РАСШИФРОВКА 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Starting now. Honey's ready a WAM.
00:00:01
Speaker 2: I love it.
00:00:02
Speaker 1: Thank you very much, sir. I appreciate that and troops like always, I appreciate you showing up for muster, and I hope all is cool and copasthetic on your end. You and I have grown up voting a particular way. Right. Used to be machines. We click, click, click, and now it's fill in the little loop and put it through the scanner. Seems pretty simple. I'm grateful for it. I have confidence in it. But there are thoughts about maybe changing some of the ways we vote, and not necessarily the technology, but some of the structure specifically maybe open primaries and something called ranked choice voting. To find out what each of those means, we're und to be joined by a long time worker in elections, an elections commissioner from Monroe County, New York, mister Peter Elder. Sir, welcome to the broadcast.
00:00:55
Speaker 2: Thanks for having me today.
00:00:56
Speaker 1: I always appreciate your time and expertise and the years of service you've rendered. First of all, the first one open primary? What does that please, sir?
00:01:05
Speaker 2: Well? Right now, New York City has a closed primary system, which means that only members of a particular party can vote in that party's primary election. So if you're a Democratic, can only vote in the Democratic primary, or Republican or Republican in primary, and so forth. So under an open primary system, the typical form of one would be that any voter regardless could vote in that party's primary. There are variations. One of the variations that use in New Hampshire for instances, you are allowed to come in, you can change your party on that very moment that you check in and then vote there. So it's a modified open primary system. So there are nuances to where an open primary system is, but basically it's that any voter has an opportunity to vote in any other party's primary.
00:01:51
Speaker 1: What would be strengths or weaknesses of that, please sir well.
00:01:55
Speaker 2: One of the proponents tend to think that that allow more participation in the voting process. Obviously, numbers of voters participating may go up. There possibly of some turnouts that might go up as well. The negative side, of course, is the parties can no longer protect themselves philosophically or numerically from they have philosophies of other parties. So you've seen situations where one party will literally flood the zone and have their their members change their party to influence another parties on the primary election. So it really becomes in those particular instances almost like a run off election rather than an open primary where everybody's just out there trying to to you know, to choose the first the first round of candidates before they get to the general election. So, but there is a little bit of a variation in the states and what open primary is. But what they're really debating in New York right now is allowing voters who are no longer who are not registered, were not enrolled in a party, to be able to vote in either of the party's primaries.
00:03:03
Speaker 1: So if you're what they saidids, this is the Elections Commissioner Peter Elder, So does that mean like blanks is there sometimes called would be able to vote then, but a Republican wouldn't be able to vote in a Democrat, and a Democrat wouldn't be able to vote in a Republicans.
00:03:16
Speaker 2: Right, It's still that exactly. That's one of its possible variations. Now, I will say you can't actually do that in New York right now, the parties could, through their own rules adopt procedures to allow for non members of the parties, non enrolled members of the parties to vote in their primary election. So so one of the one of the things that to keep in mind here is that party rules could actually take over and be another option here. If that's something a party felt particular about, there is the law to say exactly the same that it is now. But if a party felt particularly it's also particularly important to allow blanks or non enrolled people to vote in their primary, they could simply change their party rules and allow it.
00:03:57
Speaker 1: But the fact that neither party has that might the message.
00:04:01
Speaker 2: Yes, it probably does. Yes.
00:04:03
Speaker 1: If Peter L. Elders, elections commissioner in Roe County, I'm a Republican and in New York, I'm always paranoid when the state says we've got this new thing. I always figured it's going to screw Republicans somehow. Would this impact either of the two major parties and any kind of significant or disproportionate watser, Yeah, an.
00:04:25
Speaker 2: Open primary system would would more than likely impact the Republican Party more, only because the Republican Party has less total members. So the Republican Party in New York is outnumbered almost like it was about two and a half three to one were So obviously that floods of zone scenario is talking about could much more easily be done with the Republican Party. Even if the Republican Party decided to do that kind of thing with the Democratic Party, there just aren't the same numbers there to do it, so I would. Yeah, So there is obviously a disproportionate effect that could occur on each party. Now could that on the local level, could that go to the opposite? Absolutely? I mean if you're in a position, if you're in a rural county in New York and there's an open primary system, then it could very well influence the fact that there wouldn't you know, could the republic could influence a Democratic primary? But on the state wide level, the Republicans are way out numbered versus the Democrats.
00:05:17
Speaker 1: Yeah. Is there a proposal, speaking the Elections Commission, Peter Elder, is there a proposal that would say anybody can vote in any primary?
00:05:26
Speaker 2: Yeah, there are proposals out there, that's exactly correct. That's another that's another one. There are proposals
Load full transcript
where you can just cross over the parties, and again usually those are there's usually something in there that requires a voter to declare the party they're going to vote in. So I would say that that's a lot more like the New Hampshire model, where we could where you declare the party when you come in, you vote in that party's primary. Now, in that case, some states have a situation where you have a cool down period where you can't then change your party back for sixty days or ninety days. Other states literally you can walk out of the polling site and change your party the next day. That's what it was before. So it really depends on the rules that are adopted, and there's a lot of proposals out there of what that might look like.
00:06:04
Speaker 1: Is there a problem here? Is there a need for something like this? Do you think?
00:06:08
Speaker 2: I don't think there really is. Again, it is very much of an opinion here, but I would say that the New York State is an extraordinarily open enrollment registration process. If voters who are not registered in the parties feel particularly strong about a particular philosophy, what I would strongly recommend is they, when they fill out their voter registration form, just enroll in a party. There's nothing nothing prevents a voter who is under currently not enrolled in the party from enrolling in one.
00:06:38
Speaker 1: Sure, Peter Elders Alo, So it's pretty simple, Yeah, Peter Elders Elections Commissioner, Monroe County. The second one, I don't begin to comprehend ranked choice voting. What is that, please, sir?
00:06:50
Speaker 2: Well, that is that's a situation where if there's multiple candidates in a ballot, a voter indicates their choices by preference. So I'll say it's a K, indicate one, two, three, and indicate what your rank is of those vote of those particular candidates, and then they're talied at the end, and you know whoever gets the uh the third plate that's the vote for two, for instance, the third place candidate would fall off. Those those ranked numbers that were that were indicated by the voters would be reapplied to the other two. So it's a system that is used in places like New York City. There are some specific cities in New York State, it's not It's used in Maine on a state wide level for some races, so it's uh, but really it's in the other forty nine states don't use it on a state wide.
00:07:35
Speaker 1: Level, which also might send a message right. Yeah, the notion of making this state wide or spreading this in New York, I'm confused by it, and I'm not sure what the benefit of it would be, sir.
00:07:50
Speaker 2: Yeah, there's some of the people who are the people who again are proponents of attendance, think that it is a better way to represent voters wishes because you can they can literally rank their wishes when they do it. There's also there's also an argument that it helps prevent runoff elections. So that's a or at least it's an alternative to a runoff election. Again, it's a much more, much more, a little bit more our Keeam process. In terms of being able to calculate how that's done. It really is hard to recount in proportion to what we do now in comparison what we do now, So it is a lot, there's a little bit more to it. Again, my bias I've grown up in it is we have a good system for voting right now. It's simple to me. A simple voting system is a better one than the one that introduces complexities. So I can tell you, OOBVI is an election right now, if I get more votes than you do, I win, right, It's easy.
00:08:42
Speaker 1: It's very easy, and and there is I think peace of mind in that. I oh, yeah, we live in an era where people question elections and on both sides, and that's not good, right. We want everybody to have peace of mind and believe in the outcome, and additional complexity and confusion, to my mind, doesn't achieve that end well.
00:09:05
Speaker 2: I think people forget off times. This is legitimacy of an election, which really gives people confidence in it. So when you have when you have a winner take all system just like called first past the post in England, he's basically the same system as they do the you know, it's very easy to understand. Whoever comes first in the race, they win the race. Yeah, it's just literally like to track me, and so it is a it's a very simple thing. I think it adds legitimacy to the results because people know that under a ranked choice voting system it doesn't happen a lot, but it does happen sometimes that the candid that got the second most votes ends up winning. Yeah, how's that? That is nice and that and that makes people and people look at that a little bit and go huh, yeah.
00:09:45
Speaker 1: So that doesn't work. I also like systems where and I'm grateful for a two party system, and I recognize that that's not a system per se, but I like it when the winner has a majority, whatever whatever the deal is. When I have two choices A and B and we all make our choice, whoever comes out on top had the support of the most people, and that, again, I think is good for society.
00:10:11
Speaker 2: Right. We tend to and our system really is more of a plurality system. Even the majority system it whoever gets the most votes. So if I have three candies running, this is where the rank choices proponents tend to actually concentrate their argument. They say, well, there's three candidates running, you would have a situation like where one candy could win with forty seven percent of the vote. Say, because the other ones got you know, X amount of vote, and that maybe they got forty seven forty and then the remainder picked up thirteen or whatever. So then you would look at it and go, okay, well that nobody achieved the majority. Right, So that's where the argument goes. I would still maintain that it's a lot easier for voters to say, oh, yeah, but the one.
00:10:46
Speaker 1: That got the highest of the Vieah, yeah, yeah, one, one hundred percent. My solution to
this is let's not have three candidates. But my secondary solution would be the way we do it now is fine, Yeah, the guy your gal with the most votes Gemschriiser.
00:10:59
Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, No, I'm just going to say one of the reasons we have prime raceis is try to eliminate that multiple parties, multiple candidate structures. So it really the way we have it now is designed all the way along to try to get you the two candidates to the general election.
00:11:12
Speaker 1: So well, good, good, good good. Anything else on these and also, what are your sense of the prospects for these things actually spreading across up state or becoming statewide?
00:11:26
Speaker 2: Yeah, it's hard. It's hard to tell. Obviously, the Democratic Party is overwhelming in control of the state government, so they do have a preponderance and effect on these things, although I will say, to their credit, they are they very carefully looked, I think at some of these changes because their elected officials are elected under the current system, so I think they look at these and see how it will affect every race down the line, not just state races, but county races, local towns, village races, so all these because it would have an effect on everything. So while you might think all Jesus is an easier way to keep us, you know, electing a democratic controller, we already kind of are. So so the issue really is what does it do to the to the offices, say in the middle, where there's actually competitions, stay on a county wide or a town wide level, and that might change the perspective on how this, how this would be implemented. There's one other thing I just mentioned real quickly. The ranked choice boiling also will change the way the ballot looks. So so it's not just a matter. Open primary system wouldn't really change your ballot per se, but the ranked choice voting actually would physically have to We'd have to really tell voters and really make sure they're educated on how this ballot looks and how you interact the ballot.
00:12:36
Speaker 1: So yeah, I hate to sound like a conservative, but let's just leave it be we're doing Okay.
00:12:43
Speaker 2: Yeah, you're actually right. Most states have gone that way. They've they've not they people looked at this before and they've and there's actually been places that have adopted this system and then decided to go back So how's.
00:12:54
Speaker 1: That It makes me feel good? Peter Elder's elections commissioner in Roe County. Appreciate your time and expertise. Thanks for explaining these things to me. Thank you, you bet you e as well, sir back in a moment on NewsRadio Wham eleven eighty. If you've been watching these soccer games, I.
00:13:10
Speaker 3: Don't know usually what's going on unless there's a goal.
00:13:12
Speaker 1: But we're not going to try to explain it. But if you're watching the news, no one quite understands.
00:13:18
Speaker 3: We got you.
00:13:18
Speaker 1: Let me explain it differently.
00:13:20
Speaker 3: Listen carefully use.
00:13:21
Speaker 1: Radio Wham eleven eight. You've heard those ads. A brand new bathroom in just one day sounds great until the short building on new data centers across New York for a year. I want it's a stupid idea, in my opinion, But I don't understand if this is what she wants to do, why she doesn't just sign the already past legislation that does the same thing. I I'm not a fan of executive orders. I recognize you know that I voted for Trump, who seems to be, you know, the king of executive orders. But we are a legislative government. My Republicans in Congress should have been passing bills that implemented all the things that Trump put in in executive orders. But in this situation, the LEGI again, I don't think we should have a moratorium or a pause. I think we can go forward intelligently, and we can let individual communities decide, and I think we can make up policy on the run. But if Governor Hokole wants a one year moratorium and the legislature has already passed a one year moratorium, why does she just not sign it right and let the legislature act as it's supposed to, as opposed to her issue an edict which she's really not supposed to. What I'm saying, could you tell her next time you have your no King's rally that it's also a no queen's thing. Okay, just as you understands the deal, take a break, get news, be back after on news Radio Wham eleven eighty.
00:14:54
Speaker 3: Plan of the Praise Freedom does work to the vois of Fredo Use Radio Wham eleven eight.
00:15:04
Speaker 1: It's a funny thing. But that music from that little promo there makes me think about summer and your car, and that makes me think about z bart. You've seen guys out there over the years. It'll be a sunny Saturday in the summer, there'll be waxing that thing. They'll have that turtle wax or paste job, whatever's on there. Make your all shiney getting it squared away for a little cruise on a Saturday night. Well, listen at z bart. They can help you with that. How what about detailing the inside of your automobile. What about some sort of system that helps protect your car against scratches and dings. I'm about some protection for your car against russ and stuff like that. How by undercoating to protect that undercarriage. That's how take care of that ride, because it takes care of you. Taking care of your ride, keeping it squared away begins at zbart.
00:15:57
Speaker 3: Dot com RPL at Rustle Mountain, Thursday, July sixteenth at seven thirty pm.
00:16:03
Speaker 1: Kids under eighteen are free and adults.
00:16:05
Speaker 2: Hey, what you want?
00:16:06
Speaker 1: VIP dinner package is available. Talking currently to the folks at Congress and it's going pretty well. There's civil, nobody shouting at each other. And Elena Kagan said a few words about Lindsey Graham at the commencement of a remarks that were really pretty gracious and thoughtful. Are to be joined by a retired Rochester Police officer and a nationally prominent
endurance athlete, the Great Brett Sabrowski, Sir, Welcome to the broadcast.
00:16:37
Speaker 2: Good morning, Bob, how are you doing today?
00:16:38
Speaker 1: Pretty well? Stud Also, happy birthday is in order? How many is this one? Young man?
00:16:45
Speaker 3: This is apparently I've been told. I'm not sure this is true, Bob, but this is the big one. I think the big six zero sixty years old.
00:16:54
Speaker 1: Today, outstanding, congratulations, Thank you.
00:16:58
Speaker 2: I'm glad.
00:17:00
Speaker 3: There's times when I don't think I'd make it this far, and I'm glad I'm walking on the side of the earth.
00:17:04
Speaker 1: Yeah. We any thoughts at this milestone, this juncture in life.
00:17:10
Speaker 3: It really is. And I gotta be quite honest with you, I wasn't sure like last week I was gonna feel when I finally hit sixty, but nothing changed, and you know, just another number. So you know, I do believe in Father Time, and I believe he's always trying to chase this down, always trying to get a little you know, try to wiggle his way into your life. So I just try to beat that guy. Back every chance I get.
00:17:35
Speaker 1: Don't let the old man in. I think that's the line, don't let the old man in Glenn Eastwood, right, You Restlebroski've talked to of course, and you almost always have a quest. You have a grand adventure that you've got coming up starting this Saturday. What is that? Please?
00:17:54
Speaker 3: That is called the Community Action four hundred, where starting on Saturday, I'm gonna run fifty five miles a day around various high school tracks for seven days in a row. Then the final day on the twenty fifth, the following Saturday, I'll run fifteen to make it, you know, four hundred miles overall.
00:18:13
Speaker 1: That's amazing. That is amazing, And we'll get to the endurance aspect of it in the moment. But there's a specific purpose you're trying to achieve here.
00:18:24
Speaker 3: Yes, it's for Community Action of Orleans and Genesee. Just a fabulous, fabulous agency out here headquartered in LB in New York, and they do so much for this community here and in Genesee. And you know, if they ever went out of business, there's no way that social services could ever pick up the slack what these great people do day in and day out. It's just and I always say, community actions to me is always about hand ups, not handouts. It's about helping people, you know, live a better life without just giving handouts. And it's it's just fabulous. From from their their head start programs to their weatherization programs for houses. They give prom dresses. Imagine being asked to the prom and you cannot afford a priv dress. They have these prom dress giveaways. I think in seven counties eighty five dresses this last prom season. Just a great organization.
00:19:19
Speaker 1: Bob and Brett Sebrowski. You're looking to raise money, you need people to donate, to pledge. How can they do that? Please?
00:19:28
Speaker 3: So to you go
to Runner sign Up, Runner sign Up, you search it the on the Googles, and then keep me into the Action four hundred and it'll give you a place where you can donate money. And what's just as important as that is coming out to these tracks. You know, mostly in Orleans County. I'm doing all the high school tracks here, but on Monday, I'll be in the great City of I call it Batavia Batavia, and then on Tuesday I'll be in East Rochester honoring that same day, Anthony mu Zerkowitz, which will be the four year anniversary of his murder in the line of duty. I'll be honoring Darryl Pearson who was murdered in the line of duty almost twelve years ago. And then Jamison Ritter, who out in Cleveland was murdered in the line of duty just a little over two years ago. So if you, if folks can come out, you don't have to be a runner. You come out and walk a few laps from on the track, and I would gladly, gladly walk with you. Just love to fill these tracks up with people for a great organization.
00:20:32
Speaker 1: Where are you going to be Sunday?
00:20:35
Speaker 3: Sunday, I'm going to be in the great great village of Lenonville in the in the north, in the north west part of Orleans County.
00:20:46
Speaker 1: That's almost in Canada up there there, Bob.
00:20:51
Speaker 3: When I drive home, my self Service every other day says welcome to Canada. You are now roamy.
00:20:58
Speaker 1: You say, you say I don't drive to Canada, Buddy, I swim to Canada. All right.
00:21:03
Speaker 3: Yeah, if you drive, that's a cheap way out, Bob. There's only one way to get over there.
00:21:06
Speaker 1: That's exactly right.
00:21:07
Speaker 3: It's gonna take it's gonna take twenty one and a half hours. Ask THEE how I know?
00:21:11
Speaker 1: Yeah, he swam across Lake Ontario one time. Is there a runner sign up? Community Action four hundred is how people can donate and pledge such like that. Is it there or any place on Facebook or something where people could like learn the schedule of where you'll be when.
00:21:27
Speaker 3: So you just my Facebook's open, and my names are worse to spell. But if you just start spelling SOB, which I'm usually not, I never thought.
00:21:36
Speaker 1: Of that, but that's a good point there, Brett Gush.
00:21:39
Speaker 3: So when people spell my name now I say it, it says to say s ob and everyone's burst out like s O B I E R A SKI. So if you look Brett's resky up on Facebook, it's all over my page where you can just click the you can click the link and go find it. If you looked up Community Action of Orleans and Genesee's, they're right on the front of their page. Is a donation where you can link where you could donate.
00:22:07
Speaker 1: Outstanding. Now, the speaking of breast Saber, asking, here is the issue of you today. You're sixty and again you're strong and vital, but fifty five miles a day, multiple days in a row, that's a heavy, heavy lift.
00:22:23
Speaker 3: Oh, I'm you know. It didn't sink until maybe a week or two ago, Bob,
And I was like, yeah, I think, you know, And I kind of hope, you know, uh, reluctantly hope that this is the hardest thing I do, because that's kind of the purpose of it. But yeah, I think, you know, many things could go wrong, and I think mostly because it's lack of time to recover. So it's going to take me eleven hours. I'm hoping eleven no more than twelve hours a day. But you know, you think travel time to and fro, and then you know, shower times, leap time. It's not going to leave a lot of time to work on you know, sell care or preventive care. So it's gonna be tricky. There's no doubt, you know. I mean, I'm confident I'm going to do it. Come tell a highwater. It's just how well I do it, I guess.
00:23:12
Speaker 1: Yeah, Well, you'll do it with honor and grace, no doubt. I appreciate this. I am grateful to you for supporting this worthy organization and setting the example that you are setting to folks who may be in your neck of the woods in terms of age, who may not have the same background you know, in physical activity and exercise and such. What would you say to them? What do you know about this stage of life that maybe they should know?
00:23:37
Speaker 2: Sir, well, I'll tell you.
00:23:40
Speaker 3: If you don't start today, you're one day behind the curve.
00:23:43
Speaker 2: You really are.
00:23:44
Speaker 3: If you don't start today, you're one day behind. And I don't look to myself as an example. I smoke for sixteen years. I led a very poor lifestyle, and I was a poor example for my sons at that time. And you know, and the only good thing I was ever good out of my life was probably smoking, where I smoked two or three packs a day. And then I crawled myself out of that hole. And it didn't happen overnight. It happened over years in these little baby stops until where, you know, I learned that I could I could have some type of personal greatness, not greatness on a global scale, but it's possible. It's just, you know, it's a day in, a day out grind, and you know some days are better than others, but it's it's really you learn, stick to it, nous, and your life gets a heck of a lot better.
00:24:31
Speaker 1: It's great. Brett Sebrowski, Sir, let's touch base again Friday. Remind people what you're doing and we'll check in on you then. But again, best of luck with this and a very happy sixtieth birthday to you, sir. Thank you, Bob.
00:24:45
Speaker 3: You're a good man. I appreciate you.
00:24:46
Speaker 1: Thank you very much. Back in a moment on news radio Wham eleven eighty, Americans have always debated, discussed, and sometimes disagreed for two hundred and fifty years and some city hall to the capitol at all. It's America, two fifty US Radio Wham eleven eighty. Hey friends, Lnsbury here talk would you? Gerty? And she, as is her nature, angry Harsh says, how dare the federal government seek to build ICE detention facilities in New York? She said it was unbridled aggression and against the law and it couldn't happen here. Well,
we've touched on this principally for you and I. Kathy Hochel and Democrats in the legislature are why ICE has to build new detention centers in the state. Of New York. What Ice is proposed is putting in a small place in Newburgh, adding i think two or three detention cells at the federal building in Rochester, and building a second complete detention facility right next to the one that currently exists in Batavia. That's on the table. Why is this being done? Well, Taffy Hokele and the Democrats in the state legislature just passed a bill that, I mean, this legislative session just passed a bill that makes it now illegal for New York County sheriffs to in effect rent cells to the federal government to hold federal immigration prisoners. These are people who have warrants and charges and all that stuff. And what's happened previously is that in the community where they're captured, typically or in an adjoining county, they would be held in the county jail, and the federal government would pay that sheriff to hold that person in that jail, you know, covering all the expenses, you know, as their paperworkers processed or until it's time for them to be released or transferred or something like that. Just as the State Department of Corrections does the exact same thing with you know, state prison inmates for whom there's maybe not a cell open right now as they get sentenced or whatever. This is not an uncommon practice, but in New York, says no, county sheriffs can't hold. And this is not like Joe is grabbed off the street on his way to work. This is someone who has a deportation order. This is someone they've all through the they've gone through the process, they've had the judges, they've had the court, and it's time to you know, be held and to be gone. Kathy Oukles said, you can't do that. Well, here's the deal. Those people still need to be held. They there still will be a process in New York State where by federal immigration law will be enforced. As part of that, a certain percentage of the people will have to be detained. And now that the Democrats have said they cannot be detained in county jails, they will have to be detained in federal facilities. And so the small holding center at the Federal building in Rochester a just slightly larger I think it's two or three cells in Rochester, and then in Newburgh it's a similar size deal. And then an entire additional facility in Batavia. This ends up costing sheriffs a lot of money that they won't get to make. It ends up significantly inconveniencing the detainees and their lawyers. Instead of being held in a county jail where you are apprehended near maybe your family and certainly near your lawyer, you're going to be transferred all the way across the state to Batavia, far away from your family, far away from your lawyer, and that's where you will be held because of this new law by Kathy Holkland the Democrats in Albany. Without that, there's no need to be another detention center, and folks could have simply stayed in county jails as they did before. So this is Kathy hoakle plant politics not being a good governor. It's time for news. We'll get that from Dave Devo on news radio when I'm eleven eighty. America consumes a lot of news. Stay informed by friends. The iHeartRadio app, listen, walk, jog, and yes, even drive with it available in the app store, or use radio Wham eleven eighty. Downtown Definitely Events presents movies with a Downtown view this Friday at Parcel five and