РАСШИФРОВКА 🔗
speaker-1: ⁓ Andrew Piva welcome to First Light. really excited to have you on the show, mate. ⁓
speaker-0: Thank you, James. Happy to be here. Thank you.
speaker-1: you. Thanks for making some time. Like really keen to, ⁓ you know, find it nobody knows you just if you give us a little background on yourself, and we were you are now. That's okay. ⁓
speaker-0: Yep. So yes, I'm one of ⁓ three directors of BA architecture. been there for almost 25 years now. So long, long term. So ⁓ yeah, but originally I grew up in Griffith in New South Wales and went to uni in Sydney and then I sit there and made my way to Melbourne and here we are.
speaker-1: Yeah. So 25 years. And so you joined me very early in the game. Tell us about that, mate. You were you're working somewhere else and you went across.
speaker-0: Yeah, I did a little bit of work in Sydney before moving down and what worked at some places in Melbourne, it was more ad hoc work. My wife and I, we moved down when you absolutely no one down here, not a lot of work lined up. So we covered it together and this made it work. but yeah, just over time had to find some more, you know, full time work and yeah, it looked around and I enjoy the work that the architecture is doing. Yeah, to sort of persevere and confident the door and away we go.
speaker-1: When did you become a director mate?
speaker-0: It's, oh goodness James, about I think maybe 12 years ago, thereabouts, yeah.
speaker-1: Yeah. And for somebody who is encountering your work for the first time, describe what BE stands for.
speaker-0: Yes. So look, think there's quite, there's a bit of an old school feel to what we do, I'd say. ⁓ I mean, it's a pair back aesthetic, like it's a very sort of, we look at focused ideas, but it's really about, we're trying to have each building be its own representation of a building. It's a core selection of ideas. It's a materials palette, it's a series of details and how all of those work together. that defines each building. you could say, you know, that pair back I said, it comes from that process of reducing things down to core essentials, but it's always sort of deeply rooted in something old school. We're happy to look back at history. There's this sense of permanence or establishment that we're trying to create and imbue in our buildings from the onset. ⁓ So it's trying to give it some more meat and bones and just.
speaker-1: They're not locked into a, you know, this is our thing, this is what we do.
speaker-0: No, we only do start or we only do brick. No, but we want the buildings. There's an honesty to what we do. It's not trickery. It's, ⁓ it's not trying to overcomplicate something. It probably is complicated to get to that point. ⁓ but, you know what? There's a saying we, we use quite a fair bit in the office and we'd say that our buildings are strong, get quiet. So none of what we're doing is apologetic, but We're not trying to stand out. not trying to create a scene with what we're doing. And in
Load full transcript
being quiet or having a reduced palette of materials or details or form, it can still be quite strong, if that makes sense.
speaker-1: Okay. What drew you into architecture at the very start, mate? What led you to become an
speaker-0: architect. ⁓ It sort of fell into place pretty early. It wasn't like there was a light bulb moment or anything. was sort of, you know, you go to school and I enjoyed drawing and Lego and the things ⁓ that maybe come with that. ⁓ But did work experience and did it with a local architect in Griffith and enjoyed that. And then I was actually contemplating being a chef oddly enough. That was the other thing, but it's probably a good hobby to have now than a profession. But yes, I did that. I think at the time I enjoy the technical, you know, drawing and the technical aspect of it. And my exposure to architecture at Griffith was pretty limited. You only know what you know, I suppose. But then over time, I suppose, obviously that creative side. then started to kick in, kick into it. So yeah.
speaker-1: Was there something that, you know, earlier on that you can think of that you sort of brought across and thought, ⁓ this is how you do it. And then you quickly had to unlearn that to fit in with maybe the B style or, know, not even the B style.
speaker-0: wasn't even the BE style. It be the simple thing, know, pitch roof house and like a kiddie drawing of a house. That's sort of what you're used to. know, modernist style of architecture and all the, you know, old school European buildings, all those things. It's not, unless you're looking in a book for it or you're seeing it in show or a movie, ⁓ you're not exposed to it. So very... steep learning curve and just absorbing it all, suppose. So, and then you find things that you like and enjoy. And, um, you know, I found that, okay, I quite like styles of architecture that are a bit more minimal, a bit more paid back. then, you know, from a work perspective, you then try and find practices that are doing that, I suppose. So, But always housing, oddly enough, like never commercial work never appealed or yeah. Um, high rise buildings or anything. No, was just, yeah, just. just housing just seemed to be housing and interiors, you know, as one, just seemed to be the thing that sparked interest.
speaker-1: Would you ever go to a, like not go, but do a commercial project if you had the opportunity and it was like ticked all the boxes because you're excited about it.
speaker-0: Oh, for sure. I reckon if it's an extension of what we do. Sure. You know, like a hotel wouldn't be a hard, you know, one or something like that. So it'd certainly be a time and a place for it. Yeah, definitely. Yeah.
speaker-1: And has your definition of good architecture changed over the years? Like over 25 years, know, lots of change, lots of things have changed with your, your idea of good architecture. must've changed long.
speaker-0: Yeah, definitely. think, I mean, it's easy to be swayed by, you know, a
big statement or, you know, like, not to say it's obvious architecture, but oh, like, wow, look at that, that thing, but I've probably hopefully loosened up a little bit over time. So it's probably the little things now that you notice more. Yeah, it's, um, could be how something feels. could be an imperfection in, I don't know. It's just subtlety more than.
speaker-1: Sure. Yeah, yeah. So you know, it's there. Yeah, people might not know what it is. But there's something
speaker-0: Yeah, a of a slow burn could be good. I think that's probably a more layered style, I suppose.
speaker-1: Yeah, okay. Your work is very measured and feels very measured. How important is restraint in what you do?
speaker-0: Thank you, that comes across. ⁓ It's not like it's a goal to do it. It's just we're forever assessing and editing what we're doing when we're working on a project. So ⁓ whatever is in there, the look of the building, the details, form, whatever's making up this particular project, it should be there for a reason. from forever reviewing that, I suppose in a sense you're going to get that restraint. There's nothing in there that shouldn't be in there. Now it's not to say we want to do a minimal style of architecture and it's void of soul or anything like that. ⁓ And that's where we're looking at the materials we use and how we deal with the interiors and stuff like that. ⁓ there is that, yeah, it's a measured approach. We're not putting anything more that needs to be there than what's in it.
speaker-1: Yeah. And you do capture the whole project. So you're doing interiors, doing landscape, everything. there times where you, you know, you're not allowed to, they don't want you to do it. And you're like, we really want to do it because it's going to paint the whole picture. Yeah.
speaker-0: I think ⁓ we are fortunate that our clients see the benefit of doing the whole project. And that's how we approach it. just, it's not like a switch. Okay. We're only going to look at the architecture. We're not going look at the interior or the landscape. We approach it regardless, even if you're doing it all or not as a whole. Because what we're, it's just the way that we're internally in the office, how we get enjoyment and the process we've developed over the years. That's how we deal with the project. So. ⁓ But even if we weren't doing an aspect of it, say it was just the architecture that we're doing, it should be supportive enough, the idea should be clear enough that another interior could sit happily in that, or it can take another style of landscaping to support it. So it's, suppose that's quite a good question because we're forever sort of saying the house should be recessive for the person using it. The person shouldn't be changing how they're living to suit the house that we've designed or the interior that we've done. And if it's designed well enough, it should be able to take any type of interior landscape that goes with it. It'll change the flavor of it that can be a great thing too. ⁓
speaker-1: Yeah, yeah. Some people listening might have never engaged in architect. How does that first meeting look? Cause it probably be bit daunted. I mean, we can look at your projects and say, I love that. That's what I want. Or, but how do you, how do you have that first conversation? How do you get to know what they want? And then how do you then present something that maybe they don't know they need or want.
speaker-0: It's a big process. Yeah. Yeah. Well, it's where we just say from the onset, because a lot of people also try to solve things or say they're renovating your house. I live this way now and I want to, I hate how this room is. So I want to do that and sort of don't worry about that. yeah. You know, living right now in your house or when you build just what is your brief? What is that you need? How many bedrooms? What, what is it you need? And any particulars that are important to you? Yeah, it's good to know, but you know, just let us have a fresh take, do a little bubble diagram, a little plan. Let's just see, you know, what we could potentially do on your site with whatever opportunities, constraints it comes with and start the ball rolling that way. I mean, that's a spatial way to sort of start the conversation. But I suppose visually or how the house looks.
speaker-1: Yep.
speaker-0: It's not like we've got a preconceived idea going, oh, you know, we've got this great idea for a brick house that's been sitting in the top drawer for a while. I want to do this today on that one. It comes from trying to understand what resonates with the client. So, you know, we have a look at a lot of imagery with them, you know, what resonates with them and what doesn't and trying to create a picture of who they are and sort of filter those ideas, you know, through what we know to deliver something that's, you know, representative of them.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: It's not designed by them, we're designing it, but at the end of the day, it's something that the client should be able to hang their hat on and no, this house is mine. I almost felt like I've designed it because it reflects things that are important to me.
speaker-1: Yeah, great. What's something that ⁓ you shouldn't do on a job? what's something you like everyone wants to do this like we're not doing that.
speaker-0: Yeah, okay. One of our, okay, we don't do, this is our thing. So, you know, some people might do it, good on you, but I suppose one of our little rule things, we're not big fans of feature walls, I suppose. So we'd say, do a feature room if you're gonna do it, own it, be brave with it.
speaker-1: breath.
speaker-0: Yeah, but it I even say if we're doing that okay great, then how does that material? Idea relate to other areas of the room so the feature wall thing there's one yeah and We just like things to feel purposeful so It's Just don't use something for the sake of using it. How's it tie into the overall? Look of something.
It's funny like it's um You kind of all the materials out on a table, you know, looking at it with the client and you can say it all works together. And it could be just this one thing. ⁓ I always wanted to use this tile. I always loved that piece of brass. You know, it's great. We love it too. And you're looking at this palletness mixing. just, no, it's not. all, everyone's coming to the same conclusion. Yeah, that's great in isolation, but now in the mix and the momentum that this project has got, it's not, it doesn't gel well. So it's identifying that as well.
speaker-1: Yeah, yeah. doesn't. Yeah, yeah. And it's about even if they don't say it, the facility really got to point it out and say, gently say, Hey, we love it to
speaker-0: Yeah, maybe not for this. Yeah, well, let's find another way to get that in there.
speaker-1: Yeah. What's your, this is not in the questions, but what's your dream project? What's something that you haven't yet had a chance to get your teeth into that you're busting to do?
speaker-0: it's a wishlist thing. So I'd love to do an overseas Italian commission. So that's probably an easy answer for you. So yeah, will be that. Yeah, that would be a one. In any form, don't care what type.
speaker-1: ⁓ yeah. That makes perfect sense. Yeah, sure. Yeah. Okay. Well, if any one's listening.
speaker-0: Yes, please. www.texas.com ⁓
speaker-1: I love it. So at what point does a project usually click for you? it video on it clicks, but there's a lot of work to do, but or is there like a this is it's happening. That's when does that happen?
speaker-0: There is more often than not, there is a moment, it's like this positive momentum does build on a project and anyone sort of needs to be on board for that to happen. know, our client needs to be forthcoming with feedback and you know, we've got to be living up at our end and delivering what we're doing. But I suppose that stage is probably in the, our first stage is schematic design stage. Plans are pretty much better down. So external concepts seem to working the material palette. Yeah. It's all sort of all coming together. And then the ongoing explorations, what it's looking like inside or fine tuning details, it sort of just builds it's, like said before, this momentum. And not that we're not designing it anymore, we're forever designing it. But the answers become quite evident. Like what should we be doing here? Well, we should be doing this year because we're doing that there. Or it just informs itself. So. Yeah.
speaker-1: Yeah. Yeah.
speaker-0: Yeah, it can happen pretty quickly. It's sort of say this to the clients a fair bit. You don't want to move through a project. You don't want to take too long on a project because it just gets stale. And yeah, you just don't get a momentum that builds and you don't want to go too quickly as well because you want to be able to explore enough. ideas or troubleshoot things and there's this sort of sweet spot where enough time to be comfortable to test things but when it starts to get some legs you sort of have to run with it and let it go you don't want to stop that process.
speaker-1: Yeah. Yeah. Big one, I guess, I mean, talk about with a few people is budget and expectations. And, you know, it's hard for people who aren't in this world to understand how much something actually costs when they want the detail and quality and tick all those boxes. That's expensive. Yeah. How do you have those conversations with clients?
speaker-0: We have it very early on. You can't sugarcoat the money aspect. I mean, it's a real thing. ⁓ And budgets are very real and ⁓ not meeting a budget can create a lot of problems for everyone. So, mean, we're fortunate we've got a long history of projects. ⁓ We work with a good collection of builders. So we can test things real time. Even early concepts, we can get tested at market cost to sort of go, look,
speaker-1: Absolutely.
speaker-0: the current designs on the table, know, builders sort of saying sitting around this budget, how's that, you know, sitting with you. mean, you try and take a budget early and use your best knowledge to go, okay, well, this feels like it should work, you know, certain building size and the details and the materials that they're liking, but you got to test it as early as you can. And this for two reasons. is you don't want to, you don't want a client getting
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: emotionally attached to something that you're then taking away. you also don't want to have gone all the way down. You've documented all this stuff. You spend all this time, a whole lot of fees have been paid for, and then you're getting some nasty shocks. So if you sort of systematically work through it all the way through, you're sort of safeguarding that. mean, I suppose the other thing that we always try, it's the quality that we're trying to push first. So Sometimes someone might come to us saying, I need a house of X size. Don't worry about the size just yet. What's your brief? Let's see how that works. Because we might find that through some creative planning, like spatial planning and things like that, your building might not need to be that big. And it means that we can probably up the quality of finishes and details of the project and get a more elevated result. Still feels spacious, still does everything it needs to do. You know, we're not designing on spreadsheets. yeah, it's trying to make the dollar work harder. And it's also, I mean, we do roll up our sleeves a lot in the R &D side of things. you know, in whatever building technique we're exploring, the materials we're using, we workshop that early and all suppliers, all trades, we get involved because you just can't.
speaker-1: Yeah
speaker-0: flick it off and cross your fingers and hope the pricing is going to come back okay. You've got to test it, you've got to work it across multiple aspects because you've to be competitive with it and it's not just about using the
most expensive thing to get a good result. you've got to find cost activity in what you're doing.
speaker-1: Yeah, he sometimes surprised it, you know, when you've had to cut back and you've sort of compromised a little bit on maybe a finishing actually, you know what, this is better than I expected. Yeah, it's great. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Because that's that's that's important.
speaker-0: Yep, yep, yep, definitely. It is, and sometimes it's about owning that selection. you'd rather go, all right, I'm going to use this material and I'm going to use it everywhere and make it the best version of that and I'm going to labor over the, so it's a particular tile or a brick or whatever, I'm going to labor over the mortar joint and how wide it is and how the brick's laid and how it's struck off and... And you're sort of embracing using it as opposed to going, I'm just going to use it on that, I'd expensive on that wall over there. And I'm going to do something cheap over there. feature wall. Yeah. So, ⁓ yeah, it's about identifying it and working with it.
speaker-1: Good. So I've got to ask you about lighting podcast. At what stage I mean, you we've dealt with you for many, many years. Thank you. At what stage you start thinking about lighting? Is it right from the from the outset? Or does it sort of come later on after you've done
speaker-0: Of course, that's the slot. No, it's pretty early. mean, you've got obviously got solar light, you know, so you know, where your windows are placed and all those sorts of things orientation and that that's obviously from the get go. And that works in different ways. It's not just from the windows, it's overhead and skylights and things and the volumes that that can create. ⁓ But even early on, you are thinking about things daytime, nighttime, how you move through spaces. So it's not about trying to create this even sort of basic approach you want some modulation you want some change in things and so you don't need to think about how that works at night time and how lighting works with that.
speaker-1: Yeah. Yeah. And you guys are very hands on you do like you said, you're testing R &D, creating some sometimes your own pendants, things like that. Amazing. ⁓ And I think that's I think it's amazing that you go to that level of detail and made off send you on letters and things. So
speaker-0: Well, it's, mean, because we do the architecture and the interior is it all does need to work in together. And it is a more layered approach that we're trying to do. It's not a grid of downlights and away you go. So, you know, we're very mindful of that lamp lighting wall sconces, you wall lighting, up lighting, ceiling light, lights, it's how it all comes together. So, and we're consciously looking at how it works as a whole and how you move through that.
speaker-1: And so when you want to feature your architecture, are you relying mostly on the daylight or natural light versus the artificial or a bit of both?
speaker-0: They're both.
It's certainly with, as I mentioned, like we are quite a materials focused practice. We love how they behave and it's not just a simple white surface. And it's funny, something that could be seemingly smooth when you're glancing light across it, all of a sudden, the textures and the shadows that you get, you get this added richness and warmth to it.
speaker-1: Yep.
speaker-0: We did this lovely house all in granite in armadile and ⁓ this silver granite. And when the sun hit it, you get these little glints of like glitter and it almost made it feel light and ethereal. And that could only come from how the sunlight hits it. And then you can get certain things inside where, you know, light glancing across ⁓ walls or just the little hotspots you get in the darkness that you get as well. It does. Yeah, we are wonderful. How it feels. Definitely. Yeah.
speaker-1: Yeah. Do you have that conversation about lighting with the client or is it just part of the package? Do they, how involved do they get in that with you?
speaker-0: It's, there are particular clients that are very specific, you know, and some of it's functional requirements or from experience of what they like and don't like. ⁓ but most of the time it's more us guiding. Cause I think the expectation is a more simplified one from them. ⁓ yeah, we're trying to sort of elevate that experience. ⁓
speaker-1: Yeah, maybe something more expose them to indirect light and know, ambient light and task lighting. You know, just put it where you need it. Having the whole thing.
speaker-0: totally. Exactly. there's nothing wrong with dark spots in a home. It's beautiful. It can make it rich and then you move through somewhere else and then you get a different experience. yeah, yeah, yeah. Good. But as you know, one thing I suppose we're very big on as you know, know, the color temperature as well, I think, is something that we're very, I can see you smiling James, because you know I'm on tricky battering that one down. like we love that honeyed warm white glow that you get with you know old lamp lighting and so that's something that and there's something that feels old-worldly about that ⁓ and you emotionally or we emotionally resonate with something that is important to us and when you look at the buildings that we're doing where we're trying to make them feel
speaker-1: Exactly right, yeah.
speaker-0: Older more established and not to say we're making them ye oldie. Yeah. Or it's a fresh take on it, that is just what lighting is just another one of those tools that is so important to help imbue that age to a building. Yep.
speaker-1: Yeah, that's such a good point, mate. ⁓ Can you describe a project where light fundamentally shaped the overall outcome? Do you have a project you've done where it was so important?
speaker-0: That's a good one. I mean, probably, I'll probably selfishly say I mean, it's all projects. So it's a forever conversation. But I mean, it'd be silly not to say I suppose my own home. Sure. Which, you know, feature your beautiful lights in them. But because I suppose there's more you're focusing on it more. It's personal. really so you're putting everything on the table of what you like and what you don't like and experiences that
speaker-1: First.
speaker-0: have led you to, you I don't want to do this, I do want to do that. Yeah, so that's, that's obviously certainly one where I had the opportunity to pay that level of attention like we've been talking about ⁓ to create that feel that you're trying to get.
speaker-1: but also being your own. Did you take any like? I want to try this. I've wanted to try it, it's my house. I can try it. It's, know, I'm going to.
speaker-0: risks or something. Yeah, yeah, actually, what was funny is, ⁓ that was one of the ones where we worked up the read green custom color fitting. So, ⁓ yeah, that was on saying, yeah, playing with the colors of the fittings and it doesn't sound like a big thing. ⁓ but you know, in a house that had no white in it, you know, then what color do you give it? And that was, that's great. Cause I think you also start to sort of go, okay, well, this works in this setting off. I've trolled it. I've been the guinea pig. How does that relate to other projects that we're working on now? which is good.
speaker-1: so good to be able to say, I've done it, it works. We're going to do it in your place as well. I think it's great.
speaker-0: Exactly. think one of, and I suppose one of the other projects that sort of spawned it, as you mentioned, we do custom fittings and we've done these large ring lights, these beautiful big, take up the size of the room. Yeah. Our first one was in Cafe Latte restaurant in Armadale and then we did St Vincent's Place and we've done a few now, some in plaster, some in timber, others in perspex. ⁓ And that was probably one of the moments where lighting became less of a function, know, put some downlights in the ceiling to something that was quite sculptural in having this large ring, you know, taking up the volume of the space and providing that ambient light to serve its purpose. So that was sort of one that when we started rolling those out, it allowed us to think about how the light fittings can play, I suppose, a more primary role. don't necessarily have to be. We're ever trying to have them disappear, make them recessive. There's a time and a place for it to be something as well, and that's okay. It can add to the space because the space needed it.
speaker-1: Yes, yeah. And you also do a fair bit of art and sculpture in your projects as well. So another great spot to use lighting to highlight those things. So delete some downlights and use the.
speaker-0: Exactly. Use the artwork as the light source or to project the light onto it and that's yeah definitely. You know when you almost start getting that gallery light like lighting on areas it certainly elevates the way that the space can feel as well.
speaker-1: So we talked about shadow and
light and dark. I love that. Sometimes people might come to you and say, no, no, I want it perfectly lit everywhere. And that's okay, but do you sometimes like...
speaker-0: I want to We sort of try and tackle both if that's the case. Sure. So it's ⁓ how you dedicate the lighting circuits. Yeah. So you can have it all in a way that's going to be evenly lit enough. ⁓ you set up enough of the, yeah, those combinations of lights and where they are that they've still got the option for that. Exactly. Here's some scenes. Here's some scenes or something. And yeah, so you got your cake and eat it too, I suppose. Yeah.
speaker-1: ⁓ It's gonna give you that. Yeah, good. ⁓ Turning over to material materials, mate. ⁓ How does the longevity of a project influence your decision on materials? So I want something that's going to, you know, spending $20 million or $10 million, whatever it is. Want that to last a lifetime.
speaker-0: Yeah, I would. It should. Yeah, totally. It's just always there. It's not like it's even a consideration that it shouldn't be. But I mean, it's a funny thing. Yeah, it's a lot of money. It should well outlast, should be generations worth of time behind it. But it also goes hand in hand with the, you know, the fact that we love these
speaker-1: Yay.
speaker-0: time on a materials out stone break, it's there's an honesty in everything that we're using the timber, whatever it is, in having this sort of honesty of expression of the buildings. It's going to lend itself to materials that can last and sure whether the storm speak so. So it's nothing's ever really fetish or what like probably the wrong word, but
speaker-1: him. Yeah, yeah, Yeah
speaker-0: Yeah, everything is built for the long term, but the style of buildings that we do, this sort of sense of permanence to what we're doing, naturally comes with it.
speaker-1: Yep. Sure. Future proofing. So let's just say it's 15 years down the track and lighting is probably a good example. That's going to need to be replaced at some point. It's longer now, you know, and then there's automation and there's all these things that are changing pretty quickly. So how do you sort of navigate that?
speaker-0: Well, we, the automation thing's an interesting one. ⁓ cause yeah, it is ever changing. and we find you'd probably don't need, it's probably against what a lot of people say or should do, but we find if we do the hard yards early on paper and talk about exactly what the client needs and we think about where things should be, you don't necessarily need to.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: go down the whole automation path because you've done your homework early. Well, it be some certain things. That's right. But to sort of, know, 10 years ago, the blanket approach, let's see, bust the whole lot almost like because too hard basket, worry about it later, we'll get it right then. You sort of don't need to. If you measured with it and you work through it, it's more work.
speaker-1: of sensors and things
like that.
speaker-0: That's part of the design. You're thinking about all those things. ⁓
speaker-1: Yes. Yeah. Yeah, it's, ⁓ yeah. I was chatting earlier to Scott. You know, and, you know, it's, it's gonna happen. It's the tech, the tech is there and it's, but it's not for everyone. It's, know, some people are happy just to turn the switch on, turn it off.
speaker-0: Yeah, well we keep saying like someone's older parent should be able to walk in and know how to turn a switch on to turn the light on. So sometimes it can be overly complicated. Sometimes there's no alternative either. So that's fine. But with any of these things, it should feel easy to use. So that's probably our priority is even if it's there, making sure there's a a simplified way of using it.
speaker-1: How do you approach detailing without over designing? Because detail is something you walk through a project and you can see the detail. If you know you're looking at it, my god. But how do you do that without going?
speaker-0: Yeah, well, you certainly, I don't think you can't ever over detail. So, you know, the more detail, the better to get your idea across. But there's only so many hours in the day. yeah, but yeah, I think there is a point where you can over design. What we are always doing is that, and I mentioned earlier that we are always editing and forever critiquing what we're doing. think critiquing is different. to over designing. So we're for us questioning what's wrong with this picture or what's not sitting right. And we'll get that to the point that it is sitting right. And then you stop as opposed to just keeping on going. For the sake of what could be better. Let's just try another thing. So if the idea is strong enough, it sort of stands up to not having to over design it.
speaker-1: Yeah. Yep.
speaker-0: but you do also need to identify sometimes. on balance, might look at it, because we're all about balance and consistency and all these types of words that make the sense of restraint that you're talking about in the projects. But you don't want them to be boring either. You sort of need a bit of, you need some highs and lows. You need something in it. And we'd be the first to sort of go, Lucy's now too even. We need to find another layer to this to give it some more life.
speaker-1: Yeah. Yeah.
speaker-0: That's all part of that critiquing as opposed to over designing.
speaker-1: And then, mean, people who are coming to you, they've never worked with you before and, you know, found you online or whatever. Is it easier now with 25 years under the belt of, you know, they can see what you guys have been doing? You we trust you, just go and do this. And then you come back and you're like, there it is. it's like, is it that easy?
speaker-0: I wish. Yeah, no, sorry. ⁓ Sometimes, ⁓ yeah, no, no, sometimes we're very, we're lucky. I mean, yeah, we have got a back catalog and clients have confidence in us. mean, they like our work. That's why they've come to us, which is great. But you know, every project is a new project and you know, the client's voice needs to be within that. I think it's easier for us to be able to know if something's not going to work.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: because of that back catalogue of time. So it allows us to edit more quickly and get to certain design outcomes more quickly, which is good. ⁓ But also, as we get older and we experience more things and exposure to bits of architecture and other things that we're looking at, we're also trying to push ourselves as well. So it's not like, ⁓ here's the formula, away you go. We're also trying to... ⁓
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: You you want your work to progress, evolve. You don't want it to be this crazy Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde thing, but there should be a natural evolution of things. So we're trying to push that as much as it is, incorporate, you know, what makes that client's home theirs.
speaker-1: Yeah. Tell us about some of the responsibilities that architects have beyond just designing. Like what else do you, is on your. Yeah. Yeah.
speaker-0: In our day to day. I'll tell you, I wish it was just, I think, yeah, everyone thinks you're just sitting there designing away. I wish that it is a smaller part of your day. I mean, we're fortunate that we run through all the way through to construction with our projects. So, you know, you've got the whole backend where you're on site, you're having site meetings, you're working through issues, we're talking to trades, we're suppliers. builders doing all of that. And then you've got town planning, all the bureaucracy of that side, know, council and all of that. And then regulatory things with getting building permits, trying to make budgets. so the design part, you always wish you had more time. And then, you know, you've got to document it, you've got to draw it, you've got to work with engineers, you've got whatever it is, you've got to, there's a whole flurry of consultants that you're basically managing because it's sort of,
speaker-1: Running.
speaker-0: We're sort of like the head consultant pretty much trying to put it all together. ⁓ Cause to a sense where we have the most intimate knowledge of the project. So we're, you know, we're trying to get that across and weave it in. So yeah, there's a lot of balls that are juggling at any one time. ⁓ But you know, you just gotta roll up your sleeves and systematically work through it. and try and work through things all at once. It's not a linear model, unfortunately. If that was the case, it would take 10 years to build something. So you're always trying to have certain aspects of the project moving forward concurrently.
speaker-1: Yeah. Yeah. How soon do you like to get a builder on board? So you can have these kind of get into that detail. So really early.
speaker-0: Yeah, really early. It could be. It could even be a sketch plan like a hand drawn plan. Just look easy brief on your site. This is what you want. Let's don't even
worry about what we think it could be. Let's ask some builders right now. That might be the builders that are going to build it. ⁓ And what's their take? Because probably going to be more knowledgeable. ⁓
speaker-1: Yeah. Yeah, especially around costing. Yeah, exactly. Things change quickly.
speaker-0: Yeah, and especially if they know, if they've built with us before, then they know, I suppose, some of the details that it might be. I mean, we don't know what the design is really easy yet, but they can anticipate enough of a level of finish that they can, yeah, project some numbers. I mean, look, it's not by any means, you know, sign your life away type of numbers, but it's enough of a guide definitely to keep moving.
speaker-1: Yeah. Sustainability. So where are you at with that? And is it, is it just enough or are you pushing it further than needs to be or vice versa? The clients like, I want to go down this track. You don't need to.
speaker-0: It's so, okay, we're very mindful of it. And there's the given things like solar and all that, get it on board. If you can do it, do it. But the biggest thing that we're mindful of is, and we touched upon earlier, is building a building that's gonna last, that is low maintenance, that's not gonna need to be torn down in 10 years time. Build it well, insulate it well, get fundamentals of it right. And half your work's already done. It shouldn't rely on some crazy new technique to compensate for something that you've designed poorly. So get the basics right and the rest will follow. And you'll probably find you don't have to do as much. By all means do it. You're not relying on it. Yeah, I think there's a bigger responsibility there than just, yeah, ticking a few boxes.
speaker-1: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And what do you think the profession gets wrong at the moment? Is there just a general everyone's doing this? Like, is it a trend? it like ⁓
speaker-0: You know, probably not what the profession gets wrong. Um, but I think the perception of what we do, I'm not going to say is wrong, but if you go to a doctor, you go to a lawyer, no one's second guessing what their response is going to be. Oh, not as often, right? You take it with a little bit more authority. Yeah. Everyone's got a design opinion. And the difference is our
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: opinion has been filtered multiple times before it's even been put on the table. You know, we've shot down 20 times before we've even presented something. So that, you know, that, that knowledge and experience and skill set that goes into what we're presenting, I think gets undervalued, I suppose. Yeah.
speaker-1: Yeah, there's a lot of history in that, you know, that answer you're giving. Yeah. You know, like there's a lot of thought that's going into that.
speaker-0: ⁓ I'm just saying accept it because I've told you sure question anything. Yeah, I do think It's not a chip on the shoulder thing. No, it's you got to work. Yeah, you work hard. Yeah
speaker-1: Yeah. What about young architects? you know, people just coming up through the ranks. Any advice for them now that maybe you're seeing, maybe they've gone down this path of eggs and you're like, well, hang on, this happened already. Don't fall into that trap.
speaker-0: Unfortunately, you can't be experienced by time. can't fast track time. And I'd say as much construction knowledge as you can get, get it'll make you a better designer just because you know how things are put together or not put together. So I think that just absorb as much of the construction stuff as you can. But you know what? So it's a smaller offices. Yeah, like ours, we used to be smaller and everyone's got to roll up their sleeves and
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: Yeah. Do their bit. Might be answering the phones in a tear answering the phone. Mate, you'll know all the clients who know all the building. You'll sort of be this governor of knowledge. ⁓ which is great because you just become the sort of integral part of the office and it's knowledge based. So don't, don't be ashamed to roll up your sleeves in day to day office stuff. Yeah. Cause you'll probably find you're getting a better.
speaker-1: Thanks. Yes.
speaker-0: taste of what's going on, you're seeing a bigger part of the picture. It's not, yeah, I'd just say, yeah, like, get involved.
speaker-1: Absolutely. Yeah, yeah, that's good. Good advice, man. advice. Is there a project that taught you the most? Like it was everyone job you went? This is just I'm learning this. I'm learning that. Don't do that. You know, what's was there one that stuck out to you?
speaker-0: There was one, it's 20 years old now, and we did this bluestone building on a corner in South Yarra. It's tiny, it's, the site was only a couple hundred square meters. And it was an exciting job, one, I was sort of the lead project architect on it at the time, working with Brod and John on it. And we were, from a design perspective, we were pushing ourselves into some uncomfortable, like we're trying to sort of push it a bit for us, like get out of our comfort zone a little bit. that was... You know, that was dynamic and exciting, but from a construction point of view, we're doing this building with, you know, all this blue stone cladding and these big cavity sliding windows. was just a very detailed focused build and it was really engaged client that were up for it. Dealing with, you know, the site meetings. I was just as a younger architect at the time, it was full exposure, everything just the gloves are off. in being exposed to it, supported obviously in doing it. But that was sort of one where, yeah, involved in all aspects of it. Like you could walk out there and go, yeah, well, I feel like I'm part of that end result. ⁓ I just stand taller when you when you walk past it. Yeah, yeah, like, you know, I, yeah, I had the sleepless nights on that one and I had to do things and yeah, but it's, yeah, you want to you want to own what you do. And that was
certainly probably the first that, you know, from front to back and exploring the things we needed to explore, it wasn't a paint by numbers approach by any means. So, ⁓ you know, when it's challenging, more often than not, it's, you know, it's rewarding outcome.
speaker-1: Yeah. And you've come from a head over this morning. Yeah. Do you still get that same buzz and like at the end, that same sense of pride and like seeing it's all done and see the expression on the client's face and.
speaker-0: Yeah, you do. you do. It's you never jaded in that response. It's always, it's so enjoyable. And because you think, you know, you designing these homes for someone and they're going to, it's a long-term thing that their, their lives are going to evolve in this house. That house is going to evolve with them. It's something I'm not being altruistic about it, but you know, it's the, their most, biggest investment. spend their most time there and you, you've been part of. Getting them to that. So it's so enjoyable. Yeah
speaker-1: They've trusted you. They've trusted the same. You know, it's pretty amazing, mate. Yeah.
speaker-0: It is, you're always proud of it,
speaker-1: Yeah. So it's lighting. So when we talk about lighting, just back onto that. ⁓ How important is it to you? Like as an architect, and now living with our lights? How important is it? Has it changed? Has it changed over the years? Is it or have you always been kind of like lighting is amazing, but it's even better.
speaker-0: ⁓ no, it's, I don't think if you asked me that same question 10, 15 years ago, I probably wouldn't have much. I probably wouldn't be able to identify what it is that I was responding to. Like now I can sort of go, ⁓ I'm loving the warmth of this or the shadow of that. Like I can probably better picture what it is I'm trying to respond to. ⁓ I think we're designing.
speaker-1: Yeah, okay. Yep.
speaker-0: more with it in mind. ⁓ Yeah. I think, suppose the other thing is with technology, I mean, you know, again, how much we love our warm white and it's like the warm dim functions you can now get on downlights. they'd like the old halogen ones. I think we're at a point now, which is, it's great that we can.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: revisit the feeling that you get from that now in the modern houses that we're doing. So that's probably pushing us now to create spaces that are working more as we were hoping they would.
speaker-1: Just to, we're going to get to the end, we're going to wrap up soon. A couple of last questions. Is there one design rule that you often break? You might not want to tell us the answer, but is there something you always break and like, shouldn't be doing this, but I do it because it works.
speaker-0: in a big picture sense. Like when we're designing something, we're trying to distill it down to that core idea. ⁓ But sometimes it's identified like we've gone too far. know, pull it, we've got to pull it back a bit. We've got to actually inject something more. It's not the less is less is more, but yeah, sometimes you need to.
speaker-1: More. Yes.
speaker-0: put something back in. So yeah, we've ever sang it. Does it need it? Don't do it. But ⁓ if we're going to break a rule, it'll be that one because we're going now we've got to put some we push it too far.
speaker-1: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Good. Um, and I think we've covered the advice, but anyone who wants to, know, um, maybe have a chat to you about their projects or, know, is it, is it an easy conversation? Should people be afraid to reach out and have a chat?
speaker-0: ⁓ I don't think I'm too scared. No, it's It's not. It's ⁓ look, it's like anything. I understand. It's a big, big process. Yeah. You comfortably work through it as the stages you need to, you know, you you've got to digest it. So it's ⁓ you gradually work up to what you need to work up to. So it doesn't need to be daunting, really. Yeah. It's exciting thing. yeah. It's your home. It's amazing. So That will be the, you know, try and come into it enthusiastic will probably be the first thing, because it's really fun, dynamic thing to do. Yeah, no, I wouldn't be afraid at all.
speaker-1: Yeah. Yeah. Good. Well, Andrew, I'm so lucky. I've been working with you guys for nearly 20 years. Yeah. Thank you, mate. So, and many more to come, I hope. But thanks for coming on to this, you know, my podcast. But, and yeah, maybe we do a follow up, you know, season two or something. See how it goes. Yeah. Love it. Thank you, mate.
speaker-0: ⁓ We've loved it, James. That's very fun, thank you. Thank you, James.