TRANSCRIÇÃO 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.250 --> 00:00:04.360
Neil deGrasse Tyson here for StarTalk coming up. Brian Greene's
2
00:00:04.389 --> 00:00:07.540
latest book, Until the End of Time. Well, we don't
3
00:00:07.559 --> 00:00:10.380
know what that means, but we know what the subtitle means. Mind, Matter,
4
00:00:10.640 --> 00:00:15.359
and Our Search for Meaning in an Evolving Universe. Smackdown
5
00:00:15.939 --> 00:00:26.429
on StarTalk. Be there. StarTalk. Cosmic Queries Edition. Neil deGrasse
6
00:00:26.469 --> 00:00:31.079
Tyson here, your personal astrophysicist. And as is not always,
7
00:00:31.140 --> 00:00:35.020
but most of the time, Chuck Nice. Hey. Co-host. Good
8
00:00:35.039 --> 00:00:36.399
to be here, man. We just fist bumped in front
9
00:00:36.420 --> 00:00:38.500
of our guests. Yes, we did. That's rude. Is that rude?
10
00:00:38.539 --> 00:00:41.359
There we go. Now we'll do a three-way fist bump.
11
00:00:41.380 --> 00:00:43.060
Commutative property of fist bumps.
12
00:00:43.079 --> 00:00:43.359
That's right.
13
00:00:43.700 --> 00:00:46.399
Brian Green is our guest. That's right. We're doing Cosmic
14
00:00:46.439 --> 00:00:50.840
Queries Until the End of Time. I didn't just pull
15
00:00:50.859 --> 00:00:52.520
that out of an orifice. I was going to say.
16
00:00:52.539 --> 00:00:55.960
It is actually the subtitle of this book. That's the title.
17
00:00:56.340 --> 00:00:57.020
That's the title.
18
00:00:57.039 --> 00:00:57.420
That's the title.
19
00:00:57.439 --> 00:01:02.140
What's the subtitle? Mind, matter, and our search for meaning
20
00:01:02.659 --> 00:01:06.780
in an evolving universe. Nice. That kind of means everything, right?
21
00:01:06.900 --> 00:01:07.299
It is.
22
00:01:07.700 --> 00:01:12.790
But doesn't the universe automatically elicit questions of what is life?
23
00:01:13.359 --> 00:01:16.060
My purpose, my meaning, why? That's why we have him
24
00:01:16.099 --> 00:01:18.189
here to talk about this for the show. Oh, cool.
25
00:01:18.609 --> 00:01:24.329
I thought we were doing a cooking show. So we
26
00:01:24.370 --> 00:01:27.390
solicited questions. Yes, we did. About this book. I don't
27
00:01:27.409 --> 00:01:29.909
know if people read your book already. Is that possible?
28
00:01:29.930 --> 00:01:31.989
It's conceivable. I'm looking at the questions. I just know
29
00:01:32.010 --> 00:01:33.689
he's got a fan base out there. He does.
30
00:01:33.950 --> 00:01:36.069
And there is several of the questions of people who
31
00:01:36.090 --> 00:01:40.840
have already, they say... In your book. Okay, so Brian.
32
00:01:40.859 --> 00:01:42.879
Look at this one right here. Your book, Until the
33
00:01:42.939 --> 00:01:44.599
End of Time, brings me to the conclusion.
34
00:01:44.879 --> 00:01:48.319
Wow. Look at that. So there you go. All right.
35
00:01:48.379 --> 00:01:51.180
So this is the Venn diagram that overlaps his fan
36
00:01:51.200 --> 00:01:53.959
base with our viewers. There you go. Because we solicited
Load full transcript
37
00:01:54.000 --> 00:01:55.060
it from our viewers. For your base.
38
00:01:55.079 --> 00:01:55.420
Yeah, great.
39
00:01:55.439 --> 00:01:57.500
There you go. To all people, your people.
40
00:01:57.829 --> 00:01:58.310
I love that.
41
00:01:58.930 --> 00:02:01.549
All right, so Chuck, you got the questions. Just to
42
00:02:01.629 --> 00:02:04.840
remind everybody how this works, it's Cosmic Queries. And these
43
00:02:04.879 --> 00:02:06.900
are solicited from our fan base. That's right. I have never,
44
00:02:07.019 --> 00:02:09.030
not seen them. Certainly our guest hasn't. That's right. Chuck,
45
00:02:09.050 --> 00:02:12.069
you might've seen them. I read them before. And Brian
46
00:02:12.090 --> 00:02:16.919
Green and I have very strong scientific overlap, um, but
47
00:02:16.939 --> 00:02:18.949
we're going to get his view on this, and I'll
48
00:02:18.969 --> 00:02:21.069
just sit back and listen, and if he's full of shit,
49
00:02:21.289 --> 00:02:22.370
I'll tell you. No, you won't.
50
00:02:22.409 --> 00:02:25.110
His guy will not sit back and listen. I've never
51
00:02:25.169 --> 00:02:27.449
heard that before.
52
00:02:27.509 --> 00:02:33.389
That was funny. Plus, I should have said it differently. No,
53
00:02:33.430 --> 00:02:37.849
you won't. Brian Green knows almost all the astrophysics I know,
54
00:02:38.430 --> 00:02:40.030
and I only know some of the physics he knows.
55
00:02:40.740 --> 00:02:42.259
So he can take my physics to new places.
56
00:02:42.300 --> 00:02:44.439
That's very gracious. I don't know if it's true, but
57
00:02:44.460 --> 00:02:45.240
it's very gracious.
58
00:02:45.259 --> 00:02:49.360
Thank you. And he's a good mathematician, too. All right. Yeah.
59
00:02:49.539 --> 00:02:52.719
I mean, I'm going to say yes to that because
60
00:02:52.740 --> 00:02:56.039
he's an astrophysicist and a physicist.
61
00:02:56.099 --> 00:03:00.310
Math is a language of the universe in which he
62
00:03:00.349 --> 00:03:02.789
is fluent. Very cool. I'm delighted to have an all-time
63
00:03:02.830 --> 00:03:05.789
friend and colleague. All right. So let's do this. Well,
64
00:03:05.810 --> 00:03:06.229
let's do this.
65
00:03:06.270 --> 00:03:08.310
And as usual, we always start with a Patreon announcement.
66
00:03:09.120 --> 00:03:10.659
a question from our Patreon patron.
67
00:03:10.900 --> 00:03:14.460
Oh, wait, wait, wait. Excuse me. Go ahead. Brian Green
68
00:03:14.520 --> 00:03:17.120
is professor of physics at Columbia University.
69
00:03:17.259 --> 00:03:17.500
Wow.
70
00:03:17.699 --> 00:03:20.840
And also joint appointed in the Department of Mathematics. Wow.
71
00:03:21.340 --> 00:03:26.650
And he and his spouse co-founded the World Science Festival
72
00:03:26.889 --> 00:03:31.069
here in New York City every year where science and
73
00:03:31.349 --> 00:03:36.710
art and music come together to celebrate science. Wow. That's right.
74
00:03:36.789 --> 00:03:39.409
He does this. Thank you. Incredible.
He's not just some
75
00:03:39.449 --> 00:03:41.050
person who's sitting between us right now.
76
00:03:41.389 --> 00:03:41.550
Right.
77
00:03:41.750 --> 00:03:44.169
This is Brian Green. I mean, he's still that. He's
78
00:03:44.189 --> 00:03:48.879
still that. I didn't want to undo the fact he's
79
00:03:48.900 --> 00:03:51.400
a person sitting between us. Let's not demote him from personhood.
80
00:03:51.939 --> 00:03:54.159
And I think this is his fourth book.
81
00:03:54.659 --> 00:03:55.099
Yes, right.
82
00:03:55.219 --> 00:03:59.120
Okay. And his first book that anyone knows about was
83
00:03:59.159 --> 00:04:01.860
a mega bestseller, which was?
84
00:04:02.560 --> 00:04:03.370
The Elegant Universe.
85
00:04:03.469 --> 00:04:06.189
The Elegant Universe. And he's one of our leading string theorists.
86
00:04:06.289 --> 00:04:10.069
And this was a way to- share not only the
87
00:04:10.129 --> 00:04:11.870
frontier of his research with all the rest of us,
88
00:04:12.150 --> 00:04:13.849
give us a sense of hope that maybe one day
89
00:04:13.870 --> 00:04:17.839
we'll understand everything. Cool. Or not. Or not. So that
90
00:04:17.860 --> 00:04:20.720
was a mega bestseller. And we shared publishers back then.
91
00:04:20.759 --> 00:04:23.399
We had the same publisher. Oh, Norton? You were with W.W. Norton.
92
00:04:23.500 --> 00:04:27.220
Then he got so famous, he found another publisher. And
93
00:04:27.240 --> 00:04:28.699
then he published another book after that and didn't do
94
00:04:28.740 --> 00:04:31.019
as well as the first book. Okay? I just want
95
00:04:31.050 --> 00:04:34.689
to just hang some publisher. You're just giving your publisher
96
00:04:34.709 --> 00:04:38.189
some cred right now. Dirty laundry out here. There you go. Okay. Okay.
97
00:04:40.139 --> 00:04:43.970
Brian Green, Alfred Knopf, publisher. Let's do this. All right,
98
00:04:43.990 --> 00:04:44.389
here we go.
99
00:04:44.829 --> 00:04:46.550
As I said, we always start with a Patreon patron
100
00:04:46.589 --> 00:04:50.529
because they give us money. And this is Michael Tobias.
101
00:04:50.589 --> 00:04:54.230
He says, Hello, Neil and Brian. I often wonder how
102
00:04:54.350 --> 00:04:59.370
far we will journey through space within our lifetime. Will
103
00:04:59.389 --> 00:05:02.009
we be able to achieve interstellar travel or will the
104
00:05:02.050 --> 00:05:05.689
human race go extinct before we have the opportunity and technology? Now,
105
00:05:05.730 --> 00:05:08.089
he started off with our lifetime, but I think he
106
00:05:08.110 --> 00:05:12.500
means the lifetime of the species of human beings. Because
107
00:05:12.620 --> 00:05:16.350
our lifetime, the answer is No, and I am not
108
00:05:16.490 --> 00:05:18.350
an astrophysicist at all.
109
00:05:18.470 --> 00:05:19.449
Okay, we're done with that.
110
00:05:20.149 --> 00:05:22.769
No, but within the lifetime of the human species. First
111
00:05:22.790 --> 00:05:24.269
of all, what is the lifetime of the human species?
112
00:05:24.529 --> 00:05:24.990
What would that be?
113
00:05:25.009 --> 00:05:26.449
A few million years. A few million?
114
00:05:26.470 --> 00:05:29.009
Well, that's a guess, right? If you look at the
115
00:05:29.050 --> 00:05:29.730
historical trend.
116
00:05:29.790 --> 00:05:33.060
If you look at the life expectancy of mammal species,
117
00:05:33.939 --> 00:05:35.379
one in three million years, somewhere around there.
118
00:05:35.389 --> 00:05:36.500
Yeah, but we're so much special, right?
119
00:05:36.540 --> 00:05:38.459
I mean, we have this thing on top of our
120
00:05:38.500 --> 00:05:40.259
head that enables us to figure things out.
121
00:05:40.279 --> 00:05:40.939
We tell ourselves.
122
00:05:41.360 --> 00:05:43.759
So either that is going to be our own destruction,
123
00:05:43.939 --> 00:05:46.639
because we can build things that can kill ourselves, or
124
00:05:46.740 --> 00:05:48.459
we'll be able to figure out a way of living
125
00:05:48.500 --> 00:05:50.759
beyond the traditional lifetime of many species.
126
00:05:50.980 --> 00:05:53.639
So, unclear. But if you take.
127
00:05:53.759 --> 00:05:57.170
Well, let me add to that question. There's what's possible
128
00:05:57.290 --> 00:06:00.029
in the laws of physics, and there's what's within reach
129
00:06:00.470 --> 00:06:04.449
with our engineering. Absolutely. Give me your read on that.
130
00:06:04.490 --> 00:06:07.439
Well, the laws of physics constrain any speed of any
131
00:06:07.500 --> 00:06:09.560
spacecraft traveling through space to be less than the speed
132
00:06:09.579 --> 00:06:11.420
of light. So if you're not going to play games
133
00:06:11.459 --> 00:06:14.060
with imagining that, we can actually warp the fabric of space.
134
00:06:14.259 --> 00:06:15.800
That's not playing games. That's real.
135
00:06:16.000 --> 00:06:19.379
Yeah, well, it's unclear that we'll be able to achieve that.
136
00:06:19.459 --> 00:06:22.110
It's real in every movie I've ever seen. I agree.
137
00:06:22.350 --> 00:06:23.910
I agree.
138
00:06:23.949 --> 00:06:26.430
But taking the speed of a craft to be less
139
00:06:26.449 --> 00:06:28.490
than the speed of light, then I mean achieving.
140
00:06:29.629 --> 00:06:30.769
great space.
141
00:06:30.529 --> 00:06:34.230
Travel is challenging right now the weird thing is because
142
00:06:34.310 --> 00:06:37.720
time slows down when you have a spacecraft or a
143
00:06:37.759 --> 00:06:40.839
clock of any sort that's in motion you could have
144
00:06:40.879 --> 00:06:43.980
a spacecraft going out near the speed of light and
145
00:06:44.120 --> 00:06:45.779
we on earth would watch.
146
00:06:45.579 --> 00:06:47.550
Its clock and its clock would be ticking.
147
00:06:47.310 --> 00:06:49.970
Off time so slowly that to the person on the
148
00:06:50.129 --> 00:06:53.129
ship they would be able to go much further than
149
00:06:53.170 --> 00:06:54.810
we would think they would be able to if
we
150
00:06:54.829 --> 00:06:59.350
didn't take that into account. So we could send some
151
00:06:59.389 --> 00:07:02.569
intrepid Voyager out into space, and they could go near
152
00:07:02.589 --> 00:07:05.389
the speed of light, and they could go arbitrarily far
153
00:07:05.810 --> 00:07:06.790
in their lifetime.
154
00:07:06.810 --> 00:07:09.750
In their lifetime. Yes. Then they come back home, and
155
00:07:09.769 --> 00:07:12.089
everyone would have forgotten about them because hundreds of thousands
156
00:07:12.110 --> 00:07:12.990
of years would have passed.
157
00:07:13.009 --> 00:07:15.129
Or millions or billions of years. You're absolutely right.
158
00:07:15.149 --> 00:07:17.480
Right, right. So that's not... That's not what people are
159
00:07:17.500 --> 00:07:21.100
imagining when they're thinking of space travel. No. I mean, so.
160
00:07:21.279 --> 00:07:23.449
But it really matters, you know, if we were to take,
161
00:07:23.610 --> 00:07:26.629
you know, a group of our species and send them
162
00:07:26.689 --> 00:07:29.970
out into space, it really would be within their lifetime
163
00:07:30.009 --> 00:07:30.569
that they'd be.
164
00:07:30.529 --> 00:07:33.230
Able to, according to laws of physics, go arbitrarily far.
165
00:07:33.370 --> 00:07:33.569
Right.
166
00:07:33.850 --> 00:07:36.389
And so it's kind of... Now, you're right. The people
167
00:07:36.430 --> 00:07:38.649
back on Earth, they perhaps would be long extinct.
168
00:07:39.290 --> 00:07:39.589
You know.
169
00:07:39.949 --> 00:07:40.310
Wow.
170
00:07:40.769 --> 00:07:44.040
Imagine. You come back and your species isn't even around. Right.
171
00:07:44.459 --> 00:07:47.970
And the roaches took over. And the rats... Right. And
172
00:07:48.009 --> 00:07:51.639
they say, wait a minute. You come back. And there's
173
00:07:51.680 --> 00:07:54.920
a museum that the rats have, and they're the skeletons
174
00:07:54.959 --> 00:07:58.600
of humans there. Right. That long ago has terrorized the.
175
00:07:58.920 --> 00:08:01.339
Or they could even have, you know, an homage, an
176
00:08:01.379 --> 00:08:04.449
exhibit to the spacecraft that left, you know, 100,000 or
177
00:08:04.810 --> 00:08:09.769
a million years ago. And you can sort of see the.
178
00:08:08.689 --> 00:08:09.569
Origin of your own trip.
179
00:08:09.870 --> 00:08:13.139
Man. That's kind of cool, though. I mean, you could actually, so.
180
00:08:13.399 --> 00:08:15.959
Okay, so you can, but no one else can really
181
00:08:16.000 --> 00:08:16.740
participate in that.
182
00:08:16.800 --> 00:08:18.439
Unless they're part of the literal journey.
183
00:08:18.459 --> 00:08:20.420
Unless they're part of the literal journey. Right, right, good answer.
184
00:08:20.439 --> 00:08:25.319
So now what about this in terms of when you
185
00:08:25.339 --> 00:08:27.339
say you put these people on a ship, all right?
186
00:08:27.399 --> 00:08:29.100
So you take a colony of people, you put them
187
00:08:29.160 --> 00:08:34.139
on a ship, and now they go and they're looking
188
00:08:34.200 --> 00:08:35.379
for some place to live.
189
00:08:35.860 --> 00:08:37.590
And now you're just seeding the universe.
190
00:08:37.610 --> 00:08:37.679
Yes.
191
00:08:38.080 --> 00:08:41.539
You know, or at least another part of our galaxy,
192
00:08:41.570 --> 00:08:44.110
because you can't really say the universe, you know. Milky Way.
193
00:08:44.309 --> 00:08:45.960
The Milky Way, you know, because we're not going to,
194
00:08:46.289 --> 00:08:48.529
how long would it take us to get out of
195
00:08:48.929 --> 00:08:49.590
the Milky Way?
196
00:08:49.870 --> 00:08:52.490
Millions of years to the nearest galaxy. There you go. So,
197
00:08:52.850 --> 00:08:56.000
but with that. Sorry, sorry. Well, it's hundreds of thousands,
198
00:08:56.500 --> 00:08:59.779
you know. Let's get the numbers right. So our galaxy
199
00:08:59.820 --> 00:09:02.960
is about 100,000 light years across. So if we watch
200
00:09:03.019 --> 00:09:06.799
you travel at the speed of light, it'll take us 100,000
201
00:09:06.799 --> 00:09:09.929
years to observe that. but you could live an arbitrarily
202
00:09:10.029 --> 00:09:12.690
short amount of time depending on how fast you go.
203
00:09:12.830 --> 00:09:14.710
So that being said, you in principle could go to
204
00:09:14.730 --> 00:09:17.629
the Andromeda Galaxy two million light years away. We are
205
00:09:17.750 --> 00:09:22.690
long dead here, maybe, unless we're as smart as Brian
206
00:09:22.950 --> 00:09:26.860
wants to believe we are. And so, yeah. So you
207
00:09:26.889 --> 00:09:29.139
could go to another galaxy. But in practice, you want
208
00:09:29.159 --> 00:09:32.649
to pass by stars, not void of empty intergalactic space
209
00:09:32.690 --> 00:09:34.529
exactly right right yeah you want to go someplace where
210
00:09:34.549 --> 00:09:37.519
there's where there is something but brian's point that i
211
00:09:37.720 --> 00:09:39.700
take to heart is when i think of these ships
212
00:09:39.740 --> 00:09:42.120
i think that they're generational ships and they have to
213
00:09:42.139 --> 00:09:45.539
be really fertile people make babies babies grow up but
214
00:09:46.000 --> 00:09:48.120
i what was odd is you will be giving birth
215
00:09:48.620 --> 00:09:52.629
to children who will never have known earth yeah and
216
00:09:52.649 --> 00:09:55.210
that's that's kind of diabolical to me because they would
217
00:09:55.210 --> 00:09:57.470
not have had free choice to have taken that trip
218
00:09:57.470 --> 00:09:58.889
do you have any moral sense of that?
219
00:09:58.909 --> 00:10:00.899
Well, you know, I don't think any of us have
220
00:10:01.019 --> 00:10:02.200
free choice or free will.
221
00:10:02.299 --> 00:10:04.019
So if you want to get into that.
222
00:10:03.600 --> 00:10:05.019
Part of the conversation.
223
00:10:05.039 --> 00:10:08.740
That's another thing. Hey, let's just pull out two of
224
00:10:08.779 --> 00:10:10.899
those worms from that can.
225
00:10:11.379 --> 00:10:11.940
Wow.
226
00:10:12.299 --> 00:10:15.600
Holy moly. All right, we'll get back to that. I can't. Yeah,
227
00:10:15.639 --> 00:10:17.000
that's a big one right there. I don't have a
228
00:10:17.000 --> 00:10:20.100
certain bandwidth. Okay. All right, so let me ask you.
229
00:10:20.159 --> 00:10:23.220
I'm glad to be reminded that you can send a
230
00:10:24.070 --> 00:10:26.350
colony of people, and they can get anywhere they want
231
00:10:26.549 --> 00:10:29.269
in their lifetime, provided they travel fast enough.
232
00:10:29.649 --> 00:10:33.929
So now let me ask you this. Let's say they're
233
00:10:33.950 --> 00:10:36.690
going to go someplace even further, right? We're talking about
234
00:10:36.730 --> 00:10:38.210
true interstellar travel, right?
235
00:10:38.230 --> 00:10:38.750
Intergalactic.
236
00:10:38.809 --> 00:10:42.529
Intergalactic, because they're going to another galaxy, all right? And
237
00:10:42.570 --> 00:10:46.549
then they're coming back, okay? And they have kids and kids.
238
00:10:48.460 --> 00:10:51.220
What would that do? And maybe this is outside of
239
00:10:51.240 --> 00:10:51.679
your purview.
240
00:10:51.720 --> 00:10:52.080
I don't know.
241
00:10:52.519 --> 00:10:56.740
What would that do to us as a species? Would
242
00:10:56.779 --> 00:11:00.960
they be that much different from not having any of
243
00:11:01.000 --> 00:11:04.179
the effects of being on this spinning rock going around
244
00:11:04.220 --> 00:11:06.940
this little teeny star that we live in right now?
245
00:11:08.460 --> 00:11:09.539
That's beyond my purview.
246
00:11:10.980 --> 00:11:14.710
No, I would say that it is possible to speciate.
247
00:11:15.399 --> 00:11:17.490
One of the ways you make you split a species
248
00:11:17.549 --> 00:11:21.789
is you strand a variety of yourself in a place
249
00:11:21.909 --> 00:11:25.320
and then there's no more communication. That's why every fricking
250
00:11:25.440 --> 00:11:28.700
animal looks so different on in Australia. Okay.
251
00:11:28.740 --> 00:11:32.080
But you still need sufficient time during their isolated periods.
252
00:11:32.259 --> 00:11:34.059
And in this case, it could only be even a
253
00:11:34.120 --> 00:11:37.759
handful of generations, right? But there still would be generations,
254
00:11:37.799 --> 00:11:39.669
as you said, who would never have experienced life on
255
00:11:39.690 --> 00:11:40.110
planet earth.
256
00:11:40.210 --> 00:11:43.750
But you also need pressure to select against some features
257
00:11:43.870 --> 00:11:47.620
and promote others. So that those features then become something
258
00:11:47.700 --> 00:11:51.769
else that are not recognizable to where you came from. Okay,
259
00:11:52.029 --> 00:11:54.350
I got you. So you need that. And if that
260
00:11:54.470 --> 00:11:58.049
ship is exactly the environment that Earth has always been
261
00:11:58.100 --> 00:11:58.649
and always will be.
262
00:11:58.649 --> 00:12:00.360
If you create 1G and you do all this stuff,
263
00:12:00.460 --> 00:12:03.820
you're not really creating a circumstance where there's a pressure to.
264
00:12:04.080 --> 00:12:04.539
A pressure, yeah.
265
00:12:04.649 --> 00:12:06.850
But if you create a reality show where it's Survivor
266
00:12:06.970 --> 00:12:10.750
on the ship, and then you have artificial pressures, yeah,
267
00:12:10.789 --> 00:12:13.490
you could drive the species into some different places.
268
00:12:13.629 --> 00:12:16.960
That's kind of wild. So it wouldn't be natural selection,
269
00:12:16.980 --> 00:12:18.519
it would be artificial selection. Yeah, that's right.
270
00:12:18.779 --> 00:12:20.240
You just inject them from the ship.
271
00:12:20.360 --> 00:12:24.799
All right, we're going to space you. All right, next question.
272
00:12:24.879 --> 00:12:26.019
Let's do the next question.
273
00:12:26.230 --> 00:12:29.610
All right, here we go. This is Cheyenne Leo, who
274
00:12:29.769 --> 00:12:31.110
is also from Patreon.
275
00:12:32.039 --> 00:12:35.389
Cheyenne Leo. That's a nice name. I like that. Hello, Mr. Green.
276
00:12:35.830 --> 00:12:39.730
I hail from Canada, and I love your books. I've
277
00:12:39.750 --> 00:12:43.549
been wondering lately, what is time made of? I might
278
00:12:43.590 --> 00:12:45.509
be a little out there, but I was thinking that
279
00:12:45.549 --> 00:12:48.980
it must be made of something, because presumably it was
280
00:12:49.059 --> 00:12:51.480
created in the Big Bang, and it interacts with things
281
00:12:51.519 --> 00:12:54.879
like light and gravity. Light takes time to get there.
282
00:12:55.000 --> 00:12:58.340
Gravity slows it down in extreme circumstances, etc.
283
00:12:58.419 --> 00:12:58.539
etc.
284
00:12:59.480 --> 00:13:02.620
So if we can interact with other forces, shouldn't it
285
00:13:02.659 --> 00:13:04.179
be made of something?
286
00:13:04.210 --> 00:13:06.929
I love that question. It's a great question. When is
287
00:13:06.970 --> 00:13:09.649
something more than just an idea? When does it become
288
00:13:09.669 --> 00:13:10.169
a thing?
289
00:13:10.250 --> 00:13:13.169
Well, this is an idea that is starting to become
290
00:13:13.190 --> 00:13:16.629
a thing right now. So it's certainly the case that
291
00:13:16.690 --> 00:13:18.850
the intuition of the question is right on target. When
292
00:13:18.870 --> 00:13:21.480
we look at ordinary material objects in the real world,
293
00:13:21.820 --> 00:13:24.120
they are made of stuff. They're made of molecules, made
294
00:13:24.159 --> 00:13:27.860
of atoms, made of subatomic particles. Could that idea be
295
00:13:27.940 --> 00:13:31.559
relevant for space and time themselves? And people have thought
296
00:13:31.580 --> 00:13:34.120
about this for a long time, but recently there have
297
00:13:34.139 --> 00:13:36.480
been developments in a variety of fields, string theory
being
298
00:13:36.580 --> 00:13:39.100
one of them, where we're starting to catch a glimpse
299
00:13:39.259 --> 00:13:43.730
of what the ingredients of space and time might actually be.
300
00:13:44.299 --> 00:13:46.129
And in fact, there's work that's being done that shows.
301
00:13:46.149 --> 00:13:48.990
You're not talking about a time particle? Not really a time.
302
00:13:48.789 --> 00:13:51.929
Particle per se, but it's easier to talk about this
303
00:13:51.970 --> 00:13:53.889
in space, even though space and time are really the
304
00:13:53.929 --> 00:13:57.120
same thing, but we have some evidence that space itself
305
00:13:57.220 --> 00:14:01.000
may be stitched by the threads of quantum entanglement. So
306
00:14:01.019 --> 00:14:04.820
this idea of quantum entanglement that links together distant objects
307
00:14:04.860 --> 00:14:07.100
in a way that makes it appear as though they're
308
00:14:07.120 --> 00:14:09.620
right next to each other in terms of their physical properties,
309
00:14:10.100 --> 00:14:12.759
it may be that the threads of quantum entanglement are
310
00:14:13.120 --> 00:14:15.190
the stitches in the fabric of space-time itself.
311
00:14:15.350 --> 00:14:16.950
Is this where you get to the idea that in
312
00:14:16.970 --> 00:14:22.909
the distant future, where dark energy accelerates us ever greater,
313
00:14:23.669 --> 00:14:28.340
that it might accelerate us faster than quantum phenomenon can
314
00:14:28.379 --> 00:14:31.139
keep up, creating a tear in the fabric of space-time?
315
00:14:31.279 --> 00:14:33.549
Yeah, and in fact, you don't even need to know
316
00:14:33.590 --> 00:14:35.629
about the ingredients in the fabric of space to come
317
00:14:35.649 --> 00:14:36.090
to that conclusion.
318
00:14:36.110 --> 00:14:37.970
You didn't even pause when I said that. That means
319
00:14:38.049 --> 00:14:38.990
it could really happen.
320
00:14:39.070 --> 00:14:42.409
Yeah, so the idea that the dark energy... might get
321
00:14:42.529 --> 00:14:44.549
stronger over time. So right now we all know that
322
00:14:44.570 --> 00:14:48.710
there is dark energy pushing the distant galaxies away. We've
323
00:14:48.730 --> 00:14:50.080
spoken about this before.
324
00:14:50.149 --> 00:14:51.279
We actually have.
325
00:14:51.480 --> 00:14:55.940
We actually have spoken about this before.
326
00:14:56.159 --> 00:14:59.710
But it's possible that that dark energy gains strength over time,
327
00:14:59.919 --> 00:15:01.850
which means that it would not only drive the distant
328
00:15:01.870 --> 00:15:04.409
galaxies away ever more quickly, but it would start to
329
00:15:04.470 --> 00:15:07.620
drive even planets away from their stars, and it would
330
00:15:07.659 --> 00:15:11.220
even drive electrons away from the nucleus of atoms, which
331
00:15:11.259 --> 00:15:14.100
would rip matter apart. And yes, you're right, depending on
332
00:15:14.139 --> 00:15:16.500
the very nature of space-time, it could be that
this
333
00:15:16.539 --> 00:15:20.480
dark energy growing over time might sunder space itself, might
334
00:15:20.629 --> 00:15:21.909
rip the fabric of space apart.
335
00:15:21.960 --> 00:15:24.600
That's amazing. You're talking about the actual tearing of the
336
00:15:24.700 --> 00:15:27.019
universe itself. I don't even want to think about that.
337
00:15:27.080 --> 00:15:28.799
Now I should point out that since you brought up
338
00:15:28.820 --> 00:15:30.759
the tearing of the fabric of space, a paper that
339
00:15:30.820 --> 00:15:32.559
I wrote with a couple of colleagues years ago was
340
00:15:32.600 --> 00:15:36.340
the first mathematical demonstration within string theory that the fabric
341
00:15:36.360 --> 00:15:39.019
of space can rip apart in a manner that would
342
00:15:39.059 --> 00:15:41.879
not yield a catastrophe. The fabric of space would repair
343
00:15:41.919 --> 00:15:44.929
itself and it would just be a new behavior within
344
00:15:44.950 --> 00:15:48.200
the repertoire of things that space can accomplish that Einstein
345
00:15:48.220 --> 00:15:50.440
would never have thought of. But Einstein didn't think about
346
00:15:50.480 --> 00:15:53.039
quantum mechanics and the general theory of relativity. And when
347
00:15:53.080 --> 00:15:55.700
you unite them, as string theory does, you get new
348
00:15:55.759 --> 00:15:57.539
things that space and time can do. And one of
349
00:15:57.580 --> 00:15:59.419
them may be tearing apart.
350
00:15:59.639 --> 00:16:00.480
And it repairs itself.
351
00:16:00.500 --> 00:16:01.720
And it repairs itself. So it may not be as
352
00:16:01.759 --> 00:16:02.610
catastrophic as you think.
353
00:16:02.620 --> 00:16:08.710
And ointment for that. Ointment. We have a salve. Put
354
00:16:08.730 --> 00:16:10.710
some ice on it.
355
00:16:10.750 --> 00:16:12.309
Actually, it's not so much a salve.
356
00:16:12.669 --> 00:16:15.789
The strings in string theory can surround the tear and
357
00:16:15.850 --> 00:16:18.080
form more of a band-aid. So it's more that the
358
00:16:18.159 --> 00:16:20.909
strings form a bandaid that protects us from the rip
359
00:16:20.929 --> 00:16:23.450
in the fabric of space. And there's math behind this.
360
00:16:23.509 --> 00:16:24.850
It's not like a crazy guy.
361
00:16:24.950 --> 00:16:27.019
You look very skeptical at this.
362
00:16:27.159 --> 00:16:29.379
I did too because that sounds eerily like.
363
00:16:29.539 --> 00:16:31.139
Don't hide behind this math.
364
00:16:31.179 --> 00:16:31.759
I'm not hiding.
365
00:16:31.820 --> 00:16:35.159
I'm just trying to let you know. talk about some
366
00:16:35.230 --> 00:16:37.330
crazy stuff that had nothing to do with reality, and
367
00:16:37.370 --> 00:16:39.360
you know it. Don't tell me there's math behind it.
368
00:16:39.490 --> 00:16:40.210
So therefore.
369
00:16:40.250 --> 00:16:43.909
This emerges right from the most natural interpretation of the
370
00:16:43.929 --> 00:16:44.669
equations of
string theory.
371
00:16:44.690 --> 00:16:46.509
So I'm not standing on my head to make this happen.
372
00:16:46.549 --> 00:16:49.389
Okay. No, that's an important point. It is. Because there's
373
00:16:49.429 --> 00:16:51.409
a lot of stuff that we think about where you
374
00:16:51.450 --> 00:16:52.850
have to go out in left field to try to
375
00:16:52.889 --> 00:16:55.070
get the explanation. But if this flows out of your
376
00:16:55.090 --> 00:16:58.159
stuff naturally, it's a beautiful thing. Very cool.
377
00:16:58.179 --> 00:16:59.100
Can I tell you what else happened?
378
00:16:59.220 --> 00:17:00.519
Oh, please.
379
00:17:00.539 --> 00:17:01.240
Black holes.
380
00:17:02.029 --> 00:17:05.470
shrink down to a very small size, very small mass,
381
00:17:05.529 --> 00:17:09.559
and they transmute into elementary particles. So black holes that
382
00:17:09.579 --> 00:17:11.480
you normally think as being kind of this big thing
383
00:17:11.519 --> 00:17:14.519
out in the cosmos, different from the fundamental constituents of matter,
384
00:17:14.799 --> 00:17:19.240
when space rips, the process that repairs it involves black
385
00:17:19.279 --> 00:17:20.519
holes turning into particles.
386
00:17:21.240 --> 00:17:23.809
See, now he just made that one up. No, you
387
00:17:23.849 --> 00:17:26.049
had me until the humor prepares itself.
388
00:17:26.089 --> 00:17:28.650
I don't make that one.
389
00:17:28.690 --> 00:17:33.549
No, no, no. Black holes are the doctors and the nurses. No,
390
00:17:33.569 --> 00:17:44.599
I'm sorry. No, you foolish. Oh, man. No, we got
391
00:17:44.619 --> 00:17:46.319
to wrap this segment. Oh, we got to wrap this segment. No,
392
00:17:46.339 --> 00:17:48.400
I'm sorry. We're taking too long to answer these questions. No, no,
393
00:17:48.420 --> 00:17:51.859
we're not. This is great stuff. When we come back. Oh,
394
00:17:51.900 --> 00:17:54.480
I wish we were here every day, Brian. Oh, that
395
00:17:54.500 --> 00:17:58.069
was amazing. More Cosmic Queries. Until the end of time.
396
00:17:58.910 --> 00:18:02.789
Questions from the heart of the cosmos. When we return.
397
00:18:04.890 --> 00:18:08.250
The Great Courses Plus is a subscription on-demand video learning
398
00:18:08.289 --> 00:18:12.440
service with top-notch lectures and courses from top professors from
399
00:18:12.480 --> 00:18:16.519
the Ivy League and other great universities globally, and experts
400
00:18:16.579 --> 00:18:20.819
from places like National Geographic, the Smithsonian, and the Culinary
401
00:18:20.940 --> 00:18:24.660
Institute of America. Through your subscription, you get access to
402
00:18:24.700 --> 00:18:29.359
a huge library of over 11,000 video lectures about anything
403
00:18:29.380 --> 00:18:33.619
that interests you, from science, math, history, literature, even how
404
00:18:33.640 --> 00:18:37.450
to cook, play chess, or become a better photographer. And
405
00:18:37.509 --> 00:18:40.089
we know you're intellectually curious, so we know you're going
406
00:18:40.130 --> 00:18:43.109
to love it. Speaking of better photography, I've always wanted
407
00:18:43.130 --> 00:18:45.930
to take better pictures, and thanks to The Great Courses Plus,
408
00:18:46.210 --> 00:18:49.829
that's happening. I am taking The Fundamentals of Photography with
409
00:18:49.890 --> 00:18:53.930
Joel Satori, a pro photog from National Geographic. I'm learning
410
00:18:53.990 --> 00:18:57.230
about lighting and composition, and most of all, how to
411
00:18:57.289 --> 00:19:01.500
take interesting photos. Stream and enjoy it from your TV,
412
00:19:01.619 --> 00:19:05.359
your laptop, your tablet, your phone, or through any web
413
00:19:05.380 --> 00:19:08.519
browser by using the Great Courses Plus app. Learn at
414
00:19:08.539 --> 00:19:11.160
your own pace when and where you want. Now, the
415
00:19:11.180 --> 00:19:15.339
Great Courses Plus is giving you a great offer of
416
00:19:15.380 --> 00:19:18.799
a free trial. Show your support for StarTalk Radio by
417
00:19:18.880 --> 00:19:26.420
subscribing to the Great Courses Plus. Please visit thegreatcoursesplus.com slash StarTalkRadio.
418
00:19:26.859 --> 00:19:29.960
Click on the link in the description below to start
419
00:19:30.240 --> 00:19:32.220
your free trial today.
420
00:19:33.460 --> 00:19:33.839
We're back.
421
00:19:35.220 --> 00:19:36.109
StarTalk.
422
00:19:38.130 --> 00:19:43.609
Cosmic Queries. We've got Brian Green here. The one, the only,
423
00:19:43.670 --> 00:19:47.210
longtime friend, colleague. Love this man to death. He's been
424
00:19:47.230 --> 00:19:50.599
a friend of StarTalk from the beginning. From the beginning. Absolutely.
425
00:19:50.619 --> 00:19:53.940
This is not his first rodeo with us here. So, Brian,
426
00:19:54.160 --> 00:19:55.450
congratulations on your fourth book.
427
00:19:55.609 --> 00:19:55.950
Thank you.
428
00:19:56.529 --> 00:19:58.470
And got a great write-up in the New York Times,
429
00:19:58.950 --> 00:20:02.680
very enthusiastic write-up. And even when he was criticizing it,
430
00:20:02.720 --> 00:20:06.240
he was praising it. Yeah, right. It's like, oh, it
431
00:20:06.259 --> 00:20:08.079
got complicated, but it needed that. And I kind of
432
00:20:08.099 --> 00:20:09.720
liked it. And it got me into it. You know,
433
00:20:09.740 --> 00:20:11.119
it was like one of those kind of things. So
434
00:20:11.180 --> 00:20:15.369
who actually reviews your books? I'm serious.
435
00:20:15.410 --> 00:20:19.049
Like you two guys, you write these books. Who is
436
00:20:19.150 --> 00:20:22.609
it that sits down and says, Okay, let me go
437
00:20:22.670 --> 00:20:23.349
through here.
438
00:20:23.470 --> 00:20:28.650
It's his mom. Brian's mother. Intermittent employee for the New
439
00:20:28.710 --> 00:20:29.390
York Times.
440
00:20:29.730 --> 00:20:31.710
Son, I have to tell you, I don't know about
441
00:20:31.750 --> 00:20:37.029
this whole thing about
black holes and particles. So, no, really,
442
00:20:37.089 --> 00:20:40.019
who is it? I would say there's not a lot
443
00:20:40.059 --> 00:20:40.930
of people that can do that.
444
00:20:40.990 --> 00:20:45.049
They're science editors. That's their job. If they can't handle it,
445
00:20:45.480 --> 00:20:48.500
then they don't review it. There are plenty of newspapers
446
00:20:48.519 --> 00:20:49.420
that don't review science books.
447
00:20:49.480 --> 00:20:51.720
Oh, actually, the number of reviews of science books is
448
00:20:51.759 --> 00:20:55.730
going down because newspapers are really winnowing the staff.
449
00:20:55.750 --> 00:20:58.769
Yeah, they're cutting their staff so they can't afford it. Wow.
450
00:20:59.549 --> 00:21:02.470
So this, just to give him credit because he's in
451
00:21:02.509 --> 00:21:07.190
the club, Dennis Overby, longtime science writer and editor.
452
00:21:07.210 --> 00:21:07.930
One of the best, really.
453
00:21:07.950 --> 00:21:12.430
For the New York Times. And he leans cosmological, although
454
00:21:12.450 --> 00:21:15.799
when we demoted Pluto here, he wanted to dip into that.
455
00:21:16.740 --> 00:21:18.920
when I said, this is not your beat. This is
456
00:21:18.980 --> 00:21:21.920
too nearby for you. But I think he wanted some
457
00:21:21.940 --> 00:21:24.339
Pluto street cred. So he did a little Pluto article
458
00:21:24.460 --> 00:21:25.539
on our demotion.
459
00:21:25.660 --> 00:21:29.440
And was he for or against your postulate?
460
00:21:29.680 --> 00:21:34.000
He was antagonistic. Oh, okay. All right, gotcha. But anyhow,
461
00:21:34.039 --> 00:21:35.529
he's a longtime editor and he has a book of
462
00:21:35.549 --> 00:21:38.779
his own. So the real meta question is who reviews
463
00:21:38.799 --> 00:21:42.019
the book? So did you two actually review his book?
464
00:21:42.359 --> 00:21:43.930
I think he wrote a book, The Lonely Hearts of
465
00:21:43.950 --> 00:21:48.349
the Cosmos, which was about two astronomers trying to find
466
00:21:48.369 --> 00:21:50.730
the scale of the universe. Was that the book I'm remembering?
467
00:21:50.869 --> 00:21:52.210
I don't remember the details.
468
00:21:52.289 --> 00:21:57.319
Okay. But it was biographical. Okay. Astronomers who had access
469
00:21:57.359 --> 00:21:58.039
to big telescopes.
470
00:21:58.299 --> 00:21:58.500
All right.
471
00:21:58.619 --> 00:22:00.680
And you're there at night looking up at the night
472
00:22:00.720 --> 00:22:03.640
sky with the telescope, and nobody else, Lonely Hearts of
473
00:22:03.660 --> 00:22:06.920
the Cosmos. Oh, okay. Yeah. That sounds about right. Okay.
474
00:22:06.960 --> 00:22:09.640
No, I'm joking. All right, here we go. Let's get
475
00:22:09.680 --> 00:22:10.710
back to our questions.
476
00:22:11.130 --> 00:22:16.250
This is CS21. Hold it lower so people can see
477
00:22:16.269 --> 00:22:16.970
your beautiful face.
478
00:22:16.990 --> 00:22:17.210
Oh, sorry.
479
00:22:17.250 -->
00:22:19.430
Here we go. CS21. I forgot we're on camera, too.
480
00:22:20.269 --> 00:22:23.009
Hey, do you think the laws of physics are finite
481
00:22:23.450 --> 00:22:27.309
and knowable? Can we ever fully understand the universe in
482
00:22:27.349 --> 00:22:30.119
its entirety? If so, what forces might we be able
483
00:22:30.200 --> 00:22:35.920
to manipulate that are beyond us now? Ooh.
484
00:22:36.099 --> 00:22:37.980
That's a very, very cool question.
485
00:22:38.259 --> 00:22:39.700
No, it's a deep question. Yeah, it really is.
486
00:22:39.720 --> 00:22:41.519
Because, look, you look around the world and there are
487
00:22:41.559 --> 00:22:45.940
intelligent beings walking around, dogs, right? And they don't, we think,
488
00:22:46.019 --> 00:22:48.539
understand the general theory of relativity or quantum mechanics.
489
00:22:48.579 --> 00:22:50.119
So these are intelligent brains.
490
00:22:50.539 --> 00:22:51.980
Although when I say that, I always think the dogs
491
00:22:52.019 --> 00:22:53.880
are out there barking and saying, ah, he thinks we
492
00:22:53.900 --> 00:22:55.779
don't understand general relativity.
493
00:22:55.799 --> 00:22:56.319
But seeing if.
494
00:22:56.460 --> 00:22:58.259
That's really the case, then why do we think that
495
00:22:58.279 --> 00:23:01.720
the human brain would be able to understand it all?
496
00:23:01.779 --> 00:23:04.220
We may have limitations on the deep truths that we're
497
00:23:04.279 --> 00:23:07.619
able to grasp. Now, having said that, there's no evidence
498
00:23:07.940 --> 00:23:10.140
that there's any limit to what we can figure out.
499
00:23:10.180 --> 00:23:13.230
We haven't hit the wall, right? We did develop quantum mechanics.
500
00:23:13.269 --> 00:23:14.450
We did develop relativity.
501
00:23:14.470 --> 00:23:18.170
Wait, wait, wait. You and your compatriots have been at
502
00:23:18.190 --> 00:23:20.210
this string theory thing for 30 years. Yeah, here we go.
503
00:23:20.259 --> 00:23:20.539
Maybe.
504
00:23:20.559 --> 00:23:21.339
Here we go.
505
00:23:21.619 --> 00:23:23.200
Maybe that's the wall.
506
00:23:23.539 --> 00:23:24.019
It could be.
507
00:23:24.140 --> 00:23:27.099
Maybe you guys aren't smart enough. You found the wall.
508
00:23:27.480 --> 00:23:28.539
But here's what I would say to that.
509
00:23:28.559 --> 00:23:30.779
Let me hold up a mirror to you here, okay?
510
00:23:30.799 --> 00:23:32.599
Who's the one who's at the edge of the wall?
511
00:23:32.640 --> 00:23:34.279
See, but that would only be the case if we
512
00:23:34.299 --> 00:23:36.519
were sitting here saying we can't make any progress in
513
00:23:36.559 --> 00:23:40.559
understanding the mathematics of string theory. We're making incredible progress,
514
00:23:40.599 --> 00:23:42.779
but the thing is, and the part that you're responding to,
515
00:23:42.819 --> 00:23:45.519
which is completely justified- We haven't been able to make
516
00:23:45.599 --> 00:23:49.289
contact with
observation or experiment. But that's not all that
517
00:23:49.329 --> 00:23:52.990
surprising when you're dealing with a theory whose energy scale
518
00:23:53.390 --> 00:23:55.509
is like 10 to the 15, 10 to the 16
519
00:23:55.509 --> 00:23:57.769
times greater than that of the Large Hadron Collider, the
520
00:23:57.809 --> 00:24:01.250
most powerful machine in Geneva, Switzerland. So I agree that
521
00:24:01.309 --> 00:24:04.509
we have hit roadblocks, but it's not us theorists.
522
00:24:04.910 --> 00:24:06.029
It's the experimenters.
523
00:24:06.049 --> 00:24:09.369
There you go. And if I might chime in here. Smackdown.
524
00:24:09.390 --> 00:24:12.809
If I might chime in here, let me just add. Oh, right.
525
00:24:16.180 --> 00:24:19.319
That's the dog saying, we have the solution, but you just...
526
00:24:19.099 --> 00:24:23.650
There's your answer, guys. You're neutering us and you're taking
527
00:24:23.690 --> 00:24:29.950
us to... And you're feeding me Alpo. I don't know. Okay, cool, man. Oh,
528
00:24:29.970 --> 00:24:32.609
that's a great answer. That's a great answer. Wait, wait.
529
00:24:32.670 --> 00:24:34.769
Go ahead. Let me give a nuance to that question
530
00:24:34.809 --> 00:24:39.730
and hand it back to him. All right. Okay. Do
531
00:24:39.769 --> 00:24:43.690
you believe there may be missing laws of physics that'll
532
00:24:43.710 --> 00:24:46.990
help us get further or that kind of all the
533
00:24:47.009 --> 00:24:49.089
laws of physics are there, we just need to be
534
00:24:49.130 --> 00:24:50.289
more creative with what we've got.
535
00:24:50.930 --> 00:24:52.069
Yeah, I think it would be hubris.
536
00:24:52.089 --> 00:24:53.730
That's a little bit of that. Yes, it is. It's
537
00:24:54.309 --> 00:24:54.930
a different tact.
538
00:24:54.990 --> 00:24:57.259
Yeah, to think that we really have it right now
539
00:24:57.460 --> 00:25:00.319
would be sort of the classic act of hubris, right?
540
00:25:00.500 --> 00:25:02.400
I mean, every time we thought we figured it all out,
541
00:25:02.420 --> 00:25:04.519
there was a new law, there was a new particle,
542
00:25:04.539 --> 00:25:07.049
there was something else to find. So I would imagine...
543
00:25:07.140 --> 00:25:10.210
at sufficiently high energy scales, we're going to find new.
544
00:25:10.130 --> 00:25:11.529
Stuff, new particles.
545
00:25:11.549 --> 00:25:13.789
New energy scales would be beyond where anyone has gone before. Yeah,
546
00:25:13.809 --> 00:25:15.230
so right now... Bold to boldly go.
547
00:25:15.250 --> 00:25:17.569
Yeah, so let's say we've basically gone on the order
548
00:25:17.609 --> 00:25:21.380
of 10,000 times the mass of a proton, roughly speaking.
549
00:25:21.430 --> 00:25:21.779
Energy.
550
00:25:21.950 --> 00:25:25.319
Energy, energy scale. And we haven't found anything new yet.
551
00:25:25.740 --> 00:25:27.920
But I would imagine that between that scale and the
552
00:25:27.960 --> 00:25:31.380
so-called Planck scale, which is where the fundamental laws of
553
00:25:31.460 --> 00:25:34.740
quantum mechanics and gravity come together, that's 10 to the
554
00:25:34.740 --> 00:25:37.859
19 times the mass of a proton. So that's 19
555
00:25:37.859 --> 00:25:40.640
orders of magnitude bigger than a proton, and we've only
556
00:25:40.660 --> 00:25:43.279
gone up to sort of four orders of magnitude bigger
557
00:25:43.299 --> 00:25:47.180
than a proton. So in that range, I suspect there's
558
00:25:47.200 --> 00:25:48.500
going to be something new to be found.
559
00:25:48.839 --> 00:25:48.920
Okay.
560
00:25:49.019 --> 00:25:51.859
Interesting. Because just in all fairness to those who've come
561
00:25:51.900 --> 00:25:55.380
before us, they would be working in a tabletop, right?
562
00:25:55.420 --> 00:25:58.349
And there'd be some phenomenon they don't understand, and then
563
00:25:58.369 --> 00:26:00.630
they'd experiment with it, and then they isolate it and
564
00:26:00.690 --> 00:26:04.569
name it and characterize it and mathematize it. Yes. And
565
00:26:04.630 --> 00:26:08.619
so our basic known four forces of nature come out
566
00:26:08.640 --> 00:26:12.420
of that kind of experiment. Kind of tabletop plus simple
567
00:26:12.480 --> 00:26:13.880
particle accelerators, right?
568
00:26:14.079 --> 00:26:15.799
And astronomical observations.
569
00:26:15.839 --> 00:26:19.240
And observations. So what you're saying is that's a regime
570
00:26:19.420 --> 00:26:23.200
that manifested some aspects of nature that we have figured
571
00:26:23.259 --> 00:26:25.900
out in a tidy way. But there could be bigger
572
00:26:25.960 --> 00:26:29.009
questions we don't even get to yet because we haven't
573
00:26:29.309 --> 00:26:32.829
tested the regime and that regime is not on our tabletop. Exactly. Okay.
574
00:26:33.349 --> 00:26:36.269
That means the future of physics is big money, big accelerators.
575
00:26:36.970 --> 00:26:39.670
That is one way. The lone candle burning.
576
00:26:39.690 --> 00:26:41.390
It's that, but I also like to think that if
577
00:26:41.430 --> 00:26:45.660
we're sufficiently clever, we might find indirect ways of probing
578
00:26:45.799 --> 00:26:48.660
realms that you'd think would require that big machine, but
579
00:26:48.700 --> 00:26:50.920
maybe we can be smarter about it.
580
00:26:51.259 --> 00:26:51.720
Okay.
581
00:26:52.259 --> 00:26:54.500
On Star Trek, it's just all computer simulations.
582
00:26:55.599 --> 00:26:59.230
By the way, just as a signal to my people
583
00:26:59.849 --> 00:27:02.009
being clever, it was how are you going to put
584
00:27:02.049 --> 00:27:05.380
a big telescope in orbit you can't make a rocket
585
00:27:05.400 --> 00:27:08.819
that wide. No, so you... Build it, let's build it. Well,
586
00:27:08.839 --> 00:27:11.079
you can build it in space, or you can get
587
00:27:11.279 --> 00:27:14.619
a mirror that unfurls. All of a sudden, the engineers say, hey,
588
00:27:14.720 --> 00:27:17.200
I got this. Let me be clever and figure it out.
589
00:27:17.710 --> 00:27:21.950
So we've actually overcome many challenges that previously were considered
590
00:27:21.990 --> 00:27:24.910
intractable just by clever people. Yeah, exactly. I'm echoing your point.
591
00:27:24.930 --> 00:27:25.769
Yeah, yeah, exactly right.
592
00:27:25.950 --> 00:27:28.269
That is super cool, super cool, super cool. All right,
593
00:27:28.289 --> 00:27:31.009
here we go. This is Jane9117. It says, findings.
594
00:27:33.809 --> 00:27:38.109
Slash creating your own meaning is fine. But objectively, what
595
00:27:38.150 --> 00:27:43.400
do you think, Brian, is the actual meaning of this creation?
596
00:27:43.660 --> 00:27:47.880
Because meaning is a big part of where you try
597
00:27:47.900 --> 00:27:48.740
to go in this book.
598
00:27:49.619 --> 00:27:52.220
And the answer that I give to that question, which
599
00:27:52.279 --> 00:27:55.299
I developed completely and more fully, I should say, not
600
00:27:55.319 --> 00:27:58.819
completely in the book, is that there is no ultimate
601
00:27:58.920 --> 00:28:01.319
meaning floating out there in the void, right?
602
00:28:01.849 --> 00:28:02.450
Throughout these.
603
00:28:02.470 --> 00:28:04.029
I've got to go through all these pages to find
604
00:28:04.069 --> 00:28:04.930
out that there's no meaning?
605
00:28:04.990 --> 00:28:05.759
I'm going to give you the.
606
00:28:05.769 --> 00:28:07.049
I've got to read this for you to tell me
607
00:28:07.089 --> 00:28:07.809
there's no meaning?
608
00:28:07.869 --> 00:28:09.390
Cliff notes. Cliff notes right here.
609
00:28:09.630 --> 00:28:12.269
So the cliff notes are that we are the product
610
00:28:12.309 --> 00:28:15.630
of the mindless, purposeless laws of physics. We are all
611
00:28:15.650 --> 00:28:18.900
just bags of particles governed by those ironclad mathematical.
612
00:28:18.920 --> 00:28:19.119
Ectoplasm.
613
00:28:19.140 --> 00:28:19.720
That's it.
614
00:28:20.339 --> 00:28:23.519
And what we have the capacity to do, which is remarkable,
615
00:28:23.900 --> 00:28:28.079
is impose order, impose coherence, impose purpose and meaning on
616
00:28:28.119 --> 00:28:31.309
the external world and the internal conscious experience.
617
00:28:31.720 --> 00:28:33.779
And so it's not as though they're two things.
618
00:28:34.180 --> 00:28:36.640
The real answer that's floating out there in the void
619
00:28:36.720 --> 00:28:39.700
awaiting our discovery and sort of the internal one that
620
00:28:39.720 --> 00:28:42.720
we manufacture, it is only the internal one that we
621
00:28:42.759 --> 00:28:45.480
manufacture because there is nothing else.
622
00:28:45.779 --> 00:28:46.619
How do you know this?
623
00:28:46.859 --> 00:28:50.779
I don't know this beyond my experience in a lifetime
624
00:28:50.839 --> 00:28:53.740
of working with the laws of nature, the particles of nature,
625
00:28:53.779 --> 00:28:55.660
and trying to give explanations for the things that we
626
00:28:55.700 --> 00:28:56.740
observe in the external world.
627
00:28:56.779 --> 00:28:59.740
So the particles are your gods? Well, you know.
628
00:29:00.549 --> 00:29:01.690
There is a place for religion.
629
00:29:01.710 --> 00:29:04.549
You need to answer that question way faster than that. No, no.
630
00:29:04.569 --> 00:29:06.670
The particles of your gut. Oh, well.
631
00:29:06.690 --> 00:29:07.039
No, no.
632
00:29:07.099 --> 00:29:08.200
Don't really want to go there.
633
00:29:08.220 --> 00:29:09.839
Well, let me think about it.
634
00:29:09.940 --> 00:29:10.460
No, no, no.
635
00:29:10.519 --> 00:29:14.839
My altar has some neutrinos on it, but. Yeah. No, no.
636
00:29:14.920 --> 00:29:16.019
But honestly, seriously.
637
00:29:16.400 --> 00:29:18.720
I do think there's a role for religion that some
638
00:29:18.759 --> 00:29:22.599
of our colleagues step on and dismiss out of hand entirely.
639
00:29:22.640 --> 00:29:23.269
And what would that be?
640
00:29:23.349 --> 00:29:26.730
Well, it's not to understand the external world. No one
641
00:29:26.769 --> 00:29:30.329
can use any religious doctrine to calculate the electron's magnetic
642
00:29:30.410 --> 00:29:32.849
moment to nine decimal places, which is what we can
643
00:29:32.890 --> 00:29:35.869
do routinely with quantum field theory. But if you think
644
00:29:35.910 --> 00:29:39.390
about religion and the spiritual journey as something that doesn't
645
00:29:39.430 --> 00:29:39.970
illuminate the.
646
00:29:40.059 --> 00:29:42.700
External world but rather the internal world of conscious experience.
647
00:29:42.720 --> 00:29:44.480
Which many people go towards for meaning in life.
648
00:29:44.619 --> 00:29:45.559
Yes, exactly.
649
00:29:45.640 --> 00:29:48.119
Then there is a role for it. And you don't
650
00:29:48.240 --> 00:29:51.059
judge it by whether it can explain the external world.
651
00:29:51.259 --> 00:29:53.579
That's not what it's meant to do. You judge it
652
00:29:53.619 --> 00:29:56.900
by whether It is a satisfying way of trying to
653
00:29:57.019 --> 00:29:59.500
understand your place in the universe.
654
00:29:59.500 --> 00:30:01.259
90% of religious people would say that. The other 10%
655
00:30:01.259 --> 00:30:02.220
who are fundamentalists.
656
00:30:02.240 --> 00:30:03.240
Yeah, of course, go a different direction.
657
00:30:03.259 --> 00:30:05.420
Get their science out of the Bible. I agree.
658
00:30:05.480 --> 00:30:06.609
And that's problematic.
659
00:30:06.750 --> 00:30:10.190
Enlightened religious people are where you're coming from. I agree.
660
00:30:10.250 --> 00:30:13.529
Very good. That was a little journey. I liked it, man.
661
00:30:13.549 --> 00:30:16.289
I still think he's got an altar in his home.
662
00:30:16.430 --> 00:30:21.809
A neutrino altar. I'm pretty sure. He sacrifices to the
663
00:30:21.849 --> 00:30:26.420
particle gods. I'm pretty sure. I'm pretty sure about that.
664
00:30:26.720 -->
00:30:33.160
All right. Okay. Let's move on to Lee Bird. Okay.
665
00:30:34.940 --> 00:30:38.680
So Lee Bird from Facebook says, hello, Dr. Tyson and Dr.
666
00:30:38.769 --> 00:30:46.289
Green. My wife has asked, where, where does our universe end?
667
00:30:47.009 --> 00:30:47.450
Not how.
668
00:30:48.460 --> 00:30:51.039
But where does our universe end? And I would like
669
00:30:51.079 --> 00:30:53.579
to say, are there more than one ending? Is there
670
00:30:53.619 --> 00:30:56.119
an ending and then more endings? Are there levels of endings?
671
00:30:56.140 --> 00:30:57.519
That's a time ending rather than a place ending.
672
00:30:57.539 --> 00:30:58.539
Well, that's what I'm saying. All right.
673
00:30:58.640 --> 00:30:59.619
But is this a place ending?
674
00:30:59.660 --> 00:31:00.240
That's what I'm hearing.
675
00:31:00.259 --> 00:31:00.799
That's a place.
676
00:31:00.839 --> 00:31:02.079
You think it's a time ending?
677
00:31:02.119 --> 00:31:03.940
Where? Wait, no, where? It's a place. So there's a
678
00:31:03.980 --> 00:31:06.839
place ending where? Yeah. Yeah, so it's. Where's the sign
679
00:31:07.019 --> 00:31:07.859
that says.
680
00:31:07.940 --> 00:31:08.460
Stop. Stop.
681
00:31:08.480 --> 00:31:09.369
We can't go any further.
682
00:31:11.450 --> 00:31:13.970
And look, the quick answer is we don't know, but
683
00:31:13.990 --> 00:31:16.869
the possibilities are space could go on infinitely far, in
684
00:31:16.890 --> 00:31:18.910
which case there never would be an end. That's a
685
00:31:18.950 --> 00:31:22.450
strange idea to us beings that live in a finite environment,
686
00:31:22.549 --> 00:31:25.130
but nevertheless the math allows that as a real possibility.
687
00:31:25.730 --> 00:31:28.430
Or space could be curved, which means you could go
688
00:31:28.630 --> 00:31:32.509
out in that direction and ultimately circle back and return
689
00:31:32.529 --> 00:31:34.950
to your starting point. So there again wouldn't be an
690
00:31:35.210 --> 00:31:39.299
end but nevertheless the space would be finite in its extent.
691
00:31:39.720 --> 00:31:41.759
So these are sort of two big possibilities people think about.
692
00:31:41.779 --> 00:31:44.500
So you can travel an infinitely finite space. Yeah, an infinite, yeah.
693
00:31:44.539 --> 00:31:46.299
You could go infinitely far, but it would be a
694
00:31:46.359 --> 00:31:47.480
finite extent.
695
00:31:47.519 --> 00:31:48.559
Like the surface of the Earth.
696
00:31:48.619 --> 00:31:49.640
Yeah, like the surface of the Earth.
697
00:31:50.079 --> 00:31:53.509
Exactly. I can tell you this. Yes. It offers some insight.
698
00:31:53.829 --> 00:31:56.170
We look out to the edge of the observable universe. Okay.
699
00:31:56.410 --> 00:31:59.089
And we see light that has been traveling for 13.8
700
00:31:59.089 --> 00:32:05.890
billion years. Okay. That gives us evidence of the Big Bang...
701
00:32:06.920 --> 00:32:10.799
for that part of the universe experiencing it at the
702
00:32:10.839 --> 00:32:14.579
time it emitted that light. That horizon continues to push out.
703
00:32:14.819 --> 00:32:15.000
Right.
704
00:32:15.980 --> 00:32:19.230
As long as we keep seeing evidence of the big bang,
705
00:32:20.549 --> 00:32:23.369
we are still moving into a universe that's our whole.
706
00:32:23.730 --> 00:32:23.869
Yep.
707
00:32:23.890 --> 00:32:30.109
Right. Imagine the day where that horizon washes over the
708
00:32:30.210 --> 00:32:33.890
last bit of matter that experienced the big bang. then
709
00:32:34.109 --> 00:32:38.119
the information coming to us about the Big Bang ceases.
710
00:32:39.220 --> 00:32:41.220
And all of what we know of cosmology would have
711
00:32:41.279 --> 00:32:43.400
no data set at that point. And at that point,
712
00:32:43.700 --> 00:32:47.299
you're basically, the moving horizon, which gets one light year
713
00:32:47.680 --> 00:32:51.009
away from us per year at that speed, would have
714
00:32:51.329 --> 00:32:53.910
overtaken the last matter of the universe, and that would
715
00:32:53.930 --> 00:32:56.289
be the edge of the universe. Do you agree with that?
716
00:32:56.490 --> 00:32:59.170
Well, there's a version of that that I think I can...
717
00:33:00.039 --> 00:33:02.059
agree with more precisely, which is.
718
00:33:02.119 --> 00:33:05.220
I meant no, but... He's a guest on my show.
719
00:33:05.259 --> 00:33:06.480
He's a guest. He's got to be polite.
720
00:33:06.500 --> 00:33:08.579
Wait, by the way, I am taking notes. I've got
721
00:33:08.599 --> 00:33:09.619
to learn to talk to my.
722
00:33:09.579 --> 00:33:11.160
Wife like this.
723
00:33:11.299 --> 00:33:13.240
I have got to learn how to talk to her
724
00:33:13.279 --> 00:33:15.740
like this. It's just like, would you agree? Well, there's
725
00:33:15.779 --> 00:33:18.700
a version that I would agree with more precisely, dear.
726
00:33:19.960 --> 00:33:21.680
Everything but the deer. Exactly.
727
00:33:21.720 --> 00:33:25.140
He didn't say deer, but at least throw the brother
728
00:33:25.220 --> 00:33:25.740
a deer.
729
00:33:26.119 --> 00:33:26.740
At least.
730
00:33:28.829 --> 00:33:32.450
So even right now, with the accelerated expansion of space,
731
00:33:33.049 --> 00:33:36.210
we can do calculations that show us quite clearly that
732
00:33:36.259 --> 00:33:38.740
the distant galaxies that we have used to figure out
733
00:33:38.759 --> 00:33:41.940
that space is expanding, they are going to disappear over
734
00:33:42.000 --> 00:33:44.380
the cosmological horizon. We will not be able to see
735
00:33:44.420 --> 00:33:46.420
them in roughly 100 billion or a trillion years.
736
00:33:46.519 --> 00:33:46.819
Okay.
737
00:33:47.039 --> 00:33:49.960
So the evidence that we've used to even figure out
738
00:33:50.000 --> 00:33:51.259
that space is expanding.
739
00:33:51.339 --> 00:33:51.819
Is going away.
740
00:33:51.900 --> 00:33:52.380
Is going away.
741
00:33:52.400 --> 00:33:52.960
Right.
Okay.
742
00:33:53.039 --> 00:33:54.539
Which is a strange thing because we usually imagine.
743
00:33:54.559 --> 00:33:58.220
So what you're saying is expansion will overtake... Yeah. The
744
00:33:58.950 --> 00:34:03.819
matter that is giving us this information will overtake... the
745
00:34:03.859 --> 00:34:06.589
moving horizon. And then it's a moot point.
746
00:34:07.250 --> 00:34:09.690
It'll basically drop over a cliff at the edge of space,
747
00:34:09.730 --> 00:34:11.829
which is the horizon, because it's moving away so quickly.
748
00:34:11.849 --> 00:34:16.309
You're outrunning your headlights. That's what you're doing. That's cool, man.
749
00:34:16.570 --> 00:34:17.719
We've got to take a break.
750
00:34:17.780 --> 00:34:18.260
Oh, really?
751
00:34:18.300 --> 00:34:22.039
I know. This is so good. I know. I forgot
752
00:34:22.059 --> 00:34:25.360
we were doing a show. I know, right? Plus, I
753
00:34:25.400 --> 00:34:27.139
didn't still get my deer out of that.
754
00:34:29.019 --> 00:34:29.380
Deer!
755
00:34:31.579 --> 00:34:41.010
That's a different marriage! That's a real marriage! Alright, StarTalk,
756
00:34:41.110 --> 00:34:48.170
Cosmic Queries, Brian Green, Chuck Nice, we'll be right back. StarTalk,
757
00:34:48.309 --> 00:34:52.320
we're back. Cosmic Queries, until the end of time. Search
758
00:34:52.340 --> 00:34:57.690
for meaning in the universe. And Brian Greene goes there.
759
00:34:58.449 --> 00:35:01.349
He does. And how many pages, Brian? Oh, it's only 300.
760
00:35:01.349 --> 00:35:03.889
A lot of end notes. That's why it looks so thick.
761
00:35:04.190 --> 00:35:06.130
Oh, there you go. There you go. That's a nice
762
00:35:06.170 --> 00:35:08.590
picture of you. Thank you. Yeah, nice picture. Oh, wow,
763
00:35:08.610 --> 00:35:10.170
and it's recent. Yeah, yeah. And handsome.
764
00:35:10.190 --> 00:35:12.949
Yeah, it was five minutes ago. Not like a Tinder picture.
765
00:35:12.969 --> 00:35:16.730
It's like, wait a minute, this dude is 23.
766
00:35:17.969 --> 00:35:19.050
So, Chuck, give us the questions.
767
00:35:19.070 --> 00:35:19.289
All right.
768
00:35:19.309 --> 00:35:20.530
This is our last segment. See how many we can
769
00:35:20.550 --> 00:35:21.250
squeeze in. Real quick.
770
00:35:21.369 --> 00:35:24.219
Let me just ask a quick question for myself. All right,
771
00:35:24.659 --> 00:35:27.050
we're able, this is hypothetical because we're not able to,
772
00:35:27.320 --> 00:35:29.659
but we're able to get beyond this horizon that you
773
00:35:29.699 --> 00:35:34.389
were talking about. We're able to observe that there, whatever, right?
774
00:35:34.630 --> 00:35:37.289
But now we are outside of the universe that was
775
00:35:37.349 --> 00:35:38.730
created at the Big Bang.
776
00:35:39.309 --> 00:35:40.929
What is time in that place?
777
00:35:41.050 --> 00:35:43.190
Well, it could be the same as time here.
778
00:35:43.429 --> 00:35:47.179
So that cosmological horizon is, as Neil was
pointing out,
779
00:35:47.579 --> 00:35:50.500
just the distance that we can possibly see because light
780
00:35:50.519 --> 00:35:52.739
has had the time to travel from it to us
781
00:35:52.800 --> 00:35:55.449
since the Big Bang. But it could be that time
782
00:35:55.510 --> 00:35:58.329
applies throughout this realm of space, and it could be
783
00:35:58.349 --> 00:36:00.820
that it looks out there much like it looks in here.
784
00:36:01.139 --> 00:36:02.500
It's not as though you pass through it and you'd
785
00:36:02.519 --> 00:36:06.500
be in some entirely new domain. However, it's possible that
786
00:36:06.519 --> 00:36:09.059
it could be different. Since we've never been there, the
787
00:36:09.099 --> 00:36:11.199
math suggests that it will be the same, but were
788
00:36:11.219 --> 00:36:13.119
it different, that would be shocking and wonderful.
789
00:36:13.179 --> 00:36:15.739
Wait, wait, but Brian, let me take issue with that. Yeah, please.
790
00:36:16.019 --> 00:36:19.050
The horizon is not a real place. It's just a
791
00:36:19.530 --> 00:36:22.269
property of where we are and the speed of light.
792
00:36:23.349 --> 00:36:23.889
That's what I meant.
793
00:36:23.949 --> 00:36:26.800
Well, when I'm a ship at sea and I go
794
00:36:26.880 --> 00:36:30.670
to my horizon... whatever, 10 miles away, now I have
795
00:36:30.710 --> 00:36:33.510
a new horizon and I'm still at sea. So why
796
00:36:33.530 --> 00:36:35.010
are you telling me something different is gonna happen?
797
00:36:35.030 --> 00:36:36.860
That's my point. I believe that that will be the
798
00:36:36.889 --> 00:36:38.829
case in the universe, but.
799
00:36:38.739 --> 00:36:40.940
It's also conceivable. That is not what he said.
800
00:36:40.960 --> 00:36:42.079
No, no, but it's conceivable.
801
00:36:42.139 --> 00:36:44.539
You would agree that when you take your ship, it's
802
00:36:44.619 --> 00:36:47.900
possible that when you reach your current horizon, it could
803
00:36:47.940 --> 00:36:49.119
be that things are completely different.
804
00:36:49.139 --> 00:36:51.480
It could be the dragons are there. It could be
805
00:36:51.500 --> 00:36:53.480
the gates of hell that have never been there.
806
00:36:53.559 --> 00:36:56.840
Or you'd have to presume that at exactly that distance,
807
00:36:57.510 --> 00:36:59.130
and you were in the middle of where all those
808
00:36:59.170 --> 00:37:01.460
dragons were, and that's kind of... It's a very special space.
809
00:37:01.480 --> 00:37:02.199
That's a very special space.
810
00:37:02.260 --> 00:37:03.739
It's a very special space. I can't... That was the point.
811
00:37:03.820 --> 00:37:04.559
I can't go wrong with that.
812
00:37:04.579 --> 00:37:07.019
Yeah, so if I didn't say it clearly, I suspect,
813
00:37:07.099 --> 00:37:08.820
and the math strongly argues.
814
00:37:09.079 --> 00:37:10.579
That it will be the same out there.
815
00:37:10.739 --> 00:37:10.900
Fine.
816
00:37:10.920 --> 00:37:13.949
But
it's conceivable that it would be different.
817
00:37:14.010 --> 00:37:15.949
But I get what I really get out of that,
818
00:37:15.989 --> 00:37:18.110
and maybe it just helped me out here.
819
00:37:18.510 --> 00:37:19.469
What you're saying, then.
820
00:37:20.050 --> 00:37:23.250
is what we are seeing is a reference. That's what
821
00:37:23.269 --> 00:37:26.969
we're seeing. We're not really seeing an edge. We're not seeing,
822
00:37:26.989 --> 00:37:28.949
we're seeing a reference is what we're seeing. Any more
823
00:37:28.980 --> 00:37:30.780
than a ship at sea. That's not the edge of
824
00:37:30.820 --> 00:37:32.260
the Earth. You can think it's the edge of the Earth,
825
00:37:32.360 --> 00:37:34.019
and it might be the edge of the Earth. It
826
00:37:34.039 --> 00:37:34.659
probably isn't.
827
00:37:34.920 --> 00:37:40.079
However. Uh-oh. Uh-oh. Getting too much time to think. The
828
00:37:40.139 --> 00:37:41.119
brain is going.
829
00:37:41.360 --> 00:37:42.280
I should point out.
830
00:37:42.300 --> 00:37:42.719
Here we go.
831
00:37:42.980 --> 00:37:46.059
I should point out that in a universe where the
832
00:37:46.239 --> 00:37:50.579
spatial expansion is accelerating- that cosmological horizon would actually have
833
00:37:50.599 --> 00:37:51.239
a temperature.
834
00:37:51.550 --> 00:37:52.070
You're right.
835
00:37:52.280 --> 00:37:56.090
It's not a real location in space. But from that spot,
836
00:37:56.190 --> 00:38:00.329
we would have heat emerging that would give a background
837
00:38:00.389 --> 00:38:02.289
temperature that at the moment would be about 10 to
838
00:38:02.309 --> 00:38:07.300
the minus 30 Kelvin. So it actually has a physical presence,
839
00:38:07.429 --> 00:38:09.239
even though it is in some sense just a reference.
840
00:38:09.420 --> 00:38:11.219
It's a thing to measure. Oh, I love that. A
841
00:38:11.280 --> 00:38:14.079
thing to measure. That is awesome. I love things to measure.
842
00:38:14.099 --> 00:38:16.639
Moreover, can I point out, just since we're going on
843
00:38:16.679 --> 00:38:20.840
this tangent... that temperature that comes from that distant cosmological
844
00:38:20.880 --> 00:38:24.400
horizon may imperil the future of thought itself.
845
00:38:25.099 --> 00:38:25.219
Uh-oh.
846
00:38:25.599 --> 00:38:27.559
So one of the things I describe in the book
847
00:38:27.639 --> 00:38:28.860
is that in the far future.
848
00:38:28.949 --> 00:38:29.340
That's where.
849
00:38:29.260 --> 00:38:30.210
The book ends, the thought ends.
850
00:38:30.230 --> 00:38:31.449
Yeah, it is.
851
00:38:31.650 --> 00:38:32.389
I don't hit my limits.
852
00:38:32.429 --> 00:38:34.449
It's close. It's the end of thought. It ends like this.
853
00:38:34.630 --> 00:38:35.150
I'm cold.
854
00:38:35.809 --> 00:38:36.590
Never hears the idea.
855
00:38:36.610 --> 00:38:40.429
So any cogitating being through the act of thought has
856
00:38:40.449 --> 00:38:42.449
to release heat, right? Second law of
thermodynamics.
857
00:38:42.489 --> 00:38:43.010
Yeah, yeah.
858
00:38:43.159 --> 00:38:45.420
And if it's the case that that cogitating being can't
859
00:38:45.460 --> 00:38:47.969
release its heat, it will burn up. And because of
860
00:38:48.010 --> 00:38:51.090
the heat emitted by that distant cosmological horizon, in the
861
00:38:51.130 --> 00:38:53.690
far future, a cogitating being will not be able to
862
00:38:53.730 --> 00:38:54.409
release that heat.
863
00:38:54.789 --> 00:38:55.829
And if it thinks one more thought.
864
00:38:55.849 --> 00:38:57.849
But that's not very much heat. I know.
865
00:38:58.250 --> 00:39:00.469
But in the far future... That's all you got. That's
866
00:39:00.510 --> 00:39:00.929
all you got.
867
00:39:00.989 --> 00:39:04.519
Oh, that's all you got. Yeah. So you're saying, oh,
868
00:39:04.539 --> 00:39:06.460
this is scary. Don't tell me this.
869
00:39:06.539 --> 00:39:06.760
Yeah.
870
00:39:06.820 --> 00:39:08.500
Oh, now I'm sad. Yeah.
871
00:39:08.559 --> 00:39:09.920
Now you're going to read the book.
872
00:39:10.159 --> 00:39:10.579
Okay.
873
00:39:10.619 --> 00:39:10.739
No.
874
00:39:10.960 --> 00:39:13.519
Now let me repeat what I think you said. Yeah.
875
00:39:14.119 --> 00:39:19.300
That every act of thinking is a thermodynamic... electrochemical process,
876
00:39:19.679 --> 00:39:22.480
as far as we know. So that creates heat that
877
00:39:22.940 --> 00:39:25.550
needs to dissipate so that you can have your next thought.
878
00:39:26.469 --> 00:39:29.710
If the bath, the thermal bath in which you were
879
00:39:29.730 --> 00:39:35.639
immersed has a greater temperature than the temperature of your thoughts,
880
00:39:36.889 --> 00:39:41.889
then your thoughts will back up and overheat And you
881
00:39:42.070 --> 00:39:43.030
can't sustain that.
882
00:39:43.050 --> 00:39:43.750
Yeah, that's the basic idea.
883
00:39:43.769 --> 00:39:45.429
Like an overloading phaser.
884
00:39:45.510 --> 00:39:45.670
Yeah.
885
00:39:46.190 --> 00:39:48.260
Yes. Yeah. Very good.
886
00:39:48.280 --> 00:39:49.960
But now it's the brain of the thinking being.
887
00:39:49.980 --> 00:39:51.260
But now it's the brain that's actually doing it.
888
00:39:51.260 --> 00:39:51.960
So it tries to think.
889
00:39:51.980 --> 00:39:54.380
Forgot all about the overload. And it explodes. And it self-destructs. Self-destructs.
890
00:39:54.659 --> 00:39:54.860
Wow.
891
00:39:55.420 --> 00:39:58.179
All right. Let's get back to this. Okay. All right.
892
00:39:58.559 --> 00:40:00.260
We're short on time. Okay. All right. All right. What
893
00:40:00.280 --> 00:40:05.590
do you got? Here we go. This is Juan91 on Instagram. 911.
894
00:40:05.590 --> 00:40:07.789
He says, hi, Neil and Brian. He's not 911. It's just.
895
00:40:09.570 --> 00:40:13.110
It is 9-1-1. It is? Okay. That is good. All right.
896
00:40:13.670 --> 00:40:15.150
You are absolutely right. It's 9-1-1.
897
00:40:15.269 --> 00:40:18.780
And he goes, hi, Neil
and Brian and maybe Chuck.
898
00:40:19.980 --> 00:40:22.699
My question is the following. Hypothetically, if we were living
899
00:40:22.719 --> 00:40:25.940
in a universe where we can increase or lower the entropy,
900
00:40:26.199 --> 00:40:30.420
would it be possible to travel in time? Greetings from Montreal.
901
00:40:30.460 --> 00:40:32.219
I really love the podcast and it makes my commute
902
00:40:32.440 --> 00:40:32.739
all the time.
903
00:40:32.760 --> 00:40:34.480
So let me reshape that so more people can be
904
00:40:34.519 --> 00:40:37.599
part of that. So as you know and as you've written...
905
00:40:38.760 --> 00:40:40.820
The increase of entropy is one of the arrows of time.
906
00:40:41.699 --> 00:40:44.219
So if we somehow had control over entropy in the
907
00:40:44.280 --> 00:40:48.610
universe to reverse it, will that imbue us with powers
908
00:40:48.849 --> 00:40:49.829
over the arrow of time?
909
00:40:50.030 --> 00:40:52.389
I don't think so. So you're right.
910
00:40:52.530 --> 00:40:55.610
We often do think about entropy and its relentless increase
911
00:40:55.730 --> 00:40:58.739
as an arrow of time. But if it were to
912
00:40:58.820 --> 00:41:02.320
reverse itself, time would still carry on in the direction
913
00:41:02.360 --> 00:41:04.380
that it was always traveling. We would just see some
914
00:41:04.420 --> 00:41:08.070
weird things happening in the environment around us. We might see,
915
00:41:08.110 --> 00:41:11.909
for instance, eggs unbreak or candles unburn, but it wouldn't
916
00:41:11.929 --> 00:41:17.699
be time going backward. It'd be those physical processes going backwards. Now,
917
00:41:17.739 --> 00:41:20.760
if everything went backwards, that would be something else, but
918
00:41:20.800 --> 00:41:22.039
that's not what the question is.
919
00:41:22.079 --> 00:41:24.489
It's just we're able to reduce entropy in some way.
920
00:41:24.500 --> 00:41:28.199
Okay, so if we're able to reduce entropy of the universe,
921
00:41:28.539 --> 00:41:29.860
because we know we can do it locally, that's what
922
00:41:29.909 --> 00:41:38.519
life is. Life is organized matter. So it has lower
923
00:41:38.599 --> 00:41:41.280
entropy than it would otherwise have if life did not form.
924
00:41:41.599 --> 00:41:44.099
We're using energy from the sun, basically, to do this.
925
00:41:44.400 --> 00:41:48.179
So if we somehow did have power over entropy of
926
00:41:48.199 --> 00:41:49.960
the entire universe, do you think that would have any
927
00:41:50.019 --> 00:41:51.320
consequences at all? Well, yeah.
928
00:41:51.380 --> 00:41:55.179
I mean, it would radically change our predictions for what
929
00:41:55.199 --> 00:41:56.099
will happen in the far future.
930
00:41:56.119 --> 00:41:56.960
That's the end.
931
00:41:57.480 --> 00:42:01.530
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Things that our understanding of nature is
932
00:42:01.769 --> 00:42:06.989
so intermixed, intertwined with an increase in entropy, that if
933
00:42:07.260 --> 00:42:11.599
entropy systemically decreased, we'd have to rethink what was cause
934
00:42:11.639 --> 00:42:12.260
and what was effect.
935
00:42:12.340 --> 00:42:14.440
That's right, and we'd have to rethink where we are
936
00:42:14.500 --> 00:42:15.460
headed in the far future.
937
00:42:15.539 --> 00:42:18.429
Yeah, yeah, okay. Dude, that's really cool. Okay, all right,
938
00:42:18.489 --> 00:42:19.170
let's do this one.
939
00:42:19.269 --> 00:42:22.889
And I have to rewrite one of the chapters of
940
00:42:22.929 --> 00:42:23.570
my book.
941
00:42:24.070 --> 00:42:29.280
Team Forsythe Observatory on Instagram would like to know, hello Neil, Brian,
942
00:42:29.320 --> 00:42:32.420
and Chuck, what do you all believe would be the
943
00:42:32.500 --> 00:42:42.440
world's religion's response to When we are contacted from another civilization.
944
00:42:41.989 --> 00:42:44.630
Outside of our own existence. Give it to me. There
945
00:42:44.650 --> 00:42:45.010
you go.
946
00:42:45.230 --> 00:42:47.690
Yeah, I don't think it will make all that much
947
00:42:47.849 --> 00:42:52.409
of a difference. I think the nature of reality for
948
00:42:52.530 --> 00:42:55.510
us scientists would change completely because now we'd have a
949
00:42:55.610 --> 00:42:58.750
second instantiation of life out there in the universe, which
950
00:42:58.789 --> 00:43:00.860
would be a radical moment, but I think for.
951
00:43:00.800 --> 00:43:02.900
The world's religions... Not just life, but intelligent life.
952
00:43:02.920 --> 00:43:04.239
Because they're here.
953
00:43:04.570 --> 00:43:06.679
You know, but for the world's religions, I don't think
954
00:43:06.719 --> 00:43:09.750
that there'd be much of a difference because they have
955
00:43:09.789 --> 00:43:12.730
a certain perspective on where we've come from and why
956
00:43:12.750 --> 00:43:14.449
we're here and what we're doing, and I don't think
957
00:43:14.489 --> 00:43:18.570
that the existence of additional intelligent life would really change
958
00:43:18.610 --> 00:43:19.949
things in any substantial way.
959
00:43:20.030 --> 00:43:22.869
Oh, okay, let me do this for both of you.
960
00:43:22.929 --> 00:43:23.550
Here's the deal.
961
00:43:23.769 --> 00:43:29.469
That same thing, but now, here's the deal. Those beings...
962
00:43:29.929 --> 00:43:30.659
Tell us.
963
00:43:31.730 --> 00:43:36.130
We put you here. Now, what do the religions do? Well,
964
00:43:36.449 --> 00:43:37.969
so there's already a religion about that.
965
00:43:38.210 --> 00:43:38.449
What?
966
00:43:38.530 --> 00:43:39.530
They call the Ray Aliens.
967
00:43:40.590 --> 00:43:40.809
What?
968
00:43:41.570 --> 00:43:44.130
I'm just saying. I'm just saying. Is this true? Yes.
969
00:43:44.369 --> 00:43:47.369
Is this true? The Ray Aliens. So this religion is
970
00:43:47.409 --> 00:43:51.820
a religion where God is not God as imagined in
971
00:43:51.860 --> 00:43:57.239
the Hebrew Bible, but God is an
intelligent race of
972
00:43:57.380 --> 00:44:02.300
aliens that created us. Really? And so there's strong overlap
973
00:44:02.340 --> 00:44:04.590
with a god, because if a god created us, and
974
00:44:04.610 --> 00:44:07.329
they're the external thing. Or there's a creator. A creator, right.
975
00:44:08.269 --> 00:44:10.769
So there's a whole religion that's already there, is my point.
976
00:44:11.110 --> 00:44:14.289
So they would just be like, told you. Exactly. But
977
00:44:14.309 --> 00:44:18.090
to your point, there are some religions or some branches
978
00:44:18.269 --> 00:44:20.949
of religions where it is very important to them that
979
00:44:20.969 --> 00:44:24.340
the universe was created for us and for no other life.
980
00:44:24.960 --> 00:44:27.159
They would have an issue with this. But most religions
981
00:44:27.239 --> 00:44:30.000
have gotten past that. And religions are more than just
982
00:44:30.039 --> 00:44:33.360
belief systems. They're also institutions, and institutions generally have their
983
00:44:33.380 --> 00:44:36.400
own survival as a fundamental part of what they do
984
00:44:36.480 --> 00:44:37.139
and why they do it.
985
00:44:37.760 --> 00:44:40.500
And moreover, there are so many religions already practiced on
986
00:44:40.579 --> 00:44:44.639
planet Earth, and each one needs to deal with the existence.
987
00:44:44.210 --> 00:44:45.070
Of the others.
988
00:44:45.090 --> 00:44:45.750
The other religions.
989
00:44:45.769 --> 00:44:47.809
The other religions, and they're able to do that by
990
00:44:47.849 --> 00:44:49.449
virtue of saying, ours is a real one and theirs
991
00:44:49.510 --> 00:44:51.389
is not. So I think we'd have that same kind
992
00:44:51.409 --> 00:44:54.349
of response if aliens came down. But to your point
993
00:44:54.409 --> 00:44:56.909
about ray aliens, if that's the name of it, There's
994
00:44:56.969 --> 00:45:00.610
also the simulation hypothesis, right? If we are all just
995
00:45:00.690 --> 00:45:03.469
a simulation of a future supercomputer, then again, there's a
996
00:45:03.510 --> 00:45:06.510
god-like being, the kid in the garage who's fired up
997
00:45:06.550 --> 00:45:09.369
the supercomputer, and again, you don't have anything supernatural, and
998
00:45:09.409 --> 00:45:13.739
yet we would be the outcome of a creator's desires, wishes, whims,
999
00:45:13.840 --> 00:45:16.840
because that kid fired up that simulation.
1000
00:45:17.500 --> 00:45:17.699
Hmm?
1001
00:45:18.059 --> 00:45:20.179
Okay. So he has another altar, and there's a kid
1002
00:45:21.000 --> 00:45:23.159
in the altar, and he prays to the kid god
1003
00:45:23.199 --> 00:45:26.630
as well as the particle god. Right, that's it. All right,
1004
00:45:26.650 --> 00:45:28.469
let's see if we can get another one in. I
1005
00:45:28.469 --> 00:45:30.309
think we can. This is Ascot.
1006
00:45:32.750 --> 00:45:36.250
He says from Twitter, since the beginning of our civilization,
1007
00:45:36.289 --> 00:45:42.019
the human mind and consciousness have evolved so much. Can
1008
00:45:42.059 --> 00:45:46.380
the human brain figure out the human consciousness? In what
1009
00:45:46.460 --> 00:45:50.360
ways can we confidently predict that we will acquire the
1010
00:45:50.380 --> 00:45:54.190
ability to comprehend the majesty of the cosmos? Hmm.
1011
00:45:55.199 --> 00:45:57.320
So do you get into consciousness? I do. Yeah, there's
1012
00:45:57.440 --> 00:46:00.309
a whole focus on it. So we got to go quick.
1013
00:46:00.369 --> 00:46:01.590
What's your take on it?
1014
00:46:02.130 --> 00:46:05.559
My take is that consciousness is an exquisite physical process,
1015
00:46:05.599 --> 00:46:07.840
but nothing more than a physical process.
1016
00:46:07.880 --> 00:46:08.519
It is simply.
1017
00:46:08.889 --> 00:46:12.510
Particles coursing through a gloppy gray structure inside our heads, again,
1018
00:46:12.690 --> 00:46:13.829
fully determined.
1019
00:46:13.449 --> 00:46:14.309
By physical law.
1020
00:46:14.329 --> 00:46:15.610
Do you think it was emergent?
1021
00:46:16.030 --> 00:46:19.650
Yes, it certainly emerged by virtue of the organization of
1022
00:46:19.710 --> 00:46:22.409
this structure inside of our heads. I don't think there's
1023
00:46:22.550 --> 00:46:25.130
anything else beyond the particles and the laws of physics
1024
00:46:25.190 --> 00:46:26.820
required for consciousness to exist.
1025
00:46:27.300 --> 00:46:28.260
I mean, do you?
1026
00:46:28.639 --> 00:46:31.019
No, no, I'm not convinced by so much of what's
1027
00:46:31.059 --> 00:46:33.260
written about consciousness. I mean, the fact that there's so
1028
00:46:33.280 --> 00:46:35.079
many books on consciousness and everybody's talking about it, it
1029
00:46:35.099 --> 00:46:37.480
means no one knows anything about it. The evidence you
1030
00:46:37.500 --> 00:46:39.409
don't know anything is people keep writing about it. How
1031
00:46:39.449 --> 00:46:41.969
many people are still writing about Einstein's general relativity? The
1032
00:46:41.989 --> 00:46:42.869
book is on the shelf.
1033
00:46:42.889 --> 00:46:43.530
Of course, yeah.
1034
00:46:43.690 --> 00:46:43.829
Right?
1035
00:46:44.090 --> 00:46:46.550
Yeah, so it is, but I agree. I think everyone
1036
00:46:46.570 --> 00:46:48.469
would agree it is a grand mystery. You know, where
1037
00:46:48.510 --> 00:46:51.440
does consciousness come from? And many take the approach that
1038
00:46:51.699 --> 00:46:55.800
we know historically people use with life. People thought vitalism.
1039
00:46:56.179 --> 00:46:58.179
It couldn't just be particles and the laws of physics.
1040
00:46:58.199 --> 00:47:00.639
You got to inject something else, a life force.
1041
00:47:01.039 --> 00:47:03.659
Nobody talks that way any longer, right?
1042
00:47:03.760 --> 00:47:04.960
Some Christians will talk about a soul.
1043
00:47:05.119 --> 00:47:08.039
Right, but few scientists think that way any longer. Similarly,
1044
00:47:08.059 --> 00:47:09.840
there are some scientists who think you have to inject
1045
00:47:09.960 --> 00:47:13.320
something into the particles and the forces to get conscious self-awareness.
1046
00:47:13.679 --> 00:47:15.820
I think a hundred or a thousand or whatever number
1047
00:47:15.840 --> 00:47:17.820
of years from now, people will look back and smile
1048
00:47:17.840 --> 00:47:19.920
at how quaint that idea was, but there's nothing more
1049
00:47:19.960 --> 00:47:21.599
than particles and physical laws.
1050
00:47:23.179 --> 00:47:27.619
What was the question about consciousness, though? Did we answer?
1051
00:47:27.780 --> 00:47:31.260
Will we be able to understand consciousness? And then using that,
1052
00:47:31.280 --> 00:47:34.900
be able to understand or comprehend the majesty of the cosmos.
1053
00:47:34.920 --> 00:47:36.219
So let me reshape that.
1054
00:47:36.280 --> 00:47:39.800
So is there a level of consciousness that awaits us
1055
00:47:40.500 --> 00:47:43.969
that will enable us to appreciate the cosmos even deeper
1056
00:47:44.010 --> 00:47:44.699
than we already do?
1057
00:47:44.739 --> 00:47:45.659
Yeah, I certainly hope so.
1058
00:47:46.570 --> 00:47:47.690
A level of awareness, I guess.
1059
00:47:47.710 --> 00:47:51.050
You know, I think as we learn more about reality,
1060
00:47:51.170 --> 00:47:53.809
we reshape our sense of who we are and what
1061
00:47:53.849 --> 00:47:56.170
the grand mysteries of existence are. And I think that's
1062
00:47:56.210 --> 00:47:58.849
a beautiful journey that we've been on for thousands of
1063
00:47:58.869 --> 00:48:00.050
years and it will carry onward.
1064
00:48:00.860 --> 00:48:01.110
Cool.
1065
00:48:01.679 --> 00:48:04.199
Those are some final thoughts. Those are very good final thoughts.
1066
00:48:04.260 --> 00:48:04.500
Yeah.
1067
00:48:04.639 --> 00:48:07.679
Brian, you don't come by often enough. Invite me.
1068
00:48:07.690 --> 00:48:08.909
I'll be here.
1069
00:48:10.849 --> 00:48:15.150
Dear. We have to invite him more often than the
1070
00:48:15.190 --> 00:48:17.769
rate at which he writes books. That's the problem. There
1071
00:48:17.789 --> 00:48:20.010
you go. All right. Brian, always good to have you.
1072
00:48:20.030 --> 00:48:23.050
Thank you, sir. Chuck. It's a pleasure. My boy. My man.
1073
00:48:23.389 --> 00:48:26.380
All right. This has been Cosmic Queries. I'll just have
1074
00:48:26.389 --> 00:48:30.340
to say it. The Brian Green edition. All right. Neil
1075
00:48:30.360 --> 00:48:33.719
deGrasse Tyson here, your personal astrophysicist, as always, meeting you.
1076
00:48:33.739 --> 00:48:34.980
Keep looking up.