РАСШИФРОВКА 🔗
1
00:00:01,916 --> 00:00:03,919
Okay, Danielle, welcome to Behaviour Speak.
2
00:00:04,312 --> 00:00:05,352
Thank you.
3
00:00:05,790 --> 00:00:07,790
Excited to have you before we get started.
4
00:00:07,790 --> 00:00:17,170
I just want to acknowledge I am producing this podcast on the territories of the Tla'amin,
Klahoose, Homalco, and K'omoks First Nations and as always I'm grateful to be here.
5
00:00:17,370 --> 00:00:24,330
So let's start by learning a little bit about you and kind of how you got into the field,
how you found ABA.
6
00:00:24,330 --> 00:00:26,966
Tell me a little bit about that, your origin story as it were.
7
00:00:27,158 --> 00:00:28,779
Yeah, absolutely.
8
00:00:28,779 --> 00:00:33,678
So I feel like I had a little bit of a funny start jumping into this field.
9
00:00:33,678 --> 00:00:42,155
I actually just had a friend, I was working at a Little Caesars pizza shop making pizzas
and I had a friend reach out to me and they were like, hey, we have this job, there's an
10
00:00:42,155 --> 00:00:44,566
opening, it pays above minimum wage.
11
00:00:44,566 --> 00:00:46,547
And I was like, yes, sign me up.
12
00:00:46,547 --> 00:00:48,428
Like that sounds fantastic.
13
00:00:48,508 --> 00:00:53,771
And I ended up working in a special needs classroom at a school as a paraeducator.
14
00:00:53,771 --> 00:00:57,452
And from there I met my first BCBA.
15
00:00:57,452 --> 00:01:07,159
who really started to come in, would have us do certain things, and I was just in awe of
the behaviour change that I saw and I was like, wow, this stuff really works.
16
00:01:07,159 --> 00:01:08,229
Like, this is amazing.
17
00:01:08,229 --> 00:01:13,623
Like, these kids are doing fantastic and they're having a good time and they're learning
all these skills.
18
00:01:13,723 --> 00:01:14,984
And I was like, what is this?
19
00:01:14,984 --> 00:01:19,187
You know, and so he was like, you should go to school for this.
20
00:01:19,187 --> 00:01:21,909
And so I really just fell in love with it.
21
00:01:21,909 --> 00:01:23,610
I dropped everything.
22
00:01:23,610 --> 00:01:24,871
I went to school for it.
23
00:01:24,871 --> 00:01:27,002
I just started studying it and I really
24
00:01:27,002 --> 00:01:28,953
been doing it ever since.
25
00:01:28,953 --> 00:01:35,959
And so I've kind of gotten a little taste of what this looks like in the school setting,
the clinic setting, the home setting.
26
00:01:35,959 --> 00:01:44,285
So it's been a really fun experience getting to dive right into this field and get to
where I am now.
27
00:01:44,702 --> 00:01:47,044
I hear a lot of folks kind of tell that story.
28
00:01:47,044 --> 00:01:49,726
They work a job for a little bit and suddenly do a master's degree.
29
00:01:49,726 --> 00:01:55,230
How long were you doing the work before you jumped into graduate education?
30
00:01:56,505 --> 00:02:07,783
So I think I worked at that school for about four years and I think I left right when I
started my master's so that I could have a little bit of a more flexible schedule and go
31
00:02:07,783 --> 00:02:09,984
to school and all of that.
32
00:02:10,305 --> 00:02:13,357
yes, but during that time I was finishing up my bachelor's too.
33
00:02:13,357 --> 00:02:18,271
So I was like, I gotta get this done so I can go study all this fun stuff in my master's
program.
34
00:02:18,271 --> 00:02:22,811
So I was in it for a little while prior to graduate studies.
35
00:02:22,811 --> 00:02:23,772
Right on, right on.
36
00:02:23,772 --> 00:02:30,569
So definitely an upgrade from Little Caesar's then, Yeah, right on.
37
00:02:30,569 --> 00:02:41,058
And so we're talking about, this is uh the second, sorry, the third episode in a series
we're doing on behaviour speak on the constructional approach.
38
00:02:41,239 --> 00:02:46,484
And we're gonna be talking a lot about constructional exposure therapy and we'll get into
all that pretty soon.
39
00:02:47,377 --> 00:02:56,665
Tell me about how you discovered the constructional approach and what stood out for you in
the beginning.
40
00:02:57,454 --> 00:03:08,756
Yeah, so my first just kind of exposure to the constructional approach was actually a talk
given by Anna Linnehan and Sheila Klick.
41
00:03:08,756 --> 00:03:13,088
I want like many, many years ago, maybe 2021, I want to say.
42
00:03:13,088 --> 00:03:16,950
And they were giving this presentation on assent at ABAI.
43
00:03:16,950 --> 00:03:25,674
And I remember I had gone to like every assent talk I could find because I felt like this
was such an important topic that our field was really pushing to the forefront of our
44
00:03:25,674 --> 00:03:27,074
conversations.
45
00:03:27,215 --> 00:03:32,117
And the way that they discussed it and the way that they were talking about it clicked for
me.
46
00:03:32,117 --> 00:03:34,558
And I was like, this is what I feel like I've been waiting for.
47
00:03:34,558 --> 00:03:36,239
This makes so much sense.
48
00:03:36,239 --> 00:03:38,793
I feel like I can take this applied
49
00:03:38,793 --> 00:03:46,035
practice right away and use it to really support making our practices better and our
teaching procedures better.
50
00:03:46,035 --> 00:03:50,176
And so that was a big turning point for me.
51
00:03:50,196 --> 00:03:53,527
And then my good friend who I worked with at the time, Dr.
52
00:03:53,527 --> 00:03:57,419
Angela Fuhrmann-Knowles, she began to study under Dr.
53
00:03:57,419 --> 00:03:59,099
Joe Layng who
54
00:03:59,535 --> 00:04:04,175
is one of the core people in the constructional approach.
55
00:04:04,175 --> 00:04:09,075
And so he began teaching her and on the side she was like, oh, I learned this, I learned
this.
56
00:04:09,075 --> 00:04:13,515
And she was kind of teaching me after class and I really just got hooked.
57
00:04:13,515 --> 00:04:17,315
And so I was like, okay, well, I need to go study with Joe as well.
58
00:04:17,575 --> 00:04:24,195
And yeah,
Load full transcript
just have been reading every article that that group has been publishing and
seeing their talks at conferences.
59
00:04:24,195 --> 00:04:27,293
And now I'm very close with a lot of members of that group.
60
00:04:27,293 --> 00:04:28,181
Hmm.
61
00:04:28,340 --> 00:04:38,363
yeah, so I really got hooked from the beginning and I've just been so interested in this
line of research and this orientation towards um behaviour change.
62
00:04:38,363 --> 00:04:38,954
Right on.
63
00:04:38,954 --> 00:04:43,989
And just going back to 2021, you're at ABAI.
64
00:04:43,989 --> 00:04:50,156
What was it, what was happening back then that got you so interested in learning about
Asset?
65
00:04:50,156 --> 00:04:55,872
What was happening in your life and kind of in your work that you were like, I need to
know more about this stuff.
66
00:04:56,674 --> 00:05:07,277
Yeah, I at that time worked, I think it was either in home or in clinic, it was all within
the same company and I was working with...
67
00:05:07,790 --> 00:05:14,113
all children, between like three and maybe eight years old at the time, autistic children.
68
00:05:14,113 --> 00:05:21,897
And so I knew from my master's program that the field was pushing towards a more like
socially valid approach.
69
00:05:21,897 --> 00:05:30,861
And we were constantly as a field just evolving and pushing our science forward and
looking towards more effective and efficient and compassionate procedures.
70
00:05:30,861 --> 00:05:37,387
And I felt like a big piece of that was understanding assent as this, you know, agreeable
71
00:05:37,387 --> 00:05:49,579
response, but also how as the person who's responsible for setting up the environment,
setting it up in a way where someone can genuinely assent to that activity that we're
72
00:05:49,579 --> 00:05:50,660
presenting to them.
73
00:05:50,660 --> 00:05:53,030
And what do we do when they withdraw their assent?
74
00:05:53,030 --> 00:05:55,241
And what do we do when they give their assent?
75
00:05:55,241 --> 00:06:02,892
And I think that that talk specifically gave me so many answers that I had been looking
for that.
76
00:06:02,892 --> 00:06:08,445
Yeah, I was just very appreciative that they took the time to come out to ABAI and share
that with everybody.
77
00:06:08,445 --> 00:06:09,946
Right on, right on.
78
00:06:09,986 --> 00:06:15,677
And so you connect with Angela and then you connect with Dr.
79
00:06:15,677 --> 00:06:20,671
Joe Layng and you're starting to learn a lot more about this constructional approach.
80
00:06:20,671 --> 00:06:26,013
What felt different from the ABA that you had already experienced?
81
00:06:26,786 --> 00:06:30,428
Yeah, I think there's many things that I've noticed.
82
00:06:30,428 --> 00:06:33,629
I mean, it's all based on the same principles of behaviour, right?
83
00:06:33,629 --> 00:06:35,590
Our foundations are the same.
84
00:06:35,590 --> 00:06:48,036
I think it's genuinely just the orientation or the
approach that is taken um that kind of
shifts how we look at behaviour and how we then act towards changing behaviour.
85
00:06:48,036 --> 00:06:53,338
And I think that that small but kind of big shift made a big difference for me.
86
00:06:53,338 --> 00:06:56,720
And I know Awab in one of your previous episodes kind of went
87
00:06:56,720 --> 00:06:58,004
into a deep dive of this.
88
00:06:58,004 --> 00:07:00,933
So I don't want to reiterate everything that he said, but...
89
00:07:00,933 --> 00:07:03,078
um
90
00:07:03,086 --> 00:07:07,449
There was a few key pieces of the construction approach that stuck out most to me.
91
00:07:07,449 --> 00:07:13,093
um One is that they never aim to decelerate behaviour or eliminate behaviour.
92
00:07:13,093 --> 00:07:17,636
They're really looking at what behaviour, the absence of which is the problem.
93
00:07:17,636 --> 00:07:28,814
And then they specify, okay, this is the skill or the repertoire that we're gonna teach
that's gonna allow this person to get all their critical reinforcers at maybe a lesser
94
00:07:28,814 --> 00:07:31,633
cost than what they are getting right now.
95
00:07:31,633 --> 00:07:32,418
Hmm.
96
00:07:33,095 --> 00:07:45,581
I thought that that was amazing and the uh way that they discuss assent is really based
off of Israel Golddiamond teachings back in the 70s and he described it as genuine consent
97
00:07:45,581 --> 00:07:50,603
and kind of laid out this whole foundation um giving more
98
00:07:50,627 --> 00:08:01,333
context around what freedom looks like by accessing multiple alternatives that will get
you your critical consequence and how that has this kind of inverse relationship with
99
00:08:01,333 --> 00:08:02,353
coercion.
100
00:08:02,353 --> 00:08:09,497
And when you're restricted in your alternatives, you're really coerced into responding in
maybe one way to get this thing that you want.
101
00:08:09,497 --> 00:08:11,558
And I was like, man, that makes so much sense.
102
00:08:11,558 --> 00:08:14,420
Like, yeah, it was very interesting to me.
103
00:08:14,420 --> 00:08:18,385
So I, again, I was just hooked from the beginning.
104
00:08:18,385 --> 00:08:20,076
I love that.
105
00:08:20,076 --> 00:08:31,352
Before we get into CET, there's a term you use that Madura used quite a lot in her episode
that I haven't heard before.
106
00:08:31,352 --> 00:08:34,714
We talk a lot about reinforcement and reinforcers and that sort of thing.
107
00:08:34,754 --> 00:08:38,256
But this phrase, critical reinforcer, is new to me.
108
00:08:38,256 --> 00:08:39,237
What's that mean?
109
00:08:39,237 --> 00:08:40,407
What's that about?
110
00:08:40,995 --> 00:08:52,811
So this is also a term that I believe comes from Israel Golddiamond and the critical
reinforce or the critical consequence is going to be the consequence that governs the
111
00:08:52,811 --> 00:08:53,922
contingency.
112
00:08:53,922 --> 00:09:02,866
And so I think another way of saying that
is let's say that you are a young kid that is
really wanting the tablet.
113
00:09:02,878 --> 00:09:07,183
and you're like, my gosh, I really wanna play my tablet, this is my favorite thing.
114
00:09:07,223 --> 00:09:11,809
Well, the critical consequence there is gonna be that tablet.
115
00:09:11,809 --> 00:09:21,019
And so if I set it up to where I'm like, hey, if you complete your math homework, you can
then go play on your tablet, that gives you one way to access what we would call the
116
00:09:21,019 --> 00:09:23,047
critical consequence or your tablet.
117
00:09:23,047 --> 00:09:23,436
Hmm.
118
00:09:23,436 --> 00:09:25,847
And let's say I say, but I'm going to give you a choice.
119
00:09:25,847 --> 00:09:32,870
I'm going to say you can do your math homework and get your tablet or you can do your
English homework and get a cookie.
120
00:09:32,930 --> 00:09:35,942
Now we might think of a cookie as like a positive reinforcer.
121
00:09:35,942 --> 00:09:36,952
This is this great thing.
122
00:09:36,952 --> 00:09:41,094
Kids love cookies, but the critical consequence is not the cookie.
123
00:09:41,094 --> 00:09:45,256
The critical consequence is the tablet because that's what they want in that moment.
124
00:09:45,256 --> 00:09:47,457
They are working to get the tablet.
125
00:09:47,457 --> 00:09:49,301
And so I think in
126
00:09:49,301 --> 00:09:58,653
when we start talking about creating alternatives that are going to access that critical
consequence, we're talking about alternatives that are going to all lead to that
127
00:09:58,653 --> 00:09:59,227
Mmm.
128
00:09:59,227 --> 00:10:01,588
that desired outcome of the tablet.
129
00:10:01,588 --> 00:10:11,893
So a true alternative, uh what we might call like a degree of freedom, would be you can do
your math homework to get the tablet, you can do your English homework to get the tablet,
130
00:10:11,893 --> 00:10:20,777
you can do your chores to get the tablet, because those are all going to access you your
critical consequence, which is what you're actually looking for.
131
00:10:20,777 --> 00:10:26,659
And I think that's that slight distinction between just any reinforcer or any consequence.
132
00:10:26,659 --> 00:10:28,760
But we're really talking about the consequence
133
00:10:28,760 --> 00:10:30,875
that governs the contingency.
134
00:10:31,026 --> 00:10:31,747
Interesting.
135
00:10:31,747 --> 00:10:32,647
Okay.
136
00:10:33,629 --> 00:10:37,314
Let's get into CET, Constructural Exposure Therapy.
137
00:10:37,314 --> 00:10:38,625
Kind of start simple.
138
00:10:38,625 --> 00:10:42,421
What is Constructural Exposure Therapy in plain language?
139
00:10:42,946 --> 00:10:44,836
Yes, I think that's a great question.
140
00:10:44,836 --> 00:10:46,720
um
141
00:10:46,720 --> 00:10:57,115
Constructional exposure therapy really is an intervention that is used in contexts that
typically evoke really fearful or maybe aggressive behaviors.
142
00:10:57,115 -->
00:11:03,398
Behaviors that someone engages in to get distance or escape from some aversive thing in
the environment.
143
00:11:03,438 --> 00:11:13,302
And so CET or Constructional Exposure Therapy is used to uh teach the behaviour, the
absence of which is the problem.
144
00:11:13,302 --> 00:11:16,664
So said another way, we're going to go in during the assessment
145
00:11:16,664 --> 00:11:29,653
phase of CET and figure out, okay, what skill or behaviour is needed in this specific
context that's going to allow you to get that same critical consequence, but at a much
146
00:11:29,653 --> 00:11:34,726
lesser cost than maybe these fearful or aggressive behaviors are costing you.
147
00:11:34,726 --> 00:11:39,369
Because I think we all know that uh those types of behaviors can be really costly.
148
00:11:39,369 --> 00:11:46,857
They can cost us relationships, they can cost us access to things like education or even
medical care.
149
00:11:46,857 --> 00:11:53,302
So those types of responses, while very rational and make a lot of sense, can be really
costly to the person.
150
00:11:53,302 --> 00:12:02,908
And so CET is really used to help teach a skill that's going to, again, get that same
critical consequence, but without all those associated costs.
151
00:12:03,169 --> 00:12:08,193
And so what it looks like is we will kind of map out an interconnected chain.
152
00:12:08,193 --> 00:12:12,866
And so an interconnected behaviour chain consists of the behaviour of two different
organisms.
153
00:12:12,866 --> 00:12:15,830
So really like the implementer and the learner.
154
00:12:15,830 --> 00:12:22,418
in which the behaviour of one individual will serve as both the consequence and the SD for
the behaviour of the other.
155
00:12:22,418 --> 00:12:33,762
So it's really like this back and forth interaction that is going to just be mapped out of
whatever that skill is we determined is the most ecologically relevant response that is
156
00:12:33,762 --> 00:12:35,150
gonna support that learner.
157
00:12:35,150 --> 00:12:39,295
and again getting that critical consequence at a lesser cost.
158
00:12:39,336 --> 00:12:45,124
And the way that we teach that skill within CET is through shaping with negative
reinforcement.
159
00:12:45,124 --> 00:12:52,673
And this is something that I found so profound when I was first learning about CET is
160
00:12:53,420 --> 00:13:04,999
the consequence that negative reinforcement contingency or that escape or distance from
that aversive thing that's already maintaining all these behaviors, the uh fearful
161
00:13:04,999 --> 00:13:15,428
behaviors, the aggressive behaviors, that same consequence is now used to shape up this
new response that is going to allow this person to more successfully navigate this
162
00:13:15,428 --> 00:13:17,429
environment at a lesser cost.
163
00:13:17,429 --> 00:13:18,470
And so,
164
00:13:19,040 --> 00:13:25,212
In a nutshell, feel like that was a long explanation, but that is what CET is.
165
00:13:25,212 --> 00:13:31,493
And that escape or that distance from the aversive thing is always made available in
multiple different ways.
166
00:13:31,493 --> 00:13:42,466
So we are making it available not only for that fearful behaviour or the aggressive
behaviour, but we're also making it available for meeting that criteria along that shaping
167
00:13:42,466 --> 00:13:43,497
procedure.
168
00:13:43,497 --> 00:13:48,978
And we'll shape along that interconnected chain to help develop that new skill.
169
00:13:49,038 --> 00:13:58,345
And that seems to be a key point in CET and constructional approaches in general is that
there's multiple pathways to that critical reinforcer.
170
00:13:58,765 --> 00:14:06,639
Yeah, and I think that's how how Linnehan and colleagues will talk about genuine assent,
that there's multiple ways to access that critical consequence.
171
00:14:06,639 --> 00:14:16,724
And that's how we can truly start assessing whether someone is agreeing to that activity
or not, because they have other alternatives, but they're choosing this one.
172
00:14:16,724 --> 00:14:21,626
And so I think that's where we start to incorporate some of those teachings into this
procedure.
173
00:14:21,681 --> 00:14:23,332
Yeah, I'm looking forward to learning more about that.
174
00:14:23,332 --> 00:14:25,623
actually have Angela Fuhrmann-Knowles coming on.
175
00:14:25,623 --> 00:14:30,426
uh I actually participated in her current study.
176
00:14:30,426 --> 00:14:39,151
uh And it was the first time I've heard sort of genuine versus apparent assent and genuine
versus apparent consent.
177
00:14:39,151 --> 00:14:40,692
And then, of course, the idea of compulsion.
178
00:14:40,692 --> 00:14:42,933
uh Really fascinating areas.
179
00:14:42,933 --> 00:14:46,015
uh And I'm looking forward to kind of digging more into that with her.
180
00:14:46,015 --> 00:14:47,216
Really cool.
181
00:14:48,077 --> 00:14:48,877
So.
182
00:14:51,983 --> 00:14:53,322
Exposure therapy is not new.
183
00:14:53,322 --> 00:14:56,275
Why isn't traditional exposure therapy enough?
184
00:14:57,356 --> 00:15:00,287
Well, I don't know if I would say it's not enough.
185
00:15:00,287 --> 00:15:09,131
I think there's a long line of research on gold standard procedures like systematic
desensitization, graduated exposure, things like that.
186
00:15:09,332 --> 00:15:19,616
And those procedures have been very effective in supporting people with very fearful
behaviors for many, many years now.
187
00:15:19,616 --> 00:15:25,439
And so I wouldn't say that this is a better approach or anything like that.
188
00:15:25,439 --> 00:15:27,310
What I would say is this is an alternative
189
00:15:27,310 --> 00:15:28,763
to those approaches.
190
00:15:28,763 --> 00:15:37,160
And one of the reasons that I have liked this approach more when actually working and
implementing it is that
191
00:15:38,547 --> 00:15:48,952
The amount of distress that's
caused when we're working on these, honestly, very
distressing behaviors is because we always have the option to opt out, because we always
192
00:15:48,952 --> 00:15:53,774
have the option to get that escape or distance in multiple different ways.
193
00:15:53,794 --> 00:16:00,737
We never require the person to kind of get to a certain point to get out of what's
happening.
194
00:16:00,737 --> 00:16:05,579
And so that really keeps things at a very calm level while we are teaching these skills.
195
00:16:05,579 --> 00:16:07,790
And I think that I just appreciate the
196
00:16:07,790 --> 00:16:10,302
lack of distress while we're teaching these things.
197
00:16:10,302 --> 00:16:16,565
um And it's just something that we are constantly trying to research and refine.
198
00:16:16,565 --> 00:16:19,928
um you know, I think that that's science in general.
199
00:16:19,928 --> 00:16:26,232
We're always trying to evolve and learn more, try to create more effective and efficient
procedures.
200
00:16:26,232 --> 00:16:30,174
And I think that's one of the things we're doing with this procedure.
201
00:16:30,270 --> 00:16:37,254
And now know you're a doctoral student and an academic and learning a lot about these
things.
202
00:16:37,254 --> 00:16:46,222
I think in some ways, because of the work you're doing and being collegial and all that,
you can't say things like this is better or this is worse.
203
00:16:46,222 --> 00:16:47,803
And you want to avoid terms like that.
204
00:16:47,803 --> 00:16:56,389
But I really don't know how a procedure that results in way less distress than another
procedure isn't better.
205
00:16:56,789 --> 00:17:07,527
And so, you know, I think it will be interesting down the road to see if there's more
comparisons and more measures around sort of levels of distress.
206
00:17:07,527 --> 00:17:18,165
And I'm actually curious, and I don't want to tangent too far, but I'd be curious to know
if in traditional exposure therapy and graduated exposure therapy, because I think this is
207
00:17:18,165 --> 00:17:24,469
something that uh I'm digressing probably too much here, that
208
00:17:24,527 --> 00:17:37,449
In our field, we've talked a lot about social validity, uh maybe not have, but recognize
that we haven't done a great job over the years of making that an important part of all of
209
00:17:37,449 --> 00:17:47,739
our studies uh and looking at some of the, you know, from some of the criticisms of our
field around some of maybe the negative side effects of some of the things we do.
210
00:17:47,739 --> 00:17:50,101
uh
211
00:17:50,411 --> 00:17:58,959
I wonder if there has even been that kind of work to sort of look at levels of stress
during exposure therapy and whatnot and kind of how that might be compared.
212
00:17:58,959 --> 00:18:00,692
Have you seen anything like that or?
213
00:18:01,580 --> 00:18:13,315
I do know that there is some research out there that speaks to um participants dropping
out of studies that we can insinuate, maybe because of distress, maybe because of other
214
00:18:13,315 --> 00:18:13,666
things.
215
00:18:13,666 --> 00:18:16,597
I think people drop out of studies for a variety of reasons.
216
00:18:16,597 --> 00:18:28,243
um I know Awab and Jillian Baldwin and Justin Leaf put out a systematic literature review
that was looking at exposure therapies.
217
00:18:28,243 --> 00:18:31,207
I want to say that came out in 2023,
218
00:18:31,207 --> 00:18:31,844
Okay.
219
00:18:31,844 --> 00:18:38,310
they speak to a lot of those things that across the literature, what trends we're starting
to see.
220
00:18:38,310 --> 00:18:45,797
And that has been a basis of where we're trying to shift things when we're working on
constructional exposure therapy.
221
00:18:45,797 --> 00:18:51,149
I apologize I don't have all the statistics memorized, but it's a great resource to look
at.
222
00:18:51,149 --> 00:18:51,869
No, very good.
223
00:18:51,869 --> 00:18:54,609
Yeah, and we'll link to that article in the show notes.
224
00:18:54,609 --> 00:18:56,049
That's great suggestion.
225
00:18:58,289 --> 00:19:07,149
Maybe we can talk about that a little bit more in terms of how CET differs from systematic
desensitization.
226
00:19:07,149 --> 00:19:08,589
Can you tell me a little bit about that?
227
00:19:09,058 --> 00:19:12,940
Yeah, I think in general there's some differences.
228
00:19:12,940 --> 00:19:23,485
I think it's easy to pull out maybe one or two examples because the literature base for
systematic desensitization and graduated exposure is so large that there's all these
229
00:19:23,485 --> 00:19:29,147
different variations of the procedures and the outcomes.
230
00:19:29,147 --> 00:19:34,710
so I might say, you know, here's some general differences and you might be able to pull an
article that's like, no, they did this.
231
00:19:34,710 --> 00:19:38,995
um But I think the general procedures for things
232
00:19:38,995 --> 00:19:43,607
like systematic desensitization are they will
233
00:19:43,607 --> 00:19:45,748
teach first a relaxation technique.
234
00:19:45,748 --> 00:19:49,129
So they'll be like, here's what you can do to help relax.
235
00:19:49,129 --> 00:19:51,040
And then they create a fear hierarchy.
236
00:19:51,040 --> 00:19:59,334
And so they work in collaboration with the client to basically create a hierarchy of
here's the least fearful thing, here's the most fearful thing.
237
00:19:59,334 --> 00:20:02,275
Now let's build every step in between.
238
00:20:02,275 --> 00:20:10,139
And then the exposure piece of it, whether that's in vivo exposure or images or
imagination, whatever it may be.
239
00:20:10,139 --> 00:20:13,761
And they work their way up from the least fearful thing all the way to
240
00:20:13,761 --> 00:20:18,998
the most fearful thing while prompting them to use those relaxation techniques.
241
00:20:18,998 --> 00:20:20,582
oh
242
00:20:20,960 --> 00:20:25,053
whenever
things start to escalate during those exposures.
243
00:20:25,053 --> 00:20:36,450
And so I think the intention in systematic desensitization is to try and avoid distress as
you are progressing and to make small enough steps that you are not producing distress in
244
00:20:36,450 --> 00:20:39,682
the client as you are working on these things.
245
00:20:39,682 --> 00:20:45,926
But I think some of the differences in constructional exposure therapy are, uh
246
00:20:46,170 --> 00:20:51,633
One, we're not necessarily just trying to eliminate the fear or the aggression.
247
00:20:51,633 --> 00:20:54,894
Our goal is never to reduce behaviour or eliminate behaviour.
248
00:20:54,894 --> 00:21:06,420
Our goal really is to specify what behaviour, the absence of which is the problem, what
behaviour is going to produce that critical consequence at a lesser cost and how can we
249
00:21:06,420 --> 00:21:11,682
then teach that skill, strengthen that skill, or transfer that skill to this context.
250
00:21:11,762 --> 00:21:16,054
And in the procedure that we used to teach it, we're also
251
00:21:16,054 --> 00:21:24,732
breaking it down into small steps which is what shaping essentially is, but we are
providing that distance and escape in multiple ways.
252
00:21:24,732 --> 00:21:31,969
And I think that that's another key difference too is typically in systematic
desensitization you're going to continue to progress forward through the procedure if
253
00:21:31,969 --> 00:21:40,246
they're calm, but us if you are engaging in that skill that we're trying to teach and you
are not in distress we're still going to remove.
254
00:21:40,367 --> 00:21:47,311
uh that aversive item, we're still going to provide that distance as the reinforcer for
you engaging in that skill set.
255
00:21:47,311 --> 00:21:52,133
And so I think those are two big differences that I have noticed.
256
00:21:52,133 --> 00:21:57,066
And again, some procedures may use those, but I think the majority don't.
257
00:21:57,066 --> 00:22:00,601
And so that's some of the differences that I'm seeing in these procedures.
258
00:22:00,601 --> 00:22:02,282
Mm-hmm.
259
00:22:02,442 --> 00:22:03,683
No, I like that.
260
00:22:04,304 --> 00:22:18,604
And I like that distinction of, with desensitization, there's that, like you said, that
fear hierarchy and just sort of, you know, I imagine the uh sort of the, I think about
261
00:22:18,604 --> 00:22:28,881
examples like people like fear of snakes and fear of dogs and starts with photos and
eventually it's, you know, videos and eventually it's, you know.
262
00:22:29,393 --> 00:22:32,174
the dog in the kennel and then the dog getting closer and closer.
263
00:22:32,174 --> 00:22:40,657
um And in the end, it's someone standing in front of this dog that's growling away and
doing really scary things.
264
00:22:41,038 --> 00:22:48,301
Whereas exposure therapy is, or CET is sort of saying...
265
00:22:51,089 --> 00:22:53,321
What's the long-term goal here?
266
00:22:53,321 --> 00:22:55,332
And what sort of skill?
267
00:22:55,533 --> 00:23:09,795
The skill isn't to be able to approach incredibly violent dogs and stand there and uh
engage in relaxation, in sort of relaxation or whatever, behavioral relaxation therapy or
268
00:23:09,795 --> 00:23:10,685
whatever.
269
00:23:11,286 --> 00:23:12,467
The goal might be to...
270
00:23:12,467 --> 00:23:14,869
um
271
00:23:15,473 --> 00:23:29,694
you know, be able to walk past the dog and, you know, safely or I suppose in that
particular context, we might be using CET also on the dog so that we can get the dog to
272
00:23:29,694 --> 00:23:31,044
chill out a bit too.
273
00:23:31,045 --> 00:23:35,247
But it's not just about exposure to fear, exposure to fear.
274
00:23:35,981 --> 00:23:38,852
Yeah, and I think that is such a good point, Ben.
275
00:23:38,852 --> 00:23:46,296
Really the emphasis is we are teaching and shaping along that terminal goal we have for
them.
276
00:23:46,296 --> 00:23:58,161
So in the example with dogs, let's say we're just scared of even just very calm, nice
dogs, and we kind of do everything we can to get distance and get away from any dog.
277
00:23:58,161 --> 00:24:04,343
Well, the skill set might be, I want to be able to go to my friend's house that has a dog
and play games with them.
278
00:24:04,343 --> 00:24:05,984
And so in order to do that, I have
279
00:24:05,984 --> 00:24:11,787
to be able to walk past the dog and sit down at the table and play board games with my
friends.
280
00:24:11,787 --> 00:24:20,551
Well, we would teach along that specific skill, the walking past, right, slowly
approaching and then slowly passing the dog.
281
00:24:20,551 --> 00:24:22,632
And we would teach along that skill.
282
00:24:22,632 --> 00:24:33,607
Now, I think that that also might be a distinction when we're looking at systematic
desensitization, where our procedure and our shaping procedure has to do with that
283
00:24:33,607 --> 00:24:35,918
specific repertoire, where
284
00:24:35,918 --> 00:24:41,303
uh A lot of the time, because systematic desensitization, the goal is just to eliminate
the fear.
285
00:24:41,303 --> 00:24:51,861
We will go through things like imagining or using images or things like this that don't
necessarily connect to the actual skill set of I'm going to engage in these movements to
286
00:24:51,861 --> 00:24:55,074
produce this outcome in this context.
287
00:24:55,074 --> 00:24:59,757
And so that's another just slight difference between these procedures.
288
00:25:00,117 --> 00:25:01,100
Right on.
289
00:25:01,915 --> 00:25:04,546
Earlier referenced shaping with negative reinforcement.
290
00:25:04,546 --> 00:25:15,432
This was a concept I first heard from Awab at the last Endicott conference, which it uh
was a completely new concept to me.
291
00:25:15,432 --> 00:25:19,915
And I think in some ways when he was introduced to it, it was new to him as well.
292
00:25:20,895 --> 00:25:30,110
What does shaping with negative reinforcement, you've touched on it already, but really
mean and sort of how does it differ from coercion and escape extinction and things like
293
00:25:30,110 --> 00:25:30,861
that?
294
00:25:31,375 --> 00:25:31,835
Sure.
295
00:25:31,835 --> 00:25:33,815
So I...
296
00:25:33,815 --> 00:25:37,677
I a lot of behaviour analysts use shaping quite regularly, right?
297
00:25:37,677 --> 00:25:44,840
And we use shaping by reinforcing successive approximations towards some terminal goal.
298
00:25:45,000 --> 00:25:53,604
And the way that that usually works is I'm gonna take one small step that's closer to this
goal and maybe I get like an M And then I take another step closer to this goal and I get
299
00:25:53,604 --> 00:25:54,324
an right?
300
00:25:54,324 --> 00:25:56,265
Whatever that skillset may be.
301
00:25:56,425 --> 00:26:01,547
And in that context, that is gonna function as a positive reinforcer.
302
00:26:01,567 --> 00:26:03,848
Now, the only difference when we're talking about shaping
303
00:26:03,848 --> 00:26:15,515
with negative reinforcement is we're still taking those small approximations, those small
steps towards this terminal goal, but instead of providing an &M, we're removing whatever
304
00:26:15,515 --> 00:26:22,859
aversive stimulus is in the environment and that is going to function as the reinforcer
for those approximations.
305
00:26:22,859 --> 00:26:28,102
And so the only slight difference there is essentially the reinforcer.
306
00:26:29,068 --> 00:26:36,929
And I think that the differences between things like escape extinction or um those types
of things is...
307
00:26:37,070 --> 00:26:39,591
uh That would still be dependent on the procedure.
308
00:26:39,591 --> 00:26:42,783
So again with CET, we never would use extinction.
309
00:26:42,783 --> 00:26:48,035
We never would withhold the consequence of being able to escape or avoid this aversive
thing.
310
00:26:48,035 --> 00:26:51,317
What we are doing is making that available in multiple ways.
311
00:26:51,317 --> 00:26:55,809
Because I think if someone is choosing to opt out, if they're like, nope, I can't do this.
312
00:26:55,809 --> 00:26:56,594
I'm going to step away.
313
00:26:56,594 --> 00:27:00,281
I'm going to get that distance and not meet this current shaping step.
314
00:27:00,281 --> 00:27:06,384
That's just information to the implementer of like, okay, I just need to change my
procedure.
315
00:27:06,384 --> 00:27:07,064
I need to
316
00:27:07,064 --> 00:27:15,334
adjust it in a way that's going to allow this person to be successful in this context and
that might mean I need to adjust some things and I think that that's okay.
317
00:27:15,334 --> 00:27:22,282
I think those opt-out responses can be really informative and I'm not trying to get you to
opt out less.
318
00:27:22,282 --> 00:27:26,226
I'm trying to understand why you're opting out and then change the environment.
319
00:27:26,561 --> 00:27:40,321
And I think this may be hard for behaviour analysts to sort of grasp, I think, as being a
good thing to do.
320
00:27:40,321 --> 00:27:48,801
And I think also it might be tough for parents as well, because we often hear the sort of,
I don't know if there's any evidence behind it.
321
00:27:48,801 --> 00:27:55,781
I think it's a bit of a myth, but we hear this idea that if we reinforce
322
00:27:56,722 --> 00:28:01,587
problem behaviour in some way in our intervention, then we're gonna make things worse.
323
00:28:01,587 --> 00:28:13,498
And so if we allow the individual to escape when they engage in interfering behaviour or
distressing behaviour, we're reinforcing the interfering or distressing behaviour and
324
00:28:13,498 --> 00:28:16,521
therefore, and isn't that a bad thing?
325
00:28:16,521 --> 00:28:20,084
What do you kind of say to folks when they have that argument?
326
00:28:20,914 --> 00:28:23,296
I think it's a really fair concern.
327
00:28:23,296 --> 00:28:24,745
I've definitely heard that before.
328
00:28:24,745 --> 00:28:27,979
I've definitely had conversations around that before.
329
00:28:28,219 --> 00:28:34,504
And I think I would share that same concern if we stopped with, okay, they opted out.
330
00:28:34,504 --> 00:28:36,506
I'm never doing this again.
331
00:28:36,506 --> 00:28:38,367
Because I don't think that that's so helpful.
332
00:28:38,367 --> 00:28:46,513
If we've already determined that this skill is so important to work on, that it's gonna
benefit this person's life, that they're in collaboration, they're on board, it's just
333
00:28:46,513 --> 00:28:46,993
tough.
334
00:28:46,993 --> 00:28:48,774
uh
335
00:28:49,224 --> 00:28:51,876
I would agree if we stopped at that point.
336
00:28:51,876 --> 00:28:53,897
I don't think that that would be helpful.
337
00:28:53,897 --> 00:29:04,192
But what I am talking about in this procedure, and I think the way that we tend to discuss
this within the constructional approach is if someone is opting out, if they're
338
00:29:04,192 --> 00:29:10,015
withdrawing their assent, uh yes, we stop it in that moment because that's the most
compassionate thing to do.
339
00:29:10,015 --> 00:29:11,426
I'm not going to push you through it.
340
00:29:11,426 --> 00:29:16,689
I'm not going to force you to escalate for me to then still give you that same
consequence.
341
00:29:16,689 --> 00:29:18,914
I'm going to honor what you're telling me.
342
00:29:18,914 --> 00:29:26,518
But then I'm going to use that information to change my procedure to make it so that you
do want to opt in.
343
00:29:26,518 --> 00:29:28,518
I can adjust things in the activity.
344
00:29:28,518 --> 00:29:37,663
I can adjust things in a way that are going to allow you to agree to participate in a way
that's not coerced because you always have the option to still opt out.
345
00:29:37,663 --> 00:29:43,946
But I can keep making things better for
you so that we're teaching in a context where you
can truly learn.
346
00:29:43,946 --> 00:29:48,901
And I think that that once we are seeing that occur in action,
347
00:29:48,901 --> 00:29:53,527
and we are understanding that opting out doesn't mean we're done teaching.
348
00:29:53,527 --> 00:29:59,093
It means we're just giving them a break for a moment and we're working together to make
changes that are necessary.
349
00:29:59,294 --> 00:30:05,321
That kind of concern that people have tends to fade away.
350
00:30:08,224 --> 00:30:09,274
Let's get some examples.
351
00:30:09,274 --> 00:30:13,948
Let's hear a little bit about uh what this all looks like in practice.
352
00:30:14,449 --> 00:30:21,435
A lot of folks listening are familiar with uh one of your cases, the nail clipping case.
353
00:30:21,876 --> 00:30:25,840
It came up at the Innecon conference.
354
00:30:25,840 --> 00:30:27,580
A lot of folks talking about it.
355
00:30:27,721 --> 00:30:28,303
I think...
356
00:30:28,303 --> 00:30:35,377
everybody I've interviewed so far about the constructional approach references Danielle's
nail clipping case and how interesting that is.
357
00:30:35,377 --> 00:30:41,751
And through that, in some ways, we've all talked about that case in a variety of different
ways.
358
00:30:41,751 --> 00:30:44,303
So I wouldn't mind getting into some other examples.
359
00:30:44,423 --> 00:30:53,368
Maybe you start us with any one that comes to mind and walk us through what this approach
looks like from the beginning.
360
00:30:53,942 --> 00:31:06,594
Yeah, so I think another one that I tend to present on is a blood draw that I have
supported learners with, and I think that this is a good example because with nail
361
00:31:06,594 --> 00:31:10,341
clipping, there's no painful end to it.
362
00:31:10,341 --> 00:31:11,195
Mm-hmm.
363
00:31:11,195 --> 00:31:14,057
don't know about you, I don't enjoy getting my blood drawn.
364
00:31:14,057 --> 00:31:20,982
uh It is painful, they are sticking with a needle, I still get a little nervous when
going.
365
00:31:20,982 --> 00:31:32,391
So I think that this approach is not just useful for things that have ah maybe an easier
ending, but also for things that can be painful or uncomfortable or things like that.
366
00:31:32,391 --> 00:31:35,353
And we can still support individuals.
367
00:31:35,937 --> 00:31:47,229
engaging in those types of activities that are really tough and are uncomfortable and
still teach them to participate in a way that's not going to be coercive or distressing.
368
00:31:47,229 --> 00:31:48,067
Hmm.
369
00:31:48,067 --> 00:31:57,251
So, yeah, I had a learner, I want to say they were about 11 years old when their parent
came to me saying, you know, we need to get this blood drawn.
370
00:31:57,251 --> 00:31:59,592
The doctor has been requesting it.
371
00:31:59,592 --> 00:32:03,093
We've tried a few times and we haven't been successful.
372
00:32:03,093 --> 00:32:06,835
You know, as soon as we get there, we don't want to go in the building.
373
00:32:06,835 --> 00:32:10,756
Once we're in the building, it's a whole fight to get out of the room.
374
00:32:10,756 --> 00:32:15,138
And the nurses and the phlebotomists are just unable to safely
375
00:32:15,512 --> 00:32:16,603
get the blood draw.
376
00:32:16,603 --> 00:32:25,870
And I was like, okay, so this is where I reviewed the procedures of constructional
exposure therapy with them and I got their consent.
377
00:32:25,971 --> 00:32:30,084
And this is a learner who has a decent amount of language.
378
00:32:30,084 --> 00:32:37,541
There's still some things that I think needed to be shown rather than explained to make
sure they knew what they were agreeing to and things like that.
379
00:32:37,541 --> 00:32:39,106
um
380
00:32:39,106 --> 00:32:43,560
But what we did is we gathered common materials that are used for a blood draw.
381
00:32:43,560 --> 00:32:46,692
So I was decked out in scrubs.
382
00:32:46,692 --> 00:32:55,860
I had a tourniquet and we had a syringe that looks very similar to the ones that are used
at the doctor's office.
383
00:32:55,860 --> 00:32:57,722
We had alcohol swabs and band-aids.
384
00:32:57,722 --> 00:33:03,306
We had a lot of the common stimuli that are used in this medical procedure.
385
00:33:03,306 --> 00:33:05,668
And we brought that to the learner's house.
386
00:33:05,668 --> 00:33:07,489
And we first just taught them
387
00:33:08,088 --> 00:33:09,319
how this works.
388
00:33:09,319 --> 00:33:11,820
You can ask at any point for a break.
389
00:33:11,820 --> 00:33:13,180
We're gonna honor that.
390
00:33:13,180 --> 00:33:15,271
get distance from these materials.
391
00:33:15,271 --> 00:33:16,741
You can walk away, no problem.
392
00:33:16,741 --> 00:33:21,643
um If you show us any indications of distress, we're done.
393
00:33:21,643 --> 00:33:22,524
We're gonna stop.
394
00:33:22,524 --> 00:33:25,205
We're gonna take everything off and you're gonna get to walk away.
395
00:33:25,205 --> 00:33:30,727
um Or if you meet our current goal, we're gonna take everything off and you get to walk
away.
396
00:33:30,727 --> 00:33:35,169
And so in this instance, there was three different ways to get that distance or escape.
397
00:33:35,169 --> 00:33:37,390
And so that was known ahead of time.
398
00:33:37,811 --> 00:33:40,762
And what we did is we built that interconnected chain.
399
00:33:40,762 --> 00:33:42,852
So we planned this out from the beginning.
400
00:33:42,852 --> 00:33:45,273
What skill do we need to teach him?
401
00:33:45,273 --> 00:33:47,274
That absence of which is the problem.
402
00:33:47,274 --> 00:33:57,646
And so what was needed in this context was to be able to walk into the doctor's office, go
in, sit down, put your arm out and hold it still for quite a long period of time.
403
00:33:57,646 --> 00:34:00,637
Like it takes a minute to actually get that all done.
404
00:34:00,811 --> 00:34:03,778
And so we're like, OK, these are the skills that are needed.
405
00:34:04,202 --> 00:34:07,765
and for our shaping procedure we started from the beginning of that.
406
00:34:07,765 --> 00:34:12,797
So we started just with walking over with some of the materials visible on the table.
407
00:34:12,797 --> 00:34:13,358
Hmm.
408
00:34:13,358 --> 00:34:17,198
He came, he sat down, we were like, great job, get out of here.
409
00:34:17,198 --> 00:34:19,658
Like, let's go, let's go take a break.
410
00:34:19,658 --> 00:34:25,558
And so each step we would add one step of the blood draw routine.
411
00:34:25,558 --> 00:34:28,798
So next he would come over and we'd ask him to put his arm out.
412
00:34:28,798 --> 00:34:34,718
The next step we'd have him come over, put his arm out, roll his sleeve up, and maybe we
would put the tourniquet on.
413
00:34:34,718 --> 00:34:36,378
And that was a tough one.
414
00:34:36,378 --> 00:34:43,362
And so we had to start with maybe draping it over his arm at first, then loosely tying it,
then actually tying it at the tightness
415
00:34:43,362 --> 00:34:46,275
that they would need to do for the procedure.
416
00:34:46,476 --> 00:34:55,848
We then the next time he came over would add in the alcohol swab and we got to the point
where he would meet each step.
417
00:34:55,848 --> 00:35:01,041
he would get that distance, we'd give him about a two minute break, and then we would come
back to the table again.
418
00:35:01,041 --> 00:35:06,343
And so he is willingly walking up to the table, sitting down, putting his arm out.
419
00:35:06,443 --> 00:35:12,406
And the amount of distress that we were seeing was was minimal.
420
00:35:12,406 --> 00:35:16,618
Prior to this, when we had just done our baseline trials, he would come sit down.
421
00:35:16,618 --> 00:35:20,670
As soon as he saw the materials, he like jumped up out of a seat and was like, this is a
blood draw?
422
00:35:20,670 --> 00:35:21,510
No.
423
00:35:21,510 --> 00:35:23,651
And started to move away.
424
00:35:23,651 --> 00:35:25,132
And now he's coming over.
425
00:35:25,132 --> 00:35:25,802
sitting down.
426
00:35:25,802 --> 00:35:27,532
he's putting his arm out.
427
00:35:28,113 --> 00:35:36,815
And so we were able to get through the whole setup and then we got to the point where we
actually wanted to introduce the syringe um into the routine.
428
00:35:36,815 --> 00:35:47,598
And so we had started with an empty syringe where there was no cap and no needle in there
and he did pretty good with that and then we added the cap and that was a little
429
00:35:48,003 --> 00:35:48,633
That was a lot.
430
00:35:48,633 --> 00:35:55,126
So we had to take a step back and we increased the duration that we were doing with an
empty syringe first.
431
00:35:55,166 --> 00:36:02,289
Then we were able to add the cap back in because he got a little bit more used to the
syringe being present and touching his skin.
432
00:36:02,469 -->
00:36:08,392
Then we were able to add the needle in and we would just do a touch for one second and
provide that break.
433
00:36:08,392 --> 00:36:12,914
And then we do a touch for two seconds and we'd provide that break and then three seconds.
434
00:36:12,914 --> 00:36:17,936
And we kind of worked our way up until we got to the point where he was
435
00:36:17,936 --> 00:36:20,516
rocking over to the table, putting his arm out.
436
00:36:20,516 --> 00:36:23,096
We got to do the tourniquet, the alcohol swab.
437
00:36:23,096 --> 00:36:25,776
We held the syringe with the needle on his skin.
438
00:36:25,776 --> 00:36:27,416
Now we weren't piercing the skin at home.
439
00:36:27,416 --> 00:36:31,076
This is not our area of expertise, but he could still feel it.
440
00:36:31,076 --> 00:36:33,736
Like that feeling and that sensation is still there.
441
00:36:33,736 --> 00:36:44,816
And we were able to do that between 30 and 60 seconds across multiple trials before his
mom then took him back to the doctor's office and he was successfully able to get an
442
00:36:44,816 --> 00:36:46,036
actual blood draw.
443
00:36:46,036 --> 00:36:47,856
And what was really cool is
444
00:36:47,856 --> 00:36:51,256
Mom did it, I want to say like 200 days later.
445
00:36:51,256 --> 00:37:01,703
Like he needed a follow-up blood draw and without any additional practice or without any
follow-ups, he again went back and had a completely successful blood draw.
446
00:37:01,703 --> 00:37:02,419
Hmm.
447
00:37:03,322 --> 00:37:06,988
I think in total that took about six hours.
448
00:37:06,988 --> 00:37:18,644
It was a little under two hours of actual shaping steps and most of that time was just the
breaks in between where we were removing the stimuli and giving him some time away from
449
00:37:18,644 --> 00:37:19,324
it.
450
00:37:19,995 --> 00:37:25,128
And so that six hours, is that one day?
451
00:37:25,858 --> 00:37:28,445
We broke this up over four days.
452
00:37:28,445 --> 00:37:30,305
Four days, okay.
453
00:37:30,845 --> 00:37:31,845
Amazing.
454
00:37:32,365 --> 00:37:39,005
And so you get them to the point of accepting the needle tap.
455
00:37:39,265 --> 00:37:48,205
And then there was, because I think I'm thinking about sort of that fear exposure
hierarchy we talked about with sort of traditional exposure therapy.
456
00:37:51,186 --> 00:37:58,194
Initially, you couldn't even get him through the doors of the clinic uh before he sort of
ran away in bulk.
457
00:37:58,315 --> 00:38:03,861
Did you have to do any exposure in the actual clinic setting or did mom just take him?
458
00:38:03,861 --> 00:38:07,675
walked in, no problem, and blood draw happened?
459
00:38:08,128 --> 00:38:10,230
Yeah, so we were prepared for that.
460
00:38:10,230 --> 00:38:12,662
So mom was going to go take him.
461
00:38:12,662 --> 00:38:20,989
If there was any barriers, we were going to work with the doctors to then go in and follow
up with some CET at the medical office.
462
00:38:20,989 --> 00:38:22,570
But it wasn't necessary.
463
00:38:22,570 --> 00:38:29,397
He was able to just go in the next time that mom took him and had a successful blood draw
without distress.
464
00:38:29,397 --> 00:38:31,208
So, yeah.
465
00:38:31,208 --> 00:38:32,329
that's incredible.
466
00:38:32,329 --> 00:38:41,216
And did you get feedback, any kind of feedback from him on the whole process besides
obviously the participation?
467
00:38:42,050 --> 00:38:50,217
You know, he, with the language skills that he had, he did just let me know, he's like,
okay, stop dressing up as a doctor when you come over.
468
00:38:50,217 --> 00:38:51,838
And I was like, okay, no problem.
469
00:38:51,838 --> 00:38:57,793
um But he, I did talk to him that day after he got the blood draw and I was like, that was
awesome.
470
00:38:57,793 --> 00:38:58,844
Like, you did such a great job.
471
00:38:58,844 --> 00:38:59,294
How was it?
472
00:38:59,294 --> 00:39:00,765
And he was like, no problem.
473
00:39:00,765 --> 00:39:01,456
Like I did it.
474
00:39:01,456 --> 00:39:04,108
And I was like, okay, that's awesome.
475
00:39:04,108 --> 00:39:09,973
So yeah, it seemed like he knew um how great of a job that he did.
476
00:39:09,973 --> 00:39:11,682
um
477
00:39:11,682 --> 00:39:19,528
I don't know if he could truly compare the amount of stress that he was in compared to
prior to CET to then when he actually went.
478
00:39:19,849 --> 00:39:23,082
But he, yeah, he did a phenomenal job and he put in all the work.
479
00:39:23,082 --> 00:39:29,597
So really it's applause to him for doing each step and really meeting each criteria and
getting to that point.
480
00:39:29,597 --> 00:39:30,289
So.
481
00:39:30,289 --> 00:39:30,757
Hmm.
482
00:39:30,757 --> 00:39:31,620
Hmm.
483
00:39:34,971 --> 00:39:35,736
And.
484
00:39:38,236 --> 00:39:42,629
Do you have a sense of, I don't think a lot of this is really important.
485
00:39:42,629 --> 00:39:56,718
I think sometimes we worry too much about root causes of some of these problems and what
initially triggered an individual who's been engaging in SIB for 40 years to start hanging
486
00:39:56,718 --> 00:40:01,240
his head and how important is that really now to sort of the treatment?
487
00:40:02,331 --> 00:40:08,450
But did you have an idea of sort of why he had such a massive fear of needles?
488
00:40:08,450 --> 00:40:13,717
Did he actually get a needle once and like unsuccessfully?
489
00:40:13,717 --> 00:40:19,744
Or was it just like what sort of you think kind of created this fear in the first place
for him?
490
00:40:21,314 --> 00:40:23,896
You know, I think it's an interesting question.
491
00:40:23,896 --> 00:40:25,605
I don't actually have an answer.
492
00:40:25,605 --> 00:40:30,301
I don't know where this came from or even how long it really had been occurring for.
493
00:40:30,301 --> 00:40:31,938
um
494
00:40:31,938 --> 00:40:40,982
But really when we
took this approach and when we were in the assessment piece of CET, we
were really looking at what's currently maintaining the behaviour.
495
00:40:40,982 --> 00:40:48,826
Like what contingencies are in place right now that he continues to try and create
distance or escape from these things.
496
00:40:48,826 --> 00:40:52,067
And that really was what guided our intervention.
497
00:40:52,067 --> 00:41:02,332
So something different may have been the cause or the initial start of this, but what was
most helpful was the current contingencies that
498
00:41:02,537 --> 00:41:04,405
maintaining the behaviour.
499
00:41:04,477 --> 00:41:21,306
Because it makes me wonder, and maybe this is a separate question or a separate sort of
procedure uh about prevention here and sort of early intervention and how, because I think
500
00:41:21,306 --> 00:41:22,737
a lot of people.
501
00:41:22,973 --> 00:41:26,896
kids, adults are are afraid of needles.
502
00:41:28,117 --> 00:41:31,260
You were mentioning getting your blood drawn and you even being afraid.
503
00:41:31,260 --> 00:41:42,028
I remember I went to give blood once to the Red Cross and I actually blacked out and had
to have the orange juice and the cookie.
504
00:41:43,132 --> 00:41:52,269
before I pulled my sleeve up, just from walking in and watching everybody's blood coming
out of their bodies into these bags was too much for me and I lost it.
505
00:41:52,489 --> 00:41:56,992
And it took me a long time to go back and try again.
506
00:41:57,493 --> 00:41:58,493
And so...
507
00:41:59,387 --> 00:42:02,530
So it's a thing for a lot of people.
508
00:42:02,530 --> 00:42:15,715
so have you thought about that, about sort of uh how maybe exposure therapy might be a
good tool in early intervention to prep people for their very first experiences with these
509
00:42:15,715 --> 00:42:18,448
medical procedures and other scary procedures?
510
00:42:19,318 --> 00:42:23,540
Yeah, our research group has actually talked about this a little bit.
511
00:42:23,540 --> 00:42:35,165
um And one of our members, Andrew Miller, has actually done this um and has been
successful in kind of preparing someone to have injections in their leg.
512
00:42:35,165 --> 00:42:44,870
And from the beginning, kind of taught the reinforcement system and all the movements in
the interconnected chain prior to the first actual injection.
513
00:42:44,870 --> 00:42:46,691
And then it went so smooth.
514
00:42:46,691 --> 00:42:49,292
And so I think some of the prevention
515
00:42:49,292 --> 00:42:50,473
work, who knows?
516
00:42:50,473 --> 00:43:02,338
Maybe that person would have been totally fine with the injections anyway without all of
it, but I think that it was a really fun process to get to watch and hear him explain the
517
00:43:02,338 --> 00:43:05,339
progress throughout it and get to see it kind of step by step.
518
00:43:05,339 --> 00:43:15,935
So I definitely think that there is a possibility here, but I do think a lot of our focus
has been if we're already seeing those distress indicating behaviors, how can we support
519
00:43:15,935 --> 00:43:17,246
in that area?
520
00:43:17,269 --> 00:43:21,571
yeah, because it makes me think about, uh I've got Katie Gibson coming on.
521
00:43:21,571 --> 00:43:32,134
She's going to be talking a lot more about medical procedures and especially about how
she's trained medical professionals, nurses and doctors and the like to do CET themselves
522
00:43:32,134 --> 00:43:34,907
with folks.
523
00:43:34,907 --> 00:43:36,708
And again, I wonder.
524
00:43:37,182 --> 00:43:40,423
you know, and again, off track a little bit here.
525
00:43:40,684 --> 00:43:49,217
But I wonder sort of, know, even hypothetically, philosophically, you know, what creates
these initial fears in the first place?
526
00:43:49,217 --> 00:43:53,129
I mean, in the whole scheme of things, a needle doesn't hurt that much.
527
00:43:53,129 --> 00:44:02,803
um You know, it's, you know, there's a lot more painful experiences children go through in
their lives and don't run away from kids wipe out on their bikes all the time and get back
528
00:44:02,803 --> 00:44:03,934
on the bikes.
529
00:44:03,934 --> 00:44:06,515
And it probably hurts a lot more than a little pinprick.
530
00:44:06,515 --> 00:44:07,535
And so
531
00:44:07,755 --> 00:44:19,602
I wonder about sort of those early, that early kind of verbal behaviour that they're
exposed to around needles and sort of the, you don't worry, close your eyes.
532
00:44:19,602 --> 00:44:31,829
This will be quick, you know, sort of a lot of these sort of uh preparing people for the
possibility of a scary situation in their very first exposure, we kind of set them up for
533
00:44:31,829 --> 00:44:32,719
failure.
534
00:44:33,922 --> 00:44:37,305
Yeah, I agree and I share your interest.
535
00:44:37,305 --> 00:44:47,154
I think it'd be very interesting to understand really where a lot of these things are
coming from and really what is the moment and the variables that are all contributing to
536
00:44:47,154 --> 00:44:54,600
what starts some of these things and why one person may experience the same situation and
not be affected by it.
537
00:44:54,600 --> 00:44:59,625
And while someone else may then start to engage in all these fearful behaviors following
that event.
538
00:44:59,625 --> 00:45:01,286
um
539
00:45:01,298 --> 00:45:02,268
I it's so interesting.
540
00:45:02,268 --> 00:45:07,505
wish I had the answers for you, but I think it's still areas we're investigating.
541
00:45:07,597 --> 00:45:08,599
Absolutely.
542
00:45:08,599 --> 00:45:19,772
again, a lovely example, the blood draw and uh the nail clipping was another one that
again, I think.
543
00:45:20,445 --> 00:45:27,225
without kind of getting into the whole weeds of it, just for listeners that may not have
heard the whole story.
544
00:45:27,445 --> 00:45:29,025
How long did that one take as well?
545
00:45:29,025 --> 00:45:43,865
How long did it take to go from a kid whose mother was clipping his toenails while he was
asleep to him clipping his own toenails and for the sheer social reinforcement of proud
546
00:45:43,865 --> 00:45:44,425
parents?
547
00:45:44,425 --> 00:45:47,705
How long did that whole procedure take to happen?
548
00:45:49,445 --> 00:45:50,428
Wow.
549
00:45:50,428 --> 00:45:51,439
Yeah, yeah.
550
00:45:51,439 --> 00:45:57,556
And so again, that's just that that stuff's just a little mind blowing.
551
00:45:57,556 --> 00:46:05,435
And and so I'd like to talk a little bit about because I think a lot of folks are going to
be keen to try this stuff.
552
00:46:05,456 --> 00:46:06,749
And uh
553
00:46:06,749 --> 00:46:15,489
And right now, think access to, I'm hoping the series will provide some of that as well,
but right now access to the constructional approach is limited.
554
00:46:15,569 --> 00:46:20,349
There's not a lot of folks that are out there that have specialized in this.
555
00:46:21,169 --> 00:46:26,169
The conversations seem to be happening primarily at a couple universities in the States.
556
00:46:26,869 --> 00:46:30,169
I know there's some work being done in Australia as well.
557
00:46:30,169 --> 00:46:35,293
But generally speaking, Joe's lab is sort of...
558
00:46:35,293 --> 00:46:37,553
the folks that are doing this sort of thing.
559
00:46:38,033 --> 00:46:48,453
when we often hear about sort of, and I realize it's apples and oranges here, but when you
often hear about other interventions, something that's gained a lot of traction lately is
560
00:46:48,453 --> 00:46:52,013
of course, Hanley, SBT, all that kind of thing.
561
00:46:52,013 --> 00:46:58,273
There's like seven levels of certification one might need to go through to do well at
that.
562
00:46:58,273 --> 00:47:00,461
We talk about, you know.
563
00:47:00,461 --> 00:47:09,891
sexuality and requiring, you ah know, folks with sort of multi-level certifications to
provide consultation on these cases.
564
00:47:09,891 --> 00:47:14,135
uh Can we talk a little bit about...
565
00:47:14,135 --> 00:47:16,597
uh
566
00:47:18,619 --> 00:47:24,734
First off, I'd like to talk a little bit about you and your initial experiences with this.
567
00:47:25,295 --> 00:47:33,983
That nail clipping example, and when we talked before we hit the record button, you said
this was the first time you had ever done this.
568
00:47:33,983 --> 00:47:42,551
And so tell me a little bit about what sort of training preparation you had before
implementing that and.
569
00:47:42,551 --> 00:47:45,333
m
570
00:47:45,475 --> 00:47:51,374
It only took an hour, so there obviously wasn't a lot of mentoring and feedback during the
procedure because it was just one and done.
571
00:47:52,655 --> 00:48:06,584
Yeah, my experience to this prior was I had seen a talk given by Awab and Andrew at ABAI
where they presented on a case of CET.
572
00:48:06,664 --> 00:48:14,620
And so I got to see this great model of what this procedure looked like and the outcomes
that this procedure was getting.
573
00:48:14,620 --> 00:48:19,233
And so that in and of itself was incredibly helpful.
574
00:48:19,233 --> 00:48:21,772
And then in addition to that, uh
575
00:48:21,772 --> 00:48:22,052
Dr.
576
00:48:22,052 --> 00:48:29,633
Joe Layng and Awab had also published an article on constructional exposure therapy,
really breaking down the key pieces of it.
577
00:48:29,633 --> 00:48:39,485
And so between reading that and seeing this model and having a few conversations with Awab
I basically took all of that.
578
00:48:39,746 --> 00:48:49,895
and was presented with this opportunity where this mom had come to me because of this
child's fear with nail clipping and I had known this learner for a while and so we
579
00:48:49,895 --> 00:48:52,017
discussed what this looks like.
580
00:48:52,017 --> 00:49:01,705
Mom was in agreement, we discussed it with him, he was in agreement and yeah we just did
it that day and I think he taught me a lot about the procedure as we were going through
581
00:49:01,705 --> 00:49:01,865
it.
582
00:49:01,865 --> 00:49:03,438
um
583
00:49:03,438 --> 00:49:04,979
And I made some mistakes.
584
00:49:04,979 --> 00:49:09,742
I think that was highlighted in the talk you saw at the constructional conference.
585
00:49:09,923 --> 00:49:12,111
And those are all learning experiences, you know.
586
00:49:12,111 --> 00:49:17,088
I would do things differently now than what I did my very first time implementing it.
587
00:49:17,088 --> 00:49:23,693
But even with, you know, that small fidelity error, we still saw the great results that he
had.
588
00:49:23,693 --> 00:49:24,513
So.
589
00:49:25,005 --> 00:49:36,792
So you watched the presentation, you read a paper, and you had a few chats with Awab and
you were able to go out and implement this program.
590
00:49:36,792 --> 00:49:44,816
And so it seems like a fairly accessible uh method for folks.
591
00:49:44,816 --> 00:49:54,681
If a clinician listening wanted to start using CET tomorrow, they have a client that
they've been struggling with some of these, you know,
592
00:49:55,420 --> 00:50:02,136
really sort medically necessary procedures and whatnot, where do they begin?
593
00:50:02,818 --> 00:50:05,199
Yeah, I think that's a great question.
594
00:50:05,199 --> 00:50:11,302
I also know a lot of members within the group are actively pushing to get more resources
out there.
595
00:50:11,302 --> 00:50:14,904
There's a lot of articles that are in press right now going through a review.
596
00:50:14,904 --> 00:50:19,566
So I hope soon that there's going to be even more resources for people to access.
597
00:50:19,566 --> 00:50:25,929
um Additionally, there's two new books that are coming out that I think are going to be
incredible resources.
598
00:50:25,949 --> 00:50:32,792
There's going to be a second version of the nonlinear
contingency analysis book, which in
general is just going to support people with the
599
00:50:32,792 --> 00:50:34,272
constructional approach.
600
00:50:34,272 --> 00:50:46,325
But then there's also another book of case studies that's going to be coming out with the
NCA book and that is going to have a ton of examples across a variety of populations and
601
00:50:46,325 --> 00:50:50,997
skills of applying CET along with many many other things.
602
00:50:50,997 --> 00:50:56,858
And so um hopefully that's going to be out soon and will be another great resource for
people.
603
00:50:57,128 --> 00:50:58,921
I would also say feel free to reach out.
604
00:50:58,921 --> 00:51:06,152
There's a lot of people in our group that are happy to have those same conversations that
Awag was so generous with me in the beginning.
605
00:51:06,152 --> 00:51:09,346
And so we would be happy to keep chatting through these things.
606
00:51:09,346 --> 00:51:12,760
We're constantly learning more and trying to disseminate more.
607
00:51:12,785 --> 00:51:13,497
That's awesome.
608
00:51:13,497 --> 00:51:19,119
know, and Awab also shared, there's a Facebook group as well, that's available.
609
00:51:19,851 --> 00:51:21,892
That is an incredible resource also.
610
00:51:21,892 --> 00:51:30,636
There's that space for discussions and asking questions and being able to have those
questions answered by other people who are actively doing this work.
611
00:51:30,696 --> 00:51:35,979
And we also try to constantly put those resources that are just coming out on that
Facebook group.
612
00:51:35,979 --> 00:51:42,082
So that's another easy way to be like, here's the next thing that's come out and I can
access it and take a look.
613
00:51:43,612 --> 00:51:44,797
Really cool.
614
00:51:46,950 --> 00:51:58,150
And so what's, what's, there's one other piece and I'm going to have to hit pause and edit
because I'm mumbling and stumbling on what I was going to ask you.
615
00:51:58,150 --> 00:51:59,483
Um, yeah, yeah, yeah.
616
00:51:59,483 --> 00:52:05,394
So I think, think another thing you said that resonated for me.
617
00:52:05,394 --> 00:52:07,635
your very first time running it.
618
00:52:08,235 --> 00:52:13,456
That the young man taught you a lot during the procedure.
619
00:52:14,157 --> 00:52:15,237
And I think.
620
00:52:16,382 --> 00:52:23,019
I wouldn't mind having you elaborate a bit on that because that was something that Awab
talked a bit about too in that the...
621
00:52:23,019 --> 00:52:25,685
oh
622
00:52:29,893 --> 00:52:33,895
And I'm hoping to get more into this with some of the future guests that we're going to
have on.
623
00:52:34,036 --> 00:52:46,582
But this idea of assent and the withdrawing of assent and how we can take that assent
withdrawal as a learning experience.
624
00:52:47,784 --> 00:52:54,127
And we have an opportunity to learn directly from our client each time they withdraw.
625
00:52:54,127 --> 00:52:56,689
And so I wonder if you could talk a little bit about kind of
626
00:52:57,359 --> 00:53:00,284
that concept and how that applied with this fellow.
627
00:53:00,898 --> 00:53:11,107
Yeah, so I think in the moment I learned a lot from him and then on the greater scheme of
things I also learned a lot from him.
628
00:53:11,107 --> 00:53:22,886
So when we're talking about what he was agreeable to and what he was not agreeable to,
that was so informative for me because as we chose to progress throughout the shaping
629
00:53:22,886 --> 00:53:28,561
procedure, um I would learn, okay, this big of a jump is okay.
630
00:53:28,561 --> 00:53:29,661
We can do...
631
00:53:29,900 --> 00:53:31,232
this big of a step.
632
00:53:31,232 --> 00:53:38,942
And we started from just presenting the nail clippers all the way across the room, showing
it to him, having him look at it, and then putting them away.
633
00:53:38,942 --> 00:53:45,101
And we would slowly move closer and closer until we were actually at the same table with
him sitting down and...
634
00:53:45,101 --> 00:53:47,092
We would have him present his hand.
635
00:53:47,092 --> 00:53:50,694
We would bring the nail clippers up to his hand and we'd give him a break.
636
00:53:50,955 --> 00:54:00,581
And it was once we got to the point where we were going to actually cut his nail, um he
began to show all these different signs of distress.
637
00:54:00,581 --> 00:54:08,284
And being my first time, I had not seen that before because he was very calm through all
the previous steps up to this point.
638
00:54:08,284 --> 00:54:08,928
Mm-hmm.
639
00:54:08,928 --> 00:54:16,832
And so I kind of tried to push him through it when, you know, if we're looking at the
actual procedures of CET, we wouldn't do that.
640
00:54:16,832 --> 00:54:23,545
We would provide that escape and distance contingent on that first sign of distress,
change our procedure a little bit and try again.
641
00:54:23,545 --> 00:54:34,820
um And so it really was in that moment where now I saw all this distress happening because
of something that I was doing as the implementer by not giving that removal, by not
642
00:54:34,820 --> 00:54:38,862
honoring that withdrawal of assent And that really taught me how
643
00:54:38,862 --> 00:54:53,935
important that is to one honor that and one learn from that to make these changes because
we did we we made those changes and he was able to get right back onto those shaping steps
644
00:54:53,935 --> 00:55:05,518
and again within that hour was able to transfer from me to mom and mom cut all 10 of his
fingernails but i think that that also taught me a lot in general of
645
00:55:05,568 --> 00:55:17,342
It's actually faster and we progress through the procedure more when I don't have to uh
push someone to escalate to such a point where now I have to support them and calming down
646
00:55:17,342 --> 00:55:21,017
and coming back to baseline levels of responding.
647
00:55:21,017 --> 00:55:22,432
um
648
00:55:22,432 --> 00:55:30,186
I can just honor it before it ever gets to that point, give a quick break like we've been
doing anyway, and then jump right back into the learning context.
649
00:55:30,186 --> 00:55:32,377
And I think that was like a big eye opener to me.
650
00:55:32,377 --> 00:55:36,829
And I was like, this is, this is why we, you know, honor these things.
651
00:55:36,829 --> 00:55:38,219
It's respectful to him.
652
00:55:38,219 --> 00:55:39,850
It's compassionate to him.
653
00:55:39,850 --> 00:55:49,905
I don't have to be this person that's causing all this distress, but also it's not only
just more compassionate, but he's able to now learn and get back to the learning
654
00:55:49,905 --> 00:55:52,339
environment a lot quicker than what we would have.
655
00:55:52,339 --> 00:55:54,650
done if we just kept pushing through it.
656
00:55:54,650 --> 00:56:07,972
So yeah, he taught me a lot of lessons and um you know I'm very grateful because he's just
honestly such a great person um but would give feedback to you know this is how I felt
657
00:56:07,972 --> 00:56:16,554
when I was going through this procedure, this is how I felt after the procedure and he was
able to give a lot of that feedback which was incredibly helpful.
658
00:56:16,593 --> 00:56:17,634
Yeah, yeah.
659
00:56:17,634 --> 00:56:27,531
And I'm wondering also just, I said we weren't going to dive too much into this case, but
there was one other section of the case that I, maybe I just got distracted during the
660
00:56:27,531 --> 00:56:38,068
presentation, but I think you quite quickly got to the point where mum could easily clip
all of his nails and he was doing great and he was loving that.
661
00:56:39,229 --> 00:56:44,593
Tell me about what the shift looked like from mum clipping his nails to him clipping his
nails.
662
00:56:45,410 --> 00:56:47,641
Yeah, so that did happen on a different day.
663
00:56:47,641 --> 00:56:51,343
are originally our outset from the outset.
664
00:56:51,343 --> 00:56:57,636
We had determined, OK, the behaviour, the absence of which is the problem is allowing
someone to cut your nails.
665
00:56:57,636 --> 00:57:01,417
And so we were able to achieve that in that hour and that maintained.
666
00:57:01,417 --> 00:57:05,379
And, you know, each time I'd come check in, Mom continued to cut his nails.
667
00:57:05,379 --> 00:57:12,102
But then we had decided with him and with the family that it would actually be best to let
him do it.
668
00:57:12,102 --> 00:57:15,484
He had all the prerequisite skills, the fine motor skills.
669
00:57:15,484 --> 00:57:25,707
to do this and this would allow him to cut it on his own pace in his own style keep it at
the length he wanted it would just give him a lot more choices and control over the
670
00:57:25,707 --> 00:57:37,350
situation and so we did another short round of CET I want to say it was 25 minutes but
don't quote me on that I have to look again uh
671
00:57:37,975
--> 00:57:42,397
And yeah, we were able to get him to the point where he was cutting both hands.
672
00:57:42,519 --> 00:57:45,461
And it was really special because he was so excited for it.
673
00:57:45,461 --> 00:57:50,896
Dad came home early from work just to get to see him finish his other hand because he
wanted to show him.
674
00:57:50,896 --> 00:57:51,186
So.
675
00:57:51,186 --> 00:57:52,727
um
676
00:57:52,727 --> 00:57:58,772
Yeah, it was a very quick process to get from the point where mom was doing it to where he
was doing it.
677
00:57:58,772 --> 00:58:02,815
And that quickness really comes from the skillset he came in with.
678
00:58:02,815 --> 00:58:09,781
Sometimes if you have to teach some of those skills involved in that repertoire, it might
take a little bit longer.
679
00:58:09,781 --> 00:58:11,219
And I think that that's okay.
680
00:58:11,219 --> 00:58:16,116
And so what were, you don't have to tell me all of them, but what were those steps?
681
00:58:16,116 --> 00:58:20,631
So briefly, did it start with mom clipping his nails?
682
00:58:21,293 --> 00:58:26,979
Or what was sort of, in the second day, what was the, yeah, yeah.
683
00:58:26,979 --> 00:58:32,754
Yeah, so the second session, was um not mom involved.
684
00:58:32,754 --> 00:58:35,967
So this was just him and I and having the nail clippers on the table.
685
00:58:35,967 --> 00:58:42,042
And I want to say we started with just having him with both hands pick up the nail
clippers and then he'd put them back down.
686
00:58:42,042 --> 00:58:43,474
And that was like step one.
687
00:58:43,474 --> 00:58:48,478
And the next step was pick up the nail clippers and touch them to your own nail and put
them back down.
688
00:58:48,478 --> 00:58:53,542
And then we would have him for the next step, put his nail inside the nail clippers.
689
00:58:53,850 --> 00:58:55,691
but not necessarily clip them.
690
00:58:55,691 --> 00:59:04,247
And we basically just worked our way up to actually getting like one clip and then we
would do two clips on a finger and then we would do three clips and we just got it until
691
00:59:04,247 --> 00:59:05,157
he was...
692
00:59:05,538 --> 00:59:08,219
doing it no problem and he was just, yep, I got this.
693
00:59:08,219 --> 00:59:10,179
Okay, let's go take a break, you know.
694
00:59:10,179 --> 00:59:22,152
So uh what was nice is we saw in both of those cases that switch over effect where in the
beginning his responding really was maintained by that distance and the removal of the
695
00:59:22,152 --> 00:59:23,183
nail clippers.
696
00:59:23,183 --> 00:59:31,535
But by the end of it, he was just clipping his nails because of the positive social
reinforcement he was getting from both of his parents and how proud they were of him.
697
00:59:31,535 --> 00:59:35,246
And he was just so excited to get to show his fingers off to them.
698
00:59:35,474 --> 00:59:37,235
Yeah, that's amazing.
699
00:59:37,395 --> 00:59:42,729
And so it sounds like the steps themselves weren't much different than from the previous
day.
700
00:59:42,729 --> 00:59:47,122
Just now it's his hand instead of mom's hand, um sort of doing all those things.
701
00:59:47,122 --> 00:59:52,145
And I think that other piece about the social reinforcement, I think, is big.
702
00:59:52,165 --> 00:59:59,130
And I think has come up in some of the other conversations that I've had with folks in
that.
703
01:00:01,083 --> 01:00:15,972
And maybe we don't even, maybe something we don't realize that these folks have all had
this fear for so long and the act of overcoming that fear is pretty reinforcing in of
704
01:00:15,972 --> 01:00:16,783
itself as well.
705
01:00:16,783 --> 01:00:27,009
Is that something we're seeing and just hearing and sort of the social attention
associated with it is way more powerful than kind of anything else.
706
01:00:27,570 --> 01:00:39,873
Yeah, I think what we've seen and what other implementers have seen as they've gone
through this process is once that negative reinforcement contingency is addressed through
707
01:00:40,148 --> 01:00:46,801
a constructional exposure therapy, then the program specific consequences are allowed to
take their effect.
708
01:00:46,801 --> 01:00:58,707
So the things that now he's able to do and get his parents to be so proud of him, that can
actually have an effect on his behaviour because uh the the distance and escape is no
709
01:00:58,707 --> 01:01:00,408
longer motivating for him.
710
01:01:00,408 --> 01:01:00,948
He does.
711
01:01:00,948 --> 01:01:06,150
He's not experiencing those same uh responses to that nail clipper anymore.
712
01:01:06,150 --> 01:01:10,032
And I think we see that across a lot of cases, even in the blood draw,
713
01:01:10,032 --> 01:01:20,770
case, we were seeing it to where he would come over and he would sit down for a long
period of time just so he could have a back and forth conversation with the team that was
714
01:01:20,770 --> 01:01:25,163
practicing with him, not necessarily to get rid of the medical stimuli.
715
01:01:25,163 --> 01:01:34,250
And so once the escape is depotentiated, it allows for all these other positive
reinforcement contingencies to take effect.
716
01:01:34,250 --> 01:01:39,173
And I think we've seen that pretty consistently across a wide variety of our cases.
717
01:01:39,826 --> 01:01:41,166
That's awesome.
718
01:01:41,347 --> 01:01:44,279
You're only like first year into this stuff.
719
01:01:44,279 --> 01:01:58,818
So tell me about some of the other projects you're working on and uh what the next year or
so is going to hold for you and your learning.
720
01:01:59,796 --> 01:02:01,387
Ben, there's a lot coming.
721
01:02:01,887 --> 01:02:06,639
No, I think there's a lot more coming with constructional exposure therapy.
722
01:02:06,639 --> 01:02:18,595
We're constantly trying to really refine the procedure, identify like what are the most
effective and efficient ways to provide this in a way that's gonna have the most impact
723
01:02:18,595 --> 01:02:19,916
for the person that we're doing.
724
01:02:19,916 --> 01:02:22,517
And I think it just changes context to context.
725
01:02:22,517 --> 01:02:27,319
So I do hope that we will continue to work on those things and have more out.
726
01:02:27,319 --> 01:02:29,500
We're also doing a few studies on
727
01:02:29,820 --> 01:02:34,283
genuine choice, which is something that Israel Golddiamond talked about.
728
01:02:34,323 --> 01:02:45,030
And I think that just ties back to genuine assent and being able to have these
alternatives and what is really required for something to be a genuine alternative.
729
01:02:45,030 --> 01:02:50,574
um And I think that I'm, again, from the beginning, I've been so interested in that area.
730
01:02:50,574 --> 01:02:59,440
And so I'm just hoping to get some more empirical data on the variables that are involved
and what is needed in these contexts to reduce coercion and
731
01:02:59,440 --> 01:03:02,385
um what that looks like.
732
01:03:02,385 --> 01:03:07,409
And so yeah, I hope that maybe we'll talk about those one day too.
733
01:03:07,409 --> 01:03:08,530
I look forward to it.
734
01:03:08,530 --> 01:03:09,731
Danielle, this was really cool.
735
01:03:09,731 --> 01:03:17,420
I loved learning about CET with you and love seeing your passion for this work and stoked
to see what's coming up.
736
01:03:17,420 --> 01:03:18,660
Thanks for coming on.
737
01:03:18,725 --> 01:03:20,315
yeah, thank you so much for the invite.
738
01:03:20,315 --> 01:03:22,398
It was an honor to get to chat with you,
739
01:03:22,398 --> 01:03:23,260
Right on.