РАСШИФРОВКА 🔗
WEBVTT
00:01.080 --> 00:03.281
[SPEAKER_01]: Welcome back to the Lost Girls Podcast.
00:03.982 --> 00:06.583
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm Ali Smith, and I'm here with LaDonna Hupree.
00:07.644 --> 00:22.492
[SPEAKER_01]: Today we're telling the story of a Minnesota family that has lived with unanswered questions for more than a decade, and August 2015, Sheila St. Clair disappeared from the loose Minnesota, and she has never been found.
00:23.280 --> 00:30.146
[SPEAKER_00]: And now, nearly 11 years later, Sheila's daughter Stephanie St. Claire has also been reported missing.
00:30.786 --> 00:38.933
[SPEAKER_00]: Stephanie's disappearance is being investigated separately, and authorities have indicated they do not currently have reason to believe that she is in danger.
00:39.633 --> 00:47.599
[SPEAKER_00]: We want to make that very clear from the beginning, because there is no publicly established evidence that these two disappearances are connected.
00:51.290 --> 00:54.893
[SPEAKER_01]: There is an unbelievable emotional connection to these cases.
00:56.135 --> 01:03.482
[SPEAKER_01]: They've spent more than a decade wondering what happened to Sheila and now they're facing the uncertainty of that her daughter.
01:04.506 --> 01:07.487
[SPEAKER_00]: So today, we're going back to August 2015.
01:08.087 --> 01:19.691
[SPEAKER_00]: We want to understand who Sheila was, what she was planning to do the day she vanished, and why investigators still need information about the people she may have encountered during her final known hours.
01:20.051 --> 01:23.512
[SPEAKER_00]: Sheila St. Claire was 48 years old when she disappeared.
01:24.193 --> 01:29.915
[SPEAKER_01]: On August 20, 2015, she was last seen at the past-day department in the 100-block
01:35.019 --> 01:41.204
[SPEAKER_00]: As Sheila apparently had plans for that day, she was supposed to visit family when the white Earth reservation.
01:41.284 --> 01:46.948
[SPEAKER_01]: When detail immediately becomes important when trying to reconstruct all of her amendments.
01:47.808 --> 01:49.530
[SPEAKER_01]: Sheila did not own a vehicle.
01:50.285 --> 01:53.047
[SPEAKER_00]: And that raises one of the central questions in this case.
01:53.748 --> 01:55.289
[SPEAKER_00]: How was she planning to get there?
01:55.909 --> 01:57.570
[SPEAKER_00]: Did someone agree to drive her?
01:58.111 --> 02:01.093
[SPEAKER_00]: Was she expecting someone to pick her up at the apartment building?
02:01.633 --> 02:03.374
[SPEAKER_00]: Did she leave with someone she knew?
02:03.395 --> 02:07.798
[SPEAKER_00]: Or was she still trying to arrange transportation when she was last seen?
02:09.099 --> 02:13.682
[SPEAKER_01]: Nearly 11 years later, we still don't have a public answer to those questions.
02:14.747 --> 02:20.829
[SPEAKER_00]: And there's another complication in Sheila's disappearance that may have affected the investigation from its earliest days.
02:21.589 --> 02:27.210
[SPEAKER_00]: Sheila disappeared on August 20th, but she wasn't reported missing until September 10th.
02:28.170 --> 02:30.491
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, and that's almost three weeks.
02:31.731 --> 02:38.273
[SPEAKER_01]: In a missing person's investigation three weeks can represent an enormous amount of lost time.
02:43.809 --> 02:50.855
[SPEAKER_01]: People who saw something don't necessarily realize that it's important and physical evidence can disappear.
02:51.796 --> 02:58.301
[SPEAKER_00]: And investigators trying to reconstruct Sheila's final movements would have been starting with the significant disadvantage.
02:59.002 --> 03:03.305
[SPEAKER_00]: They weren't necessarily asking what happened yesterday or two days ago.
03:04.006 --> 03:06.888
[SPEAKER_00]: They were trying to determine what happened weeks earlier.
03:13.647 --> 03:15.147
[SPEAKER_01]: was not normal for her.
03:16.388 --> 03:20.309
[SPEAKER_01]: Authorities ultimately classified her as endangered missing.
03:21.109 --> 03:25.390
[SPEAKER_01]: And the circumstances surrounding her disappearance have been described as suspicious.
03:26.230 --> 03:33.492
[SPEAKER_00]: At the time she vanished, Sheila was approximately five feet four inches tall and weighed around 115 pounds.
03:34.313 --> 03:38.234
[SPEAKER_00]: She was a beautiful indigenous woman who had brown hair and brown eyes.
03:39.034 --> 03:41.615
[SPEAKER_00]: She was wearing a knee-length black, sleeveless dress
03:44.427 --> 03:49.731
[SPEAKER_01]: Sheila also had several distinguishing characteristics that could have made her recognizable.
03:50.611 --> 03:55.515
[SPEAKER_01]: Her right that was crippled, which may have caused her to walk with a noticeable limb.
03:56.616 --> 04:05.362
[SPEAKER_01]: She had a tattoo and a eagle on her right arm, and records also indicate that she may have used the last name Jackson.
04:06.078 --> 04:19.822
[SPEAKER_00]: And as we mentioned, Sheila was Native American, and over the years her disappearance has become part of a much larger conversation in Minnesota and across the country, about missing and murdered indigenous women and relatives.
04:21.223 --> 04:27.825
[SPEAKER_01]: Sheila's family and community did not allow her disappearance as they quietly into an old case file.
04:28.945 --> 04:31.826
[SPEAKER_01]: For years, people have continued gathering in her honor
04:35.868 --> 04:38.329
[SPEAKER_00]: And boy, oh boy, does that persistence matter?
04:38.509 --> 04:49.951
[SPEAKER_00]: It truly does, because long-term missing person's cases depend heavily on people continuing to say a person's name after the initial media attention disappears.
04:50.991 --> 04:58.793
[SPEAKER_00]: And Sheila's case has remained open with the Duluth Police Department, but law enforcement cannot investigate information it doesn't have.
05:04.829 --> 05:12.974
[SPEAKER_01]: And more broadly, it generated information about missing and murdered indigenous women, girls, and two-spirate people.
05:13.854 --> 05:17.276
[SPEAKER_00]: And that tells you
Load full transcript
something about the impact one missing woman can have.
05:17.996 --> 05:29.383
[SPEAKER_00]: Sheila's family was searching for answers about someone they loved, but their experience also became connected to families throughout indigenous communities, who were asking many of the same questions.
05:31.240 --> 05:38.090
[SPEAKER_01]: Let's go back to past data apartments because this is where the investigative questions become very specific.
05:39.232 --> 05:40.794
[SPEAKER_01]: Sheila needed transportation.
05:42.076 --> 05:44.860
[SPEAKER_01]: She intended to travel and then she disappeared.
05:46.889 --> 05:52.313
[SPEAKER_00]: So if Sheila left the apartments with another person, identifying that individual could be crucial.
05:53.234 --> 05:59.358
[SPEAKER_00]: Someone may have seen a vehicle outside, and someone may have heard Sheila discussing who was gonna give her a ride.
06:00.059 --> 06:03.561
[SPEAKER_00]: She may have even made a phone call or spoken to someone about her plans.
06:04.802 --> 06:12.048
[SPEAKER_01]: And there are also, may have been people in Sheila's social circle who knew more about her plans than they realized.
06:15.587 --> 06:25.329
[SPEAKER_01]: who she expected to see or when she planned to return could help establish what she intended to do before something interrupted those plans.
06:26.469 --> 06:32.070
[SPEAKER_00]: And because investigators lost those first three weeks, a witness might never have been identified.
06:32.230 --> 06:36.471
[SPEAKER_00]: Someone could have information today without realizing that police never heard it.
06:36.591 --> 06:39.552
[SPEAKER_01]: Sheila's possible destinations also mattered.
06:45.563 --> 06:48.384
[SPEAKER_01]: and may have planned to go to Red Cliff West Thompson.
06:48.505 --> 06:53.247
[SPEAKER_00]: Those destinations create a geographical trail investigators would need to consider.
06:53.547 --> 06:56.348
[SPEAKER_00]: Did anyone see Sheila traveling away from Duluth?
06:56.849 --> 06:59.830
[SPEAKER_00]: Did she communicate with relatives at either destination?
07:00.511 --> 07:02.972
[SPEAKER_00]: Did anyone believe that she was already on her way?
07:02.992 --> 07:10.916
[SPEAKER_00]: And if Sheila never arrived, then determining whether she actually left Duluth becomes critical.
07:11.720 --> 07:18.164
[SPEAKER_00]: because if she didn't, the focus remains on what happened around the cascade apartments and who she interacted with there.
07:18.865 --> 07:23.668
[SPEAKER_00]: If she did leave Duluth, then the potential search area becomes much larger, right?
07:23.688 --> 07:24.248
[SPEAKER_00]: Don't you think?
07:24.708 --> 07:25.329
[SPEAKER_01]: Absolutely.
07:26.269 --> 07:30.852
[SPEAKER_01]: Sheila's family has now lived with us on certainty since 2015.
07:31.032 --> 07:36.736
[SPEAKER_00]: And then in 2026, this family received another frightening piece of news.
07:36.956 --> 07:37.816
[SPEAKER_01]: Sheila's daughter,
07:40.857 --> 07:43.580
[SPEAKER_01]:
was reported missing from Moorhead, Minnesota.
07:44.702 --> 07:54.855
[SPEAKER_01]: According to information released about her disappearance, Stephanie was last seen June 6th at her residence in the 800 block of second Avenue.
07:56.850 --> 08:05.834
[SPEAKER_00]: Authorities have indicated that they do not currently have reason to believe Stephanie is in danger, and they believe she may have left the area voluntarily.
08:06.594 --> 08:11.096
[SPEAKER_00]: That information is important, and we need to respect what investigators are saying.
08:11.216 --> 08:14.137
[SPEAKER_01]: And adult does have the right to leave voluntarily.
08:14.897 --> 08:22.060
[SPEAKER_01]: Adults can choose to travel, relocate, interrelationships, or stop communicating with people.
08:23.297 --> 08:29.682
[SPEAKER_01]: And the existence of a missing person report does not automatically mean that a crime has occurred.
08:30.303 --> 08:38.789
[SPEAKER_00]: That's true, but at the same time, Amy, you can understand why Stephanie's disappearance would be especially scary for this particular family.
08:39.330 --> 08:43.593
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, her mother left one day in 2015 and never came home.
08:43.613 --> 08:48.297
[SPEAKER_00]: 11 years later, they're dealing with uncertainty about Stephanie's whereabouts.
08:53.273 --> 09:01.478
[SPEAKER_01]: there is no publicly established evidence that Sheila's disappearance and Stephanie's disappearance are connected.
09:02.519 --> 09:06.162
[SPEAKER_00]: So we're not trying to create a connection simply because they are mother and daughter.
09:07.062 --> 09:10.584
[SPEAKER_00]: Sheila's case has been described as suspicious and remains unsolved.
09:11.045 --> 09:18.770
[SPEAKER_00]: And as we mentioned, authorities have indicated that Stephanie could have, although they have not said for sure yet, but she could have left voluntarily.
09:19.410 --> 09:21.652
[SPEAKER_00]: And so those are very different circumstances.
09:22.970 --> 09:27.466
[SPEAKER_01]: What connects these places right now is the family that's experiencing.
09:28.508 --> 09:32.229
[SPEAKER_00]: It is, and that's why it's important that we do this episode because that's significant.
09:32.829 --> 09:38.750
[SPEAKER_00]: Can you imagine spending more than a decade wondering what happened to your mother, your sister, your aunt, your friend?
09:39.450 --> 09:42.431
[SPEAKER_00]: And then receiving word that her daughter cannot be located?
09:43.231 --> 09:47.652
[SPEAKER_00]: Whatever ultimately explains Stephanie's whereabouts, and I hope she comes home quickly.
09:48.573 --> 09:54.794
[SPEAKER_00]: That uncertainty carries a different weight for people who already know what it's like when someone just never comes home.
09:56.223 --> 10:04.507
[SPEAKER_01]: Sheila's pace also exists within a larger crisis involving missing and murdered indigenous women and relatives.
10:05.708 --> 10:20.455
[SPEAKER_01]: Families and advocates have spent years drawing attention to
cases that they believe historically received two little media coverage and consistent investigative attention or inadequate resources.
10:21.577 --> 10:28.261
[SPEAKER_00]: But responsible advocacy means treating each woman as an individual, rather than turning her into a statistic.
10:29.081 --> 10:33.303
[SPEAKER_00]: And Sheila had somewhere she intended to go that August 20, 2015.
10:34.044 --> 10:35.605
[SPEAKER_00]: She had family expecting her.
10:36.245 --> 10:39.026
[SPEAKER_00]: She had recognizable physical characteristics.
10:39.707 --> 10:42.268
[SPEAKER_00]: She had plans and she had people who loved her.
10:43.309 --> 10:46.770
[SPEAKER_00]: And somewhere along the way, those plans stopped.
10:51.992 --> 10:57.836
[SPEAKER_01]: after all these years, the most useful information may actually be one at the simplest.
10:58.737 --> 11:01.859
[SPEAKER_01]: Who was Sheila expecting to see on August 20th?
11:02.720 --> 11:19.613
[SPEAKER_00]: If someone offered Sheila a transportation investigators need to know who that person was, if you remember seeing her around the cascade apartments that day, remember a vehicle associated with her or recall hearing Sheila talk about her travel plans, that information deserves another look.
11:20.805 --> 11:28.673
[SPEAKER_01]: don't dismiss something simply because 11 years have passed, or because you assume investigators miss already know about.
11:29.413 --> 11:31.595
[SPEAKER_00]: Let law enforcement make that determination.
11:32.196 --> 11:37.842
[SPEAKER_00]: The detail you've carried around for years could fill a gap investigators have never been able to close.
11:38.986 --> 11:45.069
[SPEAKER_01]: Today, the St. Claire family is waiting for answers about not one moment, but two women.
11:45.230 --> 11:51.553
[SPEAKER_00]: For Stephanie, the immediate question is whether she is safe and whether authorities can confirm her welfare.
11:52.233 --> 11:56.156
[SPEAKER_00]: And for Sheila, the question has endured since 2015.
11:56.996 --> 12:01.279
[SPEAKER_00]: What happened after she was last seen at the Cascade Apartments?
12:01.459 --> 12:07.462
[SPEAKER_01]: Stephanie's disappearance should not be sensationalized, simply because her mother is also missing.
12:08.436 --> 12:12.339
[SPEAKER_00]: And Sheila's disappearance should not become merely background to a newer story.
12:13.139 --> 12:18.063
[SPEAKER_00]: She has been missing for nearly 11 years, at her case deserves answers all in its own.
12:19.644 --> 12:30.652
[SPEAKER_01]: If you have any information concerning Stephanie St. Larry's current whereabouts, please contact the Red River Regional Dispatch Center at 701-451-7660.
12:39.250 --> 12:51.877
[SPEAKER_00]: If you have information concerning Sheila St. Clairs, 2015 Disappearance, please contact the Duluth Police Department Violet Crime Unit at 218-730-5050.
12:53.778 --> 12:58.020
[SPEAKER_01]: For Sheila's case, did you see her near the cast-aid apartment?
12:59.021 --> 13:03.243
[SPEAKER_01]: Did you hear her discuss a ride to white earth or red cliff?
13:04.504 --> 13:06.725
[SPEAKER_01]: Did you see her get into any vehicle?
13:08.308 --> 13:15.874
[SPEAKER_00]: Nearly 11 years can make a memory fill too old to matter, but an unresolved investigation doesn't need a perfect witness.
13:16.434 --> 13:23.680
[SPEAKER_00]: Sometimes it needs one person to provide a detail that can be compared with information that investigators already have.
13:24.901 --> 13:28.223
[SPEAKER_01]: Sheila St. Claire was 48 years old when she disappeared.
13:29.124 --> 13:33.407
[SPEAKER_01]: Her family has kept searching for her through birthdays, holidays,
13:36.571 --> 13:42.496
[SPEAKER_01]: Now that St. family is waiting for confirmation that her daughter, Stephanie, is safe.
13:42.596 --> 13:50.863
[SPEAKER_00]: Two women from the St. family, two separate missing person investigations, neither should be turned into speculation, and neither should be forgotten.
13:51.963 --> 13:52.744
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm Amy Smith.
13:54.205 --> 13:55.346
[SPEAKER_00]: And I'm LaDonna Humphrey.
13:55.867 --> 13:57.588
[SPEAKER_00]: This is the Law Scrolls podcast.
13:58.249 --> 14:01.351
[SPEAKER_00]: Please share Sheila and Stephanie's information responsibly.
14:01.952 --> 14:05.234
[SPEAKER_00]: And if you know something that could help investigators, please
14:07.463 --> 14:09.974
[SPEAKER_01]: because every girl deserves justice.