TRANSCRIÇÃO 🔗
00:00:01
Speaker 1: This is twenty four a weekly highlight reel from the Clay Travis and Buck Sexton Show featuring all things the election coverage.
00:00:10
Speaker 2: Let's get started. Here are Clay and Buck. Trump remains on trial in New York City. Lots of construction workers, big Trump fans, a lot of positivity there. But I want to play for you the big story here. And I went and read the New York Times coverage just to confirm that, Yeah, the hearing went about like Buck and.
00:00:38
Speaker 3: I told you that it did.
00:00:40
Speaker 2: Because if even the Supreme Court headline on the New York Times is conservative majority seems ready to limit election case against Trump, such a ruling would probably send it back to a lower court and delay any trial until after the November election. So if the New York Times is telling you a couple of hours later what Buck and I told you at the top of the show was likely to be the case, I'm even more convinced that our analysis of this is on point, because this is not what the New York Times wants to write. This is not what the New York Times wants to report. And Buck, I pulled one line that I thought was interesting from the New York Times article here, and I do think it's significant.
00:01:32
Speaker 3: We're writing a rule for the ages.
00:01:37
Speaker 2: Justice Gore Sutch said, a lot of focus on Trump, deservedly so, but whatever precedent is put in place here, the principle of that precedent will apply for years and years to come. And we've got some audio that I think goes a long way towards establishing exactly what I am talking about. From Justice Gorsuch himself, I want to start this is earlier today. What exact presidential immunity might Trump have as it pertains to the charges brought by Jack Smith?
00:02:11
Speaker 3: How do you draw that line? Where should the line be?
00:02:15
Speaker 2: Gorsuch talks about the history here and says, I want to think about how this will apply going forward.
00:02:22
Speaker 3: Listen to Cut twenty four.
00:02:23
Speaker 4: The same thing in Nixon, we said, Gosh, Nixon versus Fitzgerald, that's something court shouldn't get engaged in because presidents have all manner of motives. And again, I'm not concerned about this case, but I am concerned about future uses of the criminal law to target political opponents based on accusations about their motives, whether it's reelection or who knows what corrupt means in fifteen twelve. Right, we don't know what that means. Maybe we'll find out sometime soon. But the dangerousness of accusing you're a political opponent, of having bad motives, and if that's enough to overcome your core powers or any other limits.
00:03:07
Speaker 2: Fabulously well said Buck. I mean, that's gorsiic. I've got a couple more I want to play. But this goes to we're not just deciding Trump. We're deciding what the precedent should be for presidents that will serve hopefully long into the future after anyone listening to this right now is gone.
00:03:23
Speaker 5: Who's your favorite justice on the Court right now?
00:03:27
Speaker 3: It's a great question.
00:03:30
Speaker 5: I'll just for me, it's Alito or Thomas, but occasionally Gorsich gets to me kind of excited.
00:03:35
Speaker 3: But Alito or Thomas.
00:03:37
Speaker 2: I think it's Gorsich because my and this is me talking as a lawyer, and maybe it's a little bit of a romantic thought, but what I like about Supreme Court cases is not deciding challenging issues of today. It's when they're so incredibly well crafted that two hundred years from now you could read them and you could say this principle still applies as a clarion call for liberty along end of the future. And I think a lot of justices get captured by the emotional wins of the moment. For instance, when we had Soda Mayor asking questions about the mandate on the COVID shot and she couldn't even get the facts right. Remember she said, there's like one hundred thousand kids currently hospitalized with COVID and she they were.
00:04:28
Speaker 5: So wrong, probably wearing two masks during the oral arguments. So that tells well, I mean, and I think that factors in here. It takes a particular type of intellect to be contemplating not only what you're deciding today, but how that principle will apply years in the future. And that, to me is what the job of a Supreme Court should be. And that ties in with this cut here Alito, who you just cited, well one sec before we get to Aledo, I just to follow up on the on the Gorsage point, there's a difference between what you want and what is just right. What you want is in emotion, it's at any moment in time, and that has to do with outcome to your point about not just this but future cases. It has to be able to stand so that there is an understanding of where the guidelines, where the rules, the UH guardrails are for a future president. Because if presidential conduct that is clearly presidential conduct that you know does not involve some external breaking of law, can be criminalized based on corrupt desire within the conduct, then you could have somebody prosecuted for any act this president that you don't like as as soon as you know, you decide to do so, right, I mean that, yeah, this is the this is the real challenge. If you're just going to read the mind of a president. You know, oh, well, he he didn't pardon that person because he thought that, you know, he should. Now pardons are interesting, aren't they? Because pardons are because it gets a little bit of a you know, what is the quid pro quo? But you have to look at whether or not it's presidential conduct, whether it goes to what the president's duties are supposed to be. I think that Gorsich understands that this is because it's the first time they're looking at it, because the implications. They have to get this right, which is why I think they'll take a very narrow and minimal act on action on it. Now you have Aledo, my favorite probably.
Load full transcript
00:06:19
Speaker 2: Jeddie Thomas Cut twenty three. Here this is important for those of you who are not students of history. One of the I think most indefensible decisions of the World War II era. Everybody wants to debate now, should we have dropped the bomb? That's been turned into a big discussion. My answer is yes, it was a right decision to drop the bomb on Japan at Hiroshima and Nagasaki, but we had containment camps in the United States for Japanese Americans and it took years for the court to come out and say, actually, sorry, we shouldn't have done that. I believe this is the lawyer. It's been a while since the bast of bar Koramatsu is the case that said this was wrong. And Alito says, okay, let's look at the scope of history. Could FDR have been prosecuted for putting Japanese Americans in concentration camps?
00:07:10
Speaker 3: Listen to Cut three twenty three.
00:07:11
Speaker 6: Mister Sauer and others have identified events in the past where presidents have engaged in conduct that might have been charged as a federal crime. And you say, well, no, that's not really true. This is page forty two of your brief. So what about President Franklin D. Roosevelt's decision to in turn Japanese Americans during World War Two? Couldn't that have been charged under eighteen USC. Two forty one conspiracy against civil rights?
00:07:39
Speaker 2: Today?
00:07:40
Speaker 7: Yes, given this court's decision in Trump versus United States, in which you know Trump versus Hawaiian excuse me, where the court said Coramatsu is overruled and President Roosevelt made that decision with the advice of his Attorney general.
00:07:57
Speaker 3: I mean, the point is a really good one.
00:08:01
Speaker 2: FDR obviously died in Powder Springs, Georgia. Correct me if I'm wrong, crew in nineteen forty four, right after basically his re election.
00:08:08
Speaker 3: I think I'm a.
00:08:09
Speaker 5: Pretty good memory. Poll there, Powder Springs, Georgia.
00:08:11
Speaker 3: Look at you.
00:08:12
Speaker 2: Well, I'm making sure that I'm right. But so, he couldn't have been prosecuted because he died. But let's pretend that in another world FDR lives until nineteen sixty four. What if a prosecutor had decided after he left the presidency as we now recognize coramats who was the poor decision? Another good example I read in the Wall Street Journal this morning. A lot of people forget Abraham Lincoln did away with the writ of habeas corpus during the Civil War. He defied his Supreme Court and he said I can put anybody in prison for any reason under my war powers while the Civil War is going on.
00:08:52
Speaker 5: That said, it's actually illegal.
00:08:56
Speaker 3: You know, I think it's actually illegal. I mean, you know, as much as we all like Lincoln.
00:09:00
Speaker 2: A lot, that's the point here is is that even though it's an illegal act, and we later find out the Supreme Court says that FDR shouldn't have been able to do the concentration camps,
where do you draw the line?
00:09:13
Speaker 8: Now?
00:09:13
Speaker 2: They tried to say, well, his Attorney General said this was all right. I think we call them internment camps, not concentration camps, I think generally.
00:09:21
Speaker 5: Right, although I know it's a similar kind, just to differentiate, right, Yeah.
00:09:25
Speaker 3: Well, they weren't killing.
00:09:26
Speaker 2: Uh that's a good question. What is the difference between a concentration camp and internment camp. But regardless, they weren't trying to put the Japanese Americans to death. They were just trying to restrict them from aiding Japan during World War Two. And also there were restrictions given to different a German population was so much larger it was not conceivable to have done that. But there were a lot of investigations into German American groups to see whether they were loyal to Germany or the United States. The reason why I bring this all up is where do you draw the line?
00:09:57
Speaker 3: Now?
00:09:57
Speaker 2: She tried to say, the Attorney General told FDR he could do it, so well, that's an interesting argument then, too, because then the argument is, well, if the conspiracy is big enough, then you're telling me that there is no criminal culpability.
00:10:12
Speaker 8: So if the.
00:10:12
Speaker 2: Attorney General agrees that the president's misbehaving, well what about the president found advisors to give him advice that he wanted to hear, because you could, you know, buck, you brief the president when you're the president of the United States, if you ask enough people if you can do something sooner or later, somebody will say, yeah, you can.
00:10:29
Speaker 3: Do it, sir.
00:10:30
Speaker 5: It's even worse than that because in the government bureaucracy, and I can tell you from the CIA to DNI office you name it, DA, NSA, NNGA will name all the different agencies. You figure out a lot of times this is what people do. What the president wants to hear, and that's what you tell him, because you're the one that gets invited back, You're the one that has access, and you're the one that gets promoted.
00:10:51
Speaker 2: Yes, men get promoted. Yes men get promoted. This is why we're positions of power. Is difficult to make good decisions because eventually you get so powerful that everybody tells you're a genius. And this is how the emperor has no clothes. He's walking around everybody lies to him. Okay, My point on this is, if you really study history, Trump will not be the last president that the opposing political party will try to put in prison. And this is why I'll give us ring the bell here a little bit of praise. You and I from the moment they raided mar A Lago in August of twenty twenty two, and Alan Dershowitz, there's very few people who actually are staying committed to principle, said, this is an awful precedent because once you set a new principle, once you set a new president, others will follow it. So as soon as the FBI
showed up and rated mar A Lago and as soon as these charges started my belief is the only way to really snuff this idea in the bud. One is the Supreme Court. I should say, there's a couple Supreme Court has been decent on this so far. The other one is there need to be political consequences. Trump needs to kick Joe Biden's ass to such an extent that people out there say, oh wow, this wouldn't have happened but for Biden trying to put Trump in prison for the rest of his life, he was very going to be the lesson in six months.
00:12:14
Speaker 5: It is very hard to see at least what is trending right now in all of the polls and not think that at this point a majority of the American people are rejecting. Wait you look, you look.
00:12:28
Speaker 2: I just got a text. I want to apologize to America.
00:12:31
Speaker 3: I thought it was power. Are we sure?
00:12:33
Speaker 2: It's not powder springs too? It's warm springs And it was not take history nerd card for the rest of the time. This is this is a shot across springs.
00:12:46
Speaker 5: How dare you, sir?
00:12:47
Speaker 2: I think that powder springs and warm springs are the same thing. It's like Antietam and UH and the UH and the UH and the sharps Place next to it. Well, it's like one. It's a river. And you know that's how they named Civil War battlefields. The North went with the UH went with the river closest or the stream closest, and the South went with the city. So you get like Manassas versus bull Run, and you get Sharpsburg versus Antietam. Sometimes they agreed because there wasn't water really close. It's just Gettysburg.
00:13:19
Speaker 3: I need to do it.
00:13:19
Speaker 2: I'm gonna go to the I'm gonna go to the instant replay here.
00:13:23
Speaker 3: But I apologize. I did get the year wrong for sure.
00:13:28
Speaker 1: If you're listening to twenty four The Year of Impact with Clay.
00:13:33
Speaker 3: And Buck.
00:13:35
Speaker 5: Our guest, you all know her, Julie Kelly with us now check out Declassified. You can subscribe to that on sub stack. That is Julie's publication there. It is excellent. I read it, Clay reads it. Julie, thanks for being here with us. I wanted to just jump into this. A lot of legal action going on today, big Supreme Court case Herd going right to the heart of presidential immunity, the J six case against Trump. Here is the headline from the New York Times wanted to have your reaction to it. After hearing oral arguments this morning, conservative majority seems ready to limit election case against Trump. Julie, I feel like I'm surprised that I'm gonna have to say this, but from the New York Times lips to Trump's ear, I mean, sorry, to God's here's uh, what do you think?
00:14:25
Speaker 6: Well?
00:14:25
Speaker 9: I think that they are probably right. And here's why. Because the big debate centered around official acts as president versus personal or even private acts, and there was a lot of discussion back and forth as to what represents an official act what doesn't, and of course that creates a whole slippery slope which several of the justices, at least Kavanagh or Sachilido had indicated serious concerns about you know who then becomes the referee as to what's official or a core function versus political, personal, private. And so going back to the indictment, and I really need to underscore this claim book, we're talking about four counts. Okay, they talked a lot about murder, they talked about bribery, about initiating a coup, killing people. That is not what this indictment is about. It's really important for people to be reminded. We're talking about four of the most vague statutes on the books, two of which we talked about last week in the Supreme Court addressed fifteen twelve C two obstruction of an official proceeding extremely vague, and then two very vague conspiracy statutes. So these are not clear cut laws crimes, murder, bribery, drug trafficking, the things that we would expect a president to face criminal prosecution for. So in the indictment, there are certainly elements that are completely within the president's purview, such as replacing and acting Attorney general with somebody else, which is what he considered replacing Jeffrey Rosen with Jeffrey Clark. There are other things that fall under official acts. Things get a little murkier. Even John Sower, who is representing Donald Trump, admitted that okay, calling using private attorneys calling up political parties or officials to conceive or encourage them to come up with alternative states of electors that might fall under personal slash politicals. So I think that that's what the New York Times and others are hinting at, is that the indictment itself could have to be narrowed down determining whether it's Jack Smithard. This gets kicked back to Judge Chuckkin, Tommy Chuckkin, who was the one who originated the order to niging immunity, and then she has to figure out official versus personal hold some sort of evidentiary hearing to determine what falls under official what falls under personal a private.
00:17:00
Speaker 2: My biggest takeaway for the particulars of the timing here, Julie, is that there's virtually no chance now that any case other than the case that is currently proceeding in New York City is going to be decided before November fifth.
00:17:17
Speaker 3: That is a jury.
00:17:18
Speaker 2: Ruling based on the arguments today, and there are a lot more issues at scope than just Trump. And we'll maybe get to that with you in a sec But would you agree with me that it's Alvin Bragg and then it's to the voters in terms of law fair and what's going to be complete?
00:17:35
Speaker 10: I do?
00:17:36
Speaker 9: I mean, we still obviously have the Southern Florida case prodding along, but and there is a slim possibility that could go to trial before the election. But look, Clay to your question, if the Supreme Court kicks this back to the District Court to Judge chuck In and says
you need to hold these hearings to figure out what falls wear. They also have some choice words for the Circuit Court. I don't know if you guys caught that. Chief Justice John Roberts not pleased with that three judge panel's decision, calling it tautological, you know, basically circular reasoning that they use to uphold Judge Chuckkin's ruling. So if they kick that back, Clay, let's say they do wait until the end of June or even the end of May.
00:18:23
Speaker 3: Sorry to cut you off.
00:18:24
Speaker 2: By the way, I wouldn't be stunned if they put this ruling come out on July third, the day before the July fourth holiday, just to kind of bury it into that, just to sorry to cut you off. I was looking at the calendar. That's kind of it's the last case they're basically hearing. That could be a possibility if they wanted to hold it as long as possible.
00:18:44
Speaker 8: True that the.
00:18:45
Speaker 9: Under their term is June. But to your point, Clay, they can issue orders I believe after that. So let's see that they do kicks back to chuck Kin, you know, after fourth of July week is over, and she immediately orders We're going to hold enough entrary hearing two three weeks after that, you have to file your emotions response, et cetera. You know, they really start to run out of time. But I'm going to posit something even more terrifying than what we've talked about is going to trial in j six before the election. Is putting Donald Trump on trial after the election. Just imagine for a moment that they have the evidentiary hearings. Chuck Kin decides, Okay, this part of the indictment, These acts are official, these aren't. It gets you know, runs, it runs the gamut, and then they toss it back. Okay, this is settled. He can go on trial for private personal apps, and here are the ones that we determined. Then can you go to trial the end of November December early January. Even if Trump went, especially if he wins, that's another nightmare scenario that could be created by but.
00:19:54
Speaker 3: He would be able to pardon himself.
00:19:56
Speaker 2: Then in that case, if he won, even if he putent actually got convicted. You're right, I mean, this is this is honestly, and I don't know why we still do this. I don't know why we have such a long period what you're hitting at, Julie, November fifth until January I'm not sure twentieth or whatever the date is when the officials. Yeah, I mean, that's a long time for a defeated president to remain in office. Historically it used to not be till March, but that was because you had to travel long distances.
00:20:26
Speaker 5: It's also time, you know, they have a transition that they're trying to prepare for, and you know, I think it's meant to ease the situation, and they didn't prepare for four now going on really five criminal indictments against one of the candidates to be apart.
00:20:39
Speaker 2: But I mean, I think it did that that like kind of a bayance area, there is is kind of a mess,
is.
00:20:43
Speaker 5: Julun to ask you about? You know, this is another one of these things. It's kind of buried today. It's a big deal on any other day. But the Supreme Court arguments about whether the president could order a coup and effectively undo the constitutional order or not, et cetera, are are pretty interesting. But eleven of the electors have been indicted in Arizona. The Arizona AG put out a video today Chris mays, what do you make of this? Like, they didn't indict Trump, they indicted Mark Meadows, And you know, it seems to be somewhat in parallel to or somewhat similar to the Georgia case, at least in terms of some of the conduct.
00:21:25
Speaker 3: What do you make of all this?
00:21:27
Speaker 9: I mean, look, I tweetd this last night and I hate to say it. You have to envy how Democrats understand how to coordinate, conspire and leverage their political power. Here's a guy who probably really didn't or woman who really probably didn't even really win the Arizona Attorney General's race, but it doesn't matter, because as soon as they take office, they leverage and weaponize their power against their political foes. I haven't had a time to go through the whole indictment, just getting ready for today, but you know, this is Georgia, this is Michigan. This is all to bolster the idea. But even though Trump is a unindicted co conspirator, it is to bolster what's happening here in this j sixth federal case. And it's also a signal. And we heard a little bit about this today, Emy Conibert really is disappointing. But to continue to raise the idea that asking for or having others create alternative electoral certificates is a crime, which it hasn't. The National Archive is told Congress we get fake electoral or manufactured, made up alternative electoral certificates every presidential election. This is not new. So to criminalize it is also to warn people if you protest in any way the twenty twenty four election, whatever happens, whatever stunts you want to pull, whatever you want to do to demonstrate against let's say Joe Biden gets re elected, we are going to use our law fair against you, and there's nothing to stop them. So this is really to i think, add more optics ulster the political and public view that there's something really criminal about concocting or pretending that you're, you know, sending an alternative electoral certificate. Just ridiculous. But so again, such dangerous descent where we are headed using this lawfair not just federally but state power too.
00:23:32
Speaker 2: Julie, last question for you. You mentioned South Florida. You've been covering that case. Judge Eileen Cannon has allowed a large amount of previously censored materials to be allowed to be displayed publicly. What should we know that is significant about what that has uncovered?
00:23:54
Speaker 9: We should know And I want to give kudos again to Judge Cannon. I know we've talked a lot about her, but it has it reveals and this is why Jacksmith wanted all of this concealed. It reveals Joe Biden's White House, including some of his top attorneys in his General Counsel's office, working collaboratively with the DATE, DOJ and Archives to manufacture a records slash documents case against Donald Trump. This completely flies in the face of what Smith Jacksmith has alleged in his indictment there, but also what we've been told that Joe Biden and his White House is completely hands off from this prosecution, so they were deeply involved, same players, DOJ, FBI, the Archives, the intelligence community. This is like getting the Russia Gate fy the gate bound back together. So kudos to her. There's going to be more unfeelings today. I will be posting later juliannderscore Kelly two, which is the grand jury transcript of the of Walteene, Nada, Trump's close personal aid. Also who has been charged in that case as well.
00:24:59
Speaker 2: J we should mention, by the way, Buck that took place in Washington, d C. Before they then flipped to the proceeding all the way down to South Florida, so that Judge Cannon wasn't in charge of this.
00:25:10
Speaker 5: Julie Kelly substack. You can all subscribe Julie real quick before I let you go. I know Clay said last question, but I'm throwing a last question because I'm really curious. What do you think the biggest legal risk for Trump is now? Of all of the cases and scenarios.
00:25:29
Speaker 9: I mean, right now, I have to think what's happening in New York.
00:25:32
Speaker 5: Unfortunately, I thought you might say that because Clay and I were just talking about that. This Actually I think what we see happening puts more pressure on them to get even crazier in New York City where they just have full control and there's really no oversight. Go check out Julie's substack. Everybody declassified.
00:25:48
Speaker 3: Julie.
00:25:48
Speaker 5: Always appreciate you being with us.
00:25:50
Speaker 9: Thanks, guys, have a good day.
00:25:52
Speaker 3: You know that I like to look and Julie's phenomenal.
00:25:54
Speaker 2: I'd encourage all of you to go follow everything that Julie Kelly's been saying, she has been in turn terms of analysis and trying to look in the direction that we are going better than almost anybody out there. Everybody was ridiculing the idea that the Supreme Court was going to take up this obstruction case as to whether or not it could be applied from a business perspective passed for sarbains Oxley being used on jan six cases.
00:26:20
Speaker 3: She was right, they're going to strike it down. I think she's right that there is.
00:26:26
Speaker 2: Only going to be now one case completed before we get to November, which makes me wonder Buck and I do think that everybody needs to prepare for this as the realization starts to set in that all of this legal wrangling. They thought we're going to have Donald Trump in court March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October, November, all the way up to election day.
We're going to hit him with federal charges. There's going to be major convictions, and Joe Biden's going to ride into the sunset and win. Now, they're probably not gonna get Trump in court at all. I don't think in terms of daily until I mean, let's say this case ends Buck mid June. Something like that may end up sooner than that. They may or may not get a conviction. But I think what you're gonna see as a result is, and we've been hinting at this, but I think you need to prepare for it. They're going to dial up the crazy in terms of the punishment that they're going to try to get on Trump as they become aware, uh oh, this is the only bite at the apple we're gonna get.
00:27:37
Speaker 5: They are they would be doing so much. I agree with that assessment. You and I talked about it, you brought it up. I agree. Julie comes on, She says it without knowing that we had just agreed on this one, which makes me feel like, this is what the trend certainly is right now, or this is where the momentum is. New York, which was the first one to go, the easiest for them to bring in terms of they were basically guaranteed full control over the process because of the jurisdiction and because of the far left progressive prosecutor Alvin Bragg, who is calling the shots there. But the damage that they will do to any faith that we could have in our legal system if they're able to use New York as this weapon. The charges in New York are a joke, an unfunny joke, but they're preposterous. I wouldn't put anyone in prison, nor convict anyone, any human being. If Alvin Bragg himself were sitting there charged with doing what Trump is doing, and I were on that jury, I would not convict him.
00:28:45
Speaker 3: It's wrong.
00:28:47
Speaker 5: It's wrong what they are doing. The charges are wrong. The stacking them the way they've done it is wrong. The delaying it's so that it comes in the election year is wrong. Clay, top to bottom in excusable, and now it's looking more and more like that's their great hope to defeat Donald Trump. That's how they're going to get four more years for Joe Biden the business records charge in New York.
00:29:16
Speaker 1: You're listening to twenty four the most Important Tier in politics with Clay, Travis and box Sexton.
00:29:26
Speaker 5: Cash Puttel is joining US former DoD chief of staff, former federal prosecutor, and public defender. He has selected sixty juries for trial service. Cash been a bit my friend.
00:29:42
Speaker 10: How you doing, Hey, great to be with you guys. Thanks for having me.
00:29:46
Speaker 5: Yeah, man, absolutely, So let's start the two big news items today. A lot of campus anti Israel stuff, but also the Trump trial that is going on, which is in some ways it's hard to believe even though it's happening. This is where we are as a country. This is what's happening, this is what's underway. What's your sense of ben, I'd start with this. Do you feel like there's any chance that anyone on this jury might be fairly disposed toward the truth of this case and Donald Trump in general.
00:30:20
Speaker 10: Look, there's always a chance, but there's a reason I live in Las Vegas and don't gamble as often as I used to, and people are gambling on this trial.
00:30:28
Speaker 8: Will probably lose.
00:30:29
Speaker 10: The reality is what is happening. The tragedy is the destruction of due process. And for some reason, these prosecutors and judges have teamed up to think that the system of due process under the Constitution no longer applies to Donald Trump, or that they can selectively apply to him in pieces. And what I mean by that is just look at the opening statement today. The lead prosecutor, who used to be the number three prosecutor at the Department of Justice, he gave the opening statement. This guy Colangelo, and he said he told the jury donald Trump is here because of a criminal conspiracy related to election Trump. Now, the Constitution forbids specifically any mention of crimes, not charging the indictment to be presented to the jury. But this judge, of course lapped it up and allowed it. There is no charge of conspiracy anywhere in the indictment. And all they continue to do is shred the do process, rites of Donald Trump and that of the Constitution in the process, and weaken our system of justice.
00:31:26
Speaker 2: I think that's a really important point you just made. Who exactly is involved in this trial. The Biden administration, Joe Biden himself, many of their allies in the media. They regularly I was reading The Times this morning, laying out and Sunday laying out all their analysis and reading all their articles saying, oh, there is no grand conspiracy against Donald Trump. This is just happens to be Alvin Bragg, It just happens to be Fanny Willis. Jack Smith is totally independent. Merrick Garland's not involved in these cases. What did you just say? I think this is so important. The former number three position at the Department of Justice is now prosecuting a state court case.
00:32:09
Speaker 3: Now you have a little bit of a background in this.
00:32:11
Speaker 2: In general, wouldn't this be akin to being a major leaguer and going back to a ball? In other words, you would want to be as high as you could be in the Department of Justice number three. Overall in the DOJ, it's a big friggin deal when it comes to trial prosecution a state court in Manhattan? Is that not a crazy decent analogy and a sports perspective, it'd be like if you made the major leagues deciding to go back to single A or double A ball to prosecute a state city court crime like this.
00:32:45
Speaker 10: Yeah, as a sportsman, I love the analogy, and look, you're absolutely right. What it shows is the two tier system of justice. And just to highlight the importance of this, the number three. There's the Attorney General, the Deputy Attorney General, and then this guy who's who used Colangelo, who used to sit at the head of the civil writs the vision as
the p DAG and now he has left that job gone on to join Bragg's team, and not just quietly joined the team. He delivered the opening statement. And this guy who's been a career prosecutor who knows you cannot tell a jury about any uncharged crimes opened with just that. And that shows you the level of connective connectivity between the DOJ, the Biden administration, and Bragg's office. And so when people say, oh, no, there's no conspiracy here, well, there's no such thing as coincidences in the United States government, certainly not at Joe Biden and Merrick Garland DOJ. And now we're seeing it front and center, and this judge is allowing it all to happen.
00:33:46
Speaker 5: Speaking of Cash but Cash matel formerly of Trump's DoD he was chief of staff at the Pentagon Cash and also former federal prosecutor ysh. If they find Trump guilty, and we know that's an if we who knows where the jury's going to go with this? What do you think will happen and how quickly do you see it happening.
00:34:06
Speaker 10: Well, what's supposed to happen, especially in a case like this, is that there would be an appellate process and the defendant would remain out of custody because this is a nonviolent crime and you're talking about an individual who has literally zero criminal history, and we're talking about an instance where there are allegedly, excuse me, there are no victims of violent crimes. But what will happen here is this judge will probably take matters into his own hands, continue to create a new system of justice and try to probably imprison Donald Trump and deny him his appellate rights that the constitution allows. So it's going to be a very very unfortunate series of events if Donald Trump is convicted, because it would be unlawful and unconstitutional. But then what this judge could do to him is completely remove him from the campaign trail, which that is a clear impetus. If you've ever watched even just one day of this trial, this judge has made up his mind like Judging Gorn did in the civil case that just happened before this one. These guys have convicted Trump in the court of public opinion and are going to convict them in their own courtrooms. They're just waiting for the process to play out.
00:35:10
Speaker 2: Cash, how do you break down the other cases you've been involved in the criminal court system before on as for as crazy as this New York City case is, Thursday, we have the presidential immunity case that's being argued the oral arguments in front of the Supreme Court. Presumably sometime in June, we'll get that decision as well as the Fisher case having to do with whether or not you can prosecute for effectively impeding official proceedings, as has been occurring with many of the January sixth related charges. How does the timeline work to you for this? Do you think that the New York City case is the only one that would go all the way through and get a jury verdict or do you think there will be a possibility of another case as well between now and November fifth.
00:35:58
Speaker 10: Well, again, if we were on the normal timeline of justice, these cases would not even be charged this year. They would be charged later, and the timeline for average prosecution is two to four years. But they took the ho v lane because it's Donald Trump. Now we'll see what the Supreme Court decides, but it's unequivocally, in my opinion, executive privilege for the president who have acted in the way he did, and that should apply here. It's also another indication that Joe Biden, who personally had to dissolve executive privilege for the DOJ to bring that prosecution in DC and Florida. He had to personally get involved. So when he says I'm not involved, that's another charade. But once the Supreme Court decides on that case and also the obstructioning case, which is a very important point you bring up, the Supreme Court, I believe, is going to deny the use of the substruction statute which is from the Enron financial crimes fiasco, and they're going to throw out three hundred plus convictions related to January sixth, and that should upend the entire timeline of any of the trials sportscoming. But we don't know what these district court judges who are going to do, like Chutkin, who have already basically stated that Donald Trump is a threat to democracy and they want him removed from the electoral process.
00:37:09
Speaker 5: Speaking to Cash Patel, former federal prosecutor, Cash, Trump is facing all this stuff. How is he able to hold up under under all of it? You know, with multiple criminal prosecutions. I mean, I know you and the President are in contact, and he knows you well, and you may well be a senior figure in his next administration. Not to get too far ahead of things, but that's very possible here. How is he able to do this run for president with four absolutely insane federal or sorry felony criminal indictments three well sorry too, federal and two state against him right now.
00:37:51
Speaker 10: Yeah, you know, I was just with the President the other week and it's a you know, it's it's a conversation. Many of my conversations I don't reveal that this one I'm happy to you know. I asked him, as a president, how do you deal to this is exact question. You know, you're being falsely prosecuted, they're taking away your money, they're coming after your family, they're defaming you constantly. And his answer is really simple. He goes cash. The future of this country is at stake and he will not let it fail on his watch. And I think that drives him every single day that he wakes up and he says when the other side says, oh, Donald Trump's just in it for the money and fame, well the reality shows it's the opposite. He's fighting for everybody else's right to have fame, to have money, to have the right to be an American citizen. And that energizes it more than anything I've ever seen. And I don't think you're going to see Donald Trump, slow down. Every time they throw an arrow at
this guy, he ingested, and he becomes the juggernaut of justice and rolls down the street, whether it's in New York, d C. Florida, or elsewhere, and convinces more and more Americans that this two tier system of justice has been weaponized for political purposes. And he's asking Americans not only to recognize that, but to go to the polls in November and elect him so we can fix our constitutional republic.
00:39:02
Speaker 2: Last question for you, and I think you kind of hinted at this at the beginning. This is obviously a rigged jury that eighty seven percent of people voted against Donald Trump in this jurisdiction. Based on analyzing the twelve jurors, the six alternates, everything else, what do you think the chances are, first of all, of a not guilty verdict? Buck and I both put that at zero. Do you think there is and I'm curious if you would agree with that. Do you think there is potentially a juror on this trial that might be willing to refuse to vote to convict and essentially give what would be a win I think through a hung jury based on what you've seen based on your analysis of this case, how would you assess that probability?
00:39:46
Speaker 10: Yeah, Look, going back to my public defender days and my federal public defender days, where I defended scores of criminals in front of scores of different juries in different court rooms, we always used to say the following, you just need one. You don't need all twelve, You just need one. And that's what you guys are talking about to get to a hung jury.
00:40:02
Speaker 8: Now.
00:40:03
Speaker 10: I think the chance is that one of those twelve jurors agrees with Donald Trump's presentation of the evidence is strong. But the chance that that same juror withstands the scrutiny that is going to come at his way from the media and the rest of the jury and the world, because this is the most important criminal prosecution in literally US if history. It's not the world that may fold that juror, that may succumb him to the pressures of the outside. But if the jurors actually stuck to the facts and the law, there's no way any of the twelve would convict Donald Trump because there is no crime here. It's not a hush money case. It has to do with ledgers and payments made to a lawyer, all of which is above board. But I think Donald Trump's attorneys are looking for that one attorney, and there's a chance that they find them cash.
00:40:46
Speaker 5: But tell everybody cash. Appreciate you being with us, man, Thanks so much.
00:40:50
Speaker 10: Thanks guys, have a great day.
00:40:53
Speaker 1: You're listening to twenty more The Year of Impact with Clay and Box.
00:41:00
Speaker 5: We are looking at some interesting stuff happening in New York these days. That's probably always true, but in a political sense, particularly interesting stuff happening right now.
00:41:10
Speaker 3: I'm just gonna put this too so we can dive into it.
00:41:13
Speaker 5: Back in two thousand and eight, Barack Obama won New York that year by a twenty six point nine percent margin of victory. Okay, so am I we'll call it twenty seven points, which is you know that is a beat down for sure. I'm looking right now, Mark at the latest Siena College polling, which was just from a week ago, and the polls all compiled here on five thirty eight dot com. They've got in New York Trump v. Biden, Biden up seven points, Biden up eight points. You think something big is perhaps in the mix. What's going on here? Is this going to be competitive?
00:41:59
Speaker 1: Oh?
00:41:59
Speaker 8: No, I think Donald Trump's going to win New York. I don't think it's going to be competitive. I think he'll win it. You got to remember about two thousand and eight, McCain was whatever reason he wasn't a strong candidate, turnout for him was extremely low. So that's not the best test. And now remember Ronald Reagan won New York twice twice, so it can be done. I know that's a long time ago. But Trump is different from anybody else. He's beloved in New York by a lot of people. I know in New York City is the problem, but half the voters are outside of New York City. He's got them, and normally he'd have trouble in New York City, but a lot of that Democratic base is secretly quietly moving over to Trump. People that just don't like the crime anymore. They don't like it out of control. He goes to Harlem where that bodega is, or as Biden would say, that Bogada, and he pier's at that bodega and watch the video. Everybody in the street is cheering him. There's no booze anywhere. He goes to the construction site Park Avenue, but Remember it's working class guys, construction workers who live in New York, and they're all cheering him and chanting for him. I think he wins. I think he wins New York. All right.
00:43:10
Speaker 2: I want to dive into this because this is a bold prediction. I love bold predictions, as Buckwell knows, although I've lost on several of my bold predictions. Here, I want to hit you with a couple of fact patterns. Close race just happened to be fair. Twenty twenty two governor's race, Kathy Hokel not very popular, Lee Zelden loses fifty three to forty seven. So let me ask you this question. If Kathy Hokel and Lee Zelden ran in twenty twenty four, in other words, if we didn't have a mid term twenty twenty two election, if they were on the ballot, I presume you think Lee Zelden would win head to head against Kathy Hokel as well, and that there's been a further shift right word since he would have lost by six points two years ago.
00:43:56
Speaker 8: Yeah, I love Leezeldon. Great guy. He'd be an excellent govern not exactly the most dynamic candidate in the world, and Hokel had all that democratic momentum behind her, but people have now seen her in office for a few years, and she thinks she's absolutely awful. Between the congestion pricing, doing nothing about this anti semitism all over the campuses, doing nothing about inflation, and the state congestion pricing is
ridiculous. She sends the National Guard into the subway to protect people. It's crime down there. They have no power in the subway to do anything, so she decides to'll inspect packages or bags or I don't know, any criminal to bring his luggage with them. They don't have briefcases, they don't have persons. I don't know what they're inspecting. So yeah, Zelden could win today, and I really think Trump. You know, he said he was seven eight points behind. That was the case in almost every swing state, and he closed those gaps. He's good at closing eight percent gaps. He'll do it in New York.
00:44:57
Speaker 2: Okay, So if he wins New York, that's going to be a landslope. Do you agree with that? I mean, because he's not going to lose Pennsylvania and win New York, right, He's not going to lose Wisconsin. And win New York. He's not going to win New York and lose Michigan. I mean that would mean that he would sweep through the Midwest. He might win Minnesota. What you're saying is six months out, you think Trump is not only going to win, he's gonna win comfortably. By ten o'clock Eastern on election night, we would know who that he was the winner.
00:45:24
Speaker 8: Well, yeah, I mean, who knows what the Democrats will pull. But it's only going to get better for Donald Trump and it's only going to get worse for Joe Biden. Mentally, things will come out. I think these trials have had just the opposite effect Democrats intended. People are starting to look at these trials. I don't mean the MSNBC cret I mean normal people, and they don't like the total perversion of our justice system. They don't like any of this. It's only going to get better for Trump in the summer. You'll see momentum.
00:45:53
Speaker 5: Just do you think Biden's going to debate Mark I'm sure you saw today he said on another radio show, Oh yeah, I'll debate Trump. Trump's response to it was, no, one really believes that, right, What do you think I.
00:46:05
Speaker 8: Don't believe it. I mean, what was the exact words. I'd be happy to that that thing, I'll do it. I'd be happy to. But the staff whoever, will come up with a million excuses not to do it. Hey, you notice Biden won't talk to the New York Times, won't give them an interview, won't give any real news organization the interview, but he's happy to do Seth Meyers and Howard Stern. What does that tell you about his confidence? Yeah?
00:46:27
Speaker 5: No, there's clearly a coddling of him in the media that goes beyond even what we normally would expect. We're speaking of Mark Simon and mister New York of seven to ten wor in NYC. So you mentioned the trials Mark and Clay and I have tried to do a little bit of jury pool analysis, but also looking back or taking a step back and looking at the overall system in New York City. Do you have any faith that there might be somebody on that jury who's just going to say this is too crazy, I can't go along with this, or do you think that it's kind of a done deal and they might get a
multi verdict on this.
00:47:02
Speaker 8: Uh, you know, I don't have a lot of confidence. It's a New York jury, it's a totally over the top biased judge. The only good news is the Harvey Weinstein reversal was based on all these things the judge did, and this judge in the Trump trial has done exactly the same thing, so that almost guarantees the reversal. Hopefully the judges looking at this and will ease up a little. But there's so far there's no crime alleged. The catch and kill perfectly legal. Biden did the biggest catch and kill in history when he had Facebook, Twitter, the biggest publishers cover up the Hunter laptop scandal. So, but you're right, you can never tell what a jury'll do.
00:47:44
Speaker 2: You mentioned that again, you think Trump's gonna win New York, which would be amazing and would be a lot of fun to watch. Can you imagine the panic that would ensue an MSNBC and CNN if because New York comes in early, and if you start seeing those numbers and buy and is only up a couple of points or Trump is within a couple of points, what does the tally look like?
00:48:06
Speaker 3: You know, at forty seven percent?
00:48:07
Speaker 2: If I'm looking at this overall you know, in terms of turnout in twenty twenty two, do you think there's going to be a massive turnout in the New York election or do you think Biden's just not getting out his base Black voters are moving on Asian Hispanic voters. What does the coalition look like for Trump if that were to happen.
00:48:28
Speaker 8: Yeah, I think that's a good point. But I think low turnout for Biden. And you don't usually get the high Republican turnout in New York, but you'll get it this time because again, crime is a huge factor. Also, this anti semitism, the stuff on the college campists, it's frightening a lot of people, not just Jews, but Christians Gentiles as well, because this kind of bigotry being tolerated is frightening a lot of people. And who just watch the perversion of the justice system, the total disintegration of our universities, the streets every time, thing is just awful, the migrants everywhere. I think you're going to see enormous Republican turnout this time. Also look at Long Island, Nasau County, which is a good barometer. The county executive, the attorney general, the Republicans swept in Nasau County. It's a good indicative of what's coming.
00:49:20
Speaker 5: Mark, Simo and everybody. Mark appreciate you being with us. Thanks for calling in from seven to ten. Wor great to have you as always.
00:49:27
Speaker 8: Thanks love listening to you every day.
00:49:29
Speaker 5: Thanks Man, Thanks so much. You know, Clay, I just want to say, you know you said it. You're a bold prediction guy. But Trump, If Trump wins New York, this is up there with you. Remember when some of you do remember this and Colter was on Bill mahershow at the very beginning of the twenty sixteen cycle primary and they said who do you think is going to win? And she said, right on camera, She started, right in the camera, this is before like the polls showed him ahead. She said, Donald Trump. And they had to have her on later. That was a heck whatever you think, that was a heck of a call. If Mark is right and Trump wins New York, the first time a Republican will have won it since Ronald Reagan, We're going to have to have him on for a little victory dance. I think Trump will. You know, it's funny, he's so ready to go that Trump will win. That me pointing out that he's only behind even by Democrat pollsters six seven points. I mean, that's a contested state. If you really look at it, right, six or seven points looks like that's up for grabs, So it's not as crazy. That's why I said Barack Obama won by almost thirty very different times.
00:50:34
Speaker 8: Now.
00:50:35
Speaker 2: Yeah, and I think this is a good question because you guys out there listening can help us with this. Is that the boldest prediction in three years of us being on the air, in terms of guests. I know you and I have made bold predictions, but I don't even think I've gone that far in making a bold prediction about New York because it's not just.
00:50:54
Speaker 3: If he's right.
00:50:56
Speaker 2: Think about it. I've made some bold predictions, many of them are wrong. But uh, but if you think about it, if New York flipped, that's why I asked him. I mean, Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Wisconsin are going to go Trump, and then I think Minnesota probably would, and I think you would flip Virginia potentially.
00:51:15
Speaker 3: Like you're right about New York. Trump.
00:51:17
Speaker 5: It's style, It's it's a total butt kicking. There's no question about it. Because you're not gonna win New York and not win Pennsylvania. You're you're not going to win New York and then fail to win Pennsylvania and some of these other these other key states. But I think that look, I mean, you've talked about predictions. I thought Leez Eldon was going to win and maybe that for governor, and that would have been at least one repudiation of a COVID lockdown lunatic governor. Unfortunately, it didn't end up happening, but he made it close. And you know, New York, right after California is the biggest Democrat stronghold state that there is, so the fact that it would even be a place where you're gonna, I think you're gonna see Republican members of Congress that are doing well in New York. We would not have the very thin and some of that is self inflicted wounds by the Republicans in Congress, unfortunately, but we would not have a Republican majority if it were not for New York Republicans and California Republicans coming out and winning in some key congressional races and the GOP base turning out for them there.
00:52:20
Speaker 2: Particularly in New York Long Island, Nasau and Suffolk Counties. I mean, turning out big for Republicans. I do think that's big Trump territory. We talked about this last year when I was up in Cooperstown. How blown away my kids were Trump flags everywhere everywhere we went in upstate New York. When we were in Cooperstown, New York, my kids couldn't get over it we were driving around. I mean, that is major Trump territory. And what some Marx Simone just hit on is it's really you win in Manhattan. I remember we had Lee Zeldon on and you went in Manhattan by limiting the amount that Democrats can run up the score. And I do think that Manhattan and in the New York City area, I don't think that Biden's going to run up the score. I think again, it comes down to these suburban moms, these suburban women, and maybe they're not threatened in New York over the abortion argument because it's easier to get an abortion now, I think in New York than it was before Roe v.
00:53:14
Speaker 3: Wade was overturned. Well, this is why I think that.
00:53:16
Speaker 5: You know, we had that caller before and he said he's so worried about how abortion's going to play into this. It worked really well in twenty twenty two because they were able to lie to people and say, even you know, in all kinds of states, they're going to stop you from getting abortions in places like New York, and I think this is a tragedy. But in places like New York, it's still just as easy to get an abortion, and so it's a lot harder, I think, to drive turnout because that is the law.
00:53:43
Speaker 3: People can understand it.
00:53:44
Speaker 8: There.
00:53:45
Speaker 3: We'll take some of your calls.
00:53:46
Speaker 5: I'm wondering if anybody else, Let's see if anybody else Clay in New York wants to back Mark up on this one among the boldest, for sure predictions we have heard on this show. And you know Mark is very tied into the political scene in New York York City and up in Albany for New York State, so you know he would. I talked to him a little bit before, I said, are you sure do you want to say?
00:54:07
Speaker 3: Do you want to say that publicly on the ass, like you really want to let it rip? You said?
00:54:10
Speaker 5: He is confident, he is fired up, and he says he sees it