РАСШИФРОВКА 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:05.320 --> 00:00:10.119
Section one of a discourse on inequality by Jean Jacques Rousseau.
2
00:00:13.519 --> 00:00:17.760
This is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox recordings are in
3
00:00:17.800 --> 00:00:22.359
the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please
4
00:00:22.440 --> 00:00:26.359
visit LibriVox dot org. This is a reading by Eric
5
00:00:26.440 --> 00:00:30.559
Jonas A discourse upon the origin and the foundation of
6
00:00:30.600 --> 00:00:39.079
the inequality among Mankind by Jean Jacques Rousseau. Introductory note.
7
00:00:39.920 --> 00:00:43.520
Jean Jacques Rousseau was born at Geneva June twenty eighth,
8
00:00:43.600 --> 00:00:47.359
seventeen twelve, the son of a watchmaker of French origin.
9
00:00:48.240 --> 00:00:52.079
His education was irregular, and though he tried many professions,
10
00:00:52.119 --> 00:00:56.320
including engraving, music and teaching, he found it difficult to
11
00:00:56.320 --> 00:00:59.640
support himself in any of them. The discovery of his
12
00:00:59.719 --> 00:01:01.920
talent as a writer came with the winning of a
13
00:01:01.960 --> 00:01:05.359
prize offered by the Academy of Dijon for a discourse
14
00:01:05.400 --> 00:01:08.840
on the question whether the progress of the sciences and
15
00:01:08.920 --> 00:01:13.319
of letters has tended to corrupt or to elevate morals.
16
00:01:13.439 --> 00:01:17.280
He argued so brilliantly that the tendency of civilization was
17
00:01:17.319 --> 00:01:21.879
degrading that he became at once famous. The discourse here
18
00:01:22.000 --> 00:01:25.439
printed on the causes of inequality among Men was written
19
00:01:25.480 --> 00:01:31.400
in a similar competition. He now concentrated his powers upon literature,
20
00:01:31.519 --> 00:01:35.879
producing two novels, The New Heloise, the forerunner and parent
21
00:01:35.920 --> 00:01:40.879
of endless sentimental and picturesque fictions, and A Meal Or
22
00:01:40.959 --> 00:01:44.519
on Education, a work which has had enormous influence on
23
00:01:44.560 --> 00:01:47.719
the theory and practice of pedagogy down to our own time,
24
00:01:48.120 --> 00:01:51.239
and in which the Savoyard Vicar appears, who is used
25
00:01:51.239 --> 00:01:56.200
as the mouthpiece for Rousseau's own religious ideas. The Social
26
00:01:56.239 --> 00:02:00.959
Contract seventeen sixty two elaborated the doctrine of the discourse
27
00:02:01.040 --> 00:02:06.120
on inequality, both historically and philosophically. It is unsound, but
28
00:02:06.200 --> 00:02:10.639
it was the chief literary source of the enthusiasm for liberty, fraternity,
29
00:02:10.680 --> 00:02:13.800
and equality which inspired the leaders of the French Revolution,
30
00:02:14.360 --> 00:02:19.560
and its effects passed far beyond France. His most famous work,
31
00:02:19.840 --> 00:02:23.919
The Confessions, was published after his death. This book is
32
00:02:23.960 --> 00:02:26.560
a mine of information as to his life, but it
33
00:02:26.599 --> 00:02:29.680
is far from trustworthy, and the picture it gives of
34
00:02:29.719 --> 00:02:33.240
the author's personality and conduct, though painted in such a
35
00:02:33.280 --> 00:02:37.039
way as to make it absorbingly interesting, is often unpleasing
36
00:02:37.080 --> 00:02:39.960
in the highest degree. But it is one of the
37
00:02:40.000 --> 00:02:45.319
great autobiographies of the world. During Rousseau's later years, he
38
00:02:45.439 --> 00:02:48.719
was the victim of the delusion of persecution, and although
39
00:02:48.719 --> 00:02:51.879
he was protected by a succession of good friends, he
40
00:02:51.960 --> 00:02:55.599
came to distrust and quarrel with each in turn. He
41
00:02:55.680 --> 00:03:00.120
died at Ermenonville, near Paris, July second, seventeen seventy eight.
42
00:03:00.520 --> 00:03:05.080
The most widely influential French writer of his age. The
43
00:03:05.120 --> 00:03:08.919
Savoyard Vicar and his profession of faith are introduced into
44
00:03:08.919 --> 00:03:12.080
a meal, not according to the author, because he wishes
45
00:03:12.159 --> 00:03:15.120
to exhibit his principles as those which should be taught,
46
00:03:15.520 --> 00:03:17.439
but to give an example of the way in which
47
00:03:17.520 --> 00:03:21.960
religious matters should be discussed with the young. Nevertheless, it
48
00:03:22.000 --> 00:03:26.400
is universally recognized that these opinions are Rousseau's own, and represent,
49
00:03:26.520 --> 00:03:31.280
in short form, his characteristic attitude towards religious belief. The
50
00:03:31.360 --> 00:03:34.240
Vicar himself is believed to combine the traits of two
51
00:03:34.319 --> 00:03:38.240
Savoyard priests whom Rousseau knew in his youth. The more
52
00:03:38.280 --> 00:03:42.120
important was the abbey game, whom he had known at Turin,
53
00:03:42.879 --> 00:03:46.879
the other the abbey Gatier, who had taught him at Annecy.
54
00:03:49.719 --> 00:03:56.039
End of introductory note. Question proposed by the Academy of Dijon,
55
00:03:57.400 --> 00:04:00.840
what is the origin of the inequality among mankind? And
56
00:04:00.919 --> 00:04:04.120
whether such inequality is authorized by the law of nature?
57
00:04:06.960 --> 00:04:09.840
A discourse upon the origin and the foundation of the
58
00:04:09.879 --> 00:04:15.439
inequality among mankind tis of man I am to speak.
59
00:04:15.639 --> 00:04:17.879
And the very question and answer to which I am
60
00:04:17.920 --> 00:04:20.800
to speak of him sufficiently informs me that I am
61
00:04:20.839 --> 00:04:24.120
going to speak to men, For to those alone who
62
00:04:24.160 --> 00:04:27.439
are not afraid of honoring truth, it belongs to propose
63
00:04:27.560 --> 00:04:31.920
discussions of this kind. I shall therefore maintain with confidence
64
00:04:31.959 --> 00:04:34.959
the cause of mankind before the sages who invite me
65
00:04:35.000 --> 00:04:37.600
to stand up in its
Load full transcript
defense. And I shall think
66
00:04:37.639 --> 00:04:40.160
myself happy if I can but behave in a manner
67
00:04:40.240 --> 00:04:44.800
not unworthy of my subject and of my judges. I
68
00:04:44.839 --> 00:04:48.439
conceive two species of inequality among men, one which I
69
00:04:48.480 --> 00:04:52.079
call natural or physical inequality, because it is established by
70
00:04:52.160 --> 00:04:56.639
nature and consists in the differences of age, health, bodily strength,
71
00:04:56.680 --> 00:04:59.079
and the qualities of the mind or of the soul.
72
00:05:00.079 --> 00:05:03.839
The other, which may be termed moral or political inequality,
73
00:05:04.120 --> 00:05:07.079
because it depends on a kind of convention and is
74
00:05:07.240 --> 00:05:11.199
established or at least authorized by the common consent of mankind.
75
00:05:12.279 --> 00:05:15.680
This species of inequality consists in the different privileges which
76
00:05:15.720 --> 00:05:18.639
some men enjoy to the prejudice of others, such as
77
00:05:18.680 --> 00:05:21.920
that of being richer, more honored, more powerful, and even
78
00:05:21.959 --> 00:05:26.480
that of exacting obedience from them. It were absurd to
79
00:05:26.519 --> 00:05:29.639
ask what is the cause of natural inequality? Seeing the
80
00:05:29.680 --> 00:05:33.839
bare definition of natural inequality answers the question. It would
81
00:05:33.879 --> 00:05:36.560
be more absurd still to inquire if there might not
82
00:05:36.600 --> 00:05:40.000
be some essential connection between the two species of inequality,
83
00:05:40.360 --> 00:05:42.519
as it would be asking, in other words, if those
84
00:05:42.560 --> 00:05:45.720
who command are necessarily better men than those who obey,
85
00:05:46.240 --> 00:05:49.279
and of strength of body or mind, wisdom or virtue
86
00:05:49.319 --> 00:05:51.839
are always to be found in individuals in the same
87
00:05:51.879 --> 00:05:55.720
proportion with power or riches, a question fit perhaps to
88
00:05:55.759 --> 00:05:58.480
be discussed by slaves in the hearing of their masters,
89
00:05:58.800 --> 00:06:02.199
but unbecoming free and reasonable beings in quest of truth.
90
00:06:03.600 --> 00:06:07.399
What therefore is precisely the subject of this discourse. It
91
00:06:07.480 --> 00:06:10.240
is to point out, in the progress of things, that moment,
92
00:06:10.360 --> 00:06:14.480
when right, taking place of violence, nature became subject to
93
00:06:14.600 --> 00:06:18.600
law to display that chain of surprising events, in consequence
94
00:06:18.600 --> 00:06:21.279
of which the strong submitted to serve the weak, and
95
00:06:21.360 --> 00:06:24.360
the people to purchase imaginary ease at the expense of
96
00:06:24.480 --> 00:06:29.439
real happiness. The philosophers who have examined the foundations of
97
00:06:29.480 --> 00:06:32.920
society have every one of them perceived the necessity of
98
00:06:33.000 --> 00:06:35.839
tracing it back to a state of nature. But not
99
00:06:35.879 --> 00:06:38.759
one of them has ever arrived there. Some of them
100
00:06:38.759 --> 00:06:41.439
have not scrupled to attribute to man in that state
101
00:06:41.519 --> 00:06:45.199
the ideas of justice and injustice, without troubling their heads
102
00:06:45.240 --> 00:06:47.879
to prove that he really must have had such ideas,
103
00:06:48.120 --> 00:06:51.360
or even that such ideas were useful to him. Others
104
00:06:51.399 --> 00:06:53.759
have spoken of the natural right of every man to
105
00:06:53.839 --> 00:06:56.720
keep what belongs to him, without letting us know what
106
00:06:56.759 --> 00:07:01.279
they meant by the word belong. Others, without further ceremony,
107
00:07:01.319 --> 00:07:04.639
ascribing to the strongest an authority over the weakest, have
108
00:07:04.759 --> 00:07:08.319
immediately struck out government, without thinking of the time requisite
109
00:07:08.319 --> 00:07:10.959
for men to form any notion of the things signified
110
00:07:10.959 --> 00:07:14.519
by the words authority in government. All of them, in fine,
111
00:07:14.720 --> 00:07:19.120
constantly harping on wants, avidity, oppression, and desires and pride,
112
00:07:19.399 --> 00:07:22.120
have transferred to the state of nature ideas picked up
113
00:07:22.160 --> 00:07:25.879
in the bosom of society. In speaking of savages they
114
00:07:25.879 --> 00:07:29.839
have described citizens. Nay, few of our own writers seem
115
00:07:29.920 --> 00:07:31.800
to have so much as doubted that a state of
116
00:07:31.879 --> 00:07:36.519
nature did once actually exist, though plainly appears by sacred history,
117
00:07:36.800 --> 00:07:39.600
that even the first man, immediately furnished as he was
118
00:07:39.680 --> 00:07:44.000
by God himself, with both instructions and precepts, never lived
119
00:07:44.000 --> 00:07:46.120
in that state, And that, if we give to the
120
00:07:46.160 --> 00:07:49.879
books of Moses that credit which every Christian philosopher ought
121
00:07:49.920 --> 00:07:52.839
to give to them, we must deny that even before
122
00:07:52.920 --> 00:07:57.079
the deluge, such a state ever existed among men, unless
123
00:07:57.079 --> 00:08:00.920
they fell into it by some extraordinary event, paradox very
124
00:08:00.959 --> 00:08:06.000
difficult to maintain and altogether impossible to prove. Let us
125
00:08:06.040 --> 00:08:08.879
begin therefore by laying aside facts, for they do not
126
00:08:08.959 --> 00:08:12.519
affect the question. The researches in which we may engage
127
00:08:12.560 --> 00:08:15.600
on this occasion are not to be taken for historical truths,
128
00:08:15.839 --> 00:08:19.920
but merely as hypothetical and conditional reasonings, fitter to illustrate
129
00:08:19.920 --> 00:08:22.399
the nature of things than to show their true origin,
130
00:08:23.600 --> 00:08:26.199
like those systems which our naturalists daily make of the
131
00:08:26.240 -->
00:08:29.720
formation of the world. Religion commands us to believe that men,
132
00:08:29.839 --> 00:08:32.360
having been drawn by God himself out of a state
133
00:08:32.399 --> 00:08:35.320
of nature, are unequal, because it is his pleasure they
134
00:08:35.360 --> 00:08:38.120
should be so. But religion does not forbid us to
135
00:08:38.200 --> 00:08:42.039
draw conjectures solely from the nature of man considered in itself,
136
00:08:42.440 --> 00:08:45.120
and from that of the beings which surround him, concerning
137
00:08:45.159 --> 00:08:47.799
the fate of mankind had they been left to themselves.
138
00:08:48.840 --> 00:08:51.080
This is then the question I am to answer, the
139
00:08:51.159 --> 00:08:54.720
question I propose to examine in the present discourse. As
140
00:08:54.759 --> 00:08:57.799
mankind in general have an interest in my subject, I
141
00:08:57.840 --> 00:09:01.200
shall endeavor to use a language suitable to all nations,
142
00:09:01.279 --> 00:09:04.519
or rather forgetting the circumstances of time and place, in
143
00:09:04.600 --> 00:09:06.600
order to think of nothing but the men I speak to.
144
00:09:07.039 --> 00:09:10.480
I shall suppose myself in the Lyceum of Athens, repeating
145
00:09:10.519 --> 00:09:13.120
the lessons of my master's, before the Plato's and the
146
00:09:13.240 --> 00:09:16.799
Xenocrates of that famous seat of philosophy, as my judges,
147
00:09:17.120 --> 00:09:20.360
and in presence of the whole human species as my audience.
148
00:09:21.320 --> 00:09:24.039
Oh man, whatever country you may belong to, whatever your
149
00:09:24.080 --> 00:09:26.960
opinions may be, attend to my words. You shall hear
150
00:09:27.000 --> 00:09:28.799
your history such as I think I have read it,
151
00:09:29.159 --> 00:09:31.519
Not in books composed by those like you, for they
152
00:09:31.519 --> 00:09:34.519
are liars, but in the Book of Nature, which never lies.
153
00:09:35.279 --> 00:09:37.440
All that I shall repeat after her must be true
154
00:09:37.440 --> 00:09:40.360
without any intermixture of falsehood. But where I may happen
155
00:09:40.440 --> 00:09:44.000
without intending it to introduce my own conceits. The times
156
00:09:44.039 --> 00:09:46.320
I am going to speak of are very remote, how
157
00:09:46.399 --> 00:09:49.440
much you are changed from what you once were. 'tis,
158
00:09:49.480 --> 00:09:51.600
in a manner the life of your species that I
159
00:09:51.600 --> 00:09:54.559
am going to write from the qualities which you have received,
160
00:09:54.919 --> 00:09:57.759
and which your education and your habits could deprave but
161
00:09:57.840 --> 00:10:01.360
could not destroy. There is is, I am sensible, an
162
00:10:01.399 --> 00:10:04.799
age at which every individual of you would choose to stop.
163
00:10:05.399 --> 00:10:07.360
And you will look out for the age at which,
164
00:10:07.440 --> 00:10:11.360
had you your wish your species had stopped. Uneasy at
165
00:10:11.360 --> 00:10:15.039
your present condition, for reasons which threaten your unhappy posterity
166
00:10:15.080 --> 00:10:18.279
with still greater uneasiness, you will perhaps wish it were
167
00:10:18.279 --> 00:10:21.120
in your power to go back. And this sentiment ought
168
00:10:21.120 --> 00:10:24.080
to be considered as the penniesiac of your first parents,
169
00:10:24.440 --> 00:10:27.919
the condemnation of your contemporaries, and a source of terror
170
00:10:27.960 --> 00:10:31.039
to all those who may have the misfortune of succeeding you.
171
00:10:34.480 --> 00:10:48.279
End opening section of the Discourse on Inequality. Section two
172
00:10:48.559 --> 00:10:56.440
of the Discourse on Inequality by Jean Jacques Rousseau. This
173
00:10:56.480 --> 00:11:01.559
is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox records in the public domain.
174
00:11:02.679 --> 00:11:07.240
For more information or to volunteer, please visit LibriVox dot org.
175
00:11:08.159 --> 00:11:12.000
This is a reading by Eric Jonas a discourse upon
176
00:11:12.039 --> 00:11:15.799
the origin and the foundation of the inequality among mankind
177
00:11:16.000 --> 00:11:26.440
by Jean Jacques Rousseau. Discourse, first Part, Section one Discourse
178
00:11:26.559 --> 00:11:30.679
first Part. However important it may be in order to
179
00:11:30.720 --> 00:11:33.360
form a proper judgment of the natural state of man,
180
00:11:33.679 --> 00:11:36.399
to consider him from his origin, and to examine him,
181
00:11:36.440 --> 00:11:39.279
as it were in the first embryo of the species,
182
00:11:39.919 --> 00:11:42.879
I shall not attempt to trace his organization through its
183
00:11:42.919 --> 00:11:47.039
successive approaches to perfection. I shall not stop to examine,
184
00:11:47.080 --> 00:11:49.000
in the animal system what he might have been in
185
00:11:49.039 --> 00:11:52.159
the beginning, to become at last what he actually is.
186
00:11:52.840 --> 00:11:56.279
I shall not inquire whether, as Aristotle thinks, his neglected
187
00:11:56.360 --> 00:12:00.080
nails were no better at first than crooked talons, His
188
00:12:00.120 --> 00:12:03.759
whole body was not bear like, thick, covered with rough hair,
189
00:12:04.240 --> 00:12:07.559
and weather walking upon all fours. His eyes directed to
190
00:12:07.639 --> 00:12:10.080
the earth and confined to a horizon of a few
191
00:12:10.120 --> 00:12:13.279
paces extend, did not at once point out the nature
192
00:12:13.279 --> 00:12:17.080
and limit of his ideas. I could only form vague
193
00:12:17.120 --> 00:12:21.840
and almost imaginary conjectures on this subject. Comparative anatomy has
194
00:12:21.919 --> 00:12:25.879
not as yet been sufficiently improved. Neither have the observations
195
00:12:25.879 --> 00:12:29.679
of natural philosophy been sufficiently ascertained to establish upon such
196
00:12:29.759 --> 00:12:33.720
foundations the basis of a solid system. For this reason,
197
00:12:33.879 --> 00:12:37.480
without having recourse to the supernatural informations with which we
198
00:12:37.559 --> 00:12:40.799
have been favored on this head, or paying any attention
199
00:12:40.919 --> 00:12:43.600
to the changes that must have happened in the confirmation
200
00:12:43.759 --> 00:12:47.399
of the interior and exterior parts of man's body, in
201
00:12:47.440 --> 00:12:50.279
proportion as he applied his members to new purposes and
202
00:12:50.320 --> 00:12:54.840
took new ailments, I shall suppose his confirmation to always
203
00:12:54.919 --> 00:12:58.279
have been what we now behold. It that he always
204
00:12:58.320 --> 00:13:00.840
walked on two feet, made the same use of his
205
00:13:00.960 --> 00:13:04.039
hands that we do of ours, extended his looks over
206
00:13:04.080 --> 00:13:06.960
the whole face of nature, and measured with his eyes
207
00:13:07.039 --> 00:13:10.679
the vast extent of the heavens. If I strip this
208
00:13:10.799 --> 00:13:14.840
being thus constituted of all the supernatural gifts which he
209
00:13:14.919 --> 00:13:18.480
may have received, and of all the artificial faculties which
210
00:13:18.480 --> 00:13:21.480
we could not have acquired, but by slow degrees, if
211
00:13:21.480 --> 00:13:23.840
I consider him in a word such as he must
212
00:13:23.879 --> 00:13:26.879
have issued from the hands of nature, I see an
213
00:13:26.919 --> 00:13:29.879
animal less strong than some, and less active than others,
214
00:13:30.240 --> 00:13:34.320
but upon the whole the most advantageously organized of any
215
00:13:34.960 --> 00:13:37.480
I see him satisfying the cause of hunger under the
216
00:13:37.519 --> 00:13:40.720
first oak, and those of thirst at the first rivulet.
217
00:13:41.440 --> 00:13:43.639
I see him laying himself down to sleep at the
218
00:13:43.639 --> 00:13:45.960
foot of the same tree that afforded him his meal.
219
00:13:46.399 --> 00:13:50.279
And behold this done, All of his wants are completely supplied.
220
00:13:51.919 --> 00:13:55.120
The earth left to its own natural fertility, and covered
221
00:13:55.120 --> 00:13:58.879
with immense woods that no hatchet, ever disfigured, offers at
222
00:13:58.879 --> 00:14:02.399
every step food and shelter to every species of animals.
223
00:14:02.960 --> 00:14:07.240
Men dispersed among them observe and imitate their industry, and
224
00:14:07.279 --> 00:14:11.039
thus rise to the instinct of beasts. With this advantage that,
225
00:14:11.080 --> 00:14:15.120
whereas every species of beasts is confined to one peculiar instinct,
226
00:14:15.559 --> 00:14:19.200
man who perhaps has not any that particularly belonged to him,
227
00:14:19.720 --> 00:14:23.759
appropriates to himself those of all other animals, and lives
228
00:14:23.799 --> 00:14:27.200
equally upon most of the different ailments which they only
229
00:14:27.240 --> 00:14:31.200
divide among themselves, a circumstance which qualifies him to find
230
00:14:31.240 --> 00:14:35.600
his subsistence with more ease than any of them. Men
231
00:14:35.679 --> 00:14:38.720
accustomed from their infancy to the inclemency of the weather
232
00:14:39.159 --> 00:14:42.399
and to the rigor of the different seasons, inured to fatigue,
233
00:14:42.440 --> 00:14:45.720
and obliged to defend naked and without arms, their life
234
00:14:45.759 --> 00:14:48.879
and their prey against the other wild inhabitants of the forest,
235
00:14:49.360 --> 00:14:52.519
or at least to avoid their fury by flight, acquire
236
00:14:52.559 --> 00:14:56.639
a robust and almost unalterable habit of body, the children,
237
00:14:56.720 --> 00:14:59.759
bringing with them into the world the excellent constitution of
238
00:14:59.759 --> 00:15:03.519
their parents, and strengthening it by the same exercises that
239
00:15:03.600 --> 00:15:07.080
first produced it. Attained by this means all the vigor
240
00:15:07.120 --> 00:15:10.759
that the human frame is capable of. Nature treats them
241
00:15:10.799 --> 00:15:13.879
exactly in the same manner that Sparta treated the children
242
00:15:13.919 --> 00:15:17.519
of her citizens. Those who come well formed into the world.
243
00:15:17.600 --> 00:15:21.279
She renders strong and robust, and destroys all the rest,
244
00:15:21.600 --> 00:15:25.159
differing in this respect from our societies, in which the state,
245
00:15:25.240 --> 00:15:28.799
by permitting children to become burdensome to their parents, murders
246
00:15:28.840 --> 00:15:31.919
them all without distinction, even in the wombs of their mothers.
247
00:15:33.159 --> 00:15:35.840
The body being the only instrument that savage man is
248
00:15:35.840 --> 00:15:39.039
acquainted with, he employs it to such different uses of
249
00:15:39.080 --> 00:15:42.360
which ours, for want of practice, are incapable, And we
250
00:15:42.440 --> 00:15:44.879
may thank our industry for the loss of that strength
251
00:15:44.919 --> 00:15:48.960
and agility which necessity obliges him to acquire. Had he
252
00:15:49.039 --> 00:15:51.879
a hatchet, would his hands so easily snap from an
253
00:15:51.879 --> 00:15:54.960
oak so stout a branch. Had he a sling, would
254
00:15:54.960 --> 00:15:58.080
it dart a stone to so great a distance? Hattie
255
00:15:58.120 --> 00:16:00.720
a ladder? Would it run so nimbly up a tree?
256
00:16:01.080 --> 00:16:03.879
Had he a horse, would he with such swiftness shoot
257
00:16:03.879 --> 00:16:07.440
along the plane? Give civilized man but time to gather
258
00:16:07.559 --> 00:16:10.720
about him all his machines, and no doubt he will
259
00:16:10.720 --> 00:16:13.279
be an overmatch for the savage. But if you have
260
00:16:13.399 --> 00:16:16.519
a mind to see a contest still more unequal, place
261
00:16:16.600 --> 00:16:19.600
them naked and unarmed, one opposite to the other, and
262
00:16:19.639 --> 00:16:22.519
you will soon discover the advantage there is in perpetually
263
00:16:22.600
--> 00:16:26.240
having all our forces at our disposal, in being constantly
264
00:16:26.279 --> 00:16:30.080
prepared against all events, and in always carrying ourselves, as
265
00:16:30.120 --> 00:16:33.919
it were, whole and entire about us. Hobbes would have
266
00:16:34.039 --> 00:16:36.480
it that man is naturally void of fear, and always
267
00:16:36.519 --> 00:16:40.679
intent upon attacking and fighting. An illustrious philosopher thinks on
268
00:16:40.720 --> 00:16:44.440
the contrary, and Cumberland and Puffendorf likewise affirm it that
269
00:16:44.519 --> 00:16:47.240
nothing is more fearful than man in a state of nature,
270
00:16:47.720 --> 00:16:50.120
that he is always in a tremble and ready to
271
00:16:50.159 --> 00:16:53.000
fly at the first motion he perceives, at the first
272
00:16:53.159 --> 00:16:56.720
noise that strikes his ears. This indeed may be very
273
00:16:56.799 --> 00:16:59.960
true in regard to objects with which he is not acquainted,
274
00:17:00.360 --> 00:17:02.879
And I make no doubt of his being terrified at
275
00:17:02.919 --> 00:17:06.319
every new sight that presents itself, as often he cannot
276
00:17:06.319 --> 00:17:09.559
distinguish the physical good and evil which he may expect
277
00:17:09.559 --> 00:17:12.559
from it, nor compare his forces with the dangers he
278
00:17:12.599 --> 00:17:16.440
has to encounter circumstances that seldom occur in a state
279
00:17:16.480 --> 00:17:19.759
of nature, where all things proceed in so uniform a manner,
280
00:17:20.240 --> 00:17:22.279
and the face of the earth is not liable to
281
00:17:22.359 --> 00:17:25.680
those sudden and continual changes occasioned in it by the
282
00:17:25.720 --> 00:17:30.400
passions and inconstanties of collected bodies. But savage man, living
283
00:17:30.440 --> 00:17:35.079
among other animals, without any society or fixed habitation, confinding
284
00:17:35.160 --> 00:17:39.799
himself early under a necessity of measuring his strength with theirs,
285
00:17:39.839 --> 00:17:43.319
soon makes a comparison between both, and, finding that he
286
00:17:43.359 --> 00:17:47.119
surpasses them more in address than they surpass him in strength,
287
00:17:47.519 --> 00:17:50.200
he learns not to be any longer in dread of them.
288
00:17:50.839 --> 00:17:54.000
Turn out a bear or a wolf against a sturdy, active,
289
00:17:54.119 --> 00:17:58.079
resolute savage, as in this they all are provided with
290
00:17:58.240 --> 00:18:01.359
stones and a good stick, and you will soon find
291
00:18:01.400 --> 00:18:04.039
that the danger is at least equal on both sides,
292
00:18:04.400 --> 00:18:07.839
and that after several trials of this kind, wild beasts
293
00:18:07.839 --> 00:18:10.480
who are not fond of attacking each other, will not
294
00:18:10.559 --> 00:18:13.559
be very fond of attacking man, whom they have found
295
00:18:13.640 --> 00:18:17.480
every whit as wild as themselves. As to animals who
296
00:18:17.480 --> 00:18:20.839
have really more strength than man has address, he is
297
00:18:20.920 --> 00:18:24.359
in regard to them, what other weaker species are who
298
00:18:24.400 --> 00:18:28.720
find means to subsist. Notwithstanding, he has even this great
299
00:18:28.759 --> 00:18:32.880
advantage over such weaker species, that, being equally fleet with them,
300
00:18:32.920 --> 00:18:36.960
and finding on every tree an almost inviolable asylum, he
301
00:18:37.079 --> 00:18:39.559
is always at liberty to take it or leave it
302
00:18:40.119 --> 00:18:43.079
as he likes best, and of course to fight or
303
00:18:43.119 --> 00:18:46.640
to fly, whichever is most agreeable to him. To this,
304
00:18:46.720 --> 00:18:50.000
we may add that no animal naturally makes war upon man,
305
00:18:50.119 --> 00:18:53.079
except in the case of self defense or extreme hunger,
306
00:18:53.559 --> 00:18:57.519
nor even expresses against him any of those violent antipathies
307
00:18:57.680 --> 00:19:00.519
which seem to indicate that some particular speed she are
308
00:19:00.559 --> 00:19:04.039
intended by nature for the food of others. But there
309
00:19:04.079 --> 00:19:07.440
are other more formidable enemies, and against which man is
310
00:19:07.480 --> 00:19:10.799
not provided with the same means of defense. I mean
311
00:19:10.920 --> 00:19:16.440
natural infirmities, infancy, old age, and sickness of every kind, melancholy,
312
00:19:16.599 --> 00:19:20.319
proofs of our weakness, whereof the two first are common
313
00:19:20.359 --> 00:19:23.720
to all animals, and the last chiefly attends man living
314
00:19:23.759 --> 00:19:27.039
in a state of society. It is even observable in
315
00:19:27.079 --> 00:19:30.440
regard to infancy, that the mother, being able to carry
316
00:19:30.440 --> 00:19:33.559
her child about with her wherever she goes, can perform
317
00:19:33.640 --> 00:19:35.839
the duty of a nurse with a great deal less
318
00:19:35.880 --> 00:19:38.880
trouble than the females of many other animals, who are
319
00:19:38.880 --> 00:19:42.000
obliged to be constantly going and coming with no small
320
00:19:42.079 --> 00:19:45.119
labor and fatigue, one way to look out for their
321
00:19:45.160 --> 00:19:49.759
own subsistence, and another to suckle and feed their young ones. True,
322
00:19:49.799 --> 00:19:52.440
it is that if the woman happens to perish, her
323
00:19:52.519 --> 00:19:55.680
child is exposed to the greatest danger of perishing with her.
324
00:19:56.119 --> 00:19:58.839
But this danger is common to a hundred other species
325
00:19:58.880 --> 00:20:00.880
whose young ones require wh i are a great deal
326
00:20:00.880 --> 00:20:04.000
of time to be able to provide for themselves. And
327
00:20:04.079 --> 00:20:07.839
if our infancy is longer than theirs, our life is longer. Likewise,
328
00:20:08.400 --> 00:20:11.319
so that in this respect, too, all things are in
329
00:20:11.319 --> 00:20:14.799
a manner equal. Not
but that there are rather rules
330
00:20:14.839 --> 00:20:17.960
concerning the duration of the first age of life and
331
00:20:18.039 --> 00:20:21.240
the number of young of man and other animals. But
332
00:20:21.359 --> 00:20:24.680
they do not belong to my subject. With old men
333
00:20:24.720 --> 00:20:27.960
who stir and perspire but little, the demand for food
334
00:20:28.000 --> 00:20:31.599
diminishes with their abilities to provide it, and as a
335
00:20:31.640 --> 00:20:34.400
savage life would exempt them from the gout in the
336
00:20:34.440 --> 00:20:38.319
Rheumatism and old age is of all ills that which
337
00:20:38.400 --> 00:20:42.079
human assistance is least capable of alleviating. They would at
338
00:20:42.119 --> 00:20:45.200
last go off without its being perceived by others, that
339
00:20:45.279 --> 00:20:49.039
they cease to exist, and almost without perceiving it themselves.
340
00:20:50.440 --> 00:20:53.000
In regard to sickness, I shall not repeat the vain
341
00:20:53.079 --> 00:20:56.599
and false declamations made use of to discredit medicine by
342
00:20:56.640 --> 00:21:00.200
most men while they enjoy their health. I shall they
343
00:21:00.240 --> 00:21:02.920
ask if there are any solid observations from which we
344
00:21:03.000 --> 00:21:05.799
may conclude that in those countries where the healing art
345
00:21:05.839 --> 00:21:08.799
is most neglected, the mean duration of man's life is
346
00:21:08.839 --> 00:21:12.079
shorter than in those where it is most cultivated. And
347
00:21:12.200 --> 00:21:14.599
how is it possible this should be the case if
348
00:21:14.640 --> 00:21:18.160
we inflict more diseases upon ourselves and medicine can supply
349
00:21:18.240 --> 00:21:22.160
us with remedies. The extreme inequalities in the manner of
350
00:21:22.200 --> 00:21:26.039
living of the several classes of mankind, the excess of
351
00:21:26.079 --> 00:21:29.680
idleness in some and of labor and others, the facility
352
00:21:29.720 --> 00:21:34.480
of irritating and satisfying our sensuality and our appetites, the
353
00:21:34.519 --> 00:21:37.480
two exquisite and out of the way ailments of the rich,
354
00:21:37.559 --> 00:21:41.240
which fill them with fiery juices and bring on indigestions.
355
00:21:41.680 --> 00:21:45.200
The unwholesome food of the poor, of which, even bad
356
00:21:45.240 --> 00:21:48.000
as it is, they very often fall short, and the
357
00:21:48.039 --> 00:21:51.359
want of which tempt them every opportunity that offers to
358
00:21:51.440 --> 00:21:56.319
eat greedily and overload their stomachs, watchings, excesses of every kind,
359
00:21:56.519 --> 00:22:00.920
immoderate transports of all the passions, fatigues, ways of spirits.
360
00:22:01.400 --> 00:22:04.480
In a word, the numberless pains and anxieties annexed to
361
00:22:04.559 --> 00:22:08.119
every condition in which the mind of man is constantly
362
00:22:08.119 --> 00:22:11.359
a prey to. These are the fatal proofs that most
363
00:22:11.359 --> 00:22:14.119
of our ills are of our own making, and that
364
00:22:14.200 --> 00:22:17.039
we might have avoided them all by adhering to the simple,
365
00:22:17.279 --> 00:22:20.880
uniform and solitary way of life prescribed to us by nature.
366
00:22:22.079 --> 00:22:25.480
Allowing that nature intended we should always enjoy good health.
367
00:22:25.759 --> 00:22:28.240
I dare almost affirm that a state of reflection is
368
00:22:28.279 --> 00:22:31.519
a state against nature, and that the man who meditates
369
00:22:31.599 --> 00:22:34.759
is a depraved animal. We need only call to mind
370
00:22:34.759 --> 00:22:37.920
the good constitution of savages. Of those at least whom
371
00:22:37.920 --> 00:22:40.920
we have not destroyed by our strong liquors, we need
372
00:22:41.000 --> 00:22:44.000
only reflect that they are strangers to almost every disease,
373
00:22:44.119 --> 00:22:46.839
except those occasioned by wounds in old age to be
374
00:22:46.880 --> 00:22:49.839
in a manner convinced that the history of human diseases
375
00:22:49.920 --> 00:22:54.480
might be easily composed by pursuing that of civil societies. Such,
376
00:22:54.480 --> 00:22:57.119
at least was the opinion of Plato, who concluded from
377
00:22:57.200 --> 00:23:00.359
certain remedies made use of or approved by Podalarrus and
378
00:23:00.400 --> 00:23:04.160
Macaron at the Siege of troy At several disorders which
379
00:23:04.200 --> 00:23:06.680
these remedies were found to bring on in his days
380
00:23:06.960 --> 00:23:11.319
were not known among men at that remote period. Man, therefore,
381
00:23:11.440 --> 00:23:13.400
in a state of nature where there are so few
382
00:23:13.480 --> 00:23:16.680
sources of sickness, can have no great occasion for physic
383
00:23:17.079 --> 00:23:20.839
and still less for physicians. Neither is the human species
384
00:23:20.880 --> 00:23:23.279
more to be pitied in this respect than any other
385
00:23:23.359 --> 00:23:27.240
species of animals. Ask those who make hunting their recreation
386
00:23:27.359 --> 00:23:30.480
or business, if in their excursions they meet with many
387
00:23:30.559 --> 00:23:34.000
sick or feeble animals, they meet with many carrying the
388
00:23:34.039 --> 00:23:37.160
marks of considerable wounds that have been perfectly well healed
389
00:23:37.200 --> 00:23:41.160
and closed up with many whose bones formally broken and
390
00:23:41.200 --> 00:23:44.960
whose limbs almost torn off, have completely knit and united
391
00:23:45.039 --> 00:23:48.440
without any other surgeon, but time, any other regimen, but
392
00:23:48.519 --> 00:23:51.240
their usual way of living, and whose cures were not
393
00:23:51.319 --> 00:23:54.640
the less perfect for their not having been tortured with incisions,
394
00:23:54.960 --> 00:23:58.640
poisoned with drugs, or worn out by diet and abstinence.
395
00:23:59.440 --> 00:24:03.000
In a word, however useful medicine
well administered may be
396
00:24:03.119 --> 00:24:05.680
to us who live in a state of society, it
397
00:24:05.759 --> 00:24:08.279
is still past doubt that if, on the one hand,
398
00:24:08.319 --> 00:24:11.480
the sixth savage destitute of help, has nothing to hope
399
00:24:11.480 --> 00:24:14.720
from nature, on the other, he has nothing to fear
400
00:24:14.799 --> 00:24:18.400
but from his disease, a circumstance which often renders his
401
00:24:18.519 --> 00:24:24.200
situation preferable to ours. Let us therefore, beware of confounding
402
00:24:24.279 --> 00:24:27.279
savage man with the men whom we daily see and
403
00:24:27.359 --> 00:24:31.559
converse with. Nature behaves towards all animals left to our care,
404
00:24:31.720 --> 00:24:34.400
with a predilection that seems to prove how jealous she
405
00:24:34.519 --> 00:24:38.759
is of that prerogative. The horse, the cat, the bull, ney,
406
00:24:38.759 --> 00:24:42.039
the aci itself have generally a higher stature and always
407
00:24:42.039 --> 00:24:47.160
a more robust constitution, more vigor, more strength, and courage
408
00:24:47.160 --> 00:24:50.599
in their forests than in our houses. They lose half
409
00:24:50.640 --> 00:24:54.240
these advantages by becoming domestic animals. It looks as if
410
00:24:54.279 --> 00:24:56.720
all our attention to treat them kindly and to feed
411
00:24:56.720 --> 00:25:00.559
them well, served only to bastardize them. It is thus
412
00:25:00.599 --> 00:25:04.400
with man himself in proportion, as he becomes sociable and
413
00:25:04.440 --> 00:25:08.680
a slave to others, he becomes weak, fearful, mean spirited,
414
00:25:08.799 --> 00:25:11.319
and his soft and effeminate way of living at once
415
00:25:11.400 --> 00:25:15.119
completes the enervation of his strength and of his courage.
416
00:25:15.279 --> 00:25:18.079
We may add that there must be still a wider
417
00:25:18.200 --> 00:25:21.440
difference between man and man in a savage and domestic
418
00:25:21.480 --> 00:25:25.279
condition than between beast and beast. For as men and
419
00:25:25.359 --> 00:25:29.319
beasts have been treated alike by nature, all the conveniences
420
00:25:29.359 --> 00:25:32.039
with which men indulge themselves more than they do the
421
00:25:32.039 --> 00:25:36.440
beasts tamed by them, are so many particular causes which
422
00:25:36.640 --> 00:25:43.200
make them degenerate more sensibly nakedness. Therefore, the want of houses,
423
00:25:43.279 --> 00:25:46.319
and of all these unnecessaries which we consider as so
424
00:25:46.599 --> 00:25:50.200
very necessary, are not such mighty evils in respect to
425
00:25:50.240 --> 00:25:53.960
these primitive men, and much less still any obstacle to
426
00:25:54.000 --> 00:25:58.079
their preservation. Their skins, it is true, are destitute of hair,
427
00:25:58.559 --> 00:26:01.119
but then they have no occasion for any such covering
428
00:26:01.119 --> 00:26:04.400
in warm climates, and in cold climates they soon learned
429
00:26:04.440 --> 00:26:07.160
to apply to that use. Those of the animals they
430
00:26:07.160 --> 00:26:10.319
have conquered. They have but two feet to run with,
431
00:26:10.759 --> 00:26:13.720
They have but two hands to defend themselves with, and
432
00:26:13.759 --> 00:26:17.039
provide for all their wants. It costs them, perhaps a
433
00:26:17.079 --> 00:26:19.720
great deal of time and trouble to make their children walk,
434
00:26:20.039 --> 00:26:22.920
but the mothers carry them with ease, an advantage not
435
00:26:23.039 --> 00:26:25.839
granted to other species of animals, with whom the mother,
436
00:26:25.960 --> 00:26:29.440
when pursued, is obliged to abandon her young ones or
437
00:26:29.599 --> 00:26:34.440
regulate her steps by theirs. In short, unless we admit
438
00:26:34.519 --> 00:26:38.519
those singular and fortuitous concurrences of circumstances which I shall
439
00:26:38.559 --> 00:26:41.839
speak of hereafter, and which it is very possible, may
440
00:26:41.880 --> 00:26:44.799
never have existed, it is evident in every state of
441
00:26:44.839 --> 00:26:48.079
the question that the man who first made himself clothed
442
00:26:48.079 --> 00:26:51.039
and built himself a cabin, supplied himself with things he
443
00:26:51.119 --> 00:26:54.000
did not much want, since he had lived without them
444
00:26:54.079 --> 00:26:56.599
till then. And why should he not have been able
445
00:26:56.599 --> 00:26:59.119
to support in his riper years the same kind of
446
00:26:59.160 --> 00:27:03.319
life which she had done supported from his infancy alone,
447
00:27:03.440 --> 00:27:07.119
idle and always surrounded with danger, savage man must be
448
00:27:07.240 --> 00:27:10.400
fond of sleep, and sleep lightly like other animals, who
449
00:27:10.440 --> 00:27:13.519
think but little, and may, in a manner be said
450
00:27:13.559 --> 00:27:15.920
to sleep all the time. They do not think. Self
451
00:27:15.920 --> 00:27:20.160
preservation being almost his only concern, he must exercise those
452
00:27:20.160 --> 00:27:23.839
faculties most which are most serviceable in attacking and defending,
453
00:27:24.319 --> 00:27:27.240
whether to subdue his prey or to prevent his becoming
454
00:27:27.279 --> 00:27:31.119
that of other animals. Those organs, on the contrary, which
455
00:27:31.200 --> 00:27:35.440
softness and sensuality alone can improve, must remain in a
456
00:27:35.480 --> 00:27:39.920
state of rudeness, utterly incompatible with all manner of delicacy.
457
00:27:40.480 --> 00:27:43.200
And as his senses are divided on this point, his
458
00:27:43.319 --> 00:27:47.039
touch and his taste must be extremely coarse and blunt,
459
00:27:47.240 --> 00:27:51.400
his sight, his hearing, and his smelling equally subtle. Such
460
00:27:51.480 --> 00:27:54.640
is the animal state in general, and accordingly, if we
461
00:27:54.680 --> 00:27:57.880
may believe travelers, it is that of
most savage nations.
462
00:27:58.400 --> 00:28:01.359
We must therefore not be supprise eyes that the Hottentots
463
00:28:01.440 --> 00:28:04.079
of the Cape of Good Hope distinguished with their naked
464
00:28:04.119 --> 00:28:07.359
eyes ships on the ocean at as a great distance
465
00:28:07.400 --> 00:28:10.640
as the Dutch can discern them with their glasses, Nor
466
00:28:10.799 --> 00:28:13.920
the savages of America should have tracked the Spaniards with
467
00:28:13.960 --> 00:28:16.880
their noses to as great a degree of exactness as
468
00:28:16.920 --> 00:28:20.000
the best dogs could have done. Nor that all these
469
00:28:20.079 --> 00:28:24.920
barbarous nations support nakedness without pain, use such large quantities
470
00:28:24.960 --> 00:28:27.920
of pimento to give their food a relish and drink
471
00:28:28.000 --> 00:28:34.279
like water the strongest liquors of Europe. End of section
472
00:28:34.480 --> 00:28:46.079
one of discourse, first part, Section three of the Discourse
473
00:28:46.160 --> 00:28:54.200
on Inequality by Jean Jacques Rousseau. This is a LibriVox recording.
474
00:28:54.799 --> 00:28:58.480
All LibriVox recordings are in the public domain. For more
475
00:28:58.480 --> 00:29:02.880
information or to volunar tir, please visit LibriVox dot org.
476
00:29:03.640 --> 00:29:07.079
This is a reading by Eric Jonas a Discourse upon
477
00:29:07.119 --> 00:29:10.880
the origin and the foundation of the inequality among Mankind
478
00:29:11.359 --> 00:29:18.680
by Jean Jacques Rousseau. Discourse, first Part, Section two. As
479
00:29:18.759 --> 00:29:22.160
yet I have considered man merely in his physical capacity.
480
00:29:22.599 --> 00:29:25.440
Let us now endeavor to examine him in a metaphysical
481
00:29:25.519 --> 00:29:29.720
and moral light. I can discover nothing in any mere
482
00:29:29.839 --> 00:29:33.680
animal but an ingenious machine to which Nature has given
483
00:29:33.759 --> 00:29:37.079
senses to wind itself up and guard to a certain
484
00:29:37.079 --> 00:29:41.279
degree against everything that might destroy or disorder it. I
485
00:29:41.319 --> 00:29:44.400
perceive the very same things in the human machine, with
486
00:29:44.480 --> 00:29:48.599
this difference that Nature alone operates in all the operations
487
00:29:48.640 --> 00:29:52.079
of the beast, whereas man, as a free agent, has
488
00:29:52.079 --> 00:29:56.279
a share in his one chooses by instinct, the other
489
00:29:56.440 --> 00:29:59.160
by an act of liberty. For which reason, the beast
490
00:29:59.200 --> 00:30:02.279
cannot deviate from the rules that have been prescribed to it,
491
00:30:02.759 --> 00:30:06.319
even in cases where such deviation might be useful, and
492
00:30:06.440 --> 00:30:09.480
man often deviates from the rules laid down for him
493
00:30:09.519 --> 00:30:13.599
to his prejudice. Thus, a pigeon would starve near a
494
00:30:13.640 --> 00:30:16.559
dish of the best flesh meat, and a cat on
495
00:30:16.640 --> 00:30:19.559
a heap of fruit or corn, though both might very
496
00:30:19.599 --> 00:30:23.160
well support life with the food they thus disdain, did
497
00:30:23.200 --> 00:30:26.559
they but bethink themselves to make a trial of it.
498
00:30:26.559 --> 00:30:29.880
It is in this manner dissolute men run into excesses,
499
00:30:30.240 --> 00:30:33.960
which bring on fevers and death itself. Because the mind
500
00:30:34.079 --> 00:30:38.079
depraves the senses, and when nature ceases to speak, the
501
00:30:38.160 --> 00:30:43.039
will still continues to dictate. All animals must be allowed
502
00:30:43.079 --> 00:30:46.680
to have ideas. Since all animals have senses, they even
503
00:30:46.720 --> 00:30:49.440
combine their ideas to a certain degree, And in this
504
00:30:49.559 --> 00:30:52.200
respect it is only the difference of such degree that
505
00:30:52.279 --> 00:30:56.480
constitutes the difference between man and beast. Some philosophers have
506
00:30:56.519 --> 00:30:59.279
even advanced that there is a greater difference between some
507
00:30:59.480 --> 00:31:03.160
men and others than between some men and some beasts.
508
00:31:03.880 --> 00:31:07.480
It is not therefore so much the understanding that constitutes
509
00:31:07.519 --> 00:31:12.039
among animals the specifical distinction of man, as his quality
510
00:31:12.200 --> 00:31:16.160
of a free agent, nature speaks to all animals and
511
00:31:16.200 --> 00:31:20.559
beasts obey her voice. Man feels the same impression. But
512
00:31:20.640 --> 00:31:22.880
he at the same time perceives that he is free
513
00:31:22.960 --> 00:31:25.920
to resist or to acquiesce. And it is in the
514
00:31:25.960 --> 00:31:29.640
consciousness of this liberty that the spirituality of his soul
515
00:31:29.759 --> 00:31:33.880
chiefly appears. For natural philosophy explains in some measure the
516
00:31:33.920 --> 00:31:37.759
mechanism of the senses and the formation of ideas. But
517
00:31:37.839 --> 00:31:41.119
in the power of willing, or rather of choosing, and
518
00:31:41.240 --> 00:31:44.519
in the consciousness of this power, nothing can be discovered
519
00:31:44.559 --> 00:31:48.160
but acts that are purely spiritual, and cannot be accounted
520
00:31:48.200 --> 00:31:52.960
for by the laws of mechanics. But though the difficulties
521
00:31:53.000 --> 00:31:55.519
in which all these questions are involved should leave some
522
00:31:55.720 --> 00:31:58.759
room to dispute on this difference between man and beast,
523
00:31:59.559 --> 00:32:02.799
there is an another very specific quality that distinguishes them,
524
00:32:03.200 --> 00:32:06.400
and a quality which will admit of no dispute. This
525
00:32:06.519 --> 00:32:11.240
is the faculty of improvement, a faculty which as circumstances
526
00:32:11.359 --> 00:32:16.759
offer successively, unfolds all the other faculties, and resides among us,
527
00:32:16.839 --> 00:32:19.880
not only in the species, but in the individuals that
528
00:32:19.960 --> 00:32:23.240
compose it. Whereas a beast is at the end of
529
00:32:23.279 --> 00:32:25.759
some months all he will ever be during the rest
530
00:32:25.759 --> 00:32:28.279
of his life, and his species at the end of
531
00:32:28.319 --> 00:32:31.319
a thousand years, precisely what it was the first year
532
00:32:31.359 --> 00:32:36.240
of that long period. Why is man alone subject to dotage?
533
00:32:37.240 --> 00:32:40.519
Is it not because he thus returns to his primitive condition,
534
00:32:41.079 --> 00:32:43.880
And because while the beast, which has acquired nothing and
535
00:32:43.920 --> 00:32:47.880
thus has likewise nothing to lose, continues always in possession
536
00:32:48.039 --> 00:32:51.559
of his instinct, Man, losing by old age or by accident,
537
00:32:51.680 --> 00:32:55.720
all the acquisitions he has made in consequence of his perfectibility,
538
00:32:56.200 --> 00:33:00.119
thus falls back even lower than the beasts themselves. It
539
00:33:00.119 --> 00:33:03.000
would be a melancholy necessity for us to be obliged
540
00:33:03.039 --> 00:33:06.559
to allow that this distinctive and almost unlimited faculty is
541
00:33:06.599 --> 00:33:10.440
the source of all man's misfortunes. That it is this
542
00:33:10.599 --> 00:33:14.160
faculty which, though by slow degrees, draws them out of
543
00:33:14.200 --> 00:33:18.279
their original condition, in which these days would slide away
544
00:33:18.480 --> 00:33:23.400
insensibly in peace and innocence. That it is this faculty which,
545
00:33:23.559 --> 00:33:27.319
in a succession of ages, produces his discoveries and mistakes,
546
00:33:27.799 --> 00:33:31.839
his virtues and his vices, and at long run renders
547
00:33:31.920 --> 00:33:35.720
him both his own and nature's tyrant. It will be
548
00:33:35.759 --> 00:33:38.839
shocking to be obliged to commend as a beneficent being,
549
00:33:39.039 --> 00:33:42.640
whoever he was that first suggested to the Ironico Indians
550
00:33:42.720 --> 00:33:45.240
the use of those boards which they bind on the
551
00:33:45.240 --> 00:33:48.359
temples of their children, and which secure to them the
552
00:33:48.480 --> 00:33:51.880
enjoyment of some part at least of their natural imbecility
553
00:33:51.960 --> 00:33:56.920
and happiness. Savage man, abandoned by nature to pure instinct,
554
00:33:57.000 --> 00:34:00.000
or rather indemnified for that which has perhaps been denied
555
00:34:00.240 --> 00:34:03.720
to him by faculties capable of immediately supplying the place
556
00:34:03.759 --> 00:34:07.039
of it, and of raising him afterwards a great deal higher,
557
00:34:07.400 --> 00:34:11.119
would therefore begin with functions that were merely animal. To
558
00:34:11.239 --> 00:34:14.360
see and to feel would be his first condition, which
559
00:34:14.360 --> 00:34:17.840
he would enjoy in common with other animals. To will
560
00:34:17.960 --> 00:34:21.119
and
not to will, to wish and to fear would
561
00:34:21.119 --> 00:34:24.320
be the first, and in a manner, the only operations
562
00:34:24.320 --> 00:34:29.199
of his soul till new circumstances occasioned new developments. Let
563
00:34:29.280 --> 00:34:32.400
moralists say what they will. The human understanding is greatly
564
00:34:32.440 --> 00:34:36.199
indebted to the passions which on their side are likewise
565
00:34:36.320 --> 00:34:39.760
universally allowed to be greatly indebted to the human understanding.
566
00:34:41.440 --> 00:34:44.079
It is by the activity of our passions that our
567
00:34:44.119 --> 00:34:48.719
reason improves. We covet knowledge merely because we covet enjoyment,
568
00:34:49.199 --> 00:34:52.199
And it is impossible to conceive why a man exempt
569
00:34:52.239 --> 00:34:55.039
from fears and desires should take the trouble to reason.
570
00:34:55.920 --> 00:34:59.679
The passions, in their turn, owe their origin to our wants,
571
00:35:00.079 --> 00:35:03.199
and their increase to our progress in science. For we
572
00:35:03.239 --> 00:35:06.599
cannot desire or fear anything but in consequence of the
573
00:35:06.679 --> 00:35:10.000
ideas we have of it, or of the simple impulses
574
00:35:10.039 --> 00:35:14.519
of nature and savage man, destitute of every species of knowledge,
575
00:35:14.599 --> 00:35:18.719
experiences no passion but those of this last kind. His
576
00:35:18.840 --> 00:35:22.480
desires never extend beyond his physical wants. He knows no
577
00:35:22.599 --> 00:35:26.599
goods but food of female and rest. He fears no
578
00:35:26.719 --> 00:35:30.400
evil but pain and hunger. I say pain and not death,
579
00:35:30.519 --> 00:35:33.480
for no animal merely as such, will ever know what
580
00:35:33.519 --> 00:35:36.039
it is to die, And the knowledge of death and
581
00:35:36.079 --> 00:35:39.440
of its terrors is one of the first acquisitions made
582
00:35:39.440 --> 00:35:42.920
by man in consequence of his deviating from the animal state.
583
00:35:43.920 --> 00:35:47.000
I could easily were requisite cite factions and support of
584
00:35:47.039 --> 00:35:49.559
this opinion and show that the progress of the mind
585
00:35:49.679 --> 00:35:53.239
has everywhere kept pace exactly with the wants to which
586
00:35:53.320 --> 00:35:57.559
Nature had left the inhabitants exposed, or to which circumstances
587
00:35:57.599 --> 00:36:01.440
had subjected them, and consequently to the passions which incline
588
00:36:01.519 --> 00:36:04.920
them to provide for these wants. I could exhibit in
589
00:36:05.039 --> 00:36:08.119
Egypt the arts starting up and extending themselves with the
590
00:36:08.159 --> 00:36:11.559
inundations of the Nile. I could pursue them in their
591
00:36:11.599 --> 00:36:15.039
progress among the Greeks, where they were seen to bud forth,
592
00:36:15.199 --> 00:36:17.559
grow and rise to the heavens in the midst of
593
00:36:17.559 --> 00:36:21.000
the sands and
rocks of Attica, without being able to
594
00:36:21.039 --> 00:36:24.239
take root on the fertile banks of the Eurotas, I
595
00:36:24.239 --> 00:36:27.280
would observe that, in general the inhabitants of the North
596
00:36:27.320 --> 00:36:30.280
are more industrious than those of the South, because they
597
00:36:30.320 --> 00:36:34.000
can do less without industry. As if Nature thus meant
598
00:36:34.039 --> 00:36:36.639
to make all things equal by giving to the mind
599
00:36:36.760 --> 00:36:41.519
that fertility she has denied to the soil. But exclusive
600
00:36:41.719 --> 00:36:45.639
of the uncertain testimonies of history, who does not perceive
601
00:36:45.719 --> 00:36:48.840
that everything seems to remove from savage man the temptation
602
00:36:49.079 --> 00:36:53.360
and the means of altering its condition, his imagination paints
603
00:36:53.400 --> 00:36:56.920
nothing to him his heart asks nothing from him. His
604
00:36:57.079 --> 00:37:00.519
moderate wants are so easily supplied with what he everywhere
605
00:37:00.559 --> 00:37:03.440
finds ready to his hand. And he stands at such
606
00:37:03.440 --> 00:37:06.880
a distance from the degree of knowledge requisite to covet more,
607
00:37:07.360 --> 00:37:11.760
and he can neither have foresight nor curiosity. The spectacle
608
00:37:11.800 --> 00:37:15.360
of nature, by growing quite familiar to him, becomes at
609
00:37:15.480 --> 00:37:20.400
last equally indifferent. It is constantly the same order, constantly
610
00:37:20.440 --> 00:37:24.079
the same revolutions. He has not sense enough to feel
611
00:37:24.079 --> 00:37:27.679
surprised at the sight of the greatest wonders, And it
612
00:37:27.760 --> 00:37:29.920
is not in his mind. We must look for that
613
00:37:29.960 --> 00:37:33.000
philosophy which man must have to know how to observe
614
00:37:33.119 --> 00:37:36.960
once what he has every day seen. His soul, which
615
00:37:37.000 --> 00:37:40.599
nothing disturbs, gives itself up entirely to the consciousness of
616
00:37:40.679 --> 00:37:45.119
its actual existence, without any thought of even the nearest futurity,
617
00:37:45.760 --> 00:37:50.360
and his projects, equally confined, with his views scarce extend
618
00:37:50.400 --> 00:37:53.320
to the end of the day. Such is even at
619
00:37:53.400 --> 00:37:57.079
present the degree of foresight. In the Caribbean, he sells
620
00:37:57.079 --> 00:37:59.559
his cotton bed in the morning, and comes in the
621
00:37:59.599 --> 00:38:02.199
evening with tears in his eyes, to buy it back,
622
00:38:02.599 --> 00:38:05.119
not having foreseen that he should want it again the
623
00:38:05.159 --> 00:38:08.880
next night. The more we meditate on this subject, the
624
00:38:08.920 --> 00:38:12.159
wider does the distance between mere sensation and the most
625
00:38:12.199 --> 00:38:16.039
simple knowledge become in our eyes. And it is impossible
626
00:38:16.039 --> 00:38:19.840
to conceive how man, by his own powers alone, without
627
00:38:19.840 --> 00:38:23.719
the assistance of communication and the spur of necessity, could
628
00:38:23.719 --> 00:38:27.360
have got over so great an interval. How many ages
629
00:38:27.440 --> 00:38:31.239
perhaps revolved before men beheld any other fire but that
630
00:38:31.360 --> 00:38:35.280
of the heavens. How many different accidents must have concurred
631
00:38:35.360 --> 00:38:37.960
to make them acquainted with the most common uses of
632
00:38:38.000 --> 00:38:41.119
this element? How often have they let it go out
633
00:38:41.159 --> 00:38:45.480
before they knew the art of reproducing it? And how often, perhaps,
634
00:38:45.559 --> 00:38:48.639
has not every one of these secrets perished with the discoverer.
635
00:38:49.480 --> 00:38:52.679
What shall we say of agriculture, an art which requires
636
00:38:52.719 --> 00:38:56.440
so much labor and foresight, which depends upon other arts,
637
00:38:57.239 --> 00:38:59.920
which it is very evident, cannot be practiced button as
638
00:39:00.039 --> 00:39:02.719
society if not a formed one, at least one of
639
00:39:02.760 --> 00:39:05.599
some standing, and which does not so much serve to
640
00:39:05.679 --> 00:39:08.280
draw ailiments from the earth, for the earth would yield
641
00:39:08.280 --> 00:39:10.920
them without all that trouble as to oblige her to
642
00:39:10.960 --> 00:39:13.800
produce those things which you like best preferably to others.
643
00:39:14.639 --> 00:39:17.159
But let us suppose that men had multiplied to such
644
00:39:17.159 --> 00:39:19.679
a degree that the natural products of the earth no
645
00:39:19.760 --> 00:39:23.719
longer sufficed for their support, a supposition which, by the bye,
646
00:39:24.039 --> 00:39:26.360
would prove that this kind of life would be very
647
00:39:26.400 --> 00:39:30.159
advantageous to the human species. Let us suppose that without
648
00:39:30.320 --> 00:39:34.079
forge or anvil, the instruments of husbandry had dropped from
649
00:39:34.119 --> 00:39:37.480
the heavens into the hands of savages. That these men
650
00:39:37.519 --> 00:39:40.159
had got the better of that mortal aversion they all
651
00:39:40.199 --> 00:39:43.400
have for constant labor, That they had learned to foretell
652
00:39:43.440 --> 00:39:46.360
their wants at so great a distance of time, that
653
00:39:46.400 --> 00:39:49.119
they had guessed exactly how they were to break the earth,
654
00:39:49.239 --> 00:39:52.519
commit their seed to it, and plant trees. That they
655
00:39:52.519 --> 00:39:55.079
had found out the art of grinding their corn and
656
00:39:55.159 --> 00:39:59.519
improving by fermentation the juice of their grapes, all operations
657
00:39:59.599 --> 00:40:02.360
which we must allow them to have learned from the gods,
658
00:40:02.639 --> 00:40:04.960
since we cannot conceive how they should make such a
659
00:40:05.079 --> 00:40:09.199
discoveries of themselves. After all these
fine presents, what man
660
00:40:09.199 --> 00:40:11.400
would be mad enough to cultivate a field that may
661
00:40:11.440 --> 00:40:13.960
be robbed by the first comer man or beast who
662
00:40:14.039 --> 00:40:16.880
takes a fancy to the produce of it, And would
663
00:40:16.880 --> 00:40:20.239
any man consent to spend his day in labor and fatigue,
664
00:40:20.239 --> 00:40:22.760
when the rewards of his labor and fatigue become more
665
00:40:22.800 --> 00:40:25.800
and more precarious in proportioned to his want of them.
666
00:40:26.119 --> 00:40:28.800
In a word, how could this situation engage men to
667
00:40:28.840 --> 00:40:31.480
cultivate the earth as long as it was not parceled
668
00:40:31.480 --> 00:40:34.280
out among them, that is, as long as a state
669
00:40:34.360 --> 00:40:38.719
of nature subsisted. Though we should suppose savage man as
670
00:40:38.760 --> 00:40:41.639
well versed in the art of thinking as philosophers make him,
671
00:40:42.000 --> 00:40:45.159
though we were, after them, to make him a philosopher himself,
672
00:40:45.199 --> 00:40:48.960
discovering of himself the sublimest truths, forming to himself by
673
00:40:48.960 --> 00:40:52.719
the most abstract arguments, maxims of justice and reason, drawn
674
00:40:52.800 --> 00:40:55.360
from the love of order in general, or from the
675
00:40:55.480 --> 00:40:58.679
known will of his creator. In a word, though we
676
00:40:58.679 --> 00:41:01.960
were to suppose his mind as intelligent and enlightened as
677
00:41:01.960 --> 00:41:05.199
it must, and is in fact found to be dull
678
00:41:05.239 --> 00:41:08.599
and stupid. What benefit would the species receive from all
679
00:41:08.719 --> 00:41:12.599
these metaphysical discoveries, which could not be communicated, but must
680
00:41:12.679 --> 00:41:16.719
perish with the individual who had made them. What progress
681
00:41:16.760 --> 00:41:19.800
could mankind make in the forests scattered up and down
682
00:41:19.840 --> 00:41:22.800
among the other animals, And to what degree could men
683
00:41:22.920 --> 00:41:25.760
mutually improve and enlighten each other, when they had no
684
00:41:25.840 --> 00:41:30.079
fixed habitation nor any need for each other's assistance. When
685
00:41:30.079 --> 00:41:33.199
the same persons scarcely met twice in their whole lives,
686
00:41:33.519 --> 00:41:36.519
and our meeting neither spoke to or so much as
687
00:41:36.599 --> 00:41:40.559
knew each other. Let us consider how many ideas we
688
00:41:40.639 --> 00:41:43.400
owe to the use of speech, and how much grammar
689
00:41:43.480 --> 00:41:48.280
exercises and facilitates the operations of the mind. Let us, besides,
690
00:41:48.360 --> 00:41:51.519
reflect on the immense pains and time that the first
691
00:41:51.519 --> 00:41:55.079
invention of languages must have required. Let us add these
692
00:41:55.119 --> 00:41:58.039
reflections to the preceding, and then we may judge how
693
00:41:58.039 --> 00:42:01.679
many thousand ages must have been requisite to develop successively
694
00:42:02.039 --> 00:42:05.519
the operations which the human mind is capable of producing.
695
00:42:06.960 --> 00:42:09.320
I must now beg leave to stop one moment to
696
00:42:09.320 --> 00:42:13.639
consider the perplexities attending the origin of languages. I might
697
00:42:13.679 --> 00:42:17.119
here barely cite or repeat the research is made in
698
00:42:17.159 --> 00:42:20.719
relation to this question by the abbe des condilact, which
699
00:42:20.760 --> 00:42:24.159
all fully confirm my system, and perhaps even suggested to
700
00:42:24.239 --> 00:42:27.480
me the first idea of it. But as the manner
701
00:42:27.559 --> 00:42:30.599
in which the philosopher resolves the difficulties of his own
702
00:42:30.679 --> 00:42:34.480
starting concerning the origin of arbitrary signs, shows that he
703
00:42:34.559 --> 00:42:38.400
supposes what I doubt, namely a kind of society already
704
00:42:38.519 --> 00:42:42.719
established among the inventors of languages. I think it my duty,
705
00:42:42.760 --> 00:42:45.480
at the same time that I refer to his reflections
706
00:42:45.519 --> 00:42:48.039
to give my own, in order to expose the same
707
00:42:48.119 --> 00:42:51.440
difficulties and a light suitable to my subject. The first
708
00:42:51.480 --> 00:42:55.079
that offers is how languages could become necessary for as
709
00:42:55.119 --> 00:42:58.760
there was no correspondence between men, nor the least necessity
710
00:42:58.800 --> 00:43:02.199
for any there is no conceiving the necessity of this invention,
711
00:43:02.480 --> 00:43:05.639
nor the possibility of it. If it was not indispensable.
712
00:43:06.719 --> 00:43:09.599
I might say, with many others, that languages are the
713
00:43:09.599 --> 00:43:13.440
fruit of the domestic intercourse between fathers, mothers, and children.
714
00:43:14.079 --> 00:43:17.320
But this besides, it's not answering any difficulties, would be
715
00:43:17.320 --> 00:43:20.119
committing the same fault with those who, reasoning on the
716
00:43:20.159 --> 00:43:23.960
state of nature, transferred to it ideas collected in society,
717
00:43:24.440 --> 00:43:28.199
always consider families as living together under one roof, and
718
00:43:28.239 --> 00:43:32.280
their members as observing among themselves a union equally intimate
719
00:43:32.320 --> 00:43:34.760
and permanent with that which we see exist in a
720
00:43:34.800 --> 00:43:39.039
civil state, where so many common interests conspire to unite them.
721
00:43:39.599 --> 00:43:42.559
Whereas in this primitive state, as there were neither houses,
722
00:43:42.599 --> 00:43:46.159
nor cabins, nor any kind of property. Everyone took up
723
00:43:46.320 --> 00:43:49.639
his lodgings at random, and seldom continued above one night
724
00:43:49.679 --> 00:43:53.159
in the same place. Males and females united without any
725
00:43:53.199 --> 00:43:57.280
premeditated design, As chance, occasion, or desire brought them together,
726
00:43:57.880 --> 00:44:00.400
nor had they any great occasion for laying which to
727
00:44:00.440 --> 00:44:03.199
make known their thoughts to each other. They parted with
728
00:44:03.280 --> 00:44:06.719
the same ease. The mother suckled her children when just
729
00:44:06.880 --> 00:44:10.440
born for her own sake, but afterwards out of love
730
00:44:10.480 --> 00:44:13.559
and affection to them, when habit and custom had made
731
00:44:13.639 --> 00:44:16.800
them dear to her, But they no sooner gained strength
732
00:44:16.880 --> 00:44:19.320
enough to run about in quest of food than they
733
00:44:19.360 --> 00:44:22.920
separated even from her of their own accord. And as
734
00:44:22.960 --> 00:44:25.400
they scarce had any other method of not losing each
735
00:44:25.440 --> 00:44:28.239
other than that of remaining constantly in each other's sight,
736
00:44:28.639 --> 00:44:31.519
they soon came to such a passive forgetfulness as not
737
00:44:31.599 --> 00:44:34.039
even to know each other when they happened to meet again.
738
00:44:34.920 --> 00:44:37.519
I must further observe that the child, having all his
739
00:44:37.679 --> 00:44:40.800
wants to explain, and consequently more things to say to
740
00:44:40.880 --> 00:44:43.400
his mother than the mother can have to say to him,
741
00:44:43.679 --> 00:44:46.559
it is he that must be at the chief expensive invention,
742
00:44:47.159 --> 00:44:49.480
and the language he makes use of must be in
743
00:44:49.599 --> 00:44:53.159
great measure his own work. This makes the number of
744
00:44:53.280 --> 00:44:55.840
languages equal to that of the individuals who are to
745
00:44:55.880 --> 00:44:59.719
speak them. And this multiplicity of languages is further increased
746
00:44:59.719 --> 00:45:03.440
by the roving and vagabond kind of life, which allows
747
00:45:03.480 --> 00:45:07.159
no idiom time enough to acquire any consistency. For to
748
00:45:07.199 --> 00:45:09.559
say that the mother would have dictated to the child
749
00:45:09.639 --> 00:45:12.280
of the words he must employ to ask her this thing,
750
00:45:12.320 --> 00:45:14.880
and that may well be enough to explain in what
751
00:45:14.960 --> 00:45:18.760
manner languages already formed are taught, But it does not
752
00:45:18.920 --> 00:45:23.039
show us in what manner they are first formed. Let
753
00:45:23.159 --> 00:45:26.480
us suppose this first difficulty conquered. Let us for a
754
00:45:26.519 --> 00:45:29.599
moment consider ourselves at this side of the immense space
755
00:45:29.639 --> 00:45:32.320
which must have separated the pure state of nature from
756
00:45:32.400 --> 00:45:36.079
that in which languages became necessary. And let us, after
757
00:45:36.199 --> 00:45:40.920
allowing such necessity, examine how languages could begin to be established.
758
00:45:41.719 --> 00:45:44.800
A new difficulty, this still more
stubborn than the preceding,
759
00:45:45.800 --> 00:45:48.039
For if men stood in need of speech to learn
760
00:45:48.039 --> 00:45:50.800
to think, they must have stood in still greater need
761
00:45:50.880 --> 00:45:53.400
of the art of thinking to invent that of speaking.
762
00:45:54.079 --> 00:45:56.440
And though we could conceive how the sounds of the
763
00:45:56.519 --> 00:45:59.519
voice came to be taken for the conventional interpreters of
764
00:45:59.519 --> 00:46:02.239
our idea is we should not be the nearer knowing
765
00:46:02.320 --> 00:46:04.920
who could have been the interpreters of this convention, for
766
00:46:05.000 --> 00:46:08.360
such ideas, as, in consequence of their not having any
767
00:46:08.360 --> 00:46:12.519
sensible objects, could not be made manifest by gesture or voice.
768
00:46:12.719 --> 00:46:16.159
So that we can scarce form any tolerable conjectures concerning
769
00:46:16.199 --> 00:46:19.039
the birth of this art of communicating our thoughts and
770
00:46:19.159 --> 00:46:23.400
establishing a correspondence between minds, a sublime art, which, though
771
00:46:23.519 --> 00:46:27.280
so remote from its origin philosophers, still behold at such
772
00:46:27.320 --> 00:46:30.639
a prodigious distance from its perfection that I never met
773
00:46:30.679 --> 00:46:32.840
with one of them bold enough to affirm it would
774
00:46:32.880 --> 00:46:37.159
ever arrive there. Though the revolutions necessarily produced by time
775
00:46:37.159 --> 00:46:40.920
are suspended in its favor, though prejudice could be banished from,
776
00:46:41.039 --> 00:46:43.239
or would be at least content to sit silent in
777
00:46:43.280 --> 00:46:46.599
the presence of our academies, And though these societies should
778
00:46:46.639 --> 00:46:50.320
consecrate themselves entirely and during whole ages to the study
779
00:46:50.360 --> 00:46:54.599
of this intricate object. The first language of man, the
780
00:46:54.639 --> 00:46:58.239
most universal and most energetic of all languages, In short,
781
00:46:58.639 --> 00:47:01.400
the only language he had occasion for before there was
782
00:47:01.440 --> 00:47:06.480
a necessity of persuading assembled multitudes was the cry of nature.
783
00:47:07.320 --> 00:47:09.920
As this cry was never extorted, but by a kind
784
00:47:10.000 --> 00:47:13.360
of instinct, in the most urgent cases, to implore assistance
785
00:47:13.400 --> 00:47:16.519
in great danger or relief in great sufferings, it was
786
00:47:16.559 --> 00:47:19.760
of little use in the common occurrences of life, where
787
00:47:19.760 --> 00:47:23.840
more moderate sentiments generally prevail. When the ideas of men
788
00:47:23.920 --> 00:47:27.599
began to extend and multiply, and a closer communication began
789
00:47:27.679 --> 00:47:30.599
to take place among them, they labored to devise more
790
00:47:30.679 --> 00:47:34.880
numerous signs and a more extensive language. They multiplied the
791
00:47:34.920 --> 00:47:38.280
inflections of the voice, and added to them gestures, which
792
00:47:38.280 --> 00:47:41.800
are in their own nature more expressive, and whose meaning
793
00:47:41.840 --> 00:47:46.840
depends less on any prior determination. They therefore expressed visible
794
00:47:46.880 --> 00:47:50.000
and movable objects by gestures and those which strike the
795
00:47:50.039 --> 00:47:55.760
ear by imitative sounds. But as gestures scarcely indicate anything
796
00:47:55.800 --> 00:47:58.840
except objects that are actually present or can be easily
797
00:47:58.880 --> 00:48:02.639
described invisible actions, as they are not of general use,
798
00:48:02.840 --> 00:48:06.519
since darkness or the interposition of an opaque medium renders
799
00:48:06.519 --> 00:48:10.599
them useless, and as besides they require attention rather than
800
00:48:10.639 --> 00:48:14.599
excite it. Men at length bethought themselves of substituting for
801
00:48:14.679 --> 00:48:18.760
them the articulations of voice, which, without having the same
802
00:48:18.800 --> 00:48:23.599
relation to any determinate object, are in quality of instituted
803
00:48:23.719 --> 00:48:28.400
signs fitter to represent all our ideas, a substitution which
804
00:48:28.440 --> 00:48:32.119
could only have been made by common consent, and in
805
00:48:32.119 --> 00:48:35.320
a manner pretty difficult to practice by men whose rude
806
00:48:35.440 --> 00:48:40.000
organs were unimproved by exercise. A substitution which is in
807
00:48:40.039 --> 00:48:43.320
itself more difficult to be conceived. Since the motives to
808
00:48:43.400 --> 00:48:47.480
this unanimous agreement must have been somehow or another expressed,
809
00:48:47.880 --> 00:48:51.480
and speech therefore appears to have been exceedingly requisite. To
810
00:48:51.599 --> 00:48:55.679
establish the use of speech, we must allow that the
811
00:48:55.719 --> 00:48:58.719
words first made use of by men had in their
812
00:48:58.760 --> 00:49:02.519
minds a much more extend signification than those employed in
813
00:49:02.639 --> 00:49:06.639
languages of some standing, and that, considering how ignorant they
814
00:49:06.679 --> 00:49:09.760
were of the division of speech into its constituent parts,
815
00:49:10.159 --> 00:49:12.639
they at first gave every word the meaning of an
816
00:49:12.800 --> 00:49:17.159
entire proposition, when afterwards they began to perceive the difference
817
00:49:17.199 --> 00:49:20.719
between the subject and attribute and between verb and noun,
818
00:49:21.199 --> 00:49:26.000
a distinction which required no mean effort of genius. The substantives,
819
00:49:26.039 --> 00:49:28.960
for a time were only so many proper names. The
820
00:49:29.000 --> 00:49:32.960
infinitive was the only tense, and as to adjectives, great
821
00:49:33.000 --> 00:49:36.239
difficulties must have attended the development of the idea that
822
00:49:36.320 --> 00:49:40.400
represents
them, Since every adjective is an abstract word. An
823
00:49:40.400 --> 00:49:45.360
abstraction is an unnatural and very painful operation. At first,
824
00:49:45.400 --> 00:49:48.480
they gave every object a peculiar name, without any regard
825
00:49:48.559 --> 00:49:51.880
to its genus or species, things which these first institutions
826
00:49:51.880 --> 00:49:54.760
of language were in no condition to distinguish, and every
827
00:49:54.760 --> 00:49:58.760
individual presented itself solitary to their minds as it stands
828
00:49:58.760 --> 00:50:02.440
in the table of nature. If they called one oak a,
829
00:50:02.719 --> 00:50:05.840
they called another oak B, so that their dictionary must
830
00:50:05.920 --> 00:50:08.679
have been more extensive in proportion, as their knowledge of
831
00:50:08.719 --> 00:50:11.760
things was more confined. It could not be but a
832
00:50:11.880 --> 00:50:14.400
very difficult task to get rid of so diffuse an
833
00:50:14.440 --> 00:50:18.320
embarrassing a nomenclature, as in order to marshal the several
834
00:50:18.360 --> 00:50:22.159
beings under common and generic denominations, it was necessary to
835
00:50:22.199 --> 00:50:25.480
be first acquainted with their properties and their differences, to
836
00:50:25.519 --> 00:50:28.679
be stocked with observations and definitions, that is to say,
837
00:50:29.000 --> 00:50:33.079
to understand natural history and metaphysics, advantages which the men
838
00:50:33.159 --> 00:50:37.920
of these times could not have enjoyed. Besides general ideas,
839
00:50:37.920 --> 00:50:40.800
cannot be conveyed to the mind without the assistance of words,
840
00:50:41.159 --> 00:50:44.880
nor can the understanding seize them without the assistance of propositions.
841
00:50:45.480 --> 00:50:48.119
This is one of the reasons why mere animals cannot
842
00:50:48.159 --> 00:50:52.239
form such ideas, nor ever acquire the perfectibility which depends
843
00:50:52.280 --> 00:50:55.760
on such an operation. When a monkey leaves without the
844
00:50:55.920 --> 00:50:58.920
least hesitation one nut for another, are we to think
845
00:50:58.960 --> 00:51:01.559
he has any general idea idea of that kind of fruit,
846
00:51:02.000 --> 00:51:04.679
and that he compares these two individual bodies with his
847
00:51:04.840 --> 00:51:09.199
archetype notion of them. No, certainly, But the sight of
848
00:51:09.199 --> 00:51:11.400
one of these nuts calls back to his memory the
849
00:51:11.480 --> 00:51:14.000
sensations which he has received from the other, and his
850
00:51:14.119 --> 00:51:17.880
eyes modified after some certain manner, give notice to his
851
00:51:17.960 --> 00:51:20.960
palette of the modification it is in turn going to receive.
852
00:51:21.960 --> 00:51:26.440
Every general idea is purely intellectual. Let the imagination tamper,
853
00:51:26.559 --> 00:51:30.360
ever so little with it. It immediately becomes a particular idea.
854
00:51:31.320 --> 00:51:34.119
Endeavor to represent to yourself the image of a tree
855
00:51:34.159 --> 00:51:36.719
in general, you never will be able to do it,
856
00:51:37.679 --> 00:51:39.920
in spite of all your efforts. It will appear big
857
00:51:40.039 --> 00:51:42.519
or little, thin or tuft of a bright or a
858
00:51:42.519 --> 00:51:45.679
deep color, And where you master to see nothing in it.
859
00:51:45.760 --> 00:51:48.039
But what can be seen in every tree, Such a
860
00:51:48.079 --> 00:51:52.800
picture would no longer resemble any tree, beings perfectly abstract
861
00:51:52.880 --> 00:51:56.320
or perceivable in the same manner, or are only conceivable
862
00:51:56.360 --> 00:51:59.880
by the assistance of speech. The definition of a trying
863
00:52:00.320 --> 00:52:02.920
can alone give you a just idea of that figure.
864
00:52:03.320 --> 00:52:05.920
The moment you form a triangle in your mind, it
865
00:52:06.000 --> 00:52:09.360
is this or that particular triangle and no other, and
866
00:52:09.400 --> 00:52:12.320
you cannot avoid giving breadth to its lines and color
867
00:52:12.360 --> 00:52:15.960
to its area. We must therefore make use of propositions.
868
00:52:16.280 --> 00:52:19.360
We must therefore speak to have general ideas for the
869
00:52:19.400 --> 00:52:22.639
moment the imagination stops, the mind must stop. Two. If
870
00:52:22.679 --> 00:52:26.800
not assisted by speech. If therefore the first inventors who
871
00:52:26.840 --> 00:52:30.079
give no names to any ideas but those they had already,
872
00:52:30.840 --> 00:52:33.559
it follows that the first substantives could never have been
873
00:52:33.599 --> 00:52:40.119
anything more than proper names. End of section two of
874
00:52:40.679 --> 00:52:51.719
Discourse first Part Section four of the Discourse on Inequality
875
00:52:51.840 --> 00:52:58.320
by Jean Jacques Rousseau. This is a LibriVox recording. All
876
00:52:58.360 --> 00:53:02.239
LibriVox recordings are in the public domain. For more information
877
00:53:02.519 --> 00:53:06.920
or to volunteer, please visit LibriVox dot org. This is
878
00:53:06.960 --> 00:53:10.599
a reading by Eric Jonas a discourse upon the Origin
879
00:53:10.679 --> 00:53:14.199
and the foundation of the Inequality among Mankind by Jean
880
00:53:14.320 --> 00:53:20.719
Jacques Rousseau, Discourse, first part Section three. But when by
881
00:53:20.800 --> 00:53:24.079
means which I cannot conceive, our new grammarians began to
882
00:53:24.159 --> 00:53:27.840
extend their ideas and generalize their words, the ignorance of
883
00:53:27.840 --> 00:53:31.639
the inventors must have confined this method to very narrow bounds.
884
00:53:32.039 --> 00:53:34.480
And as they had at first too much multiplied the
885
00:53:34.559 --> 00:53:37.199
names of individuals for want of being acquainted with the
886
00:53:37.239 --> 00:53:41.440
distinctions called genus and species, they afterwards made too fu
887
00:53:41.559 -->
00:53:44.880
genera and species for want of having considered beings in
888
00:53:44.920 --> 00:53:48.400
all their differences. To push the divisions far enough, they
889
00:53:48.480 --> 00:53:51.079
must have had more knowledge and experience than we can
890
00:53:51.119 --> 00:53:54.360
allow them, and have made more researches and taken more
891
00:53:54.440 --> 00:53:58.199
pains than we can suppose them willing to submit to. Now.
892
00:53:58.239 --> 00:54:01.119
If even at this present time we every day discover
893
00:54:01.239 --> 00:54:04.800
new species which had before escaped all our observations, how
894
00:54:04.840 --> 00:54:07.679
many species must have escaped the notice of men who
895
00:54:07.760 --> 00:54:11.440
judged of things merely from their first appearances. As to
896
00:54:11.519 --> 00:54:14.880
the primitive classes and the most general notions, it were
897
00:54:14.880 --> 00:54:18.440
superfluous to add that these they must have likewise overlooked.
898
00:54:19.000 --> 00:54:21.960
How for example, could they have thought of or understood
899
00:54:21.960 --> 00:54:27.440
the words matter, spirit, substance, mode, figure, motion. Since even
900
00:54:27.480 --> 00:54:30.320
our philosophers, who for so long a time have been
901
00:54:30.360 --> 00:54:35.079
constantly employing these terms, can themselves scarcely understand them, And
902
00:54:35.199 --> 00:54:38.880
since the ideas and next to these words being purely metaphysical,
903
00:54:39.280 --> 00:54:42.679
no models of them could be found in nature. I
904
00:54:42.719 --> 00:54:45.760
stop at these first advances and beseech my judges to
905
00:54:45.800 --> 00:54:48.599
suspend their lecture a little in order to consider what
906
00:54:48.719 --> 00:54:51.360
a great way language has still to go in regard
907
00:54:51.440 --> 00:54:55.360
to the invention of physical substantives alone, Though the easiest
908
00:54:55.360 --> 00:54:58.320
part of language to invent, to be able to express
909
00:54:58.360 --> 00:55:01.719
all the sentiments of man, to assume an invariable form,
910
00:55:02.079 --> 00:55:05.840
to bear being spoken in a public and to influence society,
911
00:55:06.559 --> 00:55:09.360
I earnestly entreat them to consider how much time and
912
00:55:09.440 --> 00:55:13.800
knowledge must have been requisite to find out numbers abstract words,
913
00:55:14.239 --> 00:55:17.920
the aortists, and all the other tenses of verbs, the
914
00:55:18.000 --> 00:55:22.519
particles and syntax, the method of connecting propositions and arguments,
915
00:55:22.559 --> 00:55:26.559
of forming all the logic of discourse. For my own part,
916
00:55:26.840 --> 00:55:29.519
I am so scared at the difficulties that multiply it
917
00:55:29.559 --> 00:55:33.079
every step, and so convinced of the almost demonstrated impossibility
918
00:55:33.119 --> 00:55:35.800
of languages owing their birth and establishment to means that
919
00:55:35.800 --> 00:55:38.199
were merely human, That I must leave to whoever may
920
00:55:38.320 --> 00:55:40.599
please to take it up the task of discussing this
921
00:55:40.679 --> 00:55:45.039
difficult problem, which was the most necessary society already formed
922
00:55:45.039 --> 00:55:49.480
to invent languages, or languages already invented to form society.
923
00:55:50.400 --> 00:55:53.480
But be the case of these origins ever so mysterious,
924
00:55:53.519 --> 00:55:55.920
we may at least infer from the little care which
925
00:55:56.000 --> 00:55:58.760
nature has taken to bring men together by mutual wants
926
00:55:59.079 --> 00:56:01.719
and make the use of speech easy to them, how
927
00:56:01.760 --> 00:56:05.119
little she has done towards making them sociable, and how
928
00:56:05.159 --> 00:56:08.199
little she has contributed to anything which they themselves have
929
00:56:08.320 --> 00:56:11.639
done to become so. In fact, it is impossible to
930
00:56:11.679 --> 00:56:15.039
conceive why, in this primitive state one man should have
931
00:56:15.119 --> 00:56:18.000
more occasion for the assistance of another than one monkey
932
00:56:18.519 --> 00:56:20.760
or one wolf, or that of another animal of the
933
00:56:20.800 --> 00:56:25.239
same species, or supposing that he had what motive could
934
00:56:25.239 --> 00:56:29.239
induce another to assist him, or even in this last case,
935
00:56:29.639 --> 00:56:32.880
how he who wanted assistance and he from whom it
936
00:56:32.960 --> 00:56:37.519
was wanted could agree among themselves upon the conditions. Authors
937
00:56:37.559 --> 00:56:40.320
I know are continually telling us that in this state,
938
00:56:40.440 --> 00:56:43.440
man would have been a most miserable creature. And if
939
00:56:43.480 --> 00:56:45.719
it is true as I fancy, I have proved it
940
00:56:46.000 --> 00:56:48.840
that he must have continued many ages without either the
941
00:56:48.920 --> 00:56:52.920
desire or the opportunity of emerging from such a state. This,
942
00:56:53.079 --> 00:56:56.559
their assertion could only serve to justify a charge against nature,
943
00:56:56.880 --> 00:56:59.880
and not against the being which nature had thus constituted.
944
00:57:00.400 --> 00:57:04.199
But if I thoroughly understand this term miserable, it is
945
00:57:04.239 --> 00:57:07.639
a word that either has no meaning or signifies nothing
946
00:57:07.960 --> 00:57:11.639
but a privation attended with pain and a suffering state
947
00:57:11.719 --> 00:57:15.159
of body or soul. Now I would fain know what
948
00:57:15.280 --> 00:57:17.280
kind of misery can be that of a free being
949
00:57:17.320 --> 00:57:20.800
whose heart enjoys perfect peace and body perfect health, and
950
00:57:20.880 --> 00:57:24.000
which is aptis to become insupportable to those who enjoy
951
00:57:24.039 --> 00:57:27.679
it a civil or a natural life. In civil life
952
00:57:27.760 --> 00:57:30.159
we can scarcely meet a single person
who does not
953
00:57:30.239 --> 00:57:33.719
complain of his existence. Many even throw away as much
954
00:57:33.760 --> 00:57:36.360
of it as they can, and the united force of
955
00:57:36.400 --> 00:57:40.079
divine and human laws can hardly put bounds to this disorder.
956
00:57:40.840 --> 00:57:43.320
Was ever any free savage known to have been so
957
00:57:43.480 --> 00:57:46.639
much as tempted to complain of life and lay violent
958
00:57:46.719 --> 00:57:51.039
hands on himself. Let us therefore judge with less pride
959
00:57:51.119 --> 00:57:54.760
on which side real misery is to be placed. Nothing
960
00:57:54.920 --> 00:57:58.400
on the contrary must have been so unhappy as savage man,
961
00:57:58.840 --> 00:58:03.079
dazzled by flashes of knowledge, racked by passions and reasoning
962
00:58:03.159 --> 00:58:05.519
on a state different from that in which he saw
963
00:58:05.639 --> 00:58:09.519
himself placed. It was in consequence of a very wise
964
00:58:09.599 --> 00:58:12.840
providence that the faculties which he potentially enjoyed were not
965
00:58:12.880 --> 00:58:16.039
to develop themselves, but in proportion as their offered occasions
966
00:58:16.079 --> 00:58:19.639
to exercise them, lest they should be superfluous or troublesome
967
00:58:19.719 --> 00:58:22.039
to him when he did not want them, or tardy
968
00:58:22.079 --> 00:58:25.400
and useless when he did. He had, in his instinct
969
00:58:25.400 --> 00:58:28.360
alone everything requisite to live in a state of nature.
970
00:58:28.679 --> 00:58:31.719
In his cultivated reason, he has barely what is necessary
971
00:58:31.760 --> 00:58:35.000
to live in a state of society. It appears at
972
00:58:35.000 --> 00:58:37.320
first sight that as there was no kind of moral
973
00:58:37.360 --> 00:58:40.639
relations between men in this state, nor any known duties,
974
00:58:40.800 --> 00:58:43.239
they could not be either good or bad, and had
975
00:58:43.280 --> 00:58:46.360
neither vices nor virtues, unless we take these words in
976
00:58:46.360 --> 00:58:49.800
a physical sense and call vices in the individual the
977
00:58:49.880 --> 00:58:53.719
qualities which may prove detrimental to his own preservation, and
978
00:58:53.840 --> 00:58:57.199
virtues those which may contribute to it, in which case
979
00:58:57.239 --> 00:58:59.760
we should be obliged to consider him as most virtuous,
980
00:58:59.760 --> 00:59:03.239
who made least resistance against the simple impulses of nature.
981
00:59:03.719 --> 00:59:06.800
But without deviating from the usual meaning of these terms,
982
00:59:07.000 --> 00:59:09.719
it is proper to suspend the judgment we might form
983
00:59:09.800 --> 00:59:12.920
of such a situation, and be upon our guard against
984
00:59:12.920 --> 00:59:16.440
prejudice till the balance in hand. We have examined whether
985
00:59:16.519 --> 00:59:20.400
there are more virtues or vices among civilized men, or
986
00:59:20.440 --> 00:59:24.159
whether the improvement of their understanding is sufficient to compensate
987
00:59:24.199 --> 00:59:27.360
the damages which they mutually do to each other in
988
00:59:27.400 --> 00:59:30.719
proportion as they become better informed of the services which
989
00:59:30.719 --> 00:59:34.400
they ought to do, or whether, upon the whole they
990
00:59:34.440 --> 00:59:37.199
would not be much happier in a condition where they
991
00:59:37.239 --> 00:59:39.480
had nothing to fear or to hope from each other
992
00:59:39.880 --> 00:59:43.320
than in that where they had submitted to a universal subserviency,
993
00:59:43.480 --> 00:59:46.559
and have obliged themselves to depend for everything upon the
994
00:59:46.559 --> 00:59:49.800
goodwill of those who do not think themselves obliged to
995
00:59:49.840 --> 00:59:54.079
give anything in return. But above all things, let us
996
00:59:54.079 --> 00:59:57.239
beware concluding with Hobbes that man, as having no idea
997
00:59:57.280 --> 01:00:01.360
of goodness, must be naturally bad, that he is vicious
998
01:00:01.360 --> 01:00:04.119
because he does not know what virtue is that he
999
01:00:04.239 --> 01:00:06.679
always refuses to do any service to those of his
1000
01:00:06.719 --> 01:00:10.639
own species, because he believes that none is due to them. That,
1001
01:00:11.159 --> 01:00:14.079
in virtue of that right which he justly claims to
1002
01:00:14.159 --> 01:00:17.360
everything he wants, he foolishly looks upon himself as a
1003
01:00:17.400 --> 01:00:21.639
proprietor of the whole universe. Hobbes very plainly saw the
1004
01:00:21.639 --> 01:00:25.519
flaws and all the modern definitions of natural right. But
1005
01:00:25.559 --> 01:00:29.360
the consequences which he draws from his own definition show
1006
01:00:29.440 --> 01:00:33.400
that it is in the sense he understands it equally exceptionable.
1007
01:00:34.400 --> 01:00:37.719
This author, to argue from his own principles, should say
1008
01:00:37.719 --> 01:00:40.760
that the state of nature, being that where the care
1009
01:00:40.840 --> 01:00:44.960
of our own preservation interferes least with the preservation of others,
1010
01:00:45.519 --> 01:00:48.880
was of course the most favorable to peace and most
1011
01:00:48.920 --> 01:00:53.559
suitable to mankind. Whereas he advances the very reverse, in
1012
01:00:53.679 --> 01:00:57.559
consequence of his having injudiciously admitted as objects of that
1013
01:00:57.719 --> 01:01:01.039
care which savage man should take of his present the
1014
01:01:01.079 --> 01:01:04.639
satisfaction of numberless passions, which are the work of society
1015
01:01:05.039 --> 01:01:08.960
and have rendered laws necessary. A bad man says he
1016
01:01:09.440 --> 01:01:13.039
is a robust child, but this is not proving a
1017
01:01:13.039 --> 01:01:16.280
savage man as a robust child. And though we were
1018
01:01:16.360 --> 01:01:19.559
to grant that he was, what could this philosopher
infer
1019
01:01:19.719 --> 01:01:23.280
from such a concession. That if man, when robust, depended
1020
01:01:23.360 --> 01:01:26.000
on others as much as when feeble, there is no
1021
01:01:26.159 --> 01:01:28.880
excess that he would not be guilty of. He would
1022
01:01:28.920 --> 01:01:31.559
make nothing of striking his mother when she delayed ever
1023
01:01:31.639 --> 01:01:34.880
so little to give him the breast. He would claw
1024
01:01:35.000 --> 01:01:37.800
and bite and strangle without remorse the first of his
1025
01:01:37.920 --> 01:01:42.880
younger brothers that ever so accidentally jostled or otherwise disturbed him.
1026
01:01:43.320 --> 01:01:46.760
But these are two contradictory suppositions in the state of nature.
1027
01:01:47.280 --> 01:01:51.280
To be robust and dependent. Man is weak when dependent,
1028
01:01:51.440 --> 01:01:55.119
and his own master before he grows robust. Hobbs did
1029
01:01:55.119 --> 01:01:58.079
not consider that the same cause which hinders savages for
1030
01:01:58.199 --> 01:02:01.159
making use of their reason, as our journy consults pretend,
1031
01:02:01.719 --> 01:02:03.960
hinders them at the same time for making an ill
1032
01:02:04.039 --> 01:02:07.480
use of their faculties, as he him self pretends. So
1033
01:02:07.559 --> 01:02:10.480
that we may say that savages are not bad precisely
1034
01:02:10.519 --> 01:02:12.880
because they don't know what it is to be good.
1035
01:02:13.760 --> 01:02:16.599
For it is neither the development of the understanding, nor
1036
01:02:16.679 --> 01:02:19.159
the curb of the law, but the calmness of their
1037
01:02:19.199 --> 01:02:22.000
passions and their ignorance of vice that hinders them from
1038
01:02:22.000 --> 01:02:28.079
doing ill tantos plus an illus proficit vitiorum ignorantia qualm,
1039
01:02:28.119 --> 01:02:33.280
and his cognito virtutis. There is besides another principle that
1040
01:02:33.320 --> 01:02:36.239
has escaped Hobbes, and which having been given to man
1041
01:02:36.280 --> 01:02:40.000
to moderate on certain occasions, the blind and impetuous sallies
1042
01:02:40.039 --> 01:02:43.639
of self love or the desire of self preservation previous
1043
01:02:43.679 --> 01:02:47.119
to the appearance of that passion, allays the ardor with
1044
01:02:47.239 --> 01:02:51.000
which he naturally pursues his private welfare, by an innate
1045
01:02:51.079 --> 01:02:55.360
abhorrence to seeing being suffer that resemble him. I shall
1046
01:02:55.400 --> 01:02:58.559
not surely be contradicted in granting to man the only
1047
01:02:58.719 --> 01:03:02.840
natural virtue which the most passionate detractor of human virtues
1048
01:03:02.880 --> 01:03:06.360
could not deny him. I mean that of pity, a
1049
01:03:06.440 --> 01:03:10.119
disposition suitable to creatures weak as we are, and libel
1050
01:03:10.119 --> 01:03:13.360
to so many evils, A virtue so much the more
1051
01:03:13.480 --> 01:03:16.679
universal and withal useful to man as it takes place
1052
01:03:16.719 --> 01:03:20.199
in him of all manner of reflection, and so natural
1053
01:03:20.239 --> 01:03:23.519
that the beasts themselves sometimes give evident signs of it,
1054
01:03:24.199 --> 01:03:26.920
not to speak of the tenderness of mothers for their young,
1055
01:03:27.480 --> 01:03:29.840
and of the dangers they face to screen them from
1056
01:03:29.920 --> 01:03:33.639
danger with what reluctance or horses known to trample upon
1057
01:03:33.760 --> 01:03:37.800
living bodies. One animal never passes unmoved by the dead
1058
01:03:37.840 --> 01:03:41.559
carcass of another animal of the same species. There are
1059
01:03:41.679 --> 01:03:44.639
even some who bestow a kind of sepulchure upon their
1060
01:03:44.639 --> 01:03:47.840
dead fellows, and the mournful lowings of cattle on their
1061
01:03:48.000 --> 01:03:51.400
entering the slaughter house. Publish the impression made upon them
1062
01:03:51.440 --> 01:03:54.719
by the horrible spectacle they are there struck with. It
1063
01:03:54.800 --> 01:03:57.360
is with pleasure we see the author of the Fable
1064
01:03:57.400 --> 01:04:00.480
of the Bees forced to acknowledge man a com passionate
1065
01:04:00.519 --> 01:04:04.119
and sensible being, and lay aside in the example he
1066
01:04:04.159 --> 01:04:08.159
offers to confirm it his cold and subtle style, to
1067
01:04:08.239 --> 01:04:11.119
place before us the pathetic picture of a man who,
1068
01:04:11.519 --> 01:04:14.519
with his hands tied up, is obliged to behold a
1069
01:04:14.559 --> 01:04:17.400
beast of prey, tear a child from the arms of
1070
01:04:17.440 --> 01:04:20.719
his mother, and then, with his teeth grind the tender limbs,
1071
01:04:20.719 --> 01:04:23.400
and with his claws rend the throbbing entrails of his
1072
01:04:23.440 --> 01:04:28.079
innocent victim. What horrible emotions must not such a spectator
1073
01:04:28.159 --> 01:04:30.440
experience at the sight of an event which does not
1074
01:04:30.599 --> 01:04:34.760
personally concern him. What anguish must he not suffer at
1075
01:04:34.800 --> 01:04:37.599
his not being able to assist the fainting mother or
1076
01:04:37.639 --> 01:04:42.159
the expiring infant. Such is the pure motion of nature,
1077
01:04:42.280 --> 01:04:45.960
anterior to all manner of reflection, Such the force of
1078
01:04:46.039 --> 01:04:49.199
natural pity, which the most dissolute manners have as yet
1079
01:04:49.239 --> 01:04:52.559
found it so difficult to extinguish. Since we every day
1080
01:04:52.639 --> 01:04:56.400
see in our theatrical representation those men sympathize with the
1081
01:04:56.480 --> 01:04:59.719
unfortunate and weep at their sufferings, who, if in the
1082
01:04:59.760 --> 01:05:03.440
time Yarn's place, would aggravate the torments of their enemies.
1083
01:05:04.400 --> 01:05:07.239
Mandeville was very sensible that men, in spite of all
1084
01:05:07.280 --> 01:05:10.679
their morality,
would never have been better than monsters if
1085
01:05:10.760 --> 01:05:14.239
nature had not given them pity to assist reason. But
1086
01:05:14.320 --> 01:05:16.960
he did not perceive that from this quality alone flow
1087
01:05:17.000 --> 01:05:20.159
all the social virtues which he would dispute mankind the
1088
01:05:20.199 --> 01:05:25.519
possession of. In fact, what is generosity, what clemencye? What humanity?
1089
01:05:25.599 --> 01:05:28.679
But pity applied to the weak, to the guilty, or
1090
01:05:28.719 --> 01:05:33.039
to the human species in general. Even benevolence and friendship,
1091
01:05:33.079 --> 01:05:35.760
if we judge right, will appear the effects of a
1092
01:05:35.800 --> 01:05:40.239
constant pity fixed upon a particular object. For to wish
1093
01:05:40.320 --> 01:05:42.599
that a person may not suffer, What is it but
1094
01:05:42.719 --> 01:05:46.039
to wish that he may be happy? Though it were true,
1095
01:05:46.079 --> 01:05:49.039
the commiseration is no more than a sentiment which puts
1096
01:05:49.119 --> 01:05:52.119
us in the place of him who suffers, a sentiment
1097
01:05:52.159 --> 01:05:56.039
obscure but active in the savage, developed, but dormant and
1098
01:05:56.079 --> 01:05:59.760
civilized man. How could this notion affect the truth of
1099
01:05:59.760 --> 01:06:03.719
what I advance? But to make it more evident? In fact,
1100
01:06:03.800 --> 01:06:07.239
commiseration must be so much, the more energetic, the more intimately.
1101
01:06:07.320 --> 01:06:10.760
The animal that beholds any kind of distress identifies himself
1102
01:06:10.760 --> 01:06:13.280
with the animal that labors under it. Now it is
1103
01:06:13.320 --> 01:06:17.000
evident that this identification must have been infinitely more perfect
1104
01:06:17.079 --> 01:06:19.559
in the state of nature than in the state of reason.
1105
01:06:20.679 --> 01:06:23.639
It is reason that engenders self love and reflection that
1106
01:06:23.719 --> 01:06:27.840
strengthens it. It is reason that makes man shrink into himself.
1107
01:06:28.320 --> 01:06:31.039
It is reason that makes him keep aloof from everything
1108
01:06:31.079 --> 01:06:34.239
that can trouble or afflict him. It is philosophy that
1109
01:06:34.320 --> 01:06:38.039
destroys his connections with other men. It is in consequence
1110
01:06:38.039 --> 01:06:40.480
of her dictates that he mutters to himself at the
1111
01:06:40.519 --> 01:06:44.079
sight of another in distress, you may perish for aught.
1112
01:06:44.119 --> 01:06:48.360
I care. Nothing can hurt me nothing less than those
1113
01:06:48.480 --> 01:06:51.679
evils which threaten the whole species can disturb the calm
1114
01:06:51.719 --> 01:06:54.880
sleep of the philosopher and force him from his bed.
1115
01:06:55.920 --> 01:06:59.719
One man may, with impunity, murder another under his windows.
1116
01:07:00.119 --> 01:07:02.400
He has nothing to do but clap his hands to
1117
01:07:02.440 -->
01:07:05.559
his ears, argue a little with himself, to hinder nature
1118
01:07:05.960 --> 01:07:09.880
that startles within him from identifying him with the unhappy sufferer.
1119
01:07:11.039 --> 01:07:15.119
Savage man wants this admirable talent, and for want of
1120
01:07:15.159 --> 01:07:18.559
wisdom and reason, is always ready foolishly to obey the
1121
01:07:18.599 --> 01:07:22.880
first whispers of humanity. In riots and street brawls, the
1122
01:07:22.920 --> 01:07:27.599
populace flock together, the prudent man sneaks off. They are
1123
01:07:27.639 --> 01:07:30.679
the dregs of the people, the poor, basket and barrow
1124
01:07:30.760 --> 01:07:34.559
women that part the combatants and hinder gentle folks from
1125
01:07:34.599 --> 01:07:39.480
countering one another's throats. It is therefore certain that pity
1126
01:07:39.559 --> 01:07:43.239
is a natural sentiment, which, by moderating in every individual
1127
01:07:43.320 --> 01:07:47.239
the activity of self love, contributes to the mutual preservation
1128
01:07:47.440 --> 01:07:51.199
of the whole species. It is this pity which hurries
1129
01:07:51.280 --> 01:07:54.000
us without reflection to the assistance of those we see
1130
01:07:54.039 --> 01:07:57.000
in distress. It is this pity which, in a state
1131
01:07:57.039 --> 01:08:01.159
of nature stands for laws for manners or virtue, with
1132
01:08:01.199 --> 01:08:04.400
this advantage that no one is tempted to disobey her
1133
01:08:04.440 --> 01:08:08.199
sweet and gentle voice. It is this pity which will
1134
01:08:08.239 --> 01:08:11.760
always hinder or robust savage from plundering a feeble child
1135
01:08:11.880 --> 01:08:15.039
or informal man of the subsistence they have acquired with
1136
01:08:15.119 --> 01:08:18.600
pain and difficulty, if he has but the least prospect
1137
01:08:18.640 --> 01:08:23.000
of providing for himself by any other means. It is
1138
01:08:23.079 --> 01:08:26.760
this pity which, instead of that sublime maxim of argumentative
1139
01:08:26.960 --> 01:08:29.359
justice due to others, as you would have others do
1140
01:08:29.520 --> 01:08:32.720
to you, inspires all men with that other maxim of
1141
01:08:32.800 --> 01:08:36.760
natural goodness, a great deal less perfect, but perhaps more useful.
1142
01:08:37.319 --> 01:08:40.319
Consult your own happiness with as little prejudice as you
1143
01:08:40.439 --> 01:08:43.279
can to that of others. It is, in a word,
1144
01:08:43.479 --> 01:08:47.399
in this natural sentiment, rather than in fine spun arguments,
1145
01:08:47.439 --> 01:08:50.119
that we must look for the cause of that reluctance
1146
01:08:50.119 --> 01:08:54.279
which every man would experience to do evil, even independently
1147
01:08:54.359 --> 01:08:58.439
of the maxims of education. Though it may be the
1148
01:08:58.439 --> 01:09:02.199
peculiar happiness of Soctcrates and other geniuses of this stamp
1149
01:09:02.520 --> 01:09:06.319
to reason themselves into virtue, the human species would long
1150
01:09:06.319 --> 01:09:09.479
ago have ceased to exist, had it depended entirely for
1151
01:09:09.520 --> 01:09:13.119
its preservation on the reasonings of the individuals that compose it.
1152
01:09:13.920 --> 01:09:17.520
With passions so tame and so salutary occur men rather
1153
01:09:17.640 --> 01:09:20.920
wild than wicked, and more attentive to guard against mischief
1154
01:09:21.079 --> 01:09:24.079
than to do any to other. Animals were not exposed
1155
01:09:24.079 --> 01:09:28.000
to any dangerous dissensions, as they kept up no manner
1156
01:09:28.039 --> 01:09:31.000
of correspondence with each other, and were of course strangers
1157
01:09:31.000 --> 01:09:34.600
to vanity, to respect, to esteem, to contempt, as they
1158
01:09:34.600 --> 01:09:37.079
had no notion of what we call mume and tomb,
1159
01:09:37.600 --> 01:09:41.359
nor any true idea of justice. As they considered any
1160
01:09:41.439 --> 01:09:43.760
violence they were liable to as an evil that could
1161
01:09:43.760 --> 01:09:47.000
be easily repaired, and not as an injury that deserved punishment.
1162
01:09:47.479 --> 01:09:49.840
And as they never so much as dreamed of revenge,
1163
01:09:49.920 --> 01:09:54.119
unless perhaps mechanically and unpremeditatedly, as a dog who bites
1164
01:09:54.159 --> 01:09:57.039
the stone that has been thrown at him, their disputes
1165
01:09:57.039 --> 01:10:00.199
could seldom be attended with bloodshed, were they never are
1166
01:10:00.199 --> 01:10:03.880
occasioned by a more considerable stake than that of subsistence.
1167
01:10:04.880 --> 01:10:07.680
But there is a more dangerous subject of contention which
1168
01:10:07.720 --> 01:10:12.199
I must not leave unnoticed. Among the passions which ruffle
1169
01:10:12.239 --> 01:10:14.880
the heart of man. There is one of a hot
1170
01:10:14.920 --> 01:10:18.920
and impetuous nature, which renders the sexes necessary to each other,
1171
01:10:19.239 --> 01:10:23.880
a terrible passion, which despises all dangers, bears down all obstacles,
1172
01:10:24.079 --> 01:10:26.760
and to which, in its transports it seems proper to
1173
01:10:26.840 --> 01:10:29.800
destroy the human species which it is destined to preserve.
1174
01:10:30.640 --> 01:10:33.239
What must become of men abandoned to this lawless and
1175
01:10:33.319 --> 01:10:37.920
brutal rage, without modesty, without shame, and every day disputing
1176
01:10:37.920 --> 01:10:40.560
the objects of their passion at the expense of their blood.
1177
01:10:42.239 --> 01:10:44.319
We must, in the first place, allow that the more
1178
01:10:44.399 --> 01:10:47.640
violent of the passions, the more necessary are laws to
1179
01:10:47.680 --> 01:10:51.520
restrain them. But besides that, the disorders and the crimes
1180
01:10:51.560 --> 01:10:54.560
to which these passions daily give rise among us sufficiently
1181
01:10:54.600 --> 01:10:57.720
grow of the insufficiency of
laws for that purpose. We
1182
01:10:57.720 --> 01:10:59.720
would do well to look back a little further and
1183
01:10:59.720 --> 01:11:02.399
again examine if these evils did not spring up with
1184
01:11:02.479 --> 01:11:06.000
the laws themselves. For at this rate, though the laws
1185
01:11:06.000 --> 01:11:08.960
were capable of oppressing these evils, it is the least
1186
01:11:09.000 --> 01:11:11.520
that might be expected from them, seeing it is no
1187
01:11:11.640 --> 01:11:14.359
more than stopping the progress of a mischief which they
1188
01:11:14.439 --> 01:11:19.279
themselves have produced. Let us begin by distinguishing between what
1189
01:11:19.439 --> 01:11:21.960
is moral and what is physical, and the passion called love.
1190
01:11:24.640 --> 01:11:27.079
The physical part of it is that general desire which
1191
01:11:27.119 --> 01:11:29.880
prompts the sexes to unite with each other. The moral
1192
01:11:29.960 --> 01:11:32.720
part is that which determines that desire and fixes it
1193
01:11:32.800 --> 01:11:35.680
upon a particular object to the exclusion of all others,
1194
01:11:36.119 --> 01:11:38.399
or at least gives it a greater degree of energy
1195
01:11:38.479 --> 01:11:41.840
for this preferred object. Now, it is easy to perceive
1196
01:11:41.960 --> 01:11:44.880
that the moral part of love is a factitious sentiment,
1197
01:11:45.159 --> 01:11:47.960
engendered by society and cried up by the women with
1198
01:11:48.039 --> 01:11:51.399
great care and address, in order to establish their empire
1199
01:11:51.520 --> 01:11:54.600
and secure command to that sex which ought to obey.
1200
01:11:55.399 --> 01:11:58.720
This sentiment, being founded on certain notions of beauty and
1201
01:11:58.800 --> 01:12:01.800
merit which are savage is not capable of having, and
1202
01:12:01.920 --> 01:12:05.239
upon comparisons which he is not capable of making, can
1203
01:12:05.279 --> 01:12:09.039
scarcely exist in him. For as his mind was never
1204
01:12:09.119 --> 01:12:12.640
in a condition to form abstract ideas of regularity and proportion,
1205
01:12:13.239 --> 01:12:17.720
neither is his heart susceptible of sentiments of admiration and love, which,
1206
01:12:17.960 --> 01:12:21.399
even without our perceiving it, are produced by our application
1207
01:12:21.560 --> 01:12:26.359
of these ideas. He listens solely to the dispositions implanted
1208
01:12:26.359 --> 01:12:28.760
in him by nature and not to taste which he
1209
01:12:28.800 --> 01:12:31.800
never was in a way of acquiring. And every woman
1210
01:12:31.880 --> 01:12:36.760
answers his purpose confined entirely to what is physical in love,
1211
01:12:36.920 --> 01:12:40.119
and happy enough not to know these preferences, which sharpen
1212
01:12:40.199 --> 01:12:42.920
the appetite for it, at the same time that they
1213
01:12:42.960 --> 01:12:46.840
increase the difficulty of satisfying such appetite. Men in a
1214
01:12:46.840 --> 01:12:49.800
state of nature must be subject to fewer and less
1215
01:12:49.880 --> 01:12:52.720
violent fits of that passion, and of course there must
1216
01:12:52.800 --> 01:12:55.800
be fewer and less violent disputes among them in consequence
1217
01:12:55.800 --> 01:12:59.800
of it. The imagination which causes so many ravages of
1218
01:12:59.840 --> 01:13:03.159
mine us never speaks to the heart of savages, who
1219
01:13:03.199 --> 01:13:06.720
peaceably wait for the impulses of nature, yield to these
1220
01:13:06.760 --> 01:13:10.520
impulses without choice, and with more pleasure than fury, and
1221
01:13:10.560 --> 01:13:16.319
whose desires never outlive their necessity for the thing desired. Nothing, therefore,
1222
01:13:16.399 --> 01:13:19.600
can be more evident than that it is society alone
1223
01:13:19.600 --> 01:13:22.399
which has added even to love itself, as well as
1224
01:13:22.439 --> 01:13:26.239
to all the other passions that impetuous ardor which so
1225
01:13:26.359 --> 01:13:29.800
often renders its fatal to mankind. And it is so
1226
01:13:29.920 --> 01:13:34.000
much the more ridiculous to represent savages constantly murdering each
1227
01:13:34.039 --> 01:13:37.840
other to glut their brutality, as this opinion is diametrically
1228
01:13:37.920 --> 01:13:41.720
opposite to experience, and the Caribbeans, the people in the
1229
01:13:41.760 --> 01:13:44.560
world who have as yet deviated least from the state
1230
01:13:44.600 --> 01:13:47.880
of nature, are, to all intents and purposes, the most
1231
01:13:47.920 --> 01:13:51.600
peaceable in their amors, and the least subject to jealousy,
1232
01:13:51.960 --> 01:13:54.680
though they live in a burning climate, which seems always
1233
01:13:54.720 --> 01:13:59.640
to add considerably to the activity of these passions. As
1234
01:13:59.680 --> 01:14:02.560
to the inductions which may be drawn in respect to
1235
01:14:02.640 --> 01:14:05.800
several species of animals from the battles of the males,
1236
01:14:05.880 --> 01:14:08.960
who in all seasons cover our poultry yards with blood,
1237
01:14:10.079 --> 01:14:13.079
and in spring particularly cause our force to ring again
1238
01:14:13.159 --> 01:14:16.399
with the noise they make in disputing their females, we
1239
01:14:16.520 --> 01:14:20.000
must begin by excluding all those species where nature has
1240
01:14:20.039 --> 01:14:24.319
evidently established and the relative power of the sexes relations
1241
01:14:24.359 --> 01:14:28.000
different from those which exist among us. Thus, from the
1242
01:14:28.039 --> 01:14:30.760
battle of cocks we can form no induction that will
1243
01:14:30.760 --> 01:14:34.840
affect the human species. In the species where the proportion
1244
01:14:35.039 --> 01:14:38.239
is better observed, these battles must be owing entirely to
1245
01:14:38.319 --> 01:14:41.520
the fewness of the females compared with the males, or
1246
01:14:41.720 --> 01:14:44.760
which is all one, to the
exclusive intervals during which
1247
01:14:44.800 --> 01:14:48.479
the females constantly refuse the addresses of the males. For
1248
01:14:48.560 --> 01:14:51.239
if the female admits the male but two months in
1249
01:14:51.279 --> 01:14:53.439
the year, it is all the same as if the
1250
01:14:53.520 --> 01:14:56.000
number of females were five to six less than what
1251
01:14:56.079 --> 01:14:59.680
it is now. Neither of these cases is applicable to
1252
01:14:59.680 --> 01:15:03.640
the hugehuman species, where the number of females generally surpasses
1253
01:15:03.760 --> 01:15:06.199
that of the males, and where it has never been
1254
01:15:06.239 --> 01:15:09.920
observed that, even among savages, the females had, like those
1255
01:15:09.960 --> 01:15:14.680
of other animals, stated times of passion and indifference. Besides,
1256
01:15:14.720 --> 01:15:17.960
among several of these animals, the whole species takes fire
1257
01:15:18.079 --> 01:15:20.920
all at once, and for some days nothing is to
1258
01:15:20.960 --> 01:15:24.600
be seen among them but confusion, tumult, disorder, and bloodshed,
1259
01:15:25.159 --> 01:15:27.840
a state unknown to the human species, where love is
1260
01:15:27.880 --> 01:15:31.800
never periodical. We can not therefore conclude from the battles
1261
01:15:31.840 --> 01:15:34.760
of certain animals for the possession of their females that
1262
01:15:34.840 --> 01:15:36.600
the same would be the case of man in a
1263
01:15:36.640 --> 01:15:40.199
state of nature. And though we might, as these contests
1264
01:15:40.279 --> 01:15:43.760
do not destroy the other species, there is at least
1265
01:15:43.800 --> 01:15:47.600
equal room to think they would not be fatal to ours. Nay,
1266
01:15:47.800 --> 01:15:51.039
it is very probable that they would cause fewer ravages
1267
01:15:51.079 --> 01:15:55.600
than they do in society. Especially in those countries where morality,
1268
01:15:55.720 --> 01:15:58.840
being as yet held in some esteem, the jealousy of
1269
01:15:58.920 --> 01:16:03.640
lovers and the vengeance of husbands every day produced duels, murders,
1270
01:16:03.640 --> 01:16:07.039
and even worse crimes, where the duty of an eternal
1271
01:16:07.039 --> 01:16:11.159
fidelity serves only to propagate adultery, and the very laws
1272
01:16:11.199 --> 01:16:14.960
of continence and honor necessarily contribute to the increase of
1273
01:16:15.039 --> 01:16:21.600
dissoluteness and multiply abortions. Let us conclude that savage man
1274
01:16:21.760 --> 01:16:26.079
wandering about in the forests, without industry, without speech, without
1275
01:16:26.119 --> 01:16:29.760
any fixed residence, an equal stranger to war in every
1276
01:16:29.800 --> 01:16:33.479
social connection, without standing in any shape in need of
1277
01:16:33.520 --> 01:16:36.920
his fellows, as well as without any desire of hurting them,
1278
01:16:37.319 --> 01:16:41.319
and perhaps even without ever distinguishing
them individually from one another,
1279
01:16:42.039 --> 01:16:45.800
subject to few passions, and finding in himself all he wants,
1280
01:16:46.479 --> 01:16:50.159
let us I say, conclude that savage man thus circumstanced
1281
01:16:50.600 --> 01:16:54.039
had no knowledge or sentiment but such as are proper
1282
01:16:54.079 --> 01:16:57.439
to that condition, that he was alone sensible of his
1283
01:16:57.560 --> 01:17:01.319
real necessities, took notice of nothing but what it was
1284
01:17:01.359 --> 01:17:04.520
his interest to see, and that his understanding made as
1285
01:17:04.520 --> 01:17:08.359
little progress as his vanity. If he happened to make
1286
01:17:08.399 --> 01:17:11.640
any discovery he could the less communicate it, as he
1287
01:17:11.720 --> 01:17:15.359
did not even know his children. The art perished with
1288
01:17:15.439 --> 01:17:21.039
the inventor. There is neither education nor improvement. Generations succeeded
1289
01:17:21.079 --> 01:17:25.239
generations to no purpose, and as all constantly set out
1290
01:17:25.279 --> 01:17:28.720
from the same point, whole centuries rolled on. In the
1291
01:17:28.800 --> 01:17:32.560
rudeness and barbarity of the first age, the species was
1292
01:17:32.640 --> 01:17:35.800
grown old, while the individual still remained in a state
1293
01:17:35.880 --> 01:17:39.960
of childhood. If I have enlarged so much upon the
1294
01:17:40.000 --> 01:17:43.479
supposition of this primitive condition, it is because I thought
1295
01:17:43.520 --> 01:17:47.960
it my duty, considering what ancient errors and inveterate prejudices
1296
01:17:48.000 --> 01:17:51.239
I have to extirpate, to dig to the very roots
1297
01:17:51.560 --> 01:17:54.439
and show in a true picture of the state of nature,
1298
01:17:54.840 --> 01:17:58.439
how much even natural inequality falls short in the state
1299
01:17:58.479 --> 01:18:02.079
of that reality and inflaences which our writers ascribe to it.
1300
01:18:03.720 --> 01:18:07.079
In fact, we may easily perceive that among the differences
1301
01:18:07.119 --> 01:18:10.920
which distinguish men several paths for natural which are merely
1302
01:18:10.960 --> 01:18:13.760
the work of habit and the different kinds of life
1303
01:18:13.840 --> 01:18:17.479
adopted by man living in a social way. Thus, a
1304
01:18:17.600 --> 01:18:21.600
robust or delicate constitution, and the strength and weakness which
1305
01:18:21.640 --> 01:18:24.960
depend upon it are oftener produced by the hardy or
1306
01:18:25.000 --> 01:18:27.960
effeminate manner in which a man has been brought up
1307
01:18:28.279 --> 01:18:32.359
than by the primitive constitution of his body, it is
1308
01:18:32.399 --> 01:18:35.199
the same. Thus, in regard to the forces of the mind,
1309
01:18:35.680 --> 01:18:39.159
an education not only produces a difference between those minds
1310
01:18:39.159 --> 01:18:42.359
which are cultivated and those which are not, but even
1311
01:18:42.359 --> 01:18:45.479
increases that which is found among the first in proportion
1312
01:18:45.640 --> 01:18:48.920
to their culture. For let a giant and a dwarf
1313
01:18:49.000 --> 01:18:51.640
set out in the same path. The giant, at every
1314
01:18:51.680 --> 01:18:55.880
step will acquire a new advantage over the dwarf. Now,
1315
01:18:55.920 --> 01:18:59.199
if we compare the prodigious variety in the education and
1316
01:18:59.319 --> 01:19:02.279
manner of life of the different orders of men in
1317
01:19:02.319 --> 01:19:06.199
a civil state with the simplicity and uniformity that prevails
1318
01:19:06.479 --> 01:19:10.039
in the animal and savage life, where all the individuals
1319
01:19:10.119 --> 01:19:13.520
make use of the same ailments, live in the same manner,
1320
01:19:13.800 --> 01:19:17.439
and do exactly the same things, we shall easily conceive
1321
01:19:17.560 --> 01:19:19.960
how much the difference between man and man in the
1322
01:19:20.000 --> 01:19:22.680
state of nature must be less than in the state
1323
01:19:22.720 --> 01:19:27.079
of society, and how much every inequality of institution must
1324
01:19:27.079 --> 01:19:33.199
increase the natural inequalities of the human species. But though nature,
1325
01:19:33.359 --> 01:19:36.560
in the distribution of her gifts, should really affect all
1326
01:19:36.600 --> 01:19:40.319
the preferences that are ascribed to her. What advantage could
1327
01:19:40.319 --> 01:19:43.720
the most favored derive from her partiality to the prejudice
1328
01:19:43.720 --> 01:19:46.359
of others? In a state of things which scarce admitted
1329
01:19:46.439 --> 01:19:50.199
any kind of relation between her pupils. Of what service
1330
01:19:50.239 --> 01:19:53.680
can beauty be where there is no love? What will
1331
01:19:53.680 --> 01:19:57.199
wit avail? People who don't speak or craft, those who
1332
01:19:57.239 --> 01:20:02.159
have no affairs to transact, are constantly crying out that
1333
01:20:02.239 --> 01:20:05.439
the strongest would oppress the weakest. But let them explain
1334
01:20:05.560 --> 01:20:08.720
what they mean by the word oppression. One man will
1335
01:20:08.800 --> 01:20:12.119
rule with violence, another will groan under a constant subjection
1336
01:20:12.239 --> 01:20:15.760
to all his caprices. This is indeed precisely what I
1337
01:20:15.800 --> 01:20:18.560
observe among us. But I don't see how it can
1338
01:20:18.600 --> 01:20:22.000
be said of savage men, into whose heads it would
1339
01:20:22.039 --> 01:20:24.520
be a harder matter to drive even the meaning of
1340
01:20:24.560 --> 01:20:29.199
the words domination and servitude. One man might indeed seize
1341
01:20:29.239 --> 01:20:32.119
on the fruits which another had gathered, on the game
1342
01:20:32.199 --> 01:20:35.439
which another had killed, on the cavern which another had
1343
01:20:35.479 --> 01:20:39.319
occupied for shelter. But how is it possible he should
1344
01:20:39.319 --> 01:20:43.359
ever exact obedience from him? And what chains of dependence
1345
01:20:43.399 --> 01:20:46.760
can there be among men who possess nothing? If I
1346
01:20:46.800 --> 01:20:49.359
am driven from one tree, I have nothing to do
1347
01:20:49.439 --> 01:20:52.560
but look out for another. If one place has made
1348
01:20:52.560 --> 01:20:55.640
it uneasy to me, what can hinder me from taking
1349
01:20:55.720 --> 01:20:59.880
up my quarters elsewhere? But suppose I should meet a
1350
01:21:00.119 --> 01:21:03.039
man so much superior to me in strength and withal
1351
01:21:03.159 --> 01:21:07.159
so wicked, so lazy, and so barbarous as to oblige
1352
01:21:07.199 --> 01:21:10.079
me to provide for his substance while he remains idle.
1353
01:21:11.000 --> 01:21:13.279
He must resolve not to take his eyes from me
1354
01:21:13.359 --> 01:21:16.680
a single moment, to bind me fast before he can
1355
01:21:16.720 --> 01:21:19.479
take the least nap, lest I should kill him or
1356
01:21:19.479 --> 01:21:22.800
give him the slip during his sleep. That is to say,
1357
01:21:23.239 --> 01:21:26.680
he must expose himself voluntarily to much greater troubles than
1358
01:21:26.720 --> 01:21:29.760
what he seeks to avoid than any he gives me.
1359
01:21:30.840 --> 01:21:33.760
And after all, let him abate ever so little of
1360
01:21:33.800 --> 01:21:37.119
his vigilance. Let him, at some sudden noise but turn
1361
01:21:37.199 --> 01:21:40.760
his head another way. I am already buried in the forest.
1362
01:21:40.840 --> 01:21:43.520
My fetters are broke, and he never sees me again.
1363
01:21:44.800 --> 01:21:49.359
But without insisting any longer upon these details, everyone must
1364
01:21:49.399 --> 01:21:52.439
see that as the bonds of servitude are formed merely
1365
01:21:52.479 --> 01:21:56.039
by the mutual dependence of men one upon another, and
1366
01:21:56.079 --> 01:21:59.800
there reciprocal necessities which unite them. It is impossible for
1367
01:21:59.800 --> 01:22:03.640
one man to enslave another without having first reduced him
1368
01:22:03.680 --> 01:22:06.239
to a condition in which he cannot live without the
1369
01:22:06.359 --> 01:22:10.479
enslaver's assistance, a condition which, as it does not exist
1370
01:22:10.520 --> 01:22:13.359
in a state of nature, must leave every man his
1371
01:22:13.439 --> 01:22:17.039
own master, and render the law of the strongest altogether
1372
01:22:17.159 --> 01:22:22.079
vain and useless. Having proved that the inequality which may
1373
01:22:22.119 --> 01:22:24.840
subsist between man and man in a state of nature
1374
01:22:25.159 --> 01:22:29.039
is almost imperceivable, and that it has very little influence,
1375
01:22:29.600 --> 01:22:32.520
I must now proceed to show its origin and trace
1376
01:22:32.560 --> 01:22:36.119
its progress in the successive developments of the human mind.
1377
01:22:37.279 --> 01:22:41.439
After having showed that perfectibility, the social virtues and the
1378
01:22:41.479 --> 01:22:46.079
other faculties which natural man had received in potentia could
1379
01:22:46.079 --> 01:22:49.680
never be developed of themselves. That for that purpose there
1380
01:22:49.720 --> 01:22:53.760
is a necessity for the fortuitous concurrence of several foreign causes,
1381
01:22:54.000 --> 01:22:56.680
which might never happen, and without which he must have
1382
01:22:56.800 --> 01:23:00.319
eternally remained in his primitive condition. I must persus seed
1383
01:23:00.399 --> 01:23:03.760
to consider and bring together the different accidents which may
1384
01:23:03.800 --> 01:23:08.359
have perfected the human understanding by debasing the species, render
1385
01:23:08.359 --> 01:23:11.319
a being wicked, by rendering him sociable, and from so
1386
01:23:11.439 --> 01:23:14.119
remote a term bring man at last in the world
1387
01:23:14.199 --> 01:23:17.840
to the point in which we now see them. I
1388
01:23:17.960 --> 01:23:20.319
must own that, as the events I am about to
1389
01:23:20.319 --> 01:23:24.039
describe might have happened many different ways, my choice of
1390
01:23:24.079 --> 01:23:26.520
these I shall assign, can be grounded on nothing but
1391
01:23:26.600 --> 01:23:30.640
mere conjecture. But besides these conjectures becoming reasons when they
1392
01:23:30.680 --> 01:23:33.159
are not only the most probable that can be drawn
1393
01:23:33.199 --> 01:23:35.760
from the nature of things, but the only means we
1394
01:23:35.760 --> 01:23:39.159
can have of discovering truth. The consequences I mean to
1395
01:23:39.199 --> 01:23:43.800
deduce from mine will not be merely conjectural, since on
1396
01:23:43.880 --> 01:23:47.039
the principles I have just established, it is impossible to
1397
01:23:47.079 --> 01:23:50.000
form any other system that would not supply me with
1398
01:23:50.039 --> 01:23:52.800
the same results, and from which I might not draw
1399
01:23:52.880 --> 01:23:56.880
the same conclusions. This will authorize me to be the
1400
01:23:56.880 --> 01:23:59.680
more concise in my reflections on the manner in which
1401
01:23:59.680 --> 01:24:02.079
the last gaps of time makes amends for the little
1402
01:24:02.159 --> 01:24:06.680
versimilitude of events, On the surprising power of very trivial
1403
01:24:06.760 --> 01:24:11.560
causes when they act without intermission, On the impossibility there is,
1404
01:24:11.760 --> 01:24:15.039
on the one hand, of destroying certain hypotheses, if on
1405
01:24:15.079 --> 01:24:17.960
the other we cannot give them the degree of certainty
1406
01:24:18.039 --> 01:24:21.800
which facts must be allowed to possess. On its being.
1407
01:24:21.880 --> 01:24:25.399
The business of history when two facts are proposed as
1408
01:24:25.479 --> 01:24:29.159
real to be connected by a chain of intermediate facts
1409
01:24:29.159 --> 01:24:32.479
which are either unknown or considered as such, to
furnish
1410
01:24:32.520 --> 01:24:36.359
such facts as may actually connect them, and the business
1411
01:24:36.359 --> 01:24:40.079
of philosophy when history is silent to point out similar
1412
01:24:40.119 --> 01:24:43.840
facts which may answer the same purpose. In fine on
1413
01:24:43.920 --> 01:24:48.680
the privilege of similitude in regard to events, to reduce
1414
01:24:48.800 --> 01:24:51.880
facts to a much smaller number of different classes than
1415
01:24:52.000 --> 01:24:56.119
is generally imagined. It suffices me to offer these objects
1416
01:24:56.199 --> 01:24:59.680
to the consideration of my judges. It suffices me to
1417
01:24:59.760 --> 01:25:02.520
have conducted by inquiry in such a manner as to
1418
01:25:02.600 --> 01:25:10.439
save common readers the trouble of considering them. End of discourse,
1419
01:25:10.560 --> 01:25:22.079
first part, section five of the Discourse on Inequality by
1420
01:25:22.159 --> 01:25:28.720
Jean Jacques Rousseau. This is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox
1421
01:25:28.760 --> 01:25:32.840
recordings are in the public domain. For more information or
1422
01:25:32.880 --> 01:25:38.000
to volunteer, please visit LibriVox dot org. This reading is
1423
01:25:38.039 --> 01:25:41.479
by Eric Jonas. A Discourse upon the Origin and the
1424
01:25:41.479 --> 01:25:45.960
foundation of the Inequality among Mankind by Jean Jacques Rousseau.
1425
01:25:47.119 --> 01:25:53.920
Discourse second part Section one. The first man who, after
1426
01:25:54.039 --> 01:25:56.640
enclosing a piece of ground took it into his head
1427
01:25:56.640 --> 01:26:00.479
to say this is mine, and found people simple enough
1428
01:26:00.520 --> 01:26:04.000
to believe him was the true founder of civil society.
1429
01:26:05.239 --> 01:26:08.920
How many crimes, how many wars, how many murders, how
1430
01:26:08.960 --> 01:26:12.079
many misfortunes and horrors would that man have saved? The
1431
01:26:12.159 --> 01:26:15.600
human species? Who pulling up the stakes or filling up
1432
01:26:15.640 --> 01:26:19.079
the ditches should have cried to his fellows. Be sure
1433
01:26:19.119 --> 01:26:22.640
not to listen to this imposture. You are lost if
1434
01:26:22.680 --> 01:26:25.199
you forget that the fruits of the earth belong equally
1435
01:26:25.239 --> 01:26:29.199
to us all, and the earth itself to nobody. But
1436
01:26:29.359 --> 01:26:32.560
it is highly probable that things were now come to
1437
01:26:32.600 --> 01:26:35.479
such a pass that they could not continue much longer
1438
01:26:35.520 --> 01:26:38.840
in the same way. For as this idea of property
1439
01:26:38.880 --> 01:26:42.960
depends on several prior ideas, which could only spring up gradually,
1440
01:26:43.000 --> 01:26:45.960
one after another, it was not formed all at once
1441
01:26:46.079 --> 01:26:49.640
in the human mind. Men must have made great progress.
1442
01:26:49.880 --> 01:26:52.840
They must have acquired a great stock of industry and knowledge,
1443
01:26:53.039 --> 01:26:56.319
and transmitted and increased it from age to age before
1444
01:26:56.359 --> 01:26:58.920
they could arrive at this last term of the state
1445
01:26:58.960 --> 01:27:02.479
of nature. Let us therefore take up things a little
1446
01:27:02.560 --> 01:27:05.800
higher and collect into one point of view and in
1447
01:27:05.880 --> 01:27:09.680
their most natural order. This slow succession of events and
1448
01:27:09.760 --> 01:27:14.279
mental improvements. The first sentiment of man was that of
1449
01:27:14.319 --> 01:27:18.479
his existence, his first care that of preserving it. The
1450
01:27:18.520 --> 01:27:22.359
productions of the earth yielded him all the assistance he required.
1451
01:27:22.960 --> 01:27:26.520
Instinct prompted him to make use of them. Among the
1452
01:27:26.600 --> 01:27:30.359
various appetites which made him, at different times experience different
1453
01:27:30.479 --> 01:27:33.640
modes of existence, there was one that excited him to
1454
01:27:33.680 --> 01:27:38.319
perpetuate his species. And this blind propensity, quite void of
1455
01:27:38.359 --> 01:27:41.840
anything like pure love or affection, produced nothing but an
1456
01:27:41.880 --> 01:27:45.640
act that was merely animal. The present heat. Once allaid,
1457
01:27:46.000 --> 01:27:48.840
the sexes took no further notice of each other, and
1458
01:27:48.960 --> 01:27:51.520
even the child ceased to have any tie to his
1459
01:27:51.600 --> 01:27:55.840
mother the moment he ceased to want her assistance. Such
1460
01:27:55.960 --> 01:27:58.720
was the condition of the infant man. Such was the
1461
01:27:58.760 --> 01:28:01.960
life of an animal, confine at first to pure sensations,
1462
01:28:02.800 --> 01:28:05.680
and so far from harboring any thought of forcing her
1463
01:28:05.760 --> 01:28:09.199
gifts from nature, that he scarcely availed himself of those
1464
01:28:09.279 --> 01:28:12.800
which she offered to him of her own accord. But
1465
01:28:12.880 --> 01:28:16.600
difficulty soon arose, and there is a necessity for learning
1466
01:28:16.640 --> 01:28:20.119
how to surmount them. The height of some trees which
1467
01:28:20.159 --> 01:28:23.960
prevented his reaching their fruits. The competition of other animals
1468
01:28:24.000 --> 01:28:27.520
equally fond of the same fruits, the fierceness of many
1469
01:28:27.560 --> 01:28:30.319
that even aimed at his life. These were so many
1470
01:28:30.359 --> 01:28:35.319
circumstances which obliged him to apply to bodily exercise. There
1471
01:28:35.359 --> 01:28:39.079
is a necessity for becoming active, swift, footed, and sturdy
1472
01:28:39.119 --> 01:28:42.840
in battle. The natural arms, which are stones in the
1473
01:28:42.880 --> 01:28:47.479
branches of trees, soon offered themselves to his assistance. He
1474
01:28:47.600 --> 01:28:51.159
learned to surmount the obstacles of nature, to contend, in
1475
01:28:51.199 --> 01:28:54.680
the case of necessity with other animals, to dispute his
1476
01:28:54.760 --> 01:28:58.960
subsistence even with other men, or indemnify himself for the
1477
01:28:59.000 --> 01:29:01.760
loss of whatever he found found himself obliged to part
1478
01:29:01.800 --> 01:29:06.119
with the strongest in proportion. As the human species grew
1479
01:29:06.199 --> 01:29:11.319
more numerous and extended itself, its pains likewise multiplied and increased.
1480
01:29:12.119 --> 01:29:15.880
The difference of soils, climates, and seasons might have forced
1481
01:29:15.920 --> 01:29:18.439
men to observe some difference in their way of living.
1482
01:29:19.199 --> 01:29:23.439
Bad harvests, long and severe winters, and scorching summers, which
1483
01:29:23.479 --> 01:29:26.800
parched up all the fruits of the earth, required extraordinary
1484
01:29:26.840 --> 01:29:31.479
exertions of industry on the seashore and the banks of rivers.
1485
01:29:31.680 --> 01:29:34.560
They invented the line and the hook, and became fishermen
1486
01:29:34.600 --> 01:29:38.960
and achthophagus. In the forests, they made themselves bows and arrows,
1487
01:29:39.199 --> 01:29:42.920
and became huntsmen and warriors. In the cold countries, they
1488
01:29:42.960 --> 01:29:45.880
covered themselves with the skins of the beasts they had killed.
1489
01:29:46.319 --> 01:29:50.239
Thunder of volcano, or some happy accident made them acquainted
1490
01:29:50.279 --> 01:29:53.680
with fire, a new resource against the rigors of winter.
1491
01:29:54.399 --> 01:29:57.840
They discovered the method of preserving this element, then that
1492
01:29:58.000 --> 01:30:01.399
of reproducing it, and lastly the way of preparing it
1493
01:30:01.439 --> 01:30:05.319
with the flesh of animals, which heretofore they devoured raw
1494
01:30:05.399 --> 01:30:09.880
from the carcass. This reiterated application of various beings to
1495
01:30:09.960 --> 01:30:14.119
himself and to one another must have naturally engendered in
1496
01:30:14.159 --> 01:30:17.800
the mind of man the idea of certain relations. These
1497
01:30:17.840 --> 01:30:24.680
relations which we expressed by the words great, little, strong, weak, swift, slow, fearful, bold,
1498
01:30:24.760 --> 01:30:29.399
in the like compared occasionally, and almost without thinking of it,
1499
01:30:29.520 --> 01:30:32.920
produced in him some kind of reflection, or rather a
1500
01:30:32.960 --> 01:30:37.000
mechanical prudence, which pointed out to him the precautions most
1501
01:30:37.079 --> 01:30:42.079
essential to his preservation and safety. The new lights resulting
1502
01:30:42.119 --> 01:30:46.239
from this development increased his superiority over other animals by
1503
01:30:46.279 --> 01:30:49.880
making him sensible of it. He laid himself out to
1504
01:30:50.000 --> 01:30:54.079
ensnare them. He played them a thousand tricks, and though
1505
01:30:54.199 --> 01:30:57.880
several surpassed
him in strength or in swiftness, he in
1506
01:30:58.000 --> 01:31:00.279
time became the master of those that could be of
1507
01:31:00.279 --> 01:31:03.319
any service to him, and a sore enemy to those
1508
01:31:03.399 --> 01:31:06.720
that could do him any mischief. Tis thus that the
1509
01:31:06.720 --> 01:31:09.680
first look he gave into himself produced the first emotion
1510
01:31:09.800 --> 01:31:12.920
of pride in him. Tis thus that at a time
1511
01:31:13.000 --> 01:31:15.960
he scarce knew how to distinguish between the different ranks
1512
01:31:15.960 --> 01:31:19.279
of existence. By attributing to his species the first rank
1513
01:31:19.319 --> 01:31:22.920
among animals in general, he prepared himself at a distance
1514
01:31:23.039 --> 01:31:26.279
to pretend to it as an individual among those of
1515
01:31:26.319 --> 01:31:30.479
his own species. In particular, though other men were not
1516
01:31:30.600 --> 01:31:34.000
to him what they are to us, and he had
1517
01:31:34.039 --> 01:31:37.560
scarce more intercourse with them than with other animals, they
1518
01:31:37.600 --> 01:31:41.960
were not overlooked in his observations. The conformities which in
1519
01:31:42.079 --> 01:31:45.560
time he might discover between them and between himself and
1520
01:31:45.600 --> 01:31:49.239
his female made him judge of those he did not perceive,
1521
01:31:49.960 --> 01:31:52.960
and seeing that they all behaved as himself would have
1522
01:31:53.000 --> 01:31:56.880
done in similar circumstances, he concluded that their manner of
1523
01:31:56.920 --> 01:32:00.479
thinking and willing was quite conformable. To his own, and
1524
01:32:00.560 --> 01:32:04.479
that this important truth, when once engraved deeply on his mind,
1525
01:32:04.600 --> 01:32:08.079
made him follow by a presentiment as sure as any logic,
1526
01:32:08.520 --> 01:32:12.399
and withal much quicker, the best rules of conduct, which,
1527
01:32:12.399 --> 01:32:15.000
for the sake of his own safety and advantage, it
1528
01:32:15.039 --> 01:32:20.159
was proper he should observe towards them. Instructed by experience
1529
01:32:20.199 --> 01:32:22.680
that the love of happiness is the sole principle of
1530
01:32:22.720 --> 01:32:26.239
all human actions, he found himself in a condition to
1531
01:32:26.319 --> 01:32:30.279
distinguish the few cases in which common interest might authorize
1532
01:32:30.359 --> 01:32:33.479
him to build upon the assistance of his fellows, and
1533
01:32:33.560 --> 01:32:36.680
those still fewer in which a competition of interests might
1534
01:32:36.880 --> 01:32:40.960
justly render it suspected. In the first case, he united
1535
01:32:41.000 --> 01:32:43.720
with them in the same flock, or at most by
1536
01:32:43.760 --> 01:32:47.319
the same kind of free association, which obliged none of
1537
01:32:47.359 --> 01:32:51.159
its members, and lasted no longer than the transitory necessity
1538
01:32:51.199 --> 01:32:54.239
that had given birth to it. In the second case,
1539
01:32:54.359 --> 01:32:58.359
everyone aimed at his own private advantage, either by open force,
1540
01:32:58.399 --> 01:33:01.520
if he found himself strong enough, or by cunning an
1541
01:33:01.520 --> 01:33:04.600
address if he thought himself too weak to use violence.
1542
01:33:05.439 --> 01:33:08.359
Such was the manner in which men might have insensibly
1543
01:33:08.399 --> 01:33:12.039
acquired some gross idea of their mutual engagements in the
1544
01:33:12.079 --> 01:33:15.600
advantage of fulfilling them. But this only as far as
1545
01:33:15.640 --> 01:33:19.920
their present and sensible interest required. For as to foresight,
1546
01:33:20.039 --> 01:33:23.079
they were utter strangers to it, and far from troubling
1547
01:33:23.119 --> 01:33:27.199
their heads about a distant futurity, they Scarce thought of
1548
01:33:27.239 --> 01:33:30.840
the day following was a dear to be taken. Every
1549
01:33:30.880 --> 01:33:33.920
one saw that to succeed he must faithfully stand to
1550
01:33:34.000 --> 01:33:37.079
his post. But suppose a hare to have slipped by
1551
01:33:37.159 --> 01:33:39.720
within reach of any one of them, it is not
1552
01:33:39.800 --> 01:33:43.199
to be doubted. But he pursued it without scruple, and
1553
01:33:43.279 --> 01:33:46.520
when he had seized his prey, never approached himself, with
1554
01:33:46.640 --> 01:33:51.359
having made his companions miss theirs. We may easily conceive
1555
01:33:51.560 --> 01:33:55.079
that such an intercourse Scarce required a more refined language
1556
01:33:55.119 --> 01:33:58.520
than that of crows and monkeys, which flocked together almost
1557
01:33:58.600 --> 01:34:03.399
in the same manner, in articulate exclamations, a great many gestures,
1558
01:34:03.720 --> 01:34:06.439
and some imitative sounds, must have been for a long
1559
01:34:06.479 --> 01:34:10.600
time the universal language of mankind, and by joining to these,
1560
01:34:10.680 --> 01:34:14.680
in every country some articulate and conventional sounds, of which,
1561
01:34:14.920 --> 01:34:17.960
as I have already hinted, it is not very easy
1562
01:34:18.000 --> 01:34:24.239
to explain the institution there arose particular languages. But rude, imperfect,
1563
01:34:24.359 --> 01:34:26.640
and such nearly as are to be found at this
1564
01:34:26.800 --> 01:34:31.159
day among several savage nations. My pens straightened by the
1565
01:34:31.239 --> 01:34:34.199
rapidity of time, the abundance of things I have to say,
1566
01:34:34.359 --> 01:34:38.479
and the almost insensible progress of the first improvements, flies
1567
01:34:38.520 --> 01:34:41.720
like an arrow over numberless ages. For the slower the
1568
01:34:41.720 --> 01:34:44.760
succession of events, the quicker I may allow myself to
1569
01:34:44.800 --> 01:34:49.600
be in relating them at length. These first improvements enabled
1570
01:34:49.600 --> 01:34:53.319
man to improve at a
greater rate. Industry grew perfect
1571
01:34:53.359 --> 01:34:57.039
in proportion as the mind became more enlightened. Men, soon
1572
01:34:57.239 --> 01:35:00.479
ceasing to fall asleep under the first tree or take
1573
01:35:00.520 --> 01:35:03.920
shelter in the first cavern, lit upon some hard and
1574
01:35:04.000 --> 01:35:08.079
sharp kinds of stone, resembling spades or hatchets, and employed
1575
01:35:08.079 --> 01:35:11.000
them to dig the ground, cut down the trees, and
1576
01:35:11.039 --> 01:35:15.000
with the branches built huts, which they afterwards bethought themselves
1577
01:35:15.079 --> 01:35:18.720
of plastering over with clay or dirt. This was the
1578
01:35:18.760 --> 01:35:22.279
epoch of a first revolution, which produced the establishment and
1579
01:35:22.319 --> 01:35:26.359
distinction of families, and which introduced a species of property,
1580
01:35:26.840 --> 01:35:29.960
and along with it perhaps a thousand quarrels and battles.
1581
01:35:30.880 --> 01:35:33.520
As the strongest, however, were probably the first to make
1582
01:35:33.560 --> 01:35:37.119
themselves cabins which they knew they were able to defend.
1583
01:35:37.640 --> 01:35:40.359
We may conclude that the weak found it much shorter
1584
01:35:40.520 --> 01:35:44.039
and safer to imitate than to attempt to dislodge them.
1585
01:35:44.399 --> 01:35:47.680
And as to those who were already provided with cabins,
1586
01:35:48.159 --> 01:35:50.920
no one could have any great temptation to seize upon
1587
01:35:51.000 --> 01:35:53.720
that of his neighbor, not so much because it did
1588
01:35:53.760 --> 01:35:56.319
not belong to him, as because it could be of
1589
01:35:56.359 --> 01:35:59.600
no service to him, And as besides, to make himself
1590
01:35:59.640 --> 01:36:02.479
master of it, he must expose himself to a very
1591
01:36:02.560 --> 01:36:06.760
sharp conflict with the present occupiers. The first developments of
1592
01:36:06.800 --> 01:36:09.600
the heart were the effects of a new situation which
1593
01:36:09.680 --> 01:36:13.479
united husbands and wives, parents and children under one roof.
1594
01:36:14.079 --> 01:36:16.720
The habit of living together gave birth to the sweetest
1595
01:36:16.720 --> 01:36:21.640
sentiments the human species. As acquainted with conjugal and paternal love.
1596
01:36:22.439 --> 01:36:25.920
Every family became a little society, so much the more
1597
01:36:26.000 --> 01:36:29.039
firmly united as a mutual attachment in liberty were the
1598
01:36:29.079 --> 01:36:32.159
only bonds of it. And it was now that the sexes,
1599
01:36:32.319 --> 01:36:35.359
whose way of life had been hitherto the same, began
1600
01:36:35.439 --> 01:36:39.479
to adopt different manners and customs. The women became more
1601
01:36:39.520 --> 01:36:42.399
sedentary and accustomed themselves to stay at home and look
1602
01:36:42.439 --> 01:36:45.479
after their children, while the men rambled abroad in quest
1603
01:36:45.520 --> 01:36:49.560
of subsistence for the whole family. The two sexes, likewise,
1604
01:36:49.600 --> 01:36:52.079
by living a little more at their ease, began to
1605
01:36:52.159 --> 01:36:56.319
lose somewhat of their usual ferocity and sturdiness. But if
1606
01:36:56.359 --> 01:36:59.640
on the one hand, individuals became less able to engage
1607
01:37:00.359 --> 01:37:03.560
with wild beasts, they, on the other, were more easily
1608
01:37:03.560 --> 01:37:07.840
got together to make a common resistance against them. In
1609
01:37:07.880 --> 01:37:11.479
this new state of things, the simplicity and solitariness of
1610
01:37:11.560 --> 01:37:15.319
man's life, the limitedness of his wants, and the instruments
1611
01:37:15.359 --> 01:37:18.159
which he had invented to satisfy them, leaving him a
1612
01:37:18.159 --> 01:37:21.520
great deal of leisure, he employed it to supply himself
1613
01:37:21.560 --> 01:37:25.920
with several conveniences unknown to his ancestors. And this was
1614
01:37:25.920 --> 01:37:29.439
the first yoke he inadvertently imposed upon himself, and the
1615
01:37:29.439 --> 01:37:32.560
first source of mischief which he prepared for his children.
1616
01:37:33.319 --> 01:37:36.640
For besides continuing in this manner to soften both body
1617
01:37:36.680 --> 01:37:40.760
and mind, these conveniences, having through use, lost almost all
1618
01:37:40.800 --> 01:37:44.439
their aptness to please, and even degenerated into real wants,
1619
01:37:44.479 --> 01:37:47.880
the privation of them became far more intolerable than the
1620
01:37:47.880 --> 01:37:51.039
possession of them. Had been agreeable to lose them, was
1621
01:37:51.079 --> 01:37:55.880
a misfortune to possess them no happiness. Here we may
1622
01:37:55.960 --> 01:37:59.520
a little better discover how the use of speech insensibly
1623
01:37:59.560 --> 01:38:03.000
commenced or improves in the bosom of every family, and
1624
01:38:03.119 --> 01:38:07.079
may likewise form conjectures concerning the manner in which diverse
1625
01:38:07.159 --> 01:38:11.920
particular causes might have propagated language and accelerated its progress
1626
01:38:11.960 --> 01:38:15.399
by rendering it every day more and more necessary. Great
1627
01:38:15.479 --> 01:38:20.319
inundations or earthquakes surrounded inhabited districts with water or precipice.
1628
01:38:20.880 --> 01:38:24.239
Portions of the continent were, by revolutions of the globe
1629
01:38:24.319 --> 01:38:27.760
torn off and split into islands. It is obvious that
1630
01:38:27.800 --> 01:38:31.000
among men thus collected and forced to live together, a
1631
01:38:31.119 --> 01:38:34.720
common idiom must have started up much sooner than among
1632
01:38:34.800 --> 01:38:37.760
those who freely wandered through the forests of the mainland.
1633
01:38:38.880 --> 01:38:42.159
Thus it is very possible that the inhabitants of the
1634
01:38:42.199 --> 01:38:45.760
islands formed in this
manner after their first essays and
1635
01:38:45.880 --> 01:38:49.119
navigation brought among us the use of speech. And it
1636
01:38:49.159 --> 01:38:52.840
is very probable at least that society and languages commenced
1637
01:38:52.880 --> 01:38:56.800
in islands, and even acquired perfection there before the inhabitants
1638
01:38:56.800 --> 01:39:01.039
of the continent knew anything of either. Everything now begins
1639
01:39:01.079 --> 01:39:04.920
to wear a new aspect. Those who heretofore wandered through
1640
01:39:04.960 --> 01:39:07.840
the woods, by taking a more settled way of life,
1641
01:39:08.159 --> 01:39:12.960
gradually flock together, coalesce into several separate bodies, and at
1642
01:39:13.039 --> 01:39:16.960
length form in every country distinct nations, united in character
1643
01:39:17.039 --> 01:39:20.520
and manners, not by any laws or regulations, but by
1644
01:39:20.560 --> 01:39:24.479
a uniform manner of life, a sameness of provisions, and
1645
01:39:24.520 --> 01:39:28.680
the common influence of the climate. A permanent neighborhood must
1646
01:39:28.720 --> 01:39:33.000
at last infallibly create some connection between different families. The
1647
01:39:33.079 --> 01:39:37.399
transitory commerce required by nature soon produced, among the youth
1648
01:39:37.479 --> 01:39:41.319
of both sexes living in contiguous cabins of another kind
1649
01:39:41.359 --> 01:39:45.520
of commerce, which, besides being equally agreeable, is rendered more
1650
01:39:45.600 --> 01:39:50.199
durable by mutual intercourse. Men begin to consider different objects
1651
01:39:50.239 --> 01:39:54.439
and to make comparisons. They insensibly acquire ideas of merit
1652
01:39:54.520 --> 01:39:58.920
and beauty, and these soon produce sentiments of preference. By
1653
01:39:58.960 --> 01:40:02.319
seeing each other off, they contract a habit which makes
1654
01:40:02.359 --> 01:40:05.640
it painful not to see each other. Always tender and
1655
01:40:05.680 --> 01:40:09.079
agreeable sentiments steal into the soul, and are by the
1656
01:40:09.119 --> 01:40:14.000
smallest opposition wound up into the most impetuous fury. Jealousy
1657
01:40:14.119 --> 01:40:18.520
kindles with love. Discord, triumphs, and the gentlest of passions
1658
01:40:18.560 --> 01:40:23.039
require sacrifices of human blood to appease it. In proportion,
1659
01:40:23.159 --> 01:40:26.520
as ideas and sentiments succeed each other, and the head
1660
01:40:26.600 --> 01:40:30.159
and the heart exercise themselves. Men continue to shake off
1661
01:40:30.239 --> 01:40:34.920
their original wildness, and their connections become more intimate and extensive.
1662
01:40:35.479 --> 01:40:38.319
They now begin to assemble round a great tree, singing
1663
01:40:38.399 --> 01:40:41.520
and dancing. The genuine offspring of love and leisure become
1664
01:40:41.600 --> 01:40:44.560
the amusement, or rather the occupation of the men and
1665
01:40:44.640 --> 01:40:49.119
women free from care. Thus gathered together, everyone begins to
1666
01:40:49.199 --> 01:40:52.680
survey the rest and wishes to be surveyed himself, and
1667
01:40:52.800 --> 01:40:57.039
public esteem acquires a value. He who sings or dances best,
1668
01:40:57.279 --> 01:41:00.680
the handsomest, the strongest, the most dexterous, the most eloquent,
1669
01:41:01.239 --> 01:41:03.880
comes to be the most respected. This was the first
1670
01:41:03.880 --> 01:41:07.840
step towards inequality, and at the same time towards weis
1671
01:41:08.880 --> 01:41:12.800
from these first preferences that proceeded on one side vanity
1672
01:41:12.840 --> 01:41:16.399
and contempt on the other, envy and shame, and the
1673
01:41:16.439 --> 01:41:20.680
fermentation raised by these new levens at length produced combinations
1674
01:41:20.720 --> 01:41:24.840
fatal to happiness and innocence. Men no sooner began to
1675
01:41:24.920 --> 01:41:28.079
set upon each other and know what esteem was, than
1676
01:41:28.119 --> 01:41:30.960
each laid claim to it, and it was no longer
1677
01:41:31.039 --> 01:41:34.520
safe for any man to refuse it to another. Hence
1678
01:41:34.560 --> 01:41:38.039
the first duties of civility and politeness even among savages,
1679
01:41:38.319 --> 01:41:42.079
and hence every voluntary injury became an affront as besides
1680
01:41:42.159 --> 01:41:45.319
the mischief which resulted from it. As an injury, the
1681
01:41:45.359 --> 01:41:48.439
party offended was sure to find a contempt for his
1682
01:41:48.520 --> 01:41:52.920
person more intolerable than the mischief itself. It was thus
1683
01:41:53.000 --> 01:41:56.159
that every man, punishing the contempt expressed for him by
1684
01:41:56.199 --> 01:41:59.039
others in proportion to the value he set upon himself,
1685
01:41:59.479 --> 01:42:02.960
the effects of revenge became terrible, and men learned to
1686
01:42:03.000 --> 01:42:07.640
be sanguinary and cruel. Such precisely was the degree attained
1687
01:42:07.680 --> 01:42:10.600
by most of the savage nations which whom we are acquainted.
1688
01:42:11.439 --> 01:42:14.680
And it is for want of sufficiently distinguishing ideas and
1689
01:42:14.760 --> 01:42:17.840
observing at how great a distance these people were from
1690
01:42:17.880 --> 01:42:20.680
the first state of nature, that so many authors have
1691
01:42:20.800 --> 01:42:24.640
hastily concluded that man is naturally cruel and requires a
1692
01:42:24.680 --> 01:42:28.359
regular system of police to be reclaimed, whereas nothing can
1693
01:42:28.399 --> 01:42:31.840
be more gentle than he in his primitive state, when
1694
01:42:31.840 --> 01:42:34.840
placed by nature at an equal distance from the stupidity
1695
01:42:34.880 --> 01:42:38.319
of brutes and the pernicious good sense of civilized man,
1696
01:42:39.079 --> 01:42:42.359
and equally confined by instinct and reason to the care
1697
01:42:42.439 --> 01:42:45.760
of providing
against the mischief which threatens him, he is
1698
01:42:45.800 --> 01:42:49.319
withheld by natural compassion from doing any injury to others,
1699
01:42:49.760 --> 01:42:52.920
so far from being ever so little prone even to
1700
01:42:53.039 --> 01:42:56.680
return that which he has received. For according to the
1701
01:42:56.720 --> 01:42:59.960
axiom of the wise luck, where there is no property,
1702
01:43:00.239 --> 01:43:04.439
there can be no injury. But we must take notice
1703
01:43:04.720 --> 01:43:08.159
that the society now formed, and the relations now established
1704
01:43:08.159 --> 01:43:12.199
among men, require in them qualities different from those which
1705
01:43:12.239 --> 01:43:16.000
they derived from their primitive constitution. That as a sense
1706
01:43:16.039 --> 01:43:20.279
of morality began to insinuate itself into human actions, and
1707
01:43:20.399 --> 01:43:23.720
every man, before the enacting of laws, was the only
1708
01:43:23.880 --> 01:43:27.399
judge and avenger of the injuries he had received. That
1709
01:43:27.560 --> 01:43:30.920
goodness of heart, suitable to the pure state of nature,
1710
01:43:31.079 --> 01:43:35.199
by no means suited infant society. That it was necessary
1711
01:43:35.279 --> 01:43:38.640
punishments should become severer in the same proportion that the
1712
01:43:38.680 --> 01:43:42.439
opportunities of offending became more frequent, and the dread of
1713
01:43:42.560 --> 01:43:47.159
vengeance added strength to the weak curb of the law. Thus,
1714
01:43:47.479 --> 01:43:51.520
though men were become less patient, and natural compassion had
1715
01:43:51.560 --> 01:43:55.760
already suffered some alteration. This period of the development of
1716
01:43:55.800 --> 01:43:59.600
the human faculties, holding a just mean between the indolence
1717
01:43:59.640 --> 01:44:03.079
of the prinsmitive state and the petulant activity of self love,
1718
01:44:03.520 --> 01:44:07.199
must have been the happiest and most durable epoch. The
1719
01:44:07.199 --> 01:44:10.119
more we reflect on this state, the more convinced we
1720
01:44:10.159 --> 01:44:13.720
shall be that it was the least subject of any revolutions,
1721
01:44:14.039 --> 01:44:16.760
the best for man, and that nothing could have drawn
1722
01:44:16.840 --> 01:44:19.760
him out of it but some fatal accident, which for
1723
01:44:19.840 --> 01:44:24.039
the public good should never have happened. The example of
1724
01:44:24.079 --> 01:44:27.359
the savages, most of whom have been found in this condition,
1725
01:44:27.800 --> 01:44:31.680
seems to confirm that mankind was formed whatever to remain
1726
01:44:31.760 --> 01:44:34.960
in it, that in this condition is the real youth
1727
01:44:35.000 --> 01:44:38.600
of the world, and that all ulterior improvements have been
1728
01:44:38.680 --> 01:44:42.479
so many steps in appearance towards the perfection of individuals,
1729
01:44:42.800 --> 01:44:47.520
but in fact towards the decrepitness of the species. As
1730
01:44:47.520 --> 01:44:51.600
long as men remained satisfied with their rustic cabins, as
1731
01:44:51.640 --> 01:44:54.359
long as they confined themselves to the use of clothes
1732
01:44:54.399 --> 01:44:57.039
made of the skins of other animals, and the use
1733
01:44:57.079 --> 01:44:59.880
of thorns and fish bones in putting these skins together,
1734
01:45:00.600 --> 01:45:03.760
As long as they continued to consider feathers and shells
1735
01:45:03.760 --> 01:45:07.840
as sufficient ornaments, and to paint their bodies of different colors,
1736
01:45:07.880 --> 01:45:11.439
to improve or ornament their bows and arrows, to form
1737
01:45:11.600 --> 01:45:15.439
and scoop out with sharp edged stone, some little fishing boats,
1738
01:45:15.520 --> 01:45:18.960
or clumsy instruments of music. In a word, as long
1739
01:45:19.000 --> 01:45:21.920
as they undertook such works only as a single person
1740
01:45:21.920 --> 01:45:24.800
could finish, and stuck to such arts as did not
1741
01:45:24.840 --> 01:45:30.239
require the joint endeavors of several hands, they lived free, healthy, honest,
1742
01:45:30.319 --> 01:45:33.520
and happy as much as their nature would admit, and
1743
01:45:33.600 --> 01:45:36.560
continued to enjoy with each other all the pleasures of
1744
01:45:36.600 --> 01:45:40.279
an independent intercourse. But from the moment one man began
1745
01:45:40.399 --> 01:45:43.600
to stand in need of another's assistance, from the moment
1746
01:45:43.640 --> 01:45:46.600
it appeared an advantage for one man to possess the
1747
01:45:46.680 --> 01:45:52.680
quantity of provisions requisite for two, all equality vanished. Property
1748
01:45:52.760 --> 01:45:58.640
started up, labor became necessary, and boundless. Forests became smiling fields,
1749
01:45:58.880 --> 01:46:02.000
which it was found necessary to water with human sweat,
1750
01:46:02.479 --> 01:46:05.399
and in which slavery and misery were soon seen to
1751
01:46:05.479 --> 01:46:08.119
sprout out and grow with the fruits of the earth.
1752
01:46:09.760 --> 01:46:14.479
Metallurgy and agriculture were the two arts whose invention produced
1753
01:46:14.479 --> 01:46:19.600
this great revolution. With the poet it is gold and silver,
1754
01:46:20.079 --> 01:46:22.880
but with the philosopher it is iron and corn, which
1755
01:46:22.920 --> 01:46:28.279
have civilized men and ruined mankind. Accordingly, both one and
1756
01:46:28.319 --> 01:46:31.840
the other were unknown to the savages of America, who
1757
01:46:31.880 --> 01:46:36.439
for that very reason have always continued savages, nay, other
1758
01:46:36.560 --> 01:46:39.600
nations seem to have continued in a state of barbarism
1759
01:46:40.119 --> 01:46:43.520
as long as they continued to exercise one only of
1760
01:46:43.560 --> 01:46:46.800
these arts, without the other. And perhaps one of the
1761
01:46:46.800 --> 01:46:49.920
best reasons that
can be assigned why Europe has been,
1762
01:46:50.119 --> 01:46:53.800
if not earlier, at least more constantly and better civilized
1763
01:46:53.840 --> 01:46:56.439
than the other quarters of the world is that she
1764
01:46:56.680 --> 01:47:00.079
both abounds most in iron and is best qualified to
1765
01:47:00.079 --> 01:47:04.640
produce corn. It is a very difficult matter to tell
1766
01:47:04.800 --> 01:47:07.840
how men came to know anything of iron and the
1767
01:47:07.920 --> 01:47:10.760
art of employing it, For we are not to suppose
1768
01:47:10.840 --> 01:47:13.640
that they should of themselves think of digging it out
1769
01:47:13.680 --> 01:47:17.159
of the mines and preparing it for fusion before they
1770
01:47:17.199 --> 01:47:19.359
knew what could be the result of such a process.
1771
01:47:19.840 --> 01:47:22.119
On the other hand, there is the less reason to
1772
01:47:22.159 --> 01:47:25.880
attribute this discovery to any accidental fire, as mines are
1773
01:47:25.880 --> 01:47:29.600
formed nowhere but in dry and barren places, and such
1774
01:47:29.600 --> 01:47:32.319
as are bear of trees and plants, so that it
1775
01:47:32.399 --> 01:47:34.920
looks as if nature had taken pains to keep from
1776
01:47:35.039 --> 01:47:39.000
us so mischievous a secret. Nothing therefore remains, but the
1777
01:47:39.039 --> 01:47:44.640
extraordinary circumstance of some volcano, which belching forth metallic substances
1778
01:47:44.720 --> 01:47:48.119
ready fused, might have given the spectators a notion of
1779
01:47:48.159 --> 01:47:51.960
imitating that operation of nature. And after all, we must
1780
01:47:52.000 --> 01:47:55.359
suppose them endured with an extraordinary stock of courage and
1781
01:47:55.399 --> 01:47:58.920
foresight to undertake so painful a work, and have at
1782
01:47:58.960 --> 01:48:01.760
so great a distance an eye to the advantages they
1783
01:48:01.840 --> 01:48:06.039
might derive from it, qualities scarcely suitable, but to heads
1784
01:48:06.079 --> 01:48:09.800
more exercise than those of such discoveries can be supposed
1785
01:48:09.840 --> 01:48:13.199
to have been. As to agriculture, the principles of it
1786
01:48:13.239 --> 01:48:15.479
were known a long time before the practice of it
1787
01:48:15.520 --> 01:48:19.399
took place, and it is hardly possible that men constantly
1788
01:48:19.439 --> 01:48:23.359
employed in drawing their subsistence from trees and plants should
1789
01:48:23.359 --> 01:48:26.039
not have early hit on the means employed by nature
1790
01:48:26.039 --> 01:48:29.520
for the generation of vegetables. But in all probability it
1791
01:48:29.560 --> 01:48:33.119
was very late before their industry took a turn that way, either,
1792
01:48:33.159 --> 01:48:37.199
because trees, which with their land and water games supplied
1793
01:48:37.239 --> 01:48:40.760
them with sufficient food did not require their attention, or
1794
01:48:40.840 --> 01:48:43.760
because they did not know the use of corn, or
1795
01:48:43.800 --> 01:48:47.039
because they had no instruments to cultivate it, or because
1796
01:48:47.039 --> 01:48:50.479
they were destitute of foresight in regard to future necessities,
1797
01:48:51.039 --> 01:48:54.159
or in fine, because they wanted means to hinder others
1798
01:48:54.239 --> 01:48:57.479
from running away with the fruits of their labors. We
1799
01:48:57.560 --> 01:49:00.479
may believe that on their becoming more in dustrials, they
1800
01:49:00.520 --> 01:49:04.760
began their agriculture by cultivating with sharp stones and pointed sticks,
1801
01:49:04.800 --> 01:49:08.079
a few pulse or roots about their cabins, and that
1802
01:49:08.159 --> 01:49:10.600
it was a long time before they knew the methods
1803
01:49:10.640 --> 01:49:14.520
of preparing corn and were provided with the instruments necessary
1804
01:49:14.560 --> 01:49:17.680
to raise it in large quantities. Not to mention the
1805
01:49:17.720 --> 01:49:21.399
necessity there is, in order to follow this occupation in
1806
01:49:21.520 --> 01:49:24.840
sol lands, to consent to lose something at present to
1807
01:49:24.880 --> 01:49:28.520
gain a great deal hereafter, a precaution very foreign to
1808
01:49:28.560 --> 01:49:31.560
the turn of man's mind in a savage state, in which,
1809
01:49:31.680 --> 01:49:34.920
as I have already taken notice, he can hardly foresee
1810
01:49:35.000 --> 01:49:38.960
his wants from morning to night. For this reason, the
1811
01:49:38.960 --> 01:49:42.279
invention of other arts must have been necessary to oblige
1812
01:49:42.279 --> 01:49:45.720
mankind to apply to that of agriculture. As soon as
1813
01:49:45.760 --> 01:49:48.600
men were wanted to fuse and forge iron, others were
1814
01:49:48.600 --> 01:49:53.359
wanted to maintain them. The more hands were employed in manufactures,
1815
01:49:53.600 --> 01:49:56.640
the fewer hands were left to provide subsistence for all,
1816
01:49:57.079 --> 01:49:59.520
Though the number of mouths to be supplied with food
1817
01:49:59.600 --> 01:50:03.720
continued the same, And as some required commodities in exchange
1818
01:50:03.720 --> 01:50:06.600
for their iron, the rest at last found out the
1819
01:50:06.640 --> 01:50:12.119
method of making iron subservient to the multiplication of commodities. Hence,
1820
01:50:12.279 --> 01:50:15.600
on the one hand husbandry and agriculture, and on the
1821
01:50:15.640 --> 01:50:18.560
other the art of working metals and of multiplying the
1822
01:50:18.680 --> 01:50:21.760
uses of them to the tilling of the earth. The
1823
01:50:21.800 --> 01:50:26.279
distribution of it necessarily succeeded, and to property once acknowledged
1824
01:50:26.279 --> 01:50:30.079
the first rules of justice. For to secure every man
1825
01:50:30.199 --> 01:50:34.760
his own, every man must have something. Moreover, as men
1826
01:50:34.840 --> 01:50:38.279
began to extend their views to futurity,
and all found
1827
01:50:38.319 --> 01:50:41.520
themselves in possession of more or less goods capable of
1828
01:50:41.560 --> 01:50:45.760
being lost, everyone in particular had reason to fear lest
1829
01:50:45.800 --> 01:50:48.880
reprisals should be made on him for any injury he
1830
01:50:48.960 --> 01:50:52.399
might do to others. The origin is so much the
1831
01:50:52.439 --> 01:50:55.960
more natural, as it is impossible to conceive how property
1832
01:50:56.000 --> 01:50:59.439
can flow from any other source mud industry. For what
1833
01:50:59.479 --> 01:51:02.000
can a man add but his labor to things which
1834
01:51:02.039 --> 01:51:05.039
he has not made, in order to acquire a property
1835
01:51:05.079 --> 01:51:09.199
in them. Tis the labor of the hands alone, which,
1836
01:51:09.239 --> 01:51:11.880
giving the husbandman a title to the produce of the
1837
01:51:11.960 --> 01:51:14.640
land he has tilled, gives him a title to the
1838
01:51:14.720 --> 01:51:17.840
land itself, at least till he has gathered in the
1839
01:51:17.840 --> 01:51:20.960
fruits of it, and so on from year to year.
1840
01:51:21.600 --> 01:51:25.960
And this enjoyment, forming a continued possession, is easily transformed
1841
01:51:25.960 --> 01:51:30.399
into a property. The ancients, says Grotius, by giving to
1842
01:51:30.520 --> 01:51:34.319
Ceres the epithet of legislatorics, and to a festival celebrated
1843
01:51:34.359 --> 01:51:38.680
in her honor the name of Thesmophoria, insinuated that the
1844
01:51:38.720 --> 01:51:42.319
distribution of lands produced a new kind of right, that is,
1845
01:51:42.359 --> 01:51:45.119
the right of property, different from that which results from
1846
01:51:45.159 --> 01:51:50.079
the law of nature. Things thus circumstanced might have remained
1847
01:51:50.119 --> 01:51:53.720
equal if men's talents had been equal, and if, for instance,
1848
01:51:53.760 --> 01:51:56.840
the use of iron and the consumption of commodities had
1849
01:51:56.880 --> 01:52:01.119
always held an exact proportion to each other. But as
1850
01:52:01.159 --> 01:52:04.960
this proportion had no support, it was soon broken. The
1851
01:52:05.039 --> 01:52:08.279
man that had most strength performed the most labor the
1852
01:52:08.359 --> 01:52:12.199
most dexterous turned his labor to best account, the most
1853
01:52:12.359 --> 01:52:16.359
ingenious found out methods of lessening his labor. The husbandman
1854
01:52:16.680 --> 01:52:20.760
required more iron or the smith more corn, and while
1855
01:52:20.800 --> 01:52:24.119
both worked equally, one earned a great deal by his labor,
1856
01:52:24.439 --> 01:52:27.479
while the other could scarce live by his. It is
1857
01:52:27.560 --> 01:52:32.000
thus that natural inequality insensibly unfolds itself with that arising
1858
01:52:32.039 --> 01:52:36.000
from a variety of combinations, and that the difference among men,
1859
01:52:36.119 --> 01:52:40.319
developed by the difference of their circumstances, becomes more sensible,
1860
01:52:40.640 --> 01:52:43.920
more permanent in its effects, and begins to influence in
1861
01:52:43.960 --> 01:52:48.720
the same proportion the condition of private persons. Things once
1862
01:52:48.840 --> 01:52:51.760
arrived at this period, it is an easy matter to
1863
01:52:51.800 --> 01:52:55.039
imagine the rest. I shall not stop to describe the
1864
01:52:55.079 --> 01:52:59.199
successive inventions of other arts, the progress of language, the
1865
01:52:59.279 --> 01:53:03.720
trial and employments of talents, the inequality of fortunes, the
1866
01:53:03.840 --> 01:53:07.079
use or abuse of riches, nor all the details which
1867
01:53:07.119 --> 01:53:11.640
follow these, and which everyone may easily supply. I shall
1868
01:53:11.800 --> 01:53:14.720
just give a glance at mankind placed in this new
1869
01:53:14.880 --> 01:53:20.520
order of things. Behold, then, all our faculties developed, our
1870
01:53:20.560 --> 01:53:26.039
memory and imagination at work, self, love interested, reason rendered active,
1871
01:53:26.239 --> 01:53:29.199
and the mind almost arrived at the utmost bounds of
1872
01:53:29.199 --> 01:53:33.800
that perfection, it is capable of behold all our natural
1873
01:53:33.880 --> 01:53:37.359
qualities put in motion the rank and condition of every
1874
01:53:37.399 --> 01:53:41.039
man established not only as to the quantum of property
1875
01:53:41.560 --> 01:53:45.159
and the power of serving or hurting others, but likewise
1876
01:53:45.199 --> 01:53:49.800
as to genius, beauty, strength, or address, merit or talents.
1877
01:53:50.319 --> 01:53:53.840
And as these were the only equalities which could command respect,
1878
01:53:54.279 --> 01:53:56.720
it was found necessary to have, or at least to
1879
01:53:56.800 --> 01:53:59.760
affect them. It was requisite for men to be thought
1880
01:53:59.800 --> 01:54:03.439
what they really were. Not to be and to appear
1881
01:54:03.920 --> 01:54:07.880
became two very different things. And from this distinction sprang
1882
01:54:08.039 --> 01:54:11.760
pomp and knavery, and all the vices which form their train.
1883
01:54:12.720 --> 01:54:17.319
On the other hand, man, heretofore free and independent, was
1884
01:54:17.359 --> 01:54:20.720
now in consequence of a multitude of nude wants, brought
1885
01:54:20.840 --> 01:54:25.800
under subjection, as it were, to all nature, and especially
1886
01:54:25.880 --> 01:54:29.239
to his fellows, whose slave, in some sense he became,
1887
01:54:29.439 --> 01:54:33.199
even by becoming their master. If rich he stood in
1888
01:54:33.279 --> 01:54:37.399
need of their services, if poor of their assistance, even
1889
01:54:37.520 --> 01:54:40.840
mediocrity itself could not enable him to do without them.
1890
01:54:41.479 --> 01:54:44.520
He must therefore have been continually at work to interest
1891
01:54:44.600 --> 01:54:47.760
them in his happiness and
make them, if not really
1892
01:54:48.439 --> 01:54:51.560
at least apparently find their advantage in laboring for his.
1893
01:54:52.680 --> 01:54:55.720
This rendered him sly and artful in his dealings with some,
1894
01:54:56.960 --> 01:55:00.600
imperious and cruel in his kneelings with others, and laid
1895
01:55:00.680 --> 01:55:03.359
him under the necessity of using ill all those whom
1896
01:55:03.359 --> 01:55:05.720
he stood in need of, as often as he could
1897
01:55:05.800 --> 01:55:08.600
not awe them into a compliance with his will, and
1898
01:55:08.640 --> 01:55:11.159
did not find it his interest to purchase it at
1899
01:55:11.199 --> 01:55:16.119
the expense of real services. In fine, an insatiable ambition,
1900
01:55:16.640 --> 01:55:20.159
the rage of raising their relative fortunes, not so much
1901
01:55:20.279 --> 01:55:25.399
through real necessity as to overtop others, inspire all men
1902
01:55:25.479 --> 01:55:28.600
with a wicked inclination to injure each other, and with
1903
01:55:28.680 --> 01:55:32.000
a secret jealousy, so much the more dangerous as to
1904
01:55:32.039 --> 01:55:35.800
carry its point with the greater security, and often puts
1905
01:55:35.840 --> 01:55:40.239
on the face of benevolence. In a word, sometimes nothing
1906
01:55:40.399 --> 01:55:43.039
was to be seen but a contention of endeavors on
1907
01:55:43.079 --> 01:55:46.199
the one hand, and an opposition of interests on the other,
1908
01:55:47.279 --> 01:55:50.079
while a secret desire of thriving at the expense of
1909
01:55:50.159 --> 01:55:54.600
others constantly prevailed. Such were the first effects of property
1910
01:55:54.960 --> 01:56:00.720
and the inseparable attendance of infant inequality riches. Before the
1911
01:56:00.800 --> 01:56:04.439
invention of signs to represent them. Could scarce consist in
1912
01:56:04.520 --> 01:56:08.399
anything but lands and cattle, the only real goods which
1913
01:56:08.439 --> 01:56:12.079
men can possess. But when estates increased so much in
1914
01:56:12.199 --> 01:56:15.600
number and an extent to take in whole countries and
1915
01:56:15.640 --> 01:56:18.800
touch each other, it became impossible for one man to
1916
01:56:18.880 --> 01:56:23.199
aggrandize himself but at the expense of some other, and
1917
01:56:23.279 --> 01:56:27.600
the supernumerary inhabitants who were too weak or too indolent
1918
01:56:27.680 --> 01:56:32.319
to make such acquisitions, in their turn impoverished without losing anything.
1919
01:56:32.760 --> 01:56:36.520
Because while everything about them changed, they alone remained the same.
1920
01:56:36.960 --> 01:56:40.239
Were obliged to receive or force their subsistence from the
1921
01:56:40.319 --> 01:56:44.039
hands of the rich, and hence began to flow according
1922
01:56:44.079 --> 01:56:48.319
to the different characters of each domination and slavery or
1923
01:56:48.399 --> 01:56:52.840
violence and rapine. The rich on their side, Scarce began
1924
01:56:52.920 --> 01:56:56.039
to taste the pleasure of commanding when they preferred it
1925
01:56:56.079 --> 01:56:59.399
to every other, and making use of their old slaves
1926
01:56:59.399 --> 01:57:02.560
to acquire new ones. They no longer thought of anything
1927
01:57:02.600 --> 01:57:07.319
but subduing and enslaving their neighbors, like those ravenous wolves, who,
1928
01:57:07.399 --> 01:57:11.119
having once tasted human flesh, despise every other food and
1929
01:57:11.199 --> 01:57:15.479
devour nothing but men for the future. It is thus
1930
01:57:15.920 --> 01:57:19.920
that the most powerful or the most wretched, respectively, considering
1931
01:57:20.000 --> 01:57:22.840
their powers and wretchedness as a kind of title to
1932
01:57:22.880 --> 01:57:26.279
the substance of others, even equivalent to that of property.
1933
01:57:26.680 --> 01:57:31.079
The equality, once broken, was followed by the most shocking disorders.
1934
01:57:32.000 --> 01:57:35.319
It is thus that the usurpations of the rich, the
1935
01:57:35.359 --> 01:57:38.840
pillagings of the poor, and the unbridled passions of all,
1936
01:57:39.279 --> 01:57:43.199
by stifling the cries of natural compassion and the as
1937
01:57:43.279 --> 01:57:48.520
yet feeble voice of justice, rendered man avaricious, wicked, and ambitious.
1938
01:57:49.279 --> 01:57:52.399
There arose between the title of the strongest and that
1939
01:57:52.439 --> 01:57:56.520
of the first occupier, a perpetual conflict which always ended
1940
01:57:56.520 --> 01:58:00.720
in battery and bloodshed. Infant society became came a scene
1941
01:58:00.760 --> 01:58:05.159
of the most horrible warfare. Mankind thus debased and harassed,
1942
01:58:05.680 --> 01:58:08.840
and no longer able to retreat or renounce the unhappy
1943
01:58:08.880 --> 01:58:13.439
acquisitions it had made, laboring in short, merely to its confusion.
1944
01:58:13.560 --> 01:58:16.600
By the abuse of those faculties which in themselves do
1945
01:58:16.680 --> 01:58:20.000
it so much honor, brought itself to the very brink
1946
01:58:20.039 --> 01:58:26.520
of ruin and destruction. Atonatous novitate molli di vesque misser
1947
01:58:26.600 --> 01:58:32.079
kay e fuguaet optat opis at Quomodo voverat owed it.
1948
01:58:33.439 --> 01:58:36.079
But it is impossible that men should not sooner or
1949
01:58:36.159 --> 01:58:40.239
later have made reflections on so wretched a situation, and
1950
01:58:40.399 --> 01:58:44.159
upon the calamities with which they were overwhelmed. The rich
1951
01:58:44.199 --> 01:58:48.039
in particular, must have soon perceived how much they suffered
1952
01:58:48.079 --> 01:58:51.560
by a perpetual war, of which they alone supported all
1953
01:58:51.640 --> 01:58:55.760
the expense, and in which though all risked life, they
1954
01:58:55.800 --> 01:58:59.880
alone risked any substance. Besides whatever color they might pret
1955
01:59:00.119 --> 01:59:04.239
tend to
give their usurpations, they sufficiently saw that these
1956
01:59:04.359 --> 01:59:09.079
usurpations were, in the main founded upon false and precarious titles,
1957
01:59:09.479 --> 01:59:12.359
and that what they had acquired by mere force others
1958
01:59:12.399 --> 01:59:15.560
could gain again by mere force, rest out of their hands,
1959
01:59:15.920 --> 01:59:18.439
without leaving them the least room to complain of such
1960
01:59:18.479 --> 01:59:22.840
a proceeding. Even those who owed all their riches to
1961
01:59:22.920 --> 01:59:26.960
their own industry could scarce ground their acquisitions upon a
1962
01:59:27.000 --> 01:59:30.720
better title. It availed them nothing to say. Twas I
1963
01:59:30.800 --> 01:59:33.920
built this wall, I acquired this spot by my labor,
1964
01:59:35.279 --> 01:59:37.960
who traced it out for you. Another might object, And
1965
01:59:37.960 --> 01:59:40.479
what right have you to expect payment at our expense
1966
01:59:40.520 --> 01:59:43.479
for doing that we did not oblige you to do?
1967
01:59:43.479 --> 01:59:46.159
Don't you know that numbers of your brethren perish or
1968
01:59:46.199 --> 01:59:49.119
suffer grievously for want of what you possess more than
1969
01:59:49.199 --> 01:59:52.000
suffice as nature, and that you should have had the
1970
01:59:52.119 --> 01:59:56.159
express and unanimous consent of mankind to appropriate to yourself
1971
01:59:56.159 --> 02:00:00.000
of their common more than was requisite for your private subsistence.
1972
02:00:00.800 --> 02:00:04.640
Destitute of solid reasons to justify and sufficient force to
1973
02:00:04.680 --> 02:00:09.039
defend himself, crushing individuals with ease, but with equal ease,
1974
02:00:09.159 --> 02:00:13.079
crushed by numbers one against all, and unable on account
1975
02:00:13.079 --> 02:00:16.439
of mutual jealousies, to unite with his equals against banditi,
1976
02:00:16.520 --> 02:00:19.720
united by the common hopes of pillage, the rich man,
1977
02:00:19.880 --> 02:00:23.960
thus pressed by necessity, at last conceived the deepest project
1978
02:00:24.199 --> 02:00:27.359
that ever entered the human mind. This was to employ
1979
02:00:27.439 --> 02:00:30.840
in his favor the very forces that attacked him, to
1980
02:00:30.880 --> 02:00:34.800
make allies of his enemies, to inspire them with other maxims,
1981
02:00:34.840 --> 02:00:38.640
and make them adopt other institutions as favorable to his pretensions,
1982
02:00:38.920 --> 02:00:43.760
as the law of nature was unfavorable to them. With
1983
02:00:43.880 --> 02:00:48.000
this view, after laying before his neighbors all the horrors
1984
02:00:48.039 --> 02:00:51.199
of a situation which armed them all one against another,
1985
02:00:51.600 --> 02:00:55.800
which rendered their possessions as burdensome as their wants, were intolerable,
1986
02:00:56.199 --> 02:00:59.000
and in which no one would expect any safety, either
1987
02:00:59.000 --> 02:01:03.520
in poverty or riches. He easily invented speciest arguments to
1988
02:01:03.560 --> 02:01:07.359
bring them over to his purpose. Let us unite, said he,
1989
02:01:07.800 --> 02:01:12.159
to secure the weak from oppression, restrain the ambitions, and
1990
02:01:12.239 --> 02:01:15.600
secure to every man the possession of what belongs to him.
1991
02:01:16.239 --> 02:01:19.079
Let us form rules of justice and peace, to which
1992
02:01:19.119 --> 02:01:23.000
all may be obliged to conform, which shall not accept persons,
1993
02:01:23.359 --> 02:01:25.960
but may in some sort make amends for the caprice
1994
02:01:26.000 --> 02:01:29.359
of fortune by submitting alike the powerful and the weak
1995
02:01:29.479 --> 02:01:33.520
to the observance of mutual duties. In a word, instead
1996
02:01:33.520 --> 02:01:37.319
of turning our forces against ourselves, let us collect them
1997
02:01:37.359 --> 02:01:40.800
into a sovereign power, which may govern us by wise laws.
1998
02:01:41.079 --> 02:01:44.039
They protect and defend all the members of the association,
1999
02:01:44.680 --> 02:01:49.720
repel common enemies, and maintain perpetual concord and harmony among us.
2000
02:01:51.079 --> 02:01:53.920
Much fewer words of this kind were sufficient to draw
2001
02:01:54.000 --> 02:01:56.840
in a parcel of rustics, whom it was an easy
2002
02:01:56.880 --> 02:02:00.880
matter to impose upon, who had, besides too many quarrels
2003
02:02:00.920 --> 02:02:04.800
among themselves, to live without arbiters and too much avarice,
2004
02:02:04.840 --> 02:02:08.760
an ambition to live long without masters. All offered their
2005
02:02:08.800 --> 02:02:11.560
next to the yoke in hopes of securing their liberty.
2006
02:02:12.039 --> 02:02:14.960
For though they had sense enough to perceive the advantages
2007
02:02:15.000 --> 02:02:18.920
of a political constitution, they had not experience enough to
2008
02:02:18.960 --> 02:02:22.439
see beforehand the dangers of it. Those among them who
2009
02:02:22.520 --> 02:02:26.399
were best qualified to foresee abuses were precisely those who
2010
02:02:26.439 --> 02:02:30.039
expected to benefit by them. Even the soberist judge that
2011
02:02:30.199 --> 02:02:33.399
requisite to sacrifice one part of their liberty to ensure
2012
02:02:33.439 --> 02:02:36.800
the other. As a man dangerously wounded in any of
2013
02:02:36.800 --> 02:02:39.319
his limbs readily parts with it to save the rest
2014
02:02:39.359 --> 02:02:43.199
of his body, Such was, or must have been, had
2015
02:02:43.279 --> 02:02:46.640
man been left to himself. The origin of society and
2016
02:02:46.760 --> 02:02:49.479
of the laws which increased the fetters of the weak
2017
02:02:49.800 --> 02:02:53.760
and the strength of the rich, irretrievably destroyed natural liberty
2018
02:02:54.159 --> 02:02:58.199
fixed forever. The laws of property and inequality change an
2019
02:02:58.319 --> 02:03:02.279
artful usurpation into aner
revocable title, and for the benefit
2020
02:03:02.319 --> 02:03:05.920
of a few ambitious individuals, subjected the rest of mankind
2021
02:03:05.960 --> 02:03:10.439
to perpetual labor, servitude and misery. We may easily conceive
2022
02:03:10.520 --> 02:03:13.680
how the establishment of a single society rendered that of
2023
02:03:13.760 --> 02:03:17.399
all the rest absolutely necessary, and how to make head
2024
02:03:17.439 --> 02:03:21.199
against united forces it became necessary for the rest of
2025
02:03:21.199 --> 02:03:25.279
mankind to unite in their turn. Society is, once formed
2026
02:03:25.279 --> 02:03:28.439
in this manner, soon multiplied or spread to such degree
2027
02:03:28.520 --> 02:03:31.079
as to cover the face of the earth, and not
2028
02:03:31.159 --> 02:03:33.680
to leave a corner in the whole universe where a
2029
02:03:33.720 --> 02:03:36.600
man could throw off the yoke and withdraw his head
2030
02:03:36.680 --> 02:03:39.800
from under the often ill conducted sword which he saw
2031
02:03:39.880 --> 02:03:44.000
permanently hanging over it. The civil law being thus become
2032
02:03:44.119 --> 02:03:47.199
the common rule of citizens. The law of nature no
2033
02:03:47.319 --> 02:03:51.279
longer obtained, but among the different societies, in which, under
2034
02:03:51.319 --> 02:03:54.640
the name of the law of nations it was qualified
2035
02:03:54.720 --> 02:03:59.239
by some tacit conventions to render commerce possible and supply
2036
02:03:59.479 --> 02:04:03.680
the place of natural compassion, which, losing by degrees all
2037
02:04:03.720 --> 02:04:07.680
that influence over societies which it originally had over individuals,
2038
02:04:08.000 --> 02:04:11.600
no longer exists, but in some great souls, who consider
2039
02:04:11.640 --> 02:04:16.079
themselves as citizens of the world, enforcing the imaginary barriers
2040
02:04:16.119 --> 02:04:19.720
that separate people from people. After the example of the
2041
02:04:19.760 --> 02:04:23.359
sovereign Being from whom we all derive our existence, make
2042
02:04:23.399 --> 02:04:30.399
the whole human race the object of their benevolence. End
2043
02:04:30.439 --> 02:04:43.600
of discourse, second part Section one, Section six of the
2044
02:04:43.680 --> 02:04:49.840
Discourse on Inequality by Jean Jacques Rousseau. This is a
2045
02:04:49.840 --> 02:04:54.520
LibriVox recording. All LibriVox recordings are in the public domain.
2046
02:04:55.359 --> 02:04:59.880
For more information or to volunteer, please visit LibriVox dot org.
2047
02:05:01.199 --> 02:05:04.880
This is a reading by Eric Jonas a discourse upon
2048
02:05:04.920 --> 02:05:08.399
the origin and the foundation of the inequality among mankind
2049
02:05:08.960 --> 02:05:15.039
by Jean Jacques Rousseau. Discourse, second part Section two. Political bodies,
2050
02:05:15.159 --> 02:05:18.640
thus remaining in a state of nature among themselves, soon
2051
02:05:18.720 --> 02:05:22.640
experienced the inconveniences which had obliged individuals to quit it.
2052
02:05:23.279 --> 02:05:25.960
And this state became much more fatal to these great
2053
02:05:26.000 --> 02:05:29.079
bodies than it had been before to the individuals which
2054
02:05:29.119 --> 02:05:34.880
now composed them. Hence those national wars, those battles, those murders,
2055
02:05:34.920 --> 02:05:39.479
those reprisals which make nature shudder and shock reason, hence
2056
02:05:39.560 --> 02:05:42.640
all those horrible prejudices which make it a virtue and
2057
02:05:42.680 --> 02:05:46.239
an honour to shed human blood. The worthiest men learned
2058
02:05:46.279 --> 02:05:48.800
to consider the cutting the throats of their fellows as
2059
02:05:48.840 --> 02:05:52.000
a duty. At length, men began to butcher each other
2060
02:05:52.079 --> 02:05:55.920
by thousands, without knowing for what. And more murders were
2061
02:05:55.920 --> 02:05:59.680
committed in a single action, and more horrible disorders at
2062
02:05:59.680 --> 02:06:02.359
the tape making of a single town, and had been
2063
02:06:02.399 --> 02:06:05.800
committed in the state of nature during ages together upon
2064
02:06:05.880 --> 02:06:09.039
the whole face of the earth. Such are the first
2065
02:06:09.039 --> 02:06:12.399
effects we may conceive to have arisen from their division
2066
02:06:12.439 --> 02:06:17.159
of mankind into different societies. Let us return to their institution.
2067
02:06:18.279 --> 02:06:21.079
I know that several writers have assigned other origins of
2068
02:06:21.119 --> 02:06:26.039
political society, as, for instance, the conquests of the powerful,
2069
02:06:26.560 --> 02:06:29.079
or the union of the week. And it is no
2070
02:06:29.279 --> 02:06:32.239
matter of which of these causes we adopt in regard
2071
02:06:32.279 --> 02:06:35.920
to what I am going to establish, that, however, which
2072
02:06:35.960 --> 02:06:38.560
I have just laid down, seems to me the most
2073
02:06:38.640 --> 02:06:43.239
natural for the following reasons. First because in the first case,
2074
02:06:43.359 --> 02:06:46.319
the right of conquest being in fact no right at all,
2075
02:06:46.600 --> 02:06:49.319
it could not serve as a foundation for any other right.
2076
02:06:50.039 --> 02:06:53.359
The conqueror and the conquered, ever remaining with respect to
2077
02:06:53.399 --> 02:06:56.479
each other in a state of war, unless the conquered,
2078
02:06:56.560 --> 02:07:00.000
restored to the full possession of their liberty, should freely
2079
02:07:00.239 --> 02:07:05.560
choose their conqueror for their chief till then whatever capitulations
2080
02:07:05.640 --> 02:07:09.000
might have been made between them, as these capitulations were
2081
02:07:09.039 --> 02:07:13.079
founded upon violence, and of course a facto null and void,
2082
02:07:13.640 --> 02:07:17.000
there could not have existed in this hypothesis either a
2083
02:07:17.039 -->
02:07:21.479
true society or a political body, or any other law,
2084
02:07:21.520 --> 02:07:26.079
but that of the strongest. Second, because these words strong
2085
02:07:26.159 --> 02:07:29.680
and weak are ambiguous. In the second case, for during
2086
02:07:29.720 --> 02:07:33.079
the interval between the establishment of the right of property
2087
02:07:33.239 --> 02:07:37.319
or prior occupation and that of political government, the meaning
2088
02:07:37.399 --> 02:07:40.720
of these terms is better expressed by the words poor
2089
02:07:40.840 --> 02:07:44.560
and rich. As before the establishment of laws, men in
2090
02:07:44.640 --> 02:07:48.199
reality had no other means of reducing their equals, but
2091
02:07:48.279 --> 02:07:51.720
by invading the property of these equals, or by parting
2092
02:07:51.720 --> 02:07:55.640
with some of their own property to them. Third, because
2093
02:07:55.680 --> 02:07:58.680
the poor, having nothing but their liberty to lose, it
2094
02:07:58.680 --> 02:08:00.760
would have been the height of men madness in them
2095
02:08:00.800 --> 02:08:03.920
to give up willingly the only blessing they had left
2096
02:08:03.960 --> 02:08:09.119
without obtaining some consideration for it. Whereas the rich, being sensible,
2097
02:08:09.319 --> 02:08:12.479
if I may say so, in every part of their possessions,
2098
02:08:12.880 --> 02:08:16.079
it was much easier to do than mischief, and therefore
2099
02:08:16.079 --> 02:08:19.600
more incumbent upon them to guard against it. And because
2100
02:08:19.760 --> 02:08:22.680
in fine, it is but reasonable to suppose that a
2101
02:08:22.720 --> 02:08:26.039
thing has been invented by him to whom it could
2102
02:08:26.119 --> 02:08:28.720
be of service, rather than by him to whom it
2103
02:08:28.800 --> 02:08:34.560
must prove detrimental. Government in its infancy had no regular
2104
02:08:34.640 --> 02:08:38.279
and permanent form for want of a sufficient fund of
2105
02:08:38.319 --> 02:08:42.039
philosophy and experience. Men could see no further than the
2106
02:08:42.079 --> 02:08:46.920
present inconveniences, and never thought of providing remedies for future ones.
2107
02:08:47.279 --> 02:08:51.119
But in proportion as they arose. In spite of all
2108
02:08:51.199 --> 02:08:55.479
the labours of the wisest legislators, the political state still
2109
02:08:55.600 --> 02:08:59.279
continued imperfect, because it was in a manner the work
2110
02:08:59.359 --> 02:09:04.079
of chance, and as the foundations of it were ill laid, time,
2111
02:09:04.600 --> 02:09:08.159
though sufficient to discover its defects and suggest the remedies
2112
02:09:08.199 --> 02:09:12.239
for them, could never mend its original vices. Men were
2113
02:09:12.279 --> 02:09:16.800
continually repairing, whereas to erect a good edifice, they should
2114
02:09:16.800 --> 02:09:20.439
have begun, as Lycurgus did at Sparta, by clearing the
2115
02:09:20.520 --> 02:09:25.840
area and removing the old materials. Society at first consisted
2116
02:09:25.920 --> 02:09:29.680
merely of some general conventions, which all the members bound
2117
02:09:29.680 --> 02:09:33.079
themselves to observe, and for the performance of which the
2118
02:09:33.159 --> 02:09:38.760
whole body became security to every individual. Experience was necessary
2119
02:09:38.800 --> 02:09:42.000
to show the great weakness of such a constitution, and
2120
02:09:42.119 --> 02:09:44.760
how easy it was for those who infringe it to
2121
02:09:44.920 --> 02:09:48.319
escape the conviction or chastisement of faults of which the
2122
02:09:48.359 --> 02:09:51.800
public alone was to be both the witness and the judge.
2123
02:09:52.439 --> 02:09:55.119
The laws could not fail of being eluded in a
2124
02:09:55.199 --> 02:10:00.439
thousand ways inconveniences and disorders, could not but multiply continueually
2125
02:10:00.880 --> 02:10:03.399
till it was at last found necessary to think of
2126
02:10:03.479 --> 02:10:07.439
committing to private persons the dangerous trust of public authority,
2127
02:10:07.680 --> 02:10:11.359
and to magistrates the care of enforcing obedience to the people.
2128
02:10:12.039 --> 02:10:15.960
For to say that chiefs were elected before confederacies were formed,
2129
02:10:16.319 --> 02:10:19.039
and that the ministers of the laws existed before the
2130
02:10:19.119 --> 02:10:23.159
laws themselves, is a supposition too ridiculous to deserve. I
2131
02:10:23.199 --> 02:10:27.920
should seriously refute it. It would be equally unreasonable to
2132
02:10:28.000 --> 02:10:31.279
imagine that men at first threw themselves into the arms
2133
02:10:31.319 --> 02:10:35.520
of an absolute master without any conditions or consideration on
2134
02:10:35.680 --> 02:10:39.399
his side, and that the first means contrived by jealous
2135
02:10:39.399 --> 02:10:43.279
and unconquered men for their common safety was to run
2136
02:10:43.319 --> 02:10:47.640
hand over head into slavery. In fact, why did they
2137
02:10:47.680 --> 02:10:51.439
give themselves superiors if it was not to be defended
2138
02:10:51.479 --> 02:10:55.319
by them against oppression and protected in their lives, liberties
2139
02:10:55.359 --> 02:10:59.159
and properties, which are, in a manner the constitutional elements
2140
02:10:59.159 --> 02:11:03.359
of their being now in the relations between man and man.
2141
02:11:03.720 --> 02:11:06.399
The worst that can happen to one man being to
2142
02:11:06.439 --> 02:11:09.399
see himself at the discretion of another would it not
2143
02:11:09.520 --> 02:11:12.039
have been contrary to the dictates of good sense to
2144
02:11:12.079 --> 02:11:15.279
begin by making over to a chief the only things
2145
02:11:15.279 --> 02:11:17.800
for the preservation of which they stood in need of
2146
02:11:17.840 --> 02:11:22.000
his assistance. What equivalent could he have offered them for
2147
02:11:22.079 --> 02:11:25.439
so
fine a privilege? And had he presumed to exact
2148
02:11:25.520 --> 02:11:28.359
it on pretense of defending them, would he not have
2149
02:11:28.479 --> 02:11:33.199
immediately received the answer in the apologue, what worst treatment
2150
02:11:33.279 --> 02:11:37.119
can we expect from an enemy? It is, therefore past dispute,
2151
02:11:37.359 --> 02:11:41.279
and indeed a fundamental maxim of political law, that people
2152
02:11:41.399 --> 02:11:44.640
gave themselves chiefs to defend their liberty, and not to
2153
02:11:44.680 --> 02:11:48.239
be enslaved by them. If we have a prince, said
2154
02:11:48.279 --> 02:11:51.279
Pliny to Trojan, it is in order that he may
2155
02:11:51.399 --> 02:11:55.880
keep us from having a master. Political writers argue in
2156
02:11:55.920 --> 02:11:59.479
regard to the love of liberty with the same philosophy
2157
02:11:59.479 --> 02:12:02.359
that philosophers due in regard to the state of nature
2158
02:12:02.720 --> 02:12:05.279
by the things they see, they judge of things very
2159
02:12:05.279 --> 02:12:08.600
different which they have never seen, and they attribute to
2160
02:12:08.680 --> 02:12:11.880
men a natural inclination to slavery on account of the
2161
02:12:11.960 --> 02:12:15.560
patients with which the slaves within their notice carry the yoke,
2162
02:12:16.520 --> 02:12:19.399
not reflecting that it is with liberty as with innocence
2163
02:12:19.439 --> 02:12:22.640
and virtue, the value of which is not known but
2164
02:12:22.680 --> 02:12:25.479
by those who possess them, though the relish for them
2165
02:12:25.560 --> 02:12:28.840
is lost with the things themselves. I know the charms
2166
02:12:28.880 --> 02:12:31.279
of your country, said bros at Us to a satrap
2167
02:12:31.319 --> 02:12:33.640
who is comparing the life of the Spartans with that
2168
02:12:33.760 --> 02:12:37.159
of the persepolites. But you cannot know the pleasures of mind.
2169
02:12:38.359 --> 02:12:42.399
As an unbroken courser erects his mane pause the ground
2170
02:12:42.479 --> 02:12:45.079
and rages at the bare sight of the bit, while
2171
02:12:45.279 --> 02:12:49.399
a trained horse patiently suffers both whip and spur. Just
2172
02:12:49.520 --> 02:12:52.359
so the barbarian will never reach his neck to the
2173
02:12:52.439 --> 02:12:55.920
yoke which civilized man carries without murmuring, but prefers the
2174
02:12:55.960 --> 02:13:00.600
most stormy liberty to a calm subjection. It is not, therefore,
2175
02:13:00.880 --> 02:13:04.439
by the servile disposition of enslaved nations, that we must
2176
02:13:04.520 --> 02:13:08.439
judge of the natural dispositions of man for or against slavery,
2177
02:13:09.039 --> 02:13:12.000
but by the prodigies done by every free people to
2178
02:13:12.039 --> 02:13:15.840
secure themselves from oppression. I know that the first are
2179
02:13:15.920 --> 02:13:19.399
constantly crying up that peace and tranquility they enjoy in
2180
02:13:19.439 --> 02:13:24.880
their irons, and that miserrimam servitudin pachim appellant. But when
2181
02:13:24.880 --> 02:13:29.079
I see the others sacrifice, pleasures, peace, riches, power, and
2182
02:13:29.159 --> 02:13:32.279
even life itself to the preservation of that single jewel,
2183
02:13:32.399 --> 02:13:35.600
so much slighted by those who have lost it. When
2184
02:13:35.640 --> 02:13:39.479
I see freeborn animals, through a natural abhorrence to captivity,
2185
02:13:39.560 --> 02:13:42.199
dash their brains out against the bars of their prison,
2186
02:13:42.640 --> 02:13:46.800
When I see multitudes of naked savages despise European pleasures
2187
02:13:47.159 --> 02:13:50.800
and brave hunger, fire and sword and death itself to
2188
02:13:50.880 --> 02:13:54.840
preserve their independency, I feel it belongs not to slaves
2189
02:13:54.880 --> 02:14:00.000
to argue concerning liberty as to paternal authority, from which
2190
02:14:00.000 --> 02:14:03.760
which several have derived, absolute government, and every other mode
2191
02:14:03.800 --> 02:14:07.720
of society. It is sufficient, without having recourse to Locke
2192
02:14:07.760 --> 02:14:10.760
and Sydney, to observe that nothing in the world differs
2193
02:14:10.840 --> 02:14:14.079
more from the cruel spirit of despotism that the gentleness
2194
02:14:14.079 --> 02:14:16.920
of that authority, which looks more to the advantage of
2195
02:14:17.039 --> 02:14:20.760
him who obeys than to the utility of him who commands.
2196
02:14:21.239 --> 02:14:24.479
That by the law of nature, the father continues master
2197
02:14:24.640 --> 02:14:27.479
of his child no longer than the child stands in
2198
02:14:27.520 --> 02:14:31.359
need of his assistance, that after that term they become equal,
2199
02:14:31.880 --> 02:14:35.199
and that then the son entirely independent of the father
2200
02:14:35.680 --> 02:14:40.319
owes him no obedience, but only respect. Gratitude is indeed
2201
02:14:40.399 --> 02:14:42.920
a duty which we are bound to pay, but which
2202
02:14:43.000 --> 02:14:47.600
benefactors cannot exact. Instead of saying that civil society is
2203
02:14:47.680 --> 02:14:51.560
derived from paternal authority, we should rather say it is
2204
02:14:51.600 --> 02:14:54.560
to the former that the latter owes its principal force.
2205
02:14:55.560 --> 02:14:58.960
No one individual was acknowledged as the father of several
2206
02:14:58.960 --> 02:15:03.640
other individuals till they settled about him. The father's goods,
2207
02:15:03.960 --> 02:15:07.199
which he can indeed dispose of as he pleases, are
2208
02:15:07.239 --> 02:15:10.800
the ties which hold his children to their dependence upon him,
2209
02:15:11.039 --> 02:15:13.960
And he may divide his substance among them in proportion
2210
02:15:14.079 --> 02:15:17.119
as they shall have deserved his attention by a continual
2211
02:15:17.199 --> 02:15:22.119
deference to his commands. Now, the subjects of a despotic
chief,
2212
02:15:22.279 --> 02:15:25.279
far from having any such favor to expect from him,
2213
02:15:25.600 --> 02:15:28.920
as both themselves and all they have, or his property,
2214
02:15:29.520 --> 02:15:32.439
or at least are considered by him as such, are
2215
02:15:32.479 --> 02:15:35.880
obliged to receive as a favor what he relinquishes to
2216
02:15:36.000 --> 02:15:39.840
them of their own property. He does them justice when
2217
02:15:39.840 --> 02:15:42.720
he strips them, he treats them with mercy when he
2218
02:15:42.800 --> 02:15:46.520
suffers them to live. By continuing in this manner, to
2219
02:15:46.560 --> 02:15:50.760
compare facts with right, we should discover as little solidity
2220
02:15:50.880 --> 02:15:54.760
as truth in the voluntary establishment of tyranny. And it
2221
02:15:54.800 --> 02:15:57.279
would be a hard matter to prove the validity of
2222
02:15:57.319 --> 02:16:01.319
a contract which was binding only on one side, in
2223
02:16:01.399 --> 02:16:04.239
which one of the parties should stake everything and the
2224
02:16:04.319 --> 02:16:07.560
other nothing, and which could turn out to the prejudice
2225
02:16:07.600 --> 02:16:12.760
of him alone who had bound himself. This odious system is,
2226
02:16:12.800 --> 02:16:16.399
even at this day, far from being that of wise
2227
02:16:16.479 --> 02:16:19.760
and good monarchs, and especially of the kings of France,
2228
02:16:20.239 --> 02:16:23.720
as may be seen by diverse passages in their edicts,
2229
02:16:24.439 --> 02:16:28.119
and particularly by that of a celebrated piece published in
2230
02:16:28.199 --> 02:16:31.960
sixteen sixty seven in the name and by the Orders
2231
02:16:32.000 --> 02:16:36.079
of Louis the fourteenth quote. Let it therefore not be
2232
02:16:36.200 --> 02:16:39.360
said that the sovereign is not subject to the laws
2233
02:16:39.399 --> 02:16:42.799
of his realm, Since that he is is a maxim
2234
02:16:42.840 --> 02:16:46.399
of the law of nations, which flattery has sometimes attacked,
2235
02:16:46.639 --> 02:16:50.600
but which good princes have always defended as the tutelary
2236
02:16:50.760 --> 02:16:54.680
divinity of their realms. How much more reasonable is it
2237
02:16:54.760 --> 02:16:58.200
to say, with the sage Plato, that the perfect happiness
2238
02:16:58.200 --> 02:17:01.280
of a state consists in the subject to obeying their prince,
2239
02:17:01.680 --> 02:17:05.719
the prince obeying the laws and the laws being equitable
2240
02:17:05.959 --> 02:17:09.920
and always directed to the good of the public, I
2241
02:17:09.920 --> 02:17:12.879
shall not stop to consider if liberty, being the most
2242
02:17:13.040 --> 02:17:17.040
noble faculty of man, it is not degrading to one's nature,
2243
02:17:17.239 --> 02:17:20.639
reducing one's self to the level of brutes who are
2244
02:17:20.680 --> 02:17:24.319
the slaves of instinct, and even offending the author of
2245
02:17:24.399 --> 02:17:27.879
one's being, to renounce without reserve, the most precious of
2246
02:17:27.920 --> 02:17:30.959
his gifts, and submit to the commission of all the
2247
02:17:31.040 --> 02:17:34.680
crimes he has forbid us merely to gratify a mad
2248
02:17:34.799 --> 02:17:38.799
or cruel master. And if this sublime artist ought to
2249
02:17:38.840 --> 02:17:42.319
be more irritating at seeing his work destroyed than at
2250
02:17:42.360 --> 02:17:46.399
seeing it dishonored, I shall only ask what right those
2251
02:17:46.760 --> 02:17:50.000
who were not afraid thus to degrade themselves could have
2252
02:17:50.200 --> 02:17:54.120
to subject their dependence to the same ignominy, and renounce,
2253
02:17:54.239 --> 02:17:57.479
in the name of their posterity, blessings for which it
2254
02:17:57.559 --> 02:18:01.319
is not indebted to their liberality, and without which life
2255
02:18:01.319 --> 02:18:04.479
itself must appear a burden to all those who are
2256
02:18:04.479 --> 02:18:08.959
worthy to live. Puffendorff says that as we can transfer
2257
02:18:09.000 --> 02:18:12.799
our property from one to another by contracts and conventions,
2258
02:18:12.920 --> 02:18:16.200
we may likewise divest ourselves of our liberty in favor
2259
02:18:16.280 --> 02:18:19.239
of other men. This, in my opinion, is a very
2260
02:18:19.360 --> 02:18:22.559
poor way of arguing, for in the first place, the
2261
02:18:22.600 --> 02:18:26.200
property I see to another becomes by such session a
2262
02:18:26.319 --> 02:18:29.360
thing quite foreign to me, and the abuse of which
2263
02:18:29.440 --> 02:18:32.760
can no way affect me. But it concerns me greatly
2264
02:18:32.799 --> 02:18:36.479
that my liberty is not abused, and I cannot, without
2265
02:18:36.520 --> 02:18:39.319
incurring the guilt of the crimes I may be forced
2266
02:18:39.319 --> 02:18:42.879
to commit, expose myself to become the instrument of any
2267
02:18:43.440 --> 02:18:47.000
Besides the right of property, being of mere human convention
2268
02:18:47.159 --> 02:18:50.559
and institution, every man may dispose as he pleases of
2269
02:18:50.559 --> 02:18:54.000
what he possesses. But the case is otherwise with regard
2270
02:18:54.040 --> 02:18:57.520
to the essential gifts of nature, such as life and liberty,
2271
02:18:57.879 --> 02:19:00.879
which every man is permitted to enjoy, and of which
2272
02:19:00.920 --> 02:19:03.280
it is doubtful at least whether any man has a
2273
02:19:03.360 --> 02:19:06.920
right to divest himself. By giving up the one, we
2274
02:19:07.000 --> 02:19:10.760
degrade our being. By giving up the other, we annihilate it,
2275
02:19:10.799 --> 02:19:12.879
as much as it is our power to do so.
2276
02:19:13.520 --> 02:19:16.879
And as no temporal enjoyments can indemnify us for the
2277
02:19:16.920 --> 02:19:20.680
loss of either, it would be at once offending both
2278
02:19:20.760 --> 02:19:24.840
nature and reason to renounce them for any consideration. But
2279
02:19:24.959 --> 02:19:28.040
though we could transfer our liberty as we do our substance.
2280
02:19:28.399 --> 02:19:31.360
The difference would be very great with regard to our children,
2281
02:19:31.399 --> 02:19:34.760
who enjoy our substance but by a session of our right.
2282
02:19:35.559 --> 02:19:38.840
Whereas liberty being a blessing which as men they hold
2283
02:19:38.920 --> 02:19:42.159
from nature, their parents have no right to strip them
2284
02:19:42.200 --> 02:19:45.040
of it. So that as to establish slavery, it was
2285
02:19:45.079 --> 02:19:49.000
necessary to do violence to nature. So it was necessary
2286
02:19:49.040 --> 02:19:52.319
to alter nature to perpetuate such a right. And the
2287
02:19:52.440 --> 02:19:55.879
juris consults who have gravely pronounced that the child of
2288
02:19:55.879 --> 02:19:59.040
a slave comes a slave into the world, have in
2289
02:19:59.120 --> 02:20:01.840
other words, to say, decided that a man does not
2290
02:20:02.040 --> 02:20:06.280
come a man into the world. It therefore appears to
2291
02:20:06.360 --> 02:20:10.360
me incontestedly true that not only governments did not begin
2292
02:20:10.479 --> 02:20:14.280
by arbitrary power, which is but the corruption and extreme
2293
02:20:14.479 --> 02:20:17.959
term of government, and at length brings it back to
2294
02:20:18.040 --> 02:20:21.399
the law of the strongest, against which governments were at
2295
02:20:21.440 --> 02:20:25.159
first the remedy. But even that, allowing they had commenced
2296
02:20:25.200 --> 02:20:28.520
in this manner, such power, being illegal in itself, could
2297
02:20:28.559 --> 02:20:32.079
never have served as a foundation to the rights of society,
2298
02:20:32.200 --> 02:20:36.319
nor of course, to the inequality of institution. I shall
2299
02:20:36.360 --> 02:20:39.600
not now enter upon the inquiries which still remain to
2300
02:20:39.600 --> 02:20:42.719
be made into the nature of the fundamental pacts of
2301
02:20:42.760 --> 02:20:48.319
every kind of government. But, following the common opinion, confine
2302
02:20:48.360 --> 02:20:51.559
myself in this place to the establishment of the political
2303
02:20:51.600 --> 02:20:55.000
body as a real contract between the multitude and the
2304
02:20:55.120 --> 02:20:59.000
chiefs elected by it, a contract by which both parties
2305
02:20:59.000 --> 02:21:02.680
obliged themselves to the observance of the laws that are
2306
02:21:02.719 --> 02:21:07.120
therein stipulated and form the bands of their union. The multitude,
2307
02:21:07.159 --> 02:21:11.399
having on occasion of the social relations between them, concentered
2308
02:21:11.559 --> 02:21:15.200
all their wills in one person. All the articles in
2309
02:21:15.280 --> 02:21:18.959
regard to which this will explains itself becomes so many
2310
02:21:19.079 --> 02:21:23.239
fundamental laws which oblige without exception all the members of
2311
02:21:23.280 --> 02:21:26.959
the state,
and one of which laws regulates the choice
2312
02:21:27.000 --> 02:21:29.920
and the power of the magistrates appointed to look to
2313
02:21:29.959 --> 02:21:34.239
the execution of the rest. This power extends to everything
2314
02:21:34.280 --> 02:21:37.959
that can maintain the constitution, but extends to nothing that
2315
02:21:38.000 --> 02:21:42.000
can alter it. To this power are added honors that
2316
02:21:42.120 --> 02:21:45.440
may render the laws and the ministers of them respectable.
2317
02:21:45.920 --> 02:21:49.239
And the persons of the ministers are distinguished by certain
2318
02:21:49.319 --> 02:21:54.280
prerogatives which may take them amends for the great fatigues,
2319
02:21:54.319 --> 02:21:59.000
and inseparable from a good administration. The magistrate on his
2320
02:21:59.159 --> 02:22:02.879
side a bliged himself not to use the power with
2321
02:22:03.000 --> 02:22:07.079
which he is entrusted, but conformably to the intention of
2322
02:22:07.120 --> 02:22:10.319
his constituents, to maintain every one of them in the
2323
02:22:10.399 --> 02:22:14.840
peaceable possession of his property, and upon all occasions prefer
2324
02:22:15.000 --> 02:22:17.840
the good of the public to his own private interest.
2325
02:22:19.239 --> 02:22:22.879
Before experience had demonstrated, or a thorough knowledge of the
2326
02:22:22.959 --> 02:22:26.280
human heart had pointed out the abuses inseparable from such
2327
02:22:26.319 --> 02:22:30.280
a constitution, it must have appeared so much the more perfect,
2328
02:22:30.600 --> 02:22:33.959
as those appointed to look to its preservation were themselves
2329
02:22:34.200 --> 02:22:39.639
most concerned therein. For magistracy and its rights being built
2330
02:22:39.680 --> 02:22:43.760
solely on the fundamental laws, so soon as these ceased
2331
02:22:43.799 --> 02:22:47.360
to exist, the magistrates would cease to be lawful, the
2332
02:22:47.399 --> 02:22:50.680
people would no longer be bound to obey them, And
2333
02:22:50.719 --> 02:22:53.200
as the essence of the state did not consist in
2334
02:22:53.239 --> 02:22:56.239
the magistrates, but in the laws, the members of it
2335
02:22:56.280 --> 02:22:59.879
would immediately become entitled to their primitive and natural liberty.
2336
02:23:01.319 --> 02:23:05.079
A little reflection would afford us new arguments in confirmation
2337
02:23:05.200 --> 02:23:08.239
of this truth, and the nature of the contract might
2338
02:23:08.280 --> 02:23:12.559
alone convince us that it cannot be irrevocable. For if
2339
02:23:12.600 --> 02:23:16.520
there was no superior power capable of guaranteeing the fidelity
2340
02:23:16.639 --> 02:23:20.319
of the contracting parties, and of obliging them to fulfill
2341
02:23:20.399 --> 02:23:24.200
their mutual engagements. They would remain sole judges in their
2342
02:23:24.200 --> 02:23:26.799
own case, and each of them would always have a
2343
02:23:26.879 --> 02:23:30.159
right to
renounce the contract as soon as he discovered
2344
02:23:30.280 --> 02:23:33.120
that the other had broke the conditions of it, or
2345
02:23:33.159 --> 02:23:37.479
that these conditions ceased to suit his private convenience. Upon
2346
02:23:37.559 --> 02:23:41.479
this principle, the right of abdication may probably be founded.
2347
02:23:42.079 --> 02:23:44.719
Now To consider, as we do nothing, but what is
2348
02:23:44.840 --> 02:23:48.360
human in this institution? If the magistrate, who has all
2349
02:23:48.399 --> 02:23:51.600
the power in his own hands, and who appropriates to
2350
02:23:51.719 --> 02:23:55.840
himself all the advantages of the contract, has notwithstanding a
2351
02:23:55.959 --> 02:23:59.159
right to divest himself of his authority, how much a
2352
02:23:59.200 --> 02:24:01.760
better right must the people, who pay for all the
2353
02:24:01.840 --> 02:24:05.639
faults of its chief have to renounce their dependence upon him.
2354
02:24:06.520 --> 02:24:10.639
But the shocking dissensions and disorders without number which would
2355
02:24:10.680 --> 02:24:14.319
be the necessary consequence of so dangerous a privilege, show
2356
02:24:14.440 --> 02:24:17.639
more than anything else, how much a human government stood
2357
02:24:17.719 --> 02:24:20.239
in need of a more solid basis than that of
2358
02:24:20.319 --> 02:24:23.840
mere reason, and how necessary it was for the public
2359
02:24:23.879 --> 02:24:27.799
tranquility that the will of the Almighty should interpose to
2360
02:24:27.920 --> 02:24:33.120
give to sovereign authority, a sacred and inviolable character, which
2361
02:24:33.120 --> 02:24:36.319
should deprive subjects of the mischievous right to dispose of
2362
02:24:36.360 --> 02:24:40.120
it whom they pleased. If mankind had received no other
2363
02:24:40.200 --> 02:24:43.799
advantages from religion, this alone would be sufficient to make
2364
02:24:43.840 --> 02:24:46.959
them adopt and cherish it, since it is the means
2365
02:24:47.000 --> 02:24:50.639
of saving more blood than fanaticism has been the cause
2366
02:24:50.680 --> 02:24:54.680
of the spilling. But to resume the thread of our hypothesis,
2367
02:24:55.360 --> 02:24:58.239
the various forms of government owe their origin to the
2368
02:24:58.319 --> 02:25:01.879
various degrees of inequality between the members at the time
2369
02:25:01.920 --> 02:25:05.639
they first coalesced into a political body. Where a man
2370
02:25:05.760 --> 02:25:09.200
happened to be eminent for power, for virtue, for riches,
2371
02:25:09.600 --> 02:25:13.159
or for credit, he became sole magistrate, and the state
2372
02:25:13.280 --> 02:25:17.920
assumed a monarchical form. If many of pretty equal eminence
2373
02:25:18.200 --> 02:25:21.600
out topped all the rest, they were jointly elected, and
2374
02:25:21.719 --> 02:25:26.360
this election produced an aristocracy. Those between whose fortune or
2375
02:25:26.399 --> 02:25:29.799
talents there happened to be no such disproportion, and who
2376
02:25:29.840 --> 02:25:32.840
had deviated less from the state of nature, retained in
2377
02:25:32.959 --> 02:25:37.840
common the supreme administration and formed a democracy. Time demonstrated
2378
02:25:37.840 --> 02:25:42.200
which of these forms suited mankind best. Some remained altogether
2379
02:25:42.360 --> 02:25:46.559
subject to the laws, others soon bowed their next to masters.
2380
02:25:47.120 --> 02:25:50.719
The former labored to preserve their liberty. The latter thought
2381
02:25:50.760 --> 02:25:54.600
of nothing but invading that of their neighbors, jealous at
2382
02:25:54.600 --> 02:25:58.879
seeing others enjoy a blessing which themselves had lost. In
2383
02:25:58.959 --> 02:26:02.559
a word, riches and conquest fell to the share of
2384
02:26:02.600 --> 02:26:05.959
the one, and virtue and happiness to that of the other.
2385
02:26:07.319 --> 02:26:10.760
In these various modes of government, the offices at first
2386
02:26:10.799 --> 02:26:15.200
were all elective, and when riches did not preponderate, the
2387
02:26:15.239 --> 02:26:18.639
preference was given to merit, which gives a natural ascendant,
2388
02:26:18.840 --> 02:26:22.000
and to age, which is the parent of deliberateness in
2389
02:26:22.079 --> 02:26:27.280
council and experience in execution. The ancients, among the Hebrews,
2390
02:26:27.399 --> 02:26:31.079
the Geruns of Sparta, the Senate of Rome. Nay, the
2391
02:26:31.200 --> 02:26:34.799
very etymology of our word signor shows how much gray
2392
02:26:34.920 --> 02:26:39.559
hairs were formerly respected the oftener. The choice fell upon
2393
02:26:39.680 --> 02:26:42.639
old men. The oftener it became necessary to repeat it,
2394
02:26:43.079 --> 02:26:46.360
and the more the trouble of such repetitions became sensible.
2395
02:26:46.760 --> 02:26:52.000
Electioneering took place, Factions arose, the parties contracted ill blood,
2396
02:26:52.440 --> 02:26:56.000
civil wars blazed forth. The lives of the citizens were
2397
02:26:56.040 --> 02:26:59.600
sacrificed to the pretended happiness of the state, and things
2398
02:26:59.639 --> 02:27:02.040
at last came to such a pass as to be
2399
02:27:02.120 --> 02:27:06.520
ready to relapse into their primitive confusion. The ambition of
2400
02:27:06.559 --> 02:27:09.479
the principal men induced them to take advantage of these
2401
02:27:09.559 --> 02:27:14.319
circumstances to perpetuate the hitherto temporary charges in their families.
2402
02:27:15.319 --> 02:27:19.399
The people, already erred to dependence, accustomed to ease and
2403
02:27:19.440 --> 02:27:22.959
the conveniences of life, and too much enervated to break
2404
02:27:23.000 --> 02:27:26.440
their fetters, consented to the increase of their slavery for
2405
02:27:26.520 --> 02:27:30.159
the sake of securing their tranquility. And it is thus
2406
02:27:30.239 --> 02:27:34.719
that chiefs become hereditary. Contracted the habit
of considering magistracies
2407
02:27:34.760 --> 02:27:38.959
as a family estate, and themselves as proprietors of those
2408
02:27:39.000 --> 02:27:42.319
communities of which at first they were but mere officers,
2409
02:27:42.600 --> 02:27:45.520
to call their fellow citizens their slaves, to look upon
2410
02:27:45.639 --> 02:27:48.639
them like so many cows or sheep, as a part
2411
02:27:48.639 --> 02:27:51.879
of their substance, and to style themselves the peers of
2412
02:27:51.959 --> 02:27:56.319
gods and kings of kings. By pursuing the progress of
2413
02:27:56.319 --> 02:27:59.959
inequality in these different revolutions, we shall discover that these
2414
02:28:00.000 --> 02:28:03.200
the establishment of laws and of the right of property
2415
02:28:03.680 --> 02:28:07.319
was the first term of it. The institution of magistrates,
2416
02:28:07.360 --> 02:28:10.440
the second, and the third and last the changing of
2417
02:28:10.520 --> 02:28:14.200
legal and arbitrary power, so that the different states of
2418
02:28:14.280 --> 02:28:17.959
rich and poor were authorized by the first epoch, those
2419
02:28:18.000 --> 02:28:20.840
of powerful and weak, by the second, and by the
2420
02:28:20.920 --> 02:28:24.360
third those of master and slave, which form the last
2421
02:28:24.399 --> 02:28:27.639
degree of inequality, and the term in which all the
2422
02:28:27.680 --> 02:28:31.520
rest at last end till new revolutions entirely dissolve the
2423
02:28:31.559 --> 02:28:35.000
government or bring it back nearer to its legal constitution.
2424
02:28:36.239 --> 02:28:39.159
To conceive the necessity of this progress, we are not
2425
02:28:39.280 --> 02:28:42.399
so much to consider the motives for the establishment of
2426
02:28:42.440 --> 02:28:46.959
political bodies as the forms these bodies assume in their administration,
2427
02:28:47.840 --> 02:28:51.920
and the inconveniences with which they are essentially attended. For
2428
02:28:52.000 --> 02:28:56.600
those vices which render social institutions necessary are the same
2429
02:28:56.639 --> 02:29:01.440
which render the abuse of such institutions unavoidable. And, as
2430
02:29:01.559 --> 02:29:05.680
Sparta alone accepted, whose laws chiefly regarded the education of children,
2431
02:29:05.760 --> 02:29:09.079
and where Lycurgus established such manners and customs as in
2432
02:29:09.159 --> 02:29:13.239
great measure made laws needless, the laws in general less
2433
02:29:13.280 --> 02:29:17.200
strong than the passions restrain men without changing them, it
2434
02:29:17.239 --> 02:29:20.000
would be no hard matter to prove that every government,
2435
02:29:20.479 --> 02:29:25.120
which carefully guarding against all alteration and corruption, should scrupulously
2436
02:29:25.159 --> 02:29:29.399
comply with the ends of its institution was unnecessarily instituted,
2437
02:29:29.879 --> 02:29:32.920
And that a country where no one either eluded the
2438
02:29:33.000 -->
02:29:36.639
laws or made an ill use of magistracy required neither
2439
02:29:36.760 --> 02:29:42.959
laws nor magistrates. Political distinctions are necessarily attended with civil distinctions.
2440
02:29:43.520 --> 02:29:46.719
The inequality between the people and the chiefs increase so
2441
02:29:46.879 --> 02:29:49.799
fast as to be soon felt by the private members,
2442
02:29:50.319 --> 02:29:53.399
and appears among them in a thousand shapes, according to
2443
02:29:53.479 --> 02:29:57.319
their passions, their talents, and the circumstances of affairs. The
2444
02:29:57.360 --> 02:30:01.959
magistrate cannot usurp any illegal power without making himself creatures
2445
02:30:02.319 --> 02:30:05.600
with whom he must divide it. Besides, the citizens of
2446
02:30:05.639 --> 02:30:09.079
a free state suffer themselves to be oppressed merely in proportion,
2447
02:30:09.319 --> 02:30:12.719
as hurried on by a blind ambition, and looking rather
2448
02:30:12.840 --> 02:30:15.959
below than above them, they come to love authority more
2449
02:30:16.000 --> 02:30:19.840
than independence. When they submit to fetters, tis only to
2450
02:30:19.879 --> 02:30:22.559
be the better able to fetter others in their turn.
2451
02:30:23.280 --> 02:30:25.840
It is no easy matter to make them obey who
2452
02:30:25.879 --> 02:30:29.280
did not wish to command, and the most refined policy
2453
02:30:29.319 --> 02:30:32.079
would find it impossible to subdue those men who only
2454
02:30:32.120 --> 02:30:36.760
desire to be independent. But inequality easily gains ground among
2455
02:30:36.920 --> 02:30:40.120
base and ambitious souls. Ever, ready to run the risks
2456
02:30:40.159 --> 02:30:43.639
of fortune, and almost indifferent whether they command or obey,
2457
02:30:44.200 --> 02:30:48.280
as she proves either favorable or adverse to them. Thus,
2458
02:30:48.360 --> 02:30:50.520
then there must have been a time when the eyes
2459
02:30:50.559 --> 02:30:53.159
of the people were bewitched to such a degree that
2460
02:30:53.200 --> 02:30:55.760
their rulers needed only to have said, to the most
2461
02:30:55.799 --> 02:30:59.760
pitiful wretch, be great you and all your posterity, to
2462
02:30:59.799 --> 02:31:03.399
make make him immediately appear great in the eyes of everyone,
2463
02:31:03.479 --> 02:31:07.000
as well as in his own. And his descendants took
2464
02:31:07.040 --> 02:31:10.840
still more upon them in proportion to their removes from him.
2465
02:31:11.600 --> 02:31:15.079
The more distant and uncertain the cause, the greater the effect,
2466
02:31:15.719 --> 02:31:19.280
The longer lines of drones of family produced, the more
2467
02:31:19.319 --> 02:31:23.920
illustrious it was reckoned. Were this a proper place to
2468
02:31:24.079 --> 02:31:27.319
enter into details, I could easily explain in what manner
2469
02:31:27.399 --> 02:31:31.760
inequalities in point of credit and authority become unavoidable among
2470
02:31:31.840 --> 02:31:36.120
private persons the moment that united into one body, they
2471
02:31:36.120 --> 02:31:39.600
are obliged to compare themselves one with another, and to
2472
02:31:39.680 --> 02:31:43.280
note the differences which they find in the continual use
2473
02:31:43.479 --> 02:31:47.360
every man must make of his neighbor. These differences are
2474
02:31:47.399 --> 02:31:51.120
of several kinds, but riches nobility or rank, power, and
2475
02:31:51.200 --> 02:31:54.600
personal merit being, in general the principal distinctions by which
2476
02:31:54.680 --> 02:31:57.840
men in society measure each other. I could prove that
2477
02:31:57.879 --> 02:32:01.200
the harmony or conflict between these different forces is the
2478
02:32:01.239 --> 02:32:04.840
surest indication of the good or bad original constitution of
2479
02:32:04.879 --> 02:32:08.360
any state. I could make it appear that, as among
2480
02:32:08.440 --> 02:32:12.440
these four kinds of inequality, personal qualities are the source
2481
02:32:12.479 --> 02:32:15.840
of all the rest riches, is that in which they
2482
02:32:15.920 --> 02:32:20.200
ultimately terminate, because being the most immediately useful to the
2483
02:32:20.239 --> 02:32:25.000
prosperity of individuals and the most easy to communicate, they
2484
02:32:25.040 --> 02:32:28.719
are made use of to purchase every other distinction. By
2485
02:32:28.760 --> 02:32:32.840
this observation, we are enabled to judge with tolerable exactness
2486
02:32:33.120 --> 02:32:36.680
how much any people has deviated from its primitive institution,
2487
02:32:37.319 --> 02:32:39.680
and what steps it has still to make. The extreme
2488
02:32:39.840 --> 02:32:44.040
term of corruption. I could show how much this universal
2489
02:32:44.120 --> 02:32:47.920
desire of reputation, of honors, of preference with which we
2490
02:32:48.000 --> 02:32:52.120
are all devoured, exercises and compares our talents and our forces,
2491
02:32:52.760 --> 02:32:56.280
how much it excites and multiplies our passions, and by
2492
02:32:56.319 --> 02:33:01.120
creating a universal competition, rivalship, or rather enmity among men,
2493
02:33:01.600 --> 02:33:05.520
how many disappointments, successes, and catastrophes of every kind it
2494
02:33:05.680 --> 02:33:10.040
daily causes among the innumerable pretenders whom it engages in
2495
02:33:10.079 --> 02:33:13.799
the same career, I could show that it is to
2496
02:33:13.879 --> 02:33:16.479
this itch of being spoken of, to this fury of
2497
02:33:16.520 --> 02:33:20.399
distinguishing ourselves, which seldom never gives us a moment's respite,
2498
02:33:20.719 --> 02:33:23.399
that we owe both the best and the worst things
2499
02:33:23.440 --> 02:33:27.200
among us, our virtues and our vices, our sciences and
2500
02:33:27.239 --> 02:33:31.719
our errors, our conquerors and our philosophers. That is to say,
2501
02:33:32.079 --> 02:33:35.280
a great many bad things to
the very few good ones.
2502
02:33:36.000 --> 02:33:38.760
I could prove, in short, that if we behold a
2503
02:33:38.840 --> 02:33:42.120
handful of rich and powerful men seated on the pinnacle
2504
02:33:42.159 --> 02:33:45.760
of fortune and greatness, while the crowd grovel in obscurity
2505
02:33:45.799 --> 02:33:48.680
and want it is merely because the first prize what
2506
02:33:48.760 --> 02:33:51.840
they enjoy, but in the same degree that others want it,
2507
02:33:52.920 --> 02:33:56.239
and that without changing their condition, they would cease to
2508
02:33:56.280 --> 02:33:59.079
be happy the minute the people cease to be miserable.
2509
02:33:59.440 --> 02:34:02.920
But these details would alone furnish sufficient matter for a
2510
02:34:02.959 --> 02:34:07.440
more considerable work, in which might be weighed the advantages
2511
02:34:07.479 --> 02:34:11.120
and disadvantages of every species of government relatively to the
2512
02:34:11.200 --> 02:34:13.959
rights of man in a state of nature. It might
2513
02:34:14.120 --> 02:34:18.040
likewise be unveiled all the different faces under which inequality
2514
02:34:18.200 --> 02:34:21.920
has appeared to this day, and may hereafter appear to
2515
02:34:22.000 --> 02:34:24.840
the end of time. According to the nature of these
2516
02:34:24.879 --> 02:34:30.319
several governments, and the revolution's time must unavoidably occasion in them.
2517
02:34:30.879 --> 02:34:34.159
We should then see the multitude oppressed by domestic tyrants,
2518
02:34:34.200 --> 02:34:37.559
and consequence of those very precautions taken by them to
2519
02:34:37.639 --> 02:34:42.159
guard against foreign masters. We should see oppression increase continually,
2520
02:34:42.239 --> 02:34:44.719
without its being ever possible for the oppressed to know
2521
02:34:44.799 --> 02:34:47.799
where it would stop, nor what lawful means they had
2522
02:34:47.879 --> 02:34:51.000
left to check its progress. We should see the rights
2523
02:34:51.000 --> 02:34:54.680
of citizens and the liberties of nations extinguished by slow degrees,
2524
02:34:55.159 --> 02:34:58.840
and the groans and protestations and appeals of the week
2525
02:34:58.959 --> 02:35:03.440
treated as seditious murmurings. We should see policy confined to
2526
02:35:03.520 --> 02:35:06.799
a mercenary portion of the people the honor of defending
2527
02:35:06.840 --> 02:35:10.959
the common cause. We should see imposts made necessary by
2528
02:35:10.959 --> 02:35:15.799
such measures, the disheartened husbandmen desert his field even in
2529
02:35:15.920 --> 02:35:18.680
time of peace, and quit the plow to take up
2530
02:35:18.719 --> 02:35:23.000
the sword. We should see fatal and whimsical rules laid
2531
02:35:23.040 --> 02:35:26.319
down considering the point of honor. We should see the
2532
02:35:26.440 --> 02:35:29.920
champions of their country sooner or later become her enemies,
2533
02:35:30.440 --> 02:35:33.520
and perpetually holding the ponyards to the breasts of their
2534
02:35:33.520 --> 02:35:37.000
fellow citizens. Nay, the time would come when they might
2535
02:35:37.040 --> 02:35:39.639
be heard to say to the oppressor of their country
2536
02:35:40.239 --> 02:35:49.479
pectore see fratris gladium juguloque parentis condere me jubias gravidoeque
2537
02:35:49.680 --> 02:35:56.159
in viscera partu conjugus in vita peragum tommin omnia dextra
2538
02:35:57.760 --> 02:36:01.520
from the vast inequality of conditions and fortunes. From this
2539
02:36:01.680 --> 02:36:05.440
great variety of passions and of talents, of useless arts,
2540
02:36:05.440 --> 02:36:09.840
of pernicious arts, of frivolous sciences, would issue clouds of
2541
02:36:09.920 --> 02:36:14.799
prejudices equally contrary to reason, to happiness, to virtue. We
2542
02:36:14.799 --> 02:36:18.200
should see the chiefs ferment everything that tends to weaken
2543
02:36:18.319 --> 02:36:22.959
men formed into societies by dividing them, Everything that, while
2544
02:36:22.959 --> 02:36:26.719
it gives society an air of apparent harmony, sows in
2545
02:36:26.799 --> 02:36:30.159
it the seeds of real division. Everything that can inspire
2546
02:36:30.239 --> 02:36:33.399
the different orders with mutual distrust and hatred by an
2547
02:36:33.399 --> 02:36:37.120
opposition of their rights and interests, and of course strengthen
2548
02:36:37.200 --> 02:36:40.639
that power which contains them all. Tis from the bosom
2549
02:36:40.719 --> 02:36:45.280
of this disorder and these revolutions, that despotism gradually rearing
2550
02:36:45.360 --> 02:36:48.760
up her hideous crests and devouring in every part of
2551
02:36:48.799 --> 02:36:52.760
the state. All that still remained sound and untainted, would
2552
02:36:52.760 --> 02:36:55.959
at last issue to trample upon the laws and the people,
2553
02:36:56.479 --> 02:37:00.680
and establish herself upon the ruins of the republic. The
2554
02:37:00.719 --> 02:37:04.680
times immediately preceding this last alteration would be times of
2555
02:37:04.719 --> 02:37:08.520
calamity and trouble, But at last everything would be swallowed
2556
02:37:08.639 --> 02:37:11.399
up by the monster, and the people would no longer
2557
02:37:11.520 --> 02:37:16.200
have chiefs or laws, but only tyrants. At this fatal period,
2558
02:37:16.319 --> 02:37:20.159
all regard to virtue and manners would likewise disappear. For
2559
02:37:20.319 --> 02:37:26.840
despotism Cui ex honesto nolla est space tolerates no other master.
2560
02:37:27.040 --> 02:37:31.159
Wherever it rains the moment it speaks, Probity and duty
2561
02:37:31.280 --> 02:37:35.000
lose all their influence, and the blindest obedience is the
2562
02:37:35.040 --> 02:37:38.840
only virtue the miserable slaves have left them to practice.
2563
02:37:39.319 --> 02:37:43.000
This is the last term of inequality. The extreme point
2564
02:37:43.040 --> 02:37:46.120
which closes the circle and meets that
which we set out.
2565
02:37:46.760 --> 02:37:50.639
Tis here that all private men return to their primitive equality,
2566
02:37:51.079 --> 02:37:54.680
because they are no longer of any account, and that
2567
02:37:54.799 --> 02:37:57.479
the subjects having no longer any law but that of
2568
02:37:57.520 --> 02:38:00.760
their masters, nor the master any law the law but
2569
02:38:00.920 --> 02:38:04.959
his passions, all notions of good and principles of justice
2570
02:38:05.000 --> 02:38:09.319
again disappear. Tis here that everything returns to the sole
2571
02:38:09.479 --> 02:38:12.479
law of the strongest, and of course to a new
2572
02:38:12.520 --> 02:38:15.079
state of nature, different from that with which we began.
2573
02:38:15.280 --> 02:38:17.879
Inasmuch as the first was the state of nature and
2574
02:38:17.920 --> 02:38:22.000
its purity, and the last the consequence of excessive corruption.
2575
02:38:22.840 --> 02:38:26.639
There is, in other respects so little difference between these
2576
02:38:26.639 --> 02:38:29.559
two states, and the contract of government is so much
2577
02:38:29.600 --> 02:38:33.719
dissolved by despotism, that the despot is no longer master
2578
02:38:33.920 --> 02:38:37.399
than he continues the strongest, and that as soon as
2579
02:38:37.399 --> 02:38:40.239
his slaves can expel him, they may do it without
2580
02:38:40.280 --> 02:38:42.639
his having the least right to complain of their using
2581
02:38:42.719 --> 02:38:46.159
him ill. The insurrection which ends in the death or
2582
02:38:46.319 --> 02:38:49.680
despotism of a sultan is as juridical an act as
2583
02:38:49.719 --> 02:38:52.440
any by which, the day before he disposed of the
2584
02:38:52.479 --> 02:38:56.840
lives and fortunes of his subjects, Force alone upheld him,
2585
02:38:57.040 --> 02:39:00.920
force alone overturns him. Thus all things take place and
2586
02:39:00.959 --> 02:39:04.040
succeed in their natural order. And whatever may be the
2587
02:39:04.159 --> 02:39:07.959
upshot of these hasty and frequent revolutions, no one man
2588
02:39:08.000 --> 02:39:11.200
has reason to complain of another's injustice, but only of
2589
02:39:11.280 --> 02:39:16.520
his own. Indiscretion or bad fortune. By thus discovering and
2590
02:39:16.639 --> 02:39:20.399
following the lost and forgotten tracts by which man from
2591
02:39:20.399 --> 02:39:23.879
the natural must have arrived at the civil state. By
2592
02:39:24.000 --> 02:39:27.200
restoring with the intermediate positions which I have been just
2593
02:39:27.319 --> 02:39:31.479
indicating those which want of leisure obliges me to suppress,
2594
02:39:31.920 --> 02:39:35.680
or which my imagination has not suggested, every attentive reader
2595
02:39:35.760 --> 02:39:39.479
must unavoidably be struck that the immense space which separates
2596
02:39:39.520 --> 02:39:44.120
these two states tis in this slow succession of things.
2597
02:39:44.360 --> 02:39:47.000
He may meet with the solution of an infinite number
2598
02:39:47.000 --> 02:39:51.040
of problems in morality and politics which philosophers are puzzled
2599
02:39:51.079 --> 02:39:54.319
to solve. He will perceive that the mankind of one
2600
02:39:54.360 --> 02:39:58.399
age not being the mankind of another. The reason why
2601
02:39:58.559 --> 02:40:01.920
Diogenes could not f a man was that he sought
2602
02:40:01.959 --> 02:40:06.079
among his contemporaries the man of an earlier period Cato.
2603
02:40:06.440 --> 02:40:09.920
He will then see fell with Rome and with liberty,
2604
02:40:10.319 --> 02:40:13.120
because he did not suit the age in which he lived,
2605
02:40:13.600 --> 02:40:17.000
and the greatest of men served only to astonish that world,
2606
02:40:17.040 --> 02:40:19.959
which would have cheerfully obeyed them had he come into
2607
02:40:20.040 --> 02:40:24.040
a five hundred years earlier. In a word, he finds
2608
02:40:24.120 --> 02:40:27.159
himself in a condition to understand how the soul and
2609
02:40:27.200 --> 02:40:31.399
the passions of men, by insensible alterations, change, as it were,
2610
02:40:31.479 --> 02:40:34.520
their nature. How it comes to pass that, at the
2611
02:40:34.559 --> 02:40:38.120
long run, our wants and our pleasures change objects, that
2612
02:40:38.639 --> 02:40:43.719
original man vanishing by degrees, Society no longer offers our inspection,
2613
02:40:43.840 --> 02:40:47.520
but an assemblage of artificial men and factitious passions, which
2614
02:40:47.559 --> 02:40:50.159
are the work of all these new relations, and have
2615
02:40:50.280 --> 02:40:54.840
no foundation in nature. Reflection teaches us nothing on that head,
2616
02:40:55.159 --> 02:40:59.920
but what experience perfectly confirms. Savage man and civilized man
2617
02:41:00.040 --> 02:41:03.440
differs so much at bottom in point of inclinations and passions,
2618
02:41:03.719 --> 02:41:06.840
that what constitutes the supreme happiness of the one would
2619
02:41:06.840 --> 02:41:10.280
reduce the other to despair. The first size for nothing
2620
02:41:10.319 --> 02:41:13.840
but repose and liberty. He desires only to live and
2621
02:41:13.920 --> 02:41:18.000
to be exempt from labor. Nay, the adoraxy of the
2622
02:41:18.040 --> 02:41:21.559
most confirmed stoic falls short of his consummate indifference for
2623
02:41:21.639 --> 02:41:26.159
every other object. On the contrary, the citizen, always in motion,
2624
02:41:26.840 --> 02:41:30.719
is perpetually sweating and toiling and racking his brains to
2625
02:41:30.760 --> 02:41:35.479
find out occupation. Still more laborious, he continues a drudge
2626
02:41:35.520 --> 02:41:38.760
to his last minute. Nay, he courts death to be
2627
02:41:38.799 --> 02:41:42.799
able to live or renounce his life to acquire immortality.
2628
02:41:43.680 --> 02:41:47.159
He cringes to men in power whom he hates, and
2629
02:41:47.200 --> 02:41:51.079
to rich men, whom he
despises. He sticks at nothing
2630
02:41:51.120 --> 02:41:53.760
to have the honor of serving them. He is not
2631
02:41:53.920 --> 02:41:57.200
ashamed to value himself on his own weakness and the
2632
02:41:57.239 --> 02:42:01.440
protection they afford him, and proud of his he speaks
2633
02:42:01.440 --> 02:42:04.079
with disdain of those who have not the honor of
2634
02:42:04.159 --> 02:42:08.520
being the partner of his bondage. What a spectacle must
2635
02:42:08.520 --> 02:42:11.760
the painful and envied labors of a European minister of
2636
02:42:11.799 --> 02:42:15.239
state form in the eyes of a Caribbean How many
2637
02:42:15.319 --> 02:42:18.799
cruel deaths would not this indolence savage prefer to such
2638
02:42:18.840 --> 02:42:22.399
a horrid life, which very often is not even sweetened
2639
02:42:22.399 --> 02:42:25.360
by the pleasure of doing good. But to see the
2640
02:42:25.479 --> 02:42:28.600
drift of so many cares, his mind should first have
2641
02:42:28.639 --> 02:42:32.879
affixed some meaning to these words power and reputation. He
2642
02:42:32.920 --> 02:42:35.959
should be apprized that there are men who consider as
2643
02:42:36.000 --> 02:42:39.520
something the looks of the rest of mankind, who know
2644
02:42:39.680 --> 02:42:42.239
how to be happy and satisfied with themselves on the
2645
02:42:42.280 --> 02:42:46.319
testimony of others sooner than upon their own. In fact,
2646
02:42:46.639 --> 02:42:49.600
the real source of all those differences is that the
2647
02:42:49.639 --> 02:42:54.600
savage lives within himself, whereas the citizen constantly beside himself
2648
02:42:54.879 --> 02:42:57.479
knows only how to live in the opinion of others,
2649
02:42:58.079 --> 02:43:01.799
insomuch that it is, if I may say, so, merely
2650
02:43:01.879 --> 02:43:05.040
from their judgment, that he derives the consciousness of his
2651
02:43:05.120 --> 02:43:09.280
own existence. It is foreign to my subject to show
2652
02:43:09.360 --> 02:43:13.120
how this disposition engenders so much indifference for good and evil,
2653
02:43:13.520 --> 02:43:19.000
notwithstanding so many and such fine discourses of morality, how everything,
2654
02:43:19.120 --> 02:43:25.600
being reduced to appearances, becomes mere art and mummery, honor, friendship, virtue,
2655
02:43:25.639 --> 02:43:29.360
and often vice itself, which we at last learn the
2656
02:43:29.399 --> 02:43:33.399
secret to boast of. How, in short, ever inquiring of
2657
02:43:33.479 --> 02:43:37.159
others what we are, and never daring to question ourselves
2658
02:43:37.159 --> 02:43:39.680
on so delicate a point, in the midst of so
2659
02:43:39.879 --> 02:43:44.680
much philosophy, humanity, and politeness, and so many sublime maxims,
2660
02:43:45.200 --> 02:43:48.000
we have nothing to show for ourselves but a deceitful
2661
02:43:48.040 --> 02:43:53.040
and frivolous exterior. Honor without virtue, reason without wisdom, and
2662
02:43:53.159 --> 02:43:57.719
pleasure without happiness. It is sufficient that I have proved
2663
02:43:57.760 --> 02:44:00.799
that this is not the original condition of man, and
2664
02:44:00.879 --> 02:44:03.799
that it is merely the spirit of society and the
2665
02:44:03.840 --> 02:44:08.399
inequality which society engenders, that thus change and transform all
2666
02:44:08.479 --> 02:44:13.520
our natural inclinations. I have endeavored to exhibit the origin
2667
02:44:13.600 --> 02:44:18.520
and progress of inequality the institution and abuse of political societies,
2668
02:44:18.680 --> 02:44:21.239
as far as these things are capable of being deduced
2669
02:44:21.280 --> 02:44:24.000
from the nature of man by the mere light of reason,
2670
02:44:24.360 --> 02:44:27.879
and independently of those sacred maxims which give to the
2671
02:44:28.000 --> 02:44:32.239
sovereign authority the sanction of divine right. It follows from
2672
02:44:32.280 --> 02:44:36.079
this picture that as there is scarce any inequality among
2673
02:44:36.159 --> 02:44:38.840
men in a state of nature, all that which we
2674
02:44:38.920 --> 02:44:41.719
now behold owes its force and its growth to the
2675
02:44:41.760 --> 02:44:45.360
development of our faculties and the improvement of our understanding,
2676
02:44:46.000 --> 02:44:49.680
and at last becomes permanent and lawful by the establishment
2677
02:44:50.120 --> 02:44:54.879
of property and of laws. It likewise follows that moral inequality,
2678
02:44:55.000 --> 02:44:59.159
authorized by any right that is merely positive, clashes with
2679
02:44:59.319 --> 02:45:02.639
natural rights as often as it does not combine in
2680
02:45:02.680 --> 02:45:07.159
the same proportion with physical inequality, a distinction which sufficiently
2681
02:45:07.200 --> 02:45:10.680
determines what we are able to think in that respect
2682
02:45:10.760 --> 02:45:15.280
of that kind of inequality which obtains in all civilized nations.
2683
02:45:16.040 --> 02:45:18.840
Since it is evidently against the law of nature that
2684
02:45:18.920 --> 02:45:23.360
infancies should command old age, folly, conduct, wisdom, and a
2685
02:45:23.440 --> 02:45:26.760
handful of men should be ready to choke with superfluities,
2686
02:45:27.120 --> 02:45:33.239
while the famished multitude want the commonest necessaries of life.
2687
02:45:35.000 --> 02:45:38.520
End of a discourse upon the origin and the foundation
2688
02:45:38.760 --> 02:45:42.840
of the inequality among mankind by Jean Jacques Rousseau