РАСШИФРОВКА 🔗
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-1: Welcome to the Learning in the Brain Podcast, a podcast connecting research to education practice. In this series, we invite experts from domains such as behavioral science and academia to share their research and experiences in the realm of applying behavioral science to educational classroom practice. Listen in to learn more. In this episode, we welcome Dr. Kathy Hirsch-Pesek and Dr. Roberta Golenkoff. Developmental psychology researchers and professors on to the show.
speaker-2: Yeah. Sure, the kids can learn, as we've shown in our research. If you just teach them stuff, they learn it. But then you ask the question of transfer. Transfer is the gold standard of education. It means that what you learn in this situation, in this classroom, can be used in a totally different situation.
speaker-0: If we have a socially gated brain and we need interactions that are well-tuned, meaningful, connected to become humans, to become members of the species.
speaker-2: That's part of making instruction meaningful. That's what we want. We want the learning to stay in there and be able to be called upon when it's needed.
speaker-0: out that the protégés don't come that way. They come by kids who meander, explore, and play first and then find their niche. Not by starting them out on the road early. I really think of teachers as professional observers and researchers. They're the best I know of. Every teacher knows her students or his students.
speaker-1: Kathy and Roberta, thank you so much for joining us. ⁓ as you know, the goal of this podcast is to have a conversation ⁓ about how we bridge the gap between research and reality, ⁓ potentials, ⁓ findings, and practice, ⁓ practices in our schools and classrooms. Thanks for joining us.
speaker-0: ⁓ my god, it's so it's so great to be here. Yeah. And thank you for all you guys do because you're like the voice, you know, the megaphone that's trying to bridge research and practice. And without you, very few people would look at what scientists are doing.
speaker-1: So for the people listening, ⁓ if you're not familiar with the with the careers of the Wonder Twins here, they have been taking psychological findings ⁓ that have true implications for child growth development, parenting, ⁓ education, ⁓ just community rearing of the next generation for the most part, and trying to figure out how can those work and how to communicate those with people who could deploy them because you don't want researchers standing in your closet. You want e everybody to understand how they how they Because the closets are as not I am big. I'm a big guy. And those closets I don't fit.
speaker-0: We know you know what we called it at one point, we called it edible science that's accessible, digestible, and usable. And people it's always been unclear to me why, you know, if a reporter would call our colleagues, seriously they would never talk to them. Right? They would hide and they would never train their their
Load full transcript
students to talk to them.
speaker-2: You know this. You know that if you're in the department of psychology or a school of education and a reporter wants to talk to you, in the past people would literally run the other way. Ed Ziegler wrote about this in one of his books, that we have to start training people not to do that, but to be able to express what they have learned in a way that is edible science. I really hope we're trying
speaker-1: And I love the the word edible as long as we add a nutritious true. I I mean yeah, 'cause i some of it is edible but doesn't move the field forward and doesn't
speaker-2: Mm-hmm.
speaker-0: Junk science is junk food, yeah. That's a good that's a good way of looking at it. That's what we've been saying a lot with the digital education. It's so hard for people to separate out the junk food from the healthy food. Yes. And I think what we need to do is develop models where an everyday teacher and everyday parent and everyday user can say, you know, this is not healthy. Right. I know these ingredients aren't gonna
speaker-2: Sometimes it's really obvious because AI, as we've all read, is now generating these little shorts where goats are born out of eggs and trucks go on fire. Garbage and children will be confused and not learn from those. So parents really have to watch what they put. That kid on. The other thing that drives me nuts is YouTube. You can really get in trouble just giving your kid a tablet.
speaker-1: We were just trying to get sponsored by YouTube. That really ruins our whole economic model for the podcast. So those on the other side of of of this podcast, they're likely teachers, ⁓ interventionists, they are early ⁓ early interventionists, they might be therapists. So in terms of your process, can you walk me through how you go from ⁓ research to to reality, not to imply that research isn't reality, but what what is an early childhood educator, what is a teacher gonna do with some of your findings? What's the process you go through to make it edible?
speaker-0: Well I wanna I wanna step back. ⁓ I think what the way you framed that was that you're either in the practical or in the research, you know? And I really think of teachers as professional observers and researchers too. They're the best I know of. Every teacher knows her students or his students. So the very best way to start the process that we use is by talking with the professionals, right? And and assuming they know as much as they know. Now I've never understood why it is that our society doesn't have that same respect for the professionals that we leave our next generation with. It doesn't make any sense.
speaker-2: Hypothesis is because they're all female. Nurses have too.
speaker-0: Okay, that's
speaker-1: Could it could go back to the translation part though because educators aren't evidence generating. Like a plumber a plumber is. A s a stand up comic is. But for some reason t teachers aren't generating their own evidence from their own experiences to build their profession. So sometimes they're looking outside the profession, ⁓ for answers. Like for co at ⁓ w what is executive functions, how can I use that? Things like that. And I think if if we did what you're sort But I think if we did what you said it encouraged the profession to ⁓
speaker-0: Well that's
speaker-1: to to develop its its own questions, its own way of answering its questions and things like that.
speaker-2: Physician also does not generate We think alike. Does not generate their own evidence. It is a small fraction of positions in medical schools where people are generating research about what kinds of treatments work and what don't. So you could talk about medicine as applied science too.
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-1: Yeah, but I think that the what what the most doctors kind of do is they appl they they're at the tail end of the of the of of the translational process. It's been put through the fire before it gets to them hypothetically. Right? It's gone through clinical trials, it's gone through those sorts of things. So the the evidence is there and that's why and they have parameters to how they how they do that. Go ahead, sorry.
speaker-0: Let me Let me suggest though that that because I believe teachers are professionals, what they haven't ever done is really been taught to trust themselves, right? We've handcuffed teachers. And to it all has to be about the A or the B or you know and
speaker-1: Exactly.
speaker-0: And they have to teach it in this way and there's scripted learning and don't trust yourself to be able to get to that. Imagine a diagnostician who's a ⁓ in medicine or a dentist and somebody tells them exactly how they're supposed to do the work and they can't individualize it. So part of what we've done, you had asked about the process, is we start by asking the professionals, what are you seeing? What do you want to see? What are you noticing? How do we help you gain agency? ⁓ not just your kids. And then use those as the basis for some of the studies that you do and say if this makes sense, if we've if we've really gotten a common sense kind of model here, we can go and test it. We can see if it feels right to you when you're in a classroom and you're working with real kids. So that translation happens as a kind of dance. Yes. You know? Yes. And I think when we talk about it as a dance in respect to each other. then the bridge is gonna happen more naturally.
speaker-2: I am dancing now. ⁓
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-1: I think so much of it is really giving teachers that autonomy. What David just mentioned about evidence based generation, I think there is a sense of that in education, but a lot of it comes down to student outcomes. Yes. And that ties right back to accountability. What do teachers feel like they have to do create these test scores? Because student outcomes is the mandate.
speaker-2: Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Which is very narrow.
speaker-1: Which is narrow and allowing them
to now teach your preparation pathways be built upon the teachers and what they're directly putting in, I think is tying exactly back.
speaker-0: Yeah, but remember there's a lot of people now who are worried about the narrow outcomes we've had. So there's two things I wanna say about that. The first is No Child Left Behind was a disaster. Okay? And we got this idea that we should only look at narrowly construed outcomes in reading and math. So
speaker-2: It was translated that way, but they did not have bad intentions. I just want to point out Ted Kennedy and George Bush, and they really cared about kids. They introduced the term achievement gap. But it was translated into we have to test. No go right ahead.
speaker-0: No no no I'm not saying. Yeah, but it's not the point I was gonna make ⁓ the point I was gonna make is that what we did ⁓ using the narrowly construed test as the outcome is that we took away recess. Yes. ⁓ we lessened the time for lunch, okay. We dropped social studies, we all but dropped time science, we all but dropped the arts. Who needs that? Okay. So what we did is we focus everything
speaker-2: Sometimes signs.
speaker-0: On making sure the kids instruction and the math instruction. Now, go forward twenty-five years and look at all the nape scores, all right? If you focus that much, any other business in the world, you focus that much on just the reading and just well, you should have seen skyrocketing scores. You should not be sitting here
speaker-2: Not the reading is
speaker-0: Forget COVID. This was like in twenty nineteen, okay? It's not a COVID problem. And you should not be seeing issues in twenty twenty five, twenty six, I guess we don't have an Ape anymore, but when we did that are thirty-nine percent twenty-three percent, you know, proficiency. Like what is that about? Any business model that use that as an outcome measure would be it would never make it in the marketplace.
speaker-2: No. I I wanna point out that during the time when no child left behind was around, Kathy and I had the privilege of speaking in the great state of Florida. I sound like a politician. And ⁓ we learned that there was something called the F Cat Play. The F Cat F Cat F Cat because that was the name of the standardized test that they use. Right. And they would recite the children's standard.
speaker-0: Yeah. More
speaker-1: Like I pledge allegiance to the Freddy.
speaker-2: Yeah. I'll do one. Okay. I will eat a good breakfast.
speaker-0: I will sleep the night before the test.
speaker-2: I will concentrate really hard.
speaker-0: I will do my math homework and review it before the test.
speaker-2: So they literally had kids saying this repeatedly before like a month or two before they gave the exam. We thought we were in Russia. I mean it was
speaker-1: I wonder how that worked out. I wonder if anybody evaluated if the kids who did that did any differently than the kids who
speaker-2: I I doubt it. I think they didn't I think they did it
very widely. So to speak to the point that Kathy made before about dancing, I'm dancing now with speech language pathologists because I understand from my niece, who is one
speaker-0: Check Florida scores against
speaker-2: that children come in, they're referred two and three years of age who aren't producing language. What's that about? For some of them, of course, there's a tube on media 24-7. The parent can even be educated, even a teacher, and think that what the media says is educational is true. There are no checks on that, other than common sense media.
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-2: And no one speaks to the kid. The kid is literally on all the time. What is the child doing? The child is not making eye contact and the child is repeating television commercials when you talk to them. Who does those things? Children who have autism.
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-2: Now when the speech pathologist tells them turn off the media, within two months the kid will often turn into a different human being. But we have to get the word out there and I'm hoping to do research with the speech language pathologists on this. And excuse me, I wrote something again for psych today. I love writing blogs because I can get my anger and frustration out at the things that we do to America's parents and kids that aren't in their best interest.
speaker-1: So then classroom teachers I I think are faced with a similar problem. ⁓ so from a college of ed perspective, so many different strategies and interventions and you should do this and you should do this and i you should teach math after physical education, you should teach math while standing up, turn cartwheels, and maybe you should do this ⁓ so all of these different choices. What I what is fascinating about lots of things are fascinating about your work, which by the way, those that are listening, they're wonderful to listen to on this podcast, but if you ever can see these two live. It is one of the most amazing experiences of a lifetime. ⁓ they really do dance on stage.
speaker-2: And we'll be in the Catskills. Next week we want to announce at Hotel Framingham.
speaker-1: So ⁓ your work helps make sense of this. ⁓ and so y you have this amazing equation where you help educators sort through some of that. Can you talk about how your how that equation came about?
speaker-0: Sure. I mean it actually broke all the rules. So let me start there.
speaker-1: Fabulous. I'm not surprised but fab
speaker-0: you know what you're supposed to do in the Department of Psychology, which is where I'm at, psych and neuroscience, you're supposed to as a scientist ask what's the next question? Okay, finish the study. What's the next question? Go after that research. What's the next question? And we do a lot of that. We've done a lot of basic research. On the other hand, one of my friends came over one day for coffee and she said to me, You've been doing this for twenty years She said, Do you know anything? Are you still asking the next question? And it seems like a simple question, but it was actually profound. And I said, You know what? We do know a lot. And so Robert and I sat down and I wasn't kidding when I said, you know, those thousands of papers. The question is, if you were gonna come up with a checklist of what do we actually know? Well at the broadest level we know that you gotta know your audience. Well anybody would know that's called marketing, right? ⁓ the second thing you gotta know is how kids learn. Right? How the brain learns. And third is what I want out of this. What's my goal? So when it breaks down into something rather simple, if you will. Some people say to me, your grandmother should have known that and you know what she should have. But when I take just our middle, the how kids learn, and then I'll I'll throw it to Roberta if it succeeds. You know, you take how kids learn. Active, engaged, meaningful, socially interactive, right, iterative and joyful. Well let's look at classrooms. Are they active? No. All of our research says for the most part they're sitting there face forward or maybe in tables listening to stuff that's coming at them, right? Is it engaging? Well then we move to gaming to make it more engaging, but the problem with gaming is it's often more distracting. It's not solitary, yeah.
speaker-2: Solitary. And solitary.
speaker-0: And so you're constantly like this all the time till you get one one of my students called it induced ADHD. Is it meaningful? Often not, you know. When you're when you're showing a kid, you know, pounds and ounces and and at home they hear about grams, right? It it's different. And that's not to say that you shouldn't teach pounds and ounces. It's just make the link. Yes. Make the link, you know. So when we came up with this it was really asking what we all agree on. It was answering my friend's question when she said, Don't you know anything? And we
speaker-1: I I think we need to unpack that a little bit. because your basic premise, I always talk to myself I'm am I in era? Yeah. Right? And and and some of your y the basic premises of of your message weren't in era, then they were and now they may be going in a different direction depending on who you talk to, right? So let's let's make sure the audience knows ⁓ the the the the role of o of play and curiosity and the basic orientation of the learner from your perspective and how to leverage that. Which is what w really what I think you talk about is what's the basic orientation of a learner and how can we leverage that in a natural, authentic way so they're soaking up learning, not being forced to learn. Right. Right.
speaker-2: It it's not like where we say f fondly, drill and kill. We want to avoid drill and kill. There are many reasons. One is, sure the kids can learn. As we've shown in our research, if you just teach ⁓ stuff, they learn it. But then you ask the question of transfer. Transfer is the gold standard of education. It means that what you learn in
this situation, in this classroom, can be used in a totally different situation. When it should arise. Children who learn with drill and kill are much less likely to recognize when that learning can be used elsewhere. So one study we did ⁓ love to mention is a study with Kelly Fisher about what kids know about sheep. She was delightful and
speaker-1: Was it she was a grad student? Yeah, she she's a f a fabulous person. I know it. But she's a great girl.
speaker-2: Glad to know her. Yeah. So one condition had the kid make believing that they were a detective and she worked with the kid to invite the kid to figure out the secrets of the shape. Then the other condition, the kid still wore the the paper hat she made to be a detective, but she discovered everything. And then when we tested what they knew about shapes, the kids in the instruction Condition who didn't do anything, sure they learned something about what was a triangle, what was a rectangle, what was a square. But when you presented them with novel shapes, shapes that didn't have four sides, they bombed. The kids in the group where they played and got to discover these things with her, scored 30% higher than the kids who were just told. The same exact facts. So I like playful learning.
speaker-0: Yeah. Yeah, and I wanna get to the point you made of not being in Vogue and then moving to Vogue. When we first started, mm, you know, play was considered
speaker-2: Dirty word. That's right, a four letter word.
speaker-1: Off task.
speaker-0: Not something anyone should do certainly touch in a school system. As I mentioned before, we tried the other way. We've done tutoring, we've reduced recess, we've increased reading, we've increased time for math, and the scores aren't going up. So if that were really an effective way to learn, You would think kids by twenty five years would have gotten it. Now add on top of that the technological revolution. Okay? Where I think more and more we're recognizing how many tasks in a society, ⁓ things like even before AI, even before AI, you know, robots were able to do. They were taking over factories.
speaker-1: Yeah, look at look at automotive.
speaker-0: And now when you look at, you know, AI taking over what they call white collar jobs. I think the reality of the situation is not learning anything, right, when we try the other way, and recognizing now the value of curiosity and creativity, perseverance and grit. ⁓ I think those are being elevated and
speaker-2: So Yeah.
speaker-0: Our risk here, if I may, is that as we move in this new phase, we have to ensure that we preserve what's human. You mentioned Pat Cool, one of my favorite discoveries from Pat is that we are born with a socially gated brain. We are meant to be a species who gets along with other members of our species. Maybe we don't get along, but we s at least we engage.
speaker-1: At least we can.
speaker-0: Okay. When we chip away at that and I think we've done that in three ways. I think with
the iPhone we started with what I call disruption. Okay? Everybody was going to dinner, they weren't talking to each other anymore because something came on the iPhone so they look that look down instead of looking across the table. the next thing that I think happened is what I'll call displacement. You know, we now have seventy percent of two year olds Are on YouTube. That's insane. Okay. ⁓
speaker-2: Tablets. Yeah. They have their own tablets.
speaker-1: Well Amazon makes their own tablets for just for kids.
speaker-0: Yeah, for sure. For sure. But anyway, so if I think of it as disruption then displacement, the thing I think I worry about the most with the AI revolution is that it could be the perfect elixir for a human to mimic humans. And it could fool the human brain and derail the whole system. And if Pat's right, if we have a socially gated brain and we need interactions that are well tuned meaningful, connected, which I think we do, to become humans, to become members of the species, then I think we have to worry about this and we have to re examine. So that's why play is becoming more and more
speaker-2: I couldn't agree.
speaker-1: Well I I also think that the there's so much data showing that. And there's there's hard there's no data showing not right. And we we've been ignoring it for years. Yes. Right? For years. And and to our peril. Right. And what what's interesting is the people who are actually leveraging it are the people who are selling us the stuff that destroys it.
speaker-2: No. Right. Yeah, sure. Yes. Right. I I have to also tell you I promise not to get into politics, but there are two commercials that I'm going to write a blog about. I want to create we all do children who are kind and considerate and care about others. There's one commercial where a guy comes around delivering a paper on a bicycle and
speaker-1: You didn't promise me you're fine.
speaker-2: All the people throw it back at his head. No one says sorry. Then someone throws it in the spokes of the bike he's riding. He falls down. No one says, Are you okay? Hate that commercial. The second one is about VRBO, where ⁓ the parents are at a VRBO and the hot tub doesn't work, and the commercial says, and they got us a new one with the new hot tub. And the mom and the adolescent daughter are sitting in the hot tub. Dad comes along and says, Can I get in room for me? And the adolescent daughter says, Think again, Bruce. Walks away. Mother doesn't say anything. This drives me nuts.
speaker-1: Is it the same guy from the bike? No. ⁓
speaker-2: It drives me crazy. And watch these commercials. We are becoming so unkind. We're not thinking about the perspective of others. If we don't have empathy, where will our society go?
speaker-1: There are people he in in this room who have have have interviews and data on this where the the the the the the teenagers actually say we need more of this, please help us parents, please help us role models, please help us world. And we're not responding 'cause we have a negative stereotype about adolescence. Yes. We frame it as negative and we don't leverage the positive side to that. So when it comes to what we do here, ⁓ there are a couple of places I'd like to go. One is as much as I love four letter words, ⁓ I'm not exactly thrilled that play is one of them. And you have in your work you you you certainly emphasize the value of that. But as you also pointed out, there's a there's some misconceptions, there's a myth about what this is. So those listening that are looking for solutions, and maybe not solutions, but at least a way to sift through this and start to to push back, play? Tell ⁓ really? Tell me about that. Yeah, and before we do that, you don't talk about feral play. That's it.
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-2: Barrel as well.
speaker-1: Yeah, just yeah, just go get go in this room go wild. When you were talking about Kel's work for example, there was there were shapes in there to explore and play with. Right? So you're not talking y you mentioned this during your talk, it's not just go play. Yes. But that's what I was talking about. Right. It's like a des you're it's a design to interact with a certain way to to play. Right. ⁓
speaker-2: You have a curricular goal. That's what we emphasize. If you don't have a curricular goal and a kid is playing, it's fantastic because that's when you figure out who you want to be. I I
speaker-1: Well, you learn physics, you learn a lot of stuff.
speaker-2: Of course, but I used to lecture to my dolls in my bedroom. What am I doing today? Right? You probably can think about stuff that you did at a ki as a kid that you do now. You also rehearse social norms when you play. When you play with others you learn to take the perspective of others. So free play, feral play as you called it, is great.
speaker-0: But ⁓ a lot of times what has happened historically is that people wanted to have a learning goal and were told to use play, used free play, exactly and then suggested that somehow the kids were gonna come back reading and they were gonna come back knowing math. And there's still by the way people who argue that. Go to the backyard, you'll come back, you learn it in time, it'll be fine.
speaker-2: Yes. Yes.
speaker-0: What we have found time and time again in our research is that we needed another way to look at this, and that way is what we call guided play, or now we've added active playful learning as as the overarching umbrella. The idea here is this, and now we're going to go to brain science. what you need to do is to zoom in. If you can't zoom in on the goal, then people won't learn it. There's just too much variability out there and they could go anywhere and it won't help them and train them ⁓ to where you wanted them to end up. So guided play uses the pedagogical approach of play which gives kids agency, gives kids exploration and discovery, but it has the directedness
speaker-2: Yeah.
speaker-0: of a direct instruction so
that it narrows down those possibilities. And by coming up with a playful learning pedagogy, what you get is the ability to have kids leapfrog their way toward a goal. And they won't get there in free play. And while they might get there in direct instruction, as Roberta said before, they won't learn it in a way that's transferable enough To be used in any other task than the task on which you've trained.
speaker-2: And that's part of making instruction meaningful to kids. Because if they're simply doing things by rote, the learning will not be sticky. I love that term, sticky learning. That's what we want. We want the learning to stay in there and be able to be called upon when it's needed. I want to call it sticky.
speaker-1: This sounds like embodied learning. It seems like it's you.
speaker-0: No, I
speaker-1: it because we I often I oftentimes like times think that we think of memory or learning as these unitary single that are specific to certain brain regions and I love that you touched on the brain because it's it's really this cohesive collaborative you know this this system that's working with so many different parts you have the parietal lobe that's bringing in all the sensory information it's relaying that to the medial temporal and so I think with with what you're talking about with sticky learning is it's touching that area of the brain the basal ganglia the motor
speaker-0: So
speaker-1: functioning, the you know it's it's firing these neurotransmitters that are entering the procedural memory and so when we talk about transfer it has to be deeply embedded, it has to be consolidated into those long term areas or else it it frankly
speaker-0: Well one of the one of the best ⁓ metaphors I heard is that learning is more like a map. ⁓ it's it's many roads to a destination and that's how you learn the best. You know, I'll take another example just if you want to go into the brain stuff for a while 'cause I just think it's so cool. ⁓ everybody that I know in education today is into the science of reading, or so they believe. Yeah, somewhere they heard the science of reading good friend Stand on. is probably to my mind one of the best, you know, cognitive neuroscientists in the world right now. And I think he's pretty well mapped out, the science of how brains read. Okay, so is it phonics? No, it's not just phonics. What he says is it's really about making the connection from the visual part of the brain, right, to the kind of mental dictionary part of the brain. And of course that has to pass through the sound part of the brain. And he's because reading is a cultural invention, he says what happens is these things kind of meet and take over an area that was actually there. To be used for facial processing. Okay? And he then calls it the visual word form area. So what it does is it allows these different areas of the brain, like you were just talking about, to coalesce in the process of reading. What does that mean? It means that if I'm going to teach reading to a kid, that the first thing I need is not merely, I'm not saying not, saying not merely. learning letters the alphabet or learning letter sound correspondence because if I don't have the words it's going to translate into and they're not in my vocabulary, I'm already in trouble. All right, now let's build that out. So I build it out. What it means is you're a teacher in a class and you've been told that what you have to do is teach the science of reading. And that means phonics. But your kids are second language learners. And your kids don't have a strong basis in let's say English vocabulary. Now you're teaching that phonics. And they go through and they find b And what is she supposed to do? The teacher says, well, at least you sounded it out great, just say it faster. Okay. And it still doesn't come out boy. So we have to make those connections. And in the way Roberta and I thought about the six Cs as outcomes, we did that as a kind of growing model. So where do you get the language from? You get it from talking to other people. That's the Pat Cool model. It's about being social. If you don't have social interactions, you don't learn language. If you don't learn language, you don't learn the content that will be relevant to reading and by the way, to mathematics as well. And until you have that content, you can't have critical thinking or creative innovation because they're reliant on having some content. All right. And the last C you know confidence we kind of snuck in there. ⁓ because you have to persist to make it all work. But that creates a holistic system that's built on brain science. And I think unless we get holistic and systematic. And stop trying to pull out pieces and say, ⁓ there's a piece of brain science. There's a piece of brain science. It's kinda like going back to your nutrition. All you need is protein. Well no, you need veggies, right? You gotta fill out the nutritional chart. And we don't do that and then we shove this onto educators. So I think educators If you see the whole picture, it's a gorgeous picture and the science of reading will definitely help you, but not if we only know parts of it.
speaker-1: Well I think I would
speaker-2: like to point out, I really agree with what Kathy's saying. What a surprise. Right. we have siloed subjects. So there's reading and then a year later maybe you get writing. And there's spatial. Nobody actually does spatial the way they should, but it relates to math. There's language arts and there's math. All separate.
speaker-0: Yeah. Thank you.
speaker-2: If we could recognize that being able to do math rests on having certain language concepts, like seven is over six, five is under six. You know, if you don't know those words or more or less or equal or less than, you will be a poor math learner. But
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-2: We don't have math and language together. We have math at ten forty on Tuesdays and we have literacy at nine A. What we need to do
now it's it's it's it sounds kinda silly, but if we pulled out how interrelated these things are based on the research, we would be encouraging teachers to follow their instincts and to talk about these things together. A woman named Young Suk Kim, someplace in Florida, I can't remember.
speaker-1: You went to Florida.
speaker-2: Yeah, I mean to Florida. Did a a massive study on the relationship between reading and writing and showed longitudinally it makes a hundred percent more sense to do reading and writing at the same time. They grow together. But the reason this is news is because it's not done that way typically in classrooms.
speaker-1: Well we don't do that with a lot of I I call it the Frankenstein problem. We we deconstruct everything. We deconstruct everything and it's no one's job to ever put it back together. So we get these artificial we put the we we try to cobble it together, it ends up being this monster thing that doesn't work. So I I want to go I wanted to play with something you said really quick. When you're talking about ⁓ what Stan and Gabrielle and other people said, ⁓ I w I wanna I want to play with see it could be a metaphor for your work. Yeah. Okay. So we didn't evolve to read. Right, right. Right. We evolved we evolved to to to process language, process visual things, the the the visual word form area, ⁓ the all those sorts of things, right? and what happens when we're teaching someone to to to read is we're actually telling you we're carving the brain, telling you make networks and make and and and and take over this this bit of real estate in a way that serves this purpose. That's right. So sometimes we leverage, for example, the s the the written word will get transmitted basically into sound. Mm-hmm. Right. ⁓ And we're leveraging what we ha we we we have to do something that's completely different. Correct. Right. ⁓ and and better for us so in some ways. And I think y what s part of your argument with play is we're gonna we're trying to leverage how we evolved, how do we naturally learn, how do we naturally do this. and leverage that to do these things that society and c and and and culture wants us to learn at the same time. That's right. So that sort of architecting Right, that sort of the the sort of building and leveraging, kind of goes throughout different levels of analysis when I talk about your your your work. It's it's really like how can we take what the how the learner actually is and and leverage that as a strength exactly instead instead of fighting against it.
speaker-0: Yeah, and I think we always try to create the one size fits all model, but generally that means this size fits no one. Yeah. But you know, I just wanted to give an example 'cause I think sometimes it's it's hard, at least for me as a teacher, to see how this could possibly work, this dump the silo mentality. I sent my kids to a school ⁓ called Friends Central School, and the reason I chose it is because it was a thematic based school. And every year the teachers would choose a different theme. When they chose the theme, they then found books that went along with the theme. They taught the same math, but within the theme, and everything coalesced. And my gosh, did they learn holistically and in a way that was rich. ⁓ so one of the themes, for example, one year was they went to Lunaguavia, a whole school. Now Lunaguavia the actually the project ⁓
speaker-1: Probably to Florida, right?
speaker-0: Orbis is ⁓ Orbis is on the other side of the moon, ⁓ the other side of the sun, equidistant from where Earth is, okay? And it had all these planets, ⁓ and it had all these continents, and the kids came to school and on the first day they were put in a continent. Now, based on which continent they got and which geographic locale they were in, they had to deal with. Are they a water country? Or they aren't a water country? They're an island, they're not an island. Can they ship? They can't ship. What are the goods you can produce? And they came up with an entire economy. Now to do that, they had to use math. They had to understand geography. This by the way is an elementary school. And it went all the way from kindergarten to fifth grade. Isn't that amazing? It's incredible. And one one day I remember the kids come to school. And had a problem. All the water fountains were closed. And there were big dots on it because it turned out there was a plague. And they didn't know what to do to solve the plague because people needed water. And so the kids from the school had to form the UN. Now, I just use that as one example. But you can see how it crosses all the lines that we're used to doing in order to give a first class education to kids.
speaker-2: I love that Kathy shared that because it gives hope to teachers and administrators who want to do integrative learning. It's a model for how to do that. It doesn't happen overnight though. You need to work with your fellow teachers and administrators, as they do in Friends every year to decide on the particular problem theme that they want to use and to work together to figure out what kinds of things they can do in a context. But even theme
speaker-0: before you make it a whole school wide thing, on which Friend Central did. You can make it a class wide thing. Of course. And I just want to say each teacher has in her control if he or she figures out how to get the geometry they have to teach, or the multiplication tables. You know, for the multiplication tables and for the little bit that they had to do when our kids were living on an island, the kids had to build a ship to get off the island. So they had to make it Two times bigger than the ship that was in the book. Never forget that. My kids still remember all the
speaker-2: Yeah.
speaker-1: So I love that and and and w we could talk to you for days at a time.
speaker-2: Stay here. We love talking to you guys.
speaker-1: So I I I thought one way to tie this up is I have been craving an
answer to this question. So you've got a a new edition of your this is I and I've been rehearsing the moment I g I found out we were gonna get to spend some time with the two of you, one of my questions that I I've got to know is, okay, so Einstein didn't use flashcards.
speaker-2: The answer is forty two.
speaker-1: And ⁓ for those you listening, ⁓ the new edition of that book is out. it's the first one was fantastic. It will likely be one of the texts I use in development. okay, so to kind of close it out, what did he use?
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-2: He it was a typical kid. He may have talked late, he went to school, he probably spent a lot of time in his own head, but no one drilled and killed him. Now he's exceptional. So I don't want people to get the idea that if they don't send their kids to a rigorous school or they drill, don't drill and kill, their kids gonna be in Einstein. That's unrealistic. If we wanna teach the way human brains learn
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-2: We want to invite children along for the ride and not just tell them what they have to do in a bubble. I think we're doing that too much the kids.
speaker-0: Well there's some great research that just came out. I forget the first author's name, so I apologize. Author, please, I'm sorry. but it was asking how people become ⁓ first class performers and that can be in music or can be in sports. And of course one of the answers, if we follow the way schools work now, the answer would be if you really want your kid to be a pro tennis player, start tennis at age five.
speaker-2: They are amazing. ⁓
speaker-0: Pro pro pianist, then you gotta start by eight, you know, and get it happening. But sadly for all this, it turns out that the proteges don't come that way. ⁓ they come by kids who meander, explore, and play first and then find their niche. Not by starting them out on the road early. And they found that the ones that started out early petered out. Yes. And the ones that meandered had a shot at becoming world class. And one place to look just to see this example in action is how many kid actors actually become adult actors and actresses. It is very, very rare that you make it both as a kid and as an adult.
speaker-2: So I wanna say one thing before we close off, that w we talk about how much respect we have for teachers. And it's true, but I just spoke to somebody who did a dissertation at Hopkins and told me she did a qualitative study of teachers and how they felt about student agency. And what she found was that the teachers felt they had no agency. Now it's awfully hard to cultivate agency and initiative in your children if you feel that you could lose your job if you're on page seven and everybody else is on page nine. So I I really want us to think about
speaker-1: Great point.
speaker-2: How to help our teachers in training and our teachers in the field to recognize, as she said to me, that together they have great power and they don't realize.
speaker-0: Yeah, that's true. And and act of playful learning, the biggest comment we get back is thank you for giving us teaching back. That's why we went into the field.
speaker-1: I can't think of a better way to end. Thank you very much. Amazing. I enjoyed that conversation. Thank you so much for such a wonderful conversation. And to everyone tuning in from home, we appreciate you sharing this space with us, tuning into this conversation. And we'll see you all next time here at the Learning in the Brain podcast.