TRANSCRIÇÃO 🔗
Jacob Herrmann: We've got episode ⁓ three, no, episode four the CBJ Bodybuilding Radio and we have ⁓ Mr. Muscles, ⁓ Dr. Reffalo. I your last name correct?
Martin Refalo: Sure. That's close enough. It's a real follow. Either way is fine. Yeah.
Jacob Herrmann: Refalo, refalo. A couple of cool things have happened of recent. WMBF president, I know you've spoken a little bit about it on social media. How did that come about? Are you pretty stoked about it?
Martin Refalo: Yeah, obviously a very exciting opportunity for me. I've been working with the WNBF since they made an impact here in Australia a few years ago as a judge mostly and some behind the scenes work over the last year helping organize shows and whatnot. ⁓ So it's all built, it's all really kind of been built over the past few years and ⁓ This next step really does make sense to me. don't perceive it to be like a lateral step or anything like that. It's the next logical step from where I'm at in my career and the amount of time I've spent around bodybuilding and the passion that I have for the WMBF. So, Leah, who announced me as president last week or so, has done such a great job over the past couple we is really building such a strong foundation and the goal is to really just build off that. We're not planning on reinventing the wheel, just planning on doing the things that we currently do so well, trying to do them even better and then refining and fine tuning as we go. So super excited for this year because we've walked our shows in, we've got four shows happening across Brisbane and Melbourne and we're only about... 11 or so weeks out from the first show of the season. So it's all happening. It's all in the works right now. It's getting closer. And yeah, I mean, I personally can't wait. I can't wait to be there and to be at the show and to host the show. It's going to be an amazing feeling, I'm sure. And yeah, I've got a great team beside me that's going to kind of help bring this kind of dream, if you will, to reality.
Jacob Herrmann: Yeah, getting close, man.
Martin Refalo: because it really is a dream when you're kind of planning this potential show and what it's going to look like. It really is a bit of a dream. So I'm looking forward to bringing that to reality in a few months time.
Jacob Herrmann: Yeah, and I assume that means you can't judge anymore.
Martin Refalo: Yeah, that's a tricky one. Basically a no, but there is a bit of ⁓ fine detail around that. as president, still don't like, as long as I don't have a conflict on stage, I can still judge and presidents do that ⁓ in some of WNBF affiliates across the globe. I'm not planning on judging unless ⁓ I need to in certain circumstances. And so we have like a For pro cards, right? You need to have seven judges on the judging table and we only have six and we need to do way of pro cards and you know, big open class then that might be something I look at doing if needed. So yeah, not as much judging though. That's for sure. More
Load full transcript
things to worry about.
Jacob Herrmann: Has anything shocked you or maybe you didn't expect it to be like it is with regards to maybe your ideas and how they could actually be implemented practically or whether they couldn't be?
Martin Refalo: Yeah, that's a good question. ⁓ Not yet. There's definitely things that have kind of popped up that maybe are a bit more tedious than I thought they would have been. Nothing that stands out though. I'm currently working on integrating ⁓ judging software. into the Federation. So that, for example, is something that I've been able to manage well, and that is going well. And that was initially something that I thought would be maybe a little bit harder, but it's working out well, which is awesome. But yeah, nothing that stands out that's shocked me at this point anyway. We're still in the early days. It's only been a few weeks.
Jacob Herrmann: Yeah, I was gonna say the, you know, I can imagine some things costing maybe a little bit more than what you'd expect, but you have been around maybe long enough to know whether that is gonna be the case or not.
Martin Refalo: Yeah, that's the thing. Yeah. Yeah, I think for the most part I knew what I was in for, right, again because I've been around ⁓ for a while. So yeah, no massive surprises yet, but I'm sure something will pop up at some point.
Jacob Herrmann: Yeah. And another thing I really love that you guys do, just not including yourself, but a part of JPS is things like your physique seminar. got Mike down, Dr. Mike down earlier this year, you know, bringing back that in-person stuff that isn't really as common anymore. I wasn't really around in the fitness scene when, you know, in-person seminars would pop up multiple times throughout the year and people would travel over.
Martin Refalo: You missed out, man. Yeah.
Jacob Herrmann: Yeah, I know. ⁓ You know, Mountain Dog, John Meadows was, he came down to the gym I train at now and did a seminar there with Eugene. That was maybe 2020, 2019. So just before things started to get a little bit crazy. ⁓ But I really love this in-person stuff that you guys do. Is there anything coming up this year that maybe I should be keeping an eye out for?
Martin Refalo: Yeah. Well, yeah. Okay, yeah. Yeah, man, ⁓ you made such a good point though. It's not only is it not more common, it's just, you people just have a, they gravitate towards just wanting things to be done online. At least that's what we found. And so I think, I think that's the issue. And then that causes things to become more common, less common, ⁓ because why would you try and do face to face things when everyone wants to do things online, right? So even for us, the frequency at which we do in-person seminars and events has decreased. ⁓ Prior to COVID, we were running the ultimate evidence-based conference. I'm not sure if you remember, but we have people like ⁓ Brett Contreras, Lane Norton, mean, Alan Aragon, Jeff Nipper came down. We had some massive names that came down for these events. But yeah, it seems that the desire and the appetite for that has shifted over time. I guess that's a separate discussion, but for this year, we are running the ultimate physique conference again. that will be taking place in June, June 6th and 7th. And we've got a nice lineup that will be released very soon. So it might be worth keeping an eye out for that. Off the top of my head, that's the only in-person, big in-person event that we have coming up. I mean, it would be awesome to do more and we want to do more. ⁓ It's just a matter of ensuring that it's feasible and that people aren't going to want to come and buy tickets instead of just watching online. That's right, right? Because some people just rather watch online.
Jacob Herrmann: Yeah. Yeah. Yep. And I mean, I've coached on the gym floor and now I'm predominantly doing online coaching and I can tell anyone for a fact that if I get someone in front of me in person, I can make a change within five seconds. Whereas it might take a couple of days depending on how quick and how responsive the individual is and maybe how easily they take on concepts. I think if anyone is wanting to learn
Martin Refalo: Yeah. Yeah.
Jacob Herrmann: as much as possible, as fast as possible. In-person stuff is, I think, really, really powerful.
Martin Refalo: Yeah, I mean, I completely agree. ⁓ Online coaching can work well, but I think just online learning itself can work well. But there's something about in-person learning and in-person interaction that you just can't really replicate online. And yeah, I only wish that more people could come to realize that.
Jacob Herrmann: Well, who knows, maybe there's going to be a ⁓ sort of equilibrium achieved with regards to like the pendulum of online versus in person stuff. Like sometimes it needs to all the other way to then they come back to the middle. So we'll find out what happens. ⁓ Now, ⁓ did a little bit of background research. I know you've done a bit of
Martin Refalo: Yeah. ⁓ True.
Jacob Herrmann: of your research on protein intakes, but probably more around proximity to failure, RR training. Would you say that's inaccurate? Cool. I really want to dig into one question I've got that's been on my mind for a while, but specifically if you were to choose one rep in reserve or zero reps in reserve for a practical application.
Martin Refalo: Yep. Yep. Yep.
Jacob Herrmann: What would you lean more to and why?
Martin Refalo: Yeah, that's an interesting question. Yeah, it's a funny one because I recently watched a reel that was using one, like a graphic from one of my papers to highlight why going to failure is a physiologically inferior rep. That's how it was described. And the message being conveyed was that you should always stop at one RIR all the time because of these fatiguing mechanisms that basically mean your attempt at reaching failure ⁓ is physiologically inferior. That was the language that was being used. I don't think it was a
correct kind of interpretation of the graphics that I had displayed in my paper. And it got me to realize that there does seem to be this discussion online, maybe on TikTok, I'm not on TikTok so I don't know. And even my conversations with Jeff Nithid ⁓ made me realise that there is this conversation happening online about whether we should be going to failure or just topping out one RIR. That's such a specific blanket ⁓ number. And I wasn't really aware of that. I was under the impression that Um, most of the discussion revolves around people just thinking that we must always train to failure all the time. But there's a subset of people that also think you can only, you should only do one RIR because doing that next rep is actually a problem. And I am not sure I agree. I agree with either of those camps. Uh, I don't really think, um, either of them kind of makes sense in isolation. ⁓ I think, you know, reaching failure and stopping at a certain number of reps and reserve, think their ideas and strategies that should sit on the same side of the fence as opposed to opposite side of the fence. Because in reality, when we're giving practical recommendations, personally, I don't like giving blanket recommendations where it's like, no, this is what you're going to do when you're going to do the same. And we're all going to do the same thing. If I'm going to give a recommendation that is going to be generalized across a demographic of people, it needs to be a little more flexible. I think that's the only way it can really make sense and that it can really apply well across numerous people is if there's flexibility and if we're thinking about probability and ranges as opposed to, you know, blacks and white. I think we need gray area. when we're giving a practical recommendation to an extent, because then you give too much gray area and people get lost. It's like there's a double-edged sword, but everything really is. So I think, long story short, to kind of ⁓ take a few steps back and get at your specific question, I don't know if I want to choose one over the other, because I just don't, I really don't think it's a false dichotomy in the sense that It must be either or. I think if I was to give a practical recommendation to the wider population of people who train and who want to build muscle, would be trying to terminate most of your sets, possibly all of your sets, within two reps shy from failure. So from that failure point to two reps in reserve, you've got that range. And that's where you want all your sets, we're trying to maximize our vertical, you want all your sets to be ending in that range and where your sets sit on that range well that's going to depend on who you are how well trained you are and what exercise you're doing whether it's your last set or your first set some people can and should probably bias most of their sets towards the value point and others should be on the other side of that range right there's there's definitely context dependent reasons for certain individuals to work their way across that range, right? Or bias one end of the range over another. And that to me, that's the practical recommendation that I have managed to put together based on my understanding of the literature, which involves some of my research and the wider research as a whole. So that's my... Yeah, roundabout answer to your question, even though I didn't really answer it directly.
Jacob Herrmann: It's funny because a lot of times when these questions are posed on a video on social media that there's supposedly one and only one answer, but a lot of times we need to think more broadly and apply nuance where, where necessary. And generally in nuances needed to be applied. But I wanted to ask with, you still do some coaching, correct? For, I know you still coach Sam. Yeah. Awesome. And with someone like Sam and maybe I
Martin Refalo: official. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Jacob Herrmann: put myself in that camp when in essence you have everything ⁓ being covered in terms of your variables. Well, for me, I at least like to think I do. Do you like to standardize ⁓ your intensity? So whether you're, you know, between zero to one RIR or like you keep everything at two RIR for a mesocycle or in general, I mean, for me personally, I like to think I'm always within one rep.
Martin Refalo: Mm-hmm.
Jacob Herrmann: within zero to one reps in reserve. If there's a rep where I'm like, ⁓ 30 % likelihood I'm gonna get this, I might choose not to take it. But then there's other times where I give it a go. I see if it's there truly and I will try and dig out myself out of the hole as much as possible. ⁓ Because then if potentially that standardized, you might be able to argue.
Martin Refalo: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. ⁓ huh. Yeah. ⁓ huh. Yeah.
Jacob Herrmann: It then comes down to exercise selection, total sets, frequency, and maybe something else if I missed it in terms of how much work you're doing to maximize the result of hypertrophy. ⁓ What would you tell someone like myself or Sam if you were the head of programming in that sense?
Martin Refalo: Mm. Mm. Yeah, yeah, I think that one, you brought up a good point about how you have all these other variables dialed in. And I think that's such an important part of the equation, because if you can dial those variables in, whether that's your nutrition, your sleep, your stress management, recovery, et cetera. Well, if you think about that range that I mentioned earlier, that strike zone, that's what I call it. You can spend more time towards that failure end. You can. And like I said before, you're probably sure because you're capable of facilitating that training stimulus, right? Providing that you aren't getting injured, that you're tolerating any pains well and other pain pains, et cetera. That's just a separate discussion. providing you're capable of tolerating the training and you are taking care of the variables that are going to allow you to adapt to that
training stimulus. Yeah, I think you can and you should spend more time there. So for someone like Sam, the instruction for him is to push each of your sets as basically as hard as you can, right? So he's also at that zero to one RIR, I guess, range. It's just a narrower range. on most of his exercises, right? And there's obviously a couple there where he might be a bit further away if they're highly fatiguing, if you're doing something like a stiff leg deadlift or whatever it might be. And I think as you become more well-trained, you can get pretty good at knowing which reps you should take and which you shouldn't when you're so close to that failure point, right? And I think, you know, Sam is really good at knowing which ones he should and he shouldn't take. And sometimes he will push to see if that extra rope is there and fail and that's fine. I don't think that's physiologically inferior. ⁓ And he might be wrong. True. So I agree. And I think that that should be welcomed. I think we should welcome that. And if you're giving that instruction,
Jacob Herrmann: And he might be wrong sometimes and that's needed to buffer that skill as well, like continual.
Martin Refalo: within a program that has been constructed well, then it's not an issue. Like his volume is prescribed to him. It's not your volume, it's his volume. And I've been coaching him for four years so I know what he should be doing, how much he can handle, what he responds to, et cetera. Like the exercise selection, it's the same. The exercise order, right? Or the volume of each individual exercise. Like all these different variables are interacting. I think if you can nail that within a program and you've got this individual who is taking care of all these external variables, then for sure, we should look at that strike zone and we should bias ⁓ RIRs closer to that failure point. And then obviously reach failure on numerous sets throughout a program, throughout a week as well. And that goes within the context of someone looking to maximize.
Jacob Herrmann: Mm-mm.
Martin Refalo: muscle hypertrophy. There's a difference between wanting to build muscle and wanting to do it well and wanting to maximise it. Although we're not really ever going to know for maximising it and this is like the optimal fallacy. It's like we don't know if we're at optimal. We don't know if optimal changes over time. It probably does and it probably looks different for me and for you. But that doesn't mean we can't push towards it and we can't attempt to optimise. But optimising obviously requires just that little bit more. I think based on my current understanding of how things work. But that doesn't mean that someone who just wants to build muscle, who's not looking to compete, can't have yet a slightly broader range of which they terminate their sets in. if they're not taking care of the other fine variables that can play such a large role in adaptation as well.
Jacob Herrmann: Absolutely. And it's funny you mentioned that sort of optimal fallacy. ⁓ It's sort of the question I've been asking myself is like, how much should I and can I do to be in a position where I'm putting on as much tissue as possible? And I'd like to ask you what are the things you look at? You know, things like the log book ⁓ that you bring together to
Martin Refalo: Mm. Mm-hmm.
Jacob Herrmann: come to a conclusion, okay, this person is probably in a green zone of covering well, putting on good amounts of muscle. What are the things you like to do from a practical sense?
Martin Refalo: Mm. Yeah, I like that question because the importance of diagnosing progress is so high. I think this is where a lot of people go wrong is they struggle to diagnose their progress to measure it because measuring muscle growth is hard and you can't just leave it after a few poses in the mirror that you do every morning. It's like you're just not going to see the changes day to day. You're probably not even going to see them week to week. So there needs to be a reliable means of diagnosing progress. And what happens if you can't do that? What happens if you can't measure progress is, well, you you're looking at the mirror, it's been a few weeks, new program isn't working, or at least you perceive it to not be working because you're not seeing changes. Well, what are you going to do? Are you just going to follow the next TikTok trend? You're going to change program, you're going to change code, you're to do this, you can do that. And we see this happen a lot. I mean, if you spend enough time around the industry, you see people chop and change, doing different things and struggling to commit to ⁓ a program for numerous months and actually see if it's going to work. So I think to answer that question directly, like the key thing that I'm looking at is, and there's a few things, but the key one, the most, I guess, reliable one, that you can easily track is, can I observe progressive overload in my client over numerous weeks and months? And what I, the definition that I'm using here to kind of describe progressive overload is what I call like the post hoc definition, is progressive overload as a result of the adaptation, right? So it's not something that we're going to the gym and forcing. It's, we've done a training session and we've induced the training stimulus. we have adapted to that stimulus. We are now stronger and bigger. And so we walk into the gym the week after and we're capable of lifting more, whether that's more weight or more reps or with better technique, whatever it might be, usually just weight and reps. They're big rocks. And if we can, if I can, as a coach, naturally observe that across weeks and months, and I'm not having to force my client to add an extra rep. will add more load and they're just naturally able to do that on multiple exercises for the target muscle groups that we're trying to across months, right? Months and months of time, which means we need to stick to the same
program. If I'm seeing that, then for me, that's like one of the most important things I can track because I can't put my client in an MRI. can't do an ultrasound. Well, I can, but I can't. I don't want to do an ultrasound one. Just a little bit. There's things that we can't do. There's things that we can do that aren't super accurate, like a dexascan. I can tell you to go get a dexascan. The only thing you need to do that is to tell me what I wanted to tell me. I can do circumference measures and I think circumference measures are fine, but we know that there's confounding factors there as well. So what I look at...
Jacob Herrmann: Just a little bit inconvenient.
Martin Refalo: which I think is a good starting point for most people is progressive overload. Like are you seeing progressive overload? Are you seeing volume load increasing over time for most of the exercises you're doing, especially for the target muscles that you're looking to grow? And if you combine that with improved visual photos, right, and body weight, you know, slowly training up, that's awesome. That's a kind of a of a trifecta for progress that's gonna tell you whether or not what you're doing is working. right? And if it's working, then you keep doing it and you don't really need to worry too much about changing it until you start to see things stall, right? Because, you know, again, if we bring the optimal fallacy back into the discussion here, it's like, who knows, man, if maybe if you added an extra set to each of your exercises, like maybe that's all you need to get to your absolute maximum point, but you're never going to know. Maybe it's maybe you're currently doing too much and you need to take take one set off like Who knows, maybe there's some physiological things happening within you that are just at this point, just proving to be like negative and hampering your muscle growth. And you don't know that. mean, like the people come up with these theoretical reasons for things happening all the time and, you know, theoretical mechanisms are taking place. It's just, we just don't know. We just don't know how they function. how accurate we can kind of measure them, all these sorts of things. So it's like, if you're seeing progress and you're looking bigger and your volume loads increasing, thumbs up. And usually for me as a coach, I try to stand my ground. I try and stick to my guns and only make changes when I really think necessary. And if I'm, you know, if... Clients getting closer to competition prep, for example. I know they're gonna be in a deficit soon. They're responding really well, but I think their arms need to be bit bigger. Okay, let's change exercise order. Let's put your arm work up closer to the beginning of your program. Let's maybe drive a little more volume to those areas and let's see how that goes for the next eight weeks. I'm happy to make changes, obviously, but I think that the key here is finding a program that is allowing your client or you to
progressively overload and just milking it, you know, trying to get as much out of it as possible over time.
Jacob Herrmann: Absolutely. I love that. ⁓ I mean, I did my last meso cycle probably would have been like 16 or 18 weeks. And really the only thing I changed of late is I'm doing a two on one off. I changed three exercises. So all the other exercises are things that I am accustomed to neurologically and the skill and then maybe move rep ranges around a little bit. ⁓ so
Martin Refalo: Wow. Okay.
Jacob Herrmann: I think that speaks volumes about you have to sort of stick to things for a fair chunk of time. think ⁓ one, people underestimate how long it takes to learn the skill of a movement if it's completely new. ⁓ And then putting into practice and keeping your head down when maybe enjoyment isn't quite there. But I think if someone's like myself where progress is where I get enjoyment out of the gym.
Martin Refalo: like it. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Right. Right.
Jacob Herrmann: one of the realms, I think that's maybe less of a concern. Now, I want to ask, so obviously we need to see progressive overload. And I think there's an inter individual, inter individuality to it in terms of like how much does someone progress weekly or does someone progress every two to three weeks? And maybe one of those variables would be training age and skill.
Martin Refalo: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Jacob Herrmann: What is, is there a sweet spot? Is there a range you sort of like, okay, this is probably pretty good or all right, I need to pull out a set or maybe consider adding an extra set in.
Martin Refalo: Hmm. Yeah, that's a trickier one to answer because you're right in saying that people will progress at different rates. And yeah, I guess one of the more explicit, I guess, factors that will influence that is trading age. Someone more advanced may not see progressive overload week to week. It might be on a fortnightly basis, maybe slightly longer than that. It can depend on the exercise, that's for sure. And I think that the key point to understand here is just because you don't see progressive overload from one week to the next, it doesn't actually mean you haven't done enough to grow some muscle from that exercise. if you've got a full program of exercises, Some of them are going to progressively overload week to week, even if you're very advanced, you're to be able to observe that. Others are going to be a bit slower. Fine. Now on those slower ones, a lack of progression, lack of performance improvement from one week to the next can still mean that you're inducing a stimulus that is beyond the threshold required for adaptation to occur. Okay, so for muscle tissue to grow, There is a certain kind of threshold level that the stimulus you induce has to exceed. Okay, so if we just don't train and we live our lives on planet Earth, we are still experiencing tension because we are having to overcome the forces of gravity. Our muscles are still doing some work to
keep us upright and to allow us to move and function. That amount of tension is not going to exceed the threshold required for adaptation. Right? So that tension stimulus is going to allow us to basically maintain our muscle mass at adulthood, during adulthood. And if we have good training experience and we actually built some muscle and we stopped training, we will lose muscle and then we'll eventually just maintain ⁓ whatever we get, whatever we get down to. Right? So training allows us to exceed that threshold required for adaptation and doing 10 reps a day with a hundred kilos. and 10 reps next week with 100 kilos, right? If it was like overloading in the first place and it allowed you to exceed that threshold, right? It's gonna allow you to do the same the week after, especially if you've got other exercises as well that are progressively overloaded. Because more often than not, we're gonna, some are gonna move forward, others might lag behind, but we wanna think about the program as a whole, right? And we're often doing more than one exercise for a muscle group. So I think that's a little bit of a misconception where people think if their reps or their load aren't going up every single week, that they haven't induced the stimulus potent enough to build muscle. But I don't think that's the case. think that growth signal required ⁓ from our training session, it's a range. There's a theoretical top end where you are optimizing, like somewhere there, but we don't really know how to reach it. And there is a bottom end too. And so I don't think as coaches, we should make these kind of fast decisions about reducing sets or adding sets just because we see like a bit of a stall in progressive overload. You know, sometimes it might take me a few weeks to make a decision. Like if I've seen a stall now for three or four weeks, okay, my alarm bells are going to go off and I'm going to make a bit of a change. But I try not to do that from week to week. ⁓ And, you know, I think the objective stuff and looking at the progressive overload, that's important, but also having these discussions with clients and trying to get qualitative feedback, I think is important too. If clients are seemingly handling sessions really well, tolerating the training really well, ⁓ you're feeling good, you're getting enough food in, all that sort of stuff, I'm absolutely fine with just adding some additional sets in ⁓ for target muscles that we wanna grow. I mean, I'm of the opinion that ⁓ volume is conducive to hypertrophy. It's like, yes, the more volume you add in, the more you grow with diminishing returns. I understand that there's probably a pretty strong diminishing return kind of component to adding volume in, but I'm happy to experiment. I'm definitely open to experimenting with additional volume here and there. I try and keep it up to sleep though, because I think the most important factors to nail You know your exercise execution your proximity to failure Because that's your volume quality and I think if you can get your volume quality, right? Most people can get a lot more Out of like less right and most people doing a lot of volume, but not doing in the right ways and it seems like the earlier the like if you're thinking about like 20 sets of training volume across a week the first five to ten of those sets probably getting you a big chunk of your gains and then we really start to see diminishing returns from there. So for a lot of people who are doing like 20 sets of volume a week for a muscle group but not X unit really well, I'm a fan of just cutting that on like half and just focusing on doing, you know, five to 10 sets for a muscle group but really getting to the point where we nail those five to 10 sets and then we can have a discussion about adding more if I think we need. So that's kind of my just general thoughts on that.
Jacob Herrmann: Absolutely. I think that's really well put. I definitely noticed even coming out of prep, my ability to execute has just rapidly increased and you know, in a position where maybe I'm doing a little bit less than I was doing in prep ⁓ and now playing around with a high frequency, doing an upper and a lower and then a rest and then repeating. ⁓
Martin Refalo: Mm-hmm.
Jacob Herrmann: I'm obviously throwing a little bit more in my total recoverable bucket with regards to putting more leg work in. Two sets of leg press versus two sets of a bicep curl, two completely different things in terms of how that impacts you across a week. ⁓ But yeah, it was really cool to hear just the things that you look for, ⁓ especially with a coaching background and some of the research you've done.
Martin Refalo: Seems like it, Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Jacob Herrmann: ⁓ But I think a big one, even going back to the intensity thing is some of the research you've done too is people's perception of RIR and that playing into one of those variables. You know, if you are training one to two RIR, is it actually one to two RIR? And just like we spoke about with Sam or any other individual, potentially going to a point where
Martin Refalo: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Jacob Herrmann: they can't complete the rep by themselves on occasion isn't a bad thing as we're just honing that sword, that skill of training intensity and knowing where to land.
Martin Refalo: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I am pretty confident in people's abilities to gauge RIR as long as they're well trained, ⁓ obviously. I'd be pretty open to putting a decent amount of money down on you, being able to hit a one to two RIR on a bench press.
Jacob Herrmann: Yeah.
Martin Refalo: or leg press. Like I'm pretty confident that if I told you to stop within two reps, try from failure, so that's strike zone that I mentioned earlier, like you're gonna do a set and you're gonna be somewhere there, right? And I say the same for myself on most exercises, at least when I've got a good training routine going. And yeah, same goes for the clients that I
train that I use RIR with and that are actually trying to maximize muscle growth. Because for a lot of the population that we might work with as coaches, at least if you're in a personal training studio or a commercial gym, people just want to build muscle and be stronger. And you don't have to be as pedantic about your RIR with those types of people. We still want to push people harder because most people aren't going to be pushing themselves as hard as they think they they are, right? So we should always be trying to push more, but we just don't have to be too pedantic about it. So I don't really care if someone stops at a three RIR when I told them it was a two, if they're just the general population client, right? So good training stimulus, we'll try and do better next week. If however, we are working with a bodybuilder and someone who is trying to maximize growth, then yes, that question will always arise. It's like, if I tell you to stop your sets at one to two RIR, how do I know you're actually there?
Jacob Herrmann: Mm.
Martin Refalo: Well, firstly, like I mentioned, I'm going to be confident in my athletes getting them, right, if I'm prescribing that sort of number, and there's still going to be some variability around it. And I think that's, you know, the beauty and like RIR, think is the subjectiveness. People see that as like a bug. don't think just because something is subjective, it means it's a flaw. I think, you know, that allows you to order regulate your training. allows you to learn, allows you to get better. So just because you miss one set today and it's just a little bit off, it wasn't as hard as you as it really should have been. Well, fine, let's just make sure we get it on the next set or we'll get it next week. I guess to prevent this issue from happening, I like to allocate that strive zone range. So like I said, I'm telling my clients keep zero to two reps in reserve. Make sure you are in that range when you finish your sets. I'm increasing the chances of them being there because really all they have to do to get there is ensure their rep speed is slowing off to the point where they're not even sure if they can do the next rep. Like, know, when you're finishing your sets, you're probably like, I actually don't know if I was the next one. I might, maybe I could get it, but I'm really not sure if I could get it. And if you're thinking like that, you're probably within that zero to RIR range. Now, of course, if You had Brandon Kempter standing beside you yelling in your ear, well, all of a sudden your arousal levels increase and you might be able to do another rep, but you don't always have him by your side. So that doesn't even matter. It's like you can only do what you can do with the amount of arousal you have going into a session. Right? Does that make sense? Like you can always, your ability to push can always be amplified, but at the end of the day, you have to work with what you've got in the training session that
you're doing.
Jacob Herrmann: Yeah.
Martin Refalo: So yeah, from the research that I've conducted, it seems that when you test people who are trained and you tell them to predict RIR, they can be quite accurate. ⁓ At least if they have a long training experience and if they have used RIR or RP in the past, they can be quite accurate. But yeah, that always leaves the door open for some uncertainty. And I think that is an issue to an extent, especially with ⁓ people who want to maximize muscle growth, right, but just aren't really there yet with their ability to push. All right, so some are, yeah, you are. Some of my clients are, but some aren't. And those are the ones that, for example, on the last set of every exercise, I might say, hey, I want you to go to all our failure. Or on these two sets, on these exercises, you just, you got to push to failure on those two sets. Those are prescriptions that I definitely give, I give all the time. But just because you prescribed by two sets of failure on one exercise doesn't mean the whole program has to look like that. You know, there's room to move. There's flexibility around the prescriptions, which I think is, again, that's the beauty of using RIR and it's the beauty of being a coach. It's like you have options and you need to use your tools wisely for your clients. So I think it's those clients who do want to maximize growth, but just aren't really there yet with their intensity that, okay, those are the ones that We need to push the value more often, right? We have to prescribe sets to value. They need a training partner. They need to record their footage and watch over it. But yeah, someone like Sam, someone like yourself, I've watched your training videos. It's like, if I tell you to stop at a certain hour, I'm gonna be pretty confident that you're gonna get there.
Jacob Herrmann: And this is where, you know, like science and art crosses over with coaching where, you know, maybe that individual isn't quite there with that skill. So prescribing a set to nothing in the tank is potentially a good thing long-term. But when you, yeah.
Martin Refalo: Yeah, it just just just quickly as well just a buy in just because you tell someone to push the set to failure, doesn't mean they're actually going to get there. It's kind of like telling someone to eat less. It's like, well, it's kind of open ended, like even telling someone to push the failure is open ended because, know, most some people will be able to do and get to the point where they involuntary terminate their sets involuntarily terminate their sets, but others just won't. Like if you had a thousand people and you said you push yourself to failure on this set, like how many are actually going to be able to push there on their own? So it's a matter of prescribing that and then providing the parameters and the instructions for them to actually get there. And if you're an in-person coach, well, okay, providing the motivation, the arousal, the queuing to
get your client to where they need to be. it's a bit more than just giving that simple instruction, right?
Jacob Herrmann: Yeah. The, was reminded of a moment in Bangkok. BK was on pendulum squat and I think he was, he did two rest pause sets after a straight set and he had Ben, the individual who organized the camp. And this is while Brandon was on his, I think it was 10 to 15 seconds he took between the rest pause sets. And you had Ben screaming in his ear. This is why you're great. This is why you have this greatness. This is why you're the best. And the way it flowed off his tongue, it was like he was speaking from a book and you know, someone had sat down for 15 minutes to think about the way you'd put these words together. And like just the, the energy and the amount of arousal I know that was being ensued was ridiculous. And I've had an experience like that. I know there was a photo, there was a photo.
Martin Refalo: I love that. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah. should have recorded it.
Jacob Herrmann: It's on BK's social. ⁓ But I remember in my first year of sports science, the lecturer were doing a ⁓ prac in the gym. He asked, does anyone want to go for a one RM on a bench press? And I, no one else put their hand up. So was like, well, stuff it. Let me give this a crack. So I went for a one RM and the encouragement was null.
Martin Refalo: Okay.
Jacob Herrmann: There was no encouragement for anyone, but just the fact you had 30 people watching you created this sense of urgency. And I could definitely feel a heart rate was higher. There was maybe a little bit more ⁓ adrenaline going on potentially, but it makes a big difference. ⁓ Yeah. So training partners, especially if maybe you're not quite there with that skill could make a big difference too.
Martin Refalo: Okay. Yes. Yes. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah, I agree. I think training partners are invaluable. Whether that's being coached by someone, mean they're virtually your training partner, or finding someone to do sessions with. Even if they're not yelling, they don't have to yell at you every rep all the time. Like just having someone there, like you said, literally someone watching. someone being there, maybe guiding you through the set, giving you that motivation when you need, even that's gonna allow you to raise your standard. when, yeah, it's a recommendation that I give, I mean, some people can't, they're trying to find them, it's like, where are you gonna find a training partner who wants to come out at 5 a.m.? But it's definitely a recommendation that I like to give now and then, for sure.
Jacob Herrmann: Yeah, absolutely. Now we could speak about this with regards to training volume, but I want to switch over to protein intakes. ⁓ So just like training, there's like a set of recommendations to potentially find a starting point for. With regards to protein intake, do you think there's a large range for
Martin Refalo: Okay.
Jacob Herrmann: people's response to different protein intakes and potentially, you know, using different intakes for different phases. And would you, and would you go about it from a performance perspective? Maybe you go, okay, we start, we start on this protein intake, performance is going pretty well. Would you consider saying, Hey, to the athlete, let's give a slightly lower protein intake approach. We're still within the recommended range, but
Martin Refalo: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Jacob Herrmann: we're gonna have more carbohydrates available.
Martin Refalo: Yeah, yeah, I like that. I think protein intake ⁓ is an area that over the years we've definitely learned more about. But there are still gaps in the research, at least when it comes to specific context dependent scenarios. Right. So you if you think about kind of what bodybuilders have been doing for the longest time possible, they've just been stuffing their face with protein, right? And two, three to four grams times body weight is something that you'll often see, right, bodybuilders do. I remember both the preps that I did when I was 20 and 21, I was eating, I was eating like 200 to 220 grams of protein. which doesn't sound like much. I only recently kind of wrapped my head around this when I was doing research in the area last year, but at the time I was only like 60 to 70 kilos. I was like 65 kilo like at my, my comp weight was 65 kilos and I was eating that much protein. So that's like nearly four times body weight, right? Three to four times body weight. So yeah, I was doing research last year looking at the impact of protein intake on muscle retention or lean mass retention and the deficit. And I realized that, okay, this is an area that, yeah, it be cool to see more research in. We have a bit of research we can kind of use to put something together. And it seemed to show that more protein does seem to be more beneficial for lean mass retention in an energy deficit, which makes sense, which does layer on top of our like foundational understanding of how like an energy deficit may impact muscle protein synthesis and... and other like physiological pathways that ⁓ influence muscle retention. And, you know, that doesn't mean that more protein is better like linearly, you know, to infinity and beyond. It's like there's always diminishing returns. Our human physiology ⁓ it involves the initial returns on so many different levels. And, you know, we want a protein intake that as athletes, as bodybuilders, we want a protein intake that isn't just the recommended daily intake, because the recommended daily intake is just going to cover off a of the key, you know, bases that we need to be healthy. We want an intake that's going to maximize growth or at least allow us to get more growth. out of the training stimulus we're inducing. And we want to make sure that that intake isn't hampering our ability to consume other macronutrients and isn't hampering our like just physiological health because you know, there's an idea out there that
eating protein can impact like your renal health, for example, which doesn't seem to be the case, even at protein intakes of like four grams times body weight. So that's why we need to answer these questions, right? It's because we want to be, we want to be somewhere in the middle there. If we have too much protein, well, that might impact your ability to consume carbohydrate, ⁓ which is an issue. I don't personally, I don't view protein as a macronutrient that will facilitate performance. I will rarely change someone's protein intake based on what phase they're in. ⁓ The key phase that I will change someone's protein intake is usually going from like a build to a long-term contest prep because I know they're to get really lean fat loss phase, whatever. I'll usually increase protein intake. Recently, I've become a fan of just whatever protein intake I think that they're going to be on in their prep or that I want them on their prep. So I'll just tell them to start on it now, even in their building phase. So hey, this is what we're going do. bit higher, but that's because I want you higher down the track. I want you to start on it now. And I don't care as much about, yeah, calories, like, yes, even more protein is going to bring your calories up now. You're in a build. I don't care too much about protein coming from calories coming from protein. That is right. So that's a strategy that I've been using as of late. I think, yeah.
Jacob Herrmann: Martin, have you been calculating that from stage weight or just body weight at that point in time?
Martin Refalo: I use like the average, like I use like the median of whatever weight they're going to be in in their comp rep. So if they start at 80 and I think they're going to finish at 70, I'll give a factor that base like 75. Yeah. So that's, that's just the way I do it. But again, like this, as coaches, you have to come up with your own way of making decisions about these things. Cause you're not going to find these decisions in the textbook. You're not going to find these frameworks. Um, some you will, some you won't. ⁓ So I think a general range for people looking to build muscle, I think like two grams should be something that times ⁓ body weight. Two grams times body weight is something that we should be able to aim for. I think it's realistic. I think you're to be sure that you're 100 % sure that you're covering all bases and it's not going to really hamper your consumption of other macronutrients. Like yes, maybe Maybe in like five years time, all this cool research will come out that will say, it doesn't actually matter. If you have 1.5 times body weight, it's actually fine. ⁓ Going up to two doesn't give you anything. doesn't make it worse off. just doesn't make things any better. I'd still be okay with giving my clients, mean, okay, the fact that I'd be giving my clients two times their body weight for the past five years. Like it's okay. ⁓ Because there does seem to be some research that shows
like even lower it takes can be beneficial for like muscle tension and muscle growth. But again, we're thinking, well, what can we do to maximize this scenario? So I would just err on the side of around two grams per kilogram of body weight. I think it's a simple one to follow and possibly even higher in an energy deficit. At least when the goal is to get lean because there might be an interaction there between body fat levels and protein intake and muscle retention, right? That interaction might exist. That is to say that the leaner you get, the more important protein intake becomes.
Jacob Herrmann: Do you think that, I mean you mentioned a couple of reasons why it becomes more important to have a higher protein intake in a contest prep. I know one of them is, you there's a down regulation of nutrient partitioning. ⁓ And you mentioned something about NPS. Could you go into a bit more detail about that if you have a good understanding of it?
Martin Refalo: Yeah, the thing is when you get lean and the reason I conducted the ⁓ meta-analysis last year on the impact of protein on muscle tension is because there are some reasons to possibly be concerned about muscle tension when you are in an energy deficit that is causing you to get down to low body fat levels. Decrease in muscle protein synthesis is the easiest one. That's the first one. So even a moderate energy deficit can reduce muscle protein synthesis, synthesis like up to like 20%. We know there's also hormonal down regulation as you get leaner. So important hormones that can impact muscle protein synthesis and that can just impact the growth response in general will plummet in contest prep. Energy availability in and of itself. So the fact that ⁓ our ability to kind of distribute energy across the body and towards vital organs and vital functions starts to diminish. That means that our body is becoming more conservative with energy and it has to be a little strategic with what it actually spends energy on. So it might spend less energy on anabolic processes. And again, the leaner you get, the more ⁓ prominent this effect might become. ⁓ Insulin sensitivity, nutrient, nutrient partitioning, there's a whole host of other things that happen as you get leaner that again, make us concerned about muscle retention. And that's why training has to be dialed in. And that's why we worry about protein intake in a contest prep. Yeah, there are physiological reasons to think that more protein may help ⁓ in a long-term energy deficit. Some of the research I've conducted does point towards that as well. But again, we just have to, practitioners, it's like, okay, that's our physiological understanding, that's our research-based understanding of how things work. But like you said before, where does that science then cross with the art? the art of coaching. need to, you know, they do cross paths. We have to think about what's worked well for us, what's worked well with our clients in the past. What am I comfortable prescribing my clients, right? What am I comfortable with them doing and what are they comfortable with doing as well? Because some people might not be comfortable doing things that you tell them to do, like eating a whole bunch of protein. So that's where the science really does cross paths with the art ⁓ of coaching.
Jacob Herrmann: Martin, thank you very much for your time today. I greatly appreciate you sitting down with a young chap like me and imparting some knowledge and hopefully, I think last episode we got two and a half listeners. So this one was driving for three. So hopefully we can wrap up a few extra people on board. Yeah. Well, always looking to be better than the last time, right? And progression. Yeah.
Martin Refalo: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Love that. Let's push for three. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, that's it. Progressive overload, yeah.
Jacob Herrmann: Maybe next week we'll have a stall, but who knows? Well, mate, if you've got training, I hope you have a good session and have an awesome rest of your day.
Martin Refalo: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, I'll head to the gym in a second actually. Yeah, awesome. Thanks so much for having me on, mate. I look forward to seeing how your podcast goes and maybe I'll be on again in the future.
Jacob Herrmann: Thanks man, I hope you will be and I'll probably see you around at some of the shows.
Martin Refalo: No worries, thank you.
Jacob Herrmann: See you man.