Die Hard Mets fan and if all I know about you is you're a Yankees fan, it's kind of like, oh, I know all about you, I watch the Mets channel, I listen to the Mets show, I listen to the Mets podcast.
00:03:04.080 --> 00:03:08.905
I know all I need to know about you You're this, you're this, you're this and all I know is you're a Yankee fan.
00:03:08.905 --> 00:03:12.329
And then do you think a good conversation is going to come out of that?
00:03:12.329 --> 00:03:19.663
So, to answer your question, my goal with the show is, like, I just want to be able to remember our humanity, you know.
00:03:19.663 --> 00:03:36.081
So I bring people on, we hear about their story, we open them up all of a sudden, instead of just like one person that you know one thing about based on one headline, they become human beings and hopefully they're people who are a lot different than you, who vote differently than you do, believe differently than you do, but you're learning.
00:03:36.081 --> 00:03:45.747
At the end of the day, they're human beings and it enables us then to have better conversations and perhaps develop relationships, and we could just do this whole democracy thing a little bit better.
00:03:45.747 --> 00:03:47.383
So that's my, that's my goal.
00:03:49.588 --> 00:03:50.030
It's interesting.
00:03:50.659 --> 00:04:01.937
You bring up a pretty intriguing point that seems to lie under the surface of a lot of these debates, conversations, arguments, which is your opinion of the quote.
00:04:02.018 --> 00:04:08.462
Other side may be informed of people within your circle of thinking and they're not.
00:04:08.462 --> 00:04:30.504
They may not be the best people to represent the other side's point of view and oftentimes it's a straw man point of argument that gets put forward, which is one of my biggest kind of like pet peeves, like I just I look for like the truth in the matter, like what is the best way that this argument is taking form and being presented, and if I still disagree with it, totally okay, but at least I know the truth.
00:04:30.504 --> 00:04:35.865
But a lot of times you kind of see, you know someone who's voting Trump or Biden.
00:04:35.865 --> 00:04:50.470
They must be xenophobic or they must be a crazy leftist or socialist or communist and all this stuff without actually like kind of digging deeper and hearing that side's argument presented in its best form.
00:04:50.470 --> 00:05:01.103
And there's a plethora of resources and podcasts, such as, say, this one by other ones and yours, to hear arguments of all different types presented in their best form, but
Load full transcript
it's a little uncomfortable, kind of like, to do that.
00:05:02.221 --> 00:05:09.372
Yeah, for sure, and I think we're surrounded by what I've come to believe are conflict entrepreneurs.
00:05:09.372 --> 00:05:34.857
So, talking about radio, podcast, tv, you know, all these different media sources there are certain guys and women who recognized a formula for being successful, for getting more clicks, getting more downloads, and one of those ways is doing the equivalent of at best like selling the equivalent of fast food as opposed to good, nutritious content, you know or at worse.
00:05:34.857 --> 00:05:36.764
Actually, we had this guy, denver Rigleman.
00:05:36.764 --> 00:06:05.689
He's a former congressman, republican congressman, but he also ended up being, like head of the Intel committee within the January 6 committee, and one of his findings in doing that research is that people's response to anger and fear driven content TV, radio, podcast, online reading is the same chemical reaction, the actual chemical reaction as when you take a hit of crack cocaine.
00:06:05.689 --> 00:06:08.827
So our brains function that way.
00:06:08.827 --> 00:06:10.966
It's like the I don't know the lizard brain or something like that.
00:06:10.966 --> 00:06:15.675
There's this chemical reaction in the how our neural process is.
00:06:15.675 --> 00:06:25.629
When we hear something that triggers our fear or triggers our anger, then we respond to it a certain way, as if we're getting ahead of drugs and that gets us addicted.
00:06:25.629 --> 00:06:27.064
We all like we don't.
00:06:27.064 --> 00:06:35.726
It feels weirdly good, in a kind of weird way, but we definitely know we want to come back for more, and those are conflict entrepreneurs.
00:06:35.726 --> 00:06:41.209
They know exactly what they're doing, but what they're not doing is telling you the truth about people that you disagree with.
00:06:41.209 --> 00:06:46.057
What they want is more anger, more fear, because their ratings go up.
00:06:46.057 --> 00:06:49.468
People got to come back for more of the political crack, if you will.
00:06:49.468 --> 00:06:55.252
So I think that it's harder to sell broccoli than it is a Big Mac.
00:06:55.252 --> 00:07:05.023
It's harder to sell broccoli than it is to sell you know some really good cocaine, but, but maybe I don't know, maybe you could put some bacon in there, put a little bit of gravy, you know.
00:07:05.023 --> 00:07:13.247
Then maybe that broccoli all of a sudden tasting good At the end of the day, I just want to be doing some political broccoli, some religious broccoli, so that we can have more substantive conversations.
00:07:13.247 --> 00:07:15.144
We can all be healthier civically.
00:07:15.144 --> 00:07:17.701
You know, so I, but it's.
00:07:17.822 --> 00:07:21.531
I think the first step, as I say is, is admitting it or at least recognizing it.
00:07:21.531 --> 00:07:32.447
So if you're recognizing that this dude or this, this, you know your favorite
pundit, or whatever, is feeding you stuff that's getting you angry and you're coming back for more, first step is disrupting that process and just realizing it.
00:07:32.447 --> 00:07:36.369
Back away from the crack pipe, back away from the Dan Bongino.
00:07:36.369 --> 00:07:40.591
Whoever your favorite person is, I might point to any Matt Walsh, dan Bongino.
00:07:40.591 --> 00:07:41.355
I don't know.
00:07:41.355 --> 00:07:44.648
Ben Shapiro I kind of like most of the time, except when he's blowing up Barbie.
00:07:44.860 --> 00:07:51.807
But you know, just maybe back away from it for a minute and find some more substantive material to read, to listen to, to watch.
00:07:51.807 --> 00:07:58.891
But mostly, mostly, it's not even about what you're reading and listening to online.
00:07:58.891 --> 00:08:11.610
Mostly it's about who you're looking at deeply next door, who you're listening to sincerely across the Thanksgiving table or just a Friday night, you know, didn't.
00:08:11.610 --> 00:08:15.009
Or on the soccer field where the kids are on the neighborhood are playing.
00:08:15.009 --> 00:08:16.437
You know that's.
00:08:16.437 --> 00:08:18.586
That's what you're really listening to, you know.
00:08:18.586 --> 00:08:21.565
So that's, I don't know, that's that's.
00:08:21.565 --> 00:08:23.029
That's that's what I've been trying to do.
00:08:24.824 --> 00:08:27.305
Yeah, this is interesting actually, so I'm going to play more into this.
00:08:27.305 --> 00:08:30.586
Do you know that commentator streamer destiny?
00:08:30.586 --> 00:08:34.881
He's a pretty known person in political like landscape.
00:08:34.881 --> 00:08:38.788
In regards to podcasts, he's only quite a few noble ones, such as the Chris Williamson.
00:08:38.788 --> 00:08:42.466
He's debated Candace Owens most recently and Ben.
00:08:42.628 --> 00:08:44.231
Shapiro and the Lex Freeman podcast.
00:08:44.231 --> 00:08:50.412
He's pretty known liberal commentator but he was on modern wisdom podcast with Chris Williamson.
00:08:50.412 --> 00:09:01.110
He brought up something pretty interesting, which is people will take your applied positions and then assume your values or lack of values from those applied positions.
00:09:01.110 --> 00:09:03.663
Let me give you an example of this, and this is coming from destiny.
00:09:03.663 --> 00:09:20.730
But if you say are say, tight on immigration, you want to secure border wall, then you must, you know and you hear that from like a point of view that you probably are more in favors of open border or wider immigration policy.
00:09:20.730 --> 00:09:27.634
Then if you disagree with that the tighter border wall not only do you disagree on that policy level, but you would disagree with that person.
00:09:27.634 --> 00:09:36.410
You know assume their values, because if they don't want the wider border and they want a tight border, then then they could be xenophobic or they could be cruel and they don't care.
00:09:36.821 --> 00:10:03.035
So instead
of taking issue with policy positions, it's like we're taking issue with the characters of one another, and I think the best conversations or debates I've ever partaken in were ones where I knew the other person had a positive intent and they likewise to me, like they return that favor as well, and it wasn't about exactly winning, even though you were trying to make a point, but more so trying to like Learn together.
00:10:03.035 --> 00:10:19.399
I think a great example of this is the jorm pierce and sam harris debates, where they debate religion and atheism and not the debating, but they're really just kind of forming beliefs like together, and I kind of seeing how they like Fall apart, line up together is interesting.
00:10:19.399 --> 00:10:22.923
So I think you know on the mark yeah, no, absolutely.
00:10:22.962 --> 00:10:25.306
We're having a conversation I'm really looking forward to.
00:10:25.306 --> 00:10:28.870
We're having a guy named joe wash and fred Gutenberg.
00:10:29.215 --> 00:10:30.698
I'm familiar with all yeah yeah.
00:10:30.739 --> 00:10:31.860
So joe had a.
00:10:31.860 --> 00:10:50.326
He was a congressman, a tea party, came in with a tea party wave Firebrand tea party guy and then had a national radio show very conservative guy but he he became an anti-trump or you know, somewhere around charlotte's fill or maybe else in key, but that's not here.
00:10:50.326 --> 00:10:52.811
No, there he's still very much a gun rights advocate.
00:10:52.811 --> 00:10:56.100
You think of himself as strong second amendment guy.
00:10:56.100 --> 00:10:59.969
Fred tragically lost his daughter in parkland in 2018.
00:10:59.969 --> 00:11:04.100
So a lot of folks wouldn't think when it realizes.
00:11:04.100 --> 00:11:07.705
But fred and joe are good friends and you know we're gonna.
00:11:07.705 --> 00:11:11.931
They really really strongly disagree on gun legislation, gun issues.
00:11:11.931 --> 00:11:15.318
So how are we gonna start that conversation?
00:11:15.318 --> 00:11:19.884
Something is close to almost tragic, as unbearable as what fred has got had to go through.
00:11:19.884 --> 00:11:28.582
You wouldn't think that he's gonna be in the same room, let alone any sort of conversation with a guy like joe who passionately supports gun.
00:11:28.582 --> 00:11:32.979
You know gun rights, second amendment issues.
00:11:33.580 --> 00:11:34.860
But where do we start?
00:11:34.860 --> 00:11:38.225
We start with what our core beliefs are.
00:11:38.225 --> 00:11:39.407
What are core values?
00:11:39.407 --> 00:11:42.311
Are you know and believe it or not?
00:11:42.311 --> 00:11:46.181
You know what, what, what are your core beliefs and what are your core values?
00:11:46.181 --> 00:11:48.705
What you know, what are your core goals?
00:11:48.705 --> 00:11:49.426
Believe it or not?
00:11:49.426 --> 00:12:09.802
There's probably a lot of similarity In what fred and joe want, even though the legislation and their conclusions about what kind of legislation to calibrate where we are as a society, as a nation, is very, very different, but the values and the goals there's a lot of similarity there actually.
00:12:10.261 --> 00:12:24.945
So I think any conversation that's fraught with tensions and you know you layer on all of these built up, you know resentments for what you perceive to be your political enemy maybe well, not maybe.
00:12:24.945 --> 00:12:30.875
I found this again and again and again that if you start with values, what do you value as well as who?
00:12:30.875 --> 00:12:42.610
As well as giving the person the dignity of looking at them as such, as a person, as a human being, as opposed to that's a creature that voted this way.
00:12:42.610 --> 00:12:44.355
That's all I need to know, bam.
00:12:44.355 --> 00:12:45.976
That's a complete.
00:12:45.976 --> 00:12:55.686
You're distilling that, that human being, down to one data point, and you're not just dehumanizing them, you're basically dismembering them from the community.
00:12:55.686 --> 00:12:57.268
So what our job is?
00:12:57.268 --> 00:13:12.260
By remember, by talking about our shared values in our shared goals, by, by looking at individuals like human beings, you're not dismembering them, you're remembering them, you're remembering their humanity.
00:13:12.260 --> 00:13:17.008
That's a much more fertile ground to have really tough conversations.
00:13:17.008 --> 00:13:18.509
That does that make sense?
00:13:19.716 --> 00:13:20.918
Yeah, I'm fine, that completely.
00:13:20.918 --> 00:13:25.888
I think that's why I'm intriguing and props you for facilitating that conversation.
00:13:25.888 --> 00:13:28.177
Short, go be a debate to extend.
00:13:28.177 --> 00:13:45.006
But I think, like when I saw the show overcoming the divide, it was in the summer, twenty twenty and all I really want to do was agree with people because it was at such a time where civil strife yeah, was I'm the present among society, social circle, social circles and even family.
00:13:45.674 --> 00:13:49.178
But now, like this, the point of disagreement is not bad.
00:13:49.178 --> 00:13:51.321
It's not exactly a bad thing to disagree.
00:13:51.321 --> 00:13:57.267
I think it's more of an issue when you always agree because one so may not just be like telling the truth but to it's.
00:13:57.267 --> 00:14:28.554
It's like then some someone, some side is not represented, which I think kind of plays into the same mega wing, the majority, pretty much other public party where you know obviously there's Cult elements to it, such as trump kind of flip, being the status quo of republican positions for like the past decades and people just in the republican party being okay with that and not having any issue with it.
00:14:28.554 --> 00:14:42.600
But I think when you hear like pundits on an s and b, c, c, n, n or wherever, like how they talk about it is such in this pejorative, disparaging way and I had that something that always turns me off.
00:14:42.620 -->
00:14:58.264
I give you example this totally jen sake was breaking down, I believe the virginia Republican primary and jen sake is to be like a press secretary was press secretary biden not too long ago but she was saying like immigration was the number one issue for republican voters.
00:14:58.566 --> 00:15:01.852
The guy living virginia were thousands of miles away for the from the border.
00:15:01.852 --> 00:15:03.014
I don't know why republicans really care so much.
00:15:03.014 --> 00:15:22.274
The only border I do know that we share, that we share with, is the west virginia border is a big laugh and big like dismissal, but like it just for me it kind of touches on like this ali ism, that even if it was an issue, it would be an issue for you because you're part of this upper like class, like you were not going to be dealing with those consequences.
00:15:22.274 --> 00:15:29.826
I'm curious to get your thoughts on that to like when you talk about the other sides, I think there's also part elements of ali ism.
00:15:29.826 --> 00:15:36.059
We're not like we can downplaying, demonize whoever we want, but like there's a reason why that exists.
00:15:36.059 --> 00:15:39.548
I can use that for like almost any side or any party like it's.
00:15:40.294 --> 00:15:44.706
Yeah, I'll let you jump in some of your thoughts yeah, there's so much of what you said there that resonates.
00:15:44.706 --> 00:16:10.399
I think that A lot of times, what feels good to us and you know coming up with the perfect comeback or remembering perfect, you know, rhetorical grenade that are favored pundit just said and then being able to remember it At the perfect time to share it in the conversation, you know, so that you can love that grenade at whoever it is that you're talking to, that's, that's not persuasion, you know that's.
00:16:10.399 --> 00:16:12.081
That's.
00:16:12.081 --> 00:16:13.082
That's alienation.
00:16:13.082 --> 00:16:15.043
It's not persuasion, alienation.
00:16:15.043 --> 00:16:15.764
You know.
00:16:15.784 --> 00:16:26.879
I think the I've heard a term that a philosopher is so sociologist is working on renee desista, called bespoke realities.
00:16:26.879 --> 00:16:32.365
There's a tendency for a lot of us to create these bespoke realities.
00:16:32.365 --> 00:16:34.327
I don't like what you have to say.
00:16:34.327 --> 00:16:36.289
I disagree, or I disagree with you.
00:16:36.289 --> 00:16:37.850
I don't like hearing what I disagree with.
00:16:37.850 --> 00:16:39.697
So I'm not even gonna listen to you.
00:16:39.697 --> 00:16:40.857
I'm gonna unfriend you.
00:16:40.857 --> 00:16:44.061
I don't want to see anything in your feed, I don't want to be around you.
00:16:44.061 --> 00:16:47.664
I'm gonna move to idaho, so I don't have to be around these people.
00:16:47.965 --> 00:17:01.048
You know, whatever it is, we literally create our own realities, our own bespoke realities, right, but somebody one of the best leaders that I ever got to know personally had this expression he goes cori.
00:17:01.048 --> 00:17:03.097
I'm sure he was quoting somebody else.
00:17:03.097 --> 00:17:03.678
He was cori.
00:17:03.678 --> 00:17:11.076
If you ever find yourself in a room where everybody's agreeing with you, you better find another room, you know, and that's.
00:17:11.076 --> 00:17:11.817
That's a really.
00:17:11.817 --> 00:17:13.662
He was a really successful leader.
00:17:13.662 --> 00:17:21.098
It happened to be in the media industry and we came out of a meeting and like, dude, everybody loves you does anybody at this?
00:17:21.098 --> 00:17:22.641
Can I curse on the show, by the way?
00:17:23.482 --> 00:17:25.747
go for it, yeah, yeah I go to.
00:17:25.926 --> 00:17:27.490
Does anybody ever tell you your full shit?
00:17:27.490 --> 00:17:30.740
Tell me, yeah, I know, is one of those meetings.
00:17:30.740 --> 00:17:31.580
Was it a set?
00:17:31.580 --> 00:17:35.548
If you find yourself in a room where everybody's agreeing with you, find another room.
00:17:35.548 --> 00:17:38.798
So I want to do those bespoke realities.
00:17:38.798 --> 00:17:44.068
I want to know, I want people to challenge my thinking, I want people to challenge my assumptions, you know.
00:17:44.068 --> 00:17:56.131
And that we enrich each other when we say, hey, you know, I don't know if you thought about this, but you know and then we enrich each other to forces me to listen better and and think in a more nuanced way.
00:17:56.131 --> 00:18:14.961
And you know, I don't know, I might come back around to an original position that I had, or or maybe not, maybe I'll be, maybe I'll have a little bit, or maybe that person will be persuaded that I'm talking to, but I think, in disagreeing with each other, that that creates a better reality for all of us, right.
00:18:16.053 --> 00:18:23.997
Mm-hmm, yeah, that's that brings up a great point and at least like for me, like I want to truth in the matter and so what's true and what's not true?
00:18:23.997 --> 00:18:28.381
And obviously that Was down to a number of different, say factors that play into that quote truth.
00:18:28.381 --> 00:18:32.720
But there are things that like blind spots and arguments.
00:18:32.720 --> 00:18:48.019
I want to know those blind spots, like I, I think it's kind of foolish To buy into a narrative that you probably do know deep down is not fully true and then have, yeah, then have the goal to take that narrative public.
00:18:48.019 --> 00:18:55.102
Yeah, you're voicing it and, god forbid, you do that with someone who's on others, like who you know has counter talking points.
00:18:55.102 --> 00:19:04.337
I was, um, it's, it's fine that you mentioned that that original position, right, like, even though you may hear other points and you want to hear the nuance and things.
00:19:04.357 --> 00:19:07.970
Like I did this debate on immigration person was in favor open borders.
00:19:07.970 --> 00:19:14.855
I was kind of learning a lot and but also kind
of like returned to after like a week and doing more research on the points.
00:19:14.855 --> 00:19:22.089
That's like no, I'm still kind of not in favor of that, but I was still happy to have that discussion because it helps you fill in the gaps.
00:19:22.089 --> 00:19:30.700
How do you know how strong say how if your ship can flow, if you never put in a mortar, that's a great point, that's, yeah yeah, that's the thing.
00:19:30.720 --> 00:19:40.594
So you have to do stress test, you have to test things out, and that's where I really get props to you and everyone in this space who kind goes on different shows and debates and you only know what's gonna come from it.
00:19:40.594 --> 00:19:46.355
But you do know you're probably learned something, whether it's the hard way or the better way, when you just feel good all around.
00:19:46.817 --> 00:19:48.862
Yeah, even your yeah.
00:19:48.862 --> 00:19:51.497
No, even even a creative question.
00:19:51.497 --> 00:19:57.859
A really thoughtful question Forces me to think about things in a way that I hadn't thought about them before.
00:19:57.859 --> 00:20:00.991
So it doesn't even require debate or disagreement necessarily.
00:20:00.991 --> 00:20:05.606
But if somebody is thoughtful and intelligent, you can structure a question in such a way.
00:20:05.606 --> 00:20:17.000
We're like huh, I Didn't think of it in those terms, and it forces me to use my brain, my imagination, and try to bring, you know, bring Seemingly chaotic things together.
00:20:17.000 --> 00:20:18.589
You know, make some sense of things.
00:20:18.710 --> 00:20:27.251
I think that helps all of us to keep just keep challenging ourselves on a on a mental level, emotional level, intellectual levels, like a Ethical level.
00:20:27.251 --> 00:20:29.397
You know, I think it's good stress testing.
00:20:29.397 --> 00:20:30.821
That's I like that.
00:20:32.191 --> 00:20:32.972
Yeah, 100%.
00:20:32.972 --> 00:20:42.556
And I'm curious for your thoughts because a Gallup poll back in April found that no record record breaking of Americans view themselves as independent.
00:20:42.556 --> 00:20:48.184
It was up where it was 49% and the other two parties were only 20 something percent each.
00:20:48.184 --> 00:20:57.340
Yeah, so what we think just turns people off about the Contemporary modern political parties the Democrats and the Republicans.
00:20:57.340 --> 00:21:05.670
Because you know you have a lot of experience talking to people across a political spectrum so I'm curious on what you hear and how you've kind of what your takeaways there are.
00:21:06.673 --> 00:21:07.856
Well, there's, there's a lot there.
00:21:07.856 --> 00:21:17.374
First of all, there's been a lot of studies over the last 10 years at least that kind of lead to the same conclusion and you will find a lot of folks will identify as Independence.
00:21:17.374 --> 00:21:23.509
Right now, I think the number is hovering somewhere around 42%, depending on where, which which survey you're getting.
00:21:23.509 --> 00:21:35.361
But I think a lot of the reason is there was another study, a really broad study that included tens of thousands of people, so there was a lot of data feeding into this study.
00:21:35.361 --> 00:21:37.527
I'm gonna say it's a common ground committee, but it's.
00:21:37.527 --> 00:21:58.925
It's not that it's related to the common ground committee, but it was a really broad study and the conclusion that they came to was, at the end of the day I think they called it highly engaged, meaning what we would think of as extremists, some guys who get up every every morning and are thinking about it, you know, first thing in the morning and are tweeting last thing before they go to bed.
00:21:58.945 --> 00:22:01.157
They're watching the programs, listen to the podcast, you know all day, every day.
00:22:01.157 --> 00:22:09.910
They're really super engaged and what we would think of as like the extremists, what they found was there was something along the lines of five or six percent on.
00:22:09.910 --> 00:22:19.750
I hate the right, left, but you know, for for shorthand We'll just say about five or six percent on the on the right and about seven or eight percent on the left are extremists.
00:22:19.750 --> 00:22:31.390
Everybody else about 85% of us are somewhere in the middle, but the narratives are being defined by that five or six percent, by that five or six percent and seven, eight percent right.
00:22:31.390 --> 00:22:36.801
They're being defined by the screamers, by the extremists, and they're taking all the oxygen out of the room.
00:22:36.801 --> 00:22:41.077
So, number one, it's important for the rest of us to know that.
00:22:41.077 --> 00:22:42.662
It's important for the rest of us.
00:22:42.662 --> 00:22:45.938
There's there's another term called the exhausted majority.
00:22:46.278 --> 00:22:55.674
David French has been talking a lot about this and it means that like, oh man, I just don't have time for this, you know, and that person's screaming, they must know what they're talking about.
00:22:55.674 --> 00:23:00.912
So let them, you know, let them take over, let them take, take all the space in the village square, if you will.
00:23:00.912 --> 00:23:10.522
Number one, it's important for us in the middle Not to fall prey to just being the exhausted and then we seed the ground to the extremists.
00:23:10.522 --> 00:23:19.779
We need to be engaged because the truth is a vast, vast majority of us are somewhere in the middle and have a lot more in common than the extremists on this side or that side.
00:23:19.779 --> 00:23:26.962
So, yeah, it's true, a lot of us, you know, with the thing that you were talking about the independence, the truth is, most of us.
00:23:26.962 --> 00:23:44.219
There's an organization called braver angels that that I'm, I'm involved with, and braver angels, when you come to their I forgot what they call it, but when you come as a delicate last year it was in
gettysburg they do great work and they ask you are you a little bit more red, a little bit more blue?
00:23:44.219 --> 00:23:47.875
I said I'm an independent and they had a follow-up Uh questionnaire.
00:23:47.875 --> 00:23:49.240
Because they're like no, you're not.
00:23:49.240 --> 00:23:51.309
Because for the most part they're usually right.
00:23:51.590 --> 00:23:52.954
Usually somebody says I'm an independent.
00:23:52.954 --> 00:23:54.961
At the end of the day they vote all republican, all democrat.
00:23:54.961 --> 00:23:58.160
There's really a very, very small percentage of people who are purple.
00:23:58.160 --> 00:24:03.031
We're purple, um, and and so.
00:24:03.031 --> 00:24:04.055
So there is that.
00:24:04.055 --> 00:24:16.089
That folks, you know, veer a little right, a little left, but still like, I still think, even if, at the end of the day, they're what we would call a traditional democrat, traditional republican, there's still some possibility of persuasion there.
00:24:16.089 --> 00:24:20.811
You know, um, and there is, like that I don't know, mike matriot.
00:24:20.832 --> 00:24:21.513
In 2020.
00:24:21.513 --> 00:24:29.982
He was like one of the most brilliant numbers, politician, politics, campaign guys in the country and he identified what's called the banon line.
00:24:29.982 --> 00:24:37.522
So, within Different constituencies, there's that middle, there's that persuadable voter and the banon line.
00:24:37.522 --> 00:24:51.423
He kind of hijacked it from steve banon, but he said he identified certain constituencies that were, in fact, that were in that purple area, that were persuadable, and at that, in that election it was five or six percent.
00:24:51.423 --> 00:25:02.359
So for him, what he was targeting was not just independence, but also registered republicans that would either Um, leave it blank, do a write-in or actually vote for biden in 2020.
00:25:02.359 --> 00:25:03.982
And it was five or six percent.
00:25:03.982 --> 00:25:05.513
It's the same thing this time.
00:25:05.513 --> 00:25:08.597
It's just a matter of figuring out who they are, I think, those constituencies.
00:25:08.679 --> 00:25:18.670
Now for talking large groups of people, I think that I was just talking to a woman named Rachel Vindman, who's one of the co-hosts of the the suburban women problem podcast.
00:25:18.670 --> 00:25:41.577
It's a great podcast and part of it is, I think, that is the hinge upon which the 2024 election is going to swing Um, suburban women who, if they're old enough, they would have been voting for reagan in the first bush, probably the second bush, um, but but sometime around 2008, 2012 and definitely by 2016, that college educated suburban woman she was.
00:25:41.577 --> 00:25:49.442
She might have still been registered republican, but she ain't having, you know, today's version of the republican party that she grew up with, you know?
00:25:49.442 --> 00:25:52.715
So, yeah, 42, 40, 9 percent.
00:25:52.715 --> 00:25:55.684
I've heard those numbers too, but that's that's where.
00:25:55.684 --> 00:25:57.470
That's where all the action really is.
00:25:57.470 --> 00:26:04.990
We think it's from the extremes, but that's just because they're loud, you know, but we gotta take some space back for the rest of us, you know.
00:26:06.012 --> 00:26:16.984
Well, you brought up a good point though that I think plays true, which is you use the word obsessed and someone who's obsessed with their quote craft is going to be better than someone who is not.
00:26:17.470 --> 00:26:26.881
Yeah, sport someone who leisurely plays tennis will not be as good as a pro athlete who wakes up at 6 am In place tennis every day, and so on and so forth.
00:26:27.151 --> 00:26:37.869
So I think it like it intuitively makes sense that the people who are most quickly Active or engaged, as you said, they'll be obsessed and they're kind of gonna dominate the discourse.
00:26:37.950 --> 00:26:50.842
You gotta dominate politics because they're the ones whose jobs are, revolve around it, they're livelihoods revolve around it families, friends, networks, and that just that adds up to me and to your, to your point, the exhausted majority.
00:26:50.842 --> 00:27:00.448
It's like it's me exhausted from like not feeling, you have to say, but I hate, I never want like blame the voter or the American for where we are.
00:27:00.448 --> 00:27:08.723
But it's like well, if someone who's playing in the like the work or is involved in is engaged, like it just makes sense that this is going to be how it is.
00:27:08.723 --> 00:27:28.844
And till people say you know what, I am good, you know, run for that seat on the city council or even lower on like a no commissioners board or something, you're just getting involved, more involved in my community and things are just kind of run its course by these people who are hyper politically engaged because they are obsessed with their craft and you know Props and never being obsessed.
00:27:28.884 --> 00:27:36.070
You know I don't really appreciate their positions but nonetheless, like anyone who's really going after it's like okay, well, I know why this is happening.
00:27:36.070 --> 00:27:39.557
If that makes sense, I don't know why they're so extreme, maybe they that's.
00:27:39.618 --> 00:27:46.910
There's a lot of reasons for that, but just to understand why they're kind of dominating the discourse is more intuitive.
00:27:46.910 --> 00:28:03.869
I want to play into another thing you said, which was education point, college education, education, college educated women, because you're seeing that as being this almost litmus test for whether someone's going to be more conservative or Liberal, which is whether they received a college education.
00:28:03.869 --> 00:28:06.336
I know that's.
00:28:06.336 --> 00:28:22.056
The polling kind of indicates that now, and you see more men who are not going to college trending more towards conservative leaders and thinking,
and then, on the opposite side, women who are trending more Enrolling in college more than men, more than men trending more liberal.
00:28:22.056 --> 00:28:23.098
So that's that's.
00:28:23.098 --> 00:28:39.760
That's an interesting line that cut across is a number of Categories and topics, but yeah, I mean it's interesting how the realignment in both parties and on political spectrum affects both gender education.
00:28:39.760 --> 00:28:46.227
It's very involved but nonetheless it intrigues me and I think I'm out of people too.
00:28:46.829 --> 00:28:50.153
And listen, it's the job of a large coalition to be aware of that stuff.
00:28:50.153 --> 00:28:59.138
You know, if, if, what you're, if, if you, your message is alienating large chunks of the population of the constituency that you're supposed to serve.
00:28:59.138 --> 00:29:09.506
You gotta be aware of that, you know, because your job is not just to represent the extreme fringe of your, your constituency, the loudest of your constituency, but your entire constituency.
00:29:09.506 --> 00:29:12.167
So, yeah, like there's, there's a lot of people.
00:29:12.167 --> 00:29:26.453
Like you know, mike Madrid also has this the guy I was referring to about that that he focused on the band in line and he was a large part of getting that band in line north of six, five or six percent, especially in those swing states in 2020.
00:29:26.453 --> 00:29:32.721
He's also been writing op eds and trying to educate the Democratic Party.
00:29:32.721 --> 00:29:34.544
Actually grew up as a Republican.
00:29:34.544 --> 00:29:38.313
I think he still identifies as a Republican, but he's not.
00:29:38.313 --> 00:29:39.355
He's not a maga guy.
00:29:39.355 --> 00:29:48.299
So he's been trying to educate his Democratic friends like hey, listen, you have a Latino problem and we first started saying it at least two years ago, if not longer.
00:29:48.950 --> 00:29:49.230
They were.
00:29:49.230 --> 00:29:52.615
They a lot of his friends and people who commented on the.
00:29:52.615 --> 00:29:54.758
You know we wrote in New York Times piece.
00:29:54.758 --> 00:30:03.174
A lot of people commenting reacted not to the substance of what he was saying but as people who just didn't like what he was saying.
00:30:03.174 --> 00:30:13.236
And we're responding, whether it was ad hominem or attacks or just kind of temper tantrum throwing, and Mike's like say what you want, do what you want to all the time tantrums you want.
00:30:13.276 --> 00:30:14.337
But this thing is real.
00:30:14.337 --> 00:30:20.693
You can either yell at me for I don't know, not looking the way you want me to look or we can deal with this problem.
00:30:20.693 --> 00:30:21.516
It exists.
00:30:21.516 --> 00:30:24.722
It's kind of like throwing a temper tantrum about gravity.
00:30:24.722 --> 00:30:27.854
You know you, you can throw a temper tantrum about gravity.
00:30:27.854 --> 00:30:30.237
It exists, regardless of what your reaction to it is.
00:30:30.237 --> 00:30:38.145
But you better get used to it, because if you test whether gravity exists or not from 20, 20 story building, it's not going to work out well for you.
00:30:38.609 --> 00:30:39.872
So he was saying Latino.
00:30:39.872 --> 00:30:42.736
You know what is it about Latino voters.
00:30:42.736 --> 00:31:03.174
Him and Chuck Rocha have this great podcast, latino vote, and they're both practitioners election practitioners and Mike has helped win a lot of Republican races over the last 30 years, chuck was, you know, historically, one of the, you know, president level campaign managers on the Democratic side and they get along.
00:31:03.174 --> 00:31:04.878
So you know they're good friends.
00:31:04.878 --> 00:31:10.534
But they're both talking about this number one is a lot of, but you know it.
00:31:10.534 --> 00:31:12.778
First of all, it's a very pluralistic vote.
00:31:12.778 --> 00:31:13.820
We got to acknowledge that.
00:31:13.820 --> 00:31:18.130
Yeah, come from Cuba, very different people who are coming from Venezuela now, for example.
00:31:18.130 --> 00:31:24.097
But you know identifying certain things of why is there leakage right now?
00:31:24.097 --> 00:31:32.130
One is, you know there's still a lot of people of you know whether it's South America, mexico, even, you know, cuba, places like that.
00:31:33.554 --> 00:31:37.930
Faith is a bigger issue than the trend lines of the general population of America.
00:31:37.930 --> 00:31:43.833
So if you're saying and doing things and representing things that alienate people based on their faith, that's a problem.
00:31:43.833 --> 00:31:55.323
If you are, a lot of folks are, you know, first generation, second generation, you know so they tend, you know, like my family we tended to be, you know, first section tend to be small business owners, like me.
00:31:55.323 --> 00:32:03.500
So if your policies are really putting way too much burden on the backs of small business owners, that's a problem, you know.
00:32:03.500 --> 00:32:07.230
So all these things have to be thought about, like you know.
00:32:07.230 --> 00:32:12.739
But at the end of the day, kicking and screaming that you don't like hearing the truth about.
00:32:12.739 --> 00:32:17.244
You know leakage from the Latino vote isn't going to do anything to help you win the next election.
00:32:17.244 --> 00:32:21.240
You got to address the problem, acknowledge the problem and do something about it.
00:32:21.240 --> 00:32:21.681
You know.
00:32:22.951 --> 00:32:23.693
A thousand percent.
00:32:23.693 --> 00:32:33.422
I mean, I think not that the Republican Party doesn't have its own issues, but I would say I feel like that's a theme, at least with the Democratic Party, and it's a modern form.
00:32:34.090 --> 00:32:35.777
Kicking and screaming throw a temper tantrum.
00:32:37.270 --> 00:32:51.083
Well, no, specifically, I said you know, but I mean I have no issue with sying my co-sign, but what I was referring to more
specifically was just with not listening to people and not looking at the facts.
00:32:51.083 --> 00:33:01.944
For example, you know you have polls upwards of 90 percent think Biden's too old to run for president, and before those polls came out, it was kind of evident that that was probably the case as well.
00:33:01.944 --> 00:33:07.338
Yet they're hopping him up to be the Dominion, is it not me?
00:33:07.338 --> 00:33:14.237
I'm pretty sure it's officially secured nomination, but like there was opportunity to be like, all right, well, we beat Trump.
00:33:14.237 --> 00:33:16.240
From a Democratic point of view, we beat Trump.
00:33:16.240 --> 00:33:22.114
Four years are coming up, you know, 2024, new election buying.
00:33:22.114 --> 00:33:23.435
We see that he's aging.
00:33:23.435 --> 00:33:25.858
Served as purpose, say serve.
00:33:25.858 --> 00:33:31.605
Well, probably someone else in there know reinvigorate, galvanized voters, all from something new.
00:33:32.750 --> 00:33:36.714
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah yeah yeah, it was just like no, no, we're going to double down.
00:33:36.714 --> 00:33:37.876
We're doubling down here.
00:33:37.876 --> 00:33:39.038
We're going to go with Biden.
00:33:39.038 --> 00:33:43.763
This is our guy, you know he's just so many complications at this point they got, I don't want to mention.
00:33:43.763 --> 00:33:52.758
I just feel bad, like bring them up, because you kind of like have a sympathy for the guy but nonetheless he's a president and should be held to that standard as much.
00:33:52.758 --> 00:34:03.579
And it's just like bizarre to me, because there are like a few other candidates that at least come to mind that they could like went with, but decide so I not to, and yeah so like us.
00:34:04.851 --> 00:34:05.571
No, it's so funny.
00:34:05.571 --> 00:34:10.579
Like you're, you're singing my song man because, like I said, I am a purple voter.
00:34:10.579 --> 00:34:20.737
So I remember in 2016 I forget exactly how many Republican candidates there were, but let's say they were Fifteen or sixteen there are easily like 14 or 15 of them I could have easily voted for.
00:34:20.737 --> 00:34:22.860
There are a lot of people on that stage now.
00:34:22.860 --> 00:34:29.213
A lot of them have devolved in the in the Trump era and I wouldn't be able to support them.
00:34:29.213 --> 00:34:32.639
You know what they've become in the Trump era.
00:34:32.639 --> 00:34:36.065
But somebody like Nikki Haley, for example, I could have voted for in a heartbeat.
00:34:36.065 --> 00:34:37.512
You know?
00:34:37.512 --> 00:34:38.833
Same thing on the democratic side.
00:34:38.833 --> 00:34:43.922
Like you put up mayor Pete or Gretchen Whitmer, josh Piro, you get me.
00:34:43.922 --> 00:34:51.056
You get me somebody who I 95, like exploded and he had that thing rebuilt in two weeks.
00:34:51.056 --> 00:34:58.032
Like get me that guy all day, every day, because at the end of the day, you need an executive, you need a chief
executive, right, somebody who can.
00:34:58.032 --> 00:35:03.760
Or as Megan Whitmer yeah, what am I not Megan Whitmer?
00:35:04.059 --> 00:35:07.786
Gretchen, gretchen Whitmer yeah, governor what you know I'm talking about from Michigan.
00:35:08.010 --> 00:35:10.554
Yeah, I did a damn rose you know, build a damn rose.
00:35:10.773 --> 00:35:16.440
So I give me somebody like that all day, every day and, frankly, like I have this.
00:35:16.440 --> 00:35:20.065
It's a stupid theory, but I call it the empty calorie vote.
00:35:20.065 --> 00:35:24.936
A lot of us are empty calorie voters because we always on a few levels.
00:35:24.936 --> 00:35:27.320
One is I'm in California.
00:35:27.320 --> 00:35:29.844
My vote at the presidential level just doesn't matter.
00:35:29.844 --> 00:35:31.876
It just doesn't matter.
00:35:31.876 --> 00:35:34.873
We know where it's going New York, you know.
00:35:34.873 --> 00:35:38.539
Certain states, just you know, like Biden is just not going to win.
00:35:38.539 --> 00:35:39.940
North Dakota just not going to happen.
00:35:39.940 --> 00:35:43.210
He's not going to win Idaho or Wyoming not going to happen, you know.
00:35:43.251 --> 00:35:46.114
Not only that, it extends on an individual level.
00:35:46.114 --> 00:35:52.965
I go to church with guys who will never, ever, ever, ever, ever cast any other vote other than Republican.
00:35:52.965 --> 00:35:56.574
They're empty calorie vote, we got it, they're built into the system.
00:35:56.574 --> 00:35:58.135
We account for empty calories.
00:35:58.135 --> 00:36:03.603
However, I spent a lot of time as a kid in box County late 20, you know.
00:36:03.603 --> 00:36:05.726
Or late teens, early 20s.
00:36:05.726 --> 00:36:10.797
My people in box County, pennsylvania, they are not empty calorie voters, you know.
00:36:10.797 --> 00:36:13.001
Or in my district, yes, I'm in California.
00:36:13.001 --> 00:36:15.605
So my presidential level vote, empty calorie vote.
00:36:15.605 --> 00:36:17.853
But my district is not my district.
00:36:17.853 --> 00:36:27.005
My US House district was one by 333 votes out of over 340,000 that were cast in 2020, so that is a vote that matters.
00:36:27.005 --> 00:36:34.041
So I bring that up to say, like my, my, my vote is a purple guy matters at the US House district.
00:36:34.041 --> 00:36:38.936
If I was in Put bucks County, pennsylvania, my presidential vote would matter there.
00:36:39.538 --> 00:36:40.981
Who's gonna win those votes?
00:36:40.981 --> 00:36:46.556
I think it's a mayor P or Gretchen Whitmer or Josh a pure on the Democratic side.
00:36:46.556 --> 00:36:49.101
I think it's a Nikki Haley on the Republican side.
00:36:49.101 --> 00:37:10.822
There's any number of others a Chris Christie, you know has other problems, but he that he's the kind of guy or even even what's his name that supported Haley from the governor of New Hampshire Is the kind of a young man that can win a larger constituency, build a larger coalition than the
very orthodox kind of must be Magal all day, every day, kind of a thing.
00:37:10.822 --> 00:37:12.364
That's not a growing coalition.
00:37:12.364 --> 00:37:13.650
That's like you know.
00:37:13.650 --> 00:37:16.438
I don't know I probably got on too long already.
00:37:16.438 --> 00:37:19.893
I got myself into trouble, but no, no, I mean, I serious.
00:37:20.153 --> 00:37:35.481
We really have some disagreements in terms of candidates, because it's interesting like I Not fan Trump now, but in terms of 2016, trump and terms of 2016, bernie Sanders, or much more in favor of like their populace rhetoric.
00:37:35.481 --> 00:37:59.557
Compare, and it's not really the figures in only have anything, find anything egregious about Bernie Sanders like character, but it's less and it's more about like what they're speaking to, which on large part part is economic factors that have kind of Driven out, say, the middle class but also deeply affected the Rust Belt area of the country.
00:37:59.557 --> 00:38:29.023
But nonetheless, I kind of like I aligns like populace rhetoric to extend and that's why I hear like people such as like Haley, or governor which man who have concerns with, say, the covert nineteen and her policy, or Haley on foreign policy, but nonetheless, like it's on to me it's like More so the communication of how and it's a communication of their policies, which are people and I don't, so I.
00:38:29.023 --> 00:38:49.237
The point I bring up here is like I don't know if I'm like Find myself, I don't know if most people find themselves to be moderate, the paying on the policy issue, like, for example, like there's a growing number of people like the Democratic Party, the overwhelming majority of the Party is in favor of a ceasefire in Israel or in Gaza, for example.
00:38:49.257 --> 00:38:51.059
I don't know if that's like a moderate position.
00:38:51.059 --> 00:38:53.242
They all ceasefire maybe is, maybe isn't.
00:38:53.242 --> 00:39:09.454
But then same thing goes for like health care, when, like no majority Democrats are in favor of like health care and then some taste me, the majority of the Republican Party is in favor of something like on the strict borders and so on.
00:39:09.454 --> 00:39:13.836
So I mean, I don't know like what Exactly.
00:39:13.836 --> 00:39:22.213
I don't know how you capture that base while also not tending to the issues that they bring up.
00:39:22.213 --> 00:39:22.795
Does that make sense?
00:39:23.996 --> 00:39:24.277
It does.
00:39:24.597 --> 00:39:29.206
And there is a solution and we've seen the solution and we also saw a missed opportunity.
00:39:29.206 --> 00:39:30.289
Now what am I talking about?
00:39:30.289 --> 00:39:39.465
A lot of folks might not like Biden, but I probably disagree with more of Biden's own policies than agree with them.
00:39:39.465 --> 00:39:42.811
However, I really agree with his process.
00:39:42.811 --> 00:39:49.081
What I mean is, if you look at his biggest pieces of legislation, they're all Republican-led or another.
00:39:49.081 --> 00:39:56.331
You know, one of the big ones that wasn't necessarily Republican-led was led by Joe Manchin, the most centrist senator in the Senate right now.
00:39:56.331 --> 00:39:58.436
So you get the gun legislation.
00:39:58.436 --> 00:40:03.603
It wasn't really gun legislation, it was like mental health legislation after the tragic events in Uvalde.
00:40:03.864 --> 00:40:04.344
Who was it?
00:40:04.344 --> 00:40:08.650
It was John Cornyn, a Republican senator from Texas, who led that piece of legislation.
00:40:08.650 --> 00:40:21.800
The bipartisan infrastructure bill was led largely by McConnell and the Republican leaders minority leaders of the Senate that led negotiations, even like the fiscal cliff about a year ago last spring.
00:40:21.800 --> 00:40:23.822
Who was in the room with Biden?
00:40:23.822 --> 00:40:29.751
It was Kevin McCarthy and it was more of Kevin McCarthy's boxes that were checked than Biden's boxes that were checked.
00:40:29.751 --> 00:40:39.226
So a lot of his biggest pieces of legislation the bipartisan infrastructure bill chips, you know, all bipartisan, not just bipartisan-led.
00:40:39.226 --> 00:40:41.188
Or you look at this last one that didn't go through.
00:40:41.188 --> 00:40:42.811
Who was in that room?
00:40:42.811 --> 00:40:54.710
One of the most conservative senators in the Senate, it was Senator Langford from Oklahoma and it was like a, you know, a Republican-conservative closed border, essentially wish list of legislation.
00:40:54.710 --> 00:40:59.726
He happened to have what's her name, the independent senator from Arizona, in the room with them.
00:41:00.255 --> 00:41:03.719
But that was the furthest left person that he had at the negotiation table.
00:41:03.719 --> 00:41:04.802
They delivered this.
00:41:04.802 --> 00:41:18.141
It was technically a bipartisan piece of legislation but it was really a mostly 89% conservative piece of legislation and it boggles my mind that Johnson didn't bring it to the floor in the house because it was their entire wish list.
00:41:18.141 --> 00:41:26.170
It was the best menu they're ever going to get for a more closed, border-minded constituency.
00:41:26.170 --> 00:41:28.900
It was like it was delivering on their wish list.
00:41:28.900 --> 00:41:30.402
But that's how it gets done.
00:41:30.402 --> 00:41:33.530
It gets done by bringing historic.
00:41:33.550 --> 00:41:34.713
There's a lot of talk about this.
00:41:34.713 --> 00:41:51.385
Stories have been told about this how Ronald Reagan and Tip O'Neill the Ronald Reagan Republican president, tip O'Neill, democratic Speaker of the House at the time you know they would negotiate and fight hard all day and at night at six o'clock they'd share a scotch Like that's how legislation, that's how it's supposed to get done.
00:41:51.385 --> 00:41:53.489
It's the art of negotiation.
00:41:53.489 --> 00:42:04.590
And if you're you know, in this instance
you know it's closely held Senate, closely held House, then a lot of things are going to look a lot more purple, frankly, in the actual legislation and execution.
00:42:04.590 --> 00:42:12.528
And if you got to tip the scales one way or the other, as a Democratic president, tips of scales that way, but Biden's legislation was a lot more conservative.
00:42:12.528 --> 00:42:19.809
That's what I think the success of the administration when hit, you know, take away all of the pundits who were putting their you know their spin on it.
00:42:21.416 --> 00:42:49.815
Historically, they're going to look at this four years of Biden's first term and say, huh, they got, you know, six major, major, major pieces of legislation, all of which had direct effects on the economy in terms of jobs, in terms of GDP growth, in terms of the stock market, in terms of even their fiscal policy, in terms of scaling back, bringing inflation back down to closer to healthier levels, or oil production.
00:42:49.815 --> 00:42:51.018
He has more.
00:42:51.018 --> 00:42:57.331
He has a record level of domestic oil production, more so than any other president in history.
00:42:57.331 --> 00:42:58.815
A lot of folks aren't paying attention to that.
00:42:58.815 --> 00:43:01.838
Why isn't gas in California six and seven bucks?
00:43:01.838 --> 00:43:04.701
Anyway, what I'm saying is it's not.
00:43:04.701 --> 00:43:16.632
I disagree with a lot of his positions, but I really agree with Biden's process of bringing in the leaders from the other party in order to craft legislation that ultimately gets passed.
00:43:16.632 --> 00:43:20.244
I think that's a successful administration and a successful country.
00:43:22.014 --> 00:43:30.755
Yeah, I mean I agree that there were pieces of legislation that were, you know, beneficial to the country for sure, and aspects of them that were bipartisan.
00:43:30.755 --> 00:43:38.409
You brought the one with providing more resources to mental health within the states, which I thought was obviously like a net positive right.
00:43:38.409 --> 00:43:48.246
But I mean, to that same token, I think this is why Biden is struggling to a large extent, which is like the material difference that you're making in people's lives.
00:43:48.246 --> 00:44:06.610
Like, if you pass that and I mainly make this point and invite your rebuttal just because I think you know I like these conversations but I think, like you know, all these pieces of legislation like they're good, they're good like talking point, not to say that's how you're deploying it, but they're talking point, looks good, sounds good.
00:44:06.610 --> 00:44:20.601
But then you look at, like the material differences that you're making in people's lives and you look at Biden's like, say, promise and the supplies are like all presidents and a lot of politicians, but you look at Biden's promise to like forgive, like student loan, debt, and he has some of it, but you know, still like fell short of the mark.
00:44:20.601 --> 00:44:30.193
You look at like we're involved in two wars, we're giving millions or billions of billions of dollars to foreign countries.
00:44:30.293 --> 00:44:36.123
Yet a lot like affordable, unaffordable housing is becoming ever more an issue for the everyday American.
00:44:36.123 --> 00:44:39.827
More Americans are let me paycheck to paycheck People are not feeling like good.
00:44:39.827 --> 00:44:49.463
I think that's what matters a little bit more than like the unity and I agree, like in an ideal world, I like that.
00:44:49.463 --> 00:44:56.815
But I think what, in terms of like the voters point of mind and how I think of it, is like what material difference have you made for me in the past four years?
00:44:56.815 --> 00:45:00.960
Because I'm not feeling it and I'm kind of feeling like that, like I'm not.
00:45:00.960 --> 00:45:07.208
I'm not like feeling the, the pros and the heralds of the legislation that was passed.
00:45:07.208 --> 00:45:17.300
I'm actually feeling a little bit worse, given, you know inflation is coming down, as you said correctly, so, but look at 2019, like still like up by like 20% of like the jump.
00:45:17.981 --> 00:45:25.550
And then you look at like unaffordable housing, then you look at like billions of dollars going to foreign countries and whether it's good or not doesn't really matter.
00:45:25.550 --> 00:45:26.690
It's just material difference.
00:45:26.690 --> 00:45:31.581
It's the optics of that and the material difference or lack of that you're making in voters lives.
00:45:31.581 --> 00:45:40.791
So and I say that because I think like unity is great when it's great for the people as well, but I don't think they always play together.
00:45:40.791 --> 00:45:51.989
I don't think Democrats and Republicans working together is always an indicator that they are working for the American people, and I do want to call that out and I invite a rebuttal.
00:45:51.989 --> 00:45:52.530
Nonetheless.
00:45:53.034 --> 00:45:54.137
No, no, no, I'm not going to rebut you.
00:45:54.137 --> 00:46:11.597
I think it's a good reminder for me as well as listeners, is that I can sit here and give you a nuanced argument about why supporting Ukraine the way we are is is the most efficient way of advancing democracy and protecting democracy both overseas and domestically.
00:46:11.597 --> 00:46:13.038
But that's a nuanced argument.
00:46:13.038 --> 00:46:16.601
At the end of the day, All it doesn't matter.
00:46:16.601 --> 00:46:22.686
A friend of mine said Corey, I know you're talking about inflation is coming down, but at the end of the day, I can't take.
00:46:22.686 --> 00:46:25.527
I can't even take my family out to McDonald's for less than 60 bucks.
00:46:25.527 --> 00:46:26.309
That's what.
00:46:26.329 --> 00:46:33.795
I feel you know my son who drives a big truck like he, he all gas prices are still high to him.
00:46:33.795 --> 00:46:44.690
So all of my you know advanced arguments about Cornyn's bill
and the Chips Act and the IRA, like he's like that I can't fill up my tank for less than 100 bucks.
00:46:44.690 --> 00:46:46.094
That's what matters to me.
00:46:46.094 --> 00:46:49.139
So I hear you like you gotta meet people where they're at.
00:46:49.139 --> 00:46:53.032
You know me meet people where their, their, their needs are at.
00:46:53.032 --> 00:46:56.639
And if you haven't done that, it's not just a messaging problem.
00:46:56.639 --> 00:47:04.056
It's like you would understand that you're wrong if you only understood how intelligent my argument was.
00:47:04.056 --> 00:47:06.226
That's not a really good argument, you know.
00:47:06.326 --> 00:47:10.333
I think yeah yeah to your point is like yeah you gotta.
00:47:10.355 --> 00:47:12.985
You gotta meet people where they're at, man and you know.
00:47:12.985 --> 00:47:17.454
But that's, that's the job of a good leader is like, yeah, I did all these things, but that doesn't matter.
00:47:17.454 --> 00:47:18.996
I heard it, this pastor who's?
00:47:18.996 --> 00:47:35.798
He was theologizing, he's gonna be a great talk and comparing a Hebrew Bible verse from from Psalms, to the concept of the body of Christ, and it was really like he was getting into eschatology, so teriology, all these allergies, and he goes.
00:47:35.798 --> 00:47:44.635
But at the end of the day, we could all do all this theologize we want, but at the end of the day it's still about, you know, my, my, my buddy's grandma's in the hospital.
00:47:44.635 --> 00:47:47.626
I go hang out with my buddy in a hospital with them, you know.
00:47:47.626 --> 00:47:51.128
So it's just every day met, need you know?
00:47:51.128 --> 00:47:53.914
And if we're not doing that, yeah, we're missing the mark.
00:47:54.175 --> 00:47:56.327
So no, that's.
00:47:56.327 --> 00:48:10.380
I think that's a great example that you put in there and great anecdote to share, because you know it's some someone I'm not the most Bible know what's the where I'm looking for fluent, and you know I went to Catholic grade school in high school so I should know a little more than I probably do.
00:48:10.380 --> 00:48:26.681
But I mean, I know, I know for at least that Jesus in the New Testament obviously, but like took issue with the Pharisees because they weren't, for they weren't actually know being virtuous people but talking as virtuous people.
00:48:26.681 --> 00:48:30.248
And there you know, sorry, I don't.
00:48:30.289 --> 00:48:32.775
I don't mean to cut you off, but there's something interesting.
00:48:32.775 --> 00:48:36.869
So first of all, I that's a whole different conversation.
00:48:36.869 --> 00:48:39.652
Jesus interaction with the Pharisees was a family conversation.
00:48:39.652 --> 00:48:42.757
A lot of people see that as as an adversarial.
00:48:42.757 --> 00:48:45.880
It kind of is kind of, especially if you look at Matthew.
00:48:45.920 --> 00:48:51.813
Twenty three You've got a vibe, or I was pretty heated language, but that's just like Tuesday at Chabad for me.
00:48:51.813 --> 00:48:57.501
You know it's like you know, if you're not not yelling that, you just not having a really good conversation.
00:48:57.501 --> 00:49:14.878
But what I was gonna say is, if you notice, if you do get a chance to read through the Gospels, in one of the first introductions of the apostles, of his immediate, his first disciples, he talks about John, who is a son of that one, and Peter, who is his brother at that one, and it's all family connections.
00:49:14.878 --> 00:49:20.288
And he gets to Simon the zealot and Matthew the tax collector.
00:49:20.288 --> 00:49:29.177
Those are the only two that are referred to by not by family affiliation, but by political or professional affiliation.
00:49:29.177 --> 00:49:30.900
Now, why was that significant?
00:49:31.219 --> 00:49:37.753
In the first century Israel, the tax collectors were working on behalf of the Romans right, they were.
00:49:37.753 --> 00:49:44.588
They were basically, you know, part of the part of the swamp, if you will, and they were hated by some people.
00:49:44.588 --> 00:49:49.353
And the zealots were were initially formed for theological purposes.
00:49:49.353 --> 00:49:54.900
You know, study Torah, study the law, study how they should be in the world, based on what the Torah was saying, that kind of thing.
00:49:54.900 --> 00:50:03.507
But they became zealots that we, as we would think of it, like passionate extremists, if you will, in response to the tax collectors.
00:50:03.507 --> 00:50:12.998
They became a politically engaged group and you couldn't have more polarized groups than tax collectors and zealots.
00:50:12.998 --> 00:50:14.559
And yet who was at the table?
00:50:14.559 --> 00:50:15.721
Who did they mention?
00:50:15.721 --> 00:50:21.092
They said Simon the zealot, not the tax collector, because Jesus had them both in the discipleship.
00:50:21.092 --> 00:50:23.536
He had them both at the table.
00:50:23.996 --> 00:50:26.260
You know, that's the other one of the thing I'll that.
00:50:26.260 --> 00:50:27.503
That I'll just leave you with.
00:50:27.503 --> 00:50:28.945
I get this from the after party.
00:50:28.945 --> 00:50:40.179
You know people I know and respect started this thing to help people learn how to talk to each other, better called the after party, started by Curtis, curtis Chang, david French and Russell Moore.
00:50:40.179 --> 00:50:47.827
And the other thing to notice about those stories is a lot of times Jesus like let's see, let's get around the table.
00:50:48.268 --> 00:50:51.833
You know, somebody comes to him after he's he's raised from the dead.
00:50:51.833 --> 00:50:52.795
They don't recognize him.
00:50:52.795 --> 00:50:53.536
They're all troubled.
00:50:53.536 --> 00:50:54.358
He's like how you look?
00:50:54.358 --> 00:50:57.686
The first thing he says you look troubled, what's up, don't you know?
00:50:57.686 --> 00:50:59.590
Like this thing that happens, jesus, messiah.
00:50:59.590
--> 00:51:01.514
He's like, yeah, that's terrible.
00:51:01.514 --> 00:51:02.396
Got anything to eat?
00:51:02.396 --> 00:51:05.347
You know, it's all all this stuff.
00:51:05.347 --> 00:51:10.311
So that tells me like, hey, let's go get a beer, let's go get a coffee, let's break bread together.
00:51:10.311 --> 00:51:16.737
You know, you might be a tax collector, I might be a zealot or vice versa, but let's sit around a table, let's figure it out.
00:51:16.737 --> 00:51:18.300
You know, I think we can figure it out.
00:51:18.300 --> 00:51:20.601
We have shared values, shared goals.
00:51:20.601 --> 00:51:34.079
You know we might disagree about how to get there, about legislation or that politician of the jersey we're wearing, but I think if we really see each other as human beings, more so than the tax collector of the republican or the Yankee fan or the whatever, then I think we could figure it out.
00:51:35.565 --> 00:51:37.427
Sure, first one, thank you for sharing that.
00:51:37.427 --> 00:51:38.548
That's, that was great.
00:51:38.548 --> 00:51:39.670
No, that's a looming.
00:51:39.670 --> 00:51:42.213
I love histories and that's kind of like historical as well.
00:51:42.213 --> 00:51:45.318
So, please, yeah, my interest quite a bit.
00:51:45.318 --> 00:51:54.353
But, yeah, thank you, and I couldn't agree more like Gang, to know someone outside of the context where you may disagree with them in is is key.
00:51:54.353 --> 00:52:10.978
Yeah, for sure, but I do want to offer you opportunity, like what, like starting to close out here, how do you View, like, what you're doing, like moving for the what's, what's up next for you, and where can people really keep in touch with you at?
00:52:11.846 --> 00:52:13.527
Thanks for letting me share that.
00:52:13.527 --> 00:52:21.838
So first, easiest way to find me, you can look up talking politics and religion without killing each other on any of your podcast apps.
00:52:21.838 --> 00:52:22.940
Were on all the apps.
00:52:22.940 --> 00:52:26.768
But just remember the talking is what about a, g, t, a, l, k a?
00:52:26.768 --> 00:52:30.614
N politics with the apostrophe there if you want.
00:52:30.614 --> 00:52:34.398
But if you put that in there or talking politics and religion usually comes up.
00:52:34.398 --> 00:52:36.340
We got this purple logo.
00:52:36.340 --> 00:52:39.289
You recognize the talk politics and religion that killing each other.
00:52:39.289 --> 00:52:47.811
You could go to our site politics and religion dot us Politics and the end of spelled out politics and religion dot us.
00:52:47.811 --> 00:52:55.333
Where you can find me, c o r e y s is in sam n a t h a n, at courier snath and on all the socials.
00:52:56.806 --> 00:53:00.128
What I hope to do is just do this thing better.
00:53:00.128 --> 00:53:02.192
You know like we're all.
00:53:02.192 --> 00:53:05.875
We're all trying to like throw the perfect bomb at each other.
00:53:05.875 --> 00:53:10.659
You know perfect like come back at each other, throw it like, just engage in the way.
00:53:10.659 --> 00:53:12.061
That's all contentiousness.
00:53:12.061 --> 00:53:20.394
I'm not to say that there's not a time to really meet like debate out points.
00:53:20.394 --> 00:53:39.927
Yeah, there's time for debate and even contentiousness at times, but like I think that should be the exception to the rule, if we're focusing on each other's humanity, each other shared values, you know then and then having better conversations as a result of that.
00:53:39.927 --> 00:53:42.431
So I'm bringing people on the show.
00:53:42.431 --> 00:53:45.697
You know some high profile people I'm really happy about.
00:53:45.697 --> 00:53:54.297
Some are just regular guys like me, and we're gonna continue doing this thing and I'm gonna continue getting involved in other organizations like braver angels and village square.
00:53:54.297 --> 00:53:57.449
I'm trying to do this work to like repair.
00:53:57.449 --> 00:54:00.436
What else is this culture, man?
00:54:00.436 --> 00:54:01.538
That's what I'm trying to do.
00:54:03.447 --> 00:54:04.590
Corey, it's been a pleasure.
00:54:04.590 --> 00:54:09.619
Thank you so much, and everyone who's listening, go check out those channels and keep up with Corey's great work.
00:54:10.224 --> 00:54:10.768
Thanks so much.
00:54:10.768 --> 00:54:11.510
This is great.
00:54:13.126 --> 00:54:14.528
Take care, everyone talk soon.