TRANSCRIÇÃO 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to plan on it.
[0:03] Hello everyone, welcome back to plan on it with attorney Christopher E.
[0:11] body, board certified specialist in estate planning, trust and probate law.
[0:16] Chris has more than 30 years of experience helping individuals and families plan for long-term
[0:21] care and protect what they've built.
[0:24] I'm Sean O'Connor, and today, Chris and I are talking about the Medi-Cal look back rule
[0:30] and how transferring assets at the wrong time can create serious problems when applying
[0:36] for long-term care coverage.
[0:39] Chris, could you see you?
[0:40] Good to see you, Sean.
[0:41] Thank you for having me.
[0:42] You bet.
[0:43] I'm not familiar with the look back rule, you know, what is it, and why is it so important
[0:48] when it comes to long-term care planning?
[0:51] Well, yeah, in this look back rule, there's a lot of misinformation out there on the internet
[0:55] because California's long-term care medical program is completely different than any other
[1:00] state's long-term care program.
[1:02] They call it Medicaid and other states, and so there's a lot of misunderstanding about what
[1:06] this look back rule is and how long it is, and we're going to get into the weeds on this
[1:10] a little bit because we have to take a deep dive on this because it's so important.
[1:14] So the look back rule basically refers to California is going to look back a period of time to determine
[1:21] if any transfer were made in contemplation of a medical application being filed, and so
[1:28] people try to transfer assets, reduce their worth, in order to qualify for medical, and
[1:35] there's a correct way to do it and an incorrect way to do it.
[1:38] And if you get the look back rules impacted and the trigger, then you've got problems.
[1:43] I got it.
[1:44] And so you mentioned there's, well, what's the period of time, when does the look back
[1:51] period apply and how far back are they looking at the financial activity?
[1:58] Okay, California, it's very simple.
[2:01] It's 30 months.
[2:02] Okay.
[2:03] I think you're going to say 30 years, I'm like, oh, that's-
[2:06] No, it's 30 months.
[2:07] Okay.
[2:08] Most states, it's five year, a five year look back.
[2:11] We get this all the time.
[2:12] What about the five year look back rule?
[2:14] We don't have a five year look back rule in California.
[2:16] We've never had it.
[2:17] We're different.
[2:18] Okay.
[2:19] We're different people like we're a good state to get sick in because our rules are different
[2:22] and much more flexible when it comes to qualifying people from medical.
[2:26] So we have a 30 month look back.
[2:28] That's it.
[2:29] Okay.
[2:30] Okay.
[2:31] And then people right now are doing the math, 30 months, okay, that's two years, it's like
[2:36] two and a half years.
[2:38] Correct.
[2:39] Yeah.
[2:40] So why, you know, why even does medical have a look back rule in the first place?
[2:45] What's, you know, is it about fraud?
[2:47] What the state would prefer, as people use your own resources before you seek assistance,
[2:52] right?
[2:53] That makes sense from public policy perspective.
[2:54] Sure.
[2:55] That, you know, let's, let's not give medical to multi-millionaires, okay?
[3:00] So we have these rules where you have an asset test and so what people sometimes mistakenly
[3:04] do is they'll start transferring assets improperly in order to qualify and pass the asset test.
[3:11] And if you do that, then you, you create problems for yourself.
[3:15] The look back rule is designed so that people will utilize their own resources first, get
[3:20] to a level where the state says, okay, now that you're at this level, we will issue a medical
[3:24] card to you and your family because you need to start, we want to provide these services
[3:30] to someone in your, in your, with your network, your wealth.
[3:34] And so all the look back rule exists so people who try to make these transfers to get below
[3:41] and pass the asset test are penalized essentially for doing that.
[3:45] So the, when they're, when they're looking back, you know, when they're reviewing the
[3:52] transfers, are there specific types of transfers that they're looking for?
[3:58] Absolutely.
[3:59] So in medical, we have basically two types of assets.
[4:03] We have exempt assets and non-exempt assets, exempt assets don't count towards eligibility.
[4:09] And so, for example, your primary residence, okay, doesn't count towards eligibility.
[4:14] And so they're not looking at transfers of exempt assets.
[4:18] You can transfer exempt assets and not trigger any look back rules whatsoever.
[4:22] So it's the non-exempt assets, the other stuff that the state says, look, we're going to
[4:26] total value of your non-exempt assets and if that number exceeds the threshold requirement
[4:32] for passing the asset test, you're not going to be able to get a medical card until you drop
[4:36] below that number.
[4:37] It's called your property preserve until your property reserve drops below the number required.
[4:42] You're respected to use your own resources to pay for your care.
[4:45] And so, so what the state's looking for is the improper transfer of non-exempt assets to
[4:52] others or their parties or, and that's what they're doing.
[4:55] That's what they're trying to prevent and that's what they're looking for.
[4:58] Can you name a couple of examples of the non-exempt?
[5:01] Sure.
[5:02] Cash assets, just regular cash in the bank account, CDs, brokerage accounts, tax, not tax
[5:08] deferred.
[5:09] I'm talking about just a standard trading brokerage account, mutual funds, most annuities,
[5:14] these are all assets, the state says, look, we're going to count these in terms of whether
[5:18] or not you're going to be deemed eligible for medical and if you have more than what we consider
[5:23] the property reserve, then you have to wait, okay, that's essentially what happens
Load full transcript
there.
[5:27] So, what I would think of as being liquid assets, for sure, right?
[5:32] Correct.
[5:33] Definitely liquid assets, that's as the business assets can be potentially incorporated
[5:37] into the look back rules depending on how that business is structured.
[5:41] How does medical determine the length of a penalty if a transfer falls within a look back period?
[5:46] It's a mathematical calculation, actually, so I'm going to give you an example of how we
[5:50] do it, okay.
[5:51] So what the state basically says is look, we're going to take the total value of the transfer,
[5:58] so let's say it's $100,000, and we're going to divide that number by what we call the average
[6:04] private pay rate of a skilled nursing facility in California.
[6:09] The average private monthly pay rate, and so that number adjusts every year for inflation,
[6:13] so the current average private pay rate is not a random number, it's $14,440, that's what
[6:20] the state says, this is the average cost of a one-month state in nursing home in California.
[6:24] And so if you make $100,000 transfer, you're going to take $14,440 divided into $100,000,
[6:30] and that's going to result in a six-month period of ineligibility where the state says, okay,
[6:35] you made a transfer improperly, you have to wait six months in order to come into us and
[6:42] seek benefits, and so that's what they call a period of ineligibility, that's the penalty
[6:46] for violating the look back rule, if you do it in court.
[6:48] Got it.
[6:49] So theoretically, that 100 grand that I moved improperly, they're basically saying,
[6:57] you've got to use that money to pay for whatever services you need.
[7:01] You should have used that money since you transferred it.
[7:07] We're going to penalize you six months, essentially, by dividing the average private pay rate into
[7:12] the total value of the amount transferred, and that's how they create this period of ineligibility.
[7:18] Are there exceptions, or there's situations where a transfer doesn't result in a penalty?
[7:24] Well, yeah, I mean, if you do it for consideration, in other words, if you sell something for fair value,
[7:30] that's not going to be a problem, because cash is coming back into the state.
[7:33] But if you sell it for at a discount, then they're going to say, well, it's a partial penalty based upon
[7:38] the value of the transfer below fair market value.
[7:42] There are ways to make these transfers that don't trigger lookbacks, and that's covered
[7:46] in great length in my ebook about how we do it.
[7:50] California has a unique system that allows you to transfer assets, as long as it's below the average
[7:55] private pay rate, that that transfer will not count or trigger a violation of lookback rules.
[8:02] So there's lots of things, the creative things that we do as elder law attorneys in this field,
[8:07] where we can potentially get people qualified for medical taking advantage of the current rules
[8:11] as they exist, and not violate the lookback rules.
[8:14] In fact, that's why you get an elder law attorney involved in the first places, so you
[8:18] don't make these improper transfers.
[8:19] You don't create these periods of an eligibility, and you do it correctly.
[8:22] And if done correctly, you can get people qualified for medical who have excess resources
[8:27] of the start of the process, but done doing the transfers properly can result in qualification
[8:33] way faster.
[8:34] It sounds like timing might be a factor, right?
[8:39] Is there a way that timing of a transfer is going to trigger a penalty or maybe not?
[8:47] Well, yeah.
[8:48] So the longer the landing strip, the better, and so if you're thinking, well, we're not
[8:53] going to, you're thinking for yourself or your spouse, it's very unlikely that we're
[8:58] going to need long-term care in the next 30 months, then you can make larger guests because
[9:03] you're going to ride out that lookback period and realize that we're not going to need
[9:07] to deploy tap into the program until after the lookback period expires.
[9:12] And so timing matters if it's, but if you're trying to do this within 30 months of seeking
[9:18] a medical card, in other words, applying from the program, you're going to have to do
[9:22] what the lookback rules.
[9:23] So timing does matter, and then if you're in that period where you can't make transfers
[9:28] because you need it right away or you need it in a short run, you're going to have to
[9:32] plan around these lookback rules and there are ways to do so, and that's really covered
[9:37] in great length in my e-book.
[9:38] I'm sure that we do it.
[9:39] I'm a little more than we can get into here.
[9:42] But in your practice, I know you see a lot of mistakes, so many attorneys I talk, that's
[9:49] when people call, and they're like, whoops, what are some of the most common mistakes you've
[9:55] found people make when they're trying to move assets before applying the medical?
[10:01] Well there's so many out there, and the state is not going to be advertising ways to avoid
[10:06] these mistakes.
[10:07] But we'd prefer, and I understand this, California, especially with our budget deficit,
[10:11] would prefer that you use your own resources.
[10:13] And so some of the states that people make, they will actually make an improper transfer of
[10:18] a non-exempt asset in violation of the lookback rule.
[10:21] The good news is that you can undo that.
[10:23] You can reverse that transfer and avoid that penalty.
[10:28] You just got to know how to do that, which typically requires someone like me to step in
[10:32] and help got it.
[10:32] The other mistake people make, it's a huge one, is with the exempt, knowing that exempt
[10:37] assets don't count towards eligibility, what people will sometimes do is they'll sell
[10:41] their home to convert it to cash, think that they need to do so because it's counted as
[10:46]
a resource.
[10:47] So now they're homeless essentially, and they're spending their resources down unnecessarily.
[10:52] That's probably the biggest, most fatal mistake that people make is taking an exempt asset
[10:57] and liquidating it or selling it, thinking they need to do so because it counts towards
[11:02] eligibility.
[11:03] And one of the reasons why I originally wrote the ebook, because so many people were making
[11:08] mistakes like that, that I said, look, I've got to educate my client base as they're getting
[11:12] older on the correct way to do this.
[11:15] And so that was the drive revenue even putting that book together in the first place, because
[11:19] mistakes are being made left and right every day, because there's so much misinformation
[11:24] out there.
[11:25] There's so much noise in the marketplace that you can't rely upon necessarily just doing
[11:30] a Google search or an AI search to get the true answer.
[11:34] And so you need to educate yourself essentially.
[11:37] So yeah, no, you just don't want to make decisions that have come really fundamental decisions
[11:43] about selling a piece of property, for example, without knowing is that really necessary?
[11:47] And the answer is no, it's not as far as your home is concerned.
[11:50] Yeah, I mean, you may have some vacation house or something, right, that might fall outside
[11:56] of the exemption, but you were talking earlier about, you know, okay, you made a transfer,
[12:04] you kind of violated a rule there, we can undo it, right, very hard to undo the sale of your
[12:09] home.
[12:11] No, that ship is held unfortunately, it's just tragic, actually, I mean, it really is tragic
[12:16] when people do that, where reverse mortgage your home, like take all the equity out, strip
[12:20] it of all the equity, wouldn't that was totally unnecessary?
[12:24] So again, I wish I can reach more people, that's the whole point of these podcasts, that's
[12:29] the whole point of the blog articles I do, that's the whole point of the ebook, I'm trying
[12:33] to educate people, don't make these mistakes, they're, they're, they're, they're devastating
[12:38] potentially.
[12:39] Yeah, it's just on, it's on, it's totally unfortunate when it happens.
[12:42] Wow, yeah, that's, that's crazy.
[12:44] So someone's concerned, right, they're concerned, I hate, I might need long-term care in the
[12:49] future.
[12:50] How early should they start planning?
[12:53] So they can avoid these lookback issues, I mean, you mentioned the 30 month lookback rule,
[12:58] but are there, you know, is it something like, oh, you should really do it, like you can't
[13:02] do it too soon, so to speak, or what's your, what's your best practice recommendation?
[13:06] Well, I, again, the longer the landing ship, the better in that you have more options, less
[13:12] address, less stress associated with the need to, to, to get aggressive in the planning
[13:17] process.
[13:18] And so it all
starts when you're doing your regular estate planning, we are much younger
[13:22] to typically, you're doing your regular estate planning.
[13:26] And at that point, you want to make sure I call this, make sure your estate plan is long-term
[13:30] care compliant.
[13:31] So in that found in those foundational documents, your trust, if you have a trust, your powers
[13:36] of attorney, you're going to want to bake into those documents, specific language to allow
[13:41] long-term planning, medical planning to occur on your behalf.
[13:45] So it starts with the estate plan, okay, now knowing that you hope not to deploy that language
[13:49] ever, but it's there in case you need it.
[13:51] And so that's the first thing you need to do is when you're designing your estate plan,
[13:55] make sure it's long-term care compliant.
[13:56] Then as time goes on, you know, if you're thinking, well, we got a diagnosis of early dementia,
[14:02] which we know that's a very typically slow and progressive disease, it will get to a point
[14:07] where you're going to need more help potentially tap into the long-term care medical program.
[14:14] With that kind of diagnosis, you want to start thinking about planning at that point, right?
[14:18] Sometimes you don't have the luxury of getting a diagnosis like that where it's a, we call
[14:22] this immediate need situation or an urgent situation where there's a stroke or a crash or whatever
[14:27] where like all of a sudden you're in it, you're being discharged from a hospital into a skilled
[14:31] nursing facility for even though, even if it's a short-term stay and you have to scramble.
[14:37] And that we do that all the time, this immediate need or urgent care or it's a planning.
[14:41] It just creates more stress for the client, but they're very grateful that we have these
[14:46] options available to help, but in the perfect world you do it further out, you wouldn't
[14:51] do it under duress.
[14:52] Right.
[14:53] So we try to preach to our clients, be prepared for thinking about these things, actually
[14:57] get older, maybe when you turn 65, okay, so what should I be doing anything else?
[15:03] Reach out, for example, we encourage our clients to reach out to us and say, is there anything
[15:08] else we need to be doing at this point?
[15:09] Mm-hmm.
[15:10] Well, it's great advice.
[15:11] Well, you know, in this, we're coming up on time here, but I'm wondering, you know,
[15:16] for people listening, I know you do these, ask Chris anything episodes, and so I want
[15:24] to share, this is such a complex, can be a complex topic and people may well have questions
[15:31] about it.
[15:32] If that's described your situation, send your questions to infoatbodylaw.com and Chris
[15:40] I'm sure in the future we'll be doing a medical specific Q&A on that, so that's something
[15:47] to consider out there.
[15:50] That's it Chris, great to see you.
[15:54] Great to see you.
[15:55] Thank you, Sean.
[15:56] And yeah, definitely guys, if you want me to do a medical specific ask me anything podcast,
[16:00] just send the questions.
[16:01] I'm probably going to do one anyway, because there's so much to cover here, we took a deep
[16:07] dive today and to look back real, but ultimately there's so many other things we can talk
[16:11] about too.
[16:12] So we're going to be doing ongoing podcast, definitely about medical.
[16:14] Excellent.
[16:15] Excellent.
[16:16] Well, that's it for today's episode of plan on it with Attorney Christopher Body.
[16:21] You can get more information resources, including the 2026 medical ebook that Chris has written,
[16:28] and information about upcoming estate planning workshops at the website bodylaw.com.
[16:34] Thanks for listening.
[16:35] I'm Sean O'Connor, and do us a favor, leave a thumbs up, leave a review, subscribe
[16:40] to the podcast, maybe share a link to someone in your world who you think would benefit from
[16:45] this medical information.
[16:47] Have a great day.
[16:52] If you're enjoying plan on it, be sure to subscribe, leave us a five star review, and like the
[16:57] post.
[16:58] Share or tag friends and family who could benefit from clear, practical estate planning guidance.