РАСШИФРОВКА 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: It is broadly about this next topic, though. We spoke with the Premier in the last half hour of the program about a decision to, by way of regulation, not legislation, restrict the capacity for local government to give fines by saying, you now have to physically stick a sticker on the vehicle. You can't send it by mail. It therefore renders the ParkSafe automated car system obsolete. It can't be done anymore. And there's some questions, too, for Glenelg that our listeners have raised that certainly by our reading, would mean you can't have the fixed cameras that just send fines after the fact now as well. This is a lot to think about for our next guest, the president of the LGA, Dr Heather Holmes-Ross. Dr Heather Holmes-Ross, good morning to you.
00:00:42
Speaker 2: Morning, Will.
00:00:42
Speaker 3: Good morning, Stacey.
00:00:43
Speaker 1: So what's your immediate reaction to the government, the state government, jumping into this space and saying these vehicles and this way of levying fines is no longer permitted?
00:00:51
Speaker 3: Yeah, we would have... Let me start by saying we 100% agree with the Premier that... when using this AI technology, there needs to be a human that's making the decisions. So we absolutely agree on that. What we're disappointed about is that we didn't have a conversation with the state government about how this technology could be used in line with what they're trying to do. So this is the same technology that we use in mobile phone detection, for red light cameras, for speed cameras. And so we're interested in why it's local government and parking fines that are being singled out. If it's the technology, that's the issue because it is used in all these circumstances.
00:01:35
Speaker 4: I guess the difference with the AI mobile phone cameras and the speed cameras is that's a snapshot in time, but at a snapshot in time, if you're still speeding, you're still speeding, whereas the AI cars might take a snapshot in time of you parked in a bus lane, but after the fact, you realise you weren't actually parked. You were just using it to reverse into a car park, for example.
00:02:00
Speaker 3: Yes, I suppose it depends whether the cameras are taking snapshots in time or whether they're videos, and I believe that we use both. I suppose the other thing is the reason that we have this technology is either for safety or to allow traffic flow. And so both of those things we want to happen. But in particular, the argument that a stationary car can't be problematic is, I think, unrealistic. And I'm thinking, for example, of bike lanes. When you have a car that's parked in a bike lane, it's then twice as unsafe if another car parks next to them in order to issue the fine. So a car that's parked isn't necessarily more safe than a parked car that's moving. Do you get what I'm trying to say here?
00:02:52
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:02:54
Speaker 1: Dr Heather, I don't want to lead the witness here, so feel free to dismiss this, okay? Let's just establish that first and foremost. But I'm imagining a scenario whereby a council may in the future argue that restricting access to more efficient means to fine people will lead to councils having to raise monies other ways, like raising rates. Is that a reasonable by-product of something like this?
00:03:23
Speaker 3: It could be, depending on the amount of money that's spent by councils and earned by councils in terms of the revenue they raise from this. For most councils, it's not a lot of money. I mean, the City of Adelaide is probably different. But most councils, it's the safety issue, the safety of the offices and the safety of the roads that are the big thing. But maybe that argument plays out in the City of Adelaide.
00:03:51
Speaker 2: I'm not sure.
00:03:53
Speaker 4: Okay. Well, thanks for your time this morning, Dr. Heather Holmes-Ross, the President of the Local Government Association.
00:04:00
Speaker 1: Well, it was Dallas Call, our next guest, the owner of Sea, Adelaide and Beyond, who I think with you and Breaking 8, Stacey, started the ball rolling on this. And Dallas joins us now. Dallas, something of a, well, not something of a, it's been a big win for you.
00:04:13
Speaker 2: Well, yeah, thanks, Will. And thank you, Stacey. You're right. It was the breaking at eight. My daughter's very worried that we're going to do a breaking at eight about keeping her room tidy now. So things happen when you do the breaking at eight.
00:04:23
Speaker 1: If you want to scare her, Dallas, just get Stacey to interview her.
00:04:28
Speaker 2: No, I think in all honesty, it's a great win for the CBD because we've got to do everything we can to get people back into the CBD with smiles on their faces, wanting to go in and shop and wanting to park and And just get some people on foot and do what we used to do and put some humanity into the decisions when they make these fines. Because if they did that for my fine, which pushed me over the edge, they would never have issued that fine under the circumstances and things would be going swimmingly right now. But yeah, I think it's a great result for Adelaide.
00:04:59
Speaker 4: Yeah, absolutely. Well, Dallas, thanks for sharing your story and I'm glad we were able to make some progress on it.