TRANSCRIÇÃO 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:10.415 --> 00:00:13.845
Hello again, everybody, and welcome back to the Bible Difficulties and Answers
00:00:13.845 --> 00:00:17.945
podcast. I'm your host, Lance Smith. This is episode 305.
00:00:18.658 --> 00:00:24.468
Well, sometimes the alleged contradictions in the Skeptic’s Annotated Bible can get a little tiresome.
00:00:25.066 --> 00:00:29.285
But we've made a commitment here on Tuesday Contradictions: We're going to take
00:00:29.285 --> 00:00:30.564
the argument seriously.
00:00:31.040 --> 00:00:34.565
We're going to give the skeptical position its best shot, and then we're going
00:00:34.565 --> 00:00:37.152
to see whether the Bible actually has a problem.
00:00:37.944 --> 00:00:41.427
And I'll admit it, today's contradiction caught me a little off guard.
00:00:42.040 --> 00:00:45.407
The question is this: When was heaven created?
00:00:46.051 --> 00:00:50.755
At first glance, that sounds like a pretty simple question. But once I started
00:00:50.755 --> 00:00:54.120
looking at the verses the Skeptic’s Annotated Bible puts together,
00:00:54.747 --> 00:00:57.487
I realized there's actually quite a bit to talk about.
00:00:58.073 --> 00:01:03.733
And frankly, I had a lot of fun researching this one. Maybe a little too much fun.
00:01:04.321 --> 00:01:09.145
Full disclosure: your humble host went down several research rabbit holes preparing
00:01:09.145 --> 00:01:13.645
this episode, so if it sounds like I brought half the library with me today,
00:01:13.645 --> 00:01:15.047
well, you've been warned.
00:01:15.883 --> 00:01:21.792
Let me start with a few questions. If Genesis 1 says God created the heavens
00:01:22.054 --> 00:01:29.612
"in the beginning," why does Genesis 1:8 say God called the firmament "Heaven" on the second day?
00:01:30.431 --> 00:01:35.458
If Matthew 25 says the kingdom was prepared from the creation of the world,
00:01:36.108 --> 00:01:41.931
why does Jesus say in John 14 that he is going to prepare a place for us?
00:01:42.636 --> 00:01:47.042
And when Paul talks about being caught up to the "third heaven,"
00:01:47.669 --> 00:01:52.615
is he talking about the same heaven we see when we look up into the nighttime sky?
00:01:53.630 --> 00:01:59.054
Those are good questions. The problem is that the Skeptic’s Annotated Bible treats
00:01:59.054 --> 00:02:03.708
them as though they are all talking about exactly the same thing.
00:02:04.449 --> 00:02:07.956
So, let's slow down and see whether they are.
00:02:08.795 --> 00:02:13.834
What is the alleged contradiction? Steve Wells in the Skeptic’s Annotated Bible
00:02:13.834 --> 00:02:18.053
lists four different answers to the question, "When was heaven created?"
00:02:19.022 --> 00:02:23.266
Genesis 1.1 says: "In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth."
00:02:23.966 --> 00:02:29.899
Genesis 1:6-8 puts the creation of the firmament on the second day.
00:02:30.610 --> 00:02:36.171
Matthew 25:34 says the kingdom was prepared "from the creation of
Load full transcript
the world."
00:02:36.860 --> 00:02:42.671
And then John 14:2 says Jesus is going to prepare a place for his followers.
00:02:43.469 --> 00:02:47.764
If all four passages are giving us different construction dates for the same
00:02:47.764 --> 00:02:51.266
thing called "heaven," then yes, we've got a problem.
00:02:52.137 --> 00:02:58.258
But are they? Let's read the passages. Genesis 1:1 in the New Living Translation:
00:02:58.890 --> 00:03:04.721
"In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth." Genesis 1:6-8:
00:03:05.523 --> 00:03:10.464
"Then God said, Let there be a space between the waters to separate the waters
00:03:10.464 --> 00:03:13.394
of the heavens from the waters of the earth."
00:03:14.010 --> 00:03:17.923
Then verse 8: "God calls the space 'sky.'"
00:03:18.736 --> 00:03:24.434
Okay that's important the New Living Translation doesn't say God called it "God's
00:03:24.434 --> 00:03:26.717
dwelling place." It says sky,
00:03:27.544 --> 00:03:33.124
Matthew 25:34, our focus verse today, says: "Then the king will say to those on
00:03:33.124 --> 00:03:38.824
his right, 'Come you who are blessed by my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared
00:03:38.824 --> 00:03:41.023
for you from the creation of the world.'"
00:03:41.682 --> 00:03:43.912
And John 14:2:
00:03:44.643 --> 00:03:49.034
"There is more than enough room in my father's home. If this were not so,
00:03:49.374 --> 00:03:52.695
would I have told you that I am going to prepare a place for you?"
00:03:54.669 --> 00:04:00.532
Right away, we can see something important. Genesis 1 is talking about creation.
00:04:01.217 --> 00:04:05.704
Matthew 25 is talking about a kingdom that has been prepared.
00:04:06.293 --> 00:04:10.450
John 14 is talking about Jesus preparing a place.
00:04:11.042 --> 00:04:13.776
Those aren't automatically the same thing.
00:04:14.372 --> 00:04:21.312
One word, more than one meaning. Part of the problem comes from the English word heaven.
00:04:21.899 --> 00:04:26.659
We tend to hear "heaven" and immediately think about the place where God dwells.
00:04:27.680 --> 00:04:31.256
Scripture uses the word in more than one sense.
00:04:31.926 --> 00:04:37.987
The Hebrew word is shamayim. The Greek word is ouranos.
00:04:38.632 --> 00:04:42.005
And context tells us what is being discussed.
00:04:42.667 --> 00:04:48.583
BibleAsk, in its article, :Are There Three Heavens?", describes three uses of the word.
00:04:49.209 --> 00:04:54.634
The first heaven is the atmosphere, the sky, clouds, rain, and birds.
00:04:55.268 --> 00:05:01.410
The second heaven is what we call outer space, the sun, moon, the stars.
00:05:02.050 --> 00:05:05.283
And the third heaven is the dwelling place of God.
00:05:05.960 --> 00:05:10.476
That's consistent with what Paul says in 2 Corinthians 12:2
00:05:10.853 --> 00:05:13.959
when he talks about being "caught up to the third heaven."
00:05:14.596 --> 00:05:22.642
So when Genesis 1:8 says God called the raqia "heaven" or shamayim,
00:05:23.170 --> 00:05:28.737
we shouldn't automatically assume that Moses is talking about God's eternal dwelling place.
00:05:29.338 --> 00:05:31.236
He's talking about the heavens, the sky.
00:05:31.871 --> 00:05:37.188
Simon Turpin, writing for Ask John Mackay, makes an important distinction here.
00:05:37.795 --> 00:05:42.398
He points out that the first two heavens are part of the created order,
00:05:43.002 --> 00:05:47.158
while the third heaven, the dwelling place of God, is eternal.
00:05:47.824 --> 00:05:52.514
And Turpin makes the point this way: "The first two heavens will pass away;
00:05:53.118 --> 00:05:56.549
however, the third heaven is eternal."
00:05:58.058 --> 00:06:03.604
That makes a great deal of sense when we remember what Isaiah 57:15 says about
00:06:03.604 --> 00:06:05.564
God dwelling in eternity.
00:06:06.231 --> 00:06:11.224
God didn't suddenly acquire a residence because he needed somewhere to live
00:06:11.224 --> 00:06:13.627
after creating the universe. God is eternal.
00:06:14.316 --> 00:06:20.114
So, when Genesis 1:1 says, "In the beginning God created the heavens and the
00:06:20.114 --> 00:06:22.982
earth," it's giving us the big picture.
00:06:23.642 --> 00:06:30.594
Thomas Constable, in his Notes on Genesis, understands Genesis 1:1 as describing
00:06:30.594 --> 00:06:35.344
God's original creation of the universe, with the following days describing
00:06:35.344 --> 00:06:38.340
God's work of forming and filling that creation.
00:06:39.072 --> 00:06:44.644
In other words, verse 1 is the headline. The rest of the chapter gives us the details.
00:06:45.276 --> 00:06:49.177
God created the heavens and the earth. Then, on the second day,
00:06:49.496 --> 00:06:51.626
He formed and named the sky.
00:06:52.256 --> 00:06:55.228
That's not two different creation events for the same thing.
00:06:56.025 --> 00:06:59.712
So what exactly is the raqia?
00:07:00.338 --> 00:07:04.344
Now, we get to one of the more interesting parts of this whole question.
00:07:04.692 --> 00:07:07.072
And this is where things get a little technical.
00:07:07.705 --> 00:07:12.430
Because apparently asking, "When was heaven created?" wasn't complicated enough.
00:07:13.156 --> 00:07:16.824
And now we're going to talk about a Hebrew word that has been keeping Bible
00:07:16.824 --> 00:07:19.274
scholars busy for a very long time.
00:07:20.068 --> 00:07:24.178
The Hebrew word in Genesis 1-6 is raqia.
00:07:24.767 --> 00:07:30.932
Depending on the translation, you will see words like firmament, expanse, space, or sky.
00:07:31.690 --> 00:07:36.384
James-Michael Smith, writing for Logos in “Firmament or Expanse?
00:07:36.384 --> 00:07:41.824
Two Ways to Interpret Genesis 1:6,” points out that there are different ways
00:07:41.824 --> 00:07:43.972
of understanding this Hebrew word.
00:07:44.557 --> 00:07:47.204
And that's where the discussion gets interesting.
00:07:47.872 --> 00:07:54.757
Some interpreters understand raqia as a solid
structure--a kind of dome or vault,
00:07:55.478 --> 00:08:00.429
Others see it as an expanse, something stretched out across the heavens,
00:08:01.091 --> 00:08:06.454
GotQuestions.org, in its discussion of the second day of creation understands
00:08:06.454 --> 00:08:13.595
God as creating the sky or expanse that separates the waters below from the waters above.
00:08:14.177 --> 00:08:17.892
They connect those "waters above" with the atmosphere and the water cycle.
00:08:18.425 --> 00:08:23.150
Water below, vapor and clouds above, with the air in between.
00:08:23.859 --> 00:08:29.397
Danny Faulkner, writing in the Answers Research Journal, takes a somewhat different approach.
00:08:30.123 --> 00:08:35.737
He argues that the raqia primarily refers to what we would call outer space,
00:08:36.335 --> 00:08:41.534
with the atmosphere being the region associated with the face of that expanse where the birds fly.
00:08:42.227 --> 00:08:46.668
Rick Lancer, writing for Associates for Biblical Research, likewise,
00:08:47.022 --> 00:08:53.124
argues that the raqia is the stretched-out heavens God creates on day two and
00:08:53.124 --> 00:08:55.607
later fills with the sun, moon, and stars.
00:08:56.319 --> 00:08:59.332
So, we've got some differences of interpretation here.
00:08:59.924 --> 00:09:08.137
But notice something. None of that creates a contradiction between Genesis 1:1 and Genesis 1:6-8.
00:09:08.927 --> 00:09:13.670
The disagreement is over exactly how we should understand the physical picture,
00:09:14.407 --> 00:09:16.810
not whether God created the universe in the beginning.
00:09:17.482 --> 00:09:23.966
Dr. William Lane Craig addresses this question in "Dealing with Spurious Claims About the Firmament."
00:09:24.565 --> 00:09:30.709
Craig makes the point that Genesis 1 tells us very little about the actual material
00:09:30.709 --> 00:09:32.663
composition of the raqia.
00:09:33.205 --> 00:09:38.829
And he quotes Benjamin Smith describing raqia as: "the whole sky,
00:09:39.421 --> 00:09:42.858
all that can be seen above the Earth from the surface."
00:09:43.517 --> 00:09:49.020
Okay, that's a useful way of looking at it. The sun and stars are seen in the sky.
00:09:49.589 --> 00:09:53.647
The birds fly through the sky. The clouds are in the sky.
00:09:54.227 --> 00:10:01.389
So when Genesis 1:8 says God called the raqia "Heaven," we're not necessarily
00:10:01.389 --> 00:10:05.060
talking about a heavenly building somewhere beyond the universe.
00:10:05.361 --> 00:10:07.892
We're talking about the heavens above us.
00:10:08.966 --> 00:10:14.649
But what about the ancient world? Now, here's where I want to be fair to the
00:10:14.649 --> 00:10:19.397
other side, because there's a legitimate scholarly discussion here.
00:10:20.070 --> 00:10:25.079
Pete Enns, writing for BioLogos, argues that the firmament in Genesis 1 should
00:10:25.079 --> 00:10:28.678
be understood within the worldview of the ancient Near East.
00:10:29.524 --> 00:10:33.731
His article is titled, "The Firmament of Genesis 1 Is Solid but That’s Not the Point.”
00:10:34.464 --> 00:10:39.929
Enns argues that the ancient world commonly pictured the sky as a solid structure
00:10:39.929 --> 00:10:41.976
holding back waters above.
00:10:42.606 --> 00:10:48.179
And his larger point is that Genesis wasn't written as a modern scientific textbook.
00:10:48.819 --> 00:10:53.629
One of Enns' statements is particularly important" "God always speaks in ways
00:10:53.629 --> 00:10:55.819
that people can actually understand."
00:10:56.502 --> 00:11:02.719
He also describes Genesis and modern science as: "neither enemies nor friends,
00:11:02.998 --> 00:11:05.332
but two different ways of describing the world."
00:11:06.662 --> 00:11:10.511
That's a position we need to take seriously, even if we don't agree with every
00:11:10.511 --> 00:11:11.910
conclusion drawn from it.
00:11:12.625 --> 00:11:18.361
John R. Roberts of SIL International makes a similar ancient Near Eastern argument
00:11:18.361 --> 00:11:21.843
in his paper, "The Cosmos Created in Genesis 1."
00:11:22.506 --> 00:11:28.954
Roberts argues that raqia is a firmament that holds back the waters above
00:11:29.093 --> 00:11:33.569
and points to biblical language about doors and windows in heaven.
00:11:34.276 --> 00:11:39.925
He also argues that the Genesis account is schematic. And I actually think that word is helpful.
00:11:40.883 --> 00:11:47.587
Think of a subway map. A subway map is useful precisely because it isn't a photograph of the city.
00:11:48.188 --> 00:11:51.681
And if you've ever tried to understand Atlanta traffic, you already know that
00:11:51.681 --> 00:11:56.814
a map doesn't have to look exactly like the real world to tell you where you're going.
00:11:57.439 --> 00:12:02.743
It tells you how things relate to each other. That's not the same thing as saying the map is false.
00:12:03.931 --> 00:12:07.734
I don't follow Roberts all the way to the conclusion that Genesis is teaching
00:12:07.734 --> 00:12:12.291
us a particular ancient scientific model as the intended science of the passage.
00:12:12.958 --> 00:12:17.624
But I do think he gets something important right. Genesis is speaking to an ancient
00:12:17.624 --> 00:12:24.494
audience. We shouldn't demand Moses write a twenty-first-century astronomy textbook before
00:12:24.494 --> 00:12:26.159
we're willing to believe what he is saying.
00:12:26.969 --> 00:12:32.124
At the same time Randall Younker and Richard Davidson push back against the idea
00:12:32.124 --> 00:12:35.189
that Genesis requires a solid metal dome.
00:12:35.915 --> 00:12:42.104
In their article, "The Myth of the Solid Heavenly Dome," they argue that the reconstruction
00:12:42.104 --> 00:12:47.885
of the biblical raqia as some kind of literal metal bowl is overstated.
00:12:48.493 --> 00:12:54.794
They point out that the Hebrew idea of raqia involves spreading out or stretching
00:12:54.794 --> 00:12:59.319
out
and does not necessarily require a solid bronze ceiling.
00:12:59.644 --> 00:13:04.254
So, even among scholars who take the ancient context seriously,
00:13:04.254 --> 00:13:08.927
there's disagreement about exactly what picture Genesis is giving us.
00:13:09.432 --> 00:13:15.086
And that's okay. We don't have to solve every question about ancient cosmology
00:13:15.498 --> 00:13:19.625
to determine whether Matthew 25:34 contradicts Genesis 1:1.
00:13:20.270 --> 00:13:22.134
So, here's where I land.
00:13:22.842 --> 00:13:28.037
Genesis 1:1 gives us the big picture. God created the heavens and the earth in the beginning.
00:13:28.628 --> 00:13:34.004
Genesis 1:6-8 then describes God's work of forming the raqia,
00:13:34.381 --> 00:13:39.188
the sky or expanse, and naming it shamayim, or heaven.
00:13:40.051 --> 00:13:45.264
Whether you understand the raqia primarily as atmosphere, outer space,
00:13:45.264 --> 00:13:49.345
or the broader heavens above us, the basic point remains the same.
00:13:49.879 --> 00:13:52.271
Day two isn't a second beginning.
00:13:52.886 --> 00:13:58.424
And certainly, it isn't the day God suddenly decided to manufacture His eternal throne room.
00:13:59.155 --> 00:14:05.337
It's part of God's ordering of the created universe. Headline first, details afterward.
00:14:06.695 --> 00:14:11.351
Let's come back to the two verses that I think really drive the skeptic's argument.
00:14:11.935 --> 00:14:18.156
Matthew 25:34 says: "Inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the creation of the world."
00:14:19.031 --> 00:14:23.617
John 14:2 says: "I am going to prepare a place for you."
00:14:24.182 --> 00:14:27.926
At first glance, someone might say, "Well, there's the contradiction.
00:14:28.384 --> 00:14:34.311
Matthew says the kingdom was prepared from creation, but Jesus says he's going to prepare it later."
00:14:35.054 --> 00:14:40.269
Except there's a problem. Neither verse says Jesus is creating heaven.
00:14:41.022 --> 00:14:46.253
Veritas Domain makes this point in their response to the alleged contradiction.
00:14:46.876 --> 00:14:52.100
A contradiction requires two statements that cannot both be true in the same sense.
00:14:52.802 --> 00:14:59.685
So what does John 14 actually say? Jesus says he is going to prepare a place.
00:15:00.383 --> 00:15:07.245
The Greek verb is hetoimazo, ready to make, excuse me, to make ready or prepare.
00:15:07.709 --> 00:15:10.194
And that distinction matters.
00:15:10.837 --> 00:15:15.486
Veritas Domain points out that the same verb is used in Acts 23:
00:15:15.486 --> 00:15:19.260
23 when soldiers are being prepared for a journey.
00:15:19.961 --> 00:15:23.420
You don't create the soldiers, you prepare them, you get them ready.
00:15:23.949 --> 00:15:28.529
And that's what Jesus says he is doing. He's preparing a place.
00:15:29.148 --> 00:15:32.434
John doesn't say Jesus is creating heaven from scratch.
00:15:33.199 --> 00:15:39.521
In fact, John 3:13 already assumes that heaven exists because Jesus says he came from heaven.
00:15:40.146 --> 00:15:44.122
So John 14 isn't giving us the creation date of heaven.
00:15:44.761 --> 00:15:48.882
It's telling the disciples what Jesus is going to do for them.
00:15:49.457 --> 00:15:50.978
He is going to prepare a place.
00:15:51.619 --> 00:15:54.516
And Matthew 25 is doing something different.
00:15:55.195 --> 00:15:59.984
Matthew says the kingdom was prepared for God's people from the creation of the world.
00:16:00.560 --> 00:16:04.862
That sounds much more like God's eternal purpose and plan than a statement about
00:16:05.175 --> 00:16:08.384
when he physically constructed a building called heaven.
00:16:08.988 --> 00:16:10.881
And that's the key distinction.
00:16:11.491 --> 00:16:16.751
Prepared doesn't automatically mean created. A wedding can be prepared without
00:16:16.751 --> 00:16:18.473
the wedding venue being created.
00:16:18.775 --> 00:16:22.299
A meal can be prepared without the kitchen being built that day.
00:16:22.871 --> 00:16:26.970
An inheritance can be prepared without the money being minted that day.
00:16:27.341 --> 00:16:33.610
And a kingdom can be prepared in God's purpose long before the people who will inherit it arrive.
00:16:34.270 --> 00:16:37.991
So that leads us to four questions answered by four verses.
00:16:38.666 --> 00:16:42.910
So let's put the pieces together. When did the physical universe begin?
00:16:43.483 --> 00:16:45.653
Genesis 1:1: In the beginning.
00:16:46.424 --> 00:16:51.114
When did God form and name the sky or heavens described by the raqia?
00:16:51.757 --> 00:16:54.787
Genesis 1:6-8: On the second day.
00:16:55.453 --> 00:16:58.842
How long has the kingdom been prepared for God's people?
00:16:59.530 --> 00:17:07.101
Matthew 25:34: "From the creation of the world." And what is Jesus doing in John 14?
00:17:07.723 --> 00:17:13.601
Preparing a place for his followers. Those aren't four competing dates on one
00:17:13.601 --> 00:17:15.304
heavenly construction calendar.
00:17:16.325 --> 00:17:20.848
In other words, we don't need to imagine God sitting down with a heavenly contractor
00:17:20.848 --> 00:17:25.886
saying, "Let's see, the sky on Tuesday, kingdom sometime later,
00:17:26.350 --> 00:17:29.096
and we'll get that guest room finished after the resurrection."
00:17:29.618 --> 00:17:31.923
That's not what these passages are saying.
00:17:32.530 --> 00:17:36.988
That's four, excuse me, there are four different statements addressing different
00:17:36.988 --> 00:17:42.144
aspects of God's creation, His purposes, and Christ's work.
00:17:42.608 --> 00:17:46.838
And there's one more thing. If you came into this episode worried that the Bible
00:17:46.838 --> 00:17:49.807
can't keep its story straight about heaven, let me encourage you.
00:17:50.422 --> 00:17:54.520
The problem may not be with the Bible. It may be with our English vocabulary.
00:17:55.093 --> 00:18:00.968
We use one word, heaven, for the blue sky over Georgia, the starry heavens above
00:18:00.968 --> 00:18:02.876
us, and the dwelling place of God.
00:18:03.921 --> 00:18:08.693
Scripture does that too, but context tells us which meaning is intended.
00:18:09.351 --> 00:18:14.339
It's a little like the word "home." I can talk about my home as my house.
00:18:14.992 --> 00:18:18.125
I can talk about my home as the state where I live.
00:18:18.852 --> 00:18:22.370
Or I can talk about "home" as the place where I belong.
00:18:22.930 --> 00:18:27.388
The same word, different meaning, context sorts it out.
00:18:27.999 --> 00:18:30.134
And there's something even more encouraging here.
00:18:30.777 --> 00:18:34.693
If you belong to Christ, the question that ultimately matters isn't whether
00:18:34.693 --> 00:18:39.595
the raqia should be translated "firmament," "expanse," or "sky."
00:18:40.144 --> 00:18:43.860
The question is whether the king has prepared a kingdom for you.
00:18:44.426 --> 00:18:49.674
Matthew 25 says that kingdom was prepared from the creation of the world.
00:18:50.394 --> 00:18:54.916
And John 14 tells us that Jesus has gone ahead to prepare a place for his followers.
00:18:55.402 --> 00:18:56.690
That's not a contradiction.
00:18:57.340 --> 00:18:58.403
That's a promise.
00:18:59.080 --> 00:19:02.708
God's plan for his people goes back to the foundation of the world.
00:19:03.286 --> 00:19:08.331
And Jesus is preparing the place where his people will ultimately be with him.
00:19:09.330 --> 00:19:16.099
So four questions, four passages, but not four contradictory creation dates.
00:19:16.799 --> 00:19:21.186
And I think that's a pretty good resolution to today's alleged contradiction. I hope this has helped.
00:19:21.720 --> 00:19:24.263
I had a great time digging through the research for this one,
00:19:24.263 --> 00:19:27.910
even if I may have brought a few too many articles along for the ride.
00:19:28.688 --> 00:19:32.793
Next Tuesday, Lord willing, we'll pick up another alleged biblical contradiction.
00:19:33.400 --> 00:19:37.093
If you'd like to support the podcast, you can do so at buymeacoffee.com/
00:19:37.093 --> 00:19:39.721
LanceSmith. As always, it's appreciated but never expected.
00:19:40.446 --> 00:19:44.045
You'll find every episode at BibleDifficultiesAndAnswers.Podbean.com.
00:19:44.492 --> 00:19:50.570
You can also find us on Facebook or email me anytime at BibleDifficultiesAndAnswers@gmail.com.
00:19:51.202 --> 00:19:53.882
I read every message and I generally enjoy hearing from you.
00:19:54.543 --> 00:19:58.810
This is Lance Smith wishing you good health, good study, and God's richest blessings.
00:19:59.175 --> 00:20:01.387
We'll see you next time. So long, everybody.