РАСШИФРОВКА 🔗
BTB Intro: Welcome to the Beyond the Bunk Podcast, where we are four everyday producers bringing you honest opinions, real experiences, and conversations straight from the bunk. Welcome to the Beyond the Bunk Podcast. Now let's meet our hosts.
Andrea Flemming`: I'm Andrea.
AJ: I'm AJ.
Jake: I'm Jake.
Ryan Vos: And I'm Ryan and welcome to the Beyond the Bunk podcast, where we are four everyday producers talking about just general everyday stuff that goes on within the within the cattle industry. Jake, are you okay today, buddy? You just that that I'm Jake wasn't wasn't quite what we usually get from you.
Jake: Yeah, I'm gonna need I'm gonna need one of you to carry the energy a little bit today. I need I need some yeah, I need some serious pump up from one of you. For real.
Ryan Vos: I just man, just a tough day for tough day to be a Jake.
Jake: Incur.
Andrea Flemming`: Yeah.
Ryan Vos: All right. Anyway, I guess my my question to start us out today is what is a single trait EPD that you that you like the most that helps you make your best decisions? I think today we're gonna be talking about phenotype, genotype, and a lot of that comes back to EPDs. So Jake, which EPD helps you make the best decision?
Jake: I'm going to take the answer of n there isn't one singular EPD that I would say I weigh more than others. for me it's more of a balance approach, which I'm sure we're gonna get into. but I can't actually name one that I pay the most attention to.
Andrea Flemming`: Bam, there it is. I think
Ryan Vos: Fair catch because he just punted.
Andrea Flemming`: it's if there's like a front loaded to this question of like, what are you selecting for? And if do you know your herd as a whole? So for me, like knowing our herd, knowing our weaknesses, I'll look at those traits a little bit more. But as Jake said, it has to be balanced. So I'm looking at marbling, I'm looking at birth weight because we do have so much birth weight, things like that that I care about. But I don't want extremes one way or the other either. So that's my two cents.
AJ: Yeah, and guess I think that kind of leads into the indexes. I mean, it's kind of a, you know, a combination of all those traits put together. So I guess I probably lean a little bit more on the indexes than anything else.
Ryan Vos: Man, could I have picked a worse question to start out with? Just everyone just punted on that. Every single one of you.
Jake: You should analyze that, Ryan.
Andrea Flemming`: I think it shows though. Like it shows the truth though. Like truly.
Ryan Vos: Yeah.
AJ: Yeah, there's not one single trait that a guy can select for. Because you select for one, it's going to hurt you in another area.
Andrea Flemming`: Mm-hmm.
Ryan Vos: Okay, let me let me rephrase the let me let me go to a different question then. We'll rephrase it into a different way. All right. We'll go with let's say this. You guys walk into a sale and you see two heifers standing side by side. One is the best looking in the
Load full transcript
entire barn, the other is average looking with outstanding numbers. Which one are you gonna go with?
Jake: So w sorry, one big numbered one that's a little planer or one that looks really good that's big numbered.
Ryan Vos: that's poor numbered. A great looker with
Jake: Poor numbered.
Ryan Vos: bad numbers or a great numbered that's an average looker?
Jake: I'll still take the a little bit plainer numbered one and one that checks all the boxes for me from a phenotype standpoint.
Andrea Flemming`: I'm gonna flip the script and pick the other one because I've seen some really pretty cows produce crap and some ugly cows produce great stuff based on numbers.
Jake: This is gonna be a good episode.
AJ: I'll take the pretty one. I'm gonna lean
Andrea Flemming`: I I think so too. Of course. We knew this. We knew this.
Jake: Ha ha ha.
AJ: on the fact that maybe she didn't come from the best environment. And you know, it's just, that's part of it.
Ryan Vos: So to answer the first question, 'cause I never did that, and also to d to answer this one, I when I go to a sale, I find the numbered animals first, and then I look at because you have to find a place to start in the in the catalog. You get a catalog of fifty animals. I go through, look at all the numbers, and I write down on a sheet like I like four, twelve, fifteen, twenty-four, and then I'm like, okay, they check my boxes. genotype and then I go look at phenotype. So I'm probably gonna take the big numbered animal first and then which EPD trait do I really care about? The one that I really care about and I I actually screwed up on pretty bad. And as long as my wife isn't listening, I can tell you guys the story. milk is the one that I really pay attention to. And the story goes when I was first getting into the cattle industry, the cow calf industry My father-in-law and I, who we had just my wife and I had just gotten married, like in July, he my father-in-law takes me down to Denver. We go down to Denver and I see a heifer there that I just absolutely fall in love with. And I bought her at the auction. Did not tell my wife that I was buying her, sent her some pictures and videos, but no discussion was really had. And she She was not overly impressed with my decision of purchasing an animal without discussing it with her. But anyway, we we got through it all. Everything worked out fine. but where I was saying
AJ: Did it have anything to do with a feedlot guy picking out a heifer?
Ryan Vos: That was 100% what she said too when I got back. So,
Andrea Flemming`: Mm.
Ryan Vos: but the the where I was saying that the milk is one where I got myself in a little bit of trouble is my first year in, I was like, big milk, big calves. Didn't really equate that to big milk, big teets and utters. And
Andrea Flemming`: And big feed intake.
Ryan Vos: yeah, so we she's a she's a good eater. That's a kids of fact.
Andrea Flemming`: Mm-hmm.
Ryan Vos: But my my issue that I'm having right now is this is her third calf
that she had this year. And her teets are getting very big where I think I'll be good for the next couple of years, but I could definitely see in a few years that that might be a hard teeth to get in a baby calf's mouth.
Andrea Flemming`: It's a Herford.
AJ: Ha ha ha ha.
Ryan Vos: So milk
Jake: Yeah, we're we're talking about a Herford issue. Mm-hmm.
Ryan Vos: is the one that I really pay attention to, but yeah. Yeah.
Andrea Flemming`: Yeah, so this is a Herford thing right now.
Ryan Vos: You guys don't have that across other breeds?
Jake: it it is you can get you can get you'll get bad uttered cows in any breed, but talking about the milk EPD,
Andrea Flemming`: Yeah.
Jake: they're milk EPD has nothing to do with shape, utter shape or teeth or volume. The only thing milk EPD
Andrea Flemming`: That's
Jake: has to do with is quality of milk. So no quite it it
Ryan Vos: I thought it was quantity. All right, I'm learning something. Once again, feed lock eye.
Jake: has it has n it actually has zero percent to do with quantity. It's a hundred percent to do with
Andrea Flemming`: Mm-hmm.
Jake: quantity. So What they're effectively the what the milk EPD does, it's based off of growth metrics. So that's the only way we can analyze quality of milk and beef cattle, because we don't put them in a parlor, right? We don't send milk tests off on beef cows to analyze butter fat and components. So the only analyzation of quality components in beef cattle milk is how big the calf is that cut that she weans off. So you can have, and this is I would challenge you, Ryan, to think about some of the cows in your herd. When you're looking at them, you might have a cow that you're like. She she has a nice udder, but man, it doesn't look like there's a big udder, but she always weans off a high high-end contemporary calf, right?
Ryan Vos: I can think of a couple of cows like that, yep.
Jake: Yeah, so that is a high milk cow because she's got higher quality milk. You can have a cow that has a big old udder and produces a crazy volume of milk, but if that milk is
Ryan Vos: Hold on, hold on, hold on, hold on. AJ, get that fly off your camera.
Andrea Flemming`: Yeah.
Jake: If if squirrel if you have a cow that has
AJ: fact that you do that.
Jake: po po the milk EPD only has to do with quality of milk, has nothing to do with utter shape, size, teat size, or volume.
Ryan Vos: Well, it's so that's interesting because it makes sense. she has a huge bag, so it must be a different underscore teeth score, which I I'll be honest with you, I'm very new to the cow calf industry. and this is if you're kind of wondering why we're going down this road as very high into the cow calf side right away, it's because what we're gonna do with this podcast is we're gonna have like essentially seasons, if you will. And right now we're just into the cow calf one. So we will get to feed lot stuff, and that's gonna be where Obviously I know more, but this is, the cow calf side. But she has a huge otter, she has, big teeth, but she always weans a huge calf. So that does make sense. She must just have high quantity and high quality. So with that being said, we're kind of in, you know, already in topic of what EPDs are, but I want to back up just a little bit here. let's talk about the difference between genotype and phenotype. Andrea, if you were to break it down for somebody, we're talking like first grade, second grade level. What do we dumb it down for me to understand?
Andrea Flemming`: I got you, Ryan. Don't you worry. Phenotype is what you are physically seeing. So if you think of phenotype, it's P-H-E-N-O-T-O-T-Y-P-E, right? Physical phenotype. This is what you are physically seeing with your eyeballs on the animal. So it's her look, it's how she's put together. It's a pretty cow, like AJ likes. That's a high phenotype animal for him, versus like those rat dog-looking cows. That's probably a lower phenotype. But then on the flip side, you have the genotype, which is basically the internal genetics potential. that you can't see that they can't exhibit within the right environment. So it's two birds of the same feather, essentially. It's just the physical side of things, the genetics actually inside of said animal. And then they cross over nicely sometimes and sometimes they don't. So
AJ: is genotype is what's inside of them. Phenotype is how those genes are expressed. Everything's
Andrea Flemming`: Mm-hmm.
AJ: got, we all have a genotype. It's what our DNA says. Environmental factors is how those.
Ryan Vos: And very sexy men like myself would be the phenotype.
Andrea Flemming`: Jesus Christ.
Jake: Well
AJ: Whatever, however you want to, however you want to think about yourself where I am.
Jake: That's crazy.
AJ: mean, I would leave more towards Jake, but.
Jake: That's crazy.
Andrea Flemming`: Confidence is good. Confidence
Ryan Vos: Yeah.
Andrea Flemming`: is good. Proud of you for that.
Jake: That's right. You go king, isn't that what the kids say?
AJ: Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Andrea Flemming`: I don't even know.
Ryan Vos: All right, moving moving on. so
Andrea Flemming`: One of time.
Ryan Vos: with that being said, when you talk about EPDs as a whole, there are so many different ways to discuss EPDs. So you hear a lot of things when you go to a sale. I was at a sale not that long ago, and you hear a lot of things like single trait EPDs and EPD accuracies and also like composite EPDs. I'd like Jake, can you explain to me when somebody says the single trait EPD? What is what does that mean when you hear somebody talk about
Jake: So if you pull up a pedigree or if you go on American Simmonsal Association or American Angus Association,
Ryan Vos: Perfect.
Jake: any association, they're gonna have a panel of EPDs and a
Andrea Flemming`: Not a Herford.
Ryan Vos: They do, we do,
Jake: not a Herbert.
Ryan Vos: trust me, we do. I just got done paying all my dues. I am up to date and in good
AJ: You
Jake: Well,
Ryan Vos: standing with the
AHA.
Jake: So if you look on that paper or to the website, you'll pull up an animal and then it'll have a plethora of EPDs. Angus has far and away the most. I would say semis probably have like the second most, and then the smaller breeds tend to have, or the smaller Yeah, smaller associations seems to seem
Andrea Flemming`: Yeah.
Jake: to not have quite as broad of a spectrum. but a single trait EPD, say we'll individually Anything from birth weight to weaning weight to yearling weight, to milk, like we talked about. So there's all of these EPDs that this animal has, which is an expected progeny difference, and each one is analyzing a trait or a combination of traits or how that trait is expressed. Like when we're talking about milk, isn't actually the volume of milk kind of as it reads, it's the quality of milk which is expressed through growth. So, but they all are targeting a certain area of that. animal and how that will probably be expressed through their calves. And it it is important to note when we're talking about EPDs is it's an expected progeny difference. It's not necessarily that that actual animal and her or his expected performance. I still like to see some of those traits represented in that individual animal. So if I'm looking at say a two year old that has or if if a calf hits the ground and you know it's got X amount of weaning, gearling weight, average daily gain, all of that and its own EPDs. Even though those EPDs are supposed to represent what she's going to raise, I still want to see her express and follow along those same lines in order for me to have kind of that extra little bump of confidence. Like, yeah, I I you are exhibiting this. I'm extra confident that you're going to pass this on to your calf. So A single trait EPD is just an area of which that a trait that that cow or bull should pass on to an offspring.
Ryan Vos: All right, so before anybody feeds into that, Andrea, you said it earlier during the intro. you talked about E P D index. So
Andrea Flemming`: Mm-hmm.
Ryan Vos: can somebody explain the difference to me between single trade E PDs and what an EPD in an EPD index is?
Andrea Flemming`: So basically, your composite, your index, whatever it's called within each breed. So if I look at the Cemetol Association, I got that one down. Then we have two API and TI. I think it keeps it pretty simple. API is your all-purpose index. So that's where we're looking at everything as a whole, but it brings in a little more of the maternal side of things versus TI is more of your terminal index. So basically you're taking anything related to terminal ending on the rail. performance on feed, that thing goes into your TI. API is gonna bring in some of the other stuff. It's gonna give you more of that broad overlook of that animal to say, okay, are they more of a cow maker? Are they more of a feedlot, calf maker sort of environment? And then how do they compare to another animal's overall score efficiently? And then you get
into like the Angus Association. They like dollar beef, dollar feedlot, dollar grid. They have so many of them. And I'm not super well versed in the Angus side of things. And to be honest, some of that's a little overwhelming when you go look at it first. But basically it's giving you a composite score based upon that area of single trait EPDs grouped into one to help you make selection a little make that a little bit easier without being so instinct on individual traits. Cause as we mentioned earlier, if you're going to choose heavily for milk, for example, you're going to kind of have issues on other traits because there's always kind of a give and a take as they work together. So that's where that comes from.
Ryan Vos: AJ, you had a video not that long ago that discussed the the the big EPD animals. Talk about that a little bit.
AJ: I just brought up the fact that you go everybody's been to bull sales and you hear them all this this bull is top 1 % of the breed for yearling weight and or or cav Weaning weight type thing But we don't see it and I've really wondered why we do not see that I got a lot of pushback. I was kind of more going after the seed stock guys. Hey, okay. Are your numbers accurate or you are you buffaloing us as commercial producers? And the amount of pushback I got from commercial producers kind of blew my mind. And it was just one of them questions I had in my head. You hear it all the time, you see these big numbered bulls, but we're still seeing 450 pound calves hitting the sale barn. And like, that's the majority of calves that hit the sale barn off the cow. They're not weaning five, six, 700 pound calves. So. it was just a question I posed. as to the accuracy of some of these EPDs.
Ryan Vos: Yeah and and I think a lot
Andrea Flemming`: accuracy and I think environmental factors play a big piece into that.
AJ: Yes, they absolutely do.
Ryan Vos: I think you're exactly right. I also think
Andrea Flemming`: Mm-hmm.
Ryan Vos: this goes back to when people date their calves and how all that works. And you know, people try to make their animal look so good on paper that it's impossible to not sell that they kind of, you know, they bluff their way a little bit here and a little bit there, and it can really screw up the whole E PD accuracy. So with that being said, when somebody says accuracy, Jake, what does that mean?
Jake: So we're talking about accuracy, and Andrea, Andrea and I will be referring to the Simi Association through this episode, because that's what we work with every day. That's the cattle that we raise. But when we're talking about accuracy and percentile rankings, it's all true for all breeds, but you're just going to hear us saying cementol slang, basically, because that's what we know. so we're talking about accuracy. If you look under an EPD, say your birth weight EPD, that'll be the actual number, there'll be an accuracy. And then there'll be a percentile ranking. So the accuracy is indicating how accurate
that EPD should be. So calves that don't have any reported data on them, you'll see down in the 15 to 20, 20.15, 20, 25. so it's it's trying to it's trying to say that there's not a whole lot of data phenotypically and genotypically on this animal. And There's not a lot of confidence in said EPDs. Now, if you look at like a 10-year-old bull that's in a stud, those EPD accuracies will be much higher. It's expressed and it's there's a lot of been a lot of cows, a lot of contemporary groups, there's been a lot of actual data analyzed on those bulls to increase the accuracy. so when we're talking about accuracy, I think that's one big thing to look at is how much. confidence is there in those EPDs based off the accuracy, i.e., how much collected data and genotype is there?
AJ: Jake, is there a way to increase accuracies of a certain animal without having a ton of progeny on the ground?
Jake: DNA testing is one thing that'll quickly increase increase your accuracy. So typically a calf, if you take a calf that the dam is not genotyped, he's not genotyped, but the sire is, because in the semi association, every sire has to have genotype on file. if you take that calf, it'll start on day one when you register that calf is probably around a 0.25 accuracy on most of its EPDs. If you send in a 100k test, which is their genot G E E P Ds, genomically enhanced EPDs, that calf will often jump up to right around a 0.4, 0.45. So they have they've analyzed the genetic markers on that calf and have seen genomes in there that will increase in accuracy and then you'll see some EPDs move. And one question I get I have got from a few of my buddies is like Man, it's weird. Some calves seem like they don't move a whole lot, and then some calves they move a whole bunch. and I think that is a little bit of the power of GEEPBs, especially in 2026. When this all started fifteen, twenty plus years ago, and I can't remember it's the it's it's the little genome marker, but there's a specific term for it. Andrew, do you know what that term is? Genuinely.
Andrea Flemming`: Genome marker, your allele. Is that what you're talking about? Your genome marker. 'Cause it's it's alleles
Jake: Maybe. Yeah. Yeah. So the markers
Andrea Flemming`: within that, yeah.
Jake: The markers they were looking at when this first started, they were looking at 15 of them. Today they're looking at over 400 of them. So they've through science and being able to try to get this technology better. I mean, the am the amount of genomes that they're analyzing is huge. and then there's also g there is also homozygous and heterozygous recessive genomes that all of these cattle possess. So one thing that like the SIMIS have.
Ryan Vos: Which that that is wild when you go into like heterozygous, homozygous, and you go back to the punnent square and all that stuff. So that's something like Right.
Jake: Yes.
Andrea Flemming`: But then there's complex punit scares too. it's not all
Jake: There's complex
Andrea Flemming`: the little fours.
Jake: bonnet swears.
Andrea Flemming`: You have attached
AJ: Yeah.
Andrea Flemming`: alleles to the main allele. Ugh.
Jake: So for the semi association specifically, there's a there's a in Cemitals, and I believe there's a couple other breeds that have it, but it's called the big birth weight gene. So that's a gene that never gets explicitly showed in the Cementol registration, but they look at that genome. So if you have an animal and I've had them, that they'll be they'll start as a plus one EPD, you'll send in G EPDs and they'll come back as a plus five. And you're like, this calf. Had a 75-pound birth weight, why did it move up so high? Well, it's because they have a homo or heterozygous trait that's sitting in those genomes that can be expressed. So if you were to mate that calf and say that calf was a homozygous big birth weight gene, you mate them to a homozygous big birth rate gene bull, that's where your like your 125 pounds come from. If you avoid that, then it'll never be expressed. She'll probably have a 75-pound calf. But if those genes click, that's why that birth weight. jumps up so high because there is a chance that you're gonna have a hip breaker out of that cow. Even though on paper and off phenotype, she may have not been exhibiting those, but there still is a chance. So they lay that in into the range outcomes in that EPD when they're doing genomes. And there's a whole bunch of those traits that aren't laid out actually under your animal's trait track for SIMES where you can look and be like, my gosh, it's positive or negative or whatnot.
Ryan Vos: AJ, you are going to war with that fly right now.
AJ: Yes, I don't know what
Jake: I am too.
AJ: it's what its fascination is with what
Andrea Flemming`: Ha ha ha.
AJ: its fascination is with the webcam, but it it seems to like that
Ryan Vos: All of a sudden, for those of you that are listening and not watching on the YouTube, AJ has a fly that like lands and you just see it get a little bit blurry on his screen, and then all of a sudden it's just like a very close-up picture of a fly. So it's that fly, that fly
Jake: It looks like Prime Muhammad Ali, do get it out on on the webcam right now. He's like, Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Andrea Flemming`: Mm-hmm.
Ryan Vos: is doing this to make AJ very mad. All right, going back to this, I think the the the one thing that I that is One of the most frustrating things to me as a feedlock guy when it comes to EPDs and genotype, phenotype, cow calf stuff is not really phenotype, take that out of what I just said there, is nothing is standard across the breeds. And you know, when I look at like an EPD for one of our cows, it reads see if I can do this off the top of my head, it goes like calving ease, because calving yees, birth weight, weaning weight, yearling weight. And then there's, a few other ones like SCF, which is their stability, and then it goes into milk, and then it goes it just goes down the line. there's
scrotal, there's all this other stuff that goes across the bottom of the EPD. But when I put that up next to let's say an Angus or a Semitol, it's so frustrating because what I see as a good number in the Herford Association is going to be an unheard of number in the Semitol Association, either from the downside or positive side. Yes, Jake, go for it.
Jake: okay, this is perfect. So I just got so excited.
Ryan Vos: Jake looked like he was seizing there for a second.
Jake: I I I I did spaz out. So this is where percentile rankings play the biggest part. So percentile rankings under that EPD will show in the breed in the registry where that animal ranks in terms of EPD. So you can take a Herford, right, and look at Herford EPDs, and if that animal is ranked in the top 20th percentile birth weight. You can subsequently go to another breed and find another animal that interbreed is top 20% with that. But here's the thing about EPDs is those EPDs aren't quite quite weighted the same based off of say a British or a continental animal. So not to ride for the brand too hard, but the one database that you can look at, and I don't know if I mean I'm quite sure there's Herefords in the semi-database. I guarantee it.
Andrea Flemming`: yeah, there is for sure.
Jake: so you can the semi database.
AJ: You don't get calves like Andrea's.
Ryan Vos: Andrea has one.
Jake: with being with being an open with being an open book, y it takes everything and puts it into the same EPDs. So there's three different classifications in the SIMI registry. There's purebreds, there's sim angus, and then there's non sim. So those non sims, it takes all say if you're an Angus or if you're a Herford or if you're a Charlet, if that animal is in the SIMI database It takes everything and goes apples to apples on an EPD level.
Andrea Flemming`: Mm-hmm. And then there's also
Ryan Vos: So AJ, when you look at
Andrea Flemming`: the charts too, you can use, where they have comparable charts if you really want to get into the nitty-gritty of
AJ: Yeah.
Andrea Flemming`: what's a plus one birth weight in an Angus versus a Herford, whatever the chart says. But the biggest thing is those percentiles are gonna be your best friend, especially if you're cross referencing. Cause for me now to look at like a simitole and to see like a 0.4 birth weight and seven on the cabinese, like in my head, I know what that looks like for my herd and comparable. But when you're trying to cross reference, it gets a little frustrating because the math doesn't math on what a seven is here versus a seven there in Kavanies.
AJ: So I do have actually a dumb question before Ryan goes any farther.
Jake: No dumb questions.
AJ: Why is there not like a zero? Like breed average across like you look at an EPD and like for weaning weight it is zero. Why do we not see that?
Jake: So because the EPDs, it's it's taking two sires and if you're it's taking at a two sire level and saying this sire is going to sire X amount more weaning weight than the next sire. So everything starts at zero, right? At a
Andrea Flemming`: Yes.
Jake: at a core basis, everything has zero EPD. But the differences in those numbers is that it's it the The idea for when selecting a sire is you can look at those EPDs and say, okay, if you have a weaning weight forty or a weaning weight eighty, bull B should sire forty more pounds of weaning weight than bull A. So that's why nothing's at zero.
AJ: Right, but if you've got
Andrea Flemming`: And I think this
AJ: two, if you've got, let's say, your cow and your bull that you're breeding, they're both 50th percentile for their breed. Let's just say they're both semitones. They're both 50th percentile for their breed for weaning weight. They should be breed, essentially breed average at 50th percentile. Why do we not see both of being zero?
Jake: Because it's when we're talking Andrea, you you look excited. Go ahead. You're ready.
Andrea Flemming`: I I just wanted to make sure we make the point of cause I get asked all the time, people are like, How do you actually utilize EPDs? And I like what you were just saying, Jake, of comparing. That was my note. I know. But
Ryan Vos: Hold on, don't go into that. Don't go into that yet. Don't go into that. We're going to get into that. Yeah.
Andrea Flemming`: when the whole like what AJ's bringing up, the zero thing is not happening because of the comparables that is happening, correct? Correct.
Ryan Vos: Right. So my my question before we get into that, I w I just want to go to AJ really quick with a question. We that that is going to that is one of my bold and underlying topics that we will cover before the end is utilizing them within your herd because that is ungodly important when you're when you're talking about matings. But AJ, do you as a whole, being a guy who really focuses on phenotype over top of genotype, do you ever feel like you're fighting an uphill battle when it comes to like calving ease or when it comes to growth in your calves, do you ever just feel like you're you're fighting an uphill battle because you started from behind in that category?
AJ: Absolutely, 100 % and I the pretty calves come from the show calf side their numbers are
Andrea Flemming`: Trash.
AJ: Not the people
Ryan Vos: Horrendous.
AJ: and Manipulated I mean, just don't I don't think at the same time too. I do not think that they are They care they It's a it's a secondary thought to them, you know, you might get a birth weight You may get a birth weight on it, but you may get a weeding weight None of those things are seen, yearling way. It's because the true show cattle guys are probably selling those calves. And it does get really, really tough. I've always tried to focus. I've always said I pretty show cap that's got good numbers. And I think it's almost impossible to do.
Ryan Vos: So now I wanna move into this, 'cause Andrew where Andrea was going, because this is, like I said, the the number one thing when it comes to
why genotype exists, why EPDs exist, and that's to better your herd. And, you know, you can go out there and you can go by bad n AJ's gonna get Get AJ. Get
AJ: I missed him.
Andrea Flemming`: Ha ha ha
Ryan Vos: Okay. when we I'm if for those of you watching, AJ is at absolute war right now.
AJ: Got him! Right there. He's...
Andrea Flemming`: he did get him.
Ryan Vos: Nice. Good job. All right. So going
Andrea Flemming`: He's done. No more fly.
Ryan Vos: into this, why we use EPDs, why we use, genotype. If you use poor number animal after poor number animal after poor number animal only to use only to better your phenotype, like AJ and I said, we're just gonna be fighting from behind. So Andrea, talk about utilizing EPDs and utilizing genotype to increase the value of your herd.
Andrea Flemming`: So the biggest thing is I want to make sure it's known that EPDs in your genetics is only part of the equation. But the other big part of this is environmental. So like that's the big disclaimer we need because sometimes there's really great EPD numbered cattle that don't exhibit it in the right situation, which is really frustrating when you like pick them out and then they like are mediocre and they suck. I have a few of them right now, and I'm like, I don't understand what's happening, but it is the environmental side of things coming in. So that's a little note. But when you're actually utilizing EPDs and you go in and you look at numbers and it's frustrating and you're confused and there's so many numbers on there, I get questions all the time. People are like, what do you even look at? And I'm like, well, if you're looking at the SIMs, it's gonna be your composite, your API, and your TI. That's where I would start. But they were created in the first place to be utilized to compare two animals at least. That is how you're supposed to utilize them. So you compare bowl A to bowl B, as Jake was saying, you know, if one's winning weight is 40 pounds or up 40 plus versus Whatever you had, 40 to 80, bull B is gonna theoretically, per genetics, be 50 pounds or 40 pounds heavier on weights for your calves that are out of him. Theoretically, is it an exact equation? No, because environmental is a big piece of that. But when you utilize EPDs in a comparison route, it'll be much easier for you to actually make decisions on how you're utilizing a sire or choosing females versus just looking at them. So when I send 50. DNA staples off for replacement females, I will rank them based on different skills and automatically if they're way at the bottom and subpar compared to the top twenty five percent, they're probably not gonna make the cut unless phenotypically I adore them or they're four fifty seven, some or some sort of thing in there. But EPDs
Ryan Vos: Pause.
Andrea Flemming`: yes.
Ryan Vos: Is four fifty seven's E P D's like are they average, above average, or below average?
Andrea Flemming`: She's probably like for our herd as a whole, she's very much like just slightly above average. She's not insane. But I think it's the whole scene in her that brings her down a little bit too.
Ryan Vos: Ha ha it.
Andrea Flemming`: Yes. She's not extreme on any end. She's very top forty
Ryan Vos: I c I can confirm from the I
Andrea Flemming`: percent everything, just there.
Ryan Vos: From looks, she looks great. From the inside, she feels like a cow. for those of you that don't know, go
AJ: Ha!
Andrea Flemming`: Yeah. Yeah.
Ryan Vos: back and listen to the episode. She tried to eat me. She's she's got a
AJ: She's only slightly diabetic.
Andrea Flemming`: Mm-hmm. Correct. Just a little bit.
Ryan Vos: sugar addiction and she won't eat cow cow feed. Anyways, proceed Andrew.
Andrea Flemming`: Yes. But anyways, as I was saying, it just helps you sort your really mediocre animals from your superior animals and then you can utilize you know, from there if you care about certain traits, you're trying to improve improve certain things, you can kinda utilize your single traits a little bit a bit. But the composites is probably your biggest route comparison wise, and then fine tune things. Jake, do you have any thoughts to add to that? Mr. Professional Nodder over there.
Jake: I'm just this is a lot of agreement. I'm just you're you're killing it right now. That's what all this is. And I think important
Andrea Flemming`: Smiles. Okay, perfect. Perfect. Perfect
Ryan Vos: So can I ask a
Jake: to important to note just to tack onto that when when Andrea's trying to articulate that these are in she's using like in theory and should, right? It's it's
Andrea Flemming`: Yes.
Jake: right in the name of what an EPD is. It's an expected progeny difference. It's not a GPD, guaranteed progeny difference, right? It's just it's a tool to allow mating decisions and when picking sires to hopefully have another tool that maybe this bull is expected to sire this over this.
Ryan Vos: So when you go back to listening to our our TikTok lives, everybody that's in there knows that I very much like to hear certain certain facts and then just hold on to them and make sure that they just live rent free in my head and then I find out later on that they were all lie. So one of them that I have heard, I'm very, very curious about and I would love for one of you guys to to to weigh in on this is is it true when you're reporting numbers? To your association breed, that it really doesn't matter what number you report as long as it's in the correct order. So, like within my herd, let's say I have 10 calves and I put for birth weight, this one was a 10. Or sorry, for my weaning weight, this one weighed 10. You know, as long as that was actually the heaviest one, I can put another one at one. That it really doesn't matter the real number, as long as it's in. chronological order within your within your herd.
Jake: No. What are you talking about? I think you're asking about
Ryan Vos: So so
Andrea Flemming`: I'm gonna punt that to Jake, because I was like,
what?
AJ: I'm assuming he's trying to talk about contemporary groups.
Jake: Yeah, are you asking about contemporary groups?
Andrea Flemming`: ranking versus
Ryan Vos: Well, so Yeah, so i like when I go fill out my American Hereford Association, if I don't have a scale, as long as I have the animals in the right order of when they were weaned, like let's say I have them at s you know, six hundred and fifty pounds versus another one who is four hundred and fifty pounds. As long as you're in the relative ballpark of close and as long as you have them in the right order, that's what's important. And like I said, I could be so far off on this. But that's what I was told at one point, and I just was like, Okay, cool. I now have a scale,
AJ: explains a lot of the hirfer numbers.
Jake: Okay, so I think what
Ryan Vos: so I don't have to worry about it, Andrea.
Andrea Flemming`: You do.
Jake: So I think what you're asking about is interherd contemporary groups. not you're not quite
Ryan Vos: Yes, sure.
Jake: getting there, but I'll I'll help you. I I'll hold your hand. You're welcome. So
Ryan Vos: Thank you. Let's cross the street together, Jake.
Jake: thank you. Just look to the left, I'll look to the right. So contemporary groups is the biggest consideration towards how your EPDs off of reported data is going to move. Because what contemporary groups do is say, I have a hundred calves, right? And I report a hundred calves. It breaks the semi association will break them down into sub-contemporaries, which is like bulls, heifers, or heifers out of heifers, heifers out of bulls. It'll break them down into groups. So what the reason contemporary groups are so important is that it's in theory, those that group of animals is the only situation that everything had equal opportunity, which is why it's also important to have different contemporary groups if they had different opportunities. So say in Andrea's situation, her contemporary groups should be her confinement calves and her calves that go on pasture. So those will be two contemporary groups, right? And then if there's other stuff like, these got creeped, these didn't, those should all be separated. But it's groups of calves that had equal opportunity. So say I have a a herd of mature cows that calves on the same place and then they're going out to the same two pastures that is equal opportunity for forage, right? Those calves will all be in a contemporary group. So the numbers, the reported data off of those calves is what is a most of the weight going into your reported data on your EPDs. Because what it allows us to do from a contemporary group side is find which ones performed or underperformed or were average in that group in an equal opportunity setting. So if That's why contemporary groups are so, so, so important because what you raise at your house versus I raise at my house based off of opportunity. And this is where we start talking about opportunity and things like that, management, environment. It's the contemporary groups are really the only way to narrow down and kind of eliminate that environmental aspect because everything should be on the same playing field. So also to tack on to what you're saying. I am of the opinion that you should not be reporting weights if unless you have a scale. If you're guessing, I think that is I think that is wrong. If you're you just I I would say you leave it blank because you're at s you're reporting accidentally reporting false data, not try saying you're trying to be false if you're someone that is reporting weaning weights without a scale. But there is inaccuracy in that guessing, right? So for me. I would if I didn't have a scale, I would just not report weaning weights is what w w what I used to do because I don't know for sure. But anyway, contemporary groups answer your question. I think that's what you're talking about when look like when you're saying rankings in your herd.
Ryan Vos: Okay. Yeah, I I I just wanted to get that out there and I think you're exactly right and having adding a scale to our operation is something that I'm very, very excited about. My father in law and I I always borrowed his scale and now because of Andrea, I now have my own scale. So
Andrea Flemming`: And some peer pressure.
Ryan Vos: Yeah. I
AJ: It only took you six months to get it.
Ryan Vos: To be fair, I think I spoke on it like a year ago.
Andrea Flemming`: Yeah, and then you just never came and got it. And then we were like, Does he actually want
Ryan Vos: Just lived in their shed.
Andrea Flemming`: it or should I put it on marketplace right now?
Ryan Vos: Yeah, no, and so so the story
Jake: Mm-hmm.
Ryan Vos: of that goes, I wanted a s so we were on TikTok live, and Andrea's like, yeah, I got this scale or whatever. And then I I think I no, it was back to a video. You were talking about a scale, and I'm like, I wish I had a scale. And you're like, boy, do I have a deal for you? So we were on TikTok live.
Andrea Flemming`: Mm-hmm.
Ryan Vos: We talked about it, and I'm like, Yeah, I'll take it. And then we never really discussed a price. And then I called her two weeks later, and I'm like, hey, what do you want for a price? She said, I'll get back to you. About a week or two later she gets back to me. A week or two later I got back to her. And then we just had like an agreement that I was gonna Yeah, exactly. We had like an agreement.
Andrea Flemming`: Then you said yes. And then it just sat there until AJ was there to actually load it for you, basically.
AJ: Yes, it took me to get you to actually take it.
Ryan Vos: I don't think that's quite how it went out. So we so we had like an agreement that we were gonna get this scale, and then like one time I just AJ comes to visit, I go down to Andrea, and Andrea goes, dude, get your scale out of my shed. So
Andrea Flemming`: And now you have and you're good.
Ryan Vos: we loaded it up and it's in the shed, and I don't know how to use an EID reader, but
that's a whole nother conversation. Yeah,
Andrea Flemming`: Yeah, it'll be fine. You'll be fine.
Ryan Vos: no. I I can't get it to talk to a spreadsheet. Don't know how to do that yet, but that's what chat GPT is for. anyway, so we're not gonna get into EIDs yet. That will be in a future episode. we'll write that down. But I think we really should navigate boy through my phone. We should really navigate into kind of the question from the bunk. I there's a few actually, you what? Before we get into that, a couple other notes in here I have are when it comes to choosing females and bulls. What are you looking for on the E P D side? Is there anything else that you guys would like to discuss within that? Is there anything else before we close out this episode of going into the question from the bunk and what's your beef? Does anybody have any closing thoughts on it?
Andrea Flemming`: I think it's important to talk about like extremes, I feel like. And this kind of ties back into AJ's thoughts on his video he did where why are weights unincreasing? There are extremes within the realms of EPDs and bulls out there. Like you can find bulls where they are like, do we want to deep dive on this chick? Do we want to take this road and harp on it? Do we say names? Do we not say names? Do we just like cover it lightly? Cause I have thoughts.
Jake: We'll s we'll we'll sprinkle. How about that?
Andrea Flemming`: Okay. So there are especially newer bulls that come out of the gates and people are very excited and they will have top 1% API, top 1% TI, which is very hard to do when you have something that is supposedly quote fingers here if you can't watch the video, that they are so good terminally and so good maternally. Those are extremes and usually they don't go in hand in hand. And there are bulls out there that come out of the gates and they're really exciting and they are marketed as extreme. And then all of a you breed to them and you put them on a good variety of cows and they don't do crap. So there's some of that accuracy issues, but also when you are so extreme one way or another, you usually, we touched on this, you lose something. Something else is going to take the hit. So for me personally, when I'm choosing bulls and choosing replacements, I don't want the extremes across the board. I like a solid top 40%. Nothing is like where all of a you see top one percent, ninety nine percent, one percent, ninety nine percent. I don't like that. I like to see more of average above average across the board. So she's not extreme one or the other. Cause I have more issues with my extremes than I do, which is my average ladies that are just solid across the board. And I think Jake would agree on that one.
Jake: For sure. when it's it's inverse and adverse effects to different things. So if you're go super high into marbling, for instance, your your maternal prowess is going to take a backseat, right? Or birth weight and weaning weight, growth versus cavities, things like that. So there's inverse and adverse effects to all of these traits that we're talking about. so finding for me, as someone who dabbles in the seed sock thing, a little Tiny little itty bitty minnow swimming in a real big ocean. I am also attracted to one that has a balanced EPD profile. So, like for me, I want kind of my basis is I want them to look good and I want them to read good. I don't want to chase extremes for, say, growth or carcass or whatnot. And sometimes they kind of get expressed like that. but as a whole, I'm trying to find balance of you know, versatile cattle that are going to. perform in a maternal and terminal setting. And then there's going to be bulls that will do one better than the other type of deal. So I think that's the biggest thing, selecting bulls for me. And it's also imperative that you understand what your goals are as a program and what your environment is. If you're in a really high forage environment like I am, a larger cow with bigger growth can handle that. So like a or if you're in If you're in say New Mexico, right? you want a small crowds, no growth. Yes. And
Andrea Flemming`: Yep. Small cows, they want thousand pounds soaking wet cows. Yep.
Jake: that will just come in bred and bring in a calf, right? So it's totally environmental and and your EPDs and your traits and your phenotype.
Andrea Flemming`: How's the mic drop? That was a good moment to end on right there.
AJ: How much extra weight does water actually, you said soak and wet, how much water, how much weight does that actually add? I know they do, 100%.
Andrea Flemming`: I don't know, fifty pounds? I don't know. But seriously, like they panic about our cow sizes down there. Like I was literally winning with some
Jake: That's a question, honestly.
Andrea Flemming`: Colorado breeders and they're like, I don't know why you'd want a cow over twelve hundred. And I was like, I don't want anything under fourteen. Like it's a whole different I don't know. It's weird. Yes, Ryan.
Jake: Yes, Ryan.
Ryan Vos: Jake. This is where I I do my interview questions. So Jake, my name is Ryan from the Beyond the Bunk Podcast. question for you today,
Jake: Good to meet you.
Ryan Vos: sir, is factor fiction, moments ago you said you were a tiny minnow swimming in an ocean. according
Jake: Correct. Factually correct.
Ryan Vos: to Google's definition, a minnow is a tiny freshwater fish. So
Jake: Mm.
Ryan Vos: if you were a minnow swimming in an ocean, you would die.
Jake: It feels like that some days, actually. So I don't think it's still
Ryan Vos: Okay, I've just
Jake: inaccurate.
Ryan Vos: I just I just wanted
Andrea Flemming`: Ha ha ha.
Ryan Vos: to throw that out there that the Google definition is a freshwater small freshwater fish. So not trying to not trying to point fingers or anything, but you were wrong. So questioning credibility.
AJ: You're more like a clown. You're
Jake: Yeah, this is
AJ: more like a clown fish swimming in the ocean.
Jake: That's
not bad. I don't hate that. More dory. I do get sidetracked
Andrea Flemming`: a dory, actually. I see him as like a dory.
Ryan Vos: Yeah.
AJ: Yeah.
Jake: for sure. Yeah, I none of these are wrong.
Andrea Flemming`: Yes.
Ryan Vos: I yeah. I'm like a starfish. I I serve zero purpose and I just lay there.
AJ: Ha ha.
Andrea Flemming`: Jesus Christ.
Ryan Vos: All right.
Jake: Nice.
AJ: We're not getting into the bedroom stuff, Ryan.
Ryan Vos: Again moving
Andrea Flemming`: Yeah.
Ryan Vos: moving.
Jake: It was crazy.
Ryan Vos: Mov moving on to the end, with the question from
Jake: Ryan steer the boat. Golly. You have one job. We're off the rails right now, dude. The pro
Ryan Vos: I can't steer the boat when AJ's putting the rudder down.
AJ: You
Jake: the prop's broke, dude. Fix it. Come on, man. We're out of gas.
Ryan Vos: AJ just put a rudder down. Just unreal. All right. the question from the bunk today. And if you don't, if you've been following along, you know that the question from the bunk is a no-dumb question where we do not judge, we will answer any question that's given to us, no matter how how in-depth it is, or if you know if it maybe you're just new to the industry and you just don't know, and we're here to help you with that. So the question from the bunk today. comes from our email and it says Can two calves from the same bull and same cow, so we're talking a full sib here, turn out completely different or will it be the same?
Andrea Flemming`: Yes, they can.
AJ: Yeah, absolutely.
Jake: AJ
Andrea Flemming`: Genetics can express different days.
Ryan Vos: AJ, can
Jake: Go, AJ.
Ryan Vos: AJ, we have not heard from you much on this episode. So do you want to take this?
AJ: Absolutely, Biggest thing is environmental and I will say environment is probably the biggest Determining factor and how genes are expressed the single biggest So yes, absolutely and you see it all the time in On the seed stock side you see two full sibs and they are Built completely differently shit clones are built completely differently and they've got the exact DNA makeup So yes, they absolutely can be. What are you laughing about, Ryan?
Jake: Ryan, come on, man.
Ryan Vos: Just just going back to a little while ago, just that was just an unreal comment.
Jake: Yeah.
Andrea Flemming`: Just gosh.
AJ: I slid that one in there perfectly, didn't I?
Andrea Flemming`: There's too much testosterone
Ryan Vos: That was that was
Andrea Flemming`: in this freaking podcast.
AJ: Ha ha ha ha.
Jake: Sure.
Ryan Vos: Yeah, and I I want to apologize
Andrea Flemming`: Boys.
Ryan Vos: to Andrea. All right, Andrea.
Jake: Ha ha ha.
Andrea Flemming`: I don't need an apology.
Ryan Vos: before we got going on this podcast, AJ, that was a very good answer. before we got going on this podcast, Andrea made the comment, ooh, that's a great question because I'm gonna find that out this year. So do you wanna explain a little bit about what you were talking about?
Andrea Flemming`: I don't remember actually. I generally
Ryan Vos: You said that you're gonna have a full sib.
Andrea Flemming`: wow. yeah, yeah. I was like, what are we talking about? I have quite a few of the same meetings this year that hit hard that I knew hit hard when I went to breed that I was like, we're gonna do the same thing again and see what happens. And I know that some of them are probably gonna hit hard again. Some of are probably gonna be a flop or not as good, right? So it's just kind of my own experience. I actually looked, there's like twenty five different same exact meetings coming, if they stuck, obviously. yeah, so we'll find out. And some of them are like really nice replacements. So one of them is a bold prospect, one of them is not. So we'll see what happens, sort of thing.
Jake: And I see it, I don't have a ton of those, but I I definitely have some of those full sibs, say twenty twenty five and twenty twenty six or or be previous to that running around and they
Andrea Flemming`: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Jake: definitely do get expressed differently. I mean their genetics as a whole are like beautifully inconsistent, right? Because you're asking all these little markers to go And then mash up. Well, sometimes they're gonna mash up like this, or they might mash up like this, right? It's not an exact replica, animal to animal, how those genes click together and then they also have to be expressed, like to AJ's environmental comment. But
Ryan Vos: That was a really, really good that was very, very good definition to what that is, Jake.
Andrea Flemming`: So good.
Ryan Vos: So I actually have that coming up this year. I have my I have a cow who is one of our best cows, and we mated her last year, and we thought, man, this heifer is really, really, really good. And we're gonna we're gonna keep her for breeding. We're gonna, you know, we're gonna have this back. She, and then when it came time for, you know, breed back, so we were gonna AI again, I was like, this heifer is. was fantastic, is fantastic. We're gonna do this again. So we full sibbed her. Well terminally, I don't want to call it terminally 'cause she's still around, but mature once she turned into a mature cow, she very much had her best days as a young calf. She very much topped out and turned into just a cow. She was not a she was not a rock star in any category. So now I'm a little bit nervous because I have another very flashy one on the ground. Very nice genotype and phenotype animal that's on the ground, she looks perfect, but I'm a little bit worried that she's gonna reach about, that year old and she's just gonna plateau. So we'll see.
Jake: And that's a thing that happens. there's early matures,
Andrea Flemming`: Mm-hmm.
Jake: there's late matures,
AJ: Mm-hmm.
Jake: there's ones that plateau early, there's ones that really don't peak till they're a cow. I have heifers that in the replacement pen as a bred heifer, I'm like, Yeah, she's nice. And then she'll cab as a two year old and she'll be nursing that first calf and I'm like, Holy crap, you turned into a nice cow or opposite.
Andrea Flemming`: It's the same thing with bulls too. Like some bulls at six months look like a freaking bull. The next one looks like the most awkward little potato in the corner. And then they'll flip flop at a yearling or two and you're like, What is happening? That's why everyone's like, Don't cut your bull prospects until they're X amount because you can't judge them right now as teenagers. It's maturity hormones.
Ryan Vos: So A AJ, let's head into what's your beef today. And my beef is AJ because that comment was just from the ropes. But other than that, AJ, what's your beef?
AJ: my beef is the use, the extreme use of low birth weight bulls on cows. Yes, I did.
Ryan Vos: Ooh, we changed it from the notes. Okay.
AJ: I got thinking about this and I cannot, it drives me absolutely bonkers. The amount of low birth weight bulls, cavities bulls that get used and I I know for a fact they get used on mature cows. And I can't blame anybody to an extent But there is no reason to use them on mature cows. You should be able to put a bull on a cow and still sleep at night. There's no reason to go out there and hope for 65 pound dinks that are never gonna turn into anything. Come weaning time, come yearling wait, you name it, they turn into junk cattle for everybody in the entire chain. So that's my beef, quit using them.
Ryan Vos: Okay. Well, that's gonna
Jake: Well said.
Ryan Vos: do it for us. That's gonna do it for us here on the Beyond the Bunk podcast. Thank you guys so much for joining us. Make sure you check us out on socials. Andrea.
Andrea Flemming`: Follow us on the Instagram and Facebook and the TikTok and whatever, YouTube, all of them. It's just Beyond the Bunk or Beyond the Bunk podcast. Come check us out.
Ryan Vos: And remember that you can always send us emails as well to be on the bunk podcast at gmail.com. And we would love to hear show topic ideas from we'd love to hear questions from the bunk and just overall interact with us. So send us a DM, send us an email, however you want to get a hold of us. We appreciate you guys tuning in and we look forward to talking with you guys next week. Andrea, AJ, Jake, you guys have yourselves a fantastic week.